INTO YOUR EFFORTS...$1.5 million in funding to the project. “Distillation accounts for roughly 40%...
Transcript of INTO YOUR EFFORTS...$1.5 million in funding to the project. “Distillation accounts for roughly 40%...
PUTSTEAMINTO YOUR EFFORTS
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK
TABLE OF CONTENTSEnergy Efficiency Soars 4
Broad-ranging efforts are providing substantial savings
Provide Better Protection from Hot Pipes 11
Use more conservative limits for insulation skin temperature
Keep Cool Designing Heat Exchanger Piping 15
Consider these points when working with exchangers, coils and jackets
Additional Resources 17
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 2
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
AD INDEXCheck-All Valve Mfg • www.checkall.com 10
Pick Heaters Inc. • www.pickheaters.com/chemical-pharmaceutical.html 14
Pick Direct steam injection water heating sys-
tems are ideal for closed-loop heating of various
products in jacketed vessels. Precise, accu-
rate temperature control eliminates the risk of
burn-on and product damage. Direct steam injec-
tion also can replace indirect heat exchangers
as hot water sets for batch filling and cleaning.
Direct steam injection provides 100% heat trans-
fer, which can cut fuel costs up to 28% compared
with indirect heat exchangers, says the company.
Pick steam injection heaters can be packaged
and skid mounted to meet process requirements
for jacketed reactors, tank filling, boiler feed water heating, cleaning and other heat trans-
fer applications.
Pick packaged hot water sets come fully assembled and ready for operation and can be
sized for pilot or full-scale production. These sets are quiet and
compact and offer temperature control within + 1°C with oper-
ating temperatures up to 302°F (150°C). Systems are available
in ten standard sizes for liquid flow rates up to 5,000 gpm, and
steam flow rates up to 50,000 lb/hr. Standard materials of
construction include cast iron, carbon steel and stainless steel.
Specialty alloys are available on request.
PRODUCT FOCUS
STEAM INJECTION HEATING SYSTEMS SUIT DEMANDING APPLICATIONS
Pick Heaters, Inc. | 262-338-1191 | www.pickheaters.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 3
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
The drive by some chemical compa-
nies to improve energy efficiency
extends well beyond their pro-
duction processes. For instance, Eastman
Chemicals, BASF, AkzoNobel and Dow are
working hard to find energy savings in all
aspects of corporate life.
One of the main efforts of Kingsport, Tenn.-
based Eastman Chemicals focuses on
reliable supply of high-pressure steam for
powering several large compressors for the
cracker at the company’s Longview, Texas,
plant. The steam comes from either an
on-site cogeneration facility or less efficient
boilers within the cracker operation itself.
The reliability problem was highlighted one
night last year when the limited turndown
of the cogeneration facility forced the shut-
down of one of its two combustion turbines.
This reduced the reliability of the high-pres-
sure steam supply, causing the cracker to
produce the steam using its own boilers.
To solve this problem, the company has
installed novel burner technology in the
two cogeneration combustion turbines. This
greatly increases their turndown, allowing
both to remain online at all times.
“This improved steam reliability to the
point that high-pressure steam production
could be shifted from the cracker to the
cogeneration plant. The two units worked
together to reduce the cracker boilers use
and increase the steam from the cogenera-
tion plant. Controls were installed to control
the steam header pressure while minimiz-
ing steam produced by the boilers. In all,
the project will save 156,000 MMBTU/y,”
Energy Efficiency SoarsBroad-ranging efforts are providing substantial savings
By Seán Ottewell, Editor at Large
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 4
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
explains Sharon Nolen, Eastman’s manager,
global natural resources management.
Since 2012, Eastman has been collaborating
with Purdue University, West Lafayette, Ind.,
and the Process Science and Technology
Center at the University of Texas, Austin,
in an ongoing effort to improve the energy
efficiency of its energy-intensive distillation
units using dividing-wall column technolo-
gies. To date, Eastman has committed over
$1.5 million in funding to the project.
“Distillation accounts for roughly 40% of
all energy consumed by industrial chemical
processes. Our efforts thus far have shown
that new distillation schemes/technology
can reduce the energy consumption by
up to 50% and the capital investment by
over 30%,” notes Scott Owens, Eastman’s
scale-up project leader.
The academic collaborators currently are
evaluating system selection, column design/
construction, process simulation and opera-
tion/control of new distillation technology.
“This work gave us a significant jumpstart
on our internal efforts to add or upgrade
experimental facilities and understand and
apply the new technologies to our own
proprietary processes. We have already
identified several processes which would
see large financial benefits from retrofitting
to a more-advanced distillation technology.
In many cases, the process would enable
reduced energy intensity and line expansion
with minimal capital investment,” he adds.
The company also is tackling non-pro-
cess-related energy inefficiencies. For
instance, a project to upgrade lighting is
underway at various company sites, build-
ing on ongoing efforts at the Kingsport
headquarters. “The majority of installations
involve replacing less efficient lighting
with LEDs [light-emitting diodes]. Energy
savings for 2016 equate to more than
$390,000,” says Lisa Lambert, Tennessee
site energy coordinator.
BROAD ENERGY CERTIFICATIONFor its part, BASF, Ludwigshafen, Germany,
is committed to achieving certification to
the ISO-50001 energy management stan-
dard by 2020 for the sites that account for
90% of its total purchased energy. It also
aims to increase energy efficiency in its
production plants by 35% by the same year
(2002 baseline).
REBORN ASSETFigure 1. Operator collects data at previously idled steam plant that has been converted to fire natural gas instead of coal. Source: BASF.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 5
In North America, this so far has involved
the implementation of 14 energy efficiency
projects at seven different production sites.
Among these is a project at its Wyandotte,
Mich., complex. In 2014, site management
learned that Wyandotte Municipal Services
would stop providing steam to the site
after 2016. After evaluating nine different
options, the site decided to reactivate a
large steam plant that had stood idle for
more than a decade. Over the next two
years, a project team converted the plant,
which originally was coal-fired, to natural
gas. This involved installing high-efficiency
natural gas burners, a new control system
and water-treatment system, enhancing the
plant’s electrical infrastructure, and hiring a
team of ten employees to run the unit. The
steam plant began operating at the end of
last year (Figure 1).
“The project at our Wyandotte site exem-
plifies our strategic approach to integrate
energy management goals into our efforts
to optimize our processes at BASF,”
stresses Ty Geiger, vice president of energy
management, BASF, Houston. “It is for
these efforts that BASF has been recog-
nized by the American Chemistry Council
for its energy efficiency improvements for
20 consecutive years,” he adds.
Efforts, of course, are taking place world-
wide. For instance, BASF has been
implementing a “triple E” (excellence
in energy efficiency) project at its
Guaratinguetá complex in Brazil where 12
plants with a total capacity of over 260,000
t/y manufacture more than 750 different
products (Figure 2).
One project focused on installing a new
heat exchanger to recover heat from a
sodium methylate product that is used as a
catalyst in biodiesel production. This saved
the company 730 t/y of steam and had a
return on investment (ROI) of 18 months.
Another involved replacing old, largely
sodium and mercury, lamps with 450 LED
lamps. This increased lamp service life
to 80,000 h from 10,000 h and reduced
energy consumption by 75% or 620 MWh/y.
The ROI here was 27 months.
A third project centered on replacing the
water heating system for locker rooms. It
had been consuming 840 t/y of steam to
MULTI-PRONGED EFFORTSFigure 2. Energy efficiency projects at Guaratinguetá, Brazil, site range from pro-cesses to lighting to even locker-room hot water. Source: BASF.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 6
heat 12,000 m3/y of water. Switching to
solar panels and introducing water flow
reducers resulted in a 2,700 m3/y saving in
water consumption, lower energy consump-
tion and an ROI of 35 months.
With these and other initiatives, BASF has
cut energy consumption by 7.098 MWh/y
at the complex, saving R$ 6.46 million/y
($2.07 million/y) in energy costs and reduc-
ing carbon dioxide emissions by 705 t/y.
RENEWABLE POWER EMPHASISAkzoNobel, Amsterdam, particularly is
focusing its energy efficiency initiatives on
developing renewable power options.
For example, a new contract with Swedish
energy company Vattenfall will enable Akzo-
Nobel to ramp up the supply of renewable
electricity to its facilities in Sweden and Fin-
land. Hydro and wind power already make
up the majority of the electricity supplied by
Vattenfall; the two companies have agreed
to further increase the share of renewable
energy to the facilities to 100% by 2020.
The contract supplies AkzoNobel with 1.25
TWh/y of electricity to power six specialty
chemicals sites and one performance coat-
ings facility. In addition, the agreement
allows the two companies to work together
to balance swings in renewable power
supply on the Swedish national grid.
Meanwhile at its chemical park in Delfzijl,
the Netherlands, AkzoNobel is switching
to sustainable steam use (Figure 3). The
company, along with Eneco and Groningen
Seaports jointly have invested around €40
million ($47 million) in a project to convert
SUSTAINABLE SUPPLYFigure 3. Steam now comes from an existing biomass unit that was converted into a combined heat and power plant. Source: AkzoNobel.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 7
an existing biomass plant into a combined
heat and power plant. When fully commis-
sioned, the project will help improve the
long-term competitiveness of the Delfzijl
plants and ensure that an additional 10% of
the company’s energy consumption in the
Netherlands comes from renewable sources
— cutting 100,000 t/y of carbon dioxide
emissions in the process.
AkzoNobel also is heading a consortium
that includes Philips, Amsterdam; DSM,
Heerlen, the Netherlands; and Google’s
Amsterdam facility, to purchase green
electricity from two new wind parks at
Bouwdokken and Krammer, both in the
Netherlands (Figure 4). These wind parks
currently supply 140 MW of power; the
consortium members now are investigating
other opportunities for sustainable energy
cooperation and working with banks and
equity investors on novel funding processes
for them.
Further afield, AkzoNobel has integrated
its production facilities in Imperatriz, Brazil,
directly with the neighboring Suzano Mara-
nhão pulp mill. One benefit here is being
able to source energy directly from waste
wood left over after eucalyptus trees
are processed.
“Our pathway to renewable energy means
going beyond the immediate business,
working with others to create a wider
change in society. That’s the pathway we
want to speed up. Partnerships will play
a key role and we are at the forefront of
working together with others to help the
world move towards renewable energy
quicker,” notes AkzoNobel’s corporate
director of sustainability Andre Veneman.
WIND PARKFigure 4. Dutch consortium is purchasing energy from this and another wind park in The Nether-lands. Source: AkzoNobel.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 8
WATER-BASED SAVINGSFor Dow, Midland, Mich., a major focus is
on developing energy-efficiency-improving
technologies that can be leveraged for use
on multiple sites. Many of these center on
water use.
For example, at its Terneuzen site in the
Netherlands, the company at one point was
using thermally desalinated water to bal-
ance the competing demands of the plant,
agriculture and the neighboring community.
Dow now relies on wastewater recycled
from the local municipality to generate
plant steam and process water and reuses
condensate in cooling towers.
“So successful was the initiative that by
2020 Dow hopes to have expanded [the]
amount we use from 10,000 m3/d to
30,000 m3/d. This 2020 initiative will lower
the energy costs by 95% and has led to the
expansion of other local municipal projects,”
notes Denise Haukkala, technical service
expert, Dow Water & Process Solutions
North America, San Francisco.
One of these is at Dow’s complex in Tar-
ragona, Spain, where the wastewater from
three local cities now is being treated with
a combination of Veolia and Dow Film-
tec technologies.
“It’s led to a very real savings in the eth-
ylene cracker cooling towers. Using up to
40% reused water has reduced blowdown
by 49% and chemical usage by 23%. Using
RO [reverse osmosis] processes means that
the cooling makeup water can be used in
5–10 more cycles, with reduced need for
chemical additives. So it’s a multiplier effect
— adding extra cycles substantially reduces
tower flow demand, together with the need
for scale, corrosion and antimicrobial chem-
ical additives,” she adds.
At Tarragona, Veolia technology serves for
pre-treatment, with the water then going
through Dow extra-fouling-resistant mem-
branes in the system’s first pass and then its
low-energy membranes in the second pass.
The design of the second pass has helped the
plant deliver higher salt rejection at 33% lower
pressure, reducing overall energy usage.
Looking to the future, Haukkala believes
that the next innovations in water-related
energy efficiency are going to come in the
areas of high-temperature RO and nano-
filtration. “How about being able to treat
condensate overhead water or various pro-
cess waste waters at 50–80°C and reuse
that product water back into the process
without adding costly heat exchangers?”
she asks.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 9
Burned alive — that was the ghastly
fate of a worker who got trapped
between two hot steam pipes
in the brewery’s sterilizer area. The skin
temperature of the pipe insulation met
company standards at 135°F — yet the man
was dead.
Engineers understand the role of insulation
for heat conservation and freeze protection.
Shielding personnel from burns from hot
hardware also is an important role for insu-
lation. However, this too often doesn’t get
sufficient scrutiny.
Many facilities such as that brewery use
135°F as the temperature target for per-
sonnel protection. Is that really realistic,
though? M. McChesney and P. McChesney
in a 1981 Chemical Engineering article
“Preventing Burns from Insulated Pipe”
instead suggest using 113°F for insula-
tion covered with aluminum jackets (and
a slightly higher temperature for canvas
jackets). This temperature represents the
“threshold of pain” for a person. Beyond
this value, skin damage grows increasingly
numbing so the person doesn’t know how
much damage is occurring.
Heat damage is like frost bite: it creeps
up on you — exposure time is important.
Touching a pipe at 113°F for a couple of
seconds causes minor damage while con-
tacting a 135°F pipe even for only a second
incurs severe damage. ASTM C1057, “Stan-
dard Guide for Heated System Surface
Conditions that Produce Contact Burn
Injuries,” notes that contact with a 140°F
surface must be kept to under five seconds
Provide Better Protection from Hot PipesUse more conservative limits for insulation skin temperature
By Dirk Willard, Contributing Editor
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 11
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
because longer exposure causes third
degree (also known as full thickness) burns,
i.e., complete and permanent destruction
of the outer layer of skin (epidermis) and
the entire layer beneath (dermis). Longer
exposure times and higher temperatures
are prohibited. In addition, always keep in
mind that damage doesn’t stop as soon
as the person’s skin no longer touches the
hot surface.
What this points up is that if you place an
operator in an area where the only way to
escape requires touching 135°F surfaces
for more than a brief period, you are risk-
ing that person’s life unnecessarily. Instead,
common sense dictates keeping the tem-
perature lower — a maximum of 126°F to
avoid anything more than first degree burns
(pain and reddening of the epidermis) but
ideally below the pain threshold of 113°F.
Always remember, an operator in pain isn’t
thinking clearly.
I suggest designing for a maximum
insulation skin temperature of 110°F.
Unfortunately, though, many engineers
don’t estimate insulation skin tempera-
ture properly.
One common error is not accounting for
the impact of radiation. Years ago, I cor-
rected a professor during a review course
for the professional engineer’s examina-
tion for missing the radiation term. Not
surprisingly, when radiation is taken into
account, the outer jacket affects the skin
temperature: dull surfaces decrease the
skin temperature by restricting radiation
from the jacket; shiny surfaces increase
jacket skin temperature by augmenting
radiation. The emissivity coefficient, , of a
matte canvas jacket is 0.9 versus 0.09 for a
shiny new aluminum jacket; that aluminum
jacket gets duller with age. Black is better
than light colors in reducing the allowable
skin temperature.
The type of jacket is a serious safety
concern. The McChesneys’ article indicated
the heat flux of a shiny new aluminum
jacket is 14× higher than that of an old
canvas jacket. This confirms an everyday
experience that shiny pipe jackets are
hotter than dull ones.
One common problem with most radia-
tion calculations is an inaccurate value of
emissivity. For a 1,100°F steam pipe, the
Always remember, an operator in pain isn’t thinking clearly.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 12
difference in insulated pipe skin tempera-
ture between a painted canvas jacket and
an aluminum one can amount to 30°F; so,
use a healthy safety factor.
Of course, maintenance lapses can com-
promise the best design. Care of insulation
often doesn’t get adequate attention. Some
facilities only deal with insulation issues
as part of their annual maintenance while
others completely ignore insulation until
forced to by a major project.
For a more detailed analysis of protection
of personnel from hot surfaces, I strongly
recommend that you read the McChesneys’
article (which, by the way, OSHA references
in its standards). You’ll have to go to your
local engineering library because it’s not
available online. Other useful references
include:
http://goo.gl/svGrns
http://goo.gl/mSYf5R
http://goo.gl/m9Na7k.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 13
I misread the drawings about pipe installa-
tion but at least had some good excuses.
It was 4 am. I had been sleeping in my
car for five days between meetings and my
nightshift duties as part of a reactor com-
missioning team. In addition, I’d recently
assumed the role of instrument engineer as
well as process engineer. While the design
team should have clearly marked the ori-
entation of the inlet and outlet connections
on the drawings, it was stretched thin. This
commissioning exercise was a catastrophe
— but that’s another story.
Pipe installation on jackets, coils, reactors
and heat exchangers is tricky. If you get it
wrong, you’ll have plenty of opportunity
to kick yourself while you’re pulling things
apart to re-do them right. Connections
generally are flanged, not threaded, to
avoid costly repairs when the threads are
stripped; the exception is sanitary connec-
tions, which usually are the male end of a
sanitary clamp.
Let’s start with the correct inlet and outlet
orientation for jackets and coils. (Coils
provide better heat transfer but are more
difficult to vent, drain and clean because
the flow often is down, around and then out
the same direction.) In a jacket or coil using
steam, the steam obviously goes in the top
nozzle while the outlet (for condensate)
goes at the bottom. Must-haves for a jacket
include a vent at the top and a drain at the
bottom. Extra nozzles help; split jackets may
require multiple nozzles. It doesn’t matter
if the unit sometimes uses steam and other
times chilled water: the inlet is at the top and
the outlet is at the bottom. However, using
Keep Cool Designing Heat Exchanger PipingConsider these points when working with exchangers, coils and jackets
By Dirk Willard, Contributing Editor
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 15
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
separate nozzles for steam and chilled water
often makes sense. With steam condensate,
it’s critical that the outlet is the lowest point
— otherwise, expect problems from corro-
sion and fouling.
If the jacket serves exclusively for cooling,
then opt for a bottom inlet and top outlet.
Oil systems for jackets usually use a bottom
inlet and top outlet, too. (The reactor I was
commissioning used N2 and the correct ori-
entation was bottom inlet/top outlet.)
With heat exchangers, there really aren’t set
rules except for vertical evaporators and
condensers, in which gravity rules: liquids
drain at the bottom. Generally, as for jack-
ets, steam enters in the higher nozzle and
leaves (presumably as condensate) from
the lower nozzle.
Different guidelines apply to horizontal
thermosiphons: recirculating thermosiphons
— liquid (from the bottom of the tower) in
bottom, vapor plus liquid out top; once-
through thermosiphons — vapor plus liquid
(from the side of the tower basin) in from
bottom, liquid (at the side of the tower
basin) out the top.
Locating relief valves also can be tricky.
Position pressure safety valves (PSVs) and
vacuum vents at the top of the jacket or
coil — except when debris might collect at
the mouth of the device. Put relief devices
on heat exchangers as high as possible
to avoid liquid partial flow, which could
obstruct vapor flow. It’s generally assumed
that if a tube ruptures, this involves a small
hole causing flow into the shell; usually, only
the area of the tubing head cover — not the
cylinder — is considered in a fire.
Let’s now turn to pressure relief calcu-
lations. For fire, assume two phases for
liquid in a jacket, coil or exchanger tubing.
Thermal relief always is a concern with
liquids. One relief valve may suffice but if
there’s a possibility of fouling or isolation
of the PSV, then add as many relief devices
as necessary.
Note that rupture discs are a better choice
for high viscosity (>100 cP) oils. Some oils
are so slippery that PSVs will require elas-
tomer seals. It’s often sensible to upgrade
pipe flanges to a higher pressure rating to
add more bolts to the flange bolt circle.
Give special consideration to nozzle rein-
forcement to account for the thrust: wound
vessel sheets may be flimsy.
Mistakes in piping around heat exchangers
and jackets can cause serious problems in
operations and maintenance. Try to re-task
nozzles as much as possible to avoid adding
potential leak sources but make sure you
plan wisely during design.
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 16
Visit the lighter side, featuring draw-
ings by award-winning cartoonist
Jerry King. Click on an image and you
will arrive at a page with the winning
caption and all submissions for that
particular cartoon.
EHANDBOOKSCheck out our vast library of past eHandbooks that offer a
wealth of information on a single topic, aimed at providing
best practices, key trends, developments and successful
applications to help make your facilities as efficient, safe,
environmentally friendly and economically competitive
as possible.
UPCOMING AND ON DEMAND WEBINARSTap into expert knowledge. Chemical Processing editors
and industry experts delve into hot topics challenging
the chemical processing industry today while providing
insights and practical guidance. Each of these free webi-
nars feature a live Q&A session and lasts 60 minutes.
WHITE PAPERSCheck out our library of white papers covering myriad
topics and offering valuable insight into products and solu-
tions important to chemical processing professionals. From
automation to fluid handling, separations technologies and
utilities, this white paper library has it all.
MINUTE CLINICChemical Processing’s Minute Clinic podcast series is
designed to tackle one critical issue at a time — giving you
hard-hitting information in just minutes.
ASK THE EXPERTSHave a question on a technical issue that needs to be
addressed? Visit our Ask the Experts forum. Covering
topics from combustion to steam systems, our roster of
leading subject matter experts, as well as other forum
members, can help you tackle plant issues.
TOP COMICAL PROCESSING
JOIN US ON SOCIAL MEDIA!
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
www.ChemicalProcessing.com
Steam Systems eHANDBOOK: Put Steam Into Your Efforts 17