Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use,...
Transcript of Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use,...
![Page 1: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theoryof Behavioral Change
Reshmaan Hussam, Harvard Business School
with Atonu Rabbani, Dhaka UniversityGiovanni Reggiani, MIT
Natalia Rigol, Harvard University
Global Handwashing Partnership Webinar
![Page 2: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Handwashing with soap
• High rates of child stunting and mortality worldwide dueto bacterial and viral transmission• Diarrhea, ARI• 2 million child deaths yearly (WHO 2013)
• Handwashing with soap• “the most effective vaccine against childhood infections”
(World Bank 2005)
• But handwashing rates abysmally low (3-35%) worldwide,especially during critical times. Why? worldwide rates
![Page 3: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Why don’t people wash their hands?
1 Scarcity of information• Information interventions have not worked. (WSP 2015,
Galiani et al. 2015)• People believe washing is important. study context
2 Scarcity of resources• Resource interventions, including our own, have not
worked. (WSP 2013, Ejemot et al. 2015, SHDS 2015)• People have soap and water. study context
3 No health returns in high-disease environments• Not true in our setting: handwashing reduces acute
respiratory infection and loose stool incidence results
• translates into significant improvements in weight andheight results
People still don’t wash. study context
![Page 4: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Key features of handwashing with soap
1 Preventive activity.• Returns are not salient.
2 Not a social norm.• No persistent social costs to shirking.
3 Repetitive activity.• Repeated engagement is costly...unless it becomes a habit.
study context
These features apply to many important health activities:water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc.
![Page 5: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Conceptual framework: habits and rationaladdiction
Becker and Murphy (1988): A Theory of Rational Addiction
1 Habit formation: intertemporal complementarities in theutility from consumption
2 Rational habit formation: Agents are aware ofcomplementarities, so changes in future consumptionaffect current consumption
the model
![Page 6: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
What we do in practice
We implement an RCT among 2900 rural households withyoung children in West Bengal.
1 Our experimental design randomizes:• whether agents receive monetary incentives, social
incentives, only a soap dispenser, or no intervention fordaily handwashing
⇒ habit formation
• whether agents anticipate monetary incentives, socialincentives, or neither
⇒ rational habit formation
2 We observe:• precise measure of handwashing behavior before, during,
and after withdrawal of the interventions• willingness-to-pay for soap• child health: diarrhea, ARI, weight, height
![Page 7: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Measurement technology: from the Media Lab
![Page 8: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Measurement technology: to the field
![Page 9: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Handwashing outcome measure
Primary outcome: binary measure of dispenser use during thefamily’s self-reported evening mealtime.
Maximize σ by making handwashing amenable to habituation:
⇒ habit loop: trigger, routine, feedback (Neal et al.2015)
![Page 10: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Experimental design
Full sample
Monitoringvillages (MV)
Incentivevillages (IV)
Households are visited once every two weeks.
![Page 11: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Incentives intervention
Incentivized households receive:
1 calendar
2 dispenser to keep
3 soap for one year
4 tracking of behavior on calendar
5 tickets (one or three) per night dispenser active• redeemed for child and household prizes (on day of receipt
or later)• 1 ticket = Rs. 3 = USD 0.05
Note: tracking measured and incentives earned daily, but recorded andreceived every two weeks
![Page 12: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Incentives
Incentivevillages
1 ticket (2 mo)3 tickets (2 mo)
SURPRISE
1 ticket (2 mo)3 tickets (2 mo)ANTICIPATE
1 ticket (2 mo)1 ticket (2 mo)
pure control
![Page 13: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Parallel monitoring experiment
Disentangling incentives from feedback alone:
Full sample
Monitoringvillages (MV)
Incentivevillages (IV)
![Page 14: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Monitoring intervention
Household Receives Incentive Monitoring
calendar × ×dispenser to keep × ×soap for one year × ×
feedback on calendar × ×tickets ×
![Page 15: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Monitoring
Monitoringvillages
dispenser (2 mo)monitoring (2 mo)
SURPRISE
dispenser (2 mo)monitoring (2 mo)
ANTICIPATE
dispenser (2 mo)dispenser (2 mo)
pure control
![Page 16: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Roadmap
1 Introduction
2 Conceptual framework
3 Experimental design4 Habit formation results
• Contemporaneous effects• Persistence effects• Anticipatory effects
5 Child health results
6 Conclusion
![Page 17: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Contemporaneous effects
![Page 18: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Contemporaneous effects: receiving anytickets increases handwashing at dinnertime
.2.3
.4.5
.6.7
Like
lihoo
d of
usin
g di
spen
ser
-70 -40 -10 20 50Day
Dispenser controlOne ticket daily incentive
Likelihood of washing during reported dinner time
Daytime use Evening use
![Page 19: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Contemporaneous effects: tripling tickets haslittle effect on handwashing
.3.4
.5.6
.7Fr
actio
n of
hou
seho
lds
-30 -20 Price change 20 30 40 50 60Day
Standard incentive3x incentive
Fraction of households who used at dinner time
![Page 20: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Contemporaneous effects: monitoringincreases handwashing
.1.2
.3.4
.5Fr
actio
n of
hou
seho
lds
-30 -20 Monitoring 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120Day
Dispenser controlMonitoring
Fraction of households who used at dinner time
![Page 21: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Persistence effects
![Page 22: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Habit formation: previously receiving incentivesmakes you wash more on extensive margin
.2.3
.4.5
.6.7
Frac
tion
of h
ouse
hold
s
50 Incentives stop 80 100 120 140Day
Dispenser controlFormer standard incentiveFormer triple incentive
Fraction of households who used at dinner time
![Page 23: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Habit formation: previously receiving triple vs.single tickets does not persist
.2.3
.4.5
.6.7
Frac
tion
of h
ouse
hold
s
50 Incentives stop 80 100 120 140Day
Dispenser controlFormer standard incentiveFormer triple incentive
Fraction of households who used at dinner time
![Page 24: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Habit formation: previously being monitoredmakes you wash more
.1.1
5.2
.25
.3.3
5.4
.45
Frac
tion
of h
ouse
hold
s
110 Monitoring stops 130 140Day
Dispenser controlFormer monitoring
Fraction of households who used at dinner time
![Page 25: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Rational habit formation effects
![Page 26: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Rational habit formation: no evidence inhouseholds anticipating triple tickets
.3.4
.5.6
.7.8
Frac
tion
of h
ouse
hold
s
-70 -40 -10 20 50 80 110 140Day
Unanticipated 3X ticketsAnticipated 3X tickets
Dinnertime dispenser use: incentives
![Page 27: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Rational habit formation: strong evidence inhouseholds anticipating being monitored
.1.2
.3.4
.5Fr
actio
n of
hou
seho
lds
-70 -40 -10 20 50 80 110 140Day
Unanticipated monitoringAnticipated monitoring
Dinnertime dispenser use: monitoring
Back
![Page 28: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Child health effects
![Page 29: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Handwashing decreasesloose stool and ARI incidence
(1) (2) (3) (4)
Any loose stool
Total days of loose stool
Any ARI symptoms
Total days of ARI
Received dispenser -0.0315*** -0.0817*** -0.0393** -0.204**[0.00975] [0.0236] [0.0154] [0.0884]
Mean of pure control 0.100 0.209 0.270 1.247[0.00572] [0.0151] [0.00886] [0.0504]
Observations 3,820 3,830 3,830 3,830Notes: Observations are at the child level. "Received dispenser" is any household that received a dispenser, pooled over treatment arms. p-values adjusted for multiple hypothesis testing using Anderson (2008). *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
disaggregated by age disaggregated by treatment arm
Back
![Page 30: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
Handwashing improveschild anthropometric outcomes
(1) (2) (3)
VARIABLES
Weight for age z-score
Height for age z-score
Mid-arm circ. for age z-
score
Received dispenser 0.135* 0.227* 0.0752*[0.0640] [0.0902] [0.0518]
Mean of pure control -2.167 -1.866 -1.365[0.0459] [0.0666] [0.0432]
Observations 863 862 858Notes: Observations are at the child level. "Received dispenser" is any household that received a dispenser, pooled over treatment arms. p-values adjusted for multiple hypothesis testing using Anderson (2008). *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
Back
![Page 31: Handwashing and Habit Formation: A Theory of Behavioral Change · water treatment, latrine use, clean cookstove use, etc. Introduction Context Conceptual framework Experimental design](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040803/5e3e4bea7eb906459814dcb3/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Introduction
Context
Conceptualframework
Experimentaldesign
Habitformationresults
Child healthresults
Conclusion
To summarize:
1 Handwashing alone has substantial impacts on childhealth
2 Financial incentives and monitoring without incentivesincreases handwashing
3 Handwashing is habitual: effects persist after incentivesor monitoring are removed
⇒ optimal scheme: frontload incentives
4 Agents are rational habit formers: anticipation of a risein the future likelihood of handwashing increases currenthandwashing
⇒ optimal scheme: delay and announce incentives