in Mixed Species Planting - app.dnp.go.thapp.dnp.go.th/opac/multimedia/ebook/47_641.pdfwni'iJn n...
Transcript of in Mixed Species Planting - app.dnp.go.thapp.dnp.go.th/opac/multimedia/ebook/47_641.pdfwni'iJn n...
'L
L3 W1fl1U L3fl W
The Results of C/zukrasia and A. auriculj[orinis
in Mixed Species Planting
AT~Ou .5MUTI-wD 15 fu
Wiroj Ratanaporncharoen
235.5 LL13J hiThu ii ni airn 16
16 nTh1vN?J1c;1 iniii ii wf
V1M. 2547
Le"
Ii IIH II IIll III llhI II II llII IH II
00018819
L
L L
L nya.1 Fnrest Thnfirtment ,ihi
L
L
i' fltJ1'I LnJ3JI1 Wfl3J111J
The Results of C/iukrasia and A. auriculformis
in Mixed Species Planting
L
L
L
L
L /Lfl WLflJ
LWiroj Ratanaporncharoen
L
L
01 1 Lt lfl U1Lfl- I, irnrsrn 16
fl hi 3i'iJi urii
W.H. 2547
wni'iJn n u1aTnhtw 91 9
The Results of Chukrasia and A. auriculiformis in Mixed Species Planting
I I'U LflJ Wiroj Ratanapomcharoen
ABSTRACT
IL The growth of Chukrasia from various provenances in Chukrasia and A. auriculiformis
mixed species trials were carried out at Ratchaburi Experimental station, Paktho, Ratchaburi
province and Maetha Seed Orchard, Meatha, Lampang province. The layout was split-plot
design with 3 replicates, each replicate consisted of 5 main plots for 5 provenances of
I ç_ Chukrasia. Each main plot consisted of 2 sub-plots with pure and mixed species. The data was
L collected for 3 years consisted of survival percentage, height growth and shoot borer assessment.
The result showed that survival percentage at Ratchaburi was higher than Lampang. At age 36
I months, the average survival percentage at Ratchaburi was more than 90% in all sub-plots. But
I at Lampang, the average survival percentage was around 60% at the first year and it looked
I constantly until the third year.
In both A. auriculiformis and Chukrasia mixed species trials, there were no effect of
A. auriculiformis on growth of Chukrasia from various provenances. But the growth of
Chukrasia was only depended on provenances at the third year in both trials. The provenance
from Myanmar showed the best growth performance at Ratchaburi and the provenance from
L Thailand showed the best growth performance at Lampang. Also with shoot borer assessment,
there was no effect of A. auriculiformis for shoot borer on Chukrasia but the average
ç percentage of attacking difference caused by provenances. All Chukrasia provenances had
L been highly damaged at shoot caused by H robusta at Ratchaburi. But at Lampang, the
- provenance from Myanmar and Thailand showed highest value attacking percentage.
Keywords: Chukrasia, Acacia auriculiformis, Mixed species planting
L L
L 7 uiLiJ'hij 1l flu fl1 U]j'fl 16 ni n
L Lai-i?n6 aolfh
L
'L Forest tuøuuih'th
nrtThPt 2
r a,,
L '1
I l n u' ini i nl mii i ui thn'vi i
LL1n]1.1 1I L Iiiith'i ]Lfl ) L1J'IU !~,IVVITOIAATI LL 111 ThLN LL'IJlJ split-plot L
design fl1JTh 3 'Th L L 1flflJJ 5 LL flh 11f1L
r nn 5 thimi L11l)Th 11J1' J11iLJ JONJciflflJ
2 Viloh L thfl5bJfl i
11J1 LL LL1iflNilbJfl 1113 1) tfl1U'1 'fl1fl11fl {3J'I1flJ 1, 2
11 3I113J1l'1i ni viiih
rninff 1mnn1 1ni1 LLiim ihiii Ici i
1fl1 1 3flfl fl1J 90 'Li tui LI
1-3 1J 60 L L]c m
iJ)' L3Jfl tTh W160f5 ITL6 1JIO?J LLt 1' L1W
vnni frE51iin
LLltLLL 1flth f m L1 L flflh1EJ1flJ
L 1 ] 3
'51.61J'500
11c1h1fl LJ )11 L1 '1W
V1J11 Ufl1Ll 1fl1'5)1J'fl1 Wfl4
L 1 1 1 1tJ WlflJ
ç
L %111LSI] 1 1flh1fl ' 411L i L L iwhth V V o o 01 2 0 a
YI1J71 Ifl1L W1L'1TLfl
flhifl: fli J1ifl NrnJ lflJ1 n U 1
L L
L
L (Chukrasia) VUfl 2 ?J) ) Chukrasia
tabularis A. Juss. Wat Chukrasia velutina (M. Roemer) C.DC. (i J, 2544) 2 71i 1Ftu13fll 0' at a I 0.1 I OJ
91 Meliaceae fl1'fl1JV11.Th L1'J?fl1 Y fl1'fl 1JlTh L1LL)U1)L?1JVV1]W.
c1ifli rnl 1N1i L1c1Sfl. Llfl' lflJ
( m i'nici) 11 n1tJLJflflJ flJ711
iinii (Lnl un)
wammagIMIU (Mabberley LUm Pannell, 1995)
i
Ll11E)J0L11
i L NY1' tU (mixed deciduous forest) LL1J1' 1j' 1.flJ1
1nt (Kalinganire ti Pinyopusarerk, 2000) 30 UJ1'
L cflflft (clear bole) J1 j'3J1U 18 W1 4€J WYflJJT) fl1ThTh 11Jt LLI1J
L1016nnti 110 ?J. U.J tci ii fl1 Lu iirn'th1iiciiinnmj L W1 W1fl
13J'[1 tJ L iWtu.nii fi 1L Lth.L *ithJ %4tflh *i LIN LLfl fl L T W11
100
flU11i'UJW (Le, 1995) I 1fflfl
1 1 Lfl 1'bfl1.fl' Meliaceae
.111 LLi111 l iilnininiu ii'iii Lill Browne
(1968) 'flJflW1 INT C. tabularis LL )1hctlj 11LLf Hypsipyla robusta, Episparis
tortuosalis, Orthaga rhodoptila LLi Zuezera coffeae 1ii 6i 1I H. robusta 9L?T1L1 S I • .J
fl1 Lfl1.fl Meliaceae LthfthWJlfl
11nn1nic1)l LI 1I?11 ' fl1I1 Mfl,OE M LLiJ I
Eungwijarnpanya (1996) flfNll.fll 13J9/ C. tabularis fill Ill 1flJ?JH
L H. robusta ith,i J1fl fl1'11fi 1911,fl1LL)fl J E) LL
IL Li flSflfl 411 1 Jviici L?fl1
L flII1ffl 1iiiU I14I?1fJ i fl?JT)
flJ'111fi H. robusta I LLIJ 1'i c tJJ Ifl14N c4' Meliaceae 1 i I ti J11
L i T nii s
L IiiflIif 1i'iifltJ ?i L 1 1 '14 (H. robusta) lofiti'v5
LL flLI JcJlLIfl1JlJ
L aflafDAU LIJLOFJ3JYIiL tn 1FMI
LIi '/ 14 ?f'I J ii Iii J flU Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research
L
L
L 4
L (ACIAR) LL 1JL'1 LLFJ
O • ç j
kW11 Lt1J111 fl1 1 fl1l1 L L?J
iLL iflJ 4 Meliaceae fl Wlflc 1
a
1. ninniii n L Ll Thu Li niiiiji vj li7
flTaLuIlfljJrn, L iJ 1flJfll, W Ll L n'bJii
2.
Jl
3.
flr1c91
i n T hiii'
fl1 Ifl L J'
fliJ'flJfl Nfl fl1JlJfl Ul JiiL WuiL113J
LL 1tLL1t114Jflc3J y.0. 2543 LFLJ111Th 2 LLth LL i1i
o I Q 1 at I a a a
fl ULJTh1 flLJ1JThflYI) i? LLLL i L 3J
Y1iiLL.fl1 51LLUJ1 i,Ji
iiLL fli'i 1
a Jc UILL niriiii mi LII
21 21 21 21 a I a 210.' d l ULJ1
ifl Commonwealth Scientific & Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO) LLflhL1c1
JlLVLJ fl U L fl LLLThiflfliL11i '1 (provenances) 5
1j'L10 ] 1 WH i L3 f1 IJLJf1i (C. tabularis) flflhiL)10
Wth fllfllJ IJ1LLtJ LIJJ1.3J1 1ii LJ11.fl1J L1lJIJ111
le
?1IJl,I (C. velutina) nnt cihii LL l3Jfl U'1 (A. auriculiformis) 1 • a, a 0'a ç '1 21 I')
LLV1 UL 1JLL31L1'j L 1fl.fl'l 2
130 20' L1l4EJ
990 29' i'n
160
29.0
1,000
110
l4fl1
4.5-6.0
thL1Jj 14fl1*1'hJ
180 10' L1iE
990 351 Efl
320
26.5
947
107
iIt w nti
4.5-6.0
5
113J1 : °bsi', 2546
WMA 2
fl°1L tU° )
1J1tJLZ?J . 5' 5'
111 iiL°IcI LZ5,
Lfl1LLN Ffl13J LUJ13JSF
flJf11L1.J1 (J) ()
20030 C .tabularis Shanya, Hainan Island 180 iON 1090 30'E 45 10
20124 C .tabularis Ulu Tranan Forest Reserve J1LnLfJ 30 44'N 1010 491E 360 4
20102 C.tabularis Khin Aye Pale LJti1flJ1 21°56'N 94°53'E 155 10
20035 C.tabularis ThanhHoa L'JflflJ 20°21'N 105°08'E 50 10
20118 C.velutina LL3JWfl, zi,im 'IrnJ 17°29'N 990 17'E 180 12
19303 A. auriculiformis Seed orchard in Fiji Fiji 18-00-S 175° 00'E n/a 20
'L 6
L -fl'1Jn 2 1fl1 L Lfl111 11flh1'L1,1
L 2543 nl n'i thJitu 14 i4 1Jfl nli wni (Hiko Box)
lu fl11fltILJfl fll lflLL 'fl'I'] LL1 Wv J1'fl) L11 i-nrn.nii LLfl141flfl C Si . ci!' cii w. a a ci' cii 'j cii , a o i ci'
L 3 LJ 1 U L(YU Th1Jflfl IJL 11flflVflLYfl1fl 111
I - LL )tii L L fl1hYfl'1'bYi flUJLL1ri (L 1JLL1' LLT (hardening)
L L L1thJ1t U 20-30 i iii n winii
Ln'17111-3 Aa all
fl1Tfl IL LLlJal TI 0 a N1in 'Lii
L IIJ'5LLn53J CycDesigN (Whitaker et al., 1999)
1Lfl11LL1J U split-plot design (William and Matheson, 1994) LLLL1]
L i nii'ti 3 21 (replicates) IL 1)JULL fl (main plots) 5
LL1iN LL LL 5 1LLK1)LLTh 'hLL
L LLt flLLflLLL iJt1 (sub-plots) 2 7JI
(n) Lfl
(L?fl) 111s IJLLl'tl1 IL L'11 N JLVfl1J 3x3 LJ1 fl-11 cii i . a Si cii cii
It LIL1flfl1, 'Lwimi 1
- f1TLflhJ?J 1J
L t ci.' Si ci, a I 9' 9' cii 9' a cii a • cii
'flJfltJ u.Jn c
L (measuring pole) l'00n1J (Ht) ii n
- Inntiu i l l ' 1,2 LL 3T hLIUJ
L l31 mi1lflflnnn I fliu (forking) n 1 1 1fln11
flh1l L1fl N L1lJ'fl iri DBH (diameter at breast height)WLYW501
L ?flJ1L111fl' (diameter tape) ii1J 1.30 L1fl U114 LL JL)fl
fl1L Lih,!LflJqfl12j 1 1IIJ n11 DBH N c cii 9' ci' ci ci' • I ccii cii
niicii. II TflUL 1jtn L QIhiir (1)
L
L
I
X
x
0 X
0 x
0 x 0 x 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 X 0 )C 0 x a 0 X 0 a 0 am 0 0 0 0
0 Jx.,O,::o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 X 0 X 0 a 0 X x 0 x 0 X 0 X 0 0 0 0 0
00 0 0 ox o xo x ox o 0 0 O . X.0 ox 0 X X ox ox ox 0 0 0 00
x ox ox o a 0 0 0 0 0 xox 0 0 x, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 x ox ox ox
x 0 o x ox 0000000000 X ox ox ox o 0000 x ox ox ox x ox ox ox 0000000000 X ox ox ox o 0000 x ox ox ox
L main-plot
main-plot
main-plot:
L main-plot
main-plot
L 7
sub-ploti sub-plot2 sub-ploti sub-plot2 Rep I Rep2
sub-plotl sub-plot2 Rep 3
L
Note: Split-plot design
x = Acacia auriculformis
o = Chukrasia
DIVA 1 111
DBH=(d12+d22+. 2)1t2
(1)
r Uj a D B H A @ U T" a-)OVFJ"fIa-WLWFJIF)fI L
dl, d2,. . . ,dn 1 L 1fl 1 L fl 1'l 1, 2, 3,..., n 111J1U
(Pinyopusarerk etal., 1999)
11LLfl111tJ (survival percentage)
L
cin tulin a p . o a p a P o V P I
lu
LL1LLiTh (nni. 15 mULL nth1n1UU'$1 ii °rn,ni 25 9N
L
iniirniiIi,sch arcsine 1c1Jfl15 angular transformation LLL Li11
LLUUJI1L3JJ (binomial proportion) 11flfl iJ7i}Th flh1Tfl'5)1I
LLUU1J11 (normal curve) tii i.JLLthi (variance) ci (tij, 2523)
L
Ii 11 •
I
flflfl*1111131
nv,i Forest TJenirtmPflt Lihrp" 8
Low
L t'11fJ 111 'iN
LJ1fl1 1JL Ininqnii.j I L1Lflfl1J1fl
L LflTLJI17J cii1bJ Ji1I Lfl 1flfl1UJU(frass) L L11T 2J L1]11
U5LI)l.ft1J LL Ic11,1fl' I 11n WV1' 9, 9,
L LLfr1fl fl1'5LL1flW)'h'UJ ( IIitu, 2543)
flTThJ1U1 c)
'1 9, .4 9,
- 'hthmi tfl In 0..' 9,
umJnTrnflJ 21
- 1l i flHWfl R Z-800A VMI VIM W ILfl Lfl
L i n u n ni n n -
- LL1fl 11YJ1 V1J1Ith LfltJ 1 LI1 UY1
9, 9, 0.' 9..' '1 9.' 0 9' 9/ •
lu 1flW 1fl114 LL1)1IiJffl
1flJ'J LIh1 LI Iii iii (seedlot) Ti 1 1 W h) fl 1 1 fl rJ'1.iJ LI11 9.' • 3 . I 0/ 9' 0/
LLfl iiiii cn' iij ItJ1)1 arcsine L JI1T5 angular transformation I?fl.4 L fl fllJ2J ) E1'fl
flh11J W LL a 60
flTflL1?IIfl1 ii
fl1L 1' 01?111LLfl3J Genstat 5 Release 3.2 Second Edition hiii'ii
?J1 U1 fl1NE)fl@051WIT5EM
118 LI f11L?flW1fl I1l11 U ifliii LJ ( mean) 'iiw LLth
' LI1 LLr 11 11flfl1 1I lfl]3JLLththTh (analysis of
variance) LY 11cfl1JLI11) '] 1fl L L1l CJ)fl T
IciiJ I1?J 'l1 LJ
rnrnnmiiii oval Forest Department Librr' 9
L 3
I (L mJ v1. 2543 I 1Th1J1 T.M. 2546) uh
It1v
L - flU fl' ii n 3 ithi.n I 1l n 1c 1I 1 J n'i
L 3
Ii nlJl, 1 n u' hJ
DATI
fl11i13flfl flfl
LL fl NLfl 11 1LL1J1J11N fl Unt U'1
1 i 1 ?J 90.7 ii 86.3 13J11i fiff1m]J 2 I 97.4 LL 96.5
113.J1U II ii?1l tI 3 95.8 LL 93.6 J1' U 'iLL
htJN fl iJ m 2 ii chlu
Lfl1E1 L1flU.I 62.7 iiu 58.1 )1J111J LL liii'n 3
lu L ULJ'fl1 1fl ini'ntiiniiii 111
flh11 flhJlJfl L1flMJ
L 1 fl LL WI4'U VdlJtl JI1 3 Thini
fl' fl L 1 fl i1T1
L JL1 3 J
I LL1111'fl1 4
1fl1E10 gritflJ LLIJN T10 a N TRA M 01 51TH11511fl fl11' Ifl1
1J1 L 11nJ'Ici 1 J fi in h
L LL JTh 2 ?J11
90.7 un 86.3 0-1341611
97.2
iLiflt HLLflJ3Jii 11 JJJLThc1fl3.J Tii i?fl1 LL
L 1LLJ 96.3, 94.8, 82.2 II1 72.0 0113JAIcN
i L]lflii,. Liir n 1 Lifl JiflfliLL YJLL
L
I
royLFoxeat Dopnxtmeflt LibL 10
L N - oo
L .7
c r1 "0 0
oc
L .7
N n C
0 C r '.0 '0 '1
N
L oc 'I Cfl N C C
N
L ('
V.
m
N N o c
.7
N N en N N . . . 00 0" 00
17, 0' 00 ON ol
00
C
L - CA
C I —
cu L - D
- en en C '1 C
.- '.0 N '.0 '0 'r
-
C-
C L C N C N en
'.0 00 '11 '.0
0' '0
—
ca
L en N 00 N N 0 00 N 00 10 0" C, CN 0' ON
.7 C
L C- V..
N N C N en oo r-
ON 0' Ol 0' 0'
ao Cl 00 Izi 00 C — N
L - N lzr 00 C N
L -
C C en
r'i c'i d '.0 1.0 '.0 '.0 'IT
oc In
cm L
C- en N en C C
—
N
cm
- N en C 00 N
N ON 0'. N 0'. 00
L
V.
Q en N N — 06 0'. '.0 0' N
en '.d 00
L C- en en en N N
- 0, 00 N
0,
C-
00 N '1' "C C - .-' C C C C
N N N
TCG (
L
L
'L
L
4 fli1 tiii 1-3 11
hLLt U1h1j7
(arcsine)
L Soy d.f. 110 210 310
M.S. M.S. M.S.
L repi stratum 2 0.2246 0.0583 0.0204
repl.mainpl
I stratum
provenances 4 0.4133 • 0.0958 0.2421
L residual 8 0.0885 0.0288 0.0416
repl.mainpl.subpl stratum
L mixed 1 0.0250 0.0001"' 0.0065 ns
provenances.mixed 4 0.0590"' 0.0283"' 0.0319 155
L residual 10 0.0245 0.0156 0.0311
Total 29
L repi stratum 2 0.3851 0.3035 0.9227
repl.mainpl
L stratum
provenances 4 0.0926"' 0.0446"' 1.8628 "S
residual 8 0.1165 0.1332 0.4573
repl.mainpl.subpl stratum
L mixed 1 0.0025 "S 0.0018"' 0.2911 "S
provenances.mixed 4 0.0329"' 0.0154"' 0.1107 "S
L residual 10 0.0659 0.0753 0.2159
29
LTotal
flJL41: * - U1JJU 95 %
L ns - 1J1J1flfl 95%
L
L
tAO
f)tfl hi oya1 Forest Department 12
(Zeuzera coffeae) Lfl113J WI-fl JT)?J 1 11 fl 1i1-?1 (Bostrychidae: Coleoptera)
Lfl iinii h csi'1 (Royal Forest Department, 2000) *i'hh c4'i.i I'ui i'i n*in i 2 2 2
LL1J'h11 in L 1iI3Jfl1l1 2 ii ii 3 ii vnrn
LLQ1fli-fl1uIthJin LL fli fliiL'hihflJ1 1 J LiNflfl flEJ 2T]
(i'ii-n) nij n
2 9,
3
• L1Th1 wiiii
c!h L ml. Ji1 6
- )l?Ji' LLTh L1 LL fin 'W1lfl1 LLt flLtFU
LL1JJ1LW. iJrniJ (sandy clay loam) YiLLifl LL iNrFULL
lu - -flfl Lflifl1 LL1u1flfl
L 1i'tfliflfll. Lfl2JflT1-kIfl
Lithil LW1fli1 fl1flIIJ IbIMU
L rnicii nn m 3iJJ1JU LUI' III V1Li ni'in I Lfl11flJ
whi 6 L 11 LIfl'I LI iJi1flfli1fl n'bni ii- niJlc 1 iild ILn ifl'U ILI
L i uIIi nii q 3 J Ii1J111 ifliI11i' ')
LIi-tI 34 TIMMOM
2 '1 2 9,
IIIifli'ifl J)- I9'
Ji11 i1L) L2L1 lkflWJ UJ
L 1 fill LJ
9'11tJ3JiTh_ (LnJ, 2546) I mI II NTh 2 ftnin L)LLn
Lniti 1 i bVianaslillumsh
II flulfl Iifl hlfl iIfl?IJ LLt1114iLW1
r n m m'i m
L 2 ' 2 1 9' • 4' '1 9 itJ1 IItJ1flTh
L 1J3J1 W1tI 20 1iLi*1fliiJ'lJ f1Lmn-1 JfThJ
@fI 3 tfl1hllLtI mui n w
iiim mn mn mnln mLiti
L
r fl1JUJfl'tU3Jifl 11 n-n mniTni 1in
1 1 1 1 1 n'1N L)fli ill 19/JUfltt LIrni ifmcrnL3nJnmhJ 24
L nU'h]ILfl SLiu1di ncimnmnnrii
L
13
L dafj 2 LI lJfl LIctyr
I L L1n'IJ'Ii'
L niuI1niaiTh.
LI thifu.J VUINTMIM2J1,
L 2 11th iicic 1-3 TI Ynsi] 1 LLu 2 TI ini
L1JI111 fl1f11 L)f N LL fl'b.ifl
L Ii wn1.ni 5 I J 1 ii wn fl1LI111
L i L L 1 Th,1J lu
MOI Lila tJLYiif ii 0.90, 0.90 ?13i. LI 0.71, 0.78
L ?1J. II iflL,d3ThflJ 2 TI
LI JJ 2 ?iit h
L 00 3Jfl-ILiIaFJL~-IA'IJ1.67, 1.79 3j. LL 1.32, 1.37J. 013M OIJ
MON
Sflflfli
L Lf1WdUii 'I LI 1JL flii'tL
LLf11th1 LLJ JLJJ Lliflfl LI I j 'biuJ
I- 0 . 0 i LJ JJJç) 1iJLL'?J1. LL1 IL iflTh1, L.thflJ 3 ii ii LW1iI1U L1
fl ifliiIfi ' 2 tini L i1Lfl
L LL I1?J1J I LIifli Li F
1.67, 1.79 3j. LL 1.98, 2.17 Mi. ii LL
L ILLt L*111J 1.98, 2.17 U. LL 2.30, 2.47 ?.J. 1-I3Ji11i
L ni 3 TI LL i3fl) L Ii't LLiJI
11iE LL LLthLJ1. lLLf 1LL 11T1?fli
L ifll1iiL Khin Aye Pale L L Ji (20102) q T 2.57 N. LL 2.81
L T - I V oil ?flJ. 013JAIou LL1ifl1 )1h1ii l'1IJ i.flt)
titmn LI 1LLUJfl i'ihth (20118) i L ni Llii cfliJ1 LIU
L 2.78 N. LL 3.53 . ormami
I L
07
C-
oC
07
1=
CD
07
CD
07
CD 07
CD
07
C- -
07
C—
CD
CD
C;
CD
C-. CD
CD
C;
CD zc
CD 'CD
CD
C;
CD
C. CD 'CD
CD
C;
CD
CO CD 'CD
CD 'CD
CD
C. CD 'CD
CD 'CD C;
CD
C. CD 1CD
CD 'CD
CD
C. CD iCD
CD 1CD C;
CD
C. CD 'CD
co 07
CD
cro
CG
07
C-
CD?
C0 CD CD
Gt
C-CD
-7;, C
C C. CD
Cr0
N
C 00
L n1 Forest Denartment 14
en C\ 00 N N en N
en Cl N c en•
en en - Cl
Cl O C 'n ON N — N 00
00 O \D 00 00 h .r, N D
" C\ 00 00 O
Cl? h .-
Cl 00 h Cl .c 00 'n
- 00 -
— 00 N
Cl Cl ,— —
'-0 h -0 C> - 00
C N en '.0 CD - 'I-C Cl en en Cl Cl — — —
lzr 00 'IC .-
en 00 00 en C 'I-C• <= enj - Cl Cl — — — 1, en Cl T - 00 00 en
0 en Cl — Cl — — - " Cl
N Cl C N Cll v 0( C> - Q
0 ,— en en Cl
V 00 C> Cl C
00 N 00 N N 00 N
C C C
en 00 'I-C Cl en 00 0\
0 0 0
en 'I en h h h C 0 0 0 C
C en 00 0 0 0 N C C C C
— 00 'I-C C 00 C 0'. 00 00
00 C 0 0'. '.0 - C
00 Cl C — 0 Cl en en — — — C C Cl Cl 0
Cl C Cl
C Cl
C Cl
15
L LLLN1c1lThflfl
2 ii visii LL JL1 1-2 TI LL;n1'n
L (main plot) LL iii 'JJ (sub-plot) 2 Wilo
vJ fl flflUflJ3J
L jçi, LL ili n u
1 Lila fl1L 1LflWJEJ 11 3 i vnrn
L fl11aflaSUMV U111'1fl13J LL1Ji1 flfl' 1N 111
4 • 4 •a a '1 a _ 11tNL11lflJ 11 iJflThi 6 LL ?JN Lfl t1LL1i
I jJj l N n 1 1 T n u Lt h uJ
0J V 4 • a 1 1 Ll q LL n1 2 iw
• i
LL1fl11'mflflflJ 1J1 1L1J1flfl L UL I1fl1flJJ I IJfl1L11J L1
n (intermediate growing species) LIi13Th iIh?1 iisi hi
L1fl niuIiii (fast growing species) "14 lJLLfl1J fN1fl1Vl
111fll11JSflfl LUJ'UJIIi'ULIfl13TVAJ OU 6,110NIJ1VJ 1Jn1J
1JflJ' LLfIL1) '1JflflUflT I 1'IIf
111' Jfl 1t1'1 '1 1 LJ n LLflh1fl1'bJ
a ?a S 1w a 1 w 'I I1q NLI
• 2 1iI1iu
VnJ Lii fl
a j 1w a 'i.i .4 '1w a 1w a J'1 L'I1fl15I11J L17J} I 11itJ11. II'i1fl111 I'I'I1- L)Sfl1111TL1J LQ7Jft IflJWU
- I I
L 101MIUMMOILOWIflULI 1tJIYhfl
ul141L1c1 Khin Aye Pale iiI LiJUrn1 1LflTII1'l W)1J LI lu
L L1flfl'lIflLl'i1f'U 3.33 3j. 5.68 16J. 1J1'1i (ii, 2546)
I
L
'L I4itthflfljth'LiJ * Loreet Department Ljjr* 16
L
L CD 00 cI en N
fl 00 - Cl 00 00
cli Cl CD Cl CD In CD L
L en
L \ _i Cl
Cl C
r N
en '.0 Cl
'.0
fl
N Cl Cl
• N 00 en - N - C4 N C' '.0 Vl Cl, Cl 0 0'
Cl fl
-
L C- C.
L L
00 '.0 '.0 Cl en 00 en en
C.
C. C'1
C.
L ca -
C.
C-. '-C 0"
.7
Cl Cl
im
cq - '$1 L .7 C.
Cl
Cl
v-
C'
Cl N 1---
Cl - .-
00 00
r- ' '.0 N N Cl CII en 00
'0
_r •Q
r •_
C- C-
L 0
C.
L
C' 00 .... 17, c-C 'zt 00 - 'C .-••-' Cl e- C.
.7 .7
I I .7
J
C-, E
-121
- C- C- rA
L
* *
C-
cc *
L 1.0
7I C- In - C-
-
L H
L
{ 1flhi1 L1 J4l LL J'
L
f1T1
1 ii LLci1LLtJ
[ LL1fl'fl1 7 LL 1fl1'J1if1'IJ
fl Nfl Ulfl 1 1fl 1 J 11TJf Lfl1l1flfl'L1I
r LL7flTh1J fli 1fl
L L1U
flh111Th U L l I l J1lth L11 L NLL)'flhi'I1
L ,uIii i l iiini tiiii 3
2 71i 1?i1J 1L fl1
L r
fl'fl Wfl'fl'I]flfl1'flL11L1i'fl1
i L 1 L 1fl h 1 L 1 L 1 FLL11
0 - -
i W H. robusta f1J fl1LLVJ'1'1Lfl1 Wu1U LL 'h4
L iii 8 LL iiiJi' viJi
F LlJ h itii 1fltJ 66.55 LL1 59.50 t-311
LL l 1?u1 VflJ1 fl 11flfl1 ii.
L 1 f l J H robusta LJLL 1Jt 111 114 7 L1'1J'3
L L11'b1EJ 2545) LL 114 11?fl in U1fli14fi1Lil
' fl 14L1 1L?fl11EJl14T1 LLLLt i 1flt h
L i,ni H robusta fli ' 1] L fl1
iflfl1'11flli1 UJLL )14Ll14U 11l 1fl)flTh)flT LLLLfl L'?J
- H robusta 11 1 'bfllfl1 Meliaceae .4 V .,}1V 2. .4 V
Ui fl?1141 S1JIUN I 1rnWn11I1]aI1Wn Ui NL 141V)l) nTL7flYflfltJ'JN
iNJ L lfl II'J11-'] 114111]
iLIflY1li1%11 0m713471l1 U'i'l LI 14nivJflfl1c1 1I1J114 I lu
L114th1')1 L1J l'fr1Lfl1fl11J1i 1Wfl4 1tJi1114 (Tilakaratna,
2001) ni n14'wli L11flh1fl1'U1J N41.114 ISflJ 1T14fl1T1th 1ni'thn
L
17
LI
L tiiturnnmiilii to1oreGt Dcpartment Librar' 18
II
L fl L11 i,in u lThiìj JiI [) hIY Acacia Lthfl1. tiiih
L f1NJ (Hybrid) A. auricu4formis LL A. mangium LLfl1 fl't l t'
hJ'bYA. dfJ1cilis iihni 3 TJ fl1fl1ulT)1i1 111th,fl1Lth4111.g
L
L
L
L
L
L
L
LU
'L 19
L L - 0 00
C, o - en - C en N
.7 .7 - L •CG
e C-- en "C 00 (-'I
00
cq L C.
i r en N en
' N C
\0 N
- kn- - -
en
- , c N 0 C
L - 00 00 , en N 00 0 0 0 00
.7
Cl 00 © Z N N 't 00
00 00 0 C O N 0 L
C. C en 00 'fC
N 'r •- 00
-
L -C c e
en 00 en 0' N N
L C
- C C C C en en en
C— 00 'fC
L C. C C C C C 00 N "0 '0 IIR
75 C 00 C-C -' - - en N CC en
cm
L
ZM
CG
N
'0 00 en - Gx - N N N 0
CG TV- C C C C C N en N "0 N
L 7
- D C' C C C C C 00
'fC N C-C 00 - en
iz -TcG 1=1 - 0 00 Cl 00 - 00 N - - -
L .7 C C 00 CC C C C en NJ
N
CG N N C
L .7 ra 75 im
L
' C N 00 00 00
C C C N
'.
L 00 '.0 C\ N
C- en
C N
- 00 o C N N
C N C-
L r-I CG 00 C N en en -
L
C 'C
- .-' C C C C C C C N N N N N
C
L
L ini miii rn14J Forest DeDsntment !.ih.-.r 20
L n'ni 8
LLIfl1 1 N1ifl Win n1.tU w)1ilfu LL
L L niiti (arcsme)
ni SOV d.f. iJ 2i 3i
L rep! stratum 2 1.25958 0.97045 0.35747
repl.mainpl stratum
L provenances 4 1.30149 0.99846 0.09658
residual 8 0.38305 0.25372 0.23327
f repl. mainpl. subpl Trdu
L ' stratum
mixed 1 0.10541 0.00750ns 0.00025m
r
L provenances.mixed 4 0.05249 0.08190 0.06808
residual 10 0.04583 0.02895 0.02137
Total 29
rep! stratum 2 0.00202 0.07852 0.24709
[ rep!. mainpi stratum
provenances 4 0.00028" 0.45723 0.39820
L 41.Lj-1,3
residua!
rep!.mainpl.subpl
8 0.00020 0.07559 0.08816
stratum
L mixed 1
flu
0.00003 0.05399 us
0.16654
provenances.mixed 4 0.00058m 0.10153113
0.12293113
L Total
residual 10
29
0.00076 0.03653 0.05309
I _______ * - 1JLL1flflfl1 1JLIilfl. 95%
L ns -i 13JLLIflfl1' 1JL1iIJ1 95%
L L L L L
L oi1 Forest Dartment Lihn" 21
L LLLflEIu m;
LLf1111 l4LSfl -. a 91 91 o 41 91 • 41
1 1 in f1iL1.lYN '1 cru£
LflIWi1 1fl11]JL3J
L 36 L1t IL i ini inniii 90 Ivtodm
- 'A 0/ 4 1 o Q1 • • I
MJ1 2 ZVO
58-62 iL ifl 11LL 17ii S)ifl
L w I2 4/ 4/ 9/ 9'
I A-1-58 al 10 N r 15 (Good, 1964) ifli 1LILL iifJ14ii L Lflit
(flLI1JIJ sandy clay loam N 1flWU I 1fl4W11J ii'bi,,n iJi1?1J Ni1tflfl.
lu
0' 01 l • '1 0'c 6 • 2 2 a 91
r 'Il3nn LI wn i i i i r n'hi
L uiV svnjii ni'
1iiflhifl1L iL)Ifl (pure) flUfl1}th fl1 U' (mixed)
I J L L W
12-36 Lil
L
L L1 1J1111 II 151 T NOTINall Rat L,J Ni OU Jfl a-III LV 813 @ fl ail fl
iflfliLlLITh IVT WZAA LI iniii'
Liu 1%
F uiii L1c1b1tJ LI LJJ1flJi iiI T ffli ifliI 1t i
L
L H. robusta
2J1 Meliaceae LI Ni' Li L i11i?JiJifl3JiJ yiijii ni'tJI1'I3.J
[ LL'5f)q L MA allffl 0fl0 'J1 LIJ1JL1JU
L NIL II WLJfl I J7J11t) Lcn
rni ffluj 36 II fl IL Yfl2J' LI II
L l,fliWl LI LI iniii'
L IILJ WJ1' fli W1iI111 I ii 1 1l W)i
I LI LJ 1i if131flJ 9' 9'I • 2
L 1 ili n ni 4 m n 1 Vflfl) 11iflLITh
- II L'flII 1fI 3JJ IL Ji1?J1' H.
L robusta' ii (Tilakaratna, 2001) i mninii ni'fu iit I?ht niiin
10-
Li 22
L
J14'1 (Hauxwell et at., 1996)
n n nfl nt U 1fl,
H robusta fli fi111Lj'ij 13J11fl111 (resistance)
LL'?I W)1,L f WflL1L fli f1141) iii I LVflfflfll41 11JNth L)1fl
*1J?J H robusta (leading
shoot) 11431 L1 1J1 LSitlI'1 1 W1UJ 1 L 1Jk) 11 *)11 J ] tfl11J L .j
1L 1 fl1fl1 Y l]111fl .fl11f1]f Thfl
1 Lfl NIIJl1]
L c11uIJ
1Jtu ct UilJJ1tJ ii u rlj nii
L1 N ]LL3J'IW flh]H
-. ?1Th11LL1JF lu
flft L L E1 L1ftJ J11fl 1 1 4Jt 1
L LLfl 1 U 1i LI
L
L
L
L 23
L
WRIJ lL f1?JU1. 2523. ii 4.
1lfl flflVfl7f 1fl1,
flTtU 41Lt1J th1ii iukuuii -inn c1ncI?n1. 2543. fl1flh1)J?JE
flLSflJ EJ iiJ LLU1 ii i]i'I', ]flflffl5111'hT, nji3ibY.
tb 2544. iithaii'hm 1JLLLJ1J vLc1. 2544. thn'iqn,t
iii]ilY, rn'n ni',]i'b', nJ1]1l3'. 814 u.
L ThSIij VILUJ. 2545 fli fl1J1LfllLThibTh, U. 37-48. ?u Th1111
05A 7 ' 1 1 n L 1 L 1i)". T h
iMj, ni]i'b'.
151i LflJ. 2546. cfl13.J N1 IIth2J flT11Jb1
L . jujiTi,
n'1wi. 115 wiii.
Browne, F.G. 1968. Pests and Diseases of Forest Plantation Trees. An annotated list of the
principal species occurring in the British Commonwealth. Clarendon Press, Oxford,
1330 p.
L Good, R. 1964. The Geography of the Flowering Plants. William Clowes&Son Limited.
London. 518p.
Hauxwell, C., J. Mayhew and A. Newton. 1996. Silvicultural Management of Hypsipyla
Species, pp. 151-163. In Hypsipyla Shoot Borers in Meliaceac. International
Workshop on Hypsipyla, Kandy, Sri Lanka, 1996, ACIAR PROCEEDINGS No. 97,
Canberra, 2001.
Kalinganire A.and K. Pinyopusarerk. 2000. Chukrasia: Biology, Cultivation and Utilisation.
ACIAR Tenical Reports 49, CSIRO Forestry and Forest Products, Australia, 35p.
Le D.K., 1995. How to produce enough planting materials for our reforestation program.
Vietnam Forestry No. 1995. Ministry of Forestry. Hanoi. 14 p.
L
L
L 24
L L Mabberley, D.J. and C.M. Pannell. 1995. Meliaceae. Meliaceae, pp. 229-300. In M.D.
Dassanayake, F.R. Fosberg and W.D. Clayton, eds. A Revised Handbook to the
L Flora of Celon. Vol.IX. Published for the Smithsonian Institute and the National
Science Foundation, Washington, D.C. Amerind Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd, New
Delhi, India.
Pinyopusarerk, K., A. Kalinganire and K. M. Aken. 1999. Guidelines for establishment
of provenance trials, mixed-species trials and provenance resources stands of
Chukrasia species. CSIRO, Forestry and Forest Products, Canberra, Australia.
Royal Forest Department. 2000. Progress report July 1999-June 2000, ACIAR Project
L FST/ 1996/005 "Development of domestication strategies for commercially
important species of Meliaceae", pp. 37-57. In A. Kalinganire and K.
L Pinyopusarerk, eds. Development of Domestication Strategies for Commercially
Important Species of Meliaceae. Annual Progress Report, July 1999-June 2000,
L (ACIAR Project FST/1996/005). CSIRO, Forestry and Forest Products,
Canberra, Australia.
L Eungwijampanya, S. 1996. Hypsipyla Shoot Borer of Meliaceae in Thailand, pp. 22-23. In
ACIAR Proceedings No. 97. Hypsipyla Shoot Borers in Meliaceae. International
Workshop on Hypsipyla. Kandy, Sri Lanka, 1996.
r Tilakaratana, D. 1996. Hypsipyla Shoot Borers of Meliaceae in Sri Lanka, pp. 3-6. In
L Hypsipyla Shoot Borers in Meliaceae. International Workshop on Hypsipyla, Kandy,
- Sri Lanka, 1996, ACIAR PROCEEDINGS No. 97, Canberra, 2001.
Whitaker, D., E.R. Williams and A.J. John. 1999. CycDesigN A package for the computer
generation of experimental designs Version 1.2. CSIRO Forestry and Forest products,
Canberra, Australia. Department of Statistics, University of Waikato, Hamilton, New
Zealand. 28 p.
Williams, E.R. and A.C. Matheson. 1994. Experimental Design and Analysis for Use in Tree
L Improvement. CSIRO/ACIAR. 174 p.
L L L
L
L
L L
235.5 IB 641 N
16 47 L I - V i
L NI1cq3 •f[cj
'flJfl IJ2JU
235.5 641 -j