IN THE SUPREME COURT2004/07/23  · MICHIGAN REPORTS CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MICHIGAN...

1055
MICHIGAN REPORTS CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MICHIGAN FROM July 23, 2004 to January 26, 2005 DANILO ANSELMO REPORTER OF DECISIONS VOL. 471 FIRST EDITION 2005

Transcript of IN THE SUPREME COURT2004/07/23  · MICHIGAN REPORTS CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MICHIGAN...

  • MICHIGAN REPORTS

    CASES DECIDED

    IN THE

    SUPREME COURTOF

    MICHIGANFROM

    July 23, 2004 to January 26, 2005

    DANILO ANSELMOREPORTER OF DECISIONS

    VOL. 471FIRST EDITION

    2005

  • Copyright 2005, by Michigan Supreme Court

    The paper used in this publication meets the minimumrequirements of American National Standard for InformationSciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials,ANSI Z39.48-1984.

  • SUPREME COURT

    TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    CHIEF JUSTICEMAURA D. CORRIGAN, GROSSE POINTE PARK...................................... 20071

    CLIFFORD W. TAYLOR, LAINGSBURG.................................................... 20092

    JUSTICESMICHAEL F. CAVANAGH, EAST LANSING............................................. 2007ELIZABETH A. WEAVER, GLEN ARBOR ............................................... 2011MARILYN KELLY, BLOOMFIELD HILLS .................................................... 2013CLIFFORD W. TAYLOR, LAINGSBURG.................................................... 20091

    MAURA D. CORRIGAN, GROSSE POINTE PARK...................................... 20072

    ROBERT P. YOUNG, JR., GROSSE POINTE PARK ...................................... 2011STEPHEN J. MARKMAN, MASON ........................................................ 2013

    COMMISSIONERSGLEN M. BIS, CHIEF COMMISSIONER3

    FRANK J. GRECO, CHIEF COMMISSIONER4

    MICHAEL J. SCHMEDLEN, DEPUTY CHIEF COMMISSIONER3

    JOHN K. PARKER ANNE-MARIE HYNOUS VOICETIMOTHY J. RAUBINGER DON W. ATKINSLYNN K. RICHARDSON JÜRGEN O. SKOPPEKKATHLEEN A. FOSTER DANIEL C. BRUBAKERGLEN M. BIS4 MICHAEL S. WELLMANCALVIN J. STERK8 MICHAEL J. SCHMEDLEN4

    NELSON S. LEAVITT GARY L. ROGERS5

    SHARI M. OBERG RICHARD B. LESLIE6

    DEBRA A. GUTIERREZ-MCGUIRE FREDERICK M. BAKER, JR.7

    PATRICK J. WRIGHT

    STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR: JOHN D. FERRY, JR.8

    STATE COURT ADMINISTRATOR: CARL L. GROMEK9

    CLERK: CORBIN R. DAVISCRIER: DAVID G. PALAZZOLO

    REPORTER OF DECISIONS: DANILO ANSELMO

    1 To January 6, 2005.2 From January 6, 2005.3 From December 1, 2004.4 To December 1, 2004.5 From November 8, 2004.6 From January 3, 2005.7 From January 10, 2005.8 To December 31, 2004.9 From January 3, 2005.

    iii

  • COURT OF APPEALS

    TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    CHIEF JUDGE

    WILLIAM C. WHITBECK, LANSING................................................... 2011

    CHIEF JUDGE PRO TEM

    MICHAEL R. SMOLENSKI, GRAND RAPIDS ....................................... 2007

    Judges

    DAVID H. SAWYER, GRAND RAPIDS .................................................. 2011WILLIAM B. MURPHY, GRAND RAPIDS ............................................. 2007MARK J. CAVANAGH, ROYAL OAK................................................... 2009RICHARD ALLEN GRIFFIN, TRAVERSE CITY .................................... 2009JANET T. NEFF, GRAND RAPIDS.......................................................... 2007KATHLEEN JANSEN, ST. CLAIR SHORES............................................ 2007E. THOMAS FITZGERALD, OWOSSO ................................................ 2009HELENE N. WHITE, DETROIT ............................................................ 2011HENRY WILLIAM SAAD, BLOOMFIELD HILLS.................................... 2009RICHARD A. BANDSTRA, GRAND RAPIDS ........................................ 2009JOEL P. HOEKSTRA, GRAND RAPIDS.................................................. 2011JANE E. MARKEY, GRAND RAPIDS..................................................... 2009PETER D. O’CONNELL, MT. PLEASANT............................................. 2007HILDA R. GAGE, BLOOMFIELD HILLS .................................................. 2007MICHAEL J. TALBOT, GROSSE POINTE FARMS.................................... 2009KURTIS T. WILDER, CANTON ............................................................ 2011BRIAN K. ZAHRA, NORTHVILLE ......................................................... 2007PATRICK M. METER, SAGINAW ......................................................... 2009DONALD S. OWENS, WILLIAMSTON................................................... 2011JESSICA R. COOPER, BEVERLY HILLS................................................ 2007KIRSTEN FRANK KELLY, GROSSE POINTE PARK ............................... 2007CHRISTOPHER M. MURRAY, GROSSE POINTE FARMS........................ 2009PAT M. DONOFRIO, CLINTON TOWNSHIP............................................. 2011KAREN FORT HOOD, DETROIT ......................................................... 2009BILL SCHUETTE, MIDLAND ............................................................... 2009STEPHEN L. BORRELLO, SAGINAW .................................................. 2007

    CHIEF CLERK: SANDRA SCHULTZ MENGELRESEARCH DIRECTOR: LARRY S. ROYSTER

    iv

  • CIRCUIT JUDGES

    TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    1. MICHAEL R. SMITH, JONESVILLE,..................................... 20092. ALFRED M. BUTZBAUGH, BERRIEN SPRINGS, .................. 2007

    CASPER O. GRATHWOHL, NILES,................................... 2005JOHN M. DONAHUE, ST. JOSEPH,.................................... 20111

    CHARLES T. LASATA, ST. JOSEPH,.................................... 20111

    JOHN T. HAMMOND, ST. JOSEPH, .................................... 20052

    PAUL L. MALONEY, ST. JOSEPH, ...................................... 20093. DAVID J. ALLEN, DETROIT,................................................ 2009

    WENDY M. BAXTER, DETROIT,......................................... 2007ANNETTE J. BERRY, PLYMOUTH, ...................................... 2007GREGORY D. BILL, NORTHVILLE TWP.,.............................. 2007SUSAN D. BORMAN, DETROIT,.......................................... 2009ULYSSES W. BOYKIN, DETROIT, ....................................... 2009MARGIE R. BRAXTON, DETROIT, ..................................... 2011HELEN E. BROWN, GROSSE POINTE PARK, ........................ 2009WILLIAM LEO CAHALAN, GROSSE ILE, ........................... 2007BILL CALLAHAN, DETROIT, ............................................. 2009JAMES A. CALLAHAN, GROSSE POINTE, ........................... 20111

    MICHAEL J. CALLAHAN, BELLEVILLE, ............................. 2009JAMES R. CHYLINSKI, GROSSE POINTE WOODS, ............... 2011ROBERT J. COLOMBO, JR., GROSSE POINTE, .................... 2007SEAN F. COX, CANTON TWP., .............................................. 2011DAPHNE MEANS CURTIS, DETROIT,............................... 2009CHRISTOPHER D. DINGELL, TRENTON,......................... 2009GERSHWIN ALLEN DRAIN, DETROIT, ............................ 2011MAGGIE DRAKE, DETROIT, ............................................... 2011PRENTIS EDWARDS, DETROIT, ........................................ 2007VONDA R. EVANS, DETROIT, ............................................. 2009

    1 From January 1, 2005.2 Retired December 3, 2004.

    v

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    EDWARD EWELL, JR., DETROIT, ....................................... 2007PATRICIA SUSAN FRESARD, GROSSE POINTE WOODS, .... 2011JOHN H. GILLIS, JR., GROSSE POINTE, .............................. 2009WILLIAM J. GIOVAN, GROSSE POINTE FARMS, ................... 2009DAVID ALAN GRONER, GROSSE POINTE PARK, ................ 2011RICHARD B. HALLORAN, JR., DETROIT,.......................... 2007AMY PATRICIA HATHAWAY, GROSSE POINTE PARK, ........ 2007CYNTHIA GRAY HATHAWAY, DETROIT,.......................... 2011DIANE MARIE HATHAWAY, GROSSE POINTE PARK, ......... 2011MICHAEL M. HATHAWAY, DETROIT, ............................... 2011THOMAS EDWARD JACKSON, DETROIT, ........................ 2007VERA MASSEY JONES, DETROIT, .................................... 2009MARY BETH KELLY, GROSSE ILE, ..................................... 2009TIMOTHY MICHAEL KENNY, LIVONIA, .......................... 2011ARTHUR J. LOMBARD, GROSSE POINTE FARMS,................ 2009KATHLEEN I. MACDONALD, GROSSE POINTE WOODS, .... 2011SHEILA GIBSON MANNING, DETROIT, .......................... 2011KATHLEEN M. McCARTHY, DEARBORN, .......................... 2007WADE H. MCCREE, DETROIT, ............................................ 2007WARFIELD MOORE, JR., DETROIT, ................................... 2009BRUCE U. MORROW, DETROIT, ......................................... 2011JOHN A. MURPHY, PLYMOUTH TWP., ................................ 2011SUSAN BIEKE NEILSON, GROSSE POINTE WOODS,........... 2009MARIA L. OXHOLM, DETROIT, .......................................... 2007LITA MASINI POPKE, CANTON, ....................................... 2011JAMES J. RASHID, NORTHVILLE,........................................ 20053

    DANIEL P. RYAN, REDFORD, ............................................... 2007MICHAEL F. SAPALA, GROSSE POINTE PARK, .................... 2007LOUIS F. SIMMONS, JR., DETROIT, ................................... 2005RICHARD M. SKUTT, DETROIT, ........................................ 20074

    LESLIE KIM SMITH, NORTHVILLE TWP., ........................... 2007VIRGIL C. SMITH, DETROIT, ............................................. 2007JEANNE STEMPIEN, NORTHVILLE, ................................... 2011CYNTHIA DIANE STEPHENS, DETROIT, ........................ 2007CRAIG S. STRONG, DETROIT,............................................ 2009BRIAN R. SULLIVAN, GROSSE POINTE PARK,..................... 2011DEBORAH A. THOMAS, DETROIT,.................................... 2007EDWARD M. THOMAS, DETROIT, ..................................... 2009

    3 Retired August 1, 2004.4 From August 23, 2004.

    vi

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    ISIDORE B. TORRES, GROSSE POINTE PARK,..................... 2011LEONARD TOWNSEND, DETROIT, ................................... 2005MARY M. WATERSTONE, DETROIT, ................................. 2007CAROLE F. YOUNGBLOOD, GROSSE POINTE,................... 2007ROBERT L. ZIOLKOWSKI, NORTHVILLE, .......................... 2009

    4. EDWARD J. GRANT, JACKSON,........................................... 2011JOHN G. MCBAIN, JR., RIVES JUNCTION, ............................ 2009CHARLES A. NELSON, JACKSON,...................................... 2007CHAD C. SCHMUCKER, JACKSON,.................................... 2011

    5. JAMES H. FISHER, HASTINGS, .......................................... 20096. JAMES M. ALEXANDER, BLOOMFIELD HILLS, ................... 2009

    MARTHA ANDERSON, TROY,........................................... 2009STEVEN N. ANDREWS, BLOOMFIELD HILLS, ..................... 2009RAE LEE CHABOT, FRANKLIN, .......................................... 2011MARK A. GOLDSMITH, HUNTINGTON WOODS, .................. 2007NANCI J. GRANT, WEST BLOOMFIELD, ................................ 2009RICHARD D. KUHN, WATERFORD, ..................................... 2005DENISE LANGFORD-MORRIS, WEST BLOOMFIELD,......... 2007CHERYL A. MATTHEWS, SYLVAN LAKE, .......................... 20115

    JOHN JAMES MCDONALD, FARMINGTON HILLS, .............. 2011FRED M. MESTER, BLOOMFIELD HILLS, ............................. 2009RUDY J. NICHOLS, CLARKSTON, ........................................ 2009COLLEEN A. O’BRIEN, ROCHESTER HILLS, ....................... 2011DANIEL PATRICK O’BRIEN, HOLLY, .............................. 2011WENDY LYNN POTTS, BIRMINGHAM, ................................ 2007GENE SCHNELZ, NOVI, .................................................... 2009EDWARD SOSNICK, BLOOMFIELD HILLS, ........................... 2007DEBORAH G. TYNER, FRANKLIN, ..................................... 2007MICHAEL D. WARREN, JR., BEVERLY HILLS, .................... 2007JOAN E. YOUNG, BLOOMFIELD VILLAGE,............................. 2011

    7. DUNCAN M. BEAGLE, FENTON, ....................................... 2011JOSEPH J. FARAH, GRAND BLANC, .................................... 2011JUDITH A. FULLERTON, FLINT, ..................................... 2007JOHN A. GADOLA, FENTON, ............................................. 2009ARCHIE L. HAYMAN, FLINT,............................................ 2007GEOFFREY L. NEITHERCUT, FLINT, ............................. 2007DAVID J. NEWBLATT, LINDEN,......................................... 20115

    ROBERT M. RANSOM, FLUSHING,..................................... 2009RICHARD B. YUILLE, FLINT, ........................................... 2009

    8. DAVID A. HOORT, PORTLAND,............................................ 2011

    5 From January 1, 2005.

    vii

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    CHARLES H. MIEL, STANTON, .......................................... 20099. STEPHEN D. GORSALITZ, PORTAGE, .............................. 2011

    J. RICHARDSON JOHNSON, PORTAGE, ........................... 2007RICHARD RYAN LAMB, KALAMAZOO,................................ 2007PHILIP D. SCHAEFER, PORTAGE,..................................... 2011WILLIAM G. SCHMA, KALAMAZOO,.................................... 2009

    10. FRED L. BORCHARD, SAGINAW, ....................................... 2011LEOPOLD P. BORRELLO, SAGINAW, ................................. 2007WILLIAM A. CRANE, SAGINAW,......................................... 2011LYNDA L. HEATHSCOTT, SAGINAW,................................. 2007ROBERT L. KACZMAREK, FREELAND,.............................. 2009

    11. CHARLES H. STARK, MUNISING, ...................................... 200912. GARFIELD W. HOOD, PELKIE, .......................................... 200913. THOMAS G. POWER, TRAVERSE CITY,............................... 2011

    PHILIP E. RODGERS, JR., TRAVERSE CITY,....................... 200914. JAMES M. GRAVES, JR., MUSKEGON, ................................ 2007

    TIMOTHY G. HICKS, MUSKEGON, ..................................... 2011WILLIAM C. MARIETTI, NORTH MUSKEGON, .................... 2011JOHN C. RUCK, WHITEHALL,.............................................. 2009

    15. MICHAEL H. CHERRY, COLDWATER, ................................. 200916. JAMES M. BIERNAT, SR., CLINTON TWP., ......................... 2011

    RICHARD L. CARETTI, FRASER,....................................... 2011MARY A. CHRZANOWSKI, HARRISON TWP., ..................... 2011DIANE M. DRUZINSKI, CLINTON TWP.,............................ 2009PETER J. MACERONI, CLINTON TWP.,.............................. 2009DONALD G. MILLER, HARRISON TWP., ............................. 2007DEBORAH A. SERVITTO, MT. CLEMENS, ......................... 2009EDWARD A. SERVITTO, JR., WARREN, ............................. 2007MARK S. SWITALSKI, RAY TWP., ..................................... 2007MATTHEW S. SWITALSKI, CLINTON TWP., ...................... 2009ANTONIO P. VIVIANO, CLINTON TWP., ............................. 2011TRACEY A. YOKICH, ST. CLAIR SHORES,........................... 20136

    17. GEORGE S. BUTH, GRAND RAPIDS, ................................... 2011KATHLEEN A. FEENEY, BELMONT,.................................. 2009DONALD A. JOHNSTON, III, GRAND RAPIDS, .................. 2007DENNIS C. KOLENDA, ROCKFORD, ................................... 2007DENNIS B. LEIBER, GRAND RAPIDS, ................................. 2007STEVEN MITCHELL PESTKA, GRAND RAPIDS,............... 2011JAMES ROBERT REDFORD, EAST GRAND RAPIDS, .......... 2011PAUL J. SULLIVAN, GRAND RAPIDS, .................................. 2009DANIEL V. ZEMAITIS, GRAND RAPIDS, .............................. 2009

    6 From January 1, 2005.viii

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    18. LAWRENCE M. BIELAWSKI, LINWOOD,........................... 2009WILLIAM J. CAPRATHE, BAY CITY,................................. 2011KENNETH W. SCHMIDT, BAY CITY,................................. 2007

    19. JAMES M. BATZER, MANISTEE,......................................... 200920. CALVIN L. BOSMAN, GRAND HAVEN, ................................ 2011

    WESLEY J. NYKAMP, HOLLAND,........................................ 2009EDWARD R. POST, GRAND HAVEN, .................................... 2011JON VAN ALLSBURG, HOLLAND,...................................... 20137

    21. PAUL H. CHAMBERLAIN, BLANCHARD, ............................ 2011MARK H. DUTHIE, MT. PLEASANT, ................................... 20137

    22. ARCHIE CAMERON BROWN, ANN ARBOR, ..................... 2011TIMOTHY P. CONNORS, ANN ARBOR, .............................. 2007MELINDA MORRIS, ANN ARBOR, ...................................... 2007DONALD E. SHELTON, SALINE, ....................................... 2009DAVID S. SWARTZ, ANN ARBOR,........................................ 2009

    23. RONALD M. BERGERON, STANDISH, ............................... 2009WILLIAM F. MYLES, EAST TAWAS, .................................... 2009

    24. DONALD A. TEEPLE, SANDUSKY, ..................................... 200925. THOMAS L. SOLKA, MARQUETTE, ..................................... 2011

    JOHN R. WEBER, MARQUETTE,.......................................... 200926. JOHN F. KOWALSKI, ALPENA, .......................................... 2009

    JOSEPH P. SWALLOW, ALPENA, ........................................ 200527. ANTHONY A. MONTON, PENTWATER, .............................. 2007

    TERRENCE R. THOMAS, NEWAYGO, ................................ 200928. CHARLES D. CORWIN, CADILLAC,..................................... 200929. JEFFREY L. MARTLEW, DEWITT,.................................... 2011

    RANDY L. TAHVONEN, ELSIE,......................................... 200930. LAURA BAIRD, OKEMOS,.................................................... 2007

    THOMAS LEO BROWN, EAST LANSING,............................ 2005WILLIAM E. COLLETTE, EAST LANSING, ......................... 2009JOYCE DRAGANCHUK, LANSING, .................................... 20117

    JAMES R. GIDDINGS, WILLIAMSTON, ................................ 2011JANELLE A. LAWLESS, OKEMOS,..................................... 2009PAULA J.M. MANDERFIELD, EAST LANSING, .................. 2007BEVERLEY NETTLES-NICKERSON, OKEMOS, .............. 2009

    31. JAMES P. ADAIR, PORT HURON,......................................... 2007PETER E. DEEGAN, PORT HURON, ................................... 2011DANIEL J. KELLY, FORT GRATIOT,..................................... 2009

    32. ROY D. GOTHAM, BESSEMER, ............................................ 200933. RICHARD M. PAJTAS, CHARLEVOIX, .................................. 200934. MICHAEL J. BAUMGARTNER, PRUDENVILLE, ................. 2011

    7 From January 1, 2005.ix

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    35. GERALD D. LOSTRACCO, OWOSSO, ................................. 200936. WILLIAM C. BUHL, PAW PAW,.......................................... 2007

    PAUL E. HAMRE, LAWTON,................................................ 200937. ALLEN L. GARBRECHT, BATTLE CREEK,.......................... 2011

    JAMES C. KINGSLEY, ALBION, ......................................... 2009STEPHEN B. MILLER, BATTLE CREEK,............................. 2011CONRAD J. SINDT, HOMER, .............................................. 2007

    38. JOSEPH A. COSTELLO, JR., MONROE, ............................. 2009MICHAEL W. LABEAU, MONROE,....................................... 2007WILLIAM F. LAVOY, MONROE, ........................................... 2005MICHAEL A. WEIPERT, MONROE, .................................... 20118

    39. HARVEY A. KOSELKA, ADRIAN, ....................................... 2009TIMOTHY P. PICKARD, ADRIAN,....................................... 2007

    40. MICHAEL P. HIGGINS, LAPEER, ....................................... 2009NICK O. HOLOWKA, IMLAY CITY, ..................................... 2011

    41. MARY BROUILLETTE BARGLIND, IRON MOUNTAIN, ..... 2011RICHARD J. CELELLO, IRON MOUNTAIN,.......................... 2009

    42. PAUL J. CLULO, MIDLAND,................................................. 2009THOMAS L. LUDINGTON, SANFORD, ............................... 2007

    43. MICHAEL E. DODGE, EDWARDSBURG, ............................... 201144. DANIEL A. BURRESS, HOWELL, ....................................... 2005

    STANLEY J. LATREILLE, HOWELL, ................................. 2007DAVID READER, HOWELL,................................................. 20118

    45. JAMES P. NOECKER, STURGIS, ......................................... 20079

    46. ALTON T. DAVIS, GRAYLING,.............................................. 2011DENNIS F. MURPHY, GAYLORD, ........................................ 2009

    47. STEPHEN T. DAVIS, ESCANABA, ........................................ 201148. HARRY A. BEACH, OTSEGO, .............................................. 2009

    GEORGE R. CORSIGLIA, ALLEGAN, ................................. 201149. LAWRENCE C. ROOT, BIG RAPIDS, ................................... 200750. NICHOLAS J. LAMBROS, SAULT STE. MARIE, .................. 200751. RICHARD I. COOPER, LUDINGTON,................................... 200952. M. RICHARD KNOBLOCK, BAD AXE, .............................. 200953. SCOTT LEE PAVLICH, CHEBOYGAN, ................................. 201154. PATRICK REED JOSLYN, CARO, ...................................... 200755. KURT N. HANSEN, GLADWIN,............................................ 200956. THOMAS S. EVELAND, DIMONDALE,................................. 2007

    CALVIN E. OSTERHAVEN, GRAND LEDGE,....................... 200957. CHARLES W. JOHNSON, PETOSKEY,................................. 2007

    8 From January 1, 2005.9 To February 2, 2005.

    x

  • DISTRICT JUDGES

    TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    1. MARK S. BRAUNLICH, MONROE, ..................................... 2009TERRENCE P. BRONSON, MONROE, ................................ 2007JACK VITALE, MONROE, .................................................... 2011

    2A. NATALIA M. KOSELKA, ADRIAN, ..................................... 2011JAMES E. SHERIDAN, ADRIAN, ........................................ 2009

    2B. DONALD L. SANDERSON, HILLSDALE, ............................ 20093A. DAVID T. COYLE, COLDWATER,........................................... 20093B. JEFFREY C. MIDDLETON, THREE RIVERS, ...................... 2009

    WILLIAM D. WELTY, THREE RIVERS,................................. 20074. PAUL E. DEATS, EDWARDSBURG,......................................... 20095. GARY J. BRUCE, ST. JOSEPH, ............................................ 2011

    ANGELA PASULA, STEVENSVILLE,...................................... 2009SCOTT SCHOFIELD, NILES, ............................................. 2009LYNDA A. TOLEN, STEVENSVILLE, ...................................... 2007DENNIS M. WILEY, ST. JOSEPH, ....................................... 2011

    7. ARTHUR H. CLARKE, III, SOUTH HAVEN,........................ 2009ROBERT T. HENTCHEL, PAW PAW,................................. 2011

    8-1. QUINN E. BENSON, KALAMAZOO,...................................... 2009ANNE E. BLATCHFORD, KALAMAZOO,.............................. 20111PAUL J. BRIDENSTINE, KALAMAZOO, ............................... 2007ANN L. HANNON, KALAMAZOO, ......................................... 2005CAROL A. HUSUM, KALAMAZOO, ....................................... 2011

    8-2. ROBERT C. KROPF, PORTAGE,........................................... 20098-3. RICHARD A. SANTONI, KALAMAZOO,................................ 2009

    VINCENT C. WESTRA, KALAMAZOO, ................................. 201110. SAMUEL I. DURHAM, JR., BATTLE CREEK,....................... 2011

    JOHN R. HOLMES, BATTLE CREEK,................................... 2007FRANKLIN K. LINE, JR., MARSHALL,................................ 2009MARVIN RATNER, BATTLE CREEK,.................................... 2009

    12. CHARLES J. FALAHEE, JR., JACKSON, ............................. 2009LYSLE G. HALL, JACKSON, ................................................. 2005JOSEPH S. FILIP, JACKSON, ............................................... 20111

    1 From January 1, 2005.

    xi

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    JAMES M. JUSTIN, JACKSON, ............................................ 2007R. DARRYL MAZUR, JACKSON, .......................................... 2009

    14A. RICHARD E. CONLIN, ANN ARBOR,.................................. 2009J. CEDRIC SIMPSON, YPSILANTI, ...................................... 2007KIRK W. TABBEY, SALINE, ................................................. 2011

    14B. JOHN B. COLLINS, YPSILANTI,.......................................... 200915. JULIE CREAL GOODRIDGE, ANN ARBOR, ...................... 2007

    ELIZABETH POLLARD HINES, ANN ARBOR,.................. 2011ANN E. MATTSON, ANN ARBOR, ....................................... 2009

    16. ROBERT B. BRZEZINSKI, LIVONIA, ................................. 2009KATHLEEN J. MCCANN, LIVONIA,.................................... 2007

    17. KAREN KHALIL, REDFORD, ............................................... 2011CHARLOTTE L. WIRTH, REDFORD, .................................. 2009

    18. C. CHARLES BOKOS, WESTLAND, ..................................... 2009GAIL McKNIGHT, WESTLAND,............................................ 2007

    19. WILLIAM C. HULTGREN, DEARBORN, .............................. 2011VIRGINIA A. SOBOTKA, DEARBORN, ................................ 20072MARK W. SOMERS, DEARBORN, ......................................... 2009

    20. LEO K. FORAN, DEARBORN HEIGHTS, ................................. 2007MARK J. PLAWECKI, DEARBORN HEIGHTS, ........................ 2009

    21. RICHARD L. HAMMER, JR., GARDEN CITY, ...................... 200922. SYLVIA A. JAMES, INKSTER, .............................................. 200723. GENO SALOMONE, TAYLOR, ............................................ 2007

    WILLIAM J. SUTHERLAND, TAYLOR,.............................. 200924. JOHN T. COURTRIGHT, ALLEN PARK,.............................. 2009

    ANTHONY S. GUERRIERO, ALLEN PARK, ....................... 2005RICHARD A. PAGE, ALLEN PARK,...................................... 20113

    25. DAVID A. BAJOREK, LINCOLN PARK, ................................ 2009DAVID J. ZELENAK, LINCOLN PARK, ................................. 2011

    26-1. RAYMOND A. CHARRON, RIVER ROUGE, ......................... 200926-2. MICHAEL F. CIUNGAN, ECORSE, ..................................... 2009

    27. RANDY L. KALMBACH, WYANDOTTE, ............................... 200728. JAMES A. KANDREVAS, SOUTHGATE, ............................... 200929. LAURA REDMOND MACK, WAYNE, ................................ 201130. BRIGETTE R. OFFICER, HIGHLAND PARK, ....................... 201131. PAUL J. PARUK, HAMTRAMCK,............................................ 2009

    32A. ROGER J. LA ROSE, HARPER WOODS, ................................ 200933. JAMES KURT KERSTEN, TRENTON, ................................ 2009

    MICHAEL K. McNALLY, TRENTON, ................................... 2007DONALD L. SWANK, TRENTON, ........................................ 20054EDWARD A. NYKIEL, GROSSE ILE, ................................... 20113

    34. TINA BROOKS GREEN, NEW BOSTON,............................. 2007

    2 Retired January 10, 2005.3 From January 1, 2005.4 Retired November 1, 2004.

    xii

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    BRIAN A. OAKLEY, ROMULUS,........................................... 2011DAVID M. PARROTT, BELLEVILLE, ..................................... 2009

    35. MICHAEL J. GEROU, PLYMOUTH,...................................... 2011RONALD W. LOWE, CANTON, ............................................ 2007JOHN E. MACDONALD, NORTHVILLE, ................................ 2009

    36. DEBORAH ROSS ADAMS, DETROIT, ................................ 2011LYDIA NANCE ADAMS, DETROIT, .................................... 2011TRUDY DUNCOMBE ARCHER, DETROIT,......................... 2007MARYLIN E. ATKINS, DETROIT, ....................................... 2007JOSEPH N. BALTIMORE, DETROIT, ................................. 2009NANCY MCCAUGHAN BLOUNT, DETROIT, ..................... 2009DAVID MARTIN BRADFIELD, DETROIT, ......................... 2009IZETTA F. BRIGHT, DETROIT, ............................................ 2011DONALD COLEMAN, DETROIT,......................................... 2007NANCY A. FARMER, DETROIT, .......................................... 2007DEBORAH GERALDINE FORD, DETROIT, ...................... 20115RUTH ANN GARRETT, DETROIT, ..................................... 2007JIMMYLEE GRAY, DETROIT, .............................................. 2009KATHERINE HANSEN, DETROIT, ..................................... 2011BEVERLY J. HAYES-SIPES, DETROIT,.............................. 2009PAULA G. HUMPHRIES, DETROIT,................................... 2011PATRICIA L. JEFFERSON, DETROIT, ............................... 2009VANESA F. JONES-BRADLEY, DETROIT, ......................... 2007DEBORAH L. LANGSTON, DETROIT, ............................... 2007WILLIE G. LIPSCOMB, JR., DETROIT,............................... 2009LEONIA J. LLOYD, DETROIT,............................................. 2011MIRIAM B. MARTIN-CLARK, DETROIT,........................... 2011DONNA R. MILHOUSE, DETROIT, .................................... 2007B. PENNIE MILLENDER, DETROIT, ................................. 2011MARION A. MOORE, DETROIT, ......................................... 2005JEANETTE O’BANNER-OWENS, DETROIT, .................... 2009MARK A. RANDON, DETROIT, ........................................... 2009KEVIN F. ROBBINS, DETROIT,........................................... 2007DAVID S. ROBINSON, JR., DETROIT,................................. 2007C. LORENE ROYSTER, DETROIT,...................................... 2007RUDOLPH A. SERRA, DETROIT,........................................ 2007TED WALLACE, DETROIT,.................................................. 2011

    37. JOHN M. CHMURA, WARREN,........................................... 2007JENNIFER FAUNCE, WARREN, ......................................... 2009DAWNN M. GRUENBURG, WARREN, ............................... 2011WALTER A. JAKUBOWSKI, JR., WARREN, ....................... 2007

    38. NORENE S. REDMOND, EASTPOINTE, .............................. 200939. JOSEPH F. BOEDEKER, ROSEVILLE,................................. 2009

    MARCO A. SANTIA, FRASER,............................................. 2007CATHERINE B. STEENLAND, ROSEVILLE, ...................... 2011

    5 From January 1, 2005.

    xiii

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    40. MARK A. FRATARCANGELI, ST. CLAIR SHORES, ............. 2007JOSEPH CRAIGEN OSTER, ST. CLAIR SHORES, ............... 20096

    41A. MICHAEL S. MACERONI, STERLING HEIGHTS,.................. 2009DOUGLAS P. SHEPHERD, MACOMB TWP.,........................ 2007STEPHEN S. SIERAWSKI, STERLING HEIGHTS, ................. 2011KIMBERLEY ANNE WIEGAND, STERLING HEIGHTS, ....... 2007

    41B. WILLIAM H. CANNON, CLINTON TWP., ............................ 20077LINDA DAVIS, CLINTON TWP., ............................................ 2009JOHN C. FOSTER, CLINTON TWP.,..................................... 2011

    42-1. DENIS R. LEDUC, WASHINGTON, ........................................ 200942-2. PAUL CASSIDY, NEW BALTIMORE,....................................... 2007

    43. KEITH P. HUNT, FERNDALE,............................................... 2007JOSEPH LONGO, MADISON HEIGHTS,................................. 2011ROBERT J. TURNER, FERNDALE, ...................................... 2009

    44. TERRENCE H. BRENNAN, ROYAL OAK, .......................... 2009DANIEL SAWICKI, ROYAL OAK, ........................................ 2007

    45A. WILLIAM R. SAUER, BERKLEY, ......................................... 200945B. MICHELLE FRIEDMAN APPEL, HUNTINGTON WOODS,... 2009

    DAVID M. GUBOW, HUNTINGTON WOODS, .......................... 200946. STEPHEN C. COOPER, SOUTHFIELD, ................................ 2011

    SHEILA R. JOHNSON, SOUTHFIELD, ................................. 2009SUSAN M. MOISEEV, SOUTHFIELD,.................................... 2007

    47. JAMES BRADY, FARMINGTON HILLS, ................................... 2009MARLA E. PARKER, FARMINGTON HILLS,........................... 2011

    48. EDWARD AVADENKA, WEST BLOOMFIELD,........................ 2005MARC BARRON, BIRMINGHAM,..................................................................... 20116DIANE D’AGOSTINI, BLOOMFIELD HILLS,.......................... 2007KIMBERLY SMALL, WEST BLOOMFIELD, ............................ 2009

    50. LEO BOWMAN, PONTIAC,................................................... 2007MICHAEL C. MARTINEZ, PONTIAC, ................................. 2009PRESTON G. THOMAS, PONTIAC, .................................... 2011CYNTHIA THOMAS WALKER, PONTIAC, ........................ 2009

    51. RICHARD D. KUHN, JR., WATERFORD, .............................. 2009PHYLLIS C. MCMILLEN, WATERFORD, .............................. 2007

    52-1. MICHAEL BATCHIK, WHITE LAKE, .................................. 2005ROBERT BONDY, MILFORD,............................................... 2007BRIAN W. MACKENZIE, NOVI, .......................................... 2009DENNIS N. POWERS, HIGHLAND, ..................................... 2007

    52-2. DANA FORTINBERRY, CLARKSTON, .................................. 2009KELLEY RENAE KOSTIN, CLARKSTON,............................ 20116

    52-3. LISA L. ASADOORIAN, ROCHESTER HILLS,........................ 2007NANCY TOLWIN CARNIAK, ROCHESTER HILLS,............... 2011JULIE A. NICHOLSON, ROCHESTER HILLS, ....................... 2009

    52-4. WILLIAM E. BOLLE, TROY, .............................................. 2009

    6 From January 1, 2005.7 Retired January 31, 2005.

    xiv

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    DENNIS C. DRURY, TROY, ................................................ 2007MICHAEL A. MARTONE, TROY, ...................................... 2011

    53. FRANK R. DEL VERO, HOWELL,....................................... 20058L. SUZANNE GEDDIS, BRIGHTON, .................................... 20119MICHAEL K. HEGARTY, BRIGHTON,................................. 2009A. JOHN PIKKARAINEN, BRIGHTON, ............................... 2007

    54A. LOUISE ALDERSON, LANSING, ......................................... 2011PATRICK F. CHERRY, LANSING,......................................... 2009FRANK J. DELUCA, LANSING, ............................................ 2007CHARLES F. FILICE, LANSING, ......................................... 2009AMY R. KRAUSE, LANSING, ............................................... 2011

    54B. RICHARD D. BALL, EAST LANSING, ................................... 2011DAVID L. JORDON, EAST LANSING, ................................... 2007

    55. ROSEMARIE ELIZABETH AQUILINA, EAST LANSING, .. 20119THOMAS E. BRENNAN, JR., EAST LANSING, .................... 2005PAMELA J. MCCABE, MASON, ........................................... 2009

    56A. PAUL F. BERGER, CHARLOTTE, .......................................... 2009HARVEY J. HOFFMAN, GRAND LEDGE,............................. 2011

    56B. GARY R. HOLMAN, HASTINGS, .......................................... 200757. STEPHEN E. SHERIDAN, SAUGATUCK,............................. 2007

    GARY A. STEWART, PLAINWELL, ........................................ 200958. SUSAN A. JONAS, SPRING LAKE, ....................................... 2009

    RICHARD J. KLOOTE, GRAND HAVEN,.............................. 2007BRADLEY S. KNOLL, HOLLAND, ....................................... 2009KENNETH D. POST, ZEELAND,.......................................... 2011

    59. PETER P. VERSLUIS, GRAND RAPIDS,................................ 201160. HAROLD F. CLOSZ, III, NORTH MUSKEGON, ...................... 2009

    FREDRIC A. GRIMM, JR., NORTH MUSKEGON,................... 2009MICHAEL JEFFREY NOLAN, TWIN LAKE, ...................... 2007ANDREW WIERENGO, MUSKEGON, .................................. 2011

    61. PATRICK C. BOWLER, GRAND RAPIDS, ............................. 2009DAVID J. BUTER, GRAND RAPIDS, ...................................... 2009J. MICHAEL CHRISTENSEN, GRAND RAPIDS,.................. 2011JEANINE NEMESI LAVILLE, GRAND RAPIDS,.................. 2007BEN H. LOGAN, II, GRAND RAPIDS, ................................... 2007DONALD H. PASSENGER, GRAND RAPIDS,....................... 2011

    62A. M. SCOTT BOWEN, WYOMING, .......................................... 2009STEVEN M. TIMMERS, GRANDVILLE,................................ 2007

    62B. WILLIAM G. KELLY, KENTWOOD,....................................... 200963-1. STEVEN R. SERVAAS, ROCKFORD, .................................... 200963-2. SARA J. SMOLENSKI, EAST GRAND RAPIDS,...................... 200964A. RAYMOND P. VOET, IONIA, ............................................... 200964B. DONALD R. HEMINGSEN, SHERIDAN, ............................. 200965A. RICHARD D. WELLS, DEWITT,......................................... 2009

    8 Retired July 31, 2004.9 From January 1, 2005.

    xv

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    65B. JAMES B. MACKIE, ALMA,................................................ 200966. WARD L. CLARKSON, CORUNNA, ...................................... 2007

    TERRANCE P. DIGNAN, OWOSSO, .................................... 200967-1. DAVID J. GOGGINS, FLUSHING,......................................... 200967-2. JOHN L. CONOVER, DAVISON,.......................................... 2009

    RICHARD L. HUGHES, OTISVILLE, ................................... 201167-3. LARRY STECCO, FLUSHING,............................................... 200967-4. MARK C. MCCABE, FENTON,.............................................. 2009

    CHRISTOPHER ODETTE, GRAND BLANC,........................ 200768. WILLIAM H. CRAWFORD, II, FLINT,............................... 2007

    HERMAN MARABLE, JR., FLINT, ..................................... 2007MICHAEL D. MCARA, FLINT, ............................................ 2009NATHANIEL C. PERRY, III, FLINT, ................................. 2009RAMONA M. ROBERTS, FLINT,........................................ 2011

    70-1. TERRY L. CLARK, SAGINAW,.............................................. 2007M. RANDALL JURRENS, SAGINAW, .................................. 2011M. T. THOMPSON, JR., SAGINAW, ...................................... 2009

    70-2. CHRISTOPHER S. BOYD, SAGINAW, ................................. 2011DARNELL JACKSON, SAGINAW, ........................................ 2009KYLE HIGGS TARRANT, SAGINAW, .................................. 2007

    71A. LAURA CHEGER BARNARD, METAMORA, ....................... 2009JOHN T. CONNOLLY, LAPEER, .......................................... 2007

    71B. KIM DAVID GLASPIE, CASS CITY, .................................... 200972. RICHARD A. COOLEY, JR., PORT HURON,......................... 2011

    DAVID C. NICHOLSON, PORT HURON, ............................. 2007CYNTHIA SIEMEN PLATZER, LAKEPORT, ...................... 2009

    73A. JAMES A. MARCUS, APPLEGATE, ....................................... 200973B. KARL E. KRAUS, BAD AXE, ............................................... 2009

    74. CRAIG D. ALSTON, BAY CITY, .......................................... 2009TIMOTHY J. KELLY, BAY CITY,......................................... 2007SCOTT J. NEWCOMBE, BAY CITY, ................................... 2011

    75. JOHN HENRY HART, MIDLAND,........................................ 2009PHILIP M. VAN DAM, MIDLAND,....................................... 200510

    76. WILLIAM R. RUSH, MT. PLEASANT, .................................. 200977. SUSAN H. GRANT, BIG RAPIDS,......................................... 200978. H. KEVIN DRAKE, FREMONT,............................................ 200979. PETER J. WADEL, BRANCH,............................................... 200980. GARY J. ALLEN, GLADWIN, ................................................ 200981. ALLEN C. YENIOR, STERLING, .......................................... 200982. RICHARD E. NOBLE, WEST BRANCH,................................ 200983. DANIEL L. SUTTON, PRUDENVILLE, .................................. 200984. DAVID A. HOGG, HARRIETTA, ............................................ 200985. BRENT V. DANIELSON, MANISTEE, .................................. 2009

    10 Died December 11, 2004.

    xvi

  • TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    86. JOHN D. FORESMAN, TRAVERSE CITY, ............................. 201111THOMAS S. GILBERT, TRAVERSE CITY, ............................. 2005MICHAEL J. HALEY, TRAVERSE CITY,................................ 2009THOMAS J. PHILLIPS, TRAVERSE CITY, ............................ 2007

    87. PATRICIA A. MORSE, GAYLORD, ....................................... 200988. THEODORE O. JOHNSON, ALPENA, ................................ 200989. HAROLD A. JOHNSON, JR., CHEBOYGAN, ......................... 200990. RICHARD W. MAY, CHARLEVOIX,......................................... 200991. MICHAEL W. MACDONALD, SAULT STE. MARIE,............... 200992. BARBARA J. BROWN, ST. IGNACE, .................................... 2005

    BETH GIBSON, NEWBERRY,................................................ 20091193. MARK E. LUOMA, MUNISING,............................................ 200994. GLENN A. PEARSON, GLADSTONE, ................................... 2009

    95A. JEFFREY G. BARSTOW, MENOMINEE, ............................... 200995B. MICHAEL J. KUSZ, IRON MOUNTAIN, ................................. 2009

    96. DENNIS H. GIRARD, MARQUETTE, .................................... 2011ROGER W. KANGAS, ISHPEMING, ....................................... 2009

    97. PHILLIP L. KUKKONEN, HANCOCK, ................................ 200998. ANDERS B. TINGSTAD, JR., BESSEMER, ........................... 2009

    11 From January 1, 2005.

    xvii

  • MUNICIPAL JUDGES

    TERM EXPIRESJANUARY 1 OF

    RUSSELL F. ETHRIDGE, GROSSE POINTE,............................. 2008CARL F. JARBOE, GROSSE POINTE PARK, ................................ 2006LYNNE A. PIERCE, GROSSE POINTE WOODS,........................... 2008NORENE S. REDMOND, EASTPOINTE, ................................... 2004MATTHEW R. RUMORA, GROSSE POINTE FARMS, .................. 2006MARTIN J. SMITH, EASTPOINTE, ............................................ 2004

    xviii

  • PROBATE JUDGES

    TERM EXPIRESCOUNTY JANUARY 1 OF

    Alcona .......................JAMES H. COOK...................................... 2007Alger/Schoolcraft ......WILLIAM W. CARMODY ......................... 2007Allegan ......................MICHAEL L. BUCK................................. 2007Alpena .......................DOUGLAS A. PUGH................................ 2007Antrim.......................NORMAN R. HAYES................................ 2007Arenac .......................JACK WILLIAM SCULLY........................ 2007Baraga.......................TIMOTHY S. BRENNAN ........................ 2007Barry .........................WILLIAM M. DOHERTY......................... 20071

    Barry .........................STEPHANIE S. FEKKES ........................ 2005Bay ............................KAREN TIGHE ........................................ 2007Benzie........................NANCY A. KIDA....................................... 2007Berrien ......................MABEL JOHNSON MAYFIELD............. 2009Berrien ......................THOMAS E. NELSON............................. 2007Branch.......................FREDERICK L. WOOD ........................... 2007Calhoun.....................PHILLIP E. HARTER.............................. 2011Calhoun.....................GARY K. REED......................................... 2007Cass ...........................SUSAN L. DOBRICH ............................... 2007Cheboygan ................ROBERT JOHN BUTTS.......................... 2007Chippewa ..................LOWELL R. ULRICH .............................. 2007Clare/Gladwin...........THOMAS P. McLAUGHLIN .................... 2007Clinton ......................LISA SULLIVAN....................................... 2007Crawford ...................JOHN G. HUNTER.................................. 2007Delta..........................ROBERT E. GOEBEL, JR. ....................... 2007Dickinson ..................THOMAS D. SLAGLE.............................. 2007Eaton.........................MICHAEL F. SKINNER........................... 2007Emmet/Charlevoix ...FREDERICK R. MULHAUSER .............. 2007Genesee .....................ALLEN J. NELSON.................................. 2009Genesee .....................DAVID J. NEWBLATT ............................. 2005Genesee .....................ROBERT E. WEISS .................................. 2007

    1 From January 1, 2005.

    xix

  • Gogebic......................JOEL L. MASSIE...................................... 2007Grand Traverse ........DAVID L. STOWE .................................... 2007Gratiot.......................JACK T. ARNOLD .................................... 2007Hillsdale ....................MICHAEL E. NYE.................................... 2007Houghton ..................CHARLES R. GOODMAN ....................... 2007Huron........................DAVID L. CLABUESCH .......................... 2007Ingham......................R. GEORGE ECONOMY.......................... 2007Ingham......................RICHARD JOSEPH GARCIA.................. 2009Ionia ..........................NANNETTE M. BOWLER ...................... 2005Ionia ..........................ROBERT SYKES, JR................................. 20072

    Iosco ..........................JOHN D. HAMILTON.............................. 2007Iron............................C. JOSEPH SCHWEDLER ...................... 2007Isabella......................WILLIAM T. ERVIN ................................. 2007Jackson .....................SUSAN E. VANDERCOOK...................... 2007Kalamazoo ................PATRICIA N. CONLON ........................... 2009Kalamazoo ................DONALD R. HALSTEAD ........................ 2011Kalamazoo ................CAROLYN H. WILLIAMS........................ 20073

    Kalkaska ...................LYNNE MARIE BUDAY .......................... 2007Kent...........................NANARUTH H. CARPENTER ............... 2011Kent...........................PATRICIA D. GARDNER......................... 2007Kent...........................JANET A. HAYNES ................................. 2009Kent...........................G. PATRICK HILLARY ............................ 2007Keweenaw.................JAMES G. JAASKELAINEN ................... 2007Lake...........................MARK S. WICKENS................................. 2007Lapeer .......................JUSTUS C. SCOTT .................................. 2007Leelanau ...................JOSEPH E. DEEGAN .............................. 2007Lenawee ....................CHARLES W. JAMESON ......................... 2007Livingston.................SUSAN L. RECK ...................................... 2007Luce/Mackinac..........THOMAS B. NORTH ............................... 2007Macomb.....................KATHRYN A. GEORGE........................... 2009Macomb.....................PAMELA GILBERT O’SULLIVAN ......... 2007Macomb.....................TRACEY A. YOKICH ............................... 2005Manistee....................JOHN R. DeVRIES................................... 2007Marquette .................MICHAEL J. ANDEREGG....................... 2007Mason........................MARK D. RAVEN ..................................... 2007Mecosta/Osceola .......LaVAIL E. HULL...................................... 2007Menominee ...............WILLIAM A. HUPY.................................. 2007Midland.....................DORENE S. ALLEN................................. 2007Missaukee .................CHARLES R. PARSONS .......................... 2007Monroe ......................JOHN A. HOHMAN, JR. .......................... 2007Monroe ......................PAMELA A. MOSKWA............................. 2009

    2 From January 1, 2005.3 Retired January 1, 2005.

    xx

  • Montcalm..................EDWARD L. SKINNER............................ 2007Montmorency............MICHAEL G. MACK ................................ 2007Muskegon..................NEIL G. MULLALLY ............................... 2011Muskegon..................GREGORY C. PITTMAN ......................... 2007Newaygo....................GRAYDON W. DIMKOFF ........................ 2007Oakland.....................BARRY M. GRANT................................... 2009Oakland.....................LINDA S. HALLMARK ............................ 2007Oakland.....................EUGENE ARTHUR MOORE .................. 2011Oakland.....................ELIZABETH M. PEZZETTI .................... 2011Oceana ......................WALTER A. URICK.................................. 2007Ogemaw ....................EUGENE I. TURKELSON ...................... 2007Ontonagon ................JOSEPH D. ZELEZNIK ........................... 2007Oscoda.......................KATHRYN JOAN ROOT ......................... 2007Otsego .......................MICHAEL K. COOPER ........................... 2007Ottawa ......................MARK A. FEYEN ..................................... 2007Presque Isle ..............KENNETH A. RADZIBON...................... 2007Roscommon ..............DOUGLAS C. DOSSON ........................... 2007Saginaw.....................FAYE M. HARRISON............................... 2009Saginaw.....................PATRICK J. MCGRAW.............................. 2007St. Clair.....................ELWOOD L. BROWN............................... 2009St. Clair.....................JOHN R. MONAGHAN............................ 2007St. Joseph .................THOMAS E. SHUMAKER....................... 2007Sanilac.......................R. TERRY MALTBY ................................. 2007Shiawassee................JAMES R. CLATTERBAUGH ................. 2007Tuscola......................W. WALLACE KENT, JR........................... 2007Van Buren.................FRANK D. WILLIS................................... 2007Washtenaw................NANCY CORNELIA FRANCIS............... 2009Washtenaw................JOHN N. KIRKENDALL ......................... 2007Wayne........................JUNE E. BLACKWELL-HATCHER ....... 2007Wayne........................FREDDIE G. BURTON, JR. ..................... 2007Wayne........................PATRICIA B. CAMPBELL....................... 2005Wayne........................JUDY A. HARTSFIELD ........................... 20074

    Wayne........................JAMES E. LACEY..................................... 2007Wayne........................MILTON L. MACK, JR. ............................ 2011Wayne........................CATHIE B. MAHER................................. 2011Wayne........................MARTIN T. MAHER................................. 2009Wayne........................DAVID J. SZYMANSKI ............................ 2009Wexford .....................KENNETH L. TACOMA.......................... 2007

    4 From July 26, 2004.

    xxi

  • JUDICIAL CIRCUITS

    County Seat Circuit

    Alcona....................Harrisville ......... 26Alger......................Munising ........... 11Allegan ..................Allegan............... 48Alpena ...................Alpena................ 26Antrim...................Bellaire .............. 13Arenac ...................Standish ............ 34

    Baraga ...................L’Anse................ 12Barry .....................Hastings ............ 5Bay.........................Bay City............. 18Benzie....................Beulah ............... 19Berrien ..................St. Joseph.......... 2Branch...................Coldwater .......... 15

    Calhoun.................Marshall, BattleCreek................ 37

    Cass .......................Cassopolis .......... 43Charlevoix.............Charlevoix ......... 33Cheboygan ............Cheboygan......... 53Chippewa ..............Sault Ste. Marie. 50Clare ......................Harrison ............ 55Clinton ..................St. Johns............ 29Crawford ...............Grayling............. 46

    Delta......................Escanaba ........... 47Dickinson ..............Iron Mountain .. 41

    Eaton.....................Charlotte ........... 5Emmet...................Petoskey ............ 33

    Genesee .................Flint ................... 7Gladwin.................Gladwin ............. 55Gogebic..................Bessemer ........... 32Grand Traverse ....Traverse City .... 13Gratiot...................Ithaca................. 29

    Hillsdale ................Hillsdale ............ 1Houghton ..............Houghton .......... 12Huron....................Bad Axe ............. 52

    Ingham..................Mason, Lansing. 30Ionia ......................Ionia................... 8Iosco ......................Tawas City ........ 23Iron........................Crystal Falls ...... 41Isabella ..................Mount Pleasant. 21

    Jackson..................Jackson.............. 4

    Kalamazoo ............Kalamazoo......... 9Kalkaska ...............Kalkaska............ 46Kent.......................Grand Rapids .... 17Keweenaw .............Eagle River........ 12

    County Seat Circuit

    Lake ................Baldwin ................. 51Lapeer .............Lapeer ................... 40Leelanau .........Leland ................... 13Lenawee..........Adrian ................... 39Livingston.......Howell ................... 44Luce.................Newberry .............. 11

    Mackinac.........St. Ignace .............. 50Macomb...........Mount Clemens .... 16Manistee .........Manistee................ 19Marquette .......Marquette ............. 25Mason..............Ludington ............. 51Mecosta ...........Big Rapids............. 49Menominee .....Menominee ........... 41Midland...........Midland ................. 42Missaukee .......Lake City .............. 28Monroe............Monroe .................. 38Montcalm........Stanton.................. 8Montmorency .Atlanta .................. 26Muskegon .......Muskegon.............. 14

    Newaygo .........White Cloud.......... 27

    Oakland ..........Pontiac .................. 6Oceana ............Hart ....................... 27Ogemaw ..........West Branch.......... 34Ontonagon ......Ontonagon ............ 32Osceola............Reed City .............. 49Oscoda.............Mio......................... 23Otsego .............Gaylord.................. 46Ottawa ............Grand Haven ........ 20

    Presque Isle....Rogers City ........... 26

    Roscommon ....Roscommon........... 34

    Saginaw...........Saginaw................. 10St. Clair ..........Port Huron ........... 31St. Joseph .......Centreville............. 45Sanilac.............Sandusky............... 24Schoolcraft......Manistique ............ 11Shiawassee......Corunna ................ 35

    Tuscola............Caro ....................... 54

    Van Buren.......Paw Paw................ 36

    Washtenaw......Ann Arbor............. 22Wayne..............Detroit ................... 3Wexford ...........Cadillac.................. 28

    xxii

  • TABLE OF CASES REPORTED

    21 CASES; 53 OPINIONS; 1,105 ACTIONS ON APPLICATIONSFOR LEAVE TO APPEAL GRANTED OR DENIED

    (Lines set in small type refer to actions on application for leaveto appeal from the Court of Appeals starting at page 851, and to

    special orders in other matters starting at page 1201.)

    PAGE

    AA L Belrose Co, Inc, Hyland v .............................................. 938ABS Properties, Inc, Horne v ............................................... 869ACIA, Devillers v ................................................................... 923AKR & Associates, SAF Construction, Inc v ...................... 899ALC Home Inspection Services, Inc, Herbrandson v ......... 906AME, Inc v Steelcon, Inc ...................................................... 889Abernathy, People v ............................................................... 872Abner, People v ...................................................................... 886Abraham, People v ................................................................ 916Abram, People v ..................................................................... 945Abt v Moore ........................................................................... 890Adams v Beaudry .................................................................. 885Adams, People v (Frank) ...................................................... 884Adams, People v (Mark) ........................................................ 885Adams, Shinholster v .......................................... 540Adell Children’s Funded Trust (Robert), City of Novi v ... 889Adelson, People v ................................................................... 949Adkins, People v .................................................................... 950Adler, People of the City of Westland v ............................... 900Advanta Nat’l Bank v McClarty ........................................... 883Aeronautics Comm, City of Lake Angelus v ....................... 866Agbo, People v ........................................................................ 949

    xxiii

  • PAGE

    Aguillon-Padron, People v ..................................................... 944Aguirre, Family Independence Agency v (In re Aguirre) ... 936Aguirre, In re (Family Independence Agency v Aguirre) ... 936Aguirre, People v ................................................................... 900Ajilon Services, Inc, DaimlerChrysler Corp v ..................... 884Akerlind, Smith v .................................................................. 920Akins, People v ...................................................................... 922Akrawi, People v .................................................................... 944Alaniz v Nan-Tay Apartments of Sunbury .......................... 873Alcoa, Inc v Dep’t of Treasury ............................................. 884Alexander v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Michigan ........... 884Alexander, People v (Anthony) ............................................. 863Alexander, People v (Brian) .................................................. 870Alexander v Vettraino ........................................................... 876Alliet v Berenholz ........................................................... 866, 922Allstate Ins Co, Burtwell v ................................................... 948Allstate Ins Co v McCarn (After Remand) ........ 283Allstate Ins Co v McCarn (After Remand) .......................... 1201Alvarado, People v ................................................................. 953Amador, People v ................................................................... 885Ambrose v Eaton Circuit Judge ........................................... 951American Axle & Mfg, Inc, Golota v .................................... 922American Axle & Mfg, Inc v Murdock ................................. 874American Bumper & Mfg Co v Nat’l Union Fire Ins Co of

    Pittsburgh, PA .................................................................. 948American Keyboard Products, Inc, Intercontinental

    Electronics, SPA v ............................................................ 899Amerisure Ins Co v Auto-Owners Ins Co ............................ 892Amerisure Ins Co, Grand Valley Health Ctr v .................... 892Amerisure Ins Co, Hope Network Rehabilitation Services

    v ......................................................................................... 892Amerisure Mut Ins Co v Farmers Ins Exch ........................ 939Anderson, DeShambo v ....................................... 27Anderson, People v (Frank) .................................................. 896Anderson, People v (Gregory) ............................................... 948Andrew, Lincoln Park Housing Comm v ............................. 899Andrews, People v ................................................................. 901Anklam Constr, Inc, Buena Vista Charter Twp v ............... 884Ann Arbor Charter Twp, Shepherd Montessori Ctr

    Milan v .................................................................................. 877

    xxiv 471 MICHIGAN REPORTS

  • PAGE

    Annapolis Hosp, Shinholster v ........................... 540Anthony v Dep’t of Community Health .............................. 892Anthony, Spectrum Health v ................................................ 892Applewhite, People v ............................................................. 902Armstrong, Piontek v ............................................................ 908Arquette, People v ................................................................. 933Artrip v Pioneer State Mut Ins Co ...................................... 900Arvin Estate, In re (Latz v Cardinal Dev Co) ..................... 932Ary v Gritter .......................................................................... 892Ashe, People v ........................................................................ 899Associated Builders & Contractors-Saginaw Valley Area

    Chapter v Dep’t of Consumer & Industry ServicesDirector ............................................................................. 877

    Aubins Service, Inc, Wayne Co v ........................ 445Auto Club Ins Ass’n, Cooper v ....................................... 915, 956Auto Club Ins Ass’n, Mistretta v ......................................... 901Auto-Owners Ins Co, Amerisure Ins Co v ........................... 892Autozone, Inc, Trouten v ...................................................... 879Avery, People v ....................................................................... 902Azzar, Ellis v (In re Azzar Living Trust) ............................. 872Azzar Living Trust, In re (Ellis v Azzar) ............................ 872Azzawi, Windsor Charter Twp v .......................................... 873

    BBachran v Bachran ................................................................ 881Baciewicz, Gulley-Reaves v ................................................... 877Badour, People v .................................................................... 899Bailey, Burkhardt v ............................................................... 920Bailey, People v (James) ........................................................ 872Bailey, People v (Steven) ....................................................... 865Baker, People v (Archie) ........................................................ 927Baker, People v (Larry) ......................................................... 901Baker, People v (Mitchell) ..................................................... 948Baldwin, People v (Anthony) ................................................ 873Baldwin, People v (Scott) ...................................................... 863Baldwin v Rykulski ............................................................... 882Balfour, Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co v .................................... 871Balfour, Patterson v ............................................................... 871Ballard, People v .................................................................... 867Balliet, Clough v .................................................................... 913

    TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxv

  • PAGE

    Banks, Family Independence Agency v (In re Banks) ........ 937Banks, In re (Family Independence Agency v Banks) ........ 937Banks v Lab Lansing Body Assembly .................................. 943Barhite, People v ................................................................... 921Barlow, People v ..................................................................... 961Barnes, People v .................................................................... 867Barry, People v ....................................................................... 884Basner, People v ..................................................................... 955Bates, People v ....................................................................... 886Batey, People v ....................................................................... 882Baum, People v ...................................................................... 946Bay City (City of), Moszyk v ................................................ 920Bay Harbor Yacht Club, Brusher v ...................................... 921Bay Harbor Yacht Club Ltd Partnership, Brusher v .......... 921Baylor, People v ..................................................................... 885Baypointe Apartments, Rump v ........................................... 871Beagle v Gen Motors Corp .................................................... 865Bearden, Family Independence Agency v (In re

    Bearden) ............................................................................ 889Bearden, In re (Family Independence Agency v

    Bearden) ............................................................................ 889Beasley, Motdoch v ................................................................ 933Beasley, People v .................................................................... 901Beaudry, Adams v .................................................................. 885Beavers, People v ................................................................... 952Becker v Richards .................................................................. 922Bell, People v ......................................................................... 895Belrose Co, Inc (AL), Hyland v ............................................ 938Belton, People v ..................................................................... 920Bennett, People v ................................................................... 877Benoit, People v ..................................................................... 947Bentley, People v .................................................................... 868Benz v Pittsfield Charter Twp ............................................. 866Berenholz, Alliet v .......................................................... 866, 922Berg, People v ........................................................................ 873Berlin Charter Twp v Proud ................................................ 884Berry, People v ....................................................................... 921Betancourt, People v ............................................................. 886Bettin, People v ..................................................................... 898Beuker, Smith v ..................................................................... 865

    xxvi 471 MICHIGAN REPORTS

  • PAGE

    Billops v St Anne’s Convalescent Ctr .................................. 932Bingham, People v ................................................................. 867Bint v Doe .............................................................................. 900Birchwood Manor, Inc v Comm’r of Revenue ..................... 877Black, People v ....................................................................... 884Blackhawk Dev Corp v Village of Dexter ............................ 905Blackmon, People v ............................................................... 884Blackwood, People v .............................................................. 871Bloomfield Twp, Lawrence v ................................................ 870Bluemlein v Delphi Automotive Systems ............................ 866Bd of State Canvassers, Citizens for United Michigan v ... 939Bd of State Canvassers, Coalition to Defend Affirmative

    Action & Integration & Fight for Equality by AnyMeans Necessary (BAMN) v ............................................ 939

    Bd of State Canvassers, Hazel Park Racing Ass’n, Inc v .. 875Bobillo v Gen Motors Corp ................................................... 921Bobo, People v ........................................................................ 951Bohn, People v ....................................................................... 951Bolton, People v ..................................................................... 873Bond, People v ................................................................. 888, 956Borthwell, People v ............................................................... 949Boscaglia v Kirsch ................................................................. 954Botsford Hosp Group, Inc, Tennyson v ............................... 949Bourne, People v .................................................................... 873Bowers v City of Flint ........................................................... 892Boyd, People v (Clifton) ........................................................ 955Boyd, People v (Kevin) .......................................................... 898Bradley, People v .................................................................... 919Branam, Haynes v ................................................................. 915Branch Co Bd of Comm’rs v Int’l Union, United

    Automobile, Aerospace & Agricultural ImplementWorkers of America, UAW ............................................... 913

    Brandt, Vowels v .................................................................... 883Brannon, People v ................................................................. 872Braswell, People v ................................................................. 950Brayman, People v ............................................... 1Brayman, People v ................................................................. 1202Brecon Commons, LLC, Brown v ......................................... 894Breighner v Michigan High School Athletic

    Ass’n, Inc .......................................................... 217

    TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxvii

  • PAGE

    Breighner v Michigan High School Athletic Ass’n, Inc ..... 1209Brennan v Dep’t of Environmental Quality ........................ 874Brewer, Family Independence Agency v (In re Brewer) ..... 937Brewer, In re (Family Independence Agency v Brewer) ..... 937Brewer, People v .................................................................... 948Brewster, People v ................................................................. 920Brock, People v ...................................................................... 954Brooks, Family Independence Agency v (In re

    Gentris-Brooks) .......................................................... 869, 875Brooks, People v (Billie) ........................................................ 949Brooks, People v (Jeffrey) ..................................................... 952Brooks, People v (Kevin) ....................................................... 948Brown v Brecon Commons, LLC .......................................... 894Brown (Jim), Family Independence Agency v (In re

    Brown ................................................................................ 943Brown (Tammy), Family Independence Agency v (In re

    Thacker) ............................................................................ 943Brown, In re (Family Independence Agency v Jim

    Brown) ............................................................................... 943Brown, People v (Darian) ..................................................... 867Brown, People v (Douglas) .................................................... 939Brown, People v (Michael) .................................................... 896Brown, People v (Steven) ...................................................... 962Brown, People v (Tony) ........................................................ 872Bruck, People v ...................................................................... 954Bruner, People v .................................................................... 883Brusher v Bay Harbor Yacht Club ....................................... 921Brusher v Bay Harbor Yacht Club Ltd Partnership ........... 921Bryant v Oakpointe Villa Nursing Centre,

    Inc ..................................................................... 411Bryant v Oakpointe Villa Nursing Centre, Inc ................... 1201Bryant, People v .................................................................... 871Buckallew, Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Michigan v .......... 940Buena Vista Charter Twp v Anklam Constr, Inc ................ 884Buena Vista Charter Twp, Fairchild v ................................. 870Burden, People v .................................................................... 945Burgher v Dansey (Burgher v Pulte of Michigan Corp) .... 947Burgher v Pulte of Michigan Corp (Burgher v Dansey) .... 947Burke Asphalt Paving, Ream v ............................................ 924Burkhardt v Bailey ................................................................ 920

    xxviii 471 MICHIGAN REPORTS

  • PAGE

    Burlingame Co v Chenard .................................................... 865Burnett v War Memorial Hosp ...................................... 873, 956Burnham, Ewin v .................................................................. 943Burrell, People v .................................................................... 919Burros, People v .................................................................... 920Burton, People v (Kenneth) .................................................. 947Burton, People v (Roxie) ....................................................... 871Burton v Reed City Hosp Corp ........................... 745Burtwell v Allstate Ins Co .................................................... 948Butler, People v ...................................................................... 954Byrd, People v ........................................................................ 899

    CCC Mid West, Inc v McDougall ............................................ 922Cal, People v .......................................................................... 921Calabrese, People v ................................................................ 954Calbert, People v .................................................................... 868Campbell, Mitan v ................................................................. 938Campbell, People v ................................................................ 946Capital Welding, Inc, Ormsby v .......................... 45Caraway, People v .................................................................. 886Cardinal Dev Co, Latz v (In re Arvin Estate) ..................... 932Carr v Midland Co Concealed Weapons Licensing Bd ........ 918Carr, People v ......................................................................... 945Carter Lumber Co, Echelon Homes, LLC v ........................ 916Carter, People v (Jeremy) ..................................................... 946Carter, People v (Maurice) .................................................... 920Carus-Wilson, People v .......................................................... 889Casco Twp v Secretary of State ........................................... 890Castillo v Exclusive Builders, Inc ........................................ 956Castillo, People v ................................................................... 872Castle Investment Co v City of Detroit ............................... 904Castro-Isaquirre, People v .................................................... 933Catalina Marketing Sales Corp v Dep’t of Treasury .......... 1209Cathey, People v ..................................................................... 938Catlett, People v .................................................................... 865Caulton, People v ................................................................... 863Cauvin, People v .................................................................... 868Cavin, People v ...................................................................... 952Celley v Stevens ..................................................................... 893

    TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxix

  • PAGE

    Cendrowski Selecky, PC, Reinhart v ............................. 871, 923Chadwell v Wojtaszek ............................................................ 939Chappelle, Shooltz v .............................................................. 922Charlton, People v ................................................................. 948Chatman, People v ................................................................. 863Chenard, Burlingame Co v ................................................... 865Chernoff v Sinai Hosp of Greater Detroit ........................... 910Cherry, People v ..................................................................... 921Childs, People v ..................................................................... 885Chisolm, People v .................................................................. 953Chisom, People v ................................................................... 920Chittle, People v .................................................................... 867Christensen v Christensen .................................................... 873Christian, People v ................................................................ 900Christman Co, Inc (The), Searfoss v ................................... 902Christy, People v .................................................................... 951Church Mut Ins Co v Consumers Energy Co ..................... 887Cipriano, People v .................................................................. 895Citibank, NA, Montgomery v ............................................... 872Citizens Bank, Eastern Savings Bank v .............................. 875Citizens for United Michigan v Bd of State Canvassers .... 939Citizens Ins Co of America, J & J Farmer Leasing, Inc v . 940Citizens Ins Co of America, Schmitz v ................................ 913City of Bay City, Moszyk v .................................................... 920City of Dearborn, Newman Holdings, LLC v ...................... 922City of Detroit, Castle Investment Co v .............................. 904City of Detroit, City of Warren v ......................................... 941City of Detroit, Curtis v ........................................................ 914City of Detroit v Detroit Fire Fighters Ass’n Local 344 .... 907City of Detroit, Herman v .................................................... 906City of Detroit, Merkur Steel Supply, Inc v ........................ 884City of Detroit, Nafso v ......................................................... 943City of Detroit, Robinson v ................................................... 870City of Detroit, Squires v ............................................... 866, 922City of Flint, Bowers v .......................................................... 892City of Flint, Linker v ........................................................... 893City of Flushing City Council, Warda v ............................... 907City of Grosse Pointe Park v Michigan Municipal

    Liability & Property Pool ................................................. 915City of Howell, 1st Rural Housing Partnership, LLP v ..... 886

    xxx 471 MICHIGAN REPORTS

  • PAGE

    City of Lake Angelus v Aeronautics Comm ........................ 866City of Monroe v Jones ......................................................... 931City of Novi v Robert Adell Children’s Funded Trust ....... 889City of Rochester Hills v Suburban Softball, Inc, .............. 949City of Romulus v Dep’t of Environmental Quality ........... 870City of Saginaw, Gerow v ...................................................... 906City of Southgate v Havrilla ................................................. 945City of Southgate v Johnson ................................................ 945City of Southgate v Miller .................................................... 945City of Southgate v Skiff ...................................................... 945City of Southgate v Whitman ............................................... 945City of Sterling Heights, Haliw v ....................... 700City of Traverse City, Nixon v .............................................. 943City of Warren v City of Detroit .......................................... 941Civil Rights ex rel Burnside (Dep’t of) v Fashion Bug of

    Detroit ............................................................................... 937Clark, People v (Dale) ........................................................... 902Clark, People v (Philip) ......................................................... 866Claybron, People v ................................................................. 950Clayton, People v ................................................................... 948Clemens, People v .................................................................. 948Clements, People v ................................................................ 868Cleveland Cliffs Iron Co, Nat’l Wildlife

    Federation v ..................................................... 608Clough v Balliet ..................................................................... 913Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action & Integration &

    Fight for Equality by Any Means Necessary (BAMN) vBd of State Cavassers ....................................................... 939

    Coates v Continental Vinyl Window Co, Inc ....................... 887Cockream, People v ............................................................... 953Coe, People v .......................................................................... 933Cogburn v Garritano ............................................................. 882Coker, People v ...................................................................... 884Cole, People v ....................................................... 1Cole, People v (Donnell) ........................................................ 895Cole, People v (Joshua) ......................................................... 1202Colin Communications, Inc v SBC Global Services, Inc .... 878Coller, Dep’t of Treasury v ................................................... 920Collette, Straub v ................................................. 109

    TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxxi

  • PAGE

    Collette, Straub v .................................................................. 1201Collins, Levitt v ..................................................................... 944Collins, People v (Thomas) ................................................... 883Collins, People v (Walter) ..................................................... 871Comerica Bank v Harbor Northwestern-30800, LLC .. 865, 922Comm’r of Revenue, Birchwood Manor, Inc v .................... 877Comm’r of Revenue, Health Care & Retirement Corp v ... 877Comm’r of Revenue, Knollview Manor, Inc v ..................... 877Community Emergency Medical Service, Smith v ............. 894Community Health (Dep’t of), Anthony v ........................... 892Community Health Plan, Inc, Procare Health Plan, Inc

    v ......................................................................................... 886Comstock Twp, Gillette v ..................................................... 898Conic, People v ....................................................................... 899Consolidated Rail Corp, Ward v ........................................... 889Consumer & Industry Services (Dep’t of), FACE Trading,

    Inc v ................................................................................... 878Consumer & Industry Services Director (Dep’t of),

    Associated Builders & Contractors-Saginaw ValleyArea Chapter v .................................................................. 877

    Consumers Energy Co, Church Mut Ins Co v .................... 887Consumers Energy Co v Public Service Comm No 1 ......... 893Consumers Energy Co v Public Service Comm No 2 ......... 915Consumers Power Co, SD Warren Co v ............................... 949Continental Ins Co, Rory v ................................................... 904Continental Vinyl Window Co, Inc, Coates v ...................... 887Continental Vinyl Window Co, Inc, Everett v .................... 887Conway, People v ................................................................... 900Conway Green Co v State of Michigan ................................ 896Cook, Grievance Administrator v ......................................... 1212Cook, People v (John) ........................................................... 868Cook, People v (Phillip) ......................................................... 933Cooper v Auto Club Ins Ass’n .........................................915, 956Cooper v Mourer-Foster, Inc ................................................. 919Cooper, People v ..................................................................... 872Cornelius v Joseph ................................................................ 902Corrections (Dep’t of), Floyd v ............................................. 900Corrections (Dep’t of), Hudson v ......................................... 949Corrections (Dep’t of), Neal v .............................................. 928

    xxxii 471 MICHIGAN REPORTS

  • PAGE

    Corrections (Dep’t of), Norwood v ....................................... 955Corrections (Dep’t of), Poindexter v .................................... 886Corrections (Dep’t of), Shipp v ............................................. 885Corrections (Dep’t of), Tague v ............................................ 871Corrections (Dep’t of), Williams v ...................................867, 902Costco Wholesale, Inc, Pica-Kras v ...................................... 893Couch, People v ...................................................................... 869Co Rd Ass’n of Michigan v Governor .................................. 887Cousino v Kiefer (Cousino v Nowicki) ................................. 885Cousino v Nowicki (Cousino v Kiefer) ................................. 885Covell, People v ...................................................................... 951Cowans, People v ................................................................... 952Craig v Oakwood Hosp ........................................ 67Craig v Oakwood Hosp ......................................................... 1201Crawford, People v ................................................................ 883Crego, People v ...................................................................... 868Cron, People v ........................................................................ 883Crump v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co ................................ 915Cummings, People v (Keith) ................................................. 873Cummings, People v (Walter) ............................................... 949Cupples v Evergreen Estates, Inc ........................................ 885Currie v Nat’l Metal Processing, Inc ................................... 883Curry, Lawsuit Financial, LLC v .......................................... 885Curry, People v (Darron) ....................................................... 921Curry, People v (Kenneth) .................................................... 948Curtis v City of Detroit ......................................................... 914Curtiss, People v .................................................................... 884Curvan, People v .................................................................... 914Custer, People v ..................................................................... 952Custer, Woodard v ................................................................. 890Cynthia M Trosin, DO, PC, Sosinski v ................................ 874

    DDaimlerChrysler Corp v Ajilon Services, Inc ...................... 884DaimlerChrysler Corp, Hofer v ............................................ 927DaimlerChrysler Corp, Magee v ........................................... 876DaimlerChrysler Corp, Nacy v ............................................. 870DaimlerChrysler Corp, Parker v .......................................... 922DaimlerChrysler Corp, Pifer v ............................................. 902Dalbec v Dalbec ..................................................................... 956

    TABLE OF CASES REPORTED xxxiii

  • PAGE

    Daly, People v ......................................................................... 906Daniel, People v ..................................................................... 953Daniels, People v ................................................................... 896Danley, People v ..................................................................... 953Dansey, Burgher v (Burgher v Pulte of Michigan Corp) .... 947Darden, Neef & Heitsch, Van Reken v ................................ 865David, People v ...................................................................... 949Davis, People v (Jason) ................................................


Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - Michigan Auto Law€¦ · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: Marilyn Kelly Justices: ... which showed some postoperative

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - Michigan Auto Law€¦ · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: Marilyn Kelly Justices: ... which showed some postoperative

STATE OF MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT · STATE OF MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT NL VENTURES VI FARMINGTON, LLC, Michigan Supreme Court: 153110 Appellant-Plaintiff, Court of Appeals.: 323144

STATE OF MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT · STATE OF MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT NL VENTURES VI FARMINGTON, LLC, Michigan Supreme Court: 153110 Appellant-Plaintiff, Court of Appeals.: 323144

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - One Court of Justicecourts.mi.gov/Courts/MichiganSupremeCourt/Clerks... · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan ... tenancy by the entirety where

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - One Court of Justicecourts.mi.gov/Courts/MichiganSupremeCourt/Clerks... · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan ... tenancy by the entirety where

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - milawyersweekly.com · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: Marilyn Kelly Justices: Michael F. Cavanagh Elizabeth A. Weaver

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - milawyersweekly.com · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: Marilyn Kelly Justices: Michael F. Cavanagh Elizabeth A. Weaver

Michigan Supreme Court

Michigan Supreme Court

Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Syllabus

Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Syllabus

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT MorningSide v. Sabree... · state of michigan . in the supreme court. morningside community organization, a michigan non-profit ... plaintiffs’

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT MorningSide v. Sabree... · state of michigan . in the supreme court. morningside community organization, a michigan non-profit ... plaintiffs’

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN … OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT _____ PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Plaintiff-Appellee, vs Michigan Supreme Court No. 154779 CARL

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN … OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT _____ PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Plaintiff-Appellee, vs Michigan Supreme Court No. 154779 CARL

Michigan Supreme Court Administrative Orders

Michigan Supreme Court Administrative Orders

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURTSTATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Plaintiff-Appellee, Supreme Court No. 148981 Court of Appeals No. 319642

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURTSTATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Plaintiff-Appellee, Supreme Court No. 148981 Court of Appeals No. 319642

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - One Court of Justicecourts.mi.gov/Courts/MichiganSupremeCourt/Clerks... · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: ... a licensee,

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - One Court of Justicecourts.mi.gov/Courts/MichiganSupremeCourt/Clerks... · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: ... a licensee,

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - Typography for Lawyers · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: Robert P. Young, Jr. Justices: Michael F. Cavanagh Marilyn

Michigan Supreme Court Opinion - Typography for Lawyers · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Opinion Chief Justice: Robert P. Young, Jr. Justices: Michael F. Cavanagh Marilyn

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT … · 2017. 11. 7. · STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT . PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Michigan Supreme Court No.

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT … · 2017. 11. 7. · STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT . PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN, Michigan Supreme Court No.

Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan 48909

Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan 48909

Order Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigancourts.mi.gov/Courts/MichiganSupremeCourt/Clerks... · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Robert P ... the appeal is from a ruling

Order Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigancourts.mi.gov/Courts/MichiganSupremeCourt/Clerks... · Michigan Supreme Court Lansing, Michigan Robert P ... the appeal is from a ruling

Michigan Supreme Court Brief_Coalition

Michigan Supreme Court Brief_Coalition

Michigan Supreme Court Controversies and Cases: The Indigenous Peoples of Michigan.

Michigan Supreme Court Controversies and Cases: The Indigenous Peoples of Michigan.

STATE OF MICHIGAN · STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN Plaintiff-Appellant, Supreme Court No.: 154494 -vs- GARY MICHAEL TRAVER,

STATE OF MICHIGAN · STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN Plaintiff-Appellant, Supreme Court No.: 154494 -vs- GARY MICHAEL TRAVER,

IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF …...2013/12/27  · STATE or MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF THE STATE. OF MICHIGAN Plaintiff-Appellee, Court of Appeals

IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF …...2013/12/27  · STATE or MICHIGAN IN THE MICHIGAN SUPREME COURT PEOPLE OF THE STATE. OF MICHIGAN Plaintiff-Appellee, Court of Appeals

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT Lower Court No....STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT. PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN. Supreme Court No. 154814 . Plaintiff-Appellee . Court

STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT Lower Court No....STATE OF MICHIGAN IN THE SUPREME COURT. PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN. Supreme Court No. 154814 . Plaintiff-Appellee . Court