IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS...

8
IPinCH Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage: Theory, Practice, Policy, Ethics *1JO$) XBT DPODFJWFE PG BT B SFTFBSDI QSPK FDU UIBU XPVME JOWFTUJHBUF OPU POMZ UIF OBUVSF PG JOUFMMFDUVBM QSPQFSUZ JTTVFT CVU BMTP UIF XBZ TVDI SFTFBSDI JT DPOEVDUFE $PVQMJOH BDBEFNJD SFTFBSDI XJUI DPNNVOJUZCBTFE JOJUJBUJWFT XPVME ZJFME OFX BOE EFFQFS JO TJHIUT JOUP IPX XIZ BOE VOEFS XIBU DPO EJUJPOT JTTVFT BSPTF DPODFSOJOH JOUFMMFDUVBM QSPQFSUZ XIJMF B SFnFYJWF PSJFOUBUJPO BOE B QSPKFDU FUIOPHSBQIFS XPVME USBDL QSPKFDU EZOBNJDT BOE LOPXMFEHF nPX 5IF DBTF TUVEZ DPNQPOFOU XPVME FOBCMF VT BOE DPN NVOJUZ QBSUOFST UP JEFOUJGZ BU HSPVOE MFWFM UIF JTTVFT DPOGSPOUJOH *OEJHFOPVT BOE PUIFS EFTDFOEBOU DPNNVOJUJFT BU UIF TBNF UJNF PGGFSJOH UIFN SFBM CFOFmUT 0O QBQFS UIJT JT BMM TP TUSBJHIUGPSXBSE 8FMMDSBGUFE UFYU BOE B CVEHFU JO UIF HSBOU QSPQPTBM TFU PVU UIF HPBMT QSPDFTTFT BOE QSPEVDUT PG UIF SFTFBSDI NFUIPEPMPHZ *U XBT UIFO KVTU B NBUUFS PG SFDFJWJOH UIF GVOE JOH BOE QVUUJOH UIJOHT JOUP NPUJPOTJNQMFþ 0G DPVSTF UIF SFBMJUZ XBT B MJUUMF EJGGFSFOU 8F TPPO GPVOE UIBU BMNPTU FWFSZUIJOH UPPL MPOHFS UIBO FYQFDUFE FTQFDJBMMZ UIF DBTF TUVEJFT XIJDI SFRVJSFE UJNF GPS DPNNVOJUZ DPOTVMUBUJPOT BOE BMTP CFDBVTF UIF UZQF PG SFTFBSDI XF QSPQPTFEUSVMZ DPMMBCPSBUJWF XPSL XJUI EFTDFOEBOU DPNNVOJUJFTGBMMT PVUTJEF PG UIF VTVBM SFTFBSDI NPEFM 5IJT NFBOU UIBU JU UPPL DPOTJEFSBCMF UJNF BOE FGGPSU PO FWFSZPOFT QBSUDBTF TUVEZ EFWFMPQFST *1JO$) QSPKFDU NBOBHFS ,FMMZ 'PY BOE VOJWFSTJUZ SFTFBSDI TFSWJDFTUP XPSL PVU FUIJDT SFWJFXT *1 JTTVFT BOE GVOE JOH USBOTGFST "MUIPVHI FWFSZPOF XPSLFE QBUJFOUMZ UP BDDPNQMJTI UIFTF UBTLT JU XBT B TMPX MFBSOJOH QSPDFTT "T QSPKFDU EJSFDUPS * XBT BMTP GSVTUSBUFE CZ UIF TFFNJOH EJTDPO OFDU CFUXFFO 44)3$T BQQSPWBM PG XIBU UIFZ TBX BT DVUUJOHFEHF SFTFBSDI BOE PVS BCJMJUZ UP EP JU HJWFO UIF VOJWFSTJUZT JOUFSQSFUBUJPO PG 44)3$ mOBODJBM SFHVMBUJPOT )PXFWFS PVS FGGPSUT JO QVTIJOH UIF FOWF MPQF SFHBSEJOH VOJWFSTJUZ VOEFSTUBOEJOH PG DSPTTDVMUVSBM DPMMBCPSBUJWF SFTFBSDI JOJUJB UJWFT BSF OPX DPOUSJCVUJOH UP B UZQF PG DSPTT DVMUVSBM VOEFSTUBOEJOH CFUXFFO *1JO$) BOE UIF VOJWFSTJUJFT XF XPSL XJUI "U 4'6 UIJT IBT CFFO BJEFE DPOTJEFSBCMZ CZ ,FMMZ 'PYT FG GPSUT XJUI UIF 3FTFBSDI "DDPVOUJOH BOE 3F TFBSDI 4FSWJDFT PGmDFT BOE CZ OVNFSPVT DPOWFSTBUJPOT XJUI )BM 8FJOCFSH %JSFDUPS PG 3FTFBSDI &UIJDT *OEFFE BGUFS * HBWF B UBML UP UIF 4'6 SFTFBSDI DPNNVOJUZ MBTU ZFBS B NFNCFS PG VOJWFSTJUZ 3FTFBSDI 4FSWJDFT TBJE i/PX * mOBMMZ VOEFSTUBOE XIBU UIJT QSPKFDU JT BCPVUw 5IJT QPJOUT UP PVS DPMMFDUJWF FGGPSUT NPWJOH UIF SFTFBSDI QSPDFTT JO OFX BOE NPSF FGGFDUJWF EJSFDUJPOT *1JO$) JT UPEBZ IFMQJOH DPNNVOJUJFT SF TFBSDIFST BOE PUIFST EFWFMPQ NPSF FRVJ UBCMF BOE DVMUVSBMMZ BQQSPQSJBUF BQQSPBDIFT UP DVMUVSBM IFSJUBHF #VU OP MFTT JNQPSUBOUMZ *1JO$) JT BMTP IFMQJOH VOJWFSTJUJFT CFDPNF BXBSF PG OFX SFTFBSDI NPEFMT UIBU XJMM * IPQF CFDPNF NPSF DPNNPO JO UIF DPNJOH EFDBEF 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL >OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$) /FXTMFUUFS 7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating IP Under Neoliberalism 4 Inuit Studies Conference 4 IPinCH at AAA Meeting 5 Heritage Research Workshop 6 New IPinCH Associates 7 PinCHes of News 8 Project Update from the IPinCH Director *1JO$) $PNNVOJUZ#BTFE )FSJUBHF 3FTFBSDI 8PSLTIPQ QBSUJDJQBOUT BDSPTT GSPN UIF $IJFG +PF .BUIJBT $PNNVOJUZ $FOUSF PO 4LXYXÞNFTI UFSSJUPSZ OFBS 7BODPVWFS $BOBEB 0DUPCFS

Transcript of IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS...

Page 1: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

IPinCHIntellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage:Theory, Practice, Policy, Ethics

*1JO$)�XBT�DPODFJWFE�PG�BT�B�SFTFBSDI�QSPK�

FDU�UIBU�XPVME�JOWFTUJHBUF�OPU�POMZ�UIF�OBUVSF�

PG� JOUFMMFDUVBM� QSPQFSUZ� JTTVFT � CVU� BMTP� UIF�

XBZ� TVDI� SFTFBSDI� JT� DPOEVDUFE��$PVQMJOH�

BDBEFNJD� SFTFBSDI� XJUI� DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�

JOJUJBUJWFT� XPVME� ZJFME� OFX� BOE� EFFQFS� JO�

TJHIUT� JOUP� IPX � XIZ � BOE� VOEFS� XIBU� DPO�

EJUJPOT� JTTVFT� BSPTF� DPODFSOJOH� JOUFMMFDUVBM�

QSPQFSUZ � XIJMF� B� SFnFYJWF� PSJFOUBUJPO� BOE�

B� QSPKFDU� FUIOPHSBQIFS�XPVME� USBDL� QSPKFDU�

EZOBNJDT� BOE� LOPXMFEHF� nPX�� 5IF� DBTF�

TUVEZ�DPNQPOFOU�XPVME�FOBCMF�VT�BOE�DPN�

NVOJUZ� QBSUOFST� UP� JEFOUJGZ � BU� HSPVOE� MFWFM �

UIF�JTTVFT�DPOGSPOUJOH�*OEJHFOPVT�BOE�PUIFS�

EFTDFOEBOU�DPNNVOJUJFT �BU� UIF�TBNF� UJNF�

PGGFSJOH�UIFN�SFBM�CFOFmUT��

0O� QBQFS� UIJT� JT� BMM� TP� TUSBJHIUGPSXBSE��

8FMM�DSBGUFE� UFYU�BOE�B�CVEHFU� JO� UIF�HSBOU�

QSPQPTBM� TFU�PVU� UIF�HPBMT �QSPDFTTFT �BOE�

QSPEVDUT� PG� UIF� SFTFBSDI� NFUIPEPMPHZ�� *U�

XBT�UIFO�KVTU�B�NBUUFS�PG�SFDFJWJOH�UIF�GVOE�

JOH�BOE�QVUUJOH� UIJOHT� JOUP�NPUJPO�TJNQMFþ�

0G� DPVSTF � UIF� SFBMJUZ� XBT� B� MJUUMF� EJGGFSFOU��

8F� TPPO� GPVOE� UIBU� BMNPTU� FWFSZUIJOH� UPPL�

MPOHFS� UIBO� FYQFDUFE � FTQFDJBMMZ� UIF� DBTF�

TUVEJFT �XIJDI� SFRVJSFE� UJNF� GPS�DPNNVOJUZ�

DPOTVMUBUJPOT �BOE�BMTP�CFDBVTF�UIF�UZQF�PG�

SFTFBSDI� XF� QSPQPTFE�USVMZ� DPMMBCPSBUJWF�

XPSL� XJUI� EFTDFOEBOU� DPNNVOJUJFT�GBMMT�

PVUTJEF�PG�UIF�VTVBM�SFTFBSDI�NPEFM��

5IJT�NFBOU� UIBU� JU� UPPL�DPOTJEFSBCMF� UJNF�

BOE� FGGPSU� PO� FWFSZPOF�T� QBSU�DBTF� TUVEZ�

EFWFMPQFST � *1JO$)� QSPKFDU� NBOBHFS� ,FMMZ�

'PY � BOE� VOJWFSTJUZ� SFTFBSDI� TFSWJDFT�UP�

XPSL�PVU�FUIJDT�SFWJFXT �*1�JTTVFT �BOE�GVOE�

JOH� USBOTGFST�� "MUIPVHI� FWFSZPOF� XPSLFE�

QBUJFOUMZ�UP�BDDPNQMJTI�UIFTF�UBTLT �JU�XBT�B�

TMPX�MFBSOJOH�QSPDFTT��"T�QSPKFDU�EJSFDUPS �*�

XBT�BMTP� GSVTUSBUFE�CZ� UIF�TFFNJOH�EJTDPO�

OFDU�CFUXFFO�44)3$�T�BQQSPWBM�PG�XIBU�UIFZ�

TBX�BT�DVUUJOH�FEHF�SFTFBSDI�BOE�PVS�BCJMJUZ�

UP�EP�JU�HJWFO�UIF�VOJWFSTJUZT��JOUFSQSFUBUJPO�

PG�44)3$�mOBODJBM�SFHVMBUJPOT��

)PXFWFS �PVS�FGGPSUT�JO�QVTIJOH�UIF�FOWF�

MPQF� SFHBSEJOH� VOJWFSTJUZ� VOEFSTUBOEJOH� PG�

DSPTT�DVMUVSBM� DPMMBCPSBUJWF� SFTFBSDI� JOJUJB�

UJWFT�BSF�OPX�DPOUSJCVUJOH�UP�B�UZQF�PG�DSPTT�

DVMUVSBM�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�CFUXFFO�*1JO$)�BOE�

UIF�VOJWFSTJUJFT�XF�XPSL�XJUI��"U�4'6�UIJT�IBT�

CFFO�BJEFE�DPOTJEFSBCMZ�CZ�,FMMZ� 'PY�T� FG�

GPSUT�XJUI�UIF�3FTFBSDI�"DDPVOUJOH�BOE�3F�

TFBSDI� 4FSWJDFT� PGmDFT � BOE� CZ� OVNFSPVT�

DPOWFSTBUJPOT�XJUI�)BM�8FJOCFSH �%JSFDUPS�PG�

3FTFBSDI�&UIJDT��*OEFFE �BGUFS�*�HBWF�B�UBML�

UP� UIF�4'6�SFTFBSDI�DPNNVOJUZ� MBTU�ZFBS �B�

NFNCFS� PG� VOJWFSTJUZ� 3FTFBSDI� 4FSWJDFT�

TBJE � i/PX� *� mOBMMZ� VOEFSTUBOE� XIBU� UIJT�QSPKFDU�JT�BCPVU�w�5IJT�QPJOUT�UP�PVS�DPMMFDUJWF�

FGGPSUT�NPWJOH�UIF�SFTFBSDI�QSPDFTT� JO�OFX�

BOE�NPSF�FGGFDUJWF�EJSFDUJPOT��

*1JO$)� JT� UPEBZ�IFMQJOH�DPNNVOJUJFT � SF�

TFBSDIFST � BOE� PUIFST� EFWFMPQ� NPSF� FRVJ�

UBCMF�BOE�DVMUVSBMMZ�BQQSPQSJBUF�BQQSPBDIFT�

UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF��#VU �OP�MFTT�JNQPSUBOUMZ �

*1JO$)� JT� BMTP� IFMQJOH� VOJWFSTJUJFT� CFDPNF�

BXBSF� PG� OFX� SFTFBSDI� NPEFMT� UIBU� XJMM � *�

IPQF �CFDPNF�NPSF�DPNNPO�JO�UIF�DPNJOH�

EFDBEF�

1

>OH[»Z� 0UZPKL>OH[»Z � 0UZPKL

*1JO$)�/FXTMFUUFS�7PM�����8JOUFS�����

IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2IPinCH Citations 2Catherine Bell Profile 3Negotiating IP Under Neoliberalism 4Inuit Studies Conference 4IPinCH at AAA Meeting 5Heritage Research Workshop 6New IPinCH Associates 7PinCHes of News 8

Project Update from the IPinCH Director

*1JO$)�$PNNVOJUZ�#BTFE�)FSJUBHF�3FTFBSDI�8PSLTIPQ�QBSUJDJQBOUT�BDSPTT�GSPN�UIF�$IJFG�+PF�.BUIJBT�$PNNVOJUZ�$FOUSF �PO�4LXYX�NFTI�UFSSJUPSZ�OFBS�7BODPVWFS �$BOBEB �0DUPCFS��� ������

Page 2: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

2 Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage Project

8FMDPNF� UP� UIF�OFX� *1JO$)�WJEFP� JOJUJBUJWFþ�5IBOLT� UP� UIF�FG�

GPSUT�PG�+VMJF�)PMMPXFMM �4UFQIFO�-PSJOH �BOE�$MBJSF�4NJUI�PG�UIF�

8PSME� "SDIBFPMPHJDBM� $POHSFTT � BOE� UIF� $PMMBCPSBUJPO � 3FMB�

UJPOTIJQ �BOE�$BTF�4UVEZ� $3$4�8PSLJOH�(SPVQ � *1JO$)�IBT�

CFFO�BQQSPWFE�UP�QSPWJEF�UXP�'MJQ�WJEFP�DBNFSBT�UP�FBDI�DBTF�

TUVEZ�HSPVQ��5IJT� JOJUJBUJWF�XJMM�QSPWJEF� UIF�PQQPSUVOJUZ� UP� UBLF�

DSPTT�QSPKFDU� DPNNVOJDBUJPO� BOE� DPMMBCPSBUJPO� JOUP� OFX� NF�

EJB�TIBSJOH�SFTFBSDI�FYQFSJFODFT �LOPXMFEHF �QSPHSFTT �BOE�

HFOFSBUJOH�EJTDVTTJPO�JO�OFX�JOUFSBDUJWF�BOE�DSFBUJWF�GPSVNT�

$PNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� JOJUJBUJWF�DBTF� TUVEZ� UFBNT� BSF� JOWJUFE� UP�

TIPPU�WJEFP�DMJQT�UIBU�DIBSBDUFSJ[F�PS�TQFBL�UP�UIFJS�QSPKFDUT �BTL�

RVFTUJPOT�PS� SFnFDU�PO� MFBSOJOH�BSPVOE�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�BOE� JO�

UFMMFDUVBM�QSPQFSUZ�JTTVFT �BOE�XFBWF�UISFBET�BDSPTT�UIF�QSPKFDU��

5IFTF�WJEFPT�XJMM� TIJOF�B�TQPUMJHIU�PO� JOTQJSJOH�BOE�DIBMMFOHJOH�

TUPSJFT�GSPN�XJUIJO�UIF�DBTF�TUVEJFT �PQFO�VQ�JOUFSDIBOHF�CFUXFFO�

FBDI�PUIFS�T�QSPKFDUT �BOE�TUSFOHUIFO�SFMBUJPOTIJQT�BDSPTT�*1JO$)�

5IF�$3$4�8PSLJOH�(SPVQ�IBT�QVCMJTIFE�B�QJMPU�WJEFP�GPDVT�

JOH�PO������0MZNQJD�PQFOJOH�DFSFNPOJFT�BT�B�XFC� GPSVN�PO�

UIF� *1JO$)�TJUF��(P� UP� i'PSVNTw� XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF�����

UP� DIFDL� PVU� UIJT� FYBNQMF� PG� UIF� LJOE� PG� WJEFP� VOEFSUBLJOHT�

UIBU�NJHIU�CF�JODMVEFE�JO�UIF�JOJUJBUJWF�y�BOE�GFFM�GSFF�UP�MFBWF�B�

DPNNFOU�XIJMF�ZPV�SF� UIFSF �DPOUSJCVUJOH� UP�OFX�DSPTT�QSPKFDU�

EJBMPHVFþ

$BTF�TUVEZ� UFBNT�XJMM�NBJOUBJO� GVMM� JOUFMMFDUVBM�BOE�DSFBUJWF�

BVUIPSJUZ�PWFS�XIBU�UIFZ�TIPPU�BOE�TIBSF �BOE�IPX�UIFZ�DIPPTF�

UP�VTF� UIF�WJEFPT� JO� SFMBUJPO� UP� UIFJS�PXO�QSPKFDUT��.FBOXIJMF �

B�WBSJFUZ�PG�WJEFP�QVCMJTIJOH�PQUJPOT�XJMM�CF�NBEF�BWBJMBCMF�BT�

EJGGFSFOU�GBDFUT�PG�*1JO$)�VOGPME �BOE�XF�MPPL�GPSXBSE�UP�NBLJOH�

VTF�PG�UIFTF�DIBOOFMT�UP�MFBSO�DPMMFDUJWFMZ�GSPN�UIF�FYQFSJFODFT�

PG�DBTF�TUVEZ�EFWFMPQFST�

,FFQ� QPTUFE� GPS� GVSUIFS� EFUBJMT� PO� UIJT� JOJUJBUJWF � PS� FNBJM�

$3$4�SFTFBSDI�BTTJTUBOU �&NNB�'FMUFT�BU�FSGFMUFT!HNBJM�DPN�

Announcing the Brand New IPinCH Flip Video InitiativeI`�,TTH�-LS[LZ�HUK�)YPHU�5VISL

Catherine Bell, Rosemary Coombe and Patricia Goff. i*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ� BOE� *OEJHFOFJUZ�� *OUFSOBUJPOBM� 1PMJDZ� .BLJOH� CFUXFFO�

/FPMJCFSBMJTN�BOE�)VNBO�3JHIUT�w�"�3PVOEUBCMF�BU�UIF�:PSL�$FO�

USF� GPS�1VCMJD�1PMJDZ�BOE� UIF�-BX��5PSPOUP �4FQUFNCFS��� �������

XXX�JQPTHPPEF�DB���������JOUFSTFDUJPOT�OFHPUJBUJOH�UIF�TQBD�

FT�PG�JOUFMMFDUVBM�QSPQFSUZ�VOEFS�UIF�DPOEJUJPOT�PG�OFPMJCFSBMJTN�

Murielle Nagy. i*1�BOE�3FTFBSDI�&UIJDT�w�4FTTJPO�PSHBOJ[FS ���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS������ �������

Murielle Nagy. i"DDFTT�UP�%BUB�BOE�3FQPSUT�"GUFS�UIF�$PNQMFUJPO�

PG�B�3FTFBSDI�1SPKFDU�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�

$POGFSFODF�JO�7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������

Catherine Bell. i"DDFTT�UP�BOE�$POUSPM�PWFS�*OGPSNBUJPO�0SJHJOBU�

JOH�GSPN�"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�JO�$BOBEB�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�

UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� �

�����

Natasha Lyons. i5IF�.JEEMF�(SPVOE��/FHPUJBUJOH� UIF�/BUVSF�BOE�

0XOFSTIJQ�PG�3FTFBSDI�0VUDPNFT� JO�$PMMBCPSBUJWF�1SPKFDUT�XJUI�

"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVE�

JFT�$POGFSFODF�JO�7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������

Daryl Pullman and George Nicholas. i*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE�UIF�&UIJDBM�-FHBM�4UBUVT�PG�)VNBO�%/"��5IF� *S�3FMFWBODF�PG�$PO�

UFYU�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�

E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������

Catherine Bell. i3FTQFDU �3JHPVS�BOE�3FTQPOTJCJMJUZ��$PMMBCPSBUJWF�&UIJDT�1SBDUJDFT�BOE�UIF�"DBEFNZ�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�UIF���UI�

*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF �7BM�E�0S �2VFCFD �0DUPCFS��� ������

George Nicholas. i*1JO$)�"DUJWJUJFT�JO������w�#$�"SDIBFPMPHZ�'P�SVN��.VTRVFBN�/BUJPO�5FSSJUPSZ �/PWFNCFS�� ������

George Nicholas. i&TTFOUJBM�5FOTJPOT�JO�"SDIBFPMPHJDBM�5IFPSZ�BOE�1SBDUJDF�w�4UBOGPSE�6OJWFSTJUZ�"SDIBFPMPHZ�8PSLTIPQ�4FSJFT �/P�

WFNCFS��� ������

Julie Hollowell��%JTDVTTBOU�GPS�iA4BWJOH�UIF�-PSF��7FSTJPO���� ��4VT�UBJOBCJMJUZ � )FSJUBHF� 4UVEJFT � $VMUVSBM� 1SFTFSWBUJPO� BOE� %FWFMPQ�

NFOU�w�"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �/FX�0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� ������

Melissa Baird��i$SJUJDBM�)FSJUBHF�4UVEJFT��,OPXMFEHF �*EFOUJUZ�BOE�1PXFS�w�4FTTJPO�DIBJS�BOE�PSHBOJ[FS �"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �/FX�

0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� ������

Melissa Baird�� iA8JUI� 4USFOHUI� PG� 5POHVF� BT�8FMM� BT� 4USFOHUI� PG�

)BOE���$PMPOJBM�4USVDUVSFT �*OEJHFOPVT�$VMUVSBM�-BOETDBQFT �BOE�

UIF�1PMJUJDT�PG�)FSJUBHF�w�1BQFS�QSFTFOUFE�BU�"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �

/FX�0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� ������

Rosemary Coombe��i1SPQFSUZ�'PSNT�BOE�)FSJUBHF�1PMJUJDT�w�1BQFS�

QSFTFOUFE�BU�"""�"OOVBM�.FFUJOH �/FX�0SMFBOT �/PWFNCFS��� �

�����

Lena Mortensen and George Nicholas�� ������ i3JEJOH� UIF� 5PVSJTN�

5SBJO ��/BWJHBUJOH�*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ �)FSJUBHF�BOE�$PNNVOJ�

UZ�#BTFE�"QQSPBDIFT�UP�$VMUVSBM�5PVSJTN�w�"OUISPQPMPHZ�/FXT���� � QQ�� ��o���� IUUQ���POMJOFMJCSBSZ�XJMFZ�DPN�EPJ���������

K����������������������Y�BCTUSBDU

IUUQ���XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF����

A Sampling of Recent IPinCH Presentations and Publications

Page 3: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

IPinCH Newsletter Vol 2.2 (Winter 2010) 3

) SPN� CFIJOE�UIF�TDFOFT� QMBOOJOH� UP�

UIF�GSPOUMJOFT�PG�DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�SF�

TFBSDI �$BUIFSJOF�#FMM�T� JOWPMWFNFOU�

XJUI� *1JO$)�DPOUJOVFT� UP� HSPX��"�6OJWFSTJUZ�

PG� "MCFSUB� MBX� QSPGFTTPS � $BUIFSJOF� CSJOHT�

FYQFSUJTF�JO�*OEJHFOPVT�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�MBX�

BOE� JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ�DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� MFHBM�

SFTFBSDI�UP�UIF�*1JO$)�QSPKFDU��"T�B�4UFFSJOH�

$PNNJUUFF�NFNCFS �TIF�IFMQT�HVJEF�QSPKFDU�

QSJPSJUJFT �GVOEJOH�BOE�PVUSFBDI��"OE�BT�B�DP�

EFWFMPQFS � TIF� IFMQT� *OEJHFOPVT� PSHBOJ[B�

UJPOT�EFWFMPQ�UIFJS�PXO�SFTFBSDI�QSPQPTBMT�

4FFJOH�*1JO$)�EFWFMPQ�IBT�CFFO�iB�HSFBU�

MFBSOJOH� FYQFSJFODF� BOE� PQQPSUVOJUZ� UP� VO�

EFSTUBOE�NPSF�BCPVU� UIF� JOUFSGBDF�PG� *1�BOE�

*OEJHFOPVT�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF w�TBZT�$BUIFSJOF��

*U� JT�BMTP�B�DIBMMFOHJOH�QSPDFTT��i8F�SF�DPO�

TUBOUMZ�NFEJBUJOH�CFUXFFO�XIBU�UIF�OFFET�BSF�

BU� UIF� DPNNVOJUZ� MFWFM� UP� EP� SFTFBSDI � BOE�

XIBU� UIF�OFFET�BSF�BU� UIF�VOJWFSTJUZ� MFWFM� UP�

EP�SFTFBSDI�w

*1JO$)�T� DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� SFTFBSDI�

DPNQPOFOU�NFUIPEPMPHZ�XBT� JOnVFODFE� CZ�

$BUIFSJOF�T� i1SPUFDUJPO� BOE� 3FQBUSJBUJPO� PG�

'JSTU�/BUJPO�$VMUVSBM�)FSJUBHFw �B� UFO�ZFBS� JO�

UFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ � DPMMBCPSBUJWF� SFTFBSDI� JOJUJB�

UJWF�JOWPMWJOH�'JSTU�/BUJPO�QBSUOFST�JO�8FTUFSO�

$BOBEB � JODMVEJOH� UIF� #MBDLGPPU�� "NPOH� JUT�

PVUDPNFT�XFSF�UXP�CPPLT��'JSTU�/BUJPOT�$VM�UVSBM�)FSJUBHF�BOE�-BX��$BTF�4UVEJFT �7PJDFT�BOE� 1FSTQFDUJWFT� XJUI� 7BM� /BQPMFPO�� BOE�'JSTU�/BUJPOT�$VMUVSBM�)FSJUBHF�BOE�-BX��3FD�PODJMJBUJPO�BOE�3FGPSN�XJUI�3PCFSU�1BUFSTPO��

5IF�QSPKFDU�BMTP�CSPVHIU�UP�MJHIU�BSFBT�OFFE�

JOH�NPSF�SFTFBSDI �MFBEJOH�(FPSHF�/JDIPMBT �

,FMMZ�#BOOJTUFS �BOE�+VMJF�)PMMPXFMM� UP� GVSUIFS�

FYQMPSF� IPX� BSDIBFPMPHJDBMMZ� EFSJWFE� JOGPS�

NBUJPO� mUT� XJUI� *OEJHFOPVT� QFSTQFDUJWFT� PO�

DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�BOE�MBX �BOE�VMUJNBUFMZ�UP�UIF�

*1JO$)�QSPKFDU�

'PS�*1JO$) �$BUIFSJOF�JT�BHBJO�QBSUOFSJOH�

XJUI�UIF�1JJLBOJ�/BUJPO�BOE�#MPPE�5SJCF�PG�UIF�

#MBDLGPPU�$POGFEFSBDZ��5IF�i,BJOJTJOOJw�JOJ�

UJBUJWF�MPPLT�BU�IPX�#MBDLGPPU�LOPXMFEHF�JT�

JODPSQPSBUFE�BOE�QSPUFDUFE�JO� MFHBMMZ�NBO�

EBUFE�HPWFSONFOU� DPOTVMUBUJPO� QPMJDZ� QSP�

DFTTFT�� i5IF� GVOEBNFOUBM� RVFTUJPO� JT� IPX�

UP� FNQMPZ� #MBDLGPPU� USBEJUJPOBM� LOPXMFEHF�

JO�UIF�DPOTVMUBUJPO�QSPDFTT�UP�NBLF�JU�NPSF�

NFBOJOHGVM�BOE�BU�UIF�TBNF�UJNF�QSPUFDU�UIF�

LOPXMFEHF�UIBU�JT�CFJOH�TIBSFE�GSPN�QVCMJD�

BDDFTT�PS�JNQSPQFS�VTF w�TBZT�$BUIFSJOF�

4IF� JT� BMTP� POF� PG� UIF� EFWFMPQFST� PG� B�

QSPQPTBM�XJUI� UISFF� :VLPO� 'JSTU� /BUJPOT�� UIF�

$IBNQBHOF� BOE� "JTIJIJL� 'JSTU� /BUJPOT � UIF�

$BSDSPTT�5BHJTI� 'JSTU� /BUJPO � BOE� UIF� 5B�BO�

,XÊDI�ÊO� $PVODJM�� 5IBU� TUVEZ� XJMM� FYBNJOF�

IPX�'JSTU�/BUJPOT�WBMVFT�BOE�DVMUVSF�BSF�DPO�

TJEFSFE�JO�DVMUVSBM�NBOBHFNFOU�EFDJTJPOT �PO�

UIFJS�MBOET�BOE�VOEFS�UIFJS�DPOUSPM �BT�XFMM�BT�

CZ� UFSSJUPSJBM � QSPWJODJBM � BOE� GFEFSBM� HPWFSO�

NFOUT��"T� JO�IFS�PUIFS�XPSL �$BUIFSJOF�BJNT�

UP� SFDPODJMF�PGUFO�EJGGFSJOH�8FTUFSO�BOE�"C�

PSJHJOBM�DPODFQUT�BCPVU�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF��4IF�

TBZT �i*O�BMM�UIF�BSFBT�*�XPSL�JO �UIF�MBX�JT�EBUFE�

PS�EPFTO�U�UBLF�JOUP�BDDPVOU�"CPSJHJOBM�SJHIUT�w

$BUIFSJOF� BMTP� BTTJTUFE� UIF� "UBWBR� $VM�

UVSBM�*OTUJUVUF�JO�EFWFMPQJOH�UIFJS�DBTF�TUVEZ�

QSPKFDU� FYQMPSJOH� UIF� SPMF� UIF�/VOBWJNNJVU�

QMBZ� JO� DVMUVSBM� UPVSJTN� JO� /VOBWJL � BOE�

XIFUIFS� UIF� SFTQPOTJCMF� EFWFMPQNFOU� UIFZ�

FOWJTJPO�JT�CFJOH�SFBMJ[FE�

"T�TIF�TQFOET�UJNF�BXBZ�GSPN�UFBDIJOH�UP�

GPDVT�PO�SFTFBSDI �$BUIFSJOF�T�QMBUF�SFNBJOT�

GVMM��4IF�IBT�GBDJMJUBUFE�XPSLTIPQT�BOE�HJWFO�

UBMLT� PO� MBX� SFGPSN�BOE� *OEJHFOPVT� DVMUVSBM�

IFSJUBHF� JTTVFT�BDSPTT�$BOBEB�BOE�BCSPBE �

JODMVEJOH�BT�B�WJTJUJOH�TDIPMBS�BU�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�

PG�"CFSEFFO �4DPUMBOE��*O�+BOVBSZ����� �TIF�

DPOOFDUFE�XJUI�MFHBM�DPMMFBHVFT�GSPN�BSPVOE�

UIF� XPSME� PO� JTTVFT� PG� USBEF� JO� *OEJHFOPVT�

DVMUVSBM� IFSJUBHF� BU� B� XPSLTIPQ� JO� -VDFSOF �

4XJU[FSMBOE��*O�UIF�TQSJOH �TIF�XJMM�TQFBL�PO�

DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�BOE�JEFOUJUZ�JTTVFT�BU�B�XPSL�

TIPQ�PO�*OEJHFOPVT�1FPQMFT�PG�4PVUI�"NFSJ�

DB�BU�UIF�)FCSFX�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�+FSVTBMFN�

$BUIFSJOF�TFFT�B�DIBMMFOHF�OPU�VOJRVF�UP�

$BOBEB�� CSJEHJOH� 8FTUFSO� TFQBSBUJPOT� CF�

UXFFO�UBOHJCMF�BOE�JOUBOHJCMF �BOE�QSPQFSUZ�

BOE�IVNBO�SJHIUT�JO�MBX�SFGPSN��i*OEJHFOPVT�

QFPQMF�EP�OPU�BMXBZT�SFMBUF�UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJ�

UBHF� JO� UIF� XBZ� 8FTUFSO� MBXT� BOE� QFPQMF�

EP w�TIF�TBZT��

$BUIFSJOF�XBT�ESBXO�UP�*OEJHFOPVT�MFHBM�

JTTVFT�JO�IFS�ZPVUI �BGUFS�PCTFSWJOH�UIF�USFBU�

NFOU�PG�VSCBO�"CPSJHJOBM�QFPQMF��-BUFS �TIF�

TBX�JOUFMMFDUVBM�DIBMMFOHFT�JO�IVNBO�SJHIUT�

BOE�TPDJBM�KVTUJDF�EJNFOTJPOT �BOE�PQQPSUV�

OJUJFT�GPS�DIBOHF�BOE�EJWFSTF�JOUFSQSFUBUJPOT�

JO�$BOBEB�T�FNCSZPOJD�MBX��"CPSJHJOBM�BOE�

USFBUZ� SJHIUT�XFSF� POMZ� SFDPHOJ[FE� JO� �����

XJUI�UIF�TJHOJOH�PG�UIF�$POTUJUVUJPO�

"T� *OEJHFOPVT�DPOUSPM�PWFS�DVMUVSBM�IFSJ�

UBHF�CFDBNF�B�NPSF�QSPNJOFOU�JOUFSOBUJPO�

BM� JTTVF � 'JSTU� /BUJPO� DPNNVOJUZ�NFNCFST�

TPVHIU� $BUIFSJOF� PVU� XJUI� SFQBUSJBUJPO� BOE�

BDDFTT�JTTVFT��i"MM�UIBU�UFNQUFE�NF�UP�MPPL�

BU�TPNF�PG�UIF�MFHBM�SBNJmDBUJPOT��*�EFDJEFE�

UP�EP�TPNFUIJOH�BCPVU�JU��*U�CFHBO�XJUI�B�DPM�

MBCPSBUJPO�XJUI� UIF�6�NJTUB�$VMUVSBM�4PDJFUZ�

BOE�A/BNHJT�/BUJPO�BOE�HSFX�GSPN�UIFSF�w

$BUIFSJOF� TBZT� NPSF� BUUFOUJPO� JT� CFJOH�

QBJE� UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF� JTTVFT� UPEBZ��&OWJ�

SPONFOUBM�DPOTVMUBUJPO�QSPDFTTFT�BOE�QPMJDZ�

DIBOHFT�IBWF�BSJTFO� UISPVHI�OFHPUJBUJPO�PG�

NPEFSO� USFBUZ � TFMG�HPWFSONFOU � BOE� MBOE�

DMBJNT��4UJMM � MBXT� UIBU� SFHVMBUF�BSDIBFPMPHJ�

DBM � NPWFBCMF � BOE� JOUBOHJCMF� DVMUVSBM� IFSJ�

UBHF� SFNBJO� MBSHFMZ� VODIBOHFE�� 4IF� MPPLT�

GPSXBSE� UP� XPSLJOH� XJUI� GSJFOET� BOE� DPM�

MFBHVFT�JO�#MBDLGPPU �:VLPO �BOE�*OVJU�DPN�

NVOJUJFT� PO� UIFTF� JTTVFT�� i5IBU�T�XIFSF� *�N�

IBQQJFTU��PO�UIF�HSPVOE�MBX�SFGPSN�w

Catherine Bell: A Legal Reformer Bent on Contributing to Solutions for Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage I`�5V]H�7PLYZVU

1SPUFDUJPO� PG� 'JSTU� /BUJPOT� $VMUVSBM� )FSJUBHF�� -BXT �1PMJDZ � BOE� 3FGPSN�� ������ &EJUFE� CZ� $BUIFSJOF� #FMM�SJHIU�BOE�3PCFSU�,��1BUFSTPO�

Page 4: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

4 Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage Project

0O�4FQUFNCFS��� ����� �*1JO$)�BOE�UIF�

:PSL� $FOUSF� GPS� 1VCMJD� 1PMJDZ� BOE� -BX�

CSPVHIU�UPHFUIFS�UISFF�*1JO$)�NFNCFST �

Catherine Bell�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�"MCFSUB �Pa-tricia Goff� -BVSJFS�6OJWFSTJUZ� BOE�Rose-mary Coombe�:PSL�6OJWFSTJUZ�UP�EJTDVTT�IPX�*OEJHFOPVT�SJHIUT �JOUFMMFDUVBM�QSPQ�

FSUZ� BOE� IVNBO� SJHIUT� BSF� JOUFSTFDUJOH�

BOE�DIBOHJOH�UIF�EJNFOTJPOT�PG�JOUFSOB�

UJPOBM�MBX�BOE�QPMJDZ�JO�UIF�QSPDFTT��

$BUIFSJOF�#FMM�EJTDVTTFE� UIF�DBTF�PG� UIF�&DIP�.BTL�BOE� UIF�

BUUFNQUT�PG�UIF�/VYBML�/BUJPO�UP�SFQBUSJBUF�BO�JNQPSUBOU�QJFDF�PG�

UIFJS�IFSJUBHF��5IJT�GSVTUSBUJOH�DBTF�JT�FNCMFNBUJD�PG�TPNF�PG�UIF�

DIBMMFOHFT�OPX�GBDJOH�MBXZFST�BOE�QPMJDZ�NBLFST�BT�UIFZ�BUUFNQU�

UP� SFDPODJMF�NPEFSO� DBUFHPSJFT� PG� PXOFSTIJQ� BOE� QSPQFSUZ�XJUI�

NPSF�DPNQMFY�OPUJPOT�PG�DPNNVOJUZ�PXOFSTIJQ �DVMUVSBM�QSPQFSUZ�

BOE�UIF�DVMUVSBM�SJHIU�UP�BDDFTT�BOE�DPOUSPM�POFT�PXO�IFSJUBHF�

*OUFSFTUFE� JO� RVFTUJPOT� PG� HMPCBM� HPWFSOBODF � 1BUSJDJB� (PGG�

EJTDVTTFE�UIF�FGGPSUT�PG�UIF�8PSME�*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�0SHBOJ[B�

UJPO� 8*10� UP� SFBDI�PVU� UP� iOFX�CFOFmDJBSJFTw� JO�BO�BUUFNQU� UP�

mOE�XBZT� UP� SFDPHOJ[F �NBJOUBJO� BOE� QSPUFDU� USBEJUJPOBM� DVMUVSBM�

FYQSFTTJPOT �XIJMF� FOTVSJOH� UIF�HMPCBM� JOUFMMFDUVBM� QSPQFSUZ� TZT�

UFN�SFUBJOT�MFHJUJNBDZ�JO�PVS�DVMUVSBMMZ�QMVSBMJTUJD�TPDJFUZ��)PXFWFS �

BDDPSEJOH� UP�(PGG � UIF�XPSL� PG�8*10� SFNBJOT�DIBMMFOHJOH� TJODF�

JUT�QMBDF�XJUIJO� UIF� MBSHFS�TUSVDUVSF�PG� UIF�HMPCBM�FDPOPNZ�QSPC�

MFNBUJ[FT�GVMM�SFDPHOJUJPO�PG�UIF�JNQPSUBOU�MJOLT�CFUXFFO�USBEJUJPOBM�

LOPXMFEHF �DVMUVSBM�SJHIUT�BOE�DVMUVSBM�SFDPHOJUJPO�

'JOBMMZ �3PTFNBSZ�$PPNCF�SFNJOEFE�UIF�BVEJFODF�UIBU�OFPMJC�

FSBMJTN�JT�OPU�NPOPMJUIJD�� JU�EPFT�IBWF�MJNJUT��4IF�BSHVFE�UIBU�BT�

UIF� SJHJE� MJOFT�CFUXFFO�PME�DBUFHPSJFT�TVDI�BT� iUSBEJUJPO w� iIFSJ�

UBHF w�iDVMUVSFw�BOE�iFDPOPNZw�IBWF�CFDPNF�CMVSSFE �OFX�GPSNT�

PG� DMBJN�NBLJOH� IBWF� CFDPNF� QPTTJCMF � BOE� OFX� PQQPSUVOJUJFT�

IBWF�CFFO�QSPWJEFE� UP� UIPTF�TFFLJOH� SFDPHOJUJPO�CZ� JOTUJUVUJPOT�

UIBU�BU�POF�UJNF�FYDMVEFE�UIFN�

#Z�QSPWJEJOH�B�OFX�DVMUVSBMJTU�SIFUPSJD�UIBU�HSPVOET�QPMJUJDBM�BOE�

QSPQSJFUBSZ�DMBJNT �OFPMJCFSBMJTN�IBT�DSFBUFE�TQBDFT�XIFSF�JOUFM�

MFDUVBM�QSPQFSUZ�DPOUJOVBMMZ�DPMMJEFT�XJUI� JTTVFT�PG�DVMUVSBM� SJHIUT �

*OEJHFOPVT� SJHIUT� UP� TFMG�EFUFSNJOBUJPO � BOE� SJHIUT� UP� SFDPHOJ�

UJPO��5IVT �RVFTUJPOT�TVDI�BT�UIF�POF�HJWFO�OPUPSJFUZ�CZ�.JDIBFM�

#SPXO�8IP� 0XOT� /BUJWF� $VMUVSF �BSF� UVSOJOH� PVU� UP� CF� MFTT�

BCPVU�EPDUSJOBM�MFHBM�SVMFT�BOE�DMBTTJD�QSPQFSUZ�SFMBUJPOT �BOE�NPSF�

BCPVU�DSFBUJOH�TQBDFT�PG�QPMJUJDBM �MFHBM �BOE�DVMUVSBM�OFHPUJBUJPO�

*1JO$)� UFBN�NFNCFS�Murielle Nagy� PSHB�OJ[FE�B�WFSZ�TVDDFTTGVM�GPVS�TFTTJPO�NBSB�

UIPO�PO�*1�BOE�3FTFBSDI�&UIJDT�BU�UIF���UI�

*OVJU�4UVEJFT�$POGFSFODF� JO�7BM�E�0S �2V�

CFD�PO�0DUPCFS����BOE��� �������

5IF�mWF�*1JO$)�UFBN�NFNCFST�DPOUSJCVU�

JOH�UP�UIF�TFTTJPOT�JODMVEFE�.VSJFMMF�IFSTFMG�

PO� UIF� DSVDJBM� UPQJD � i"DDFTT� UP�%BUB� BOE�

3FQPSUT�BGUFS�UIF�$PNQMFUJPO�PG�B�3FTFBSDI�

1SPKFDU�w� *1JO$)�4UFFSJOH�$PNNJUUFF�NFN�

CFS�Catherine Bell�QSFTFOUFE�i"DDFTT�UP�BOE�$POUSPM� PWFS� *OGPSNBUJPO� 0SJHJOBUJOH� GSPN�

"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�JO�$BOBEB�w�$BUIF�

SJOF�BMTP�TQPLF�PO�BOPUIFS�WJUBM�UIFNF �i3F�

TQFDU �3JHPVS�BOE�3FTQPOTJCJMJUZ��$PMMBCPSB�

UJWF�&UIJDT�1SBDUJDFT�BOE�UIF�"DBEFNZ�w

*1JO$)�DBTF�TUVEZ�DP�EFWFMPQFS�Natasha Lyons� EJTDVTTFE� i5IF�.JEEMF�(SPVOE��/F�

HPUJBUJOH�UIF�/BUVSF�BOE�0XOFSTIJQ�PG�3F�

TFBSDI�0VUDPNFT� JO�$PMMBCPSBUJWF�1SPKFDUT�

XJUI�"CPSJHJOBM�$PNNVOJUJFT�w�Daryl Pullman �

#JPBSDIBFPMPHZ � (FOFUJDT� BOE� *1� 8PSLJOH�

(SPVQ�DP�DIBJS �BOE�1SPKFDU�%JSFDUPS�George Nicholas�QSFTFOUFE�PO �i*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE�UIF�&UIJDBM�-FHBM�4UBUVT�PG�)VNBO�%/"��

5IF�*S�3FMFWBODF�PG�$POUFYU�w�

0UIFST� QSFTFOUJOH� JO� UIF� *1� BOE� 3F�

TFBSDI�&UIJDT�TFTTJPOT�XFSF�

t� :WFT�-BCSÒDIF�$PMMÒHF�6OJWFSTJUBJSF�EF�

4BJOU�#POJGBDF�� i/BNF� BOE� 4FMG�SFQSF�

TFOUBUJPO�BNPOH�UIF�-BCSBEPS�*OVJU�.F�

UJT�BOE�UIF�.BOJUPCB�'SBODPQIPOF�.ÏUJT��

5PXBSET�BO�&UIJDT�PG�3FDPODJMJBUJPO w

t� $VOFSB� #VJKT� /BUJPOBM� .VTFVN� PG� &UI�

OPMPHZ �/FUIFSMBOET�BOE�"WJBBKB�3PTJOH�

+BDPCTFO�(SFFOMBOE�/BUJPOBM�.VTFVN��

i3FQBUSJBUJPO�PG�*OEJHFOPVT�,PXMFEHF�BOE�

*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�UP�&BTU�(SFFOMBOE�w

t� &MJTB�)BSU�BOE�8JMMJBN�,PPMBHF�6OJWFSTJUZ�

PG� .BOJUPCB�� i1BTU� 3FTFBSDI� BOE� /FX�

"VEJFODFT��"SF�/FX�(VJEFMJOFT�/FFEFE w

t� 4DPU� /JDLFMT� *OVJU� 5BQJSJJU� ,BOBUBNJ� BOE�

$BUIMFFO� ,OPUTDI�

/BUJPOBM� "CPSJHJ�

OBM� )FBMUI� 0SHBOJ�

[BUJPO � $BOBEB��

i*OVJU�4QFDJmD� 1FS�

TQFDUJWFT� PO� UIF�

5SJ�$PVODJM� 1PMJDZ�

4UBUFNFOU� 3FHBSE�

JOH�&UIJDBM�$POEVDU�

PG�3FTFBSDI�*OWPMWJOH�)VNBOT�*5, �/")0 �

BOE�*OVJU�-BOE�$MBJN�0SHBOJ[BUJPOT�w

t� -FOF� ,JFMTFO� )PMN� *OVJU� $JSDVNQPMBS�

$PVODJM � (SFFOMBOE�� -FOPSF� "�� (SFOP�

CMF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�$IJDBHP�BOE�3PTT�"��

7JSHJOJB� %JDLFZ�$FOUFS� GPS� *OUFSOBUJPOBM�

6OEFSTUBOEJOH � 64"�� i5PXBSE� B� /FX�

3FTFBSDI�&UIJD�GPS�(SFFOMBOE�w

.BOZ� PG� UIFTF� QSFTFOUBUJPOT� BSF� CFJOH�

SFWJTFE�BOE�XJMM�CF�TVCNJUUFE�GPS�UIF������

WPMVNF����o�� PG�²UVEFT�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�PO�*OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE�&UIJDT�

.VSJFMMF�/BHZ �%JSFDUPS�BOE�&EJUPS�PG�UIF�+PVSOBM�²UVEFT�*OVJU�4UVEJFT�

IPinCH at the 17th Inuit Studies Conference, Val D’Or, Québec

Negotiating the Spaces of Intellectual Property Under Neoliberalism I`�5PJVSL�(`S^PU

/JDPMF�"ZMXJO �1I�%��4UVEFOU�3FTFBSDI�"TTJTUBOU�

Page 5: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

IPinCH Newsletter Vol 2.2 (Winter 2010) 5

*1JO$)� 1PTU�EPDUPSBM� "TTPDJBUF�

Melissa Baird PSHBOJ[FE� B� TFTTJPO�

FOUJUMFE� $SJUJDBM� )FSJUBHF� 4UVEJFT��,OPXMFEHF � *EFOUJUZ� BOE� 1PXFS� GPS�UIF� SFDFOU� "NFSJDBO� "OUISPQPMPHJDBM�

"TTPDJBUJPO� "OOVBM� .FFUJOH� JO� /FX�

0SMFBOT�� "U� JUT� DPSF � DSJUJDBM� IFSJUBHF�

TUVEJFT�FYBNJOF�UIF�TPDJP�QPMJUJDBM�JN�

QMJDBUJPOT�BOE�DPOTFRVFODFT�PG�IFSJ�

UBHF� BOE� BEESFTT� IPX� QPXFS � JEFO�

UJUZ � BOE� LOPXMFEHF� JOUFSTFDU� XJUI� BOE� JOnVFODF� DPOUFNQPSBSZ�

IFSJUBHF�QSBDUJDFT��5IFTF�TUVEJFT�FODPNQBTT�OFX�EJSFDUJPOT�JO�

BOUISPQPMPHZ � NVTFVN� TUVEJFT � GPMLMPSF � IJTUPSZ � FOWJSPONFOUBM�

TUVEJFT�BOE�MBX �BOE�CSJOH�UPHFUIFS�EJWFSTF�EJTDJQMJOBSZ�QFSTQFD�

UJWFT�UIBU�IBWF�QPUFOUJBM�UP�QSPEVDF�OFX�XBZT�PG�UIJOLJOH�BCPVU�

IFSJUBHF��$SJUJDBM�)FSJUBHF�4UVEJFT�BSF�JOUFSFTUFE�JO�IPX�EJGGFSFOU�

TDIPMBST�FOHBHF�XJUI� TJNJMBS�RVFTUJPOT�BOE�IPX� UIFTF�EJWFSTF�

SFTQPOTFT�BEE�UP�PS�DPNQMJDBUF�XIBU�XF�LOPX�PS�UIJOL�XF�LOPX�

BCPVU� IFSJUBHF�� 5IF� EJTDVTTBOU� XBT� IFSJUBHF� TDIPMBS� )FMBJOF�

4JMWFSNBO � BOE� QBOFMJTUT� JODMVEFE� *1JO$)� DPMMFDUJWF� NFNCFST�

Rosemary Coombe�BOE�Anne Pyburn �BOE�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�TDIPMBST�-BVSBKBOF� 4NJUI � 1IJM� 4DIFS � BOE� +PZ� 4BUIFS�8BHTUBGG�� 1BSUJDJ�

QBOUT�XFSF�BTLFE�UP�BOBMZ[F�UIFJS�XPSL�XJUIJO�B�$)4�GSBNFXPSL�

BOE�UP�UIJOL�BCPVU�UIF�XBZT�JO�XIJDI�LOPXMFEHF�BCPVU�IFSJUBHF�

JT�DPOTUJUVUFE� JO� UIFJS�XPSL��5IF�TFTTJPO�XBT�XFMM� SFDFJWFE�BOE�

-BVSBKBOF�4NJUI �XIP�JT�UIF�FEJUPS�PG�UIF�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�+PVSOBM�PG�)FSJUBHF�4UVEJFT �JOWJUFE�#BJSE�UP�TVCNJU�B�TFMFDUJPO�PG�QBQFST�GPS�

TQFDJBM�JTTVF�PG�UIF�KPVSOBM��)FMBJOF�4JMWFSNBO�QMBOT�PO�PSHBOJ[�

JOH�B�GPMMPX�VQ�$)4�TFTTJPO�GPDVTFE�PO�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�TDIPMBST�GPS�

UIF������"""�NFFUJOH�JO�.POUSFBM�

*1JO$)� DP�EFWFMPQFS� Julie Hollowell� SFQ�SFTFOUFE� *1JO$)� JO� B� GPSVN�PSHBOJ[FE�CZ�

"MJDJB�&CCJUU�.D(JMM�UJUMFE �iA4BWJOH�UIF�-PSF��

7FSTJPO���� ��4VTUBJOBCJMJUZ �)FSJUBHF�4UVE�

JFT � $VMUVSBM� 3FWJUBMJ[BUJPO� BOE� %FWFMPQ�

NFOU�w�5IF�GPSVN�CSPVHIU�UPHFUIFS�QFPQMF�

XPSLJOH� JO� IFSJUBHF� DFOUSFT� PS� XJUI�NBKPS�

IFSJUBHF�SFMBUFE� QSPKFDUT� UP� EJTDVTT� UIFJS�

XPSL�� *U� XBT� B� XPOEFSGVM� PQQPSUVOJUZ� GPS�

TIBSJOH �OFUXPSLJOH �BOE�DPNQBSJOH�FYBN�

QMFT�PG�HPPE�QSBDUJDF�JO�UIF�mFME�PG�IFSJUBHF�

TUVEJFT��0UIFS�QBSUJDJQBOUT�JODMVEFE��&MJ[B�

CFUI�$IJMUPO �%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�$FOUFS�GPS�)FSJ�

UBHF�BOE�4PDJFUZ�BU�6.BTT�"NIFSTU��"OUPJ�

OFUUF�+BDLTPO �%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�%FQBSUNFOU�

PG� "OUISPQPMPHZ�T� )FSJUBHF� 3FTFBSDI� -BC�

BU�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�4PVUI�'MPSJEB��1FUFS�4UPOF �

)FBE�PG�4DIPPM�PG�UIF�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�$FOUSF�

GPS� $VMUVSBM� BOE� )FSJUBHF� 4UVEJFT� BU� UIF�

6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�/FXDBTUMF �6,��%BWJE�(BUTCZ �

GPSNFS�"TTJTUBOU�%JSFDUPS�PG� UIF�$FOUFS�GPS�

)FSJUBHF� 3FTPVSDF� 4UVEJFT� BU� UIF� 6OJWFS�

TJUZ�PG�.BSZMBOE��$ISJTUJBO�8FMMT � IFSJUBHF�

UPVSJTN� JO� )POEVSBT�� 3FCFDDB� ;BSHFS �

USBEJUJPOBM� FOWJSPONFOUBM� LOPXMFEHF� BOE�

TDIPPM�DVSSJDVMB�JO�#FMJ[F��BOE�%BO�4VTMBL�

BOE�4FSBmO�$PSPOFM�.PMJOB �XIP�XPSL� UP�

HFUIFS� PO� 2VFDIVB� MBOHVBHF� SFWJUBMJ[B�

UJPO� QSPKFDUT��%JTDVTTJPO� SBOHFE� GSPN� UIF�

CSPBE� TQFDUSVN�PG� QBSUOFSTIJQT� UIBU� IFSJ�

UBHF�QSPKFDUT�PGUFO�FNCSBDF�UP�JOTUJUVUJPOBM�

DIBMMFOHFT�BOE�CBSSJFST�SFMBUFE�UP�CVJMEJOH�

DBQBDJUZ� BU� UIF� DPNNVOJUZ� MFWFM�� &EVDB�

UJPO�XBT�BOPUIFS� LFZ� UPQJD � OPU� KVTU� JO� SF�

HBSE�UP�TUVEFOU�USBJOJOH �CVU�JO�DPOKVODUJPO�

XJUI�FEVDBUJOH�UIF�BDBEFNZ�BOE�GVOEFST �

TVQQPSUJOH� LOPXMFEHF� FYDIBOHF� BNPOH�

ZPVUI�BOE�FMEFST�JO�DPNNVOJUJFT �OFUXPSL�

JOH� BOE� TIBSJOH� TUPSJFT� XJUI� UIPTF� GBDJOH�

TJNJMBS�JTTVFT�B�OFFE�XIJDI�UIF�GPSVN�XBT�

EFTJHOFE� UP�NFFU�� 1BOFMJTUT� FNQIBTJ[FE�

UIF� WFSZ� EJGGFSFOU� NFBOJOHT� PG� iIFSJUBHFw�

BU� MPDBM � OBUJPOBM � BOE� JOUFSOBUJPOBM� MFWFMT�

BOE� UIF�OFDFTTJUZ� PG� USBOTEJTDJQMJOBSZ� BQ�

QSPBDIFT�UP�IFSJUBHF�SFTFBSDI �XJUI� USBOT�

QBSFODZ�BCPVU�XIP�CFOFmUT�BOE�IPX�

"O�*1JO$)�HBUIFSJOH�BU�UIF�#PVSCPO�)PVTF�

PO� #PVSCPO� 4USFFU� JO� /FX� 0SMFBOT� ESFX�

UFBN�NFNCFST �QBSUOFST �BOE�BTTPDJBUFT�UP�

HFUIFS�GPS�TPNF�OFUXPSLJOH��*O�BEEJUJPO �+VMJF�

QPTUFE�PVS�1SPKFDU�&UIOPHSBQIFS�1PTUEPDUPS�

BM�QPTJUJPO�JO�UIF�"""�KPC�QMBDFNFOU�DFOUFS �

NFU� FJHIU� QPUFOUJBM� DBOEJEBUFT � BOE� IFBSE�

GSPN�TFWFSBM�PUIFST�XIP�FYQSFTTFE�JOUFSFTU��

"MM�XFSF�SFDFOU�1I�%�T�XJUI�MPUT�PG�JOUFSFTU�JO�

*1JO$)� BOE� JUT� JOJUJBUJWFT � XIJDI� EPWFUBJMFE�

XJUI�UIFJS�PXO�XPSL�JO�OVNFSPVT�XBZT�

IPinCH at the 2010 AAA Meeting in New OrleansMelissa Baird’s Panel: Critical Heritage Studies: Knowledge, Identity and Power

I`�4LSPZZH�)HPYK�

IPinCH Represented in Heritage Forum / IPinCH AAA Gathering

I`�1\SPL�/VSSV^LSS

.FMJTTB�#BJSE �*1JO$)�1PTU�EPDUPSBM�'FMMPX�"TTPDJBUF

Your Input Needed for Newsletter, Website and Monthly Digest8F�XBOU� UP�SFQSFTFOU� UIF�XJEF�SBOHF�PG� BDUJWJUJFT� PG� UIF� NFNCFST� PG� PVS�*1JO$)� DPMMFDUJWF�� 1MFBTF� TFOE� TIPSU�VQEBUFT�PO�ZPVS�SFTFBSDI �QIPUPT �PS�TVHHFTUJPOT� GPS� PVS� NPOUIMZ� EJHFTU �XFCTJUF �BOE�OFXTMFUUFS�

Page 6: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

6 Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage Project

IPinCH Community-based Heritage Research Workshop I`�2LSS`�-V_

0VS� 0DUPCFS�$PNNVOJUZ�CBTFE� )FSJUBHF�3FTFBSDI� 8PSLTIPQ� XBT� BO� PQQPSUVOJUZ�GPS�DPNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�UFBNT�UP�TIBSF�UIFJS�

OFFET� BOE� FYQFSJFODFT�� "EWJTPS� %BWF�

4UFQIFOTPO�SFnFDUFE �i"MUIPVHI�UIF�XPSL�

TIPQ� IBE� XFMM�SFTQFDUFE� JOUFSOBUJPOBM�

QSPGFTTJPOBM� DVMUVSBM� IFSJUBHF� SFTFBSDI�

FST� JO�BUUFOEBODF � UIJT�XPSLTIPQ�EFNPO�

TUSBUFE� UIBU� *1JO$)� JT� EJTUJODUMZ� CSFBLJOH�

PVU�PG�UIF�NPME�PG�USBEJUJPOBM�TDIPMBSMZ�BOE�

BDBEFNJD�BQQSPBDIFT�UP�DVMUVSBM�IFSJUBHF�

DBTF� TUVEJFT� CZ� JUT� BDUJWF � POHPJOH� FO�

DPVSBHFNFOU� PG� DPNNVOJUZ� QFSTQFDUJWFT�

BOE�QBSUJDJQBUJPO�BU�BMM�TUBHFT�PG�UIF�DBTF�

TUVEZ�QSPDFTT�w�

5IF�XPSLTIPQ�CFHBO�XJUI�B�QSPKFDU�PWFS�

WJFX� GSPN� FBDI� UFBN � HJWJOH� QBSUJDJQBOUT�

BO�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�PG� UIF� SBOHF�PG�FYDJUJOH�

SFTFBSDI� FODPNQBTTFE� CZ� *1JO$)�� -BUFS �

BDBEFNJDT�BOE�DPNNVOJUZ�NFNCFST�TFQ�

BSBUFMZ�EJTDVTTFE�LFZ�SFTFBSDI�JTTVFT��5IF�

HSPVQT�UIFO�SFDPOWFOFE�UP�TFMFDU�UISFF�LFZ�

UPQJDT� GPS� JO�EFQUI� DPOTJEFSBUJPO�� "SJTJOH�

GSPN� DPNNVOJUZ� NFNCFST � UIF� mSTU� JTTVF�

XBT�QBSUJDJQBUJPO�PG�FMEFST�BOE�ZPVUI��5IF�

4NJUITPOJBO�*OVWJBMVJU�7JTJU�BOE�.PSJPSJ�$VM�

UVSBM� %BUBCBTF� DP�EFWFMPQFST� CVJMU� TVDI�

QBSUJDJQBUJPO� JOUP� UIFJS� JOJUJBUJWFT �BOE� UIFZ�

DBO�TFSWF�BT�SFTPVSDFT�GPS�PUIFS�UFBNT�JO�

FBSMZ�TUBHFT�PG�SFTFBSDI�

5IF�TFDPOE�LFZ�UPQJD�XBT�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�

UIF�DVMUVSF�PG�SFTFBSDI�JO�B�DPNNVOJUZ�DPO�

UFYU�� "DBEFNJDT� mOE� JU� DIBMMFOHJOH� UP� HFU�

SFDPHOJUJPO� GPS� UJNF�TQFOU�PO�BDUJWJUJFT�OPU�

USBEJUJPOBMMZ� DPOTJEFSFE� SFTFBSDI � TVDI� BT�

EFWFMPQJOH� BOE� NBJOUBJOJOH� SFMBUJPOTIJQT�

XJUI�DPNNVOJUJFT��5IJT�MFE�UP�B�EJTDVTTJPO�

PO� i8IBU� DPOTUJUVUFT� SFTFBSDI w� $IBSMFT�

"SOPME �SFUJSFE�IFBE�PG�UIF�1SJODF�PG�8BMFT�

/PSUIFSO� )FSJUBHF� $FOUSF � CSPVHIU� VQ� B�

OFX�SFTFBSDI�NPEFM�FYFNQMJmFE�CZ�/PSUI�

FSO�$BOBEJBO� DPNNVOJUJFT� UIBU� QSPEVDFE�

3FRVFTUT� GPS� 1SPQPTBMT� DBMMJOH� PO� BDB�

EFNJDT� UP� DPOTJEFS� DPOEVDUJOH� SFTFBSDI�

GPS� DPNNVOJUJFT�iPVS� SPMF� BT� SFTFBSDI�

FST�NJHIU�CF� UP�TUFQ�CBDL� GSPN�EPJOH� UIF�

IBOET�PO�TUVGG�VOMFTT�XF�SF�JOWJUFE�UP�EP�JU �

BOE�QMBZ�NPSF�PG�<BO>�JOUFSNFEJBSZ�SPMF�w�)F�

XFOU�PO�UP�TBZ�UIBU�UIF�$BOBEJBO�iHPWFSO�

NFOU�IBT�CFFO�NPWJOH�NPSF� UP�XIBU� UIFZ�

DBMM� B� SFTVMUT�CBTFE� QFSGPSNBODF� SFWJFX w�

CSJFnZ� EFmOFE� BT� iMFU�T� GPDVT� PO� HFUUJOH�

UBTLT� EPOF � UIFO� HFUUJOH� SFTVMUT�JO� UIJT�

DBTF � SFTVMUT� JEFOUJmFE� CZ� UIF� *OEJHFOPVT�

HSPVQT�w�$IVDL�JOEJDBUFE�VOJWFSTJUJFT�NJHIU�

BMTP�DPOTJEFS�NPWJOH�JO�UIJT�EJSFDUJPO�

1FSIBQT� UIF�NPTU�QPJHOBOU�VOEFSTUBOE�

JOH�PG�SFTFBSDI�DBNF�GSPN�*OVWJBMVJU�FMEFS�"M�

CFSU�&MJBT��i.Z�XIPMF�FYQFSJFODF�BOE�PCTFS�

WBUJPOT�MJWJOH�PGG�UIF�MBOE�JO�JUTFMG�JT�SFTFBSDI��

8JUIPVU�LOPXJOH� JU � *�XBT� SFTFBSDIJOH�OFX�

UIJOHT��DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�JT�BO�FYBNQMF��&WFSZ�

UJNF�*�XFOU�IPNF �*�UPME�TUPSJFT�BCPVU�UIF�FG�

GFDUT�PG�DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�PO�UIF�XJMEMJGF �BOE�

PO�UIF�FOWJSPONFOU��5P�NF �UIBU�T�SFTFBSDI�w

5IF�LFZ�UIJSE�JTTVF�FYQMPSFE�BU�PVS�XPSL�

TIPQ�BSPTF�GSPN�DPNNVOJUZ�NFNCFST��UIF�

JNQPSUBODF� PG� DPNNVOJDBUJOH� UIF� EJGGFS�

FODF�CFUXFFO� JOEJWJEVBM � DPNNVOJUZ � BOE�

PUIFS� WPJDFT� JO� *1JO$)� XPSL�� 3FQPSUT� PG�

PVS�XPSL�OFFE�UP�FNCFE�BOTXFST�UP�TVDI�

RVFTUJPOT�BT��i'PS�XIPN�BN�*�TQFBLJOH w�

i8IP� IBT� BVUIPSJUZ� UP� TQFBL w� *U� CFDBNF�

DMFBS�XF�OFFE�NPSF�DPOTJEFSBUJPO�PG�7PJDF�

JO�*1JO$)�DPNNVOJDBUJPOT��

#POOJF�/FXTPN �DP�EFWFMPQFS�PG�UIF�1F�

OPCTDPU�/BUJPO�$PNNVOJUZ�CBTFE�*OJUJBUJWF�

TVNNFE�VQ�UIF�XPSLTIPQ �i*�SFBMMZ�BQQSF�

DJBUF� UIF�nVJEJUZ�PG� UIF�BHFOEB�� *U�T� SBSF� JO�

UFSNT�PG�NFFUJOHT�UIBU�XF�DBO�BDUVBMMZ�IBWF�

B�WPJDF�JO�TIBQJOH�XIBU�XF�SF�UBMLJOH�BCPVU��

*�BQQSFDJBUF�FWFSZCPEZ�T�QSPKFDUT�BOE�UIFJS�

DPOUSJCVUJPOT�UP�UIF�QSPDFTT��*�UIJOL�UIFZ�SF�

BMM� FYDJUJOH�� *� KVTU� XBOU� UP� NBLF� TVSF� UIBU�

XF�EPO�U�TFF�UIJOHT�KVTU�UISPVHI�POF�MFOT�w�

#POOJF�T�DPOUSJCVUJPOT�XFSF�FYBDUMZ�UIF�LJOE�

PG�GFFECBDL�UIBU�XJMM�FOTVSF�*1JO$)�VOGPMET�

XJUI�UIF�OFFET�PG�DPNNVOJUJFT�BU�JUT�IFBSU��

8IFO�BTLFE�GPS�TVHHFTUJPOT�UP�JNQSPWF�

*1JO$)� DPNNVOJDBUJPO � QBSUJDJQBOUT� QSP�

WJEFE�B�WBSJFUZ�PG�DPNNFOUT��%BOJFM�(FO�

ESPO�PG�/VOBWJL�T�"WBUBR�$VMUVSBM� *OTUJUVUF�

TBJE � i*O� NZ� OFDL� PG� UIF� UVOESB � *OUFSOFU�

DPOOFDUJPO� JT� OPU� WFSZ� HPPE�� )BSE� DPQZ�

JT�TUJMM �BT�GBS�BT�XF�SF�DPODFSOFE �UIF�CFTU�

XBZ�UP�HFU�UIBU�JOGPSNBUJPO�BDSPTT�w�"MPOH�

XJUI� PUIFS� SFRVFTUT� GPS� TIPSUFS � NPSF� GSF�

RVFOU� DPNNVOJDBUJPOT � UIJT� TQBSLFE� UIF�

SFWJWBM�PG�PVS�NPOUIMZ�EJHFTU��

5IFSF�XFSF�BMTP�TVHHFTUJPOT�GPS�UIF�XFC�

TJUF�� /BUBTIB� -ZPOT � DP�EFWFMPQFS� PG� UIF�

*OVWJBMVJU�DBTF�TUVEZ �TVNNFE�VQ�UIF�GFFM�

JOHT�PG�NBOZ�XJUI � iUIF�TJUF� JT�WFSZ�EFOTF�

BOE�TMJHIUMZ�CVSFBVDSBUJD�w�,BUF�)FOOFTTZ �

BMTP�XPSLJOH�XJUI�UIF�*OVWJBMVJU �BEEFE �iJG�JU�

EPFTO�U�BDUJWFMZ�IFMQ�JO�XIBU�XF�IBWF�UP�EP�

EBZ�UP�EBZ �UIFO�OP�POF�XJMM�UBLF�UIF�UJNF�UP�

HP�TFF�JU�w�

3FTFBSDI�"TTJTUBOU�&NNB�'FMUFT�TIBSFE�

IFS�FYQFSJFODF�PG�QPTUJOH�B�WJEFP �i*O�UIF�

ZFBS�UIBU�*�WF�CFFO�USZJOH�UP�JOUFSBDU�XJUI�UIF�

TJUF �*�UIJOL�JU�IBT�JNQSPWFE�B�MPU��8F�XFSFO�U�

TVSF�UIBU�JU�XBT�HPJOH�UP�XPSL�XJUI�UIF�VTF�

PG�NVMUJNFEJB�BOE�XIFO�XF�CSPVHIU�TPNF�

PG�PVS�DPODFSOT� UP�,FMMZ� <'PY> �BMM�PG� UIFN�

XFSF�BEESFTTFE�w�

5IF�TVHHFTUJPOT� GPS�DIBOHF � UIPVHIUGVM�

TUSBOET�PG�EJTDVTTJPO�PO� JTTVFT� JNQPSUBOU�

UP�NFNCFST�PG�UIF�DPMMFDUJWF �BOE�OFX�VO�

EFSTUBOEJOHT�PG�PVS�SFTFBSDI�UIBU�DPOUJOVF�

HSPXJOH�PVU� PG� PVS�XPSLTIPQ�XJMM� CF� GPSF�

HSPVOEFE�BT�*1JO$)�NPWFT�BIFBE�

4RVBNJTI�/BUJPO�&MEFS�"VESFZ�3JWFST�JT�JOUSPEVDFE�UP�"JOV�UFBN�NFNCFST�M�UP�S�5BUTVP�/JTIJKJNB �)JEFIJLP�,JNVSB �)JSPGVNJ�,BUP�BOE�)JEFLJ�:PTIJIBSB �BOE�PUIFS�QBSUJDJQBOUT�JODMVEJOH�M�UP�S�%BOJFM�(FOESPO �+VMJF�)PMMPXFMM �%BWF�4UFQIFOTPO �BOE�+PBOOF�#JSE �EVSJOH�UIF�XPSLTIPQ�DMPTJOH�DFSFNPOJFT �0DUPCFS��� ������

Page 7: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

IPinCH Newsletter Vol 2.2 (Winter 2010) 7

"VTUSBMJBO�CPSO�*BO�.D*OUPTI �1I�%� �JT�UIF�%JSFDUPS�PG�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�1BSUOFSTIJQT�BU�*OEJBOB�6OJWFSTJUZ�

1VSEVF�6OJWFSTJUZ�BU�*OEJBOBQPMJT �XIFSF�IF�JT�BMTP�BO�BEKVODU�QSPGFTTPS�PG�"OUISPQPMPHZ�JO�UIF�4DIPPM�PG�

-JCFSBM�"SUT �UFBDIJOH�DMBTTFT�PO�QFBDF�BOE�SFDPODJMJBUJPO�JO�UIF�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�BSFOB��)F�JT�UIF�"TTPDJBUF�

%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�$POGVDJVT�*OTUJUVUF�XIFSF�UIF�HPBM�JT�UP�CVJME�CSJEHFT�PG�GSJFOETIJQ�BOE�DPNNVOJDBUJPO�

CFUXFFO�UIF�6OJUFE�4UBUFT�BOE�$IJOB��"O�BQQMJFE�BOUISPQPMPHJTU �*BO�JT�B�GPSNFS�.BOBHJOH�%JSFDUPS�PG�UIF�

)BSWBSE�CBTFE�*OEJHFOPVT�SJHIUT�PSHBOJ[BUJPO�$VMUVSBM�4VSWJWBM�*OD��*O����� �IJT�XPSL�PO�QPWFSUZ�SFEVDUJPO�

BOE�SFGPSFTUBUJPO�JO�"SNFOJB�SFDFJWFE�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�SFDPHOJUJPO�XJUI�BO�&OFSHZ�(MPCF�"XBSE�GPS�TVTUBJO�

BCJMJUZ��*BO�IBT�QVCMJTIFE�UXP�CPPLT�BOE�NBOZ�BSUJDMFT�PO�*OEJHFOPVT�JTTVFT�HMPCBMMZ �CVU�OPSUIFBTU�"SO�

IFN�-BOE�JO�QBSUJDVMBS��)JT�HSFBU�JOUFSFTU�JT�JO�DPOnJDU�SFTPMVUJPO�BOE�UIF�DPODFQU�PG�SFDPODJMJBUJPO �BOE�JO�

���� �3PUBSZ�*OUFSOBUJPOBM�BXBSEFE�IJN�B�8PSME�1FBDF�'FMMPXTIJQ�BU�$IVMBMPOHLPSO�6OJWFSTJUZ�JO�5IBJMBOE�

"NZ�JT�B�NVMUJ�EJTDJQMJOBSZ�SFTFBSDIFS�XJUI�USBJOJOH�BOE�FYQFSJFODF�JO�CPUI�BSDIBFPMPHZ�BOE�BOUISPQPMPHZ��

*O����� �"NZ�XBT�BXBSEFE�IFS�EPDUPSBUF�UISPVHI�'MJOEFST�6OJWFSTJUZ �4PVUI�"VTUSBMJB��)FS�1I�%��SFTFBSDI�

JOWPMWFE�B�CSPBE�SBOHJOH �JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ�JOWFTUJHBUJPO�PG�UIF�QPJOUT�PG�BHSFFNFOU�BOE�DPOnJDU�CFUXFFO�*O�

EJHFOPVT�QFPQMFT�BOE�UIF�BSDIBFPMPHJDBM�EJTDJQMJOF��"NZ�IBT�DPNQMFUFE�B�(SBEVBUF�$FSUJmDBUF�JO�"QQMJFE�

"OUISPQPMPHZ�UISPVHI�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�8FTUFSO�"VTUSBMJB��'SPN������UP����� �TIF�XBT�FNQMPZFE�JO�WBSJPVT�

BSDIBFPMPHJDBM�BOUISPQPMPHJDBM�SPMFT�BU�UIF�"CPSJHJOBM�-FHBM�3JHIUT�.PWFNFOU�BOE�4PVUI�"VTUSBMJBO�/BUJWF�

5JUMF�4FSWJDFT�JODMVEJOH��3FTFBSDI�0GmDFS �4FOJPS�1SPGFTTJPOBM�0GmDFS�BOE�"DUJOH�.BOBHFS�PG�3FTFBSDI��*O�

SFDFOU�ZFBST�IFS�QSJNBSZ�SPMF�IBT�CFFO�BT�BO�iFYQFSUw�GPS�B�OVNCFS�PG�/BUJWF�UJUMF�DMBJNT��4JODF������"NZ�IBT�CFFO�B�MFDUVSFS�JO�UIF�'MJOEFST�

6OJWFSTJUZ�"SDIBFPMPHZ�%FQBSUNFOU��4IF�DPOUJOVFT�IFS�SFTFBSDI�XJUI�.VSSBZ�BOE�.BMMFF�"CPSJHJOBM�DPNNVOJUJFT�JO�4PVUI�"VTUSBMJB�

3BDIFM�)JSTDI� GPDVTFT� PO� LOPXMFEHF� USBOTMBUJPO� SFMBUFE� UP�"SDUJD� DMJNBUF� DIBOHF� BEBQUBUJPO� QPMJDZ�

EFWFMPQNFOU��)FS�1PTU�EPDUPSBM�QSPKFDU�FOUJUMFE �i4IBSJOH�SFTFBSDI�mOEJOHT�JO�UIF�$BOBEJBO�"SDUJD��"T�

TFTTJOH�UIF�JOUFHSBUJPO�PG�*OVJU�LOPXMFEHF�JO�QPMJDZ�DPNNVOJDBUJPOT�BCPVU�DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�SFMBUFE�GPPE�

JOTFDVSJUZ w�QVSTVFT�UIF�HPBM�PG�GBDJMJUBUJOH�QPMJDZ�NBLJOH�CZ�QSPNPUJOH�HSFBUFS�VOEFSTUBOEJOH�PG�UIF�DB�

QBDJUJFT�PG �BOE�DPOTUSBJOUT�BDUJOH�PO �UIF�HFOFSBM�QVCMJD��8JUI�DPNNVOJUZ�QBSUOFST�JO�UIF�/PSUI �HPWFSO�

NFOU�SFTFBSDIFST �BOE�PUIFS�TDJFOUJTUT �3BDIFM�XJMM�DPOUJOVF�UP���TVQQPSU�DPNNVOJUZ�SFTFBSDI�HSPVQT�

CZ�EFWFMPQJOH�B�XBZ�PG� USBDLJOH� JOGPSNBUJPO�FYDIBOHF � TVDI�BT� MPDBM� BOJNBM�DPVOUT� GSPN�IVOUFST �

USBEJUJPOBM�TUPSJFT�GSPN�FMEFST �PS�TDJFOUJmD�HFOFUJD�WBSJBUJPO�BNPOH�DBSJCPV�LOPXMFEHF��BOE���DPMMBCPSBUF�XJUI�DPNNVOJUZ�SFTFBSDI�

HSPVQT�UP�USBDL�mOEJOHT�GSPN�UIFJS�TUVEJFT�PO�DMJNBUF�DIBOHF�BOE�GPPE�TFDVSJUZ��3BDIFM�DPOUJOVFT�UP�FYQMPSF�UIF�TPDJBM�DPOUFYU�PG�IB[BSE�

FYQFSJFODFT�BU�:PSL�6OJWFSTJUZ �XIJDI�FYUFOET�UIF�(FPHSBQIZ�1I�%��TIF�DPNQMFUFE�BU�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�8FTUFSO�0OUBSJP�

Ian McIntosh, New IPinCH Scholar Associate

Amy Roberts, New IPinCH Scholar Associate

Rachel Hirsch, New IPinCH Post-doctoral Fellow Associate

Sarah Carr-Locke, New IPinCH Graduate Student Associate4BSBI�$BSS�-PDLF�T�1I�%��SFTFBSDI�FYQMPSFT�IPX�"CPSJHJOBM�QFPQMFT��JOUBOHJCMF�IFSJUBHF�BOE�JOUFMMFDUVBM�

QSPQFSUZ�BSF�QSFTFOUFE�JO�QVCMJD�NVTFVNT��4BSBI�mSTU�CFDBNF�JOUFSFTUFE�JO�UIF�UFOTJPOT�CFUXFFO�BSDIBF�

PMPHZ�BOE�*OEJHFOPVT�1FPQMFT�XIJMF�QVSTVJOH�IFS�VOEFSHSBEVBUF�EFHSFF�JO�/BUJWF�4UVEJFT�BOE�"OUISPQPM�

PHZ�BU�5SFOU�6OJWFSTJUZ��4IF�JT�UIBOLGVM�GPS�UIF�QPMJUJDBM�BXBLFOJOH�BOE�DSJUJDBM�BOBMZUJDBM�TLJMMT�TIF�MFBSOFE�

GSPN�QSPGFTTPST�BOE�PUIFS�*OEJHFOPVT�QFPQMF�UIFSF��*O����� �4BSBI�SFDFJWFE�IFS�.�"��GSPN�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�

PG�/PSUIFSO�#SJUJTI�$PMVNCJB�GPS�i4IBSJOH�UIF�1BTU��$PNNVOJUZ�#BTFE�"SDIBFPMPHZ�BOE�"CPSJHJOBM�1FPQMF�

JO�$BOBEB�w�0WFS�UIF�MBTU�GPVS�ZFBST �TIF�IBT�IBE�UIF�QSJWJMFHF�PG�XPSLJOH�BU�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�#SJUJTI�$P�

MVNCJB�T�.VTFVN�PG�"OUISPQPMPHZ �XIFSF�TIF�XJUOFTTFE�$BOBEJBO�BOE�JOUFSOBUJPOBM�DPMMBCPSBUJWF�QSPKFDUT�

XJUI�*OEJHFOPVT�QFPQMFT�BOE�UIFJS�IFSJUBHF��5IJT�FYQFSJFODF �DPVQMFE�XJUI�IFS�JOUFSFTU�JO�NVTFVNT �BS�

DIBFPMPHZ �SFQSFTFOUBUJPO �BOE�*OEJHFOPVT�SJHIUT �MFE�IFS�UP�4'6�BOE�TFOJPS�TVQFSWJTPS�(FPSHF�/JDIPMBT��

Page 8: IPinCH - Simon Fraser University · 1 >OH[»Z 0UZPKL>OH[»Z 0UZPKL *1JO$)/FXTMFUUFS7PM 8JOUFS IPinCH Flip Video Initiative 2 IPinCH Citations 2 Catherine Bell Profile 3 Negotiating

Contact Us� www.sfu.ca/ipinch

Project Director

George NicholasOffice: 778-782-5709Fax: 778-782-5666E-mail: [email protected]

Project Manager

Kelly FoxOffice: 778-782-8596Fax: 778-782-5666E-mail: [email protected]

Project Mailing Address

IP Issues in Cultural Heritage ProjectDepartment of ArchaeologySimon Fraser University8888 University DriveBurnaby, British Columbia, Canada V5A 1S6

PinCHes of News

IPinCH Newsletter edited by Kelly Fox & George Nicholas. Contributors: Nicole Aylwin, Melissa Baird, Emma Feltes, Kelly Fox, Julie Hollowell, George Nicholas, Brian Noble and Nova Pierson. Designed by Cheryl Takahashi.

"GUFS�IFS�TUJOU�BT�1SPKFDU�&UIOPHSBQIFS �Jane Anderson�IBT�NPWFE�PO�UP�KPJO�UIF�'BDVMUZ�PG�UIF�6OJWFSTJUZ�PG�.BTTBDIVTFUUT�

o�"NIFSTU��'PSUVOBUFMZ �TIF�SFUVSOT�UP�UIF�*1JO$)�UFBN �SFDFOUMZ�TFOEJOH�UISFF�QBQFST�UP�QPTU�PO�UIF�*1JO$)�XFCTJUF����B�

%JTDVTTJPO�1BQFS�PO�1SPUPDPMT�XSJUUFO�XJUI�(SFHPSZ�:PVOHJOH�GPS�UIF�$BOBEJBO�1VCMJD�"SU�'VOEFST�1SPGFTTJPOBM�%FWFMPQ�

NFOU�.FFUJOH�PO�"CPSJHJOBM�"SUT� XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF�������� *OUFMMFDUVBM�1SPQFSUZ�BOE� UIF�4BGFHVBSEJOH�PG�5SBEJ�UJPOBM�$VMUVSFT��-FHBM�*TTVFT�BOE�1SBDUJDBM�0QUJPOT�GPS�.VTFVNT �-JCSBSJFT�BOE�"SDIJWFT�XSJUUFO�GPS�UIF�8PSME�*OUFMMFDUVBM�

1SPQFSUZ�0SHBOJ[BUJPO�CZ�.PMMZ�5PSTFO�BOE�+BOF�"OEFSTPO�XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF������BOE���B�MJOL�UP�%VLF�6OJWFS�

TJUZ�4DIPPM�PG�-BX�T�$FOUFS� GPS� UIF�4UVEZ�PG� UIF�1VCMJD�%PNBJO �XIFSF�+BOF�T�QBQFS� *OEJHFOPVT�5SBEJUJPOBM�,OPXMFEHF�BOE� *1� DBO� CF� EPXOMPBEFE� VOEFS� B�$SFBUJWF�$PNNPOT� "UUSJCVUJPO�/PO�$PNNFSDJBM�4IBSF� "MJLF� ���� VOQPSUFE� MJDFOTF�

XXX�TGV�DB�JQJODI�OPEF�����

World Archaeological Congress Inter-Congress, Indianapolis, Indiana, June 22-25, 2011*1JO$)�JT�PSHBOJ[JOH�TFWFSBM�TFTTJPOT�GPS�UIF�GPSUIDPNJOH�8PSME�"SDIBFPMPHJDBM�$POHSFTT�8"$�*OUFS�$POHSFTT�PO�i*O�

EJHFOPVT�1FPQMFT�BOE�.VTFVNT��6OSBWFMMJOH�UIF�5FOTJPOT�w�)PTUFE�CZ�*OEJBOB�6OJWFSTJUZ�1VSEVF�6OJWFSTJUZ�*OEJBOBQPMJT�

*616*�BOE�UIF�&JUFMKPSH�.VTFVN�PG�"NFSJDBO�*OEJBOT�BOE�8FTUFSO�"SU �8"$*OEZ�JT�CFJOH�IFME�JO�DPOKVODUJPO�XJUI�UIF�

&JUFMKPSH�.VTFVN�T���UI�"OOVBM�*OEJBO�.BSLFU�BOE�'FTUJWBM �+VOF����BOE�����5IF�*1JO$)�TFTTJPOT�XJMM�GPDVT�PO�JOUFMMFDUVBM�

QSPQFSUZ�JTTVFT�SFMBUJOH�UP�UIF�DPOGFSFODF�UIFNF�

Marina La Salle �4UVEFOU�3FQSFTFOUBUJWF�PO� UIF� *1JO$)�4UFFSJOH�$PNNJUUFF�BOE�8"$�T�+S��3FQSFTFOUBUJWF� GPS�/PSUI�

FSO�"NFSJDB �JT�BMTP�PSHBOJ[JOH�B�TUVEFOU�TFTTJPO�FYQMPSJOH�UIF�SPMFT�PG�TUVEFOUT�JO�BSDIBFPMPHZ �BOUISPQPMPHZ �NVTFVN�

TUVEJFT� BOE� SFMBUFE� mFMET�� 4IPXDBTJOH� UIF� JOOPWBUJWF� BOE� FYDJUJOH� TUVEFOU� SFTFBSDI� VOEFSXBZ� BSPVOE� UIF� HMPCF � UIF�

TFTTJPO� XJMM� CSJOH� TUVEFOUT� BOE� QSPGFTTJPOBMT� UPHFUIFS� UP� TIBSF� JEFBT� BOE� JOTJHIUT� JOUP� UIF� GVUVSF� PG� IFSJUBHF� TUVEJFT�

NMBTBMMF!JOUFSDIBOHF�VCD�DB�

*1JO$)�"EWJTPS�Robert K. Paterson�DP�BVUIPSFE�B�CPPL�UIBU�BQQFBSFE�JO�%FDFNCFS��+BNFT�/BG[JHFS �3PCFSU�1BUFSTPO�BOE�

"MJTPO�%VOEFT�3FOUFMO��i$VMUVSBM�-BX��*OUFSOBUJPOBM �$PNQBSBUJWF �BOE�*OEJHFOPVT�w�$BNCSJEHF�6OJWFSTJUZ�1SFTT��������

"øCPPL�MBVODI�BU�6#$�T�.VTFVN�PG�"OUISPQPMPHZ�XJMM�PDDVS�JO�UIF�4QSJOH�

IPinCH Digest Launched5P�GPTUFS�HSFBUFS�BOE�NPSF�GSFRVFOU�TIBSJOH�PG�JOGPSNBUJPO �B�NPOUIMZ�OFXT�EJHFTU�GPS�NFNCFST�PG�PVS�*1JO$)�DPMMFDUJWF�

XBT� JOJUJBUFE� JO�%FDFNCFS��5P�CF�TVSF�ZPVS� *1JO$)�BDUJWJUJFT�BSF� JODMVEFE� JO� UIF�EJHFTU �TIBSF�ZPVS�TUPSJFT�XJUI�1SPKFDU�

.BOBHFS�,FMMZ�'PY��4VHHFTUJPOT�GPS�OFXTMFUUFS�BOE�XFCTJUF�TUPSJFT�BSF�BMXBZT�XFMDPNF�UPP��.FNCFST�PG�UIF�*1JO$)�DPM�

MFDUJWF �XF�OFFE�UP�IFBS�ZPVS�WPJDFT�