Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights...

26

Transcript of Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights...

Page 1: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge
Page 2: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights(Formerly National Labor Committee) 5 Gateway Center, 6th Floor, Pittsburgh, PA 15222 , U.S.A.+1-412-562-2406 | [email protected] | www.globallabourrights.org

April 2015

Cover photo: AP Photo/Richard Vogel

A Race to the Bottom: TPP & The Quintessential Case of Nike in Vietnam Nike’s internal e-mail to employees Minimum Wages in Several TPP CountriesDeep Concerns Voiced Regarding the Trans-Pacific Partnership

AppendixSample Shipments of Nike Footwear from Vietnam, February 2015

147

10

13

Table of Contents

Page 3: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

1

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

A Race to the Bottom:TPP & The Quintessential Case of Nike in Vietnam

By Charles KernaghanInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights

1

Nike is truly the canary in the coal mine, pointing us to what unfettered “free trade” looks like, and what the world will look like under the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP).

In the year 2014, Nike produced over 365 million pairs of athletic shoes, while at the same time refusing to make a single sneaker in the United States. Meanwhile, they are making these shoes at a tremendous profit while paying their overseas workers pennies. In fact, Nike’s largest production center is Vietnam, where more than 330,000 workers, mostly young women, toil in 67 factories mak-ing goods for Nike. Everyone knows that Nike shoes do not come cheap, selling in the U.S. from $60 to $120 to well past $200.

Nike DominatesSixty Percent of

All Athletic Footwear Sold in U.S.

In 2014, Nike controlled about 60 percent of the U.S. footwear market (worth some $21.2 billion in 2014) and some 30 percent of the global footwear market.

60%

Page 4: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

2

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

Fiscal Quarter Revenues

Q4 2014 (March-May 2014) $ 7.4 billion

Q1 2015 (June-August 2014) $ 8.0 billion

Q2 2015 (September-November 2014) $ 7.4 billion

Q3 2015 (December 2014-February 2015) $ 7.5 billion

$30.3 billionNike’s revenues from March 2014 to February 2015

were $30.3 billion.

Page 5: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

3

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

According to U.S. Customs records analyzed by the Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, there were at least 16,423 shipments of Nike Athletic footwear exported from Vietnam to the U.S. in 2014, with an estimated customs value of $491 million!

In February 2015, we looked at a sampling of ten shipments of Nike sneakers from Vietnam destined for the U.S. market. It did not take long to find that the average customs value of the Nike sneakers was just $5.27 per pair!

Meanwhile, Nike’s presence in Vietnam led to a continua-tion of wages as low as 27 cents an hour in 2012, with a slight increase to 48 to 69 cents an hour in January 2015, which is well below subsistence levels.

It is common that Vietnamese workers have no legal rights. Nor has Vietnam ratified the United Nations Conventions on freedom of association and the right to organize.

Nike’s CEO, Mark Parker, announced that “Fiscal year 2015 is off to a strong start. Our connection to consumers and ability to innovate, combined with our powerful global portfolio, is a complete offense… Nike has never been better posi-tioned to realize our tremendous growth potential.”

Nike’s revenues for the year ending February 2015 totaled $30.3 billion.

Let’s be honest. For years, Nike has been exploiting the 330,000 Vietnamese workers, mostly young women, who are poorly paid and denied their most funda-mental rights.

But every once in a while, the truth leaks out. In this case, it was Thanh Nien News in Vietnam that spilled the beans:

“Analysts acknowledge that Vietnam’s abundance of cheap labour has played an increasingly pivotal role in

I do not believe that American workers

should have to compete against

people in Vietnam who have a

minimum wage of 56 cents an hour.

— Senator Bernie Sanders

Page 6: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

4

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

An E-mail from Nike to its employees sent on March 10, 2015.

Page 7: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

5

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

wooing foreign firms looking to set up overseas manu-facturing operations in a country with a population of 90 million.

“This edge appears to be working well in the context of rising labor costs in China and political mayhem in Thailand… They [foreign and local companies] warn any further wage hikes will cause grave consequences on Vietnam’s competitiveness in the near term, adding it needs to be considered ‘very carefully.’”

— Thanh Nien News, “Vietnam Approves Minimum-Wage Hike of 15 Percent in 2015,” November 11, 2014

On March 10, 2015, Ms. Hilary Krane, Chief General Counsel at Nike, asked all 44,000 Nike staff to lobby for the Trans-Pacific Partnership, telling them that the TPP would:

“reduce duties on footwear and apparel among TPP coun-tries, including Nike products manufactured in Vietnam

for sale in the U.S. For Nike, rolling back these duties will allow us to grow in new markets, reinvest in innova-tion, and offset costs of doing business.”

In short, Nike is after even cheaper prices, and expanded ac-cess to Vietnamese workers with no legal rights, no voice and no way out. Is this how we want to live?

If Nike had the guts and morals, Nike would demand that their products made in Vietnam be made by workers who are guaranteed their freedom of association, their right to orga-nize and to collectively bargain.

I am certain that many Nike workers are desperate for reform which will allow them to make a living wage and to freely or-ganize unions to defend their interests. Together we can work on making this a reality!

Workers assemble Nike shoes at a factory on the outskirts of Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. (AP Photo/Richard Vogel, 2000.)

Page 8: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

6

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

Trans-Pacific Partnership countries include Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore, United States, and Vietnam. The wages in Vietnam, Mexico, Peru and Chile range from 48 cents to $1.86 per hour. The United States has trade deficits with Vietnam, Mexico, Malaysia, Canada, and Japan.

“It comes as Vietnam tries to lure big firms with its cheap labor, tax breaks and its looming accession to Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) with its biggest partners.”

— Ho Binh Minh. “Vietnam Hit by Rare Strike for a Fifth Day at Major Footwear Factory.” Reuters. March 31, 2015

“…I am also concerned that this agreement threatens worker rights. I have not been convinced that countries such as Vietnam, which is controlled by a one-party government, will implement labor provisions that sup-port freedom of association and collective bargaining. Any TPP agreement must include strong and enforceable labor protections as well as an action plan to ensure that countries are complying with internationally recognized labor rights.”

— Congressman Chris Van Hollen, Letter to Congressman Sandy Levin announcing opposition to “fast track” Trade Promotion Authority, April 15, 2015

United States

Canada

Peru

Chile

Australia

New Zealand

Singapore

Vietnam

Malaysia

Japan

BruneiMexico

($66.97 B)

($24.86 B)

($17.31B)

($33.94 B)

($53.83 B)

Page 9: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

7

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

Minimum Wages in Several TPP Countries

Vietnam: 48 to 69 cents per hourMexico: 56 to 73 cents per hour

Peru: $1.17 per hourChile: $1.86 per hour

Vietnam48 to 69 cents an hour

8-hour day, 48-hour work week(Effective Beginning January 1, 2015)

* Exchange Rate: $1.00 = $21,476 Vietnamese Dong as of 3/24/2015

Mexico56 to 73 cents an hour

8 hour day, 40-hour workweek

* Exchange rate: $1.00 = 14.911 Mexican Pesos as of 3/24/2015

Region I(3,100,000 VND/month)

$0.69 an hour$5.52 a day (8 hrs)

$33.31 a week$144.35 a month$1,732.20 a year

Region II(2,750,000 VND/month)

$0.62 an hour$4.96 a day (8 hrs)

$29.54 a week$128.03 a month$1,536.36 a year

Region III(2,400,000 VND/month)

$0.54 an hour$4.32 a day (8 hrs)

$25.78 a week$111.72 a month$1,340.64 a year

Region IV(2,150,000 VND/month)

$0.48 an hour$3.84 a day (8 hrs)

$23.10 a week$100.08 a month$1,200.96 a year

General Worker-Area A(66.45 Mexican Pesos per day)

$0.56 per hour$4.46 per day (8 hours)$22.40 weekly (48 hrs)

$97.07 per month$1,164.80 per year

General Worker-Area B(70.10 Mexican Pesos per day)

$0.59 per hour$4.70 per day (8 hours)$23.60 weekly (48 hrs)

$102.27 per month$1,227.20 per year

Cutter in Area B Shoe Factory(87.10 Mexican Pesos per day)

$0.73 per hour$5.84 per day (8 hours)$29.20 weekly (48 hrs)

$126.53 per month$1,518.40 per year

PeruPrivate Sector: $1.17 per hour

8-hour day, one rest day per week(750 Peruvian New Sol per month)

$1.17 per hour$9.36 per day (8 hours)

$56.25 per week (48 hours)$243.74 per month$2,924.88 per year

* Exchange rate: $1.00 = 3.077 PEN as of 3/24/2015

Chile$1.86 per hour

45 hour standard workweek(225,000 Chilean Pesos per month)

$1.86 per hour$14.88 per day (8 hours)

$83.58 per week (45 hours)$362.20 per month$4,346.40 per year

* Exchange rate: $1.00 = 621.2 CLP as of 3/24/2015

Page 10: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

“Made in Vietnam

Labor Rights Violations in Vietnam’s Export Manufacturing Sector”

“ Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining—These basic labor rights are not respected under Vietnamese law. Workers who have attempted to form labor organizations outside of the official union structure dominated by the state and the Communist Party have been prosecuted and jailed on criminal charges in retaliation for their efforts.”

“Forced Labor—As noted, the U.S. Department of Labor has added garments from Vietnam to its annual list of products made with forced and child labor…”

“Child Labor—As noted, the U.S. Labor Department has included garments from Vietnam on its global list of products made with forced and child labor…”

“Gender Discrimination—Women workers in Vietnam face pervasive pregnancy-based discrimination ranging from termi-nation of employment to denial of statutory maternity benefits.”

“Health and Safety Hazards—Factory workers are often at risk from hazards such as locked fire exits and failure to provide protective equipment…”

“Excessive Working Hours—Garment factory employees report being required to work far in excess of legal limits on work-ing hours often without a single weekly rest day…”

“Inadequate Wages—Despite significant recent increases in the legal minimum wage, manufacturing workers continue to receive wages that provide only a fraction of the cost of an adequate standard of living.”

- Worker Rights Consortium, “Made in Vietnam: Labor Rights Violations in Vietnam’s Export Manufacturing Sector,” May 2013

8

Page 11: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

“The human rights situation in Vietnam deteriorated significantly in 2013, worsening a trend evident for several years. The year was marked by a severe and intensifying crackdown on critics, including long prison terms for many peaceful activists whose “crime” was calling for political change….

“Vietnam bans all political parties, labor unions, and human rights organizations independent of the government or CPV. The authorities require official approval for public gatherings and refuse to grant permission for meetings, marches, or pro-tests they deem politically or otherwise unacceptable….

“In May 2013, authorities in three Vietnamese cities intervened with violence, temporary arrests, and concerted harassment to prevent and break up peaceful “human rights picnics” at which activists planned to disseminate and discuss the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other human rights standards….”

— Human Rights Watch. “World Report 2014: Vietnam.”

9

Page 12: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

10

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

Nearly Five Million Manufacturing Jobs Lost

“Over two decades, a series of trade agreements not only failed to meet their business sector and political backers’ glowing promises of job creation, but instead resulted in unprecedented and unsustainable trade deficits, the net loss of nearly 5 million U.S. manufacturing jobs and more than 57,000 factories, millions of higher-wage service sector jobs offshored, flat median wages despite significant productivity gains and the worst U.S. income inequality in the last century. And, even for U.S. agriculture, a sector that consistently has been promised gains from past trade pacts, U.S. food exports have stagnated while U.S. food imports have more than doubled in the past 20 years of NAFTA-style deals. Given that the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) pact now under negotiation replicates and expands on the same model, opposition in Congress and among the public is deep and broad.”

— Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch. “Prosperity Undermined Fast-Tracked Trade Agreements’ 20-Year Record of Massive U.S. Trade Deficits, American Job Loss and Wage Suppression.” January 2015.

Deep Concerns Voiced Regarding the Trans-Pacific Partnership

“Companies like New Balance are simply asking that they be given an opportunity to compete and keep good manufac-turing jobs in the United States.”

— Senator Susan Collins (R-ME). Wall Street Journal. October 4, 2013.

“The TPP, if passed, would implement trade rules that make it illegal for governments to create and enforce regulations on everything from environmental standards, to wage and labor laws, to the duration of copyrights. A law prohibiting the sale of goods made in sweatshops in Vietnam could be ruled illegal, for example, as a barrier to trade.”

— Amy Goodman and Denis Moynihan. “Flush the TPP.” Democracy Now. March 19, 2015.

Fast-Tracked Trade Deals Have Battered American Workers

“The TPP [Trans-Pacific Partnership] would be the largest so-called free trade agreement that the United States ever bound itself to. Trade among the 12 nations accounts for 38 percent of global economic activity.

“Fast track is nothing more than Congress pulling a fast one on the American people. It’s a plan for lawmakers to abdicate their Constitutional responsibility to regulate international trade. With fast track, Congress shirks its duty to subject trade deals to lengthy line-by-line scrutiny, fulsome public hearings and amendment.

“While gratifying Wall Street and multinational corporations, past fast-tracked trade deals have battered American workers as factories fled off shore, wages stagnated and layoffs multiplied. Fast track is an outmoded strategy for indolent politicians. Workers in the 21st century deserve in-depth deliberation over trade proposals to ensure jobs, the environment, food safety and national sovereignty are protected.”

— Leo Gerard, President, United Steelworkers. “Hey Sen. McConnell: Don’t Fast Track the Trans-Pacific Partnership.” In These Times. January 20, 2015.

Page 13: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

11

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

“Big-business groups are squarely behind the TPP and have ramped up their lobbying efforts for fast-track authority….[On the hand] various labor, environmental and health groups, meanwhile, fear the deal would benefit corporations at the expense of workers and ordinary families. Fair minimum wages and access to generic medicines are among areas of concern.”

— Don Lee. “China is Obama’s trump card in push for Pacific Rim trade pact.” LA Times. March 8, 2015.

5.7 Million U.S. Manufacturing Jobs Lost

“FTAs and other trade deals have cost millions of U.S. jobs, most in the manufacturing sector. Congress should be very wary about approving new trade and investment deals like the TTIP.”

— Robert Scott. “Transatlantic Free Trade Agreement: Job Claims Are Pure Baloney.” EPI. November 1, 2013.

“Rising trade deficits are to blame for most of the 5.7 million U.S. manufacturing jobs (nearly a third of manufactur-ing employment) lost since April 1998.”

— Robert E. Scott. “Stop Currency Manipulation and Create Millions of Jobs.” EPI. February 26, 2014.

“White House estimates show that for every $1 billion in goods exported, the economy creates 5,000 jobs. Unfortu-nately, that street goes both ways — data from the Economic Policy Institute shows that for every $1 billion in goods imported, the economy loses 9,000 jobs.”

— John Olen, “Lack of Jobs is Due to Our Trade Deficit,” Economy in Crisis, March 8, 2014

“The public has no access to materials drafted thus far, and even members of Congress have limited access.”

— Jared Bernstein, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities

“Meanwhile, more than 500 official corporate “trade advisors” have special access…”

- Lori Wallach, Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch

[The TPP is] designed to carry forward the neoliberal project to maximize profit and domination, and to set the working people in the world in competition with one another so as to lower wages to increase insecurity.

“It’s very hard to make anything of the TPP because it’s been kept very secret. A half-secret, I should say. It’s not secret from the hundreds of corporate lawyers and lobbyists who are writing the legislation. To them, it’s perfectly public. They’re, in fact, writing it. It’s being kept secret from the population. Which of course raises obvious ques-tions.”

— Noam Chomsky. Huffington Post. January 13, 2014.

“Over and over again we’ve been told that trade deals will create jobs and better protect workers and the environment… Those promises have never come to fruition.”

— Senator Bob Casey, Democrat-Pennsylvania

Page 14: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

12

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

60,000 Manufacturing Plants Closed

“Our free trade policy encourages production to leave the country. We’ve lost millions of manufacturing jobs. More than 60,000 manufacturing plants were closed between 2000 and 2010 as production moved overseas.”

— Stan Sorscher, Society for Professional Engineering Employees in Aerospace. “‘Free Trade’ Was Never Re-ally About Trade.” Huffington Post. June 17, 2013.

“Secrecy has real costs. Because the negotiating process combines a general shield from the public with privileged access for industry advisers, the substance of American free trade agreements does not represent truly national interests. It represents the interests of those members of industry who sit on the office’s Industry Trade Advisory Committees, which have regular access to negotiating information.”

— Margot E. Kaminski, Fellow, Information Society Project at Yale Law School (New York Times Op-Ed, April 17, 2015)

Over 330,000 workers in 67 factories in Vietnam make Nike footwear and clothing while being paid 48 to 69 cents an hour.

Page 15: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

13

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

Appendix

Sample Shipments of Nike Footwear from Vietnam, February 2015

1.) Annora Vietnam Foowear Limited Xuan Lam Town, Nghi Son Economic Zone, Tinh Gia County, Thanh Hoa Province, VietnamWage Region III

Port of Arrival: Los Angeles, February 24, 2015264 cartons / 3,156 pairs Nike Kids Grade School FootwearEstimated Value: $19,698.56 [$6.24 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CM

PACKAGING INFORMATION

2,132.34

264.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 22.00

1.00TEUs:

CM

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MAERSK LINE Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MAEU

MSC RENEEVessel:

57078

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HAIPHONG

MAEU591656378

505NVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

10

02/24/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$19,698.56

0

9465306IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

YANTIAN

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

3156 PRS OF NIKE KIDS GRADE SCHL FOOTWEAR SHIP TO:000006 5961 INVOICENO: VQC1501087 CUSTOMER PO #: 766772_ SHI PPER: ANNORA VIETNAM FOOTWEARLIMITED XUAN LAM TOWN, NGHI SON ECONOMIC ZONE, TINH GIACOUNTY,THANH HOAPROVINCE VI ETNAM. RELAY VESSEL MSC RENEE V.505N CONTAINER SUMMARY --------------------- -------------- MRKU7671241 ML-VN188820020X8'6 264CT N 22.820CBM 2132.740KGS B/L TOTAL SUMMARY----------------------------------- 264CTN 22.820CBM 2132.740KGS

264MRKU7671241

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 19 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

MRKU7671241

MARKS & NUMBERS

- TSA FONTANA, CA USA COUNTRYOF ORIGIN: VIETNAM

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

7008550640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

3156 PRS NIKE KIDS FOOTWEAR

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 20 of 20

Page 16: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

14

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

2.) Pou Sung Vietnam Co. Ltd. Bau Xeo Industrial, Trang Bom District, Dong Nai Province, VietnamWage Region I

Port of Arrival: Los Angeles, February 25, 20151,311 cartons / 11,232 pairs of Nike Kids Pre-School FootwearEstimated Value: $38,974.51 [$3.47 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

X

PACKAGING INFORMATION

5,793.00

1,311.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 73.00

2.25TEUs:

X

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MOL Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MOLU

MOL CONTINUITYVessel:

55206

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MOLU15453803537

014EVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

11

02/25/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$38,974.51

0

9388352IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

144 CTN TOTAL 11232 PRS SHIP TO 0000010770 1728 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRESCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO PSVU1501172B CUSTOMER PO 1870648SHIPPER POUSUNG VIETNAM CO., LTD. BAU XEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOM DISTRICT, DONG NAIPROVINCE, VIETNAM 417 CTN 5004 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRE SCHOOL FOOTWEARINVOICE NO PSVU1501172ACUSTOMER PO 1870648 217 CTN 1302 PRS OF NIKEKIDS GRADE SCHL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO VHN14L1281 CUSTOMER PO 1870692SHIPPER VIETNAM CHINGLUH SHOES CO.,LTDTHUANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE, BENLUCDISTRICT, LONG AN PROVINCE, VIETNAM 533 CTN 3198 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRESCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO PSVU1501174 CUSTOMER PO 1870647SHIPPER POUSUNG VIETNAM CO., LTD. BAU XEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOM DISTRICT, DONG NAIPROVINCE, VIETNAM S/C NO US000045H

1311MOEU1416961

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 13 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

MOEU1416961

MOEU1416961

MOEU1416961

MOEU1416961

MOEU1416961

MARKS & NUMBERS

- 144 CTNTOTAL 11232 PRSSHIP TO 00000107701728 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRE SCHOOLFOOTWEARINVOICENO PSVU1501172BCUSTOMER PO 1870648SHIPPER POU SUNG VIETNAM CO., LTD.

-BAU XEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOMDISTRICT, DONG NAI PROVINCE,VIETNAM417 CTN5004 PRS OF NIKEKIDS PRE SCHOOLFOOTWEARINVOICE NO PSVU1501172ACUSTOMER PO 1870648

-217 CTN1302 PRS OF NIKE KIDS GRADE SCHLFOOTWEARINVOICE NO VHN14L1281CUSTOMER PO1870692SHIPPER VIETNAM CHINGLUH SHOESCO.,LTDTHUANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE,

-BENLUC DISTRICT,LONG AN PROVINCE, VIETNAM533 CTN3198 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRESCHOOLFOOTWEARINVOICE NO PSVU1501174CUSTOMER PO 1870647SHIPPER POU SUNG VIETNAM CO.,LTD.

-BAU XEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOMDISTRICT, DONG NAI PROVINCE,VIETNAMS/C NO US000045H

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

73790007008550

950390 640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

1094217

CTNCTN

KIDS PRESCHOOLNIKE KIDS FOOTWEAR SHOES INDUSTRIAL

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 14 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

X

PACKAGING INFORMATION

5,793.00

1,311.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 73.00

2.25TEUs:

X

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MOL Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MOLU

MOL CONTINUITYVessel:

55206

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MOLU15453803537

014EVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

11

02/25/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$38,974.51

0

9388352IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

144 CTN TOTAL 11232 PRS SHIP TO 0000010770 1728 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRESCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO PSVU1501172B CUSTOMER PO 1870648SHIPPER POUSUNG VIETNAM CO., LTD. BAU XEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOM DISTRICT, DONG NAIPROVINCE, VIETNAM 417 CTN 5004 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRE SCHOOL FOOTWEARINVOICE NO PSVU1501172ACUSTOMER PO 1870648 217 CTN 1302 PRS OF NIKEKIDS GRADE SCHL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO VHN14L1281 CUSTOMER PO 1870692SHIPPER VIETNAM CHINGLUH SHOES CO.,LTDTHUANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE, BENLUCDISTRICT, LONG AN PROVINCE, VIETNAM 533 CTN 3198 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRESCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO PSVU1501174 CUSTOMER PO 1870647SHIPPER POUSUNG VIETNAM CO., LTD. BAU XEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOM DISTRICT, DONG NAIPROVINCE, VIETNAM S/C NO US000045H

1311MOEU1416961

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 13 of 20

Page 17: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

15

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

3.) Vietnam Chingluh Shoes Co., Ltd Thuandao Industrial Zone, Benluc District, Long An Province, VietnamWage Region II

Port of Arrival: Los Angeles, February 2, 201584 cartons / 1008 pairs of Nike Women’s FootwearEstimated Value: $6,436.29 [$6.39 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CM

PACKAGING INFORMATION

696.72

84.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 9.00

1.00TEUs:

CM

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MAERSK LINE Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MAEU

A P MOLLERVessel:

55206

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MAEU565686825

151SVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

10

02/02/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$6,436.29

0

9214898IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

1008 PRS OF NIKE WOMENS FOOTW EAR INVOICE NO: VHN14K0833 CUSTOMER PO#:6648894-08 SH IP TO: 0000198341 SHIPPER: V IETNAM CHINGLUH SHOESCO.,LTD THUANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE, BENLUC DISTRICT, LONG AN PROVINCE,VIETNAM CONTAINER SUMMARY ------------------- ----------------MSKU5213278 VN1716154 20X8'6 84C TN 9.250CBM 697.000KGS B/L TOTAL SUMMARY --------------- -------------------- 84CTN 9 .250CBM697.000KGS

84MSKU5213278

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 3 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

MSKU5213278

MARKS & NUMBERS

- LFL POMONA, CA USA COUNTRY OFORIGIN: VIETNAM

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

7008550640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

1008 PRS NIKE WOMENS FOOTWEAR

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 4 of 20

Page 18: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

16

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

4.) Pou Chen Vietnam Enterprise Ltd. Nguyen Ai Quoc St, Hoa An Village, Bien Hoa City, Dong Nai Province, S.R. VietnamWage Region I

Port of Arrival: Los Angeles, February 25, 2015522 cartons / 4,440 Pairs of Nike Men’s FootwearEstimated Value: $59,446.53 [$13.39 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

X

PACKAGING INFORMATION

6,435.00

522.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 61.00

2.00TEUs:

X

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MOL Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MOLU

MOL CONTINUITYVessel:

55206

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MOLU15453803619

014EVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

11

02/25/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$59,446.53

0

9388352IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

302 CTN TOTAL 4440 PRS SHIP TO 0000191130 1800 PRS OF NIKE MENS FOOTWEARINVOICE NO PCVU1412440 CUSTOMER PO 6653425-29 SHIPPER POU CHEN VIETNAMENTERPRISELTD. NGUYEN AI QUOC ST,HOA AN VILLAGE,BIEN HOA CITY,DONG NAIPROVINCE,S.R.VIETNAM 220 CTN 2640 PRS OF NIKE MENS FOOTWEAR INVOICE NOPCVU1412602CUSTOMER PO 6647838-29 S/C NO US000045H

522CAIU9529661

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 11 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CAIU9529661

CAIU9529661

CAIU9529661

MARKS & NUMBERS

- 302 CTNTOTAL 4440 PRSSHIP TO 00001911301800 PRS OF NIKE MENS FOOTWEARINVOICE NOPCVU1412440CUSTOMER PO 6653425-29SHIPPER POU CHEN VIETNAM ENTERPRISELTD.

-NGUYEN AI QUOC ST,HOA ANVILLAGE,BIENHOA CITY,DONG NAIPROVINCE,S.R.VIETNAM220 CTN2640 PRSOF NIKE MENS FOOTWEARINVOICE NO PCVU1412602CUSTOMER PO 6647838-29

-S/C NO US000045H

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

7008550640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

220 CTN NIKE MENS FOOTWEAR

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 12 of 20

Page 19: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

17

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

5.) Vietnam Dona Orient Company Limited A6 Song May Industrial Zone, Bac Son, Trang Bom District, Dong Nai Province, VietnamWage Region I

Port of Arrival: Los Angeles, February 2, 2015250 cartons / 2,400 pairs of Nike Men’s FootwearEstimated Value: $16,009.10 [$6.67 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CM

PACKAGING INFORMATION

2,541.93

250.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 27.00

2.00TEUs:

CM

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MAERSK LINE Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MAEU

A P MOLLERVessel:

55206

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MAEU565686824

151SVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

10

02/02/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$16,009.10

0

9214898IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

TOTAL: 2400 PRS SHIP TO: 000 0191130 1800 PRS OF NIKE ME N FOOTWEARINVOICE NO: VOIN1 45792 CUSTOMER PO #: 6635509 -29 SHIPPER: VIETNAMDONA OR IENT COMPANY LIMITED A6 SONG MAY I.Z,BAC SON,TRANG BOMDISTRICT,DONG NAI PROVINCE,VIET NAM ON BEHALF OF HOLD GOLD T RADINGCO.LTD

600 PRS OF NIKE MEN FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO: VOIN145793 CUS TOMER PO #:6635511-29 C ONTAINER SUMMARY ----------- ------------------------ MRK U0490982 VN1716152 40X8 '6 250CTN 27.890CBM 2542.160KGS B/LTOTAL SUMMARY ---- ------------------------------ - 250CTN 27.890CBM2542.160K GS

150

100

MRKU0490982

MRKU0490982

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 1 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

MRKU0490982

MARKS & NUMBERS

- FTA JUNCTION CITY, KS USA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: VIETNAM FTA JUNCTION CITY, KS USA COUNTRYOF ORIGIN: VIETNAM

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

700855070085506831000

640590 640590850619

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

2400600250

PRSPRSCTN

NIKE MEN FOOTWEAR MAYNIKE MEN FOOTWEARGS

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 2 of 20

Page 20: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

18

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

6.) Pou Sung Vietnam Co. Ltd. Bau Xeo Industrial, Trang Bom District, Dong Nai Province, VietnamWage Region I

Port of Arrival: Long Beach, February 25, 20151,000 cartons / 6,000 pairs of Nike Infants FootwearEstimated Value: $7,390.40 [$1.23 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

X

PACKAGING INFORMATION

800.00

1,000.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 12.00

0.67TEUs:

X

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: K LINE Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2709

SCAC: KKLU

COSCO EUROPEVessel:

55224

LONG BEACH

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

KKLUSGN205569C

040EVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

11

02/25/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$7,390.40

0

9345415IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LONG BEACH

HO CHI MINH

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

6000 PRS OF NIKE INFANTS FOOTWEAR SHIP TO 00 00034782 INVOICE NOPSVU1411648 CUSTOMER PO 6637136-16 SHIPPER POU SUNG VIETNAM CO., L TD. BAUXEO INDUSTRIAL, TRANG BOM DISTRICT, D ONG NAI PROVINCE, VIETNAM

1000KKFU7512239

KKFU7512239

MARKS & NUMBERS

- KFL JUNCTION CITY,KS USA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN VIETNAMNANANA

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

7008550640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

6000 PRS NIKE INFANTS FOOTWEAR INDUSTRIAL

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 17 of 20

Page 21: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

19

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

7.) Vietnam Chingluh Shoes Co. Ltd Thu Andao Industrial Zone, Benluc District, Long An Province, VietnamWage Region II

Port of Arrival: Long Beach, February 26, 2015675 cartons / 8,052 pairs of Nike Kids Grade School FootwearEstimated Value: $39,701.60, [$4.93 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CM

PACKAGING INFORMATION

4,492.38

675.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 60.00

2.00TEUs:

CM

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MAERSK LINE Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2709

SCAC: MAEU

GUDRUN MAERSKVessel:

55206

LONG BEACH

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MAEU565870660

1502Voyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

10

02/26/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$39,701.60

0

9302877IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LONG BEACH

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

TOTAL:8052 PRS SHIP TO: 0000 010744 2988 PRS OF NIKE KID S GRADE SCHLFOOTWEAR INVOIC E NO: VHN14L0690 CUSTOMER PO #: 11597600 SHIPPER:VIETNA M CHINGLUH SHOES CO.,LTD THU ANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE, BENLUCDISTRICT, LONG AN PROVINCE , VIETNAM

1404 PRS OF NIKE KIDS GRADE S CHL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO: VHN 14L0205CUSTOMER PO #: 11598 703

2256 PRS OF NIKE KIDS GRADE S CHL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO: VHN 14L0201CUSTOMER PO #: 11597 601

1404 PRS OF NIKE KIDS GRADE S CHL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO: VHN 14L0209CUSTOMER PO #: 11598 761 CONTAINER SUMMARY------------------------------ ----- MRKU5400750 VN1587490 40X9'6675CTN 60.620CBM 4493.000KGS B/L TOTAL SUM MARY ----------------------------------- 675CTN 60.620CB M 4493.000KGS

249

119

188

119

MRKU5400750

MRKU5400750

MRKU5400750

MRKU5400750

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 5 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

MRKU5400750

MARKS & NUMBERS

- FHL INDIANAPOLIS, IN USA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: VIETNAM FHL INDIANAPOLIS, IN USA COUNTRY OFORIGIN: VIETNAM FHL INDIANAPOLIS, IN USA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: VIETNAM FHL INDIANAPOLIS, INUSA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: VIETNAM

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

700855070085507985000

640590 640590007985

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

80525064119

PRSPRSCTN

NIKE KIDS FOOTWEAR SHOES INDUSTRIALNIKE KIDS FOOTWEARBLANK COMMODITY

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 6 of 20

Page 22: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

20

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

8.) Pou Sung Vietnam Co. Ltd. Bau Xeo Industrial, Trang Bom District, Dong Nai Province, VietnamWage Region I

Port of Arrival: Long Beach, February 26, 2015959 cartons / 5,754 pairs of Nike Women’s FootwearEstimated Value: $40,205.84, [$6.99 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CM

PACKAGING INFORMATION

4,352.22

959.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 52.00

2.00TEUs:

CM

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MAERSK LINE Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2709

SCAC: MAEU

GUDRUN MAERSKVessel:

55206

LONG BEACH

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MAEU951778331

1502Voyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

10

02/26/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$40,205.84

0

9302877IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LONG BEACH

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

TOTAL: 5754 PRS SHIP TO: 000 0389907 4752 PRS OF NIKE WO MENS FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO: PS VU1412017 CUSTOMER PO #: 000 2171194 SHIPPER: POU SUNGVI ETNAM CO., LTD. BAU XEO INDU STRIAL, TRANG BOM DISTRICT,DONG NAIPROVINCE, VIETNAM

582 PRS OF NIKE WOMENS FOOTWE AR INVOICE NO: VHN14K1765C CUSTOMER PO #:0002310034 S HIPPER: VIETNAM CHINGLUH SHOES CO.,LTD THUANDAO INDUSTRIALZONE, BENLUC DISTRICT, LO NG AN PROVINCE, VIETNAM

420 PRS OF NIKE WOMENS FOOTWE AR INVOICE NO: FVE1501158 CUSTOMER PO #:0002171611 SH IPPER: FREETREND INDUSTRIAL A (VN) CO.,LTD INDUSTRIALZONE LINH TRUNG EXPORT PROCESSIN G II,BINH CHIEU,THU DUC DISTHCMC,VIETNAMC/O LONG DEAN CO MPANY LTD CONTAINER SUMM ARY------------------------ ----------- APMU4034882 VN1 587283 40X8'6 959CTN 5 2.320CBM 4352.620KGS B/L TOT AL SUMMARY ----------------------------------- 959CTN 52.320CBM 4352.620KGS

792

97

70

APMU4034882

APMU4034882

APMU4034882

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 7 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

APMU4034882

MARKS & NUMBERS

- ACD KATY,TX USA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: VIETNAM ACD KATY, TX USA COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: VIETNAMACD KATY, TX USA COUNTRY OFORIGIN: VIETNAM

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

7008550640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

6756 PRS NIKE WOMENS FOOTWEAR

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 8 of 20

Page 23: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

21

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

9.) Vietnam Chingluh Shoes Co., Ltd. Thuandao Industrial Zone, Ben Luc District, Long An Province, VietnamWage Region II

Port of Arrival: Los Angeles, February 25, 2015426 cartons / 5,112 pairs of Nike Men’s FootwearEstimated Value: $40,397.77 [$7.90 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

X

PACKAGING INFORMATION

4,373.00

426.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 61.00

2.00TEUs:

X

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: MOL Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 2704

SCAC: MOLU

MOL CONTINUITYVessel:

55206

LOS ANGELES

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

HO CHI MINH

MOLU15453803141

014EVoyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

11

02/25/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$40,397.77

0

9388352IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

LOS ANGELES

VUNG TAU

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

254 CTN TOTAL 5112 PRS SHIP TO 0000079456 3048 PRS OF NIKE MENSFOOTWEAR INVOICE NO VHN14L0747 CUSTOMER PO 6658610-18 SHIPPER VIETNAMCHINGLUH SHOESCO.,LTD THUANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE, BENLUC DISTRICT, LONG ANPROVINCE, VIETNAM 172 CTN 2064 PRS OF NIKE MENS FOOTWEAR INVOICE NOVHN14L0251 CUSTOMER PO 6658598-18S/C US000045H

426TCNU5966543

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 9 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

TCNU5966543

TCNU5966543

MARKS & NUMBERS

- 254 CTNTOTAL 5112 PRSSHIP TO 00000794563048 PRS OF NIKE MENS FOOTWEARINVOICE NOVHN14L0747CUSTOMER PO 6658610-18SHIPPER VIETNAM CHINGLUH SHOESCO.,LTD

-THUANDAO INDUSTRIAL ZONE,BENLUC DISTRICT,LONG AN PROVINCE, VIETNAM172 CTN2064 PRS OF NIKEMENS FOOTWEARINVOICE NO VHN14L0251CUSTOMER PO 6658598-18S/C US000045H

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

7008550640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

172 CTN NIKE MENS FOOTWEAR

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 10 of 20

Page 24: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge

22

Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights

10.) Vietnam Mocbai Joint Stock Company Hiep Thanh Commercial Area, Loi Thuan Commune, Ben Cau District, Tay Ninh Province, VietnamWage Region III

Port of Arrival: Tacoma, February 18, 2015814 cartons / 9,768 pairs of Nike Toddler and Pre-School Kids FootwearEstimated Value: $31,631.76, [$3.24 per pair]

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

CM

PACKAGING INFORMATION

4,422.00

814.00

Weight

Quantity:

KG

CTN

Measure: 53.00

2.00TEUs:

CM

SHIPPER

ORDER

CONSIGNEE

ORDER

NOTIFY PARTY

EXPEDITORS INTERNATIONAL

ALSO NOTIFY

ORDER

SHIPMENT DETAIL

Carrier: AMERICAN PRESIDENT LINES Country of Origin: VIETNAM

Coastal Region: West Coast

Port of Arrival: 3002

SCAC: APLU

HYUNDAI COURAGEVessel:

58201

TACOMA

Foreign Destination:

U.S. Destination:

Port of Departure:

BINH DUONG

APLU074900100

00041Voyage:

Bill of Lading

Pre Carrier:

10

02/18/2015Arrival Date:

Mode of Transport:

$31,631.76

0

9347542IMO Number:

Inbond Code:

Estimated Value:

TACOMA

HONG KONG

AMS COMMODITIES

Qty DescriptionContainer

TOTAL- 9768 PRS SHIP TO- 0000050033 1188 PRS OF NIKE KIDS TODDLER FOOTWEARINVOICE NO- VMF14115243Z CUSTOMER PO #- 118548 SHIPPER- VIETNAM MOCBAIJOINT STOCK COMPANY HIEP THANH COMMERCIAL AREALOI THUAN COMMUNE BEN CAUDIST., TAY NINH PROVINCE 1236 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRE SCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICENO- VMF14115246Z CUSTOMER PO #- 118477 1236 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRE SCHOOLFOOTWEAR INVOICE NO- VMF14115240ZCUSTOMER PO #- 118528 1164 PRS OF NIKEKIDS PRE SCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO- VMF14115320Z CUSTOMER PO #- 1185961164 PRS OF NIKE KIDS PRE SCHOOL FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO- VMF14115244Z CUSTOMERPO #- 118547 1320 PRS OF NIKE KIDS GRADE SCHLFOOTWEAR INVOICE NO-VMF14115322Z CUSTOMER PO #- 118595 1188 PRS OF NIKE KIDS TODDLER FOOTWEARINVOICE NO- VMF14115319Z CUSTOMER PO #- 118597 1272 PRS OF NIKE KIDSTODDLER FOOTWEAR INVOICE NO- VMF14115241Z CUSTOMER PO #- 118530

814APZU4177797

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 15 of 20

IMPORT BILL OF LADING DETAILSample Shipment Nike Footwear from Vietnam February 2015

APZU4177797

APZU4177797

APZU4177797

APZU4177797

APZU4177797

APZU4177797

MARKS & NUMBERS

- - LVT -HANOVER, MDUSACOUNTRY OFORIGIN-VIETNAM- LVT -HANOVER, MD

-USACOUNTRY OFORIGIN-VIETNAM- LVT -HANOVER, MDUSACOUNTRY OF

-ORIGIN-VIETNAM- LVT -HANOVER, MDUSACOUNTRY OFORIGIN-VIETNAM

-- LVT -HANOVER, MDUSACOUNTRY OFORIGIN-VIETNAM- LVT -HANOVER, MD

-USACOUNTRY OFORIGIN-VIETNAM- LVT -HANOVER, MDUSACOUNTRY OF

-ORIGIN-VIETNAM- LVT -HANOVER, MDUSACOUNTRY OFORIGIN-VIETNAM

PIERS Commodity Description

JOC Code

737900070085507008550

950390 640590640590

HS CodePIERS Commodity DescriptionUnitsQty

480013201188

PRSPRSPRS

KIDS PRESCHOOLNIKE KIDSNIKE KIDS CHILD FOOTWEAR

Container Marks & Numbers

Copyright JOC Group Inc. [email protected] is a registered trademark of JOC Group Inc. PIERS TI ® reports are provided for the exclusive use of our clients in accordance with ourpurchase agreement. They may not be sold or released for the benefit of a third party. JOC Group Inc. 2 Penn Plaza East, 12th floor, Newark, NJ 07105.

Page 16 of 20

Page 25: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge
Page 26: Institute for Global Labour and Human · PDF fileInstitute for Global Labour and Human Rights ... some 30 percent of the global footwear market. 60%. 2 ... “Analysts acknowledge