Investigating Subjectivity

21
Investigating Subjectivity Weeks #2-3

description

Investigating Subjectivity. Weeks #2-3. What is a subject ?. Implications. Subject of subjective “ the mind, ego, or agent of whatever sort that sustains or assumes the form of thought or consciousness” -- Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary Subject to - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Investigating Subjectivity

Page 1: Investigating Subjectivity

Investigating Subjectivity

Weeks #2-3

Page 2: Investigating Subjectivity

•What is a subject?

Page 3: Investigating Subjectivity

Implications

• Subject of subjective “the mind, ego, or agent of whatever sort that

sustains or assumes the form of thought or consciousness”

--Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary

• Subject to “one that is placed under authority or control” --Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary

Page 4: Investigating Subjectivity

Related Terms

• Individual

• Identity

•Agent

•Self

•Ego

Page 5: Investigating Subjectivity

René Descartes

• The ideology of the Enlightenment

• “I think therefore I am.”

Page 6: Investigating Subjectivity

René Descartes• “From that I knew that I was a substanc

e, the whole essence or nature or which is to think, and that for its existence there is no need of any place, nor does it depend on any material thing; so that this ‘me,’ that is to say, the soul by which I am what I am, is entirely distinct from body, and is even more easy to know than is the latter; and even if body were not, the soul would not cease to be what it is.” (qtd. in Damasio 249)

Page 7: Investigating Subjectivity

René Descartes

• The Cartesian mind-body split: the thinking mind was somehow more real than the body in which it is housed

http://www.wsu.edu/~dee/ENLIGHT/DESCARTE.HTM

Page 8: Investigating Subjectivity

• Louis Althusser

• “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses”

• http://www.brocku.ca/english/jlye/ideology.html • http://www.colorado.edu/English/courses/ENGL2012Klag

es/marxism.html (general)• http://www.colorado.edu/English/courses/ENGL2012Klag

es/1997althusser.html (Althusser)• http://www.brocku.ca/english/courses/4F70/aunt.html (an

example)

Page 9: Investigating Subjectivity

• RSAs—Repressive State Apparatuses

(e.g. the police, the criminal justice, prison)

• ISAs—Ideological State Apparatuses

(e.g. the family, the educational system, language, the media, the political system)

Page 10: Investigating Subjectivity

• We are “always already subjects” (32).

• Rituals of ideological recognition (e.g. the hand-shake, calling you by your name) “guarantee for us that we are indeed concrete, individual, distinguishable and (naturally) irreplaceable subjects” (32).

Page 11: Investigating Subjectivity

• “[All] ideology hails or interpellates concrete individuals as concrete subjects” (33).

• Interpellation or hailing: e.g. police hailing: “Hey, you there!” (33)

Page 12: Investigating Subjectivity

Individuals Interpellation subjects

hailing

rituals

recognition

misrecognition

Page 13: Investigating Subjectivity

• “[Ideology] has no outside (for itself), but at the same time that it is nothing but outside (for science and reality).” (34)

Page 14: Investigating Subjectivity

• On Christian religious ideology: “there can only be such a multitude of possible religious subjects on the absolute condition that there is a Unique, Absolute, Other Subject, i.e. God” (35).

Page 15: Investigating Subjectivity

• “[The] interpellation of individuals as subjects presupposes the ‘existence’ of a Unique and central Other Subject, in whose Name the religious ideology interpellates all individuals as subjects” (35)

Page 16: Investigating Subjectivity

• “God is thus the Subject, and Moses and the innumerable subjects of God’s people, the Subject’s interlocutors-interpellates: his mirrors, his reflections. Were not men made in the image of God? As all theological reflection proves, whereas He ‘could’ perfectly well have done without men, God needs them, the Subject needs the subjects, just as men need God, the subjects need the Subject” (36).

Page 17: Investigating Subjectivity

• “[All] ideology is centred, that the Absolute Subject occupies the unique place of the Centre, and interpellates around it the infinity of individuals into subjects . . .” (36).

Page 18: Investigating Subjectivity

• 1. Scientific discourse is privileged as a “subject-less” discourse, the language to be used when uncovering/examining ideology (31-32). Is this view justified? Could we ever be outside ideology?

• 2. What’s the ideology of the boy scouts’ oath? Or that of US naturalization oath of allegiance?

• 3. Give an example of interpellation.

Page 19: Investigating Subjectivity

梅花 (dir. 劉家昌 )

Page 20: Investigating Subjectivity

梅花• What’s the predominant ideology?

• Locate the moment when the second son ( 柯俊雄飾 ) is interpellated by the Chinese ideology.

• Which ideology is omitted or repressed?

Page 21: Investigating Subjectivity

•The End