Mind the Gap!Transcending the Tunnel View on Ontology Engineering

Pieter De Leenheer Stijn Christiaens

Pragmatic Web 2007 (Tilburg, NL)

Realistic Scenario:

Job Provider

(Industry)

Public Employment

Agencies

Educational Institutes

competency

jobproduct

workflowskill

ONTOLOGY

crystalise

http://www.prolixproject.org/

http://www.codrive.org/

http://cvc.ehb.be/PoCeHRMOM/Frameset.htm

Competency MapHR-XML consortium: “an RCD is a

specific, dentifiable, definable, and measurable knowledge, skill, ability and/or other

deployment-related characteristic (e.g. attitude, behavior, physical ability) which a human resource

may possess and which is necessary for, or material to, the performance of an activity within a specific business context.”

The Gap

delivery msg

what is delivery ?

delivery is a type of educational task

delivery#2delivery#1

http://www.moonraker.com.au/techni/lightning.jpg

Towards Community-based Evolution

Requirements for Semiotics Engineering

•Constructive methodology

•Variability and reusability

•Application-specific Contextualisation

•Flexible Operationalisation

delivery msg

what is delivery ?

delivery is a type of educational task

delivery#2delivery#1

SOCIALISATION

EXTERNALISATION/

INTERNALISATION

COMBINATION

individual mental models

community-shared models

Lexon building blocks

Jury Thesis

! = university

Context

evaluates / evaluated by

Head-term Tail-term

Role Co-role

DOGMA Layers

Reusable Lexon Base Base

(Domain- specific)

Commitment Layer Applications

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameYear Wine

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameMan Woman

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameCoffee Drink

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameAnimal Mammal

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameOS Computer

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameComputer Desktop

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameComputer Mouse

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameCar Name

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameAddress Person

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameEngine Car

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameCar Person

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson Name

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameYear Wine

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameMan Woman

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameCoffee Drink

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameComputer Mouse

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameCar Name

Person NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NamePerson NameAddress Person

Jury Thesis

Person Car

Man Woman

Lorem Dotis

Ipsum Thesis

Jury Thesis

Lorem Ipsum

Jury Thesis

Jury Soccer

Control Thesis

Jury Person

Party Thesis

“Double articulation principle”

Analysing Communication Breakdowndelivery msg

what is delivery ?

delivery is a type of educational task

Process

ROOT

Quality

Educational Task Competence

Skill Attitude

Punctual

Deliver

Employer Job Seeker

Context Dependency Management

GLOSS = "a person who acts and gets things done"SYNSET= {doer, worker}

Educational Task

Quality

exhibiting / exhibited by

Competence

Actor

APP

TEMPLATETAXONOMY

Process

ROOT

Quality

Competence

Actor

EducationalTask

performed by / performing

requiring / required for

GLOSS = "a required work that students must master"

SYNSET= {educational work}

Sample Conflict (i)

Educational Task

Quality

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Skill

exhibiting / exhibited by

Educational Task

Competence

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Skill

exhibiting / exhibited by

Educational Task

Quality

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Punctual

exhibiting / exhibited by

changeDifferentiaToSibling

specialiseDifferentia

SPE

SPE

SPE

Educational Task

Competence

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Punctual

exhibiting / exhibited by

SPE

TEMPLATE

TEMPLATE TEMPLATE

TEMPLATE

SPECIALISATION

SPECIALISATION

SPECIALISATION

SPECIALISATION

Process

ROOT

Quality

Educational Task Competence

Skill Attitude

Punctual

Deliver

Sample Conflict (ii)

Educational Task

Quality

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Skill

exhibiting / exhibited by

Educational Task

Competence

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Skill

exhibiting / exhibited by

Educational Task

Quality

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Punctual

exhibiting / exhibited by

changeDifferentiaToSibling

specialiseDifferentia

SPE

SPE

SPE

Educational Task

Competence

exhibiting / exhibited by

Deliver Punctual

exhibiting / exhibited by

SPE

TEMPLATE

TEMPLATE TEMPLATE

TEMPLATE

SPECIALISATION

SPECIALISATION

SPECIALISATION

SPECIALISATION

Process

ROOT

Quality

Educational Task Competence

Skill Attitude

Punctual

Deliver

DOGMA Studio demo movies

• please visit:

• http://www.starlab.vub.ac.be/website/dogmastudio

DOGMA Studio

Towards Community-based Evolution of K-IS

3 Negotiation and Argumentation

2 Community Modelling

1 Communication Analysis

4 Knowledge Analysis and Evolution

Recommended Reading