Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance...

25
© 2012 CLEAResult All rights reserved. Industrial Facility

Transcript of Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance...

Page 1: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Industrial Facility

Page 2: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Objectives

ECM Matrix Power Factor Correction Water & Wastewater Measurement and Verification

Page 3: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

ECM MatrixEnergy Conservation Measures

Ligh

ting

Ligh

ting

Cont

rols

Dayl

ight

Har

vest

ing

HVAC

BAS

Syst

ems

Retr

o-Co

mm

issi

onin

g

AC T

une-

Up

Cool

ing

Tow

er

Proc

ess C

oolin

g Sy

s.

Mot

ors (

High

Effi

cien

cy)

VFD

Mot

ors

Air C

ompr

esso

r Sys

.

Inje

ctio

n M

old

(Hig

h Ef

f.)

Blow

ers V

S. C

ompr

esse

d Ai

r

Roof

ing

Pipi

ng In

sula

tion

Refr

iger

atio

n

Pum

ps

BUILDING TYPESCity/Gov. Bldg. X X X X X X X X X X

Schools X X X X X X X X X X

Colleges/Universities X X X X X X X X X X

Hospitals X X X X X X X X X

Departments Stores X X X X X X X

Small Retail X X X X X X

Big Box Retail X X X X X X X

Grocery/Supermarkets X X X X X X X X X

Office Buildings X X X X X X X X X X

Hotels X X X X X X X X X

Restaurants X X X X

Fast-Food Restaurants X X X

Theatres X X X X X

Convenience Stores X X X X X X

Parking Garages X

Page 4: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

ECM Matrix (cont’d)Energy Conservation Measures

Ligh

ting

Ligh

ting

Cont

rols

Dayl

ight

Har

vest

ing

HVAC

BAS

Syst

ems

Retr

o-Co

mm

issi

onin

g

AC T

une-

Up

Cool

ing

Tow

er

Proc

ess C

oolin

g Sy

s.

Mot

ors (

High

Effi

cien

cy)

VFD

Mot

ors

Air C

ompr

esso

r Sys

.

Inje

ctio

n M

old

(Hig

h Ef

f.)

Blow

ers V

S. C

ompr

esse

d Ai

r

Roof

ing

Pipi

ng In

sula

tion

Refr

iger

atio

n

Pum

ps

INDUSTRIALWaste Water Treatment X X X X X X

Warehouses X X X X

Dairy Industry X X X X X

Refrigerated Warehouses X X X X X X

Metal Fab. X X X X X X X X X

Pottery X X X X X X X X X X

Distribution Center X X X X X

Food Distribution Center X X X X X X

Food Mfg X X X X X X X X

Plastic Injection Mfg X X X X X X X X X X X

Blow Mold Mfg X X X X X X X X X X

Bottling Mfg X X X X X X X X X X X

Foundry X X X X X X X X X

Printing X X X X

Corragated Pkging X X X X

Cable Mfg X X X X X X X

Chemical Processing X X X X X X X X

Powder Coating X X X X X X

Funiture Fab. X X X X

Page 5: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Power Factor Correction

Page 6: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Draft Beer: $11 per Glass at theNEW Cowboys Stadium

Page 7: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Objectives

What is Power Factor? How to correct Power

Factor? How does Power

Factor effect billing? Issues with correcting

Power Factor? Myths of Power Factor

Correction

Page 8: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

What is Power Factor?

kW – Real Power (work, HP)

kVAR – Reactive Power (non-working power

kVA – Apparent Power (what the utility supplies)

kW

kVAr

kVA

kW

kVAr

kVA

kVAkWPF =

Page 9: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

How to Correct Power Factor

Add a “Capacitive” load offset the “Inductive” load. You can add capacitors at the motor load or connect to the main switch gear.

Page 10: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

How Does Power Factor Effect Billing

ADJ = Increase to applicable Demand Charge,kW = Monthly Billing Demand,PF = Monthly measured Power Factor, andDC = Demand Charge

The billing demand will be the highest of:

DCkWPF

kWADJ ×

×=

95.

Large Power Service Rate Customersa) the maximum measured demand (adjusted

for primary voltage if applicable), orb) 65% of the highest measured demand

established during the twelve (12) month period ending with the current month, or

c) 800 kilowatts

General Service Rate Customersa) Applies to customers with peak < 799 kWb) the maximum measured demand (adjusted

for primary voltage if applicable), orc) 65 percent of the highest measured demand

established during the twelve (12) month period ending with the current month, or

Page 11: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Issues with Power Factor Correction

Harmonic Distortion Harmonics are

generated by non-linear load on your electrical distribution.

VFD or VSD are common culprits.

Arc welders, DC rectifiers and soft start motors (on start up only) are also contributors.

Secondary Bus Voltage Waveform during Utility Capacitor Switching

Page 12: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Myth of Power Factor Correction

Power Factor will reduce your energy demand. FACT: Adding kVAr will decrease the amperage

used by the facility, BUT increase the voltage. More kVAr is better. FACT: Over-correcting power factor can damage

voltage sensitive EQ in the facility. The supply voltage will increase by 10% or more.

Recommended: Reduce energy demand first through energy efficiency, before correcting power factor

Page 13: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Water & Waste Water Treatment

Page 14: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Why WWTP are Important

Grade “D-” assigned by ASCE

1.5% of total US electrical usage

10 – 20M kWh/yr total usage

Aeration: 40-70% of plant electrical use

Typical electrical savings: 2M kWh/yr

2

Aeration System

Page 15: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Aeration Options

3

Surface

Sub-Surface

Page 16: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

WWTP Energy Savings

VFD for Aerations Blowers Using UV

Disinfection versus chemical Biogas capturing

and power generation

Page 17: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Injection Molding

Insulating the barrel heater can reduce the amount energy it takes to melt the plastic pellets prior to injecting the plastic into the mold.

VFD controls on cooling tower and chill water pumps

Limit switch controls on grinders and granulators

Page 18: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Measurement & Verification

Page 19: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Objectives

Purpose of M&V Two Basic Methods of M&V Whole Facility Retrofit Isolation

General M&V Rules of Thumbs

Page 20: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Purpose of M&V

Increase Energy Savings

Document financial transactions

Support evaluation of efficiency programs

Educate facility users about there energy impacts

Page 21: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Two Basics Methods

Retrofit Isolation Method: Measures the effect of the retrofit, only

Savings are unaffected by changes beyond the measurement boundary

Usually needs a new meter (data loggers) Adjustments can be simple

Whole Facility Method: Measures all effects in the facility

Retrofits AND other changes (intended and unintended) Often uses the utility meter Adjustments can be complex

Page 22: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Retrofit Isolation

Option A - Key Parameter Measurement

Measure only the keyparameters

Make estimates or assumptions that will significantly affect reported savings

Option B - All Parameter Measurement

Measure independent variables that affect energy savings

Decide the metering system Decide on a baseline period

Chiller

Cooling Loads

CoolingTower

Boundary of Measurement

Page 23: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

Whole Facility

Option C – Whole Facility Need both baseline and reporting period data Assess performance of the whole facility, retrofitted and

non-retrofitted systems or areas Significant energy savings (10% or more of consumption

measured by utility meter)

Option D – Calibrated Simulations When there is no meter (of facility) in the baseline Baseline data can be ‘manufactured’ under controlled

circumstances. Most expensive method and complicated

Page 24: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

M&V Rules of Thumb

Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP)

Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings should be presented as

defined in the M&V Plan The cost to M&V should be less than 10% of the

annual savings Weigh the cost benefits of M&V accuracy vs.

M&V cost

Page 25: Industrial Facility - El Paso ElectricM&V Rules of Thumb Adhere with International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) Define an M&V Plan M&V reports of Savings

© 2012 CLEAResult │ All rights reserved.

QUESTIONS?

Presentations Available at www.elpasoelectric.comwww.epesaver.com