9th InternationalWorkshopon

DESIGNTHEORYSpecialInterestGroupoftheDesignSociety

1st-2ndFebruary2016MINESParisTech

Organizedbythe ChairofDesignTheoryandMethodsforInnovationıCGS– MINESParisTech Contact:akin.kazakci@mines-paristech.fr - stephanie.brunet@mines-paristech.fr

9th SIGDesignTheoryWorkshopMINESParisTech

MondayFebruary1st TuesdayFebruary2nd

ChairedbyAkinKazakci8:00-8:45:Welcome8:45-9:00:Introductionandopening, PascalLeMasson(MINESParisTech),EswaranSubrahmanian(CMU),AkinKazakci(MINESParisTech)

SESSION: EVOLUTIONOFDESIGNTHEORY9:00-9:30:Theoryoftechnicalsystems,BasisforaSystematicEngineeringDesignProcess.W.ErnstEder,Honorary fellow ofthedesignsociety (RoyalMilitaryCollegeofCanada)9:45-10:15:TheevolutionofdesigntheoryanddesignmethodologyatTechnischeUniversitätIlmenau. ChristianWeber,DesignSocietyFellow(TechnischeUniversitätIlmenau)10:30-11:00:Theevolutionofteachingofdesigntheoryinengineeringschools,ArmandHatchuel,DesignSocietyFellow(MINESParisTech)

COFFEEBREAK

11:30-12:30:InvitedPresentation:Creativeadaptationbyartificialevolution,Jean-BaptisteMouret(INRIA)

9:00- 12:00PARALLELSESSIONS• Session1:DesignTheoryandApproaches(ChairedbyBenoitWeil)

•Session2:DesignTheoryandModels(ChairedbyEswaranSubrahmanian)

• Session3:DesignTheoryandManagerialImplications(ChairedbyBernardYannou)

• Session4:DesignTheoryandIdentityofObjects(ChairedbyAnnieGentes)

ChairedbyYoramReich

SESSION:DESIGNTHEORYANDKNOWLEDGESTRUCTURES• 13:30-14:00 :Howinnovativedesigncancontributetochemicalandprocess

engineering?OlivierPotier(LRGP-CNRS)JulietteBrun,PascalLeMasson,BenoitWeil(MINESParisTech)

• 14:15-14:45—MathematicsforMulti-facetedDesign, SpencerBreiner(NIST),AlJones(NIST) andEswaranSubrahmanian(CMU)

COFFEE BREAK

SESSION:DESIGNTHEORYANDSCIENTIFICPROCESS• 15:30-16:00 :Designchallengesinscienctificcommunities:generatingdesign

optionsfortheLHCbcollaborationatCERN, VladimirGligorov(CERN)• 16:15-16:45 :Understandingdatascientists’designprocess:adatascience

observatory:Akin Kazakci (MINES ParisTech)BalazsKégl(CNRS)

• 17:00:18:30 :DISCUSSIONSESSIONS

ChairedbyArmandHatchuel

SESSION:DESIGNTHEORY - DEALINGWITHRISKANDUNCERTAINTY• 13:30-14:00:Categoricalriskperceptionfordesigntocombineexpertiseand

analysis,DavidBroniatowski(GWU)• 14:00-14:30:RadicalInnovationDesign,BernardYannou(EcoleCentrale)• 14:30-15:00:MindfulDeviationthroughcombiningandcausationandeffectuation:

Adesigntheorybasedstudyoftechnologyentrepreneurship,MarineAgogué(HECMontréal),MatLundqvist,KarenWilliamsMiddleton(ChalmersUniversity)

COFFEE BREAK

SESSION:DESIGNTHEORYANDEVOLUTIONOFDESIGNS• 15:30-16:00:ProductevolutionusingcrowdsourcingandAffordancebaseddesign,

IvanMataandGeorgesFadel(ClemsonUniversity)• 16:00-16:30:DesignTheoryandTechnologicalEvolution,AndyDong(Warren

CentreforEngineeringInnovation)

• 16:30-17:30:FUTUREPROGRAM

Parallelsessions1:DesignTheoryandMethods(20mneachpresentation)ChairedbyBenoitWeil

• Designtheoryandinnovation inworkspacedesign:Lessonslearnedfromadesignproject,Maria Ianeva (GRePS, Université Lyon 2), Patrick Chotel (Colliers International)

• Usingdesigntheory togeneratenewapplications forindustry4.0:Beyondtraditional measuresofindustrial performance:Yohann Sitruk, Akin Kazakci (MINES ParisTech)

• Models inengineering design:Claudia Eckert(OpenUniversity),Rafaela Hillerbrand (ITAS-KIT)• "Thinking outofthebox - whomovedmybox"– AnimplicitPSIanalysis:Yoram Reich (University of Tel Aviv)

BREAK

• Designorientedmanufacturing:thecaseoffailuremodeandeffectanalysisinsemiconductor industry:Benjamin Cabanes, Stéphane Hubac (ST MicroElectronics), Pascal Le Masson, Benoit Weil (MINES ParisTech)

• Castinginnovative aerospacedesigncasestudiesinparameteranalysisframeworktouncoverdesignprocessesofexperts:Ehud Kroll, Ido Farbman (ORT Braude College)

• Designdrivenmethodsforcreatingconceptual IPcartography:Olga Kokshagina, Pascal Le Masson, Benoit Weil, (MINES ParisTech)• Howsmartproducts with built-inflexibility empower users toself-designtheir uses?Atheoretical framework forusegeneration :Morgane

Benade, Frank Piller (Aachen University), Juliette Brun, Pascal Le Masson, Benoit Weil (MINES ParisTech), Ingi Brown (Agendize)

Parallelsessions2:DesignTheoryandModels(20mneachpresentation)ChairedbyEswaranSubrahmanian

• Archeology ofNonstandardDesignphilosophy: Anexperimentaltext:Muriel Mambrini-Doudet (INRA), Ira Monarch (CMU), Anne-Francoise Schmid (chaire TMCI) , Eswaran Subrahmanian (CMU)

• Confronting theCPM/PDD approachwiththeC-Ktheory:Christian Weber (Technische Universität Ilmenau)• Demarcationproblem ofageneraldesigntheory:Damien Motte, Robert Bjarnemo (Lund University)• Reasoningandmakingsenseofdataintheabsenceofgoals,Mary Lou Maher (UNC Charlotte), Kathryn Merrick, Bing Wang (UNSW)

BREAK

• Whydowethink thatsynthesisiscreativeandanalysisisrational? Lauri Koskela (University of Huddersfield)• Shannonentropyasameasureofdesignpotential: John Gero, Jeff Kan (UNC Charlotte)• Surpriseandreformulationasmeta-cognitiveprocessesincreativedesign: Kalzon Grace, Mary Lou Maher (UNC Charlotte)• Designtheoryandmachinegenerativity: Mehdi Cherti, Balazs Kégl (CNRS), Akin Kazakci, (MINES ParisTech)

ParallelSessions– TuesdayFebruary2nd (9h00-12h00)

ParallelSessions– TuesdayFebruary2nd (9h00-12h00)

Parallelsessions3:DesignTheoryandManagerialImplications(20mneachpresentation)ChairedbyBernardYannou

• Ontheartofscienceandthe scienceofartinremarkableatemporaldesigninnovation framesofreference:Patrick Corsi (IKBM), Dominique Morin (Snecma)

• Cognitive processesundergirding thedesignlogicinbusinessmodelinnovation: Dirk Schneckenberg (ESC Rennes School of Business), Vivek Velamuri, Christian Comberg (HHL Leipzig Graduate School of Management)

• Systemarchitecture,riskperception, anddesignworldviews:David Broniatowski (GWU)

BREAK

• Candesignchancethe financialindustry? AcasestudyofabankofEnglandproject: Marta Gasparin (University of Leicester), Christiana Parisi (Copenhagen Business School), Hermann Rapp (Anglia Ruskin University)

• DesigningInnovationecosystems:NASAsshifttowardsdesigningalow-earthorbiteconomiczone: Douglas Robinson, Mariana Mazzucato (University of Sussex)

• TheDebutoftheDesignStudioinPsychologyClinicalTrainingPrograms:Susan Imholz• Implicitcomparisons bringsoutdifferent features:Allison Faye, Barbara Tversky (Stanford University)

Parallelsessions4:DesignTheoryandIdentityofObjects(20mneachpresentation)ChairedbyAnnieGentes

• Smatphonestoexploremovement:scienceanddesigncollaboration: Joel Chevrier (CIME Nanotech & CRI Paris)• Discoursesonthemethods:Tiphaine Kazitani, Frédéric Valentin (Codesign Lab, Télécom ParisTech)• Disputingergonomics.Deconstructingusers.Aqueerperspectiveondesign:Emeline Brulé, Tiphaine Kazitani ( Codesign Lab, Télécom

ParisTech)

• TheCognitiveEffectofLeadershipInstructions onCreativeIdeation: ANovelty-basedapproachof“Goal-Settings”:Hicham Ezzat, Pascal Le Masson, Benoit Weil (MINES ParisTech)

BREAK

• Designandcreativity,thearchitecturaldesignprocess:Rossella Stufano, Stefano Borgo, Dino Borri, Domenico Camarda (Dicatech)• Designandtime:movement–object and time-object:Cross reflexionsbeteenC-KtheoryandDeleuze’stheoryofcinemaand

Creation:Christophe Abrassart (Université de Montréal)

• Draftingandtestingdesignreasoningmodels:thecaseofcodesign: Louis-Etienne Dubois, Pascal Le Masson, Benoit Weil (MINES ParisTech)

Session1:Fromdesigntheorytoindustrialapplications…andback.ChairedbyArmandHatchuel(MINESParisTech)

This discussion session will consider the complex and contrasted relationships between theory-driven field interventions and theory-buildingthrough such interventions. The following two presentations will launch the debate.

• Design theory for innovation at the plant level. Guillaume Bulin. Airbus.

• Innovation in value networks.Hans Bjorkman

DiscussionSessions– MondayFebruary1st(16h30-18h30)

Session2:Theoryoftechnicalsystems.ChairedbyPascalLeMasson(MINESParisTech)

This session will consider additional issues related to TTS and its relationship with other frameworks some of which are (non exlusive): Pahl &Beitz, VDI 2221 / 2222, Koller, and Ullman, as well as of IPD (Olsson, Ehrlenspiel) and Dynamic Product Development (Ottosson), in acomparison matrix with the following criteria: Basic concepts; integration capabilites; process model; adaptibility and flexibility; predictability;portability.

Session3:Designandscience:« closeencounters ofthethird type».Chaired byAnnieGentès (TélécomParisTech)

Analyzing the dialog between Sciences & Design through the activity of symbolization can place them on a common field of investigation.Designers and scientists, combining their creative process, contribute to an objectification of the activity of symbolization and thus operate ata higher level of innovation. The workshop will present and test with the participants some hybrid objects created by designers based oncollaborations with quantum physicists. Participants will be given some of these objects and asked to interpret them, evaluate them, and ifpossible, proposesome possible scenarios of use.