Interactive Physically-based Simulation of Virtual Objects ...
INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD...
Transcript of INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD...
![Page 1: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION
A Thesis
by
DEREK ROBERT OVERBY
Submitted to the Office of Graduate Studies of Texas A&M University
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
MASTER OF SCIENCE
May 2002
Major Subject: Computer Science
![Page 2: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION
A Thesis
by
DEREK ROBERT OVERBY
Submitted to Texas A&M University
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
MASTER OF SCIENCE
Approved as to style and content by:
John Keyser (Chair of Committee)
Bart Childs (Member)
Ergun Akleman
(Member)
Jennifer Welch (Head of Department)
May 2002
Major Subject: Computer Science
![Page 3: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ABSTRACT
Interactive Physically-Based Cloud Simulation. (May 2002)
Derek Robert Overby, B.S., Texas A&M University
Chair of Advisory Committee: Dr. John Keyser
Clouds play an important role in the depiction of many natural outdoor scenes.
Realistic modeling and rendering of such scenes is important for applications in games,
military training simulations, flight simulations, and even in the creation of digital
artistic media. Previous methods for modeling the growth of clouds do not account for
the fluid interactions that are responsible for cloud formation in the physical atmosphere.
We propose a model for simulating cloud formation based on a basic computational fluid
solver. This allows us to simulate the complex air motion that contributes to cloud
formation in our atmosphere. Among the natural processes that we simulate are
buoyancy, relative humidity, and condensation. Because we have built this model on top
of a visually realistic fluid simulator with which the user is able to interact, we are also
able to give the user artistic control over a physically accurate environment.
In practice, the user need only set the initial conditions for our virtual atmosphere to
produce different types of cloud formations.
iii
![Page 4: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
For us
iv
![Page 5: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank everyone who has contributed to this project, especially my
colleague and partner in research, Zeki Melek, who has been around to help answer
countless questions. I would also like to thank my advisor, John Keyser, for guiding my
vision and helping me to get my work published. I must also thank Dr. Mike Biggerstaff
of the Texas A&M Meteorology Department, Mark Harris of the University of North
Carolina for his ongoing help with rendering, and my brother Darryl for his help with the
fluid dynamics. I thank my parents for giving me the education and discipline to
complete this project, as well as all the teachers, professors, and authors whose words
and instruction have given me the opportunity to learn how to learn and think for myself.
And finally I must offer the greatest thanks and appreciation to my soul mate, Kristie,
without whose love and support I could not have done any of this.
v
![Page 6: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………… iii
DEDICATION…………………………………………………………………… iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS……………………………………………………… v
TABLE OF CONTENTS………………………………………………………… vi
LIST OF FIGURES……………………………………………………………… viii
1 INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………….. 1
2 PREVIOUS WORK…………………………………………………………… 3
2.1 Cloud Models in Computer Graphics……………………….. 3 2.2 Cloud Models in Meteorology………….…………………… 20 3 CLOUD FORMATION IN THE ATMOSPHERE…………………………… 22 3.1 Thermodynamics……………………………………………. 24 3.2 Physical Process…………………………………………….. 25 4 FLUID MODEL………………………………………………………………. 32 4.1 Fluid Model Basics…………………………………………. 32 4.2 Application of Fluid Model to Atmospheric Simulation…... 36 5 CLOUD MODEL………………………………………..…………………… 38 5.1 Software Model…………………………………………….. 38 5.2 Interface…………………………..………………………… 43 5.3 Creating Different Cloud Types…………………………….. 46 6 RESULTS AND PROBLEMS ENCOUNTERED…………………………. … 50 7 IMPLEMENTATION DETAILS……………………………………………… 53 7.1 Data Structure……………………………………………….. 53 7.2 Visualization………………………………………………… 54 7.3 Simulation…………………………………………………… 54
vi
![Page 7: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Page
7.4 Constraints…………………………………………………... 55
8 FUTURE WORK……………………………………………………………… 56
9 CONCLUSIONS……………………………………………………………… 59
REFERENCES…………………………………………………………………… 60
APPENDIX A…………………………………………………………………… 63
APPENDIX B…………………………………………………………………… 64
APPENDIX C…………………………………………………………………… 65
APPENDIX D…………………………………………………………………… 66
APPENDIX E…………………………………………………………………… 67
VITA …………………………………………………………………………… 68
vii
![Page 8: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE Page
1 Kajiya example……………………………………………………... 5
2 Example of Perlin noise, courtesy of Zeki Melek ………………….. 5
3 Example of clouds using Lewis method……………………………. 6
4 Transition functions for Nagel’s cellular automaton……………….. 7
5 Clouds generated using Nagel’s method…………………………… 7
6 Example of Neyret’s clouds………………………………………. 8
7 Convection simulated using CML…………………………………. 9
8 Miyazaki example………………………………………………….. 9
9 Blinn’s volume rendering method…………………………………. 11
10 Example of Gardner’s textured ellipsoids…………………………. 12
11 Max example………………………………………………………. 13
12 Levoy example……………………………………………………... 14
13 Concentric spheres used in Dobashi method………………………. 15
14 Visual description of Dobashi method…………………………….. 15
15 Image from Dobashi method………………………………………. 16
16 Example of Harris’s rendering method……………………………. 16
17 Particle system proposed by Reeves in 1983……………………… 18
18 Foster and Metaxas example………………………………………. 19
19 Fedkiw and Stam example………………………………………… 19
viii
![Page 9: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
FIGURE Page
20 Air-Mass Thunderstorm…………………………………………..… 21
21 Cumulus cloud formation…………………………………………… 22
22 Stratus cloud formation……………………………………………... 23
23 Artificial cloud seeding over 45 minute period……………………... 26
24 Example of ascension caused by convection……………………….. 27
25 A cloud formation caused by orographic uplift…………………….. 28
26 Graph of pressure vs. altitude……………………………………… 29
27 Visual depiction of cloud droplet size……………………………… 30
28 Continuous collision model………………………………………… 31
29 Backward tracing time-step method proposed by Stam……………. 36
30 Heat enters the environment from defined sources at ground level… 40
31 Humidity is shown being advected upward by thermal currents…... 40
32 Graphical User Interface for cloud modeling application ………… 43
33 Wind interface……………………………………………………… 45
34 Source interface……………………………………………………. 45
35 Cumulus cloud formation caused by vertical air movement………. 47
36 Stratus cloud formation caused by horizontal air flow……………. 48
37 Proposed expansion algorithm in two dimensions..……………….. 51
38 Proposed momentum conservation algorithm……………………... 52
39 Simulation pipeline………………………………………………… 55
40 Clouds generated and rendered using Dobashi method……………. 63
ix
![Page 10: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
FIGURE Page
41 Second view of clouds generated and rendered using Dobashi method…………………………………………………………….. 63 42 Humidity field being advected by buoyancy……………………… 64
43 Heat field………………………………………………………….. 64
44 Resulting cloud field……………………………………………… . 64
45 Graph of pressure vs. altitude in the troposphere.………………… 66
46 Graph of air density vs. altitude in the troposphere……………….. 66
x
![Page 11: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
1
1 INTRODUCTION
The digital creation of clouds is important for many applications in Computer
Graphics, including those involving the rendering of outdoor scenes. Fast, efficient
methods of generating clouds are valuable tools for these and other applications such as
outdoor simulations and the digital rendering of atmospheric effects. These models are
used extensively by both the motion picture industry and the gaming industry, often as
background imagery. By making the background content of outdoor images appear
more natural, the graphic artist can more skillfully direct the viewer's attention. The
modeling of realistic cloud shape is fundamental for the creation of these types of digital
images. In this paper, we focus on the simulation of physical processes that contribute to
the formation of clouds in our lower atmosphere1. By simulating these physical
processes we are able to more accurately model the structure of a cloud that forms under
given atmospheric conditions.
Previous methods for generating cloud models have traditionally used a procedural or
fractal method to generate cloud structure [Nagel and Raschke 1992]. While these
methods may at times produce visually compelling results when coupled with complex
rendering
This thesis follows the style and format of ACM Transactions on Graphics. 1 In this paper, when we refer to the atmosphere, we are referring specifically to the troposphere or sphere of weather [Wallen 1992]. The troposphere is the lowest division of our atmosphere which extends from the ground to an altitude of approximately 12km.
![Page 12: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
2
techniques, these structures are essentially deterministic and are difficult to modify for creating different cloud types. Our method allows the user to interact in with a
physically-based simulated environment in order to produce the desired cloud formation.
All the user needs is a basic understanding of the fundamental processes involved in
cloud formation: buoyancy, relative humidity, and condensation. By manipulating the
parameters of these processes in our simulation, the user is able to interact with the
simulation.
First we will discuss previous work on this topic both in the field of Computer
Science and also in the field of Meteorology. We will then discuss the physical process
of cloud formation in our atmosphere in Section 3. In Section 4 we will discuss the fluid
model upon which our simulation is based. In Section 5 we present our proposed
software model for the physical process of cloud formation, and in Section 6 we discuss
results and problems that were encountered during the course of this research. We will
discuss various details of our implementation in Section 7. In Section 8 we present
several directions for future work, and finally we present our conclusions in Section 9.
![Page 13: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
3
2 PREVIOUS WORK
Cloud modeling has been a subject of extensive research in both Computer Science
and Meteorology. Both fields have been active in researching methods for simulating,
visualizing, and predicting clouds and other natural phenomena that occur in our
atmosphere.
In section 2.1 we discuss previous models of cloud formation in the field of Computer
Graphics and some of the advantages and shortcomings of these methods. This section
is divided into three categories, corresponding to three main categories of cloud models
that have been studied. Procedural models are discussed in section 2.1.1, rendering
models in section 2.1.2, and particle systems and fluid models in section 2.1.3. Then in
section 2.2 we present a brief look at some models of cloud formation in Meteorology
and why they are so different from those in Computer Graphics.
2.1 CLOUD MODELS IN COMPUTER GRAPHICS
Within the field of Computer Graphics there has been extensive research aimed at
quickly generating realistic looking clouds. Early research was hindered not only by the
large memory and processing requirements inherent when working on and rendering
volumetric data on a coarse grid, but also by the limited rasterization functions provided
![Page 14: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
4
by the contemporary graphics hardware. However, realistic fluid motion can now be
obtained on coarse grids through the use of recently proposed efficient three-dimensional
fluid solvers [Stam 1999]. Also, the memory and processing power provided by today's
desktop PC's has greatly improved our ability to simulate complex interactions like fluid
motion.
2.1.1 PROCEDURAL MODELS IN COMPUTER GRAPHICS
In 1984, James Kajiya presented his paper in which he not only presented methods
for single and multiple scattering2, but also presented a method for modeling the
formation of cloud structure based on atmospheric fluid dynamics [Kajiya and Von
Herzen 1984]. However, in his method Kajiya accounted for the effects of viscosity, as
well as using a less accurate method for simulating the fluid motion in the system. An
example of clouds produced by Kajiya using this method are shown below in Figure 1.
2 Single scattering refers to a reflectance model which only accounts for one reflection of light from a light source, while multiple scattering refers to a reflectance model in which more than one reflection is considered.
![Page 15: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
5
Figure 1: Kajiya example. Figure taken from [Kajiya and Von Herzen 1984].
Many early implementations of cloud models were based on the work presented by
Perlin [1989] in which he presented a method for generating continuous random data
within a volumetric space. The method was based on using harmonics, or series of
overlapping waves, to generate a continuous function. An example of Perlin noise is
shown below in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Example of Perlin noise, courtesy of Zeki Melek.
![Page 16: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
6
Contemporary work by Lewis [1989] was also based on using random functions
to approximate clouds, but his method used two dimensional random textures applied to
ellipsoids to make his clouds. The textures also included opacity values, to give the
clouds some transparency. An example of Lewis’s method is shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Example of clouds using Lewis method. Figure taken from [Lewis 1989]
Other early models of cloud structure were developed within the field of
Mathematics. In their 1992 paper, Nagel and Raschke [1992] presented a model of
cloud growth based on a simple Boolean function iterated within a volumetric data
space. This method, which is called a cellular automaton and shown in Figure 4, can
give a somewhat realistic looking growth pattern for the formation of a cloud. However
clouds that are generated using this method are limited to growth in one direction and
![Page 17: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
7
tend to produce very uniform cloud structures. An example of clouds generated using
this method is shown in Figure 5.
Figure 4: Transition functions for Nagel's cellular automaton. Figure taken from [Dobashi et al. 2000]. Act, hum, and cld are the three fields which are updated by the transitions functions.
Figure 5: Clouds generated using Nagel's method. Taken from early prototype application.
![Page 18: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
8
Another model which was presented by Fabrice Neyret in 1997 is based on
simulating high-level process such as currents, vortices, and bubbles to produce a
simulation of cloud formation. This model is quite unique in its focus on these high-
level phenomena that occur in the atmosphere and their contributions to cloud formation
[Neyret 1997]. An example of clouds generated using Neyret’s method is shown in
Figure 6. The use of bubble-like particles is evident in this image.
Figure 6: Example of Neyret's clouds. Figure taken from [Neyret 1997].
In 1990, Kaneko presented a method for simulating physical processes with an
expanded version of the cellular automaton used in Nagel’s method. He used a Coupled
Map Lattice to simulate convection currents in two dimensions. Since that time, this
work has been used to simulate many other physical processes, especially gaseous
phenomena. An example of 2D convection generated using CML is shown in Figure 7.
![Page 19: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
9
Figure 7: Convection simulated using CML. Figure taken from [Miyazaki 2001].
Recently, Kaneko’s method has been applied to generating clouds based on
atmospheric fluid dynamics in a paper by Miyazaki et al. [2001]. This method, used in
conjunction with Dobashi’s rendering methods, can produce excellent results of cirrus
cloud formations as shown below in Figure 8.
Figure 8: Miyazaki example. Figure taken from [Miyazaki et al. 2001].
![Page 20: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
10
The problem with procedural methods is that in the quest to mimic the seemingly
random shape of natural clouds, they can quickly become gross mathematical
abstractions of simple fluid motion. Furthermore, these methods are not based on the
many physical processes which contribute to natural cloud formation in our atmosphere.
2.1.2 RENDERING MODELS IN COMPUTER GRAPHICS
Computer rendered clouds are often generated for the purpose of background
imagery, and therefore the primary goal of the modeler is to fool the eye into dismissing
the puffy thing it sees in the background as a cloud. By making the cloud appear more
natural in color and texture, the artist can draw the viewer's eye away from the actual
structure of the cloud and toward the heart of the image. Such effects can be achieved
using only rendering techniques and artistic control, without actually putting much effort
into the underlying model of the cloud. Our model differs in that we seek to create an
accurate model of the growth of the cloud's volumetric structure. Any of these advanced
rendering methods can be used with our data to produce excellent offline images or
animations of cloud formation.
Some of the earliest work on volume rendering was presented at SIGGRAPH by Jim
Blinn in 1982. Blinn’s method was the first to address the light interactions that occur
![Page 21: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
11
when light passes through a low-albedo3 particle cloud. An image taken from Blinn’s
paper is shown in Figure 9.
Figure 9: Blinn's volume rendering method. Figure taken from [Blinn 1982].
Another early rendering concept was presented in 1985 by Gardner. Gardner’s
idea was to create a cloud scene using both 2D and 3D representations. He would use a
two dimensional texture to display high-level clouds in the background, while using 3D
textured ellipsoids to model foreground clouds. An example of a scene generated by
Gardner using this method is shown below in Figure 10.
3 Albedo refers to the reflectance ratio of the material. Therefore a low-albedo analysis accounts more for diffuse lighting caused by the particle cloud.
![Page 22: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
12
Figure 10: Example of Gardner's textured ellipsoids. Figure taken from [Gardner 1985].
Work in 1986 presented by Nelson Max also contributed to the art of rendering
volumetric data. Max presented a method for rendering atmospheric effects such as
shadows and attenuation based on a scanline algorithm implemented in polar
coordinates. This method is also applicable to rendering clouds and other volumetric
data where atmospheric effects are desired. An example of Max’s work is shown in
Figure 11.
![Page 23: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
13
Figure 11: Max example. Figure taken from [Max 1986].
As the rendering of volumetric data was more fully explored by researchers, the field
of medicine supplied a practical application for these methods, as well as a new source
of high-resolution data. Medical diagnosis procedures such as MRI and CT4 scans
produce very high-resolution data sets, which must be visualized in order to be useful for
doctors and surgeons. In 1990 Marc Levoy presented an efficient method for volume
rendering that made use of octree data representations and adaptive termination of rays.
An example of a rendering using Levoy’s method is shown in Figure 12.
4 Magnetic resonance imaging and Computerized Tomography, respectively.
![Page 24: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
14
Figure 12: Levoy example. Figure taken from [Levoy 1990].
Much of the recent research into advanced rendering methods for clouds and other
volumetric data has focused on accounting for effects such as skylight and atmospheric
attenuation5. Yoshinori Dobashi has presented an efficient method for rendering
volumetric cloud data in which several transparent concentric spheres are rendered in
front of the viewer [Dobashi et al. 2000], as shown in Figure 13. The texture that is
mapped onto these spheres is a function of atmospheric attenuation at each vertex. This
gives very nice renderings of sunsets and other scenes in which sunlight shines through
from behind the clouds. A visual description of Dobashi’s rendering method is shown in
Figure 14, and an example of Dobashi’s method is shown in Figure 15.
5 Atmospheric attenuation is responsible for shafts of light protruding through large cloud formations. It is equivalent to the degree to which the light has been ‘masked’ by passing through the cloud or sky.
![Page 25: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
15
Figure 13: Concentric spheres used in Dobashi method. These spheres are mapped with a texture which is a function of atmospheric attenuation and then rendered around the viewpoint so that the
viewer looks through them.
Figure 14: Visual description of Dobashi method. Image taken from [Dobashi et al. 2000]. Shows how vertex computations are used to create shafts of light.
![Page 26: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
16
Figure 15: Image from Dobashi method. Image taken from [Dobashi et al. 2000].
Recent research into rendering methods includes that by Harris and Lastra [2001].
Their paper focuses on using imposters to speed up rendering, approximating multiple
forward and anisotropic scattering of light through volumetric data. An example of
Harris’s work is shown in Figure 16.
Figure 16: Example of Harris's rendering method. Figure taken from [Harris and Lastra 2001].
![Page 27: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
17
2.1.3 PARTICLE SYSTEMS AND FLUID MODELS IN COMPUTER GRAPHICS
Other methods have developed models in Computer Graphics by making use of
techniques designed to approximate fluid motion. Traditionally, many of these models
have been based on particle systems, but methods have also been implemented using
both regular and irregular grid structures.
Some of the earliest work presented regarding using particle systems for modeling
fuzzy objects was presented by William Reeves in 1983. Reeves presented a technique
for using a particle system to model fire, clouds, or water. He did this simply by
designing the particles' behavior to mimic the desired fluid motion [Reeves 1983]. This
work was introduced to the motion picture industry in the movie Star Trek II: The Wrath
of Kahn, and is shown in Figure 17.
![Page 28: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
18
Figure 17: Particle system proposed by Reeves in 1983. Figure taken from [Reeves 1983].
Others have developed methods which use the principles of physics and fluid
dynamics to model the motion of fluids for computer models. Early CG research in this
area was presented by Foster and Metaxas [1997], whose model was one of the first in
the field of Computer Graphics to be based on the Navier-Stokes solution. An example
of the Foster and Metaxas model of fluid flow is shown in Figure 18. Fedkiw and Stam
have recently presented a method for efficiently modeling the fluid-like motion of a
substance such as smoke [Fedkiw et al. 2001], while Fedkiw and Foster have developed
models of different fluids such water and mud [Foster and Fedkiw 2001]. An example
of the more recent method presented by Fedkiw and Stam is shown in Figure 19. Details
of this method will be discussed in more detail in section 4.
![Page 29: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
19
Figure 18: Foster and Metaxas example. Figure taken from [Foster and Metaxas 1997].
Figure 19: Fedkiw and Stam example. Figure taken from [Fedkiw et al. 2001].
![Page 30: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
20
2.2 CLOUD MODELS IN METEOROLOGY
There is a fundamental difference in the approach that the meteorologist takes when
modeling clouds from the approach that the computer scientist takes. The Computer
Graphics perspective is to strive primarily for visual effect and speed. The goal is to
simulate as little as necessary to get the desired level of detail. On the other hand, the
meteorologist will try to get the highest level of accuracy possible, regardless of how
long it takes or how it looks. The meteorological approach to modeling nature is to
simulate everything that physics can tell us, and thus these models are inherently
different than models developed within the field of Computer Graphics.
To understand the meteorological approach, we must first examine the way in which
meteorologists have traditionally studied the atmosphere. Extensive, documented
research into storm systems began as early as the 1940's when commercial aviation
began to first feel the threat of severe weather. After WWII, Congress decided to make
use of some of the Air Force's Northrup P-61C-type airplanes [Braham 1996], in order to
gain a better understanding of how weather patterns formed thunderstorms. This project,
known as the Thunderstorm Project, has been the largest study to date of storm
formation. It used a multitude of sensors both on the ground and in the air for many
large storm systems. A total of 76 thunderstorms were recorded [Braham 1996]. From
this study, Byers and Braham developed a model thunderstorm formation called the Air-
Mass Thunderstorm, shown in Figure 20. The model was a three-stage model of storm
![Page 31: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
21
development: the cumulus stage, the mature stage, and the downdraft stage. This study
was only the beginning of this area of research in meteorology, however the dataset from
this project remains one of the largest of storm data to this day, and is still used as input
for many contemporary meteorological models.
Figure 20: Air-Mass Thunderstorm [Byers and Braham 1949].
Today research in this area has culminated in a distributed project called Mesoscale and
Microscale Meteorology. The MMM simulator is able to simulate almost all known
atmospheric phenomena on both meso- and micro- scales. Simulations can take
anywhere from days to minutes, depending on the resolution and the amount of detail
required. More information on the MMM Project can be obtained from the National
Center for Atmospheric Research6 or Pennsylvania State University7.
6 MMM Home Page, National Center for Atmospheric Research. http://www.mmm.ucar.edu/mmm/home.html 7 MM5 Home Page, Pennsylvania State University. http://www.mmm.ucar.edu/mm5/mm5-home.html.
![Page 32: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
22
3 CLOUD FORMATION IN THE ATMOSPHERE
The study of clouds has never been limited to scientists alone. Artists, poets, and
even daydreamers watch with interest as the clouds constantly change before their eyes.
At any one time, nearly half of the earth's surface may be obscured by cloud cover
[Wallace and Hobbs 1977]. This is because there are so many different ways for cloud
to form in our atmosphere. Two of the most common types of clouds are convective
clouds and layer clouds. Convective clouds are formed by the local ascent of warm air
parcels in a conditionally unstable environment [Wallace and Hobbs 1977]. Convective
clouds are also known as cumulus clouds and can be distinguished by their
predominantly upward growth. These clouds range in size from 0.1 to 10 km. Their
ascension velocities can range anywhere from 1 m/s to 10 m/s, and they can last from
minutes to hours [Wallace and Hobbs 1977]. An example of a cumulus cloud formation
is shown in Figure 21.
Figure 21: Cumulus cloud formation. Figure taken from [Wallen 1992].
![Page 33: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
23
Layer clouds, on the other hand, which are also known as stratus clouds, are
produced by upward motion of stable air and may occur anywhere from ground level up
to the tropopause8. These clouds can extend from hundreds to thousands of square
kilometers, are usually driven by vertical velocities ranging from 1 to 10 cm/s, and can
last for tens of hours [Wallace and Hobbs 1977]. An example of a stratus cloud
formation is shown in Figure 22.
Figure 22: Stratus cloud formation. Figure taken from [Wallen 1992].
In addition to cumulus and stratus clouds, clouds can also be classified as either
cirrus or nimbus. Cirrus clouds are those clouds which appear fibrous, and nimbus
refers to any cloud that precipitates. Most clouds can be classified by one of these types
or their compounds, like cirrocumulus or cumulonimbus. Of course there are many more 8 Remember that the troposphere extends approximately 12 km above the surface of the earth.
![Page 34: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
24
documented cloud types than we will present here. However, for those interested more
information can be found in the International Cloud Atlas, published by the World
Meteorological Organization in 1956.
3.1 THERMODYNAMICS
Several thermodynamic principles are active participants in the formation of clouds in
our atmosphere. One of the foremost and most relevant for our simulation model is the
ideal gas law, given in Equation 1.
nRTPV =
Equation 1. P is pressure, V is volume, n is number of moles, R is the universal gas constant9, and T is temperature.
This equation tells us that, given constant pressure in a gas under ideal conditions,
volume and temperature will be directly proportional. Or, given constant volume, the
pressure and temperature will be directly proportional. Because of this relationship, a
rising parcel of air will experience a decrease in temperature just as it experiences a
decrease in pressure10.
9 Given as Kmol
J⋅315.8 [Lide 1992].
10 A chart of the pressure gradient in the troposphere is given in Figure 45.
![Page 35: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
25
3.2 PHYSICAL PROCESS
3.2.1 STAGE ONE: DIRTY MOIST AIR
The physical process of cloud formation as it occurs every day in our atmosphere is a
quite complicated process. In order for the process to begin, the presence of “dirty moist
air” is required. We must have air which contains tiny particles, called hygroscopic
nuclei, upon which the water vapor can condense11, along with having air saturated with
water vapor (near 100% relative humidity12). Water vapor can actually condense at
relative humidity levels lower than 100% if the air contains a high concentration of these
particles (over 50%). For example, in a city with severe air pollution clouds may form
with relative humidity as low as 76% [Wallen 1992]. Also, cloud formation can be
artificially aided by increasing the local concentration of hygroscopic nuclei. In fact,
this is the same concept used in artificially seeding real clouds — planes release fine
particles into saturated air to aid in the condensation process [Wallen 1992]. An
example of this is shown in Figure 23.
11 In order to condense, pure water must have a surface to adhere to. 12 Relative humidity is the amount of water within a differential volume of air over the total amount of water vapor that differential volume can hold (which is dependant upon pressure and temperature) [Wallen 1992].
![Page 36: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
26
Figure 23: Artificial cloud seeding over 45 minute period. Figure taken from [Wallace and Hobbs 1977].
3.2.2 STAGE TWO: ASCENSION The second stage in atmospheric cloud formation is ascending air. Ascension is most
often caused in our atmosphere by thermal currents. Thermal currents are the result of
buoyancy within our atmosphere. The surface of the earth, warmed by the sun, radiates
heat into the atmosphere, which causes the temperature of the air to increase. This
causes the air to expand due to increased local pressure and then rise due to buoyancy13.
13 Buoyancy is a result of variation in density within a fluid. In our simulation, we do not account for local variations in density, only the resulting buoyant force.
![Page 37: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
27
A visual example of how temperature variations create thermal currents is shown in
Figure 24.
Figure 24: Example of ascension caused by convection. Figure taken from [Wallen 1992].
Ascension of air can also be caused by orographic uplift which is when air is ‘pushed
up’ by the terrain below it. For example, clouds often form around mountain ranges as
the air blows up and over the surface of the mountain [Wallen 1992]. An example of
this is shown in Figure 25.
![Page 38: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
28
Figure 25: A cloud formation caused by orographic uplift. Figure taken from [Wallace and Hobbs 1977].
3.2.3 ADIABATIC COOLING/SATURATION As air rises, pushed by either buoyancy within the air or orographic uplift, the air
expands as the pressure decreases. The decrease in pressure results in a proportional
decrease in temperature. A graph of pressure (mBar) vs. altitude (km) is shown in
Figure 26. Because cool air is able to hold less water vapor than warm air, the result is
an increase in relative humidity as a moist air parcel rises. Eventually, the rising air will
reach a point of saturation. The temperature at which this occurs is called the dew point.
![Page 39: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
29
Figure 26: Graph of pressure vs. altitude. Data taken from [Lide 1992].
3.2.4 CONDENSATION AND LATENT HEAT Once the dew point has been reached and if hygroscopic nuclei are present,
condensation will occur. Since the process of condensation is an exothermic process, it
causes the release of what is called the latent heat of condensation. This energy, which
is proportional to kgJ6105.2 × [Wallace and Hobbs 1977], increases the temperature of
the nearby air, thus increasing it's buoyancy and causing the air to rise even more. This
is why so many clouds seem to grow upward, especially when the surrounding air is
calm. Different atmospheric conditions contribute to the growth of different cloud types,
which will be discussed later in section 5.3.
![Page 40: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
30
3.2.5 PRECIPITATION
The final stage of the process is precipitation. Precipitation is a gradual process
involving the collision and coalescence of condensed cloud droplets. As droplets collide
with each other within the cloud, many smaller droplets will combine to create a few
larger droplets. As these droplets grow in mass, the gravitational force exerted upon
them increases and thus the terminal velocity of these droplets increases. This increase
in size and velocity also increases the probability of collision. Figure 27 below shows a
comparison in size among cloud droplets and their larger counterparts, raindrops. CCN
stands for Cloud Condensation Nuclei, and is equivalent to our concept of hygroscopic
nuclei. In the figure, r is the radius in micrometers, n is the number of particles per liter
of air, and v is the terminal velocity in cm/s.
Figure 27: Visual depiction of cloud droplet size. Figure taken from [Wallace and Hobbs 1977].
The statistical model of the precipitation process is called the continuous
collision model, and is shown in Figure 28. This model provides a statistical distribution
![Page 41: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
31
of droplet size within a cloud based on a stepwise function of collision probability. The
collision probability in the figure is 101 . One shortcoming of this model is that it fails to
consider increased probability associated with increasing size, although it can be argued
that such a small change in size may not affect collision probability. As a point of fact,
however, the complete collision probability solution is much more complicated,
involving not only accurate simulation of simple physical properties of cloud droplets
such as mass, velocity, and acceleration, but also more complicated characteristics such
as surface tension and body deformation. However, for the purposes of a visual
simulation, this model would present an adequate basis for a simulated model of the
precipitation process.
Figure 28: Continuous collision model. Figure taken from [Wallace and Hobbs 1977].
![Page 42: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
32
4 FLUID MODEL
Our simulation of cloud formation is based upon an implementation of a course grid
fluid solver presented recently by Stam [1999]. This solver uses the Navier-Stokes fluid
equations to model fluid flow through a volumetric space. Here we present a brief
description of the Navier-Stokes solution and why it is acceptable for our model. For
details concerning our implementation, the reader should consult both Stam's paper
[1999] and the paper by Fedkiw et al [2001].
4.1 FLUID MODEL BASICS
The Navier-Stokes solution is an approximation of incompressible flow.
Incompressible flow is that which contains no sharp changes in density, as would be
caused by a supersonic shockwave. This model is preferred to those of compressible
flow because compressible flow solutions require relatively small time steps to maintain
accuracy. There is no disadvantage to using incompressible flow as long as the
maximum flow speed remains below Mach 1 (the speed of sound) [Brower 1999].
When building a model of fluid flow, we begin by assuming that mass is conserved.
This means that the net change in mass must always be zero. This is expressed
mathematically in Equation 2, shown below. This equation states that the time rate of
![Page 43: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
33
change in density )( t∂∂ρ
is balanced by the divergence )(∇⋅ of the mass flux )( uρ at
any point in space.
tu ∂∂−=⋅∇ ρρ
Equation 2
In Equation 2, ρ is the density and u is the vector field representing velocity within
the fluid. If we assume that our density is constant ( 0=∂∂
tρ ), non-zero, and varies
gradually compared to changes in velocity, Equation 2 simplifies to
0=⋅∇ u
Equation 3
This equation expresses conservation of mass within our system, and is required for
the system to be properly constrained. We need four equations to solve for the four
unknowns in a fluid system: velocity in x,y,z directions and pressure. Therefore
Equation 3 and the three Navier-Stokes equations are a complete solution for fluid flow.
The Navier-Stokes equations can be written together as shown below in Equation 4
[White 1991].
![Page 44: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
34
ρρ ν fptu uuu +∇+=∇⋅+ −∇∂∂ 2)(
Equation 4
The terms on the left of the equation are our inertial acceleration terms. The first
term expresses our temporal acceleration while the second expresses spatial effects
within the system. On the right of the equation we have a pressure term followed by a
term which expresses the viscous force (shear stress). The final term, f, represents any
external forces per unit volume applied to the system. This equation shows that motion
within the system is dependant upon force due to pressure, force due to viscous effects,
and force due to any external forces such as gravity (or buoyancy).
Because the inertial effects outweigh the contribution of viscous effects in air, we can
ignore the viscous term. To see this we examine the Reynolds number for our system.
The Reynolds number expresses the dimensionless ratio of inertial forces to viscous
forces and is given below in Equation 5 [White 1991]:
νLuR ⋅=
Equation 5
![Page 45: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
35
In Equation 5 u is a characteristic velocity, L is characteristic length and ν is
kinematic viscosity14. For air at approximately 20 °C, sm25104.1 −×=ν [Lide 1992].
Also, since the troposphere extends approximately 12 km from the surface of the earth
[Wallen 1992], we can use m310 as our characteristic length. Therefore, in order for the
Reynolds number to be 1.0 (where the inertial effect equals that of the viscous effect),
our flow speed would have to remain below sm810− . Since the fluid motion we will be
modeling will be much faster than this, we can assume that 1>>R and therefore viscous
effects can be ignored. Although the precise value of the characteristic length (L) or
kinematic viscosity )(ν may vary slightly in a particular simulation, this remains a safe
assumption since the Reynolds number will remain much greater than 1. Looking at the
Navier-Stokes equation again, we can see that, having removed the viscous term, our
inertial acceleration in the system will be balanced by pressure and external forces
within the system. This makes our fluid flow computation much easier since we do not
have to compute the effects of viscosity.
The fluid solver we use for our simulation, presented by Stam [Stam 1999], is based
on this Navier-Stokes system. At each simulation step, the Navier-Stokes equations —
neglecting the viscous term — are solved for each voxel in the grid. One of the main
aspects of this method is the use of backward-tracing particle motion within the system.
This approach allows for unconditional stability even when using large time steps and is
14 The kinematic viscosity of a material is defined as the fluidic viscosity of the material over the density [White 1991].
![Page 46: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
36
shown in Figure 29. As shown in the figure below, at each timestep we trace the motion
of a particle in the direction of it’s current velocity times t∆− . Instead of calculating
where a particle is going, we are calculating what is coming toward this particle. This
method introduces a small amount of inaccuracy, but makes the simulation much more
stable and allows for larger timesteps.
Figure 29: Backward tracing time-step method proposed by Stam. Figure taken from [Stam 1999].
4.2 APPLICATION OF FLUID MODEL TO ATMOSPHERIC SIMULATION
In order to apply this fluid model to a simulation of the atmosphere, we must account
for several discrepancies between the model and the actual atmosphere. As we have
mentioned previously, the Navier-Stokes model of fluid motion assumes constant
![Page 47: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
37
pressure and density of air, which is not realistic in the atmosphere. Air in our
atmosphere is stratified, meaning that its pressure and density decrease as we go up.
Fortunately for us, these variances in pressure and density do not affect the motion of the
fluid within the atmosphere, since the only direct affect of these changes would have on
fluid motion would be realized as effects of viscosity (in our model viscous effects are
ignored). What these changes in pressure and density do affect are the processes that
occur at different altitudes within our simulation. For example, the pressure and density
of air does have an effect on the amount of water vapor the air can hold, which directly
affects the relative humidity computation in the simulation. Therefore, although we do
not model local changes in pressure or density of the air, we do keep track of these
values and how they change over large changes in altitude. By storing pressure and
density values in lookup tables, we are able to use empirical data from the atmosphere to
compute derived values such as relative humidity and how they change with varying
altitude.
![Page 48: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
38
5 CLOUD MODEL
In this section we discuss our software model of the physical process of cloud
formation in the atmosphere. In section 5.1 we present the software model we have
developed to mimic this physical process. In section 5.2 we briefly discuss the user
interface we have developed and in section 5.3 we describe how we can use our software
model and interface to produce different types of clouds. Pseudocode for the software
model is included in Appendix C.
5.1 SOFTWARE MODEL
We have mentioned that our model of cloud formation is physically based. What this
means is that we simulate the condensation of water vapor within the atmosphere based
on parameters derived from the physical process. To do this we must model the fluid
flow of air in our atmosphere. Local airflow is based on a number of environmental
factors, including large-scale wind and turbulence.
Aside from modeling the local motion of the air, we must also model the thermal
currents that occur in the atmosphere. We do this by modeling the motion of heat energy
in the atmosphere. We first define heat sources at ground level. These sources radiate
heat into the atmosphere. We are able to compute the temperature of any point in the
![Page 49: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
39
field by multiplying the amount of heat energy present by the pressure, as shown in
Equation 6. The pressure in our system is defined as a gradient based on altitude. The
pressure is 1.0 Bar at ground level and decreases exponentially with height to 0.1 Bar at
the tropopause15. These values are taken directly from measurements within our own
atmosphere [Wallen 1992].
locallocallocal PET ×=
Equation 6: Temperature computation. localT is temperature, localE is heat energy, and localP is pressure.
Once we compute the temperature at each point we use this information to compute
our buoyant forces. At each point, if the surrounding temperature16 is less than the
current temperature at that point then we add a positive buoyant force. Likewise, if the
surrounding temperature is greater than the current temperature, we add a negative
buoyant force. This enables us to model the thermal currents in our atmosphere caused
by heat sources. We compute the actual buoyant force added to our system as shown in
Equation 7, where buoyancyK is a user-defined constant. Figure 30 shows heat being
added to the system and causing buoyancy, and Figure 31 shows humidity within the
system being advected upward by that buoyant force.
15 The tropopause refers to the upper boundary of the troposphere. 16 The surrounding temperature is computed by averaging the temperature values for all neighbor voxels in the same horizontal plane.
![Page 50: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
40
)( gsurroundinlocalbuoyancybuoyancy TTKF −=
Equation 7: Buoyant force computation. T is temperature.
Figure 30: Heat enters the environment from defined sources at ground level. This creates buoyancy, which causes vertical convection currents within our system.
Figure 31: Humidity is shown being advected upward by thermal currents (caused by added heat shown above in Figure 30). The humidity is colored based on temperature, blue being cold and red
being hot.
![Page 51: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
41
Next we must compute relative humidity at each point. In order to compute relative
humidity, as shown in Equation 8, we must compute how much water vapor the current
volume can hold at maximum. This value is dependant upon the current temperature and
pressure. We can simply multiply these two values together (after rescaling to [0,1]) to
compute how much water vapor can be stored by the current voxel. Since the value for
the current amount of water vapor held is also on the scale [0,1], the calculation for
relative humidity is straightforward.
wv
wv
TotalCurrentRH =
Equation 8: Relative humidity computation.
The final process we must include is condensation. We have already stated that the
relative humidity at a given voxel must be at or near saturation for condensation to
occur. If the concentration of hygroscopic nuclei is very high, condensation can occur at
lower relative humidity levels. The hygroscopic nuclei concentration can be thought of
a seed for the cloud, and can be used to scale the thickness of the cloud appropriately.17
Therefore the amount of condensation that occurs at any point is a function of the
relative humidity and the concentration of hygroscopic nuclei, as shown in Equation 9,
17 See Figure 23.
![Page 52: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
42
where cK is an appropriate user-defined constant. In our model we assume that the
concentration of hygroscopic nuclei is constant.
cRH
condensed KHNW ××= 100
Equation 9: Condensation computation.
Next we compute the latent heat released from the phase transition of the water
vapor. The amount of latent heat released is directly proportional to the mass of the
water vapor condensed. For water at 0 °C, the latent heat of condensation is given as
kgJ6105.2 × [Lide 1992]. Therefore we can compute the amount of latent heat released
as shown in Equation 10, where lK is a user-specified constant.
lcondensedlatent KWH ×××= 6105.2
Equation 10: Latent heat computation.
![Page 53: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
43
5.2 INTERFACE
Our graphical user interface for the cloud modeling software application has been
implemented using the GLUI interface toolkit18 on top of OpenGL. The user has the
ability to change view parameters, as well as bring up additional menus for simulation
parameters which can be modified during the simulation. This allows the user maximum
control over the simulation environment during run-time. An example of our GUI is
shown in Figure 32.
Figure 32: Graphical User Interface for cloud modeling application. View controls are on bottom left, and simulation controls are on right.
18 Paul Rademacher’s GLUI Interface Toolkit. http://www.cs.unc.edu/~rademach/glui/
![Page 54: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
44
Among the parameters we give the user access to through our interface, we have
included a window for manipulating wind in the environment, shown in Figure 33. The
user can set the speed and direction of a global wind, which affects all voxels in the
system19; or the user can specify the direction, speed, height, and source20 of a local
wind which can be used to create turbulence. The user is also able to customize the heat
source configuration at ground level and set the source of humidity, — either from
humidity entering from just above sea level as if by evaporation or incoming from cross-
winds. The interface window we have implemented for this is shown in Figure 34. In
our implementation we use a Perlin noise function scaled by an overall concentration
value to define both of our humidity sources [Perlin 1989]. Perlin noise is a more
natural source for an initial random distribution than simply initializing a volumetric
block of space.
19 The effect of the wind is dependant upon altitude because of the decrease in density as we go up. Therefore the wind has more effect higher in the atmosphere. 20 The user can specify which direction the wind is coming from (North, South, East or West), as well as an incoming angle and an aperture which defines how wide the incoming velocity source will be.
![Page 55: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
45
Figure 33: Wind interface. User is given control of both global and local winds.
Figure 34: Source interface. User can specify the source configuration for both heat energy and humidity.
![Page 56: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
46
In our application, volumetric data is rendered interactively using alpha-blended
billboards generated from front to back, following the approach presented by Fedkiw et
al. [2001]. However, the volumetric data generated can be exported for off-line
rendering using a ray-tracing algorithm21 or other off-line rendering method such as that
presented recently by [Harris and Lastra 2001].
5.3 CREATING DIFFERENT CLOUD TYPES
Cloud formation is a scene with many "actors" in it. Consequently, there are many
distinct ways that the actors in the atmosphere can interact to form clouds. This is why
different atmospheric conditions produce different cloud formations. Currently our
simulation focuses only on two main cloud types — cumulus clouds and stratus clouds.
Cumulus clouds are formed by vertical air movement caused by thermal currents over
land. Stratus clouds, on the other hand, are formed by horizontal wind currents over
oceans or other large bodies of cold water. We will explain in detail how we set up our
environment to form each cloud type.
5.3.1 CUMULUS TYPE CLOUDS
We form cumulus clouds by defining a plume of humidity and a heat source at
ground level. The heat raises the temperature of the air and buoyancy causes the humid
21 Data resampling may be advantageous to give better volume-rendering results.
![Page 57: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
47
air to rise. The heat source pattern can be tailored to fit the approximate cloud shape
desired. As the humidity rises and condenses, latent heat increases the upward buoyant
force and produces a predominantly vertical cloud growth pattern.
In our simulation we have included wind functionality to help shape the cloud as
well. A global wind defines the drift pattern of the cloud, while local crosswinds
introduce turbulence into the environment. We have also included an implementation of
vorticity confinement presented by Steinhoff and Underhill [1994] which helps preserve
conservation of momentum during turbulence. Figure 35 is an example of cumulus
cloud formation.
Figure 35: Cumulus cloud formation caused by vertical air movement. Spheres at bottom are designated heat sources.
![Page 58: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
48
5.3.2 STRATUS TYPE CLOUDS
Stratus clouds are formed slightly differently than cumulus clouds. Stratus clouds
usually form over cold ocean water, with little or no vertical air movement. Contrary to
the cumulus cloud set-up, for stratus clouds we do not define any additional heat source
for our environment and our source of humidity is outside our simulation region, carried
in on a high-velocity cross-wind. The user can define the direction and altitude of the
crosswind and also the amount of humidity carried in by the wind. This gives us
humidity generally traveling horizontally instead of vertically. When any of the water
vapor condenses, the latent heat released causes some buoyancy and therefore we
sometimes see wispy streaks of cloud, interspersed horizontally around the dew point.
Figure 36 is an example of stratus cloud formation.
Figure 36: Stratus cloud formation caused by horizontal air flow.
![Page 59: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
49
The above images were rendered interactively on a grid size of 15x50x15 at an
approximate frame rate of 1 frame/sec. Frame rate can be increased to 7-10 frames/sec
with a grid size of 15x15x15. We have used a Pentium III 800MHz processor with
256Mb RAM and a Geforce 2 graphics accelerator.
![Page 60: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
50
6 RESULTS AND PROBLEMS ENCOUNTERED
In this section we discuss the results of our study as well as present some of the
problems that were encountered during the course of this research and their proposed
solutions.
Many of the problems encountered are related to our application of the Navier-Stokes
fluid model to the problem of atmospheric simulation. As we have previously
mentioned, we have assumed that density, and therefore pressure, are constant in our
system in order to make the Navier-Stokes solution less expensive to compute.
However, we have used empirical data to specify the pressure in our system, which is
exponentially proportional to altitude, as shown in Figure 45 in Appendix A. Because
our system is not solving for the variance in pressure over the space dimension, we must
introduce additional steps to our simulation to account for the physical effects of this on
the fluid flow in the atmosphere.
First, we realized that our system failed to account for expansion of the air during
ascension. Because air experiences a decrease in density and thus pressure as we go up,
the air expands to occupy a larger volume, and thus anything in the air such as water
vapor or condensed particles will experience this expansive force. We have accounted
for this in our system at a low-level by adding a step to our simulation pipeline. During
this step, we analyze the entire velocity grid, and for every voxel with a positive vertical
![Page 61: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
51
velocity we add a proportional horizontal force22 in every surrounding direction. This
concept is shown in two dimensions below in Figure 37. The net effect will be an
expansive force added along the perimeter of any cells of vertical motion. Because we
are tracing backwards when advecting our system, this expansive force on the perimeter
of the cell will actually ‘pull-out’ density from this area, which gives the same effect as
an internal expansive force ‘pushing out.’
Figure 37: Proposed expansion algorithm in two dimensions.
Furthermore, we found that our model also failed to properly conserve momentum in
a system with density variance in the space dimension. As an air parcel rises, it collides
with other air parcels above it. These higher air parcels have a lower density, thus the
transfer of momentum between the two parcels results in an increase in upward velocity.
We have also accounted for this at a low-level by adding a simulation step. At every
time-step we analyze the velocity and we increase all positive vertical motion and
decrease all negative vertical motion. This is shown visually in two dimensions in
22 The scale of this force should be experimentally determined. However we have not yet implemented this method, therefore the proper constant has not yet been ascertained.
![Page 62: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
52
Figure 38. We account for this because although there may be no local variation in
density in our simulated atmosphere, we are solving for our fluid motion on a coarse grid
and therefore there may be considerable variation in density from one voxel to another
voxel at a higher/lower altitude. To ensure that momentum is conserved properly, we
can recompute the Navier-Stokes solution at each voxel (using our altitude dependant
pressure term) to ensure that error is within tolerance.
Figure 38: Proposed momentum conservation algorithm.
![Page 63: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
53
7 IMPLEMENTATION DETAILS
In this section we will discuss details of the implementation developed. All code
discussed has been developed using OpenGL, GLUI, and C++ and has been written and
tested on an 800MHz PentiumIII with 256Mb RAM and a Geforce2 graphics
accelerator. A version of this implementation is also available for UNIX.
7.1 DATA STRUCTURE
The fields we have in this simulation are humidity, heat, and condensation. In order
to keep track of the different fields (e.g. humidity, condensation) that are being advected
within our simulation, we have developed a data structure which contains the relevant
information for each field. This data element is called a `Field' and contains a pointer to
the three-dimensional grid structure that contains the mass distribution for the current
field, as well as a pointer to the velocity field being used. Also contained within the
Field structure are several constants used in the simulation such as diffusion rate, a
resistance factor used to scale the motion of the vector field, and a gravity term for the
field.
![Page 64: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
54
7.2 VISUALIZATION
Our simulation uses OpenGL to visualize our data. We display one field of data
(either humidity, heat, or condensation) at each step in the simulation. The data is
displayed using semi-transparent smooth-blended quadrilateral strips oriented from back
to front with respect to the current view. Other visualization packages could also be
used, however we have chosen OpenGL because of its portability.
7.3 SIMULATION
At each step in the simulation, we perform three basic operations — we advect the
mass within the system using the current velocity field, we diffuse each field according
to the diffusion rate defined for each field as well as the velocity field. We then execute
a projection step which ensures that our system is divergence free with respect to
pressure. The simulation steps are shown visually in Figure 39.
![Page 65: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
55
Figure 39: Simulation pipeline.
7.4 CONSTRAINTS
Most of the computational expenses in our method were a result of the cost of the
fluid solver. The graphics processor we used, a Nvidia Geforce2 with 32Mb video
memory, was adequate for this application. No bottlenecks were experienced when the
system was rendering, only when executing the fluid solver. In our implementation we
were unable to allocate a grid size larger than 25x25x50. However, with increased CPU
speed and memory, which are both becoming increasingly more common on standard
desktop PC’s, we would be able to increase both grid size and performance. We would
like to test our application on a more powerful machine, such as a 2GHz PC with 1+Gb
RAM. We would like to be able to run the simulation on a grid size of approximately
50x50x100 with interactive frame rates.
![Page 66: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
56
8 FUTURE WORK
In this section we discuss several directions for further research.
• More cloud types
There are many more types of cloud formations than just the two we have
addressed in our current simulation. These include cirrus, cirrocumulus,
cirrostratus, altocumulus, altostratus, nimbostratus, stratocumulus, and finally
cumulonimbus [Wallen 1992]. As the names suggest, many of these cloud types
are variations of the three main cloud formations: stratus, cumulus, and cirrus.
Although we have not yet explored creation of these other types, we believe our
model should easily adapt to handle them. With additional research we would like
to add environmental presets for each cloud type to aid the user in creating these
different base types.
• Complete growth cycle including precipitation and dissipation
We also hope to add to the current growth cycle of our clouds. Once enough water
vapor has condensed into cloud form, gravity starts to pull down on some of the
larger condensed particles. As the large droplets fall through the cloud colliding
with other condensed particles, the process of precipitation begins [Wallen 1992].
We would like to experiment with modeling the precipitation stage of the cloud
life cycle in our model. This model could be implemented simply by overlaying a
![Page 67: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
57
simple particle system on top of our volumetric cloud data. Because the
continuous collision model provides a statistical distribution of particle size in the
cloud, we would not have to perform the more expensive collision detection
algorithms in order to reproduce the process. However, some research may be
required in order to develop an accurate algorithm for computing collision
probability under varying environmental conditions. This would not only include
rain but also other forms of precipitation including snow and frozen rain.
• More research into atmospheric model
By improving our model of the atmosphere, we will be able to better mimic the
complex processes that contribute to the formation of other cloud types and storm
systems. We would like to improve our model to the point that we are able to
successfully incorporate all three stages of the thunderstorm lifecycle described by
Byers and Braham [1949]: the cumulus stage, the mature stage, and the downdraft
stage.
• Gesture interface for artistic creation of environment
We would like to conduct some user experiments with a three-dimensional
augmented reality interface in which the user is able to interact with the
environment by means of a gesture-based interface. Using such an interface the
user would be able to more accurately shape the volumetric structure of the cloud
during the course of the simulation.
![Page 68: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
58
• Modeling of nebulous clouds in deep space
We have also considered in the future applying this model to the formation and
evolution of nebulous gas clouds in deep space. Our model would require
modifications to match the different environment and properties of gas flow in the
zero-gravity vacuum of deep space.
• Application to high-level atmospheric simulation
We believe that this model could be applied to a high-level atmospheric simulator
that could be used to visually simulate a section of the atmosphere equivalent to a
360° view from a point on Earth. The high-level simulator could use atmospheric
data to determine where clouds might form and what type of clouds would form
there. The low-level simulator (presented in this paper) could then be used to
generate a local cloud of the correct type.
![Page 69: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
59
9 CONCLUSIONS
We have developed an efficient physically-based simulation of cloud formation
which can be run interactively on a standard desktop PC with an average video
accelerator. This model provides a basis for modeling clouds in 3D using a
computational fluid solver. We believe that the proposed model is a significant
improvement over previous models of cloud formation in the field of Computer
Graphics because of our use of an efficient three dimensional fluid solver and our
detailed analysis of the physical process of atmospheric cloud formation. We hope to
improve this model in the future by proceeding in the directions set out in section 8.
![Page 70: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
60
REFERENCES
Blinn, J. 1982. Light Reflection Functions for Simulation of Clouds and Dusty Surfaces. Proc. of SIGGRAPH '82, pp.21–29.
Braham Jr., R.R. 1996. The Thunderstorm Project. Bulletin of the American
Meteorological Society, 77,8. Brower Jr., W. B. 1999. A Primer in Fluid Mechanics: Dynamics of Flows in One
Space Dimension. CRC Press, Boca-Raton, FL. Byers, H. R. and Braham Jr., R.R. 1949. The Thunderstorm. U.S. Department of
Commerce, Washington D.C. 287pp. Dobashi, Y., Kaneda, K., Yamashita, H., Okita, T., and Nishita, T. 2000. A Simple,
Efficient Method for Realistic Animation of Clouds. Proc. of SIGGRAPH 00, pp.19–28.
Ebert, D.S. 1997. Volumetric Modeling with Implicit Functions: A Cloud is Born.
Visual Proc. of SIGGRAPH '97, pp. 147. Fedkiw, R., Stam, J., and Wann Jensen, H. 2001. Visual Simulation of Smoke. Proc. of
SIGGRAPH 01, pp. 15–22. Foster, N. and Fedkiw, R. 2001. Practical Animation of Liquids. Proc. of SIGGRAPH
'01, pp. 23–30. Foster, N. and Metaxas, D. 1997. Modeling the Motion of a Hot, Turbulent Gas.
Computer Graphics. 31,181–188. Gardner, G. 1985. Visual Simulation of Clouds. Proc. of SIGGRAPH '85, pp. 297–303. Harris, M. J. and Lastra, A. 2001. Real-Time Cloud Rendering. Computer Graphics
Forum (Eurographics '01 Proc.), 20,3. Kajiya, J. and Von Herzen, B. 1984. Ray Tracing Volume Densities. Proc. of
SIGGRAPH '84, pp. 165–174. Kaneko, K. 1990. Simulating Physics with Coupled Map Lattices---Pattern Dynamics,
Information Flow, and Thermodynamics of Spatiotemporal Chaos. World Scientific, 1. Singapore.
Levoy, M. 1990. Efficient Ray Tracing of Volume Data. ACM Transactions on
Graphics, 9,3,245–261.
![Page 71: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
61
Lewis, J. 1989. Algorithms for Solid Noise Synthesis. Proc. of SIGGRAPH '89, pp.
263–270. Lide, D. R. 1992. CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. CRC Press, Boca-Raton,
FL. 72nd Ed. Max, N. 1986. Atmospheric Illumination and Shadows. Proc. of SIGGRAPH ’86, pp.
117–124. Miyazaki, R., Yoshida, S., Dobashi, Y., and Nishita, T. 2001. A Method for Modeling
Clouds based on Atmospheric Fluid Dynamics. Proc. of Pacific Graphics ‘01, pp. 363–372.
Nagel, K. and Raschke, E. 1992. Self-organizing Criticality in Cloud Formation?
Physica A, (182):519–531. Neyret, F. 1997. Qualitative Simulation of Convective Clouds Formation and Evolution.
Computer Animation and Simulation '97. pp. 113–124. Perlin, K. 1989. Hypertexture. Proc. of SIGGRAPH '89, pp. 253–261. Reeves, W. T. 1983. Particle Systems—A Technique for Modeling a Class of Fuzzy
Objects. ACM Transactions on Graphics, 2,2,91–108. Stam, J. and Fiume, E. 1995. Depiction of Fire and Other Gaseous Phenomena Using
Diffusion Processes. Proc. of SIGGRAPH '95, pp. 129–136. Stam, J. 1999. Stable Fluids. Proc. of SIGGRAPH 99, pp. 121–128. Steinhoff, J. and Underhill, D. 1994. Modification of the Euler Equations for "Vorticity
Confinement": Application to the Computation of Interacting Vortex Rings. Physics of Fluids, 6,8,2738–2744.
Wallace, J. and Hobbs, P. 1977. Atmospheric Science: An Introductory Survey.
Academic Press, New York, NY. Wallen, R. N. 1992. Introduction to Physical Geography. Wm. C. Brown Publishers,
Dubuque, IA. White, F. 1991. Viscous Fluid Flow. McGraw-Hill, New York , NY.
![Page 72: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
62
SUPPLEMENTAL SOURCES CONSULTED
Foley, J., van Dam, A., Feiner, S., Hughes, J., and Phillips, R. 1993. Introduction to Computer Graphics. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA.
Woo, M., Neider, J., Davis, T., and Shreiner, D. 1999. OpenGL Programming Guide,
Third Edition. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA.
![Page 73: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
63
APPENDIX A — ADDITIONAL IMAGES
Figure 40: Clouds generated and rendered using Dobashi method. Taken from early prototype
model.
Figure 41: Second view of clouds generated and rendered using Dobashi method.
![Page 74: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
64
APPENDIX B — SEQUENTIAL IMAGES
Figure 42: Humidity field being advected by buoyancy.
Figure 43: Heat field. Notice added heat where condensation occurs.
Figure 44: Resulting cloud field.
![Page 75: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
65
APPENDIX C — PSEUDOCODE
The basic steps of our simulation:
• Initialize grid space. Initialize each voxel's: o Velocity o Humidity o Heat o Condensation
• Simulation Loop:
o Source Step. Add external velocity forces based on: Wind Vorticity Confinement Buoyancy
o Simulation Step. Handles motion of fluid based on Stam's model [Stam 1999]
Transport Step -- Handle Periodic Boundaries Diffusion/Dissipation Step Momentum Conservation Step Expansion Step Projection Step
o Compute relative humidity o Condense water
Compute condensation Reduce humidity Add latent heat
![Page 76: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
66
APPENDIX D — ATMOSPHERIC TABLES
Figure 45: Chart of pressure vs. altitude in troposphere
Figure 46: Chart of air density vs. altitude in troposphere
![Page 77: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
67
APPENDIX E — USEFUL TERMS
Buoyancy — An upward force caused by differences in temperature and density of air. Dew Point — The temperature at which a rising air parcel reaches saturation and
condensation begins. Hygroscopic Nuclei — Tiny particles in the air upon which water can condense to form
clouds. Kinematic viscosity —The fluidic viscosity of the material over the density [White
1991]. Relative Humidity — The ratio of water vapor currently held by a constant volume of air
to the total amount of water vapor that volume could hold at maximum. Tropopause — The upper boundary of the tropopause. Troposphere — The lower 12 km of the atmosphere. Also known as the zone of
weather.
![Page 78: INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATIONresearch.cs.tamu.edu/keyser/Papers/Overby_Thesis_MS.pdf · 2005-01-07 · INTERACTIVE PHYSICALLY-BASED CLOUD SIMULATION A Thesis by DEREK](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040302/5e82f8f83ef84053501e47ec/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
68
VITA
Derek Robert Overby 111 West Ruelle
Mandeville, LA 70471
Derek Robert Overby was born in Metaire, Louisiana in May of 1978 to Dennis and
Yvette Overby. He attended Catholic school from kindergarten through high school,
when he attended Jesuit High School in New Orleans, Louisiana. After graduating
Summa Cum Laude from Jesuit and being named a National Merit Scholar in 1996,
Derek came to Texas A&M University as a recipient of the President’s Endowed
Scholarship, where he initially enrolled in the Mechanical Engineering program. After
transferring to the Computer Science department, Derek went on to graduate from Texas
A&M University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Computer Science in August
2000. Continuing on, Derek immediately entered the graduate program at A&M,
pursuing his Master’s degree in the field of Computer Science. After a summer
internship at the Naval Research Laboratory in Washington, D.C., Derek returned to
A&M to complete the degree of Master of Science in Computer Science in May of 2002.