Vietnam - Informal Settlement in Formal Town- Analysis and Project
In situ informal settlement upgrade and densification_Nov 2015_Lili Smith
-
Upload
lili-smith -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
3
Transcript of In situ informal settlement upgrade and densification_Nov 2015_Lili Smith
IN SITU
INFORMAL
SETTLEMENT
UPGRADE AND
DENSIFICATION
WITH RESILIENT
SHORELINE UPGRADE
VISION
• IMPROVE THE LIVING CONDITIONS OF THOSE WITH
LOW AND UNSTABLE INCOME LOCATED IN INFORMAL
SETTLEMENTS AT MOST RISK OF NATURAL DISASTER
AND WITHOUT ACCESS TO TRADITIONAL FINANCE OR
MARKET RATE HOUSING.
• AVOID RE-LOCATION ACTIONS AND KEEP AT RISK
COMMUNITIES SAFE WHILE IMPROVING THEIR
QUALITY OF LIFE AND PROVIDING THEM WITH
PERMANENT HOUSING.
• DESIGN TO SUPPORT CULTURAL NORMS AND DAILY
LIFE ACTIVITIES, UTILIZING THE TRADITIONAL
VERNACULAR AND THE PRINCIPALS OF
AVAILABLILITY, AFFORDABILITY, ACCESSABILITY
AND ADEQUACY.
• DEVELOP HOUSING THAT IS DEFENSIVE AGAINST
EXTREME WEATHER CONDITIONS AND SEA LEVEL
RISE FROM GLOBAL WARMING
• INCORPORATE CENTRALIZATION OF INFRASTUCTURE
DESIGNED WITH DISASTER DEFENSE AND LARGE
SCALE SHORLINE DISASTER MITIGATION
PHILIPPINES
STATS ON WEATHER, DENSITY AND POVERTY
WHERE ARE WE NOW? PHILIPPINES
2014
179 DISASTERS
22,400 BARANGAYS EFFECTED
2,136,294 FAMILIES DISPLACED
9,654,293 INDIVIDUALS EFFECTED
1200 AVG. DEATHS PER YEAR
$30,591,625 SHELTER ASSISTANCE
Hazard
Absolute
[Million
US$]
Social
exp [%]
Total
Reserves
[%]
Earthquake 703.46 6.160 0.929
Wind 4,071.51 35.655 5.379
Storm
Surge 2,541.62 22.258 3.358
Tsunami 30.63 0.268 0.040
Flood 545.43 4.776 0.721
Volcano 557.60 4.883 0.737
Multi-
Hazard 7,892.65 69.118 10.428
Population
2014 99,138,690
Avg. Density
Manila
Mexico City
332/km2
19k/km2
10k/km2
Below
Poverty
25.8%
=25,577,782
PEOPLE
Urban Growth
Annual 1.3%
Urban Pop 64.2%
% of Urban
Pop. In
Informal
Settlements
54.3%
=35,560,341
PEOPLE
Manila Pop.
in informal
settelements
located in
danger area
4,200,000
POLITICAL STRUCTURE
IN RELATION TO HOUSING
WHERE ARE WE NOW? PHILIPPINES
SOCIAL HOUSING
FINANCE CORP
(PRIVATE , MANDATED BY THE
GOVERNMENT
TO FACILITATE SOCIAL HOUSING
THROUGH FINANCE SOLUTIONS)
NHA – NATIONAL HOUSING
ASSOCIATION (GOV.
DEVELOPER) MOST HOUSING
DEVELOPMENT DEPENDS ON
THIS ENTITY. EXPECTED TO
TAKE CARE OF ALL SUPPLY.
HOME DEVELOPMENT
MUTUAL FUND
DE-CENTRALIZATION:
Urban Development and Housing Act (UDHA) of 1992 and the
Comprehensive Shelter Finance Act (CISFA) of 1994
NATIONAL SHELTER PROGRAM – REGULATES HOUSING
PRODUCTION
1989 -PEOPLE’S POWER REVOLUTION
ADOPTION OF U.S. POLITICAL SYSTEM
EXECUTIVE/LEGISLATIVE/JUDICIAL
NATIONAL HOME
MORTGAGE FINANCE
CORP. (CURRENTLY NOT
HEAVILY INVOLVED IN SOCIAL
HOUSING)
HGC – RISK
COVERAGE
AND FINANCIAL
INSENTIVES
HOUSING AND
LAND USE REGULATORY
BOARD
CASH TRANSFER
PROGRAM –
REQUIRED $805 MIL
BORROWED FROM
WB AND ASIAN DEV.
BANK
HOUSES
PEOPLE
WHO NEED
HOMES NOW
RE-LOCATION
CENTRIC HOUSING AND
URBAN DEV. COORD.
COUNCIL
DEPT. OF
SOCIAL WELFARE
AND DEVELOPMENT
HOUSING HINDERING ISSUES TO CONSIDER:
• 4 MIL HOUSE BACK-LOG / NO COHERENT HOUSING POLICY
• NHA IS THE ONLY AGENCY DEPENDED ON FOR SUPPLY SIDE – CAN’T KEEP UP
• SMALL PROJECT BASED PROJECTS AND MINIMAL BANK INVESTMENT
• CASH TRANSFER CONTAINS POVERTY, BUT RARELY IMPROVES LIVING COND.
• HANDS OFF GOVERNMENT IS NOT WORKING
• INTERNAL GOVERNMENTAL STRUCTURAL ISSUES IN ALL BRANCHES OF GOV.
AND AGENCIES –PORK BARREL
• BUDGET ALLOCATION ISSUES – DEBT (20-25% OF BUDGET)
• ENVIRONMENT 10TH AND SOCIAL WELFARE IS 6TH IN BUDGET / MAJORITY AMOUNT SPENT ON
RESPONSE NOT PREVENTION
STRATEGIC THEMES FOR THE VISION PHILIPPINES
DATA & LOCATION
ANALYSIS
LOCATE INFORMAL SETTLEMENTS AT
MOST RISK OF DISPLACEMENT FROM
SEVERE WEATHER CONDITIONS AND
SEA LEVEL RISE FROM GLOBAL
WARMING.
CONDUCT ETHNOGRAPHIC
STUDY PRIOR TO DESIGN
PROCESS.
COLLECT DATA FROM RESIDENTS
AND STAKEHOLDERS
THROUGHOUT PROCESS,
INCLUDING A POST-OCCUPANCY
ASSESSMENT.
INSTITUTIONAL AND
LEGAL IMPROVEMENT +
CLEAR AND ACCESSIBLE
POLICIES. MOVE FROM
RELOCATION CENTRIC
TO IN-SITU FOCUSED.
IMPROVE ORGANIZATION AND INTER-
SUPPORT BETWEEN NATIONAL AND
LOCAL AGENCIES: INCREASE BUDGET
FOR HOUSING SUBSIDIES, INCREASE
GOVT. INVOLVEMENT IN SUPPLY,
ELIMINATE BUROCRATIC PROCESSES
BY GIVING POWER AND BUDGET TO
LOCAL WATCH DOG AGENCIES.
DEVELOP ADDITIONAL HOUSING
AGENCIES AT NATIONAL AND
LOCAL LEVEL TO SUPPORT THE
NHA: STRATEGY, PARTNERSHIP
RELATIONS, HOUSING
ALLOCATION.
LOCATE AND ENLIST EXISTING AND
REVISED LEGAL ENTITIES:TITLE
DOCUMENTATION, POLICY
IMPLEMENTATION, PARTNERSHIP
AGREEMENTS AND DISPUTE
RESOLUTION.
IMPLEMENTATION
OF STRATEGIC
PARTNERSHIPS
PARTNERSHIPS WITH NGO’S TO
FACILITATE EHTHNOGRAPHIC
STUDIES, ONGOING LIASON WORK
BETWEEN COMMUNITY AND
GOVERNMENT/PARTNERS AND
PROJECT MONITORING.
ENLIST COMMUNITY
ORGANIZATIONS FOR
COMMUNITY TRUST BUILDING,
INFORMATION FEEDBACK,
CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND
PROJECT MONITORING.
PARTNERSHIPS WITH PRIVATE AND
NOT FOR PROFIT ENTITIES FOR
DESIGN, ENGINEERING, SUPPLY,
MANAGEMENT AND PROJECT
MONITORING.
FINANCIAL STRUCTURE
FOR
LONG TERM SUCCESS
IMPLEMENT CITIZEN TAX NATION
WIDE.
COMMUNITY BANK, CROSS
COLLATORILZATION AND
CROWD FUNDING.
GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES AND
INCENTIVES.
TENURE MODEL TO
MAXIMIZE PARTICIPATION
AND LONGEVITY
SATISFACTION
RENT TO OWN, INSTLALLMENT SALE
WITH COLLECTIVE AND INDIVIDUAL
OPTIONS FOR OWNERSHIP
STUCTURING.
RESIDENTIAL UNITS PLUS
COMMERCIAL SPACE FOR
INFORMAL AND FORMAL
BUSINESS.
FORMAL COMMERCIAL WILL BE
RENTAL AND INFORMAL
COMMERCIAL WILL BE COMMUNITY
OWNED.
DESIGN AND
ENGINEERING STRATEGY
FOR HOUSING AND
COASTAL RESILIENCE
PHASE DRIVEN INCREMENTAL
HOUSING, CORE HOUSE PROTOTYPES
WITH SELF BUILD AND ABILITY TO
EXPAND. SEMI-VERTICAL
DENSIFICATION AND CENTRALIZED
SERVICES.
STRUCTURES ARE ENGINEERED
TO WITHSTAND NATURAL
DISASTERS INCLUDING
TYPHOONS AND SEA LEVEL
RISE.
CONCURRENT COASTLINE
RESILIENCY PROGRAM TO
MITIGATE WATER AND STORM
DAMAGE AND MINIMIZE RISK.
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES RELATED TO HOUSING
AND LAND MANAGEMENT
WHERE ARE WE NOW? PHILIPPINES
Department of
Social Welfare and
Development
Department of Transportation and Communications
National Economic and Development Authority
Senate of the Philippines
House of Representatives
Department of Environment and Natural Resources
Department of Finance
Office of the President
Department of Agrarian Reform
Department of Agriculture Department of Budget and Management
Development Bank of the Philippines
Government-Owned and/or Controlled Corporations
Home Development Mutual Fund
Human Settlements Development Corporations
Land Bank of the Philippines
Local Water Utilities Administration
Social Security System
Philippine Center for Economic Development
People’s Credit and Finance Corporation
National Power Corporation National Housing Authority
National Home Mortgage Finance Corporation
Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board
Housing and Urban Development Coordinating
Council
National Anti-Poverty Commission
Presidential Commission for the Urban Poor
Climate Change Commission
Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office
(10% to NSP)
DISASTER PREVENTION AND RISK REDUCTION
COAST GUARD
INFORMATION AGENCY
NATIONAL GRID CORP (PRIVATE)
LISTAHANAN
CIDSS-COMMUNITY DRIVEN TO EMPOWER COMMUNITIES
TO PARTICIPATE IN LOCAL GOVT.
NCDDP- WOMEN’S COMMUNITY
GROUPS – MICRO FINANCE AND
TRAINING
STRATEGIC IMPLEMENTATION PHILIPPINES
INSTITUTIONAL AND LEGAL
IMPROVEMENT + CLEAR AND
ACCESSIBLE POLICIES AND
REGULATIONS
IMPROVE ORGANIZATION AND INTER-
SUPPORT BETWEEN NATIONAL AND
LOCAL AGENCIES:
RE-THINK BUDGET ALLOCATOIN,
INCREASE BUDGET FOR HOUSING
SUBSIDIES, INCREASE GOVT.
INVOLVEMENT IN SUPPLY, ELIMINATE
BUROCRATIC PROCESSES BY GIVING
POWER AND BUDGET TO LOCAL
WATCH DOG AGENCIES.
DEVELOP ADDITIONAL HOUSING
AGENCIES AT NATIONAL AND
LOCAL LEVEL TO SUPPORT THE
NHA: STRATEGY, COMMUNITY
PARTNERSHIP RELATIONS,
HOUSING ALLOCATION.
REVISED BUDGET ALLOCATIONS
FOR ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPROVEMENTS, HOUSING
SUPPLY AND A MORE
COMPREHENSIVE LENDING
SYSTEM.
LOCATE AND ENLIST EXISTING AND
REVISED LEGAL ENTITIES:
TITLE DOCUMENTATION, POLICY
IMPLEMENTATION, PARTNERSHIP
AGREEMENTS AND DISPUTE
RESOLUTION. ENLIST LOCAL
LEGAL ENTITITES TO MONITOR
FOR CORRUUPTION ACTIVITIES.
GOVERNMENT
WATCH DOGS
INCREASE ABILITY TO
INSURE RISK FOR
PRIVATE INVESTMENT
IN PUBLIC/PRIVATE
PARTNERSHIPS.
RE-THINK LAND USE
LAWS AND FACILITATE
LAND ALLOCATION
FOR UPGRADE
PROVIDE MORE
PROTECTION
FROM RISK IN
ORDER TO
INCREASE
ELIGIBLE
BORROWERS
MANDATE MORE
FUNDS
FORSOCIAL
HOUSING
PRIVATE
PARTNERS
NATIONAL HOME
MORTGAGE FINANCE
CORP. – GIVE THEM
BUDGET TO HELP OTHER
AGENCIES STRUCTURE
FINANCIAL CONTRACTS
KNOWLEDGE
CAPITAL
FINANCIAL
CAPITAL
COMMUNITY
ENGAGEMENT
NGO’S
LEGAL
SECTOR
KALAHI-
CIDSS -NCDDP
COMMUNITY
GROUPS
WOMEN’S
COMMUNITY
GROUPS
HUMANITARIAN
AGENCIES
LGU’S REFORM THE
CASH TRANSFER
PROGRAM – INCREASE
COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS,
MORE CAPACITY BUILDING
MORE REGULATION
INCREASE BUDGET
CAPACITY
BUILDING
LIMIT DEBT-
INCREASE DONATION
STRATEGIC THEMES FOR THE VISION PHILIPPINES
FINANCIAL STRUCTURE
FOR
LONG TERM SUCCESS
IMPLEMENT CITIZEN TAX NATION
WIDE.
COMMUNITY BANK, CROSS
COLLATORILZATION AND
CROWD FUNDING.
GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES AND
INCENTIVES.
RENT TO OWN – INSTALLMENT SALE – INCREMENTAL CORE HOUSE – CROSS COLLATORAL
FILIPINOS HAVE AN
INEHERENT
UNDERSTANDING THAT
HOME OWNERSHIP IS THE
MOST DESIRABLE TYPE OF
TENURE. THEY HAVE AN
ABILITY TO CONNECT
THROUGH COMMUNITY IN
BOTH FORMAL AND
INFORMAL CONSTRUCTS
100% SUBSIDIZED
LAND AND CORE HOME
GOVT. GRANTS LAND
TITLE TO DEVELOPER
FUNDS ARE RAISED PARTIALLY
THROUGH A CITIZEN TAX ENFORCED
ON ALL INCOME EARNERS
COMMUNITY BANK IS CREATED FOR THE PURPOSE OF
PROVIDING LOW INTEREST FINANCING TO THE DEVELOPER
AND FOR THE COMPLETION OF THE HOMES. THE CITIZEN
TAX IS ALSO HELD HERE FOR DISTRIBUTION
THE COMMUNITY BANK HOLDS MORTGAGES FOR MARKET RATE HOUSING,
USING THE INTEREST GAINED TO FURTHER RE-INVEST IN THE SOCIAL HOUSING
PROJCECT. IT ALSO RECEIVES RENT FROM
THE MARKET RATE COMMERCIAL PORTION OF THE PROJECT.
LAND OCCUPANCY PERMITS ARE GIVEN TO ALL RESIDENTS FOR SECURITY, AND
LAND TITLE WILL BE TRANSFERRED ONCE THE UNITS ARE COMPLETED AND
PAID IN FULL. THIS CAN BE PAID THROUGH A PORTION OF THE RENTAL FEE.
CROSS BANKING COLLATORALIZATION FOR COMMUNITY PROFIT WILL HELP
FUND EXTRA SUBSIDIES FOR LONG TERM MAITENANCE AND MANAGEMENT.
THOSE WITH NO INCOME CAN BE COMPENSATED FOR WORK DONE. THE
ELDERLY AND PHYSICALLY/MENTALLY CHALLENGED WILL BE FULLY
SUBSIDIZED , FUNDED BY THE CITIZEN TAX, THE BANK FUND AND ONGOING
NATIONAL WELFARE
$ $
BOTTOM UP APPROACH –
CROWED FUNDING
COMMUNITY BUILDING
INDEPENDENCE
STRATEGIC THEMES FOR THE VISION PHILIPPINES
DESIGN AND
ENGINEERING STRATEGY
FOR HOUSING AND
COASTAL RESILIENCE
PHASE DRIVEN INCREMENTAL
HOUSING, CORE HOUSE
PROTOTYPES WITH SELF BUILD
AND ABILITY TO EXPAND. SEMI-
VERTICAL DENSIFICATION AND
CENTRALIZED SERVICES.
STRUCTURES ARE
ENGINEERED TO WITHSTAND
NATURAL DISASTERS
INCLUDING TYPHOONS AND
SEA LEVEL RISE.
CONCURRENT COASTLINE
RESILIENCY PROGRAM TO
MITIGATE WATER AND STORM
DAMAGE AND MINIMIZE RISK.
RAPID COASTLINE DEFENSE.
TYPHOON /FLOOD /EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT DEFENSIVE ARCHITECTURE • CORE HOME WITHIN
LARGER STRUCTURAL
CONTEXT
• APPLY TYPHOON RESISTANT
DESIGN TO A LARGER
LINKED STRUCTURE
•ABILITY TO GROW AND
CUSTOMIZE
• TRANSFORMING SHIPPING CONTAINERS
• USE SUSTAINABLE AND READILY
AVAILABLE MATERIALS
• MAINTAIN DESIGN BASED ON THE
• VERNACULAR, AND APPEAL TO THE
•COUNTRYSIDE ROMANTICISM
•OUTDOOR “DIRTY” KITCHEN AND PROPER
HEAT MITIGATOIN
STRICT
CONST.
STANDARDS
TO ENSURE
ALL PHASES
OF BUILDIGNG
REMAIN
DEFENSIVE.
ONGOING
INSPECTIONS
OF ADD-ONS.
HIGHLY ORGANIZED
MANAGEMENT
AND
MAITENANCE
EMPHASIS ON
COMMUNITY
INVOLVEMENT
DESIGN WITHSOCIAL
INTERACTIONS IN MIND
LOCATE SPECIFIC AGREEMENTS
BETWEEN PUBLIC ENTITIES
MORE WORK TO DO PHILIPPINES
SOLIDIFY DESIGN IDEAS AND ENGINEERING
POSSIBLITIES
COMPLETE A STAKEHOLDER AND COST
ANALYSIS
CREATE CONDUSIVE PUBLIC/PRIVATE
PARTNERSHIP SUGGESTION
DETAIL THE TENURE MODEL AND
MANAGEMENT PLAN DURING OWNERSHIP
TRANSITION.
DETAIL SHORLINE BUFFERING PLAN