IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS...
Transcript of IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS...
IPinCHIntellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage:Theory, Practice, Policy, Ethics
*1JO$)�XBT�DPODFJWFE�PG�BT�B�SFTFBSDI�QSPK�
FDU�UIBU�XPVME�JOWFTUJHBUF�OPU�POMZ�UIF�OBUVSF�
PG� JOUFMMFDUVBM� QSPQFSUZ� JTTVFT � CVU� BMTP� UIF�
XBZ� TVDI� SFTFBSDI� JT� DPOEVDUFE��$PVQMJOH�
BDBEFNJD� SFTFBSDI� XJUI� DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�
JOJUJBUJWFT� XPVME� ZJFME� OFX� BOE� EFFQFS� JO�
TJHIUT� JOUP� IPX � XIZ � BOE� VOEFS� XIBU� DPO�
EJUJPOT� JTTVFT� BSPTF� DPODFSOJOH� JOUFMMFDUVBM�
QSPQFSUZ � XIJMF� B� SFnFYJWF� PSJFOUBUJPO� BOE�
B� QSPKFDU� FUIOPHSBQIFS�XPVME� USBDL� QSPKFDU�
EZOBNJDT� BOE� LOPXMFEHF� nPX�� 5IF� DBTF�
TUVEZ�DPNQPOFOU�XPVME�FOBCMF�VT�BOE�DPN�
NVOJUZ� QBSUOFST� UP� JEFOUJGZ � BU� HSPVOE� MFWFM �
UIF�JTTVFT�DPOGSPOUJOH�*OEJHFOPVT�BOE�PUIFS�
EFTDFOEBOU�DPNNVOJUJFT �BU� UIF�TBNF� UJNF�
PGGFSJOH�UIFN�SFBM�CFOFmUT��
0O� QBQFS� UIJT� JT� BMM� TP� TUSBJHIUGPSXBSE��
8FMM�DSBGUFE� UFYU�BOE�B�CVEHFU� JO� UIF�HSBOU�
QSPQPTBM� TFU�PVU� UIF�HPBMT �QSPDFTTFT �BOE�
QSPEVDUT� PG� UIF� SFTFBSDI� NFUIPEPMPHZ�� *U�
XBT�UIFO�KVTU�B�NBUUFS�PG�SFDFJWJOH�UIF�GVOE�
JOH�BOE�QVUUJOH� UIJOHT� JOUP�NPUJPO�TJNQMFþ�
0G� DPVSTF � UIF� SFBMJUZ� XBT� B� MJUUMF� EJGGFSFOU��
8F� TPPO� GPVOE� UIBU� BMNPTU� FWFSZUIJOH� UPPL�
MPOHFS� UIBO� FYQFDUFE � FTQFDJBMMZ� UIF� DBTF�
TUVEJFT �XIJDI� SFRVJSFE� UJNF� GPS�DPNNVOJUZ�
DPOTVMUBUJPOT �BOE�BMTP�CFDBVTF�UIF�UZQF�PG�
SFTFBSDI� XF� QSPQPTFE�USVMZ� DPMMBCPSBUJWF�
XPSL� XJUI� EFTDFOEBOU� DPNNVOJUJFT�GBMMT�
PVUTJEF�PG�UIF�VTVBM�SFTFBSDI�NPEFM��
5IJT�NFBOU� UIBU� JU� UPPL�DPOTJEFSBCMF� UJNF�
BOE� FGGPSU� PO� FWFSZPOF�T� QBSU�DBTF� TUVEZ�
EFWFMPQFST � *1JO$)� QSPKFDU� NBOBHFS� ,FMMZ�
'PY � BOE� VOJWFSTJUZ� SFTFBSDI� TFSWJDFT�UP�
XPSL�PVU�FUIJDT�SFWJFXT �*1�JTTVFT �BOE�GVOE�
JOH� USBOTGFST�� "MUIPVHI� FWFSZPOF� XPSLFE�
QBUJFOUMZ�UP�BDDPNQMJTI�UIFTF�UBTLT �JU�XBT�B�
TMPX�MFBSOJOH�QSPDFTT��"T�QSPKFDU�EJSFDUPS �*�
XBT�BMTP� GSVTUSBUFE�CZ� UIF�TFFNJOH�EJTDPO�
OFDU�CFUXFFO�44)3$�T�BQQSPWBM�PG�XIBU�UIFZ�
TBX�BT�DVUUJOH�FEHF�SFTFBSDI�BOE�PVS�BCJMJUZ�
UP�EP�JU�HJWFO�UIF�VOJWFSTJUZT��JOUFSQSFUBUJPO�
PG�44)3$�mOBODJBM�SFHVMBUJPOT��
)PXFWFS �PVS�FGGPSUT�JO�QVTIJOH�UIF�FOWF�
MPQF� SFHBSEJOH� VOJWFSTJUZ� VOEFSTUBOEJOH� PG�
DSPTT�DVMUVSBM� DPMMBCPSBUJWF� SFTFBSDI� JOJUJB�
UJWFT�BSF�OPX�DPOUSJCVUJOH�UP�B�UZQF�PG�DSPTT�
DVMUVSBM�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�CFUXFFO�*1JO$)�BOE�
UIF�VOJWFSTJUJFT�XF�XPSL�XJUI��"U�4'6�UIJT�IBT�
CFFO�BJEFE�DPOTJEFSBCMZ�CZ�,FMMZ� 'PY�T� FG�
GPSUT�XJUI�UIF�3FTFBSDI�"DDPVOUJOH�BOE�3F�
TFBSDI� 4FSWJDFT� PGmDFT � BOE� CZ� OVNFSPVT�
DPOWFSTBUJPOT�XJUI�)BM�8FJOCFSH �%JSFDUPS�PG�
3FTFBSDI�&UIJDT��*OEFFE �BGUFS�*�HBWF�B�UBML�
UP� UIF�4'6�SFTFBSDI�DPNNVOJUZ� MBTU�ZFBS �B�
NFNCFS� PG� VOJWFSTJUZ� 3FTFBSDI� 4FSWJDFT�
TBJE � i/PX� *� mOBMMZ� VOEFSTUBOE� XIBU� UIJT�QSPKFDU�JT�BCPVU�w�5IJT�QPJOUT�UP�PVS�DPMMFDUJWF�
FGGPSUT�NPWJOH�UIF�SFTFBSDI�QSPDFTT� JO�OFX�
BOE�NPSF�FGGFDUJWF�EJSFDUJPOT��
*1JO$)� JT� UPEBZ�IFMQJOH�DPNNVOJUJFT � SF�
TFBSDIFST � BOE� PUIFST� EFWFMPQ� NPSF� FRVJ�
UBCMF�BOE�DVMUVSBMMZ�BQQSPQSJBUF�BQQSPBDIFT�
UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF��#VU �OP�MFTT�JNQPSUBOUMZ �
*1JO$)� JT� BMTP� IFMQJOH� VOJWFSTJUJFT� CFDPNF�
BXBSF� PG� OFX� SFTFBSDI� NPEFMT� UIBU� XJMM � *�
IPQF �CFDPNF�NPSF�DPNNPO�JO�UIF�DPNJOH�
EFDBEF�
1
>OH[»Z� 0UZPKL>OH[»Z � 0UZPKL
*1JO$)�/FXTMFUUFS�7PM�����8JOUFS�����
IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2IPinCH Citations 2Catherine Bell Profile 3Negotiating IP Under Neoliberalism 4Inuit Studies Conference 4IPinCH at AAA Meeting 5Heritage Research Workshop 6New IPinCH Associates 7PinCHes of News 8
Project Update from the IPinCH Director
*1JO$)�$PNNVOJUZ�#BTFE�)FSJUBHF�3FTFBSDI�8PSLTIPQ�QBSUJDJQBOUT�BDSPTT�GSPN�UIF�$IJFG�+PF�.BUIJBT�$PNNVOJUZ�$FOUSF �PO�4LXYX�NFTI�UFSSJUPSZ�OFBS�7BODPVWFS �$BOBEB �0DUPCFS��� ������
2 Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage Project
8FMDPNF� UP� UIF�OFX� *1JO$)�WJEFP� JOJUJBUJWFþ�5IBOLT� UP� UIF�FG�
GPSUT�PG�+VMJF�)PMMPXFMM �4UFQIFO�-PSJOH �BOE�$MBJSF�4NJUI�PG�UIF�
8PSME� "SDIBFPMPHJDBM� $POHSFTT � BOE� UIF� $PMMBCPSBUJPO � 3FMB�
UJPOTIJQ �BOE�$BTF�4UVEZ� $3$4�8PSLJOH�(SPVQ � *1JO$)�IBT�
CFFO�BQQSPWFE�UP�QSPWJEF�UXP�'MJQ�WJEFP�DBNFSBT�UP�FBDI�DBTF�
TUVEZ�HSPVQ��5IJT� JOJUJBUJWF�XJMM�QSPWJEF� UIF�PQQPSUVOJUZ� UP� UBLF�
DSPTT�QSPKFDU� DPNNVOJDBUJPO� BOE� DPMMBCPSBUJPO� JOUP� OFX� NF�
EJB�TIBSJOH�SFTFBSDI�FYQFSJFODFT �LOPXMFEHF �QSPHSFTT �BOE�
HFOFSBUJOH�EJTDVTTJPO�JO�OFX�JOUFSBDUJWF�BOE�DSFBUJWF�GPSVNT�
$PNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� JOJUJBUJWF�DBTF� TUVEZ� UFBNT� BSF� JOWJUFE� UP�
TIPPU�WJEFP�DMJQT�UIBU�DIBSBDUFSJ[F�PS�TQFBL�UP�UIFJS�QSPKFDUT �BTL�
RVFTUJPOT�PS� SFnFDU�PO� MFBSOJOH�BSPVOE�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�BOE� JO�
UFMMFDUVBM�QSPQFSUZ�JTTVFT �BOE�XFBWF�UISFBET�BDSPTT�UIF�QSPKFDU��
5IFTF�WJEFPT�XJMM� TIJOF�B�TQPUMJHIU�PO� JOTQJSJOH�BOE�DIBMMFOHJOH�
TUPSJFT�GSPN�XJUIJO�UIF�DBTF�TUVEJFT �PQFO�VQ�JOUFSDIBOHF�CFUXFFO�
FBDI�PUIFS�T�QSPKFDUT �BOE�TUSFOHUIFO�SFMBUJPOTIJQT�BDSPTT�*1JO$)�
5IF�$3$4�8PSLJOH�(SPVQ�IBT�QVCMJTIFE�B�QJMPU�WJEFP�GPDVT�
JOH�PO������0MZNQJD�PQFOJOH�DFSFNPOJFT�BT�B�XFC� GPSVN�PO�
UIF� *1JO$)�TJUF��(P� UP� i'PSVNTw� XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF�����
UP� DIFDL� PVU� UIJT� FYBNQMF� PG� UIF� LJOE� PG� WJEFP� VOEFSUBLJOHT�
UIBU�NJHIU�CF�JODMVEFE�JO�UIF�JOJUJBUJWF�y�BOE�GFFM�GSFF�UP�MFBWF�B�
DPNNFOU�XIJMF�ZPV�SF� UIFSF �DPOUSJCVUJOH� UP�OFX�DSPTT�QSPKFDU�
EJBMPHVFþ
$BTF�TUVEZ� UFBNT�XJMM�NBJOUBJO� GVMM� JOUFMMFDUVBM�BOE�DSFBUJWF�
BVUIPSJUZ�PWFS�XIBU�UIFZ�TIPPU�BOE�TIBSF �BOE�IPX�UIFZ�DIPPTF�
UP�VTF� UIF�WJEFPT� JO� SFMBUJPO� UP� UIFJS�PXO�QSPKFDUT��.FBOXIJMF �
B�WBSJFUZ�PG�WJEFP�QVCMJTIJOH�PQUJPOT�XJMM�CF�NBEF�BWBJMBCMF�BT�
EJGGFSFOU�GBDFUT�PG�*1JO$)�VOGPME �BOE�XF�MPPL�GPSXBSE�UP�NBLJOH�
VTF�PG�UIFTF�DIBOOFMT�UP�MFBSO�DPMMFDUJWFMZ�GSPN�UIF�FYQFSJFODFT�
PG�DBTF�TUVEZ�EFWFMPQFST�
,FFQ� QPTUFE� GPS� GVSUIFS� EFUBJMT� PO� UIJT� JOJUJBUJWF � PS� FNBJM�
$3$4�SFTFBSDI�BTTJTUBOU �&NNB�'FMUFT�BU�FSGFMUFT!HNBJM�DPN�
Announcing the Brand New IPinCH Flip Video InitiativeI`�,TTH�-LS[LZ�HUK�)YPHU�5VISL
Catherine Bell, Rosemary Coombe and Patricia Goff. i*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ� BOE� *OEJHFOFJUZ�� *OUFSOBUJPOBM� 1PMJDZ� .BLJOH� CFUXFFO�
/FPMJCFSBMJTN�BOE�)VNBO�3JHIUT�w�"�3PVOEUBCMF�BU�UIF�:PSL�$FO�
USF� GPS�1VCMJD�1PMJDZ�BOE� UIF�-BX��5PSPOUP �4FQUFNCFS��� �������
XXX�JQPTHPPEF�DB���������JOUFSTFDUJPOT�OFHPUJBUJOH�UIF�TQBD�
FT�PG�JOUFMMFDUVBM�QSPQFSUZ�VOEFS�UIF�DPOEJUJPOT�PG�OFPMJCFSBMJTN�
Murielle Nagy. i*1�BOE�3FTFBSDI�&UIJDT�w�4FTTJPO�PSHBOJ[FS ���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS������ �������
Murielle Nagy. i"DDFTT�UP�%BUB�BOE�3FQPSUT�"GUFS�UIF�$PNQMFUJPO�
PG�B�3FTFBSDI�1SPKFDU�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�
$POGFSFODF�JO�7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������
Catherine Bell. i"DDFTT�UP�BOE�$POUSPM�PWFS�*OGPSNBUJPO�0SJHJOBU�
JOH�GSPN�"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�JO�$BOBEB�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�
UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� �
�����
Natasha Lyons. i5IF�.JEEMF�(SPVOE��/FHPUJBUJOH� UIF�/BUVSF�BOE�
0XOFSTIJQ�PG�3FTFBSDI�0VUDPNFT� JO�$PMMBCPSBUJWF�1SPKFDUT�XJUI�
"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVE�
JFT�$POGFSFODF�JO�7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������
Daryl Pullman and George Nicholas. i*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE�UIF�&UIJDBM�-FHBM�4UBUVT�PG�)VNBO�%/"��5IF� *S�3FMFWBODF�PG�$PO�
UFYU�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�
E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������
Catherine Bell. i3FTQFDU �3JHPVS�BOE�3FTQPOTJCJMJUZ��$PMMBCPSBUJWF�&UIJDT�1SBDUJDFT�BOE�UIF�"DBEFNZ�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�
*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������
George Nicholas. i*1JO$)�"DUJWJUJFT�JO������w�#$�"SDIBFPMPHZ�'P�SVN��.VTRVFBN�/BUJPO�5FSSJUPSZ �/PWFNCFS�� ������
George Nicholas. i&TTFOUJBM�5FOTJPOT�JO�"SDIBFPMPHJDBM�5IFPSZ�BOE�1SBDUJDF�w�4UBOGPSE�6OJWFSTJUZ�"SDIBFPMPHZ�8PSLTIPQ�4FSJFT �/P�
WFNCFS��� ������
Julie Hollowell��%JTDVTTBOU�GPS�iA4BWJOH�UIF�-PSF��7FSTJPO���� ��4VT�UBJOBCJMJUZ � )FSJUBHF� 4UVEJFT � $VMUVSBM� 1SFTFSWBUJPO� BOE� %FWFMPQ�
NFOU�w�"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �/FX�0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� ������
Melissa Baird��i$SJUJDBM�)FSJUBHF�4UVEJFT��,OPXMFEHF �*EFOUJUZ�BOE�1PXFS�w�4FTTJPO�DIBJS�BOE�PSHBOJ[FS �"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �/FX�
0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� ������
Melissa Baird�� iA8JUI� 4USFOHUI� PG� 5POHVF� BT�8FMM� BT� 4USFOHUI� PG�
)BOE���$PMPOJBM�4USVDUVSFT �*OEJHFOPVT�$VMUVSBM�-BOETDBQFT �BOE�
UIF�1PMJUJDT�PG�)FSJUBHF�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �
/FX�0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� ������
Rosemary Coombe��i1SPQFSUZ�'PSNT�BOE�)FSJUBHF�1PMJUJDT�w�1BQFS�
QSFTFOUFE�BU�"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �/FX�0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� �
�����
Lena Mortensen and George Nicholas�� ������ i3JEJOH� UIF� 5PVSJTN�
5SBJO ��/BWJHBUJOH�*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ �)FSJUBHF�BOE�$PNNVOJ�
UZ�#BTFE�"QQSPBDIFT�UP�$VMUVSBM�5PVSJTN�w�"OUISPQPMPHZ�/FXT���� � QQ�� ��o���� IUUQ���POMJOFMJCSBSZ�XJMFZ�DPN�EPJ���������
K����������������������Y�BCTUSBDU
IUUQ���XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF����
A Sampling of Recent IPinCH Presentations and Publications
IPinCH Newsletter Vol 2.2 (Winter 2010) 3
) SPN� CFIJOE�UIF�TDFOFT� QMBOOJOH� UP�
UIF�GSPOUMJOFT�PG�DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�SF�
TFBSDI �$BUIFSJOF�#FMM�T� JOWPMWFNFOU�
XJUI� *1JO$)�DPOUJOVFT� UP� HSPX��"�6OJWFSTJUZ�
PG� "MCFSUB� MBX� QSPGFTTPS � $BUIFSJOF� CSJOHT�
FYQFSUJTF�JO�*OEJHFOPVT�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�MBX�
BOE� JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ�DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� MFHBM�
SFTFBSDI�UP�UIF�*1JO$)�QSPKFDU��"T�B�4UFFSJOH�
$PNNJUUFF�NFNCFS �TIF�IFMQT�HVJEF�QSPKFDU�
QSJPSJUJFT �GVOEJOH�BOE�PVUSFBDI��"OE�BT�B�DP�
EFWFMPQFS � TIF� IFMQT� *OEJHFOPVT� PSHBOJ[B�
UJPOT�EFWFMPQ�UIFJS�PXO�SFTFBSDI�QSPQPTBMT�
4FFJOH�*1JO$)�EFWFMPQ�IBT�CFFO�iB�HSFBU�
MFBSOJOH� FYQFSJFODF� BOE� PQQPSUVOJUZ� UP� VO�
EFSTUBOE�NPSF�BCPVU� UIF� JOUFSGBDF�PG� *1�BOE�
*OEJHFOPVT�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF w�TBZT�$BUIFSJOF��
*U� JT�BMTP�B�DIBMMFOHJOH�QSPDFTT��i8F�SF�DPO�
TUBOUMZ�NFEJBUJOH�CFUXFFO�XIBU�UIF�OFFET�BSF�
BU� UIF� DPNNVOJUZ� MFWFM� UP� EP� SFTFBSDI � BOE�
XIBU� UIF�OFFET�BSF�BU� UIF�VOJWFSTJUZ� MFWFM� UP�
EP�SFTFBSDI�w
*1JO$)�T� DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� SFTFBSDI�
DPNQPOFOU�NFUIPEPMPHZ�XBT� JOnVFODFE� CZ�
$BUIFSJOF�T� i1SPUFDUJPO� BOE� 3FQBUSJBUJPO� PG�
'JSTU�/BUJPO�$VMUVSBM�)FSJUBHFw �B� UFO�ZFBS� JO�
UFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ � DPMMBCPSBUJWF� SFTFBSDI� JOJUJB�
UJWF�JOWPMWJOH�'JSTU�/BUJPO�QBSUOFST�JO�8FTUFSO�
$BOBEB � JODMVEJOH� UIF� #MBDLGPPU�� "NPOH� JUT�
PVUDPNFT�XFSF�UXP�CPPLT��'JSTU�/BUJPOT�$VM�UVSBM�)FSJUBHF�BOE�-BX��$BTF�4UVEJFT �7PJDFT�BOE� 1FSTQFDUJWFT� XJUI� 7BM� /BQPMFPO�� BOE�'JSTU�/BUJPOT�$VMUVSBM�)FSJUBHF�BOE�-BX��3FD�PODJMJBUJPO�BOE�3FGPSN�XJUI�3PCFSU�1BUFSTPO��
5IF�QSPKFDU�BMTP�CSPVHIU�UP�MJHIU�BSFBT�OFFE�
JOH�NPSF�SFTFBSDI �MFBEJOH�(FPSHF�/JDIPMBT �
,FMMZ�#BOOJTUFS �BOE�+VMJF�)PMMPXFMM� UP� GVSUIFS�
FYQMPSF� IPX� BSDIBFPMPHJDBMMZ� EFSJWFE� JOGPS�
NBUJPO� mUT� XJUI� *OEJHFOPVT� QFSTQFDUJWFT� PO�
DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�BOE�MBX �BOE�VMUJNBUFMZ�UP�UIF�
*1JO$)�QSPKFDU�
'PS�*1JO$) �$BUIFSJOF�JT�BHBJO�QBSUOFSJOH�
XJUI�UIF�1JJLBOJ�/BUJPO�BOE�#MPPE�5SJCF�PG�UIF�
#MBDLGPPU�$POGFEFSBDZ��5IF�i,BJOJTJOOJw�JOJ�
UJBUJWF�MPPLT�BU�IPX�#MBDLGPPU�LOPXMFEHF�JT�
JODPSQPSBUFE�BOE�QSPUFDUFE�JO� MFHBMMZ�NBO�
EBUFE�HPWFSONFOU� DPOTVMUBUJPO� QPMJDZ� QSP�
DFTTFT�� i5IF� GVOEBNFOUBM� RVFTUJPO� JT� IPX�
UP� FNQMPZ� #MBDLGPPU� USBEJUJPOBM� LOPXMFEHF�
JO�UIF�DPOTVMUBUJPO�QSPDFTT�UP�NBLF�JU�NPSF�
NFBOJOHGVM�BOE�BU�UIF�TBNF�UJNF�QSPUFDU�UIF�
LOPXMFEHF�UIBU�JT�CFJOH�TIBSFE�GSPN�QVCMJD�
BDDFTT�PS�JNQSPQFS�VTF w�TBZT�$BUIFSJOF�
4IF� JT� BMTP� POF� PG� UIF� EFWFMPQFST� PG� B�
QSPQPTBM�XJUI� UISFF� :VLPO� 'JSTU� /BUJPOT�� UIF�
$IBNQBHOF� BOE� "JTIJIJL� 'JSTU� /BUJPOT � UIF�
$BSDSPTT�5BHJTI� 'JSTU� /BUJPO � BOE� UIF� 5B�BO�
,XÊDI�ÊO� $PVODJM�� 5IBU� TUVEZ� XJMM� FYBNJOF�
IPX�'JSTU�/BUJPOT�WBMVFT�BOE�DVMUVSF�BSF�DPO�
TJEFSFE�JO�DVMUVSBM�NBOBHFNFOU�EFDJTJPOT �PO�
UIFJS�MBOET�BOE�VOEFS�UIFJS�DPOUSPM �BT�XFMM�BT�
CZ� UFSSJUPSJBM � QSPWJODJBM � BOE� GFEFSBM� HPWFSO�
NFOUT��"T� JO�IFS�PUIFS�XPSL �$BUIFSJOF�BJNT�
UP� SFDPODJMF�PGUFO�EJGGFSJOH�8FTUFSO�BOE�"C�
PSJHJOBM�DPODFQUT�BCPVU�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF��4IF�
TBZT �i*O�BMM�UIF�BSFBT�*�XPSL�JO �UIF�MBX�JT�EBUFE�
PS�EPFTO�U�UBLF�JOUP�BDDPVOU�"CPSJHJOBM�SJHIUT�w
$BUIFSJOF� BMTP� BTTJTUFE� UIF� "UBWBR� $VM�
UVSBM�*OTUJUVUF�JO�EFWFMPQJOH�UIFJS�DBTF�TUVEZ�
QSPKFDU� FYQMPSJOH� UIF� SPMF� UIF�/VOBWJNNJVU�
QMBZ� JO� DVMUVSBM� UPVSJTN� JO� /VOBWJL � BOE�
XIFUIFS� UIF� SFTQPOTJCMF� EFWFMPQNFOU� UIFZ�
FOWJTJPO�JT�CFJOH�SFBMJ[FE�
"T�TIF�TQFOET�UJNF�BXBZ�GSPN�UFBDIJOH�UP�
GPDVT�PO�SFTFBSDI �$BUIFSJOF�T�QMBUF�SFNBJOT�
GVMM��4IF�IBT�GBDJMJUBUFE�XPSLTIPQT�BOE�HJWFO�
UBMLT� PO� MBX� SFGPSN�BOE� *OEJHFOPVT� DVMUVSBM�
IFSJUBHF� JTTVFT�BDSPTT�$BOBEB�BOE�BCSPBE �
JODMVEJOH�BT�B�WJTJUJOH�TDIPMBS�BU�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�
PG�"CFSEFFO �4DPUMBOE��*O�+BOVBSZ����� �TIF�
DPOOFDUFE�XJUI�MFHBM�DPMMFBHVFT�GSPN�BSPVOE�
UIF� XPSME� PO� JTTVFT� PG� USBEF� JO� *OEJHFOPVT�
DVMUVSBM� IFSJUBHF� BU� B� XPSLTIPQ� JO� -VDFSOF �
4XJU[FSMBOE��*O�UIF�TQSJOH �TIF�XJMM�TQFBL�PO�
DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�BOE�JEFOUJUZ�JTTVFT�BU�B�XPSL�
TIPQ�PO�*OEJHFOPVT�1FPQMFT�PG�4PVUI�"NFSJ�
DB�BU�UIF�)FCSFX�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�+FSVTBMFN�
$BUIFSJOF�TFFT�B�DIBMMFOHF�OPU�VOJRVF�UP�
$BOBEB�� CSJEHJOH� 8FTUFSO� TFQBSBUJPOT� CF�
UXFFO�UBOHJCMF�BOE�JOUBOHJCMF �BOE�QSPQFSUZ�
BOE�IVNBO�SJHIUT�JO�MBX�SFGPSN��i*OEJHFOPVT�
QFPQMF�EP�OPU�BMXBZT�SFMBUF�UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJ�
UBHF� JO� UIF� XBZ� 8FTUFSO� MBXT� BOE� QFPQMF�
EP w�TIF�TBZT��
$BUIFSJOF�XBT�ESBXO�UP�*OEJHFOPVT�MFHBM�
JTTVFT�JO�IFS�ZPVUI �BGUFS�PCTFSWJOH�UIF�USFBU�
NFOU�PG�VSCBO�"CPSJHJOBM�QFPQMF��-BUFS �TIF�
TBX�JOUFMMFDUVBM�DIBMMFOHFT�JO�IVNBO�SJHIUT�
BOE�TPDJBM�KVTUJDF�EJNFOTJPOT �BOE�PQQPSUV�
OJUJFT�GPS�DIBOHF�BOE�EJWFSTF�JOUFSQSFUBUJPOT�
JO�$BOBEB�T�FNCSZPOJD�MBX��"CPSJHJOBM�BOE�
USFBUZ� SJHIUT�XFSF� POMZ� SFDPHOJ[FE� JO� �����
XJUI�UIF�TJHOJOH�PG�UIF�$POTUJUVUJPO�
"T� *OEJHFOPVT�DPOUSPM�PWFS�DVMUVSBM�IFSJ�
UBHF�CFDBNF�B�NPSF�QSPNJOFOU�JOUFSOBUJPO�
BM� JTTVF � 'JSTU� /BUJPO� DPNNVOJUZ�NFNCFST�
TPVHIU� $BUIFSJOF� PVU� XJUI� SFQBUSJBUJPO� BOE�
BDDFTT�JTTVFT��i"MM�UIBU�UFNQUFE�NF�UP�MPPL�
BU�TPNF�PG�UIF�MFHBM�SBNJmDBUJPOT��*�EFDJEFE�
UP�EP�TPNFUIJOH�BCPVU�JU��*U�CFHBO�XJUI�B�DPM�
MBCPSBUJPO�XJUI� UIF�6�NJTUB�$VMUVSBM�4PDJFUZ�
BOE�A/BNHJT�/BUJPO�BOE�HSFX�GSPN�UIFSF�w
$BUIFSJOF� TBZT� NPSF� BUUFOUJPO� JT� CFJOH�
QBJE� UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF� JTTVFT� UPEBZ��&OWJ�
SPONFOUBM�DPOTVMUBUJPO�QSPDFTTFT�BOE�QPMJDZ�
DIBOHFT�IBWF�BSJTFO� UISPVHI�OFHPUJBUJPO�PG�
NPEFSO� USFBUZ � TFMG�HPWFSONFOU � BOE� MBOE�
DMBJNT��4UJMM � MBXT� UIBU� SFHVMBUF�BSDIBFPMPHJ�
DBM � NPWFBCMF � BOE� JOUBOHJCMF� DVMUVSBM� IFSJ�
UBHF� SFNBJO� MBSHFMZ� VODIBOHFE�� 4IF� MPPLT�
GPSXBSE� UP� XPSLJOH� XJUI� GSJFOET� BOE� DPM�
MFBHVFT�JO�#MBDLGPPU �:VLPO �BOE�*OVJU�DPN�
NVOJUJFT� PO� UIFTF� JTTVFT�� i5IBU�T�XIFSF� *�N�
IBQQJFTU��PO�UIF�HSPVOE�MBX�SFGPSN�w
Catherine Bell: A Legal Reformer Bent on Contributing to Solutions for Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage I`�5V]H�7PLYZVU
1SPUFDUJPO� PG� 'JSTU� /BUJPOT� $VMUVSBM� )FSJUBHF�� -BXT �1PMJDZ � BOE� 3FGPSN�� ������ &EJUFE� CZ� $BUIFSJOF� #FMM�SJHIU�BOE�3PCFSU�,��1BUFSTPO�
4 Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage Project
0O�4FQUFNCFS��� ����� �*1JO$)�BOE�UIF�
:PSL� $FOUSF� GPS� 1VCMJD� 1PMJDZ� BOE� -BX�
CSPVHIU�UPHFUIFS�UISFF�*1JO$)�NFNCFST �
Catherine Bell�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�"MCFSUB �Pa-tricia Goff� -BVSJFS�6OJWFSTJUZ� BOE�Rose-mary Coombe�:PSL�6OJWFSTJUZ�UP�EJTDVTT�IPX�*OEJHFOPVT�SJHIUT �JOUFMMFDUVBM�QSPQ�
FSUZ� BOE� IVNBO� SJHIUT� BSF� JOUFSTFDUJOH�
BOE�DIBOHJOH�UIF�EJNFOTJPOT�PG�JOUFSOB�
UJPOBM�MBX�BOE�QPMJDZ�JO�UIF�QSPDFTT��
$BUIFSJOF�#FMM�EJTDVTTFE� UIF�DBTF�PG� UIF�&DIP�.BTL�BOE� UIF�
BUUFNQUT�PG�UIF�/VYBML�/BUJPO�UP�SFQBUSJBUF�BO�JNQPSUBOU�QJFDF�PG�
UIFJS�IFSJUBHF��5IJT�GSVTUSBUJOH�DBTF�JT�FNCMFNBUJD�PG�TPNF�PG�UIF�
DIBMMFOHFT�OPX�GBDJOH�MBXZFST�BOE�QPMJDZ�NBLFST�BT�UIFZ�BUUFNQU�
UP� SFDPODJMF�NPEFSO� DBUFHPSJFT� PG� PXOFSTIJQ� BOE� QSPQFSUZ�XJUI�
NPSF�DPNQMFY�OPUJPOT�PG�DPNNVOJUZ�PXOFSTIJQ �DVMUVSBM�QSPQFSUZ�
BOE�UIF�DVMUVSBM�SJHIU�UP�BDDFTT�BOE�DPOUSPM�POFT�PXO�IFSJUBHF�
*OUFSFTUFE� JO� RVFTUJPOT� PG� HMPCBM� HPWFSOBODF � 1BUSJDJB� (PGG�
EJTDVTTFE�UIF�FGGPSUT�PG�UIF�8PSME�*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�0SHBOJ[B�
UJPO� 8*10� UP� SFBDI�PVU� UP� iOFX�CFOFmDJBSJFTw� JO�BO�BUUFNQU� UP�
mOE�XBZT� UP� SFDPHOJ[F �NBJOUBJO� BOE� QSPUFDU� USBEJUJPOBM� DVMUVSBM�
FYQSFTTJPOT �XIJMF� FOTVSJOH� UIF�HMPCBM� JOUFMMFDUVBM� QSPQFSUZ� TZT�
UFN�SFUBJOT�MFHJUJNBDZ�JO�PVS�DVMUVSBMMZ�QMVSBMJTUJD�TPDJFUZ��)PXFWFS �
BDDPSEJOH� UP�(PGG � UIF�XPSL� PG�8*10� SFNBJOT�DIBMMFOHJOH� TJODF�
JUT�QMBDF�XJUIJO� UIF� MBSHFS�TUSVDUVSF�PG� UIF�HMPCBM�FDPOPNZ�QSPC�
MFNBUJ[FT�GVMM�SFDPHOJUJPO�PG�UIF�JNQPSUBOU�MJOLT�CFUXFFO�USBEJUJPOBM�
LOPXMFEHF �DVMUVSBM�SJHIUT�BOE�DVMUVSBM�SFDPHOJUJPO�
'JOBMMZ �3PTFNBSZ�$PPNCF�SFNJOEFE�UIF�BVEJFODF�UIBU�OFPMJC�
FSBMJTN�JT�OPU�NPOPMJUIJD�� JU�EPFT�IBWF�MJNJUT��4IF�BSHVFE�UIBU�BT�
UIF� SJHJE� MJOFT�CFUXFFO�PME�DBUFHPSJFT�TVDI�BT� iUSBEJUJPO w� iIFSJ�
UBHF w�iDVMUVSFw�BOE�iFDPOPNZw�IBWF�CFDPNF�CMVSSFE �OFX�GPSNT�
PG� DMBJN�NBLJOH� IBWF� CFDPNF� QPTTJCMF � BOE� OFX� PQQPSUVOJUJFT�
IBWF�CFFO�QSPWJEFE� UP� UIPTF�TFFLJOH� SFDPHOJUJPO�CZ� JOTUJUVUJPOT�
UIBU�BU�POF�UJNF�FYDMVEFE�UIFN�
#Z�QSPWJEJOH�B�OFX�DVMUVSBMJTU�SIFUPSJD�UIBU�HSPVOET�QPMJUJDBM�BOE�
QSPQSJFUBSZ�DMBJNT �OFPMJCFSBMJTN�IBT�DSFBUFE�TQBDFT�XIFSF�JOUFM�
MFDUVBM�QSPQFSUZ�DPOUJOVBMMZ�DPMMJEFT�XJUI� JTTVFT�PG�DVMUVSBM� SJHIUT �
*OEJHFOPVT� SJHIUT� UP� TFMG�EFUFSNJOBUJPO � BOE� SJHIUT� UP� SFDPHOJ�
UJPO��5IVT �RVFTUJPOT�TVDI�BT�UIF�POF�HJWFO�OPUPSJFUZ�CZ�.JDIBFM�
#SPXO�8IP� 0XOT� /BUJWF� $VMUVSF �BSF� UVSOJOH� PVU� UP� CF� MFTT�
BCPVU�EPDUSJOBM�MFHBM�SVMFT�BOE�DMBTTJD�QSPQFSUZ�SFMBUJPOT �BOE�NPSF�
BCPVU�DSFBUJOH�TQBDFT�PG�QPMJUJDBM �MFHBM �BOE�DVMUVSBM�OFHPUJBUJPO�
*1JO$)� UFBN�NFNCFS�Murielle Nagy� PSHB�OJ[FE�B�WFSZ�TVDDFTTGVM�GPVS�TFTTJPO�NBSB�
UIPO�PO�*1�BOE�3FTFBSDI�&UIJDT�BU�UIF���UI�
*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF� JO�7BM�E�0S �2V�
CFD�PO�0DUPCFS����BOE��� �������
5IF�mWF�*1JO$)�UFBN�NFNCFST�DPOUSJCVU�
JOH�UP�UIF�TFTTJPOT�JODMVEFE�.VSJFMMF�IFSTFMG�
PO� UIF� DSVDJBM� UPQJD � i"DDFTT� UP�%BUB� BOE�
3FQPSUT�BGUFS�UIF�$PNQMFUJPO�PG�B�3FTFBSDI�
1SPKFDU�w� *1JO$)�4UFFSJOH�$PNNJUUFF�NFN�
CFS�Catherine Bell�QSFTFOUFE�i"DDFTT�UP�BOE�$POUSPM� PWFS� *OGPSNBUJPO� 0SJHJOBUJOH� GSPN�
"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�JO�$BOBEB�w�$BUIF�
SJOF�BMTP�TQPLF�PO�BOPUIFS�WJUBM�UIFNF �i3F�
TQFDU �3JHPVS�BOE�3FTQPOTJCJMJUZ��$PMMBCPSB�
UJWF�&UIJDT�1SBDUJDFT�BOE�UIF�"DBEFNZ�w
*1JO$)�DBTF�TUVEZ�DP�EFWFMPQFS�Natasha Lyons� EJTDVTTFE� i5IF�.JEEMF�(SPVOE��/F�
HPUJBUJOH�UIF�/BUVSF�BOE�0XOFSTIJQ�PG�3F�
TFBSDI�0VUDPNFT� JO�$PMMBCPSBUJWF�1SPKFDUT�
XJUI�"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�w�Daryl Pullman �
#JPBSDIBFPMPHZ � (FOFUJDT� BOE� *1� 8PSLJOH�
(SPVQ�DP�DIBJS �BOE�1SPKFDU�%JSFDUPS�George Nicholas�QSFTFOUFE�PO �i*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE�UIF�&UIJDBM�-FHBM�4UBUVT�PG�)VNBO�%/"��
5IF�*S�3FMFWBODF�PG�$POUFYU�w�
0UIFST� QSFTFOUJOH� JO� UIF� *1� BOE� 3F�
TFBSDI�&UIJDT�TFTTJPOT�XFSF�
t� :WFT�-BCSÒDIF�$PMMÒHF�6OJWFSTJUBJSF�EF�
4BJOU�#POJGBDF�� i/BNF� BOE� 4FMG�SFQSF�
TFOUBUJPO�BNPOH�UIF�-BCSBEPS�*OVJU�.F�
UJT�BOE�UIF�.BOJUPCB�'SBODPQIPOF�.ÏUJT��
5PXBSET�BO�&UIJDT�PG�3FDPODJMJBUJPO w
t� $VOFSB� #VJKT� /BUJPOBM� .VTFVN� PG� &UI�
OPMPHZ �/FUIFSMBOET�BOE�"WJBBKB�3PTJOH�
+BDPCTFO�(SFFOMBOE�/BUJPOBM�.VTFVN��
i3FQBUSJBUJPO�PG�*OEJHFOPVT�,PXMFEHF�BOE�
*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�UP�&BTU�(SFFOMBOE�w
t� &MJTB�)BSU�BOE�8JMMJBN�,PPMBHF�6OJWFSTJUZ�
PG� .BOJUPCB�� i1BTU� 3FTFBSDI� BOE� /FX�
"VEJFODFT��"SF�/FX�(VJEFMJOFT�/FFEFE w
t� 4DPU� /JDLFMT� *OVJU� 5BQJSJJU� ,BOBUBNJ� BOE�
$BUIMFFO� ,OPUTDI�
/BUJPOBM� "CPSJHJ�
OBM� )FBMUI� 0SHBOJ�
[BUJPO � $BOBEB��
i*OVJU�4QFDJmD� 1FS�
TQFDUJWFT� PO� UIF�
5SJ�$PVODJM� 1PMJDZ�
4UBUFNFOU� 3FHBSE�
JOH�&UIJDBM�$POEVDU�
PG�3FTFBSDI�*OWPMWJOH�)VNBOT�*5, �/")0 �
BOE�*OVJU�-BOE�$MBJN�0SHBOJ[BUJPOT�w
t� -FOF� ,JFMTFO� )PMN� *OVJU� $JSDVNQPMBS�
$PVODJM � (SFFOMBOE�� -FOPSF� "�� (SFOP�
CMF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�$IJDBHP�BOE�3PTT�"��
7JSHJOJB� %JDLFZ�$FOUFS� GPS� *OUFSOBUJPOBM�
6OEFSTUBOEJOH � 64"�� i5PXBSE� B� /FX�
3FTFBSDI�&UIJD�GPS�(SFFOMBOE�w
.BOZ� PG� UIFTF� QSFTFOUBUJPOT� BSF� CFJOH�
SFWJTFE�BOE�XJMM�CF�TVCNJUUFE�GPS�UIF������
WPMVNF����o�� PG�²UVEFT�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�PO�*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE�&UIJDT�
.VSJFMMF�/BHZ �%JSFDUPS�BOE�&EJUPS�PG�UIF�+PVSOBM�²UVEFT�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�
IPinCH at the 17th Inuit Studies Conference, Val D’Or, Québec
Negotiating the Spaces of Intellectual Property Under Neoliberalism I`�5PJVSL�(`S^PU
/JDPMF�"ZMXJO �1I�%��4UVEFOU�3FTFBSDI�"TTJTUBOU�
IPinCH Newsletter Vol 2.2 (Winter 2010) 5
*1JO$)� 1PTU�EPDUPSBM� "TTPDJBUF�
Melissa Baird PSHBOJ[FE� B� TFTTJPO�
FOUJUMFE� $SJUJDBM� )FSJUBHF� 4UVEJFT��,OPXMFEHF � *EFOUJUZ� BOE� 1PXFS� GPS�UIF� SFDFOU� "NFSJDBO� "OUISPQPMPHJDBM�
"TTPDJBUJPO� "OOVBM� .FFUJOH� JO� /FX�
0SMFBOT�� "U� JUT� DPSF � DSJUJDBM� IFSJUBHF�
TUVEJFT�FYBNJOF�UIF�TPDJP�QPMJUJDBM�JN�
QMJDBUJPOT�BOE�DPOTFRVFODFT�PG�IFSJ�
UBHF� BOE� BEESFTT� IPX� QPXFS � JEFO�
UJUZ � BOE� LOPXMFEHF� JOUFSTFDU� XJUI� BOE� JOnVFODF� DPOUFNQPSBSZ�
IFSJUBHF�QSBDUJDFT��5IFTF�TUVEJFT�FODPNQBTT�OFX�EJSFDUJPOT�JO�
BOUISPQPMPHZ � NVTFVN� TUVEJFT � GPMLMPSF � IJTUPSZ � FOWJSPONFOUBM�
TUVEJFT�BOE�MBX �BOE�CSJOH�UPHFUIFS�EJWFSTF�EJTDJQMJOBSZ�QFSTQFD�
UJWFT�UIBU�IBWF�QPUFOUJBM�UP�QSPEVDF�OFX�XBZT�PG�UIJOLJOH�BCPVU�
IFSJUBHF��$SJUJDBM�)FSJUBHF�4UVEJFT�BSF�JOUFSFTUFE�JO�IPX�EJGGFSFOU�
TDIPMBST�FOHBHF�XJUI� TJNJMBS�RVFTUJPOT�BOE�IPX� UIFTF�EJWFSTF�
SFTQPOTFT�BEE�UP�PS�DPNQMJDBUF�XIBU�XF�LOPX�PS�UIJOL�XF�LOPX�
BCPVU� IFSJUBHF�� 5IF� EJTDVTTBOU� XBT� IFSJUBHF� TDIPMBS� )FMBJOF�
4JMWFSNBO � BOE� QBOFMJTUT� JODMVEFE� *1JO$)� DPMMFDUJWF� NFNCFST�
Rosemary Coombe�BOE�Anne Pyburn �BOE�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�TDIPMBST�-BVSBKBOF� 4NJUI � 1IJM� 4DIFS � BOE� +PZ� 4BUIFS�8BHTUBGG�� 1BSUJDJ�
QBOUT�XFSF�BTLFE�UP�BOBMZ[F�UIFJS�XPSL�XJUIJO�B�$)4�GSBNFXPSL�
BOE�UP�UIJOL�BCPVU�UIF�XBZT�JO�XIJDI�LOPXMFEHF�BCPVU�IFSJUBHF�
JT�DPOTUJUVUFE� JO� UIFJS�XPSL��5IF�TFTTJPO�XBT�XFMM� SFDFJWFE�BOE�
-BVSBKBOF�4NJUI �XIP�JT�UIF�FEJUPS�PG�UIF�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�+PVSOBM�PG�)FSJUBHF�4UVEJFT �JOWJUFE�#BJSE�UP�TVCNJU�B�TFMFDUJPO�PG�QBQFST�GPS�
TQFDJBM�JTTVF�PG�UIF�KPVSOBM��)FMBJOF�4JMWFSNBO�QMBOT�PO�PSHBOJ[�
JOH�B�GPMMPX�VQ�$)4�TFTTJPO�GPDVTFE�PO�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�TDIPMBST�GPS�
UIF������"""�NFFUJOH�JO�.POUSFBM�
*1JO$)� DP�EFWFMPQFS� Julie Hollowell� SFQ�SFTFOUFE� *1JO$)� JO� B� GPSVN�PSHBOJ[FE�CZ�
"MJDJB�&CCJUU�.D(JMM�UJUMFE �iA4BWJOH�UIF�-PSF��
7FSTJPO���� ��4VTUBJOBCJMJUZ �)FSJUBHF�4UVE�
JFT � $VMUVSBM� 3FWJUBMJ[BUJPO� BOE� %FWFMPQ�
NFOU�w�5IF�GPSVN�CSPVHIU�UPHFUIFS�QFPQMF�
XPSLJOH� JO� IFSJUBHF� DFOUSFT� PS� XJUI�NBKPS�
IFSJUBHF�SFMBUFE� QSPKFDUT� UP� EJTDVTT� UIFJS�
XPSL�� *U� XBT� B� XPOEFSGVM� PQQPSUVOJUZ� GPS�
TIBSJOH �OFUXPSLJOH �BOE�DPNQBSJOH�FYBN�
QMFT�PG�HPPE�QSBDUJDF�JO�UIF�mFME�PG�IFSJUBHF�
TUVEJFT��0UIFS�QBSUJDJQBOUT�JODMVEFE��&MJ[B�
CFUI�$IJMUPO �%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�$FOUFS�GPS�)FSJ�
UBHF�BOE�4PDJFUZ�BU�6.BTT�"NIFSTU��"OUPJ�
OFUUF�+BDLTPO �%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�%FQBSUNFOU�
PG� "OUISPQPMPHZ�T� )FSJUBHF� 3FTFBSDI� -BC�
BU�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�4PVUI�'MPSJEB��1FUFS�4UPOF �
)FBE�PG�4DIPPM�PG�UIF�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�$FOUSF�
GPS� $VMUVSBM� BOE� )FSJUBHF� 4UVEJFT� BU� UIF�
6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�/FXDBTUMF �6,��%BWJE�(BUTCZ �
GPSNFS�"TTJTUBOU�%JSFDUPS�PG� UIF�$FOUFS�GPS�
)FSJUBHF� 3FTPVSDF� 4UVEJFT� BU� UIF� 6OJWFS�
TJUZ�PG�.BSZMBOE��$ISJTUJBO�8FMMT � IFSJUBHF�
UPVSJTN� JO� )POEVSBT�� 3FCFDDB� ;BSHFS �
USBEJUJPOBM� FOWJSPONFOUBM� LOPXMFEHF� BOE�
TDIPPM�DVSSJDVMB�JO�#FMJ[F��BOE�%BO�4VTMBL�
BOE�4FSBmO�$PSPOFM�.PMJOB �XIP�XPSL� UP�
HFUIFS� PO� 2VFDIVB� MBOHVBHF� SFWJUBMJ[B�
UJPO� QSPKFDUT��%JTDVTTJPO� SBOHFE� GSPN� UIF�
CSPBE� TQFDUSVN�PG� QBSUOFSTIJQT� UIBU� IFSJ�
UBHF�QSPKFDUT�PGUFO�FNCSBDF�UP�JOTUJUVUJPOBM�
DIBMMFOHFT�BOE�CBSSJFST�SFMBUFE�UP�CVJMEJOH�
DBQBDJUZ� BU� UIF� DPNNVOJUZ� MFWFM�� &EVDB�
UJPO�XBT�BOPUIFS� LFZ� UPQJD � OPU� KVTU� JO� SF�
HBSE�UP�TUVEFOU�USBJOJOH �CVU�JO�DPOKVODUJPO�
XJUI�FEVDBUJOH�UIF�BDBEFNZ�BOE�GVOEFST �
TVQQPSUJOH� LOPXMFEHF� FYDIBOHF� BNPOH�
ZPVUI�BOE�FMEFST�JO�DPNNVOJUJFT �OFUXPSL�
JOH� BOE� TIBSJOH� TUPSJFT� XJUI� UIPTF� GBDJOH�
TJNJMBS�JTTVFT�B�OFFE�XIJDI�UIF�GPSVN�XBT�
EFTJHOFE� UP�NFFU�� 1BOFMJTUT� FNQIBTJ[FE�
UIF� WFSZ� EJGGFSFOU� NFBOJOHT� PG� iIFSJUBHFw�
BU� MPDBM � OBUJPOBM � BOE� JOUFSOBUJPOBM� MFWFMT�
BOE� UIF�OFDFTTJUZ� PG� USBOTEJTDJQMJOBSZ� BQ�
QSPBDIFT�UP�IFSJUBHF�SFTFBSDI �XJUI� USBOT�
QBSFODZ�BCPVU�XIP�CFOFmUT�BOE�IPX�
"O�*1JO$)�HBUIFSJOH�BU�UIF�#PVSCPO�)PVTF�
PO� #PVSCPO� 4USFFU� JO� /FX� 0SMFBOT� ESFX�
UFBN�NFNCFST �QBSUOFST �BOE�BTTPDJBUFT�UP�
HFUIFS�GPS�TPNF�OFUXPSLJOH��*O�BEEJUJPO �+VMJF�
QPTUFE�PVS�1SPKFDU�&UIOPHSBQIFS�1PTUEPDUPS�
BM�QPTJUJPO�JO�UIF�"""�KPC�QMBDFNFOU�DFOUFS �
NFU� FJHIU� QPUFOUJBM� DBOEJEBUFT � BOE� IFBSE�
GSPN�TFWFSBM�PUIFST�XIP�FYQSFTTFE�JOUFSFTU��
"MM�XFSF�SFDFOU�1I�%�T�XJUI�MPUT�PG�JOUFSFTU�JO�
*1JO$)� BOE� JUT� JOJUJBUJWFT � XIJDI� EPWFUBJMFE�
XJUI�UIFJS�PXO�XPSL�JO�OVNFSPVT�XBZT�
IPinCH at the 2010 AAA Meeting in New OrleansMelissa Baird’s Panel: Critical Heritage Studies: Knowledge, Identity and Power
I`�4LSPZZH�)HPYK�
IPinCH Represented in Heritage Forum / IPinCH AAA Gathering
I`�1\SPL�/VSSV^LSS
.FMJTTB�#BJSE �*1JO$)�1PTU�EPDUPSBM�'FMMPX�"TTPDJBUF
Your Input Needed for Newsletter, Website and Monthly Digest8F�XBOU� UP�SFQSFTFOU� UIF�XJEF�SBOHF�PG� BDUJWJUJFT� PG� UIF� NFNCFST� PG� PVS�*1JO$)� DPMMFDUJWF�� 1MFBTF� TFOE� TIPSU�VQEBUFT�PO�ZPVS�SFTFBSDI �QIPUPT �PS�TVHHFTUJPOT� GPS� PVS� NPOUIMZ� EJHFTU �XFCTJUF �BOE�OFXTMFUUFS�
6 Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage Project
IPinCH Community-based Heritage Research Workshop I`�2LSS`�-V_
0VS� 0DUPCFS�$PNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� )FSJUBHF�3FTFBSDI� 8PSLTIPQ� XBT� BO� PQQPSUVOJUZ�GPS�DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�UFBNT�UP�TIBSF�UIFJS�
OFFET� BOE� FYQFSJFODFT�� "EWJTPS� %BWF�
4UFQIFOTPO�SFnFDUFE �i"MUIPVHI�UIF�XPSL�
TIPQ� IBE� XFMM�SFTQFDUFE� JOUFSOBUJPOBM�
QSPGFTTJPOBM� DVMUVSBM� IFSJUBHF� SFTFBSDI�
FST� JO�BUUFOEBODF � UIJT�XPSLTIPQ�EFNPO�
TUSBUFE� UIBU� *1JO$)� JT� EJTUJODUMZ� CSFBLJOH�
PVU�PG�UIF�NPME�PG�USBEJUJPOBM�TDIPMBSMZ�BOE�
BDBEFNJD�BQQSPBDIFT�UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�
DBTF� TUVEJFT� CZ� JUT� BDUJWF � POHPJOH� FO�
DPVSBHFNFOU� PG� DPNNVOJUZ� QFSTQFDUJWFT�
BOE�QBSUJDJQBUJPO�BU�BMM�TUBHFT�PG�UIF�DBTF�
TUVEZ�QSPDFTT�w�
5IF�XPSLTIPQ�CFHBO�XJUI�B�QSPKFDU�PWFS�
WJFX� GSPN� FBDI� UFBN � HJWJOH� QBSUJDJQBOUT�
BO�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�PG� UIF� SBOHF�PG�FYDJUJOH�
SFTFBSDI� FODPNQBTTFE� CZ� *1JO$)�� -BUFS �
BDBEFNJDT�BOE�DPNNVOJUZ�NFNCFST�TFQ�
BSBUFMZ�EJTDVTTFE�LFZ�SFTFBSDI�JTTVFT��5IF�
HSPVQT�UIFO�SFDPOWFOFE�UP�TFMFDU�UISFF�LFZ�
UPQJDT� GPS� JO�EFQUI� DPOTJEFSBUJPO�� "SJTJOH�
GSPN� DPNNVOJUZ� NFNCFST � UIF� mSTU� JTTVF�
XBT�QBSUJDJQBUJPO�PG�FMEFST�BOE�ZPVUI��5IF�
4NJUITPOJBO�*OVWJBMVJU�7JTJU�BOE�.PSJPSJ�$VM�
UVSBM� %BUBCBTF� DP�EFWFMPQFST� CVJMU� TVDI�
QBSUJDJQBUJPO� JOUP� UIFJS� JOJUJBUJWFT �BOE� UIFZ�
DBO�TFSWF�BT�SFTPVSDFT�GPS�PUIFS�UFBNT�JO�
FBSMZ�TUBHFT�PG�SFTFBSDI�
5IF�TFDPOE�LFZ�UPQJD�XBT�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�
UIF�DVMUVSF�PG�SFTFBSDI�JO�B�DPNNVOJUZ�DPO�
UFYU�� "DBEFNJDT� mOE� JU� DIBMMFOHJOH� UP� HFU�
SFDPHOJUJPO� GPS� UJNF�TQFOU�PO�BDUJWJUJFT�OPU�
USBEJUJPOBMMZ� DPOTJEFSFE� SFTFBSDI � TVDI� BT�
EFWFMPQJOH� BOE� NBJOUBJOJOH� SFMBUJPOTIJQT�
XJUI�DPNNVOJUJFT��5IJT�MFE�UP�B�EJTDVTTJPO�
PO� i8IBU� DPOTUJUVUFT� SFTFBSDI w� $IBSMFT�
"SOPME �SFUJSFE�IFBE�PG�UIF�1SJODF�PG�8BMFT�
/PSUIFSO� )FSJUBHF� $FOUSF � CSPVHIU� VQ� B�
OFX�SFTFBSDI�NPEFM�FYFNQMJmFE�CZ�/PSUI�
FSO�$BOBEJBO� DPNNVOJUJFT� UIBU� QSPEVDFE�
3FRVFTUT� GPS� 1SPQPTBMT� DBMMJOH� PO� BDB�
EFNJDT� UP� DPOTJEFS� DPOEVDUJOH� SFTFBSDI�
GPS� DPNNVOJUJFT�iPVS� SPMF� BT� SFTFBSDI�
FST�NJHIU�CF� UP�TUFQ�CBDL� GSPN�EPJOH� UIF�
IBOET�PO�TUVGG�VOMFTT�XF�SF�JOWJUFE�UP�EP�JU �
BOE�QMBZ�NPSF�PG�<BO>�JOUFSNFEJBSZ�SPMF�w�)F�
XFOU�PO�UP�TBZ�UIBU�UIF�$BOBEJBO�iHPWFSO�
NFOU�IBT�CFFO�NPWJOH�NPSF� UP�XIBU� UIFZ�
DBMM� B� SFTVMUT�CBTFE� QFSGPSNBODF� SFWJFX w�
CSJFnZ� EFmOFE� BT� iMFU�T� GPDVT� PO� HFUUJOH�
UBTLT� EPOF � UIFO� HFUUJOH� SFTVMUT�JO� UIJT�
DBTF � SFTVMUT� JEFOUJmFE� CZ� UIF� *OEJHFOPVT�
HSPVQT�w�$IVDL�JOEJDBUFE�VOJWFSTJUJFT�NJHIU�
BMTP�DPOTJEFS�NPWJOH�JO�UIJT�EJSFDUJPO�
1FSIBQT� UIF�NPTU�QPJHOBOU�VOEFSTUBOE�
JOH�PG�SFTFBSDI�DBNF�GSPN�*OVWJBMVJU�FMEFS�"M�
CFSU�&MJBT��i.Z�XIPMF�FYQFSJFODF�BOE�PCTFS�
WBUJPOT�MJWJOH�PGG�UIF�MBOE�JO�JUTFMG�JT�SFTFBSDI��
8JUIPVU�LOPXJOH� JU � *�XBT� SFTFBSDIJOH�OFX�
UIJOHT��DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�JT�BO�FYBNQMF��&WFSZ�
UJNF�*�XFOU�IPNF �*�UPME�TUPSJFT�BCPVU�UIF�FG�
GFDUT�PG�DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�PO�UIF�XJMEMJGF �BOE�
PO�UIF�FOWJSPONFOU��5P�NF �UIBU�T�SFTFBSDI�w
5IF�LFZ�UIJSE�JTTVF�FYQMPSFE�BU�PVS�XPSL�
TIPQ�BSPTF�GSPN�DPNNVOJUZ�NFNCFST��UIF�
JNQPSUBODF� PG� DPNNVOJDBUJOH� UIF� EJGGFS�
FODF�CFUXFFO� JOEJWJEVBM � DPNNVOJUZ � BOE�
PUIFS� WPJDFT� JO� *1JO$)� XPSL�� 3FQPSUT� PG�
PVS�XPSL�OFFE�UP�FNCFE�BOTXFST�UP�TVDI�
RVFTUJPOT�BT��i'PS�XIPN�BN�*�TQFBLJOH w�
i8IP� IBT� BVUIPSJUZ� UP� TQFBL w� *U� CFDBNF�
DMFBS�XF�OFFE�NPSF�DPOTJEFSBUJPO�PG�7PJDF�
JO�*1JO$)�DPNNVOJDBUJPOT��
#POOJF�/FXTPN �DP�EFWFMPQFS�PG�UIF�1F�
OPCTDPU�/BUJPO�$PNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�*OJUJBUJWF�
TVNNFE�VQ�UIF�XPSLTIPQ �i*�SFBMMZ�BQQSF�
DJBUF� UIF�nVJEJUZ�PG� UIF�BHFOEB�� *U�T� SBSF� JO�
UFSNT�PG�NFFUJOHT�UIBU�XF�DBO�BDUVBMMZ�IBWF�
B�WPJDF�JO�TIBQJOH�XIBU�XF�SF�UBMLJOH�BCPVU��
*�BQQSFDJBUF�FWFSZCPEZ�T�QSPKFDUT�BOE�UIFJS�
DPOUSJCVUJPOT�UP�UIF�QSPDFTT��*�UIJOL�UIFZ�SF�
BMM� FYDJUJOH�� *� KVTU� XBOU� UP� NBLF� TVSF� UIBU�
XF�EPO�U�TFF�UIJOHT�KVTU�UISPVHI�POF�MFOT�w�
#POOJF�T�DPOUSJCVUJPOT�XFSF�FYBDUMZ�UIF�LJOE�
PG�GFFECBDL�UIBU�XJMM�FOTVSF�*1JO$)�VOGPMET�
XJUI�UIF�OFFET�PG�DPNNVOJUJFT�BU�JUT�IFBSU��
8IFO�BTLFE�GPS�TVHHFTUJPOT�UP�JNQSPWF�
*1JO$)� DPNNVOJDBUJPO � QBSUJDJQBOUT� QSP�
WJEFE�B�WBSJFUZ�PG�DPNNFOUT��%BOJFM�(FO�
ESPO�PG�/VOBWJL�T�"WBUBR�$VMUVSBM� *OTUJUVUF�
TBJE � i*O� NZ� OFDL� PG� UIF� UVOESB � *OUFSOFU�
DPOOFDUJPO� JT� OPU� WFSZ� HPPE�� )BSE� DPQZ�
JT�TUJMM �BT�GBS�BT�XF�SF�DPODFSOFE �UIF�CFTU�
XBZ�UP�HFU�UIBU�JOGPSNBUJPO�BDSPTT�w�"MPOH�
XJUI� PUIFS� SFRVFTUT� GPS� TIPSUFS � NPSF� GSF�
RVFOU� DPNNVOJDBUJPOT � UIJT� TQBSLFE� UIF�
SFWJWBM�PG�PVS�NPOUIMZ�EJHFTU��
5IFSF�XFSF�BMTP�TVHHFTUJPOT�GPS�UIF�XFC�
TJUF�� /BUBTIB� -ZPOT � DP�EFWFMPQFS� PG� UIF�
*OVWJBMVJU�DBTF�TUVEZ �TVNNFE�VQ�UIF�GFFM�
JOHT�PG�NBOZ�XJUI � iUIF�TJUF� JT�WFSZ�EFOTF�
BOE�TMJHIUMZ�CVSFBVDSBUJD�w�,BUF�)FOOFTTZ �
BMTP�XPSLJOH�XJUI�UIF�*OVWJBMVJU �BEEFE �iJG�JU�
EPFTO�U�BDUJWFMZ�IFMQ�JO�XIBU�XF�IBWF�UP�EP�
EBZ�UP�EBZ �UIFO�OP�POF�XJMM�UBLF�UIF�UJNF�UP�
HP�TFF�JU�w�
3FTFBSDI�"TTJTUBOU�&NNB�'FMUFT�TIBSFE�
IFS�FYQFSJFODF�PG�QPTUJOH�B�WJEFP �i*O�UIF�
ZFBS�UIBU�*�WF�CFFO�USZJOH�UP�JOUFSBDU�XJUI�UIF�
TJUF �*�UIJOL�JU�IBT�JNQSPWFE�B�MPU��8F�XFSFO�U�
TVSF�UIBU�JU�XBT�HPJOH�UP�XPSL�XJUI�UIF�VTF�
PG�NVMUJNFEJB�BOE�XIFO�XF�CSPVHIU�TPNF�
PG�PVS�DPODFSOT� UP�,FMMZ� <'PY> �BMM�PG� UIFN�
XFSF�BEESFTTFE�w�
5IF�TVHHFTUJPOT� GPS�DIBOHF � UIPVHIUGVM�
TUSBOET�PG�EJTDVTTJPO�PO� JTTVFT� JNQPSUBOU�
UP�NFNCFST�PG�UIF�DPMMFDUJWF �BOE�OFX�VO�
EFSTUBOEJOHT�PG�PVS�SFTFBSDI�UIBU�DPOUJOVF�
HSPXJOH�PVU� PG� PVS�XPSLTIPQ�XJMM� CF� GPSF�
HSPVOEFE�BT�*1JO$)�NPWFT�BIFBE�
4RVBNJTI�/BUJPO�&MEFS�"VESFZ�3JWFST�JT�JOUSPEVDFE�UP�"JOV�UFBN�NFNCFST�M�UP�S�5BUTVP�/JTIJKJNB �)JEFIJLP�,JNVSB �)JSPGVNJ�,BUP�BOE�)JEFLJ�:PTIJIBSB �BOE�PUIFS�QBSUJDJQBOUT�JODMVEJOH�M�UP�S�%BOJFM�(FOESPO �+VMJF�)PMMPXFMM �%BWF�4UFQIFOTPO �BOE�+PBOOF�#JSE �EVSJOH�UIF�XPSLTIPQ�DMPTJOH�DFSFNPOJFT �0DUPCFS��� ������
IPinCH Newsletter Vol 2.2 (Winter 2010) 7
"VTUSBMJBO�CPSO�*BO�.D*OUPTI �1I�%� �JT�UIF�%JSFDUPS�PG�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�1BSUOFSTIJQT�BU�*OEJBOB�6OJWFSTJUZ�
1VSEVF�6OJWFSTJUZ�BU�*OEJBOBQPMJT �XIFSF�IF�JT�BMTP�BO�BEKVODU�QSPGFTTPS�PG�"OUISPQPMPHZ�JO�UIF�4DIPPM�PG�
-JCFSBM�"SUT �UFBDIJOH�DMBTTFT�PO�QFBDF�BOE�SFDPODJMJBUJPO�JO�UIF�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�BSFOB��)F�JT�UIF�"TTPDJBUF�
%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�$POGVDJVT�*OTUJUVUF�XIFSF�UIF�HPBM�JT�UP�CVJME�CSJEHFT�PG�GSJFOETIJQ�BOE�DPNNVOJDBUJPO�
CFUXFFO�UIF�6OJUFE�4UBUFT�BOE�$IJOB��"O�BQQMJFE�BOUISPQPMPHJTU �*BO�JT�B�GPSNFS�.BOBHJOH�%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�
)BSWBSE�CBTFE�*OEJHFOPVT�SJHIUT�PSHBOJ[BUJPO�$VMUVSBM�4VSWJWBM�*OD��*O����� �IJT�XPSL�PO�QPWFSUZ�SFEVDUJPO�
BOE�SFGPSFTUBUJPO�JO�"SNFOJB�SFDFJWFE�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�SFDPHOJUJPO�XJUI�BO�&OFSHZ�(MPCF�"XBSE�GPS�TVTUBJO�
BCJMJUZ��*BO�IBT�QVCMJTIFE�UXP�CPPLT�BOE�NBOZ�BSUJDMFT�PO�*OEJHFOPVT�JTTVFT�HMPCBMMZ �CVU�OPSUIFBTU�"SO�
IFN�-BOE�JO�QBSUJDVMBS��)JT�HSFBU�JOUFSFTU�JT�JO�DPOnJDU�SFTPMVUJPO�BOE�UIF�DPODFQU�PG�SFDPODJMJBUJPO �BOE�JO�
���� �3PUBSZ�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�BXBSEFE�IJN�B�8PSME�1FBDF�'FMMPXTIJQ�BU�$IVMBMPOHLPSO�6OJWFSTJUZ�JO�5IBJMBOE�
"NZ�JT�B�NVMUJ�EJTDJQMJOBSZ�SFTFBSDIFS�XJUI�USBJOJOH�BOE�FYQFSJFODF�JO�CPUI�BSDIBFPMPHZ�BOE�BOUISPQPMPHZ��
*O����� �"NZ�XBT�BXBSEFE�IFS�EPDUPSBUF�UISPVHI�'MJOEFST�6OJWFSTJUZ �4PVUI�"VTUSBMJB��)FS�1I�%��SFTFBSDI�
JOWPMWFE�B�CSPBE�SBOHJOH �JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ�JOWFTUJHBUJPO�PG�UIF�QPJOUT�PG�BHSFFNFOU�BOE�DPOnJDU�CFUXFFO�*O�
EJHFOPVT�QFPQMFT�BOE�UIF�BSDIBFPMPHJDBM�EJTDJQMJOF��"NZ�IBT�DPNQMFUFE�B�(SBEVBUF�$FSUJmDBUF�JO�"QQMJFE�
"OUISPQPMPHZ�UISPVHI�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�8FTUFSO�"VTUSBMJB��'SPN������UP����� �TIF�XBT�FNQMPZFE�JO�WBSJPVT�
BSDIBFPMPHJDBM�BOUISPQPMPHJDBM�SPMFT�BU�UIF�"CPSJHJOBM�-FHBM�3JHIUT�.PWFNFOU�BOE�4PVUI�"VTUSBMJBO�/BUJWF�
5JUMF�4FSWJDFT�JODMVEJOH��3FTFBSDI�0GmDFS �4FOJPS�1SPGFTTJPOBM�0GmDFS�BOE�"DUJOH�.BOBHFS�PG�3FTFBSDI��*O�
SFDFOU�ZFBST�IFS�QSJNBSZ�SPMF�IBT�CFFO�BT�BO�iFYQFSUw�GPS�B�OVNCFS�PG�/BUJWF�UJUMF�DMBJNT��4JODF������"NZ�IBT�CFFO�B�MFDUVSFS�JO�UIF�'MJOEFST�
6OJWFSTJUZ�"SDIBFPMPHZ�%FQBSUNFOU��4IF�DPOUJOVFT�IFS�SFTFBSDI�XJUI�.VSSBZ�BOE�.BMMFF�"CPSJHJOBM�DPNNVOJUJFT�JO�4PVUI�"VTUSBMJB�
3BDIFM�)JSTDI� GPDVTFT� PO� LOPXMFEHF� USBOTMBUJPO� SFMBUFE� UP�"SDUJD� DMJNBUF� DIBOHF� BEBQUBUJPO� QPMJDZ�
EFWFMPQNFOU��)FS�1PTU�EPDUPSBM�QSPKFDU�FOUJUMFE �i4IBSJOH�SFTFBSDI�mOEJOHT�JO�UIF�$BOBEJBO�"SDUJD��"T�
TFTTJOH�UIF�JOUFHSBUJPO�PG�*OVJU�LOPXMFEHF�JO�QPMJDZ�DPNNVOJDBUJPOT�BCPVU�DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�SFMBUFE�GPPE�
JOTFDVSJUZ w�QVSTVFT�UIF�HPBM�PG�GBDJMJUBUJOH�QPMJDZ�NBLJOH�CZ�QSPNPUJOH�HSFBUFS�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�PG�UIF�DB�
QBDJUJFT�PG �BOE�DPOTUSBJOUT�BDUJOH�PO �UIF�HFOFSBM�QVCMJD��8JUI�DPNNVOJUZ�QBSUOFST�JO�UIF�/PSUI �HPWFSO�
NFOU�SFTFBSDIFST �BOE�PUIFS�TDJFOUJTUT �3BDIFM�XJMM�DPOUJOVF�UP���TVQQPSU�DPNNVOJUZ�SFTFBSDI�HSPVQT�
CZ�EFWFMPQJOH�B�XBZ�PG� USBDLJOH� JOGPSNBUJPO�FYDIBOHF � TVDI�BT� MPDBM� BOJNBM�DPVOUT� GSPN�IVOUFST �
USBEJUJPOBM�TUPSJFT�GSPN�FMEFST �PS�TDJFOUJmD�HFOFUJD�WBSJBUJPO�BNPOH�DBSJCPV�LOPXMFEHF��BOE���DPMMBCPSBUF�XJUI�DPNNVOJUZ�SFTFBSDI�
HSPVQT�UP�USBDL�mOEJOHT�GSPN�UIFJS�TUVEJFT�PO�DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�BOE�GPPE�TFDVSJUZ��3BDIFM�DPOUJOVFT�UP�FYQMPSF�UIF�TPDJBM�DPOUFYU�PG�IB[BSE�
FYQFSJFODFT�BU�:PSL�6OJWFSTJUZ �XIJDI�FYUFOET�UIF�(FPHSBQIZ�1I�%��TIF�DPNQMFUFE�BU�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�8FTUFSO�0OUBSJP�
Ian McIntosh, New IPinCH Scholar Associate
Amy Roberts, New IPinCH Scholar Associate
Rachel Hirsch, New IPinCH Post-doctoral Fellow Associate
Sarah Carr-Locke, New IPinCH Graduate Student Associate4BSBI�$BSS�-PDLF�T�1I�%��SFTFBSDI�FYQMPSFT�IPX�"CPSJHJOBM�QFPQMFT��JOUBOHJCMF�IFSJUBHF�BOE�JOUFMMFDUVBM�
QSPQFSUZ�BSF�QSFTFOUFE�JO�QVCMJD�NVTFVNT��4BSBI�mSTU�CFDBNF�JOUFSFTUFE�JO�UIF�UFOTJPOT�CFUXFFO�BSDIBF�
PMPHZ�BOE�*OEJHFOPVT�1FPQMFT�XIJMF�QVSTVJOH�IFS�VOEFSHSBEVBUF�EFHSFF�JO�/BUJWF�4UVEJFT�BOE�"OUISPQPM�
PHZ�BU�5SFOU�6OJWFSTJUZ��4IF�JT�UIBOLGVM�GPS�UIF�QPMJUJDBM�BXBLFOJOH�BOE�DSJUJDBM�BOBMZUJDBM�TLJMMT�TIF�MFBSOFE�
GSPN�QSPGFTTPST�BOE�PUIFS�*OEJHFOPVT�QFPQMF�UIFSF��*O����� �4BSBI�SFDFJWFE�IFS�.�"��GSPN�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�
PG�/PSUIFSO�#SJUJTI�$PMVNCJB�GPS�i4IBSJOH�UIF�1BTU��$PNNVOJUZ�#BTFE�"SDIBFPMPHZ�BOE�"CPSJHJOBM�1FPQMF�
JO�$BOBEB�w�0WFS�UIF�MBTU�GPVS�ZFBST �TIF�IBT�IBE�UIF�QSJWJMFHF�PG�XPSLJOH�BU�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�#SJUJTI�$P�
MVNCJB�T�.VTFVN�PG�"OUISPQPMPHZ �XIFSF�TIF�XJUOFTTFE�$BOBEJBO�BOE�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�DPMMBCPSBUJWF�QSPKFDUT�
XJUI�*OEJHFOPVT�QFPQMFT�BOE�UIFJS�IFSJUBHF��5IJT�FYQFSJFODF �DPVQMFE�XJUI�IFS�JOUFSFTU�JO�NVTFVNT �BS�
DIBFPMPHZ �SFQSFTFOUBUJPO �BOE�*OEJHFOPVT�SJHIUT �MFE�IFS�UP�4'6�BOE�TFOJPS�TVQFSWJTPS�(FPSHF�/JDIPMBT��
Contact Us� www.sfu.ca/ipinch
Project Director
George NicholasOffice: 778-782-5709Fax: 778-782-5666E-mail: [email protected]
Project Manager
Kelly FoxOffice: 778-782-8596Fax: 778-782-5666E-mail: [email protected]
Project Mailing Address
IP Issues in Cultural Heritage ProjectDepartment of ArchaeologySimon Fraser University8888 University DriveBurnaby, British Columbia, Canada V5A 1S6
PinCHes of News
IPinCH Newsletter edited by Kelly Fox & George Nicholas. Contributors: Nicole Aylwin, Melissa Baird, Emma Feltes, Kelly Fox, Julie Hollowell, George Nicholas, Brian Noble and Nova Pierson. Designed by Cheryl Takahashi.
"GUFS�IFS�TUJOU�BT�1SPKFDU�&UIOPHSBQIFS �Jane Anderson�IBT�NPWFE�PO�UP�KPJO�UIF�'BDVMUZ�PG�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�.BTTBDIVTFUUT�
o�"NIFSTU��'PSUVOBUFMZ �TIF�SFUVSOT�UP�UIF�*1JO$)�UFBN �SFDFOUMZ�TFOEJOH�UISFF�QBQFST�UP�QPTU�PO�UIF�*1JO$)�XFCTJUF����B�
%JTDVTTJPO�1BQFS�PO�1SPUPDPMT�XSJUUFO�XJUI�(SFHPSZ�:PVOHJOH�GPS�UIF�$BOBEJBO�1VCMJD�"SU�'VOEFST�1SPGFTTJPOBM�%FWFMPQ�
NFOU�.FFUJOH�PO�"CPSJHJOBM�"SUT� XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF�������� *OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE� UIF�4BGFHVBSEJOH�PG�5SBEJ�UJPOBM�$VMUVSFT��-FHBM�*TTVFT�BOE�1SBDUJDBM�0QUJPOT�GPS�.VTFVNT �-JCSBSJFT�BOE�"SDIJWFT�XSJUUFO�GPS�UIF�8PSME�*OUFMMFDUVBM�
1SPQFSUZ�0SHBOJ[BUJPO�CZ�.PMMZ�5PSTFO�BOE�+BOF�"OEFSTPO�XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF������BOE���B�MJOL�UP�%VLF�6OJWFS�
TJUZ�4DIPPM�PG�-BX�T�$FOUFS� GPS� UIF�4UVEZ�PG� UIF�1VCMJD�%PNBJO �XIFSF�+BOF�T�QBQFS� *OEJHFOPVT�5SBEJUJPOBM�,OPXMFEHF�BOE� *1� DBO� CF� EPXOMPBEFE� VOEFS� B�$SFBUJWF�$PNNPOT� "UUSJCVUJPO�/PO�$PNNFSDJBM�4IBSF� "MJLF� ���� VOQPSUFE� MJDFOTF�
XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF�����
World Archaeological Congress Inter-Congress, Indianapolis, Indiana, June 22-25, 2011*1JO$)�JT�PSHBOJ[JOH�TFWFSBM�TFTTJPOT�GPS�UIF�GPSUIDPNJOH�8PSME�"SDIBFPMPHJDBM�$POHSFTT�8"$�*OUFS�$POHSFTT�PO�i*O�
EJHFOPVT�1FPQMFT�BOE�.VTFVNT��6OSBWFMMJOH�UIF�5FOTJPOT�w�)PTUFE�CZ�*OEJBOB�6OJWFSTJUZ�1VSEVF�6OJWFSTJUZ�*OEJBOBQPMJT�
*616*�BOE�UIF�&JUFMKPSH�.VTFVN�PG�"NFSJDBO�*OEJBOT�BOE�8FTUFSO�"SU �8"$*OEZ�JT�CFJOH�IFME�JO�DPOKVODUJPO�XJUI�UIF�
&JUFMKPSH�.VTFVN�T���UI�"OOVBM�*OEJBO�.BSLFU�BOE�'FTUJWBM �+VOF����BOE�����5IF�*1JO$)�TFTTJPOT�XJMM�GPDVT�PO�JOUFMMFDUVBM�
QSPQFSUZ�JTTVFT�SFMBUJOH�UP�UIF�DPOGFSFODF�UIFNF�
Marina La Salle �4UVEFOU�3FQSFTFOUBUJWF�PO� UIF� *1JO$)�4UFFSJOH�$PNNJUUFF�BOE�8"$�T�+S��3FQSFTFOUBUJWF� GPS�/PSUI�
FSO�"NFSJDB �JT�BMTP�PSHBOJ[JOH�B�TUVEFOU�TFTTJPO�FYQMPSJOH�UIF�SPMFT�PG�TUVEFOUT�JO�BSDIBFPMPHZ �BOUISPQPMPHZ �NVTFVN�
TUVEJFT� BOE� SFMBUFE� mFMET�� 4IPXDBTJOH� UIF� JOOPWBUJWF� BOE� FYDJUJOH� TUVEFOU� SFTFBSDI� VOEFSXBZ� BSPVOE� UIF� HMPCF � UIF�
TFTTJPO� XJMM� CSJOH� TUVEFOUT� BOE� QSPGFTTJPOBMT� UPHFUIFS� UP� TIBSF� JEFBT� BOE� JOTJHIUT� JOUP� UIF� GVUVSF� PG� IFSJUBHF� TUVEJFT�
NMBTBMMF!JOUFSDIBOHF�VCD�DB�
*1JO$)�"EWJTPS�Robert K. Paterson�DP�BVUIPSFE�B�CPPL�UIBU�BQQFBSFE�JO�%FDFNCFS��+BNFT�/BG[JHFS �3PCFSU�1BUFSTPO�BOE�
"MJTPO�%VOEFT�3FOUFMO��i$VMUVSBM�-BX��*OUFSOBUJPOBM �$PNQBSBUJWF �BOE�*OEJHFOPVT�w�$BNCSJEHF�6OJWFSTJUZ�1SFTT��������
"øCPPL�MBVODI�BU�6#$�T�.VTFVN�PG�"OUISPQPMPHZ�XJMM�PDDVS�JO�UIF�4QSJOH�
IPinCH Digest Launched5P�GPTUFS�HSFBUFS�BOE�NPSF�GSFRVFOU�TIBSJOH�PG�JOGPSNBUJPO �B�NPOUIMZ�OFXT�EJHFTU�GPS�NFNCFST�PG�PVS�*1JO$)�DPMMFDUJWF�
XBT� JOJUJBUFE� JO�%FDFNCFS��5P�CF�TVSF�ZPVS� *1JO$)�BDUJWJUJFT�BSF� JODMVEFE� JO� UIF�EJHFTU �TIBSF�ZPVS�TUPSJFT�XJUI�1SPKFDU�
.BOBHFS�,FMMZ�'PY��4VHHFTUJPOT�GPS�OFXTMFUUFS�BOE�XFCTJUF�TUPSJFT�BSF�BMXBZT�XFMDPNF�UPP��.FNCFST�PG�UIF�*1JO$)�DPM�
MFDUJWF �XF�OFFE�UP�IFBS�ZPVS�WPJDFT�