IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in...

16
/ IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA ( GAUTENG DIVISION PRETORIA) PRETORIA THIS 24 TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2015 TUESDAY CRIMINAL TRIALS IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE ISMAIL IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TEFFO IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM IN COURT4E AT9;30 5 OCTOBER UNTILL 4 DESEMBER 2015 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILLL State v MN Mokwena and 8 others CC126/12 URGENT COURT IN COURT B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MURPHY IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS

Transcript of IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in...

Page 1: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

/

IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA

( GAUTENG DIVISION PRETORIA)

PRETORIA THIS 24 TH

DAY OF NOVEMBER 2015

TUESDAY

CRIMINAL TRIALS

IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE ISMAIL IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TEFFO IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM

IN COURT4E AT9;30 5 OCTOBER UNTILL 4 DESEMBER 2015 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILLL

State v MN Mokwena and 8 others CC126/12

URGENT COURT

IN COURT B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MURPHY IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS

Page 2: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 2 of 16

CRIMINAL APPEALS

IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI Name of Advocate for the state : Williams

No. Case no. Name of appellant Jail/Bail

1. A314/15 P T Lola + 2 jail

2. A73/15 P P Nkosi jail

3. A387/15 K P Zwane jail

4. A448/15 M Moagi jail

FULL BENCH MATTER

IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 23//11 TO 25/11/15 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MSIMEKI BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AA LOUW COMPENSATION SOLUTIONS 11820/15

ADMISSIONS

IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI AJ 1. M. ESTERHUIZEN ATT 83908/15

2. B. SWART ATT 75258/15

Page 3: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 3 of 16

CIVIL APPEALS

IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN VAN NIEUWENHUIZEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SEMENYA AJ MATHATHA PETRUS MATEBELE VS NOZIPHO EVYDENCE MATEBELE A552/15

UNOPPOSED MOTIONS

IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE NICOLIS AJ IN COURT 2C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MADIBA AJ

OPPOSED MOTIONS

IN COURT C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN

Page 4: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 4 of 16

JUDGMENTS

IN COURT4A AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE

Jimmy Kubjana +13 vs Thupane Joseph Makgoba +15 51017/15 IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEUWEN HUISEN

1. IN THE MATTER BETWEEN:

BLESSED NCUBE PLAINTIFF

AND

PASSENGER RAIL AGENCY OF SA DEFENDANT

CASE NUMBER 64821/2013

LASTLY AT TEN

IN THE MATTER BETWEEN:

THE LAW SOCIETY OF THE NORTHERN PROVINCE (TRANSVAAL)

AND

MR HAMLIN MSIBI RADEBE

CASE NUMBER: 352/2002

Page 5: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 5 of 16

IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI

1. CASE NO. A311/15

SOLOMON MATEBISE MKHWANAZI

AND

THE STATE

2. CASE NO. A902/14

SKUMBUZO SHONGWE

AND

THE STATE

3. CASE NO.A281/15

NOKO JOHANNES MOTHUPI

AND

THE STATE

IN COURT 8E AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI

1. JAMES FRANS MABUSELA v MIN OF SAFETY & SECURITY 67322/10 2. VORSTER GABRIEL J PETRUS v VORSTER FREDERIKA B 68708/13 3. DR MPOTOANE v HPSCA 68746/14 4. THE WILCASS GROUP CC v PREMIER OF LIMPOPO + 2 29074/12 5. TREVOR THOMAS KEYES v ELLINAS CHRIS +1 62385/13

IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE Parties: HP KIDSON v MINISTER OF POLICE

Case No: 76732/2010

LEAVE TO APPEALS

IN COURT 8G AT 9:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE STRIJDOM AJ

RAF

VS

NAISBITT

Page 6: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 6 of 16

SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS

IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 UNTILL 27/11 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 UNTILL 4/12 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICETUCHTEN

IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 PALACE 23/11 TO 4/12/15 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 4/12 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI

3RD

COURT MOTIONS

IN COURT A AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AA LOUW IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI

Page 7: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 7 of 16

CIVIL TRIALS THAT STOOD DOWN

IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI DJ P A POLLEY B T VS RAF 7302/14 B NKADIMENG T VS RAF 17537/13 C JACOBS N VS MINISTER OF POLICE +1 18371/14 D HASANI S N VS RAF 73335/13 E DU TOIT A W VS RAF ALLOCATION 53927/13 F BRITS A VS RAF 51316/12 G NDOU T VS RAF 26302/14 H NANDLAL S B VS RAF 53422/14 I LETHAKU S B VS RAF 25510/15 J McMURRAY C J VS RAF 3896/10 K ADV M ROLLER VS RAF 9080/14 L MOEKETSI X VS RAF 67731/14 M MOKOATEDI M P VS RAF 38536/12 N RATABA T +2 VS RAF 6784/13 O SWALIBANE O VS RAF 86344/14 P J D ACKERMAN VS RAF 2475/14 Q L DIKGALE VS RAF 10076/12 R E N MSAMANE VS RAF 69490/13 S M L KOBE VS RAF 40155/13 T D GERBER VS RAF 6830/14 U B P XIMBA VS RAF 78408/14 V N S SHLANGU VS RAF 29336/14 W S VAN JAARSVELD VS RAF 13295/12

Page 8: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 8 of 16

X PS SHABANE VS RAF 27255/14 Y C B MABENA VS RAF 21959/12 Z J D MOSS VS RAF 128986/14 Z1 K P SEBATE VS RAF 22859/15 Z2 M KHOZA VS RAF 6603/09 Z3 T THWALA VS RAF 26046/09 Z4 E PHOKU VS RAF 14734/14 Z5 B G MATSUBUKE VS RAF 69307/14 Z6 MALOPE M G VS RAF 15523/14 Z7 C TMAEMA VS RAF 47129/15 Z8 H E FERREIRA VS RAF 67809/16 Z9 P M SELOMO VS RAF 31778/14 Z10 MALEPE M J VS RAF 3440/13 Z11 H P CILLLIERS VS TRANSNET ALLOC 23250/14 Z12 P MOTSHUMI VS RAF ALLLOC 82789/14 Z13 S T K MOEKETSI VS RAF ALLOC 16534/14 Z14 A T VAN DER WETERING VS RAF 9105/12 Z15 B L MOSHE VS RAF 27551/14 Z16` W J RETIEF VS RAF 76522/13 Z17 J OLYN VS RAF 53498/10 Z 18 P M PHUMZILE VS RAF 15341/13 Z19 K MHLONGU VS RAF 49236/11 Z20 M Z DHLAMNI VS RAF 58107/10 Z21 MHLONGO A VS RAF ALLOCATION 65762/13 Z22 S F BALOYI VS RAF ALLOC 39508/13 Z23 M G MALOPE VS RAF 15523/14

Page 9: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 9 of 16

Z24 M TSHEPO VS RAF 10992/13 Z25 R MABENA VS RAF 42495/13

CIVIL TRIALS

IN COURT 8E AT 9;30 ROLL CAL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI DJ P 1A H R KHUZWAYO VS RAF PREFDATE NO FILE37420/14 1B S B NANDLA VS RAF PREFDATE NO FILE 53422/14

COURT ROLL 24 NOVEMBER 2015

1 N.G. KEKANA VS RAF 58087/10

2 S B LETLHAKU VS RAF 25511/15

3 T.J. MADISHA VS RAF 25668/14

4 S. MABHOZA VS RAF 28415/14

5 N. NKOMO VS RAF 21162/14

6 S. XABA VS RAF 22297/14

7 S.E. JELE VS RAF 18277/13

8 N. THEKISO VS RAF 9048/14

9 S.D. MADUNA VS RAF 14164/14

10 G.Y. MATHEBULA VS RAF 23172/13

11 E. BABE VS RAF 54078/14

12 T.S. MASANGO VS RAF 51190/14

13 R.J. MADIBANA VS RAF 40082/14

14 R.N. MTHIYANE VS RAF 35517/11

15 N. SIBANYONI VS RAF NO FILE 32620/11

16 L. M. MALEYANA VS RAF NO FILE 66399/09

Page 10: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 10 of 16

17 T. D. MASHEGO VS RAF 36258/11

18 E. BOTH VS RAF 65963/12

19 J. P. PRETORIUS VS RAF 57891/13

20 A.R. PASSE VS RAF 63562/13

21 S.S. NTSIMANE VS RAF 40196/13

22 E. VISSER VS RAF 67086/13

23 B.S. MOKGABUDI VS RAF 48337/14

24 C.M. ODENDAAL VS RAF 38161/14

25 A. SOKO VS RAF 28276/14

26 A.J. MATHE VS RAF 55569/12

27 M.A. ALI VS RAF 54010/12

28 D. I. MALULEKA VS RAF 6159/11

29 L.L. MKABI VS RAF 14231/14

30 W. VOS VS PADONGE 20588/12

31 T.S. MODISADIFE VS RAF 20791/14

32 F.P. MAHLAKO VS RAF 19809/14

33 M. FISHER VS RAF 10205/13

34 A.S. DE BEER VS PADONGE 17062/08

35 R.D. MNISI VS PADONGE 39027/13

36 J.F. VAN AARDT VS PADONGE 740/10

37 E. J. MATHULE VS PADONGE 25145/12

38 J.K. MAROTHI VS PADONGE 25146/12

39 D.N. MAVUNDLA VS PADONGE 18573/10

40 G. BEZUIDENHOUT VS RAF 23831/14

41 J. BEETGE VS RAF 14209/14

42 M. S. MAVIMBELA VS RAF 71993/13

Page 11: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 11 of 16

43 D. M. MHLONGO VS RAF 36065/12

44 M. WILLEMSE VS PADONGE 18542/14

45 A.W. SCHUURMAN VS RAF 31853/11

46 T. S. SIYAYA VS RAF 36328/14

47 L.B. MOKUBUNG VS RAF 19392/14

48 A.B. ROSSOUW VS RAF 19393/14

49 NTYINKALA F S VS RAF 67435/10

50 T. MAVHUNE VS RAF 54039/13

51 N G MATLOPELA VS RAF 55447/12

52 S. BOURECHE VS RAF REMOVED 9332/14

53 E. NDLOVU VS RAF REMOVED 66059/12

54 C.M. MENDES VS RAF 29518/14

55 F.M. FAKU VS RAF 31122/14

56 J.T. DU PLESSIS VS RAF NO FILE 67572/12

57 S.D. MKHALIPHI VS RAF 73656/13

58 I. A. GQOBOKA VS RAF 47040/14

59 N. DYASOPU VS RAF 58531/13

60 D.K. JANA VS RAF 38151/14

61 THOBANE C M VS RAF 20997/12

62 H M DHLAMINI VS RAF 16090/15

63 S. NGCOBO VS PADONGE 29813/12

64 M.F. LUKHOZI VS PADONGE 6430/09

65 A.E. VAN BUUREN VS RAF 68932/12

66 A.N. NGOBENI VS RAF 8880/14

67 I. J. DE VILLIERS VS PADONGE 72621/13

68 ADV SAYED VS RAF 60758/14

Page 12: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 12 of 16

69 J. MARAZ VS PADONGE 65474/12

70 J.C. STEYN VS PADONGE NO FILE 42607/12

71 D.J. V/RENSBURG VS PADONGE 23171/14

72 D. V/ RENSBURG VS PADONGE NO FILE 23172/14

73 M.M. JACOBS VS PADONGE 991/14

74 A.L. TAYLOR VS PADONGE 72622/13

75 A.A. GANIYU VS RAF 21479/14

76 L. MTHWESI VS PADONGE 63556/13

77 S. VAN WYK VS PADONGE 21093/14

78 S M MOLOTSI VS RAF 43410/12

79 T. WATSON VS PADONGE 13397/14

80 T.M. MABASWE VS PADONGE 75389/13

81 D.J. SWAN VS PADONGE 37092/14

82 A. BADENHORST VS PADONGE 783/14

83 E. KARELSE VS PADONGE NO FILE 29288/14

84 W.VAN RENSBURG VS RAF 338/14

85 M V NKOSI VS RAF 69040/13

86 C.E. VILJOEN VS LOUW PROK. NO FILE 5489/11

87 E. BRONKHORST VS M. BRONKHORST 44210/14

88 S. MALEBE-THEMA VS MIN. SAFETY & SEC NO FILE 58693/12

89 K. DANPHALL VS MIN SAFETY & SEC 43096/11

90 Z. KLAVER VS GIJIMA HOLDINGS 45076A/14

91 ABSA BANK LTD VS V.F. WENTZEL 21310/14

92 NEDBANK LTD VS W. SILVERTON 39474/13

93 ABSA BANK LTD VS V. F. WENTZEL NO FILE 28212/14

94 NEDBANK LTD VS TOTALLY BOARD NO FILE 39472/13

Page 13: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 13 of 16

95 SEAN AGENCIES VS EDENVALE STORAGE REMOVED 13165/14

96 M.S. SKOSANA VS MIN OF POLICE 70763/13

97 S VERMAAAK VS ICJ VERMAAK 47509/13

98 T. E. MABUNDA VS MTH. ATTORNEYS 65360/13

99 PROACTIVE VS P.J. STEENKAMP NO FILE 22314/14

100 D.J. MARITZ VS P. PRETORIUS 27198/12

101 KATANEC VS 4WAY LIFE HOSP DON’T REMOVED 70932/11

102 J.A. DEKKER VS MIN STATE SEC. REMOVED 31154/13

103 MANZINI I VS RAF 58814/12

104 CHANTAL HOME VS A.W. SIMAAN NO FILE 67234/11

105 R.M. MATHOSA VS S.M. SKOSANA NO FILE 72338/12

106 NEDBANK LTD VS J. ANNANDALE 23480/13

107 P.A. ABRANTES VS J. L. ABRANTES 27391/12

109 PIP PLUMBING VS CARRIM CONSTR. 1590/10

110 A. MAKONDE LELA VS PRASA 3290/13

111 N. MAPUNDU VS RAF 65636/13

112 J ZWINIVASHE VS RAF 31686/14

113 E S SEHLABANE VS RAF 25291/13

114 N J MOTSWENI VS RAF 27603/10

115 M S MOSOTHO VS RAF NO FILE 59174/12

116 T R LIDOVHO VS RAF NO FILE 83769/14

117 R G CHABALALA VS RAF 55794/12 118 M R MALULEKE VS RAF 40210/11 119 M A MANAVE VS RAF 68378/13 120 M J PHALANE VS RAF 32244/13

Page 14: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 14 of 16

121 A M P VAN DEN BERG VS RAF READINESS 39838/13 122 N P MAHLANGU VS RAF 61497/14 123 NN NHLEKO VS RAF 51421/14 124 N P MAIBILA VS RAF 1436/15 125 RA SAASA VS RAF 29531/12 126 P C BEUKMAN VS RAF READINESS 40703/13 127 N C TSOMELE VS RAF READINESS 41493/13 128 J MARULI VS RAF 44297/14 129 P E SELOWA VS RA MER 27676/12 130 M L PHAGO VS RAF MER 22709/11 131 P N MNISI VS RAF NO FILE 15096/11 132 L MANELL VS RAF 7273/13 133 L MOLLER VS RAF 47775/14 134 S J MOTOAI VS RAF READINESS 36923/14 135 A MAHLANGU VS RAF READINESS 3346/15 136 P J MOFOKENG VS RAF 61601/14 137 M L NKOTO VS RAF 15506/14 138 A BEUKMAN VS RAF READINESS 13058/15 139 A BRITS VS P BRITS NO FILE EGSK 51316/12 140 B M CACABILE VS RAF NO FILE 6904314 141 M K GUMEDE VS RAF READINESS7279/15 142 K R NJILO VS RAF READINES 7277/15 143 MM MOKOATEDI VS RAF PAST MEDS 38536/12 144 j I masilela VS RAF 57122/14 145 C J MC MURRY VS RAF PAST MEDS 3896/10 146 F MANZINI VS RAF READINESS NO FILE 4074/12

Page 15: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 15 of 16

147 P B HERMAN VS RAF READINESS 38432/10 148 J C STEYN VS RAF REMOVED 782/14 149 S M DLAMINI VS THE MIN OF POLICE 18542/15 150 R E SANOKA VS RAF 64348/12 151 H R KHUSWAYO VS RAF RAF 37420/14 152 M X NGWANE VS RAF 87291/14 153 M P MATHULE VS RAF 59569/11 154 M SHIPDANE VS RAF 67158/11 155 M O M MAMETJA VS RAF 69298/11

CIVIL TRIAL JUDGES

IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEGODI IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRINSLOO IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MSIMEKI IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSEN

Page 16: IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA · 3. case no.a281/15 noko johannes mothupi and the state in court 8e at 9:00 before the honourable justice legodi 1. james frans mabusela v min

Page 16 of 16

IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES NEDBANK MATTER IN COURT 8B 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KOEVERTJIE AJ IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MODIBA AJ

COURTS AVAILABLE