High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri...

48
High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association (NSMA) Annual Meeting Arlington, VA May 16 th , 2018 [email protected] (o) 202-223-1028 (m) 202-253-3956

Transcript of High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri...

Page 1: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

High Frequency BandDevelopmentsJoseph M. Sandri

Founder & ceo

Thought Delivery Systems, Inc.

National Spectrum Managers Association (NSMA) Annual Meeting

Arlington, VA

May 16th, 2018

[email protected]

(o) 202-223-1028

(m) 202-253-3956

Page 2: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Higher Frequencies Are Experiencing

• Unprecedented Attention• Significant Accelerating Investment

• Spectrum• Chipsets• Innovations• Use cases• Infrastructure

• Ongoing Standardization and Channelization• Relative Peace That:

• Will Not Last If Unaddressed Interference Studies are not handled in the near-term

Page 3: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

• Developments in High Frequencies

• Regulatory

• Spectrum Frontiers (Upper Microwave Flexible Use Service

(UMFUS)

• Spectrum Horizons (95 GHz)

• Replicate 70/80/90 GHz Rules

• 102.2 GHz License PTP

• 15.2 GHz for Unlicensed

• New Experimental Regime (longer terms, ability to sell

services)

• (GN Docket No. 18-22) – Section 7 of Communications

Act – Encourage New Technologies & Services

• WRC-15 >> WRC-19 >> WRC-23

Overview (p 1 of 2)

Page 4: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

• Developments in High Frequencies

• Regulatory (cont’d)

• WRC-15 >> WRC-19 >> WRC-23

• Terrestrial Fixed Service, IMT, Satellite & HAPS

• Incumbent Licensees

• Market Developments & Forecasts

• Merger & Acquisitions

• Auctions (24GHz – 40 GHz, etc)

• Design, Deployment and Operations Challenges

• New Leaps: Circularly polarized transmit arrays; Massive MIMO

to Full Dimensional MIMO; Flexible Duplexing and other

innovations.

Open Discussion

Overview (p. 2 of 2)

Page 5: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

5G – The Goal

Omnipresent Gigabit!• Low Latency

• High signal availability

• Much more precision

Page 6: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

High Frequencies – In the Field

Some selected highlights:

-Radial Modulation

-Above 95GHz Chip sets

-IEEE MTTS

-TMO: 100Gbps Test bed @60 GHz

-BMW/SK Telecom: 5G Infrastructure in Korea• Low latency, autonomous car on highway 2018

-BMW/Intel: WiGig & Monumental Summit Chips• 28GHz, 39GHz, 60GHz. 15Gbps

-Qualcomm X50 chip (base band & RF at sub-

6GHz, 28GHz, 39 GHz• TDD, Adaptive beamforming, outdoor up to 30Mph w/ seemless

handover, 64QAM, 800MHz bandwidth, 5.25 bits per second

per hertz.

Page 7: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Radial (Circular

Polarization)

Source: Cambridge

University Press

Page 8: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

AT&T and Verizon 5G Press Releases“In addition to using mmWave for wireless and potentially fixed-wireless services, Stephens added AT&T is considering the use of mmWave for 5G backhaul. Particularly, he said AT&T tested mmWave to provide backhaul to small cells in “really congested areas”. T-Mobile trialed similar technology in November 2017”

8

Reflections from Day 1 at Mobile

World CongressBy: Hans Vestberg 06 MAR 2018

It was a fast paced first day at GSMA Mobile World Congress. The

industry is clearly moving away from discussions about what 5G could be

and towards what 5G WILL be. And those are the conversations Verizon

is eager to be central given the work we've done. I was excited to hear the

pace at which some of our partners and suppliers are working to

accelerate development cycles to make 5G a commercial reality as soon as

possible.

Several of us have noted: Verizon will be first in both fixed AND mobile

5G deployments. Check out the Light Reading story.

I'm looking forward to the next few days ahead and talking more about

how Verizon can collaborate and work with our most innovative and

aggressive partners to fuel the 5G ecosystem and solve problems for

customers. Here is one of a number of media interviews my colleagues

and I have done here at the show. This aired on CNBC Europe.

Tomorrow, Nicki Palmer will share her reflections of what's going on

with the mobile industry, and especially on 5G, in Barcelona.

“Several of us have noted: Verizon will be first in both fixed AND mobile 5G deployments.”

“The vendors named are similar to those listed as partners in Verizon’s ongoing fixed-wireless evaluations in 11 cities and the test location of Euless (a suburb of Dallas, Texas) was listed among Verizon’s fixed-wireless trial cities.”

Higher Frequency Stakeholders

Page 9: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Selected Mergers & Acquisitions

Verizon

• XO Communications • 28-31 GHz (LMDS)

• 39 GHz

• StraightPath ($3.1 B)• 28-31 GHz (LMDS)

• 39 GHz

AT&T ($208 M)

• FiberTower• 39 GHz (518 licenses nationwide)

9

Page 10: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

10

AT&T’s FiberTower Spectrum (514 Licenses in the 39GHz Band)

Page 11: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

11

Incomplete! ITU-R source documents, including fixed service system characteristics -- WRC-2019

Band(a)

(GHz)

Frequency range

(GHz)

Recommendations

ITU-R

F Series

Channel separation

(MHz)

27 24.25-29.5 748 Up to 112

31 31.0-31.3 746 Up to 50

32 31.8-33.4 1520 Up to 112

38 36.0-40.5 749 Up to 112

42 40.5-43.5 2005 Up to 112

52 51.4-52.6 1496 Up to 56

57 55.78-66 1497 Up to 56

70/80 71-76/81-86 2006 Up to 5000

94 92.0-94 / 94.1-95 2004 Up to100, N× 100Note:

a Although these are parts of the bands included in Recommendation ITU-R F.746, all frequency bands may not be designated for fixed service use in some countries.

Page 12: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

5G – In the Field: Selected Point to Multipoint TDD Characteristics

CCS 24-28GHz,

NLOS and LOS, 270-

Degree, SON, TDD,

Sweep every 100ms

PHAZR 28GHz, 39GHz;

Up to 16Gbps at hub using 200MHz

Channel; fixed & mobile 1Gbps

to remote location

Page 13: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

• Current and Near-Future Fixed Wireless / 5G Backhaul Characteristics

• Example: ITU-R F.749

• Common Sense Fixed Wireless Deployment Configurations

• NO Elevation Angle Flexibility studied• NO Low Power + Higher Power Deployment

Combinations

Satellite/HAPS WRC-2019 Interference StudiesMissing:

Page 14: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

5G – In the Field: Constant activity- today’s examples: T-Mobile Building Out 5G in 30 Cities This Year…and That’s Just the Start

(newsroom.t-mobile.com/news-and-blogs/mwc-2018-5g.htm) (February 27,

2018)

T-Mobile and Sprint to Combine, Accelerating 5G Innovation & Increasing

Competition, (April 29, 2018)

Sprint Blog Post:

Commercial gigabit LTE service set for launch this year in New Orleans to

supplement its 2.5 GHz-based network trials that started in March 2017.

"[M]illimeter and centimeter wave bands will serve as capacity hotspots,"

Chief Technology Officer John Saw said.

Page 15: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Above 24 GHz – 2nd Memorandum Opinion & Order – Spectrum Frontiers

Page 16: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

95 GHz NPRM – Spectrum Horizons

Page 17: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Above 24 GHz NPRM: Core Spectrum Blocks

Bands at issue:

• NPRM

• UMFUS

• 37-40 GHz

• LMDS

• Possible FNPRM

• 24 GHz DEMS: (24.25-24.45; 25.05-25.25 GHz)

• 42 GHz: (42.0-42.5 GHz)

• 60 GHz: (57-64 GHz; 64-71 GHz)

• 80/90 GHz: 71-76; 81-86 GHz)

Page 18: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Above 24 GHz 2nd MO&O

FURTHER Notice of Proposed Rulemaking:

• Overall: 12.5 GHz Added for UMFUS (Upper

Microwave Flexible Use Service; Part 30 in 47 CFR)

• 24.25-24.45

• 24.75-25.25

• 27.5-28.35

• 37.0-38.6

• 38.6-40.0

• 47.2-48.2

Page 19: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Tension Points on the Highway

• Terrestrial – to – “Sky”

• Satellite (FSS, MSS, BSS)

• NGSO

• GSO

• LEO

• High-Density

• HAPS

• Traditional Fixed Wireless and UMFUS

• FDD

• TDD

• Large Blocks

• Low Power & High Power

• In-Band

Page 20: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Satellite Coalition Sharing Requests – Overlapinto ITU

• FCC must address UMFUS aggregate interference skyward

From the surface of the earth.

• Preliminary results: Limited number of mobile terrestrial at

FCC proposed power levels could be severely disruptive

• SIA working with terrestrial providers

• Protect 28 GHz satellites from aggregate interference from

Terrestrial transmitters

• 37/39 GHz is an important expansion band.

Page 21: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Above 24 GHz NPRM: Core Currently Licensed Spectrum Blocks

Wide Area: Exclusively Licensed

• 24 GHz: (24.25-24.45; 25.05-25.25 GHz)

• 400 MHz – Divided into 5 channels

• LMDS: (27.5-28.35; 29.1-29.25, 31-31.3 GHz)

• Block A – 1150 MHz (27.5-28.35; 29.10-

29.25; 31.075-31.225 GHz)

• Block B – 150 MHz (31.00-31.075; 31.225-

31.300 GHz)

• 39 GHz: (38.6-40.0 GHz)

• 1.4 GHz – Divided into 14 channels

Page 22: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

22

Challenges for mmWave Mobility

• Acceptance on Security

• Beamforming

• Power Source

• Human Exposure: Heat more than RF

• Handset size

• Also:

• “more and higher carrier frequencies, more transitions, and wider modulation bandwidths, of

transmitters and receivers. Among the radio components, the power amplifier is often of central

interest due to its relative cost and relative importance in determining performance. Thus in a 5G

context, characterization and analysis of power amplifier performance can be quite important and

will be more challenging for a number of reasons:

• With higher carrier frequencies, stability and repeatability of the measurement can be more

difficult.

• Broader band and high frequency devices, and measurement systems, tend to have lower

return losses which can affect measurement accuracy. These mismatch effects are one part

of a broader power measurement accuracy question.

• Measurement speed can become an issue as the amount of frequency space to be

analyzed increases and the number of different parameters to be measured likely increases.

• Practicality of the measurement setup may become an issue as levels of complexity

increase” [Source: http://dl.cdn-anritsu.com/ja-jp/test-measurement/reffiles/About-

Anritsu/R_D/Technical/91/91-06-5g-2.pdf ]

Page 23: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

23

Potential interference scenerios in UMFUS (mmWave) bands

[Source: ITU-R]

Page 24: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

24

mmWave 5G & Automotive

Issues: 5G Mobile Networks have certain common environmental challenges regardless if they service:

• automotive occupants

• automobile functions

• highway/roadway management functions

[Source: ITU-R]

Page 25: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Conclusion

Higher Frequencies Are Experiencing

• Unprecedented Attention

• Significant Accelerating Investment in:

• Spectrum

• Chipsets

• Innovation research

• Use cases

• Infrastructure

• Ongoing Standardization and Channelization, and

• Relative Peace That:

• Will Not Last If Unaddressed Interference Studies are not handled in the

near-term

THANK YOU!Joseph Sandri

THOUGHT DELIVERY SYSTEMS

Ph: 202.223.1028

[email protected]

Page 26: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Selected References (1 of 6) Mobile World Congress, Barcelona, Spain (Feb. 27-March 3, 2017)

Mobile World Conggress, Barcelona, Spain (Feb. 26-March 1, 2018)

▪ Reflections from Day 1 at Mobile World Congress, by Hans Vestberg, February 26, 2018

▪ AT&T Weighs Fixed-Wireless Opportunity, Mobile World Live, March 6, 2018

Satellite / HAPS / Fixed Wireless 39GHz Interference Studies Underway for WRC-19 include:

▪ Agenda Item 1.6 to “consider the development of a regulatory framework for non-GSO FSS satellite systems that may

operate in the frequency bands 37.5-39.5 GHz (space-to-Earth), 39.5- 42.5 GHz (space-to-Earth), 47.2-50.2 GHz (Earth-

to-space) and 50.4-51.4 GHz (Earth-to-space), in accordance with Resolution 159 (WRC-15)” (Emphasis supplied).

▪ Resolution 160 section on HAPS global use at 38-39.5 GHz and region 2 use at 24.25-27.5 GHz (among other bands).

▪ Resolution 161 is designed to study spectrum needs and possible new allocations to the fixed-satellite service in the

frequency band 37.5-39.5 GHz (Earth-to-space).

▪ Resolution 810 has set a preliminary agenda for WRC-23, including Resolves 2.4, which seeks new allocations at 37.5-

39.5 GHz for earth-to-space systems in accordance with Resolution 161.

System parameters and considerations in the development of criteria for sharing or compatibility between

digital fixed wireless systems in the fixed service and systems in other services and other sources of

interference. Rec. ITU-R F.758 et al.

Determination of the criteria to protect fixed service receivers from the emissions of space stations operating

in non geostationary orbits in non frequency bands Rec. ITU-R F.1108-4 (2005)

https://www.itu.int/dms_pubrec/itu-r/rec/f/R-REC-F.1108-4-200501-I!!PDF-E.pdf

Maximum allowable error performance and availability degradations to digital fixed wireless systems arising

from radio interference from emissions and radiations from other sources. Rec ITU-R F.1094-2 (2007)

https://www.itu.int/dms_pubrec/itu-r/rec/f/R-REC-F.1094-2-200709-I!!PDF-E.pdf

Methods for Determining the Effects of Interference on Performance and Availability of Terrestrial Radio

Relay Systems and Systems in the Fixed Satellite Service Rec ITU-R SF.766 (1992)

https://www.itu.int/dms_pubrec/itu-r/rec/sf/R-REC-SF.766-0-199203-I!!PDF-E.pdf

Page 27: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Selected References (2 of 6)

Mobile World Congress, Barcelona, Spain (Feb. 27-March 3, 2017)

Rohde & Schwarz Webinar: Interference Hunting in 5G Networks (Scheduled May 24, 2017)

PHAZR, 5G Mobile Internet is Coming! www.phazr.net (screen capture May 16, 2017)

FIBERTOWER LAUNCHES WIRELESS TECHNOLOGY FROM CCS: The First Self-Organizing 24GHz

System in the U.S. Supports 5G Infrastructure, http://www.fibertower.com/press-

releases/2016/10/4/fibertower-launches-wireless-technology-from-ccs (Oct. 2016)

“Millimeter-Wave Base Station for Mobile Broadband Communication,” F.Aryanfar, Z. Pi, H. Zhou, T.

Henige, G. Xu, S. Abu-Sura, D. Psychoudakis, F.Khan, Samsung Research America (May 2015)

“Study of Coexistence between 5G Small-Cell Systes and Systems of the Fixed Service at 39 GHz

Band,” J.Kim, L.Xian, A. Maltev, R. Aregi, A.S. Sadri, Intel Corporation, Nizhny Nogorod State

University

IEEE MTT-S (IMS2015) May 2015

JRC Small Cell Backhaul WIPAS 2 (Mar. 2013)

JRC 24GHz PMP & PTP small cell backhaul: “The JRC-FiberTower Process for Providing Access to

Licensed 24GHz and 39GHz Spectrum” (May 2012)

http://www.jrcamerica.com/download/WIPAS_Spectrum_in_US.pdf

Wikipedia Femtocell: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femtocell

Wikipedia Macrocell: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macrocell

Inacon Picocell: http://www.inacon.de/glossary/Pico-cell.php

ITU-T (July 2011) (see p.11): http://www.itu.int/dms_pub/itu-t/oth/06/4D/T064D0000020072PDFE.pdf

IWPC small cell workshop Jan-Feb 2012:

http://www.iwpc.org/Workshop_Folders/12_02_SmallCell_Backhaul/12_02_Agenda_Backhaul.html

Page 28: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Selected References (3 of 6)

Comptel Connection, Vol. 9, No. 18 (May 6, 2013)

FCC Small Cell and DAS program (Feb 1, 2012): http://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-workshop-das-

and-small-cells-february-1-2012

FCC Gigabit City Workshop, Mar. 2013 (http://www.fcc.gov/events/gigabit-workshop-1 )

JDSU

Ericsson Review 2013.3

Marvedis Front Haul Trends (Dec 2012)

FCC ULS search May 8, 2013: Call sign WPND768

John Janka et al, Latham & Watkins LLP Letter to FCC re: FiberTower Corporation’s Request for

Extension of Time, or in the Alternative, Limited Waiver of Substantial Service Requirement, ULS File

No. 0005207557 et al. (May 3, 2013)

John Janka et al, Latham & Watkins LLP Letter to FCC re: FiberTower Corporation’s Request for

Extension of Time, or in the Alternative, Limited Waiver of Substantial Service Requirement, ULS File

No. 0005207557 et al. (April 3, 2013)

FCC Small Cell and DAS program (Feb 1, 2012): http://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-workshop-das-

and-small-cells-february-1-2012

CTIA Small Cell program (May 2012): http://www.ctiawireless.com/events/eventdetails.cfm/1468

AT&T Small Cell pilot due late 2012; early 2013: http://www.engadget.com/2012/05/08/att-small-cell-

site-pilot-due-late-2012-2013/

Lightreading: DragonWave small cell product with FiberTower spectrum:

http://www.lightreading.com/document.asp?doc_id=213881

Page 29: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Selected References (4 of 6)

Verizon; WirelessWeek “VoLTE: Coming Soon to a Phone Near You”, Oct. 15,

2013, http://www.wirelessweek.com/articles/2013/10/volte-coming-soon-phone-near-you

Pascagoula School District: TV White Space Project Presentation, SHLB, May 9, 2014, Washington,

DC

New America Foundation: SHLB Conference, 5/9/2014

Dell’Oro Group

NTT DOMOCO, 5/8/2014, "DOMOCO to Conduct 5G Experimental Trials with World-leading Mobile

Technology Vendors“

“Samsung Says New Superfast “5G” Works with Handsets in Motion” MIT Technology Review 6/3/13

http://www.technologyreview.com/news/515631/samsung-says-new-superfast-5g-works-with-

handsets-in-motion

WirelessTelecom.Wordpress.com , 5/4/2014

FCC; Fletcher Heald & Hildred CommLaw Blog, 11/20/2013

2013 Samsung DMC R&D Communications Research

Use of Spectrum Bands Above 24 GHz for Mobile Radio Services, et al., GN Docket No. 14-177, et al.,

Notice of Inquiry, 29 FCC Rcd 13020 (2014) (“NOI”)

Use of Spectrum Bands Above 24 GHz for Mobile Radio Services, et al., GN Docket No. 14-177, et al.,

Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, 81 Fed. Reg. 1802 (2015) (NPRM).

NOI Comments of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings, LLC, GN Docket No. 14-177 (filed Jan. 15, 2015)

NOI Reply Comment of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings, LLC, GN Docket No. 14-177 (filed Feb. 18,

2015)

Page 30: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Ex Parte Letter of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings LLC, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Apr. 24, 2015)

Ex Parte Filing of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings LLC, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Sep. 2, 2015)

Ex Parte Letter of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings LLC, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Oct. 15, 2015)

NPRM Comments of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings, LLC, GN Docket No. 14-177 (filed Jan. 27, 2016)

NPRM Reply Comments of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings, LLC, GN Docket No. 14-177 (filed Feb. 26,

2016)

Ex Parte Filing of FiberTower Spectrum Holdings LLC, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Mar. 28, 2016)

Ex Parte Filing of Ericsson, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Feb. 23, 2016)

Ex Parte Letter of Ericsson, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Jan. 8, 2016)

Ex Parte Letter of Verizon, GN-Docket No. 14-177 (filed Dec. 18, 2015)

“Verizon 5G Fixed Wireless Pilot Tracking for 2017”, RCR Wireless News, Sean Kinney, (Apr 22,2016)

http://www.rcrwireless.com/20160422/carriers/verizon-tracking-fixed-wireless-5g-pilot-2017-tag17 (last

accessed 5/5/16)

Spectrum Frontiers Workshop, Federal Communications Commissions, March 10 2016,

https://www.fcc.gov/news-events/events/2016/03/spectrum-frontiers-workshop (last accessed 5/5/16)

“5G a Triumph of Hype Over Expectation?”, Industrial iot 5G, David Pringle,(April 25, 2016)

http://industrialiot5g.com/5g-triumph-hype-expectation-tag28/ (last accessed 5/10/16)

“5G Standards Work Enables Global Scale”, Industrial iot 5G, Sean Kinney (April 22, 2016)

http://industrialiot5g.com/5g-standards-work-enables-global-scale-tag17-tag99/ (last accessed 5/10/16)

“Dish Warns Key 5G Spectrum ‘will be controlled almost exclusively by Verizon’ if XO deal approved”, Fierce

Wireless, Colin Gibbs (May 4, 2016) http://www.fiercewireless.com/story/dish-warns-5g-will-be-controlled-

almost-exclusively-verizon-if-carrier-acqu/2016-05-04 (last accesses 5/10/16)

Selected References (5 of 6)

Page 31: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Telecom Pulse (showcase Alcatel-Lucent cube): http://telecompulse.com/2011/02/12/small-cell-

technology-that-can-replace-cellular-towers-to-be-showcased-at-mwc-2011/

ITU-R P.1411-1:

http://symoon.free.fr/scs/ofdm/biblio/Transmission%20pour%20micro%20drones%202004/Netograph

ie/Modelisation%20de%20canal/ITU_R_P1411.pdf

Instat Small Cell study: http://www.instat.com/mp/10/IN1004712GW_Sample.pdf

EFYMag (Jan. 2011): http://www.efymagonline.com/pdf/Femto-Cells_Jan11.pdf

“Verizon Confirms XO Spectrum in 28 GHz and 39 GHz Bands Will Be Used in 5G Tests”, Fierce Wireless,

Colin Gibbs (February 23, 2016). http://www.fiercewireless.com/story/verizon-confirms-xo-spectrum-28-ghz-

and-39-ghz-bands-will-be-used-5g-tests/2016-02-23 (last accessed 5/10/16)

Petition To Deny of DISH Network Corporation in Application of XO Communications. LLC and Verizon

Communications Inc. for Transfer of Control of Licenses and Authorizations, WC Docket. 16-70 (filed May 3,

2016)

Jon Martens, Anritsu Paper, Millimeter-Wave VNA Characterization using Modulated Signals, (Mar 2016)

http://dl.cdn-anritsu.com/ja-jp/test-measurement/reffiles/About-Anritsu/R_D/Technical/91/91-06-5g-2.pdf (last

accessed 5/10/16)

“CEO Details Sprint 5G Plans, Upcoming Trial”, Industrial iot 5G, Sean Kinney (May 4, 2016).

http://industrialiot5g.com/sprint-5g-plans-tag17/ (last accessed 5/10/16)

ITU-R F.748 (24.25-29.5 GHz)

ITU-R F.746 (31.0-31.3 GHz)

ITU-R F.1520 (31.8-33.4 GHz)

ITU-R F.749 (36.0-40.5 GHz)

Selected References (6 of 56

Page 32: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Selected Background Slides

Page 33: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

Working Party 5 ITU

1.Fixed Service Working Party 5 addresses fixed wireless sharing IMT, HAPS ad satellite in

preparation for WRC-19

2. Total U.S. mmWave Licensees attending

3.ITU-R Recommendation F.758/9 System Characteristics needs input ASAP

Page 34: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION: System Parameters and considerations in the development of criteria for sharing or compatibility between digital fixed Wireless systems in the fixed service and systems in other services and other sources of interference

Page 35: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION:Table 8

Page 36: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION: Table 9

Page 37: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION: Table 10

Page 38: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION: Table 11

Page 39: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION: Table 12

Page 40: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

ITU RECOMMENDATION F.758 REVISION: Table 16

Page 41: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

WRC-2015: 5G Related Resolutions for WRC-19: Slide A

SPECTRUM DEVELOPMENT OVERVIEW:

• Mobile industry

o 24-27 GHz and 37-40.5 GHz, along with eight other bands, were cleared for

global IMT (International Mobile Telecommunications) development.

▪ Agenda Item 1.13

▪ LMDS (28-31 GHz) was blocked internationally, but the U.S., Japan &

Korea stated they will continue their development domestically.

• Satellite industry

o LMDS and 39 GHz bands.

▪ Agenda Items 1.5 and 1.6

• Google: High altitude platforms (HAPS) broadband system

o 21.4-22 GHz and 24.25-27.5 GHz (Region 2 – Americas), and 38-39.5 GHz

(Globally) were cleared.

▪ Agenda Item 1.14

▪ Fixed Industry Opposition to Google: Google also is making similar filings

for experimental licenses at the FCC for the 70-90 GHz bands, though they

are redacted. The Fixed Wireless Communications Coalition (FWCC) and

other organizations are starting to prepare oppositions at the FCC to force

them to identify their proposed sharing criteria.

Page 42: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

WRC-2015: 5G Related Resolutions for WRC-19: Slide C

1.6 to consider the development of a regulatory framework for non-GSO FSS satellite systems that may

operate in the frequency bands 37.5-39.5 GHz (space-to-Earth), 39.5-42.5 GHz (space-to-Earth), 47.2-50.2 GHz (Earth-

to-space) and 50.4-51.4 GHz (Earth-to-space), in accordance with Resolution COM6/18 (WRC-15);

Resolution

COM6/18 (WRC-15)

Studies of technical,

operational issues and

regulatory provisions for

non-geostationary fixed-

satellite services satellite

systems in the frequency

bands 37.5-39.5 GHz

(space-to-Earth), 39.5-

42.5 GHz (space-to-

Earth), 47.2-50.2 GHz

(Earth-to-space) and 50.4-

51.4 GHz (Earth-to-space)

WP 4A

resolves to invite ITU-R

to conduct, and complete in time for WRC-19:

1 studies of technical and operational issues and

regulatory provisions for the operation of non-GSO FSS satellite

systems in the frequency bands 37.5-42.5 GHz (space-to-Earth) and

47.2-48.9 GHz (limited to feeder links only), 48.9-50.2 GHz and

50.4-51.4 GHz (all Earth-to-space), while ensuring protection of GSO

satellite networks in the FSS, MSS and BSS, without limiting or

unduly constraining the future development of GSO networks across

those bands, and without modifying the provisions of Article 21;2 studies carried out under resolves to invite ITU-R 1 shall focus exclusively on the development of equivalent power flux-

density limits produced at any point in the GSO by emissions from all the earth stations of a non-GSO system in the fixed-satellite service

or into any geostationary FSS earth station, as appropriate;

3 studies and development of sharing conditions between non-GSO FSS systems operating in the frequency bands listed in

resolves to invite ITU-R 1 above;

4 studies of possible necessary revisions to Resolution 750 (Rev.WRC-15) to ensure protection of the EESS (passive) in the

frequency bands 36-37 GHz and 50.2-50.4 GHz from non-GSO FSS transmission, taking into account recognizing i) above, including study

of aggregate FSS interference effects from networks and systems operating or planned to operate in the frequency bands described in

resolves to invite ITU-R 1 above;

5 studies towards ensuring protection of the radio astronomy frequency bands 42.5-43.5 GHz, 48.94-49.04 GHz and 51.4-

54.25 GHz from non-GSO FSS transmissions, taking into account recognizing i) above, including study of aggregate FSS interference

effects from networks and systems operating or planned to operate in the frequency bands described in resolves to invite ITU-R 1 above,

further resolves

to invite WRC-19 to consider the results of the above studies and take appropriate action,

WP 5A

WP 5B

WP 5C]

WP 5D

WP 6A

WP 7B

WP 7C

WP 7D

(WP 3M)

(WP 4B)

Page 43: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

WRC-2015: 5G Related Resolutions for WRC-19: Slide D

1.12 to consider possible global or regional harmonized frequency bands, to the maximum extent

possible, for the implementation of evolving Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS) under existing mobile-

service allocations, in accordance with Resolution COM6/13 (WRC-15);

Resolution COM6/13 (W

RC-15)

Intelligent Transport

Systems applications

WP 5A

resolves to invite the 2019 World Radiocommunication

Conference

taking into account the results of ITU Radiocommunication

Sector (ITU-R) studies, to consider possible global or regional

harmonized frequency bands for the implementation of

evolving ITS under existing mobile-service allocations,

invites ITU-R

to carry out studies on technical and operational aspects of

evolving ITS implementation using existing mobile-service

allocations,

WP 4A

WP 4B

WP 4C

WP 5B

WP 5C

WP 5D

WP 7C

WP 7B

WP 7D

(WP 3K)

(WP 6A)

Page 44: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

WRC-2015: 5G Related Resolutions for WRC-19: Slide E

1.13 to consider identification of frequency bands for the future development of International Mobile

Telecommunications (IMT), including possible additional allocations to the mobile service on a primary basis, in

accordance with Resolution COM6/20 (WRC-15);

Resolution COM6/20 (W

RC-15)

Studies on frequency-

related matters for

International Mobile

Telecommunications

identification including

possible additional

allocations to the mobile

services on a primary basis

in portion(s) of the

frequency range between

24.25 and 86 GHz for the

future development of

International Mobile

Telecommunications

for 2020 and beyond

TG5/1

resolves to invite ITU-R

1 to conduct and complete in time for WRC-19 the appropriate studies to determine the spectrum needs for the terrestrial

component of IMT in the frequency range between 24.25 GHz and 86 GHz, taking into account:

– technical and operational characteristics of terrestrial IMT systems that would operate in this frequency range, including the

evolution of IMT through advances in technology and spectrally efficient techniques;

– the deployment scenarios envisaged for IMT-2020 systems and the related requirements of high data traffic such as in dense

urban areas and/or in peak times;

– the needs of developing countries;

– the time-frame in which spectrum would be needed;

2 to conduct and complete in time for WRC-19 the appropriate sharing and compatibility studies1, taking into account the

protection of services to which the band is allocated on a primary basis, for the frequency bands:

– 24.25-27.5 GHz2, 37-40.5 GHz, 42.5-43.5 GHz, 45.5-

47 GHz, 47.2-50.2 GHz, 50.4-52.6 GHz, 66-76 GHz and 81-

86 GHz, which have allocations to the mobile service on a

primary basis; and

– 31.8-33.4 GHz, 40.5-42.5 GHz and 47-47.2 GHz,

which may require additional allocations to the mobile service

on a primary basis,

further resolves

1 to invite CPM19-1 to define the date by which

technical and operational characteristics needed for sharing and

compatibility studies are to be available, to ensure that studies referred

to in resolves to invite ITU-R can be completed in time for

consideration at WRC-19;

2 to invite WRC-19 to consider, based on the results of the above studies, additional spectrum allocations to the

mobile service on a primary basis and to consider identification of frequency bands for the terrestrial component of IMT; the bands to be

considered being limited to part or all of the bands listed in resolves to invite ITU-R 2,

____________

1 Including studies with respect to services in adjacent bands, as appropriate.

2 When conducting studies in the band 24.5-27.5 GHz, to take into account the need to ensure the protection of existing earth stations and the

deployment of future receiving earth stations under the EESS (space-to-Earth) and SRS (space-to-Earth) allocation in the frequency band 25.5-

Note: the

groups

below are

involved

groups

contributi

ng to this

issue

WP 3J

WP3K

WP 3M

WP 4A

WP 4B

WP 4C

WP 5A

WP 5B

WP 5C

WP 5D

WP 6A

WP 7B

WP 7C

WP 7D

Page 45: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

WRC-2015: 5G Related Resolutions for WRC-19: Slide F

1.14 to consider, on the basis of ITU-R studies in accordance with Resolution COM6/21 (WRC-15),

appropriate regulatory actions for high-altitude platform stations (HAPS), within existing fixed-service allocations;

Resolution COM6/21

(WRC-15)

Facilitating access to

broadband applications

delivered by high-altitude

platform stations

WP 5C

resolves to invite ITU-R

1 to study additional spectrum needs for gateway and fixed terminal links for HAPS to provide broadband connectivity

in the fixed service taking into account:

– the existing identifications and deployments of HAPS systems;

– the deployment scenarios envisioned for HAPS broadband systems and related requirements such as in remote areas;

– the technical and operational characteristics of HAPS systems, including the evolution of HAPS through advances in

technology and spectrally-efficient techniques, and their deployment;

2 to study the suitability of using the existing identifications in recognizing c), on a global or regional level, taking into

account the regulatory provisions, such as geographical and technical restrictions associated with existing HAPS identifications based on

the study performed in resolves to invite ITU-R 1;

3 to study appropriate modifications to the existing footnotes and associated resolutions in the identifications in

recognizing c) in order to facilitate the use of HAPS links on a global or regional level, limited to the currently identified frequency bands

and, where the use of an identification is not technically feasible for HAPS use, the possible removal of

the unsuitable identification;

4 to study, in order to meet any spectrum needs which

could not be satisfied under resolves to invite ITU-R 1 and 2, for the

use of gateway and fixed terminal links for HAPS, the following

frequency bands already allocated to the fixed service on a primary

basis, not subject to Appendices 30, 30A, and 30B in any region:

– on a global level: 38-39.5 GHz, and

– on a regional level: in Region 2, 21.4-22 GHz and

24.25-27.5 GHz,further resolves

1 that the studies referred to in resolves to invite ITU-R 3 and 4 include sharing and compatibility studies to ensure protection

of existing services allocated in the frequency ranges identified and, as appropriate, adjacent band studies, taking into account studies

already performed in ITU-R;

2 that modifications studied under resolves to invite ITU-R 3 shall not consider the use of HAPS links in the frequency bands

subject to Appendix 30B;

3 to develop ITU-R Recommendations and Reports, as appropriate, on the basis of the studies called for in resolves to invite

ITU-R 1, 2, 3, and 4 above,

resolves to invite the 2019 World Radiocommunication Conference

to consider the results of the above studies and take necessary regulatory actions, as appropriate, provided that the results referred to in

resolves to invite ITU-R are complete and agreed by ITU-R study groups.

WP 4A

WP 4C

WP 5A

WP 5D

WP 7B

WP 7C

(WP 3M)

(WP 7D)

Page 46: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

IMT Support for Giving Incumbent mmWave Licensees Flexible Mobile/Fixed Rights

Verizon CEO Lowell McAdams to Tom Wheeler

“Mr. McAdam emphasized the importance to the US economy and US consumer of the Commission acting quickly to make the spectrum bands above 24 GHz available for mobile broadband. Verizon agrees with the Commission’s primary proposal to grant flexible use rights to existing terrestrial licensees in the 28 GHz and 39 GHz bands.”

Page 47: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

mmWave Mobile Handset

Page 48: High Frequency Band Developments - Spectrum …...High Frequency Band Developments Joseph M. Sandri Founder & ceo Thought Delivery Systems, Inc. National Spectrum Managers Association

48

mmWave: Handset Coverage Between Base Stations Sources: Samsung, Intel, IEEE MTT-S 2015, FiberTower

0-100 meters

0-100

Meters: -60

GHz,

-70/80 GHz

0-300 Meters –

-LMDS

-37 GHz

-39 GHz

-42 GHz

0-500 Meters:

-20 GHz,

-24GHz,

-26GHz