I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... ·...

23
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS DIVISION OF ST. CROIX MOHAMMAD NAMED by His Authorized ) Agent WALEED HAMED, ) ) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff, ) v. ) ACTION FOR DAMAGES ) INJUNCTIVE AND FATHI YUSUF and UNITED CORPORATION,) DECLARATORY RELIEF ) Defendants. ) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ) PLAINTIFF HAMED'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' "EMERGENCY MOTION" RE BOND Plaintiff Hamed, by and through its undersigned counsel, opposes the "Emergency Motion" filed by Defendants on December 16, 2013. Interestingly, Defendants chose to file this "emergency motion" without first responding to Plaintiff's pending motion to partially reconsider /clarify the Bond Order. In any event, for the reasons set forth herein, Plaintiff respectfully submits that this "emergency motion" be denied until this Court can address the December 16th motion for reconsideration. I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in this Jurisdiction and not a Refusal to Post Bond The posting of a non -cash bond consisting of property is common in this jurisdiction, as has been noted very recently by the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands, the Appellate Division of the District Court and the District Court itself. Most importantly, in First Am. Dey. Group v. WESTLB, et al., 2012 WL 1526100 at *5 (D.V.I. April 30, i As noted in that motion, it was filed 3 days after the receipt of the Bond Order. See Exhibit 1 to Plaintiff's December 13th motion. Hence, it can hardly be said that Plaintiff is not diligently paying attention to this Court's Bond Order. Indeed, since the filing of that motion, Plaintiff has been obtaining title reports to demonstrate that the real property being offered as collateral is free and clear of any liens.

Transcript of I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... ·...

Page 1: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDSDIVISION OF ST. CROIX

MOHAMMAD NAMED by His Authorized )

Agent WALEED HAMED, )

) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370Plaintiff, )

v. ) ACTION FOR DAMAGES) INJUNCTIVE AND

FATHI YUSUF and UNITED CORPORATION,) DECLARATORY RELIEF)

Defendants. ) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED)

PLAINTIFF HAMED'S OPPOSITIONTO DEFENDANTS' "EMERGENCY MOTION" RE BOND

Plaintiff Hamed, by and through its undersigned counsel, opposes the

"Emergency Motion" filed by Defendants on December 16, 2013. Interestingly,

Defendants chose to file this "emergency motion" without first responding to Plaintiff's

pending motion to partially reconsider /clarify the Bond Order. In any event, for the

reasons set forth herein, Plaintiff respectfully submits that this "emergency motion" be

denied until this Court can address the December 16th motion for reconsideration.

I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in thisJurisdiction and not a Refusal to Post Bond

The posting of a non -cash bond consisting of property is common in this

jurisdiction, as has been noted very recently by the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands,

the Appellate Division of the District Court and the District Court itself. Most importantly,

in First Am. Dey. Group v. WESTLB, et al., 2012 WL 1526100 at *5 (D.V.I. April 30,

i As noted in that motion, it was filed 3 days after the receipt of the Bond Order. SeeExhibit 1 to Plaintiff's December 13th motion. Hence, it can hardly be said that Plaintiff isnot diligently paying attention to this Court's Bond Order. Indeed, since the filing of thatmotion, Plaintiff has been obtaining title reports to demonstrate that the real propertybeing offered as collateral is free and clear of any liens.

Page 2: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaintiff's Opposition to Emergency MotionPage 2

2012), the Supreme Court of the Virgin Islands approved the filing of real property as

security for a bond (in a case where Defendants' counsel was counsel in that case as

well), holding in part:

Consequently, if First American wishes to effectuate the stay of the execution ofthe Superior Court's August 24, 2011 Judgment, it must post a bond counter-signed by a qualified surety or secured by unencumbered property of a valueequal to or greater than the bond with the Superior Court .... (Emphasisadded).

See also, Milligan v. Khodra, 46 VI 305, 2004 WL 3383654 at *10 (D.V.I. App. Div.

2004)( "bond can be cash, property or surety bond "); Marrero v. United Indus., Serv.

Transp., Profl & Gov't Workers of N. Am., 2012 WL 2865970 at *1 (D.V.I. July 12,

2012). ( "Courts in this jurisdiction have permitted the posting of property bonds in lieu of

a cash bond ").2

Indeed, in remanding this case, the Supreme Court did not criticize this Court's

use of other security in the form of escrowed profits, it simply held that these profits

could not be used because of the encumbrance created by the TRO in the criminal

case.

2 While these cases deal with a supersedeas bond under Rule 62(c), both Rule 62(c)and Rule 65(c) use the term "security" so this distinction is moot. See e.g. Nichols v.Deutsche Bank Nat. Trust Co., CIV. 07CV2039 -L NLS, 2007 WL 4181111 (S.D. Cal.Nov. 21, 2007):

As security pursuant to Rule 65(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, thedeed of trust shall remain on the Property as security for the payment of suchcosts and damages as may be incurred or suffered by any party who is found tohave been wrongfully enjoined or restrained.

Page 3: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaintiff's Opposition to Emergency MotionPage 3

Thus, the request to clarify this Court's Bond Order is not novel or without merit.

Moreover, in Frank C. Pollara Grp., LLC v. Ocean View Inv. Holding, 9 -60, 2013 WL

5135690 (D.V.I. Sept. 13, 2013), the District Court, after noting it has discretion in the

posting of security, just this year allowed real property to be posted as a bond, using

the amount of the tax assessment of the property as its value, as proposed by

Plaintiff here.

In short, there has been no refusal to post a bond as suggested by Defendants,

simply clarification so the bond can be posted using unencumbered property.

II. The Amount of the Bond

Aside from the fact that Plaintiff has also requested a reduction in the bond of

$100,000 because Defendants have conceded they are no longer considering

amending the in the case (upon which this based),

two additional points need to be noted.

First, in calculating the bond, this Court relied on the salaries of the managers as

being $347,000, which included $61,000 in the annual bonus and vacation pay of each

manager, which figures were submitted by Defendants. See ¶3 of Gaffney declaration

attached as Exhibit 1 to Defendants' May 9th motion to amend bond. Using this figure,

this Court found that half of this salary was the cost that would be needed to replace the

four current Flamed managers. However, Defendants have now stated in writing that

they will not pay this $61,000 payment this year, which they have refused to rescind

despite being told that this unilateral change violates the terms of the preliminary

injunction. See Exhibit A. Thus, unless these bonuses and vacation pay are paid, the

bond also needs be reduced accordingly since Defendants represented to this Court

Page 4: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaintiff's Opposition to Emergency MotionPage 4

that this amount was part of each manager's current salary, which this Court then used

to calculate the bond.3

Second, the bond includes $695,000 to cover one -half of the four Flamed salaries

going forward. At the very least, Plaintiff should be given the option of having his four

sons forego this portion of their salaries if this Court choses not to accept a property

bond, as no bond is needed to secure this amount ($695,000) if this portion of their

salaries is not actually being paid going forward.

It is respectfully submitted that this Court should dutifully consider all of these

issues -the posting of property, the reduction in the amount required where appropriate

and the alternatives that exist regarding the amount of the bond -before granting the

drastic remedy of dissolving an injunction that has been in place for almost eight months

without incident. Indeed, Defendants did not even address the bond issue for over six

weeks after the Supreme Court's September 30th ruling, confirming this is not as much

of an urgent issue as a tactical one to try to change the status quo without regard to the

merits of the case.

3In its motion to reconsider /clarify the bond, Plaintiff proposed to use this sum --fourtimes $61,000 less taxes, or approximately $200,000 --as part of the bond in this case,so a reduction of $200,000 would be an appropriate reduction to deal with this issue. Itwould also moot the need to file a motion addressing this issue if the payment is notmade, as these payments have been paid on a regular basis well before the injunctionwas entered, as noted in the attached summary documents. See Exhibit B. Indeed,that is why Gaffney listed this amount as part of the manager's regular salary.

Page 5: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaintiff's Opposition to Emergency MotionPage 5

III. Conclusion

Clearly the "emergency motion" is designed to prevent this Court from being able

to carefully consider the motion to reconsider /clarify the Bond Order, including

alternative solutions that will secure Defendants as required by Rule 65(c), while

allowing the status quo to continue while the case proceeds on the merits. Indeed,

$795,000 of the required $1,200,000 (the $100,000 no longer needed in the criminal

case and the $695,000 in future salaries) has still not been incurred. As such, it is

respectfully submitted that Defendants' emergency motion should be denied, as the

motion to reconsider /clarify will result in an adequate bond being timely posted.

Dated: December 23, 2013Jo r . It, Esq.Cyur'se for Plaintiff

w Offices of Joel H. Holt132 Company Street,

Christiansted, VI 00820Email: holtvi @aol.comTele: (340) 773 -8709Fax: (340) 773 -8677

Carl J. Hartmann Ill, Esq.Co- Counsel for Plaintiff5000 Estate Coakley Bay,Unit L -6Christiansted, VI 00820Email: carl @carlhartmann.comTele: (340) 719 -8941

Page 6: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaintiff's Opposition to Emergency MotionPage 6

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on this 23rd day of December, 2013, I served a copy of theforegoing in compliance with the parties consent, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 5(b)(2)(E),to electronic service of all documents in this action on the following persons:

Nizar A. DeWoodThe DeWood Law Firm2006 Eastern Suburb, Suite 101Christiansted, VI [email protected]

Gregory H. HodgesVI Bar No. 174Law House, 10000 Frederiksberg GadeP.O. Box 756ST. Thomas, VI 00802ghodges©a,dtflaw.com !qx

Page 7: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDSDIVISION OF ST. CROIX

MOHAMMAD NAMED, )

) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370Plaintiff,

) ACTION FOR DAMAGES,v. ) INJUNCTIVE AND

) DECLARATORY RELIEFFATHI YUSUF and UNITED CORPORATION, )

Defendants. ) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

DECLARATION OF JOEL H. HOLT

I, Joel H. Holt, declare, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Section 1746, as follows:

1. I am counsel of record for the Plaintiff and have personal knowledge of theforegoing facts.

2. Fathi Yusuf sent a memo, a copy of which is attached, stating that no vacationpay or bonuses will be paid this year.

3. Plaintiff believes this decision violates the April 25th Preliminary Injunction Order,which provides that no unilateral action may be taken that affects the operationsof the three Plaza Extra Supermarket stores as they have been operated prior tothis commencement of this litigation. In this regard, these bonuses and vacationpay have been considered part of the regular salary of the seven Yusuf andHamed managers, as noted in ¶3 of Gaffney's declaration submitted to this Courtby Defendants in support of their May 9th motion to amend the bond.

4. However, when asked to reconsider this directive that no bonuses or vacation bepaid, Defendants' counsel, Nizar DeWood, stated that these bonuses andvacation pay would not be paid.

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

Dated: December 23, 2103 L

EXHIBIT

l

Page 8: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

f

PLAZ EXTRA EAST

EXHIBIT

6

Page 9: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

PLAZA EXTRA (EAST) BONU

WADDA E. CHARRIEZMARY S. GONZALEZLAVEINA BARTLETTEJACEIVER BARTLETTEALBERTO MALDONADOMICHAELINA HENRYFATHI HANNUNCHRITUS THEOPHILUSCLARIS JOSEPHRAYMOND WILLIAMSFUAD MAHMOUDJUAN CONCEPCIONJOAQUIN ORTIZMANUELA LIMAWALLY NAMEDMUFEED HAMEDYUSUF YUSUFMONICA LLOYDGERRY SEERAMNEALYSA ARMSTRONGREUEL SALTERS

2010

OFFICE MANAGERACCOUNTS PAYABLEASST. ACCOUNT PAYABLESRECEIVABLEGROCERY MANAGERFLOOR MANAGER

PRODUCE MANAGERWAREHOUSERECEIVING

DAIRY MANAGERSECURITYSECURITYMEAT MANAGERMEAT CLERKGENERAL MANAGERMANAGERMANAGERDELI -BAI{ MANAGERPRODUCE ASST.COMPUTER ROOMFROZEN MANAGER

TOTAL

$4,500.00$3,000.00$1,000.00

$500.00$2,000.00$4,500.00$2,000.00$2,500.00$1,000.00$3,500.00$3,000.00$7,000.00$9,000.00$1,000.00

$50,000.00$50,000.00 L-1$50,000.00 ""'"

$250.00$2,000.00

$500.00$2,000.00

$199,250.00

Page 10: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

PLAZA EXTRA (EAST) BONU 2011)

WADDA E. CHARRIEZLAVEINA BARTLETTEMARY S. GONZALEZJACEIVER BARTLETTEALBERTO MALDONADOMICI-IAELINA HENRYFATHI HANNUNCHRISTUS THEOPHILUSCLARIS JOSEPHRAYMOND WILLIAMSFUAD MAHMOUDJUAN CONCEPCIONJOAQUIN ORTIZWALLY NAMEDMUFEED HAMEDYUSUF YUSUFMONICA LLOYDGERRY SEERAMNEALYSA ARMSTRONGREUEL SALTERSTROY WILLIAMS

OFFICE MANAGEROFFICE ASST.ACCOUNTS PAYABLERECEIVABLEGROCERY MANAGERFLOOR MANAGER

WAREHOUSE MANAGERWAREHOUSERECEIVINGDAIRY MANAGERSECURITYSECURITYMEAT MANAGERGENERAL MANAGERMANAGERMANAGERDELI -BAK MANAGERPRODUCE ASST.COMPUTER ROOMFROZEN MANAGERVALUE PACK

4500.001000.00

3,000.00750.00

2,000.004,500.002,000.002,500.001,000.00

3,500.003,000.007,000.009,000.00

50,000.0050,000.0050,000.00

500.002,000.00

500.002,000.001000.00

TOTAL 199,750.00

Page 11: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

PLAZA EXTRA (EAST) BOND 2412

WADDA E. CHARRIEZLAVEINA BARTLETTEMARY S. GONZALEZSABRINA MOTILALALBERTO MALDONADOMICHAELINA HENRYFATHI HANNUNCHRISTUS THEOPHILUSCLARIS JOSEPHRAYMOND WILLIAMSFUAD MAHMOUDJUAN CONCEPCIONJOAQUIN ORTIZWALLY HAMEDMUFEED HAdv1EDYUSUF YUSUFMONICA LLOYDGERRY SEERAMREUEL SALTERSTROY WILLIAMSKIZMA PETERSENKATISHA KING

OFFICE MANAGEROFFICE ASST.ACCOUNTS PAYABLERECEIVABLEGROCERY MANAGERFLOOR MANAGER

WAREHOUSE MANAGERWAREHOUSERECEIVINGDAIRY MANAGERSECURITYSECURITYMEAT MANAGERGENERAL MANAGERMANAGERMANAGERDELI -BAK MANAGERPRODUCE ASST.FROZEN MANAGERVALUE PACKFRONT ENDASST. FLOOR/FRONT

4500.001000.00

3,000.00500.00

2,000.004,500.002,000.002,500.001,000.00

3,500.003,000.007,000.009,000.00

50,000.00 Zs"-50,000.0050,000.00

500.002,000.002,000.001000.00500.00500.00

TOTAL 200,000.00

Page 12: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

PLAZ EXTRA WEST

Page 13: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaza Extra WestBonus 2010

NameKhalil Ahmad

Myra SenhouseVeronica CruzClara ModesteLissette Lima

Salomòn LaurencinJuan LedesmaOrlando GarciaPatricia Martin

Iris OsorloKaren Quinn

Virg!lio HenriquezAbdelkrem Boucenna

Victor PetersenTrevor SablonMarva SamsonKenia WalcottMaher Yusuf

Hisham HamedMarian James

Mary JnDapliisteRaymond Davis

PositionWarehouse Manager

Office ClerkOffice ClerkOffice ClerkOffice Clerk

Meat ManagerAsst. Meat Manager

FrozenMeat ClerkMeat Clerk

Computer Room ManagerProduce ManagerGrocery Manager

GroceryFloor ManagerDeli Manager

Asst. Deli ManagerGeneral Manager

Asst. General ManagerGrocery ClerkGrocery ClerkDairy Manager

Amount$6;090.00$3,500.00$600,00

$2,000.00$3,500.00.$8,000.00$3,500:00$1,500.00$800.00$750.00

$3,000,00$2;000.00

$20,000:00$1,500:00$3,000:00$750.00$500.{)0

$50,000-00$50,000.00 Li'$1,500 00$800.00

$2,000.00

Total $165,200.00

Page 14: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaza .E ctira \NestBonus 2011

NameKhalil Ahmad

Myra SenhouseVeronica CruzClara ModesteLrssette Lima

Salomon LaurencinJuan LedesmaOrlando Garcia

Iris OsorioKaren Quinn

Abdelkrem BoucennaTrevor SablonMarva SamsonMaher Yusuf

Hisham HomedManan James

Mary JnBaptisteJess Isaie

PositionWarehouse Manager

Office ClerkOffice ClerkOffice ClerkOffice Clerk

Meat ManagerAsst. Meat Manager

FrozenMeat Clerk

Computer Room ManagerGrocery Manager

Floor ManagerDeli Manager

Genera! ManagerMat. General Manager

Grocery ClerkGrocery Clerk

Warehouse Assistant

Amount56.000 00$3.500.00$600.00

$2.000.00$3.500.00$8,000.00$3 500.00$1,500 00$750.00

$3,000 00$24,000.00$3,000.00$750.00

$50,000 00$50,000.00$1,500.00$800.00

S 1.000.00

Total 5163,400.00

Page 15: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

Plaza Extra WestBonus 2012

NameKhalil Ahmad

Myra SenhouseVeronica CruzClara ModesteLissette Lima

Salomon LaurencinJuan LedesmaOrlando Garcia

Iris OsorioKaren Quinn

Abdelkrem BoucennaTrevor SablonMarva SamsonMaher Yusuf

Hisham NamedMarian James

Mary JnBaptisteJess !sale

Alfredo Nieves

PositionWarehouse Manager

Office ClerkOffice ClerkOffice ClerkOffice Clerk

Meat ManagerAsst. Meat Manager

FrozenMeat Clerk

Computer Room ManagerGrocery ManagerFloor ManagerDeli Manager

General ManagerAsst. General Manager

Grocery ClerkGrocery Clerk

Warehouse AssistantProduce Manager

AmountS6.000.00$3,500.00$600.00

$2.000.00$3.500.00$8,000.00$3,500.00$1,500.00$750.00

$3,000.00$24.000.00$3,000.00S750.00

$50,000.00S50,000.00$1,500.00$800.00

$1.000.00$2,000.00

Total $165,400.00

Page 16: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

PLAZA EXTRA

ST. THOMAS

Page 17: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

12/2

9/10

at 1

5:13

:04.

31P

age:

28

Filt

er C

riter

ia in

clud

es: R

epo

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion

Pay

roll

Reg

iste

rF

or th

e P

erio

d F

rom

Dec

31,

201

0 t

rt o

rder

is b

y C

heck

Dat

e. R

epor

t is

prin

ted

in D

etai

l For

mat

.

Em

ploy

ee ID

Em

ploy

eeM

aske

d S

S N

oR

efer

ence

Dat

e

Pay

Typ

eP

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssM

edic

alln

sG

arni

shm

ent

Soc

_Sec

_ER

Med

ical

lns

Fed

_Inc

ome

Em

piLo

anM

AS

AM

edic

are_

ER

Soc

_Sec

Chi

ldC

are

Cas

hDra

wer

FU

TA

ER

Med

icar

eH

ighe

rEdu

cA

FLA

CS

UI_

ER

5800

8368

8S

alar

y75

0.00

596.

1175

0.00

-96.

51-4

6.50

-10.

88R

ICH

AR

DS

, CH

ER

YL

XX

X -

XX

-36

8814

1769

-46.

50-1

0.88

12/3

1 /1

0

5800

8920

1S

alar

y9,

000.

005,

784.

669,

000.

00-2

,526

.84

-558

.00

-130

.50

FR

EY

LIN

GE

R, G

ER

AR

XX

X -

XX

-92

0114

1770

-558

.00

-130

.50

12/3

1/10

5800

9101

3S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,5

21.0

050

,000

.00

-16,

754.

00-7

25.0

00_

__/

YU

SU

F, F

AT

HI

XX

X -

XX

-10

1314

1771

-725

.00

12/3

1/10

5801

3906

8S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,5

94.7

050

,000

.00

-16,

680.

30-7

25.0

00

HA

ME

D, W

AH

EE

D M

.X

XX

-X

X -

9068

1417

72-7

25.0

012

/31

/10

5801

5186

1S

alar

y40

0.00

341.

5.9

400.

00-2

7.81

-24.

80-5

.80

IND

US

TR

IOU

S, J

UD

ITX

XX

-X

X -

1861

1417

73-2

4.80

-5.8

012

/31/

10

5801

6149

3S

alar

y40

0.00

341.

5940

0.00

-27.

81-2

4.80

-5.8

0JA

CK

SO

N, M

AU

RE

EN

XX

X -

XX

-14

9314

1774

-24.

80-5

.80

12/3

1/10

5801

6852

1S

alar

y30

0.00

272.

7230

0.00

-4.3

3-1

8.60

-4.3

5B

RA

TH

WA

ITE

, CA

RIN

XX

X -

XX

-85

2114

1775

-18.

60-4

.35

12/3

1/10

Page 18: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

1212

9(10

at 1

5:13

:04.

33P

age:

29

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion

Pay

roll

Reg

iste

rF

or th

e P

erio

d F

rom

Dec

31,

201

0 to

Dec

31, 2

010

Filt

er C

riter

ia in

clud

es: R

epor

t ord

er is

by

Che

ck D

ate.

Rep

ort i

s pr

inte

d in

Det

ail F

orm

at.

Em

ploy

ee ID

Em

ploy

eeM

aske

d S

S N

oR

efer

ence

Dat

e

Pay

Typ

eP

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssM

edic

alln

sG

arni

shm

ent

Soc

_Sec

_ER

Med

ical

lns

Fed

_Inc

ome

Em

plLo

anM

AS

AM

edic

are_

ER

Soc

Sec

Chi

ld-C

are

Cas

hDra

wer

FU

TA

_ER

Med

icar

eH

ighe

rEdu

cA

FLA

CS

UI_

ER

5801

6921

6S

alar

y12

5.00

100.

4412

5.00

-15.

00-7

.75

-1.8

1LA

KE

-K

ING

, JE

NN

IFE

RX

XX

-X

X -

9216

1417

76-7

.75

-1.8

112

/31/

10

5801

6965

9S

alar

y50

0.00

440.

0050

0.00

-21.

75-3

1.00

-7.2

5M

AD

UR

O, J

ULI

AX

XX

-X

X -

9659

1417

77-3

1.00

-7.2

512

/31/

10

5801

7598

8S

alar

y17

,000

.00

10,2

91.5

017

,000

.00

-5,4

08.0

0-1

,054

.00

-246

.50

GU

MB

S, W

EN

TW

OR

TX

XX

-X

X -

5988

1417

78-1

,054

.00

-246

.50

12/3

1/10

5802

5384

0S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,5

21.0

050

,000

.00

-16,

754.

00-7

25.0

0Y

US

UF

, NA

JEH

F.

XX

X -

XX

-38

4014

1779

-725

.00

12/3

1/10

5803

3939

2S

alar

y2,

500.

001,

903.

502,

500.

00-4

05.2

5-1

55.0

0-3

6.25

DE

LA

RO

SA

CA

ST

ILL

XX

X -

XX

-93

9214

1780

-155

.00

-36.

2512

/31/

10

5803

5810

1S

alar

y3,

000.

002,

101.

823,

000.

00-6

68.6

8-1

86.0

0-4

3.50

MA

HD

, MA

'MO

UN

F.

XX

X -

XX

-81

0114

1781

-186

.00

-43.

5012

/31/

10

5803

7269

8S

alar

y10

0.00

67.7

310

0.00

-20.

00-6

,20

-1.4

5E

SP

RIT

, LIN

DA

L.

XX

X -

XX

-26

98-4

.62

1417

82-6

.20

-1.4

5-0

.80

12/3

1/10

Page 19: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

1141

12 a

t 09:

03 :0

1.31

Pag

e: 2

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion*

Payr

oll R

egis

ter

For

the

Peri

od F

rom

Dec

30,

201

1 to

Dec

30,

201

1F

ilter

Crit

eria

incl

udes

: Rep

ort o

rder

is b

y C

heck

Dat

e. R

epor

t is

prin

ted

in D

etai

l For

mat

.

Em

ploy

ee ID

Pay

Typ

eP

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssF

ed_I

ncom

eS

oc_S

ecM

edic

are

Em

ploy

eeM

edic

alin

sE

mpl

Loan

Chi

ldC

are

Hig

herE

duc

Mas

ked

SS

No

Gar

nish

men

tM

AS

AC

ash

D r

awer

AF

LAC

Ref

eren

ceP

reT

xAF

LAC

Pre

TxC

IGN

AS

oc_S

ec_E

RM

edic

are_

ER

Dat

eF

UT

A_E

RS

UI_

ER

Med

ical

lns_

5800

6733

4R

egul

ar25

0.00

235.

8725

0.00

-10.

50-3

.63

JOS

EP

H B

LYD

EN

, CH

XX

X -

XX

-73

3415

1102

-15.

50-3

.63

12/3

0/11

5800

6839

7R

egul

ar15

0.00

117.

5615

0.00

-23.

96-6

.30

-2.1

8A

BR

AH

AM

, DIA

NE

C.

XX

X -

XX

-83

9715

1103

-9.3

0-2

.18

12/3

0/11

5800

7188

9R

egul

ar30

0.00

262.

9530

0.00

-20.

10-1

2.60

-4.3

5

CA

ST

RO

, CA

RLO

SX

XX

-X

X -

1889

1511

04-1

8.60

-4.3

5

12/3

0/11

5800

8320

4R

egul

ar10

0.00

94.3

510

0.00

-4.2

0-1

.45

BE

LL, A

NT

OIN

ET

TE

E.

XX

X -

XX

-32

0415

1105

-6.2

0-1

.45

12/3

0/11

5800

8368

8R

egul

ar75

0.00

604.

7475

0.00

-102

.88

-31.

50-1

0.88

RIC

HA

RD

S, C

HE

RY

LX

XX

-X

X -

3688

1511

06-4

6.50

-10.

88

12/3

0/11

5800

8920

1S

alar

y9,

000.

005,

974.

079,

000.

00-

2,51

7.43

-378

.00

-130

.50

FR

EY

LIN

GE

R, G

ER

AR

XX

X -

XX

-92

0115

1107

-558

.00

-130

.50

12/3

0/11

5800

9101

3S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,5

32.0

950

,000

.00

-16,

742.

91-7

25.0

0

YU

SU

F, F

AT

HI

XX

X -

XX

-10

1315

1108

12/3

0/11

-725

.00

Page 20: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

1/4/

12 a

t 09:

03 :0

1.33

Pag

e: 3

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion*

Payr

oll R

egis

ter

For

the

Peri

od F

rom

Dec

30,

201

1 to

Dec

30,

201

1F

ilter

Crit

eria

incl

udes

: Rep

ort o

rder

is b

y C

heck

Dat

e. R

epor

t is

prin

ted

in D

etai

l For

mat

.

Em

ploy

ee ID

Pay

Typ

eP

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssF

ed_I

ncom

eS

oc_S

ecM

edic

are

Em

ploy

eeM

edic

alln

sE

rnpl

Loan

Chi

ldC

are

Hig

herE

duc

Mas

ked

SS

No

Gar

nish

men

tM

AS

AC

ash

Dra

wer

AF

LAC

Ref

eren

ceP

reT

xAF

LAC

Pre

TxC

IGN

AS

oc_S

ec _

ER

Med

icar

e_E

RD

ate

FU

TA

ER

SU

LER

Med

ical

lns_

5801

3906

8S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,6

06.8

050

,000

.00

-16,

668.

20-7

25.0

0N

AM

ED

, WA

HE

ED

M.

XX

X -

XX

-90

6815

1109

-725

.00

12/3

0/11

5801

6149

3R

egul

ar50

0.00

421.

6550

0.00

-50.

10-2

1.00

-7.2

5JA

CK

SO

N, M

AU

RE

EN

XX

X -

XX

-14

9315

1110

-31.

00-7

,25

12/3

0/11

5801

6852

1R

egul

ar40

0.00

352.

9840

0.00

-24.

42-1

6.80

-5.8

0B

RA

TH

WA

ITE

, CA

RIN

XX

X -

XX

-85

2115

1111

-24.

80-5

.80

12/3

0/11

5801

6921

6R

egul

ar12

5.00

102.

9412

5.00

-15.

00-5

.25

-1.8

1

LAK

E -

KIN

G, J

EN

NIF

ER

XX

X -

XX

-92

1615

1112

-7.7

5-1

.81

12/3

0/11

5801

6965

9R

egul

ar50

0.00

471.

7550

0.00

-21.

00-7

.25

MA

DU

RO

, JU

LIA

XX

X -

XX

-96

5915

1113

-31.

00-7

.25

12/3

0/11

5801

7080

6R

egul

ar50

0.00

471.

7550

0.00

-21.

00-7

.25

DO

RS

ET

, KA

RE

EM

AX

XX

-X

X -

0806

1511

14-3

1.00

-7.2

5

12/3

0/11

5801

7598

8S

alar

y17

,000

.00

10, 5

64.8

117

,000

.00

-5,4

74.6

9-7

14.0

0-2

46.5

0

GU

MB

S, W

EN

TW

OR

TX

XX

-X

X -

5988

1511

1512

/30/

11-1

,054

.00

-246

.50

Page 21: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

1141

12 a

t 09:

03:0

1.33

Pag

e: 4

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion*

Pay

roll

Reg

iste

rF

or th

e P

erio

d F

rom

Dec

30,

201

1 to

Dec

30,

201

1F

ilter

Crit

eria

incl

udes

: Rep

ort o

rder

is b

y C

heck

Dat

e. R

epor

t is

prin

ted

in D

etai

l For

mat

.

Em

ploy

ee ID

Pay

Typ

eP

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssF

ed_t

ncom

eS

oc_S

ecM

edic

are

Em

ploy

eeM

edic

alln

sE

mpl

Loan

Chi

ldC

are

Hig

herE

duc

Mas

ked

SS

No

Gar

nish

men

tM

AS

AC

ashD

raw

erA

FLA

CR

efer

ence

Pre

TxA

FLA

CP

reT

xCIG

NA

Soc

_Sec

_ER

Med

icar

e E

RD

ate

FU

TA

_ER

SU

I_E

RM

edic

alln

s

5802

1266

3R

egul

ar15

0.00

137.

6715

0.00

-3.8

5-6

.30

-2.1

8R

ED

D, B

RIT

TA

NY

L.

XX

X -

XX

-26

6315

1116

-9.3

0-2

.18

12/3

0/11

5802

5384

0S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,5

56.9

950

,000

.00

-16,

718.

01-7

25.0

0Y

US

UF

, NA

JEH

F.

XX

X -

XX

-38

4015

1117

-725

.00

12/3

0/11

5802

7034

9R

egul

ar10

0.00

94.3

510

0.00

-4.2

0-1

.45

CA

LLW

OO

D, K

AN

EE

SX

XX

-X

X -

0349

1511

18-6

.20

-t45

12/3

0/11

5803

3939

2R

egul

ar3,

000.

002,

302.

323,

000.

00-5

28.1

8-1

26.0

0-4

3.50

DE

LA

RO

SA

CA

ST

ILL

XX

X -

XX

-93

9215

1119

-186

.00

-43.

50

12/3

0/11

5803

5898

7R

egul

ar25

0.00

222.

0225

0.00

-13.

85-1

0.50

-3.6

3

EU

SE

BE

, AN

DR

EW

R.

XX

X -

XX

-89

8715

1120

-15.

50-3

.63

12/3

0/11

5803

7269

8R

egul

ar12

5.00

79.4

812

5.00

-38.

46-5

.25

-1.8

1

ES

PR

IT, L

IND

A L

.X

XX

-X

X -

2698

1511

21-7

.75

-1.8

1

12/3

0/11

5803

7327

6R

egul

ar20

0.00

188.

7020

0.00

-8.4

0-2

.90

LEW

IS, E

DIL

IAX

XX

-X

X -

3276

1511

22-1

2.40

-2.9

0

12/3

0/11

Page 22: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

1;8/

13 a

t 13:

20:2

9.71

Pag

e: 3

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion

- S

TT

OLD

Pay

roll

Reg

iste

rF

or th

e P

erio

d F

rom

Dec

29, 2

012

to D

ec 2

9, 2

012

Filt

er C

riter

ia in

clud

es: R

epor

t ord

er is

by C

heck

Dat

e. R

epor

t is

prin

ted

in D

etai

l For

mat

.

Em

ploy

ee ID

Em

ploy

eeM

aske

d S

S N

oR

efer

ence

Dat

e

Pay

Typ

e P

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssM

edic

alln

sG

arni

shm

ent

Pre

TxA

FLA

CF

UT

A_E

R

Fed

_Inc

ome

Em

plLo

anM

AS

AP

reT

xCIG

NA

SU

I_E

R

Soc

_Sec

Chi

ldC

are

Cas

hDra

wer

Soc

_Sec

_ER

Med

icar

eH

ighe

rEdu

cA

FLA

CM

edic

are_

ER

5801

6921

6R

egul

ar12

5.00

102.

9412

5.00

-15.

00-5

.25

-1.8

1LA

KE

-K

ING

, JE

NN

IFE

RX

XX

-X

X -

9216

6518

2-7

.75

-1.8

112

/29/

12-0

.63

5801

6965

9R

egul

ar50

0.00

444.

2050

0.00

-27.

55-2

1.00

-7.2

5M

AD

UR

O, J

ULI

AX

XX

-X

X -

9659

6518

3-3

1.00

-7.2

512

/29/

12-2

.50

5801

7080

6R

egul

ar50

0.00

471.

7550

0.00

-21.

00-7

.25

DO

RS

ET

, KA

RE

EM

AX

XX

-X

X -

0806

6518

4-3

1.00

-7.2

512

/29/

12

5801

7598

8S

alar

y17

,000

.00

10,5

76.4

517

,000

.00

-5,4

63.0

5-7

14.0

0-2

46.5

0G

UM

BS

, WE

NT

WO

RT

XX

X-X

X-5

988

6518

5-1

,054

.00

-246

.50

12/2

9/12

5802

5384

0S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,6

02.0

350

,000

.00

-16,

672.

97-7

25.0

0Y

US

UF

, NA

JEH

F.

XX

X -

XX

-38

4065

186

-725

.00

12/2

9/12

5803

3939

2R

egul

ar3,

000.

002,

308.

673,

000.

00-5

21.8

3-1

26.0

0-4

3.50

DE

LA

RO

SA

CA

ST

ILL

XX

X -

XX

-93

9265

187

-186

.00

-43.

5012

/29/

12

5803

7269

8R

egul

ar12

5.00

99.5

712

5.00

-18.

37-5

.25

-1.8

1E

SP

RIT

, LIN

DA

L.

XX

X -

XX

-26

9865

188

-7.7

5-1

.81

12/2

9/12

-0.6

3

Page 23: I. A Request to Post Non -Cash Security Is Normal, Allowed in Hamed Docket Entries/2013... · 2013-12-28 · Agent WALEED HAMED,)) CIVIL NO. SX -12 -CV -370 Plaintiff,) v.) ACTION

1:81

13 a

t 13:

20:2

9.69

Pag

e: 2

Filt

er C

riter

ia in

clud

es: R

epor

tF

or th

eor

der

is b

y C

heck

Dat

e. R

epor

t is

prin

ted

Uni

ted

Cor

pora

tion

- S

IT O

LDP

ayro

ll R

egis

ter

Per

iod

Fro

m D

ec 2

9, 2

012

in D

etai

l For

mat

.D

ec 2

9, 2

01

Em

ploy

ee ID

Em

ploy

eeM

aske

d S

S N

oR

efer

ence

Dat

e

Pay

Typ

e P

ay H

rP

ay A

mt

Am

ount

Gro

ssM

edic

alln

sG

arni

shm

ent

Pre

TxA

FLA

CF

UT

A_E

R

Fed

_Inc

ome

Em

plLo

anM

AS

AP

reT

xCIG

NA

SU

I_E

R

Soc

_Sec

Chi

ldC

are

Cas

hDra

wer

Soc

_Sec

_ER

Med

icar

eH

ighe

rEdu

cA

FLA

CM

edic

are_

ER

5800

7188

9R

egul

ar30

0.00

263.

5830

0.00

-19.

47-1

2.60

-4.3

5C

AS

TR

O, C

AR

LOS

XX

X -

XX

-18

8965

175

-18.

60-4

.35

12/2

9/12

5800

8368

8R

egul

ar75

0.00

606.

8075

0.00

-100

.82

-31.

50-1

0.88

RIC

HA

RD

S, C

HE

RY

LX

XX

-X

X -

3688

6517

6-4

6.50

-10.

8812

129/

12-3

.75

5800

8920

1S

alar

y9,

000.

005,

989.

499,

000.

00-

2,50

2.01

-378

.00

-130

.50

FR

EY

LIN

GE

R, G

ER

AR

XX

X -

XX

-92

0165

177

-558

.00

-130

.50

12/2

9/12

5800

9101

3S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,5

50.8

750

,000

.00

-16,

724.

13-7

25.0

0Y

US

UF

, FA

TH

IX

XX

-X

X -

1013

6517

8-7

25.0

012

/29/

12

5801

3906

8S

alar

y50

,000

.00

32,6

27.6

150

,000

.00

-16,

647.

39-7

25.0

0%

/H

AM

ED

, WA

HE

ED

M.

XX

X -

XX

-90

6865

179

-725

.00

12/2

9/12

5801

6149

3R

egul

ar50

0.00

422.

2850

0.00

-49.

47-2

1.00

-7.2

5JA

CK

SO

N, M

AU

RE

EN

XX

X -

XX

-14

9365

180

-31.

00-7

.25

12/2

9/12

5801

6852

1R

egul

ar40

0.00

353.

8940

0.00

-23.

51-1

6.80

-5.8

0B

RA

TH

WA

ITE

, CA

RIN

XX

X -

XX

-85

2165

181

-24.

80-5

.80

12/2

9/12

-2.0

0