IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND...

68
1 IAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT ASSETS - Anand Banka BASIC CONCEPTS Liability Present obligation Past event Which will result in outflow Obligating event Legal or constructive obligation Provisions Uncertain timing or amount

Transcript of IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND...

Page 1: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

1

IAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND

CONTINGENT ASSETS

- Anand Banka

BASIC CONCEPTS

Liability

Present obligation

Past event

Which will result in outflow

Obligating event

Legal or constructive obligation

Provisions

Uncertain timing or amount

Page 2: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

2

BASIC CONCEPTS

Contingent liability

Possible obligation

Present obligation but

outflow not probable

Not reliably measurable

Onerous contractOnerous contract

Obligations exceed economic benefits

PROVISION VS. REVENUE

Customer Loyalty ProgramBad DebtsBad DebtsWarrantiesCash discount – if paid 45 daysDealer discounts – escalation clause

Page 3: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

3

ProvisionPresent obligation (Legal or Constructive)

RECOGNITION

Present obligation (Legal or Constructive)Probable outflow of resourcesReliable estimate can be made

Contingent LiabilityNot recognized Disclosed

Contingent AssetsNot recognized Disclosed only when probable

Legal Obligation Constructive ObligationC t t E t bli h d tt f t ti

LEGAL OR CONSTRUCTIVE OBLIGATION

Contract Established pattern of past practicesLaw/ Act/ Legislation Published Policies

Creation of valid expectations

Page 4: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

4

CASE STUDY

Which of the following does not lead to recognising a provision?recognising a provision?

There is a legal or constructive obligationThere is a probable outflow of resourcesThere is a general risks of future lossesThe amount can be estimated reliably

Case filed by customer on September 15

CASE STUDY

Year end December 31

Whether provision required?

Page 5: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

5

Government planning to declare a land as forest

CASE STUDY

land

The Company has a warehouse on that land

Whether provision required?

Best estimate

MEASUREMENT

◦ Judgment

◦ Expected value

Present value, if material

Future events

Page 6: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

6

Warranty on productsManufacturing defects repaired for free

CASE STUDY

Manufacturing defects repaired for freeMinor defects in all – 1 mioMajor defects in all – 4 mioPast experience

75% - no defects20% - minor defects5% - major defects

Expected value = 75% * NIL + 20% * 1 mio + 5% * 4 mio

Dismantling cost

CASE STUDY

A new technology to be launched after 3 years

Existing cost: 10 lacs

Cost as per new technology: 7 lacs

Page 7: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

7

2009

CASE STUDY

Provision for advertisement = 100

2010

Actual expense for advertisement = 70

Bonus given to salesman based on 2009 sales = g

20

Can the company setoff the provision against this expense and reverse the remaining 10?

Separate asset

REIMBURSEMENTS

Expense may be net of reimbursements

Page 8: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

8

ONEROUS CONTRACTS

Unavoidable costs > Economic benefitsExample: Example: -

Company X enters into a contract to lease a warehouse for Rs. 10,000 a monthContract cancellable within 2 years only on payment of Rs. 1 LakhsCompany stops using the warehouse after one year

Sale or termination of a line of business

RESTRUCTURING

Closure of business at a location

Relocation

Changes in management structure e.g.

eliminating a layer of management

Page 9: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

9

Detailed formal plan including identification of

CONSTRUCTIVE OBLIGATION

Business concerned

Locations

Approximate number of employees

Expenditure involved

Timing of implementation of the plan

Raised a valid expectation by making an

announcement

CASE STUDY

XP oil company limited

N l / l i l ti No laws/ legislations

regarding contamination

Company announces

environmental policy for

clean upp

Whether provision required?

Page 10: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

10

CASE STUDY

Manufacturer Purchaser

Contract Price: 100 mio

Cost of the project: 70 mio

Penalty of 50 mio if not delivered on time

SUMMARY

Asset Virtually certain (>=90%) Recognizey ( ) g

Contingent AssetProbable (> = 50%)Possible (< = 50%)Remote (< = 10%)

DiscloseNo DisclosureNo Disclosure

LiabilityVirtually CertainProbable (reliably measurable)

RecognizeRecognize

P b bl di lContingent Liability

ProbablePossibleRemote

disclosedisclosedo not disclose

Page 11: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

11

DECISION TREEStart

Present Obligation as a

result of an obligating event?

Probable outflow Remote?

Possible Obligation

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No No

No

No

Yes

Yes

No

No

No

Yes

No

Yes

Reliable estimate

Provide

Disclose Contingent liability Do nothing

Yes

Yes

No

No (rare)

Yes

Yes

No

No

Page 12: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

12

QUESTION # 1The company introduced a new car model two

months before the reporting date. months before the reporting date. This model, in accordance with company policy

which applies to all cars sold by the company, is guaranteed for a period of 12 months, whereby the company covers the costs of repairs for any defects.

By the reporting date and the date when the By the reporting date and the date when the financial statements are prepared, no claims have been received concerning this model.

QUESTION # 2A famous actor, who bought a specially designed version of the A170 model from the company last year, had an accident with a deer five days before the reporting date accident with a deer five days before the reporting date. The car was completely destroyed and the actor was badly hurt. A few days ago, the company received notification that the actor had filed a lawsuit against the company, alleging that the brakes which were guaranteed to last for two years, had failed and caused his accident. He claims Rs. 50L for the replacement of the car and another Rs.20L for medical and hospital bills and

i f l d i h k h i compensation for revenue lost during the week he spent in the hospital. The company reviewed the situation with its legal advisor who recommended that the company contest the case and strongly believes that the company will not be required to pay anything based on similar cases in the past.

Page 13: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

13

QUESTION # 3The company purchased a batch of goods from its supplier, which contained some defective items. Th b h h ld d f h The batch was then sold unopened to one of the company’s customers. The company was informed, prior to the issuance of its financial statements, that this customer won its claim for the defective product delivered – Rs. 3 L. However, under the terms of the company’s agreement with its supplier, the cost of any defect is recoverable from the supplier including along with

l d dd ( l ) f 2%penalty and an add-on (penalty) of 12%.The supplier has already indicated that it will reimburse Rs. 3.36L to the company.No provision had been recognised as it was believed that no obligation was incurred.

Anand Banka

Email: [email protected]: 98673 53743

Page 14: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

1

IAS 12 –INCOME TAXES

- Anand Banka

SCOPE

Deferred taxCurrent tax

Income tax

=

+

Page 15: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

2

RECOGNITION OF CURRENT TAX

On the basis of computation of taxTax for the year = expenseTax for the year = expenseTax payable = liabilityTax paid but recoverable = asset

MEASUREMENT OF CURRENT TAX

Applicable tax rate for that type of income

1. General rate2. Specific rates (e.g. capital gains tax rate)

Page 16: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

3

RACK YOUR BRAINS!!!

What is deferred tax?

Why is it required?

UNDERSTANDING DEFERRED TAX

Library X purchases books

costing Rs. 100 million

having a useful life of 2 years

As per the tax laws, 100% depreciation is allowed

in the first year itself

Profit before depreciation and tax was Rs. 200

million

Page 17: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

4

UNDERSTANDING DEFERRED TAX

Year 1 Year 2

Profit before depreciation and tax 200,000,000 200,000,000

Depreciation (100,000,000/2) (50,000,000) (50,000,000)

Profit before tax 150,000,000 150,000,000

Profit as per taxation laws 100,000,000 200,000,000

Current tax expense (30% of tax profits) (30,000,000) (60,000,000)

Effective tax rate 20% 40%

Profit after tax 120,000,000 90,000,000

WHY DEFERRED TAX?

Fundamental Accounting Assumptions

Going concern

Consistency

AccrualAccrual

Page 18: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

5

WHY DEFERRED TAX?

Year 1 Year 2

Profit before depreciation and tax 200,000,000 200,000,000

Depreciation (100,000,000/2) (50,000,000) (50,000,000)

Profit before tax 150,000,000 150,000,000

Profit as per taxation laws 100,000,000 200,000,000

Current tax expense (30% of tax profits) (30,000,000) (60,000,000)

Deferred tax (15,000,000) 15,000,000

Profit after tax 105,000,000 105,000,000

BALANCE SHEET METHOD

The Balance Sheet Liability method is based on

the following principles:

Asset recorded in the financials will be realised

for at least its carrying amount

in the form of future economic benefits, in future

i dperiods

that will give rise to amounts used in determination

of tax

Page 19: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

6

IMPORTANT TERMS

Timing differences are the differences between taxableincome and accounting income for a period that originate inincome and accounting income for a period that originate inone period and are capable of reversal in one or moresubsequent periods

Temporary Difference is a difference between thecarrying amount of an asset or liability and its tax baseBalance Sheet methodBalance Sheet method

Tax Base is the amount that will be deductible for taxpurposes. If the economic benefits will not be taxable, thetax base of the asset is equal to its carrying amount

TAX BASE – CASE STUDY

Cost of Machine = 100

Depreciation rate as per books = 10%

Depreciation rate as per tax = 20%

Tax Base after 1 year = ?

Page 20: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

7

TAX BASE – CASE STUDIES

Interest receivable = 100 (taxed on cash basis)

Trade receivable = 100 (related revenue taxed)

Penalties payable = 100 (not allowable as an

expense)

IMPORTANT TERMS

Taxable temporary differences are temporarydifferences that will result in taxable amounts indifferences that will result in taxable amounts indetermining taxable profit (tax loss) of futureperiods when the carrying amount of the asset orliability is recovered or settled

Deductible temporary differences aretemporary differences that will result in amountstemporary differences that will result in amountsthat are deductible in determining taxable profit(tax loss) of future periods when the carryingamount of the asset or liability is recovered orsettled

Page 21: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

8

SHORTCUT

BV f BV f BV of Assets > Tax Base

BV of Assets < Tax Base

BV of Liability

< Tax Base

BV of Liability

< Tax Base

DTL DTA DTL DTA

CASE STUDY

PPE original cost = 100Useful life = 10 yrs depreciation = 10%Useful life = 10 yrs, depreciation = 10%Tax depreciation = 20%Year 1:

Book Value = 90Tax Base = 80

Taxable Temporary Difference = 10

Page 22: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

9

CASE STUDY

Interest receivable = 100Tax Base = 0Tax Base = 0Taxable Temporary Difference = 100

CASE STUDY

Warranty Provision = 100Tax Base = 0Tax Base = 0Deductible Temporary Difference = 100

Page 23: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

10

SUMMARY

Book Value vs. Tax base= =

Temporary differences

Taxable Deductible

MEASUREMENT OF DEFERRED TAX

Applicable tax rateBased on expected manner of recoveryBased on expected manner of recovery

Use – normal tax rateSale/ disposal – capital gains

Rate enacted or substantively enacted by end of the reporting periodNo Discounting

Page 24: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

11

SUMMARY

Book Value vs. Tax base= =

Temporary differences

Taxable Deductible

Tax rate applicablepp

SPECIFIC ISSUES

Revaluation of AssetsBusiness CombinationBusiness CombinationConsolidationUndistributed ProfitsLandForeign Currency Translation Reserve (FCTR)

Page 25: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

12

REVALUATION OF ASSETS

WDV as per book as well as tax = 100Remaining useful life = 5 years i e 20% p aRemaining useful life = 5 years i.e. 20% p.a.Tax depreciation rate = 20%Revalued Amount = 150Taxable Temporary Difference = 50Reversal on

SaleExcess depreciation every year

ACCOUNTING ENTRY

R l ti R A/ D 15Revaluation Reserve A/c Dr.(50 * 30%)

15

To DTL A/c 15

Page 26: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

13

BUSINESS COMBINATION

Company A buys Company B for Rs. 1,500Book value of assets of B = 1 000Book value of assets of B = 1,000Fair value of assets of B = 1,200Goodwill = 1,500 – 1,200 = 300Taxable temporary difference = 1,200 – 1,000 = 200DTL = 200 * 30% = 60DTL 200 30% 60Goodwill = 300 + 60 = 360

ACCOUNTING ENTRY

G d ill A/ D 60Goodwill A/c Dr.(200 * 30%)

60

To DTL A/c 60

Page 27: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

14

CONSOLIDATION

Company X

(Holding)

Company Y

(Subsidiary)

Cost to X = 60

Sold to Y = 100

Consolidated Accounts

Stock = 100

Unrealised Gain = (40)Unrealised Gain (40)

Net Stock = 60

Tax Base for Y = 100

ACCOUNTING ENTRY

DTA A/ D 12DTA A/c Dr.(40 * 30%)

12

To P&L A/c 12

Page 28: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

15

LAND

Land is a non-depreciable assetAs per Income Tax Act land is eligible for As per Income Tax Act, land is eligible for indexation benefitTax base of land > Carrying amount of land

FCTR

H ldi C S b idi CHolding CompanyNet Assets Rs. 7,000

Subsidiary CompanyNet Assets $ 50

Consolidated CompanyNet Assets Rs. 9,500

FCTR Rs. 300FCTR Rs. 300

DTL on 300 @ 30% = 90

Page 29: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

16

ACCOUNTING ENTRY

FCTR A/ D 90FCTR A/c Dr.(300 * 30%)

90

To DTL A/c 90

RECOGNITION

• If the item has been OCI If the item has been recognized in OCIOCI

• If the item has been recognized in EquityEquity

• If it arises on business combinationGoodwill

• All other casesP&L

Page 30: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

17

EXAMPLES

• Revaluation of• PPE (IAS 16)PPE (IAS 16)• Intangibles (IAS 38)• AFS (IAS 39)

• FCTR (IAS 21)• Cash Flow Hedge (IAS 39)

OCI

• Compound Financial Instruments p(IAS 39)

• Adjustments to opening balance of retained earnings (IAS 8/ IFRS 1)

• Share Based Payments (IFRS 2)Equity

SUMMARY

Book Value vs. Tax base= =

Temporary differences

Taxable Deductible

Tax rate applicable

GoodwillOCI / EquityProfit or loss

Page 31: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

18

RECOGNITION OF DEFERRED TAX ASSETS

All Deferred Tax Assets – Probable CertaintyTaxable temporary differencesTaxable temporary differencesTaxable profits

CASE STUDY

Company Deductible Tax DTA Forecasted DTA p yTemporary Difference

Rate profit recognized

A 400 50% 200 1,000 ?B 400 50% 200 300 ?C 400 50% 200 (500) ?

Page 32: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

19

REASSESSMENT

Unrecognized deferred tax assetsRecognized deferred tax assetsRecognized deferred tax assets

Anand Banka

Email: [email protected]: 98673 53743

Page 33: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

1

IFRS 2/ IND-AS 102 – SHARE BASED PAYMENTS

-Anand Banka

SCOPE Share-based payments

Share-basedEquity-settledshare-based

payments

Cash-settled share-based

payments

Share based paymentswith cash

alternatives

Entity receives goods/services as consideration for

Entity receives goods/services by

incurring a liability to transfer cash or

other assets to the supplier for amounts

Either entity or the counterparty has a choice to settle in

equity instruments or equity instruments. supplier for amounts

that are based on the price (or value) of the

entity’s shares.

in cash or other assets.

e.g. Shares, Optionsagainst receipt

of services from employees

e.g. Share appreciation

rights

Page 34: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

2

EXAMPLES

Company purchases 10 sacks of rice for 100 shares

Company grants 100 ESOPs

Company gives 100 shares for 10 years’ land lease

Company gives 100 shares for advertisement in newspaper

Company buys 10 sacks of rice for 100 shares worth

(100 shares * share value on the date of delivery)(100 shares share value on the date of delivery)

ABC Ltd. obtains 60% of the equity of XYZ Ltd. by issuing

equity shares

SCOPE OUT

Transactions with employee-shareholders (in capacity of shareholders)capacity of shareholders)Transactions under business combination

Page 35: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

3

CASE STUDY

Employee holds 100 sharesEntity grants ESOP of 100 more sharesEntity grants ESOP of 100 more sharesWhether share based payment?

Entity declares bonus of 1:1 to all share holdersEmployee gets another 200 sharesEmployee gets another 200 sharesWhether share based payment?

EXAMPLE

Franco Ltd procures 75% of the shares of Macro Ltd. In the financial books of Franco Ltd, does Ltd. In the financial books of Franco Ltd, does this transaction qualify as a share based payment?

Answer:This transaction is a procurement of shares,

hi h fi i l i t t Fi i l which are financial instruments. Financial instruments are outside the scope of share-based payment. Hence this transaction does not fall within the scope of share-based payment.

Page 36: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

4

IFRS 2 VS. IAS 32/39Company E enters into a forward contract to buycertain quantity of steel at a price equal to 1000certain quantity of steel at a price equal to 1000of company E’s ordinary shares. Company E cansettle the contract net, but does not intend to doso (nor does it have a practice of doing so). Thistransaction would be with in the scope of IFRS 2.However, if company E had a practice of settlingthese contracts net, or did not intend to takethese contracts net, or did not intend to takephysical delivery, then the forward contractwould be within the scope of IAS 32 and IAS 39

RECOGNITION

EQUITY

Goods or Services received or acquired

are recognised asAsset or Expense

EQUITY (Equity settled transactions)

LIABILITY (cash settled transactions)(cash settled transactions)

Page 37: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

5

MEASUREMENT PRINCIPLESMeasurement principles

Equity-settledshare-based

payments

Cash-settledshare-based

payments

Non-employees Employees

Goods/services are measured directly

Goods/services are measured by Good/services are Goods/services aremeasured directly,

based on fair value of goods/services

received

measured by reference to fair value of equity

instruments granted

measured at the intrinsic value of the equity instruments

If not reliably measurable

If not reliably measurable (only

in very rare cases)

Goods/services are measured at the fair value of the liability

DETERMINING THE FAIR VALUE OF EQUITYINSTRUMENTS GRANTED

Fair ValueMeasure employee services indirectly, based on fair value of equity instruments grantedFair value of equity instruments measured at market price for instruments with similar terms and conditions (rarely available)If no market exists, fair value is estimated by applying an option pricing modelIf f i l i t bl li bl ( l i If fair value is not measurable reliably (only in very rare cases), then services are measured at the intrinsic value of the equity instruments

Date of measurementFair value measured at grant date

Page 38: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

6

CASE STUDY

Company buys 100 sugarcane for 10 shares

FV of Sugarcane= 10 per sugarcane

Face value of shares = 10Market value of shares =

50

SC = 1000SC = 500

or 100

CASE STUDY

Papa Ltd. is a parent entity of Beta Ltd.

Papa Ltd. transfers its own equity instruments to

the employees of Beta Ltd.

Page 39: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

7

ESOP

Grant date

Vesting period

Vesting date

Exercise period

Exercise date

Exercise price

ESOPVesting period

Vesting period - the period during which all the specifiedvesting conditions are to be satisfied

Year 1 Year 2 Year 3

Grantdate

Vestingdate

Exercisedate

Time

Grant date - the date atVesting date – the date when the vesting conditions for entitlement are satisfied

Exercise date is the datewhen awards (e.g. options) are exercised.

Grant date the date at which the entity andthe counter party have ashared understanding ofthe terms and conditions of the arrangement

Page 40: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

8

CASE STUDY

Company A agrees with its CEO to grant the CEO share options (to be vested immediately) on 31 May share options (to be vested immediately) on 31 May subject to ratification at the AGM. The company’s year- end is 30 June and the AGM is held on 31 July. The share options are ratified at the AGM and are eventually issued on 30 September.

Grant Date is Grant Date is ...31 May31 July30 September

VESTING CONDITIONS

Vesting diti

The conditions that determine whether

the entity receives the services

conditions

Service conditions

Performance conditions

Market conditions

Non-market conditions

To complete a specified Performance,

b t t k t Related to the market price of

To stay employed for 3 three years after grant

date

Revenue must increase by

10%

Share price must increase

by 15%

spec e period of service

but not market price related

pthe equity instrument

Page 41: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

9

NON-VESTING CONDITIONS

Non-vesting conditions are all requirements that do not represent service or performance p pconditions, but which have to be met in order for the counterparty to receive the share-based payment.

share-based payment arrangements in which an employee has to provide funding during the vesting period, which is then used to exercise the options;scenarios in which the entity can discontinue the share-based payment plan at its own discretion

Taken into account when estimating the fair valueSimilar to market based performance condition

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (1) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

Vesting conditions:Three years continued employment (service Three years continued employment (service condition)A performance condition (see next slide)

Assumptions:100 options granted on 1 January 2001All employees remain in service over the vesting period of the optionpe od o t e opt oGrant date fair value of each option, 3.50 (excluding market conditions)Best estimate is that the performance condition is met

Page 42: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

10

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (2) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

If market condition, e.g., share price hitting a specified levelThe estimated discount for market-based performance condition is 0 500.50Therefore grant date fair value of each option is 3.00 (3.50 - 0.50) Total compensation cost is 300

Market conditionExpense recognised:p g

Year 2001 100 Year 2002 100

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (3) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

Now, assume that at the end of 2002 the best estimate becomes that the market condition will not be met (the target share price will not be reached).will not be reached).All service conditions are expected to be met

Employee service cost of 300 is recognised even if the market condition is not met (as long as services are provided)

Market conditionExpense recognised:

Year 2001 100Year 2001 100 Year 2002 100 Year 2003 100Total 300

Page 43: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

11

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (4) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

If non-market condition, e.g., certain revenue target must be met:

G d f i l f h i i Grant date fair value of each option is 3.50Total expected compensation cost is 350Allocate over service period based on best estimate of outcomeEmployee service cost is adjusted for any forfeiture

Expected total compensation

t

Accumulated attribution

Expensed in prior period(s)

Expense incurrent year

cost2001 350 117

(350/3)*10 117

2002 350 233(350/3)*2 -117 116

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (5) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

Now, assume that at the end of 20X2 the best estimate becomes that only 50% of employees will meet the

f diti All i diti performance condition. All service conditions are expected to be met.

Expected total compensation cost

Accumulated attribution

Expensed in prior period(s)

Expense in current year

2001 350 117(350/3)*1

0 117

2002 350 117 117 02002 350

175

117

(175/3)*2

-117 0

2003 175 175(175/3)*3

-117 58

Total 175

Page 44: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

12

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (6) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

Comparison:A change in the expectation whether or not a performance condition will be met

is ignored for market-conditionsbut recognised for non-market conditions.

Market condition Non-market conditionExpense recognised:

Year 2001 100 117

Year 2002 100 0

Year 2003 100 58 Total 300 175

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (7) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

Question:What if 50% of the employees left the company at p y p ythe end of 2002? (assuming that this is split equally between employees that have fulfilled and have not fulfilled the performance condition)

Market condition Non-market conditionExpense recognised:

Year 2001 100 117

Year 2002 0 -58

Year 2003 50 29 Total 150 88

Page 45: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

13

MEASUREMENT ILLUSTRATION (8) -PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS

Question:What if only 80% of the 100 options ultimately are What if only 80% of the 100 options ultimately are exercised?

Answer:There are no subsequent adjustments after vesting date for equity-settled share-based payments!

IFRS

SUMMARY

Page 46: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

14

RELOAD FEATURE

For options with a reload feature, the reload feature shall not be taken into accountfeature shall not be taken into accountwhen estimating the fair value of options granted at the measurement date.Instead, a reload option shall be accounted for as a new option grant, if and when a reload option is subsequently granted.

AFTER VESTING DATE

No change in equityEven if no options exercisedEven if no options exercisedEven if market conditions do not get fulfilledTransfer within equity allowed

Page 47: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

15

CASE STUDY

ESOP granted for 100 sharesFV on the date of grant = 10FV on the date of grant = 10Vesting period = 2 years

ACCOUNTING ENTRIES

Particulars Dr/ Cr

Amount

Year 1Share based payment expense A/c Dr 500Option Reserve Cr 500Year 2Share based payment expense A/c Dr 500Option Reserve Cr 500Year end entriesOption Reserve A/c Dr 1,000Share Capital A/c Cr 100Securities Premium A/c Cr 900

Page 48: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

16

MODIFICATION

Separate additional expense if modifications are beneficial to employee e.g. reduction in the beneficial to employee e.g. reduction in the exercise price or vesting periodNo reduction in expenses if modification is not beneficial to employeeMinimum expense = original grant date fair value

Sit ti M difi tiSituation Modification

Decrease in exercise price

Increase in vesting period

Increase in number of shares offered

Shortening exercise period

CANCELLATION

To be accounted for on accelerated basisPayments madePayments made

To the extent of FV – deduct from equityExcess – charge to P&L

New equity instruments grantedAccounted for as modificationBeneficial – accountedN b fi i l i dNon-beneficial – ignored

Non-vesting condition not met – account for it as cancellation

Page 49: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

17

CASE STUDY

An entity grants an employee the opportunity to participate in a plan in which the employee obtains p p p p yshare options if he agrees to save 25 per cent of his monthly salary of Rs.40,000 for a three-year period. The monthly payments are made by deduction from the employee’s salary. The employee may use the accumulated savings to exercise his options at the end of three years, or take a refund of his contributions at any point during the three-year y p g yperiod. The estimated annual expense for the share-based payment arrangement is Rs.12,000.After 18 months, the employee stops paying contributions to the plan and takes a refund of contributions paid to date of Rs.180,000.

CASH SETTLED

FV of the liabilityEach year endEach year endDifference to profit or loss

Page 50: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

18

CASE STUDY

Mona Ltd manufactures and sells utensils. It buys steel from Steelcraft Ltd. Steelcraft Ltd is to buys steel from Steelcraft Ltd. Steelcraft Ltd is to be paid amount equivalent to 1,500 shares of Mona Ltd on the date when the steel is to be delivered. Does this transaction qualify as a cash-settled share based payment transaction?

Answer:This transaction involves purchase of “goods” This transaction involves purchase of goods . The amount of consideration is based on the value of the shares of Mona Ltd. Hence this qualifies as a cash-settled share based payment transaction.

STOCK APPRECIATION RIGHTS (SAR)Stock Appreciation Rights (SAR) entitle the employees to claim cash payment to the extent of employees to claim cash payment to the extent of excess of market price of underlying shares on exercise date over the exercise price. Stock Appreciation Rights are not exercised if market price of underlying shares on exercise date is less than the exercise price. SAR is therefore a call option held by employees SAR is therefore a call option held by employees. The employer recognise the value of call as expense over the vesting period.

Page 51: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

19

CASE STUDY

Company grants share appreciation rightsCurrent share value = 100Current share value = 100After one year = 110After two years = 120After third year = 130

CASH ALTERNATIVES

Counter-party has the right to chooseAccounted for as Compound Financial Accounted for as Compound Financial InstrumentDebt portion accounted as cash settledEquity portion accounted as equity settled

Entity has the right to chooseAccounted for as Equity SettledAccounted for as Cash Settled if present Accounted for as Cash Settled, if present obligationPresent obligation when settlement in equity has no commercial substance or based on past practice or stated policy

Page 52: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

20

CASE STUDIES

The following particulars in respect of stock options granted by a company are available:

CASE I

Grant date April 1, 2006Number of employees covered 525Number of options granted per employee 100Vesting condition: continuous employment for 3 yearsExercise per share(Rs.) 125 Market price per share on grant date (Rs ) 149 Market price per share on grant date (Rs.) 149 Vesting Date March 31, 2009 Exercise date March 31, 2010 Fair value of option per share on grant date (Rs.) 30

Page 53: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

21

Position on 31.3.2007Estimated annual rate of departure 2%Number of employees left=15

Position on 31.3.2008Estimated annual rate of departure 3%Number of employees left=10

Position on 31 3 2009Position on 31.3.2009Number of employees left=8

Number of employees entitled to exercise option = 492

Position on 31.3.2010

Number of employees exercising the option = 480Number of employees not exercising the option = 12

Compute expenses to recognise in each year by (i) fair value method (ii) intrinsic Value method and show important accounts in books of the Company by both of the methods.

Page 54: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

22

Year 2006-07Fair value of option per share=Rs.30

SOLUTION

Number of shares expected to be vest under the scheme = (525 X 0.98 X0.98X 0.98) X 100 = 49,400Fair value = 49,400 X Rs. 30 = Rs 14, 82,000Vesting period = 3 yearsValue of option recognized as expense in 2006-07 = Rs. 14, 82,000/3 = Rs.4, 94,000.

Year 2007-08Fair value of option per share = Rs.30Number of shares expected to be vest under the scheme = (525 –15) X 0.97 X 0.97) X 100 = 47,986Fair value = 47,986 X Rs. 30 = Rs 14, 39,580Vesting period = 3 yearsNumbers of years expired = 2 YearsCumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 2006-07 and 2007-08 = (Rs. 14,39,580/3) X 2 = Rs.9,59,720Value of option recognised as expense in 2007-08 = Rs. 9,59,720 –Rs. 4,94,000 = Rs. 4,65,720

Page 55: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

23

Year 2008-09Fair value of option per share=Rs.30Number of shares actually vested under the scheme = 492 X 100 = 49,200Fair value = 49,200 X Rs. 30 = Rs 14, 76,000Vesting period = 3 yearsCumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 3 years = Rs. 14,76,000Value of option recognised as expense in 2008-09 = Rs. 14,76,000 – Rs. 9,59,720 = Rs. 5,16,280

Year 2009-10Fair value of option per share=Rs.30Number of shares not subscribed = (492-480) X 100 = 1, 200Value of option forfeited = 1,200 X 30 = Rs. 36,000

Employees’ Compensation A/c.Year Rs Year Rs.

2006-07 To ESOP o/s A/c 4,94,000 2006-07 By P/L A/c 4,94,000

4,94,000 4,94,000

2007-08 To ESOP o/s A/c 4,65,720 2007-08 By P/L A/c 4,65,720

4,65,720 4,65,720

2008-09 To ESOP o/s A/c 5,16,280 2008-09 By P/L A/c 5,16,280

5,16,280 5,16,280

Page 56: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

24

ESOP OUTSTANDING A/CYear Rs Year Rs.

2006-07 To Balance c/d 4,94,000 2006-07 By Emp Comp A/c 4,94,000

4,94,000 4,94,000

2007-08 To Balance c/d 9,59,720 2007-08 By Bal b/d 4,94,000By Emp Comp A/c 4,65,720

9,59,720 9,59,720

2008-09 To Balance c/d 14,76,000 2008-09 By Bal b/d 9,59,720By Emp Com A/c 5,16,280

14,76,000 14,76,000

2009-10 To Gen Res(1,200 X 30)

36,000 2009-10 By Bal b/d(49,200 X 30)

14,76,000

To sh Capital(48,000 X 100)

48,00,000 By bank(48,000 X 125)

60,00,000

To Sec premium(48,000 X 55)

26,40,000

74,76,000 74,76,000

Note: Securities Premium

Rs.Exercise Price received per share 125Value of service received per share 30Consideration received per share 155Less: Nominal value per share 100Securities premium per share 55

Page 57: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

25

Intrinsic Value method

Year 2006-07Intrinsic value of option per share = Rs.149 – Rs. 125= Rs 24Number of shares expected to be vest under the scheme = (525 X 0.98 X0.98X 0.98) X 100 = 49,400Intrinsic value = 49,400 X Rs. 24 = Rs 11,85,600Vesting period = 3 yearsValue of option recognized as expense in 2006-07 = Rs Value of option recognized as expense in 2006 07 Rs. 11,85,600/3 = Rs.3,95,200

Year 2007-08

Intrinsic value of option per share = Rs.149 – Rs. 125= Rs 24Number of shares expected to be vest under the scheme = (525 –15) X 0.97 X 0.97) X 100 = 47,986Intrinsic value = 47,986 X Rs. 24 = Rs 11,51,664Vesting period = 3 yearsNumbers of years expired = 2 YearsCumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 2006-07 Cumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 2006 07 and 2007-08 = (Rs. 11,51,664/3) X 2 = Rs.7,67,776Value of option recognised as expense in 2007-08 = Rs. 7,67,776 –Rs.3,95,200 = Rs. 3,72,576

Page 58: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

26

Year 2008-09

Intrinsic value of option per share = Rs.149 – Rs. 125= Rs 24Number of shares actually vested under the scheme = 492 X 100 = 49,200Intrinsic value = 49,200 X Rs. 24 = Rs 11,80,800Vesting period = 3 yearsCumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 3 years = Rs. 11,80,800Value of option recognised as expense in 2008-09 = Rs. 11,80,800 – Rs. 7,67,776 = Rs. 4,13,024

Year 2009-10Intrinsic value of option per share = Rs.149 – Rs. 125= Rs 24Number of shares not subscribed = (492-480) X 100 = 1, 200Value of option forfeited = 1,200 X 24 = Rs. 28,800

Employee’s Compensation A/c.

Year Rs Year Rs.2006-07 To ESOP o/s A/c 3,95,200 2006-07 By P/L A/c 3,95,200

3,95,200 3,95,200

2007-08 To ESOP o/s A/c 3,72,576 2007-08 By P/L A/c 3,72,5763,72,576 3,72,576

2008-09 To ESOP o/s A/c 4,13,024 2008-09 By P/L A/c 4,13,0244,13,024 4,13,024

Page 59: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

27

Year Rs Year Rs.

2006-07 To Balance c/d 3,95,200 2006-07 By Emp Comp A/c 3,95,200

3,95,200 3,95,200

ESOP OUTSTANDING A/C

2007-08 To Balance c/d 7,67,776 2007-08 By Bal b/d 3,95,200 By Emp Comp A/c 3,72,576

7,67,776 7,67,776

2008-09 To Balance c/d 11,80,800 2008-09 By Bal b/d 7,67,776By Emp Com A/c 4,13,024

11,80,800 11,80,800

2009-10 To Gen Res(1,200 X 24)

28,800 2009-10 By Bal b/d(49,200 X 24)

11,80,800

To sh Capital(48,000 X 100)

48,00,000 By bank(48,000 X 125)

60,00,000

To Sec premium(48,000 X 49)

23,52,000

71,80,800 71,80,800

Note: Securities Premium

Rs.Exercise Price received per share 125Value of service received per share 24Consideration received per share 149Less: Nominal value per share 100Securities premium per share 49

Page 60: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

28

The following particulars in respect of stock options granted by a company are available

CASE II.

Grant date April 1.2006Number of employees covered 500 Number of options granted peremployee

100

Fair value of option per share on grantdate (Rs.)

25

Th i i d h ll b d i d b lThe vesting period shall be determined as below:

a) If the company earns Rs.120 crore or above after taxes in 2006-07, the options will vest on 31.03.2007.

b) If condition (a) is not satisfied but the company. Earns Rs. 250 crores or above after taxes in aggregate in 2006-07 and 2007-08, th ti ill t 31 03 2008the options will vest on 31.03.2008.

c) If conditions (a) and (b) are not satisfied but the company. Earns Rs. 400 crores or above after taxes in aggregate in 2006-07, 2007-08 and 2008-09, the options will vest on 31.03.2009.

Position on 31.03.2007

) Th d R 115 f i 2006 07a) The company earned Rs 115 crore after taxes in 2006-07b) The company expects to earn Rs 140 crores in 2007-08 after taxesc) Expected vesting date: March 31, 2008d) No. of employees expected to be entitled to option = 474

Page 61: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

29

Position on 31.03.2008

a) The company earned Rs 130 crore after taxes in 2007-08b) The company expects to earn Rs 160 crores in 2008-09 after taxesc) Expected vesting date: March 31, 2009d) No. of employees expected to be entitled to option = 465

Position on 31.03.2009

a) The company earned Rs. 165 crore after taxes in 2008-09b) No. of employees on whom the option actually vested = 450

Compute expenses to recognize in each year

Year 2006-07Fair value of option per share=Rs.25

SOLUTION

Number of shares expected to be vest under the scheme = 474 X 100 = 47,400Fair value = 47,400 X Rs. 25 = Rs 11,85,000Vesting period = 2 yearsValue of option recognized as expense in 2006-07 = Rs. 11,85,000/2 = Rs.5,92,500

Page 62: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

30

Year 2007-08Fair value of option per share=Rs.25Number of shares expected to be vest under the scheme = 465 X 100 = 46,500Fair value = 46,500 X Rs. 25 = Rs 11,62,500Expected vesting period = 3 yearsCumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 2006-07 and 2007-08 = (Rs. 11,62,500/3) X 2 = Rs.7,75,000Value of option recognised as expense in 2006-07 = Rs. 5,92,500Value of option recognised as expense in 2007-08 = Rs. 7,75,000 –Rs 5,92,500 = Rs. 1,82,500

Year 2008-09Fair value of option per share=Rs.25Number of shares actually vested under the scheme = 450 X 100 = 45,000Fair value = 45,000 X Rs. 25 = Rs 11,25,000Vesting period = 3 yearsCumulative value of option to recognize as expense in 3 years = Rs. 11,25,000Value of option recognised as expense in 2006-07 and 2007-08 = Rs. 7,75,000Value of option recognised as expense in 2008-09 = Rs 11,25,000 –Rs 7,75,000 = Rs 3,50,000

Page 63: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

31

Rahul Ltd has offered share options of 200 shares to each of its 1,000 employees. The vesting condition is that the employees need t i i ti l t f t 5 Th ti t

CASE III.

to remain in continuous employment for next 5 years. The estimate fair value of each share up to is Rs30. The entity estimates that 25% of the employees will leave the organization during the 5 year period.

Determine the amount to be recognized in the financial statements

SOLUTION

Step-1: Fair value on grant date = 200 X 1,000 X 30 = 6,000,000

Step-2: Cumulative charge to statement of comprehensive income:

Year1: 6,000,000 X 75% X (1/5) = 900,000Year2: 6,000,000 X 75% X (2/5) = 1,800,000Year3: 6 000 000 X 75% X (3/5) = 2 700 000Year3: 6,000,000 X 75% X (3/5) = 2,700,000Year4: 6,000,000 X 75% X (4/5) = 3,600,000Year5: 6,000,000 X 75% X (5/5) = 4,500,000

Page 64: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

32

Step 3: expense for the period:Amount calculated in 2- Amount charged in previous periodYear 1: 900,000-0 = 900,000Year 2 : 1,8000,000-900,000 = 900,000Year 3: 2,700,000-1,800,000 = 900,000Year 4: 3, 6000,000 – 2,700,000 = 900,000Year 5: 4,500,000-3,600,000 = 900,000

Pretty Ltd offers 200 shares at Rs 30 to each of its 1000 staff if they stay with them for 3 years. At the end of the first year, 15

l l d th tit ti t th t 25 % ill h l ft t

CASE IV.

employees leave and the entity estimates that 25 % will have left at the end of the vesting period. During the second year a further 15 employees leave and the entity revises its estimate of total departures over the vesting period from 25% to 27%. During the third year a further 15 employees leave the entity.

Determine the amount to be recognized in the financial statements

Page 65: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

33

SOLUTION

Step 1 - Fair value on grant date: 200 X 1,000 X 30 =6,000,000

Step 2 - Cumulative charge to Statement of comprehensive income: Year 1: 6,000,000 X 75% X (1/3) = 1,500,000Year2: 6 000 000X 73% X (2/3) = 2 920 000 Year2: 6,000,000X 73% X (2/3) 2,920,000 Year3: 5,730,000(955X 30X 200) X(3/3) =5,730,000

Step 3- Expense for the period: Amount calculated in 2 –Amount charged in previous period Year 1: 1,500,000 -0 =1,500,000Year 2: 2,920,000 – 1,500,000 = 1,420,000 Year 3: 5,730,000 -2,920,000 = 2,810,000

Page 66: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

34

On 1 October 2005, Sanjay LTD granted 100 employees options to purchase 100 shares in the entity. The options

CASE V.

vest on 1 October 2007 for those employees who remain employed by the entity until that date. The options allow the employees to purchase the shares for Rs. 9 per share. The market price of the shares was Rs9 on 1 October 2005 and Rs9.5 on 1 Oct 2006. The market values of options was Rs3 on 1 Oct 2005 and Rs3.60 on 1 Oct 2006.On 1 Oct 2005, the directors estimated that 10% of the relevant employees would leave in each of the years ended 30 sep employees would leave in each of the years ended 30 sep 2006 and 30 sep 2007 respectively. It turned out that 2% of the relevant employees left in the year ended 30 sep 2006 and directors now believe that a further 6% will leave in the year ended 30 sep 2007.

This transaction is an example of an equity-settled share-based payment transaction that is accounted for in accordance with IFRS 2 h b d t S h t ti d

SOLUTION

IFRS 2 – share-based payment. Such transactions are measured using the, market value of the, relevant equity instrument on the grant date. In this case, the relevant market value is Rs.3 (market value of the share option on 1 October 2005). The cost of the grant is taken to statement of comprehensive income over the two-year vesting period. Where the grant is subject to future employment or future conditions then the latest known estimates of the extent of performance are used to determine the total cost. This means that in this case the total charge to the statement of that, in this case, the total charge to the statement of comprehensive income will be: 100 X 92 X 3 = Rs. 27,600. In the year ended 30 September 2006, 1/2 of this amount, i.e. Rs. 14,700, is debited to income as an operating cost and credited to equity.

Page 67: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

35

On 1 April 2004 Saurav limited granted 50 executives call options to purchase up to 1000 shares each on 1 April 2006. The options only vest if the executives are still employed on 1 April 2006. Personnel estimate that 95% of executives will remain for the 2 year period and exercise their

CASE VI.

95% of executives will remain for the 2 year period and exercise their options in full:

i. The option price is Rs10 per shareii. The market value of each share was Rs15 on 1 April 2004 and Rs18 on

31st March 2005. It is Rs19 on 31st March 2006.iii. The market value of share option was Rs3 on 1 April 2004 and Rs2.20

on 31st march 2005 It is Rs2 25 on 31st March 2006on 31 march 2005. It is Rs2.25 on 31 March 2006.

State where in the statement of financial position and where in the statement of comprehensive income the relevant amounts will be presented. Where appropriate, you should justify your treatment with reference to the relevant international financial reporting standards.

The market value of a Share options on 1April 2004 was Rs. 3 and so the market value of a Share options is Rs.3 X 50 X 1,000 X 95% R 142 500 Si th h ti i b d i

SOLUTION

95% = Rs. 142,500 Since the share option is based on service over a two-year period then the charge to income for the current year is ½ i.e. Rs. 71,250. An equivalent amount will be credited to equity and will be included in the future proceeds of issue of the shares, assuming the options are exercised

Page 68: IAS 37 – PROVISIONS CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND …ymec.in/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Recognition-Measurement-of-liabilities.pdfIAS 37 – PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND CONTINGENT

36

Anand BankaEmail: [email protected]: 98673 53743