Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

15
Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs CORE Conference IV Berlin, June 15-16, 2009 Dr. Marian Deblonde, Dr. Ann Crabbé, Dr. Anne Bergmans University of Antwerp www.openraam.eu

description

Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs. CORE Conference IV Berlin, June 15-16, 2009 Dr. Marian Deblonde, Dr. Ann Crabbé, Dr. Anne Bergmans University of Antwerp. A short introduction…. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Page 1: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in

Flemish SMEs

CORE Conference IVBerlin, June 15-16, 2009

Dr. Marian Deblonde, Dr. Ann Crabbé, Dr. Anne BergmansUniversity of Antwerp

www.openraam.eu

Page 2: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

A short introduction…

Open window on innovative materials technology for a sustainable Flemish production landscape A project in the service of the Flemish production

industry… … to stimulate more sustainable products and production

processes via the application of materials technology

December 1, 2008 – November 30, 2010

Funded by the European Fund for Regional Development

www.openraam.eu

Page 3: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Project partners

Sirris: knowledge centre of the Belgian technological industry

University of Antwerp: two research groups with expertise in technology assessment, inter- en transdisciplinarity, SD, participatory methods, philosophy and sociology of science

K.U. Leuven – MRC: interfaculty materials research centre, interface between materials technology and technology research groups of the K.U.Leuven

VITO: Flemish Institute for Technological Research

www.openraam.eu

Page 4: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Project plan: creating a funnel

www.openraam.eu

workshops

diffusion

business cases

opportunity-scans

Implementation courses

scans implementations

interviews

testimonies

Page 5: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Four steps

1/ Creation of testimonies (Qualitative) interviews (Quantitative) mini-survey

2/ Workshops: diffusion + mobilisation

3/ Opportunity scan: development + application

4/ Definition of implementation courses

www.openraam.eu

Page 6: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

Interviews 7 enterprises

Workshop « Solutions for tomorrow. Towards sustainable product

innovations » Tuesday, May 26 Co-organised by OVAM, Flanders In Shape, Euregio Platform

for Sustainable Design and living (EPSD), ‘OpenWindow’ 7 tracks 2 ‘OpenWindow’ tracks

track 5: presentation of business cases Track 7: incentives and hindrances (10 enterprises, 10

intermediary organisations

www.openraam.eu

Page 7: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

Main reasons for introducing materials innovations Economic

Cost savings Using less raw materials Dumping less waste Reusing waste as raw material Elimination of highly skilled labour

Competitive advantages Products with better functional features Cheaper products or production processes Products better adapted to regulatory context of clients Products or production processes respond better to sustainability

expectations

www.openraam.eu

Page 8: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

Secondary reasons for introducing materials innovations Social

CSR‘As owner of this enterprise, I think I also can educate my employees. When we

introduce a project to collect paper and cardboard, than we do this not only because of considerations of cost savings, but also because we are aware of the impacts this will have on future generations ’.

Image‘Yes, we have the intention to apply for an ISO 14 000 certificate next year. […].

We want to create a distinct profile of ourselves with this certificate’.

Ecological …

www.openraam.eu

Page 9: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

SD impacts Ecological

Clear impacts ‘We provide components for machines that are 20 -30 % more compact, smaller,

lighter. […] When you link lighter components with savings in fuels over 20-30 years that this entails—for instance, in aviation—then you will notice how much it contributes to sustainability’.

Ambiguous impacts‘Suppose that you put 300 suitcases in an aeroplane and that each suitcase is 1

kg lighter… [But] if people load their suitcases with one additional kg…’.

Questionable impacts‘It induces a bit of automation. In this sense, you can say: it replaces man power,

because you do not need that specialized craftsman anymore, to make a milling cutter programme, for example.’

www.openraam.eu

Page 10: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

SD impacts Economic

Clear impacts‘Plus, as I say, if you do not need to get the components of your car from India or

China, then you can save all the back and forth transport costs’.

Ambiguous impacts ‘We do not expect something spectacular with respect to cost savings. Cost-

benefit analysis will, moreover, depend on market evolutions. Prices of raw materials are decreasing for the moment…’.

Impacts in the long run Social

Some examples Employees’ pride Employment Working conditions

www.openraam.eu

Page 11: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

Preliminary conclusions Main reasons for introducing materials innovations

Economic > CSR and Image > Ecological The SD impacts of materials innovations vary Clear SD impacts occur in case considerable reductions in

use of raw materials/energy/waste production occur (ecological benefits // economic benefits)

The SD assessment perspective is a corporate perspective impacts within the firm, within the immediate surroundings of

the firm, or within the business network of the firm The SD perspective takes actual, Western lifestyles as a

starting point<-> globalizing world <-> vision on a sustainable future.

www.openraam.eu

Page 12: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

Main hindrances (1) No clear insights in SD impacts of materials innovations

No shared interpretation of SD Sensitizing initiatives are needed

a. To create a shared and substantiated interpretation of SD both with employees, customers, consumers

b. to stimulate a switch in customers’ mental frames so that they consider their part in production chains from the perspective of the whole chain and from an SD perspective

c. to induce a common SD drive within society.

Assessment methods are too expensive Information from databases and at knowledge centres is not

easily obtained

www.openraam.eu

Page 13: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

First results

Main hindrances (2) No clear insights in opportunities for co-operation between

enterprises Increasing complexity of products

Prevents an adequate management of the recycling system Induces new and uncertain risks

www.openraam.eu

Page 14: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Conclusions (1)

Appropriate economic conditions are most important to realize more sustainable materials innovations To make sure that ecological advantages imply at the

same time economic advantages

An important hindrance for the introduction of more sustainable materials innovations relates to lacking knowledge with regard to the possibilities and SD performance of

actual and possible products and production processes With regard to opportunities for co-operation between

enterprises

www.openraam.eu

Page 15: Incentives and hindrances for sustainable materials innovations in Flemish SMEs

Conclusions (2)

Materials innovations can contribute to an increasing complexity of products Challenge to management of recycling systems Introduction of new, uncertain risks

The non-existence of a socially shared and mobilizing interpretation of the concept of SD is another important hindrance

In the context of Flemish SMEs, the CSR concept seems to be more relevant in theory than in entrepreneurial practice.

www.openraam.eu