HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

11
Reticom Solutions Measure, Monitor, Manage 2455 Wyandotte St West , Windsor, ON, Canada N9B0C1 Tel: (226) 344-7809 Fax: (519) 253-3000 www.reticom.ca [email protected] HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS ENGINEERING SERVICES FOR POWER PLANTS AND ENERGY SYSTEMS

Transcript of HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

Page 1: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

Reticom SolutionsMeasure, Monitor, Manage

2455 Wyandotte St West , Windsor, ON, Canada N9B0C1Tel: (226) 344-7809 Fax: (519) 253-3000www.reticom.ca [email protected]

HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSISENGINEERING SERVICES FOR POWER PLANTS AND ENERGY SYSTEMS

Page 2: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

HRSG & DUCT BURNER

2

Superheater

Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG)with Supplementary Firing

Main Challenges of Design of burners:

Providing uniform and aligned flow around burners tohave a safe & stable flame

Providing flow with uniform temperature and velocity atsuperheater cross-section

Duct burner is used to enhance the amount of energyof hot gas entering the HRSG.

Page 3: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

FLOW AROUND BURNERS

3

Hot spot on burner

RecirculationZone

Reverse Flame Region

Minor Reverse Flame

Major Reverse Flame

Page 4: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

FLOW & TEMPERATURE AT SUPERHEATER SECTION

4

Superheater Inlet

Temperature Normalized VelocityDistribution of temperature

and velocity of flue gasentering HRSG

Non-Uniformity is inevitable!

Page 5: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

FLOW & TEMPERATURE AT SUPERHEATER SECTION

5

All thermal calculations of heatexchangers are based onassuming uniform distribution offlow and temperature on theflue gas side.

Heat transfer Efficiency

Metal temperature

Mechanical Strength

Fin tip temperature

Thermal stress

All calculations are affected by non-uniformity of flow and temperature on the gas side.

Page 6: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

ESTIMATION OF EFFECTS OF NON-UNIFORMITIES

6

Method #1: Conjugate Heat Transfer Analysis(CFD of flue gas, tube metal and steam simultaneously)

Only applicable for simplified geometries

Impossible to implement forreal arrangements due to

excessive computational cost

Page 7: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

ESTIMATION OF EFFECTS OF NON-UNIFORMITIES

7

Method #2: CFD of flue gas side and assuming uniform heat sink in domain, then applyingdesign criteria to limit degree of non-uniformity in temperature and velocity distributions offlue gas flow entering heat exchangers

This method is currently used by boiler designers.

Examples of Design criteria

Keep RMS of velocity deviations below 30%.

Temperature variations are limited to ±50°C fromaverage temperature.

Each boiler vendor uses its own standards.

Margins are always conservative.

Does not consider finned tube arrangements.

Results in unnecessary duct length.

Requires high value of draft loss.

Fin density is not considered.

Does not consider steam temperature.

Accurate stress analysis is impossible.

Page 8: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

ESTIMATION OF EFFECTS OF NON-UNIFORMITIES

8

Method #3: CFD of flue gas side and implementing a mathematical modelto calculate heat transfer of finned tubes as a heat sink

Each computational cell isconsidered as an individualheat exchanger!

Steam flow is solvedvirtually by engaging user-defined scalar approach.

Our Method!

Note! Ansys Fluentprovides a similar method,but it comes with severallimitations.

Page 9: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

SAMPLES OF RESULTS

9

1 2 3 4

561: Gas Temperature (inlet)

2: Gas Velocity (inlet)

3: Steam Temperature

4: Fin Base Temperature

5: Fin Tip Temperature

6: Gas Temperature (outlet)

Page 10: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

OTHER POTENTIAL APPLICATIONS

10

Hel

ical

Hea

tEx

chan

ger

Fire

-Tub

e Bo

iler

Olefin CrackingFurnace

Page 11: HIGH-FIDELITY HEAT TRANSFER ANALYSIS

RETICOM SOLUTIONS www.reticom.ca [email protected]

Reticom SolutionsMeasure, Monitor, Manage

2455 Wyandotte St West , Windsor, ON, Canada N9B0C1Tel: (226) 344-7809 Fax: (519) 253-3000