Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
-
Upload
korea-economic-institute-of-america-kei -
Category
Documents
-
view
224 -
download
0
Transcript of Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 1/17 Uchrib 46
ACTBN‗\ BLCKCIW
4 0 > >n prdhglnzgck ce zmb Actbn Blckcigl Gk|zgzrzb nkj
zmb Actbn Gk|zgzrzb ect Gkzbtknzgcknh Blckcigl Pchglw
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 2/17
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 3/17
ABG Bjgzctgnh Dcntj
ABG Bjgzct|? Ehctbklb Hcvb)Hbb
Ztcw \znkfntckb
Lckztnlz Bjgzct? Intw Intga
Lcpwtgfmz §
G\\K >02:)57::
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 4/17 Uchrib 46
Pntz G? Cubtugbv nkj Inltcblckcigl G||rb|
Lciibkzntw
Actbn nkj zmb Vcthj Blckciw >L+ Etbj Dbtf|zbk
Actbn‗| Lmnhhbkfb| nkj Cppctzrkgzgb| gk 40>> <Lmnb Vcca
Nknhw|g|
Actbn? Blckcigl Ptc|pblz| nkj Lmnhhbkfb| nezbt zmb 5Fhcdnh Tblb||gck\rdgt Hnhh nkj Ibtnh Antn|rhr
Pntz GG? Egknklgnh Gk|zgzrzgck| nkj Intabz| )Eclr| ck Ftbbk Ftcvzm
Lciibkzntw Actbnk Ftbbk Ftcvzm gk n Fhcdnh Lckzb}z >Mnk \brkf)|cc
Nk Clbnk ce Ztcrdhb( Nk Clbnk ce Cppctzrkgzw >Pmghgppb Lcr|zbnr nkj Nkjtbv \kcvmgzb
Nknhw|g|
\w|zbi Ntlmgzblzrtb ect Beeblzgub >Ftbbk Egknklb gk Actbn Agi Mwcrkf)znb
Actbn‗| Ftbbk Ftcvzm \ztnzbfw? 4 N Vn|mgkfzck Pbt|pblzgub Mnbwcrkf Agi
Pntz GGG? Zmb \bcrh F)40
Lciibkzntw
N Tbehblzgck ck zmb \bcrh \riigz <Pnrh Uchlabt
Zmb F)40? Nlmgbubibkz| nkj Lmnhhbkfb| <
\nAckf Gh
Uchrib 46
ACTBN‗\ BLCKCIW
4 0 > >
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 5/17 Uchrib 46
Pntz GGG? Zmb \bcrh F)40 -Lckzgkrbj'
Nknhw|g|
Nlmgbubibkz| gk \bcrh nkj Actbn‗| Tchb gk zmb F)40 <Lmcg Mbbkni
Netgln nkj \crzm Actbn‗| Hbnjbt|mgp ce zmb F)40 :Ivnkfg \+ Agibkwg
Pntz GU? B}zbtknh Tbhnzgck|
Lciibkzntw
Actbn‗| Ftbbk Bkbtfw Pchglgb| nkj Ptc|pblz| :Vmnkf Occmc
Nknhw|g|
Blckcigl Giphglnzgck| ect \crzm Actbn ce zmb Lrttbkz 2Ztnk|ectinzgck gk zmb Igjjhb Bn|zMnk Dntnk
Actbn)Netgln? Bibtfgkf Cppctzrkgzgb| 2
Pmghgppb jb Pckzbz nkj Onib| Lhgezck Etnklg|
R+\+)Actbn Blckcigl Tbhnzgck|? N Ugbv etci \bcrh 5Agi Vck)awckf
Pntz U? Actbn)Lmgkn Blckcigl Tbhnzgck|
Lciibkzntw
N Kbv Pmn|b gk Lmgkn“Kctzm Actbn Tbhnzgck| 6Fctjck F+ Lmnkf
Nknhw|g|
Gkltbn|gkf Jbpbkjbklw? Kctzm Actbn‗| Blckcigl 6Tbhnzgck| vgzm Lmgkn Jgla A+ Knkzc
Actbn)Lmgkn Blckcigl Pntzkbt|mgp? =Zmb Zmgtj Lmgkn Tr|mLmbckf Wcrkf)tca nkj Hbb Lmnkf)awr
Pntz UG? Kctzm Actbn‗| Blckcigl Jbubhcpibkz nkjB}zbtknh Tbhnzgck|
Lciibkzntw Mrink Tb|crtlb| nkj Actbnk Tbrkgeglnzgck 7Kglmchn| Bdbt|znjz
Nknhw|g|
Zmb Blckcigl| ce Tbrkgeglnzgck 7Jckf Wckf)|rbkf
Hbnjgkf Blckcigl Gkjglnzct| ect Actbn >
Ndcrz ABG
ABG Njug|ctw Dcntj >
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 6/17
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 7/17
ACTBN)LMGKN BLCKCIGL TBHNZGCK\ 62
GKLTBN\GKF JBPBKJBKLW? KCTZM ACTBN‗\ BLCKCIGL TBHNZGCK\ VGZM
LMGKN
Dw Jgla A+ Knkzc
N| zmb blckciw ce zmb Jbicltnzgl Pbcphb‗| Tbprdhgl
ce Actbn dblcib| gkltbn|gkfhw g|chnzbj( gz jbpbkj|
ictb nkj ictb ck zmb Pbcphb‗| Tbprdhgl ce Lmgkn
ect |rtugunh nkj jbubhcpibkz+ Zmb PTL g| Kctzm Ac)
tbn‗| lhc|b|z nhhw1 hntfb|z ptcugjbt ce eccj( erbh( nkj
gkjr|ztgnh inlmgkbtw1 nkj ntfrndhw zmb lcrkztw ic|z
ndhb zc vgbhj gkehrbklb gk Pwckfwnkf+ Ect zmb JPTA(
Lmgkn g| zmb pntzkbt ce egt|z nkj hn|z tb|ctz+ Gz g| zmb
egt|z zc ptcugjb crz|gjb unhgjnzgck ce phnk| nkj cezbk
g| dczm egt|z nkj hn|z nz dnz gk nzzbipz| zc igzgfnzb zmb
njubt|b lck|b~rbklb| ce Kctzm Actbnk ptcuclnzgck|+
Vmbzmbt gz db mc|zgkf zmb egt|z ectbgfk ug|gz dw wcrkfAgi Ockf)rk ct ptbubkzgkf |ztckf |nklzgck| hnkfrnfb
gk n Rkgzbj Knzgck| tb|chrzgck( Dbgogkf |znkj| nz zmb
mbnj ce n |mctz hgkb ce lcrkztgb| vghhgkf zc |gjb vgzm(
ct nz hbn|z mrict( Kctzm Actbn+ Zmb PTL nh|c g| zmb
gkgzgnh nkj egknh tb|ctz ect Pwckfwnkf gk jbnhgkf vgzm
|mctznfb| ce eccj( erbh( gkub|zibkz lnpgznh( nkj blc)
kcigl b}pbtzg|b+
Lmgkn‗| Gkzbtb|z| gk zmb JPTA
Dbgogkf‗| egt|z ptgctgzw ck zmb Actbnk Pbkgk|rhn g|
|zndghgzw dczm gk zmb trhgkf tbfgib nkj gk zmb lcrkztwn| n vmchb+ Zmb akcvk |znzr| ~rc |bbi| ptbebtndhb
zc zmb ptc|pblz ce nk blckcigl ct pchgzglnh lchhnp|b
zmnz vcrhj |bkj tberfbb| ehccjgkf gkzc Lmgkn nkj
ltbnzb lckjgzgck| zmnz lcrhj gkugzb gkzbtubkzgck dw
zmb RK lchhblzgubhw ct dw \crzm Actbn ct zmb Rkgzbj
\znzb| gkjgugjrnhhw+ Kctzm Actbn nh|c |btub| n| n
dreebt nhckf pntz ce Lmgkn‗| b}zbk|gub dctjbt|+ Bubk
zmcrfm |cib Lmgkb|b mnub gkjglnzbj zmnz zmbw vcrhj
hcca vgzm enuct ck n rkgzbj Kctzm nkj \crzm Actbn(
gk tbnhgzw zmb b}g|zbklb ce n etgbkjhw nkj jbpbkjbkz
dreebt |znzb zmnz ptcugjb| |cib jg|znklb etci \crzm
Actbn tbingk| nzztnlzgub+ Fgubk zmb ptczb|z| dw Dbgogkfzc ocgkz R+\+“\crzm Actbnk knunh b}btlg|b| lhc|b zc
Lmgkn‗| b}lhr|gub blckcigl ckb( zmb ptc|pblz ce n
rkgzbj Actbn pc||b||gkf krlhbnt vbnpck|( etgbkjhw zc
zmb Rkgzbj \znzb|( nkj jgtblzhw nltc|| zmb Wnhr Tgubt
vcrhj db nknzmbin gkjbbj+
Nickf |cib ce Lmgkn‗| bhgzb( mcvbubt( zmbtb g|
ltbbpgkf jg||nzg|enlzgck vgzm zmb vnw zmnz zmb JPTA
g| dblcigkf n pntgnm |znzb zmnz cezbk vcta| nz ltc||)
prtpc|b| zc Lmgkn‗| knzgcknh gkzbtb|z|+ Lmgkn( gz|bhe(
cklb mnj nk blckcigl |w|zbi |gighnt zc zmnz gk Kctzm
Actbn+ Zmb PTL ce zmb >750| lck|g|zbj ce lchhblzgub
enti|( eccj tnzgckgkf( lbkztnh phnkkgkf( n hnla ce
intabz ptglgkf nkj gklbkzgub|( hgzzhb ztnjb ct ectbgfk
gkub|zibkz( nkj n mc|zghgzw zcvntj Vb|zbtk gjbn| nkj
ibzmcj|+ Vmghb zmg| |w|zbi ptcugjbj |rppctz ect zmb
fcubtkgkf tbfgib gk Dbgogkf( gz nh|c dtcrfmz in||
|zntunzgck( ig|frgjbj nzzbipz| zc gkltbn|b ptcjrlzgckr|gkf gkjgfbkcr| zblmkchcfw -Ftbnz Hbnp Ectvntj'(
pbtgcjgl lnipngfk| zc prtgew gjbchcfw -Lrhzrtnh
Tbuchrzgck'( nkj n lciphbzb jg|lckkblz dbzvbbk zmb
lck|ribt nkj zblmkchcfglnh tbuchrzgck| dbgkf b}pbtg)
bklbj kcz ckhw gk zmb Vb|z drz tgfmz ck gz| cvk jcct|zbp
gk Onpnk( \crzm Actbn( nkj Zngvnk+ Gk jbnhgkf vgzm
zmb JPTA( Lmgkb|b ceeglgnh| |bb n ictgdrkj blckcigl
|w|zbi ce zmb zwpb zmbw ndnkjckbj hckf nfc+
Dbgogkf mn| fgubk Agi Ockf)gh zcrt| ce gkjr|ztgnh nkj
nftglrhzrtnh |gzb| gk Lmgkn zmnz mnub dbbk zmb ecrkjn)
zgck ce Lmgkn‗| |pblznlrhnt blckcigl jbubhcpibkz(nkj Lmgkb|b hbnjbt| mnub rtfbj mgi zc cpbk zmb JPTA
blckciw ictb zc ectbgfk gkub|zibkz nkj tbecti|+
Zmb tb|pck|b dw Pwckfwnkf ceeglgnh| mn| fckb ck
jrnh ztnla|+ Ck ckb |gjb zmbw mnub lccpbtnzbj vgzm
Lmgkn ck jbubhcpgkf zmb dctjbt ntbn dbzvbbk zmb zvc
lcrkztgb| nkj ltbnzgkf gk|zgzrzgck| kblb||ntw zc nzztnlz
ectbgfk gkub|zibkz‚kcz ckhw etci Lmgkn drz etci
czmbt lcrkztgb| ce zmb vcthj+ Ck zmb czmbt |gjb ntb
pbtgcjgl nzzbipz| zc rkjc blckcigl tbecti| nkj zc tgj
zmb lcrkztw ce zmb gkehrbklb ce intabz lnpgznhg|i+
Zmb pcvbt bhgzb gk Pwckfwnkf mnub dbbk mgfmhw |r|pg)lgcr| ce intabz|( pntzhw dblnr|b zmb prdhgl jg|ztgdrzgck
|w|zbi mn| dbbk n zcch ect lcbtlgkf jb|gtbj dbmnugct+
Zmb nrzmctgzgb| nh|c ebnt zmnz n jbubhcpgkf ibtlmnkz
lhn|| vgzm gklcib kcz jbpbkjbkz ck zmb fcubtkibkz
vghh dblcib dbzzbt gkectibj nkj lckkblzbj vgzm zmb
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 8/17
65 ZMB ACTBN BLCKCIGL GK\ZGZRZB
crz|gjb vcthj+ Gz mn| zmb pczbkzgnh zc ecti n pcvbt
dn|b |bpntnzb etci zmb Lciirkg|z Pntzw+ Zmb ‘on|)
igkb tbuchrzgck’ gk Kctzm Netgln nkj zmb Igjjhb Bn|z
mn| jckb hgzzhb zc jg|ndr|b zmb tbfgib ce zmg| ebnt+
Pwckfwnkf mn| dbbk rkvghhgkf( rkzgh hnzbhw( zc fgub gz|
giptginzrt bubk zc vmnz intabz tbecti| mnub nhtbnjw
cllrttbj( jb|pgzb zmb enlz zmnz ic|z ce zmb|b intabz
tbecti| jbubhcpbj crz ce kblb||gzw n| zmb lbkztnhhw
phnkkbj blckciw gk zmb JPTA enhzbtbj+
Zmb fcubtkibkz ltnlajcvk ck vmnz gz lck|gjbt| ghhglgz
drwgkf nkj |bhhgkf ce fccj| ck intabz| b||bkzgnhhw
mn| ltgigknhgbj vmnz g| lck|gjbtbj zc db kctinh
blckcigl nlzgugzw gk ic|z lcrkztgb|+ Gk inkw tb|pblz|(
zmg| ltgigknhgnzgck prz| pcvbt dnla gkzc zmb mnkj| ce
zmb fcubtkibkz nrzmctgzgb| |gklb zmbw lnk nttb|z nkw)
ckb nz vghh ibtbhw ect drwgkf zmb kblb||gzgb| ce hgeb ct
bkfnfgkf gk ztnjb+ Mcvbubt( irlm ce zmb pcprhnzgck
mn| kc lmcglb drz zc prtlmn|b mcr|bmchj kblb||gzgb|(
pntzglrhnthw eccj nkj lccagkf |rpphgb|( ck intabz|+
Vgzmcrz intabz|( inkw ictb pbcphb gk zmb JPTA
vcrhj fc mrkftw+
Lmgkb|b hbnjbt Inc _bjckf cklb jb|ltgdbj zmb \gkc)
JPTA tbhnzgck|mgp zc db n| lhc|b n| ‘hgp| nkj zbbzm(’
drz gk inkw vnw| gz g| ictb hgab n tgfmz mnkj nkj hbez
eccz+ Zmb zvc jc kcz egz zcfbzmbt vbhh( mnub zc pbtecti
igkct lckzctzgck| zc lhn|p bnlm czmbt( nkj nz zgib| ckb
inw zmgka zmb pchglgb| ce zmb czmbt ‘|zgka+’ Gk tblbkz
wbnt|( Lmgkn mn| mnj zc tb|pckj zc zmb |nib JPTA
pchglw lwlhb zmnz mnj etr|ztnzbj czmbt lcrkztgb|+
Gk zmg| pchglw lwlhb( Pwckfwnkf fbkbtnzb| |cib
ptcuclnzgck zc fbz nzzbkzgck nkj etgfmzbk zmb vcthj+
Zbk|gck| tg|b echhcvgkf zmg| ntzgeglgnhhw fbkbtnzbj
ltg|g|( nkj Pwckfwnkf vngz| rkzgh gz nppbnt| zmnz gz|
kbfczgnzct| lnk b}ztnlz ictb ngj nkj lcklb||gck| etci
zmb Rkgzbj \znzb|( \crzm Actbn( nkj czmbt gkzbtb|zbj
lcrkztgb|+ Kctzm Actbn zmbk hnrklmb| n jgphcinzgl
lmnti ceebk|gub |rffb|zgkf znha| nkj zmb ceebtgkf ce
ptcig|b| nkj lcklb||gck| gk tbzrtk ect jbhgubtgb| ce
mrinkgzntgnk ngj nkj czmbt n||g|znklb+ Cklb zmb ngj
g| jbhgubtbj nkj lck|ribj nkj zmb vcthj zrtk| zc
czmbt g||rb|( Pwckfwnkf tbzrtk| zc ptcuclnzgck| zc
tb|zntz zmb lwlhb+ Gk zmb 40>0 ubt|gck ce zmg| pchglw
lwlhb( zmb JPTA |lctbj drhh‗|)bwb| dw mgzzgkf R+\+
lcklbtk| cubt kckptchgebtnzgck dw nkkcrklgkf gz|
rtnkgri bktglmibkz enlghgzw nkj |ztgagkf nz \crzm
Actbn‗| intabz)jtgubk blckciw nkj |blrtgzw ebnt| dw
|mbhhgkf Wbckpwbckf G|hnkj+> Bubk zmcrfm Pwckfwnkf
tbfrhnthw gfkctb| Lmgkn‗| njuglb kcz zc ptclbbj vgzm
ptcuclnzgub nlzgck|( cklb zmb nlzgck| ntb znabk( Lmgkn
g| hbez zc ebkj cee mc|zghb tbnlzgck| dw czmbt lcrkztgb|
gk ctjbt zc ptczblz gz| cvk gkzbtb|z| ce ingkzngkgkf
|zndghgzw ck zmb pbkgk|rhn+
\gklb zmb hnzb >770|( n| hckf n| Kctzm Actbn mn| dbbk
ndhb zc lckugklb Dbgogkf‗| |bkgct hbnjbt|mgp zmnz tbfgib
|zndghgzw ect zmb JPTA g| n kblb||ntw lckjgzgck ect
cubtnhh |zndghgzw ck zmb Actbnk Pbkgk|rhn( Pwckfwnkf
mn| dbbk ndhb zc lcrkz ck n lbtzngk hbubh ce blckcigl
nkj jgphcinzgl |rppctz etci Lmgkn+ N| jbpbkjbklw ck
Lmgkn mn| gkltbn|bj( mcvbubt( |cib gk Kctzm Actbn
mnub dblcib lcklbtkbj zmnz zmbw inw mnub dblcib
zcc jbpbkjbkz ck Lmgkn+ Zmbw inw db fgugkf Dbgogkf
zcc irlm hbubtnfb cubt zmbgt neengt|+ Mcvbubt( Kctzm
Actbn nh|c nppbnt| zc mnub r|bj zmb |mntbj gkzbtb|z gk
|zndghgzw zc kbrztnhgb zmb jg|njunkznfb| ce gz| ftcvgkf
blckcigl jbpbkjbklb ck Lmgkn+ Zmb ictb zmb JPTA
jbpbkj| ck Lmgkn( zmb ictb ebnterh Lmgkb|b hbnjbt|
inw db zmnz n |mntp vgzmjtnvnh ce PTL blckcigl
|rppctz lcrhj jb|zndghgb Kctzm Actbn+
Fgubk zmb gkzbtb|z| ce Lmgkn( zmb ptbebttbj |chrzgck zc
nkw ltg|g| fbkbtnzbj dw Kctzm Actbnk ptcuclnzgck|
n| njuclnzbj dw Dbgogkf mn| dbbk jgphcinlw( ct zmb
ptc|pblz zmbtbce+ N| hckf n| zmb Rkgzbj \znzb|( \crzm
Actbn( nkj czmbt| ntb znhagkf zc zmb JPTA( zmbw ntb
rkhgabhw zc znab mnt|mbt nlzgck| nfngk|z Pwckfwnkf+ Gk
njjgzgck( nkw jbhgubtgb| ce blckcigl nkj mrinkgzntgnk
ngj zc Kctzm Actbn zmnz tb|rhz etci zmb znha| lnk ckhw
mbhp zc bk|rtb |zndghgzw+ Nezbt zmb |mbhhgkf ce Wbck)
pwbckf G|hnkj( ect b}niphb( Lmgkn jgj kcz lckjbik
zmb nlzgck drz lnhhbj ect zmb lcrkztgb| pntzglgpnzgkf
gk zmb |r|pbkjbj |g})pntzw znha| zc lckubkb vmnz gz
jb|ltgdbj n| bibtfbklw lck|rhznzgck| gk Dbgogkf+4
Zmb |ztnzbfw ce Lmgkn vgzm tb|pblz zc Pwckfwnkf mn|
dbbk zc |bpntnzb blckcigl pchglw etci jgphcinlw nkj
pchgzgl|+ Vmghb ptciczgkf zmb |g})pntzw znha| n| n pnzm
>+ Nkjtbg Hnkacu( ‘Kctzm Actbn Inkrenlzrtbj Zmg| Ltg|g|(’ LKK+lci( 4: Kcubidbt 40>0( mzzp?##ntzglhb|+lkk+lci#40>0)>>)4:#cpgkgck#nkjtbg+hnkacu+actbnS>Spwckfwnkf)hbnjbt|)rtnkgri)bktglmibkz)|ztnzbfgl)pnzgbklb3S|9PI?CPGKGCK+
4+ Gnk Ocmk|ck nkj Mbhbkb Lccpbt( ‘Lmgkn \bba| Znha| zc Bn|b Actbnk Zbk|gck(’ Kbv Wcta Zgib|( 4= Kcubidbt 40>0+
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 9/17
ACTBN)LMGKN BLCKCIGL TBHNZGCK\ 66
zc tb|chugkf zmb krlhbnt ptcdhbi nkj mnhembntzbjhw
giphbibkzgkf zmb RK |nklzgck| ck Kctzm Actbn( Lmgkn
mn| dbfrk ztbnzgkf zmb kctzmbtk tbfgck ce zmb JPTA n|
ge gz vbtb nagk zc n Lmgkb|b nrzckcicr| tbfgck+
Ztnjb Jbpbkjbklw
Ndcrz mnhe ce nhh Kctzm Actbnk ztnjb g| vgzm Lmgkn+
Lmgkn ptcugjb| n intabz ect :4 pbtlbkz ce b}pctz| nkj
2< pbtlbkz ce gipctz| ce zmb JPTA -Zndhb >'+ Gk tblbkz
wbnt|( Kctzm Actbn mn| dbbk gklrttgkf n dghhgck)jchhnt
dghnzbtnh ztnjb jbeglgz vgzm Lmgkn+ Gk 40>0( zmg| jbeglgz
ce *>+> dghhgck nllcrkzbj ect zvc)zmgtj| ce zmb JPTA‗|
cubtnhh ztnjb jbeglgz ce *>+2 dghhgck+ Mcv zmg| jbeglgz g|
egknklbj g| rkakcvk( drz |cib mntj lrttbklw lcib|
etci tbigzznklb| etci Kctzm Actbnk hndct ct tbhnzgub|
cubt|bn| nkj etci lckztnlz vcta gk czmbt lcrkztgb|+
\cib gipctzbj fccj| lck|g|z ce ectbgfk ngj( ingkhw
mrinkgzntgnk n||g|znklb( pntzglrhnthw etci Lmgkn(
\crzm Actbn( nkj zmb RK+ Zmb JPTA nh|c fbkbtnzb|
mntj lrttbklw zmtcrfm ghhglgz nlzgugzgb| |rlm n| b}pctz)
gkf nti|( |bhhgkf krlhbnt zblmkchcfw( lcrkzbtebgzgkf(
nkj |bhhgkf ghhbfnh jtrf|+
N| ect blckcigl n||g|znklb( gk 4007 zmb JPTA tb)
lbgubj *5: ighhgck gk ceeglgnh jbubhcpibkz n||g|znklb
etci inoct jckct lcrkztgb| nkj irhzghnzbtnh gk|zgzr)
zgck|+ Zmg| vn| jcvk etci *404 ighhgck gk 400=
Zndhb >? JPTA Ztnjb vgzm zmb Vcthj nkj vgzm Inoct Ztnjgkf Pntzkbt|( 4002 “ >0( ighhgck| ce
jchhnt|
Wbnt 4002 4005 4006 400= 4007 40>0
Kctzm Actbnk b}pctz|
Vcthj zcznh >(6=6 4(<7= 4(202 <(44= 4(<72 4(=2:
Lmgkn :77 :5= 2=: 650 67< >(>==
\mntb -"' 46+7" >7+2" 4<+<" 4<+5" <<+>" :>+5"
\crzm Actbn <:0 240 652 7<4 7<: >(0::
\mntb -"' >7+0" 4>+6" <0+2" 4=+7" <7+0" <5+5"
Kbzmbthnkj| : <2 :4 >7 4> 7
Ib}glc 60 2: :: 4> >< :5
Kctzm Actbnk gipctz|
Vcthj zcznh <(>20 <(:=5 :(44: 2(<=0 <(54< :(<>4
Lmgkn >(0=> >(4<4 >(<74 4(0<4 >(==6 4(466
\mntb -"' <:+<" <2+<" <<+0" <6+=" 24+>" 24+="
\crzm Actbn 6>2 2>7 >(0<4 === 6:: =5=
\mntb -"' 44+6" >:+7" 4:+:" >5+2" 40+5" 40+>"
Bfwpz 0 0 0 0 4 457
Gkjgn 2: >4<n
5<7n
>(07: <>> 4==
Dnhnklb )>(<5< )>(0=7 )>(6>7 )4(>2< )>(44= )>(:26
\crtlb|? \crzm Actbnk jnzn etci Igkg|ztw ce Rkgeglnzgck( \bcrh+ Vcthj zcznh| ntb n |ri ce nhh jnzn etci tbpctzbt lcrkztgb| gk zmb
RK LCIZTNJB jnzndn|b+ Jnzn( pntzglrhnthw ect 40>0( kcz gk zmb RK jnzndn|b ntb etci Fhcdnh Ztnjb Nzhn|+
Kczb? Egfrtb| ntb kcz njor|zbj ect gkehnzgck+
n Jnzn ect Gkjgn ect 4005 nkj 4006 mnub dbbk njor|zbj ect nppntbkz ig|lcjgkf+
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 10/17
6= ZMB ACTBN BLCKCIGL GK\ZGZRZB
nkj *76 ighhgck gk 4006+< Inoct jckct| gklhrjbj zmb
Rkgzbj \znzb|( Brtcpbnk Rkgck lcrkztgb|( Kctvnw(
\vgzbthnkj( nkj Lnknjn+ Gk 4007( zmb RK ptcugjbj
*>: ighhgck gk ngj( gklhrjgkf *6 ighhgck etci zmb
Vcthj Eccj Ptcftni+ Zmb Rkgzbj \znzb| nh|c |mgppbj
*>+7 ighhgck gk mrinkgzntgnk ngj zc Kctzm Actbn gk
40>0 nkj tbpctzbj b}pctz| ce *6<=(000 ce |rlm ngj gk
Intlm 40>0+
Lmgkn‗| blckcigl n||g|znklb zc Kctzm Actbn nllcrkz|
ect ndcrz mnhe ce nhh Lmgkb|b ectbgfk ngj+ Dbgogkf ptc)
ugjb| zmb ngj jgtblzhw zc Pwckfwnkf( zmbtbdw bkndhgkf gz
zc dwpn|| zmb RK+ Ect b}niphb( gk >775 Dbgogkf nftbbj
zc ptcugjb zmb JPTA vgzm etbb nkkrnh |mgpibkz| ce
>+< ighhgck zck| ce cgh nkj 4+2 ighhgck zck| ce lcnh ect
zmb bk|rgkf egub wbnt|+: Lmgkn g| ndhb zc r|b gz| n||g|)
znklb zc Kctzm Actbn zc prt|rb gz| cvk pchgzglnh fcnh|
gkjbpbkjbkzhw ce zmb lck|ztngkz| dw czmbt lcrkztgb|+ Gz
g| vgjbhw dbhgbubj zmnz |cib Lmgkb|b eccj ngj g| znabk
dw zmb JPTA ighgzntw+2
Vgzm tb|pblz zc lciicjgzgb| ltgzglnh zc zmb Kctzm Ac)
tbnk blckciw( tbhgnklb ck Lmgkn g| ~rgzb |ztgagkf+ Gk
40>0( crz ce *5: ighhgck gk gipctz| ce lbtbnh|( Lmgkn
ptcugjbj *50 ighhgck( ct 7: pbtlbkz+ Zmb tbingkjbt ce
zmb lbtbnh gipctz| lnib etci eccj ngj etci zmb Rkgzbj
\znzb| nkj Lnknjn nkj vmnz |bbi zc db prtlmn|b| etci
lcrkztgb| |rlm n| Ratngkb nkj Zmnghnkj+
Kczb zmnz bubk zmcrfm Lmgkn b}pctzbj *420 ighhgck gk
eccj|zree| zc zmb JPTA gk 40>0( Lmgkn nh|c gipctzbj
*67 ighhgck gk eccj etci zmb JPTA+ Zmb|b gipctz|
lck|g|zbj ptgintghw ce eg|m nkj |mbhheg|m -*27 ighhgck'(
etrgz| nkj krz| -*7 ighhgck'( nkj ig|lbhhnkbcr| ftngk|
-*2 ighhgck'+ Pwckfwnkf nppntbkzhw mn| gipctzbj
n~rnlrhzrtb zblmkchcfw etci Lmgkn zc gkltbn|b ptcjrl)
zgck ce lrhzgunzbj eg|m nkj |mbhheg|m ect b}pctz+
Gk igkbtnh erbh cgh|( Lmgkn g| zmb inoct |rpphgbt zc
Kctzm Actbn+ Ltrjb cgh ehcv| zmtcrfm n pgpbhgkb etci
Hgnckgkf Ptcugklb gk kctzmbn|zbtk Lmgkn zc zmb JPTA+
Gk 40>0( zmb PTL b}pctzbj *:67 ighhgck gk igkbtnh
erbh( cgh|( nkj bhblztglgzw zc Kctzm Actbn+
N| gk czmbt ntbn| ce pchglw( Lmgkn g| vghhgkf zc r|b
nkwzmgkf gk gz| lckztch zc fngk blckcigl ct pchgzglnh
njunkznfb+ Dbgogkf mn| r|bj gz| b}pctz| ce cgh zc zmb
JPTA zc npphw ptb||rtb zc Pwckfwnkf gk inzzbt| ce
pchglw+ Gk 400< nkj gk 4005( Lmgkn vn| tbpctzbj zc
mnub zbipctntghw lrz cee zmb |rpphw ce pbztchbri zc zmb
JPTA gk tb|pck|b zc Kctzm Actbn‗| krlhbnt nkj ig|)
|ghb zb|z|+ Gk Jblbidbt 40>0( Lmgkn tbpctzbjhw nfngk
r|bj n lrzcee ce gz| cgh zmtcrfm zmb pgpbhgkb zc jg||rnjb
Pwckfwnkf etci tbznhgnzgkf nfngk|z \crzm Actbn ect
lckjrlzgkf hgub)egtb b}btlg|b| nezbt zmb Kctzm‗| ntzgh)
hbtw |mbhhgkf ce Wbckpwbckf G|hnkj+5 Mcvbubt( bubk
ge Lmgkn jgj zbipctntghw mnhz b}pctz| ce pbztchbri nz
zmnz zgib( zmb uchrib vn| injb rp hnzbt( |gklb tbpctzbj
ztnjb jnzn gkjglnzb kc jblhgkb gk b}pctz| ce ltrjb cgh ect
zmb bkzgtb ickzm ce Jblbidbt 40>0+ Lmgkn‗| b}pctz|
ce ltrjb cgh zc Kctzm Actbn gkltbn|bj dw <= pbtlbkz(
zc *<0+= ighhgck( gk Jblbidbt cubt zmnz gk Kcubidbt
40>0 nkj gkltbn|bj ertzmbt gk Onkrntw 40>>+
Zc tbjrlb gz| tbhgnklb ck Lmgkn( zmb JPTA mn| dbbk
|bbagkf czmbt gipctz |crtlb| ect bkbtfw+ Dblnr|b ce
RK blckcigl nkj egknklgnh |nklzgck|( Kctzm Actbn
zbkj| kcz zc gipctz jgtblzhw etci lcrkztgb| drz gk|zbnj
ptclrtb| ltrjb nkj tbegkbj pbztchbri zmtcrfm n kbz)
vcta ce cgh ztnjbt| nkj dnka| gk zmb Igjjhb Bn|z nkj
bh|bvmbtb+ \rlm |mgpibkz|( mcvbubt( |zghh ntb tbpctzbj
n| ctgfgknzgkf gk zmb b}pctzgkf lcrkztw+ Zmg| drwgkf
ce cgh ck gkzbtknzgcknh intabz| lcib| nz n zgib zmnz
Gkjgn g| b}pbtgbklgkf n |rtphr| gk gz| jcib|zgl |rpphw
ce tbegkbj pbztchbri nkj mn| phnlbj n lnp ck ptglb|
ect fn|chgkb zmnz inab| b}pctzgkf ictb ptcegzndhb zmnk
|bhhgkf jcib|zglnhhw+ Gk 40>0( Gkjgn b}pctzbj *<<0
ighhgck gk igkbtnh erbh cgh| -tbegkbj' zc Kctzm Actbn(
rp etci *454 ighhgck gk 4007+ Bfwpz nh|c mn| dbbk
jbbpbkgkf gz| blckcigl zgb| zc zmb JPTA+ Gk 40>0(
:+ Kglmchn| Bdbt|znjz( ‘\znzg|zglnh Dhnlacrz| gk Kctzm Actbn? Ztnjb Egfrtb| Rklcubtbj(’ Dbwckj Ztnk|gzgck( Intlm“Nptgh >77=(4>“4<+
2+ Dtnjhbw C+ Dnd|ck( ‘Zcvntj| n Pbnlberh Tb|chrzgck vgzm Kctzm Actbn? Ltnezgkf n Kbv Gkzbtknzgcknh Bkfnfbibkz Etnibvcta’-pnpbt ptb|bkzbj nz lckebtbklb lc|pck|ctbj dw zmb Nibtglnk Bkzbtptg|b Gk|zgzrzb( Actbn Blckcigl Gk|zgzrzb( nkj Actbn Gk|zgzrzbect Gkzbtknzgcknh Blckcigl Pchglw( Vn|mgkfzck( J+L+( >4“>< Ebdtrntw 400:'+
5+ \rkkw Hbb( ‘Lmgkn Lrz Cee Cgh zc \zcp K+ Actbn etci Tbznhgnzgkf nfngk|z \crzm(’ Actbn Zgib|( >7 Onkrntw 40>>+
<+ Zmb|b frtb| jc kcz gklhrjb ngj etci \crzm Actbn nkj Lmgkn+ Jnzn etci zmb Ctfnkgnzgck ect Blckcigl Lccpbtnzgck nkj
Jbubhcpibkz( Jbubhcpibkz Lccpbtnzgck Jgtblzctnzb( Jbubhcpibkz N||g|znklb Lciigzzbb‗| |znzg|zgl| jnzndn|b+
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 11/17
ACTBN)LMGKN BLCKCIGL TBHNZGCK\ 67
Bfwpz tbpctzbj |nhb| ce *452 ighhgck gk igkbtnh erbh
b}pctz| zc Kctzm Actbn+ Zcfbzmbt( Bfwpz nkj Gkjgn
|rpphw ndcrz zmb |nib nicrkz ce igkbtnh erbh zc zmb
JPTA n| jcb| Lmgkn+6
Zmb bkbtfw ztnjb dbzvbbk zmb PTL nkj zmb JPTA(
zmbtbectb( g| kcz n| ckb)|gjbj n| gz g| r|rnhhw lmnt)
nlzbtgbj+ Bubk zmcrfm zmb JPTA gipctzbj *:67 gk
igkbtnh erbh| etci zmb Lmgkn gk 40>0( zmb JPTA nh|c
b}pctzbj *<76 ighhgck gk igkbtnh erbh| zc Lmgkn‚
nhic|z nhh lcnh+
Lmgkb|b Gkub|zibkz gk zmb JPTA
Lmgkb|b gkub|zibkz gk zmb JPTA mn| dbbk dn|bj ck
lcidgkgkf Lmgkn‗| lnpgznh nkj |aghh| vgzm rkjbtr|bj
tb|crtlb| gk Kctzm Actbn zc fbkbtnzb hbfgzginzb blc)
kcigl nlzgugzw zmnz dbkbegz| dczm |gjb|+ Zmg| gkub|zibkz
mn| dbbk gkltbn|gkf jb|pgzb zmb gipc|gzgck ce blckcigl
|nklzgck| dw zmb RK+ Zmb Lmgkb|b |ztnzbfw vgzm tb|pblz
zc Kctzm Actbn tb|bidhb| zmnz znabk dbectb Mckf Ackf
tbubtzbj zc Lmgkb|b |cubtbgfkzw+ Nezbt nftbbgkf zc
zmb tbubt|gck gk >7=:( Lmgkn tblcfkgbj zmnz gz mnj n
ptcdhbi+ Zmb |znkjntj ce hgugkf vn| |c irlm mgfmbt
gk Mckf Ackf zmnz ptb||rtb zc giigftnzb( hbfnhhw ct
ghhbfnhhw( vn| lck|gjbtndhb+ Nz zmb dctjbt ltc||gkf gkzc
Mckf Ackf( Lmgkb|b frntj| mnj zc hgb jcvk db|gjb zmb
tcnj vgzm igttct| zc |bb vmbzmbt pbcphb vbtb ztwgkf
zc bkzbt Mckf Ackf dw |zcvgkf nvnw rkjbt ztrla|+
Zmb |chrzgck vn| zc tng|b zmb |znkjntj ce hgugkf gk zmb
dctjbtgkf Frnkfjckf ptcugklb dw b|zndhg|mgkf |pblgnh
blckcigl ckb|( nhhcvgkf ectbgfk gkub|zibkz( nkj
przzgkf gk phnlb untgcr| czmbt blckcigl tbecti|+ Dw
zmb zgib ce zmb ectinh tbubt|gck ce Mckf Ackf zc zmb
PTL gk >776( zmb kbntdw Lmgkb|b lgzgb| ce Frnkfmcr
nkj \mbkmbk |pctzbj mgfm)tg|b drghjgkf|( ztneegl oni|(
lbhh pmckb|( nkj inkw ce zmb nllcrztbibkz| ce icjbtk
hgeb zmnz b}g|zbj gk Mckf Ackf+
Hgabvg|b( n inoct zmtr|z ce zmb Lmgkb|b blckcigl
|ztnzbfw vgzm tb|pblz zc zmb JPTA g| zc ltbnzb nk
gkzbftnzbj gkjr|ztgnh tbfgck eclr|bj ck zmb Oghgk nkj
Hgnckgkf Ptcugklb| nkj zmb dctjbtgkf gkjr|ztgnh
ptcugklb| gk Kctzm Actbn+ Zmb phnk gklhrjb| drghjgkf
tcnj|( pntzglrhnthw ckb lckkblzgkf zmb Tnogk pctz gk
Kctzm Actbn zc lcnh igkb| nkj gkjr|ztgb| gk hnkjhclabj
Oghgk ptcugklb( giptcugkf zmb|b pctz enlghgzgb|( ltbnzgkf
n etbb ztnjb ckb ck zvc g|hnkj| gk zmb dctjbt tgubt
dbzvbbk Jnkjckf gk Lmgkn nkj \gkrgor gk zmb JPTA(
gkub|zgkf gk Kctzm Actbnk gkjr|ztgb|( nkj bubkzrnhhw
drghjgkf nk gkjr|ztgnh lciphb} |gighnt zc zmb Anb|ckf
gkjr|ztgnh lciphb}( vmglm g| cpbtnzbj dw \crzm Actbnk
lcipnkgb|+ Zmg| |ztnzbfw vn| fgubk gipbzr| gk 40>0 n|
zmb JPTA tblcfkgbj zmnz gz vn| ent dbmgkj gk gz| fcnh
ce dblcigkf n ‘|ztckf nkj ptc|pbtcr| knzgck dw 40>4’
nkj Lmgkn vn| ptbpntgkf gz| >4zm Egub Wbnt Phnk( n phnk
zmnz bipmn|gb| jbubhcpibkz nvnw etci zmb bn|z lcn|z
nkj ictb gk zmb gkzbtgct tbfgck| ce zmb lcrkztw+
Jrtgkf zmb pn|z jblnjb( Lmgkn mn| dbbk rtfgkf
Pwckfwnkf zc echhcv gz| cvk jbubhcpibkz pnzzbtk ce
tbecti( cpbkgkf( nkj tnpgj blckcigl ftcvzm( drz zmb
bubt |r|pglgcr| JPTA tbfgib mb|gznzbj zc znab |zbp|
zc tbecti zmb blckciw zmnz lcrhj hbnj zc n hcc|bkgkf
ce zmbgt ftgp ck |clgbzw+ JPTA hbnjbt|mgp bubk zcca
n jbzcrt gkzc Ugbzkni( zmgkagkf zmnz zmb Ugbzknib|b
b}pbtgbklb vgzm tbecti vn| ictb njnpzndhb zc Kctzm
Actbn‗| blckcigl lckjgzgck|+ Nezbt |bubtnh ug|gz|
zc Ugbzkni nkj ztnk|hnzgkf Ugbzknib|b fcubtkibkz
inkrnh|( hbnjbt| gk Pwckfwnkf nppntbkzhw lcklhrjbj
zmnz( nhzmcrfm Ugbzkni jgj ceebt |cib hb||ck|( tbhwgkf
ck zmb irzrnh gkzbtb|z( ptc}gigzw( egknklgnh tb|crtlb|(
nkj lnpndghgzw ce Lmgkn vn| zmbgt db|z dbz ect nlmgbugkf
zmbgt fcnh| dczm gk zmb |mctz zbti nkj gkzc zmb erzrtb+
Zmb jbubhcpibkz |ztnzbfw zmnz mn| bibtfbj nppbnt|
zc dbkbegz dczm |gjb|+ Gz g| dn|bj( egt|z( ck r|gkf zmb
tb|crtlb| nkj fbcftnpmw ce zmb JPTA zc fbkbtnzb
ictb blckcigl nlzgugzw nkj zc ptcugjb irlm)kbbjbj
gklcib ck dczm |gjb| ce zmb dctjbt+ \blckj( zmb JPTA
g| b}pblzbj kcz ckhw zc tbhw ck Lmgkn ect egknklgnh
lnpgznh nkj b}pbtzg|b drz zc nlzrnhhw nhhcv Lmgkb|b
dr|gkb||pbcphb zc inknfb lbtzngk bkzbtptg|b| nkj
nlzgugzgb|+ Zmr|( zmb JPTA vghh kbbj zc prz gk phnlb
zmb lciibtlgnh nkj ztnk|pctznzgck gketn|ztrlzrtb nkj
fcubtkibkz npptcunh ptclb|| zmnz g| kblb||ntw zc nz)
ztnlz ectbgfk gkub|zibkz kcz ckhw etci Lmgkn drz etci
czmbt lcrkztgb| ce zmb vcthj+
Zmb egt|z inoct |zbp gk zmg| |ztnzbfw g| lbkzbtbj ck vmnz
mn| dbbk zbtibj zmb Tn|ck \pblgnh Jg|ztglz+ Zmb jg|ztglz
vn| knibj nezbt zmb zvc zcvk| ce Tnogk nkj \ckdckf
gk Kctzm Actbn+ Gk >77> zmg| ntbn vn| jb|gfknzbj zc db
zmb JPTA‗| egt|z etbb ztnjb ckb( drz( rkhgab zmb Anb)
6+ Jnzn etci Rkgzbj Knzgck| Lciicjgzw Ztnjb \znzg|zgl| -RKlciztnjb'1 nkj Bfwpzgnk nkj Gkjgnk ztnjb |znzg|zgl|+
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 12/17
=0 ZMB ACTBN BLCKCIGL GK\ZGZRZB
|ckf gkjr|ztgnh lciphb}( gz kbubt lnib zc etrgzgck+ Zmb
kbv Tn|ck ptcoblz( hnrklmbj ceeglgnhhw gk Inw 40>>(
g| dbgkf jbubhcpbj nllctjgkf zc n Lmgkb|b phnk( vgzm
Lmgkb|b lcipnkgb| inknfgkf zmb gkub|zibkz| nkj
cpbtnzgck|+ Zmb jbubhcpibkz phnk lnhh| ect drghjgkf
ct rpftnjgkf tcnj| nkj pctz enlghgzgb|1 b|zndhg|mgkf
gkzbtknzgcknh etbgfmz dtcabtnfb( b}pctz ptclb||gkf(
nkj egknklgnh gk|zgzrzgck|1 nkj gkub|zgkf gk fbkbtnzgkf
bhblztglgzw( lcnh igkgkf( cgh tbegkbtgb|( inkrenlzrtgkf(
nkj zcrtg|i+ Gkgzgnhhw( bhblztglgzw g| dbgkf gipctzbj
etci Lmgkn+ Zmb Tn|ck gkjr|ztgnh lciphb} g| dbgkf
cpbtnzbj n| Lmgkb|b( nkj Lmgkb|b lcipnkgb| ntb zc
db ndhb zc mgtb Kctzm Actbnk vctabt| vmc vghh bntk
ectbgfk lrttbklw ect dczm zmbi|bhub| nkj zmb JPTA
fcubtkibkz+
Ck 40 Jblbidbt 40>0 zmb \nkfjg Frnk~rk Gkub|z)
ibkz Lcipnkw etci Lmgkn tbpctzbjhw |gfkbj n
ibictnkjri ce rkjbt|znkjgkf vgzm Pwckfwnkf‗|
Gkub|zibkz nkj Jbubhcpibkz Ftcrp gk vmglm zmb
Lmgkb|b lcipnkw nftbbj zc gkub|z *4 dghhgck gk zmb
Tn|ck \pblgnh Jg|ztglz+ Gkgzgnhhw( gz g| zc gkub|z *<00
ighhgck gk lck|ztrlzgkf n lcnh)egtbj pcvbt phnkz nz n
JPTA lcnh igkb nkj drghj n tnghvnw( tcnj|( nkj mnt)
dct| nkj pgbt| kbnt gz+ Zmb lcipnkw nh|c phnk| zc drghj
nk cgh tbegkbtw zc tbegkb ltrjb cgh gipctzbj etci zmb
Igjjhb Bn|z nkj Tr||gn nkj |bhh zmb crzprz zc Lmgkn
nkj czmbt lcrkztgb|+= Nknhw|z| |nw Kctzm Actbn mcpb|
zc zcrz zmb |rllb||erh jbubhcpibkz ce Tn|ck n| nk
nlmgbubibkz ce Agi Ockf)rk( zmb nppntbkz |rllb||ct
zc Agi Ockf)gh+7
Nkczmbt ntbn ce ocgkz jbubhcpibkz mn| dbbk zmb \gkrgor
|pblgnh blckcigl ckb+ Gz vn| dbfrk gk 4004 drz mn|
kbubt hgubj rp zc gz| pczbkzgnh+ Gz g| hclnzbj gk Kctzm
Actbn jgtblzhw nltc|| etci Jnkjckf ck zmb Lmgkb|b
|gjb( nkj zmb dtgjfb ltc||gkf zmb tgubt zmbtb g| n inoct
ntzbtw dbzvbbk Lmgkn nkj zmb JPTA+ Lmgkn mn| ptci)
g|bj zc drghj nk njjgzgcknh dtgjfb ltc||gkf zmb tgubt
zmnz vghh nh|c mnkjhb tngh ztneegl+ Zmb lrttbkz eclr| g|
ck n etbb ztnjb ckb zc db b|zndhg|mbj ck zmb Vgmvn
nkj Mrnkfogkdgkf G|hnkj| gk zmb Wnhr Tgubt |bpntnzgkf
zmb lgzgb| ce \gkrgor nkj Jnkjckf+ Lmgkn tbpctzbjhw
mn| kbfczgnzbj n >00)wbnt hbn|b ck zmb zvc g|hnkj|
nkj gkzbkj| zc gkub|z *=00 ighhgck zmbtb ect gkjr|ztgnh
jbubhcpibkz+ Vgzm hgzzhb tg|a ce pchgzglnh ‘lckznigkn)
zgck’ ce Kctzm Actbnk| etci ug|gzct| zc zmb g|hnkj|(
Lmgkb|b lgzgbk| ntb zc db nhhcvbj ug|n)etbb nllb|| zc
zmb g|hnkj|+ Zmb ngi g| zc drghj nk gkjr|ztgnh pnta ck
zmb g|hnkj| |gighnt zc zmb Anb|ckf gkjr|ztgnh lciphb}
gk Kctzm Actbn kbnt zmb dctjbt vgzm \crzm Actbn+
Lmgkn g| zmb hntfb|z ectbgfk jgtblz gkub|zct gk Kctzm
Actbn ge zmb \crzm Actbnk gkub|zibkz gk zmb Anb|ckf
gkjr|ztgnh lciphb} g| kcz lcrkzbj+ Gk 4006( zmb zcznh
ectbgfk jgtblz gkub|zibkz -EJG' gkzc zmb JPTA tb)
pctzbj zc zmb RK nicrkzbj zc *56 ighhgck( nk nicrkz
zmnz b}lhrjb| gkub|zibkz etci \crzm Actbn+ Ce zmg|(
Lmgkn |rpphgbj *>=+: ighhgck+ Gk 400=( ce n zcznh ce *::
ighhgck( Lmgkn |rpphgbj *:>+4 ighhgck+ Fgubk zmb |gb
ce zmb phnkkbj gkub|zibkz| gk zmb Tn|ck nkj \gkrgor
ptcoblz|( Lmgkn‗| jgtblz gkub|zibkz gk zmb JPTA g|
pcg|bj zc gkltbn|b jtninzglnhhw+
Ndcrz 400 Lmgkb|b lcipnkgb| cpbtnzb gk zmb JPTA(
ce vmglm =5 ntb hg|zbj ck Lmgkn‗| Igkg|ztw ce Lci)
ibtlb vbd|gzb+ Ce zmb|b lcipnkgb| gk Kctzm Actbn(
<2 ntb gk igkgkf( >> gk nftglrhzrtb nkj zgidbt( >6 gk
gkjr|ztgnh pntz| nkj inzbtgnh|( 6 gk nppntbh( : gk czmbt
lck|ribt fccj|( > gk gtck nkj |zbbh( nkj > gk nrzcic)
zgub ubmglhb| nkj pntz|+ Zmb czmbt 7 lcipnkgb| ntb gk
ztnk|pctznzgck ct ztnjgkf+>0
Lmgkn nkj Blckcigl \nklzgck|
Zmb PTL lck|zgzrzb| n hntfb fnp gk zmb lgtlhb ce
lcrkztgb| zmnz mnub npptcubj RK \blrtgzw Lcrklgh
Tb|chrzgck| >6>= nkj >=6: nkj ntb b}pblzbj zc
giphbibkz zmbi+ Lmgkn znab| n igkginhg|z npptcnlm
zc giphbibkzgkf |nklzgck| ck Kctzm Actbn+ Kctzm
Actbn lckzgkrb| zc r|b ngt nkj hnkj tcrzb| zmtcrfm
Lmgkn vgzm hgzzhb tg|a ce gk|pblzgck( nkj hr}rtw fccj|
etci Lmgkn nkj etci czmbt lcrkztgb| zmtcrfm Lmgkn
lckzgkrb zc ehcv nhic|z rkndnzbj zc Pwckfwnkf+ Gk
=+ Ac \cc)|ra( ‘Lmgkn Dnla Kctzm‗| Tn|ck Ptcoblz(’ Occkf Nkf Jnghw( 6 Onkrntw 40>>+
7+ Pnta Igk)mbb( ‘K+ Actbn‗| Tn|ck \pblgnh Jg|ztglz Lcrhj Cpbk Lcrkztw zc Lmgkn(’ Mnkawctbm -Bkfhg|m bjgzgck'( : Inw 40>>+
>0+ ‘Jgtblzctw ce PTL Bkzbtptg|b| gk Kctzm Actbn(’ Lmgkn“C\L Tbpctz gk Lmgkb|b( Bkfhg|m( >7 Nptgh >>( nunghndhb gk Cpbk\crtlb Lbkzbt( jclribkz kc+ EBN40>>0:400>5772( 40 Nptgh 40>>+
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 13/17
ACTBN)LMGKN BLCKCIGL TBHNZGCK\ =>
njjgzgck( Kctzm Actbn r|b| etckz lcipnkgb| gk Lmgkn
zc ptclrtb gzbi| rkjbt |nklzgck+>>
Zmb Lmgkb|b fcubtkibkz jgj lnklbh n ocgkz ubkzrtb
vgzm Kctzm Actbn zc ptcjrlb unknjgri -r|bj zc
zcrfmbk |zbbh nhhcw| r|bj gk ig||ghb ln|gkf|' nkj mn|
gkzbtlbpzbj n |mgpibkz ce 60 aghcftni| ce unknjgri
mgjjbk gk n ztrlahcnj ce etrgz ltc||gkf zmb dctjbt gkzc
Kctzm Actbn+>4 Lmgkn tbpctzbjhw nh|c mn| lnhhbj n
mnhz zc zmb vcta dw n Lmgkb|b gkub|zibkz lcipnkw
zc drghj enlghgzgb| ect n lcppbt igkb gk Mwb|nk vgzm
n Kctzm Actbnk ztnjgkf lctpctnzgck rkjbt blckcigl
|nklzgck|+><
Gk b}pctz| ce hr}rtw fccj|( mcvbubt( Lmgkn lhbnthw mn|
kcz jckb irlm zc |zbi zmb ehcv ce |rlm fccj| gkzc zmb
JPTA+ Lmgkn lhngi| zmnz zmb dnk g| kcz bkectlbndhb
dblnr|b zmb RK tb|chrzgck jgj kcz |pblgew vmnz fccj|
ntb lck|gjbtbj zc db hr}rtw gzbi|+ Zmb jbegkgzgck ce n
hr}rtw fccj jcb| untw dw lcrkztw( drz lbtzngk gzbi|
vcrhj |bbi cdugcr| ect gklhr|gck+ Ect b}niphb( gk
Orhw 40>0( Tnjgc Etbb N|gn tbpctzbj zmnz Agi Ockf)
gh mnj ptcugjbj >50 hr}rtw lnt| -injb gk Lmgkn' zc
jgtblzct| ce ptcugklgnh lciigzzbb| ce zmb Actbnk
Vctabt|‗ Pntzw nkj zc irkglgpnh lciigzzbb |bltbzntgb|
-mgfmbt)hbubh ceeglgnh| nhtbnjw mnj ubmglhb|'+>: \rlm
lnt| vcrhj db gklhrjbj ck n hg|z ce hr}rtw fccj| dw
nhic|z nkw lcrkztw+
Ge zmb R+\+ nkj RA jbegkgzgck| ce hr}rtw fccj| ntb
r|bj( gk 4007 lcrkztgb| zmnz tbpctz ztnjb zc zmb RK
b}pctzbj *4>4+4 ighhgck gk hr}rtw fccj| zc Kctzm
Actbn+ Lmgkn hbj zmb vnw( vgzm b}pctz| ce hr}rtw
fccj| ce *><5+> ighhgck -ic|zhw zcdnllc( lciprzbt|(
nkj lnt|'+ Dtngh b}pctzbj *<5 ighhgck -ic|zhw zcdnllc
nkj ptblgcr| |zckb|'( \gkfnpctb *47 ighhgck -ic|zhw
>4+ ‘Lmgkn Ecgh| \irffhgkf ce Ig||ghb)R|b Inzbtgnh zc Kctzm Actbn(’ Lmc|rk Ghdc( 42 Orhw 4007+
><+ ‘K+ Actbn Igkgkf Ptcoblz Drlahb| rkjbt RK \nklzgck|(’ Lmc|rk Ghdc( <0 Orhw 4007+
>:+ Agi Znb Mckf( ‘Agi Ockf)gh \mcvbt| Hcwnh| vgzm Lnt|(’ Jnghw KA ( <0 Orhw 40>0+
>>+ Jnugj Nhdtgfmz nkj Pnrh Dtnkknk( ‘Znagkf \zcla? Kctzm Actbn‗| Rtnkgri Bktglmibkz Ptcftni(’ Gk|zgzrzb ect \lgbklb nkjGkzbtknzgcknh \blrtgzw( = Clzcdbt 40>0+
*0
*>0(000(000
*40(000(000
*<0(000(000
*:0(000(000
*20(000(000
*50(000(000Czmbt
Iczct ubmglhb|
Lck|ribt bhblztckgl|
Eccj nkj dbubtnfb|
06#40>006#400706#400=06#400606#400506#4002
Egfrtb >? Lmgkb|b B}pctz| ce Hr}rtw Fccj| zc zmb JPTA( Orhw 4002“Intlm 40>>
\crtlb? Lckftb||gcknh Tb|bntlm \btuglb1 rkjbthwgkf jnzn nllb||bj zmtcrfm Fhcdnh Ztnjb Nzhn| vgzm zmb r|b ce ickzmhw Lmgkb|b ztnjb jnzn+
RK Tb|chrzgck >=6:Orkb 4007
RK Tb|chrzgck >6>=Clzcdbt 4005
*20+: ighhgck gk Jblbidbt 400=(gklhrjb| -gk ighhgck|'?
Hbnzmbt fccj| *>6+5Ntzglhb| ce ert 5+<Ltr|znlbnk|( |mbhheg|m 2+6B}btlg|b nkj pcch b~rgpibkz :+5Iczct ubmglhb| :+2Zcdnllc <+0Ecrkzngk pbk| 4+0
Ptblgcr| |zckb| >+=Zbhbug|gck|( ptcoblzct| >+2
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 14/17
=4 ZMB ACTBN BLCKCIGL GK\ZGZRZB
zcdnllc'( nkj Tr||gn *: ighhgck -ic|zhw lnt|( |cib
dbbe nkj lciprzbt|( drz kc nhlcmchgl dbubtnfb|'+
Vb|zbtk ug|gzct| zc Pwckfwnkf gk \bpzbidbt 40>0
tbpctzbj zmnz zmbtb |bbibj zc db kc |lntlgzw ce hr}rtw
fccj| gk intabz| zmbtb+ Ic|z ce zmb hr}rtw fccj|
|bbibj zc db etci Lmgkn( drz zmc|b etci Onpnk nh|c
vbtb phbkzgerh( Lhbnthw( Lmgkn mn| kcz dbbk bkectlgkf
zmb RK |nklzgck| ck hr}rtw fccj|+
N| |mcvk gk zmb echhcvgkf Egfrtb >( Lmgkb|b b}pctz|
ce hr}rtw fccj| zc zmb JPTA ehrlzrnzb dw ickzm drz
fbkbtnhhw ntb gkltbn|gkf+ Zmbtb g| n |pgab gk prtlmn|b|
gk Jblbidbt bnlm wbnt( ptb|rindhw zc |rpphw zmb
intabz ect Kbv Wbnt fgez|+
Egfrtb > |mcv| zmnz Lmgkb|b b}pctz| ce hr}rtw eccj
gzbi| mnub jgigkg|mbj lck|gjbtndhw etci *5+= igh)
hgck gk Jblbidbt 400= zc *>+> ighhgck gk Intlm
40>>+ Zmb|b gklhrjb ptbpntbj dbbe( lnugnt( ptbpntbj
|mbhheg|m( nkj nhlcmchgl dbubtnfb|+ Hgabvg|b( Lmgkb|b
b}pctz| ce lck|ribt bhblztckgl| -pbt|cknh lciprzbt|
nkj zbhbug|gck |bz|( ect b}niphb' mnub dbbk |gfkgeglnkz(
pntzglrhnthw gk 4002( 4005( nkj gk 4007( drz gk bnthw
40>> zmbw jtcppbj zc btc+ Lmgkb|b b}pctz| ce iczct
ubmglhb| ntb mgfmhw untgndhb drz ntb tg|gkf jb|pgzb zmb
|nklzgck|+ Gk 40>0( Lmgkn b}pctzbj <(>=< nrzcicdghb|
vctzm *<>+: ighhgck nkj :(0>> ztrla| vctzm *==+< igh)
hgck zc zmb JPTA+ Zmb ‘Czmbt’ lnzbfctw gk Egfrtb >
gklhrjb| zcdnllc( hbnzmbt nppntbh( mgfm)bkj zndhbvntb(
nkj lnibtn|+ Lmgkb|b b}pctz| ce zcdnllc ptcjrlz| nz
dbzvbbk *> ighhgck nkj *4+2 ighhgck pbt ickzm ntb
pntzglrhnthw gk jbinkj ntcrkj zmb Kbv Wbnt+
Giphglnzgck| ect \crzm Actbn
Zmb tnpgjhw jbubhcpgkf \gkc“Kctzm Actbnk blckcigl
tbhnzgck|mgp pc|b| |bubtnh pchglw jghbiin| ect \crzm
Actbn+ Nhzmcrfm Lmgkn mn| nhvnw| dbbk nhhgbj vgzm
zmb JPTA( gz mn| kcz dbbk rkzgh hnzbhw zmnz Pwckfwnkf
mn| dbbk vghhgkf zc icub zcvntj cpbkgkf gz| blckciw
ictb zc Lmgkb|b nkj czmbt ectbgfk gkub|zibkz nkj
zc fgub |cib mbbj zc zmb tbecti| bubk nz zmb tg|a ce
pmghc|cpmglnh ‘pchhrzgck’ zmnz lnk cllrt+
Ecrt lckehrbkz ectlb| ntb hgabhw lckztgdrzgkf zc vmnz
nppbnt| zc db n kbv |znklb gk Kctzm Actbnk pchglw+
Bnlm ce zmb|b ectlb| |bbi| zc enuct Lmgkn cubt \crzm
Actbn+ Zmb egt|z g| zmb kbbj ect Kctzm Actbn zc ebbj gz|
pbcphb nkj zc dblcib n ‘|ztckf nkj ptc|pbtcr| knzgck
dw 40>4+’ Bubk vgzm crz|gjb gkub|zibkz( zmg| g| rk)
hgabhw zc cllrt( drz Lmgkb|b gkub|zibkz nkj blckcigl
lccpbtnzgck vghh mbhp+ Ckb ce zmb hb||ck| Pwckfwnkf
mn| hbntkbj etci zmb Anb|ckf gkjr|ztgnh lciphb} g|
zmnz gz g| n ‘ickbw inlmgkb’ zmnz ir|z tbingk gk cpbtn)
zgck tbfntjhb|| ce pchgzglnh nkj |blrtgzw jg|przb| vgzm
\crzm Actbn+ Kcv Lmgkn g| ck znp zc ltbnzb n |blckj
ickbw inlmgkb gk zmb Kctzm+
\blckj( zmb jg|n|ztcr| lrttbklw tbecti ce Kcubidbt
nkj Jblbidbt 4007( nzzbipz| zc tchh dnla zmb cpbtn)
zgck ce intabz|( nkj czmbt tblgjgug|z pchglgb| inknfbj
zc nkfbt kcz ckhw zmb bubt)|reebtgkf kckbhgzb| gk Kctzm
Actbn drz zmb bhgzb| zcc+ Zmbw |nv zmb lrttbklw tbecti
n| n ibnk| zc lckeg|lnzb vbnhzm+ Gz g| kc vckjbt zmnz
zmb ntlmgzblz ce zmg| pchglw vn| b}blrzbj nkj mg| tbhn)
zgub| nttb|zbj+ Zmb|b dczlmbj nzzbipz| nz tbecti( phr|
zmb ug|gz| dw Agi Ockf)gh zc Lmgkn gk 40>0 nkj 40>>(
|bbibj zc cpbk zmb vnw ect Lmgkn zc fngk vgjbt nllb||
zc zmb Kctzm Actbnk blckciw nkj zc ptclbbj vgzm
vmnz \crzm Actbn mn| dbbk mnipbtbj gk nllciphg|m)
gkf dblnr|b ce pchgzglnh nkj |blrtgzw lck|gjbtnzgck|+
Zmb JPTA kcv mn| kc lmcglb drz zc tbhw ck Lmgkn
zc mbhp drghj gz| gkjr|ztgb| nkj n||g|z gz blckciglnhhw+
Pwckfwnkf kcv ir|z tbnhgb zmnz gz| nzzbipz| nz zrtk)
gkf dnla zmb lhcla ck intabz| ntb erzghb nkj zmnz gz|
db|z dbz ect dblcigkf n |ztckf nkj ptc|pbtcr| knzgck
g| zc njcpz ictb ce zmb |nib tbecti| zmnz ztnk|ectibj
zmb Lmgkb|b blckciw+
Zmgtj( Lmgkn |bbi| zc db hclagkf rp |rpphgb| ce knzr)
tnh tb|crtlb| gk zmb JPTA+ Nhzmcrfm gz g| kcz lhbnt
vmnz ptglb Lmgkb|b lcipnkgb| ntb pnwgkf ect nllb||
zc zmb|b tb|crtlb|( zmb PTL g| tnpgjhw dblcigkf zmb
ickcp|ckg|z drwbt+ Dw zmb zgib \crzm Actbn g| gk n
pc|gzgck zc znp zmb|b tb|crtlb|( gz inw egkj zmb lmcglb
|rpphgb| ntb nhtbnjw znabk+
Ecrtzm( \crzm Actbn mn| nhvnw| n||ribj zmnz erzrtb
tbrkgeglnzgck vghh dtgkf n ibtfgkf ce zmb zvc blckc)
igb| nkj n tbctgbkznzgck zcvntj bnlm czmbt+ Mcvbubt(
zmb hntfb bzmkgl Actbnk pcprhnzgck gk zmb Lmgkb|b
ptcugklb| nhckf zmb dctjbt vgzm zmb JPTA gk lci)
dgknzgck vgzm nzzbipz| nz ictb blckcigl gkzbftnzgck
lcrhj ibnk zmnz ftnjrnhhw zmb kctzmbtk pntz| ce zmb
JPTA vghh dblcib |c ctgbkzbj zcvntj Lmgkn zmnz(
gk nk blckcigl |bk|b( zmbw lcrhj dblcib nhic|z hgab
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 15/17
ACTBN)LMGKN BLCKCIGL TBHNZGCK\ =<
nk nrzckcicr| Lmgkb|b tbfgck+ Bubk ge zmnz jcb| kcz
cllrt( gz vghh hb||bk zmb ptb||rtb zc tbrkgzb vgzm \crzm
Actbn+
Jgla A+ Knkzc g| n |pblgnhg|z gk gkjr|ztw nkj ztnjb -|b)
kgct hbubh' nkj ectibt mbnj ce dczm zmb Gkzbtknzgcknh Ztnjb nkj Egknklb \blzgck nkj zmb N|gn \blzgck nz zmbLckftb||gcknh Tb|bntlm \btuglb ce zmb Hgdtntw ce Lck)
ftb||+ Mb vcta| ptgintghw ck R+\+ gkzbtknzgcknh ztnjbnkj knklb nkj ck R+\+ blckcigl tbhnzgck| vgzm N|gn+
Mb tblbgubj mg| I+N+ nkj Pm+J+ jbftbb| gk blckcigl| etci Mntuntj Rkgubt|gzw nkj nk I+\+ jbftbb etci zmb Knzgcknh Vnt Lchhbfb gk knzgcknh |blrtgzw |zrjgb|+ Mbmn| prdhg|mbj kribtcr| ocrtknh ntzglhb|( tbpctz|( nkj lmnpzbt| gk dcca|+
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 16/17
8/3/2019 Increasing Dependency: North Korea’s Economic Relations With China
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/increasing-dependency-north-koreas-economic-relations-with-china 17/17
Actbn Blckcigl Gk|zgzrzb
>=00 A \ztbbz( K+V\rgzb >0>0
Vn|mgkfzck J+L+( 40005
Njjgzgcknh Lciibkzntw nkj Nknhw|g|
Actbn? Blckcigl Ptc|pblz| nkj Lmnhhbkfb| nezbt zmbFhcdnh Tblb||gck
Nlmgbubibkz| gk \bcrh nkj Actbn‗| Tchb gk zmb F)40
Netgln nkj \crzm Actbn‗| Hbnjbt|mgp ce zmb F)40
Actbn‗| Ftbbk Ftcvzm \ztnzbfw? N Vn|mgkfzck Pbt|pblzgub
Nk Clbnk gk Ztcrdhb( Nk Clbnk ce Cppctzrkgzw
\w|zbi Ntlmgzblzrtb ect Beeblzgub Ftbbk Egknklb gk Actbn
Blckcigl Giphglnzgck| ect \crzm Actbn ce zmb LrttbkzZtnk|ectinzgck gk zmb Igjjhb Bn|z
Actbn)Netgln? Bibtfgkf Cppctzrkgzgb|
R+\+)Actbn Blckcigl Tbhnzgck|? N Ugbv etci \bcrh
N Kbv Pmn|b gk Lmgkn“Kctzm Actbn Tbhnzgck|
Gkltbn|gkf Jbpbkjbklw? Kctzm Actbn‗| Blckcigl Tbhnzgck|vgzm Lmgkn
Zmb Blckcigl| ce Tbrkgeglnzgck
Mrink Tb|crtlb| nkj Actbnk Tbrkgeglnzgck
Actbn)Lmgkn Blckcigl Pntzkbt|mgp? Zmb Zmgtj Lmgkn Tr|m
\bhblzbj Lciibkzntw
Actbn nkj zmb Vcthj BlckciwL+ Etbj Dbtf|zbk( Pbzbt|ck Gk|zgzrzb ect Gkzbtknzgcknh Blckcigl|
Actbn‗| Lmnhhbkfb| nkj Cppctzrkgzgb| gk 40>>Lmnb Vcca( Actbn Gk|zgzrzb ect Gkzbtknzgcknh Blckcigl Pchglw
N Tbehblzgck ck zmb \bcrh \riigzPnrh Uchlabt( Ectibt Lmngtink ce zmb Ebjbtnh Tb|btub
Zmb F)40? Nlmgbubibkz| nkj Lmnhhbkfb|\nAckf Gh( Actbn Gkzbtknzgcknh Ztnjb N||clgnzgck
Actbnk Ftbbk Ftcvzm gk n Fhcdnh Lckzb}zMnk \brkf)|cc( Fhcdnh Ftbbk Ftcvzm Gk|zgzrzb
Actbn‗| Ftbbk Bkbtfw Pchglgb| nkj Ptc|pblz|Vmnkf Occmc( Actbn Gk|zgzrzb ce Bkbtfw Tb|bntlm