Introduction and Status of QCD Exotics K. Peters GSI Darmstadt/JWGU Frankfurt Hadron Physics at COSY...

Introduction and Status of QCD Exotics

K. PetersGSI Darmstadt/JWGU Frankfurt

Hadron Physics at COSY 2005Bad Honnef, July 25-29

2

K. Peters - Status of QCD Exotics

Overview

IntroductionStatus of Spin-ExoticsStatus of Glueball-SearchFuture Experiments

Not coveredPentaquarksBaryoniumCharmonium-Spectrum

3


What are EXOTIC hadrons ?

Unconventional hadronsDepends on what is the convention

ConventionMatter is build out of quarks

• proton consists of 3 quarks

• pion consists of a quark and an antiquark

UnconventionalHadronic matter is not made entirely out of quarksQuark configurations different from baryons and mesons

But not forbidden !

4


Classification (Close & Lipkin)

Exotics of the first kind

External quantum numbers unambiguously incompatible with assignment to baryons or mesons

B=1 – baryon-likeQ>2, Q<-1, S<-3, S>0, I>3/2, ....

B=0 – meson-like|Q|>1, I>1, |S|>2, |C|>2, |S-C|>1, ....

1

5



Exotics of the second kind

Combination of quantum numbers not allowed for leading Fock-term

Only possible for B=0

JPC = 0--, 0+-,1-+, 2+-, ...cannot be formed by any unexcited qq-System

2

6



Exotics of the third kind – Crypto-Exotics

Internal exotic structurelike gluonic excitationslike N-quarks

but no model free signature

approach:overpopulation of hadron multipletsunexpected masses and decay propertiesa well understood conventional

meson picture is mandatory 3

7


( )14 0

( )54 8

'( )95 7

K( )49 51 S1

0

( )1300

( 1295)

'(1490 )

K( )14602 S1

0

( )1800

( )1775

K( )18303 S1

0

( )77 0

( )78 2

(10 20 )

K*( )89 21 S3

1

( )1450

( 1420)

( )1680

K *( )14102 S3

1

a 2

( )1320

a 1

( )1260

f2

( )1270

f1

( )1285

f '2

( )1525

K 2

( )1430

K 1

( )1400

b 1

( )1235

h 1( 1170)

h '1

( )1380

K 1

( )12701 P1

1

a 0

( )1450

f0

( )1370

f0

( )1710

K 0

(1430)1 P3

0

1 P31

1 P32

f2

( )1810

f '2( 2040)

K 2

( )19802 P3

2

2 P31

2 P30

2 P11

L=0 L=1

F ( )0 975

a ( )0 980

f ( )0 1515

1( )1400

1( )1600

( )1410

f ( )2 1565

f ( )2 1640

M

seen at single decayunam biguousestablished (PDG)

LEAR

notq q ?!

1 GeV/ c2

2 GeV/ c2

a 1

( )1700

a 2

(1 650)

b 1

( )1700

Meson Spectrum after the LEAR Era

The LEAR Era withthe experiments

@ CERN

• Asterix/Obelix

• Crystal Barrel

• Jetset/PS185

• WA102/Gams@ BNL

• E818/E852@ FNAL

• E760/E835@Serpukhov

• VES/Gams

produced impressive results with high statistics and high resolution

8


SPIN-PARITY EXOTICS (2nd Kind)Search for Hybrids

9


Intermediate State Mixing

Many states may contribute to a final state

not only ones with well defined

(already measured) properties

not only expected ones

Many mixing parameters are poorly known

K-phasesSU(3) phases

In additionalso D/S mixing (b1,a1 decays)

10


Simplest Hybrids

S-Wave+Gluon (qq)8g with ()8=coloured1S0 3S1

combined with a 1+ or 1- gluon

Gluon 1– (TM) 1+(TE)

1S0, 0–+ 1++ 1––

3S1, 1–– 0+- 0–+

1+- 1–+

2+- 2–+

Meson – Hybrid Mixing

gMIX

gFSI

q

q

11


Fluxtube Predictions

N. Isgur, R. Kokoski und J. Paton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 (1985) 869 and refs thereinF.E. Close und P. R. Page, Nucl. Phys. B443 (1995) 233

(u,d)g

(n,s)g

ccg

12


Light-quark hybrids

recent new determination of exotic 1-+ hybrid mesonimproved staggered fermions (lighter quark masses)quenched and unquenched, Wilson gluon actiona ~ 0.09 fmlightest mass still

above experiment

MILC, hep-lat/0301024

quenched continuum limit

sduf mmmN ,3

sdu mmm 4.0(around strange quark mass)

13


Rediscovery of the 1(1400)

peak @ 1.4 GeV/ cphasem otion at a tail visible

2

2

B N LE 852

B N LE 852

^ ( ) 1400

Advantage: I = 1 and no S calars

GeV / c2 4

Ge

V/c

24

m ( )

m(

)

1.

1.

2.

2.

3.( )770

a2( )1320

^ ( ) 1400

Cr ystalB ar r el

52.500 E.

πp π-η p (and π0η n) pd π-π0η p @ Rest in liq.D2

14


Proof of evidence for exotic wave - CB

Posit ive (F it - D at a)

Ne g a tive

2 (F it - D at a)

5

5

no 1 in F it

1 in F it

2

a2

a2

a2

a2

0 1

1

2

2

3

3

GeV / c2 4

GeV / c2 4

0 1

1

2

2

3

3

GeV / c2 4

GeV / c2 4

0 1

1

2

2

3

3

GeV / c2 4

GeV / c2 4

0 1

1

2

2

3

3

GeV / c2 4

GeV / c2 4

Cr ystalBar r el

15


Controversary in E852

FSI Description in ηπ-

Szczepaniak, et al., PRL 91, 092002 (2003)

16


Controversary in E852, cont‘d

in E852 in ηπ0

the amplitudes are different for different regions

BW solution fails

17


π1(1400) Summary

1400 MeV/c2 region well establishedphase motion against a2(1320) in πp

interference with ρ(770) in pd @ rest

signal in πη is at b1π and f1π thresholdinfluences resultsline shapes and pole positions affected

exotic wave is evidentit might span over a wide rangeis it a Hybrid? probably not – decuplet state?

18


E852 ρπ

BN LE 852

1

(X - 1 )- +

2

1 (I =1) 1 (I =1)

2

2 f 2

0 f 0

π-p π-ρ0p π-π-π+pshows a clear resonance in the 1-+ wave around 1600 MeV/c2

19


VES η‘π

resonant structurein η‘π at 1600 MeV/c2

in ηπ at 1400 MeV/c2

η and η‘ are coupled via SU(3) any interpretation of the π1

resonances have to explain the

difference

Verificationof πη(') resultsin ρπ channel

ρ(16xx) observedby two independentexperiments in ρπand η‘π

V E S

1

(2 - 1 )++ - +

V ES , H adron ‘95 /’97

V E SI ( J ) = 1 (1 )G PC - - +

1(14 0 0 )

1(16 0 0 )

E852

20


E852 f1π and b1π

blue one 1-+ poleblack two poles2=70.6/47=1.5

E852

E852

E852

21


E852 more b1π

first observation of a non 1-+ exotic

h2(1950) with JPC=2+-

M=1954±8Γ=138±3

another h2 may be at M=2300

22


Spin-exotic Summary

thanks to G. Adams, RPI

23


Charmed Hybrids

LQCD: gluonic excitations of the quark-antiquark-potential may lead to bound states-potential

• for one-gluon exchange-potential

• from excited gluon flux

mHcc ~ 4.2-4.5 GeV/c2

Light charmed hybridscould be narrow if open charm decays are inaccessible or suppressed

important <r2> and rBreakup

3

3.5

4

1 2

R/r0

V(R)/GeV

J/ψ

χc

ψ‘

Hcc

DD

24


GLUEBALLS(usually 3rd Kind)

25


SU(N) Glueballs on the Lattice

recent study of 0++,2++, 0++* glueballs in SU(N), N=2,3,4,5

masses depend linearly on N large N limits differ little from N=3

Lucini, Teper, JHEP 06, 050 (2001).

Morningstar und Peardon, PRD60 (1999) 034509Morningstar und Peardon, PRD56 (1997) 4043

26


f0(1500) – Crystal Barrel @ LEAR

f0(1500) is very narrow (~100 MeV/c2) and decays dominantly to (2n)π

und p 2 @ Ruhep 0 p 3p 0

GeV

/c2

4

G eV / c2 4

m ( )2 1 2 m ( )2

m(

)2

1

3

m(

)2

712.000 E.

1.

2.

3.

1. 2. 3.

f (1350)0

f (1500)0

f (1550)2

f (1270)2

f (975)0

C B , A ker et a l., P LB 260(1991)249C B , A m sle r et a l., PLB 342(1995)433

f ( 1350)0

f ( 1500)0

a (980)0

a (980)0

211.000 E .MeV / c2 4

MeV / c2 4

C B , A m sle r et a l., PLB 291(1992)347C B , A m sle r et a l., PLB 353(1995)571

K*

K*

1500 MeV

ein K beobachtetein K durch fehlende Masse

L

L

p p K KL L0

m (K )/GeV /2 0 2 4L c

m(K

)/G

eV/

20

24

Lc

02.55

7.510

12.515

17.520

22.5

1550 1600 1650 1700m(,) MeV

Einträ

ge

2300

2400

2500

2600

2700

2800

2900

3000x 103

1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700x 10

3m(0,)2

/MeV

/c24

m(, )2

/MeV/c2 4

m( ')

p ’p

m(4 )

p 5p

27


fj(1710) in radiative J/ decays

Mark III and DM2found a scalar resonance @ 1700 MeV/c2

in KK in radiative decays of the J/

It took more than a decade to establish the scalar nature of this object

DM2

MarkIII

28


SOZI - DOZI - Analysis

SOZI DOZI

DOZISOZI

MarkI I I

f0(1500) in 4π and

fj(1710) in KK

.........“DOZI”-enhanced

......... both should contain remarkable gg content

J /

c

c

G

J /

c

c

J /

c

c

f,f' (q )q

S OZI

DOZI suppression forconventional qq

29


Central Production

CERN-experiments:WA76, WA91, WA102Important results in the

scalar (ππ,KK,KsKs,4) tensor (ππ,KK,KsKs,4)pseudoscalar (KKπ,ππη) sectors

But: ~ 1/M2

no charm-sectorpartial wave (moment)-

analysis complicated little фф,ωω statistics

Future:Compass, much

higher statistics

Pomeron-Pomeron

N

P

PSee-Quark-Formation

N

N

30


Meson Glueball Mixing

Physical Massesf0(1370),f0(1500),f0(1710)

Bare Masses:m1,m2,mG

( )uu dd

2

+

ss

(G) (S) (N)f0(1370) -0.690.07 0.150.01 0.700.07f0(1500) -0.650.04 0.330.04 –0.700.07f0(1710) 0.390.03 0.910.02 0.150.02

m1=137720 m2=167410 mG=144324

octet piece

Lattice of about 1600

31


Anisovich & Sarantsev

Anisovich and Sarantsev, hep-ph/0204328

K-Matrix approach M= 280 – 1900 MeV

Uses data from GAMS at small and large nucleon momentumE852CERN-Munich scatteringCrystal Barrel

For the channels ππ, ηη, ηη‘, KK, ππππNo f0(600) = σ

Found f0(980), f0(1300), f0(1500),

f0(1750) and f0(1200-1600)

32


DS+ π+π-π+ (+c.c)

E791

BaBar

E.M. Aitala et al., PRL 765 (2001)

B. Lewandowski, Proc. Meson 2002PHD Th. Deppermann, Bochum 2003

848 E.

2903 E.PRELIMINARY

DDS

non-unitary approach needs interference of 4 resonances for the strange peak K-Matrix approach resolves it

33


D+ π+π-π+ (+c.c)

E791E.M. Aitala et al., PRD 770 (2002)

1172 E.

non-unitary approach yields 50% σ K-Matrix approach removes any σ contribution

34


Problems in Analysis and Interpretation

many processes, therefore no trivial production amplitude

coupled channels contain very many production amplitudes

complicated interferences

in K0SK0

S contr. from K0K0 and K0K0

direct FSI

directFSI

directFSI

+

Wc

s_

s

s_

Wc

s_ s

_s

I=0, KK* or c.c._

no only K0K0*+c.c.Wc

s_

s_

s_DCS

W

c

s_

s_

s

ColorS

35


The scalar particles

most interpretations assume the doubtless K0*(1430) from LASS to be the I=1/2-state

and that the a0(1400) is the I=1-state

two classes of arrangementsa00(980) & f0(975) are isospin-partner

a0(980) & f0(975) are completely independent

a reasonable model must be able to handle the mixing of isoscalars

as well as t- and u-channel exchange

36


Scalar Summary

Puzzle still unsolved ....

37


KK

’

4

4

re vie w

K* K*

NN

1.8 2.2

100

200

300

M

2.0

f (19 2 0 )2

f (18 10 )2

f (19 8 0 )2

(2 2 3 0 )

f (2 3 5 0 )2f (2 2 0 0 )2

f (2 0 5 0 )2

1.8

2.2

100

200

300

M

G .I.-Sta te s

0 ?+ +

2.0

2 GeV Tensors

Sorted by measured final state

Structure unclear

38


f2(1920)

1.6 2.0 2.4GeV/c2

600

400

200

1.6 2.0 2.4GeV/c2

1.6 1.8 2.0

100

200

300

GeV/c2

GAMS

VES

cos <0.5

cos >0.5

all p cex.-

’

’ ’

t<0.06 0.2<t<0.35

0.35<t<0.6

39


f2(2200)

MarkI I I

rad. J /

K KS S4K±

K K 2K±L S

MarkI I I

rad. J /

K KS S4K±

K K 2K±L S

c. prod.

t<0.06

GAMS

Broad resonanceat 2.2 GeV/c2

L3

K KS S

40


SUMMARY and OUTLOOK I

Hybrids

Many Spin-Parity Exoticsπ1(1400) ***

π1(1600) ****

π1(2000) **

h2(1950) *

h2(2300) (*)

Future investigationsGlueX for the light quark sectorPanda for the onia and heavy light sector

41


SUMMARY and OUTLOOK II

Glueballs

Too many scalars with an unclear natureexperimental situation fairly good, saturatedD(s)-decays can not help solving this issue

Many unconfirmed tensorsimportant field for the future to settle the spectrumBESIII and Panda are well suited

42


FUTURE EXPERIMENTS

43


pion

π-p X0n

exotic/non-exotic ~ 1exotic/non-exotic ~ 0.1

Szczepaniak & Swat (01)

photon

γp X+n

Possible narrow QCD exotic (M=1.6 GeV) (E852 π-p π+π-π-p)

Implications for exotic meson searches

44


CHL-2CHL-2

Upgrade magnets Upgrade magnets and power and power suppliessupplies

Hall D @ JLab and the 12 GeV Upgrade

Construction start - 200?Physics - 200?+4

45


The GSI Future Facility

Panda

Existing GSI Facilities

46


0 2 4 6 8 12 1510

p Momentum [GeV/c]

Mass [GeV/c2]

Two bodythresholds

Molecules

GluonicExcitations

qq Mesons

1 2 3 4 5 6

Hybrids

Hybrids+Recoil

Glueball

Glueball+Recoil

ΛΛΣΣΞΞ

ΛcΛc

ΣcΣc

ΞcΞc

ΩcΩcΩΩ DDDsDs

qqqq ccqq

nng,ssg ccg

ggg,gg

light qqπ,ρ,ω,f2,K,K*

ccJ/ψ, ηc, χcJ

nng,ssg ccg

ggg

Accessible Charmed Hadrons at PANDA @ GSI

Other exotics with identical decay channels same region

conventionalcharmonium

exoticcharmonium

47


BES III @ BEPC2

BEPC2 will operate as τcf and synchrotron light source

Start of operation 2007

Beam energy 1 – 2.1 GeV

Optimal energy 1.89 GeV

Luminosity 1 x 10 33 cm-2s-1 @ 1.89 GeV

Linac requirements Full energy injection: 1.55 1.89 GeV Positron injection rate > 50 mA/min

Dedicated SR 250 mA @ 2.5 GeV

48


BES III Physics Performance Example

J/ψρ0ηπ0

Well identified ρ(1390) ρ(2300)via partial waveanalysis

Introduction and Status of QCD Exotics K. Peters GSI Darmstadt/JWGU Frankfurt Hadron Physics at COSY...

Documents

Transcript of Introduction and Status of QCD Exotics K. Peters GSI Darmstadt/JWGU Frankfurt Hadron Physics at COSY...