INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering...

36
INSTRUMENTS for for X-ray crystallography and solution scattering experiments solution scattering experiments EMBL Grenoble outstation Instrumentation Group Instrumentation Group Diffraction Instrumentation Team, Florent Cipriani

Transcript of INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering...

Page 1: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

INSTRUMENTS forfor

X-ray crystallographyand

solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments

EMBL Grenoble outstationInstrumentation GroupInstrumentation Group

Diffraction Instrumentation Team, Florent Cipriani

Page 2: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

EMBL Basic research in Molecular Biology

Study the STRUCTURE of biological macromoleculesy gNature and position of the ATOMS

Understand the function of the macromoleculesUnderstand the mechanisms of life

Understand diseasesDesign drugs

TOOLS X-rays and Neutrons scattering

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 2

Page 3: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

EMBLGrenoble

Beamlines6 x MX1 x BioSAXS

ESRFX-Rays

ILL

Diffraction Instrumentation Team

ILLNeutrons

Diffraction Instrumentation TeamMission: Develop Instruments and Methods for diffraction experiments

The TEAMFranck Felisaz

Jerome HalbwachsRaphael Moya

Alexandre GobboAlexandre GobboGergely PAPP

Julien HuetChristophe Landret

Silvia Russi

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 3

Florent Cipriani

Page 4: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Structure determinationTwo X-ray diffraction techniques

■ Atomic resolution (0.8 Å -50 nm)■ Crystallised form

1 – Macromolecular crystallography

■ Crystallised form■ Size of macromolecules is limited

2 – Small angle scattering (SAXS)

■ Sample in solution■ Large macromolecules, assemblies (complexes)■ Kinetics■ Resolution is limited to 10 Å (Up to 500 nm)■ Resolution is limited to 10 Å (Up to 500 nm)

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 4

Page 5: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Typical InstrumentsCrystal Centring

SC3

◄ Crystallography

▼ Small Angle X-ray Scattering

SC3Sample Changer

MD2MD2Diffractometer

ESRF BM14

MAATEL

BioSAXSSample changer

● 25 beamlines equipped in Europe, US, Canada,Australia, Asia

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 5

ESRF ID14-4

Page 6: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Diffraction Instrumentation TEAMOur expertise: System engineering

Precision mechanics Optics

Cryogenics

p y g g

y g

Analog/digital ElectronicsM i lMotion control

Software

Instrument controlImage computing

Automatic crystal detection & alignment

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 6

Automatic crystal detection & alignmentBernard Lavault

Page 7: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Instruments for Macromolecular Crystallography

Crystal Centring

SC3Sample Changer

MD2Diffractometer

ESRF BM14ESRF BM14

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 7

Page 8: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Macromolecular X-ray crystallography Remindersin θ = nλ / 2dBragg's reflectionsBragg s reflections

in a crystal lattice

X-ray beam

θd

yθλ (typically 1Å)

Diffraction image Electron density Structuremap

First crystallize the macromolecules ... 96 wellsProtein 96 wellsplate

Drop dispenser

+ Crystallization farm

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 8

crystallization solutions

Page 9: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

X-ray crystallography data collection ReminderTypical Experimental setup Crystals mounted in a “cryo-loop”Typical Experimental setup

X-ray Diffractometer

Crystals mounted in a cryo loop

15 μm protein crystals

GoniometerOMEGA

Cryo-Cooler5 to 500 μm1 cm

OMEGA

CrystalX-ray detector

Shutter

Collecting a diffraction data setSeveral hundred images collected during angular ScansTypical scan: 1 degree in 0.1 to 5 sec

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 9

Typical scan: 1 degree in 0.1 to 5 sec

Page 10: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

X-ray crystallography data collection ReminderTypical Experimental setup Crystals mounted in a “cryo-loop”Typical Experimental setup

X-ray Diffractometer

Crystals mounted in a cryo loop

15 μm protein crystals

GoniometerOMEGA

Cryo-Cooler5 to 500 μm1 cm

Data qualityOMEGA

Crystal

Alignment of the crystal with the beam

P i i f th

Data quality

X-ray detector

Shutter Signal to noise ratio

Radiation damage

Precision of the scans

Collecting a diffraction data setSeveral hundred images collected during angular ScansTypical scan: 1 degree in 0.1 to 5 sec

Radiation damage

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 10

Typical scan: 1 degree in 0.1 to 5 sec

Page 11: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Our solution the MD2 diffractometer family

Diffractometer

Control electronics

Control softwareWindowsdo s(.NET, C++, VB)

C3D CrystalCentring software

MD2

Designed for optimal Data Quality and Automation

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 11

Designed for optimal Data Quality and Automation

Page 12: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

The MD2 Goniometer

High precision Air bearing goniometer with crystal alignments & centring table

Air bearing spindle a few nm error motion

T t d i ( b )

High precision Air bearing goniometer with crystal alignments & centring table

Torque motor driven (no gearbox)

Direct encoding 4.6M pulses/turn

XY t i t bl 0 2 l tiXY centring table 0.2 µm resolution..

XYZ Alignment table 0.2 µm resolution

PMAC motion control (Close loop PID)

Angular error <1 mDeg @ 20 Deg/s Shutter synchronisation error <<1 mDeg (scans)Delta-Tau

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 12

y g ( )Delta Tau

Page 13: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

MD2 Goniometer

Précision controlPrécision control

Scales

Green grid:10 μmRed circle: 1 μm diameterScreen resolution: 0.25 μm / pixel

10 µm

Real time videoNeedle with 1 μm hole at tipRotation 45 deg/sec

10 µm

g

Beam like view

Observed sphere of confusion ≈ 1 μm

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 13

Page 14: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Processing micro-crystals

Micro-crystal10 years ago

Today10 years ago

10 µm

How to improve the precision of Goniometers?

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 14

Page 15: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Improving the goniometer precision0 . 4

5 0 1 0 0 1 5 0 2 0 0 2 5 0 3 0 0 3 5 0

0 . 2

0.9 µm SOR diameter

‐ 0.9 µm pp‐ 0 25 µm rm s

- 0 . 4

- 0 . 2

‐ 0.25 µm r.m.s

Rotation 360 º

osition

5 0 1 0 0 1 5 0 2 0 0 2 5 0 3 0 0 3 5 0

- 0 . 1

0 . 1

0 . 2

0 . 3

2nd+3rd harmonics

0.75

 µm

Gravity effectC t i t bl

FFT analysis

at sam

ple p

- 0 . 4

- 0 . 3

- 0 . 2

0 on Centering table

FFT l i

Error 

5 0 1 0 0 1 5 0 2 0 0 2 5 0 3 0 0 3 5 0

- 0 . 1

- 0 . 0 5

0 . 0 5

0 . 1

0 . 1 5

20th+23rd harmonics

0.3 µm

Poles of theOMEGA motor

FFT analysis

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 15

- 0 . 1 5

Page 16: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

New GoniometerSet in vertical orientation

■ SOC <0.5 µm with Kappa Crystal down to 2-3 µm

0.3 µmglass needle

Microscope

Crystal down to 2 3 µm

g

) 0

100Needle position2 2 turns

Positio

n (nm) 0

2 Glass needle observed with a microscope (125 nm/pixel ) + sub pixel i t l ti + I ti

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 16

Angle (deg)0                           360                           720‐100

interpolation + Image computing 

Page 17: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

The MD2 – On beam axis video-microscope

beam viewing

High resolution On Beam Axis video-microscope Patented

Sample viewing

Beam

X-ray

High resolution Camera

Li hti d scintillatorLighting condenser

No parallax error Perfect alignment with the beam

Real view of thecollimated beam12µm needle

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 17

No parallax error Perfect alignment with the beam

Page 18: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

The MD2 micro-diffractometerto get the best data from the crystals

BUT… not all the crystals are good…

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 18

Page 19: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Before automation

An ordinary day on a beamline… Screening crystals

Changing a Crystal:g g y

Unmounting the previous

…Opening the hutch

Unmounting the previous

Mounting the new one

Aligning itAligning it

Closing the hutch

Starting data collectionStarting data collection…

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 19

Page 20: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

An ordinary day on a beamline! …Screening crystals…An ordinary day on a beamline! …Screening crystals…

MD2 diffractometerGUI

SC3 Sample ChangerGUI

MD2SC3

Automatic screening

50 samples in 2H30’

… And also thanks to , the automatic crystal centring softwaredeveloped by Bernard Lavault

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 20

developed by Bernard Lavault

Page 21: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Instruments for Small Angle Scattering experiments

BioSAXSSample changer

■ Sample in solution■ Large macromolecules, assemblies (complexes)■ Kinetics

R l ti i li it d t 10 Å (U t 500 )■ Resolution is limited to 10 Å (Up to 500 nm)

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 21

Page 22: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

BioSAXS Typical experimental setupMonochromaticX b

2D Detector

All beam path in vacuum

X-ray beam

ExposurecellExposure

Cell

cell

Solvant+prot.Solvant

D t t

Flight tube …

Detector Model Building

X33 beamline EMBL-HH/Doris D. Svergun, M. Roessle

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 22

Page 23: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

BioSAXS Sample Changer at ID 14-3

Sample Exposure Unit

Sample changer unit GUI

5 200µlEMBLGrenoble

Control electronics

5‐200µl

EMBLHamburg

Fluidic rack

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 23

Page 24: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

A design for low volumes & high speed

Challenging design

■ Two separated units

■ Pipetting needle is fixed

■ Microplates are moved to the samples

Short tubing

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 24

Page 25: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

BioSAXS Sample Changer – Sample Exposure UnitExposure CellI VIn Vacuum,Tº control

Camera

P dPod

Ø2 mm quartz capillaryWith 10µm wall

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 25

Page 26: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Control electronics■ Field bus electronics EtherCat

( ff)(Beckhoff) ■ PLC and et motion control:

TwinCat real time layer in a Windows PC

EtherCAT

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 26

Page 27: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Control softwareDesigng■ Core & GUI Written in Java■ Process scripted in Phyton■ Image computing C++/Javag p g

■ Full remote control■ High and low level control

Socket + Libraries■ Tango device server (ESRF)■ Tine device server (EMBL HH)■ Tine device server (EMBL-HH)

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 27

Page 28: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Load Sample

Sample arrives in field of view: position controll takes overSample arrives in pod: thermal exchangeTable is moving – sample aspirated

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 28

Page 29: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Flow sample During exposure to X-rays

Optimal use of solution to reduce radiation damage

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 29

Page 30: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Clean Needle, tubing and Exposure Capillary

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 30

Washing with detergentRinsing with waterDrying with dry airDrycontrol by image processingParking the cleaning station

Page 31: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

BioSAXS Sample Changers today

■ Two machines installed

ESRF ID14-3, routinely used

EMBL@PETRA-III, commissioning

■ One machine under construction

for Diamond Light Source

(Maatel/Bruker)

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 31

Page 32: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Macromolecular Crystallography Crystal harvesting

Crystallization is automated MX beamlines are automatedy

??

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 32

Page 33: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Crystal Direct The CD plate

In-platecrystal screening

Harvesting by photo-ablation

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 33

Page 34: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Crystal Direct crystal harvesting (Photo ablation)

vapour diffusion experimentexperiment

Crystaly

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 34

Page 35: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Crystal DirectHarvester prototype

Cartesian XYZ robot

p ypScanning head Precision mechanics

Optics (Laser, microscope)

CD plate Robotics & Motion control

Fluidics (gluing, pico-drops of cryo-protectant)

Image computing (Laser Auto focus, alignmentImage computing (Laser Auto focus, alignment control)

Low level automation (PLC)

Process automation (Java/Phyton/C++)

fs laser

Process automation (Java/Phyton/C )

Communication (Device server, Databases)

A i d iAgain a good mixof physics, mechanicselectronics and software!

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 35

Page 36: INSTRUMENTS for X-ray crystallography and solution ... · PDF fileand solution scattering experimentssolution scattering experiments ... Diffraction Instrumentation Team, ... X-ray

Thank youyfor your attention!

Franck FelisazJerome Halbwachs

Raphael MoyaAlexandre GobboAlexandre Gobbo

Gergely PAPPJulien Huet

Christophe LandretSilvia Russi

Florent Cipriani

EMBL GrenobleDiffraction Instrumentation Team, [email protected] ESI-2011 May 18th 36