idIIIM - Microsoft...Korolkovas Essentials of Molecular Pharmacology Background for Drug Design...
Transcript of idIIIM - Microsoft...Korolkovas Essentials of Molecular Pharmacology Background for Drug Design...
BIOMEDICAL LIBRARY
_idIIIM 80
LO
MYLAN - EXHIBIT 1025
____ Chemical Society Reviews
Vol No 1979
PageTILDEN LECTURE
Concerning Stereochemjcal Choice in Enzymic Reactions
By Overton 447
The Acidity of Solid Surfaces and its Determination
by Amine Titration and Adsorption of Coloured
Indicators
By Atkinson and Curthoys 475
Non-isoprenoid Long Chain Phenols
By Tyman 499
Some New N.M.R Methods for Tracing the Fate of
Hydrogen in Biosynthesis
By Garson and Staunton 539
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
By Thornber563
1979 Indexes581
The Chemical Society London
Chemical Society Reviews
Chemical Society Reviews appears quarterly and comprises approximately 25articles ca 500 pp per annum It is intended that each review article shall be ofinterest to chemists in general and not merely to those with specialist interest
in the subject under review The articles range over the whole of chemistry andits interfaces with other disciplines
Although the majority of articles are intended to be specially commissionedthe Society is always prepared to consider offers of articles for publication Insuch cases short synopsis rather than the completed article should be submitted to The Managing Editor Books and Reviews Section The Chemical
Society Burlington House Piccadilly London W1V OBNMembers of the Chemical Society may subscribe to Chemical Society Reviews
at 6.00 per annum beginning 1980 7.50 per annum they should place their
orders on their Annual Subscription renewal forms in the usual wayNon-members may order Chemical Society Reviews for 16.00 $33 be
ginning 1980 22.00 $50 per annum remittance with order fromThe Publications Sales Officer The Chemical Society Blackhorse Road
Letchworth Herts SG6 1HN England
Note to subscribers We regret the delays in publication of the 1979 issues
CS Reviews The main causes were the long-term effects of shortages in submitted articles and production difficulties during earlier years Steps have beentaken to rectify this distressing situation and the intention is to revert to the
usual quarterly publication dates by the end of 1980 or the beginning of 1981
Copyright reserved by The Chemical Society 1980
ISSN 03060012
Published by The Chemical Society Burlington House London WIV OBNPrinted in England by Eyre Spottiswoode Ltd Thanet Press Margate
Isosterism and Molecular Modffication in Drug Design
By Thornber
IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES LIMITED PHARMACEUTICALS
DIVISION MERESIDE ALDERLEY PARK MACCLESFIELDCHESHIRE SK1O 4TG
Introduction
The idea of isosterism goes back to Langmuir1 in 1919 At that time the word
isosterism was used to describe the similarity of molecules or ions which have the
same number of atoms and valence electrons e.g 02 Ne Cleariy only
those isosteres with the same nett charge show similar chemical and physical
properties Grimm2 enunciated his hydride displacement law to describe the
similarity between groups which have the same number of valence electrons but
different numbers of atoms For example some similarities are present in the
sequence CH3 NH2 OH Hal
Grimms hydride displacement law points out some similarities of size in
groupings based on elements in the same row of the periodic table Other similar
ities to be found in the periodic table are within the groups where chemical
reactivities are similar but with electronegativity decreasing as atomic weight
increases and lipophilicity and polarizability increasing with the size of the
atom Other relationships exist in diagonal lines across the periodic table where
atoms of similar electronegativity such as nitrogen and sulphur oxygen and
chlorine are found
In trying to relate biological properties to the physical and chemical properties
of atoms groups or molecules many physical and chemical parameters may be
involved and the simple relationships mentioned above are clearly inadequate
for this purpose Friedman3 introduced the term bioisosterism to describe the
phenomenon in which compounds which are related in structure have similaror
antagonistic properties The use of the word isosterism has clearly outgrown its
original meaning when used in medicinal chemistry and loose flexible definition
could be adopted such as Bioisosteres are groups or molecules which have
chemical and physical similarities producing broadly similar biological properties
The term non-classical isosterism is also used interchangeably with bioisoster
ism particularly in connection with isosteres which do not have the same numberof atoms but do produce similarity in some key parameter of importance in
Langmuir Amer Chem Soc 1919 41 868 1543Grimm Elektrochem 1925 31 474 1928 34 430 1934 47 53 594Friedman Influence of Isosteric Replacements upon Biological Activity National
Academy of SciencesNational Research Council Publication No 206 WashingtonD.C 1951 295
563
isosterism and Molecular Modfication in Drug Design
that series For example4 the two /3-adrenergic stimulants compounds andhave similar activity
CHOHCH2NHMe Cl-IOHCH2NHMe
HO3MeSO2N
pKa 9.6pKa 9.1
The concept of bioisosterism has been described in reviews by Burgersa
Schatz5b Foye6 Korolkovas7 Ariens8 and Hansch.9 This present review
collates and extends the earlier observations with more recent reports from the
literature and suggests new techniques for exploiting the conceptThe classical isosteres as defined by Burger5 and Korolkovas7 are given in
Table
Table
Univalent atoms and groups
OH NH2 Me Cl
SH PH2But
Br Pr1
Bivalent atoms and groups
Se CH2CO2R COSR COCH2R CONHR
Tervalent atoms and groups CHAsQuadrivalent atoms
C- -Si
Ring equivalentsCHCH e.g benzene thiophen
N.- e.g benzene pyridine
S---- CH2 NHLarson and Lish Nature 1964 203 1283
Burger in Medicinal Chemistry 3rd Edn ed Burger Wiley-Interscience New York1970
5b Schatz in Medicinal Chemistry 2nd Edn ed Burger Wiley-Interscience NewYork 1960
Foye Principles of Medicinal Chemistry Lea and Febiger Philadelphia 1970Korolkovas Essentials of Molecular Pharmacology Background for Drug Design
Wiley 1970Ariens in Drug Design ed Ariens Academic Press New York 1971 Vol
Hanscb Jntra-Sclcnce Chem Rep 1974 17
564
Thornber
Bioisosterism in Molecular Modification
In the process of developing lead compound an antagonist to knownagonist or an anti-metabolite from known substrate large number of
systematic molecular modifications will be made The modern concept of
bioisosterism can be an aid to the design of such modifications In makingbioisosteric replacement the following parameters of the group being changedcould be considered
Size
Shape bond angles hybridization
Electronic distribution polarizability inductive effects charge dipoles
Lipid solubility
Water solubility
pKa
Chemical reactivity including likeithood of metabolism
Hydrogen bonding capacity
It is unlikely that any bioisosteric replacement will leave all these parametersundisturbed The extent to which the replacement is useful will depend uponwhich of these parameters is important and which ones the bioisostere can best
mimic
The element of molecule being modffied may have one or more of the follow
ing roles
Structural If the moiety has structural role in holding other function
alities in particular geometry parameters such as size and bond angle will be
important The moiety may be buried deep in the molecule and have little
contact with the external medium
ii Receptor interactions If the moiety to be replaced is concerned with
specific interaction with receptor or enzyme its size shape electronic
properties pICa chemical reactivity and hydrogen bonding will be the
important parameters
iii Pharmacokinetics The moiety to be replaced may be necessary for the
absorption transport and excretion of the compound In this case lipophili
city hydrophilicity hydrogen bonding and pKa are likely to be important
iv Metabolism The moiety may be involved in blocking or aiding metabolism In this case chemical reactivity will be an important parameter Forexample chloro and methyl substituents on benzene ring may be inter
changeable for certain purposes but the toluene derivative can be metabolized
to benzoic acid and may therefore have shorter half-life or unexpectedside effects
Usually one will not know which roles the various parts of the molecule
plays in its action and this determination will be part of the structureactivity
study However from the simple considerations listed above it is clear that
565
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
given molecular modification may allow some but probably not all of
the parameters ah to be kept the same
Whether the same or different biological activity results from the replace
ment will be governed by the roles which that moiety fulfils in the molecule
and whether parameters affecting that role have been disturbed
From and it follows that what proves to be good bioisosteric
replacement in one series of compounds will not necessarily be useful in
another
Completely identical properties are rarely sought and will in any case be
difficult if not impossible to achieve What we are more likely to be seeking is
subtle change in the molecule which will leave some properties the same and
some different in order to improve potency selectivity absorption duration and
toxicity Bioisosteric replacements allow molecular modifications in which the
number of variables changed are limited Ariens8 and Korolkovas7 have tried to
introduce the idea of partial bioisosteric groups as those which turn an agonist
into an antagonist Although their lists of groups may be suggestive to the drug
designer the idea is probably incorrect because of the statement above Anantagonist group in one molecule will only antagonize similaragonist group
in another molecule if the agonist groups in both series are performing the samefunction If an isosteric replacement results in molecule which has some
properties similar to the parent molecule but some important property has
changed it may be possible to compensate for this undesirable change by modifi
cations elsewhere in the molecule For example molecular modification mayreduce the lipid solubility of the molecule thereby affecting its absorption
transport and apparent potency Optimum activity may be regained by inserting
lipophilic groups into the molecule at some sterically undemanding site Consequently the best compounds in this parallel series of isosteres such as for
example furans and thiophens are likely to have different substituent patterns
The Mathematical Formulation
The arguments used above can be expressed in the mathematical form used byHansch for the case where simple substituent is being varied for example onbenzene ring If the potency of drug is function of several parameters of the
substituent then
log A7r Bor CE8
where Hanschs ir value is used for the lipophilic character Hammetts value
for the electronic property Tafts steric parameter to denote the size of the
group and is the concentration of drug required to achieve given effect
If such relationship were found for drug series in which the constants
and were zero then the potency would be function of IT only In this context
groups would be bioisosteric if they have similar IT values independent of their
10 Hansch Accounts Chem Res 1969 232
566
Thornber
and values If however the three constants and are all significantmuch more limited range of equivalent groups will be available
If series of compounds has more than one property as is usual then morethan one equation will be needed to describe the effects of changing the substituent
log Air Bar CE8
Desired activity
log Dir Ea FESide effects
Clearly if and etc no selectivity can be found withinthis limited series If however then for the desired activity E8 is not important and ir and may be optimized while reducing the value of therebyreducing the side effects This phenomenon of increasing selectivity by bioisosteric replacement relies upon the fact that some desirable properties in the
molecule can be retained when unimportant parameters can be varied An unimportant parameter for the biological activity desired may be key parameter in
the side effect
Thus bioisosteric replacements are useful in searching for potency selectivity
absorption and duration Following the Hansch treatment one could producemodem definition of bioisosterism based upon measurable parameters such as
ir E8 hydrogen bonding properties pK etc and Hansch9 has used the term
isolipophilic for groups with the same value
Table shows some functional groups with similar electron-withdrawingproperties If electronic effects alone influence the biological activity in series ofdrugs then these groups would be equivalent If however the lipophilicity andsteric factors are important then absolute identity cannot be achieved
Table
Functional Group IT Es
0.34 0.14 0.78
Cl 0.37 0.71 9.27
Br 0.39 0.86 0.08
0.35 1.12 0.16CF3 0.43 0.88 1.16SCF 0.40 1.44
COMe 0.31 0.55CHO 0.36 0.65CO2Me 0.32 0.01CHCHN02 0.32 0.11
567
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
Extensive tables of IT and E5 values are now available These can be usedto gain more quantitative idea of some aspects of isosterism using the better
known functional groups
Chemical Reactivity
Biological effects are generally produced by weak interactions between the drugand the receptor but covalent bonding does occasionally play part series of
aspirin isosteres was reported in 1975.12 The nitrogen sulphur and carbon
MeCOX
3x NHor Cl-i2
isosteres were all totally inactive despite the classical purity of the replacementstried Now that it is known that aspirin is an acetylating agent for prostaglandinsynthetase this result is more readily understood.3 The agents are widely differ
ent in their ability to act as acylating agents unless other substantial modifications are made in the molecules
Non-classical Isosteres Some Further Points
In considering bioisosterism in its widest sense it should be noted that similar
effects in two functional groups need not imply atom upon atom overlapEdwards4 has pointed out that common enzyme or receptor interaction involves hydrogen bonding to carbonyl group Strong hydrogen bonds may beformed to the carbonyl oxygen by hydrogen atoms within cone having an angleof about 60 at its apex Two molecules RXH and RAXH where is an additional atom may be able to bind to the active site without identical positioningof the or In addition the conformational mobility in both the drug and the
receptor molecule will allow essentially similarbinding of two drugs without the
need to consider that the binding groups on the drugs are positioned in spacein an identical manner
Examples of Non-classical Isosteres.The list shown in Table is drawn fromearlier reviews59 and from the examples given in Table at the end of this
1Tables of substituent constants can be found in the following papers HanschRockwell Jow Leo and Steller Med Chem 1977 20 304Topliss Med Chem 1972 15 1006 and 1977 20463 Hansch Leo UngerKi Hwan Kim Nikaitoni and Lien Med Chem 1973 16 1207
12 Thompkins and Lee Pharm Sd 1975 64 760Roth Stanford and Majerus Proc Nat Acad Sd U.S.A 1975 72 3073Edwards IC. Pharmaceuticals Division personal communication
568
Thornber
review In addition few proposals5-7 which have not yet been realized in
medicinal chemical work are included
Table
arbonyl group
-SO2L
ref 15
Carboxylie acid group
CO2H SO2NHR SO3H POOHNH2 POOHOEt
CON HCN HO....15
ref 16
Ilydroxy-group
OH NHCOR NHSO2R CH0H NHCONH2
NHCN C-1CN2
ref 16 ref 16
Catechol
N20 HOO HOXXNR
Halogen
Halogen CF3 CN NCN CCN3 ref 16 17
Wallenfels Friedrich Rieser Ertel and Thieme Angew Chem Internat
Edn 1976 15 261
von Kohier Eichler and Salewski anorg Chem 1970 379 183 also includes
other possibilities in the sulphur and phosphorus and nitro acid series
von Wallenfels Chimia 1966 20 303
569
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
Table continued
Thioet herCN CN CN\/
/N\ /S\ /C\ref 16
Thiourea
NCN CHNO2Ii
IIIINHCNH2 NHCNH2 NHCNH2
CNAzomethine
ref 17
Pyridine
NO9
RNR3Spacer groups
CH3
In addition ring-opened forms of molecules may be considered to be isostericwith the corresponding ring-closed forms although the conformation of theseco form will be unlike the parent molecule However if in ring opening anatom is removed conformation similar to the parent molecule may be possible
Subsfructure Searching and Bioisosterism
Although the classical Hansch approach is used largely for optimization within
series molecular modifications based on bioisosterism principles can generatenew series or even develop new leads if an agonist is used as the starting point forthe design of an antagonist One aid to this process is the use of compoundcollection and computer techniques for doing substructure searches e.g the
570
Thornber
Crossbow suite of programmes.8 For example suppose that random screening
has turned up the lead One may consider bioisosteric replacements for
the ring the oxygen the polymethylene chain or the amidic moiety and design
substructure search for compounds of type vast number of permutations
are possible and from these compounds may be available for tests which result
in new leads which have properties worth exploiting such as perhaps
01OC1LNHCOMe
CHCH CHN or NR
SO SO2 Se NCN or NCOR
NHCONHMe n23or4or alkylincluding forming ring
Me COR CO2R SOR SO2R or CONHR
AB defined substituents
Examples.The literature of medicinal chemistry is rich in examples of the use
of the concept of bioisosterism and the reader is referred to the reviews mentioned5-8 and the references quoted therein for examples reported before 1970There follows brief discussion of bioisosteres of some indoleamines which has
some useful lessons and Table lists examples culled from the literature since
1970 Only the structures are given in this Table as an illustration of the kinds
of change which have been useful The reader is referred to the original papersfor the full details of biological activity and selectivity The list is not comprehensive but represents some uses of more novel non-classical types Rudinger9has reviewed isosteric replacements in the field of peptide chemistry up to 1971
and some further discussions2 have been published recently
Indole-amines..-Campaigne2 has studied and reviewed the work on bioisosteres
of 5-hydroxytryptamine and one or two details of the work are instructive
Whereas was inactive as an agonist or antagonist on the rat uterus preparation
the corresponding tryptophan analogue had weak activity as an enzymeinhibitor for 5-hydroxytryptamine decarboxylase.22 This type of bioisostere
Townsley and Warr Chemical and Biological Data An Integrated On-Line
Approach in Retrieval of Medicinal Chemical Information ed Howe Mime and Pennell
Symposium Series No 84 American Chemical Society Washington D.C1J Rudinger in ref Vol II Chapter20 Further discussion of peptide backbone replacement is found in ref 19 and Soudyn and
van Wijngaarden in Biological Activity and Chemical Structure ed KeverlingBuisman Elsevier Holland 1977 peptide link isostere CH2S has been reportedby Yankeelov Kam-Fook Fok and Carothers Org Chem 1978 43 1623
Campaigne Maichel and Bosin Medicinal Chemistry Specialist Contributions 3rd International Symposium 1972 Butterworths 1973 65
Pigini Gianella Gualtieri Meichiorne Bolle and Angelucci EuropeanMed Chem 1975 10 29 33
571
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
5-hydroxytryptamine
10 C021-1 5-hydroxytryptophan CO2H
loses all affinity for the 5-hydroxytryptamine 5-HT receptor but retains it in
part for an enzyme system Similarly in the series of compounds 5-HT 11 12and 13 activity has been measured against the rat fundic strip preparation andon the enzyme caeruloplasmin.23 Whereas 5-HT is substrate for the enzymecompound 11 inhibited caeruloplasmins oxidation of 5-HT and noradrenaline
Rat Fwzdic Strzp
Intrinsic PD2
activity
5HT0.96
ti. jj 12 0.84 4.6
Compound 12 inhibits only 5-HT oxidation and compound 13 was inactive as
substrate or an antagonist This would appear to demonstrate that for the
enzyme system the imino grouping at the 1-position of the ring is essential
On the rat fundic strip however all the analogues have full agonist activity
though with reduced potency demonstrating that the 5-HT receptor has
greater tolerance for loss of the imino nitrogen These simple experiments demonstrate the role of bioisosteric replacements in exploring selectivity betweendifferent receptors and enzymes
Barrass Goult Pinder and Sheds Blochem Pharmacol 1973 222891
572
Thornber
Table Some recent examples of bioisosterism
Dihydroxyphenylalanine analogues
xxTo2H H.co2HDopa Mimosine ref 24
HO/Z2 HO12ref 25 ref 26 ref 27
Histamine H-2 antagonists
IjI
MeCH7SCH2CHNNHMC
HNNor NCN ref 28
NHMeMe2NCH2
NCN or CHNO2 ref 29
24 Haguchi Mo Pharmacol 1977 13 36225 natural product from Streptomyces species Inoue Shamura Tsurvoka
Ogawa Watanabe Yoshidea and Nuda Chem and Pharm Bull Japan 197523 2669
26Synthesized as mimosine analogue Harris and Teitei AustraL Chem1977 30 649
27 Norton and Sanders Med Chem 1967 10 96128 Brimblecombe Duncan Durant Emmett Gannelin and
Parsons mt Med Res 1975 86 See also Suiphurmethylene isosterism in the
development of metiamide Black Durant Emmett and GannelinNature 1974 248 65 and Gannellin App Chem Biotechnol 1978 28 183
26 and Hanbury U.S.P 128 658
573
isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
Table continued
Neuroleptics
CH 23X
II or CHCN ref 30
Anthelmintics
PhS PhS
NHCO2Me NHCO2Me
ref 31
PhyXSorSe ref 32
fl-A drenergic blockers
R_ç--
ref 33
Boehringer Sohn U.S.P 085 216Fisher and Lusi Med Chem 1972 15 982 Bochis Dybas EskolaKulsa Linn Lusi Mutzner Milkowski Mrozik Olen
Peterson Tolman Wagner Waksmunski Egerton and
Osteind Med Chem 1978 21 23532 Hanson Giese Davis and Costello Med Chem 1978 21
49633T Jen Frazee Schwartz Erhard Kaiser Colella and
Wardell Med Chem 1977 20 1263
574
Thornber
$-Adrenergic stimulants
01-i OH
1_.NHR Cl..LNHBut
H01 H2NCl
Me 01-1 Adrenaline Clenbuterol ref 37
But CH2OHSalbutamol ref 34
But NHCONH2Carbuterol ref 35
Pr NHSO2MeSoterenol ref 36
NJ..NHPr1 HOX NHPr
ref 38 ref 39
HZIIL_
OH
ref 39Hk.1ç
ref 40
Hartley Jack Lunts and Ritchie Nature 1968 219 861 CollinHartley Jack Lunts Press Ritchie and ToonJ Med Chem
1970 13 674
Kaiser Med Chem 1974 17 4936A Larsen Gould Roth Corner Uloth Dungan and
Lish Med Chem 1967 10 462Keck Kruger Noll and Machleidt Arzneimittelforsch 1972 22 861
38Arnett Wright and Zenker Med Chem 1978 21 72
30Williams Canad .1 Chem 1976 54 3377
Yoshizakj K. Tarimura Tamada Yabuuchi and Nakagawa Med Chem1976 19 1138
575
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
Table continued
Vasodilators
-LXRor SO2 ref 41XO YCO ref.42XS YCO.ref.43
MeO2CJJUL
Me Me
CO2Me ref 44
SO2Me ref 45
Androgens OAc
SorNCN ref.46
SmithKline Corp U.S.P 117 12842 Vaughan Williams and Polster European Pharmacol 1974 25 241 Unlisted
Drugs 1971 23 110Claeys Goldenberg Wandestrick Devay Descamps Delaunois
Bauthier and Charlier Chim Ther 1972 377Bossert and Vater Naturwiss 1971 58 578 Drugs of Today 1975 11 154
Ciba-Geigy B.P 464 324W.-H Chiu Klein and Wolff Med Chem 1979 22 119
576
Thornber
Anti-inflammatory
MeOS%CH2_X
Cl N-NCO2H or ref 49
N-Nref
CO2H ref 48
Ornithine decarboxylase inhibitor
H2NCH23CHNN
NH2
ref 50
Gabergic agents
HO2C.NH2 HO Ji OH
HOS NH2 11NH2 H2Nref 53 ref 51 ref 52
Juby and Hudyma Med Chem 1969 12 396Shen Ellis Windholz Matzuk Rosegay Lucas WitzelStammer Wilson Holly Willet Sarett Holtz
Risley Nuss and Winter Amer Chem Soc 1963 85 488Drain Davy Horlington Howes Scruton and Seiway .1Pharm Pharmaco/ 1971 23 857
Bey Danzin van Dorsselaer Mamont Jung and Tardiff Med Chem1978 21 50
51Atkinson Giraud Rokach Rooney McFarlane Rackham andShare Med Chem 1979 22 99
52Curtis Duggan Felix and Johnston Brain Res 1971 32 69Curtis and Watkins Nature 1961 191 1010
577
Isosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
Table continued
Prostaglandin ring system
L_ref 54 ref 54 ref 55 ref 55
II
MeN MeY
ref 56 ref 57 ref 58
MeN HNAN H2NAN_
Lre
.0 00
Me Meref 60 ref 60 ref 61
Zoretic Soja and Shiah Prostaglandins 1978 16 555Zoretic Soja and Shiah Med Chem 1978 21 1330
Harris Whittaker Higgs Armstrong and Reed Prostaglandins1978 16 773
Jones Holtz Bicking Cragoe Mandel and Kuehl MedChem 1977 20 1299
58 Bicking Robb Smith Cragoe Kuehi and MandelMed Chem 1977 20 35
Jones Hoitz Bicking Cragoe Mandel and KuehiMed Chem 1977 20 44
60 Smith Bicking Gould T.-J Lee Robb Kuehi Mandeland Cragoe Med Chem 1977 20 540
Eggelte de Koning and Huisman Rec Tray chim 1977 96 271
578
Thornber
HN1N HN1NL% L%ref 62 ref 63 ref 63
1LN RNJL
ref.64 ref 65ref 63
RNAN/
HOref 66 ref 67 ref 68
oa
HO HOref 69 ref 70 ref 71 ref 72
eaZoretic Branchard and Sirka Org Chem 1977 42 3201 Bruin
de Koning and Huisman Tetrahedron Letters 1975 4599 Bollinger andMuchowski Tetrahedron Letters 1975 2931Smith T.-J Lee Gould Cragoe Olen and Kuehi Med
Chem 1977 20 129264 Merck U.S.P 087 435
Beechams Belgian 861 95666 Beechams Belgian 861 957
Miles U.S.P 27 61268
Pfizer U.S.P 132 84769 Vlattas and Dellavecchja Tetrahedron Letters 1974 4459
Vlattas and Dellavecchia Tetrahedron Letters 1974 445571 Tanabe Seijaku G.P 229 225 Hauser and Huffman Tetrahedron Letters
1974 90572
Harrison Taylor and Fried Tetrahedron Letters 1975 1165
579
sosterism and Molecular Modification in Drug Design
Table continued
Prostaglandin ring system continued
Oyref 73 ref 74 ref 75 ref 76
Harrison Fletcher and Fried Tetrahedron Letters 1974 2733du Pont de Nemours B.P 428 431Harrison and Fletcher Tetrahedron Letters 1974 2729Bender Med Chem 1975 18 1094
580