Introduction Mapping Land Cover Change...all Haiti needs a comprehensive reforestation management...

1
Hai, one of the poorest countries in the western hemisphere, shares the Caribbean island of Hispaniola with the Dominican Republic. Today Hai is nearly 98% deforested. This issue caught internaonal aenon in the 1990s when Naonal Geographic published a photo of Hispaniola, where the border between the two countries could be idenfied by differences in vegetaon. In the photo, Hai on the leſt, lacked the lush green color of the DR on the right. Deforestaon in Hai was accelerated in the 1980s when polical turmoil and dictatorships led to high levels of poverty and the United States capitalized on favorable trade agreements to buy Haian lumber. Subsistence farming in common in Hai, parcularly in the rural mountainous regions. Although planng crops on Hai’s many hillsides is both economically counterproduc- ve and ecologically unsustainable, reforesta- on is not feasible for the majority of Haian farmers because many of them survive on an- nual incomes of less than 700 USD and depend on subsistence farming for food. This cycle of overuse has resulted in low producvity, erosion, mudslides, flooding and leached topsoil. Ecologists assert that naons require at least 30% of forest cover to maintain ecological balance. It is believed that in a mountainous country such as Hai, higher levels of coverage are necessary to protect topsoil from erosion and mudslides. Reaching these levels of reforestaon in Hai is stunted by poverty, the use of charcoal for cooking and lack of polical will. Accurate mapping of land cover in Hai is sll limited and idenficaon of priority reforestaon areas has yet to be completed using remote sensing. Over- all Hai needs a comprehensive reforestaon management plan that can bal- ance environmental remediaon needs and the pracce of subsistence farming. This project focuses on mapping change in vegetaon cover in the Northwest Region of Hai as proof of the lack of progress in addressing Hai’s known de- forestaon issues. In order to create a land cover classificaon for the Northwest Peninsula of Hai, satellite imagery was downloaded from LandSat. The 2013 map was cre- ated using LandSat 8 imagery from August 2013. Bands 2, 3, 4 and 7 were made into a composite layer that was then masked to the country border for Hai. Next the unsupervised Iso Cluster tool was run using 20 classes. The 2000 map was created using LandSat 4/5 imagery from August 2000. The same steps were repeated using Bands 1, 2, 3 and 7 of the LandSat 4/5 imagery. Once the Iso Cluster layers were created, satellite imagery and Google Earth imagery we referenced to reclassify the layer into 5 categories for the 2000 map and 6 categories for the 20013 map. A broad classificaon was used for this analysis because the purpose was to look at the presence or absence of forest cover, not the difference between urban areas and agricultural land for exam- ple. In addion, a Boolean analysis was used to compare vegetaon change be- tween the 2000 and 2013 maps. performing this analysis 2013 land cover was masked to the same size as the 2000 layer because it has a larger land area overall. The 1 (forested) and 2 (sparse forest) values for 2000 were subtracted from the 1 (forested) and 2 (sparse forest) values for the 2013 map leading to the new values found in Table 1. Before This Boolean analysis therefore only shows changes in forest cover based on the forested and sparse forest classifica- ons from both layers. This land cover analysis showed that there has not been a significant change in forested land in the Northwest region of the country. In fact a Boolean analy- sis showed that there was more area deforested that reforested between 2000 and 2013. This could be explained by the addional cloud cover in the 2013 im- agery which may be covering forested areas. Visually there appears to be some connued deforestaon in the middle of the region with some reforestaon in the northeast poron of the region studied. It is also clear from visual analysis that the far west remained defor- ested. These findings confirm that Hai has not made significant pro- gress in addressing deforestaon from 2000 ll now following cover- age of the issue on the internaon- al stage in the 1900s despite inia- ves to promote reforestaon. This remote sensing analysis was sufficient to show forested areas in com- parison to deforested areas in the region, however it was not sufficient to show different types of vegetaon. Similarly it was able to show changes in the forest- ed areas in the region based off the limited land cover classificaons. However, the Iso Cluster reclassificaon misclassified a substanal amount of pixels throughout the region. In parcular the northwest coast. Errors in misclassifica- on between the 2000 and 2013 layers was not consistent leading to less accu- rate comparisons between the two years. In addion, increased cloud cover in the 2013 satellite imagery further reduced the validity of the data because it was included in the Boolean analysis. Further research in this area should include mapping of current and historic land cover in all of Hai. More detailed land cover analysis, with addional veg- etaon and land use categories, would allow for more detailed analysis of land cover or land use changes over me as well as idenfying areas for reforestaon in Hai. Mapping Land Cover Change 2000 to 2013 Northwest region, Haiti Jessica Laporte ● ENV117 - Introducon to GIS ● Fall 2013 Map Data Sources: Landsat 8, Landsat 4/5 and Hai Data Scale 1:655,664 ● Projecon: WGS_1984_UTM_Zone_18N Land cover 2000 Table 1. Calculang Change (2000-2013) 2000 Value 2013 Value Reclass val- ues for 2000 and 2013 Values from Boolean Analysis Classificaon 1 - Forested 1 - Forested 1 -1 Forest cover lost 2 - Sparse Forest 2 - Sparse Forest 1 0 Forest cover re- mained the same 3-5 3-6 0 1 Forest cover gained Land cover 2013 Change in Land Cover 2000-2013 Introduction Results Methods - Part I Methods - Part II Limitations Figure 1. Map: Hai and Dominican Republic Figure 2. Change in Land Cover 2000-2013

Transcript of Introduction Mapping Land Cover Change...all Haiti needs a comprehensive reforestation management...

Page 1: Introduction Mapping Land Cover Change...all Haiti needs a comprehensive reforestation management plan that can bal-ance environmental remediation needs and the practice of subsistence

Haiti, one of the poorest countries in the western hemisphere, shares the

Caribbean island of Hispaniola with the Dominican Republic. Today Haiti is

nearly 98% deforested. This issue caught international attention in the 1990s

when National Geographic published a photo of Hispaniola, where the border

between the two countries could be identified by differences in vegetation. In

the photo, Haiti on the left, lacked the lush green color of the DR on the right.

Deforestation in Haiti was accelerated in the 1980s when political turmoil and

dictatorships led to high levels of poverty and the United States capitalized on

favorable trade agreements to buy Haitian lumber.

Subsistence farming in common in Haiti,

particularly in the rural mountainous regions.

Although planting crops on Haiti’s many

hillsides is both economically counterproduc-

tive and ecologically unsustainable, reforesta-

tion is not feasible for the majority of Haitian

farmers because many of them survive on an-

nual incomes of less than 700 USD and depend

on subsistence farming for food. This cycle of overuse has resulted in low

productivity, erosion, mudslides, flooding and leached topsoil.

Ecologists assert that nations require at least 30% of forest cover to maintain

ecological balance. It is believed that in a mountainous country such as Haiti,

higher levels of coverage are necessary to protect topsoil from erosion and

mudslides. Reaching these levels of reforestation in Haiti is stunted by poverty,

the use of charcoal for cooking and lack of political will.

Accurate mapping of land cover in Haiti is still limited and identification of

priority reforestation areas has yet to be completed using remote sensing. Over-

all Haiti needs a comprehensive reforestation management plan that can bal-

ance environmental remediation needs and the practice of subsistence farming.

This project focuses on mapping change in vegetation cover in the Northwest

Region of Haiti as proof of the lack of progress in addressing Haiti’s known de-

forestation issues.

In order to create a land cover classification for the Northwest Peninsula of

Haiti, satellite imagery was downloaded from LandSat. The 2013 map was cre-

ated using LandSat 8 imagery from August 2013. Bands 2, 3, 4 and 7 were made

into a composite layer that was then masked to the country border for Haiti.

Next the unsupervised Iso Cluster tool was run using 20 classes. The 2000 map

was created using LandSat 4/5 imagery from August 2000. The same steps were

repeated using Bands 1, 2, 3 and 7 of the LandSat 4/5 imagery.

Once the Iso Cluster layers were created, satellite imagery and Google Earth

imagery we referenced to reclassify the layer into 5 categories for the 2000 map

and 6 categories for the 20013 map. A broad classification was used for this

analysis because the purpose was to look at the presence or absence of forest

cover, not the difference between urban areas and agricultural land for exam-

ple.

In addition, a Boolean analysis was used to compare vegetation change be-

tween the 2000 and 2013 maps. performing this analysis 2013 land cover was

masked to the same size as the 2000 layer because it has a larger land area

overall. The 1 (forested) and 2 (sparse forest) values for 2000 were subtracted

from the 1 (forested) and 2 (sparse forest) values for the 2013 map leading to

the new values found in Table 1. Before This Boolean analysis therefore only

shows changes in forest cover based on the forested and sparse forest classifica-

tions from both layers.

This land cover analysis showed that there has not been a significant change

in forested land in the Northwest region of the country. In fact a Boolean analy-

sis showed that there was more area deforested that reforested between 2000

and 2013. This could be explained by the additional cloud cover in the 2013 im-

agery which may be covering forested areas. Visually there appears to be some

continued deforestation in the middle of the region with some reforestation in

the northeast portion of the region studied. It is also clear from visual analysis

that the far west remained defor-

ested. These findings confirm that

Haiti has not made significant pro-

gress in addressing deforestation

from 2000 till now following cover-

age of the issue on the internation-

al stage in the 1900s despite initia-

tives to promote reforestation.

This remote sensing analysis was sufficient to show forested areas in com-

parison to deforested areas in the region, however it was not sufficient to show

different types of vegetation. Similarly it was able to show changes in the forest-

ed areas in the region based off the limited land cover classifications. However,

the Iso Cluster reclassification misclassified a substantial amount of pixels

throughout the region. In particular the northwest coast. Errors in misclassifica-

tion between the 2000 and 2013 layers was not consistent leading to less accu-

rate comparisons between the two years. In addition, increased cloud cover in

the 2013 satellite imagery further reduced the validity of the data because it

was included in the Boolean analysis.

Further research in this area should include mapping of current and historic

land cover in all of Haiti. More detailed land cover analysis, with additional veg-

etation and land use categories, would allow for more detailed analysis of land

cover or land use changes over time as well as identifying areas for reforestation

in Haiti.

Mapping Land Cover Change

2000 to 2013

Northwest region, Haiti

Jessica Laporte ● ENV117 - Introduction to GIS ● Fall 2013

Map Data Sources: Landsat 8, Landsat 4/5 and Haiti Data

Scale 1:655,664 ● Projection: WGS_1984_UTM_Zone_18N

Land cover 2000

Table 1. Calculating Change (2000-2013)

2000 Value 2013 Value Reclass val-ues for 2000 and 2013

Values from Boolean Analysis

Classification

1 - Forested 1 - Forested 1 -1 Forest cover lost 2 - Sparse

Forest 2 - Sparse

Forest 1 0 Forest cover re-

mained the same 3-5 3-6 0 1 Forest cover gained

Land cover 2013

Change in Land Cover 2000-2013

Introduction

Results

Methods - Part I

Methods - Part II

Limitations

Figure 1. Map: Haiti and Dominican Republic

Figure 2. Change in Land Cover 2000-2013