Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 ·...

25
Impact of Galactic subhalos Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons with cosmic-ray antiprotons Martin Stref, in collaboration with J. Lavalle and T. Lacroix (LUPM, Montpellier, France)

Transcript of Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 ·...

Page 1: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

Impact of Galactic subhalos Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches on indirect searches

with cosmic-ray antiprotonswith cosmic-ray antiprotons

Martin Stref,

in collaboration with

J. Lavalle and T. Lacroix(LUPM, Montpellier, France)

Page 2: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

2

Cold Dark Matter SubhalosCold Dark Matter Subhalos

CDM structures at scales much smaller than typical galaxies

Mass of the first halos given by the kinetic decoupling of the dark matter particle

According to simulations, many small halos survive up to now :

[Bringmann 09,Berezinsky+ 14]

Aquarius simulation [Springel + 08],See also Via Lactea II [Diemand+ 08],Illustris [Vogelsberger+ 14]

Page 3: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

3

Subhalos and dark matter searches Subhalos and dark matter searches

DM annihilation

Earth position

Detection via photons, neutrinos or charged cosmic rays

Indirect searches:

Direct detection:

Xe nucleus

recoil

WIMPSensitive to the local DM density.Fraction of that density inside clumps?

If subhalos present in the galaxy, signal is boosted! [Silk & Stebbins 93]

Page 4: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

4

A dynamically constrainedA dynamically constrained model of model of

Galactic subhalosGalactic subhalos

Based on

Stref & Lavalle : arXiv:1610.02233

Page 5: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

5

A dynamically constrained GalaxyA dynamically constrained Galaxy

The Milky Way dark halo is tightly constrained by observations

Terminal velocities from McMillan 11

Mass models from McMillan 17

Sun position

Page 6: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

6

A dynamically constrained GalaxyA dynamically constrained Galaxy

The Milky Way dark halo is tightly constrained by observations

constrained modeled/predicted

Page 7: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

7

A dynamically constrained GalaxyA dynamically constrained Galaxy

The Milky Way dark halo is tightly constrained by observations

Subhalo mass function :

Aquarius simulation [Springel+ 08]

Press-Schechter type :

with mass cutoff

Page 8: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

8

A dynamically constrained GalaxyA dynamically constrained Galaxy

The Milky Way dark halo is tightly constrained by observations

Page 9: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

9

A dynamically constrained GalaxyA dynamically constrained Galaxy

The Milky Way dark halo is tightly constrained by observations

Tidal effects!

Page 10: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

10

Tidal effectsInteraction of subhalos with external gravitational fields.

Two different effects :

Halo stripping Disk shocking

Stellar diskV

z

Clump center

r

DM particles get a net velocity kick[Ostriker+ 72]

[Stref & Lavalle 17]

Subhalos are stripped by the potential of the Galaxy

[Binney & Tremaine 87]

Page 11: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

11

Number densityNumber density

Sun position

Page 12: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

12

Luminosity and boost factors

Sun position

Page 13: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

13

Indirect searches with Indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotonscosmic-ray antiprotons

Based on

Stref, Lacroix & Lavalle : arXiv:17xx.xxxxx

Page 14: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

14

Why antiprotons?Why antiprotons?

[Aguilar+ 16]

[Bergstrom 09]

Indirect searches :

with gamma rays[Bergstrom+ 99],

with antimatter cosmic rays [Lavalle+ 07,08]

f

AMS-02 data

Page 15: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

15

Why antiprotons?Why antiprotons?

[Cuoco+ 16, see also Cui+ 16]

[Bergstrom 09]

Indirect searches :

with gamma rays[Bergstrom+ 99],

with antimatter cosmic rays [Lavalle+ 07,08]

f

AMS-02 “hot spot”

Page 16: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

16

Cosmic-ray propagationCosmic-ray propagation[Mertsch, 2010]

Propagation eq. for cosmic rays sourced by DM

Propagation parameters fixed by B/C (secondaries/primaries) :

Page 17: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

17

Cosmic-ray propagationCosmic-ray propagation[Mertsch, 2010]

Propagation eq. for cosmic rays sourced by DM

L

Propagation parameters fixed by B/C (secondaries/primaries) :

r

Critical for DM searches

Page 18: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

18

Antiproton fluxAntiproton flux

Spectra from PPPC4DM ID[Cirelli+ 11]

Page 19: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

19

Exclusion curves : MED modelExclusion curves : MED model

Page 20: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

20

Exclusion curves : model of Kappl et al.Exclusion curves : model of Kappl et al.

Page 21: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

21

SummarySummary

● DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect searches : dynamical constraints must be accounted for.

● Cold dark matter, and WIMPs in particular, forms very small-scale subhalos.

● The subhalo population can be modeled in a dynamically consistent way, including tidal disruption effects.

● Subhalos strongly impact indirect searches, e.g. with cosmic-rays antiprotons, and should be accounted for (at least as a theoretical uncertainty).

Page 22: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

22

BackupBackup

Page 23: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

23

Predicted mass density profilesPredicted mass density profiles

Sun position

Main model

Page 24: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

24

Posterior mass functionPosterior mass function

Page 25: Impact of Galactic subhalos on indirect searches with cosmic-ray antiprotons - TeVPA 2017 · 2017-08-13 · 21 Summary DM distribution is fondamental to make predictions on direct/indirect

25

Cored DM profileCored DM profile