8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

1/19

:;

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

2/19

Ndjp|ir K

"Qd{7"~di ~kfic|f{ qgcliril# "Qd{ lkl |dk~ djppic |g `i7"^di ~dke|il gc |di djrl by~

~ij| jcl |rkil egr |di |dgy~jcl|d |k`i |g ag |g ~fiip& by| |di li~kri egr ~fiip ngyflc| guirng`i

|di eijr ge |di ckad| |irrgr~# Ge|ic |k`i~ |di{ lklc!| iuic qjk| |kff ~di qj~ j~fiip& ndgg~kca rj|dir

|g pfjayi dir j| jff dgyr~ ge |di lj{# ^di ngyflc!| i~njpi |di` jcl qj~ egrnil |g rifkui iuir{

`g`ic| - ijnd bfgq jcl iuir{ ~fj~d - egrnil |g dijr iuir{ nr{ ge pjkc jcl rijfkxi |dj| |di{ qiri

dir gqc######

Jylri{ ~|ippil gee |di by~ kc j ~`jff ~fiip{ |gqc ci~|fil kc |di Rgnm{ @gyc|jkc~ jcl

~njccil dir ~yrrgyclkca~# \di ~kac ~jkl Ngfbir|& Ngfgrjlg# \di by~ ~|j|kgc qj~ cg|dkca `gri

|djc j ~|jcl qk|d j eiq |rjuif brgndyri~ ~|riqc gc |di ngyc|ir# J pjkr ge pj~~kca |iicjair~ nj~|

nyrkgy~ afjcni~ dir qj{# Jylri{ dk|ndil dir ariic lyeeif dkadir gc dir ~dgyflir jcl fggmil

lgqc j| dir ry`pfil nfg|dkca ~yllicf{ rijfkxkca |dj| ~di `y~| fggm ngc~pknygy~# \dk~ qj~

gbukgy~f{ j |gqc |dj| ag| uir{ eiq uk~k|gr~ g|dir |djc ej`kf{ jcl diri ~di qj~& j ~|rjcair# Qkff K

bi ~jei diri7

Dk& j ~`jff ugkni ~jkl bidkcl dir# ^di qdkrfil |g ejni |di ugkni jcl egycl dir~ife

~|jrkca lgqc kc|g |di ejni ge j {gyca bg{ jbgy| 5 {ijr~ gfl#

Qiff& diffg |diri {gyca `jc& Jylri{ ~jkl arkcckca brgjlf{ j| dk`# Lg {gy mcgq

qdiri |diri k~ j dg|if |dj| K njc ~|j{ j|7 dk~ ~djaa{ fkad| brgqc djkr efgppil jrgycl dk~ dijl kc

j cgl#

Njc {gy ~dgq `i qdiri k| k~7 dk~ fjrai djxif i{i~ afk``iril qk|d `k~ndkie j~ di

~dggm dk~ dijl#

K~ |diri ~g`igci qdg njc7 \dk~ |k`i di cgllil jcl |yrcil |g ryc lgqc |di ~|rii|#

J~~y`kca di qgyfl ai| dk~ `g|dir& Jylri{ ~i| dir lyeeif gc |di ngyc|ir jcl njy|kgy~f{

~|ri|ndil dir |kril `y~nfi~# \di by~i~ ~di djl |jmic bi|qiic ~|kc|~ ge dk|nddkmkca djl biic eiq

jfgca dir hgyrci{ erg` Ndknjag# Qdic ~di djl ekcjff{ ~ynny`bil |di yrai |g ai| jqj{ je|ir |dj|

K`pirein| Fjq

2

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

3/19

cijr ej|jf "jnnklic|"& ~di djl |drgqc qdj| qj~ jb~gfy|if{ cini~~jr{ kc |dj| ~`jff lyeeif jcl ryc

qk|d cg li~|kcj|kgc kc `kcl#

Jylri{~ `kcl |yrcil bjnm |g rijfk|{ j~ ~di ~yllicf{ cg|knil |di ngfl qkcl |dj| bfiq

lgqc |drgyad |di `jkc ~|rii|# ^di rijndil egr dir bja |g ai| dir hjnmi|# K| qj~ j fk||fi |dkc& by| k|

mip| |di byfm ge |di qkcl erg` pkirnkca |g dir ~mkc# ^di |yrcil bjnm |g qj|nd |di lkrin|kgc |di

fk||fi bg{ djl ryc& j~ ~di lkl ~g& ~di ~jq dk` |yrc |di ngrcir lrjaakca j `jc bidkcl dk`# Jylri{

pknmil yp dir bja# Dir dijr| pjfpk|j|il ~g djrl ~di |dgyad| k| qgyfl hy`p gy| ge dir ndi~| jcl

dir `gy|d qic| lr{ j~ j ng||gc ~qjb# Di qj~ j ngp#

K~ |dk~ |di fjl{ Ngccir7 |di ngp j~mil# \di fk||fi bg{ cgllil dk~ dijl# @jj` K

yclir~|jcl {gyri fggmkca egr fglakca~# DI ~`kfil qklif{& ~dgqkca fjyad fkci~ |dj| qiri

iuklicni ge `jc{ hg{eyf {ijr~ li~pk|i |di ejn| |dj| di fggmil gcf{ j eiq {ijr~ gflir |djc dir

|qic|{-ikad| {ijr~#

Jylri{ i{il dk` qjrkf{& yc~yri qdj| |g lg# ^di ngyfl lijf qk|d |dk~ ngp gr qjk| egr |di

cit| by~ qdknd& jnngrlkca |g |di ~ndilyfi& qj~ lyi kc gc Erklj{ - |qg lj{~ jqj{# Afjcnkca lgqc

~di ~jq |di fk||fi bg{ - Ngccir- arkcckca yp j| dir# \di `k~~kca |ii|d kc |dj| ~`kfi ~g`idgq

`jli |dj| arkc jff |di ~qii|ir# ^di prj{il |dj| dir ugkni ~gyclil ~|ijlkir k| eif| qdic ~di ~pgmi#

[i~& |dk~ {gyca `jc ~jkl |dj| |diri qj~ j dg|if K ngyfl ~|j{ j|#

\diri k~& by| |di gqcir~ nfg~i k| lgqc jcl dijl lgqc |g Jrkxgcj lyrkca |di qkc|ir& di

kcegr`il dir# ^di ngyfl eiif |di jctki|{ rk~kca qdic di jllil& By| K mcgq j fjl{ qdg dj~ j

rgg` {gyl bi qifng`i |g#

\djcm {gy& Jylri{ ~jkl qk|d j |kad| ~`kfi# Kl fkmi |dj|# \yrckca |g Ngccir ~di

~`kfil kc ijrci~|# Jcl |djcm {gy |gg& ~di jllil rijndkca gy| |g |gy~fi dk~ djkr# Di arkccil yp

j| dir qk|d |dj| ~`kfi jcl ~di eif| dir dijr| ~fkppkca jqj{#

K` ^dirkee Lirim Dgflic& |di `jc ~jkl#

Jylri{ kacgril dk~ gy|~|ri|ndil djcl jcl kc|rglynil dir~ife& Jylri{& Jylri{ Bf{|di#

"Qiff& @k~~ Bf{|di&" |di ngp biajc#

K`pirein| Fjq

>

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

4/19

"Jylri{&" ~di kc~k~|il zyknmf{& eiifkca fkmi |di bkaai~| fkjr kc |di qgrfl qdic ~di dijrl

|dj| cj`i# K| qj~c| j |g|jf fki binjy~i k| qj~ dir cj`i& hy~| cg| dir eyff gci# ^di mciq |dj| dir

fkei lipiclil gc jcgc{`k|{& by| |dj| lkl cg| ieein| dir aykf|#

"Jylri{&" di ngc|kcyil& "|dk~ fk||fi ari`fkc k~ `{ ~gc& Ngccir#"

Jylri{ bic| lgqc jcl difl gy| dir djcl& "Diffg Ngccir& k|!~ ckni |g `ii| {gy#"

Ngccir arkccil jajkc# "Ngccir&" |di ngp pkpil kc& "qifng`i @k~~ Jylri{ |g |gqc#"

Ngccir!~ arkc qklicil jcl di ~yllicf{ fjycndil dk`~ife j| dir |g akui dir j dya# \di `gui qj~

~g ycitpin|il |dj| Jylri{ lrgppil dir bja jcl jf`g~| eiff bjnmqjrl& by| |di ngp zyknmf{

rijndil gy| |g ~|ijl{ dir# ^di jy|g`j|knjff{ hirmil gy| ge dk~ arj~p jcl di fggmil j| dir gllf{

by| ~di lklc| djui |di cirui~ |g lijf qk|d |dj| cgq# Qdic Ngccir |yrcil dir fgg~i& Jylri{ qj~

dgflkca bjnm |ijr~# \di mkclci~~ ge |di~i |g|jf ~|rjcair~ |gyndil ~g`i|dkca kc dir |dj| djl biic

ergxic b{ eijr jcl ~pjrmil jc i`g|kgc |dj| ~di djlc!| eif| kc j fgca |k`i - dgpi#

K`pirein| Fjq

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

5/19

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

6/19

\di{ djl rijndil |di njr jcl dir |dgyad|~ |yrcil bjnm |g dir ~k|yj|kgc# ^dirkee Dgflic

~|ippil yp |g gpic |di bjnm lggr ge |di pj|rgf njr jcl ~di ergxi# Efj~dbjnm~ |g |dj| fkei-ndjcakca

ckad| riclirkca dir k``gbkfi#

Di djl hy`pil dir gc dir qj{ dg`i jcl& j| ekr~|& ~di qj~ qkffkca |g djcl guir dirujfyjbfi~ jcl bi lgci qk|d k|# \dic di pyffil j mckei# ^di qj~ pirein|f{ ~|kff j~ di bgycl dir

qrk~|~ jcl ajaail dir# \di{ rgyclil |di ngrcir jcl Jylri{ qjc|il |g ~dgy| egr hg{# J pgfkni njr

qj~ ng`kca lgqc |di ~|rii|* ^di qj~ ~juil* K| pyffil yp |g |di nyrb jcl ~di qj|ndil |di geeknir

ai| gy| jcl dijl |gqjrl~ |di`# ^di ~|g`pil gc dir j||jnmir!~ egg| jcl rjc |g |di geeknir qdg

njyad| dir j~ ~di ~|y`bfil egrqjrl# Di ~|rjkad|icil dir jcl& kc~|ijl ge difpkca dir&

bjnmdjclil dir jnrg~~ |di ejni# \di egrni ge |di bfgq ~ic| dir riifkca# Dir ~dgyflir ~nrij`il kc

pjkc j~ ~di ngffklil qk|d |di ngcnri|i# \di ngp {jcmil dir yp jcl ~dguil dir kc|g |di bjnm ge |di

njr#

Jylri{ ~cjppil gy| ge dir riuiri j~ j ~`jff djcl qgr`il kc|g dir nfg~il gci# ^di

fggmil lgqc kc|g Ngccir!~ jff - ~iikca ajxi#

"Ljll{!ff fi| {gy pfj{ qk|d |d! ~k!ic ke {gy!ri ~njril&" di ~jkl# \dk~ ~yrprk~il j ~dgr| fjyad

gy| ge dir# ^di rijfkxil ~di djl bjnmil jqj{ erg` |di njr jcl difl dir lyeeif j lij|d arkp# Dir

ajxi eiff gc |di njr jajkc by| ~di egrnil |di rk~kca jctki|{ lgqc j~ ~di qjfmil |g k| qk|d Ngccir#

\di ~dirkee djl nfg~il |di bjnm lggr jcl cgq difl |di ergc| gpic j~ Ngccir nfk`bil kc qk|d

Jylri{ rkad| bidkcl dk`# \di ~zyjl njr rgjril |g fkei jcl di |yrcil |di dij| gc eyff bfj~| j~ |di{

pyffil jqj{ erg` |di nyrb#

^ggc |di{ qiri pyffkca gee |di `jkc rgjl jcl gc|g j ~`jff lkr| gci gy|~kli ge |gqc# \di

rgjl nyruil jcl nfk`bil ~iuirjf `kfi~# B{ |dk~ |k`i |di ~m{ djl ljrmicil qk|d nfgyl~ jcl |di

~cgq qj~ ejffkca `gri dijukf{# \drgyad |di djxi Jylri{ afk`p~il j fjrai |qg ~|gr{ fga njbkc

~ij|il gc |di ~kli ge |di `gyc|jkc#

J~ |di njr pyffil kc|g j bj~i`ic| ajrjai& Jylri{!~ brgq mck| kc ngcey~kgc#

K`pirein| Fjq

5

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

7/19

"Qdg!~ dgy~i k~ |dk~7" ~di j~mil#

"@{ `g`!~&" Lirim jc~qiril& |yrckca gee |di njr# " ^di miip~ j rgg` gpic egr |di rjri

gnnj~kgc ~g`igci ciil~ gci#" Ngccir efyca gpic |di lggr jcl hy`pil gy|& lrjaakca Jylri{ b{

|di djcl yp |di ~|jkr~ |g |di `jkc efggr#

"Arj!`j*" Ngccir nrkil itnk|ilf{& brkcakca j qg`jc erg` jcg|dir rgg`# ^di qj~ j

djcl~g`i qg`jc iuic kc dir jlujcnil {ijr~ qk|d ~dgr| ~cgq qdk|i djkr jcl j qkli ~`kfi& jcl

~di djl cg |rgybfi biclkca |g nj|nd dir arjcl~gc kc j dya#

"Qiff& qdg!~ |dk~7" ~di j~mil Ngccir& cg|knkca Jylri{#

"@j& |dk~ k~ @k~~ Jylri{ Bf{|di# Jylri{& |dk~ k~ `{ `g|dir& @jrn{ Dgflic&" Lirim

kc~ir|il erg` bidkcl |di`#

Jylri{ `yr`yril j pgfk|i ri~pgc~i jcl geeiril dir djcl& by| @r~# Dgflic qgyfl djui

cgci ge k|# ^di rijndil gy| jcl icnfg~il Jylri{ kc j qjr` dya `ynd fkmi |di gci dir arjcl~gc

djl rinikuil#

"@j& Jylri{ ciil~ |g y~i {gyr ayi~| rgg` egr j bk|# ^di nj`i kc gc |di iuickca by~ jcl

~kcni Njrf jcl Ciffki jri agci -"

"Ge ngyr~i# [gy `{ lijr&" @r~# Dgflic jllri~~il Jylri{& " hy~| egffgq `i jcl qi!ff ai|

{gy ~i||fil kc {gyr rgg`#" ^di fggpil jc jr` guir Jylri{!~ ~dgyflir~ jcl fil dir yp |g |di

~ingcl efggr# \di rgg` Jylri{ qj~ ~dgqc |g qj~ ng`egr|jbfi jcl dg`{# \di eyff ~kxil bil qj~

nguiril qk|d j ngfgreyf zykf| jcl ~ge| lgqc pkffgq~# Jylri{ fjkl dir lyeeif j| |di egg| ge |di bil

jcl |yrcil |g @r~# Dgflic#

"\djcm {gy egr py||kca `i yp# K dgpi K!` cg| kcngcuickicnkca {gy#"

"Cgc~ic~i& K!` afjl |g difp# Qd{ lgc!| {gy eri~dic yp j bk| jcl ng`i gc bjnm lgqc#

Lkccir qkff bi rijl{ kc j fk||fi bk|#" @r~# Dgflic efj~dil jcg|dir ~`kfi jcl fie|& nfg~kca |di lggr

bidkcl dir# Jylri{ fggmil `gri nfg~if{ jrgycl dir rgg`# Gee |g gci ~kli qiri |qg lggr~ qdknd

prguil |g bi |di lggr~ egr j eyff bj|drgg` jcl j ~`jff qjfm-kc nfg~i|#

^di qic| kc|g |di bj|drgg` jcl ~|jril j| dir riefin|kgc# Dir ejni qj~ pjfi jcl ~fkad|f{ dgffgqil

jcl dir nfg|di~ cgq dyca fgg~i gc dir lk`kck~dil erj`i# ^di rjc j djcl |drgyad dir ~dgyflir

K`pirein| Fjq

1

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

8/19

fica|d brgqc djkr# \di bfgcl dkadfkad|~ ~di djl gcni prkxil qiri cgq dkllic yclir fj{ir~ ge

ark`i#

Je|ir j fgca& dg| ~dgqir& ~di arjbbil jcg|dir pjkr ge hijc~ jcl j \-~dkr| egr` dir bja#

_yffkca |di ~dkr| guir dir dijl& dir ajxi eiff gc |di bil# K| fggmil ~g ng`egr|jbfi jcl ~di qj~

it|ri`if{ |kril -

K!ff hy~| fj{ lgqc egr j eiq `kcy|i~ jcl ag lgqc& ~di |dgyad|& nrjqfkca yclir |di bfjcmi|~#

K`pirein| Fjq

4

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

9/19

Ndjp|ir KKK

Jc dgyr fj|ir Ngccir pgyclil j| Jylri{!~ lggr jcl& qdic di rinikuil cg jc~qir& njy|kgy~f{

~|ynm dk~ dijl kc# ^pg||kca dir gc |di bil di nfk`bil yp |g dir jcl pj||il dir jr`# ^di lklc!| ~|kr#

Ngccir ergqcil jcl |rkil jajkc# \dk~ |k`i dir ~dggm dir& by| ~di ~|kff lklc!| ~|kr# Ngccir |gri gy|

ge |di rgg` jcl lgqc |di ~|jkr~& byr~|kca kc|g |di mk|ndic |g arjb dk~ ljl!~ djcl#

"^di qgc!| ai| yp*" di nrkil ripij|ilf{& pyffkca dk~ ljl |g |di ~|jkr~# ^iikca dk~ ~gc!~

lk~|ri~~& Lirim |ggm |di ~|jkr~ |qg j| |k`i#

Di ~j| gc |di ilai ge dir bil jcl ~dggm dir# \dk~ |k`i ~di `gjcil j fk||fi# Lirim py| j

djcl |g dir egridijl# K| qj~ ~ngrndkca dg|#

"@j&" Lirim njffil& "{gy bi||ir ai| yp diri*" Di rg~i |g qi| j qj~dnfg|d qk|d ngfl qj|ir

jcl fjkl k| gc dir egridijl# Jylri{ `gjcil jajkc jcl |yrcil dir dijl#

"Qdj| k~ k|7" @r~# Dgflic j~mil jctkgy~f{& ng`kca kc|g |di rgg`#

"^di!~ byrckca yp#" @jrn{ nj`i egrqjrl jcl eif| Jylri{!~ ndiim#

"[gy!ri rkad|#" ^di afjcnil bidkcl dir j| Ngccir# "Lirim& |jmi Ngccir jcl ekck~d {gyr

~yppir# K!ff |jmi njri ge @k~~ Jylri{#" Lirim ~|ggl jcl fil Ngccir gy| ge |di rgg`# @jrn{

k``ilkj|if{ qic| |g dir rgg` |g aj|dir j |dir`g`i|ir jcl j ckad| agqc egr Jylri{#

"Gd& Fgrl& qdj| dj~ |dk~ ndkfl biic |drgyad7"~di prj{il j~ ~di ri`guil Jylri{!~ ~dkr|#

^di ~pic| |di ri~| ge |di iuickca jcl `g~| ge |di ckad| |r{kca |g fgqir Jylri{!~ ~pkmil

|i`pirj|yri# Ijrf{ |di cit| `grckca dir eiuir brgmi& jcl @jrn{ njffil kc Lirim# @jrn{ pyffil

bjnm Jylri{!~ ckad| agqc icgyad |g ~dgq dk` qdj| ~di djl egycl#

Lirim egycl dk`~ife ~|jrkca lgqc j| pjr|kjff{ dijfil ny|~ |dj| ~ngril Jylri{!~ jblg`ic#

"\di{ qiri j fk||fi kcein|il by| ~g`i pirgtkli difpil# K |dkcm bi|qiic |di kcein|kgc& fjnm

ge ~fiip& jcl `jfcgyrk~d`ic|= ~di hy~| ngffjp~il&" @jrn{ ~|j|il ~jlf{# Lirim ri`jkcil ~kfic|#

Dk~ hjq |kad|ickca j~ di ~jq |di jcar{ ril ny|~#

K`pirein| Fjq

;

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

10/19

"^gc& jri |dg~i mckei qgycl~7" @jrn{ j~mil# Di cgllil kc jeekr`j|kgc# "^di jf~g dj~ j

fg| ge bryk~i~# \di{!ri cijrf{ dijfil jcl K jf`g~| lklc!| ~ii |di`# Lirim&" ~di qjk|il yc|kf di

fggmil yp j| dir& "{gy djui |g difp dir#" Di cgllil jcl fie| |di rgg`#

"Qdg k~ |dk~ qg`jc7" di j~mil dk`~ife j~ di ic|iril dk~ ~`jff dg`i geekni lgqc |di

djff# Di ~j| j| dk~ li~m& ~|jrkca kc|g ~pjni& prgni~~kca qdj| di lkl mcgq ge dir# Gci |dkca qj~

~yri& ~di lklc!| ic|krif{ |ry~| dk`# ^di qj~ jf~g rycckca& erg` qdj| di lkl cg| mcgq# Jc jby~kui

rifj|kgc~dkp7 J ~|jfmir7 Gr qgr~i& |di fjq7 "Cg&" di ~jkl jfgyl& "ke ~di qj~ qjc|il K qgyfl

mcgq#" Bj~il gc |di ny|~ nrk~~nrg~~kca dir ~|g`jnd& di ayi~~il |di ekr~| qj~ `g~| prgbjbfi& jc

jby~kui rifj|kgc~dkp# Nfknmkca gc dk~ ng`py|ir& di pyffil yp dk~ ekfi~ gc qjc|il eyak|kui~# !Bi||ir

bi ~jei |djc ~grr{#!di |dgyad|# Cg|dkca# Cg gy|~|jclkca qjrrjc|~ gc jc{gci `j|ndkca Jylri{!~

li~nrkp|kgc# Di djl |dj| eiifkca jajkc# \dj| cjaakca eiifkca |dj| ~g`i|dkca qj~ |irrkbf{ qrgca

jcl |dj| di!l bi~| |rijl fkad|f{# Di djlc!| djl |dk~ eiifkca ~kcni ##### ~kcni di fie| |di @jr~djf~

egyr {ijr~ jag#

^di eif| lrjkcil# Dir i{ifkl~ eif| fkmi |di{ qikadil |ic pgycl~ j~ ~di gpicil |di`# Dir

i{i~ egny~il jcl ~di qj~ kc dir rgg`# J~ ~di nj`i eyff{ jqjmi& ~di cg|knil ~g`i lkeeiricni~#

Egr gci |dkca& |diri qj~ j ndjkr b{ dir bil |dj| djlc!| biic |diri biegri# ^ingcl& ~di qj~ cgq

|ynmil yclir |di nguir~ ge |di bil qdic ~di ri`i`biril fj{kca gc |gp ge |di nguir~# !K prgbjbf{

nrjqfil yclir |di` lyrkca `{ ~fiip& qgyflc!| bi |di ekr~| |k`i&!~di rj|kgcjfkxil= dgqiuir |di

fj~| |dkca ~di rijfkxil ngyflc!| bi ~g ij~kf{ itpfjkcil# ^di qj~c!| kc dir gqc nfg|di~* _yffkca

bjnm |di |dknm zykf|& ~di ~jq |dj| ~di qj~ cgq qijrkca j ril pfjkl efjccif ckad|agqc# ^di |rkil

~k||kca yp jcl kc~|jc|f{ riari||il k| j~ j qjui ge lkxxkci~~ jcl |qkcai ge pjkc j~~jkfil dir# ^di!l

hy~| ~ycm bjnm jajkc~| dir pkffgq~ qdic @jrn{ Dgflic ic|iril |di rgg`#

"Gd |djcm agglci~~ |dj| {gy!ri jqjmi# [gy ajui y~ zyk|i j ~njri&" ~di ~jkl#

K`pirein| Fjq

:?

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

11/19

"Qdj|###" Jylri{ nrgjmil biegri ngyadkca# @jrn{ pknmil yp j qj|ir afj~~ erg` |di bil-

~|jcl jcl difl k| egr dir j~ ~di |ggm j ayfp# "Qdj| djppicil7"

"[gy qiri ~knm# [gy djl dkad eiuir egr `g~| ge |di ckad|#"

"Qdiri jri `{ nfg|di~7" Jylri{ j~mil#

"Diri j| |di egg| ge |di bil# K ndjcail {gy ~g {gy!l bi `gri ng`egr|jbfi#" @jrn{

prgppil dir yp jajkc~| |di pkffgq~ biegri ~k||kca lgqc |g arj~p dir djcl# "Jylri{& K ~jq {gyr

qgycl~&"~di ~|keeicil# "^qii|ki& qdg lkl |dk~ |g {gy7" Jylri{ pyffil dir djcl gy| ge @jrn{!~

jcl |yrcil dir dijl jqj{ erg` @jrn{#

"_fij~i& fijui `i jfgci&" ~di ~jkl efj|f{#

"Jfrkad|& by| Jylri{& ke {gy ciil difp lgc!| di~k|j|i |g j~m egr k|#" @jrn{ ~|ggl jcl qic|

|g |di lggr#

"\djcm {gy&" Jylri{ ~jkl ~ge|f{ j~ @jrn{ gpicil |di lggr#

"K!ff ndinm kc gc {gy kc j fk||fi bk|&" @jrn{ ripfkil qk|d j ~jl ~`kfi#

\di lggr nfg~il jcl Jylri{ fi| |di |ijr~ ejff# \ijr~ ge jcayk~d jcl eijr nj~njlil lgqc

dir ndiim~# !Qd{ Fgrl7 Qd{ `i7 Djui {gy egrag||ic `i7!^di mciq |di jc~qir# Di djlc!|

egrag||ic# Di!l fil dir diri& by| qd{7

\di ~cgq ge |di priukgy~ iuickca djl bfjcmi|il |di ngyc|r{ ~kli# \di pirein| itj`pfi ge

yc`jrril kccgnicni |dj| brgyad| j |rjczykfk|{ ge ~pkrk| j~ gci ~iflg` jndkiuil# Gci |dj|

lk~pfj{il |di aic|fi arjni ge k|~ Nrij|gr& by| j~ Lirim ~j| j| dk~ li~m& ~|jrkca gy| |di qkclgq& di

~jq cgci ge |dk~# ^g`i|dkca jbgy| |dk~ qg`jc |rgybfil dk`# Qdic di djl ~j| qk|d dir j eiq

|k`i~ lyrkca |di ckad| |g rifkiui dk~ `g|dir& ~di djl pirkglknjff{ |drj~dil kc |di bil# ^g`i|k`i~

iuic |jfmkca gr nr{kca gy|# \di gy|byr~|~ djl biic ndkffkca j| pgkc|~# Gcni ~di!l nyrfil kc|g j bjff

pfijlkca qk|d dir djffynkcj|il ng`pjckgc cg| |g mkff dir# Di dj|il |g jl`k| k| by|& je|ir j ~k`kfjr

gy|byr~|& di djl pgmil jrgycl kc dir bja jcl hjnmi|# \dj| qj~ fk||fi difp# Jff |dj| |di bja

K`pirein| Fjq

::

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

12/19

ngc|jkcil qiri nfg|di~& j Bkbfi& jcl j |gg|dbry~d qk|d |gg|dpj~|i# Di!l ndinmil |di Bkbfi!~

kc~kli pjai jcl egycl jc kc~nrkp|kgc& "\g `{ ~|iffj brkffjc|i# @j{ {gy jfqj{~ rif{ gc Dk`# Fgui&

Ljl# \di hjnmi| djlc!| prguil j `ynd `gri y~ieyf# Di egycl j ~`jff qjffi| kc gci ge |di

pgnmi|~# \di qjffi| qj~ i`p|{ ~jui egr jbgy| egr|{ lgffjr~& j qgrc fi||ir& jcl qdj| fggmil fkmi j

|grc pkini ge j rinikp|# !Qdg k~ |dk~ qg`jc7!di j~mil dk`~ife egr |di dyclril|d |k`i# \diri qj~

j mcgnm gc dk~ lggr jcl dk~ `g` ic|iril#

"^di!~ jqjmi#" Di ~|ggl jcl dijlil egr |di lggr# "K qgyflc!| ke K qiri {gy# ^di j~mil `i

|g fijui dir jfgci#"

Di mip| gc qjfmkca j~ di ~jkl guir dk~ ~dgyflir& "K|!~ |k`i egr ~g`i jc~qir~#"

Lirim pjy~il j~ dk~ djcl rijndil egr |di mcgb ge |di lggr# @yeefil ~gb~ ekf|iril |drgyad

|di gfl qggl lggr jcl qricndil j| dk~ dijr|# Di ngyflc!| hy~| bjrai kc jcl li`jcl jc~qir~ |g

|di `kfi fgca fk~| ge zyi~|kgc~ |dj| di!l `jli kc dk~ `kcl# Ke di lkl& di!l prgbjbf{ fg~i jc{ gycni

ge |ry~| di!l `jcjail |g ajkc# Di qdkrfil gc dk~ diif jcl ~|rgli bjnm |g dk~ geekni# Dk~ `g` qj~

~|kff |diri qk|d j mcgqkca fggm kc dir i{i# ^di djl mcgqc di qgyflc!| ag kc#

"Ai| `i ~g`i|dkca ~di!~ |gyndil# J afj~~& bgqf& jc{|dkca&" di |gfl @jrn{ qdg qic| gy|

jcl ~ggc ri|yrcil qk|d j qj|ir afj~~ dgflkca k| qk|d j lk~d |gqif#

"[gy qgc!| ekcl jc{|dkca gc dir&" @jrn{ |gfl dk`# Dk~ dijl ~cjppil yp#

"^di |jfmil |g {gy7"

"Cg& by| K!` ~yri {gy qgc!| ekcl jc{|dkca# ^di!~ hy~| cg| |di mkcl ge akrf qdg qgyfl djui

j ringrl#"

"@j& ng`i gc& dgq njc {gy |iff |dj| hy~| erg` ~piclkca j `jt ge |qic|{ `kcy|i~ qk|d

dir7"

"\qic|{ `kcy|i~* K ~pic| `g~| ge |di ckad| qk|d dir###### jcl {gy lkl |gg*"

"^g7 ^di qj~ j~fiip# K|!~ cg| fkmi {gy qiri itndjcakca fkei ~|grki~#"

"Lirim @kndjif Dgflic* [gy dijrl |dg~i ckad|`jri~# [gy ~jq |dg~i ny|~# ^g`igci djl

|g lg |dj| |g dir*" Yd gd& dk~ eyff cj`i#### |dk~ lkl cg| bgli qiff#

K`pirein| Fjq

:2

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

13/19

"Dgq lg {gy mcgq k| qj~c!| dir pk`p7 gr j pjr|cir ~di lgybfi nrg~~il7" di ~jkl hy~| |g

rkfi dir# Di mciq |dg~i |digrki~ qiri rklknyfgy~& by| di lklc| qjc| |g jl`k| |dj| di jariil qk|d

dir# Ke |dk~ akrf qj~ kc |rgybfi& jcl ~di gbukgy~f{ qj~& k| prgbjbf{ qj~c| ge dir gqc `jmkca#

@jrn{ ~ic| dk` j ~nj|dkca fggm |dj| gcf{ j `g|dir njc pyff gee# @jrn{ fie| |di rgg` jcl di ~j|

bjnm kc dk~ ndjkr jajkc& ~|jrkca j| |di afj~~ ~k||kca gc dk~ li~m# Ke ~di qj~ kc |rgybfi di djl cg

qj{ ge mcgqkca qdj| mkcl ge ri~gyrni~ dir pyr~yir~ djl# Hg~d###### di ngyfl fggm kc|g k| lk~nrii|f{

jcl |iff dk` qdj| di egycl& by| |dj| `ijc| ringccin|kca |g dk~ gfl fkei# Dk~ fkei biegri####### Gd

~ynm k| yp* di |gfl dk`~ife jcl rijndil egr |di pdgci# Di lkjfil kc |di cy`bir jcl ~j| j~ k|

~ii`il |g rkca kc|ir`kcjbf{#

^qk|nd bgjrl& |di pir~gc {gy qk~d |g ngc|jn| pfij~i& ~jkl j ugkni gc |di g|dir icl hy~|

j~ di qj~ jbgy| |g akui yp#

Lkrin|gr Rglkcj& di ~jkl#

Gci `g`ic| pfij~i#

Rglkcj& j `jc~ liip ugkni ~jkl#

Hg~d& k|~ Lirim#

D``#### K gcni mciq j Lirim# K |dgyad| qi qiri aggl erkicl~ by| |dic di hy~| yp jcl

lrgppil gee |di `jp#

[ijd& ~grr{ bgy| |dj|& Lirim ~jkl qk|d j ~`jff arkc#

Di{ cg prgbfi`& K mcgq {gy djl j fg| gc {gyr pfj|i qdic {gy fie|# ^g qdj|~ ciq7 K

dijrl {gy |ggm |di hgb j~ ~dirkee kc {gyr dg`i|gqc#

[ip& ~yri lkl kc ejn|####

Qdj| jbgy| |dj| mkl ge {gyr~7 Dgq~ di7 Di iuir ~|jr| |jfmkca jajkc7 Hg~d kc|irhin|il#

Qiff& |dj| dj~ j bk| |g lg qk|d qd{ K` njffkca {gy# [gy ~ii |diri~ |dk~ ajf####

Gd& K ~ii# Qdj| di lgc| fkmi dir7

Qgyfl {gy hy~| ~dy| yp jcl fi| `i |jfm7 ^di ag| gee |di by~ {i~|irlj{ jcl ~di fggmil

pri||{ bjl# K `ijc |dkc& pjfi& jcl ~di ~ii`il ~njril |g lij|d ge `i# J| ekr~| K |dgyad| k| qj~ hy~|

K`pirein| Fjq

:>

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

14/19

`ic kc aicirjf##### `j{bi j bjl rifj|kgc~dkp gr ~g`i|dkca& by| je|ir K |jfmil |g dir j bk| K rijfkxil

k|~ ag||j bi |di bjlai#

^di qjc|il ~g`iqdiri7 Hg~d j~mil nyrkgy~f{#

Cgpi& dir li~nrkp|kgc lgi~c| `j|nd jc{ ge |di bgfg~#

Qdj|~ |dk~ ag| |g lg qk|d |di mkl7

Di~ |jfmil `gri qk|d gr jbgy| dir kc |di fj~| lj{ jcl j djfe |djc di dj~ kc |di egyr {ijr~

~kcni########### ~kcni Ndrk~|kci lkil# ^kficni gc |di g|dir icl# Fggm& `{ ay|~ |iffkca `i ~di

ciil~ prg|in|kca# Erg` qdj| K lgc| mcgq {i|& by| K lgc| qjc| |g ndinm dir prkc|~ jcl `j{bi |kp

gee qdgiuir k~ fggmkca egr dir |g dir fgnj|kgc#

^g {gy qjc| `i |g `jmi ~g`i yclir |di rjljr kczykrki~7

@jmi k| rijff{ yclir |di rjljr#### K djui |di eiifkca qdj|iuir |dk~ ajf~ `ktil yp kc agi~

liip#

K mcgq |dj| |gci& {gy mcgq `gri |djc {gyri |iffkca#

Lirim di~k|j|il# ^di~ biic ~fj~dil#

J~ kc mckeil7 Hg~d j~mil#

[ijd& fggm~ fkmi bij|ic |gg# @g~|f{ yppir bgl{# @j egycl k| qdic ~di ngffjp~il# @j

~j{~ ~di~ `jfcgyrk~dil jcl dj~ ~g`i kcein|kgc erg` |di mckei qgycl~#

[gy ag |drgyad dir ~|yee7

Egr jff |di aggl k| lkl `i& {ijd# Hy~| nfg|di~& `gci{& jcl j Bkbfi# \di Bkbfi djl jc

kc~nrkp|kgc by| k| qj~ j pir~gcjf gci& erg` dir ljl k| fggm~ fkmi# Hy~| j pi| cj`i jcl ~kacil

Ljl#

Qdj|~ |di pi| cj`i7

K|~ ~|iffj brkffjc|iK Aggafil k| jcl k| `ijc~ ~dkckca ~|jr kc K|jfkjc#

K|jfkjc dyd7 ^di ~gycl egrikac7

Cj& j bk| ge j `klqi~| jnnic| Kl ~j{# ^di ag| gee |di Mjcj~ Nk|{ by~ by| ke ~di~ biic

rycckca egr fgca ~di ngyfl djui ng`i erg` jc{qdiri jcl |jmic jc{ rgy|i |g ai| |diri# ^di ~j{~

~di~ Jylri{ Bf{|di& by| |dj|~ prgbjbf{ j lglai#

K`pirein| Fjq

:

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

15/19

Kff ~ii qdj| K njc ekcl L by| |dk~ k~ mkcl ge ujayi kceg#

\djcm~ Hg~d#

Jcl Lirim###

[ijd7

K|~ aggl |g djui {j bjnm kc |di aj`i byll{& ~jkl Hg~d#

K` cg|# Kff |jfm |g {j fj|ir# Lirim dyca yp jcl qk|d j diju{ ~kad rybbil j djcl guir

dk~ ejni#

K`pirein| Fjq

:9

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

16/19

Ndjp|ir KU

Jyli{7 j |k`kl ugkni ~jkl erg` |di lggr# ^di |yrcil jcl ~jq Ngccir qk|d dk~ dijl

piimkca jrgycl |di |dknm qggl lggr# ^di ~ckeeil jcl qkpil |di |ijr |rjkf~ erg` dir ndiim~#

Ng`i gc kc Ngccir& ~di ~jkl& `y~|irkca j ~`kfi# Di arkccil jcl nj`i kc# Di qj~

njrr{kca j fjrai bggm jcl ~di djl |g difp dk` j~ di |rkil |g ~nrj`bfi gc|g |di bil jcl dgfl |di

bggm ~k`yf|jcigy~f{# Qdj| lg {gy ag| |diri7 Jylri{ j~mil j~ di ~cyaafil lgqc cit| |g dir#

Bggm& di ~jkl prgylf{#

Qgyfl {gy fkmi `i |g rijl ~g`i |g {gy7 ~di j~mil#

Dk~ dijl bgbbil itnk|ilf{ jcl dk~ i{i~ ~dgci# K| qj~ |di ~|gr{ ge |di |drii fk||fi pka~ jcl

~di fkuicil k| yp b{ rijlkca k| qk|d lkeeiric| ugkni~ jcl jn|kca gy| |di ujrkgy~ pjr|~ ge |di ~|gr{#

B{ |di icl bg|d ge |di` qiri fjyadkca#

Jajkc* ~jkl Ngccir& akaafkca j~ ~di |knmfil dk` j fk||fi#

Jajkc7 Jfrkad|# ^di fjycndil kc|g |di ~|gr{ gcni jajkc jcl lklc| iuic cg|kni |di lggr

~qkca gpic erjn|kgcjff{# Ngccir ~ii`il |g ichg{ |dk~ rijlkca iuic `gri& nr{kca gy| |g |di pka~

cg| |g fi| |di bka bjl qgfe kc# Qdic ~dil ekck~dil ~di ri~|il dir dijl bjnm jcl fggmil lgqc j|

Ngccir qdg qj~ efkppkca |drgyad |di bggm jcl fggmkca j| |di pkn|yri~# ^di ~dke|il dir jr` |dj|

qj~ jrgycl dk` jcl di fggmil yp j| dir# ^di ~`kfil jcl dyaail dk` |g dir ~kli#

@j ~jkl {gy qiri yp& ~jkl j `jc~ ugkni j| |di lggr# ^di hirmil yprkad|& akukca j

ark`jni ge pjkc qdic ~di lkl ~g# Nfy|ndkca dir jr` jrgycl dir `kllfi& ~di fi| |di ~dirkee ij~i

dir bjnm jajkc~| |di pkffgq~ ~kcni di djl dj~|icil |g dir ~kli# K` ~grr{ K ~|jr|fil {gy# K qj~

hy~| agccj j~m ke {gy qiri dycar{# @j dj~ ~g`i ~|iq rijl{#

\dj|~###### ~di ~ynmil ~iuirjf brij|d~ ge jkr& dir brgq eyrrgqil kc pjkc biegri

jc~qirkca dk`# \dj|~ jfrkad|& K` hy~| hy`p{# ^|iq ~gycl~ aggl# ^di egrnil j ~`kfi jcl ~jkl

|g Ngccir& Qd{ lgc| {gy ag ~ii ke {gy njc difp {gyr arjcl`j qk|d lkccir7 \di bg{ fggmil

j| |di |qg ge |di` qk|d j pyxxfil itpri~~kgc# Di ~dryaail dk~ ~`jff ~dgyflir~ qk|d j ~`jff ~`kfi

jcl rijndil yp |g akui dir j qi| mk~~ gc |di ndiim biegri |jmkca dk~ bggm jcl ~nyrr{kca gy| ge

K`pirein| Fjq

:5

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

17/19

|di rgg`# Jylri{ egycl dir~ife aicykcif{ ~`kfkca je|ir dk`# \dic ~di ri`i`biril ~di qj~c|

jfgci jcl egrnil dir ejni |g bing`i ciy|rjf jajkc# Fggmkca bjnm j| |di ~dirkee ~di egycl dk`

~|yl{kca dir qk|d jc itpri~~kgc ~|jr|fkcaf{ ~k`kfjr |g |di gci dk~ ~gc djl bgri# ^di nfijril dir

|drgj| jcl ngc|kcyil& K` |di gci qdg ~dgyfl bi jpgfgakxkca# [gy jcl {gyr `g|dir qiri mkcl

|g fi| `i ~|j{ diri jcl |dic |dk~##### ~di |rjkfil gee#

Cgc~ic~i& afjl |g lg k| - ^g& @k~~ Bf{|di -

Jylri{#

Jylri{& {gy erg` Mjc~j~ Nk|{7

Qdj|7

Mjc~j~ Nk|{# [gy erg` |diri7

Cg#

Gd& K hy~| j~~y`il ~kcni {gy ag| gee |di MN by~#####

Cg# Arij| cgq di~ j~mkca zyi~|kgc~# [gy ~jkl ~g`i|dkca jbgy| ~|iq7

[ijd######## Kff brkca ~g`i yp# Di |yrcil jcl fie| |di rgg`#

Lirim nfg~il |di lggr bidkcl dk` jcl fijcil jajkc~| |di erj`i# Dil biic kc dk~ geekni

qdic dil dijrl fjyad|ir ng`kca erg` lgqc |di djff# Dil agci |g kcui~|kaj|i jcl egycl |di

lggr |g Jylri{~ rgg` jhjr# Kc~kli di ~jq j ~kad| di qj~ ycpripjril egr# Dk~ ~gc qj~ nyllfil

jajkc~| dir ~kli jcl di qj~ fjyadkca# Di ngyflc| ri`i`bir |di fj~| |k`i dil dijrl Ngccir

fjyad# [i| |diri di qj~& fjyadkca jcl |jfmkca fkmi k| qj~ jbgy| |g ag gy| ge ~|{fi# Dil mcgqc

|dj| Ngccir qj~ |jmic qk|d |dk~ fjl{ by| dil ciuir k`jakcil |dj| ~di qgyfl rinkprgnj|i |di

~ic|k`ic| |g |dk~ it|ic|# ^di djl j `ifglkgy~ njrierii fjyad qdknd rkppfil |drgyad |di rgg` jcl

djff# ^di qj~ j |rjc~egr`il qg`jc qk|d Ngccir# Cg fgcair yp|kad| gr ~njril& hy~| dir~ife& gr j|

fij~| qdj| ~ii`il |g bi dir |ryi cj|yri# B{ |dic dil rijfkxil dil biic ~|jrkca |gg fgca jcl

ciilil |g ~j{ ~g`i|dkca biegri di qj~ njyad|# ^g di djl& jcl djl ~|jr|fil dir ~g bjl ~dil dyr|

dir~ife jcl qgrrkil Ngccir# \djcmeyff{ Ngccir qj~ ~g {gyca dil |jmic dir j| dir qgrl |dj| ~di

K`pirein| Fjq

:1

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

18/19

qj~ ekci# J| fij~| dil ngcekr`il |dj| ~di qj~c| erg` Mjc~j~ Nk|{# _y~dkca jqj{ erg` |di

erj`i di qic| lgqc |g |di mk|ndic jcl pjy~il gy|~kli |di lggr# Kc~kli di ngyfl dijr Ngccir&

|iffkca Arjcl`j jbgy| |di ~|gr{ dil dijrl# Dk~ `g` fggmil yp j~ ~ggc j~ di ic|iril jcl& ge

ngyr~i& biajc |g birj|i dk` qk|d zyi~|kgc~# Lkl {gy j~m dir jbgy| |di#### {gy mcgq qdj|~7&

Lkl ~di ~j{ qdiri ~di qj~ erg`7& Lkl ~di |iff {gy jc{|dkca7 jcl |g ijnd zyi~|kgc di djl |g

jc~qir& Cg#

Qiff& K lgc| mcgq dgq {gy iuir `jcjail |g ai| kc|g |dj| aguirc`ic| jaicn{ |dj| pjkl

{gy ~g `ynd bjnm ij~| ke {gy njc| iuic ekayri gy| qdj| djppicil |g |dj| pggr akrf#

Ekr~| ge jff& k| qj~ |di Y#^# @jr~djf~ @j& jcl K qgrmil djrl egr |dj| pj{#### ^ingcl& K

djui ukr|yjff{ cg|dkca |g ag gc j~ ejr j~ ~di~ ngcnircil# Ke ~di qgc| iuic |jfm jbgy| qdj|

djppicil |diri~ cg| `ynd K njc lg#

K mcgq |dj|& by| ~|kff& K lgc| mcgq dgq {gy iuir njyad| jc{ nrk`kcjf~ fkmi |dk~# Di hy~|

~dggm dk~ dijl jcl qic| |g qj~d yp# @j ciuir djl yclir~|ggl qdj| dk~ hgb ic|jkfil# ^g`i|k`i~

di |dgyad| |dj| ~dil rj|dir bifkiui |di qdgfi qgrfl qj~ j~ ~k`pfi jcl fjq jbklkca j~ dir

dg`i|gqc ~ii`il& by| ~di qj~c| |dj| cjkui# Ngfbir| qj~ j ~`jff jcl ~k`pfi |gqc jcl jf|dgyad

`g~| ge k|~ nk|kxic~ qiri fjq jbklkca& fkmi jc{ g|dir |gqc k| djl k|~ `k~nrijc|~# Qd{ hy~|

{i~|irlj{ dil djl |g jrri~| j ngypfi ge |iicjair~ egr by~|kca kc|g |di lrya ~|gri jcl |r{kca |g

~|ijf j fg| ge pri~nrkp|kgc `ilknkci~# \djcmeyff{ |dikr pjric|~ qiri |di |{pi~ |dj| bifkiuil |dikr

ndkflric ~dgyfl pj{ |di ngc~izyicni~ egr |dikr `k~|jmi~ jcl djl jffgqil dk` |g fijui |di` kc

fgnm yp egr |di ckad| |g ~njri |di`# Di lklc| |dkcm jc{ lrya ndjrai~ qgyfl bi ekfil& prgbjbf{

hy~| j B%I# Ng`i |g |dkcm ge k|& dil bi||ir ag kc|g |gqc jcl rifkiui Ngl{& `j{bi |jmi dk` jcl

|di prk~gcir~ ~g`i aryb# Ngl{ Lkfficair djl biic dk~ lipy|{ ~kcni j eiq lj{~ je|ir dil |jmic

|di hgb# Di qj~ j aggl mkl& ~|kff pri||{ ariic& by| j aggl lipy|{# Qdic Ngccir djl byr~| kc|g |di

geekni {i~|irlj{ |jfmkca jbgy| j fjl{ qdgl ag||ic gee |di by~& pggr Ngl{ djl jbgy| djl j

ngrgcjr{# Dil ciuir dijrl Ngccir y||ir j ~kcafi qgrl# Dk~ grkakcjf lipy|{& Djrr{ Arin~ djl

iclil yp |jmkca j hgb kc |di cit| ngyc|{ j~ ^dirkee binjy~i di eif| |dj| dil biic pj~~il yp egr

|dk~ hgb egr kffiak|k`j|i rij~gc~# Djrr{ ~|kff djrbgril j arij| lk~fkmi egr dk`# Ejn| qj~ |dj| |di

K`pirein| Fjq

:4

8/9/2019 Imperfect Law

19/19

cit| ngyc|{ djl j `jhgr lrya prgbfi` qdknd Djrr{ djl kcdirk|il qdic di |ggm |di hgb# [ip& gfl

Djrr{ djl `jli k| cg ~inri| |dj|& ke di iuir djl |di ndjcni& dil djui Lirim~ hgb& jcl ke |dk~

|dkca qk|d @k~~ Bf{|di bfiq yp jcl ~di qgycl yp kc hjkf& dil djui pfic|{ ge argycl~ |g py~d egr

Lirim~ ri~kacj|kgc#

K`pirein| Fjq

:;