ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General...

79
ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014

Transcript of ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General...

Page 1: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting

Luxembourg, 22 January 2014

Page 2: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Welcome and opening remarks Godfried De Vidts, Chairman of the ICMA European Repo Committee

Page 3: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Approval of the Minutes

» Approval of the minutes of the ERC General Meeting

held on 16 October 2013 in London

Page 4: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

4

European Repo Council AGM

Luxembourg, 22 January 2014

Triparty Settlement Interoperability

Status update

Page 5: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

• Memorandum of Understanding signed in July 2013

• Parties: Eurex Clearing AG (ECAG), Euroclear Bank (EB), Clearstream Banking

Frankfurt (CBF) & Clearstream Banking Luxembourg (CBL), European Repo

Council (ERC)

• MoU scope: GC Pooling (the multi-baskets and multi-currencies repo product

cleared by ECAG) to be settled across multiple Collateral Management Systems

(CMS) and Securities Settlement Systems (SSS)

5

Triparty Settlement Interoperability (TSI)

Memorandum of Understanding

Collateral Management System Clearstream Banking

Eurex Clearing AG

Collateral Management System Euroclear Bank

ECAG

CBL

EB

CBF

CoBM / CeBM

Repo ATS

DvP

Settlement

Page 6: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Triparty Settlement Interoperability (TSI)

Work done so far

6

• Four workshops held between TSI parties, with the objective to conduct a top-

down analysis and get a mutual understanding of the functioning of the GC

Pooling product and the general processes involved in the management of

trades and the impacts of TSI on the different layers in the post-trade

processing chain, taking into account future implementation of T2S;

• Layers primarily impacted:

Clearing

Exposure & Collateral Management

Asset Servicing & Reference data

Settlement & Bookings

• Pre-requisites to:

Project definition and scoping

Detailed feasibility analysis

Page 7: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Triparty Settlement Interoperability (TSI)

Outcome

7

.

• Consistently with EBF-ERC-ECB Working Group on CoBM settlement, the

two ICSDs already agreed that the « Bridge » (CBL-EB settlement link)

mandatory and optional timings must be improved to be aligned with T2S and

TSI settlement windows, including the T2S end-of-day window for Bilaterally-

Agreed-Treasury-Management (BATM) adjustments;

• TSI will require a high level of harmonization and synchronization of

settlement and asset servicing infrastructures of Clearstream Banking

Frankfurt, Clearstream Banking Luxembourg and Euroclear Bank, including

the links between them, pre- or post- implementation of T2S;

• TSI parties have not yet completed the on-going top-down analysis and the

building of end-to-end scenarios under TSI;

• Based on work done so far, two settlement models are being considered to

support the cross-ICSDs settlement flows for relevant TSI trades (directly

through the « Bridge » or indirectly via the ICSDs-CBF links), but additional

work is required to draw conclusions.

Page 8: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Triparty Settlement Interoperability (TSI)

Next steps

8

• Set-up of a new workstream between the two ICSDs on the «Bridge»

mandatory and optional timings improvements;

• On TSI, pursue the work through additional workshops between TSI parties

focusing on:

Exposure management

Links between relevant Securities Settlement Systems and the bookings

of settlement flows, pre- and post-T2S

Design and agree on end-to-end scenarios;

• With the objective to draw conclusions on the TSI model, finalize project

scope and detailed feasibility analysis by May/June 2014.

Page 9: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

ERC semi-annual repo survey Richard Comotto, Senior Visiting Fellow, ICMA Centre

Page 10: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

European Repo Council 26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 11: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Survey overview

• Outstanding value of contracts at close of business

on Wednesday, 11th December 2013

• 68 responses from 64 groups

Page 12: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Headline numbers

• December 2013 EUR 5,499 billion • June 2013 EUR 6,076 billion

• December 2012 EUR 5,611 billion

• June 2012 EUR 5,647 billion

• December 2011 EUR 6,204 billion

• June 2011 EUR 6,124 billion

• December 2010 EUR 5,908 billion

• June 2010 EUR 6,979 billion

• December 2009 EUR 5,582 billion

• June 2009 EUR 4,868 billion

• December 2008 EUR 4,633 billion

• June 2008 EUR 6,504 billion

• December 2007 EUR 6,382 billion

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 13: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Headline numbers

EUR 5,499 bn

Jun-10 Jun-07

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Lehman

Dec-10

LTRO

Page 14: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Europe v US

Jun-10

Dec-10

Jun-07

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Lehman LTRO

Page 15: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Comparable market growth

• 61 respondents participating in last 3 surveys

-8.2% since June 2013

+0.5% year-on-year

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 16: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Trading analysis

bilaterally-negotiated

by phone or EM

bilaterally-settled

bilaterally-negotiated

by phone or EM

triparty-settled

arranged by voice-broker

bilaterally-settled

automatic trading system

includes GC Pooling

bilaterally/triparty/CCP-settled

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 17: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Trading analysis

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 18: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Trading analysis (directly-reported by providers)

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 19: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Geographical analysis

from reporting bank

cross-border to a(nother)

eurozone counterparty

ATS via CCP

from reporting bank

cross-border to a

non-eurozone counterparty

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 20: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Geographical analysis

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 21: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Anonymous ATS business

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 22: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Business cleared across CCP

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 23: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Currency analysis

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 24: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Currency analysis

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 25: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Collateral analysis

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 26: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Collateral analysis

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%D

ec-0

1

Dec-0

2

Dec-0

3

Dec-0

4

Dec-0

5

Dec-0

6

Dec-0

7

Dec-0

8

Dec-0

9

Dec-1

0

Dec-1

1

Dec-1

2

Dec-1

3

DE

IT

FR

UK

other EU

other

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 27: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Collateral analysis

EU non-

govis

19.9%

EU govis

80.1%

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 28: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Collateral analysis

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 29: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Collateral comparison

EU govis

80.1%

EU non-

govis

19.9%

EU govis

50.1%EU non-

govis

49.9%

banks tri-party

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 30: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Collateral analysis (triparty)

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 31: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Maturity analysis

short dates

= 57.7% (57.2%)

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 32: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Maturity analysis

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

Jun-0

1

Jun-0

2

Jun-0

3

Jun-0

4

Jun-0

5

Jun-0

6

Jun-0

7

Jun-0

8

Jun-0

9

Jun-1

0

Jun-1

1

Jun-1

2

Jun-1

3

SD+open

1M+

forward

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 33: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Maturity analysis

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

Jun-0

1

Jun-0

2

Jun-0

3

Jun-0

4

Jun-0

5

Jun-0

6

Jun-0

7

Jun-0

8

Jun-0

9

Jun-1

0

Jun-1

1

Jun-1

2

Jun-1

3

SD + open

1-6M

6M+

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 34: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Maturity analysis

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

Jun-0

1

Jun-0

2

Jun-0

3

Jun-0

4

Jun-0

5

Jun-0

6

Jun-0

7

Jun-0

8

Jun-0

9

Jun-1

0

Jun-1

1

Jun-1

2

Jun-1

3

1D

2D-1W

1W-1M

open

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 35: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Maturity comparison

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

1D

1W 1

M3M

6M

+6M

fd-fd

open

banks

triparty

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 36: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Maturity comparison

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

1D 1W 1M 3M 6M +6M fd-fd open

ATS

voice broker

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 37: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Rate analysis

fixed77.4%

floating6.6%

open13.5%

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 38: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Rate analysis

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Dec-0

1

Dec-0

2

Dec-0

3

Dec-0

4

Dec-0

5

Dec-0

6

Dec-0

7

Dec-0

8

Dec-0

9

Dec-1

0

Dec-1

1

Dec-1

2

fixed rate

floating rate

open

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 39: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Product analysis

repo

90.1%

lending

9.9%

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 40: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Product analysis

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Dec-0

1

Dec-0

2

Dec-0

3

Dec-0

4

Dec-0

5

Dec-0

6

Dec-0

7

Dec-0

8

Dec-0

9

Dec-1

0

Dec-1

1

Dec-1

2

repo

SL

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 41: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Concentration analysis

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Dec-0

1

Dec-0

2

Dec-0

3

Dec-0

4

Dec-0

5

Dec-0

6

Dec-0

7

Dec-0

8

Dec-0

9

Dec-1

0

Dec-1

1

Dec-1

2

Dec-1

3

remainder

20-30

10-20

top 10

Lehman LTRO

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 42: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Next survey

Wednesday, 11th June 2014

26th European repo market survey

conducted in December 2013

Page 43: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Legal update

Lisa Cleary, Director, Associate Counsel, ICMA

Page 44: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Panel Session: The Safety Net » Moderator: Lisa Cleary, Director, Associate Counsel, ICMA

» Panellists:

• Duncan Wales, General Counsel, ICAP

• Habib Motani, Partner, Clifford Chance

• Jean-Robert Wilkin, Head of Product Management, Clearstream

Page 45: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Elections to the European Repo Committee

Page 46: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Leverage Ratio

Richard Comotto, Senior Visiting Fellow, ICMA Centre

Page 47: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Settlement under T+2 Richard Comotto, Senior Visiting Fellow, ICMA Centre

Page 48: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Bank A

ECB FRBNY Bank B Inst. X Bank C ECB FRBNY

Cust.5 Cust.4 Bank E Cust.3 Cust.2 Cust.1 Bank D

Inst. X

Bank F Bank B

Bank J Bank I Bank H Bank G

Cust.4 Cust.5 Cust.2 Cust.3 Cust.1

Bank L Bank K

CeBM (USD)

CoBM (USD) CoBM (EUR)

CeBM (EUR)

customers customers customers

Correspondent bank A Correspondent bank B Correspondent bank C

Bank G Bank E Bank D

USD

USD

EUR

+ - + - + - + - + - + -

+ - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + -

+ - + - + - + - + - + -

Page 49: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

49

settlement across a CSD

A sec

B sec

CSD

CEBM

T2

A cash

net or gross

gross

CEBM

A sett

cash

A main

cash

SBB cash

SBB

cash

B cash

COBM

CEBM

security

SB = settlement (custodian) bank

Page 50: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

50

A sec

A cash

ICSD

DvP

ICSD sec

B sec

ICSD sett

cash

B sett

cash

CSD

CeBM

T2

ICSD cash

B cash

net or

gross

gross

CeBM

CoBM

ICSD main

cash

B main

cash

CeBM CeBM

settlement across an ICSD and CSD

Page 51: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

51

A sec

A cash

ICSD

CoBM

security

DvP

B cash

CoBM

B sec

CBB cash

settlement across an ICSD

Page 52: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

CSD CP CP

ICSD CP CP

CSD CP ICSD CP

central bank money

CSD CP CP

ICSD CP CP ICSD

CSD CP CP custodian

custodian

custodian

CSD CP CP custodian custodian ICSD

CSD CP CP custodian ICSD

commercial bank money

commercial bank money

(1)

(2)-(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

(7), (8)

(9)

(10), (11)

Bridge

Page 53: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00

CSD

CSD-ICSD

ICSD-CSD

ICSD

ICSD-ICSD

cust-CSD

cust(x)-CSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-cust(y)

cust-CSD-ICSD

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(y)

range of internal cut-off times in banks for instructions for same-day settlement German fixed-income securities --- real-time DvP settlement

16:00

15:00-16:00

13:00-18:30

16:00-18:30

13:00-17:45

13:00-15:00

13:00-15:00

13:00-15:00

13:00-15:00

13:00-15:00

13:00-15:00

CSD

on

line

CSD

FT/

cust

od

ian

2

2

12

12

11

3

3

3

3

3

3

?

EOC

man

dat

ory

ICSD

op

tio

nal

EOC

man

d.B

rid

ge

CB

L m

and

.Bri

dge

ICSD

op

t.B

rid

ge

CB

L m

and

ato

ry

FT = file transfer online = real-time link to CBF

?

Page 54: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00

CSD

CSD-ICSD

ICSD-CSD

ICSD

ICSD-ICSD

cust-CSD

cust(x)-CSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-cust(y)

cust-CSD-ICSD

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(y)

range of internal cut-off times in banks for instructions for same-day settlement French fixed-income securities --- real-time DvP settlement

15:00-15:55

15:00-16:00

15:00-17:30

16:00-18:30

13:00-17:10

15:00-16:00

ICSD

op

tio

nal

15:00-16:30

15:00-16:30

15:00-16:30

15:00-16:30

15:00-16:30

3

3

6

7

7

6

5

5

5

5

5

?

EOC

man

d.(

15

:30

)

EOC

man

d.B

rid

ge

CB

L m

and

.Bri

dge

ICSD

op

t.B

rid

ge

CSD

CB

L m

and

.(1

5:4

5)

cust

od

ian

(1

5:5

0)

EOC

-CSD

?

?

?

?

?

?

19:00

Page 55: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00

CSD

CSD-ICSD

ICSD-CSD

ICSD

ICSD-ICSD

cust-CSD

cust(x)-CSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-cust(y)

cust-CSD-ICSD

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(y)

range of internal cut-off times in banks for instructions for same-day settlement Italian fixed-income securities --- real-time DvP settlement

15:30-17:50

15:00-16:15

16:00-18:30

13:00-17:45

14:00-16:15

14:00-16:15

14:00-16:15

14:00-16:15

14:00-16:15

14:00-16:15

2

1

4

6

5

11

11

11

8

8

8

17:50

ICSD

op

tio

nal

EOC

man

d.

EOC

man

d.B

rid

ge

CB

L m

and

.Bri

dge

ICSD

op

t.B

rid

ge

CB

L m

and

.

cust

od

ian

CSD

CSD

(B

AN

M)

(17

:50

)

BANM = bilaterally-agreed non-matching

?

19:00

Page 56: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00

CSD

CSD-ICSD

ICSD-CSD

ICSD

ICSD-ICSD

cust-CSD

cust(x)-CSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-cust(y)

cust-CSD-ICSD

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(x)

cust(x)-CSD-ICSD-cust(y)

range of internal cut-off times in banks for instructions for same-day settlement Spanish fixed-income securities --- real-time DvP settlement

15:00

15:00-16:00

15:30-18:30

13:00-17:45

12:00-17:00

12:00-17:00

12:00-17:00

12:00-17:00

12:00-17:00

12:00-17:00

CSD

1

0

4

4

5

11

11

11

9

9

9

?

?

?

?

?

? EO

C m

and

.

ICSD

op

tio

nal

cust

od

ian

(1

5:2

5)

EOC

man

d.B

rid

ge

CB

L m

and

.Bri

dge

ICSD

op

t.B

rid

ge

CSD

(2

nd b

atch

)

CB

L m

and

.(1

4:1

0)

cust

od

ian

Second batch-processing cycle accepts instructions at 16:15

?

19:00

Page 57: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

UK bilat/dom

UK LCH

ES bilat/dom

IT bilat/dom

SE bilat/dom

etc bilat

FR, ES CNet

BE bilat/dom

LCH etc

DE bilat

IT CNet

GR bilat/dom

DK bilat/ICSD

12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00

range of BrokerTec ON repo trading deadlines CET (specials = red; GC = blue)

LCH DE

11:00 10:00 09:00 08:00

DBV bilat/dom

DBV LCH

09

:50

16

:50

09

:20

T2

T2 BATM LCH DE

11

:25

LCH nonDE EGC LCH UK LCH GBP GC

?

FR

CSD FR CSD IT

CSD ES CSD DE

Page 58: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Alternatives for Repo Indices / Establishing a Standard for European Repo Indices

Page 59: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Importance of a widely accepted repo index

» Significance of the European repo market

• Today, the secured segment accounts for almost 80% of lending and borrowing transactions

• Repo markets have been able to absorb a substantial part of the reduction of unsecured lending/borrowing following the crisis, therefore limiting the intervention of the ECB to facilitate liquidity

-327

+212

-115

113

Reduction in

unsecured turnover

Increase in secured

turnover

Net reduction of

turnover

Increase in

Eurosystem BS

EU

R b

n

The Repo market has lessened the burden on the ECB* Secured vs. Unsecured (volumes for 2012)*

192

254

5375

Lending Borrowing

Secured Unsecured

− Increased market transparency

− Enhanced visibility for regulators

− Helping market participants manage risks

− Monitoring the monetary policy transmission mechanisms

*Source: ICMA “The Future of the Repo Market” – June 2013 , Presentation by Francesco Papadia, Chairman of the Board of the Prime Collateralised Securities (PCS) and former Director General, Market Operations, European Central Bank

» There is a need of a pan-European effort to establish a widely-accepted standard

Page 60: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

A working example in the US: the DTCC GCF Repo index*

» The index was developed in response to concerns of the Treasury Markets Practice Group, sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, regarding the need for enhanced transparency in the Treasury, agency debt and mortgage-backed securities markets

» Based on an average daily volume of close to USD400bn of overnight transactions

» Based only on actual transactions

» Fully transparent index methodology

» Suite of 3 DTGCC GCF Repo Indices, each calculated as the weighted average of the interest paid each day on overnight transactions involving GCF Repos for:

• U.S. Treasury (< 30Y maturity) (GCFRTSY Index)

• Non-mortgage backed US agency securities (GCFRAGY Index)

• Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac fixed rate MBS (GCFRMBS Index)

» Futures and swap market

• Bloomberg page: Tulett Prebon Tullett Prebon OIS GC Index Swaps (GDCO 6793 3)

• Bloomberg tickers: USTA Cmdty

*Average daily trading in GCF Repos in 2012.

Page 61: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Adapting best practices to the Euro Zone reality

» Key differences from the US market • Heterogeneous market: European repo markets liquidity is along national “GC” lines and are certain basket products (e.g. GC Pooling)

• CCP: sovereign risks subject the CCP model to constrains unknown to the US

• Data Ownership: transaction data remains with inter-dealer brokers and not with CCPs

• GCF/DBV: no pure GCF/DBV type of product with high turnover

» Several parallel initiatives • Capturing different segments of the European market

• Varying index methodologies

• Different levels of industry backing

• In some cases, filtering algorithm to capture broader GC concept out of specific transactions

» A working group of the ICMA European Repo Committee has discussed the need for, and features of, a suite of secured benchmark indices reflective of the European repo market

Guiding Principles for Euro Repo Indices

Anchored on actual market

transactions: Objective Transparent Credible

Overnight and term fixing

Useful alternative to unsecured short term indices Current reality of the liquidity is on the overnight

Anchored on existing liquid

markets Accurate pan-European picture Displays both trends and tiering

Capturing only centrally cleared

transactions Accurate representation of the cost of collateral

Broad- based secured index capturing the

concept of “GC” Broader representation of secured transactions

Governed by an industry body

Highly representative

Sustainability

Experience

Credibility

Page 62: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Assessing and comparing existing initiatives

Eurepo RepoFundsRate GC Pooling GCF Characteristics

Anchored on actual market transactions

Overnight and term fixing

Anchored on existing liquid markets

Capturing only centrally cleared transactions

Broad- based secured index

Governance by industry body

Pure GC basket product

Euro Zone US

RONIA

UK

Page 63: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

» In September last year, to the invitation of the EBF, The ERC Repo Index task force, the Eurepo steering committee and an observer from the ECB met as a working group to get an update on the various initiatives and devise the way forward

» For the benefit of the wider public, it comes out as a necessity to build the index as a unique pan Eurozone daily index capturing the weighted average of all centrally cleared, electronically transacted 1 day repo transactions

» This is a challenge given the liquidity structure of the Euro Repo markets but a challenge that can be resolved. Extracting information from the deepest and most liquid funding market with volumes in excess of Euro 250bn transacted daily is a worthwhile goal

» The next meeting of ERC Repo Index task force & Eurepo steering committee is scheduled for January 23rd

» The work on repo indices has laid bare some other challenges which we should take upon us as an industry (dealers, CCPs and post-trade providers):

• The creation and development of liquidity in a Euro GCF like basket

• The establishment of a true term benchmark

The way forward

Page 64: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

ERC Operations Group Update Nicholas Hamilton, Chairman of the ERC Operations Group

Page 65: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

European Repo Council Operations groups

Committee Structure:

18 members:

3 working groups:

Matching & Affirmation – Camille Mckelvey (CITI)

Target 2 Securities - Rob Mason (RBS)

Repo Data Repository - Jonathan Lee (JPM)

2 focus groups:

ICSD / CCP Tri-party interoperability

COGESI - T2S Treasury deadlines

Contributions

CSDR article 7 – Buy in and settlement

Repo Best Practice Guidelines

Page 66: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Matching and Affirmation Working Group – progress 2013

Overview

9 ICMA ERC Ops firms form part of the working group

Working towards best practice as a industry on trade date matching and affirmation

Focus areas

Industry alignment to best practice documents and terminology

Review of current vendor service offerings

Feedback from the ERC community of their vendor usage

Encouraging the industry to T0 affirm and match

Progress 2013

Sub group re-established to review current state

Survey issued to vendor community to review detailed offerings

New best practice statement developed with ICMA on Matching, Affirmation and Confirmation

Partnership with ISLA to share best practices

Page 67: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Matching and Affirmation Working Group – Looking forward

» Production of short report for vendors and ERC members highlighting survey findings

» Work closely with vendors to define industry requirements

» Promote Repo matching and affirmation on trade date

» Be proactive to potential regulatory change in the industry

» Further partnership & collaboration with AFME, ISLA & industry groups

Page 68: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

ERC Ops – Target 2 Securities

» Firms have now decided on their intention for direct/indirect access to T2S. The deadline for “non binding expression of interest” to be a direct partipant passed in October 2013, with a list available on the ECB website.

» Consultation with Rule Financial has been initiated. Aim is to determine if a joint venture with ICMA to produce more information on T2S is of benefit to the industry and its actors.

» Topics likely to be in focus for more research in H1 2014 include:

• Articulating the infrastructure landscape in T2S and what it means for the industry

• Understanding the impact on settlement mechanics and settlement discipline

• Identifying potential risks, benefits and opportunities of T2S for the industry

• Understanding the impact of T2S on Triparty Repo and Triparty Interoperability

» Further educational materials and seminars likely in 2014, aimed at all market participants.

Page 69: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

ERC Repo Market Data Repository Working Group 2013

» Working group formed of ERC banks with a significant interest in Repo market regulation.

» Requirements (explicit and implicit) collated based upon published papers from the European Central Bank, European Systemic Risk Board, Committee on Payment & Settlement Systems/Bank for International Settlements and Federal Reserve Bank of New

York.

» Hopes, Fears & Unknowns Identified – Need for a thorough specification including product scope & standardisation of terms.

» Working group identifying readily available data, potential application to meet majority of micro and macro prudential regulatory requirements without building a full Trade

Repository at this time.

» ERC paper launched on “Enhancing the Transparency of the European Repo Market.” Putting forward proposals to offer a rapid expansion in Repo market transparency leveraging existing data sources.

Page 70: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

ERC Repo Market Data Repository Working Group 2014

» Preparing for the inclusion of Repo Data Repository requirements in forthcoming European legislation on the separation of certain trading activities from credit institutions and their EU parents. Looking to engage / influence Level 2 discussions.

» Engaged with the FSB on Global Data Collection & Aggregation, formal engagement requested in London in mid-March.

» Plans to expand the number of ERC working group participants as this agenda approaches

fruition.

» Reviewing the possibility of an ERC Repo Position Data Survey pilot to demonstrate its potential as a micro/macro prudential regulatory tool – front running formal regulatory requirements and helping shape those requirements.

Page 71: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Update on regulatory issues John Serocold, Senior Director, ICMA

Page 72: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Regulatory Update

» Other relevant regulatory developments include:

» Shadow banking:

• Active and on-going ERC engagement in efforts at both international and EU levels

» BCBS leverage – treatment of SFTs

• BCBS published finalised leverage ratio framework on 12 January. The technical modifications to the June 2013 proposals relate to (a.o.):

• Securities financing transactions (SFTs). SFTs include transactions such as repos and reverse repos. The final standard now allows limited netting with the same counterparty to reduce the leverage ratio's exposure measure, where specific conditions are met.

• “The Committee thanks those who provided feedback and comments as these were instrumental in revising and finalising the leverage ratio standard.”

» Asset encumbrance

• EBA published consultation on asset encumbrance in a CRD context on 20 December

• Open hearing 22 January

• We expect to respond

Page 73: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Shadow banking - summary

» FSB shadow banking workstream related to securities lending/repos (WS5)

• 29 August 2013: release of 11 final policy recommendations on securities lending/repos

• Improvements in the areas of transparency; regulation; and structural aspects

• Consultation re two further recommendations concerning haircuts

– ERC responded jointly with ISLA by 28 November deadline

» We broadly welcomed the proposals for a limited regime of mandatory minimum haircuts

» Reservations remain in other areas. In particular, there is concern regarding the call for haircut methodologies to be used in all non-CCP cleared securities financing transactions to set haircuts. This requirement should be limited in scope in the same way as for mandatory minimum haircuts

– QIS2 prepared by FSB in conjunction with the consultation published 5 November 2013

• FSB technical data experts group to develop proposed standards and processes by end 2014

» Parallel European Commission project continues:

• 4 September shadow banking roadmap communication published

• Commission proposal for an EU Money Market Funds Regulation

» Active and on-going ERC engagement in efforts at both international and EU levels

Page 74: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Shadow banking – ‘haircuts’ – QIS

» On the 5 November 2013, the FSB launched its Quantitative Impact Study (QIS2) on Proposed Regulatory Framework for Haircuts on Securities Financing Transactions. This includes:

• a more comprehensive quantitative assessment of the impact on a broader set of firms of the FSB's detailed haircuts proposals:

• both the proposed minimum standards for methodologies used by firms in calculating their own haircuts and

• the numerical haircut floors to be applied to certain securities financing transactions.

• QIS comprises a quantitative data collection template (template A) and a questionnaire (template B).

» Although the ERC is not responding itself, the ERC (with ISLA) has offered advice to the FSB on the design of the exercise and encouraged its individual member firms to respond.

» The deadline for responses is 23 December 2013.

Page 75: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

BCBS leverage – treatment of SFTs – 1

» Leverage = Capital/Exposure

» The capital measure used for the leverage ratio at any particular point in time is the Tier 1 capital measure applying at that time under the risk-based framework.

» The exposure measure is the sum of:

• On balance sheet exposures (excluding SFTs but including collateral);

• Derivatives exposures;

• Securities financing transaction (SFT) exposures; and

• Off balance sheet items.

» Banks will be required to comply with these requirements from the date of publication of their first set of financial statements relating to a balance sheet on or after 1 January 2015.

Page 76: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

BCBS leverage – treatment of SFTs - 2

Securities financing transaction exposures

12 Gross SFT assets (with no recognition of netting), after adjusting for sales accounting transactions

13 (Netted amounts of cash payables and cash receivables of gross SFT assets)

14 CCR exposure for SFT assets

15 Agent transaction exposures

16 Total securities financing transaction exposures (sum of lines 12 to 15)

Page 77: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Results of the elections to the European Repo Committee

Page 78: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

1. Constantino Toribio Garcia, BANKIA, S.A., Valencia

2. Stephen Malekian, Barclays Capital Securities Limited, London

3. Eugene McGrory, BNP Paribas, London

4. Maria Arauzo Arranz, CAIXABANK, S.A., Barcelona

5. Grigorios Markouizos, Citigroup Global Markets Limited, London

6. Andreas Biewald, Commerzbank AG, Frankfurt

7. Romain Dumas, Credit Suisse Securities (Europe) Limited, London

8. Tony Baldwin, Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Limited, London

9. Ronan Rowley, Deutsche Bank AG, Frankfurt

10. Olly Benkert, Goldman Sachs International, London

11. Jean-Michel Meyer, HSBC Bank plc, London

12. Godfried De Vidts, ICAP Securities Ltd, London

13. Andrea Masciovecchio, Intesa Sanpaolo S.p.A, Milan

14. Stefano Bellani, J.P. Morgan Securities plc, London

15. Rajen Patel , Morgan Stanley & Co. International PLC, London

16. Ulf Bacher, Newedge Group SA, Paris

17. Sylvain Bojic, Société Générale, Paris

18. Guido Stroemer, UBS AG, London

19. Eduard Cia, UniCredit Bank AG, Munich

Results of the elections to the European Repo Committee

Page 79: ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting€¦ · ICMA European Repo Council Annual General Meeting Luxembourg, 22 January 2014 . ... held on 16 October 2013 in London . 4

Any other business and next meetings

» The next ERC General Meeting will be held on 7 October 2014 in London, hosted

by MTS