IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to...

22
IOU Collaboration November 15 th , 2016 Mitch Brey Campaign Director RePower Madison 920-323-9585 [email protected] www.repowermadison.org

Transcript of IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to...

Page 1: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

IOU Collaboration

November 15th, 2016

Mitch Brey

Campaign Director

RePower Madison

920-323-9585

[email protected]

www.repowermadison.org

Page 2: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

What is RePower Madison?

Citizen group formed in 2014 in response

to MGE's unpopular billing scheme.

Working to increase citizen involvement

in energy decision-making.

Page 3: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

MGE's Rate Case -2014

Changes to energy bill:

Higher mandatory monthly fixed fees

Slightly lower charge base on usage

Page 4: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Billing Scheme

Low-energy users suffer

High-energy users save

Page 5: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Uproar

Page 6: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Strong Community Pushback

Page 7: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Broad Community Outcry

Page 8: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

“MGE opposes Madison’s

Effort to Grow Solar Energy”

The utility didn’t support city’s 2014 SunShot grant application

Page 9: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Pressure causes MGE to

Consider Changing Course

In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000

customers promising the opportunity to weigh in before

further bill restructuring – “Community Energy Conversations”

MGE asked for input on next 10 year plan

Guidance to become “the utility of the future”

Page 10: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Four-Phase Process

Phase I - Introductory meetings

with key stakeholders - June

2015.

Phase II - Community Energy

Conversations, designed to

engage customers and the

public to contribute guidance

for future energy decisions -

July to November 2015.

Page 11: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Phase III - Community Energy Workshop – April

19th, 2016. Phase III also included individual

dialogues between MGE and stakeholder

groups.

Phase IV – JSA proposal for formation of a

Community Energy Partnership – Fall 2016

Page 12: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Community Energy

Partnership

Strong community representation with

transparency and accountability.

Promote programs to increase energy efficiency

and renewables for all.

Assure customers have an active role in decision

making.

Page 13: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

MGE CEO Gary Wolter “we wanted to ask customers, communities and

stakeholders to help MGE become the utility of the future.”

Community Energy Partnership?

http://www.channel3000.com/madison-magazine/business-city-life/madison-could-be-

home-of-utility-of-the-future/33385174

Page 14: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Community Conversation Results

The report listed participants most important issues:

A reduced carbon footprint

Self-generated power

More information about the grid and reliability

More diverse MGE leadership

An emphasis on conservation

A renewed commitment to equity

More information and communication

RPM’s analysis found:

Opposition to mandatory fees was 2nd most frequent comment

Page 15: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

What did MGE do with all that

community input?

Page 16: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

MGE's Energy 2030 Framework

Provide 30% of retail energy sales from

renewable resources by 2030

Reduce CO2 pollution by 40% from 2005

levels by 2030

Pledged not to increase fixed fees in 2017

Page 17: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Additional Pressure

A “Technical Workgroup” - CUB, Clean WI, & MGE

Alternative business models and rate designs

Shareholder Advocates

Withdrew shareholder resolutions in exchange

for dialogue and a renewable energy study

“MGE Shareholders for Clean Energy”

City of Madison’s Energy Work Plan

Explored (legal) options to meet energy goals

City currently in negotiations with MGE over

potential collaboration

Page 18: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Empowered

A tale of three cities taking

charge of their energy future.

Boulder, Minneapolis, Madison

Available for free at

midwestenergynews.com/books

Page 19: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Madison's Energy Plan

In 2011 The Sustainability Plan was put together to

help Madison reach its clean energy goals.

80% carbon reduction by 2050

25% of electricity, heating, and

transportation energy produced from clean

energy by 2025

Reduce overall energy consumption by 50%

by 2030

Page 20: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

10 Point Plan

1) Review the city's climate change goals.

2) Create city staff to focus on energy issues and

implement the plan.

3) Support regional energy initiatives.

4) Promote existing city programs related to energy

efficiency and renewable energy.

5) Establish a city-wide Property Assessed Clean

Energy (PACE) program.

Page 21: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

6) Implement benchmarking.

7) Record city-owned

property suitable for solar

development.

8) Increase the city's green

sector economic development

efforts.

9) Study feasibility of an

internal sustainability fund

based on city-operations.

10) Negotiate with MGE on

clean energy efforts.

Page 22: IOU Collaborationus.sustain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Investor-Owned...Pressure causes MGE to Consider Changing Course In October 2014, MGE sent a formal letter to 141,000 customers

Thank you! Questions?

Contact Mitch Brey:

[email protected]

www.facebook.com/repowermadison

www.repowermadison.org

Twitter: @RePowerMadison