Implementing a First Power/Energy Systems Management Course Via Multidisciplinary- Project-Context...

1
Implementing a First Power/Energy Systems Management Course Via Multidisciplinary-Project-Context Learning Paulo Ribeiro, Calvin College, Grand Rapids, Michigan The Electrical Power & Energy Systems Management Systems Course introduced students to real world problems. Besides learning the analytical basis of power and energy systems and the consequent environmental impact, and using professional state-of- the-art computational tools, the students (from mechanical, electrical and civil engineering concentrations) were divided in small groups to work on several real world projects in the local area. Abstract Projects Wind Generation Feasibility Study Conclusions Student Evaluation "Our class looked at almost all of the new energy ideas I wanted to hear about“ "Working on our own projects ensured we enjoyed our topic and learned something we felt was valuable“ "For many of the projects, the work continued after the class, meaning we could go back later to look at the progress or continue it ourselves.“ “The class was flexible in terms of what field of Power Systems to study, allowing me to focus on my particular field of interest while still learning about others. The field trips to Consumers Energy, the potential Figure 1 – Site for Wind Project Table - Analysis of a Variety of Wind Turbines ARE110 ARE442 BWC XL.1 BWC Excel EW15 Northwind 100 Skystream 3.7 JACOBS 31-20 Swift Rated(kW) 2.50 10.00 1.00 10.00 50.00 100.00 1.90 20.00 1.50 Possible(10MPH) (kW) 0.23 1.80 0.17 0.93 5.71 5.64 0.32 1.00 0.14 Possible(15MPH) (kW) 0.65 3.00 0.39 2.44 18.26 22.94 0.72 3.80 0.27 Possible(20MPH) (kW) 1.67 7.10 0.57 4.10 28.54 48.31 1.02 9.40 0.76 Possible(25MPH) (kW) 2.50 10.05 0.65 7.90 34.36 74.73 1.16 18.00 1.27 Cost Of Turbine($1000) 12.65 39.60 2.59 27.90 145.00 250.00 5.00 27.40 6.82 Cost Of Tower($1000) 3.00 10.00 2.05 10.00 0.00 0.00 1.85 15.80 0.00 $/W(Rated) 6.26 4.96 4.64 3.79 2.90 2.50 3.61 2.16 4.55 $/W(10MPH) 68.04 27.56 27.78 40.69 25.39 44.34 21.75 43.20 47.71 $/W(15MPH) 24.08 16.53 11.78 15.55 7.94 10.90 9.49 11.37 25.64 $/W(20MPH) 9.39 6.99 8.18 9.24 5.08 5.18 6.72 4.60 8.92 $/W(25MPH) 6.26 4.94 7.15 4.80 4.22 3.35 5.92 2.40 5.39 Grid Connection Issues State requirements Agreements with Consumers Energy Selling back power to CE Technical requirements of the connection Additional Considerations Documented in Michigan Electric Utility Generator Interconnection Requirements Interconnection Application to the Utility filing fee Data outlining project details Standards adopt IEEE 1547 specification Standard for Interconnecting Distributed Resources with Electric Power Systems Interconnection Study Determines any changes necessary for the connection Interconnection and Operating Agreement Net Metering Fee for installation of generation meter(s) Small Hydro Power Station Feasibility Study Civil Problems Most likely from settling Poor soils Scouring beneath abutment Abutment likely to need total replacement Need geotechnical engineer to analyze X X = - X = X = + = Average costof Average houshold consum ption Plainw ell buildingsestim ated to consum e Value ofpow er powerin M I ofpow erin USA 30tim esm ore pow erthan average house saved in buildings $.0835/kWh 10,656kW h/yr 30 $26,693/yr Energyproduction Average houshold consum ption Plainw ell buildingsestim ated to consum e Extraenergyto ofplantperyear ofpow erin USA 30tim esm ore pow erthan average house sell backto grid 6,000M W h/yr 10,656kW h/yr 30 5,680,320kWh/yr Extraenergyto Average price Consum ersEnergy Value ofpow ersold sell backto grid w ill payforextrapow er to Consum ersEnergy $26,693/yr $214,886/yr $241,579/yr 5,680,320kWh/yr $.03783/kWh $214,886/yr Value ofpow er Value ofpow ersold YearlyRevenue saved in buildings to Consum ersEnergy Figure 3 – Site of Small Hydro Figure 2 - Zoning Among the projects, prearranged by the instructor to give the students a real world experience, were: A Feasibility Study for Wind Power Generation at Belknap Lookout. This project is being developed with the support of the Newberry Co-Housing Community, A Feasibility Study for the Recovery of a Small Hydro Power Station at the City of Plainwell, Michigan. This project is being developed with the support of the City of Plainwell. Other projects include Learning about Grid Operations with the support of Consumers Energy, analytical studies regarding Distributed Generation and Micro- Grids, and Nuclear Power Assessment. Students visited the sites, talked to managers and engineers and collected the data necessary to produce the analyses. Since the studies may take longer than the class period the projects will be extended to the end of the summer. The reality however is that the students will be exposed and attempt to solve real world power and energy engineering problems. The Approach Figure 4 – Site of Small Hydro Figure 5 – Kaplan Turbine Figure 6 – Electronic Instruction Electronic Communication During the course the instructor had to travel, but continued to instruct students via Skype. The process worked well and students thought the communication was very effective. Table – FERC Suitability Table Economic Analysis

Transcript of Implementing a First Power/Energy Systems Management Course Via Multidisciplinary- Project-Context...

Page 1: Implementing a First Power/Energy Systems Management Course Via Multidisciplinary- Project-Context Learning Paulo Ribeiro, Calvin College, Grand Rapids,

Implementing a First Power/Energy Systems Management Course Via Multidisciplinary-Project-Context Learning

Paulo Ribeiro, Calvin College, Grand Rapids, Michigan

Implementing a First Power/Energy Systems Management Course Via Multidisciplinary-Project-Context Learning

Paulo Ribeiro, Calvin College, Grand Rapids, Michigan

The Electrical Power & Energy Systems Management Systems Course introduced students to real world problems. Besides learning the analytical basis of power and energy systems and the consequent environmental impact, and using professional state-of-the-art computational tools, the students (from mechanical, electrical and civil engineering concentrations) were divided in small groups to work on several real world projects in the local area.

Abstract

Projects

Wind Generation Feasibility Study

Conclusions

Student Evaluation"Our class looked at almost all of the new energy ideas I wanted to hear about“

"Working on our own projects ensured we enjoyed our topic and learned something we felt was valuable“

"For many of the projects, the work continued after the class, meaning we could go back later to look at the progress or continue it ourselves.“

“The class was flexible in terms of what field of Power Systems to study, allowing me to focus on my particular field of interest while still learning about others. The field trips to Consumers Energy, the potential wind power site and the former hydro-electric dam site were all very useful and tied to very practical projects.”

Figure 1 – Site for Wind Project

Table - Analysis of a Variety of Wind Turbines

ARE110 ARE442 BWC XL.1 BWC Excel EW15Northwind

100 Skystream 3.7JACOBS 31-20 Swift

Rated(kW) 2.50 10.00 1.00 10.00 50.00 100.00 1.90 20.00 1.50

Possible(10MPH)(kW) 0.23 1.80 0.17 0.93 5.71 5.64 0.32 1.00 0.14

Possible(15MPH)(kW) 0.65 3.00 0.39 2.44 18.26 22.94 0.72 3.80 0.27

Possible(20MPH)(kW) 1.67 7.10 0.57 4.10 28.54 48.31 1.02 9.40 0.76

Possible(25MPH)(kW) 2.50 10.05 0.65 7.90 34.36 74.73 1.16 18.00 1.27

Cost Of Turbine($1000) 12.65 39.60 2.59 27.90 145.00 250.00 5.00 27.40 6.82

Cost Of Tower($1000) 3.00 10.00 2.05 10.00 0.00 0.00 1.85 15.80 0.00

$/W(Rated) 6.26 4.96 4.64 3.79 2.90 2.50 3.61 2.16 4.55

$/W(10MPH) 68.04 27.56 27.78 40.69 25.39 44.34 21.75 43.20 47.71

$/W(15MPH) 24.08 16.53 11.78 15.55 7.94 10.90 9.49 11.37 25.64

$/W(20MPH) 9.39 6.99 8.18 9.24 5.08 5.18 6.72 4.60 8.92

$/W(25MPH) 6.26 4.94 7.15 4.80 4.22 3.35 5.92 2.40 5.39

Grid Connection IssuesState requirementsAgreements with Consumers EnergySelling back power to CETechnical requirements of the connectionAdditional ConsiderationsDocumented in Michigan Electric Utility Generator Interconnection RequirementsInterconnection Application to the Utility filing feeData outlining project detailsStandards adopt IEEE 1547 specificationStandard for Interconnecting Distributed Resources with Electric Power SystemsInterconnection StudyDetermines any changes necessary for the connectionInterconnection and Operating AgreementNet MeteringFee for installation of generation meter(s)

Small Hydro Power Station Feasibility Study

Civil Problems Most likely from settling

Poor soilsScouring beneath abutment

Abutment likely to need total replacementNeed geotechnical engineer to analyze

X X =

- X =

X =

+ =

Average cost of Average houshold consumption Plainwell buildings estimated to consume Value of powerpower in MI of power in USA 30 times more power than average house saved in buildings$.0835/kWh 10,656 kWh/yr 30 $26,693/yr

Energy production Average houshold consumption Plainwell buildings estimated to consume Extra energy toof plant per year of power in USA 30 times more power than average house sell back to grid

6,000 MWh/yr 10,656 kWh/yr 30 5,680,320 kWh/yr

Extra energy to Average price Consumers Energy Value of power soldsell back to grid will pay for extra power to Consumers Energy

$26,693/yr $214,886/yr $241,579/yr

5,680,320 kWh/yr $.03783/kWh $214,886/yr

Value of power Value of power soldYearly Revenue

saved in buildings to Consumers Energy

Figure 3 – Site of Small Hydro

Figure 2 - Zoning

Among the projects, prearranged by the instructor to give the students a real world experience, were:

A Feasibility Study for Wind Power Generation at Belknap Lookout. This project is being developed with the support of the Newberry Co-Housing Community,

A Feasibility Study for the Recovery of a Small Hydro Power Station at the City of Plainwell, Michigan. This project is being developed with the support of the City of Plainwell.

Other projects include Learning about Grid Operations with the support of Consumers Energy, analytical studies regarding Distributed Generation and Micro-Grids, and Nuclear Power Assessment.

Students visited the sites, talked to managers and engineers and collected the data necessary to produce the analyses. Since the studies may take longer than the class period the projects will be extended to the end of the summer. The reality however is that the students will be exposed and attempt to solve real world power and energy engineering problems.

The Approach

Figure 4 – Site of Small Hydro

Figure 5 – Kaplan Turbine

Figure 6 – Electronic Instruction

Electronic CommunicationDuring the course the instructor had to travel, but continued to instruct students via Skype. The process worked well and students thought the communication was very effective.

Table – FERC Suitability Table

Economic Analysis