I need to do an evaluation
-
Upload
lane-walter -
Category
Documents
-
view
22 -
download
2
description
Transcript of I need to do an evaluation
This slide deck is part of a presentation given by Saul Greenberg at a UIST 2007 panel on Evaluating user interface systems research (see paper by Dan Olson in ACM DL)
Its content was based on a paper written by Saul Greenberg and Bill Buxton, available at:
http://grouplab.cpsc.ucalgary.ca/papers/2007/07-UsabilityHarmful-Greenberg-Report/07-usabilityHarmful-report2007-879-31.pdf
TimeLe
arn
ing
Brian Gaines
Breakthroughmajor creative advances
Replicationideas mimicked and altered; increasing experience
Empiricismlessons formulated as empirical design rules
Theoryunderlying causal systems
Automationaccepted
Maturityused routinely
Breakthrough Replication Empiricism Theory Automation Maturity
Interface validation and refinement*
Evaluation sweet spot
*70% quantitative, 30% qualitative
Unimplemented and untested design. Microfilm is impractical. The work is premature.
Resubmit after you build and evaluate this design.
Complex controls,overly simplistic drawings
Recommend you evaluate a trained draftsman using Sketchpad vs. paper and pencil with real drafting tasks
TimeLe
arni
ng
Brian Gaines
Breakthrough Replication Empiricism Theory Automation MaturityBreakthrough Replication Empiricism Theory Automation Maturity
Interface validation
Sketches Cultural appropriation