7/23/2019 His wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed Contributors | Jerusalem Post

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/his-wasnt-the-central-role-in-the-northern-ireland-peace-deal-op-ed 1/4

wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed C... http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1233304687555&pag

f 4 19/03/2009

Talkbacks for this article: 11

US Mideast envoy George Mitchell.

Photo: AP

RSS | Blogs | Judaica Gifts  23 Adar 5769, Thursday, March 19, 2009 15:57 IST |

Subscribe! Judaica Gifts

RSS Feeds E-mail Edition

Podcasts Archives

Web JPost.com 

Home Headlines Iranian Threat Jewish World O pi ni on Business Real Estate Local Israel Blogs Arts & Culture Français Classifieds

Israel Middle East International Health & Sci-Tech Features Travel Cafe Oleh Magazine Sports Israel Guide Subscribe ServicesServices

Right of Reply:ConservativeJudaism as

3-generationmovementComments: 22

I am not Jewishbut...Comments: 10

UK Jewish students

get some out-of-classlessons

Comments: 2

RECENT POSTS

3 pending political

"Jewish" matters

What was Mullen saying

about attack on Iran?

COLUMNISTS

Larry Derfner

Gilad Schalit is

gone

Douglas

Bloomfield

Passing the big

bucks

FEATURED BLOGGERS

Masorti Matters

The Rabbi, The

Pope and the

Western Wall

Alan Dershowitz

UN justice:

verdict first, trial

later

Window Israel

The grass isn't

greener in Gaza

JPost.com » Opinion » Op-Ed Contributors » Article

Feb 4, 2009 21:56 | Updated Feb 4, 2009 22:15

His wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland

peace dealBy ED MOLONEY

Print Subscribe

E-mail Toolbar

+ Recommend:

What's this?

Barack Obama's choice of former senator George Mitchell as his Mideast envoy has provoked hope and

fear in equal measure on either side of the divide in that region that peace between Israel and the

Palestinians has been edged a little closer.

"What a powerful choice," trumpeted J Street,

the new-ish pro-peace, pro-Israel lobby in

Washington, a view echoed by chief Palestinian

negotiator and Fatah spokesman Ahmed Qurei,

who praised Mitchell's impartiality, adding: "[He

is] someone with experience in... the settlementof political conflicts." But George Mitchell's

perceived neutrality is precisely what worried

 Abe Foxman of the Anti-Defamation League:

"He's been meticulously even-handed. So I'm

concerned."

Whatever their differences, all three would

doubtless agree that George Mitchell earned his reputation as a disinterested peacemaker from his stint

in Northern Ireland, where he chaired the talks that led to the 1998 Good Friday Agreement that ended

some three decades of bloodshed and a conflict that at times had seemed so beyond resolution that it

was often compared to the Middle East.

The depiction of Mitchell as the architect of a peace agreement that persuaded the IRA to put down its

weapons and Northern Ireland's competing Nationalist and Unionist politicians to sit together in the same

government, is by now so widely accepted that to question it seems absurd or even mean-spirited.

 As The New York Times stated baldly, in an editorial published the day after his appointment: "He

negotiated the 1998 Good Friday accord in Northern Ireland, good training for taking on the

Israeli-Palestinian conflict." Or this, in the Boston Globe, two days later: "The Obama administration is

hoping that Mitchell will bring the same mixture of toughness and subtlety, patience and impatience, to

his new post as special envoy on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict."

So just what was Mitchell's role in securing peace in Northern Ireland? Was he as central and crucial as

is widely believed, and what lessons can be drawn from all this of relevance to his new mission?

THERE IS NO BETTER man to turn to for an

answer to the first of those questions than

Mitchell himself. In Making Peace, his account

of the peace talks in Belfast, he gives this

description of the final 24 hours leading up to

the Good Friday Agreement: "Throughout the

Sisters in StruggleNew York, March 19

ZAP! POW! BAM! Tour Los Angeles, March 19

In the Memory of theForestSan Francisco, March 19

JCC Pecha Kucha NightLondon, March 19

The Aliyah Monologues

Sheini: Still Can't Find a

JobJerusalem, March 19

Jewish Speed Dating

25-35Tel Aviv, March 19

7/23/2019 His wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed Contributors | Jerusalem Post

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/his-wasnt-the-central-role-in-the-northern-ireland-peace-deal-op-ed 2/4

wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed C... http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1233304687555&pag

f 4 19/03/2009

 

GOT A QUESTION?Word of the day:stomach

JPOST.COM EXTRA!

Special Reports

Learn Hebrew

Brain Games

Audio Programs

Map of Israel

Israel Resources

Obituaries

Weather

Shabbat Times

Financial Tables

Cartoon

Sudoku

Specials

Eldan Rent a CarIsrael's leading carrental company offers a20% discount on onlinereservations

The Best JewishCharityLearn how Efrat saved30,000 lives of Jewish

children

Israeli BasketballWatch Live IsraeliPremier BasketballGames

Send flowers tosomeoneSend flowers tosomeone in Gush Danwith Alon Levin - floral

design

Tamir Rent a carCar rental in Israel,special prices

Find love at

JChuppah.comUse your mouse to findyour spouse!

Attractions In Israel

Hotels In Israel

Israel guideYour guide to Israel

Judaism

Download JPost.com'stoolbar and listen toIsraeli radio 24/7

Green IsraelProtecting Israel'senvironment

Unique gifts fromIsrael

The future of musicGlobal community ofmusic makers discovernew music

Jerusalem Gold Hotel

Your Home in JerusalemPay 6 Stay 7 days

Careers at JPost

day on Thursday, April 9, and on to the night,

the parties moved closer to agreement. Blair

and Ahern played a central role in these

negotiations. They obviously had developed a

warm personal relationship; that made progress

possible. They didn't just supervise the

negotiations; they conducted them. Word by

word, sentence by sentence, paragraph by

paragraph, the compromise came together."

The reader could be forgiven for wondering

where Mitchell was when this was going on?Shouldn't he, rather than British premier Tony

Blair and his Irish counterpart, Bertie Ahern,

have been the one putting the words, sentences and paragraphs together at this most critical, final

moment? Well, he certainly was in the building while all this was happening, and he was definitely aware

of what was going on, but this implied admission that he was peripheral to the main event holds the clue

to his real role.

LONG BEFORE the Good Friday Agreement talks were convened, the British and Irish governments

had a very good idea of how they ought to end and what sort of agreement could fly. Their difficulty was

getting there. They knew that any proposed agreement presented to the rival parties in their names

stood an excellent chance of being rejected thanks to the iron rule of Northern Irish politics.

That rule stated: Never accept a suggestion from the other side, because it will likely do you harm and

them good. So the Unionists would be inclined to reject anything in the draft agreement they suspected

had been the work of the Irish government, while Sinn Fein, the IRA's proxy at the talks, would assume

everything coming from the British had to be tainted.

It was a stroke of genius from the two governments to realize that if the proposed agreement were to

come instead from the Americans, this difficulty could be sidestepped. Not only that, but the Americans

could do something beyond the ability of Britain or Ireland: credibly allocate blame if the talks failed and

the violence resumed.

 And so Mitchell, the peace envoy appointed by Bill Clinton then as he has been appointed by Barack

Obama now, was the chosen channel through which the British and Irish achieved their goal. The draft

agreement introduced at the talks had been composed and written by British and Irish officials, but it

was presented as if it had come from Mitchell's own hand.

The parties knew the truth and they acted accordingly. The bulk of the negotiations leading up to

agreement were between them and the two governments, with Mitchell very secondary to events. But

they had been trapped by London and Dublin. The world believed it was Mitchell's deal and none wanted

to be the target for US criticism if the talks collapsed.

 AND SO A MYTH was born. Mitchell had negotiated the Good Friday Agreement. For a while it was

even called the "Mitchell Agreement," but that term soon fell into disuse, not least because there was

little appetite to perpetuate the fable among the participants.

None of this is to minimize the very constructive role that Mitchell otherwise played in the peace talks.

He was widely liked, scrupulously fair and was tough enough in the dealings he did have with all the

parties. But to credit him with winning the peace in Northern Ireland is a step too far. If Obama has

chosen him because he believes that he performed the role in Northern Ireland ascribed to him, then he

has made a mistake.

There is though an important lesson from Mitchell's time in Northern Ireland. The ploy devised by the

British and Irish governments worked for a very simple reason. The Americans were seen by all sides

as a largely disinterested party whose judgment and verdict thereby carried extra weight. They had no

dog in the fight. The same cannot be said for America's role in the Middle East. The real question

arising from Mitchell's appointment is whether Obama wishes to change that.

The writer is author of  A Secret History of the IRA and  Paisley - From Demagogue to Democrat?

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Be the first to rate this [?] | Top Rated Articles

2 more recommended posts »

 ADVERTISE WITH US  | MEDIA KIT

Have a question about something in this story? Ask it here

and get answers from other users like you.

Ask

You might like:

Nationalists riot in N. Ireland riots after police arrest 3 over killings

North Ireland riots after police arrest 3 over killings

Solar Stock Pick - EVSOEmerging Green Energy Co. Growth StockInvestmentwww.EvolutionSolar.com

"My Teeth Aren’t Yellow"Read the trick, discovered by a...CathysTeeth.com

Make up to $363 per day After I got laid off, I found a easy way tomake $7k a month...http://coreyhasmoney.com/ca

7/23/2019 His wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed Contributors | Jerusalem Post

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/his-wasnt-the-central-role-in-the-northern-ireland-peace-deal-op-ed 3/4

wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed C... http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1233304687555&pag

f 4 19/03/2009

Print Subscribe

E-mail Toolbar

+ Recommend:

What's this?

7/23/2019 His wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed Contributors | Jerusalem Post

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/his-wasnt-the-central-role-in-the-northern-ireland-peace-deal-op-ed 4/4

wasn't the central role in the Northern Ireland peace deal | Op-Ed C... http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1233304687555&pag

f 4 19/03/2009

JPost Sites: JPost Store · Judaica JPost Mall · America's Voices · Jhappening · Français · The Jerusalem Report · Invest in Israel · Jewish Obituaries

Sites of Interest: Car Donations · Donate Car  · BreitBart.com · The future of music · Maps of Israel · Gravesite Services · Unique Jewish Gifts · Fundraising Ideas · Car Rentals inIsrael · Web Hosting Providers · Dental Plans · Prom dresses and gowns · Prom dresses Jovani · Dresses · Trace Phone Number  · Poalim Online

 

Services: Print Edition · JPost CD-Rom · Subscriptions · Classifieds · Place a Classified Ad · Careers · E-mail Edition · Archives · ePaper  · JPost Toolbar  · NewsTicker · Podcasts · JP Mobile · AllJobs Israel · Christian World · Youth Magazines · Exclusive Content

JPost Guides: Charitable Funds · Green Israel · Real Estate Index · Israel Tour Guide · Philanthropy Guide  · Learn Hebrew  

Information:  About Us · Feedback · Media Kit · Sales · Staff E-mails · Privacy Statement · Copyright · Terms of Use · News Partners

© 1995 - 2009 The Jerusalem Post. All rights reserved.  About Us | Media Kit | Exclusive Content | Advertise with Us | Subscribe | Contact Us | RS S

The online edition of The Jerusalem Post – JPost.com – provides first class news and analysis about Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world. Whether news about Iran, Gaza, Syria, Fatah, Hamas or Hezbollah, JPost.com

covers the burning issues of the Middle East and the Israeli-Arab conflict.