Hesed Depend s on Saying No

2
(Jewish ma a Jewish m Library’s wo Ketubbah for of Moses Ha In this ketu groom “agr hiding or control the between th this matter celebrates Sephardi, p The decora The floral implements that has no See t To receive T arriage contracts) marriage. This no orld-renowned co r the wedding of Ju i Curiel, Friday, Ma ubbah’s unusually ree to conduct t concealing anyt ir possessions eq em, they shall fo r.” The latter s a “mixed” mar presumably Ashk ation is characte border contain s from the ancie beginning or en the full ketubba orah from JTS by e TORAH FROM J ) have establishe otable ketubbah ollection. udah Leon, son of J ay 30, 1749, Venice, y romantic enga their mutual life thing from each qually. However, ollow the custom stipulation was rriage between kenazi, groom. eristic of Venice ns the twelve si nt Jerusalem Te nd is borrowed fro ah at www.jtsa. email, visit www.jts JTS ed the financial r is one of over 5 Jehiel mi-Salom, an , Italy agement articles with love and af h other; further in case of a qua s of the Ashkena inserted becaus a Sephardi bri e and the surrou igns of the zod emple in the corn om Italian folk cu edu/venetian- sa.edu/torah responsibilities in 500 in The JTS nd Rachel, daughter s, the bride and ffection, without rmore, they wil rrel, God forbid, azim in Venice in se the contract de and a non- unding environs. diac, as well as ners. A love knot ulture. -ketubbah Hayy Of al (kindn “no.” Rebec She ca called camels mome twice i and co Rebec open f as you to our Hesed preced Rebec three orkhim import who w In all t “yes” t strang behalf n S r d t l , n t - . s t yei Sarah 577 Hes Rabbi Leagu l the lessons t ness), perhaps its cca, the heroine an lift a heavy wa hesed. When s s, she fulfills Eli ents earlier to fin in this brief pray ompletely by Reb cca’s hesed is rew field at dusk (Ge ung love, and is a sense of human d is defined earl ded—and may cca will marry. I strangers to his m (welcoming gu tant kindness lea will become the fi these scenes, the to another perso er; or Eliezer ea f of Abraham; or www.jtsa. 77 ed Depend Lilly Kaufman, e for Conservat that Parashat H s most important of the parashah ater urn with ease she gives water iezer’s eloquent nd a fitting wife er (Gen. 24:12, 1 becca’s action th warded later on w en. 24:62-66). Ap as basic to our inn autonomy and p lier in the Bible have precipitate In Parashat Vay and Sarah’s ten uests), which is a ads to the announ irst heir to Abrah e kind acts that w on: whether it is arnestly praying r the protective l .edu/torah ds on Sayi Director, Torah tive Judaism, JT Hayyei Sarah te t lesson can be h, is both physica e, and she posses to Abraham’s s prayer, in whic for Isaac. He na 14), and his praye hat Eliezer is stun with an awkward pparently hesed ner capaciousnes possibility. e, without being ed—the birth o yera, Abraham nt, inventing the a central form of ncement of the m ham’s spiritual leg we read about ar Rebecca genero to God, not on ove of the strong ה ר תשע" זng No h Fund of Wom TS eaches us abou summed up in t ally and ethically sses a deep grac servant, Eliezer, ch he appealed ames the value o er is answered so nned (Gen. 24:21) but real love sce is as natural to h ss as a wide-ope named, in an of Isaac, the ve energetically we e mitzvah of hac f hesed in Judais miraculous birth gacy. re forms of an e ously offering wa n his own behalf, g Rebecca for th ר ש חייen's ut hesed he word y strong. iousness and his to God of hesed o rapidly ). ene in an umanity n field is act that ery man elcomed chnassat sm. This of Isaac, mpathic ater to a , but on he quiet,

Transcript of Hesed Depend s on Saying No

Page 1: Hesed Depend s on Saying No

(Jewish maa Jewish mLibrary’s wo Ketubbah forof Moses HaIn this ketugroom “agrhiding or control thebetween ththis mattercelebrates Sephardi, pThe decoraThe floral implementsthat has no

See t

To receive T

arriage contracts)marriage. This noorld-renowned co

r the wedding of Jui Curiel, Friday, Ma

ubbah’s unusuallyree to conduct tconcealing anytir possessions eqem, they shall for.” The latter sa “mixed” mar

presumably Ashkation is characteborder contain

s from the anciebeginning or en

the full ketubbaTorah from JTS by e

TORAH FROM J

) have establisheotable ketubbah ollection.

udah Leon, son of Jay 30, 1749, Venice,y romantic engatheir mutual life thing from eachqually. However, ollow the customstipulation was rriage between kenazi, groom. eristic of Venicens the twelve sint Jerusalem Te

nd is borrowed froah at www.jtsa.email, visit www.jts

JTS

ed the financial ris one of over 5

Jehiel mi-Salom, an, Italy agement articleswith love and af

h other; furtherin case of a quas of the Ashkenainserted becausa Sephardi bri

e and the surrouigns of the zod

emple in the cornom Italian folk cuedu/venetian-sa.edu/torah

responsibilities in500 in The JTS

nd Rachel, daughter

s, the bride andffection, withoutrmore, they wilrrel, God forbid,

azim in Venice inse the contractde and a non-

unding environs.diac, as well asners. A love knotulture. -ketubbah

Hayy

Of al(kindn“no.” RebecShe cacalled camelsmometwice iand coRebecopen fas youto our HesedprecedRebecthree orkhimimportwho wIn all t“yes” tstrangbehalf

n S

r

d t l ,

n t -

. s t

yei Sarah 577

Hes

Rabbi Leagu

l the lessons tness), perhaps its

cca, the heroine an lift a heavy wa

hesed. When ss, she fulfills Eli

ents earlier to finin this brief prayompletely by Rebcca’s hesed is rewfield at dusk (Ge

ung love, and is asense of human

d is defined earlded—and may cca will marry. Istrangers to his

m (welcoming gutant kindness lea

will become the fithese scenes, theto another persoer; or Eliezer ea

f of Abraham; or

www.jtsa.

77

ed DependLilly Kaufman, e for Conservat

that Parashat Hs most important

of the parashahater urn with easeshe gives water iezer’s eloquent nd a fitting wife er (Gen. 24:12, 1becca’s action th

warded later on wen. 24:62-66). Apas basic to our inn autonomy and plier in the Biblehave precipitateIn Parashat Vay

and Sarah’s tenuests), which is aads to the announirst heir to Abrahe kind acts that won: whether it is arnestly praying r the protective l

.edu/torah

ds on SayiDirector, Torah

tive Judaism, JT

Hayyei Sarah tet lesson can be

h, is both physicae, and she possesto Abraham’s sprayer, in whic

for Isaac. He na14), and his prayehat Eliezer is stunwith an awkward pparently hesed ner capaciousnespossibility.

e, without beinged—the birth oyera, Abraham nt, inventing thea central form ofncement of the mham’s spiritual legwe read about arRebecca generoto God, not onove of the strong

ז"תשערה

ng No h Fund of WomTS

eaches us abousummed up in t

ally and ethicallysses a deep gracservant, Eliezer, ch he appealed ames the value oer is answered so

nned (Gen. 24:21)but real love sceis as natural to hss as a wide-ope

named, in an of Isaac, the veenergetically we

e mitzvah of hacf hesed in Judaismiraculous birth gacy. re forms of an eously offering wan his own behalf,g Rebecca for th

חיי שר

en's

ut hesed he word

y strong. iousness and his to God

of hesed o rapidly ).

ene in an umanity n field is

act that ery man elcomed chnassat sm. This of Isaac,

mpathic ater to a , but on he quiet,

Page 2: Hesed Depend s on Saying No

TORAH FROM JTS www.jtsa.edu/torah

pensive Isaac in his mother’s tent in the field. All these kindly “yeses” are tempered with an important “no” that is implied in two scenes in Hayyei Sarah. When Abraham instructs Eliezer to seek a wife for Isaac in Abraham’s homeland and bring her back to Canaan to marry Isaac, Eliezer raises a question: “What if the woman doesn’t consent to follow me to this land, shall I then take your son to the land from which you came?” (Gen. 24:5) Abraham answers that if the woman refuses consent, Eliezer is relieved of his oath. If she does not want to go with Eliezer, she doesn’t have to. She can say “no.” Rebecca’s right to say “no” to a man is expressed still more forcefully later on in the story, when Eliezer invites Rebecca to leave her family home and travel to Canaan to become Isaac’s wife. Her mother and her brother invent a simple way to decide whether Rebecca should go or not: They ask her! “Nikra lana’arah venishalah et pihah,” “Let us call the girl and ask for her reply” (Gen. 24:57). Here, too, Rebecca can say “no.” In Hayyei Sarah, the happiest form of “yes,” the consent to marry, is twice predicated on the woman’s right to say “yes” or “no.” Her “no,” if she had said it, would have been decisive, both to her nuclear family and to her future father-in-law, Abraham. Regrettably, Abraham was not always so sensitive to the wishes of women. The first time the word hesed appears in the Bible, it is used in a rather terrible way by Abraham towards his wife, Sarah. In the incident at Gerar in Parashat Vayera (Gen. 20), Abraham asks Sarah to present herself as his sister in order to protect him from violence, should the godless men of Gerar desire her. Abraham believes that if these men were to learn that he is her husband, they would kill him in order to seize her. He tells her, “let this be hasdech [your kindness] that you shall do to me: whatever place we come to, say there of me: He is my brother” (Gen. 20:13). Here hasdech is pointedly Sarah’s kindness, since Sarah is in a unique position to rescue Abraham from danger. The problem is that making Sarah complicit in this lie about their relationship could result in her unwanted sexual intimacy with dangerous strangers. As the story unfolds, the local king, Abimelech, does seize her, and God must intervene to prevent adultery. Abraham’s plan for Sarah opens the door to Sarah’s sexual coercion, and almost entraps Sarah and Abimelech in a mortal sin. Abraham has instructed Sarah to act against her

own best interests; as Rashi notes, “He [Abraham] did not ask [her] permission, rather he forced her, not to her benefit” (Gen. 20:2). Readers are justified in asking: Why was Abraham the only one who deserved protection in Gerar? Why was Sarah not protected? The beautiful word hasdech has become a tool of manipulation; it is now a deep distortion of the idea of hesed, voiced by Abraham, who is the master of hesed. Years later, in Hayyei Sarah, Abraham has grown ethically, and not only as evidenced by his offer of hospitality to three strangers. Now Abraham readily accepts his servant’s concern that a woman may say “no” to a proposal of marital intimacy with Isaac. Perhaps the death of Sarah, recorded in this parashah, has caused Abraham to regret how he treated her at Gerar. In Abraham’s old age there will be no more misrepresentations of a woman’s endangerment as her volitional act of kindness. The vigorous woman of the next generation, Rebecca, is no passive object of desire to be manipulated by men. She has agency, value, and strength, and her powerful and unassuming hesed, freely shared, is her most astonishingly beautiful feature. From the first moment we meet her, Rebecca possesses the two essential emotional qualities to be a great practitioner of hesed in her own right: empathy for others and respect for herself. This is how Abraham’s hesed is transformed by the next generation. It is profoundly shaped by Rebecca’s ability to say “no,” which allows her, when she wishes, to freely and enthusiastically say “yes.” Hesed as a biblical idea becomes kind to women in Parashat Hayyei Sarah, and is no less effective for it. If anything, hesed is now more strong, more gentle, more vigorous, more joyous, and more hopeful than it ever has been. So it remains to this day.

A Different Perspective | דבר אחר

A Venetian Ketubbah The Library of the Jewish Theological Seminary This week’s parashah prominently features the mission of Abraham’s servant to find a wife for Isaac. The account includes the giving of gifts to Rebecca and her family (24:22, 53) and the assurance from Abraham’s family that they themselves are wealthy (Gen. 24:35). For thousands of years, ketubbot

The publication and distribution of the JTS Parashah Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee (z”l) and Harold Hassenfeld (z”l).