IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

download IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

of 244

Transcript of IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    1/244

    1

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    2/244

    2

    F T 2013: A G R R, L S, D A

    H, A, N a ca b Iaa Ha a EcaU (IHEU). T La A Ma C, E Bb Cc.

    T Iaa Ha a Eca U a 120 Ha,a, aa, ca, ca c, a aa a 40

    c. I a ba Ha , a

    a b a Ha c a a c a a ca a

    .

    I a a, a cc a @IHEU.

    b a.

    T c a a IHEU, a a , .

    T c a a a a a a c aa ..

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    3/244

    3

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    4/244

    4

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    5/244

    5

    C

    C .................................................................................................................................................. 5

    Ic .......................................................................................................................................... 14

    A R .................................................................................................................................... 14

    A W ................................................................................................................................. 16

    Sca Ta .............................................................................................................................. 18

    A S W ................................................................................................................................ 18

    A c ca ............................................................................................................................ 19

    H a Ac ........................................................................................................... 20

    Pac: H U R ........................................................................................................... 22

    T Ra S ............................................................................................................................. 22

    T C a Caca Da ..................................................................................... 22

    Ca ............................................................................................................................................ 27

    AFRICA ................................................................................................................................................... 29

    Ea Aca ........................................................................................................................................ 29

    B .............................................................................................................................................. 29

    C ............................................................................................................................................ 30

    Db .............................................................................................................................................. 30

    Ea ................................................................................................................................................ 31

    Ea ............................................................................................................................................. 32

    Ka ................................................................................................................................................. 34

    Maaaca ....................................................................................................................................... 34

    Maa............................................................................................................................................... 35

    Ma ........................................................................................................................................... 35

    Mab ..................................................................................................................................... 36

    Raa ............................................................................................................................................. 36

    Sc .......................................................................................................................................... 38

    Saa .............................................................................................................................................. 39

    S Sa ...................................................................................................................................... 40

    Uaa .............................................................................................................................................. 41Taaa ............................................................................................................................................ 42

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    6/244

    6

    Zaba ............................................................................................................................................... 43

    Zbab.......................................................................................................................................... 44

    M Aca ......................................................................................................................................... 45

    Aa ............................................................................................................................................... 45

    Ca .......................................................................................................................................... 46

    Ca Aca Rbc ................................................................................................................... 46

    Ca .................................................................................................................................................. 47

    C ................................................................................................................................................ 48

    Dcac Rbc C.......................................................................................................... 48

    Eaa Ga ............................................................................................................................. 49

    Gab ................................................................................................................................................ 49

    S T a Pc ..................................................................................................................... 50

    N Aca ..................................................................................................................................... 51

    Aa ............................................................................................................................................... 51

    E ................................................................................................................................................. 53

    H Ca: ......................................................................................................................... 53

    Lba .................................................................................................................................................. 55

    Mcc (c W Saaa) ............................................................................................... 57

    H Ca: ......................................................................................................................... 58

    Sa ................................................................................................................................................ 60

    Ta ............................................................................................................................................... 61

    H Ca: ......................................................................................................................... 62

    S Aca ..................................................................................................................................... 64

    Baa........................................................................................................................................... 64

    L .............................................................................................................................................. 64

    Naba ............................................................................................................................................. 65S Aca ....................................................................................................................................... 66

    Saa .......................................................................................................................................... 66

    W Aca ...................................................................................................................................... 68

    B ................................................................................................................................................. 68

    B Fa ...................................................................................................................................... 68

    Cab V ........................................................................................................................................ 69

    C I ...................................................................................................................................... 69

    Gaba .............................................................................................................................................. 70

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    7/244

    7

    Gaa ................................................................................................................................................ 71

    Ga ............................................................................................................................................... 72

    GaBa.................................................................................................................................... 73

    Lba ................................................................................................................................................ 74

    Ma ................................................................................................................................................... 75

    Maaa ......................................................................................................................................... 76

    N .................................................................................................................................................. 77

    Na ............................................................................................................................................... 78

    H Ca: ......................................................................................................................... 79

    Sa .............................................................................................................................................. 80

    Sa L ...................................................................................................................................... 80

    T .................................................................................................................................................. 81

    AMERICAS ............................................................................................................................................. 82

    La Aca a Cabba.......................................................................................................... 82

    Aa a Baba ........................................................................................................................ 82

    Baaa ............................................................................................................................................ 82

    Baba ........................................................................................................................................... 83

    Cba .................................................................................................................................................. 83

    Dca ........................................................................................................................................... 84

    Gaa............................................................................................................................................. 84

    Ha ................................................................................................................................................... 85

    Jaaca .............................................................................................................................................. 86

    Sa K a N.......................................................................................................................... 86

    Sa Lca ......................................................................................................................................... 87

    Sa Vc a Ga .................................................................................................... 87

    Ta a Tba ......................................................................................................................... 88Ca Aca .................................................................................................................................... 89

    B ................................................................................................................................................. 89

    Ca Rca .......................................................................................................................................... 89

    E Saa ......................................................................................................................................... 90

    Gaaa ......................................................................................................................................... 91

    Ha ........................................................................................................................................... 91

    Mc ............................................................................................................................................... 92

    Ncaaa .......................................................................................................................................... 93

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    8/244

    8

    Paaa ............................................................................................................................................. 94

    S Aca ....................................................................................................................................... 95

    Aa........................................................................................................................................... 95

    Ba ................................................................................................................................................ 95

    Ba .................................................................................................................................................. 96

    C .................................................................................................................................................. 96

    Cba ........................................................................................................................................... 97

    Eca ............................................................................................................................................. 98

    Gaa .............................................................................................................................................. 99

    Paaa ......................................................................................................................................... 100

    P ................................................................................................................................................. 101

    Sa ......................................................................................................................................... 102

    Ua ........................................................................................................................................... 103

    Va ........................................................................................................................................ 103

    N Aca ..................................................................................................................................... 105

    Caaa ............................................................................................................................................ 105

    U Sa Aca ................................................................................................................ 105

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 107

    ASIA ..................................................................................................................................................... 110

    Ca Aa ......................................................................................................................................... 110

    Kaaa ...................................................................................................................................... 110

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 110

    Ka ....................................................................................................................................... 111

    Taa ......................................................................................................................................... 112

    Ta .................................................................................................................................. 112

    Uba ....................................................................................................................................... 113Ea Aa ......................................................................................................................................... 115

    Ca (c Tb, Maca a H K) .............................................................................. 115

    N Ka ( DPRK) .................................................................................................................... 116

    Jaa ............................................................................................................................................... 117

    Ma ......................................................................................................................................... 117

    S Ka ..................................................................................................................................... 118

    Taa ............................................................................................................................................. 119

    S Aa ...................................................................................................................................... 120

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    9/244

    9

    Aaa ..................................................................................................................................... 120

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 123

    Baa ...................................................................................................................................... 123

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 125

    Ba ............................................................................................................................................. 126

    Ia ................................................................................................................................................ 127

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 128

    Ia .................................................................................................................................................. 129

    H Ca:....................................................................................................................... 132

    Ma .......................................................................................................................................... 133

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 134

    Na ............................................................................................................................................... 135

    Paa ........................................................................................................................................... 136

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 138

    S Laa .......................................................................................................................................... 139

    SEa Aa .............................................................................................................................. 141

    B .............................................................................................................................................. 141

    Caba ........................................................................................................................................ 142

    Ia ......................................................................................................................................... 143

    Ca ca: .............................................................................................................. 144

    La ................................................................................................................................................. 145

    Maaa .......................................................................................................................................... 146

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 147

    Maa ......................................................................................................................................... 148

    P ....................................................................................................................................... 150

    Sa ........................................................................................................................................ 151Taa ........................................................................................................................................... 153

    T L ..................................................................................................................................... 154

    V Na ......................................................................................................................................... 155

    W Aa ....................................................................................................................................... 157

    Aa ........................................................................................................................................... 157

    Abaa ....................................................................................................................................... 158

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 159

    Baa ............................................................................................................................................ 159

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    10/244

    10

    H ca: ....................................................................................................................... 161

    C ............................................................................................................................................. 161

    Ga ............................................................................................................................................ 162

    Ia .................................................................................................................................................. 163

    Ia ................................................................................................................................................ 165

    Ja .............................................................................................................................................. 167

    Ka ............................................................................................................................................. 169

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 169

    Lba .......................................................................................................................................... 170

    Oa ............................................................................................................................................... 172

    Qaa ............................................................................................................................................... 174

    Sa Aaba .................................................................................................................................... 176

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 177

    Pa, Sa ........................................................................................................................... 178

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 179

    Sa ................................................................................................................................................. 180

    T ............................................................................................................................................. 181

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 182

    U Aab Ea ...................................................................................................................... 183

    Ia Ca:.......................................................................................................................... 185

    Y ............................................................................................................................................. 186

    EUROPE ............................................................................................................................................... 188

    Ea E .................................................................................................................................... 188

    Ba ............................................................................................................................................ 188

    Baa ........................................................................................................................................... 189

    Cc Rbc ................................................................................................................................ 189Ha ........................................................................................................................................... 190

    Pa ............................................................................................................................................. 192

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 193

    Ma (a Taa) ............................................................................................................. 193

    Raa .......................................................................................................................................... 194

    Ra .............................................................................................................................................. 195

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 197

    Saa ........................................................................................................................................... 197

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    11/244

    11

    Ua ............................................................................................................................................ 198

    N E ................................................................................................................................. 200

    Da .......................................................................................................................................... 200

    Ea ............................................................................................................................................. 201

    Fa ............................................................................................................................................. 201

    Ica ............................................................................................................................................. 202

    Ia ............................................................................................................................................. 203

    Laa ............................................................................................................................................... 204

    Laa ......................................................................................................................................... 205

    Na ............................................................................................................................................ 206

    S ............................................................................................................................................ 206

    U K .............................................................................................................................. 207

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 209

    S E ................................................................................................................................. 210

    Abaa ............................................................................................................................................ 210

    Aa ........................................................................................................................................... 210

    Ba a Ha .................................................................................................................. 211

    Caa ............................................................................................................................................. 212

    Gc ............................................................................................................................................. 213

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 214

    Ia ................................................................................................................................................. 215

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 216

    K ............................................................................................................................................. 216

    Maa ............................................................................................................................................... 217

    M .................................................................................................................................... 218

    Pa ........................................................................................................................................... 219Sa Ma ...................................................................................................................................... 219

    Sba .............................................................................................................................................. 220

    Sa ........................................................................................................................................... 221

    Sa ................................................................................................................................................ 221

    Maca ...................................................................................................................................... 221

    W E .................................................................................................................................. 223

    Aa ............................................................................................................................................. 223

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 223

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    12/244

    12

    B ........................................................................................................................................... 224

    Fac.............................................................................................................................................. 225

    Ga .......................................................................................................................................... 225

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 226

    Lc ................................................................................................................................... 227

    Lb .................................................................................................................................... 228

    Mac ........................................................................................................................................... 229

    Na..................................................................................................................................... 229

    Sa...................................................................................................................................... 230

    H ca: ....................................................................................................................... 231

    OCEANIA.............................................................................................................................................. 232

    Aaa a N Zaa ................................................................................................................. 232

    Aaa .......................................................................................................................................... 232

    H Ca: ....................................................................................................................... 233

    N Zaa ................................................................................................................................... 234

    Maa ............................................................................................................................................ 236

    F .................................................................................................................................................... 236

    Paa N Ga .......................................................................................................................... 237

    S Ia .............................................................................................................................. 238

    Mca .......................................................................................................................................... 239

    Kba ............................................................................................................................................. 239

    Maa Ia .............................................................................................................................. 239

    Mca (Fa Sa ) ................................................................................................... 239

    Na .............................................................................................................................................. 240

    Paa ................................................................................................................................................ 240

    Pa ............................................................................................................................................. 241Saa ............................................................................................................................................. 241

    Ta............................................................................................................................................... 242

    Ta .............................................................................................................................................. 245

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    13/244

    13

    "F . W

    , . O , , .

    I ,

    . A . L "" ,

    , ,

    , .

    W . T ."

    Kac a Ab a b c aba

    a a ca a a

    Mcc a E c.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    14/244

    14

    I

    F T 2013 a a a c . Scca, a a

    ca a, ac, a, a

    a a bca ac abc b a . W c

    ca b a a; a c, a ca ca a

    c , b a .

    I b a ba a a a ac

    a : , ccc, ;

    ; a, , ab a aca.

    O a a c a c aa . T a a a a , c,

    c a, bc acc bc ca, b

    bc c, a, ca cc , a

    c a a. I ca, a

    a , a c b a ac.

    A ( b a ), a a ( bac a a

    c a a a a a aa a aa c),

    a c , a a a a a ac

    . A a 2012 a a a 59%

    a, a a a 13%, a a aa 23% a ( a a). T b Ga Iaa

    Aca (aaab a://.a.c/b///14//14.)

    c ba . I a a a a a a

    b 9% a a b 3% b 2005 a 2012a a c

    ca a a c, c a a

    c.

    T , ccc, b c a ccc

    a b. T a a b ba c 1948 Ac 18 Ua Dcaa Ha R. I a:

    E a , ccc a ; c

    ca b, a , a c

    a bc a, a b ac, acc,

    a bac.

    A 18, U D H R

    T b a b a c

    aa a b Ac 18 Iaa Ca C a Pca R 1966.

    T 1981 a ba aca a a b UN Dcaa Ea A F Iac a Dca Ba R B.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    15/244

    15

    J a , ccc, b c a

    a , a c c a b, a a a,

    a a cc , ac a acc. A U

    Na Ha R C a (Ga C 22):

    1. T , ( ) 18.1 ; , ,

    .

    2. A 18 , , . T .

    A 18

    .

    (T, ca cb a a a , a aa , aa

    a a c a b. O ca, a a a

    c a a aa aa accc.)

    R b a b a a a bca a a a,

    c b. J a c a a

    aa b a ccc, a cc b a acc.

    J a a cc a a a ca b aa

    a a ac a, ca aca c a a cac,

    , aa, a a , aca ca, a

    b,acc a a, a b. A a, a U

    Na a, b, a , aa

    cc (UN Dcaa Ea A F Iac a Dca Ba R B).

    Ac 18 c a a: c a b a a a

    a ba b bc a a a, ac a a acc. T

    b ca aa a a

    a a . B a a a ca

    ccc, a b.

    T , b, ca b, b

    a a ca a. A a b Ac 19 Ua Dcaa

    Ha R, c a a a, cca, a a ca ca a a :

    E a a ; c

    c a , c a a a a a

    a a a a .

    A 19, U D H R

    I a a c bc a a

    a aca a b, a a

    , c bc ab a a. T a c b Ac 20

    Ua Dcaa Ha R: E a ac

    ab a aca A 20, U D H R.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    16/244

    16

    I ccc a a a Ua Dcaa Ha

    R: Ac 18, 19, a 20 a ac , a a a a .

    O a a , ab a aca, a

    a b, a ,

    c , a a a a.

    T c c a a c

    c a a . T ccc: a c, ca

    .

    I c, a b a a. F a, c Ma

    b a M a a a Ia a. Ma c, a

    , , b a a . A c

    aaa a a. I ac, 19 c c aa, a 12 c ab b a. Paa ' a a

    a c aa b ba, a 'ba' ca

    ; c ca b a a 13 c.

    M c a c a a

    a, a ca a aa a

    b. Ma c a ba a a a

    cc c a

    . F a, Paa a c

    a a a ba c c

    c aba a 1988. A bca , Dcb 2013,

    Iac c Paa ca a

    a a accab ba:

    a c Ia a .

    T c cc a aa ca ba; ca a a

    c ( a b a b aa aca c a c)

    bca a . T c 'ba'

    a a c 55 c, ca a 39

    c, a a ab b a c. I a, c

    c aa a a a 'ba' a c aa.

    O a a ac c c ba a bc

    c, a c a a ID

    ca ab a a, a, a a a a

    . S c ca aa

    a a b b a accac

    a.

    "

    "

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    17/244

    17

    I ac ca aa ca b , a, b

    . R c ca

    aa a. F b, a a a a

    c b. B a a c b a b b

    b a , ca aaca . F a, Lba

    ba caa a a aaab S M a S M a Ma Ca , c. T acc

    c a ca ca b a ca a

    b, bca a a

    a c b a .

    R a a c bc

    c a bc ca. T c a

    baa c

    a c. F a, N Ia

    94% a c a caac.

    T c caa b ca, b a c . I Ea a

    Wa, 16% a c ac ( 1.2

    c), a bc a c a

    ca aa a.

    I c , a a

    a a

    ca a , b a a a

    a ca ca aa a.

    W a a ca, a

    a b a caaa aaab . E a a a c c

    , b a , c ca c a ca aa

    .

    F a, US a a a a a acc a a b b a

    Aca, a c a. S a a Ca D. B

    c a a a I G W T a, a c a

    a a c b aac O Na G, cca a

    cc a b Aca b G. T US

    c a a a b a a aca a

    c; a a Aca ca b Aca a 535 b US C bc a b .

    T, a c ca, ,

    ca ca bc. W a bc: b a

    b a c a c ca a .

    T a a ca aa a c c. T

    a b a ! I a ac b Bb Cc a

    a ca ca a a c . B

    a a a ac a b

    a : a a.

    "

    "

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    18/244

    18

    Fa a, a a a a a, a a c aa, c,

    ac, c a a c ca a . M a a, a a a

    a a a c a a: a, a a

    a a a a a a a a. Ma M c

    c a a Saa c a M, c, a. O c, a

    ca a , a a a c c. Ua a a , a a,

    a, a a c ca bc a a a a

    a, a a c aa a ca c

    aba b ' a.

    I ca a a a a c

    . I ac, a a ca a.

    Taaa a N Ka a (a a a c

    a) a a a a ac a a a a a a

    cac. Sb a a c a c, c c ac a a, c a

    ac . A c ac a a ,

    ca, ab b .

    T a a c , a a ca c

    a. E a a c a bca a,

    bca , a ab a

    aca a a.

    W a a a c a a c a. T a b

    a c a bca ca b a, a

    a, a a cc. W b c b a: a

    a ac, a a ac a a a . T a aa

    c a b c a a c

    Ua, a cc aa c a a c a c

    a. S c a a a ca, a

    ac a a c aa ca.

    I, a ab a 2013 a c a a a ac aac a. F a, Fba, Baa

    b A Rab Ha a bca ca ac. A ,

    M a a b, A M. (T Baa

    b a aac b b ca M a

    b c Ia a P.) I A, Ia a

    a ac, D. Naa Daba, a a a caa

    a H aa ( a ca a ca a aaa, b

    c a b ca a c, c ac, a b acc

    a a). T a aa c a c

    a a c, a a a ac a

    a a ac acc.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    19/244

    19

    S a a a, a, a c

    a a. B a a a a a a c. A a

    a a a a b; b c a

    cc a

    c a, , a.

    W a a a a c. (A a a a, c ca

    b a a, , b a .) T a a

    c ba a a a a . A a

    a a b

    a a.

    Y a a a c . T

    a a ca aa .

    H, a a ac, a a a. I a a a c a c a

    , a a b c a a a ccac a

    : aca , b a ca a bac, a

    a ca . I a c b N Ka (

    a, Ga Va) a S Ka (F a Ea), c

    b Lba a a ( a b ) a Lba a (M

    Saac), ca a c b a bca a,

    a . W a a, ca a ba

    ac ca ca a c ab a a. Ca b.

    Tac a a aa ac.

    W a ca c, ac

    a a a . B

    cab ; a Ac 18 Ua Dcaa

    ac, b a b, a a :

    , ccc a . M aa, a c a

    c a b Ac 1 Ua Dcaa: A a

    b a b a a a . T a a a ccc

    a ac a a a b.

    L A RI I H E U

    P NGO C F R B U N

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    20/244

    20

    H A

    T a a ba aa ca a b US SD O I R F. I 2012 A

    H A(AHA) Oc a cc ab ca a a

    a c aa bca Ha, a ac . T

    Oc b a AHA b a a aa c ca.

    T AHA C I, I H E U, R D

    F R S, a S C A a

    . T aa , a ba a

    cac, ca a 40 a , c a 40 a a . T a

    b US Sa Da A 2012.

    S a, cb a , Ma C Iaa Ha

    a Eca U (IHEU), a a a. T , a

    a a a c a aa 20 c, a a F T

    2012 a ac Dcb 10, 2012, W Ha R Da.

    T aac bc a F T R 2012, a ca

    b a a aa . T , a ca c

    c a ca a b a . S F

    T R 2013 c c .

    Sc c a ac a aa c a .

    S, ab M DD a C I, a c.

    I a, a ca a

    ac: US S D O I R F . T US Sa

    Da aa I R F Ra a

    c . W a a a

    b a . A a a

    aa c, ca a F H, C P

    J, F 18, R W B, a I C. H R W

    a A I a aa a c a

    ab.

    W a a a b a a a,

    ba a a a b . A a a

    a c ac a ca. W

    a a a a accac a ac, a a ca a

    a a ac. W a a a a c.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    21/244

    21

    W a a c a a c. B a a a

    a b . T c

    a b a. W a a

    . Pa .. b ca, a

    a.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    22/244

    22

    P: H U R

    T c a c c.

    I c c a a ca aa a, a a

    a . I a c ca a ac a

    cc a.

    T c a b a a aabca .

    E c a a "F T" . T a caca a,

    ca : "F a Ea", "M Saac", "Sc Dca",

    "S Dca", a "Ga Va".

    Ba a a, c cc aa ac 44

    . Eac ba c aac caca.

    I a c ba c aca a caca

    . T a a c c caca a

    . T c a a. T cb ba

    c a b a a a a b .

    F a ba c "Oca bc c " (a

    bca a cca a a a) a "M Saac"

    a b . H, ba c "I a c a a

    a a " , a "Ga a" a b a

    c b ca a, ca. B c a b

    Ga a a b, b ca "I a c a a a

    a " b b.

    I c a c c b b a c

    c. I ca a c a b a a

    c, a aa c . F a, ba ab b

    a a c "a", c

    ba a ab b "".

    T ac caca a, b ba c (b)

    c a ac.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    23/244

    23

    F b a a ca caaa aT .

    A L T

    ,

    . H "F

    E" .

    T

    O T

    ,

    .

    S

    T

    ,

    ( S E C ).

    R '' T

    . H

    ,

    ;

    . T "S"

    ,

    .

    S ,

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    24/244

    24

    C

    E H ,

    T

    . G

    ,

    T T "S" : "T

    ".

    T

    . I

    "S D".

    S / P T "S " "S

    " . T

    ,

    . B H ,

    /

    ,

    .

    L M "",

    . H ,

    .

    S

    D ,

    T , ,

    ,

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    25/244

    25

    R I

    . N

    "" ;

    , .

    S , T

    , ,

    .

    S R

    I , ,

    , ,

    .

    R

    C T

    S C T ,

    ,

    . I ,

    , "" . H,

    .

    C

    E H ,

    T T

    . W

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    26/244

    26

    ,

    .

    P T , ,

    . M

    " ". T . I

    .

    R S S A B

    I H, , NGO

    E H ,

    T .

    C , T ,

    , "G V".

    Q T

    " "

    R I "G "

    ,

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    27/244

    27

    . I .

    S I ,

    . B

    .

    T

    I

    ,

    .

    A B T T

    .

    I G , ,

    I ,

    I H, , NGO ,

    F

    I b a ca ca b a. W a a a

    c , "a " a a a a ca

    ac ca . L, ca

    a a, a .

    I c cc c, a c a, ac , a

    b c a c acc a ca. I c a a

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    28/244

    28

    ba a a ca a a c aca ac a a

    a ( a) .

    I c c aa aa a a a

    c c a. M ca cb a ,

    a a ca a b a acc a a.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    29/244

    29

    AFRICA

    E A

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc, b, a

    b ca ba

    cc.

    H ,

    . I 2013, P P Na a a a

    c ca c a .

    W a a a

    T c aa a a ab a

    aca. H,

    , . T

    , .

    E ,

    U P R UN H R

    C J 2013.

    T a c acc ,

    30 M, .

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    30/244

    30

    T c a a a c c

    b. H,

    c a a a

    I .

    A ca a Ma 2009 a

    "I .T

    S F .

    P I ,

    I .

    I I,

    , .

    W a a

    a

    T c aa a ab a aca. W

    a a ab a aca,

    aa.

    A c a a a c

    c b, a

    ,

    .

    M a 99% a a S

    M. C M

    ;

    .

    H, a ac

    b Iac ac acc

    b. N c cca

    b .

    M ( M!) I . N

    M a accac c a . T

    a M ; aDb a a, b ab ( a a

    STATE LEGISLATION IS LARGELY OR ENTIRELYDERIVED FROM RELIGIOUS LAW OR BY

    RELIGIOUS AUTHORITIES

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTS INSIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    APOSTASYIS OUTLAWED AND PUNISHABLEWITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    BLASPHEMYIS OUTLAWED OR CRITICISM OFRELIGION IS RESTRICTED AND PUNISHABLE

    WITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TORELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

    RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY INAT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

    PROHIBITIVE INTERRELIGIOUS SOCIALCONTROL

    RELIGIOUS CONTROL OVER FAMILY LAW ORLEGISLATION ON MORAL MATTERS

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTSIN SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANIST PRINCIPLESON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND HUMAN

    RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    OFFICIAL SYMBOLIC DEFERENCE TO RELIGION

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    31/244

    31

    a ). T : a M a a a a

    M a a c Ia. Acc a c, " a

    aa cc a M a a a M."

    T ;

    , c a aa, Ca C, SC, Cab Acc, a c a a. W a

    ab b a, a a ca c C

    c a b a . N

    .

    T a c ca, a a a M c. Sa c

    ac .

    W a a a

    A c b c,

    .

    F ab a aca a a c c, b a

    .

    Ea a c 1997 a aa

    ba aa aa b, a a

    a . Ua,

    c a b : E

    . I

    .

    I ,

    . E c a a Ea a a c

    R W B

    a a. M

    ,

    .

    I 2002

    . F a :

    Ea O Cc, Eaca(La) Cc Ea, Ia, a Ra Cac Cc. R

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS BRUTALLY REPRESSED

    IT IS ILLEGAL OR UNRECOGNISED TO IDENTIFYAS AN ATHEIST OR AS NONRELIGIOUS

    IT IS ILLEGAL TO ADVOCATE SECULARISM ORCHURCHSTATE SEPARATION,OR SUCH

    ADVOCACY IS SUPPRESSED

    IT IS ILLEGAL TO REGISTER AN EXPLICITLYHUMANIST,ATHEIST,SECULARIST OR OTHERNONRELIGIOUS NGOOR OTHER HUMAN

    RIGHTS ORGANIATION WHICH DEFENDS

    FREEDOM OF THOUGHT AND EXPRESSION

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTS INSIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    BLASPHEMYIS OUTLAWED OR CRITICISM OFRELIGION IS RESTRICTED AND PUNISHABLE

    WITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY INAT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    32/244

    32

    . T

    ,

    , .

    M

    . T ,

    .B 2012, a a a

    a a a 2,000 3,000. S a a

    a a a ca b a a

    a ca a a c a.

    T ,

    O R

    A, , ,

    .

    W a a a

    T 2001,

    E. T

    . Ja a bc

    c. T a acc a 2007. T

    a a a aa a a baca Ea. T

    c I ac a b cca.

    A 11 a a 2001 a b ca a. I 2013 R

    W B (RWB) c a a a;

    a a aa c bca . A

    30 a Ea a J 2013, acc RWB.

    F . T

    : NGO E

    , 2011.

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    a . H,

    .

    Ac 11 c a (1) Sa

    a a aa. (2) T a b a

    .(3) T a a a a a a aa.

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT OF RELIGION CRITICISM OF RELIGION IS RESTRICTED IN LAW

    OR A DE FACTO BLASPHEMYLAW IS IN

    EFFECT

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    33/244

    33

    T a c . I a, Ac 27 aa

    , b , Ac 29 aa ,

    a . A

    , .

    A 2008 , , .

    T c aa b, b

    M a M a a

    Ea O Cc a c a .

    W a a a

    T .O

    a a, A N, c 2009, ca aa b

    a. T a a a a ca c.

    I 2009 a aac A Pcaa a a b

    aa a ac. Ma a a b

    A . I J 2012, cc . F

    cc aba, b , E Na, a c 18 a . T

    C Pc Ja a Ea a 79 a a

    ca, a a a.

    I 2012

    .Cc a a a a b b ca a, a c a S a c

    c c a ca b a a b a ac ac.

    T aa a a a, ca

    .

    F ab a aca a aa b c b acc.

    Oa a bc a 48

    aac, b b a a .

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    34/244

    34

    A c a 2010 aa

    , ccc a , a a

    a , a

    ab a aca. H,

    .

    T

    I

    , ,

    , ,

    M . Ab

    c Ka a M. T ca H C a c c ca

    c, c c, a c aa a cc.

    W a a a

    T c c c a ; ,

    . I a a a c a, 2012

    ac a b a a cca

    a c; a ca c ac a

    ($58,100). J ,

    .

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    a . H,

    c 2009.

    I , ,

    A R.

    T a c aa ab, b a a ac.

    W a a a

    T c c c a . H,

    Raaa a c, a

    , , ,

    .

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    SOME RELIGIOUS COURTS RULE IN CIVIL ORFAMILY MATTERS ON A SOCIALLY COERCIVE

    OR DISCRIMINATORYBASIS

    STATEFUNDED SCHOOLS OFFER RELIGIOUSINSTRUCTION WITHOUT SECULAR

    ALTERNATIVES BUT IT IS OPTIONAL

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    35/244

    35

    Sc 2009 c, . T a

    c c a cb a,

    a c.

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    a . T a

    a c acc.

    R

    . Ca Bb K

    c a Ma a R Eca c

    a c M, H, Baa', a Caaa a aaab, b M c a aaab. Ia aac aca

    c c c c c .

    T a a a baca a a a, ,

    ( )

    c a Rbc bc a

    a.

    W a a a

    T a a a c, a a

    a c acc.

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    a . T a

    a c acc.

    A aaa c c

    a c, c

    Cac, Aca, Pba, Sa

    A, H, a M. T

    . T

    a aca , c a a

    b. T .

    CRITICISM OF RELIGION IS RESTRICTED INLAW OR A DE FACTO BLASPHEMYLAW IS IN

    EFFECT

    STATEFUNDED SCHOOLS OFFER RELIGIOUSINSTRUCTION WITHOUT SECULAR

    ALTERNATIVES BUT IT IS OPTIONAL

    PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT OF RELIGION STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS

    OR SALARIES,OR DISCRIMINATORY TAX

    EXEMPTIONS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    36/244

    36

    T a a a a cabca ba. A

    a c c ac, ba b

    a c a a ac a.

    W a a a

    T c aa a . Sa a a a

    bca cc b a a, b M

    B C .

    F ab a aca a , c a ccaa c

    c .

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    a . T

    b a c acc, b

    ,

    ,

    .

    P

    .

    W a a a

    W ,

    .

    A ac ab ca c, bc a

    ba ca aa.

    T c a a c

    b, a a a

    c acc. H, a a acc

    a

    .

    T c c a

    c ca a b

    ca ba , c

    a c a 2012 ab b

    a a 100,000 Raa ac (US$160 $1,590).

    SOME CONCERNS ABOUT POLITICAL ORMEDIA FREEDOMS,NOT SPECIFIC TO THE

    NONRELIGIOUS

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    STATEFUNDED SCHOOLS OFFER RELIGIOUSINSTRUCTION WITHOUT SECULAR

    ALTERNATIVES BUT IT IS OPTIONAL

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    37/244

    37

    T a c a ab 20,000 Raa ac (US$30

    $1,590) a a a a acc

    , bc a , b, bc , , a, ca

    aa a a.

    A . T

    (

    ).

    T c b a ca aa ba

    ac a c ca.

    W a a a

    T ,

    .T

    a c b a a c

    1994 Raa c. T a a aa c a

    cc .

    I 2010 , P K

    93% , (

    ), ,

    M H C.

    I Fba 2011, Uab a a A Uaa N a Saa Mabb c 17 a 7 a, c, c, c c bc,

    a a bc ca ba a 2009 ac cc P Pa Kaa. N a

    Mabb aa ca Jaa 2012, a A, S C c

    c a a, c. I J 2012, I Gaaa B, a

    a Cc, a a 30 a a b a c

    a a c a c a a ab a

    cca a a.

    R

    .I Nb 2011, Ca Iab, Uaaba bca I

    N a a cc Kaa a Raa 2007 a,

    a a Uaa. H a a 2012. Sc

    c a a a Raa.

    F ,

    . T 2012 a c a bc a ab 100,000

    Raa ac (US$160 $7,935) a a a

    a bc , c ab a.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    38/244

    38

    T c a a c

    b a a c

    acc.

    T

    ( H ).

    W a a

    a

    T a ab a a aa b

    c. H, ,

    c a Sc Na a. S

    , a c. I Ocb 2012, c L Na ScW a cc c c a a 2011 ac, a a c

    a .

    T .

    PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT OF RELIGION SOME CONCERNS ABOUT POLITICAL OR

    MEDIA FREEDOMS,NOT SPECIFIC TO THE

    NONRELIGIOUS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    39/244

    39

    S

    .T

    I S

    (I ) ,

    . I A 2012, a

    ab a ca a,

    Saa a a a

    c a ca

    , a a .

    H, I

    I.

    P S S,

    ,

    ,

    , I,

    I.

    I a, Ia ASabaab

    a c a aa a

    ca .. AS I,

    .

    T a a Sa c a

    2012 ab I a

    S

    . I a a a c, a

    , a a a a b

    a a a ac acc

    , b I. T

    .

    T Pa c, a b a c ab 2012, a a ca b

    c a a a b. I M

    I. T Pa a c

    Pa c a a c Ia b.

    T Saa c c b. H, a a I

    M , b ac a a a

    a, a I. Saa

    STATE LEGISLATION IS LARGELY OR ENTIRELYDERIVED FROM RELIGIOUS LAW OR BY

    RELIGIOUS AUTHORITIES

    APOSTASYOR CONVERSION FROM A

    SPECIFIC RELIGION IS OUTLAWED AND

    PUNISHABLE BY DEATH

    BLASPHEMYOR CRITICISM OF RELIGION IS

    OUTLAWED AND PUNISHABLE BY DEATH

    THE NONRELIGIOUS ARE BARRED FROMGOVERNMENT OFFICE

    IT IS ILLEGAL OR UNRECOGNISED TO IDENTIFYAS AN ATHEIST OR AS NONRELIGIOUS EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANIST PRINCIPLES

    ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND HUMAN

    RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    PROHIBITIVE INTERRELIGIOUS SOCIALCONTROL

    RELIGIOUS CONTROL OVER FAMILY LAW ORLEGISLATION ON MORAL MATTERS

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTS INSIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    APOSTASYIS OUTLAWED AND PUNISHABLEWITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    BLASPHEMYIS OUTLAWED OR CRITICISM OFRELIGION IS RESTRICTED AND PUNISHABLE

    WITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    IT IS MADE DIFFICULT TO REGISTER OROPERATE AN EXPLICITLY HUMANIST,ATHEIST,

    SECULARIST OR OTHER NONRELIGIOUS NGO

    OR OTHER HUMAN RIGHTS ORGANIZATION

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY INAT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    40/244

    40

    a Saa c a a c Ia

    b.

    T a c 1963 a a c. I b

    c Ia, b I,

    .

    T M. T S

    , ,

    M.T P M.

    T a a c a Pa a c a c

    a, aaa, a .

    T a a c cb Fa Rbc Saa a a M c.

    T S I. T

    P I .

    T ( ), I ,

    1963 . L bca ac c a

    a a c , c.

    W a a a

    T c Pa, Saa a Saa ca c a

    , b a c acc. S

    , .

    Ac c 2011, S Sa

    a a a. T aa

    c a a a c c

    . T aa c

    a, A a b a a, a

    b a b

    .

    H,

    . I

    ,

    .

    T aa c a c a a a a

    a c. I ; , , a

    a bca; cca a a c

    PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT OF RELIGION LEGAL OR CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS

    EXCLUDE NONRELIGIOUS VIEWS FROM

    FREEDOM OF BELIEF

    SOME CONCERNS ABOUT POLITICAL ORMEDIA FREEDOMS,NOT SPECIFIC TO THE

    NONRELIGIOUS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    41/244

    41

    a a b a aa a aa ; a ac

    b ac ab .

    T aa c c a a ac a a

    c a a b a . T

    .

    T a b ca aa bc a, ca, a

    c a, , c, b, a c.

    W a a a

    W aa c c , acc a b

    .G c a

    a c c cca , a a aa a

    a.

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    , ab a aca.

    H,

    , .

    T a , a ca c a c acc.

    T cc b

    Ca a a M . T a

    b ca ca a ba

    .

    T , .

    T (

    C I) .

    T a a a b Ha c a ( Iaa

    Ha a Eca U a a a c).

    I c a c M Ec a b cc a a

    a AHa B, c a aa "a"

    ca a (a aa a). I MP

    ( C) MP

    , .

    W a a a

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY INAT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

    OFFICIAL SYMBOLIC DEFERENCE TO RELIGION

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    42/244

    42

    T c c, b ,

    . F

    .

    T c c ,

    ccc a , a a

    , ab a aca. H,

    ,

    ,

    .

    G c b ca aa ba aa, b,

    acc. Zaba a a aca

    Taaa. W Zaba a ,

    c, c , a a, a bc Taaa c a

    . T Zaba c a ca .

    O aa, ca a Ca a M b ca a c ca c

    aa ca. I , , , ,

    C M I . T

    I M , , I .

    Sa c a ac , b a a aa cc. Sc aa

    a a ac aca a c ca, a a ccaa ba b

    a .

    T a a c a ac. P

    . S

    .Aca ca ca a c aa a a cc c a b b.

    W a a a

    A c c, cca aa

    . C

    ,

    . M . T

    .

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    SOME RELIGIOUS COURTS RULE IN CIVIL ORFAMILY MATTERS ON A SOCIALLY COERCIVE

    OR DISCRIMINATORYBASIS

    STATEFUNDED SCHOOLS OFFER RELIGIOUSINSTRUCTION WITHOUT SECULAR

    ALTERNATIVES BUT IT IS OPTIONAL

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    43/244

    43

    T c aa ab a aca. H, a

    aa c. Oa ca a ba aac

    c, a .

    T c a a a c c

    b, a

    a ab. H,

    ,

    .

    Sc 2011 a a a

    a. N, C

    , a

    c c a c.

    T C

    . T

    C P

    .

    T C , a ccc . T c

    a a c; ca b; a

    a a aa b , ac, acc, a bac. O a

    a a.

    T a a c a cca 2013, a b Dcb a b

    a, a a. I c c,

    G A;

    R C N,

    .

    H, "C" ;

    , , , ,

    " () C ....

    I a ccab, b a b , ac Ca, a

    b aCa ac b ca a ba a cc Ca

    ac a acc.

    W a a a

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE LEGAL OR CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS

    EXCLUDE NONRELIGIOUS VIEWS UNDER

    FREEDOM OF BELIEF

    DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TORELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

    CRITICISM OF RELIGION IS RESTRICTED INLAW OR A DE FACTO BLASPHEMYLAW IS IN

    EFFECT

    RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY INAT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    44/244

    44

    T a c aa a

    a, a a a a a. I a

    aca a ac ab a a aa.

    A c 2013, Zbab a

    c b, a

    ab, P

    R M

    ,

    .

    T c a a a c

    c . T a c c a c

    a ca a a a bc a a aa

    , ac, acc, a bac.

    M ' .

    T . M

    C ,

    a c , a ac. R

    ca a a ca c.

    S C . T

    a ca a c b a

    aa a ac.

    W a a a

    T c B R a aa a a

    . H, 2002 P O S A (POSA)

    , , .

    I ,

    .

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    CONCERNS THAT SECULAR OR RELIGIOUSAUTHORITIES INTERFERE IN SPECIFICALLY

    RELIGIOUS FREEDOMS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    45/244

    45

    M A

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    a . T c

    a ccc, , a

    , a b a cc

    bc.

    T

    , . T a

    c a c ,

    c a a a ca ac

    ab b c a a.

    R aa a a a c a cc

    c a ac . I a Cac c 83 ""

    C. T M a 90,000 a b

    100,000 b 12 18 c a a a. T a ca

    a 2013

    .

    D a a A 2011 a c ca a MPLA

    a a , , C C

    C MPLA.

    W a a a

    T c aa , , a ac

    ab. H, c c a a 2010, A

    . P

    .Sa a a a b ba a a a ca a a.

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONSOR SALARIES,OR DISCRIMINATORY TAX

    EXEMPTIONS

    CONCERNS THAT SECULAR OR RELIGIOUSAUTHORITIES INTERFERE IN SPECIFICALLY

    RELIGIOUS FREEDOMS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    46/244

    46

    T c aa a ca a, a

    c a a a c c

    b. H,

    , C I,

    .

    T a aa b a a

    a a ca ca ,

    c a b a.

    S

    C I

    , a a c

    aa a a aa .

    W a a

    a

    T c aa c, b

    . T ab a

    aca a aa bc ca aa bc ;

    .

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    , aca

    a ab. H, Mac 2013 b

    P Fac B, a a

    c cc Ca Aca Rbc. Sc

    ,

    . W a c ba

    ,

    M C

    . A 2013

    aac, Aca U a a a

    ac c CAR

    c a ac.

    P c ba 2013, ca

    c b a a

    a c acc. T c

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTSIN SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANIST PRINCIPLESON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND HUMAN

    RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS

    OR SALARIES,OR DISCRIMINATORY TAX

    EXEMPTIONS RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY IN

    AT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUTSECULAR ALTERNATIVES

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTSIN SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TORELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

    RELIGIOUS GROUPS CONTROL OR HAVEHIGHLY PRIVILEGED ACCESS TO SOME PUBLIC

    OR SOCIAL SERVICES

    CRITICISM OF RELIGION IS RESTRICTED IN LAWOR A DE FACTOBLASPHEMYLAW IS IN

    EFFECT

    NOTE:GIVEN THE WIDESPREAD SECTARIAN

    CONFLICT IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT THE

    SECURITY OF EVERYONE IN CARIS

    CURRENTLY SEVERELY THREATENED.THIS

    RATING REFLECTS THE TECHNICAL STATE OF

    TH LAW.

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    47/244

    47

    b ac, a b c, b a

    .

    T P B a c , c

    . H,

    . T a a baca a, b a aa a a a a. T a c

    acc I.

    T

    .O a , a

    baca , a aa.

    T c a a a c c , ccc a .

    A

    ,

    I.

    A c c b H

    Cc Iac Aa (HCIA) a Dca

    R a Taa Aa M

    I (MOI) a Mcca Ha(a 12 Iac

    caa) a Ua (a).

    T D R T A

    .T HCIA Iac

    ac, c

    Aabcaa c a

    a, a a c aa Iac . T HCIA,

    , , M,

    ' . I , , I

    , , I

    .

    R ' . A a

    c R Maa C, b a Ca

    . T M C .

    W a ba a a a a,

    M M ,

    .

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTSIN SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANIST PRINCIPLESON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND HUMAN

    RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TORELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

    STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONSOR SALARIES,OR DISCRIMINATORY TAXEXEMPTIONS

    RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY INAT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

    RELIGIOUS GROUPS CONTROL OR HAVEHIGHLY PRIVILEGED ACCESS TO SOME PUBLIC

    OR SOCIAL SERVICES

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    48/244

    48

    W a a a

    T c a . H, b a

    . B .T

    c acc I.

    T c a a a c c

    b. T c

    cca b ca ba .

    W a a

    a

    W c c

    a , c . T

    ,

    .T a c acc,

    a aca cc a a

    c.

    F

    .

    T c a a a c c

    b a, acc,

    a c .

    H, C ( )

    , E

    .

    W a a a

    F a a aa b c. B

    C. I

    , , . T

    a a E

    C. T c cca c acc

    , b a acc.

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SOMEWHAT RESTRICTED

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    49/244

    49

    T c a a a c c

    , a a a c

    acc. T c a aa

    a , a a aca a ab;

    .

    A 1991 a ab a

    c a

    . A 1992 a c

    aa a, c

    R C C R C

    E G.

    T 1992 c a a . R b a

    aca M Jc, R Aa, a Pa I. T

    c a cac c a a c. T Cac a

    R cc a . U . R

    .

    T a a a ac a a b c

    a a. R a bc c a ca b ac b a c ca

    cc ca.

    G C R .Cac a a a a a a a ca c, c a Ocb 12 Naa

    Da a P Ba J 5.

    W a a a

    T P T O N M

    . A c aa a ,

    c a c a a 1992 a a

    c a a a. F ab a aca a

    c. Pca a a a ac ca aa.

    T c a a a c c

    , ccc a , a a

    , ab a aca.

    H, acc

    .

    W a a

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS ARE SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTSIN SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TORELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

    OFFICIAL SYMBOLIC DEFERENCE TO RELIGION

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    50/244

    50

    a

    P aa b a b c acc. S

    , . T

    , .

    T N C C

    .I Jaa 2012, baca TV+ a

    baca a aa a b ca Mba Oba. TV+ , c c

    aca Mba Oba, a a b a b a ac aba. A

    2012, a Ec D N a , a,

    Eb a La U, ac cc .

    J

    ,

    G.

    T c a a a c c

    b, ,

    a ab a aca. T

    a a c acc.

    A 8 S T

    P

    . A 14 A

    ,

    , , ,

    .

    Ac 26 c b a,

    a, "F ccc, a ab. N a b c,

    cc ba bca cc acc

    . N a b b a a ab cc acc

    c cc aca aa a ab b c

    a. R c a , ca a aa.

    W a a a

    T c aa a ab a

    aca, accac aa a .

    T a ca c acc.

    FREEDOM OF RELIGION OR BELIEF IS UPHELDAND THERE ARE NO KNOWN CASES OF

    DISCRIMINATION AGAINST NONRELIGIOUS

    INDIVIDUALS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    51/244

    51

    N A

    T c , b

    , ,

    . T a

    b a a c ab

    aa b. H,

    .

    A I

    I "".

    T

    , ,

    P M. A

    M R A

    .

    Oac 0603 b ca ba

    a aa a c M a a a c

    . H,

    M

    . NM a bc c

    a .

    T , S (I ),

    , . T a a ca

    c: T a c b M a M a c Ia (a a c c). T c

    b M a M , b b

    a a a a c .

    F 2005 a c, c a a aa

    a a aa c a a Aa aa

    c. U , M M

    .NM M

    .

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    THE NONRELIGIOUS ARE BARRED FROMSOME GOVERNMENT OFFICES

    PROHIBITIVE INTERRELIGIOUS SOCIALCONTROL

    RELIGIOUS CONTROL OVER FAMILY LAW ORLEGISLATION ON MORAL MATTERS

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE RESULTSIN SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL DISCRIMINATION

    STATE LEGISLATION IS PARTLY DERIVEDFROM RELIGIOUS LAW OR BY RELIGIOUS

    AUTHORITIES

    BLASPHEMYIS OUTLAWED OR CRITICISMOF RELIGION IS RESTRICTED AND

    PUNISHABLE WITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONSOR SALARIES,OR DISCRIMINATORY TAX

    EXEMPTIONS

    STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY IN

    AT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    52/244

    52

    T MRA . I

    .M c, c a a, ca a ac

    aac . T M ;

    , M . M

    , .

    C . H, 0603,

    M

    (US$12,845) , ,

    M ;

    , , , , , .Ma, ,

    b c, aa aa, a

    a a M a a b a. T aa c

    c.

    T M N E R A , ,

    I .T M Naa Eca a a c

    b cca aa aa, aca a ac Ia a

    Aabc a a aa c, b c.

    W a a a

    T , ,

    A 1990.

    A D 2011

    , c c c cc

    . B ca a a ca

    a. Ja a a ac a a ca

    b; a a b a aa b c c.

    A J 2009

    . T I ac. I Fba 2011, a

    aa , ac A a c Aaba acc

    a ca ac. I Ma 2012, a b

    ca Aa bc aaa c a

    a a a a c.

    T

    2012, F 2011. I

    M 2012 . A

    , .

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    53/244

    53

    E a a a , a abac

    ca acac

    M Bbac P

    M 2013. T M B,

    S 2013.

    L

    ,

    , ,

    .

    T Mbaaa c cca a

    a, a a a a c

    c b. H, Ac

    98() c a c, a a b a

    147/2006, a a

    , , ,

    , ,

    ,

    , /

    . T .

    T 2012 C

    C. T ca c M , b a a b

    M a YTb Icc M (c b Cc a

    E). Ba ca 2013, b M a

    .

    T ca a a ca, ab a , c ca cc.

    Ea a a c M B a a

    a a a, cca a S M a. A D 2013

    ( MB)

    I I , , AA I

    , I S .

    :

    O Fba 22, 2007 A Ea c c a b, A K S,

    a' Ia a . Sa' a a a a b

    a b c E. H a b cc c' Iac

    , aAa a P H Mbaa, ca a ca.

    THERE IS A PATTERN OF IMPUNITY ORCOLLUSION IN VIOLENCE BY NONSTATE

    ACTORS AGAINST THE NONRELIGIOUS

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANIST PRINCIPLESON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND HUMAN

    RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    STATE LEGISLATION IS PARTLY DERIVED FROMRELIGIOUS LAW OR BY RELIGIOUS

    AUTHORITIES

    BLASPHEMYIS OUTLAWED OR CRITICISM OFRELIGION IS RESTRICTED AND PUNISHABLE

    WITH A PRISON SENTENCE

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TO

    RELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    54/244

    54

    O Oc. 27, 2007, b K A a c Facb

    Ia, a b a H Mbaa. H a a N. 17, 2010,

    c a a b c c a a .

    O Oc. 12, 2011, a c a A Y M, 24, a a c aab bca a a Iac cc

    Facb. T c a aaab a ac Ma Facb a

    c.

    I Fba 2012, a Ca c ca a M Da c a

    P Ma. A b 2,500 M a

    c a a Dab b c a. Dab a aa cc

    M ca, a a a a.

    O 4 A 2012, A Ea c c 17a Ca b, G A M,

    a a b ca Facb a a c Ia a

    P Maa. Ma a a acc b ca

    c a a c A, a a Ca a. T

    c' c A c Gaa Ab Ma a "a

    Ia a b a b c a Ia a P".. T ca,

    b b Ma Dcb, a aa M aac Ca,

    a Ca b a a c.

    Sb 2012 a E YT I M,

    c M aa P Maa. A a , Nb

    a Ea c cc, aba, C C, a

    c , " Iac aca c a

    a a Ia a ." A a , c cc a

    Aca Ca a, T J, b Qa YTb. A

    c a, b a a aba c a a c a

    E.

    O Sb 14, 2012, Icc M, A S a

    a a a b a a a .

    Sab a a ac ca cac E. Ra a

    Cc Ca , Sab a a a Ea A

    a Facb a a b a ca cc aa Ia. Sab a

    ba a a a ac ca Sab c. O Dcb 12,

    2012, Sab a c a . U b a ba, Sab a ab

    ca E, a aba .

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    55/244

    55

    I a J 2012 a Cc Ca ac, B K, 32, a a

    a Sa a acca a a Ia

    Facb a. Pc b aAa a a a Ka c b ca

    ba a ac a cc. T a a

    ca c P Ma a E P Ma

    M. Ma Saa, ca aa Ka, a a a

    ac a a b a. Ka a aa

    Facb a a b ca, ca acc a b

    ac. I Sb 2012 Ka a c a ba.

    T

    ,

    , .

    A , a c a a

    b a b 2013, b c a

    b b a . L

    L

    I

    .

    F Qaa , a

    c a, a ca caa a

    a a c a a

    c a a a b .

    T I

    I

    , M

    . Ac 6

    c a a b

    ca a Lba ba

    c a a, ca, a c .

    T a a a c ca ,

    c, a b. T a a b c Ia

    a ; , M.

    R I

    , . T

    a aa c bc c, b

    a c a a c aa c.

    S (I ) M, , ,

    .U b a, a M a a a M a

    STATE LEGISLATION IS LARGELY OR ENTIRELYDERIVED FROM RELIGIOUS LAW OR BY

    RELIGIOUS AUTHORITIES

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANIST PRINCIPLESON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND HUMAN

    RIGHTS IS SEVERELY RESTRICTED

    PROHIBITIVE INTERRELIGIOUS SOCIALCONTROL

    RELIGIOUS CONTROL OVER FAMILY LAW ORLEGISLATION ON MORAL MATTERS

    THERE IS AN ESTABLISHED CHURCH OR STATERELIGION

    SYSTEMATIC RELIGIOUS PRIVILEGE DISCRIMINATORY PROMINENCE GIVEN TO

    RELIGIOUS BODIES,TRADITIONS OR LEADERS

    STATEFUNDING OF RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS RELIGIOUS INSTRUCTION IS MANDATORY IN

    AT LEAST SOME PUBLIC SCHOOLS WITHOUT

    SECULAR ALTERNATIVES

    CRITICISM OF RELIGION IS RESTRICTED IN LAWOR A DE FACTO BLASPHEMYLAW IS IN

    EFFECT

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    56/244

    56

    c Ia, a a ; , M

    I M . C b a a 40 a Ha. T

    M Aa a Iac Aa a M a a , a a

    aa a a. T a b c a a c

    M.

    W a a a

    T , ,

    Q. I J 2012, Lba S C c a a a a c a

    c c a .

    H,

    . O

    .

    W ab a a ca c Qaa, c c, a

    a a a, ac ab a bc

    .

  • 8/22/2019 IHEU Freedom of Thought Report 2013

    57/244

    57

    ( )T c a a aa

    b. H,

    ,

    .

    T c a a a I

    , a a K a

    Ca Fa a D

    C a Fa c.

    A ,

    ,

    I.

    Aa a c c ca a, c ba

    a ( b) aa b . I A

    2013 S Ua Cc Mcc,

    a a b , a

    aa a a a aa.

    T a S M Ma c

    , b

    S M M S

    . Va c a c ca c c.

    Acc Ac 220 Pa C, a

    a c

    b aac a

    c a a a b b 3 6

    ' a a 115 575

    a (US$16 $79). H, 220

    "

    M ", (

    H C ).

    T J

    c c a aa, ac, a a a. Rabbca a,

    a a c ca, a J a c.

    T I M S J.

    J S (I )

    . H, Ca

    EXPRESSION OF CORE HUMANISTPRINCIPLES ON DEMOCRACY,FREEDOM AND

    HUMAN RIGHTS IS BRUTALLY SUPPRESSED

    THERE IS A PATTERN OF IMPUNITY ORCOLLUSION IN VIOLENCE BY NONSTATE

    ACTORS AGAINST THE NONRELIGIOUS

    GOVERNMENT FIGURES OR STATE AGENCIESOPENLY MARGINALIE,HARASS,OR INCITE

    HATRED OR VIOLENCE AGAINST THE NON

    RELIGIOUS

    IT IS ILLEGAL TO REGISTER AN EX