IB English Language & Literature: How and why is a social group represented in a particular way?

download IB English Language & Literature: How and why is a social group represented in a particular way?

of 5

description

Written task 2, in response to the prescribed question in the title. Joesph Conrad's ' Heart of Darkness' was one of the works studied as a part of Literature- critical study course in our class and this is the text analyzed in this essay.English L&L was an HL subject for me.

Transcript of IB English Language & Literature: How and why is a social group represented in a particular way?

  • Name: Momina Amjad

    Candidate Number: 002223-0028

    Session: May 2014

    Outline

    Prescribed question:

    Power and privilege: How and why is a social group represented in a particular way?

    Title of text for analysis:

    Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad. London: Penguin Classics, 2007. 1-96. Print.

    Task is related to course section:

    Part 4: Literature- critical study

    Task focus:

    This essay focuses on Conrads negative portrayal of the natives and an explanation of what

    narrative purpose that representation serves in the text.

    This essay claims that Conrad sets up Africa and its people as an antithesis to Europe and

    civilization. In order to do that, the native is constantly dehumanized. He is not even given the

    gift of language and expression. The main purpose of the novella is not to shed light on the ills of

    colonialism and atrocities committed on the native people, rather its focus is the European mans

    mental disintegration which is facilitated by the wilderness and Africa. This reduces the place and

    its people as a prop to prove a point and eliminates its human factor.

    The wilderness is built up as a character on its own in Heart of Darkness, and indeed with much

    more personality and power than the natives. Its used complimentarily with the description of

    natives as savages to prove how ancient this world is and how the white man has evolved beyond

    the point of recognizing this as their past selves. This essay discusses how this is inherently racist,

    in spite of the novella famously being an anti-colonial book in classic literature.

    Word count; outline: 249 words, essay: 999 words

  • How and why is a social group represented in a particular way? 002223-0028

    1

    Heart of Darkness is a novella about, among many other things, the evaluation of the

    European mans soul in contrast with that of the African natives. Conrad uses a frame narrative

    to tell the story of Charles Marlow as he makes the long and excruciating journey up the Congo

    River in central Africa. This journey is a life changing experience for Marlow as he discovers the

    inherent hypocrisy in imperialism and Europes civilizing mission and he realizes the depravity

    and hollowness of the human existence against the backdrop of African wilderness. Marlow

    learns of sanity and madness, of civilization and savagery and the many shades in between these

    false dichotomies. However, in a supposed expos on colonialism, very little is mentioned of the

    millions of innocent natives who have suffered through this gross injustice. The horror presented

    by Conrad is not that the natives were exploited like slaves; rather the horror was what happened

    to the European mans psyche in the wilderness. To accomplish this narrative end, the black man

    is constantly dehumanized, to the extent that the horrible treatment he receives is mentioned in

    passing and the focus is on him being a savage. The representation of African natives in Heart

    of Darkness is the focus of this essay and I will discuss how and why a civilized/uncivilized

    discourse is created.

    The natives are stripped off their humanity and any sense of individuality early on in the

    story. They shouted, sang; their bodies streamed with perspiration; they had faces like grotesque

    masksbut they had bone, muscle, a wild vitality, an intense energy of movement, this is the

    first of many passages in the novel that describe the natives using their discrete body parts. They

    arent recognizable as people, rather only as labor that is profitable. The simile grotesque masks

    connotes something bizarre and ugly. Elsewhere, the simile of ants is used to further reinforce

    the idea of them being a collective whole that works menial jobs together and reports back

    obediently to a ruling figure. It is also used to imply that they can be crushed easily as they are

    insignificant. Further along the story, black people are repeatedly described as dark human

    shapes, shadows and unhappy savages in similar fashion.

    The natives are also completely silenced in Heart of Darkness. Majority of the natives are

    shown to be helpless and have no say in their fate. In the beginning when Marlow is in the

    Companys offices, he compares one of the black women there to a somnambulist; a sleep

    walker- someone who has no control or agency about themselves. In order to show apparent

  • How and why is a social group represented in a particular way? 002223-0028

    2

    uncivilization of the natives, Conrad stole the natives language from them as well. Instead of

    speech, they made a violent babble of uncouth sounds and they exchanged short grunting

    phrases. In the rare instance when the native man is given speech; it only serves to bare more

    savagery. This is seen when the natives request the body of a fellow native to Eat im!, allowing

    the white man to witness their inherent foulness.

    The wilderness is anthromorphized and given a character of its own on Heart of Darkness.

    Its an omnipotent and all-encompassing force which has a strong bond with the natives. The

    wilderness depicts the same uncivilization Conrad wants to talk about as much as any other

    description of a savage. One of the passages around the midpoint of the story use this in a

    combined description: We were wanderers on a prehistoric earth ... leaving hardly a sign -- and

    no memories. This prehistoric earth together with the prehistoric man is set up as an antithesis

    to Europe and its civilization1. In this way, Africa the land and Africa the people are developed as

    the other, from which the European has evolved so much from that he doesnt recognize this

    as his past self. This passage makes the natives of Congo otherworldly. They have rudimentary

    souls and most primitive instincts.

    All of the above becomes even more striking when contrasted to the representations of

    the Europeans in Heart of Darkness. This is not to say that Conrad does not criticize them, but

    they are depicted in such a way that each character has a distinct and rich personality. When

    Marlow first meets the accountant he says, I met a white man, in such an unexpected elegance

    of get-up that in the first moment I took him for a sort of vision and later called him a miracle.

    The words phantom and apparition are used elsewhere in the story while describing the white

    man suggesting a supernatural aura and also links into Kurtz in the end, who became a god-like

    figure for the natives. Compare this to how Marlow talks of the deceased African helmsman,

    Perhaps you will think it passing strange this regret for a savage who was no more account than

    a grain of sand in a black Sahara which creates an imagery of the natives devoid of feelings,

    personality or dignity in an endless and lifeless desert.

    1 Achebe, Chinua. "An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad's "Heart of Darkness"."

  • How and why is a social group represented in a particular way? 002223-0028

    3

    The thought of their humanity - like yours - the thought of your remote kinship with this

    wild and passionate uproar. Ugly. Although Marlow struggles with the idea that the natives are

    inhuman, the thought of their humanity being compared to his is so intolerable that he calls it

    ugly. Heart of Darkness is a racist book in spite of it speaking against colonialism and

    deconstructing the ills of the European mind. It can be argued that Conrad was a product of his

    society and this text was in line with the Victorian approach to racial differences. First published

    in 1899, the dominant image of Africans in Europe was utilized in the text and the racism was

    acceptable. However, reading the novella with in retrospect, it is easy to notice how Conrad has

    reduced Africans as tools and symbols to explore European issues. In the process he

    dehumanized them severely as mere insects, savages and voiceless objects, reinforcing racist

    stereotypes.

    Word Count: 999

  • Bibliography

    Achebe, Chinua. "An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad's "Heart of Darkness"." Kirbyk.net, 2014.

    Web. 5 Jan 2014. http://kirbyk.net/hod/image.of.africa.html

    Conrad, Joseph. Heart of Darkness. London: Penguin Classics, 2007. Print.