(TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA PART – I SECTION – II)

No.I-12015/2/2007-IPS.IV

Government of India Ministry of Home Affairs

Room No.220, North Block, New Delhi-110 001, dated the 23rd April, 2010.

N O T I F I C A T I O N 

In exercise of powers conferred by Sub-rule (1) of Rule-5 of the Indian Police Service (Cadre) Rules, 1954, the Central Government allocates the following cadres to the candidates allocated to the Indian Police Service on the basis of their qualifying the Civil Services Examination, 2008.

S.No. Rank No. Name of the Candidate S/Shri

Cadre allotted

1. 28 Naveen Singla Punjab 2. 82 Kuldeep Singh Punjab 3. 84 Ms Debasmita Das West Bengal 4. 86 Sharanappa S.D. Karnataka 5. 88 Rahul Sharma Haryana 6 93 Jasmeet Singh AGMUT 7 99 Atul Sharma Uttar Pradesh 8 100 M.N. Anucheth Karnataka 9 104 Ms Manusmriti AGMUT 10 109 Ms. Shaveta Dhankhar Rajasthan 11 110 Navneet Bhasin Madhya Pradesh 12 111 Indrajeet Mahatha Jharkhand 13 113 Deshmukh Abhinav Diliprao Maharashtra 14 115 Naveen Chandra Jha Bihar 15 118 Swapan Sharma Punjab 16 119 Thomson Jose Kerala 17 120 Koya Praveen Andhra Pradesh 18 122 Kundan Kumar Uttarakhand 19 125 Tarun Nayak Madhya Pradesh 20 129 Ms Preeti Jain Rajasthan 21 134 Imtiaz Ismail Parray Jammu & Kashmir 22 137 Keshav Kumar Choudhary Uttar Pradesh 23 138 Ms Neha Pandey Uttar Pradesh 24 140 Karthik Kashyap Gujarat 25 142 Ms. Monika Bhardwaj AGMUT 26 143 Ms. Harpreet Kaur Bihar 27 144 Amit Singh Madhya Pradesh 28 149 Srinivas A. Kerala 29 150 Shantanu Sinha Karnataka 30 151 Narendra Kumar Bihar 31 152 Shiladitya Chetia Assam-Meghalaya 32 153 C.Vamsi Krishna Karnataka

S.No. Rank No. Name of the Candidate S/Shri

Cadre allotted

33 154 Rahul Uttar Pradesh. 34 155 Borase Bhushan Gulabrao Karnataka 35 156 Abhinav Khare Karnataka 36 157 Bhaskar Bhushan Andhra Pradesh 37 159 Samant Rohan Rajendra Tamil Nadu 38 161 Ambar Kishor Jha Andhra Pradesh 39 166 Abhinav Kumar Tamil Nadu 40 167 Saurav Kumar Shah Bihar 41 169 Ziaul Haque Tamil Nadu 42 171 Rupesh Kumar West Bengal 43 176 Ajay Singh Rajasthan 44 179 Ms. Disha Mittal Tamil Nadu 45 180 Akhileshvar Singh Orissa 46 181 Mishra Shailendra Kumar Rajesh Jammu & Kashmir 47 182 Ms Vijayanta Tamil Nadu 48 183 Brijesh Kumar Rai Orissa 49 186 Harish N. Tamil Nadu 50 187 Amit Kumar Singh West Bengal 51 189 Nagendra Nath Tripathi West Bengal 52 192 Manjunath H. Kerala 53 194 Akash Magharia West Bengal 54 196 Sumit Kumar West Bengal 55 198 Ajay Kumar Sahni Uttar Pradesh 56 199 Rahul Malik Jammu & Kashmir 57 200 Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat West Bengal 58 203 Ms Amanjeet Kaur Assam – Meghalaya 59 204 Nimbalkar Vaibhav Chandrakant Assam – Meghalaya 60 205 Awadhesh Pathak West Bengal 61 206 Ms Anjali Ahuja West Bengal 62 207 Manavjit Singh Dhillon Jammu & Kashmir 63 211 Vijaya Kumar C. Tamil Nadu 64 229 Durai M. Tamil Nadu 65 230 P. Vijaya Kumar Tamil Nadu 66 238 K. Balaji AGMUT 67 241 Pushkar Anand Bihar 68 248 Paraskar Anil Subhash Maharashtra 69 254 Yogesh Yadav Rajasthan 70 264 Virendra Singh Yadav Gujarat 71 271 Pawan Kumar Uttar Pradesh 72 274 Ms. Bharati Hollikeri Tamil Nadu 73 276 Nirmala Devi S. Maharashtra 74 278 J. Mahesh Tamil Nadu 75 279 Holkar Prashant Vilasrao Maharashtra 76 282 M. Ram Kumar Maharashtra 77 285 MsVidhi Choudhary Gujarat 78 287 Ms N. Ambika Maharashtra 79 290 Ms Baddipudi Vijaya Jyothsna Gujarat 80 299 Pankaj Kumar Choudhary Rajasthan 81 304 Anees Ahmad Ansari Uttar Pradesh 82 305 Rudolf Alvares R.J. Madhya Pradesh

S.No. Rank No. Name of the Candidate S/Shri

Cadre allotted

83 315 R. Sathiya Sundaram AGMUT 84 322 A. Koan AGMUT 85 326 Ved Prakash Surya AGMUT 86 336 Akhilesh Kumar Chaurasia Uttar Pradesh 87 337 Shivasimpi Channappa Uttar Pradesh 88 339 Sunil Kumar Yadav West Bengal 89 344 R. Venkatesh Kumar Uttar Pradesh 90 345 Dinesh Kumar P Uttar Pradesh 91 347 Avvaru Ravindranath West Bengal 92 348 Muniraj G Uttar Pradesh 93 349 Gaurav Sharma AGMUT 94 364 Babloo Kumar Uttar Pradesh 95 368 Badana Varun Chandra Sekhar West Bengal 96 372 Suresh Kumar Chadive West Bengal 97 375 V. Ramparasath Manohar Uttar Pradesh 98 377 Rohan P. Kanay Uttar Pradesh 99 379 Nimbalkar Santosh Uttamrao West Bengal 100 383 Ram Niwas yadav Sikkim 101 397 Sudeep Sarkar West Bengal 102 407 Kuwar Rastradeep Rajasthan 103 423 Gaurav Singh Himachal Pradesh 104 425 Babu Ram Bihar 105 472 T.K. Shibu Kerala 106 491 Kamble Amit Tukaram Chhatisgarh 107 508 Ms Priyanka Nagaland 108 509 G. Dharmarajan Tamil Nadu 109 518 Sibichakravarthi M.R. Tamil Nadu 110 534 Dipak Ranjan Kerala 111 556 Vaghela Vishal Kumar Baldevbhai Gujarat 112 565 P. Goulungmuon Singsit Manipur-Tripura 113 570 Jayant Kant Bihar 114 576 Rama Rajeshwari R. Andhra Pradesh 115 587 Vikas Nagaland 116 589 P. Sridharan West Bengal 117 624 B. Ramesh Karnataka 118 670 Shashi Kumar Meena Maharashtra 119 684 Iada Martin Marbaniang Karnataka 120 691 Santhosh Kumar Meena Tamil Nadu 121 697 Charan Singh Meena Orissa 122 703 Ravi D. Channannavar Karnataka

(Inderjeet Kaur) Director (Police)

Tel. No. 011-23093256 To

The Manager, Government of India Press, Faridabad (Haryana).

No.I-12015/2/2007-IPS.IV Dated : 23rd April, 2010. Copy forwarded for information to: 1. The Director, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel National Police Academy, Hydeabad, Andhra

Pradesh. PIN : 500 052. 2. The Director, Lal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration, Mussoorie,

Uttaranchal. PIN : 248179. 3. The Chief Secretary to the Government of Andhra Pradesh / Assam / Meghalaya / Bihar /

Chhattisgarh / Gujarat / Haryana / Himachal Pradesh / Jammu and Kashmir / Jharkhand / Karnataka / Kerala / Madhya Pradesh / Maharashtra / Manipur / Tripura / Nagaland / Orissa / Punjab / Rajasthan / Sikkim / Tamil Nadu / Uttar Pradesh / Uttaranchal / West Bengal.

4. The Joint Secretary (UT), Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block, New Delhi. 5. Department of Personnel and Training ( Deputy Secretary- AIS), North Block, New

Delhi, with reference to their OM No.13015/2/2009-AIS-I-Dossier, dated 05.11.2009, 14.12.2009 and 01.01.2010.

6. The Secretary, Union Public Service Commission, Dholpur House Shahjahan Road, New

Delhi. 7. IPS-I Section / IPS- II Section / IPS-III Desk 8. Ten spare copies for IPS-IV Desk.

(Inderjeet Kaur) Director (Police)

Reference preceding notes.

This is regarding allocation of cadres to the candidates who have been allocated to the Indian Police Service on the basis of Civil Service Examination 2008. 2. The cadre allocation is to be made in accordance with the new cadre allocation policy notified by DOPT vide O.M. dated 10.4.08 (Flag ‘A’). The number of vacancies to be filled through Civil Services Examination 2008 has been determined as 130 in consultation with the States. These vacancies have also been distributed category wise on the basis of 200 point running vacancy based roaster. The category and cadre wise distribution of these vacancies between outsider and insider in the ratio of 2:1 has been carried out as per 30 point vacancy roster and reserved roster. The details of each cadre regarding outsider/insider distribution of the 130 vacancies have been tabulated below:-

Number of vacancies- 130

Insider-42

Outsider - 88 S. No

Name of State Cadre

- GEN OBC SC ST GEN OBC SC ST

1 AGMUT (UT) 8 1 1 - - 2 3 - 1 2 Andhra Pradesh 4 1 - - - 2 - 1 - 3 Assam – Meghalaya 4 1 - - - 2 - - 1 4 Bihar 7 1 - 1 - 3 - 2 - 5 Chhatisgarh 1 - - - - - 1 - - 6 Gujarat 5 1 1 - - 1 2 - - 7 Haryana 1 - - - - - - 1 - 8 Himachal Pradesh 1 - - - - - - 1 - 9 Jammu & Kashmir 4 1 - - - 3 - - - 10 Jharkhand 1 - 1 - - - - - - 11 Karnataka 9 2 - - 1 4 - - 2 12 Kerala 5 2 - - - 2 - 1 - 13 Madhya Pradesh 4 2 - - - 2 - - - 14 Maharashtra 7 1 2 - - - 3 - 1 15 Manipur- Tripura 2 - - 1 - - - 1 - 16 Nagaland 6 - 1 1 - 2 - 2 - 17 Orissa 4 1 - - - 1 - - 2 18 Punjab 3 1 - - - 2 - - - 19 Rajasthan 6 2 - - - 1 1 2 - 20 Sikkim 1 - - - - - 1 - - 21 Tamil Nadu 14 3 2 - - 6 2 - 1 22 Uttar Pradesh 15 2 3 - - 2 7 1 - 23 Uttarakhand 1 - - - - 1 - - - 24 West Bengal 17 1 2 2 - 6 3 3 - Total 130 23 13 5 1 42 23 15 8 3. In accordance with Para 5, 7 (d) and 8 (ii) the 24 State cadres for the purpose of cadre allocation have been arranged in alphabetical order. The alphabetical order followed for cadre allocation of IPS is same as the one followed by DoP&T for IAS (Flag-‘B’). While processing the cadre allocation it has been observed that though the candidates are supposed to fill one preference of State/Cadre in one block of the prescribed form yet (i) 08 candidates for outsider vacancies have given more than one preference (Flag-‘C’) within one block and (ii) one candidate for home State has ticked in the block in affirmative (Yes) whereas written by hand in negative (No). Such cases may be dealt in following ways:-

(i) (a) All the preferences may be treated as ‘Nil’ as the form of preference has been filled wrongly. (b) More than one States preferred in a block be treated as ‘cancelled’ and rest of the States written in each block be counted for the purpose of cadre allocation. (c) More than one State preferred in one block be considered alphabetically while making cadre allocation.

(ii) (a) The preference of home state be taken as negative because the

candidate has written “No” for that. (b) The candidate while preferring cadres for outsider vacancies has written his home State as first preference therefore at two places he has given preference for allocation to the ‘home State’. The preference for the home State may therefore be taken as ‘Yes’.

Taking a liberal view in the above scenarios, the exercise of allocation of cadres

has been based for outsider vacancies as per above (i) (c) and for insider vacancy as per (ii) (b). Such cases have been discussed below:-

(1) Sh Sharanappa S.D. belonging to the State of Karnataka (Rank No 86) while giving preference for home State has ticked on ‘Yes’ but written ‘No’ in hand in the form of UPSC main examination against column No 20 (b). In the preference form, for outsider vacancy he has written 1st option as Karnaktaka (Home State). Presuming that the candidate has written ‘No’ in the column 20 (b) inadvertently, his preference for Karnataka as his home state has been accepted.

(2) Shri Kamble Amit Tukaram (Rank No. 491) has given preference 3 as Chattisgarh and Madhya Pradesh. He is getting Chattisgarh as preference No.3

4. Out of the 130 candidates allocated to the Indian Police Service by the DOP&T (Flag-‘D’). 8 candidates have not joined the service and therefore, their names are not considered for cadre allocation. Their offers of appointment have been cancelled (Flag-‘E’). The remaining 122 shall be allotted to Home State/Cadre or any other State/Cadre on the basis of merit, preference and vacancy available at their turn in the cadres. All the candidates but for Ms. Priyanka, SC (Rank 508) have given preferences. Ms. Priyanka has given her option only for the Home State and not for the outsider vacancy. The details regarding Home States/other cadres and preferences thereof are placed at (Flag-‘F’). 5. The cadre allocation is being made for the first time as per new Cadre Allocation Policy of DoP&T dated 10.04.2008 in reference to the candidates selected on the basis of CSE 2008. The cadre allocation broadly involves two stages (a) filling up of insider vacancies with the candidates who have opted for the Home States, (b) filling up of outsider vacancies with candidates as per their merit and preferences. In the first step the cadre allocation process is to be initiated by making cadre allocation to the available

candidates belonging to various categories on the insider vacancies. In the second step the general OBC category candidates are to be given benefit under Para-9. In the third step the general insider vacancies which could not be filled due to non-availability of general candidates are to be filled in accordance with Para 7 (d). In the fourth step the insider SC vacancies which could not be filled due to non-availability of the SC category candidates are to be filled by exchange as stipulated in Para 7 (a). In the fifth step insider ST vacancies are to be filled by exchange as stipulated in Para 7 (b). In the sixth step the insider OBC category candidates are to be exchanged and filled as per Para 7 (c). After completion of this exercise, the remaining unfilled insider vacancies are to be converted into outsider vacancies as per Para-8 (iii). The outsider vacancies are to be filled as per merit and preferences of the candidates. Lastly, the candidates who have not given any preference for outsider vacancies are to be allocated cadres in accordance with Para 5. INSIDER VACANCIES 6. As per para 8(i) of Cadre Allocation Policy, “First, all those candidates who can be allocated against the insider vacancies available in their category would be so allocated.” Accordingly, out of 42, the following 26 candidates ( 17 General Category, 7 OBC, 1 SC and 1 ST) have been allocated to their Home States: (I) General Category candidates allocated to Home State

S.No. Name Rank No.

Category Home State Cadre allotted

1 Sh. Naveen Singla 28 General Punjab Punjab 2 Ms Debasmita Das 84 General West Bengal West Bengal 3 Sh. Sharanappa S.D. 86 General Karnataka Karnataka 4 Sh. Atul Sharma 99 General Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh

5 Sh. M.N. Anucheth 100 General Karnataka Karnataka 6 Ms Manusmriti 104 General Delhi AGMUT 7 Sh. Navneet Bhasin 110 General Madhya Pradesh Madhya Pradesh 8 Sh. Deshmukh Abhinav

Diliprao 113 General Maharashtra Maharashtra

9 Sh. Naveen Chandra Jha 115 General Bihar Bihar 10 Sh. Thomson Jose 119 General Kerala Kerala 11 Sh. Koya Praveen 120 General Andhra Pradesh Andhra Pradesh 12 Sh. Tarun Nayak 125 General Madhya Pradesh Madhya Pradesh. 13 Ms Preeti Jain 129 General Rajasthan Rajasthan 14 Sh. Imtiaz Ismail Parray 134 General J&K J&K 15 Ms Neha Pandey 138 General Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh 16 Sh. Shiladitya Chetia 152 General Assam Assam-Meghalaya 17 Sh. Ajay Singh 176 General Rajasthan Rajasthan

(ii) OBC Category candidates allocated to Home State

S.No. Name Rank No. Category Home State Cadre allotted

1 Sh. Paraskar Anil Subash 248 OBC Maharashtra Maharashtra

2 Sh. Holkar Prashant Vilasrao

279 OBC Maharashtra Maharashtra

3 Sh. Gaurav Sharma 349 OBC Delhi AGMUT 4 Sh. Vijay Kumar C. 211 OBC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu

5 Sh. Durai M. 229 OBC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu 6 Sh. Anees Ahmad Ansari 304 OBC Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh 7 Sh. Akhilesh Kumar

Chaurasia 336 OBC Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh

(iii) SC Category candidates allocated to Home State

S.No. Name Rank No. Category Home State Cadre allotted

1 Sh. Sudeep Sarkar 397 SC West Bengal West Bengal

(iv) ST Category candidates allocated to Home State

S.No. Name Rank No. Category Home State Cadre allotted

1 Sh. Ravi D. Channannavar

703 ST Karnataka Karnataka

7. Under Para 9 of the cadre allocation policy, “a reserved category candidate selected on general standards shall be eligible for allocation against the available insider unreserved vacancy as per his merit and preference. But if he cannot be allocated against such vacancy, for he is lower in rank as compared with other general category candidates, he shall be considered for allocation as per his merit and preference against the available insider vacancy of his category and in case found eligible, adjusted by exchanging insider vacancy in his category into insider UR vacancy and outsider UR vacancy into outsider reserved vacancy of his category. This is to ensure that such candidate is not placed at disadvantageous position vis-à-vis other candidates of his category in the merit list below him.” DoP&T have forwarded lists of the candidates allocated to the Indian Police Service on the basis of CSE 2008. These lists contain the names of the candidates as per their category e.g. unreserved OBC, SC and ST. However, the candidates qualifying on the general merit though belonging to reserved categories are a part of unreserved list. In the OBC category, there are 3 candidates who have been selected on General merit but only one could be given the benefit under the para 9 raising the filling of insider vacancies from 26 to 27. The details of the three OBC candidates qualifying on general merit are as follows:-

(i) Sh Manjunath H (Rank-192), Gen/OBC candidate (Home State – Karnataka) :- In IPS Cadre of Karnataka, there are two insider general vacancies. These are getting filled by two insider General candidates (Rank No 86 and 100). Sh Manjunath H therefore cannot be allocated to Home State against the insider general vacancy. He can also not be adjusted on insider OBC vacancy as the same is not available in IPS cadre of Karnataka. Sh Manjunath H could therefore not be allocated to his Home State Karnataka. He has been allotted the cadre as an outsider candidate under para 8 (iii).

(ii) Sh Ajay Kumar Sahni (Rank No 198) Gen/OBC candidate (Home State –Uttar Pradesh) :- In IPS cadre of Uttar Pradesh, there are two (2) insider general vacancies and three (3) insider OBC vacancies. Sh Sahni is not eligible for allocation to his Home State against the insider general vacancies as the same are being filled by allocating two insider general

candidates having higher ranks ( Rank No 99 and 138). Sh Ajay Kumar Sahni is eligible for allocation to home state by exchanging insider OBC vacancy with insider unreserved vacancy and outsider unreserved vacancy with outsider reserved vacancy of his category in IPS cadre of Uttar Pradesh. Shri Sahni (Rank No.198) therefore is adjusted in U.P as per Clause 9 of the cadre allocation policy.

(iii)Sh Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat (Rank No 200) Gen/OBC candidate (Home State –Maharashtra) :- In IPS cadre of Maharashtra, there is one insider General vacancy and two insider OBC vacancies. The insider general vacancy is filled by allocation of Rank No.113 over there. Sh Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat (Rank No 200) therefore cannot be allocated to his home state against the insider general vacancy. He could have been adjusted against the OBC insider vacancy but the same is not possible due to non availability of General category outsider vacancy to facilitate exchange. Shri Rathod Amit Kumar therefore is not getting the benefit under Rule 9. The 2 OBC candidates who are lower in rank than him are getting Home State. Shri Paraskar Anil Subhash (Rank No.248) and Sh Holkar Prashant Vilasrao Rank No 279 have therefore been allocated to their home state Maharashtra as per Rules. Shri Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat and Shri Holkar Prashant Vilasrao have represented for allocation to the home state.  Since as per para 9, the exchange of insider vacancy into insider unreserved vacancy and outsider unreserved vacancy into outsider reserved vacancy is not possible in Maharashtra due to non-availability of outsider unreserved vacancy, Shri Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat (Rank No. 200), an OBC candidate qualified on general merit is on disadvantageous position in respect of allocation of home state with reference to the two candidates qualified on OBC category and are getting their home state. This is against the spirit of the policy. The matter was therefore referred to DOP&T in file No.I-21023/8/2010-IPS-IV (link file) for their comments. DOP&T have furnished their advice at flag ‘G’.

(a) Clause 7 (d) of the cadre allocation policy provides, “When no insider unreserved candidate is available against an Insider Unreserved vacancy, available in a cadre but insider SC/ST/OBC candidate (s) is/are available, such senior most ST candidate (failing which such senior Most SC candidate and such senior most OBC candidate in that order ) shall be adjusted by shifting out the Unreserved insider vacancy to the next cadre in alphabetical order having outsider vacancy in that category and bringing in an Outsider vacancy of that category from that cadre”. Accordingly, in the following cadres, 5 candidates have been adjusted on the UR/General vacancies due to non-availability of UR general candidates and availability of reserved category candidates. Consequently, the number of filled vacancies has risen to 32. (i) GUJARAT :- There is one insider General vacancy but no insider

general candidate has qualified. No insider ST candidate has also qualified. However, one SC candidate namely Shri Vaghela Vishal Kumar Baldevbhai ( Rank No 556) has qualified. He is eligible for

allocation to Gujarat under the above Rule. For adjusting him in Gujarat, the insider general vacancy of Gujarat has been shifted out to Haryana and SC outsider vacancy has been brought in from there as an insider SC vacancy. Shri Vaghela Vishal Kumar Baldevbhai ( Rank No 556), SC candidate accordingly has been allocated to his Home State, Gujarat.

(ii) KERALA :- There are two insider General vacancies in Kerala but only one General category candidate has qualified from the State of Kerala. For the second insider vacancy UR candidate is not available. No insider ST candidate is also available. However, S.C. candidates have qualified. The senior most SC candidate is eligible for allocation to his Home State as per the above rule. For adjusting him, the general insider vacancy of Kerala has been shifted out to Manipur-Tripura and SC outsider vacancy has been brought in from there as an insider SC vacancy. Shri T.K Shibu (Rank No.472) accordingly, has been allocated to his home State, Kerala.

(iii) TAMILNADU :- In the IPS cadre of Tamil Nadu, there are 3 insider General Category vacancies but insider General Category candidates have not qualified. No insider ST candidates has also qualified.However insider SC category candidates eligible for allocation to home state are available. The three general category vacancies have been shifted out, one to Uttar Pradesh and two to West Bengal. SC outsider vacancy has been brought in from there as insider SC vacancies to Tamil Nadu. S/Shri P. Vijay Kumar (Rank No.230), G Dharmarajan (Rank No.509) and Sibichakravarthi. M.R. (Rank No. 518) have been allocated to their home State, Tamil Nadu.

8. Clause 7(a) of the cadre allocation policy provides, “when no candidates is available against an insider SC vacancy in a Cadre, the same shall be filled up by bringing in the senior most insider officer available in the merit list of ST candidates (failing which in the merit list of OBC candidates and in the merit list of the Unreserved candidates in that order) and shifting the SC vacancy of the cadre to the cadre to which the incoming officer would have been allocated against the available outsider vacancy in his category (failing which to the next cadre in alphabetical order in which the outsider vacancy is available).” In order to make adjustments under this Rule, first the candidates are allocated to the cadres on the vacancies which remain unfilled after adjusting the candidates as per 8 (i) and 7 (d). The allocation chart of the remaining 90 (122-26-1-5= 90) candidates after 8(i) and 7 (d) is placed at Flag ‘H’. The following two cases are getting covered under Para 7(a) of the Cadre Allocation Policy. Consequently, 34 insider vacancies are getting filled. (i) BIHAR :- In IPS cadre of Bihar, there is one insider SC vacancy but no

candidate of SC category has qualified. No insider ST candidate has also qualified. However, OBC candidates are available. Shri Pushkar Anand, the senior most OBC candidate from Bihar (Rank No 241) is getting allocated to Chhatisgarh against the outsider OBC vacancy. Under Para 7(a), the insider SC vacancy of Bihar is shifted out to Chhatisgarh and OBC outsider vacancy has

been brought in from there as insider OBC vacancy. Sh Pushkar Anand (Rank No.241) accordingly, has been allocated to his home state, Bihar.

(ii) MANIPUR-TRIPURA :- In IPS Cadre of Manipur-Tripura, there is one insider SC vacancy but no candidate from SC category has qualified. However one candidate of ST Category has qualified. Shri P. Goulungmuon Singsit (Rank No. 565), the senior most ST candidate from Manipur is get allocated to AGMUT against the outsider ST vacancy. Under Para 7(a), the insider SC vacancy of Manipur-Tripura is shifted out to AGMUT and ST outsider vacancy has been brought in from there as insider ST vacancy. Sh. P. Goulungmuon Singsit (Rank No. 565) accordingly, has been allocated to his home state, Manipur-Tripura.

(iii) It is also to be mentioned that there is only1 insider ST vacancy and it is filled under 8 (i) and therefore , there is no case under 7 (b).

9. Clause 7(c) of the cadre allocation policy provides, “when no candidates is available against an insider OBC vacancy in a cadre, the same shall be filled up by bringing in the senior most insider officer available in the merit list of ST candidates (failing which in the merit list of SC candidates and in the merit list of the Unreserved candidates in that order) and shifting the OBC vacancy of the cadre to the cadre to which the incoming officer would have normally been allocated against the available outsider vacancy in his category (failing which to the next cadre in alphabetical order in which the outsider vacancy is available).” . From the allocation chart at flag ‘P’ it can be seen that Sh. Indrajeet Mahatha get allocated to the IPS cadre of Madhya Pradesh against the outsider vacancy. He has been allocated to the State of Jharkhand under Clause 7 (c) of the Policy. In IPS cadre of Jharkhand, there is one insider OBC vacancy but no candidate from OBC, SC or ST category has qualified. However, Shri Indrajeet Mahatha (Rank No.111), the senior most general candidate is eligible for allocation to his Home State under Para 7 (c). The insider OBC vacancy of Jharkhand is shifted out to Madhya Pradesh and General outsider vacancy has been brought in from there as insider General vacancy. Shri Indrajeet Mahatha (Rank No.111) accordingly, has been allocated to his home state, Jharkhand. 10. After making adjustment as indicated above, it is stated that no other candidate is eligible for allocation of home State against the remaining unfilled insider vacancies. The allocation chart of 35 insider candidates as discussed in the preceding para is placed at flag ‘I’. The details regarding 35 insider vacancies have been filled and 07 vacancies which still remain vacant are tabulated below:-

Category Insider vacancy

Cadre allocated

under Rule

Filled Unfilled Remarks

GEN 23 8 (i), 7 (c), 9 19 4 8 (i), 7 (c), 9 OBC 13 8 (i), 7 (a) 8 5 8 (i), 7 (a) SC 5 8 (i), 7 (d) 5+1=6 +1 8 (i), 7 (d) ST 1 8 (i), 7 (a) 1+1=2 +1 8 (i), 7 (a) Total 42 35 Non-availability of candidates and finally converted

into outsider

12. The vacancy position as indicated in Para 2 of note after filling the above insider vacancies has got changed as per following Table:-

Insider Outsider S.No

Name of State Cadre No. of vacancies

GEN OBC

SC ST

GEN OBC

SC ST

Total of outsider

1 AGMUT (UT) 8 1 1 - - 2 3 1 - 6 2 Andhra Pradesh 4 1 - - - 2 - 1 - 3 3 Assam – Meghalaya 4 1 - - - 2 - - 1 3 4 Bihar 7 1 +1 1-1 - 3 - 2 - 5 5 Chhatisgarh 1 - - - - - 1-1 +1 - 1 6 Gujarat 5 1-1 1-1 +1 - 1 2+1 - - 4 7 Haryana 1 - - - - +1 - 1-1 - 1 8 Himachal Pradesh 1 - - - - - - 1 - 1 9 Jammu & Kashmir 4 1 - - - 3 - - - 3 10 Jharkhand 1 1 - - - - - - - 11 Karnataka 9 2 - - 1 4 - - 2 6 12 Kerala 5 2-1 - +1 - 2 - 1 - 3 13 Madhya Pradesh 4 2 - - - 2-1 1 - - 2 14 Maharashtra 7 1 2 - - - 3 - 1 4 15 Manipur- Tripura 2 - - 1-1 1 +1 - 1-1 - 1 16 Nagaland 6 - 1-1 1-1 - 2 +1 2+1 - 6 17 Orissa 4 1-1 - - - 1+1 - - 2 4 18 Punjab 3 1 - - - 2 - - - 2 19 Rajasthan 6 2 - - - 1 1 2 - 4 20 Sikkim 1 - - - - - 1 - - 1 21 Tamil Nadu 14 3-3 2 +3 - 6 2 - 1 9 22 Uttar Pradesh 15 2+1 3-1 - - 2+1-1 7+1 1-1 - 10 23 Uttarakhand 1 - - - - 1 - - - 1 24 West Bengal 17 1 2-2 2-1-1 - 6+2 3+2 3-2+1 - 15 Total 130 19 8 6 2 46 28 14 7 95 OUTSIDER VACANCIES 13. Under Rule 8 (ii), “…If an insider vacancy cannot be filled as per para 7 above, it would be converted to outsider vacancy and filled as such, duly accounting the fact of unfilled insider vacancy in the insider-outsider roster of the relevant cadre.”Accordingly, the remaining 7 unfilled insider vacancies have been converted into outsider and added in the rest of outsider vacancies. The outsider vacancies therefore have risen from 88 to 95. After adjusting 35 insider candidates on the insider vacancies, the remaining 86 candidates (General-43, OBC-27, SC-11, ST-5) have been allocated cadres against 86 outsider vacancies on the basis of their merit and preference. One candidate namely, Ms. Priyanka who had not given any preference has been allocated to Nagaland cadre on an outsider vacancy in accordance with Para-5 of the Cadre Allocation Policy. 14. Para 8 (iii) of the Cadre Allocation Policy provides, “finally, all the remaining candidates will be listed under their respective category in the order of merit and then allocated to a cadre on the basis of their merit, preference and the outsider vacancies in their category (including the outsider vacancies resulting from conversion of insider vacancy, which remain eventually unfilled after the allocation as per clause

(i) and (ii) of Para 8 above) available at their turn in the cadres other than their home cadre. Notwithstanding this, however, if during the course of allocation against the outsider vacancies as above a candidate is going to be allocated to his own home cadre because there are no other vacancies left for allocation other than those in his home cadre, an ‘exchange’ would be resorted to whereby the allocation of such candidate would be swapped with the cadre allotted to the first candidate above him in the list whose home state and allotted cadre are different”. Accordingly, 86 candidates have been allocated cadres on the outsider vacancies as per their merit and preference. None of the candidates is getting allocated to his home state. The details regarding the preference of State cadres of 43 General, 27 OBC, 12 SC and 5 ST candidates allocated against outsider vacancies may please be perused at flag ‘K’, L, M & N respectively. 15. Para 5 of Cadre Allocation Policy provides, “if a candidate does not give any preference for any of the cadre (s), it will be presumed that he/she has no specific preference for those cadres. Accordingly, if he is not allocated to any of the cadre for which he has indicated preference, he shall be allocated alongwith other such candidates in the order of rank to any of the remaining cadres, arranged in alphabetical order, in which there are vacancies in his category after allocation of all the candidates who can be allocated to cadre in accordance with their preference.” Ms Prinyanka (Rank No.508), SC candidate has not given any preference for cadres against outsider vacancies. However, she had opted for the home state. The same could not be allocated to her as there was no insider SC vacancy in Punjab. After allocating 86 candidates, the SC vacancies are available in Nagaland & West Bengal. Under para 5 above, Ms Priyanka (Rank No.508) has been allocated to the IPS cadre of Nagaland. The allocation chart of the 87 candidates is placed at flag ‘J’. 16. As may be seen from the above, 122 vacancies (35 insider + 87 outsider) have been filled (cadrewise details are at Flag-‘P’) and 8 vacancies have remained vacant due to non availability of 8 candidates who had not joined the Service. The details of unfilled vacancies are as under:-

Unfilled vacancy

Sl No. Cadre

Gen OBC SC ST Total 1. Assam Meghalaya - - - 1 1 2. Manipur Tripura 1 - - - 1 3. Nagaland 2 1 1 - 4 4. Orissa - - - 1 1 5. West Bengal - - 1 - 1 Total 3 1 2 2 8

17. Details regarding allocation of cadres to 122 candidates are tabulated below:-

CADRE ALLOCATION S.No. Name Rank Category Home State Cadre allotted Under

Para

1 Sh. Naveen Singla 28 General Punjab Punjab 8 (i) 2 Sh. Kuldeep Singh 82 General Haryana Punjab . 8 (iii) 3 Ms Debasmita Das 84 General West Bengal West Bengal 8 (i) 4 Sh. Sharanappa S.D. 86 General Karnataka Karnataka 8 (i) 5 Sh. Rahul Sharma 88 General Punjab Haryana. 8 (iii) 6 Sh. Jasmeet Singh 93 General Punjab AGMUT 8 (iii) 7 Sh. Atul Sharma 99 General Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh 8(i) 8 Sh. M.N. Anucheth 100 General Karnataka Karnataka 8(i) 9 Ms Manusmriti 104 General Delhi AGMUT 8(i) 10 Ms. Shaveta Dhankad 109 General Haryana Rajasthan 8 (iii)

11 Sh. Navneet Bhasin 110 General Madhya Pr. Madhya Pr. 8(i) 12 Sh. Indrajeet Mahatha 111 General Jharkhand Jharkhand 8(i) 13 Sh. Deshmukh Abhinav

Diliprao 113 General Maharashtra Maharashtra 8 (i)

14 Sh. Naveen Chandra Jha 115 General Bihar Bihar 8 (i) 15 Sh. Swapan Sharma 118 General Himachal Pr. Punjab 8 (iii) 16 Sh. Thomson Jose 119 General Kerala Kerala 8(i) 17 Sh. Koya Praveen 120 General Andhra Pr. Andhra Pr. 8 (i) 18 Sh. Kundan Kumar 122 General Bihar Uttarakhand 8 (iii) 19 Sh. Tarun Nayak 125 General Madhya Pr. Madhya Pr. 8 (i) 20 Ms Preeti Jain 129 General Rajasthan Rajasthan 8 (i) 21 Sh. Imtiaz Ismail Parray 134 General J&K J&K 8 (i) 22 Sh. Keshav Kumar 137 General Bihar Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii)

23 Ms Neha Pandey 138 General Uttar pr. Uttar pr. 8 (i) 24 Sh.Karthik Kashyap 140 General Karnataka Gujarat 8 (iii) 25 MsMonika Bhardwaj 142 General Haryana AGMUT 8 (iii) 26 Ms Harpreet Kaur 143 General Punjab Bihar 8 (iii) 27 Sh. Amit Singh 144 General Uttar Pr. Madhya Pr. 8 (iii) 28 Sh. Srinivas A. 149 General Karnataka Kerala 8 (iii) 29 Sh.Shantanu Sinha 150 General Delhi Karnataka 8 (iii) 30 Sh.Narendra Kumar 151 General Uttar Pr. Bihar 8 (iii) 31 Sh.Shiladitya Chetia 152 General Assam Assam-

Meghalaya 8 (i)

32 Sh. C.Vamsi Krishna 153 General Andhra Pr. Karnataka 8 (iii) 33 Sh. Rahul 154 General Haryana Uttar 8 (iii)

34 Sh. Borase Bhushan 155 General Maharashtra Karnataka 8 (iii)

35 Sh. Abhinav Khare 156 General Madhya Pr. Karnataka 8 (iii)

S.No. Name Rank Category Home State Cadre allotted Under Para

36 Sh. Bhaskar Bhushan 157 General Bihar Andhra Pradesh

8 (iii)

37 Sh. Samant Rohan Rajendra 159 General Maharashtra Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 38 Sh. Ambar Kishor Jha 161 General Bihar Andhra 8 (iii)

39 Sh. Abhinav Kumar 166 General Bihar Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 40 Sh. Saurav Kumar Shah 167 General Delhi Bihar 8 (iii) 41 Sh. Ziaul Haque 169 General Bihar Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 42 Sh. Rupesh Kumar 171 General Bihar West Bengal 8 (iii) 43 Sh. Ajay Singh 176 General Rajasthan Rajasthan 8 (i) 44 Ms. Disha Mittal 179 General Chandigarh Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 45 Sh. Akhileshvar Singh 180 General Uttar Pr. Orissa 8 (iii) 46 Sh.Mishra Shailendra 181 General Maharashtra J&K 8 (iii)

47 Ms Vijayanta 182 General Punjab Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 48 Sh. Brijesh Kumar Rai 183 General Uttar Pr. Orissa 8 (iii) 49 Sh. Harish N. 186 General Karnataka Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 50 Sh. Amit Kumar Singh 187 General Uttar Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii) 51 Sh. Nagendra Nath Tripathi 189 General Uttar Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii) 52 Sh. Manjunath H. 192 Gen./OBC Karnataka Kerala 8 (iii) 53 Sh.Akash Magharia 194 General Chhatisgarh West Bengal 8 (iii) 54 Sh. Sumit Kumar 196 General Jharkhand West Bengal 8 (iii) 55 Sh. Ajay Kumar Sahni 198 Gen./OBC Uttar Pr. Uttar Pr. 8 (i) &

9 56 Sh. Rahul Malik 199 General Delhi J&K 8 (iii) 57 Sh Rathod Amit Kumar 200 Gen./OBC Maharashtra West Bengal 8 (iii)

58 Ms Amanjeet Kaur 203 General Punjab Assam – Meghalaya

8 (iii)

59 Sh. Nimbalkar Vaibhav 204 General Maharashtra Assam Meghalaya

8 (iii)

60 Sh. Awadhesh Pathak 205 General Uttar Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii) 61 Ms Anjali Ahuja 206 General Delhi West Bengal 8 (iii) 62 Sh. Manavjit Singh Dhillon 207 General Punjab J&K 8 (iii) 63 Sh. Vijay Kumar C. 211 OBC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu 8(i)) 64 Sh. Durai M. 229 OBC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu 8 (i) 65 Sh. P. Vijaya Kumar 230 SC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu 7 (d) 66 Sh. K. Balaji 238 OBC Tamil Nadu AGMUT 8 (ii) 67 Sh. Pushkar Anand 241 OBC Bihar Bihar 7 (a) 68 Sh. Paraskar Anil Subhash 248 OBC Maharashtra Maharashtra 8 (i) 69 Sh. Yogesh Yadav 254 OBC Haryana Rajasthan 8 (iii) 70 Sh. Virendra Singh Yadav 264 OBC Rajasthan Gujarat 8 (iii) 71 Sh. Pawan Kumar 271 OBC Rajasthan Uttar Pr. 8 (iii) 72 Ms Bharati Hollikeri 274 OBC Karnataka Tamil Nadu 8 (iii)

S.No. Name Rank Category Home State Cadre allotted Under Para

73 Ms Nirmala Devi S. 276 OBC Tamil Nadu Maharashtra 8 (iii) 74 Sh. J. Mahesh 278 OBC Karnataka Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 75 Sh. Holkar Prashant Vilasrao 279 OBC Maharashta Maharashtra 8 (i) 76 Sh. M. Ram Kumar 282 OBC Tamil Nadu Maharashtra 8 (iii) 77 MsVidhi Choudhary 285 OBC Rajasthan Gujarat 8 (iii) 78 Ms N. Ambika 287 OBC Tamil Nadu Maharashtra 8 (iii) 79 Ms Baddipudi Vijaya 290 OBC Andhra Pr. Gujarat 8 (iii)

80 Sh. Pankaj Kumar Choudhary

299 SC Uttar Pr. Rajasthan 8 (iii)

81 Sh. Anees Ahmad Ansari 304 OBC Uttar Pr. Uttar Pr. 8 (i) 82 Sh. Rudolf Alvares R.J. 305 OBC Tamil Nadu Madhya

Pradesh 8 (iii)

83 Sh. R. Sathiya Sundaram 315 OBC Tamil Nadu AGMUT 8 (iii) 84 Sh. A. Koan 322 OBC Tamil Nadu AGMUT 8 (iii) 85 Sh. Ved Prakash Surya 326 SC Madhya Pr. AGMUT 8 (iii) 86 Sh. Akhilesh Kumar

Chaurasia 336 OBC Uttar Pr. Uttar Pr. 8(i)

87 Sh. Shivasimpi Channappa 337 OBC Karnataka Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii) 88 Sh. Sunil Kumar Yadav 339 OBC Uttar Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii) 89 Sh. R. Venkatesh Kumar 344 OBC Tamil Nadu Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii) 90 Sh. Dinesh Kumar P 345 OBC Tamil Nadu Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii) 91 Sh. Avvaru Ravindranath 347 OBC Andhra Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii) 92 Sh. Muniraj G 348 OBC Tamil Nadu Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii) 93 Sh. Gaurav Sharma 349 OBC Delhi AGMUT 8 (i) 94 Sh. Babloo Kumar 364 OBC Bihar Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii) 95 Sh. Badana Varun Chandra 368 OBC Andhra Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii)

96 Sh. Suresh Kumar Chadive 372 OBC Andhra Pr. West Bengal 8 (iii) 97 Sh. V. Ramparasath 375 OBC Tamil Nadu Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii)

98 Sh. Rohan P Kanay 377 OBC Karnataka Uttar Pradesh 8 (iii) 99 Sh Nimbalkar Santosh

Uttamrao 379 OBC Maharashtra West Bengal 8 (iii)

100 Sh. Ram Niwas yadav 383 OBC Rajasthan Sikkim 8 (iii) 101 Sh. Sudeep Sarkar 397 SC West Bengal West Bengal 8 (i) 102 Sh. Kuwar Rastradeep 407 SC Uttar Pradesh Rajasthan 8 (iii) 103 Sh. Gaurav Singh 423 SC Uttar Pr. Himachal 8 (iii) 104 Sh. Babu Ram 425 SC Haryana Bihar 8 (iii) 105 Sh. T.K. Shibu 472 SC Kerala Kerala 7 (d) 106 Sh. Kamble Amit Tukaram 491 SC Maharashtra Chhatisgarh 8 (iii) 107 Ms Priyanka 508 SC Punjab Nagaland 5 108 Sh. G. Dharmarajan 509 SC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu 7(d) 109 Sh. Sibichakravarthi M.R. 518 SC Tamil Nadu Tamil Nadu 7(d)

S.No. Name Rank Category Home State Cadre allotted Under Para

110 Sh. Dipak Ranjan 534 SC UP Kerala 8 (iii) 111 Sh. Vaghela Vishal Kumar

Baldevbhai 556 SC Gujarat Gujarat 7(d)

112 Sh. P. Goulungmuon Singsit 565 ST Manipur Manipur-Tripura

7(a)

113 Sh. Jayant Kant 570 SC Uttar Pr. Bihar 8 (iii) 114 Sh. Rama Rajeshwari R. 576 SC Kerala Andhra

Pradesh 8 (iii)

115 Sh. Vikas 587 SC Delhi Nagaland 8 (iii) 116 Sh. P. Sridharan 589 SC Tamil Nadu West Bengal 8 (iii) 117 . B. Ramesh 624 ST Andhra Pr. Karnataka 8 (iii) 118 Sh. Shashi Kumar Meena 670 ST Rajasthan Maharashtra 8 (iii) 119 Sh. Iada Martin Marbaniang 684 ST Meghalaya Karnataka 8 (iii) 120 Sh. Santhosh Kumar Meena 691 ST Rajasthan Tamil Nadu 8 (iii) 121 Sh. Charan Singh Meena 697 ST Rajasthan Orissa 8 (ii) 122 Sh. Ravi D. Channannavar 703 ST Karnataka Karnataka 8(i) 18. Kind approval of the Hon’ble HM is solicited to the cadre allocation made in the para-17/N for the candidates allotted to the Indian Police Service on the basis of CSE 2008.

sd (Rajinder Kumar)

Section Officer (IPS- IV) 16.4.2010

Director (P) JS (P-II)

Notes on pp.25-37/N dealing with the cadre allocation of candidates who have been allocated to the Indian Police Service on the basis of Civil Services Examination, 2008 may be perused in toto.

2. The number of vacancies and candidates recommended is 130. The break-up of vacancies available in different cadres and different categories may be seen in the Table in para-2. 3. The methodology followed has been explained in para-3. Out of 130 candidates allocated to IPS by DoPT (Flag-‘D’), 8 candidates have not joined the service and therefore they are not considered for cadre allocation. The names of these candidates may be seen at Flag-‘E’.

4. The step by step procedure followed as per the new Cadre Allocation Policy of DOP&T, which is being followed for the first time, has been outlined in para.5 (p.26/N). Accordingly, the procedure followed in allocating insider vacancies as per para-8(i) of the Cadre Allocation Policy and the result thereof may be seen in para-6(p.27/N). It may be seen that out of 42 insider vacancies, 26 candidates (17 General category, 7 OBC category, 1 SC and 1 ST) have been allocated to their home State as per para-8(i) of the Cadre Allocation Policy.

5. Under para-9 of the Cadre Allocation Policy, only one candidate could be given the benefit of being allotted an insider vacancy. It may be seen that there are 3 candidates belonging to the OBC category who have been selected on general merit as per policy but only one could be given the benefit under para-9 of the Cadre Allocation Policy. These 3 candidates are: (i) Shri Manjunath H, (ii) Shri Ajay Kumar Sahni, and (iii) Shri Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat. Their cases have been explained in para-7 of the note on pp.28-29/N. It may be seen that out of these three candidates only Shri Ajay Kumar Sahni has been allocated to his home cadre as per policy and Shri Manjunath H and Shri Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat have not been allotted their home cadre in keeping with the provisions of the Cadre Allocation Policy. The case of Shri Rathod Amit Kumar Bharat, who is in a disadvantageous position because of being considered on General merit instead of OBC category to which he belongs was referred to

DoPT, who have advised as per Flag-‘G’ (linked file) that the cadre allocation proposed by MHA is as per policy and should be followed.

6. The cadre allocation made as per clause 7 (d) of the Cadre Allocation Policy has been discussed in para-7(a) on pp.29-30/N. Similarly, the cadre allocation made as per the provisions of clause 7(a) and 7(c) of the Cadre Allocation Policy may be seen at para-8 and para-9. 7. The details of the unfilled vacancies of insider candidates may be seen in para-10, according to which, out of 42 insider vacancies, 35 have been filled.

8. The procedure according to which the outsider vacancies have been filled and cadre allocation is made under Rule 8 (ii) and (iii) has been discussed in para-13, 14 & 15 of the note on pp.32-33/N.

9. As per the above system of cadre allocation 122 vacancies (35 insider + 87 outsider) have been filled and 8 vacancies have remained unfilled due to non-availability of 8 candidates who have not joined the service. The details of unfilled vacancies are in para-16 of the note on p.33/N.

10. Accordingly, the cadre allocation of 122 candidates finalized as per the Cadre Allocation Policy of DoPT as in para-17 (pp.34-37/N) ante is submitted for approval of HM. sd

(Ashok Lavasa) Joint Secretary(P-I)

20.4.2010