Hegel, Spinoza, Critical Marxism

7/23/2019 Hegel, Spinoza, Critical Marxism

1/20

!"#$%& () *#"+,#-. !"#$%& () /%&+&,#0$%1 2 3+&,(4+$#- 5#,%4+#-+&6 *(0)%4%0$%78(49 :0+;%4&+,?@>A

!"#"$ &' ()*+&,-. (/012-+3"4 (/05"324 -+6 7'*2*3-$ 8-'9*1:

"#$ %&'()#

*+,('-'.+/ 0#.12&3#4&5#22,&'- 5'((#6#

7'281(9: 5; ?=

&-&'()#@A#22,&'-B#$C

%(1D'E F,)#9 +1- 8'4$#2#$ 8+#&+#2 ,& ,- .'--,G(# 0(,&' ('D# %.,4')1B H4$##$:

+# 1-9-: IJ+' A14 G# 161,4-& 1 ('4# K#8 8+': '4 &'. 'L ,&: 81- #MA'33C4,A1$ G/

&+# N'LL,A,1(O K#8,-+ A'33C4,&/ ,&-#(LP Q4# 'L &+# 3'-& &'CA+,46 #M.2#--,'4- 'L &+,-

('D# ,- +'8 '4# 'L 1&&2,GC- &' +,3 1(3'-& $,D,4# A1.1A,&,#-R(,9# *,#22#

S1A+#2#/: 8+': ,4 +,- '&+#28,-# 1$3,21G(# 3%B%- (C !"+0(D# T126C,46 161,4-& &+#

U#6#(,14 A2,&,VC# 'L %.,4')1W: A(1,3- &+1& '4# A144'& 1D',$ &+# ,3.2#--,'4 &+1&

%.,4')1 +1$ 1(2#1$/ 2#1$ U#6#( 14$: ,4 1$D14A#: 14-8#2#$ +,- 2#.2'1A+#-BX Y

;(&+'C6+: 1- H +'.# &' $#3'4-&21 ,4 8+1& L'(('8-: F,)#9 ,- G1$(/ 3,-&19#4 1G'C&

S1A+#2#/O- 'GE#A&,D# ,4 +,- G''9 14$ 2#(1$ 12&,A(#-:ZH A144'& 1D',$ &+# ,3.2#--,'4

&+1& 1 A#4&C2/ 16' [#4,4 +1$ 1(2#1$/ 2#1$ F,)#9 14$: ,4 1$D14A#: 14-8#2#$ &+#

(1&O- 4C3#2'C- 2#.2'1A+#- 161,4-& &+# A'4.'212/ S12M,-& &C24 &' %.,4')1B

\C2,#$ ,4 [#4,4O- EF+-(&("F+$#- G(,%H((9& 12# +,- #MA#2.&- L2'3 ](1$,3,2

S,9+1,('D,A+

%+C(/1&,9'DO- Y


2/20

Z

cJd+#4 %.,4')1 $,#$: 1- ,- 8#(( 94'84: &+# L,4# L(#C2 'L &+# 0C&A+ G'C26#',-,#

8,&+ 62#1& .'3. 1AA'3.14,#$ &+# +#12-# &+1& A122,#$ +,- 2#31,4-B ;4$ ,L 8#

G#A'3# 3'2# A('-#(/ 1AVC1,4$ 8,&+ +,- A,2A(# 'L -3;/-*+2-+3"1 -+6

3&''"1)&+6"+21: 8# 161,4 3##& 8,&+ &+# L,4# L(#C2 'L &+# G'C26#',-,#R14$

4'& '4(/ 'L U'((14$ GC& 'L &+# #4&,2# 8'2($BBBB "+# G'C26#',-,# 2#D#2#$

%.,4')1: &+#,2 G12$B %.,4')1O- A'4A#.&,'4 'L &+# 8'2($ ,- &+# -'46 'L

&2,C3.+14& A1.,&1(: 'L 1((bA'4-C3,46: 1((bA#4&21(,-,46 A1.,&1(B "+#2# ,- 4'

G#,46: &+#2# 12# 4' &+,46-: 1.12& L2'3 &+# -,46(# -CG-&14A#e &+#2# A14 G# 4'

#M,-A# L'2 .2'$CA#2- 1.12& L2'3 &+# (126#b-A1(# 314CL1A&C2,46

#4.2,-#BBBBX

"' %+C(/1D&,D,A+O- &2,C3.+1( A'4A(C-,'4 &+1& I%.,4')1O- A'4A#.&,'4 'L &+# 8'2($ ,-

&+# -'46 'L &2,C3.+14& A1.,&1(: 'L 1((bA'4-C3,46: 1((bA#4&21(,-,46 A1.,&1(:X [#4,4

A1C-&,A1((/ 2#.(,#$ 8,&+ 1 -,46(# 8'2$ ,4 &+# 3126,4 'L +,- 4'G''9f I,4L14&,(#BX` H&

81- 1- ,L [#4,4 8#2# 2#GC9,46 ,4 1$D14A# F,)#9O- A21-- 2#3129 &+1& %.,4')1

#3G'$,#- I&+# ,$#'('6/ 'L (1 A1.,&1(,-3Xg? U'8 A14 S12M,-&- 1D',$ &+# L1(-#

$,(#331 'L #,&+#2 ('D,46 %.,4')1: '2 +1&,46 +,3P *#2+1.- G/ &2/,46 &' C4$#2-&14$

%.,4')1: G/ 2#1$,46 +,3 A12#LC((/ 14$ 2#-.'4-,G(/R14$ G/ A2,&,A1((/ 1..2'.2,1&,46

-'3# 'L +,- A'4A#.&-B>


3/20

_

H4 -#D#21( $#4-# .16#- 'L +,- 3'4C3#4&1( 4#8 G''9 L%&& ,F#0 G(,F+0B1 3%B%-

#0M ,F% !F#M(N () O+#-%$,+$#- 5#,%4+#-+&6:aF,)#9 +1- 2#L,4#$ +,- #12(,#2 A2,&,A,-3- 'L

&+# S12M,-& 1..2'.2,1&,'4 'L %.,4')1 G/ -##9,46 &' ,$#4&,L/ &+# I.2#A,-# .',4&X 1&

8+,A+ +# &+,49- I&+# A'4&21-& G#&8##4 U#6#( 14$ %.,4')1 1..#12- 1& ,&- I.C2#-&BX

F,)#9 G#6,4- 8,&+ +,- '84 [1A14,14 D12,1&,'4 '4 U#6#(O- L13'C- A'3.(1,4&f

I%.,4')1O- ;G-'(C ,- 1 %CG-&14A# 8+,A+ N#M.2#--#-O ,&-#(L ,4 ,&- 1&&2,GC- 14$

3'$#- 8,&+'C& &+# -CGE#A&,D,),46 "(+0, M% $#"+,(0 cVC,(&,46 .',4&dBX^ F,)#9 &+#4

1$$2#--#- &+# (,3,&1&,'4- 'L 8+1& +# &19#- &' G# %.,4')1O- IL13'C- .2'.'-,&,'4X &+1&

(60+& M%,%46+0#,+( %&, 0%B#,+( TI1(( $#,41&,'4 ,- 4#61&,'4XW: 8+,A+ I31/ -'C4$

U#6#(,14X GC& ,- ,4 L1A& I14&,bU#6#(,14:X $#-., &8' .'--,G(# 81/- &' C4$#2-&14$

8+1& ,- 4#61$: 14$ +'8B HL: '4 &+# '4# +14$: 4#61&,'4 I2#L#2- &' &+# ;G-'(C ,&-#(L:

,& 319#- 1 4#61&,D#b&+#'('6,A1( .',4&f #D#2/ .'-,&,D# $#,41&,'4 'L &+# ;G-'(C:

#D#2/ .2#$,A1 8# 1&&2,GC &' ,&: ,- ,41$#VC1: L1,(- &' 621-. ,&- #--#4A# 14$ &+C-

1(2#1$/ 4#61- ,&Xe ,L: '4 &+# '&+#2 +14$: I,& 2#L#2- &' .12&,AC(12 #3.,2,A1( &+,46-: ,&

319#- 1 .',4& 1G'C& &+#,2 &214-,#4& 41&C2#f #D#2/ #4&,&/ $#(,3,$ L2'3 '&+#2- G/ 1

.12&,AC(12 $#,41&,'4 8,(( -''4#2 '2 (1 E',4 &+# A+1'&,A 1G/-- 'C& 'L 8+,A+ ,&

12'-#: L'2 #D#2/ .12&,AC(12 $#,41&,'4 ,- 1 4#61&,'4 4'& '4(/ ,4 &+# -#4-# &+1& ,&

8,(( ,4D'(D# &+# 4#61&,'4 'L '&+#2 .12&,AC(12 $#,41&,'4-kGC& ,4 1 3'2# 21$,A1(

-#4-# &+1& ,& 2#L#2- &' ,&- ('46b ,4-&1G,(,&/BXaBab>^B


4/20

`

,3.#23#1G(# ,$#4&,&/ G#/'4$ &+# &214-,#4& 8'2($ 'L L,4, &+,46-e &+# '4(/ &2C#

;G-'(C ,- 4'&+,46 GC& &+,- D#2/ .2'A#-- 'L &+# 2,-,46 14$ .1--,46 181/ 'L 1((

.12&,AC(12 &+,46-BX \C&: F,)#9 A'4&,4C#-: &+,- 8'C($ 3#14 &+1&: 1AA'2$,46 &' U#6#(:

%.,4')1O- .+,('-'.+/ 2#-#3G(#- I1 .-#C$'bQ2,#4&1( U#21A(, 8,-$'3 A'4A#24,46

&+# #( L('8 'L &+# 6#4#21&,'4 14$ A'22C.&,'4 'L 1(( &+,46- C4$#2 &+# -C4R,4

3'2# .+,('-'.+,A1( -: -CA+ 1 D,-,'4 2#(,#- '4 &+# C4,D'A,&/ 'L G#,46BXY=

F,)#9 1(('8- &+1& '4# A'C($ $#L#4$ %.,4')1 1('46 &+# (,4#- 'L 8+1& ;(&+C--#2

A1((#$ I1(#1&'2/ 31,1(,-3X G/ A(1,3,46 &+1& %CG-&14A# I,- 4'& -,3.(/ &+# #(

6#4#21&,D# .2'A#-- 8+,A+ A'4&,4C#- 8,&+'C& 14/ ,4C.&,'4 '2 AC&: GC& &+1& ,& ,-: '4

&+# A'4&212/: &+# C4,D#2-1(,)1&,'4 'L 1 AC& '2 L1(( T$-+0#6%0Wf %CG-&14A# ,- 4'&+,46

GC& &+# A'4-&14& .2'A#-- 'L IL1((,46X T,4&' $#,41l.12&,AC(12 #4&,&,#-We

#D#2/&+,46 &+#2# ,-: ,- 1 L1((kB "+#2# ,- 4' %CG-&14A# 8+,A+ L1((-: AC2D#-: ,4C.&-

&+# L('8: #&ABe -CG-&14A# -,3.(/ +& &+# ,4L,4,(/ .2'$CA&,D# A1.1A,&/ 'L -CA+

L1((-lAC&-l,4C.&,'4-: &+#/ 12# ,&- '4(/ 2#1(,&/BX ;AA'2$,46 &' -CA+ 14 1(#1&'2/

31,1(,-& $#L#4-# 'L %.,4')1: I%CG-&14A# 14$ $-+0#6%0 T&+# AC2D1&C2# 'L &+#

%CG-&14A# 8+,A+ 6#4#21- $#,41 #4&,&,#-WX 8'C($ I$,2#A&(/ A',4A,$#e ,4 &+,-

C(&,31 -.#AC(1&,D# ,$#4&,&/: %CG-&14A# ,- 4'&+,46 GC& &+# .2'A#-- 'L ,&- '84 NL1((:O

&+# 4#61&,D,&/ &+1& .C-+#- &'812$- .2'$CA&,D# $#,41&,'4kBXYY

7'& -C2.2,-,46(/: F,)#9 2#E#A&- &+,- 3'D# G#A1C-#: +# A'4$-: ,& 8'C($

-,3.(/ I2#4'231(,)#X &+# $-+0#6%014$: 1- 1 2#-C(&: &C24 ,& I,4&' ,&- '..'-,:X L'2 I,L

1(( &+1& &+#2# ,- 12# ,4C.&,'4- '2 L1((-: &+#4 &+# 9#/ 1-.#A& 'L -C2.2,-#: 'L &+#

,4&2C-,'4 'L 14 C4#M.#A$ A'4&,46#4A/: ,- ('-&: 14$ 8# L,4$ 'C2-#(D#- ,4 1 G'2,46:

Y=F,)#9 Z=YZ: .B _>^BYYF,)#9 Z=YZ: .B _>^B


5/20

?

L(1& C4,D#2-# 8+'-# A'4&,46#4A/ ,- &'&1((/ .2#$,A&1G(# 14$ 4#A#--12/BXYZ F,)#9 -##9-:

&+#4: 4'& &' I21$,A1(,)#X %.,4')1 G/ A'4A#,D,46 'L -CG-&14A# 1- I4'&+,46 GC& &+#

.2'A#-- 'L $-+0#6%0:X L'2 ,4 -CA+ 1 A1-#: +# A'4$-: I%CG-&14A# 2#31,4- Q4#: 1

51C-# ,3314#4& &' ,&- #LL#A&-BX H4-$: 1('46 U#6#(,14b[1A14,14 (,4#- +# -##9- &'

I&19# 1 -. LC2&+#2X 14$ I2#D#2-# &+# 2#(1&,'4-+,.f &+#2# ,- 4' %CG-&14A#: '4(/ &+#

m#1( 1- &+# 1G-'(C 61.: 4'4b,$#4&,&/: 14$ .12&,AC(12 .+#4'3#41 T3'$#-W 12# Q4#-:

-' 314/ 1&.&- &' -&1G,(,)# &+,- 61.BXY_

F,)#9 &+#4 -C3- C. 8+1& +# 2#612$- 1- &+# -&129 A'4&21-& G#&8##4 %.,4')1

14$ U#6#(f

H4 A'4&21-& &' %.,4')1: L'2 8+'3 &+#2# ,- 4' S1-b%,64,L,#2 #41A&,46 1 AC&:

3129,46 1 A'4A(C-,'4: I$'&&,46 &+# ,&:X GC& EC-& 1 A'4&,4C'C- A+1,4 'L A1C-#-:

&+# U#6#(,14 $,1(#A&,A1( .2'A#-- ,4D'(D#- AC&-: -C$$#4 ,4C.&,'4 'L &+#

A'4&,4C'C- L('8: 2#D#2-1(- 8+,A+ 2#&2'1A&,D#(/ 2#-&2CA&C2# &+# #4&,2# L,#($B H4

'2$#2 &' .2'.#2(/ C4$#2-&14$ &+,- 2#(1&,'4-+,. G#&8##4 1 A'4&,4C1( .2'A#--

14$ ,&- AC&- '2 #4$-: 8# -+'C($ ,64'2# &+# -&C.,$ 4'&,'4 'L 1 IA'4&21$,A&,'4X

,4 U#6#(O- &+'C6+& G#&8##4 3#&+'$ T#4$(#-- .2'A#--W 14$ -/- T#4$We ,& ,-

1(-' 4'& -CLL,A,#4& &' A'4A#,D# AC&- 1- 3'3#4& 8,&+,4 14 #4A'3.1--,46

.2'A#--: ,4( $,LL#2#4A#- 8+,A+ 12,-# 14$ $,-1..#12BY`

F,)#9 A'4A(C$#- 8,&+ I1 .121((#( 8,&+ &+# L('8 'L -.##A+BX KC-& 1- I&+# L('8 'L -.##A+

A144'& 6' '4 ,4$#L,4,(/:X &+#2# +1- &' G# 1 -'3#&+,46 (,9# I&+# .',4& &+1& A'4A(C$#-

1 -#4A#:X L'2 I,& ,- '4(/ &+# $'& 1& &+# #4$ &+1& 2#&2'1A&,D#(/ L,M#- '2 $#,4#-

YZF,)#9 Z=YZ: ..B _>^b>


6/20

>

&+# 3#14,46 'L &+# -#4A#BX ;4$ /#&: +# 1$$-: &+,- $'& A144'& G# I1 -,3.(# L,M1&,'4

8+,A+ 2#3'D#- 1(( 2,-9: 1G'(,-+,46 1(( 13G,6C,&/ 14$ '.#44#--BX m1&+#2: I&+# $'&&,46

,&-#(L: ,&- AC&k2#(#1-#-R-#&- L2##R3#14,46 14$ ,4.2#&1&,'4f &+# $'& 1(81/-

'AAC2- A'4&,46#4&(/: 1- 1 -C2.2,-#: ,& 6#4#21- 1 -C2.(C-R8+/ F%4%P J+1& $'#- &+,-

3#14PXY?

U'8 -+'C($ '4# 2#-.'4$ &' F,)#9O- ,$#4&,L,A1&,'4 'L &+# I.2#A,-# .',4&X 1&

8+,A+ U#6#(O- .+,('-'.+/ $,D#26#- L2'3 %.,4')1O-P "' G#6,4 8,&+: ,& ,- 1-&'4,-+,46

&+1& ,4 F,)#9O- Y===b.16# 8'29 '4 U#6#( &+#2# ,- 4'& 1 -,46(# 2#L#2#4A# &' S1A+#2#/B

*2#-C31G(/ F,)#9 +1$ 2#1$ S1A+#2#/O- G''9 ,4 h2#4A+ 1- 'L Z==`: 8+#4 &+# VC'

8,&+ 8+,A+ H '.#4#$ 1..#12#$BY> HL F,)#9 +1$ '4A# 2#1$ S1A+#2#/: &+'C6+: ,& ,- 4'

('46#2 1..12#4& ,4 Z=YZB

;- 1 2#-C(&: F,)#9O- &2#1&3#4& 'L %.,4')1O- .+21-# (60+& M%,%46+0#,+( %&,

0%B#,+(&C24- 'C& &' G# ,22#(#D14&: -,4A#: 1- S1A+#2#/ 1(2#1$/ 1G(/ $#3'4-&21$ ,4

A+1. L'C2 'L 3%B%- (4 !"+0(D#: 4'& '4(/ $,$ %.,4')1 4#D#2 C-# &+,- #M1A& .+21-#:

GC& U#6#( 3,-VC'$ +,3: &''9 &+# -#4A# %.,4')1 $,$ C-# (0$%,4 1 (#&R4'& 1

.CG(,-+#$ 8'29R'C& 'L A'4M&: 14$ &+#4 -#2,'C-(/ 3,-A'4-&2C#$ ,&- 3#14,46BYa H

8'C($ (,9# &' L'AC- ,4-$ '4 F,)#9O- A'4&,'4 &+1&: C4(,9# U#6#(: %.,4')1O-

.+,('-'.+/ 'LL#2- 4' 81/ &' 621-. -CG-&14A# 1- -CGE#A&,D,&/ 14$ -' 1(-

G#&8##4 #,&+#2 I1 .-#C$'bQ2,#4&1( U#21A(, 8,-$'3 A'4A#24,46 &+# #( L('8

Y?F,)#9 Z=YZ: .B _>F,)#9 Z==`BYaH4 n.?= &' K12,6 K#((#-: $1$ KC4# Z: Y>a`: %.,4')1 $,$ 4'& A'4$ &+1&

%;%4


7/20

a

'L &+# 6#4#21&,'4 14$ A'22C.&,'4 'L 1(( &+,46- C4$#2 &+# -C4X '2 I1 G'2,46: L(1&

C4,D#2-# 8+'-# A'4&,46#4A/ ,- &'&1((/ .2#$,A&1G(# 14$ 4#A#--12/BX 7#,&+#2 ,- 14

1..#1(,46 '.&,'4: &' -1/ &+# (#1-&B

\C& F,)#9 ,- 4'& 1('4# ,4 .,&&,46 U#6#( 161,4-& %.,4')1 8,&+ 2#-.#A& &' &+#

.2'G(#3 'L -CG-&14A# &+1& +1- 4'& /#& G#A'3# -CGE#A&B H4 L(B+$& () J(4-M& ;(1,4

\1$,'C +1- (,9#8,-# 126C#$ &+1& U#6#(O- 62#1& .+,('-'.+,A1( ,4-,6+& IA14 G# -C33#$

C. ,4 &+2## .2,4A,.(#-f

bb"+# '4(/ &2C&+ ,- &+1& 'L &+# J+'(#B

bb"+# J+'(# ,- 1 -#(LbC4L'($,46: 14$ 4'& 14 1G-'(CbC4,&/ #M( &' &+#

-CGE#A&B

bb"+# J+'(# ,- &+# ,3314#4& 122,D1( 'L ,&- '84 A'4A#.&BX

"+,- 3#14-: L'2 \1$,'C: I&+1& &+# &+'C6+& 'L &+# J+'(# ,- &+# #LL#A&C1&,'4 'L &+#

J+'(# ,&-#(LB 5'4-#VC#4&(/: 8+1& $,-.(1/- &+# J+'(# 8,&+,4 &+'C6+& ,- 4'&+,46

'&+#2 &+14 &+# .1&+ 'L &+,49,46: &+1& ,- ,&- 3#&+'$B U#6#( ,- &+# 3#&+'$,A1( &+,49#2 'L

&+# J+'(#BXY^\/ A'4&21-&: \1$,'C A'4$-: I%.,4')1 -18 .#2L#A&(/ &+1& #D#2/

&+'C6+& 3C-& .2#-C..'-# &+# J+'(# 1- A'4&1,4,46 $#,41&,'4- ,4 ,&-#(L: G/ -#(Lb

4#61&,'4B \C& +# L1,(#$ &' 621-. &+# &CHQ%$,+;% 1G-'(C#-- 'L &+# J+'(#: 8+,A+

1('4# 6C1214#- ,4( ,3314#4A#BXY


8/20

^

I-CGE#A&,D# 1G-'(C#-- 'L &+# J+'(#BX H4$##$: ,4 &+# '.#4,46 (,4#- 'L .12& Z 'L &+#

K,F+$&%.,4')1 8124#$ &+1& +# 81- A'4A#24#$ 4'& 8,&+ &+# I,4L,4,(/ 314/ &+,46-X

&+1& 4#A#--12,(/ L'(('8 I,4 ,4L,4,(/ 314/ 81/-X L2'3 +,- A'4A#.&,'4 'L o'$ 1-

I#( 14$ ,4L,4, G#,46X GC& '4(/ 8,&+ 8+1& IA14 (#1$ C- 1- ,L G/ &+# +14$ &'

94'8(#$6# 'L &+# +C314 3,4$ 14$ ,&- +,6+#-& G(#--#$4#--BX ;- 1 2#-C(&: %.,4')1 81-

(#-- A'4A#24#$ 8,&+ 3#2#'('6/R&+# '4&'('6,A1( -&C$/ 'L .12&- 14$ 8+'(#-Z=R&+14:

1- \#2412$ ]14$#81((# +1- A'3.#((,46(/ 126C#$: 8,&+ 2#L1-+,'4,46 .+,('-'.+,A1(

1A&,D,&/ 1- 1 9,4$ 'L I&+#21.#C&,A- 'L &+# G'$/ 14$ 3,4$X ,4 G'&+ ,4$,D,$C1( 14$

&214-,4$,D,$C1( 2#-.#A&-BZY

"' A(1,3: &+#4: 1- \1$,'C 14$ F,)#9 +1D#: &+1& %.,4')1 L1,(#$ &' 1$$2#-- &+#

.2'G(#3 'L -CGE#A&,D,&/ ,- &' ,64'2# &+# (1-& L'C2 .12&- 'L &+# K,F+$&&+1& A'4A#24 &+#

+C314 3,4$: ,&- 2#(1&,'4-+,. &' &+# G'$/ 14$ &+# #M( 8'2($: &+# 41&C2# 'L

1LL#A&- 14$ &+#,2 .'8#2: 14$ &+# #M& &' 8+,A+ 2#1-'4 A14 3'$#21: -&1G,(,)#:

2#$,2#A&: '2 &214-L'23 .1--,D# ,4&' 1A&,D# 1LL#A&- ,4 .C2-C,& 'L ,4$,D,$C1( 14$

Z=H& ,- 8'2&+ 4'&,46: +'8#D#2: &+1& %.,4')1 $,$ 1$$2#-- &+# .12&-l8+'(#2#(1&,'4 ,4 1 (#& &' U#42/ Q($#4G#26: $1$ 7'D#3G#2 Z=: Y>>?: ,4 8+,A+ +#

.2'.'-#$ 1 L13'C- 14$ -&2,9,46 141('6/ G#&8##4 +C314 G#,46- I(,D,46 ,4 'C2 .12& 'L

41&C2#X 14$ 1 I&,4/ 8'23 (,D,46 ,4 &+# G(''$BX KC-& 1- -CA+ 1 8'23 I8'C($ 2#612$#1A+ ,4$,D,$C1( .12&,A(# 'L &+# G(''$ 1- 1 8+'(#: 4'& 1 .12&k14$k8'C($ +1D# 4' ,$#1

1- &' +'8 1(( &+# .12&- 12# A'4&2'((#$ G/ &+# 'D#21(( 41&C2# 'L &+# G(''$:X -' &'' $'

+C314 G#,46- L1,( &' 621-. &+1& I#D#2/ G'$/: ,4 -' L12 1- ,& #M,-&- 1- 3'$,L,#$ ,4 1$#L,4, 81/: 3C-& G# A'4-,$#2#$ 1- 1 .12& 'L &+# 8+'(# C4,D#2-#BX S'2#'D#2: EC-& 1-

&+# 3'&,'4 'L G(''$ ,&-#(L ,- 1LL#A$ G/ #M( L'2A#-: 14$ ,- '4(/ 1 .12& 'L 1 (126#28+'(#: -' &'' &+# 41&C2# 'L &+# C4,D#2-# ,- I1G-'(C(/ ,4L,4, 14$ I,&- .12&- 12#

A'4&2'((#$ G/ &+# 41&C2# 'L &+,- ,4L,4, .'8#2 c"(,%0,+#d ,4 ,4L,4, 81/- 14$ 12#A'3.#((#$ &' C4$#26' ,4L,4, D12,1&,'4-X Tn. _ZWB

ZY]14$#81((# Z=YYB ;(&+'C6+ ;4&'4,' 7#62, TY>WB


9/20

7'4#&+#(#--: &+#2# 2#31,4- 1 VC#-&,'4 'L #3.+1-,-B H 31,4&1,4 &+1& U#6#(,14

6214$,'-,&/ 4##$- &' G# .#2#$ G/ %.,4'),-& 3'$#-&/B`a H& ,- 8#(( 14$ 6''$ &' (1/

`_%## S,&'D Z=YZB``S,&'DO- L'2 31& A'3.'-#$ 'L $C1(b1LL,4,&/ 3'(#AC(#-: L'2 #M13.(#:

&+# (#A,&+,4 ,4 #66 /'(9- 8,&+'C& 8+'-# 3#$,1&,'4 G#&8##4 81 14$ ',(31/'441,-# 8'C($ 4'& G# -&1G(# TS,&'D Z=YZ: ..B ?bYYWB

`?0,$4O& F,)#9 TZ===W +,3-#(L '4A# 2#-.'4$ &' &+# L1(-# 1(&,D# G#&8##4

.'-&3'$#24,-3 14$ S12M,-3 8,&+ 14 ,4-,-& Ip#-: .(#1-#gX`>S1A+#2#/ Y


16/20

Y>

A(1,3 &' 1 G2'1$ D,-,'4 'L &+# +,-&'2,A1( .2'A#--: 14$ -&2'46(/ &' G#(,#D# &+1& 8# 12#

'2,#4$ ,4 1 21&,'41( $,2#A&,'4f &'812$- #D#2b62#1 L2##$'3 L'2 1(( +C314,&/B \C&

1A&C1( +,-&'2,A1( &214-L'231&,'4 '4 &+# 62'C4$ (''9- D#2/ $,LL#2#4&R3#--/: C4#D#4:

'L G'2,46: L2C-&21&,46(/ -('8R14$ &+#4 1& '&+#2 &,3#- -' -.##$#$bC. 14$ ,4-#

&+1& '4# 31/ -CLL#2 L2'3 $,-'2,#4&1&,'4 '2 #D#4 (1.-# ,4&' 8+1& %.,4')1 #$

ID1,4 6('2/BX`^ U'8 ,- ,& .'--,G(# &' AC(&,D1 14$ -C-&1,4 -CA+ D,2&C#- 1- L,$#(,&/:

A'C216#: .1&,#4A#: +'.#: 14$ #4$C214A# ,4 &+# L1A# 'L &+# .#2-'41( 2,-9- 12,-,46 L2'3

1A&,D,-3P "' 14-8#2 -CA+ VC#-&,'4- 8# 3C-& (''9 &' %.,4')1: 4'& U#6#(B

F,)#9 +1- 126C#$ &+1& S12M,-&- -+'C($ I.2'A##$ (,9# [#4,4 ,4 Y


17/20

Ya

4#'bi14&,14,-3 'L &+# %#A'4$ H4&,'41(B?= \C& .#2+1.-REC-& .#2+1.-R+#

-+'C($ 1(-' +1D# &19#4 &+# &,3# &' 2#1$ %.,4')1O- K,F+$&B HL +# +1$ $'4# -': ,4 &+#

3126,4 '..'-, +,- L13'C- 4' I[#1.-g [#1.-g [#1.-gX +# 3,6+& +1D# 1$$#$

%.,4')1O- [1&,4 3'&&'f I51Cg 51Cg 51CgX?Y

C"?"'"+3"1

;(&+C--#2: ['C,- Y: K&


18/20

Y^

h'CA1C(&: S,A+#( Z==>: 3+&,(4< () 5#M0%&&: #$,$ G/ K#14 i+1(L1: &214-(1$ G/

K'41&+14 SC2.+/ 14$ K#14 i+1(L1: 7#8 p'29f m'C&(#$6#B

U#6#(: oB JB h2,#$2,A+ Z==a: EF+-(&("F< () 5+0M: &214-(1$ G/ J,((,13 J1((1A# 14$

;B]B S,((#2: 2#D,-#$ G/ S,A+1#( H48''$: 7#8 p'29f QML'2$ s4,D#2-,&/ *2#--B

U#6#(: o#'26 J,(+#(3 h2,#$2,A+ Z==


19/20

Y

Hegel, Spinoza, Critical Marxism

Documents

Transcript of Hegel, Spinoza, Critical Marxism