Hand Therapy

download Hand Therapy

of 23

description

literature review

Transcript of Hand Therapy

  • HAND THERAPY 1

    LITERATURE REVIEW

    HAND THERAPY AND EXTENDED SCOPE PRACTICE

    Name

    Institution

    Professor

    Unit

    Date

  • HAND THERAPY 2

    Introduction

    This literature review focuses on the roles of hand therapy notably the linkage between

    clinical and surgical practice for hand-related disorders. The literature review will engage the

    current literature on the professional development of hand therapist and how it has changed over

    the last 15 years. The selection of literature is evenly distributed for the time-based analysis. The

    review will look into extended scope practice, barriers, and future application of hand therapy in

    both physical and occupational therapy.

    Key words

    Hand therapy, Extended-Scope Practice (ESP), occupational therapy, physical therapy,

    physiotherapy, Hand therapy roles, Continuing Professional Development (CPD)

    Key word search for each section are explained in each section.

    Hand therapy roles

    The search keywords/phrase combination for this section was Hand therapy roles,

    functions. The inclusion criteria included only peer reviewed journal articles. The articles were

    chosen randomly with specific bias on relevance and British literature.

    In the current dispensation, hand therapists perform more tasks than their counterparts did

    a decade ago. According to Valdes, Naughton and Burke (2015), do general practice

    consultancy, conduct diagnostics, refer patient for investigative tests, and person tests. Further,

    hand therapists perform therapeutic functions that extend from clinical roles, they engage with

    other specialists notably doctors to relieve them some routine duties, including and not limited to

  • HAND THERAPY 3

    splinting, removal of surgical stiches and other aids, and scar management. These roles are

    common among hand therapists working under surgical practitioners. Some of these functions

    start before the surgical practice. Hand therapists perform physical exercises to patients in

    rehabilitation. According to Toemen and Midgely (2008), hand therapists conduct tests notably

    electrotherapy, conduction and ensuring organization of home-based care, self-care and assisted

    care in hospital and outpatient environment.

    Health professions tend to converge and the boundaries in practice are changing rapidly.

    In the context of interlink ages of health practitioners, a hand therapist presides over orthopaedic,

    and rheumatic of the hand (Daker-White, Carr, Harvey, Woolhead, Bannister, Nelson, 1999).

    Further, hand therapists work with neuromuscular specialists in complications affecting nerves.

    Daker-white and colleagues examined orthopaedic therapists and their roles in hospitals and

    practice. They found out that orthopaedic therapists reduced direct hospital costs while also

    reducing the burden on doctors and surgeons (1999 p.648). In the research, though orthopaedic

    physiotherapists are specialists, the role of extended scope including other specialised training in

    other fields. The research had a short follow-up despite being the only known controlled trial and

    perhaps with a longer follow-up, they would have reported with more authority on key research

    agendas. The authors concluded that trained physiotherapists are adequately capable of

    conducting triage referrals (p.649). The use of therapists works to plug the hole where surgical

    options may not work to rectify disorders. Lastly, the authors point at the lack of blinding in the

    samples as a strength in ensuring practical application.

    Health promotion is dependent on health service delivery. Timely health service delivery

    does not only save time but also saves resources. Regarding time, Ellis and Kersten (2002) argue

    that the purpose of extended scope practice which gives rise to the specialist group of therapists

  • HAND THERAPY 4

    notably occupational therapists is a realignment of the healthcare system with an aim of saving

    time lost by patients. Hand and occupational therapists work in pre and post environments

    mostly in screening, surgical, and other clinical settings to conduct pre-examination or follow-up

    on already existing case management. In such environments, occupational therapists work to

    enhance the quality and speed of care to allow the patient to return to normal productive

    functionality (p.119). In pre-examination stage, the authors observed that the hand and

    occupational therapists provided timely recommendations regarding cases. The advice enhanced

    the quality of intervention. In new clinics, therapists do initial contact with follow-up cases or

    joint and nerves patients, conduct initial diagnosis and case review of hand and other injuries

    (p.120-1). The authors used a qualitative research design, themes are well developed and no

    notable research drawback emerged.

    After surgical procedures, patients require assistive devices like continuous passive

    motion (CPM). Hand devices like CPM are aimed at enhancing nerve, rheumatic or tendon

    motion. Schwartz and Chafez (2008) studied the use of CPM in hand rehabilitation noting that

    such use of devices may not have significant effects. Hand therapists however use such devices

    in encouraging patients to exercise without putting pressure of individual musculoskeletal or

    surgical conditions of the therapy. The authors conducted a retrospective research design, which

    is prone to confounders and bias. The use of the research relies on the overarching agreement

    with other researches on issues of importance to the study including the active benefits of

    therapeutic rehabilitation. The research did not control for accuracy in measurement both

    preoperatively and post operatively which provides another doubt for reliability. The research

    however points to the important role that occupational therapists do before and after surgery and

    possible popular use of locomotion devices in aiding rehabilitation and faster recovery of the

  • HAND THERAPY 5

    patient. The research points to the underlying role of ensuring that patients return to normal

    functional capacity within the optimally possible time (pp.261-2).

    Occupational therapy borrows from other practice. In most cases, hand therapy works as

    a cross-sectional practice. As Shin (2010) noted, the use of reflexology, acupuncture and other

    traditional remedial medical practices is popular in occupational therapy culture and so in hand

    therapy. Shin observed the use of such a traditional remedy the Koryo Hand Therapy. Using a

    two-group experimental design to test quantitatively hypotheses, she found the use of Koryo

    Hand Therapy beneficial to menopausal women (p.141). Although this research is not related to

    occupational hand therapy, the relevance of the tackled topic shows the diversity and purpose of

    hand therapy as a health profession. Notable in this research is the conclusion that Koryo hand

    therapy can correct determinants of nervous imbalance relevant to rheumatic therapists. Such use

    signifies the growing scope of handling rheumatic conditions like arthritis as a way of enhancing

    dexterity among patients.

    In accidents and emergency departments can cause strains in delivery of care. Peck and

    Turner (2013) engaged in the development of therapy-led clinics and the functional capacities

    under which they operate. Hand trauma injuries are common in daily activities and so are the

    cases in hospitals. To remove pressure on hospital settings, creation of hand trauma clinics in

    Britain as a system aid to extended scope practice is evident. In their evaluation of the

    involvement of hand-trauma therapists and subsequent enhancement of their skill-set to support a

    multidimensional notably musculoskeletal, orthopaedic and rheumatic disorders, enhances the

    capacity, range of practice and support to other professions (p.91). Further, the authors

    confirmed the value of occupational therapists in their ability to use their professional

    development and experience to reduce cases referred for surgical procedures and their ability to

  • HAND THERAPY 6

    handle the cases within their capacity using their gained skill-set. The research design is not

    stated and the methods unclear, but the conceptual analysis and grounds of conclusion are

    evident.

    Education/continuing professional development of hand therapists

    The search terms for this section were Education continuing professional development hand

    therapists. The inclusion criteria was relevance and peer reviewed journal articles. 10 articles

    were initially picked and only those that reflect significant issues worth addressing in the review

    were picked.

    At the beginning of the millennium, therapists had a high turnover (Collins, Jones,

    McDonnell, 2000). The blame was placed on the lack of motivation in training, development and

    functionality of the healthcare system. Healthcare system focused on profiteering moves making

    it hard for occupational therapists whose work is labour and personnel intensive yet lacking in

    financial incentive. The development of new professions such as hand therapy provided new

    enthusiasm for prospective therapists and motivation for existing therapists (p.3). Using self-

    administered questionnaires and a combination of mixed methods in analysis, the authors found

    out that such new role within the healthcare system provided hope for those contemplating career

    changes (p.3). Most of the concerns cited by therapists was that their efforts were poorly

    motivated and rewarded. As a common understanding, the authors point tout the demanding

    nature of therapy-based patient care requiring technical, innovative and extended scope of

    approach. The advised the need to enhance professional development beyond the normal

    extended scope practitioner-led training and development (p.11).

  • HAND THERAPY 7

    Hand therapists training include capacity to perform four key functions in healthcare. The

    therapist must be capable of using basic and fundamental science-based knowledge. The

    therapist must be proficient in evaluation of upper extremities. Ability to form independent but

    informed prognosis is imperative. In addition, the person must have capacity to organize

    professional practice (Dimick, Caro, Kasch, Muenzen, Fullenwider, Taylor, ... & Walsh, 2009).

    Because of this enormous range of expended proficiency, certification of hand therapists and

    professional development has gradually changed and grown over time. Inclusion of a wide range

    of proficiency aimed at making the therapist aware of the conditions necessary for consideration

    before engaging the patient ensures that the level of innovativeness required is immense. Further,

    in this paper, the authors noted the bulging professional diversity as a key ingredient to the

    training programs and academic requirements of certification to work as a hand therapist.

    Although most physiotherapists and occupational therapists are nurses, further requirements to

    enhance proficiency in the upper extremity functions only serves to enlarge the professional

    scope of the therapist (p. 372). This review focuses on the experiential position of existing

    professional and certified practising hand therapists.

    One of the professional development expected of a therapist is capacity to administer a

    health facility. In such a move, the administration of a clinic by a hand therapist can enhance

    capacity to create fully developed departments and care centres where referral to a hand therapist

    is possible (Warwick & Belward, 2004). Alternatively, organization of such departments prove

    efficient in handling and sorting out hand disorders. The author proved that having a consultant

    wing and a hand therapy wing could enhance the suitability of cases handled by each (p.26). for

    example, patients requiring both nerve conduction studies and electrophysiology diagnostic tests

    from the general practitioner and therapist, respectively, can take advantage of having a one way

  • HAND THERAPY 8

    care delivery. The patient will not have any more referral when such order of events is followed.

    Unlike in other cases where any hand-related complication is referred to the therapists to conduct

    tests. Such a case leads to more than one referral to ascertain the clients condition. The capacity

    to align therapeutic care with consultant care in a general and specialised care is dependent on

    the capacity and efficacy of the two departments (p.26).

    While evaluating the need and the technical application of continued professional

    development among and between increasing areas of physical and occupational therapy, French

    and Dowds (2008) acknowledge the challenges envisaged by most professionals. While there is a

    need to ensure that the professional capacity improves with increased research, inventions and

    technological advances, there are barriers to extensive and practice-led professional growth.

    Apart from professional growth, the value and application of research, reflective practice and

    updated technical capacity to improve patient care is expected (p.193-5). The future lies in

    overcoming the challenges of cost of development and sustainability of extensive specialization.

    The authors of the research used literature review to examine what the other researchers

    concluded. There is no particular concern preventing the use and adoption of this review work.

    The authors conclude that development of specialist positions notably in the consultant level of

    therapy, extended scope practitioner like hand therapists, and others find documenting

    professional growth a challenge (p.195). The need to enhance a nomenclature to understand the

    acquisition of specialist soft skills is recommended as a way of enhancing understanding of

    individual professional position.

    Though professional development is highly encouraged, core experience skills (soft

    skills) that prove successful in therapy practice. In their research, Chipchase, Johnston and Long

    (2012) advised on the growing overemphasis on professional notably academic development

  • HAND THERAPY 9

    without focusing on its veracity. In their evaluation, every effort in healthcare system must be

    evaluated on how it improves the quality of care and overall impact on the patient. They

    evaluated the course content of most of the professional development courses noting the

    continued emphasis on administrative, enterprise and commercial purposes. For example,

    professional seek the reasons to refer to their consultant capacity mostly through professional

    certification, but with little regard of ensuring consultant capacity in practice. Such issues

    emerge as educational institutions venture with the popular consumerism to keep up with

    competition (p.90). The review does not show how the review was conducted. The use and

    acceptance of the source for this review rests on the fact that the paper is peer reviewed and it

    allows one to develop the growing discontent on the quality of professional curriculum. The

    authors conclude that there is a major disconnect between what is offered and what is required to

    improve patient health outcomes. They however place responsibility on the practitioner to know

    what their status is and how to align it towards enhancing patient outcomes (p.91).

    A major component of professional development is adoption and alignment of research

    findings in ones field in professional practice. In their research, Groth and Farrar-Edwards

    (2013) envisaged a strong proportion of hand therapists who did not keep abreast with current

    research on their field let alone try to use it in professional practice. It is hard for patient

    outcomes to improve when research and development are not priorities. In this research, using a

    randomized mail survey, the researchers proved that the use of research in practice is appalling

    with the highest group having 45% adoption rates. They also observed the influence of age at the

    expense of experience and demographic indicators as major differences between and among

    group members (p.245). Though the research has its limitations based on the sampling and

    possible bias, the population under scrutiny can adequately inform future areas of research

  • HAND THERAPY 10

    notably different demographical characteristics. The four groups of certified hand therapists

    evaluated notably analytics, pragmatic, sceptic and traditional groups exhibited poor adoption of

    research findings with most remaining static to the status quo. Understanding the reasons for this

    can help so that focus on improving research adoption can be realized.

    How hand therapy has changed over the past 15 years

    The search phrase was hand therapy changes over time History of hand therapy The

    inclusion criteria was relevance and peer reviewed journal articles. Ten articles were initially

    picked and only those that reflect significant issues worth addressing in the review were picked.

    To understand these changes, the literature search focused on an inclusive criteria, research ideas

    and review of the outcomes. Sources were picked selectively within the 15-year period, two in

    every 2-3 years. The Elsevier ScienceDirect database was used to provide a bias of UK

    journals.

    Hand therapy is an extended scope practice that branched from physical and occupational

    therapy. The hand therapists therefore generally have general practitioner knowledge like

    occupational therapy and specialist skills in dealing with hand disorders. According to Amadio

    (2001), the branch was informed by increased need for specialist skills in the field of physical

    and occupational therapy. The argument is that, due to the growing medical cases in terms of

    physical and occupational requirements of each case, the need to have specialist skills became

    inevitable. During this time, general practice therapy was common with attention to occupational

    therapy going to plug the need for therapists in biomechanical fields. According to Sullivan

    (2001), the emergence of other neuromuscular, rheumatic and demands of the health system

    ensured that such professional skills gained acceptance and development. Wide range of hand

  • HAND THERAPY 11

    disorders emerged and the focus veered off the requirements and attentions of either physical or

    occupational therapists. The development of a field that focused on Disabilities of the Shoulder,

    Arm Hand (DASH) was gaining prominence then with attention on the disorders likely to lead

    problems in the mentioned areas. The prominence of the hand in the field is obvious as it bridges

    physical and occupational needs of a person. As evident in Sullivan research, the lack of a

    universal modality in the practice signified a field in its development with greater promise and

    emphasis on diversity of purpose (pp.66-7).

    To plug growing need for efficiency in the health system especially in developed

    countries of Europe and North America, Practitioner-led clinics become emerged (MacDermid &

    Stratford, 2004) as various specialist practice-based fields gained acceptance (Peck, Kennedy,

    Watson, & Lees, 2004). A major reason for the development of such practitioner-led clinics was

    increase in hand trauma cases. As McDermid and Stratford observed the use of evidence and

    research outcome in informing policy and system reviews can be assumed to play a part in such

    development. However, they observed several challenges in research application including how

    such clinics operated. Being a new idea, the need for extensive application of system, practice

    and outcome evidence ought to be thoroughly synthesised. Since this research focused on

    evidenced-based practice, it efficacy can be evaluated on the demands of pragmatism. It is

    structural and thematically organized to warrant consideration and use in this review. Evaluation

    by Peck et al. (2004) showed how responsive and effective such clinics were in improving

    patient outcomes. The research showed a positive impact of practitioner-led clinics in both the

    patient outcomes and in the efficiency of the whole system. The development and usage of

    practitioner-led clinics further show resilience in moderating continuous care, which reduces

    healthcare system pressure on demand for personnel involvement.

  • HAND THERAPY 12

    According to Stanton (2008) in her review of Barr (2007) lecture, the development of

    therapy as a holistic field, one that encompasses the mind, body and science, is inevitable. This

    theoretical disposition of hand therapy emerged from the increased attempts and success in

    incorporating historical therapies, notably eastern therapies like acupuncture, reflexology and

    others. As evident in Kaiser, Bodell and Berger (2008) research, surgical methods may not

    function fully without further assistance from therapy. Though science recommends the body,

    that is the musculoskeletal, neuromuscular and other physical sides of hand disorders, a blend of

    a holistic approach, one that seeks to innovate for case-by-case, remains paramount. Stanton

    (2008) shows growing confidence in the acceptance of therapy-led approach as a way of

    enhancing restorative capacity to function in an occupational setting. Kaiser et al. (2008) on the

    other hand gives a similar response with emphasis on a stronger integration of the services for

    patients. The aim is to improve patient outcomes. As expected, patients seek medical attention so

    that they can lead a normal, fruitful and comfortable life. Without articulate attention to that

    important goal, the efforts of individualized response may adversely undermine provision of

    care. The two papers are peer reviewed and systematically organized to warrant acceptance for

    this review.

    Hand therapy tends towards rehabilitative functions of therapy. Current methods of

    rehabilitation have improved to the extent of the use of hybrid methods. According to Liu,

    Fujiwara, Shindo, Kasashima, Otaka, Tsuji and Ushiba (2012), such use hybrid methods of

    rehabilitation are in use. While evaluating their efficacy, the authors observed the overwhelming

    extended scope requirements for functional approaches towards care. The argument is that

    rehabilitation of upper extremities have historically proved difficult and all efforts to change the

    situation focus on the hybrid requirements of enhancement of the physical characteristics of most

  • HAND THERAPY 13

    disorders. In the research, the use of newer rehabilitation approaches is emphasize. Further

    research on the changes in the hand therapy includes the development of various approaches and

    protocol. Despite dynamism and liberal protocols making sense to most, the referral and

    continued resilience in the use of conservative protocols to respond to practice challenges cannot

    be overstated. According to Wollstein, Wollstein, Rodgers and Ogden (2013) recommendation

    and acceptance of a dynamic approach to care becomes evident. While evaluating the use of

    hand therapy protocol among patients with lunate overloads, thy observed the possible need to

    other protocols. This is a significant part of development of hand therapy as a collaborative field,

    which seeks to enhance success in patient outcomes. Liu et al. (2012) shows how the use of

    hybrid methods notably, HANDS and robots, and integration with other methods can enhance

    occupational rehabilitation.

    As more emphasis in medical care focuses on areas where profit can be achieved, a

    growing risk area is that where specialized treatment is required without the incentive of bring

    full recovery but improvement of quality of life. Children disorders, for example amyoplasia and

    elderly citizens with chronic musculoskeletal and neuromuscular disorders can be time and

    resource consuming. The expected outcome for the care may not bring the same level of

    enthusiasm among caregivers. As Lake and Oishi (2015), observed, this cases represent a

    neglected area but rowing in the community. The development of an extensive lifetime care

    protocol involving a holistic and personnel dependant practice is required. Modern ideas about

    the changing role of hand therapy to represent a strategic review of existing healthcare needs to

    include neglected cases and to increase capacity and ability to function can help facilitate

    improved outcomes for such patients. In the review of case study based on outcomes, the authors

    show the need to improve elbow flexion among children with amyoplasia. Further, in the same

  • HAND THERAPY 14

    theme of changing roles of hand therapists, innovativeness in improving quality of care is

    emphasized by Peck-Murray (2015). The use of everyday items or he use of a home setting to

    enhance quality of care as a way of removing the burden bestowed upon the extended scope

    practitioners.

    In this review of the last 15 years, three phases emerge, the phase where the role of hand

    therapy is entrenched in other fields (Dependent), when it is independent, and when it seeks to

    share some of its practice-based responsibilities.

    Introduction of extended-scope-practitioner hand therapists

    The original search included extended-scope-practitioner hand therapists The inclusion

    criteria was relevance and peer reviewed journal articles. Ten articles were initially picked and

    only those that reflect significant issues worth addressing in the review were picked.

    Orthopaedics, rheumatologists, surgeons, general practitioners and other established

    professional teams work hand in hand to develop a care protocol relevant for each case.

    Therapeutic specialists also form part of this specialist group. Due to complications and desire to

    align delivery of care, emergence of roles outside the traditional scope call for extended scope of

    practitioners (Ellis & Kersten, 2001). The presence of these professional roles give rise to the

    growth of the same professional requirements. The need is informed by the need to have relevant

    knowledge and skill in such extension of service. As a requirement by most relevant bodies,

    notably the British association of therapists, search extensive application comes with expected

    training and professional growth. Normally certification is expected and recommended. The

    reference term given to this professional is Extended Scope Practitioner ESP. Ellis and Kersten

    (2001) further envisage the scope of practice and the field as one that is going beyond

  • HAND THERAPY 15

    opportunistic roles, but also one that depends on the training needs of such practice. In their

    research, they envisaged networking and professional orientation of the relevant fields to

    enhance their service delivery. They arrived at this conclusion following a mixed method survey

    using descriptive statistics to inform generalization. The research showed the extent of ESP

    participation notably in non-medical or surgical clinic, rheumatology clinics, preoperative and

    post-operative environments (pp.127-8).

    Because of increased recognition of professional requirements and role-play among

    physical and occupational therapists, and the confidence bestowed to them to manage various

    disorders, ESP became possible. According to Gardiner and Turner (2002) who evaluated the

    clinical diagnosis between ESPs and doctors, the role of ESPs is extensive depending on the

    professional requirements of the scope of practice. Using a retrospective audit, they observed

    that ESPs (physiotherapists) working in arthroscopy were more accurate that orthopaedic

    doctors. The research was not independently audited which leaves room for possible bias. The

    authors concluded that further acknowledgement of areas where ESs can assist should be sought

    and even development of independent triage clinics facilitated by such ESP work (p. 156). The

    challenge lies in enhancement of system level analysis to determine where ESPs can safely be

    deployed.

    Physiotherapists and occupational therapists forms the bulk of ESPs in UK. Their role

    spans in various other medical, surgical and non-medical fields, which prompts evaluation of the

    needs and requirements for one to function as an ESP. using a Delphi study, Ellis, Kersten and

    Sibley (2005) looked at the roles and requirements of practice among ESPs. Workforce

    shortages ranks high in current healthcare system requirements among the things that require

    permanent solutions. One way of trying to bridge this disparity of need and availability of

  • HAND THERAPY 16

    practitioners is partly filled by the ESPs. In the research, the authors found out the need to have

    proper guidelines regarding deployment and roles expected is missing. The problem of

    overreaching expectations among ESPs is real and a significant barrier in their development

    commonplace. The authors used three questions to come out with the following outcomes. There

    was a consensus that an ESP must have 3years of practice, know the scope of their abilities and

    have specialist skills in the area of clinical ESP. Secondly, there was significant focus on the

    professional capacity to administer and interpret investigative tests as a requirement to function

    as an ESP. Regarding role parameters, the authors found emphasis on ability to run outpatient

    clinics as the most significant requirement (p.84). ESPs receive support from other healthcare

    stakeholders with the majority of the drivers towards ESP-led roles coming from existing

    demands in the healthcare (Kersten, McPherson, Lattimer, George, Breton & Ellis, 2007). In the

    same research, Kersten et al. (2007) view the ESP debate as a paradigm in the scope of practice.

    The driver of the paradigm however does not reflect the holistic healthcare promotion approach.

    They further identify patient outcomes, cost benefits, and informed research as the best drivers

    for such a paradigm. The research uses a systematic review in an expanded Cochrane approach

    to study the drivers growth of ESPs. In evaluating how ESPs work, Rose and Probert (2009)

    enthused that ESPs work by altering patient pathways to care (p.96). By doing so, they require

    experience, observation and training on specialist needs. The research looked at these issues in

    depth. They stressed the need to develop specialist investigative skills of testing, creation of

    mock pathways, training and assessment as stages of creation of an ESP clinic. The capacity to

    function as assistive experts and independently to exercise leant clinical expertise is an important

    stage of development for all ESPs.

    Roles and barriers to practice currently and in the future

  • HAND THERAPY 17

    The original search included Roles and barriers to practice currently and in the future for

    hand therapists and Extended scope practitioners The inclusion criteria was relevance and peer

    reviewed journal articles. Ten articles were initially picked and only those that reflect significant

    issues worth addressing in the review were picked.

    Development and encouragement of ESP roles faces significant barriers. According to

    Huisstede, Fridn, Coert, Hoogvliet and European Handguide Group (2014), role definition can

    impact negatively on the role an ESP plays in a clinical setting. Further, they noticed the growing

    problem with definition of roles in a hierarchy. Even in clinical settings where clinical-led or

    practitioner-led clinics, the concern about hierarchy of both protocol and practice is not always

    developed well making the role uncertain. The research being a Delphi study shows the possible

    issues likely to affect normal functionality in practice. The study is limited to the composition of

    the group of participants of the research. However, if this was taken to mean that the group

    reflects a multidimensional professional group expected to develop practice. Without a strongly

    developed protocol, confusion and time wastage is inevitable. Hansen & Tromborg (2013) agree

    with this concern about patient pathways. In their conclusion, they argued that evaluation of

    measured functional outcomes relevant to the patient should be the guiding principle (p.2010).

    They argue that the existing patient pathways guiding most ESP use tend to focus on the success

    factors of practice. ESP being a relatively new protocol especially outside therapy-led practice.

    In developing a patient pathway in hand therapy and occupational therapy, emerging

    requirements include evidence-based and cost effective methods. Li, Westby, Sutton, Thompson,

    Sayre and Casimiro (2009) identified significant concerns about the training requirements and

    coordination of resources as considerable barriers to ESP practice. In the research, pursuing of

    specialization and certification among and clinical experts seeking to venture in ESP does not

  • HAND THERAPY 18

    support the fear of change and acceptance of extended role. Time management, training

    requirements, coordination of resources and staff, fear of change and fear of taking more roles

    and responsibilities, loss of job diversity and lack of mentors ought to be overcome to enhance

    future development of ESP and related clinical practice roles.

    The development of specific guidelines notably on matters beyond certification and

    mostly on practice remains untrusted by existing functional bodies. A model of certification and

    guidelines can work to alleviate deviation from acceptable levels of practice. Further, guideline-

    setting efforts do not always collaborate with those of expected implementation always breeding

    avenues of further concerns. However, with the implementation of nationwide and preferably

    universal protocols, it can enhance the level of job satisfaction and self-efficacy among

    upcoming professionals (Huisstede et al. 2014: Chipchase, Johnston & Long, 2012). Further

    development of successful ESP role models can play a part in encouraging the grown of the

    practice. Practical guidelines can set the tone for other professional seeking to venture into

    creative fields, notably in ESP and hand therapy.

  • HAND THERAPY 19

    Reference list

    Amadio, P. C., 2001. Outcome assessment in hand surgery and hand therapy: an update. Journal

    of Hand Therapy, 14(2), 63-67.

    Chan, J., & Spencer, J., 2004. The usefulness of qualitative knowledge development in hand

    therapy. Journal of Hand Therapy, 17(1), 1-5.

    Chipchase, L. S., Johnston, V., & Long, P. D., 2012. Continuing professional development: the

    missing link. Manual therapy, 17(1), 89-91.

    Collins K, Jones M.L, McDonnell, A., 2000. Do new roles contribute to job satisfaction and

    retention of staff in nursing and professions allied to medicine? Journal of Nursing Management

    8, 3-12.

    Daker-White, G, Carr, A J, Harvey, I, Woolhead, G, Bannister, G, Nelson, I 1999. A randomised

    controlled trial. Shifting boundaries of doctors and physiotherapists in orthopaedic outpatient

    departments, J Epid Comm Health, 53, 643-650.

    Dimick, M. P., Caro, C. M., Kasch, M. C., Muenzen, P. M., Fullenwider, L., Taylor, P. A., ... &

    Walsh, J. M., 2009. 2008 practice analysis study of hand therapy. Journal of Hand Therapy,

    22(4), 361-376.

    Ellis, B, Kersten P., 2001. An exploration of the developing role of hand therapists as extended

    scope practitioners. British Journal of Hand Therapy, 6(4), 126-131.

    Ellis, B, Kersten P., 2002.The developing role of hand therapists within the hand surgery and

    medicine services: an exploration of doctors views. British Journal of Hand Therapy, 7(4), 119-

    123.

  • HAND THERAPY 20

    Ellis, Kersten & Sibley 2005. A Delphi study of the role parameters and requirements of

    extended scope practice in hand therapy. British Journal of Hand Therapy. 10(314), 80-87

    French, H. P., & Dowds, J., 2008. An overview of continuing professional development in

    physiotherapy. Physiotherapy, 94(3), 190-197.

    Gardiner J, Turner, P, 2002. Accuracy of clinical diagnosis of internal derangement of the knee

    by extended scope physiotherapists and orthopaedic doctors. Retrospective audit. Physiotherapy,

    88(3), 153-157.

    George, S., Bialosky, J. E., Bishop, M. D., Robinson, M. E., & Price, D. D., 2008. Effects of

    manual therapy on pain perception in individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome. Journal of Hand

    Therapy, 21(4), 428.

    Groth, G. N., & Farrar-Edwards, D., 2013. Patterns of research utilization among Certified Hand

    Therapists. Journal of Hand Therapy, 26(3), 245-254.

    Hansen, A. ., & Tromborg, H., 2013. Increased use of the affected hand one and a half years

    after surgical correction for cerebral palsy and subsequent intensive hand therapy. Hand

    Therapy, 19(1) 1725.

    Huisstede, B. M., Fridn, J., Coert, J. H., Hoogvliet, P., & European HANDGUIDE Group.

    2014. Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: Hand Surgeons, Hand Therapists, and Physical Medicine and

    Rehabilitation Physicians Agree on a Multidisciplinary Treatment GuidelineResults From the

    European HANDGUIDE Study. Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation, 95(12), 2253-

    2263.

  • HAND THERAPY 21

    Jack, J., & Estes, R. I., 2010. Documenting progress: Hand therapy treatment shift from

    biomechanical to occupational adaptation. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 64(1),

    8287.

    Kaiser, G. L., Bodell, L. S., & Berger, R. A. 2008. Functional outcomes after arthroplasty of the

    distal radioulnar joint and hand therapy: a case series. Journal of Hand Therapy, 21(4), 398-409.

    Kersten, P., McPherson, K., Lattimer, V., George, S., Breton, A., & Ellis, B., 2007.

    Physiotherapy extended scope of practicewho is doing what and why?. Physiotherapy, 93(4),

    235-242.

    Lake, A. L., & Oishi, S. N. 2015. Hand therapy following elbow release for passive elbow

    flexion and long head of the triceps transfer for active elbow flexion in children with amyoplasia.

    Journal of Hand Therapy, 28(2), 222-227.

    Li, L. C., Westby, M. D., Sutton, E., Thompson, M., Sayre, E. C., & Casimiro, L. 2009.

    Canadian physiotherapists' views on certification, specialisation, extended role practice, and

    entry-level training in rheumatology. BMC health services research, 9(1), 88-98.

    Liu, M., Fujiwara, T., Shindo, K., Kasashima, Y., Otaka, Y., Tsuji, T., & Ushiba, J. 2012. Newer

    challenges to restore hemiparetic upper extremity after stroke: HANDS therapy and BMI

    neurorehabilitation. Hong Kong Physiotherapy Journal, 30(2), 83-92.

    MacDermid, J. C. 2004. The quality of clinical practice guidelines in hand therapy. Journal of

    Hand Therapy, 17(2), 200-209.

    MacDermid, J. C., & Stratford, P., 2004. Applying evidence on outcome measures to hand

    therapy practice. Journal of Hand Therapy, 17(2), 165-173.

  • HAND THERAPY 22

    MacDermid, J. C., & Tottenham, V. 2004. Responsiveness of the disability of the arm, shoulder,

    and hand (DASH) and patient-rated wrist/hand evaluation (PRWHE) in evaluating change after

    hand therapy. Journal of Hand Therapy, 17(1), 18-23.

    Morris, J., Grimmer, K., Gilmore, L., Perera, C., Waddington, G., Kyle, G., ... & Murphy, K.

    ,2014. Principles to guide sustainable implementation of extended-scope-of-practice

    physiotherapy workforce redesign initiatives in Australia: stakeholder perspectives, barriers,

    supports, and incentives. Journal of multidisciplinary healthcare, 7, 249-258.

    Peck, F, Turner, S, 2013. The development of a therapy-led hand trauma clinic. British Journal

    of Hand Therapy, 18(3), 87-91.

    Peck, F. H., Kennedy, S. M., Watson, J. S., & Lees, V. C., 2004. An evaluation of the influence

    of practitioner-led hand clinics on rupture rates following primary tendon repair in the hand.

    British journal of plastic surgery, 57(1), 45-49.

    PeckMurray, J. A. 2015. Utilizing everyday items in play to facilitate hand therapy for pediatric

    patients. Journal of Hand Therapy, 28(2), 228-232.

    Rose, R. L., & Probert, S. 2009. Development and implementation of a hand therapy extended

    scope practitioner clinic to support the 18-week waiting list initiative. Hand Therapy, 14(4), 95-

    104.

    Schwartz, D. A., & Chafetz, R. 2008. Continuous passive motion after tenolysis in hand therapy

    patients: a retrospective study. Journal of Hand Therapy, 21(3), 261-267.

    Shin, H. S., 2010. Effects of Koryo hand therapy on serum hormones and menopausal symptoms

    in Korean women. Journal of Transcultural Nursing, 21(2), 134-142.

  • HAND THERAPY 23

    Stanton, D. E. B., 2008. The Mind, Body, and Science of Hand Therapy: Nathalie Barr Lecture

    delivered at the ASHT Annual Meeting, Phoenix, Arizona, October 2007. Journal of Hand

    Therapy, 21(1), 91-96.

    Sullivan, J. L., 2001. Hand therapy: The healing touch with a touch of humor!. Journal of Hand

    Therapy, 14(1), 3-9.

    Toemen, A., & Midgley, R. 2010. Hand therapy management of metacarpal fractures: an

    evidence-based patient pathway. Hand Therapy, 15(4), 87-93.

    Valdes, K. A., 2008. Hand therapy & osteoarthritis: Efficacy of conservative treatment based on

    literature review. Journal of Hand Therapy, 21(4), 427-428.

    Valdes, K., Naughton, N., & Burke, C. J., 2015. Therapist-Supervised Hand Therapy Versus

    Home Therapy With Therapist Instruction Following Distal Radius Fracture. The Journal of

    hand surgery, 40(6), 1110-1116.

    Warwick, D., Belward, P., 2004. Hand therapist carpal tunnel clinic, British Journal of Hand

    Therapy, 9 (1) 23-26.

    Wollstein, R., Wollstein, A., Rodgers, J., & Ogden, T. J. 2013. A hand therapy protocol for the

    treatment of lunate overload or early Kienbock's disease. Journal of Hand Therapy, 26(3), 255-

    260.