How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson...

96
How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference November 5, 2014

Transcript of How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson...

Page 1: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

How to Speak SEM-eseChallenges and Leadership in Enrollment

Management

Stanley E. HendersonUniversity of Michigan-Dearborn

MACRAO 2014 Annual ConferenceNovember 5, 2014

Page 2: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 2

Introducing Stanley Henderson

• Vice Chancellor for Enrollment Management and Student Life, University of Michigan-Dearborn since 2005

• Began in Admissions at Michigan State in 1970, went on to Wichita State, Western Michigan, University of Cincinnati, University of Illinois

• AACRAO’s first VP for Enrollment Management (1990); President (1995-96); Distinguished Service Award (2007), Founders Award for Leadership (2008)

• Co-founder of SEM conference in 1991 (one of only three people to have attended every SEM); wrote first history of SEM; most quoted on the “Academic Context” of SEM; SEM Lifetime Achievement Award (2014)

• BA from Michigan State, MA from Cornell, doctoral course work at Illinois

• Once called “Dad to 9000 students.” Ask anything about US Presidents!

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 3: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 3

SEM-ese is like Chinese: 4 Definitions for Each Character, Depending on the Inflection

1. While those of us in Enrollment Management are speaking from the SEM text, which brings insight to enrollment issues and offers significant assistance, including leveraging existing staff...

2. It would be the rare enrollment manager who had never thought about how there always seems to be an academic solution to every problem on campus

3. Provosts, deans, and the faculty all see issues through an academic lens and formulate resolutions on their terms without regard for—or even inclusion of—others’ perspectives

Page 4: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 4

The Result: The Academic Tower of Enrollment Babel1. Academic departments hire new advisors or staff that will

continue to do what hasn’t worked

2. Faculty design new programs that will attract the few while ignoring SEM’s sure winners and insisting that “Admissions should visit high schools!”

3. Academic policies seek maximum penalties instead of teachable moments for offenses students don’t understand

4. Deans and chairs ignore the role their actions have played in enrollment shortfalls and expect SEM practitioners to fix things they were excluded from in the first place

Page 5: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 5

SEM-ese Interpreters: Translating Our Language into an Academic Context

1. We need to know grammar and structure of SEM-ese 1. The context2. The theory3. The template4. The practice

2. We also need to know what gives it inflection and makes it come alive1. Service2. Collaboration3. Culture4. Partnerships5. Community

Page 6: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

The Challenges of Context

Off Campus and On

Page 7: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 7

What Shapes the EM Environment?

• Demographic shifts

• Changing economics of higher education

• The public policy and the legal environment

• The changing competition

• The “Information Age”

• The “Communication Age”

Page 8: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 8

Impact of 2014 Midterm Elections and a GOP Congress

• Good news: less regulation

• Bad news: less money for research and student aid

• Opposition to executive action agenda re:• For-profit college industry• Push for college ratings system

• Democrats agenda de-emphasized• Allowing student loan borrowers to lower their interest rates• Holding colleges accountable for high default rates• Further clamp-down on for profits

• AACRAO, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 9: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 9

Impact of the 2014 Midterm Elections in the Senate

• New chair of Education Committee in the Senate will be Lamar Alexander of Tennessee

• His main higher ed agenda: Deregulate it!

• Will drive reauthorization of the Higher Education Act

• What to expect:• Staunch opponent of Obama accountability agenda• Likely to shift accreditors away from regulatory compliance• Supporter of streamlining student aid; could see simplified federal student aid form

• AACRAO, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 10: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 10

Redefining Higher Ed

Industrial Age1. Teaching franchise2. Information infrastructure as a

support tool

3. Separate learning systems4. Silos5. Bureaucratic systems

6. Rigid pre-designed processes

Information Age1. Learning franchise2. Information infrastructure as

instrument of transformation3. Fused learning systems4. Big tent5. Self-informing, self-correcting

systems6. Families of transactions

customized to needs of learners, faculty, staff

Page 11: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 11

Consider Elements of Campus Culture

• Pervasive attitude to not be content to rest on past success

• Sense of inclusiveness on the part of all members of the campus community as opposed to just an institution

• A strongly held sense of mission that recognizes the campus as “distinctive” or “special.” “The people are special.”

A Matter of Culture and Leadership: Student Success in State Colleges and Universities, AASCU, 2005

Page 12: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 12

Unpacking Culture – Setting High Expectations

A culture of high expectations is a culture of mutual expectations. – Student success is up to students. Set high expectations for students.

“People don’t rise to low expectations.”– We cannot just hold students to high standards. We must also do everything

in our power to provide them with the support they need to succeed and to build students’ sense of personal responsibility for their achievement.

– Leaders need to set high targets for faculty and staff performance. They need to set targets that actually can be met, provide support and example to meet them, then raise the bar another notch.

A culture that succeeds like this is always in dynamic balance.

A Matter of Culture and Leadership: Student Success in State Colleges and Universities, AASCU, 2005

Page 13: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 13

The Corporate University

• Our campuses are being “corporatized” by business practices, a drive for efficiency, intrusion of portfolios that have non-student-centered viewpoints—all couched in terms of “professionalizing” the campus

• Hierarchical leadership models concentrate decision-making in senior leadership without input from those in the trenches who understand the issues and student needs

• Deliver or else management requires results NOW

• The impact on us as enrollment professionals is that we are as much at risk as Brady Hoke if we don’t have that perfect recruitment season—the only difference is that if he’s fired, he gets a multi-million dollar payout

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 14: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 14

The Dispensable Staff

• There is a concerning faculty/staff divide where increasingly staff are likened to the wheels on a wagon—necessary but easily replaced

• Staff with operational responsibilities in running offices are upbraided if they fall behind the on campus projects that dedicated academic staff can devote full time to

• Deans meet to discuss enrollment planning without representatives of the enrollment units present

• A view that “we will decide and you will implement”

• “Our new program is stalled in the Registrar’s Office”

• As a result, there is a sense of marginalization among many staff, a sense of almost being disrespected

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 15: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 15

Enrollment Management is an Institutional Balancing Act

• Meeting Enrollment Goals

• Improving Quality

• Increasing Diversity

• Ensuring Access and Affordability

• Increasing Net Tuition Revenue

• Increasing Retention & Graduation Rates

• Improving Student Learning Outcomes

Page 16: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

Theory: Guiding Principles for the SEM Ethos

Page 17: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 17

STRATEGIC Enrollment Management

• Comprehensive process

• Achieving and maintaining optimal recruitment, retention, and graduation rates

• Optimum defined in academic context

• Institution-wide process that touches every aspect of institutional function and culture

• Academics are an umbrella concept• M. Dolence, 1993

Page 18: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 18

Shared Responsibility

• If SEM reflects institutional identity, culture, it becomes an institution-wide strategy owned by each member of the community

• No individual or office is responsible for enrollment strategy or outcomes

• Each member of community takes responsibility for nurturing SEM Ethos

Page 19: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 19

Integrated Institutional Planning

• As an academic enterprise, SEM can be easily integrated into institutional planning

• If it’s academically centered, SEM will be a defining part of institutional positioning

• If SEM isn’t part of strategic planning, not much can be accomplished

Page 20: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 20

Focus on Service

• In SEM Ethos processes and procedures are more important than structure

• Academic foundation dictates business practices

• Business practices need to be aligned with academic mission

• Institutions want to test students’ talents in the classroom, not their patience in navigating institutional business practices

Page 21: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 21

Students’ Seamless View

• Students see enrollment as a seamless process, not as a railroad track with multiple station stops

• Enrollment is non-stop rather than stop and go (or even one-stop)

• SEM is a big tent view of student expectations: everything is there, but they don’t want to touch what they don’t need

Page 22: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 22

Intuitive Service

• It doesn’t matter if it makes sense to us: does it make sense to the students?

• Why is the student in the institution?

• The only way he/she stays in school is for an academic reason

• Retention is academic success

• Processes and procedures should enhance academic success

Page 23: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 23

Key Performance Indicators

• Enrollment managers struggle with notion of KPIs as indices of institutional health

• In reality, KPIs are placeholders for institutional values

• Bodies, not student fit, approach is out of synch with the academic values of the institution

• If the enrollment manager has an academic understanding of the place, KPIs set themselves

Page 24: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 24

Research and Evaluation

• With SEM Ethos SEM has to have research and evaluation plan

• SEM staff are “people people”

• More and more industry standard is data and research—tools of the academy

• SEM units cannot continue to do “feel good” programs that can’t show support for academic goals

Page 25: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 25

SEM for the Long Haul

• SEM is long-term and never finished

• Academic foundation is fluid; so must SEM be

• Academic disciplines change with new research, new paradigms, new interests

• Changes cannot be instantaneous

• There needs to be a run up to the take-off point

• SEM must follow the deliberate path of the long-term academic, not the quick fix of the repairman

Page 26: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

The SEM Blueprint: A Refocusing of SEM

Page 27: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 27

The Elusive SEM Template

• Every enrollment manager wants one

• We all say it doesn’t exist, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach

• It’s not very helpful to tell the young enrollment manager that she has to get to know her institution

• In fact, the SEM Ethos does provide a template

Page 28: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 28

Template: Academic Leadership

• Leadership articulates the strategic academic aspirations, goals, needs, and strategies of faculty and students

• If the CEO says, “Enrollment is paramount,” and fails to say, “to the academic mission,” EM fails

• All must understand that academic well-being is linked to enrollment health

Page 29: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 29

Template: Integrated Planning

• enrollment management (lower case) is just managing enrollments

• STRATEGIC Enrollment Management (upper case) happens when SEM unit planning and strategies are integrated with the institution’s strategic plan, academic master plan, and its fundamental (academic) mission

Page 30: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 30

Template: Lateral Communication

• Top-down communication is necessary to set the tone, but successful implementation of SEM requires lateral communication across campus

• SEM needs lateral communication to ensure adherence to the institution’s academic ethos

• Colleges to enrollment units and enrollment units to colleges: the tentacles of an octopus

• Communication has to become a part of the culture; it has to express the ethos of the place

Page 31: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 31

Template: Structure for Participation

• The institutional academic ethos will set the structure to provide a means for faculty, staff, and students to contribute to SEM

• SEM structure grows out of the core of an individual institution; it cannot be transplanted from institution X or Y

• The structure cannot be more important than the cultural foundation itself

Page 32: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 32

Template: Matching Structure to Mission

• A community college may have a campus-wide structure

• The research extensive university may have multiple structures in academic units

• The wise enrollment manager will seek to know the academic grounding of the institution and then seek a structure based on that foundation

Page 33: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

Applying the SEM TEMPLATEThe Faces of SEM

Integrating Structure, Planning, Leadership, and Community

Page 34: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 34

Structural/Managerial Face of SEM

• Focuses on the structure and management of those departments and functions formally charged with achieving the institution’s enrollment goals

• SEM decisions focus on optimal resource allocation to achieve enrollment goals• Marketing and recruitment priorities• Need-based versus merit-based FA packaging• Course offerings and scheduling• Service efficiency – One-Stop • Processing of academic policy• Student intervention initiatives

Page 35: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 35

Planning Face of SEM

• Focuses on the outward- and forward-looking at activities that guide the institution’s pursuit of its preferred future in a constantly changing and competitive environment

• Focuses on long-range planning and institution-wide strategy development• New curricula & academic programs• Facilities development and renovation• Marketing and image campaigns• Investments in technology• Pricing decisions• Retention planning programs (early alert interventions, first year

seminar, learning communities, support services, academic advising, etc.)

Page 36: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 36

Leadership Face of SEM

Focuses on leadership as a shared responsibility—occurring at all levels and deeply embedded in the way the institution works as on organization on a day-to-day basis

– No silos– Enabling leadership at multiple levels– Servant leadership– Engender trust– Communicate purpose– Motivate people

Page 37: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 37

The Human Face of SEM

• In an institution, there is always a policy, a rule, a faculty culture, or an answer

• In a community, we must look beyond the policies and the history to find what benefits individual students and the community itself

• The Community of SEM is about building relationships; understanding how to create, nurture, and appreciate relationships will help the enrollment manager to structure, plan, and lead SEM

• This is the Human Face of SEM, integrating the other faces into the Community of SEM that emphasizes Student Success through services and inclusion in a culture of participation and contribution

Page 38: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 38

Putting Humanity into Each SEM Face

• The community of SEM can harness the broader culture and broaden the academic solution syndrome by ensuring that there is a human face in each of SEM’s traditional three faces.

• Structure should facilitate seamless service and create open channels for feedback and foster creativity.

• Planning should understand that data are critical only insofar as they improve service and contribute to the cradle to endowment concept of student success, and…

• Leadership must be willing to lose itself in followership

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 39: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 39

The Community of SEM…

• Requires an understanding of the complex dynamics that shape the university’s culture as well as its enrollment profile

• Requires a focus not on individual functional and departmental silos but on the entire enrollment process as service for success

• Requires keeping the emphasis on student success through the enrollment continuum

Page 40: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 40

Prospects

Inquiries

Applicants

Depositors

Enrollees

ContinuingStudents

Graduates

Alumni

General

Specific

Continued Cultivation

ACTIONS

Page 41: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 41

SEM Planning

Recruitment / Marketing

Admission

OrientationCo-curricular

supportDegree/goal attainment

Academic support

RetentionFinancial support

Student’s college career

Classroom experience

Turning the enrollment funnel on its side…..to express progression forward….and emphasize the multi-dimensional processes that exist.

Alumni

Page 42: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 42

Moving from the traditional enrollment management perspective….

Recruitment / Marketing

Admission

OrientationCo-curricular

supportDegree/goal attainment

Academic support

RetentionFinancial support

Student’s Experiences

Classroom experience

Traditional Enrollment Perspective

Alumni

Page 43: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 43

…to a fully integrated Strategic Enrollment Management perspective.

Recruitment / Marketing

Admission

OrientationCo-curricular

supportDegree/goal attainment

Academic support Retention

Financial support

Student’s Experiences

Classroom experience

The SEM Perspective

Alumni

Page 44: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 44

Setting Enrollment Goals: The Classic Conundrum

• All may want better students

• Administration may want more students

• Faculty usually want fewer students

• Departments may be reducing capacity

• Access vs. Quality

Page 45: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 45

Important Reminders

• SEM is…– Mission and niche based

– Subject to organizational history

– Dependent on expertise of available staff

– About collaboration, not org charts

Page 46: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 46

SEM is a Journey

• SEM requires systems thinking

• SEM requires strategic thinking

• SEM is resource hungry and it is all about ROI

• SEM is growth by substitution (can’t do it unless you take something away)

• SEM Math (2 + 3 = 7)

Page 47: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

The PracticeStrategic Enrollment Management at

Work in an Academic World

Page 48: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 48

Our Every Day Reality in Student Success

1. There is abundant evidence that students are not as engaged as we would like

2. There is also evidence that students are not as engaged during the first year of college as they thought they would be!

3. Levels of performance in high DWFI rate courses should be a cause for embarrassment and action, especially in mathematics

4. There is still too much unacceptable attrition

5. There is much instability in the viability and leadership of retention of Student Success “programs”

Page 49: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 49

Our Every Day Reality in Student Success

6. The response of the academy to the challenges of Student Success has been primarily to design “programs” rather than a more comprehensive institutional response

7. We are competing for ever scarcer resources in a larger society that does not currently share our values

8. And we are competing for students’ most precious of resources: their time, energies, attention, priorities, discretionary monies—Success in college vis a vis their jobs, families, pursuits of pleasures, busy demanding lives

Page 50: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 50

What Will It Take to Build Success?1. Core values that support a set of assumptions about a comprehensive,

integrated, and coordinated approach

2. Programs and services designed with intentionality, purpose, integration of effort, service efficiency, and positive interventions with students

3. Integrated cross-campus collaborations and partnerships between faculty, staff, and administration

4. Use of assessment and data for informed decision making

5. Understanding of how campus cultures impact enrollment management efforts

Page 51: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 51

But Remember…

1. There are NO SILVER BULLETS! There is no template, one-size-fits-all model that ensures student success

2. Campuses have to move from “enrollment by chance” to “enrollment by design”

3. To do that, strategic enrollment planning has to first understand and then become part of the culture of the entire campus

4. Only then can there be clear goals and efforts for optimal enrollment to fulfill institutional mission and services and programs to improve student learning and success

Page 52: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 52

Defining Moments of the Millennials Experience

• Oklahoma City bombing

• Schoolyard shootings

• OJ Simpson arrest

• Columbine

• Contested presidential election

• 9/11 and the War on Terror

• 2 sets of parents, 4 sets of grandparents

• Technology pervasive

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 53: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 53

Common Experiences Shape Common Values• Special

• Sheltered

• Family-oriented

• Confident

• Team-oriented

• Conventional

• Pressured

• Achieving

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 54: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 54

Millennial College Students…

• Have “helicopter parents” who will scrutinize what goes on in the classroom and on campus

• Assume they will be successful

• Expect one-on-one attention that “no child left behind” instills

• Expect technology to be integrated into the classroom

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 55: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 55

Millennials’ Behavior

• Perceive greater danger and less reward in being creatively different

• Are risk averse

• Want and expect team teaching and team grading of team projects

• Are less likely to “cheat” but may have difficulty defining “cheating”—is it plagiarism or is it information morphing?

• Expect and want high academic standards but also expect A’s

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 56: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 56

How to Sweet-Talk Millennials

• “You’ll be working with other bright, creative people.”

• “Your professor is in his/her late sixties” (the later, the better!).

• “You and your team can help turn this place around/accomplish this task/finish this project.”

• “You can be a hero here.”

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 57: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 57

How Different Are the Millennials?

• When they see wire-rimmed glasses, they think Harry Potter, not John Lennon

• “Press pound” on the phone is now translated as “hit hashtag.”

• Celebrity “selfies” are far cooler than autographs.

• The Daily Show with Jon Stewart has always been the only news program that really “gets it right.”

• Hard liquor has always been advertised on television.

• Hong Kong has always been part of China

• Courts have always been overturning bans on same-sex marriages.

• Joe Camel has never introduced one of them to smoking.

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 58: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 58

The Millennials’ World

• Yet another blessing of digital technology: They have never had to hide their dirty magazines under the bed.

• Attending schools outside their neighborhoods, they gather with friends on Skype, not in their local park.

• Affirmative Action has always been outlawed in California.

• “Good feedback” means getting 30 likes on your last Facebook post in a single afternoon.

• Their collection of U.S. quarters has always celebrated the individual states.

• Since Toys R Us created a toy registry for kids, visits to Santa are just a formality.• Beloit College, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 59: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 59

Guess Who’s NOT Going to College?

• Among high achievers from low-income families, 75% went to college but only 29% graduated

• Among high achievers from high-income families, 99% went to college and 74% graduated

Page 60: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 60

Hopes Delayed

• Among the best-prepared American high school students: 20% of those from low-income families don’t go directly on to college

• Among high achievers from high-income families, only 3% don’t enter college right away

Page 61: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 61

The Changing College Student

• Hispanic students will increase from a 9.3% share of public high school graduates in 1994 to nearly 20% in 2014.

• White students will decline as a percentage of the high school graduating class, going from 72.4% to 58% in the same time period

• WICHE, 2003

Page 62: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 62

The Faces of the New Students

• Minority share of high school grads has grown from about 7 percent in 1960 to 31 percent by 2002 and

• Will grow further to 45 percent by 2018.• Mortenson

• When the Boomer Echo peaks at 3.2 million high school grads in 2009, 80% of the growth from the beginning of the 21st century will be students of color.

Page 63: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 63

New Students: A Profile in Barriers

• Over 16% of the entering class each year will come from families with annual incomes under $20,000

• The New Students will be the first in their families to go to college

• Many will come from academically weak schools

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 64: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 64

First Generation Students

• 34% of 5-17 year olds in the US are considered first generation students

• 41% of those are African-American

• 61% are Latino

• 23% are white• NCES, 2012

Page 65: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 65

First Generation Students

• 82% of non-first generation students enrolled in US colleges immediately after high school

• 54% of first generation students whose parents finished high school enrolled immediately

• 36% of those whose parents had less than a high school education enrolled immediately

• Choy, NCES, 2001

Page 66: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 66

First Generation Students

• 50% of students in US higher education are first generation

• 30% (5.6 million) of US college freshmen are first generation

• 24% (4.5 million) are first generation and low income

• More than 25% of those will leave after their first years

• Only 11% will eventually graduate

• Whereas 55% of higher income, first generation students will

• And 78% of higher income, second generation student will• US Department of Education, 2010

Page 67: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 67

First Generation Students

• The average age of enrollment for first-generation college students is 22, compared to 20 for students who are not first generation

• 54% of first-generation students were financially on their own, while only 27% of students who were not first generation had full financial responsibility for themselves

• 30% of first generation students had dependents with 11 percent being single parents, while only 14% of non-first generation students had dependents and only 4% were single parents.

• Concordia University-Online, 2009

Page 68: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 68

Latino/a Students

• Between 2000 and 2012 the states with the fastest growing Latino population were:

• Tennessee up 163%

• South Carolina up 161%

• Alabama up 157%

• Kentucky up 135%

• South Dakota up 132%• Saenz, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 69: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 69

Latinos in the US 2014

• 54.1 million

• 17% of US population

• 35.5% foreign born

• Nearly half live in California and Texas

• Two thirds live in California, Texas, Florida, New York, and Illinois

• Median age is 27; nationally it’s 37

• Every year an estimated 600,000 Latinos turn 18• Saenz, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 70: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 70

Latinos in College

• In California in 2012 23% of Latino high school graduates were eligible for admission to the CU OR the CSU systems; for Latinas it was 33%

• This means that 77% of Latinos and 67% of Latinas were eligible ONLY for the California community college system

• In Texas 8.9% of Latino eighth graders earn a higher education credential in 11 years

• 7.7% of African-American eighth graders earn a higher education credential in 11 years

• 16% of all eighth graders earn a higher education credential in 11 years• Saenz, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 71: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 71

What’s Happening to our Latino boys?

• Over-representation in special ed

• Over-representation in school discipline pipeline

• Under-resourced schools, novice teachers, leadership turnover, systemic inequalities

• Fewer males in teaching ranks

• Disparate learning styles are not considered• Saenz, 2014

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 72: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 72

A Generation Abandoned

• They will not be students who have traditionally been represented in American higher education

• What will be the response to them by our admissions officers embedded in enrollment management?

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 73: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 73

Building Rankings, not Futures

• The Academy Awards of higher education

• Lobbying the rankers

• Mailed ads

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 74: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 74

Tools and Accomplices: The Usual Suspects

• Early admission

• Out-of-state admission at public institutions

• High school counselors and their trophy schools

• Helicopter parents and their Christmas card kids

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 75: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 75

Raising Our Profile vs. Growing Our Leaders

• Abandoning the marginally prepared to raise the academic profile

• Screening out with traditional measures

• Higher education as the hospital that doesn’t want anyone too sick

• Excellence measured by diversity or academic quality: Are they mutually exclusive?

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 76: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 76

A New SEM Agenda: Beating Back Barriers

• Begin early with providing information and support related to going to college

• Embrace families’/communities’ social and cultural values that support achievement and college aspirations

• Create school structure that facilitates supportive relationships with caring adults, mentors, and peers with postsecondary aspirations

• Empower parents to advocate for their children

How to Speak “SEM-ese”

Page 77: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 77

Who’s Job Is It Anyway?

• Retention officer, yes, but where does he/she reside?

• Academic Affairs? The faculty have the most contact with the student

• Student Affairs? Over 50% of what you learn in college is learned outside of class

Page 78: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 78

It’s a Partnership

• The faculty need to take responsibility for engaging the student, whether in the co-curriculum, the academic realm of the classroom, or experiential learning

• The student life professional needs to take responsibility for the academic success of students—every student activity or organization is an enrollment unit

Page 79: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 79

The Blended Outlook

• Enrollment Management is a quintessentially academic enterprise

• Still, at the end of the day, it is about individual student academic success

• And it is supported by administrative changes to policies and procedures that make it difficult for students to navigate the campus

Page 80: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 80

The Sex Appeal of Recruitment

• Campuses obsess over freshmen numbers

• The glitz and glamour of recruitment lives in the fast lane

• Retention is the gray lady of enrollment management

• Enrollment Management as the tortoise and the hare—steady wins the race

Page 81: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 81

The Value of Value

• Autopsy studies always show students leave for academic, financial, or personal reasons.

• These may be placeholders for students’ perceptions that they are not getting enough value for the time, money, effort they are putting in

• Price elasticity studies show cost is not as important in decision as perceived value

Page 82: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 82

Build Value and They Will Stay

• The enrollment management agenda should be directed at what leads students to perceive value in their education

• Value provides a new definition of retention built around what motivates students

• Perhaps the high ability, third generation student can more readily see value in school; hence more go, and more stay

Page 83: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 83

Service as Retention

• Retention improvement comes from improved business practices• B. Bontrager

• Seamless enrollment processes provide perception of value

• Let students’ talents be challenged in the classroom rather than have their patience tested in navigating the institutional bureaucracy

Page 84: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 84

Engagement as Retention

• Involvement redefined

• What keeps the student going to class, doing the assignments, passing the tests?

• For some, extracurricular activities

• For others, internships and co-op

• For still others, undergraduate research

• For a few, study abroad

• Don’t forget what they do in their community—how can that be harnessed to the campus?

Page 85: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 85

Linking Recruitment and Retention

• Market student engagement through individualized opportunities to capture student interest

• Guarantee student engagement

• Study retention rates by individual high schools: where they fall below the class average, gear recruitment to retention services

Page 86: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 86

Building Buy-in to Value

• Parents want to be reassured they sent their student to the right place—tell them that regularly, at least during the freshman year

• If the student is unhappy or unfocussed, the parents who have been told repeatedly they did the right thing may be more likely to support the student in staying the course

Page 87: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 87

Retention for More Than a Day

• Data identifies and tracks the at-risk groups

• Research identifies the services that can keep students successful

• Recruiting for retention identifies and admits the students most likely to match the institutional Ethos and to succeed

• Service helps retention

Page 88: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 88

MERGERS AND PARTNERS Through the SEM Lens

• Improving service as a template for partnership development.

• Reviewing processes and procedures on an annual basis.

• Building a culture of education, not regulation.

• Cross-training and blending.

Page 89: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 89

STRATEGY ISSUES

• Academic offerings and support services

• Marketing

• Security

• Buildings and grounds—the Million Dollar Walk

• Student services and activities

• Recruitment/admissions/enrollment

• Information technology

• KPIs/data/research/evaluation

Page 90: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 90

Student Success, not Retention

1. Retention is clinical rather than aspirational

2. Retention is merely a measurement, a benchmark of educational attainment

3. And often, as John Gardner would argue, a minimum one at that: Retention is a C- and a pulse, the ability to fog a mirror

4. Retention restrains us, limits our vision and our capacity for creativity and excellence

Page 91: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 91

Recent trends in Student Success Best Practices

1. Use of technology to track and monitor student engagement, utilization of services– Starfish Early Alert and Connect– MapWorks– Degree audits and maps– Swiping

2. Use of data to identify risk characteristics, apply predictive modeling– Matching GPA’s to graduation rates to determine where to put

resources– Identifying key courses for graduation– Attendance

Page 92: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 92

Recent trends in Student Success Best Practices

3. Structures– Retention Office– Retention Committee– Student Success Alliance– Executive officers or Boots-on-the-ground Staff?

4. Policies– Requiring students to take certain courses and earn certain GPAs

semester by semester– Reassigning majors– Advising plans requiring use of career planning

Page 93: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 93

Recent trends in Student Success Best Practices

5. State accountabilities– Funding based on graduation rates– Loss of state aid for repeated classes (students pay)– Federal policies

• Lifetime limits on federal financial aid (Pell Grants, loans)• Future: Loss of aid for poor graduation rates?

6. Membership Organization services– Education Advisory Board

• Research publications, general and customized• Interest Forums: Academic Affairs, Student Affairs, Business Affairs, etc.• Data and analytics for end-to-end solutions

Page 94: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Leadership: Inspiration and Perspiration

Reflections

Page 95: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 95

Acknowledgements

With thanks to my fellow AACRAO Senior Consultants…

Bob BontragerJody GordonTom GreenWendy KilgoreClayton SmithAmanda Yale

Page 96: How to Speak SEM-ese Challenges and Leadership in Enrollment Management Stanley E. Henderson University of Michigan-Dearborn MACRAO 2014 Annual Conference.

SEM Planning Model 96

Questions & Comments

Stanley E. [email protected]