ICME Prize: Kickoff Meeting 1

Sponsoring Organizations:

OUTLINE

• Definition of ICME

• ICME PRIZE: Details

• Example: Jet Engine Perspective

• Potential Resources

• AIAA SciTech 2016 ICME Activities

2

Part Continuum

Quantum

Handshake via

Constitutive Model

System

Assembly

Mesoscale

Atomistic

Design “The” Material Design “With” Material

Integrated Computational Materials Engineering Is The Future

ICME is an approach to the design of

products and the materials which

comprise them by linking materials

models at multiple length scales.

Quantum Mechanics

Molecular Dynamics

Micromechanics /

Statistical Mechanics

Continuum Mechanics

P-M Relationships

M-P Relationships

Mu

ltis

cale

Mo

del

ing

Processing

Properties

Material

Properties

Levels of

microstructure

Qu

antu

m M

ech

anic

s

Mo

lecu

lar

Dyn

amic

s

Mic

rom

ech

anic

s /

Sta

tist

ical

Mec

han

ics

Co

nti

nu

um

Mec

han

ics Products

Len

gth

Sca

le

ICME Brings With It A Tsunami of Information

Needs : Metallic Materials ICME Is More than M-P or P-M Relationships

Metallic Material Example

Inaugural: ICME Award

The AIAA Materials Technical Committee (TC) with the support of Composite Design and Manufacturing HUB (cdmHUB), NASA (National Aeronautics and Space Administration) and Rolls Royce Corporation funding have established an ICME (Integrated Computational Materials Engineering) prize for the best aerospace focused ICME project.

• This bi-annual award, the first to be presented at SciTech 18, will not only include recognition at a SciTech conference itself, but will also provide a $1,500.00 team award.

• Furthermore, each winning project and project team will be given special consideration for internship or follow-on effort to further realize the benefit of the proposed project with one or more of the sponsoring organizations: cdmHUB, NASA, and/or Rolls-Royce.

5

Inaugural ICME Prize Time Schedule:

• Letter of intent to propose due to the ICME award team Jan 29, 2016

• Contestant Proposed Project Descriptions as SciTech Abstract June 30, 2016

• Acceptance (or rejection) letter to Contestants Aug 3, 2016

• Final Report due to the ICME award team June 2, 2017

• Each team must give final presentation at SciTech SciTech 18

• Winning team announced during the Recognition Luncheon SciTech 18

6

Within the context of this year’s contest

We are looking for projects that will not only demonstrate scale linkage with respect to

customer performance requirements but will also at the same time address specific bottom line

aerospace business benefit.

• Specific topic objectives and metrics are team specified; however teams are highly encouraged to

include at least three levels of scale integration (e.g., processing, microstructure, properties or

microstructure/properties/performance).

• Since aerospace structures are tightly regulated an important aspect to address/demonstrate is not

only user acceptance but regulatory/certification bodies acceptance of proposed method/process as

well.

• Consequently, it is anticipated that these projects will engage the entire supply chain [education

(workforce development), raw material and component suppliers, Original Equipment Manufacturers

(OEMs) including airframe and/or propulsion system manufacturers, large and small software

companies familiar with materials, processes and structures model development and

commercialization, and material/structures information management experts] and engage expertise

from all relevant disciplines (be multi-disciplinary in nature).

7

Participation

8

To be considered for participation in the 15-month competition, the abstract

submission must contain the following information:

1. Names and affiliation of all team members

2. Identified customer industry

3. Customer requirements and associated business case

4. A non-confidential description of the proposed project including - objectives,

criteria for success from both a technical and business case standpoint,

proposed metric(s) to measure success, novelty and how the entity or

technology developed or utilized will advance the state of the art with respect

to ICME and impact the bottom line business case of the customer.

5. A clear statement of work with associated time line and required resources.

6. Metric(s) for measuring success of the project.

The ICME prize selection committee will assess the submitted abstract for

completeness per above and send out notification to submitting teams of

acceptance, rejection, or needed modification to progress to full competition

Judging Criteria • The AIAA material technical committee will assemble an award panel to evaluate each

proposed project (based on its own merits) from all those accepted projects for the given 15-month competition timeframe.

• The ICME prize selection committee will evaluate each proposal response based against its own described merits, presentation of final project results and accompanying material:

Contestants will be judge based on the following criteria:

1. Technical scope, difficulty and quality 35 points

2. Achievement of stated goals 20 points

3. Business Impact – Return on Investment 15 points

4. Extent and quality of multidisciplinary team 10 points

5. Quality of Final Report 10 points

6. Quality of Final Presentation 10 points

9

Selection Process For ICME Prize Judges

• AIAA Material Technical Committee (TC) is responsible to assemble an ICME Prize Selection

Committee through conventional nomination process during the Materials TC meeting at SciTech.

• This selection committee shall be comprised of four ICME discipline experts that must be

members of an AIAA Technical Committee. In addition, the ICME Prize Selection Committee shall

include 1 representative from each of the donor organizations (i.e., cdmHUB, NASA, Rolls-Royce

Corporation) It is required that Donor organizations nominate an ICME Prize Selection Committee representative that actively serves

on an AIAA TC, if one exists. However, in the event a Donor organization does not have an active TC representative,

the Donor has the right to nominate a relevant non-TC subject matter expert candidate for participation.

• The resulting 7 member ICME Prize Selection Committee shall then elect a Chair from its

members. The nominated selection committee shall serve for one bi-annual award cycle, after

which the Materials TC will review and nominate new or reinstate existing members of the

committee through conventional nomination process.

• The prize chair cannot be held by the same individual (or organization) for two successive bi-

annual award cycles in a row.

10

Resources

• AIAA ICME Prize Website: http://www.aiaa.org/ICME/

• cdmHUB: https://cdmhub.org/

• National Network of Manufacturing Innovation Institutes

NNMI Overview: www.manufacturing.gov/NNMI.html

LIFT (lightweight metals): http://lift.technology/

IACMI (composites): http://iacmi.org/

America Makes (additive manufacturing): https://www.americamakes.us/

DMDII (digital design/make/use technologies): http://dmdii.uilabs.org/

11

• Simulate composites processing/performance in the cloud on

any devices connected to a browser

• Network with composites experts in academic and industry

• Collaborate 24/7 via secure groups and projects

• Facilitate pervasive and accelerated composites learning

• Benchmark simulation tools and promote best practices

Composites Design and Manufacturing HUB

Key References

• Previous AIAA ICME Symposium Material SciTech 2015

SciTech 2014

SDM 2013 • Arnold, S.M.; “Paradigm Shift in Data Content and Informatic Infrastructure Required for Generalized Constitutive

Modeling of Material Behavior, MRS Bulletin: Materials Informatics, Special Issue, Dec 2006

• Will Marsden, David Cebon and Elizabeth Cope, “Managing Multi-Scale Material Data For Access Within ICME Environments,” in Tools, Models, Databases, and Simulation Tools Developed and Needed to Realize the Vision of Integrated Computational Materials Engineering, S.M. Arnold and T. Wong (Eds.); ASM International, (Materials Park, OH, 2011).

• Arnold, S.M.*, Holland, F.A., Gabb, T., Nathal, M. and Wong, T.; “The Coming ICME Data Tsunami and What Can Be Done”, 54th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ACS Structures, Structural Dynamics, Materials Conference, Boston, MA (April 23-27, 2013), AIAA 2013-1850.

• Arnold, S.M., Holland, F. and Bednarcyk, B.A.; (2014). Robust Informatics Infrastructure Required For ICME: Combining Virtual and Experimental Data, 55th AIAA/ASMe/ASCE/AHS/SC Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, National Harbor, Maryland, 13 - 17 January 2014, AIAA-2014-0460.

• Arnold, S.M., Holland, F.A., Bednarcyk, B.A., and Pineda, E.J.; “Combining Material and Model Pedigree is Foundational to Making ICME a Reality”, IMMI, 4:4 DOI 10.1186/s40192-015-0031-2, 2015.

• Bolcavage et al. “Integrated Computational Materials Engineering from a Gas Turbine Engine Perspective”, Integrating Materials and Manufacturing Innovation 2014, 3:13

13