International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE 1 MICE 1 st MICE COLABORATION BOARD MEETING...
-
Upload
patience-bridges -
Category
Documents
-
view
227 -
download
0
Transcript of International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE 1 MICE 1 st MICE COLABORATION BOARD MEETING...
1International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
MICE
1st MICE COLABORATION BOARD MEETING BERKELEY 25 10 2002
2International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
The proposal, along the guidelines required by the PPARC Project Peer Review Panel, should address the layout and integration of the experimental facility and cover all safety aspects.
The financial, technical and experimental needs should be clearly spelled out along with their probable and realistic solutions.
THE JOINT CLRC/PPARC PANEL TO REVIEW THE MICE PROPOSAL REPORT OF THE 1ST PANEL MEETING, HELD ON 25 MARCH 2002.
3International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
MICE Video Conferences and collaboration meetings
MUCOOL/MICE Collaboration meeting 22-26 October @BerkeleyFinalize who does what and cost estimatesSchedule remaining open questions (decision tree)at that time the input to the proposal should be defined and proposal drafting underway.
Deadline for contributions 15 November 2002
Date of submission: 15 December 2002
dates for SG meeting 23dates for video conferences -> steering group meeting I.e. 24 afternooncollaboration board meeting Friday morning 7H30
NEXT Collaboration meeting: 27-29 March 2003
Geneva (CERN or Uni)
4International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Steering committee:
Europe: A. Blondel*1 , H. Haseroth, R. EdgecockJapan : Y. KunoUS: S. Geer, D. Kaplan2, M. Zisman+ I. Ivaniouchenkov as project engineer+ Y. Torun as secretary
*convener for coming year (till june 2003), 1 EU spokesperson, 2 US spokesperson
NB US spokesperson will be complemented with a deputy.
5International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Technical group conveners:
Concept development: A. Lombardi, R. Palmer. This includes cooling optics and general configuration issues
Experiment simulations: M. G. Catanesi, Y. Torun. Includes simulation, reconstruction and general software issues
Absorbers: M. A. Cummings, S. Ishimoto
RF cavities and power supplies: D. Li, H. Haseroth + (C. Church)
Magnet systems: M. Green, J. M. Rey
Detectors: A. Bross, V. Palladino
Beamline: P. Drumm
RF radiation: E. McKigney, J. Norem
Engineering integration: E. Black, I. Ivaniouchenkov. Technical specifications, service needs, safety issues and installation.
6International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Participating institutes in LOI(In parentheses: contact person in each institute)
Louvain La Neuve (G. Grégoire) CERN** (H. Haseroth)NESTOR Institute (L. Resvanis)University of Athens (L. Resvanis)Hellenic Open University (S. Tzamarias)INFN Bari (G. Catanesi) INFN LNF Frascati (M. Castellano, L. Palumbo)INFN Legnaro (U. Gastaldi) INFN Milano (M. Bonesini)INFN Padova (M. Mezzetto)INFN Napoli (G. Osteria) INFN Roma I (L. Ludovici)INFN Roma II (L. Catani)INFN Roma III (L. Tortora)INFN Trieste (M. Apollonio)
** pending the review of CERN activities in accelerator R&D which will take place in the framework of the LHC cost-to-completion analysis.
7International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
ETH Zurich (A. Rubbia)Paut Scherrer Institute (C. Petitjean)University of Geneva (A. Blondel) University of Zurich (A. Van der Schaaf) Imperial College London (K. Long)Liverpool (John Fry) Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (R. Edgecock) University of Birmingham (J. Wilson)University of Oxford (G. Barr)Sheffield (Chris Booth)
KEK (S. Ishimoto)Osaka University (Y. Kuno)
8International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Participating institutes (ctd)(In parentheses: contact person in each institute)
Argonne National Laboratory (J. Norem)Brookhaven National Laboratory (R. Palmer) Columbia University (A. Caldwell) Fairfield University (D.Winn)FermiLab (S. Geer (?A. Bross))Illinois Institute of Technology (D. Kaplan)Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (M. Zisman)Michigan State University (M. Berz)Northern Illinois University (M. A. Cummings) Princeton University (K. McDonald) University of California Los Angeles (D. Cline)University of California, Riverside (G. Hanson)University of Chicago – Enrico Fermi Institute (K.-J. Kim)(?)University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (D. Errede) University of Iowa (Y.Onel)University of Mississippi (D. Summers)
9International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
possible newcomers:
1. NIKHEF (Lange) was contacted for magnetic field measurements. enthusiastic, need to clear with director and clarify involvement 2. Saclay (Rey) JM is only part time and will become soon overloaded with ATLAS responsibilities. Seek saclay physicist to justify involvement.
3. Dubna (Alexandre Malakhov) has contacted me re: construction of magnets. (was at cern this week, I have not replied yet)
4. within TPG development, several labs (Karlsruhe, Sheffield, Aachen) have expressed interest in collaborating, but only on TPG aspect. (TESLA R&D)
5. Glasgow Edinburgh Brunel
6. US? Enrico Fermi Institute (M. Oreglia)
10International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
We will need a list of signatures for the proposal.
11International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Job Opportunities……
It is evident that the project cries for manpower in many domains.
most striking to me:
-- software: simulation, reconstruction, online, slow control studies of systematics, etc…
-- RF cavity development & noise studies.
-- mag. field measurements, etc..
12International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
PRIORITIES (status as of RAL coll.meeting)
1. Find a home for the experiment
2. Understand the X ray issue and quantify it in terms of particle detector performance
2.’ Develop reconstruction with noise and efficiencies 3. Choose detectors
3’. Finalize parameters
4. Establish technical specs and cost estimates
4’ Distribute contributions and begin fund hunt mission
5. Write proposal
DONE
getting there, BRAVO!
Crisis…
pending questions on magnet match, beam sizes, absorber design, safety measures
no, but define set of criteria, actions and decision points
13International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
.43 X 4 cells = 1.7 m 11.5 MV for 1X 4 = 6.70 MV/m
16 MV for 2X4 = 4.65 MV/m
16 MV for 1X4 = 9.3 MV/m
=> 6.70 MV/m => 4.65 MV/m
14International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Simulation of performance of cooling cell fairly well understood.
Now needed : … simulation of detector response, for design of e.g. downstream PID or to understand performance of Sci-Fi or TPG and first go at some systematics-----
… groundwork by Janot needs to be extended … large organized effort started in August 2002 much exists, some results will already be with us keep going!
SIMULATIONS
conceptual thinking of systematic uncertainties in the measurement needed magnetic field quality / measurements noise and efficiencies in trackers absorber thickness etc…
15International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Proposed grand time line:
2001 Expose detectors to RF radiation (potential show stopper) write first description of experiment with two options
US design (200 MHz) or CERN design (88 MHz) US simulate CERN scheme [and vice versa if possible]
Evaluate availability and cost of main cost drivers: RF cavities / amplifiers/ power supplies/solenoids for each scheme evaluate beams + host labs
1st workshop 25-27 October 2001, CERN ! 16 Nov. 2001 ! Chose technology + host lab, write +
submit LETTER OF INTENT (that was 28 Nov 2001) 25 March 2002 CLRC reviewJune 2002 CLRC + PPARC invite submission of proposal
15/12/2002 Proposal submissionend 2004 1st beam (debugging of spectrometers)
end 2006 demonstrate ionization cooling
after that … … more systematic studies
16International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
MICE : WHEN?
GOAL: The long-term goal is to have a Conceptual Design Report for a Neutrino Factory Complex by the time of JHF and LHC start-up, so that, by that date, this would be a valid option for the future of HEP
(European Muon Coordination and Oversight Group, April 2002)
=2007
MICE must have measured cooling end 2006
19International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
First go at very incomplete tables of who does whatWill be updated during meeting
item comm. resp. LOI cost
rev.cost
US EU RAL/UK
JP
RF cells
critical path item
LNBL 0.8-1.3 1.6-2.8 1.6-2.8 ? -- --
powersourcesplumbing
CERN refurb
CERN 0.2 0.3 -- 0.3some
rad. monitors
rad. safetydark current
RALANL
-- ?? ?
?
Beam line
RAL(+PSI sol.)
-- -- -- ? ?
20International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
First go at very incomplete tables of who does what
item comments
resp. LOI cost
revisedcost
US EU RAL/UK
JP
flip coils 3-4 1.6 1.6
comp. coils 2-3 2 2
solenoids 2 1.6
Helium plant
same as beam
RAL -- ? ?
global supervision of coils necessary
(Green)
among Oxford/MUCOOL/RAL/LBL/Saclay/INFN
1.6
Suggestion: Mike Green will organize a get-together of those who could bid for the magnets and share (at least the cost, maybe construction) and come up with a proposal.
21International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
First go at very incomplete tables of who does what
item comm. resp. LOI cost
revisedcost
US EU RAL/UK
JP
H2 absorbers
MUCOOL/KEK
MUCOOL/KEK
.7-.8 .15 x1 -- -- x2
LH2 Plant + safety
RAL 2(?) 2(?) 2(?)
solid absorbers
?
common funds
22International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
First go at very incomplete tables of who does what
item comm. resp LOI cost
revisedcost
US EU RAL/UK
JP
Sci fi >>2 planes of 3 double layers
ICL/FNAL/KEKLong/Bross/yoshimura
NA 5(?)
TPG Needs validation!
Legnaro/INFN
/CERN/ GVA (Gastaldi)
-- NA 0.5(?)
TOF most existsadequate
Milano/Padova -- 0.18 0.1
down-stream PID
technique not decided or both?
Louvain/Mississipi for Cerenkov
-- 0.1
DAQ Bari (Radicioni)
.32 .32
to be shared
point was made that slow control and online reconstruction should be addressed
23International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
draft Proposal for MICE proposal Layoutoverall edition: Blondel & Kaplan
Executive Summary 1 pagetable of contents 1 pagefull author list -------!!!!!! 2 pagesresponsibility structure 1 page
1. General motivation (S.Geer & K. Long) 1.1 Neutrinos and our lives (PR motivation)
1.2 Neutrino oscillations and the role of NuFact (Particle physics motivation) 1.3 other physics at NuFact complex and Muon collider
1.4 Neutrino Factory description (the accelerator) 1.5 Role of cooling in Neutrino Factory and muon collider, the need for MICE (Acc. physics motivation) 6 pages
2. Cooling (Kaplan) 2.1 principle of Ionization cooling 2.2 cooling channel design 2.3 possible extensions (gas cooling and ring coolers) 5 pages
3. The International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment (Blondel, Hanke, Palmer) 3.1 Layout and principle 3.2 Experiments to be performed 3.3 Expected performance and statistical precision 3.4 Systematic errors and resulting requirements 3.5 possible development of the experiment in time 8 pages
24International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
draft Proposal for MICE proposal Layout (ctd)
4. The magnetic channel (Green/Rey) 4.1 layout and optics (Palmer / Fernow) 4.2 design of coils (Green/Rey) 4.3 services (->move to infrastructure chapter 10) 4.4 magnetic measurements (Rey) 4.5 return flux and constraints 8 pages 4.6 responsibilities cost and time line
5. The RF system (Li, Haseroth) 5.1 Cavities 5.2 Windows 5.3 Power supplies 5.4 achievable performance 8 pages 5.6 services and safety (->move to infrastructure chapter 10) 5.5 responsibilities, cost and time-line
6. The absorbers (Cummings/Ishimoto) 6.1 general design (incl. safety constraints) 6.2 windows 6.3 thermodynamics (heat exchanger, etc..) 6.4 accommodating different length and materials 6.6 responsibilities, cost and time-line 8 pages
25International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
draft Proposal for MICE proposal Layout (ctd)
7. Beam and beam line (Drumm) 7.1 layout and location 7.2 expected performance and time structure 7.3 time line 6 pages
8. Detectors (Bross/Palladino) 8.1 overall description, functionality and redundancy 8.2 TOF and trigger 8.3.1 tracking device (option I) Scintillating fiber tracker 8.3.2 tracking devices (option II) TPG 8.4 Particle ID 8.5 DAQ, on-line monitoring and reconstruction in each section : responsibilities, costs and time line 15 pages
9. RF radiation on detectors (Norem/McKigney) 9.1 general understanding and characteristics 9.2 measurement results and effect on detectors 9.3 projected effect on performance of MICE (with help of simulation team) 9.4 further measurements to come 6 pages
26International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
draft Proposal for MICE proposal Layout (ctd)
10. implementation of MICE at RAL (Ivaniouchenkov, Black) 10.1 Hall layout 10.2 services, cryogenics etc… 10.3 safety issues 10.4 interference with ISIS 10.5 installation plan, time-line, costs and requirements 6 pages
11. Summary of responsibilities, costs, funding and grand time line (Zisman, Edgecock) 6 pages
12. Summary and requirements from RAL 3 pages
references appendices (if needed)
92 pages…..
31International Muon Ionization Cooling Experiment MICE
Steering group membership: I. Ivaniouchenkov is added as the project engineer.
Y. Torun will be invited as webmaster/secretary (and has agreed to generating minutes to be archived on the web and made public following review by the steering group)
Technical group conveners:
Concept development: A. Lombardi, R. Palmer. This includes cooling optics and general configuration issues
Experiment simulations: M. G. Catanesi, Y. Torun. Includes simulation, reconstruction and general software issues
Absorbers: M. A. Cummings, S. Ishimoto -- no change
RF cavities and power supplies: D. Li, H. Haseroth + (C. Church)
Magnet systems: M. Green, J. M. Rey -- no change
Detectors: A. Bross, V. Palladino -- no change
Beamline: P. Drumm only
RF radiation: E. McKigney, J. Norem -- no change
Engineering integration: E. Black, I. Ivaniouchenkov. This is a new working group on technical specifications, service needs, safety issues and installation.
from sg meeting in July: