Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

40
CRICOS #00212K Prof Colin Butler 27 th ISEE conference, Sao Paulo September 2, 2015 + Introducing Health in the “Anthropocene”

Transcript of Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

Page 1: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Prof Colin Butler

27th ISEE conference, Sao Paulo September 2, 2015

+ Introducing Health in the “Anthropocene”

Page 2: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

I have no actual or potential competing financial interests in the last 3 years, including but not limited to: grant support; employment (past, present, or firm offer of future); patents (pending or applied); payment for expert witness or testimony; personal financial interests by the authors, immediate family members, or institutional affiliations that may gain or lose financially through this presentation, other than travel funding from the University of Canberra, I have no consultancies, board positions, patent and royalty arrangements, stock shares, or bonds.

Page 3: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212KCRICOS #00212K

Integrated Science for Sustainable Transitionshttp://www.iiasa.ac.at/web/home/about/events/

150428-IGBP.html

State of the art lecture on sustainability science.. Yet nothing on health (including in Future Earth)

Page 4: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Planetary BoundariesA safe operating space

for humanity

Steffen et al, 2015

What does this mean for society? And for health?

Page 5: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

8 institutional co-founders6 countries + UNU

UO FdUC

Au

MU NZ

ULUK VU

Ca

UCSD US

UWUSUNU

IIGH

Page 6: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

A second “circle”

PHFIn

icddr,b Bd

ILRIKe

USP Br

PHFIn

Page 7: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

and more

PHFIn

icddr,b Bd

ILRIKe

USP Br

PHFIn

?

?

?

?

?

? ?

Page 8: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

H-Earth at ISEE

Wael Al-Delaimy

US

Colin SoskolneCanada/

AUS

Colin ButlerAUS

Page 9: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

452 - INTRODUCTION TO HEALTH-EARTH AND THE ANTHROPOCENECOLIN BUTLER - UNIVERSITY OF CANBERRA  

601 - LIMITS TO ADAPTATIONKRISTIE L. EBI - UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON

360 - EPIDEMIOLOGICAL METHODS IN GLOBAL HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT: WHICH PARADIGM AND IN WHOSE BEST INTERESTS?

COLIN SOSKOLNE - UNIVERSITIES OF ALBERTA AND CANBERRA

1022 - ETHICAL ASPECTS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL EPIDEMIOLOGISTS IN THE ANTHROPOCENE

WAEL AL-DELAIMY - UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO

Page 10: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212KNature, 2003

Health in

Page 11: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

July, 2015

Reviewers included.. Colin D Butler, Trevor Hancock

Page 12: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

ISEE and Health-Earth

Page 13: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Prof A.J. (Tony) McMichael1942-2014

Page 14: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

A/Prof Colin D Butler ([email protected]) National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health Australian National

University, Australia

Three wise epidemiologists Nikko Toshogu Shinto Shrine, Tokyo.

Photo: Rangaku 1976, 2008

Limits to growth and public health: where is environmental epidemiology?

APOLOGIES: future generations

23rd ISEE meeting, Barcelona,

September, 2011

Page 15: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

ISEE/ISES/ISIAQ, Basel, Switzerland, August 21, 2013

Professor Colin Butler(Australian Research Council Future Fellow)

Limits to growth and environmental epidemiology: a conceptual framework

Page 16: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

FROM

Page 17: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Trevor Hancock, Colin Sosoklne

Page 18: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

“eco-social” determinants of health

Focus on either social or ecological often incomplete – need to see the inter-relationships, otherwise policy solution lacking

Health issue Illustrative determinant

social ecological

rural suicide (India)

indebtedness drought

conflict (Yemen) “political” water scarcity

Rwandan genocide 1994

ethnic tension, “youth bulge”

fertile land scarcity

ebola (West Africa)

poor health services, poverty

deforestation (?) (more contact, ?viral spillover)

migration

Page 19: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Page 20: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Page 21: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Page 22: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

“surges exceeding 11m in Tampa and 7m in Dubai .. non-negligible probabilities, especially towards end of century.”

Page 23: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Warning

Page 24: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K24

Page 25: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

“Reuters regularly uses the term ‘economic migrants.’

We need to pressure them into using the more appropriate and descriptive ‘freeloading parasites’.’’

Page 26: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Page 27: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

3 case studies

1.Syria2.Food prices3.Bangladesh 2100

Page 28: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212KPNAS - 2015

Page 29: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Damascus, 2014. Line for food aid from UN Relief and Works Agency in a great city - large parts of which have been destroyed by civil war, along with basic food supply infrastructure

Page 30: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

“a risk multiplier”

Page 31: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

2. Food prices

Page 32: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Page 33: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

decline in price due to Green Revolution

oil, speculation, rice panic

extreme events

World food price index (deflated) (1961-2015) (data FAO)

Page 34: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

3. Bangladesh 2100

Page 35: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212KRohingya and Bengali refugees – May 2015

Page 36: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

New methods

Integrate large scale social and environmental “indicators”

For certain locations, times, environmental influences.

Scale (1-5)social cohesiveness environmental stresschance of a catalyst (eg assassination)develop metrics and models that reflect/predict chance of population “corrections” (a euphemism)

Page 37: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

New methods

Rank (1-5) by historical data, expert judgement

Eg Rwanda 1961, 1994SyriaYemenDarfur (Sudan), South SudanArakan (Myanmar)Bangladesh (future)

Page 38: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Taboos

Scientific reticenceGovernmental resistance

But

Whenever we encourage “development” or “resilience” we have many of these ideas somewhere in our mind

Page 39: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Emerging issue in global health curricula but far too little, given topic’s importance

Page 40: Health earth anthropocene_isee_2015

CRICOS #00212K

Vatican official calls for moral awakening on global warmingApril 28, 2015