Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2) University of Pennsylvania.

45
Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2) University of Pennsylvania

description

Prof. Vernon W. Hughes (1921  2003)

Transcript of Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2) University of Pennsylvania.

Page 1: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Huaizhang Deng

Yale University

Precise measurement of (g-2)

University of Pennsylvania

Page 2: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Collaboration

Page 3: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Prof. Vernon W. Hughes (1921 2003)

Page 4: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Outline

•What is (g-2) and why we measure it ?

•Preliminary result of muon electric dipole moment.

•Analysis and result from the 2000 run.

•Principle of and experimental setup for the measurement.

•Theory of (g-2) and its new development.

•Conclusions.

Page 5: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

What is g-2The magnetic moment of a particle is related to its spin

g Smce

2

For Dirac pointlike particle :

g=2

For the proton : ap1.8 because the proton is composite particle.

Anomalous magnetic moment2

2

ga

Page 6: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

g - 2 0 for the muon

Largest contribution : 800

12

a

Other standard model contributions :

QED hadronic weak

Contribution from new physics : a(exp)-a(SM)=a(new physics)

Page 7: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Why muon?

• The muon is a point particle, so far.

(Hadrons, like p and n, are composite particles.)

• The muon lives long enough for us to measure.

• The effects from heavy particles are generally proportional to m2. 000,40/ 2 emm

Page 8: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Principle of the measurement

When =29.3 (p=3.09 Gev/c),a is independent of E.

cme

a

a

B

EaBacm

e

1

12

csa

Page 9: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

How to measure B

B is determined by measuring the proton nuclearmagnetic resonance (NMR) frequency p in the magnetic field.

)1(//

24

2

a

gcmeB

cmea

p

pa

p

p

a

p

p

aa

pap

paa

//

/

/p=3.183 345 39(10), W. Liu et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 711 (1999).

Page 10: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

How to measure a

In the parity violated decay , e+ are emittedpreferentially along the muon spin direction in muon restframe. And e+ emitted along the muon momentumdirection get large Lorentz boost and have high energy in laboratory frame. Hence, a is determined by countingthe high energy e+ .

ee

Page 11: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Muon storage ring

Page 12: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Some numbers about the experiment

Time scales :149.2 ns cyclotron (or fast rotation) period c , 4.4 s g-2 period a , what we want to measure 64.4 s dilated muon lifetime

Experimental sequence :t =0 beam injection

Magnetic field : 1.45 T p : 61.79MHz

35 — 500 ns beam kicked onto orbit 0 — 15 s beam scraping 5 — 40 s calorimeters gated on

45 — 1000 s g-2 measurement 33 ms beam injection repeats (12 times)

3 s circle repeats 3 day field measurement by trolley 1 year data-taking repeats

20 year whole experiment repeats

Page 13: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

NMR trolley

17 trolley probes

378 fixed probesaround the ring

The NMR system iscalibrated against a standard probe† of aspherical water sample.

† X. Fei, V.W. Hughes, R. Prigl,NIM A394 349 (1997)

Page 14: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Trolley measurement

The B field variation at thecenter of the storage region. <B>1.45 T

The B field averagedOver azimuth.

Page 15: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Fixed probe measurements

Calibration of the fixedprobe system with respectto the trolley measurements

The magnetic fieldmeasured by the fixedprobe system during2000 run.

Page 16: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Systematic errors for p

Source of errors Size [ppm]2000 1999

Absolute calibration of standard probe 0.05 0.05Calibration of trolley probe 0.15 0.20Trolley measurements of B0 0.10 0.10Interpolation with fixed probes 0.10 0.15Inflector fringe field -- 0.20Uncertainty from muon distribution 0.03 0.12Others† 0.10 0.15Total 0.24 0.4

† higher multipoles, trolley temperature and voltage response,eddy currents from the kickers, and time-varying stray fields.

Page 17: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

2000 a data

))(cos()(1)()( /0 EtEAeENtN a

t

Page 18: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Coherent betatron oscillation (cbo)

nccbo 11

kick

)]cos(1)[()( ,/

,00 Ncbocbot

Ncbo teAENEN cbo 01.0, NcboA)]cos(1)[()( ,

/, Acbocbo

tAcbo teAEAEA cbo 001.0, AcboA

)]cos(1)[()( ,/

,

cbocbot

cbo teAEE cbo 001.0, cboA

Page 19: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

CBO effect on ωa

)2/()2( acboacbo

a

Page 20: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Cancellation of cbo around the ring

CBO effect shown onthe average energy of e+

Cancellation of cbo effectafter summing all detectortogether.

Page 21: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Error for a

Source of errors Size [ppm]2000 1999

Coherent betatron oscillation 0.21 0.05Pileup 0.13 0.13Gain changes 0.13 0.02Lost muons 0.10 0.10Binning and fitting procedure 0.06 0.07AGS background 0.10Others† 0.06Total systematic error 0.31 0.3Statistical error 0.62 1.3

† Timing shifts, E field and vertical oscillations, beam debunching/randomization.

Page 22: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Blind analysis and result

After two analyses of p had been completed,

p=61 791 595(15) Hz (0.2ppm),

and four analyses of a had been completed,

a=229 074.11(14)(7) Hz (0.7ppm),

separately and independently, the anomalous magneticmoment was evaluated,

a=11 659 204(7)(5) 10-10

Page 23: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Standard model calculation of aa(SM)= a(QED)+ a(had)+ a(weak)

a(QED)=11 658 470.57(0.29)10-10 (0.025 ppm)

a(weak)=15.1(0.4)10-10 (0.03 ppm)

Both QED and weak contribution has been calculatedto high accuracy.

The accuracy of a(had) is about 0.6 ppm.

Page 24: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Cannot be calculated from pQCD alonebecause it involves low energy scalesnear the muon mass.

Hadronic contribution (LO)

However, by dispersion theory,this a(had,1) can be related to

)(e)(

e

hadronseeR

measured in e+e- collisionor tau decay.

24 2

2

)()(3

)1,(

m

sRsKsdsm

hada

Page 25: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Evaluation of R

M. Davier et al., hep-ph/0208177

Page 26: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Comparison between e+e- and

M. Davier et al., hep-ph/0308213M. Davier et al., hep-ph/0208177

Page 27: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Experimental and theoretical values

Page 28: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Beyond standard model

• extra dimensions, or extra particles,

• compositeness for leptons or gauge bosons.

particularly supersymmetric particles

Page 29: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Muon electric dipole moment

Bacm

eaobs

s

ωobs

ωedm

ωa

δ 115 )(109.8

2 cmed

af

Vertical profile of decay positrons oscillates • with frequency of g-2• with phase 90o different from g-2 phase• with amplitude proportional to dμ

cmefd

4

where

Bfedm

21

Page 30: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Amplitude with CBO frequency [μm]

Am

plitu

de w

ith g

-2 fr

eque

ncy

[μm

]

Preliminary result of muon EDM

dμ=(−0.1±1.4)×10-19e·cm

dμ< 2.8×10-19e·cm (95% CL)

Page 31: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Conclusions

•Improve the accuracy of a to 0.7 ppm

•The discrepancy between a(exp) and a(SM) is 0.7-1.9, depending on theory.

•Uncertainty is about half the size of the weak contribution.

•We are analyzing the data for negative muons, a test of CPT.•Factor 3.75 improvement on the upper limit of muon electric dipole moment.

Page 32: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Superconducting inflector

The radial phase space allowed by the inflector aperture(green) is smaller than that allowed by the storage ring (red).

Page 33: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Photo of the storage ring

inflector kickers

Detectors

Page 34: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Magnet

Page 35: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Muon distribution

Radial muon distribution determined by the Fourier trans-formation of cyclotron periods when beam is debunching.Vertical muon distribution is symmetric.

Page 36: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Residual after fit with ideal function

Page 37: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Detectors and positron signals

Page 38: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Polarized muons

Parity violated decay

produces longitudinally polarized muons.

+ +sp

: spin 0: left handed

: left handed

Page 39: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Half ring effect due to cbo

Page 40: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Pileup correction

real pileup : |t|<2.9 ns

constructed pileup : |t-10|<2.9 ns

rawcorrected

rawcorrectedlater time

Page 41: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Muon loss

Absolute normalization is determined by fit.

Page 42: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Evaluation of R (low energy region)

M. Davier et al., hep-ph/0208177

Page 43: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

a(had,1)

Page 44: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

a(had,lbl)=8.6(3.5)10-10

Higher order hadronic contributions

a(had,2)=10.1(0.6)10-10

Page 45: Huaizhang Deng Yale University Precise measurement of (g-2)  University of Pennsylvania.

Near future

• Analysis of 2001 data on with reduced systematic error and roughly the same statistical error.• Test CPT. Assuming CPT, reduce the total statistical error.• Measurement of muon electric dipole moment.• Muon life time measurement.• Sidereal day variation of a.

• Theoretical evaluation continues to be scrutinized.• Radiative return data from KLOE and B factory.• Lattice QCD calculation.