Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity...
Transcript of Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity...
![Page 1: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Intensity Correlation Tricks
• Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopynot applicable for unsteady or evolving dynamics
• eg nearly-jammed matter
• Our extensions:Higher-order intensity correlationsSpeckle-Visibility Spectroscopy (SVS)
Adam Abate, Dr. Ranjini Bandyopadhyay,Prof. Paul Dixon, Alex Gitting, Dr. Hiroaki Katsuragi,
Pierre-Anthony Lemieux, Rajesh OjhaDouglas J. DURIAN
UCLA & University of Pennsylvania
![Page 2: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DLS/PCS Review• Conventional intensity-correlation spectroscopy
[1] Measure <I(0)I(τ)> for ~one speckle[2] Equate to <I>2 [ 1 + β|γ(τ)|2 ] {“Siegert relation”}[3] Deduce motion of scattering sites from E-field
autocorrelation, γ(τ) = F.T. of power spectrum
• Pitfalls– Unsteadiness (eg evolution, intermittency, periodicity,
temperature fluctuations, etc) will be misinterpreted as slow modes in scattering site dynamics
– NonGaussian electric field statistics (eg from number fluctuations or correlated motion) invalidate Siegert• these issues often arise in the most interesting systems:
– Phase separation, glassy behavior, and…
![Page 3: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Granular Matter• Grains, bubbles, colloids, cells, tectonic plates...
• No basis for usual intuitiondisordered / heterogeneous: no periodicity or symmetrykBT<<interaction energy: no statistical mechanicsflow beyond threshold: no linear response
hard problems = new physics!few engineering guidelines!hard problems = new physics!few engineering guidelines!
NagelBehringer Durian Goldhirsch
![Page 4: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Selected granular unsteadiness• Avalanches in sand• Rearrangements in foam• Heterogeneities near jamming• Aging near glass transition Durian
Abate-DurianVolfson-Tsimring
![Page 5: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Temporal intensity statistics• Normalized nth-order intensity correlations:
• I=EE* so this is really a (2n)th-order field correlation
• Experiment:– g(2)(τ) is routinely measured with a digital correlator– We have used a home-build digital delay device (T) and
a commercial correlator (τ) to measure:• g(3)(T,τ) = <I(0)I(T)I(τ)>/<I>3
• g(4)(T,τ,τ+T) = <I(0)I(T) I(τ)I(τ+T)>/<I>4
• Theory: analyze in terms of γ(τ)=<E(0)E*(τ)>/<EE*>• The Fourier transform of the power spectrum; if spectrum is
symmetric then γ(τ)=|γ(τ)|Exp[iωoτ], ωo=central frequency
![Page 6: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Ordinary systems• If there are many independent scattering sites:
E is complex Gaussian random variable• phasor diagram for total E at some point is a random walk• “speckle” pattern with spatial and temporal correlation lengths
g(n)(τ1,τ2,…) can be computed in terms of γ(τ):• sum of products of all possible two-time field correlations• spatially average over detector area
– For example <I(0)I(t)> is <E0E0*E1E1*>= <E0E0*><E1E1*> + <E0E1><E0*E1*> + <E0E1*><E1E0*>
= <I>2 + 0 + <I>2 γ(τ)γ(τ)*
which, after averaging over 1/β speckles, is <I>2 [ 1 + β|γ(τ)|2 ]
![Page 7: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Correlations for Gaussian fieldsLemieux and DJD, JOSA-A (1999)
• Subscripts denote time delay differences• Expressions for n={3,4} are not in previous literature
![Page 8: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Verify health of data• Generate g(n)(τ1,τ2,…) predictions from g(2)(τ) data:
• agreement means Gaussian field statistics and hence that field autocorrelation may be extracted from g(2)(τ) using Siegert
• this check ought to be routinely performed!
![Page 9: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Failure of Gaussian predictions• Nature of discrepancy indicates the problem:
• eg number fluctuations, correlations in dynamics, source drift, source incoherence, static/heterodyning component,…
• Extra information is available in higher orders• eg intermittent flow of sand:
(stationary unsteadiness)
![Page 10: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Intermittent granular avalanchesLemieux and DJD, PRL (1999) and Appl.Opt. (2001)
• Deduce on/off times and switching prob functs
![Page 11: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Intermittent bubble rearrangementsGittings and DJD (preprint)
• Deduce event frequency and rearrangement size
![Page 12: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Time-resolved DLS• If unsteadiness in dynamics is not stationary,
then a good way to capture the physics is<I(to)I(to+τ)> vs τ power spectrum at age to
• sequence of start-times to
• <…> is ensemble average of many speckles by use of area detector like CCD camera
Wiltzius; Sillescu; Sutton; Mochrie; Weitz; Pine-Lequeux; Cipelletti
Low frame rates; extensive storage and post-processing; short evolution
• We propose an alternative…
![Page 13: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Speckle-visibility spectroscopy– match speckle size to pixel size– measure the speckle pattern’s visibility by variance of detected
intensity levels for a single exposure of duration T:• speckle is less visible for faster dynamics and vice-versa
– Just ONE exposure gives information on microscopic motion– OK if motion varies from exposure to exposure– Remove β by computing variance ratio V2(2T)/V2(T)
• This opens up a world of new experiments…
Dixon & DJD, PRL (2003); Bandyopadhyay, Gittings, Suh, Dixon & DJD, RSI (2006)
[ ] ( )
⎩⎨⎧
→
−=−≡ ∫
dynamicsfast / exposure long0dynamics slow / exposureshort 1
/d)(/12 1)(0
21
222 TttgTtIITV
T
Tβ
![Page 14: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Eg: sand shaken at 10 HzSource:
NdYAG laser535 nm1 W
Camera:Linescan CCD1024 pixels8 bits58 kHz
(Dixon & DJD, PRL 2003)
![Page 15: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Analysis of visibility data• Deduce grain fluctuation speed, δv, vs phase in
cycle and for different shaking amplitudes:[m δv2 / 2 is granular temperature]
0
60 kHz
γ c~δ
v/λ
1.00
1.75
1.251.50
ao/g
1.00
0.00phase0.50
0.750.25
10 kHz
20 kHz
30 kHz
40 kHz
50 kHz
![Page 16: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Eg: SVS for granular avalanches• Flow down a heap Abate, Katsuragi, & DJD, PRE (2007)
![Page 17: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Deduce avalanche statistics• On/off durations:
• Speeds vs time:
![Page 18: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
SVS on Foam• Illuminate / detect through 1 mm aperture
Laser
CCD
![Page 19: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
A typical rearrangement event• Raw image data:
• Variances vs time:
• Linewidths:Γ=4πv/λv=bubble speed IF allbubbles are in motion
T = 10 msT = 20 msT = 40 msT = 80 ms
0
2
4
6
8
10
39 40 41 42 43 44
Γ (H
z)
t - to (s)
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
V2(2
T)/V
2(T)
Pix
el N
o.
0
50
100
![Page 20: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Events Times
• Between events:
• Event durations:
![Page 21: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
ConclusionHIGHER-ORDER INTENSITY CORRELATIONS:
– Assess health of data for ordinary systems• ought to be routine feature in commercial correlators:
<I(0)I(t)> <I(0)I(t)I(2t)> <I(0)I(t)I(2t)I(3t)>
– Deduce experimental artifacts– Characterize stationary unsteadiness
SPECKLE-VISIBILITY SPECTROSOPY:– A time-resolved dynamic light scattering method– Application to problems of current interest– Advantages over <I(to)I(to+τ)>:
• Short times• Long runs• No storage issues• No post-processing
![Page 22: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
Granular physics at Penn• Five faculty: DJD, Gollub, Kamien, Liu, Lubensky• DJD & group:
“sand”, foam, microfluidics; novel optical spectroscopies
TODAY’S TALK:Adam Abate, Ranjini Bandyopadhyay, Paul Dixon, Alex Gittings, Hiroaki Katsuragi, Pierre-Anthony Lemieux, Rajesh Ojha
![Page 23: Intensity Correlation Tricks - Brookhaven National Laboratory · DURIAN DURIAN DURIAN Intensity Correlation Tricks • Good-old photon-correlation spectroscopy ... Lemieux and DJD,](https://reader031.fdocuments.in/reader031/viewer/2022021811/5cab371888c993e6068ce794/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
DU
RIAN
THE END• Thank you for your interest.