Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
-
Upload
brownbag80 -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
1/28
321055
Thermal Design
Considerations for
Embedded
ApplicationsDecember 2008
White Paper
Chris Gonzales andHwan Ming Wang
Thermal/MechanicalEngineers
Intel Corporation
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
2/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
2 321055
Executive SummaryEmbedded Applications differ from the typical desktop, server and mobile
markets. Some of the different requirements for embedded applications
include higher ambient temperatures, need for higher max component
temperature spec, low platform power, long life support, small form
factors, and extended usage conditions (24 x 7 x 365 operation). Due to
these differences there are special considerations for component and
system level thermal solution design.
Thermal solution design requires an engineer to fully understand the
system and various form factor boundary conditions and component level
attributes. This document will define thermal cooling schemes: passive,
active and fanless thermal solutions and their difference via the three
modes of heat transfer (conduction, convection, and radiation). The
thermal performance metrology will be explained, using a thermal
resistance calculation and how to apply to Intel components. The
methodology will highlight typical Intel component specifications such as
TJ-MAX, TCASE-MAX, TAMBIENT and Thermal Design Power (TDP). In addition
some thermal features such as the Digital Thermal Sensor (DTS) and
Thermal Monitor will be explained.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
3/28
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
4/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
4 321055
Introduction
Computing platform component power has decreased as a result of silicontechnology improvement. However, it is still critical to cool the components to
adequately ensure a products long-life reliability.
In embedded applications, there are challenges which are more demanding
than the general computing systems such as desktops, notebooks, andworkstations/servers. The major differences are the target usage model andoperating environment. Typically, embedded applications are in harsh
environments, such as outdoors, factory assembly lines, and telecomm basestations. Conversely, the usual desktop, mobile, and workstation/ server aretypically deployed in homes, offices, and data centers where there are
controlled environmental conditions.
Intel provides a wide variety of embedded processors and chipsets that havefeatures and specifications that are suited for embedded markets. These
components typically have high maximum temperatures limits, long lifeavailability and features such as Digital Thermal Sensor and Enhanced IntelSpeedStep Technology. All of these features will aid the embedded thermalengineer in designing robust thermal solutions for Intel Architecture.
Cooling Methods and Component
Specifications
There are three basic types of thermal solutions for electronics cooling:passive thermal solutions, active thermal solutions and fanless thermal
solutions. The type of cooling solution used in an embedded system will varydepending on the form factor, component specifications, and boundaryconditions. All thermal solutions rely on the three modes of heat transfer to
dissipate the heat from the component: conduction, convection and radiation.
The following sections will explain the different cooling methods as well asIntels component specifications.
Three Modes of Heat Transfer
Conduction
Thermal conduction is the process in which thermal energy transfers through
matter, from a region of higher temperature to lower temperature and acts toequalize the temperature difference. It can also be described as the heatenergy transferred from one material to another by direct contact.
Fouriers Law of Conduction states that the rate of heat flow equals theproduct of the area normal to the heat flow path, the temperature gradient
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
5/28
321055 5
along the path and the thermal conductivity of the medium. Heat flux, q is
the rate of heat transfer per unit area and it depends on the direction.
Consider a one dimensional block with one side at a constant T1 and the
other side at a constant T2, where T1 > T2.
Figure 1. One Dimensional Heat Conduction
The total heat flow in the x-direction is expressed by the following equation:
Where:
k - is the conductive heat transfer coefficient
A area of surface contact
L length
Rearranging this same equation you get:
Where conduction thermal resistance is:
In regards to cooling electronic components this equation can be used toexpress a conductive thermal resistance. Thermal resistance (Theta) is a
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
6/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
6 321055
method used to represent thermal systems. Thermal resistance is analogous
to electrical resistance.
Figure 2. Thermal Resistance and Electrical Resistance
The thermal resistance calculation will be used when determining thenecessary thermal performance for a keeping a component within its
temperature specification. Conduction is the main mode of heat transferthrough the package and how the heat is transferred out of the package to
the attached thermal solution and the printed circuit board. Typical
designation given for thermal resistance from package junction to ambient islabeled Theta-JA whereas from package junction to board (PCB) is labeled
Theta-JB.
Figure 3. Thermal Resistance of Package to Its Surroundings
Tambient
T unction
Tboard
Theta-JA
Theta-JB
Si die
Substrate
Board
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
7/28
321055 7
Convection
Convection is the transfer of thermal energy between two surfaces as a
consequence of a relative velocity between them. The most practical
application is where one surface is a solid and the other is a fluid.
Figure 4. Convection
Newtons law of convection cooling can be written as
)(
= TThAq SS Where:
h Convective heat transfer coefficient
AS Surface Area
TS Surface Temperature
T- Fluid Temperature
In this equation the complexity lies in the determination of the distribution ofthe convective heat transfer coefficient, h. The heat transfer coefficient willdepend on the boundary layer conditions, surface geometry and nature of the
fluid motion. These parameters can be modeled using CFD (ComputationalFluid Dynamics) software to optimize thermal solution design and determinethe amount of convective heat transfer.
Convective heat transfer can also be expressed as a thermal resistance asshown in Figure 5.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
8/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
8 321055
Figure 5. Convective Thermal Resistance
On a basic level, the convective heat transfer can be improved with higherairflow and more surface area. However, it is not always possible to make
the thermal solution larger or increase the airflow, due the constraints ofembedded form factors. Therefore, the thermal solution designer must factorin all the boundary conditions in order to develop a suitable solution.
Convective heat transfer plays a very important role in electronics cooling.This mode of heat transfer (airflow over heatsink) will allow higher powerprocessors to be cooled in most applications.
Radiation
Radiation cooling is the transfer of heat by electromagnetic emission,primarily in the infrared wavelengths. While the transfer of energy byconduction and convection requires the presence of a material medium,
radiation does not. In fact, radiation transfer occurs most effectively in avacuum. Figure 6 graphically represents the radiation heat transfer betweentwo surfaces at different temperatures.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
9/28
321055 9
Figure 6. Radiation
The calculation for radiation emitted from an object can be expressed by the
following equation:
4" STq = Where:
- Emissivity of the object ranges from 0 to 1
- Stefan-Boltzmann constant
TS Surface temperature (absolute temperature)
For the majority of embedded applications, radiation will result in a very smallpercentage of the total heat transfer. The only applications where it will have
significant impact are in fanless designs.
Active Thermal Solutions
An active thermal solution is a heatsink that incorporates a fan attacheddirectly to it. This is the most common type of thermal solution for desktopcomputers. In general embedded applications do not use this type of thermal
solution. These solutions usually require more height above the motherboardthan embedded form factors can provide.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
10/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
10 321055
Figure 7. Active Fan Heatsink
Active solutions typically have very good thermal performance due to the
large volume of the heatsink and the directly attached fan which provides asignificant amount of airflow when compared to other types of thermalsolutions. Active solutions rely on the heat to be conducted from the package
into the heatsink and then removed by the forced air flow flowing in betweenthe heatsink fins. Since the fan is directly attached to the heatsink, the
velocity is usually high and thus results in an overall thermal solution withlow thermal resistance.
Passive Thermal Solution
Passive thermal solutions are the most common type of thermal solution for
embedded applications. This type of thermal solution employs a solid metalheatsink attached to the heat dissipating component and then with system
airflow the heat is removed. Since the airflow is provided by system fan(s),the velocity tends to be much lower than that of an active heatsink, resultingin a lower convection heat transfer coefficient. There could be obstacles, like
motherboard components, that are placed between the system fan and thepassive heatsink, which creates a resistance to the forced air flow from
system fan. In turn, this usually requires a larger heatsink to achieve thesame performance, since the thermal solution must rely on more conductiveheat transfer. The advantage of passive thermal solutions is that they can be
used in form factors where the z-height above the motherboard is limited. Insome usage models, the fans are grouped into an easily removable trayfastened to the system chassis air inlet, which allows for swapping of
defective fan(s) from the system chassis. Below is an example of a passiveheatsink:
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
11/28
321055 11
Figure 8. Passive Heatsinks
Fanless Thermal Solution
A fanless thermal solution refers to a solution that does not use a fan (systemor component level) to provide airflow. The only airflow is induced by the
buoyancy effect where hot air moves opposite the direction of gravity and
cool air moves towards the direction of gravity. This air movement is createdby the difference in air density and the resulting velocity is very low.
There are two basic types of fanless solutions:
Conduction Cooled Natural Convection System. This solution isusually referred to a thermal solution in which the heat dissipatingcomponents are attached to the system chassis (via direct contact
or heat pipe); therefore, the chassis acts as a big heatsink. All heatfrom various heat sources will have to be channeled out viaconduction to the chassis. The heat is conducted from the
components to the chassis and then out to the surroundingenvironment via natural convection and radiation. This type of
cooling scheme is very common in In-vehicle infotainment systemsand many military type applications.
The second type of fanless solution would be a standard naturalconvection heatsink mounted to a heat generating component. Anatural convection system chassis will typically have ventilation
slots or a grille to allow for minimal air flow to enter and exit thechassis. This prevents the internal temperature of the chassis
Passive Heatsink
Passive Heatsink on amini-ITX motherboard
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
12/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
12 321055
from becoming too high. This solution looks just like a typical fin
heatsink and it relies on natural convection to remove the majorityof the heat to its surroundings, although radiation can positively
impact the performance.
All fanless thermal solutions will be somewhat limited on the amount of heatthat can dissipate. There are many factors that impact the amount of power
that can be dissipated (e.g. max component temperature or ambienttemperature) but a good rule of thumb is to target components that are 10 Wor less.
Design Considerations for a Fanless Solution:
Below are some general recommendations and considerations for a fanlessdesign. The best way to optimize the thermal solution design is through CFDmodeling. Intel provides component level package models that a system
designer can use to develop a robust thermal solution. Through modeling,
the system designer can try many different approaches to solving the thermalchallenge, reduce prototype cost and decrease time to market.
Heat Distribution. Optimizing the heat distribution from the heat source(s)by using multiple heatpipes as a fast heat conduction path to larger area of
system chassis is a good method to improve thermal solution design. Pleaserefer to Figure 9 for illustration of channeling heat from sources tosurrounding environment in a conduction cool system solution.
Figure 9. Heat Transfer Path & Distribution
Heatsink Design. Fin pitch, height, and thickness for natural convectionthermal solution will be different from typical forced convection heatsink fins.
The fin-to-fin spacing should be optimized (larger fin pitch) for the amount ofair flow that is induced by natural convection. Fin height can limit the
Conduction
Convection & Radiation
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
13/28
321055 13
radiation of the heat from one surface to the surrounding. The fins on a
fanless solution are typically much thicker than forced convection fins thusallowing more conductive heat transfer from the chassis/heatsink base.
System Orientation. The orientation and mounting of a fanless system willplay a critical part in the heat dissipation effectiveness. Having multiple setsof fin orientations will allow the chassis more flexibility in the orientation in
which the chassis is mounted. The thermal solution will perform better whenthe fins are oriented parallel to the direction of gravity, so ideally it should bemounted in a vertical position to achieve maximum convective heat transfer.
Refer to Figure 10 for a better illustration.
Figure 10. System and Fin Orientation
Surface Emissivity. The amount of heat transferred through radiation from
the outer surface of chassis will be affected by the surface emissivitycharacteristics. The heat transfer via radiation is improved by surfaces withhigher emissivity. A surface's emissivity can be improved by painting the
surface a dark color, with black being the optimum color.
Hot Spot Determination. Through simulations, locating the hot spot(s) isfairly simple and the thermal solution can be optimized to eliminate hot spots.
For example, the heat is localized at one area on the conduction cooledchassis as shown in Figure 11. The fins on the cooler area can be re-assessedif they are necessary on system level cooling. If not then they could be
removed and thus eliminate weight and unnecessary cost.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
14/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
14 321055
Figure 11. Hot Spot Identification
Exotic thermal solutionsThere are a number of other cooling technologies that can be used to remove
the heat from component, these include:
Heat pipes. A heat pipe is a device with highly effective heattransfer from one end of the pipe (hot side) to the opposite side(cold side). For a heat pipe to function properly, a temperature
differential must exist between the hot and cold sides. A heat pipewill be attached to a heat source on one end (evaporator) and aheat exchanger (condenser) on the opposite side. The way that it
operates is the fluid inside a heat pipe will evaporate (by absorbingthe heat from its surroundings) and then flow to the cool side. At
the cool side, the vapor will condense and turn back into fluid. The
fluid will then flow back to the hot side via the wick structure (incapillary action) at the inner wall of the heat pipes. This cycle will
continue to occur as long as the temperature differential exists.Heat pipes are generally used to transfer the heat fromvolumetrically constrained area to larger area where there is more
volume for the heat exchanger. See an example of heat pipe in anactive heatsink in Figure 12. In this case the heat pipes aid in the
removal of heat from the heatsink base and transport the heat tothe fin array where the heat is dissipated by the fins and active
fan.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
15/28
321055 15
Figure 12. Active Heatsink with Heat Pipes
Vapor Chamber. A vapor chamber is very similar in function to aheat pipe. The vapor chamber is manufactured within the heatsinkbase. This in effect creates a heatsink base that is similar to aheat pipe and the vapor chamber increases the heat spreading
within the base. The hot side (component side) of the base will bethe evaporator where heat transforms the liquid in the base into avapor. The heat then moves towards the cooler side (heatsink fins
side). At the cooler side, the heat dissipation through the fins willcondense the vapor back into fluid. The fluid will then return tothe hot side and starts the cycle again. A vapor chamber base will
usually result in higher effective conductivity for the heatsink basewhen compared to copper, but manufacturing costs will increaseand is only effective in high power dissipating applications.
Liquid Cooling. Liquid cooling is very similar to a car radiator in aclosed loop system. A cold plate is attached to the heat generatingcomponent. Through conduction heat is transferred through the
cold plate to the fluid inside. The fluid, usually a water and glycolmixture, is pumped through tubing to a heat exchanger (radiator).The radiator is typically located on the system chassis wall and a
large fan will be attached to the radiator. The heat will be removedfrom the fluid and to the environment via the radiator fins andforced air flow from the fan. The cooled fluid will then flow back
towards the cold plate and continue the cycle. Liquid cooling hasthe advantage of high heat transfer efficiency and can besignificantly quieter that standard thermal solution. However,
additional space for the cooling solution and cost are the majordrawback. Most embedded applications cannot take advantage ofliquid cooling due to the required amount of volume needed for the
total solution.Figure 13 shows a diagram of a liquid cooling
solution.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
16/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
16 321055
Figure 13. Single Phase Liquid Cooling Diagram
TECs (Thermo Electric Coolers). A TEC is a solid state heatpump based on Peltier Effect that moves heat from one end to theother due to an external energy (electrical energy). It is useful inelectronic cooling as well as heating. The polarity of the electrical
current supply will determine which side of the TEC will be hot andwhich will be cold. Depending on the application a computer
system could take advantage of both the hot and the cold. Thedownside of this cooling method is high cost, low efficiency, and it
requires external energy to move heat which in turn increases theoverall power of the system.
In most cases the cost of implementing these solutions will not improve thethermal solution enough to warrant the increase in cost over the typical
thermal solution, except for heat pipes which have become much morereasonable to cost effectively manufacture in the last couple of years.
Intels Component Thermal Specifications
The thermal specifications for Intels components are described below. Theseterms will be used to determine thermal budgeting for thermal solution
design and help determine if a component can be used in an application.
TJUNCTION-MAX Maximum temperature that the die is allowed toreach and still function reliably for the lifetime of the product. Thisis the typical thermal specification for bare die CPUs. It ismeasured at the hottest point within the die. System designers
can monitor the PROCHOT# signal to determine when the max TJhas been reached.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
17/28
321055 17
TCASE-MAX Maximum temperature specification for components withan Integrated Heat Spreader (IHS) on top of the die. It is located
at the geometric center of the IHS. TCASE-MAX requirement alsoapplies to bare die FCBGA type MCH and PBGA type ICH products.
For server class products the thermal specification is called the
Thermal Profile. The Thermal Profile relates the TCASE-MAX value tothe power being dissipated. Refer to the processor datasheet formore information.
Thermal Design Power (TDP) TDP is the realistic-worst casepower dissipation for thermal solution design. TDP is NOTmaximum power nor is it the amount of power that a customersapplication will dissipate in normal operation.
The basic equation for TDP is:
[ ]SiccDiccVccTDP +=
Where:
Vcc - Voltage
Dicc Dynamic Current
Sicc Leakage Current
The dynamic current is determined by testing a wide variety of applicationsand benchmarks. The worst case realistic application will be chosen for thedynamic portion of TDP. The dynamic current will be consistent from part-to-
part of the same CPU (e.g. Intel EP80579 Integrated Processor at 600 MHz).One thing to note is that the dynamic current can vary greatly fromapplication to application. A customers application may not be able to
generate the same amount of power as the TDP application. It is highlyunlikely that an application will be more stressful and cause a part to exceedTDP, but the Intel Thermal Monitor feature is available to control the
processor temperature in the event that TDP is exceeded.
The static or leakage current portion of the TDP is determined by process
technology, temperature, and voltage. The leakage current will be differentfrom part-to-part, so for a given CPU, the power can vary. In order to getthe maximum amount of leakage current, components are tested at their
maximum temperature to ensure that the leakage current is at its highestpossible limit.
Processor Thermal Features
There are a number of features available on Intel processors that aid inprotecting the parts from thermal damage and also provide feedback to theuser on temperature status.
To ease the burden on thermal solutions, the Thermal Monitor feature and
associated logic have been integrated into the silicon of the processor. Onefeature of the Thermal Monitor is the Thermal Control Circuit (TCC). Whenactive, the TCC lowers the processor temperature by reducing power
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
18/28
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
19/28
321055 19
The case-to-local ambient thermal characterization parameter (CA) is used
as a measure of the thermal performance of the overall thermal solution. It isdefined by the following equation, and measured in units of C/W:
Equation 1. Case-to-Ambient Thermal Characterization Parameter (CA)
Power
TT AMBIENTCASECA
=
The case-to-local ambient thermal characterization parameter, CA, is
comprised ofCS, the thermal interface material thermal characterization
parameter, and ofSA, the sink-to-local ambient thermal characterization
parameter:
Equation 2. Case-to-Local Ambient Thermal Characterization Paramter Components
SACSCA
+=
CS is strongly dependent on the thermal conductivity and thickness of the
TIM between the heat sink and device package.
SA is a measure of the thermal characterization parameter from the bottom
of the heat sink to the local ambient air. SA is dependent on the heat sink
material, thermal conductivity, and geometry. It is also strongly dependenton the air velocity through the fins of the heat sink. Figure 14 illustrates thecombination of the different thermal characterization parameters.
Figure 14. Thermal Characterization Parameter
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
20/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
20 321055
Example: Calculating the Required Thermal Performance
The cooling performance, CA, is defined using the thermal characterizationparameter previously described. The process to determine the required
thermal performance to cool the device includes: Define a target component temperature TCASE-MAX and
corresponding TDP.
Define a target local ambient temperature, TLA. Use Equation 1 and Equation 2 to determine the required thermal
performance needed to cool the device.
The following provides an illustration of how one might determine theappropriate performance targets.
Note: The following example is just an illustration of how to calculate the thermal resistance.The TDP and TCASE-MAX used in the example may not be the actual specifications of the
device. See the component datasheet for actual power and temperaturespecifications.
Assume:
TDP = 13.0 W & TCASE-MAX = 100 C Local processor ambient temperature, TLA = 55C.
Then the following could be calculated using Equation 1 for the givenprocessor frequency:
WCTDP
TT AMBIENTMAXCASECA /46.3
13
55100=
=
=
To determine the required heat sink performance, a heat sink solutionprovider would need to determine CS performance for the selected TIM and
mechanical load configuration. If the heat sink solution were designed to
work with a TIM material performing at CS 0.1 C/W, solving fromEquation 2, the performance needed from the heat sink is:
WCCSCASA /36.31.046.3 ===
If the local ambient temperature is relaxed to 40C, the same calculation canbe carried out to determine the new case-to-ambient thermal resistance:
WCTDP
TTAMBIENTMAXCASE
CA /62.413
40100=
=
=
It is evident from the above calculations that a reduction in the local ambienttemperature has a significant effect on the case-to-ambient thermalresistance requirement. This effect can contribute to a more reasonable
thermal solution including reduced cost, heat sink size, heat sink weight, anda lower system airflow rate.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
21/28
321055 21
More detailed information and reference thermal solutions can be viewed in
product specific thermal design guides located atwww.intel.com/embedded/edc.
Below is a list of typical form factors and the approximate thermalcharacterization parameters and TDP ranges that are achievable. This is justa basic guidance, the actual performance can change based on package
characteristics, and system boundary conditions. Each individual designshould be evaluated on a case by case basis. Take note that the typicalDesktop (ATX) and server (1U and 2U) form factors have much lower
resistance than the embedded form factors (ATCA, CPCI, and AMC).
Figure 15. Approximate Thermal Solution Performance by Form Factor
Cooling Challenges for Embedded
Applications
Thermal management for embedded applications can be more challenging
when compared with traditional markets like server, desktop and mobilecomputing. Some critical parameters to consider for designing embeddedcooling solutions will be discussed in the following sections.
Ambient Temperature
The target ambient temperature for thermal solution design plays a very
important part in the ability to develop an adequate solution. This was shownin the previous section on how to calculate the thermal characterizationparameter. Embedded applications will typically operate in higher than 45C
ambient temperature depending on the target market segment. Whereas
http://www.intel.com/embedded/edchttp://www.intel.com/embedded/edc -
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
22/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
22 321055
solutions in traditional PCs rarely go beyond 45C, and usually are meant for
operating at below 38C (normal operating temperature for home or office).Some of these higher temperature requirements for embedded applications
are:
+55C for telecommunications equipment. This is requirement forNEBS level 3 qualifications.
+70C for in-vehicle infotainment and other commercialapplications
-40C to +85C for some industrial, military or aerospaceapplications in extended temperature range.
These high ambient temperatures affect the design of cooling solutions forembedded applications. The higher the ambient goes, the lower the
resistance of the thermal solution needs to be in order to meet the maximumcomponents temperature spec. In some cases if the ambient is too high thendesigning a viable solution will not be possible. Thermal solution designers
should understand their target ambient temperature requirements and if atall possible, try to reduce it.
Form Factor and Available Volume for Thermal Solution
The available volumetric solution space for many embedded applications isvery dependant on target application. It is usually smaller and more
constrained than the solution space of typical PC markets. There are multiplereasons for the difference in solution space; some are governed by industrialstandards and some are proprietary form factors that are unique and provide
a niche for certain customers. The following table shows the dimensions ofvarious form factors and the available height for thermal solution. Note that
the embedded form factors are smaller and therefore, the available volumefor a thermal solution is less. Based on lessons from earlier sections in thisdocument it should be noted that a larger heatsink will usually result in abetter performing thermal solution. Table 1 should provide a clearer pictureof space constraints for thermal solutions in embedded applications.
Table 1. Form Factor and Solution Space Height
Form Factor Dimension X, Y, and Z (mm) General Max. SolutionSpace Height1 (mm)
3.5 SBC or ECX 146 x 105 x z2
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
23/28
321055 23
uATX 244 x 244 x z3
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
24/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
24 321055
The thermal specification for Intel Xeon products is the thermal profile.
The thermal profile relates TCASE specification to the power dissipation. Thisspecification is required to ensure product long term reliability. The thermalprofile for embedded specific processors is different from server product
thermal profile. This is to allow for higher ambient temperatures required byembedded markets.
Figure 16 shows two thermal profiles, Profile A and B, that are meant for 1Userver and 2U standard server products. The standard server will only allowambient temperature of up to 43.5 C and a TCASE of 70C. Whereas, Figure
17 shows the thermal profile for an embedded processor that is targeted fordemanding telecommunication applications. The embedded specific processorhas low power, higher allowable Tcase and is divided into nominal and short
term operating conditions. The nominal operating condition will allow aTAMBIENT of up to 45C and the short term operation condition will allow aTAMBIENT of up to 60C. This thermal profile will allow this processor to meetthe NEBS requirement of short-term excursions to higher ambient operating
temperatures, not to exceed 96 hours per instance, 360 hours per year, anda maximum of 15 instances per year. By tailoring server class processors
with embedded friendly thermal specifications, Intel allows system architectsthe advantage of implementing the latest and greatest processors in theirembedded applications.
Figure 16. Thermal Profile of the Quad-Core Intel Xeon Processor X5400 Series
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
25/28
321055 25
Figure 17. Thermal Profile of the Quad-Core Intel Xeon Processor L5408
Extended Usage
The typical usage conditions for embedded computers are different when
compared to a typical PC. In some applications embedded computers will runcontinuously at maximum or very high bandwidth. For the PC environment,the usage is heavily dependant on the PC users, but the system will typically
spend a good amount of time in an idle state or turned off.
Thermal engineers designing for embedded applications will need to consider
the extended usage of the parts at high workloads. When a component
needs to be run in these types of conditions the reliability can be affected. Insome cases it might require a better performing thermal solution so that the
average temperature of the part will be lower. The extended usageconditions can also impact fan selection. Designers will have to choosehigher reliability fans which usually come at a premium price.
Long Life Support
Embedded applications are typically targeted for more than five years ofoperating life and in certain market segments they will require 10 years or
longer of operating life. The embedded components (CPU and chipsets) areavailable for sale for seven years from product launch date. Therefore, the
long term reliability of the thermal solution will have to be considered andincorporated in the design. For example, the thermal interface material (TIM)that sits in between the heatsink base and package must be able to meet the
thermal performance throughout the useful life of five to seven years fortypical embedded usage. Thermal engineers will need to evaluate the thermalperformance of the heatsink at the end of life time based not only on TIM
degradation but the potential for the fastening mechanism (springs, clips,etc.) relaxing over time and not providing enough force on the package.
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
26/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
26 321055
Conclusion
Thermal solution design requires a thermal engineer to fully understand thethree modes of heat transfer and how to apply them in their designs.Additionally, embedded markets have more challenges when compared to
typical computing markets (server, desktop and mobile computing).Embedded applications have much stiffer constraints such as, higheroperation ambient temperature, smaller form factors, and continuous
operation. The thermal solution design must take into account the componentspecifications (TCASE-MAX, TJ-MAX, and TDP) and develop a solution that will meetthe system boundary conditions and thermal targets.
Intels Embedded and Communications group provides processors andchipsets that are targeted for these markets and enable system designers tosuccessfully design a thermal solution that will meet both the components
and their systems requirements. For official product specifications, detailedthermal design guides, and embedded reference thermal solutions, visitwww.intel.com/embedded/edc.
http://www.intel.com/embedded/edchttp://www.intel.com/embedded/edc -
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
27/28
321055 27
Authors
Hwan Ming Wang is a Sr. Thermal/Mechanical Engineer with
Embedded and Communications Group at Intel Corporation.Chris Gonzales is a Sr. Thermal/Mechanical Engineer with
Embedded and Communications Group at Intel Corporation.
Acronyms
SBC Single Board ComputerNEBS Network Equipment Building SpecificationTDP Thermal Design Power
ECX Embedded Compact extended form factorEPIC Embedded Platform for Industrial ComputingEBX Embedded Board expandableATCA Advanced Telecommunications Computing Architecture
DTS Digital Thermal SensorTDP Thermal Design Power
-
7/27/2019 Intel - Thermal Design for Embedded Apps
28/28
Thermal Design Considerations for Embedded Applications
28 321055
INFORMATION IN THIS DOCUMENT IS PROVIDED IN CONNECTION WITH INTEL PRODUCTS.NO LICENSE, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, BY ESTOPPEL OR OTHERWISE, TO ANY INTELLECTUALPROPERTY RIGHTS IS GRANTED BY THIS DOCUMENT. EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN INTELS TERMSAND CONDITIONS OF SALE FOR SUCH PRODUCTS, INTEL ASSUMES NO LIABILITY WHATSOEVER,AND INTEL DISCLAIMS ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTY, RELATING TO SALE AND/OR USE
OF INTEL PRODUCTS INCLUDING LIABILITY OR WARRANTIES RELATING TO FITNESS FOR APARTICULAR PURPOSE, MERCHANTABILITY, OR INFRINGEMENT OF ANY PATENT, COPYRIGHT OROTHER INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHT. Intel products are not intended for use in medical, lifesaving, or life sustaining applications.
Intel may make changes to specifications and product descriptions at any time, without notice.
This paper is for informational purposes only. THIS DOCUMENT IS PROVIDED "AS IS" WITH NO
WARRANTIES WHATSOEVER, INCLUDING ANY WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY,
NONINFRINGEMENT, FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OR ANY WARRANTY OTHERWISE
ARISING OUT OF ANY PROPOSAL, SPECIFICATION OR SAMPLE. Intel disclaims all liability, including
liability for infringement of any proprietary rights, relating to use of information in this specification.
No license, express or implied, by estoppel or otherwise, to any intellectual property rights is granted
herein.
Intel, the Intel logo, Intel. leap ahead. and Intel. Leap ahead. logo, Enhanced Intel SpeedStep
Technology, Intel EP805799 Integrated Processor, Intel Core 2 Duo, Quad-Core IntelXeon Processor
L5408, Intel Xeon, and Quad-Core IntelXeon Processor 5400 series are trademarks or registered
trademarks of Intel Corporation or its subsidiaries in the United States and other countries.
*Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others.
Copyright 2008 Intel Corporation. All rights reserved.