IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)

I.A. No. of 2016In

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4347 OF 2014

IN THE MATTER OF

State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. ………...PETITIONERSVERSUS

Shiv Kumar Pathak .…….RESPONDENTS

AND

IN THE MATTER OF:

1. Satya Kumar S/o Parasu Ram R/o Village- Siraichnow Post-

Jarauli Newada, District- Hardoi- 241403, U.P.

2. Murli Dhar Sharma S/o Munnalal Sharma R/o 2, Shubash

Nagar, Panchampurawa Road, District- Sitapur, U.P.

3. Vipin Kumar Mishra S/o Shiv Kumar Mishra R/o 137

Narayan Nagar, Shahjahanpur Road, Hempurwa,

District- Sitapur, U.P.

4. Alka Srivastava D/o Pankaj Kumar Srivastava, R/o 114,

Lohar Bagh, District- Sitapur, U.P.

5. Praveen Kumar Mishra S/o Ram Chandra Mishra R/o

Village- Bhat Purwa, Post- Bachhawal, District- Sitapur,

U.P.

6. Amit Banswar S/o Ram Nath Verma R/o 24, Kathali Bagh,

Sitapur, U.P.

7. Komal Shukla D/o Badshah Shukla R/o Agnihotri Nagar,

Garhi near Idea Tower Post- Midania District- Lakhimpur

Khiri, U.P.

8. Mohammad Aroon S/o Mubarak Ali R/o Village

Lodhpurwa, Post- Bawdhiya Kalan District- Sitapur, U.P.

9. Brijesh Kumar Shukla S/o Bangali Prasad R/o Village-

Allipur, Post- Jar, District- Sitapur, U.P.

10. Rajesh Kumar Mishra S/o Ramesh Chandra Mishra R/o

M.N. 106, Police Line Paraid, Jail Road, District- Sitapur,

U.P.

11. Rishi Mishra S/o Sudhir Mishra R/o Naimishpuram,

Naipalpur, District- Sitapur, U.P.

12. Rachna Bajpai D/o Arvind Kumar Bajpai R/o

Naimishpuram, Naipalpur, District- Sitapur, U.P.

13. Priya Mishra D/o Karuna Sankar Mishra R/o Sandhya

Sadan, Baragaon Moholi, District- Sitapur, U.P.

14. Om Prakash Singh S/o Chhavi Nath Singh R/o Village-

Kamalpur, Post- Kutubnagar, District- Sitapur, U.P.

15. Rajesh Kumar Dixit S/o Krishna Dutt Dixti R/o Village-

Harni Post- Keshavpur District- Sitapur, U.P.

16. Ram Pratap Singh S/o Shatrohan Prasad R/o Village

Takela Post- Karsyora, District- Sitapur, U.P.

17. Anil Kumar S/o Than Singh R/o Village- Baghulyai Post-

Mohammadabad, District- Auraiya-206241, U.P.

18. Lalit Kumar Verma S/o Pramod Kumar R/o Village Takela

Post- Karsewra, District- Sitapur, U.P.

19. Pankaj Kumar Sharma S/o Sarvesh Kumar Sharma R/o

Village and Post- Miaun District- Baddun, U.P.

20. Dileep Kumar Singh S/o Ram Narayan Singh R/o Village-

Baherava, Post- Arthapur, District- Sitapur, U.P.

21. Amit Mishra S/o Umesh Mishra R/o Sardar form Durga

Purva, District- Sitapur, U.P.

22. Lalit Mohan Gupta S/o Rajendra Prasad Gupta R/o Village

and Post- Talgaon District- Sitapur, U.P.

23. Savitri Singh D/o Surendra Singh R/o 124, Adda

Nurakhan Sirajamao, District- Etwah, U.P.

24. Ashok Kumar Shukla S/o Ram Kanth Shukla R/o 334,

Budhnagar, Hussainganj, District- Sitapur, U.P.

25. Alok Kumar Shukla S/o Ram Kanth Shukla R/o 334,

Budhnagar, Hussainganj, District- Sitapur, U.P.

26. Sandeep Kumar S/o Sewak Ram R/o Village- Kureli Post-

Pipargaon, District- Farrukkabad, U.P.

27. Alok Tiwari S/o Baikunth Nath Tiwari R/o Village- Kureli

Post- Pipargaon, District- Farrukabad, U.P.

28. Rama Singh D/o Ravi Pratap Singh R/o 538 K 1444 Shri

Puram Triveni Nagar-3, Lucknow, U.P.

29. Ram Babu Mishra S/o Ashok Kumar Mishra R/o Village

and post- Daranagar, District- Sitapur, U.P.

30. Rajneesh Pratap S/o Munna Lal Rathor R/o 294, Durga

Purwa, Sitapur, U.P.

31. Seema Singh D/o Arvind Kumar Singh R/o Village-

Babauna, Post- Mitauli, District- Lakhimpur Kheri, U.P.

32. Abbas Zaidi S/o Mohd. Abbas Zaidi R/o Village and Post-

Vadhaiya, District- Lakhimpur Khiri, U.P.

33. Ram Singh Yadav S/o Chhatra Pal Yadav R/o Village-

Periya Kodar, Post- Machhreath, District- Sitapur, U.P.

34. Niharika Pandey D/o Pankaj Pandey R/o H.N. 97 A Moh.

Shbash Nag District- Shajahanpur, U.P.

35. Praveen Kumar S/o Arun Kumar R/o Village Shabajpur,

Post- Hanumanganj, District- Allahabad, U.P.

36. Saroj Singh S/o Lallu Singh R/o Village- Prayagpur

Chhapra, Sohnag Salempur, District- Deoria, U.P.

37. Ajay Kumar Srivastava S/o Anil Kumar Srivastva R/o

Moh. Bhikhpura Post- Sikandarpur, District- Ballia-

277303, U.P.

38. Amresh Kumar Verma S/o Hira Lal Verma R/o Village-

Ganj Kishor, Post- Chetankishor, District- Ballia- 277303,

U.P.

39. Rajneesh Verma S/o Hans Nath Verma R/o Village- Duha,

Post- Dudhabihara, District- Ballia, 221717, U.P.

40. Pritam Baboo Chauhan S/o Jay Ram Chauhan R/o

Village- Manikpur, Post- Gahami, District- Mau- 221705,

U.P.

41. Bhuwal S/o Shyama Yadav R/o Village- Nausemar, Post-

Kopaganj, District- Mau- 275305, U.P.

42. Dinesh Kumar Singh S/o Ram Kailash Singh R/o Village-

Sarai Mahmajiya, Post- Bhopatpur, District- Allahabad,

U.P.

43. Kaushlesh Singh S/o Raj Bahadur R/o Village and Post-

Jagatpur, District- Allahabad, U.P.

44. Abhishek Kumar Srivastava S/o Ram Kumar Srivastava

R/o Dwarikapuri Oppsite Krishna Takij, Post- Lakhimpur,

District- Lakhimpur, PIN-262701, U.P.

45. Rajni Mishra D/o R.D. Mishra R/o 210 Santoshnagar

Colony Post-Lakhimpur, District- Lakhimpur, PIN 262701,

U.P.

46. Jaya shukla D/o Vinod Shankar Shukla R/o Village and

Post Khamaila District- Kanpur Dehat, PIN-209302 U.P.

47. Kamal Kant S/o Brij Mohan Verma R/o Yogendra Vihar

Khandepur Naubasta District-Kanpur, PIN-208021, U.P.

48. Ajay Kumar Hans S/o Chet Ram Hans R/o H. No. 220, B-

Block Ambedkar Nagar Loharbagh, District- Sitapur, PIN-

261001, U.P.

49. Mahfooz Alam S/o Mohd. Habib R/o Islam Bagh Sekh

Sarai Near Sitapur City Station District- Sitapur PIN-

261001.

50. Mohd. Ishaq S/o Ali Ahamad R/o 346 Butts Ganj Near

Bandh, District- Sitapur, PIN 261001, U.P.

51. Priyanka Singh D/o Shiv Kumar Singh R/o 109 New Gwal

Mandi Post- Sitapur, District- Sitapur, PIN- 261001, U.P.

52. Rehan Ahmad Khan S/o Irfan Ahmad Khan R/o 211,

Mirdahi Tola City Station Road District- Sitapur, PIN-

261001, U.P.

53. Sajid Ali S/o Waris Ali R/o Hazi Ready Made Moh- Katra

Laharpur District- Sitapur PIN-261135, U.P.

54. Ram Das S/o Ram Swaroop R/o V-Khandheriya Post-

Bansa District- Hardoi, PIN 241303, U.P.

55. Mamta Mishra D/o Raj Kumar Mishra R/o Moh- Krishna

Nagar District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

56. Vikas Mishra S/o Raj Kumar Mishra R/o Moh- Krishna

Nagar District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

57. Parvej Ekbal S/o Liyakat Hussain R/o 64, Fattan Sarain

Manni Chauraha District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

58. Abhishek Mishra S/o Karuna Shanker Mishra R/o 509,

Sanjay Nagar District- Sitapur PIN-261001, U.P.

59. Madhu Shanker Mishra S/o Ajay Kumar Mishra R/o

148/10 Narrottam Nagar Pani Tanki Road Sidhuli

District- Sitapur, U.P.

60. Sanjai Kumar S/o Shitala Prasad R/o H.N. 83/164 A, Juhi

Param Purwa Post- Juhi District – Kanpur, PIN 208014,

U.P.

61. Kalpana Singh D/o Ram Naresh Singh R/o Azad Nagar

Colony, District- Sitapur, U.P.

62. Priti Pandey D/o Anil Kumar Pandey R/o M. No. 788

Narmal Tiraha Pandey Hatha Road, Turkmanpur,

District- Gorakhpur, U.P.

63. Atul Kumar S/o Ram Kumar R/o 243, Ghuramou Bangla

District- Sitapur, PIN 261001, U.P.

64. Dharmendra Kumar S/o Sankta Prasad R/o Vill- Kaima

Bujurg Post- Karanpur, District- Lakhimpur Kheri, U.P.

65. Sanjay Gupta S/o Bicharan Lal Gupta R/o Village

Gondhiya Post- Parariya Tola District- Lakhimpur Kheri

PIN-262901, U.P.

66. Devendra Kumar S/o Chandra Bhal R/o Vill-Jaitapur Post-

Kaimahra District- Lakhimpur Kheri, PIN- 262701, U.P.

67. Dinesh Kumar Gautam S/o Sunder Lal R/o Moh-Hathipur

Koriyana, H. No. 2042, District- Lakhimpur Khiri PIN-

262701, U.P.

68. Jag Jiwan Ram S/o Ram Lal R/o Moh- Gomti Nagar Ward-

2, Ramnagar District- Lakhimpur Khiri, PIN-262701, U.P.

69. Vijay Prakesh S/o Hajaree Lal R/o Village- Phool Behar,

District- Lakhimpur Kheri PIN- 261506, U.P.

70. Mohammad Afzaal S/o Mohammad Ayyub R/o Moh-Katra

Azadnagar, Post- Laharpur District- Sitapur, U.P.

71. Mukesh Kumar S/o Hetpal Singh R/o Village Nagla Gariba

Post- Barat Kalyanpur, Awagarh, District – Etah, PIN-

207301, U.P.

72. Anil Kumar S/o Deen Dayal R/o H.No. 192 Prem Nagar

Etah District- Etah PIN-207001, U.P.

73. Amitosh Tiwari S/o Banvir Prasad R/o Veer Prasad Ashok

Nagar, Nidholi Road Etah District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

74. Naveen Chhauhan S/o Ravendra Singh Chauhan R/o 10-

Shrinagar Gali No-2, Nidholi Road District- Etah, PIN-

207001, U.P.

75. Prashant Gupta S/o Suresh Chandra Gupta R/o H.No.

199, Prem Nagar, Behind of Chaprai House, Etah,

District- Etah, PIN – 207001, U.P.

76. Girish Chandra Verma S/o Tara Chandra Verma R/o H.

No. 36 Nai Basti City Kotwali Etah District- Etah PIN-

207001, U.P.

77. Ramesh Chandra S/o Duryodhan Singh R/o Village-

Dattapur Post- Ishara District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

78. Sachin Kumar Gupta S/o Mahesh Chandra Gupta R/o

Village and Post- Bhagipur Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

79. Jai Prakash S/o Ganpati Singh R/o Village- Post –

Bhagipur Thana- City Kotwali District- Etah- PIN- 207001,

U.P.

80. Brajesh Kumar S/o Sujan Singh R/o Village-Post Akbarpur

Aunchha District- Mainpuri, PIN-205263, U.P.

81. Tejendra Kumar S/o Thakur Das R/o Village & Post-

Rarpatti District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

82. Sunil Kumar S/o Ranveer Singh R/o Moh-Yadav Nagar

Soron Gate Kasganj District- Kasganj PIN-207123, U.P.

83. Ashok Kumar S/o Tej Singh R/o Village- Post Neorai

District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

84. Reena Kumari D/o Roop Kishor R/o Village- Bakshipur

Post- Rajpur, District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

85. Balbeer Singh S/o Sobran Singh R/o Village Bakshipur,

Post- Rajpur, District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

86. Manish Tomar S/o Dharmendra Tomar R/o 331 Mayur

Vihar, Sahawar Road, Etah, District- Etah, PIN 207001,

U.P.

87. Asheesh Gupta S/o Dinesh Chandra Gupta R/o 242,

Sunder Lal Street, Patiyali Gate, District- Etah, PIN-

207001, U.P.

88. Hasan Imam S/o Naushad Husain R/o 17/128, Ram

Narain Bazar, District- Kanpur Nagar, PIN-208001, U.P.

89. Akhilesh Agrahari S/o Jiyalal Agrahari R/o 57/1, Sirki

Mohal Chauraha, District- Kanpur, PIN 208001, U.P.

90. Sandeep Kumar Yadav S/o Arvind Kumar Yadav R/o 139,

Adarsh Vihar, 80 Feet Road, Infront of Sundari Nath

Mandir, Post- New Pac District- Kanpur, PIN- 208015,

U.P.

91. Ritu Rani D/o Hari Krishan Gupta R/o Khajuri, Akbarpur,

Post-Khas Saharanpur, District- Saharanpur, PIN-247001,

U.P.

92. Priyana D/o Brahmpal Singh R/o Village- Sadiyapur, Post-

Agri, District-Bijnor, PIN-246701, U.P.

93. Prerna D/o Madan Singh R/o Village- Faridpur Uddu Near

Chandpur Ki Chungi, Post- Bijnor, District- Bijnor, PIN-

246701, U.P.

94. Deepika Shakya D/o Om Prakesh Shakya R/o Moh. Lukari

Darwaja Post- Aliganj, District- Etah, PIN- 207247, U.P.

95. Netrapal Singh S/o Lakshman Singh R/o Village-

Mohanpur, Post- Barnahal District- Mainpuri, PIN-

205261, U.P.

96. Suchi Pandey S/o Anil Kumar Pandey R/o Village-Dhirauli

Pandey, Post- Shankapur, District- Basti, PIN-272129,

U.P.

97. Abhishek Pandey S/o Rajesh Kumar Pandey R/o Moh-

Mevatiyan, Gonda, District- Gonda, PIN-271001, U.P.

98. Rama Verma D/o Siyaram Verma R/o Village- Post

Hardaspur, District-Bar, PIN-243303, U.P.

99. Rajesh Kumar S/o Ashok Kumar Pal R/o Kishanpur Rama

Nursingh Home Ramghat Road, District- Aligarh, PIN-

202001, U.P.

100. Anoop Verma S/o Suresh Chandra Verma R/o Village and

Post- Basara District- Sitapur, U.P.

101. Satyam Verma S/o Shravan Kumar Verma R/o 607,

Holinagar Post- Sitapur, District- Sitapur, PIN-261001,

U.P.

102. Sarita Yadav S/o Vijay Pal Singh R/o Kakaji Ki Gali Post-

Gokul District-Mathura, PIN- 281303, U.P.

103. Neetu Chaudhary S/o Gajendra Singh Chaudhary R/o

495 Atal Vihar Dhauli Pvau District- Mathura, PIN-

281001, U.P.

104. Brij Mohan S/o Nekram R/o Village- Thana, Post- Sonkh

Khera District- Mathura, PIN-281308, U.P.

105. Hari Om S/o Durga Prasad R/o Village- Ram Nagla, Post-

Gangchaoli District- Hathras, PIN-204101, U.P.

106. Ramhari Singh S/o Devki Nandan Singh R/o Village and

Post- Neemgaon Via Raya, District- Mathura, PIN-

281204, U.P.

107. Kamlesh Kumar S/o Shyamlal Maurya R/o Village-

Bhanipur Post- Balolpur District- Pratapgarh, PIN-

230131, U.P.

108. Preeti Singh S/o Durgesh Kumar Singh R/o Village and

Post- Vishnoharpur District- Gonda, PIN-271203, U.P.

109. Pramod Kumar S/o Chandra Mani Prasad R/o Village-

Belwa Bujurg Post- Belwa Babu District- Gorakhpur, U.P.

110. Naveen Kumar S/o Suresh Chandra Gupta R/o 46,

Motiganj, Bharthana District- Etawah, PIN-206242, U.P.

111. Jitendra Singh S/o Prakash Chandra R/o 20, Bajpai Nagar

Near Railway Bridge Bharthana, Distirct- Etawah PIN-

206242, U.P.

112. Devesh Kumar S/o Om Prakash Yadav R/o Village-

Mudaina Post- Baghaipur, District Etawah, PIN-206241,

U.P.

113. Aradhana Shukla D/o Deep Chandra Shukla R/o 89 ‘C’

Block Shyam Nagar, District- Kanpur, PIN- 208013, U.P.

114. Ranjeet Singh S/o Surendra Pratap Singh R/o Village-

Bawanpura, Post- Merhan District- Chandauli, PIN-

232106, U.P.

115. Khushboo Jaiswal D/o Jagdamba Prasad Jaiswal R/o C

539 Teliyana Varanasi PIN-221001, U.P.

116. Arshad Ali S/o Nusrat Ali R/o Durgapuri, District-

Barabanki, PIN- 225001, U.P.

117. Pooja D/o Harpal Singh R/o Village and Post- Peepli

Nayak District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

118. Kuldeep Singh S/o Vijay Singh R/o Village Mahamdpur,

Post- Peepli Nayak District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

119. Rajesh Singh S/o Chandra Pal R/o Village Roopapur,

Post-Darayal, District- Rampur, PIN 244925, U.P.

120. Gresh Kumar S/o Mohan Singh R/o Village- Seekampur

Post- Ramnagar Latipupur District- Rampur, PIN-

244925, U.P.

121. Ghan Shyam Singh S/o Rampal Singh R/o Village-

Hasanpur, Post- Dhanupura, District- Rampur, PIN-

244925, U.P.

122. Vinod Kumar S/o Mukhram Singh R/o Village Roopaur,

Post- Dariyal District- Rampur PIN- 244925, U.P.

123. Yashoda Devi S/o Kishan Swaroop R/o Village and Post-

Piplinayak District- Rampur, PIN- 244925, U.P.

124. Bhavna S/o Balbeer Singh R/o Village- Chandupura Post-

Lambakhera District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

125. Tej Ram S/o Teekam Singh R/o Village- Muvana Post-

Darhiyal District- Rampur, PIN- 244925, U.P.

126. Dhirendra Singh Yadav S/o Sundar Lal Yadav R/o Village

– Narayan Purwa, Post- Shahabda Madhoganj, District-

Hardoi, PIN-243102, U.P.

127. Pankaj Trivedi S/o Chandra Narayan Trivedi R/o Moh-

Krishna Nagariya Near Baba Mandir, District- Hardoit,

PIN-241001, U.P.

128. Amit Kumar Sharma S/o Shripal Sharma R/o Village-

Itara Post- Pihani, District- Hardoi, PIN- 241406, U.P.

129. Krishna Kumar Tiwari S/o Ramanivas Tiwari R/o Village-

Natthanpur, Post- Parsada, District- Sitapur, PIN-261001,

U.P.

130. Pawan Kumar Rai S/o Devi Prasad Rai R/o Moh.

Buddhanagar Post- Hussainganj, District- Sitapur, PIN

261001, U.P.

131. Rohit Singh S/o Sravan Kumar Singh R/o Village- Narsohi

Post-Shahmoholi District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

132. Pratibha Sharma S/o Prem Chandra Sharma R/o D-59-

198-K-3-C-5 Bank Colony Yognaga R. Shivpurva, District-

Varanasi, PIN-221010, U.P.

133. Sushil Kumar Yadav S/o Raja Ram Yadav R/o Village-

Akhtyarpur Post- Pasaner District- Hardoi, PIN- 241201,

U.P.

134. Sunil Kumar Seth S/o Sanhaiya Lal R/o Kanhaiya Lal R/o

CK 65155A Badi Piyari District- Varanasi, PIN 221001,

U.P.

135. Narendra Pal Singh S/o Chanan Singh R/o Village and

Post- Hathwant District- Firozabad, PIN-205145, U.P.

136. Shashi Kant Maurya S/o Nanda Lal R/o Village and Post

Dhanapur, District- Chandauli, 232105 U.P.

137. Suryanath Maurya S/o Ram Nayan R/o Village-

Shahdeeh Post- Dewara Khas Raja District- Azamgarh,

PIN-277122, U.P.

138. Geeta Varma D/o Bhoodev Singh Verma R/o Vill+Post-

Kutubpur, District- Firozabad, U.P.

139. Hemlata Kumar D/o Gulab Singh R/o Vill+Post-

Kutubpur, District- Firozabad, U.P.

140. Alka Yadav D/o Om Prakash R/o Village- Dhananagla

Post- Amroha, District- Amroha, PIN-244221, U.P.

141. Shameem Jahan S/o Sharafat Ali R/o Village- Muvana

Post- Darhiyal, District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

142. Rekha Rani D/o Ram Murti Singh R/o Vishnu Vihar

Sahabad Road, Sai Auto Parts Jwala Nagar, District-

Rampur, PIN-244901, U.P.

143. Shehzad Ali S/o Kallan Khan R/o Moh- Darziyan Kanth

Road, District- Moradabad, PIN-244001, U.P.

144. Shailesh Kumar S/o Ram Kishore R/o Village- Mahlakpur

Nizampur Post- Aghwanpur, District- Moradabad, PIN-

244001, U.P.

145. Zulfiqar Ahmad S/o Abrar Ahmad R/o Village- Siadpur

Khajuria P.S.- Pac, District- Bareilly, U.P.

146. Anju Maury S/o Kanhaiya Lal Maurya R/o Village-

Dhoviya Post- Lalgopal Ganj, Nawabganj Soraon,

District- Allahabad, PIN-229413, U.P.

147. Mohammad Faisal S/o Mahammad Hasiulla R/o Village-

Chholo Bari, Post- Barhazyan District- Lakhimpur Khiri,

PIN-261505, U.P.

148. Shashank Misra S/o Guru Narain Misra R/o 95- A Vijay

Laxmi Nagar, District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

149. Mukund Dwivedi S/o Anjani Kumar Dwivedi R/o

Bhuwalpur Pandit Ka Pura, Post- Utrethu, District-

Ambedkar Nagar, PIN-224234, U.P.

150. Aditya Dwivedi S/o Sharda Prasad Dwivedi R/o 23/313

Pinhoona Mandir, Urdu Bazar Nayaghat, Post- Ayodhya,

District- Faizabad, U.P.

151. Mohd. Rasool S/o Irshad Husain R/o Village- Kotra, Post-

Shujaganj District- Faizabad, U.P.

152. Neeraj Kumar S/o Ram Sagar R/o 482/44 Khabhan do Tola

Iradat Nagar Daliganj, District- Lucknow, PIN- 226020,

U.P.

153. Jitendra Patel S/o Nar Singh Patel R/o HN- 183, Madri,

Post- Jaalaun, PIN-285123, U.P.

154. Bipin Singh Gurjar S/o Arun Kumar Singh Gurjar R/o RSA

Paradhani, U.P.

155. Shweta Sharma D/o Shailendra Kumar Sharma R/o Civil

Line Sarayan Power House Road, District- S.R.N. Bhadohi,

PIN-221401.

156. Satyendra Kumar Jais S/o Amar Nath Jais R/o 116/23,

Ranapratap Nagar, Kanpur, U.P.

157. Vijay Kumar S/o Ram Asare R/o Village- Mohammdabad,

Post- Bhopatpur, District- Allahabad, PIN-221503, U.P.

158. Manjula S/o Ram Pratap R/o Village- Mohammdabad Post-

Bhopatpur, District- Allahabad, 221503, U.P.

159. Reena Kumar Roy D/o Manoj Kumar Roy R/o Village-

Saraipitha Post- Sahipur, District- Allahabad, U.P.

160. Mohd. Yaqeen S/o Abdul Mannan R/o Purana Gorakhpur,

Neargorakhnath Imambara, Gorakhpur, PIN-273015, U.P.

161. Shakuntala Gupta S/o Jawahar Lal Gupta R/o HNo.88G,

Tiwaripur Part- 2, Barahaj, District- Gorakhpur, PIN

274603, U.P.

162. Tejpal Sharma S/o Krishna Murari Sharma R/o Village-

Mant, Post- Mant, District- Mathura, PIN-281202, U.P.

163. Amita Kumar Agarwal S/o Vijay Shankar Agrawal R/o

Village- Mant Mula Ram, Post- Mant, District- Mathura PIN-

281202, U.P.

164. Ram Kumar Bhardwaj S/o Om Prakash R/o 34-C, Janak

Puri, Maholi Road, District- Mathura U.P.

165. Kanchan Lata D/o Shambhu Prasad R/o Village-

Mahadewa Bazar, Post- Badhyapur, District- Gorakhpur,

(U.P.) PIN-273211.

166. Arvind Kumar Singh S/o Indrapal Singh R/o Village-

Aurangabad, Post- Kesarpur District- Bareilly, (U.P.) PIN-

210001.

167. Divya Shikha Singh D/o Indra Bahadur Singh Gaur R/o

Sabjimandi Banda, District-Banda, (U.P.) PIN-210001.

168. Komal Singh D/o Jas Ram Singh R/o Village- Paindapur

Post- Buhanpur, District- Bijnor, (U.P.) PIN-246746.

169. Arvind Kumar S/o Shish Ram Singh R/o Village-

Sattonangli Post- Seohara, District- Bijnor, (U.P.), PIN-

246746.

170. Sompal Singh S/o Hardayal Singh R/o Village- Berkhera

Post- Doltabad, District- Bijnor, (U.P.), PIN-246746.

171. Govind Kumar S/o Krishan Pal R/o Village & Post- Jatoli

Kanker Khera, District- Meerut, (U.P.).

172. Om Prakash S/o Janardan Prasad R/o Village- Chhotaka

Budhanchak, post- Dayachhapra, District- Balia, (U.P.)

PIN- 277205.

173. Rakesh Kumar Yadav S/o Chhedi Lal R/o Village- Taraul

Post- Narayanganj, District- Pratapgarh, (U.P.) PIN-

230902.

174. Kamrujjama S/o Jamaluddin R/o Village- Sisaisipah Post-

Nasratpur, District- Allahabad, (U.P.). PIN-212502.

175. Samarath Singh S/o Krishan Singh R/o Village & Post

Gariya Jagannath District- Etah, (U.P.) PIN-207244.

176. Vipin Kumar S/o Ashok Kumar R/o 541 Agrawal God Sahab

Wali Gali, District- Mainpur, (U.P.).

177. Mohd. Qadir Ali S/o Mohd. Usman Ali R/o Tarkapur Nai

Basti, Post- Sadar, District- Mirzapur (U.P.).

178. Km. Minakshi D/o Podi Singh R/o Moh. Hussainpura, Town-

Jansath, District- Muzaffar Nagar, (U.P.).

179. Gaurav Singh S/o R.P. Pandey R/o Village- Kamas Post-

Gonde District- Pratapgarh, (U.P.) PIN-230001.

180. Neeraj D/o Prem Prakash R/o Village- Nagla Vijayi post-

Raya, District- Mathura- 281204.

181. Vertika Singh S/o Shiv Ratan Singh R/o H.N. 63, Sector-

6, Jagriti Vihar, Meerut-250004, (U.P.).

182. Rajesh Kumar S/o Hari Chand R/o Village- Tabar, Post-

Tabar, District- Saharanpur, (U.P.).

183. Jamal Akhtar S/o Tanvirulhaq R/o Moh. Moolchand Post-

Ganjdunowara, District- Kasganj, (U.P.).

184. Amit Singh S/o Ram Sagar Singh R/o H.N. 492, Awas

Vikas Colony District- Basti, (U.P.).

185. Vijeta Singh S/o Vinod Kumar Singh R/o Kapilwastu

Bansdih District- Ballia, (U.P.).

186. Vineet Kishore Mishra S/o Ram Kishore Mishra R/o H.N.

114, Bakhtawar Lal, Bisalpur, District- Pilibhit, (U.P.).

187. Mohit Shukla S/o Ram Naresh Shukla R/o Garhi Raod

Chandipuram District- Lakhimpur Kheri, (U.P.).

188. Sunil Kumar Mishra S/o Jaidev Mishra R/o Bharatpuri

Colony District- Lakhimpur Kheri, (U.P.).

189. Ravi Prakash Dixit S/o Ramesh Chandra Dixit R/o

Laxminagar Colony, Laxmipur Road, Gola Gokarnath

District-Lakhimpur Kheri, (U.P.).

190. Kamlesh Chandra S/o Jagat Pal R/o Village-

Bhakaranpur, Post- Ganeshpur, District- Lakhimpur

Kheri, (U.P.).

191. Kalindi Mishra S/o O.P. Mishra R/o Bhuiphorwa Nath

Garahi Road, District- Lakhimpur Kheri, (U.P.).

192. Amitosh Tiwari S/o Banvir Prasad Sharma R/o Mo. Ashok

Nagar Nidhauli Road, Post- Etah, District- Etah, PIN-

207001, (U.P.).

193. Anil Kumar S/o Din Dayal R/o Mo. 192, Prem Nagar,

Post- Etah, District- Etah, (U.P.) PIN-207001.

194. Deepal Kumar Bhardwaj S/o Ramraksha Sharma R/o

Village- Harrajpur, Post- Pilkhuni District- Kasganj PIN-

207246, (U.P.).

195. Pratibha Dixit D/o Shiv Kumar Dixit R/o Mo. 05, C Shanti

Nagar, Post- Etah, District- Etah, PIN-207001, (U.P.).

196. Pradip Kumar S/o Talevar Singh R/o H.N. 79, Ashok

Nagar, Nidhauli Road, Etah, PIN- 207001, (U.P.).

197. Rameshwar S/o Talewar Singh R/o Lodhi Nagar, Gali No-

05, Bangaon Road, District- Etah, (U.P.).

198. Jitendra Kumar Tripathi S/o Girish Kumar Tripathi R/o

105 Anna purana Sadan Shasiri Nagar, District-

Lakhimpur Kheri, (U.P.).

199. Puja Dixit D/o Prakash Narayan Dixit R/o 177 Sant

Sidhauli District- Sitapur, (U.P.).

200. Manju Devi D/o Daya Shaner R/o B-927, Awas Vikas

Naubasta, District- Kanpur Nagar, (U.P.).

201. Ramjivan Rajpoot S/o Gaya Singh R/o H.N. 434 Gandhi

Nagar Orai, District- Jalaun, (U.P.).

202. Poonam Gupta D/o Hari Prasad R/o Purana Bazar

Kadaura District- Jalaun, (U.P.).

203. Shivali Tiwari D/o Jagdish Narayan R/o H.N. 46

Gopalganj Orai, District- Jalaun, (U.P.).

204. Sanjeeta Gupta D/o Vashwa Nath Gupta R/o Village-

Roshanpur, Post- Surajpur, District- Mau, (U.P.).

205. Asheesh Kumar Gupta S/o Bindra Prasad R/o Village-

Roshanpur, Post- Surajpur, District- Mau, (U.P.).

206. Amit Kumar Singh S/o Pradumn Singh R/o Nai Tahseel

Jail Road, Habeebpur, District- Fatehpur, (U.P.).

207. Amit Kumar S/o Putti Lal R/o Village & Post-

Makrandpur, District- Fatehpur, (U.P.).

208. Sadiya Karimi D/o Zameer Ahmad R/o 156 b 9a1

Shams Nagar Karela Bagh District- Allahabad, (U.P.)

PIN-211006.

209. Samiksha Verma S/o Phool Chand Verma R/o H.No. 885,

Ward No.2 Shivpuram Colony, Ramnath District- Deoria,

PIN 274001, (U.P.).

210. Nitesh Singh S/o Ramesh Singh R/o Village- Usari

Madaina, Post- Indupur, District- Deoria, PIN 274202,

(U.P.).

211. Saroj D/o Maukhi Ram R/o Moh. Nalbandan Post-

Nagina, District- Bijnor, PIN-2246762, (U.P.)

212. Shashi D/o Ram Dula Pal R/o Mo. 30A/12 Amar Nath

Jha Marg Post- George Town District- Allahabad, PIN-

211002, (U.P.)

213. Sulakshna D/o Om Prakesh Arya R/o Mo. 37,

Vasundhara View Colony, Post- Mathura, District-

Mathura, PIN-281004, (U.P.).

214. Raghvendra Prasad S/o Bhola Prasad R/o Village-

Kornie Post- Kornie District- Fathepur, PIN-212601,

(U.P.).

215. Sunil Kumar S/o Balgovind Kaithal R/o Mo. Gautam

Nagar Post- Fatehpur, District- Fatehpur, PIN-212601,

(U.P.).

216. Pradeep Kumar Trivedi R/o Krishna Colony Hariharganj

Post- Fatehpur, District- Fatehpur, PIN-212601, (U.P.).

217. Manju Yadav D/o Rang Lal Yadav R/o Village- Teliatara

Post- Dumduma, District- Allahabad, PIN-221508,

(U.P.).

218. Raj Kumar Yadav S/o Fojdar Yadav R/o Village-

Teliatara Post- Dumduma District- Allahabad, PIN

221508, (U.P.)

219. Prithivi Nath S/o Ram Chhabile R/o Village- Karmohna

Post- Khajuriya, District- PIN-271201, (U.P.).

220. Amit Kumar S/o Udayveer Singh R/o Village- Khiriya

Post- Kapoorpur, District- Mainpuri PIN- 205001, (U.P.).

221. Vivek Yadav S/o Bhikhari Das Yadav R/o D-10, Adarsh

Nagar, Kalyanpur, Lucknow PIN- 226022 (U.P.)

222. Sandeep S/o Shyam Pal Singh R/o New Basti Navadiya,

Post- Fatehgarh, Dist.- Farrukhabad PIN- 209601 (U.P.)

223. Abhay kant S/o Ramakant R/o Ganga Nagar Colony,

near Gayatri Gali, Farrukhabad PIN- 209625 (U.P.)

224. Santosh Kumar Shukla S/o Munna Lal Shukla R/o South

of Prakash Cold Storage, Lal Gate, Farrukhabad PIN-

209625 (U.P.)

225. Amravati D/o Lallan Prasad Gupta R/o Prakash Nagar,

Maharajganj, Raibareli PIN- 229306 (U.P.)

226. Rahul Bajpai S/o Anil Kumar Bajpai R/o Village- Kakraha Post- Angra District- Sitapur, U.P.

Applicants/Intervenors

To,THE HON’BLE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIAAND HIS COMPANION JUDGES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

THE HUMBLE APPLICATION OF THE INTERVENORS ABOVE NAMED

MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH:

1 That the instant application for intervention is being

filed by the Applicants herein seeking indulgence of

this Hon’ble Court for permitting them to intervene in

the above noted matter as they are also similarly

situated persons as the petitioners are in this matter

and seek the same relief as the petitioners in the

above noted Civil Appeal No. 4347 of 2014 arising

from Special Leave to Appeal No. 1874 of 2014.

2 That in the beginning a G.O. dated 27.09.2011 was

issued by the government wherein the basis of

selection was Academic merit (Quality Point marks)

and TET was to be a qualifying criteria only.

3 That on the basis of G.O. dated 27.09.2011 an

advertisement dated 30.11.2011 was issued by the

government, which was against the G.O. itself,

wherein TET marks were made the basis of selection.

4 That the advertisement dated 30.11.2011 was issued

on the basis of 12th Amendment to the Basic Education

Rules. This 12th Amendment is applicable to BTC and

Special BTC degree holders because the post

advertised had to be mentioned in rule 8 of the Basic

Education Service Rules, 1981.

5 That as per Basic Education Service Rules, 1981, only

Basic Shiksha Adhikari i.e. District Education Officer is

empowered to issue advertisement whereas

advertisement dated 30.11.2011 was issued by

Secretary, Basic Education.

6 That as a result of aforesaid discrepancies various writ

petitions were filed before the Hon’ble High Court of

Judicature at Allahabad and vide order dated

04.01.2012 the Hon’ble High Court stayed the

advertisement dated 30.11.2011. In Writ Petition No.

76039/ 2011 the Hon’ble High Court vide its order

dated 11.09.2012 directed that separate

advertisements be issued for Trained Teachers and

Trainee Teachers. As a consequence, 15th Amendment

was made for Trained Teachers and 16th Amendment

was made regarding B.Ed. degree holders.

7 That in view of aforesaid discrepancies, the Hon’ble

High Court directed the State government to issue a

fresh advertisement, wherein in compliance the state

government had issued a new advertisement dated

07.12.2012.

8 That there are thousands of applicants who have

applied only in response to the advertisement dated

07.12.2012 and if relief is not granted by this Hon’ble

Court in the present Civil Appeal No. 4347 of 2014,

many applicants of advertisement dated 07.12.2012

will be adversely affected.

9 That the facts of the Special Leave to Appeal No. 1874

of 2014 may be treated as a part and parcel of this

Application for Intervention and same facts are not

repeated herein for the sake of brevity. It would be in

the interest of justice that the present application for

Intervention may be allowed and the applicants may

be allowed to intervene in the above petition.

PRAYER

It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed that this Hon’ble

Court may be pleased to:

a) allow the application for Intervention filed by the

applicants and permit them to appear as Interveners in

Special Leave to Appeal No. 1874 of 2014 now

converted to Civil Appeal No. 4347 of 2014; and

b) pass such other or further order(s) / direction(s) as this

Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper under the facts

and circumstances of the present case.

Drawn by:Amit Upreti(Advocate)

Filed by:

(Anurag Pandey)Advocate for the INTERVENORS

New Delhi

Filed on: 18.02.2016

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)

I.A. No. of 2016In

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4347 OF 2014IN THE MATTER OF

State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. ………...PETITIONERSVERSUS

Shiv Kumar Pathak .…….RESPONDENTSAND

IN THE MATTER OF:Satya Kumar

AFFIDAVITI, Satya Kumar, son of Parashuram, R/o Village-

Siraichnow, P.O. – Jaravli Newada, District- Hardoi (U.P.)

PIN- 241403 presently at New Delhi, do hereby solemnly

affirm and state as under:-

1. That I am the applicant no. 1 in the present

Application for intervention and am well acquainted

with the facts and circumstances of the case and thus

competent to swear the present affidavit.

2. That I have read and understood contents of the

present Application for intervention which are true

and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.

DEPONENT

VERIFICATION

Verified at New Delhi on this the 18th day of

February, 2016 that the contents of my above affidavit are

true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief

and nothing material has been concealed therefrom.

DEPONENT

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)

I.A. No. of 2016In

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4347 OF 2014

IN THE MATTER OF

State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. ………...PETITIONERSVERSUS

Shiv Kumar Pathak .…….RESPONDENTS

AND

IN THE MATTER OF:

SATYA KUMAR

Applicant/Intervener

INDEX

S.No. PARTICULARS Page No.1 An Application for Intervention with affidavit

ADVOCATE FOR INTERVENER: ANURAG PANDEY