Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (±...

13
1 ARTÍCULO ORIGINAL Patología 2019;57:1-13. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 conjunctival nevi and their probable histogenetic significance Estructuras hamartomatosas y coristomatosas en 726 nevos conjuntivales y su probable significado histogenético. Héctor A. Rodríguez-Marnez, 1 Abelardo A. Rodríguez-Reyes, 2 Dolores Ríos y Valles-Valles, 2 Alfredo Gó- mez-Leal, 2 Stephanie de la O-Pérez, 2 Leonora Chávez-Mercado, 3 Ofelia Pérez-Olvera, 1 Armando Medina-Cruz, 3 Ivee Hernández-Ayuso, 2 C. Marina Camargo-Espia, 1 Fabiola Valencia-Luna 1 1 Laboratorio de Invesgaciones anato- mopatológicas Roberto Ruiz Obregón, Departamento de Medicina experi - mental, Facultad de Medicina de la Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México; Hospital General de México Dr. Eduardo Liceaga, Ciudad de México. 2 Servicio de Patología oſtálmica, Asocia- ción para Evitar la Ceguera en México, IAP, Hospital Dr. Luis Sánchez Bulnes, Ciudad de México. 3 Servicio de Patología, Hospital General de México Dr. Eduardo Liceaga; Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Nacional Au- tónoma de México, Ciudad de México. Correspondencia Héctor A. Rodríguez Marnez [email protected] Este arculo debe citarse como Rodríguez-Martínez HA, Rodrí - guez-Reyes AA, Ríos y Valles-Valles D, Gómez-Leal A, de la O-Pérez S, Chávez-Mercado L, Pérez-Olvera O, Medina-Cruz, A, Hernández-Ayuso I, Camargo-Espia M, Valencia-Luna F. Hamartomatous and choristoma- tous structures in 726 conjunctival nevi and their probable histogenec significance. Patología Rev Lanoam. 2019;57:1-13. https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl. v57id.3118 Abstract OBJECTIVE: To establish clinicopathologic differences that presumably exist between conjunctival and cutaneous nevi. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective, observational and descriptive, to evaluate conjunctival nevi. Stains performed were: H&E, PAS, Masson’s trichrome, Fontana-Mas- son, Warthin-Starry, Grimelius, Jones´ periodic acid silver methenamine and Hale´s colloidal iron; immunostains carried out were: vimentin, S-100 protein, Melan-A, tyrosi- nase, MiTF, HMB-45, MBP, EMA and GFAP. Results were tabulated for statistical analysis. RESULTS: We studied 726 conjunctival nevi. The age range was 6 months to 85 years, 54% were females. Size varied from 2 to 15 mm, median 5 mm. Nevi were flat in 91% and nodular in 9%. Average evolution time was 12.6 years. Eighteen per cent nevi were congenital. Eighty-seven per cent were compound, 12% subepithelial and 1% intraepithelial nevi. Sixty-four per cent nevi presented association of type A nevus cells with Masson´s laminated cells and melanogenesis, producing an organoid growth pattern. Hamartomatous epithelial cysts were an intrinsic part of 92% nevi, 33% showed melanotic pigmentation. Hamartomatous vessels and nerves were immersed within nevus cells in 46 and 24% nevi, respectively. Choristomatous pilosebaceous units were located between nevus cells in 8% nevi; moreover, intraepithelial nevi-like thecae and minute mucinous cysts were incorporated within the mere structure of hair follicles. CONCLUSIONS: Significant clinicopatologic differences were found between conjuncti- val and cutaneous nevi. Besides the 3 classical types of nevic cells (A,B,C), we presented evidence to recognize a fourth type of nevus cell: Masson´s laminated cells. These singular cells constitute a fundamentaI ingredient for the organoid growth pattern of conjunctival nevi. Intranevic hamartomatous structures, such as epithelial cysts, vessels and nerves, as well as choristomatous structures, such as pilosebaceous units, help to define conjunctival nevi as true neoplasias. KEYWORDS: conjunctival nevi, conjunctival cysts, conjunctival hamartomas, conjunc- tival choristomas, Masson´s laminated nevus cells. Resumen OBJETIVO: Establecer las diferencias clínico-patológicas entre los nevos conjuntivales y los nevos cutáneos. MATERIALES Y MÉTODOS: Estudio retrospectivo, observacional y descriptivo, llevado a cabo para evaluar muestras de nevos conjuntivales con tinciones de: HyE, PAS, tricrómico de Masson, Fontana-Masson, Warthin-Starry, Grimelius, ácido periódico metenamina de Jones y hierro coloidal de Hale; así como con inmunotinciones con- tra: vimentina, PS-100, Melan-A, tirosinasa, MiTF, HMB-45, MBP, EMA y GFAP. Los resultados se tabularon para análisis estadístico. www.revistapatologia.com Patología Revista Latinoamericana

Transcript of Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (±...

Page 1: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

1

Artículo originAl

Patología 2019;57:1-13.

Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 conjunctival nevi and their probable histogenetic significance

Estructuras hamartomatosas y coristomatosas en 726 nevos conjuntivales y su probable significado histogenético.Héctor A. Rodríguez-Martínez,1 Abelardo A. Rodríguez-Reyes,2 Dolores Ríos y Valles-Valles,2 Alfredo Gó-mez-Leal,2 Stephanie de la O-Pérez,2 Leonora Chávez-Mercado,3 Ofelia Pérez-Olvera,1 Armando Medina-Cruz,3 Ivette Hernández-Ayuso,2 C. Marina Camargo-Espitia,1 Fabiola Valencia-Luna1

1 Laboratorio de Investigaciones anato-mopatológicas Roberto Ruiz Obregón, Departamento de Medicina experi-mental, Facultad de Medicina de la Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México; Hospital General de México Dr. Eduardo Liceaga, Ciudad de México.2 Servicio de Patología oftálmica, Asocia-ción para Evitar la Ceguera en México, IAP, Hospital Dr. Luis Sánchez Bulnes, Ciudad de México.3 Servicio de Patología, Hospital General de México Dr. Eduardo Liceaga; Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Nacional Au-tónoma de México, Ciudad de México.

Correspondencia Héctor A. Rodríguez Martí[email protected]

Este artículo debe citarse comoRodríguez-Mart ínez HA, Rodrí -guez-Reyes AA, Ríos y Valles-Valles D, Gómez-Leal A, de la O-Pérez S, Chávez-Mercado L, Pérez-Olvera O, Medina-Cruz, A, Hernández-Ayuso I, Camargo-Espitia M, Valencia-Luna F. Hamartomatous and choristoma-tous structures in 726 conjunctival nevi and their probable histogenetic significance. Patología Rev Latinoam. 2019;57:1-13. https://doi.org /10.24245/patrl .v57id.3118

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To establish clinicopathologic differences that presumably exist between conjunctival and cutaneous nevi.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective, observational and descriptive, to evaluate conjunctival nevi. Stains performed were: H&E, PAS, Masson’s trichrome, Fontana-Mas-son, Warthin-Starry, Grimelius, Jones´ periodic acid silver methenamine and Hale´s colloidal iron; immunostains carried out were: vimentin, S-100 protein, Melan-A, tyrosi-nase, MiTF, HMB-45, MBP, EMA and GFAP. Results were tabulated for statistical analysis. RESULTS: We studied 726 conjunctival nevi. The age range was 6 months to 85 years, 54% were females. Size varied from 2 to 15 mm, median 5 mm. Nevi were flat in 91% and nodular in 9%. Average evolution time was 12.6 years. Eighteen per cent nevi were congenital. Eighty-seven per cent were compound, 12% subepithelial and 1% intraepithelial nevi. Sixty-four per cent nevi presented association of type A nevus cells with Masson´s laminated cells and melanogenesis, producing an organoid growth pattern. Hamartomatous epithelial cysts were an intrinsic part of 92% nevi, 33% showed melanotic pigmentation. Hamartomatous vessels and nerves were immersed within nevus cells in 46 and 24% nevi, respectively. Choristomatous pilosebaceous units were located between nevus cells in 8% nevi; moreover, intraepithelial nevi-like thecae and minute mucinous cysts were incorporated within the mere structure of hair follicles. CONCLUSIONS: Significant clinicopatologic differences were found between conjuncti-val and cutaneous nevi. Besides the 3 classical types of nevic cells (A,B,C), we presented evidence to recognize a fourth type of nevus cell: Masson´s laminated cells. These singular cells constitute a fundamentaI ingredient for the organoid growth pattern of conjunctival nevi. Intranevic hamartomatous structures, such as epithelial cysts, vessels and nerves, as well as choristomatous structures, such as pilosebaceous units, help to define conjunctival nevi as true neoplasias.KEYWORDS: conjunctival nevi, conjunctival cysts, conjunctival hamartomas, conjunc-tival choristomas, Masson´s laminated nevus cells.

Resumen

OBJETIVO: Establecer las diferencias clínico-patológicas entre los nevos conjuntivales y los nevos cutáneos.

MATERIALES Y MÉTODOS: Estudio retrospectivo, observacional y descriptivo, llevado a cabo para evaluar muestras de nevos conjuntivales con tinciones de: HyE, PAS, tricrómico de Masson, Fontana-Masson, Warthin-Starry, Grimelius, ácido periódico metenamina de Jones y hierro coloidal de Hale; así como con inmunotinciones con-tra: vimentina, PS-100, Melan-A, tirosinasa, MiTF, HMB-45, MBP, EMA y GFAP. Los resultados se tabularon para análisis estadístico.

w w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

Page 2: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

2

Patología Revista Latinoamericana Volumen 57, Año 2019

https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl.v57id.3118

BACKGROUND

Customarily, a priori has been accepted that intra, subepithelial and compound conjuncti-val nevi have practically the same histological characteristics of junctional, intradermal and compound nevi of skin. If anything, Thiagalin-gam et al1 noted that conjunctival nevi show “a pattern of confluent growth and a lack of maturation”. Nonetheless, we have already tried to determine the histological differences that could exist between these 2 types of nevi. Thus, in a previous study2, we reviewed the clinico-pathologic characteristics of 726 conjunctival nevi, intending to compare their attributes with those of cutaneous nevi which have been already sanctioned by the literature.3,4 In summary, the main results of our previous study2 were two: a) we could not find important histological diffe-rences between conjunctival intraepithelial nevi and cutaneous junctional nevi; b) however, we found significant clinical and histologic diffe-rences between conjunctival subepithelial and compound nevi and cutaneous intradermal and compound nevi. Presentation of these findings

and our interpretation of their probable histopa-thogenic significance, constitute the main reason for this work.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective, observational and descriptive study, to evaluate a conjunctival compound, subepithelial and intraepithelial nevi. Clinical information, photographs and H&E stained sections of all cases were reviewed. In addition, sections from 121 cases were stained with: PAS, Masson’s trichrome, Fontana-Masson, Warthin-Starry, Grimelius, Jones’ periodic acid silver methenamine and Hale’s colloidal iron. Same 121 cases were either depigmented and stained with H&E or dehydrated and mounted without staining. Immunostains of 12 cases were prepared for: vimentin, S-100 protein, Melan-A, tyrosinase, MiTF, HMB-45, MBP, EMA and GFAP. We reviewed, evaluated and digitally photogra-phed 2,056 slides, including several sections, with histochemical and immunohistochemical stains. Data of frequency of cutaneous nevi were obtained from Hospital General de México

RESULTADOS: Se registraron 726 muestras de nevos conjuntivales. El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio fue de 12.6 años. El 18% eran congénitos; 87% fueron com-puestos, 12% subepiteliales y 1% intraepiteliales. El 64% de los nevos se asociaron con células névicas de tipo A, células laminadas de Masson y melanogénesis, produ-ciendo un patrón de crecimiento organoide. Los quistes epiteliales hamartomatosos formaron una parte esencial de 92% de los nevos y de estos, 33% tuvo pigmentación melánica. Los vasos y nervios hamartomatosos estaban inmersos entre células névicas (46 y 24%, respectivamente). El 8% de los aparatos pilosebáceos coristomatosos se entremezclaban con células névicas; además, tecas iguales a los nevos intraepiteliales y minúsculos quistes mucinosos se encontraban incorporados dentro de la misma estructura de folículos pilosos. CONCLUSIONES: Se encontraron diferencias clínico-patológicas significativas entre los nevos conjuntivales y cutáneos. Además de los 3 tipos clásicos de células névicas (A, B, C), se presentó evidencia para reconocer un cuarto tipo: células laminadas de Masson. Estas células constituyen un punto fundamental del patrón de crecimiento organoide de los nevos conjuntivales. Las estructuras hamartomatosas intranévicas (quistes epiteliales, vasos y nervios) y coristomatosas (aparatos pilosebáceos) ayudan a definir los nevos conjuntivales en verdaderas neoplasias.

PALABRAS CLAVE: Nevos conjuntivales; quistes conjuntivales; hamartomas conjuntivales; coristomas conjuntivales; células névicas laminadas de Masson.

Page 3: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

3

Rodríguez-Martínez HA y col. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structuresw w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

Dermatopathology Laboratory files. Statistical analyses were accomplished with nonparametric statistics. Quantitative variables were summari-zed in terms of ranges and medians. Categorical variables were abbreviated in terms of frequen-cies and percentages.

RESULTS

We registered 726 conjunctival compound, subepithelial and intraepithelial nevi. The age ranged from 6 months to 85 years, average 17 and median 14 years. Females were 392 (54%) and males 334 (46%). Side: OS 378 (52%) and OD 348 (48%). Size varied between 2 and 15 mm, average and median 5 mm. Shape: 661 (91%) nevi were flat or macular and 65 (9%) were nodular or papular (Figure 1). Specific conjunctival site of 153 nevi was unknown. Location of 573 nevi was: bulbar conjunctiva (unspecified) 442 (77%), sclerocorneal limbus 58 (10%), “extensive” 35 (6%), semilunar fold 12 (2%), caruncle 12 (2%) and tarsal conjunctiva 12 (2%). One nevus was placed in the lacrimal sac. Most nevi were situated in interpalpebral region. Evolution time was unspecified in 366 cases, whereas in 360 it varied from 24 days to 75 years, with an average of 12.6 years. In 128 cases (18%) nevi had been present from birth, that is, they were congenital.

Only 1% nevi were entirely intraepithelial and 12% exclusively subepithelial. Eighty-seven percent nevi were compound, with significant volumetric predominance of the subepithelial component (Figure 2). Nevi growth pattern was mainly organoid in 91.7% (Figures 3A and 4); the remaining 8.3% had either a neuroid growth pattern (Figure 3C) or lacked specific pattern. Cellular composition of nevi showed a clear prevalence of type A nevus cells in 70% of cases (Figures 3A and 4); a mixture of type A and B cells in 16% (Figures 3A and 3B); a combination of type A and C cells in 7% (Figures 3A and 3C); and different proportions of type A, B and C cells in around 5%. Types A and C nevus cells possessed silver-positive basement membranes, which were not apparent in every cell (Figure 5). In 98%, nevus cells´ cytoplasms (mostly type A, some type B and exceptionally type C cells) as well as melanophages were tattooed with melanin pigment (Figure 6), while 2% nevi were considered amelanotic.

One or several type A nevus cells were encircled by one or various layers of thin laminated cells and their silver-positive basement membranes, giving a dazzling organoid growth pattern (Figu-res 4, 6B and 7). We identified these “flat” cells (“onion layers-like cells”) as Masson´s lamés foliacées,5,6 which were demonstrated in 77 out

Figure 1. Clinical features of 3 different conjunctival nevi.

Page 4: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

4

Patología Revista Latinoamericana Volumen 57, Año 2019

https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl.v57id.3118

Figure 2. Compound nevus, both intraepithelial and subepithelial (H&E).

Figure 3. Nevus cells: type A, type B and type C (H&E).

Figure 4. Type A nevus cells and Masson´s laminated nevus cells with organoid growth pattern (H&E).

Figure 5. Type A nevus cells surrounded by basement membranes (Jones´ silver methenamine).

Page 5: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

5

Rodríguez-Martínez HA y col. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structuresw w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

Figure 6. Melanogenesis in type A nevus cells and in Masson´s laminated nevus cells: A (H&E) and B (Fontana-Masson).

Figure 7. Masson´s laminated nevus cells in 3 different subepithelial nevi (H&E).

Page 6: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

6

Patología Revista Latinoamericana Volumen 57, Año 2019

https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl.v57id.3118

of 121 nevi (64%) with different stains (Figures 6B and 7). These enveloping laminated cells displayed silver-positive basement membranes and fine cytoplasmic melanin granules (Figures 6B and 7); moreover, they gave positive reactions for Melan-A, tyrosinase, MiTF, HMB-45, S-100 protein and EMA (Figures 8A, B, C and D). Eleven subepithelial nevi presented giant multinuclea-ted nevus cells and 5 other subepithelial nevi showed typical balloon cell changes in type A nevus cells.

Ninety-two per cent compound and subepithe-lial nevi were associated with epithelial cysts of different sizes. These cysts showed a lining resembling normal conjunctiva, although with variable goblet cell richness (Figure 9) and/or changes alike to conjunctival non-keratinizing squamous metaplasia. Thirty-three per cent of these cysts presented variable degrees of mela-notic pigmentation of their epithelium, both in keratinocytes and goblet cells (Figures 10A and B). Cyst wall pigmentation occurred, either on account of multiple dendritic melanocytes within their epithelium (Figures 11A and B) and/or due to slender nests of nevus cells forming part of the cystic wall (Figures 11C and D). Some nevus cell nests even resembled thecae of typical intraepi-thelial nevi (Figure 11C). Therefore, epithelial cysts were classified as hamartomatous.

Obviously abnormal “intranevic” blood vessels -in number, size and shape- were found in 46% of nevi (Figure 12). Furthermore, “intranevic” nerves were present in 24% nevi, which varied from small myelinated nerve trunks infiltrating between nevus cells (Figure 13A) to single un-myelinated axons immersed within type A nevus cells´ cytoplasm (Figure 13B). Consequently, we considered these vessels and nerves as hamar-tomatous too.

Eight per cent nevi presented ectopic “in-tranevic” pilosebaceous units with notorious

malformation of their histological structures, which we classified as choristomatous (Figures 14 and 15). Forming part of their choristomatous structure, there were some significant abnormali-ties. Intraepithelial nests or thecae of nevus cells were placed inside the basement membranes of pilosebaceous units (Figures 14A and B). Various undercoat-like hairs were contained within the lumen of several pilosebaceous units. And, most importantly, within the mere histologic structure of an unquestionable hair follicle, there were abundant goblet cells forming several small epi-thelial mucinous cysts (Figure 15). The specific location and minute size of these mucinous cysts allowed us to rule out pseudoglands of Henle or glands of Manz.

On the other hand, the conjunctiva surrounding the nevi presented primary acquired melanosis (PAM) without atypia in 27% of cases. Lympho-plasmacytic inflammatory infiltrate, varying from scanty to moderate, was identified in 61% nevi.

Vimentin and S-100 protein were positive in all nevus cell types from all cases, including type C cells. Melan-A was positive in 83% of types A and B nevus cells, whereas tyrosinase and MiTF were positive in 67% of type A and B nevus cells. HMB-45 was positive in only 42% of cases, mainly in type A cells and Masson´s laminated nevus cells. Both EMA and GFAP were positive in type A nevus cells in the same two cases. MBP gave negative results in all cases. Immunostaining properties of Masson´s lamina-ted nevus cells were mentioned elsewhere (vide supra et infra).

DISCUSSION

Conjunctival subepithelial and compound nevi are much less frequent than cutaneous intra-dermal and compound nevi. Because if one takes into consideration that each human being presents between 20 and 30 nevi on the skin,7

Page 7: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

7

Rodríguez-Martínez HA y col. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structuresw w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

Figure 8. Masson´s laminated nevus cells treated for: tyrosinase (A), HMB-45 (B), Melan-A (C) and EMA (D).

Figure 9. Epithelial cysts´ walls showing abundant goblet cells (Hale´s colloidal iron).

Figure 10. Melanotic pigmentation of cysts´ walls epithelia: H&E (A) and Fontana-Masson (B).

A B

Page 8: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

8

Patología Revista Latinoamericana Volumen 57, Año 2019

https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl.v57id.3118

Figure 11. Melanocytes infiltrating cysts´ walls: vimentin (A) and Melan-A (B). Nevus cells infiltrating cysts´ walls: Masson´s t. (C) and Melan-A (D).

Figure 12. Several abnormal intranevic vessels (H&E).Figure 13. Intranevic myelinated nerve cord: Grimelius (A). Intranevic unmyelinated nerve: Warthin-Starry (B).

Page 9: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

9

Rodríguez-Martínez HA y col. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structuresw w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

then the frequency of conjunctival nevi becomes exceptional. Thus, our 726 conjunctival nevi were found amongst 30,225 surgical ophthalmic specimens, studied between 1957 and 2011, which stand for 0.24% of this material.2 On the other hand, 8,642 cutaneous intradermal and compound nevi were found amidst 23,066 surgi-cal specimens of skin, studied between 2008 and 2018, which represent 37.5% of such material. As a result: the ratio was 119 cutaneous nevi to one conjunctival nevus. Considering that the cu-taneous nevi were collected in only less than one fifth of time, the real ratio could be 119 to 0.2.

Other clinical characteristics of our 726 patients and their nevi, were not significantly different

Figure 14. Two malformed pilosebaceous units with nevus cells´ thecae (H&E).

Figure 15. Hair follicle of a pilosebaceous unit harboring several minute mucinous cysts (Hale´s colloidal iron).

Page 10: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

10

Patología Revista Latinoamericana Volumen 57, Año 2019

https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl.v57id.3118

than those described in the literature.8 It is stated, for example, that conjunctival nevi are more frequent in children and young people, and that intraepithelial nevi are the most common type of nevi at that age. However, average age in our study was 17 years and median 14 years. In addition, exclusively intraepithelial nevi were found in only 1% of our cases, although 87% of nevi were compound and in consequence of they had an intraepithelial component too. Location of our nevi did not show important differences with those described in the literature,8 excepting in semilunar fold and caruncle, which were more frequent (4%, both sites included). Nevi were present from birth in 18%, without implying that these nevi were of congenital histologic type.9,10

Epithelial cysts -as a rule multiple and exceptio-nally single-, always had a lining of keratinocytes and goblet cells. In 33% they showed melanic pigment in both cell types cytoplasm, which unmistakably is a singular and distinctive feature of conjunctival subepithelial and compound nevi cysts. Melanin was present either as a powdery pigment or as clusters of melanin granules, such as occurs in melanophages. Melanotic pigmen-tation of cysts walls was due to participation of abundant dendritic melanocytes and/or slender nests of nevus cells, and it represents an impor-tant characteristic of cysts which has not been emphasized before.11 Cyst wall melanocytes and nevus cells were clearly marked with Melan-A, tyrosinase, MiTF, HMB-45 and S-100 protein. Abnormal cellular composition of cysts´ lining -having greater number of goblet cells than nor-mal conjunctiva or resembling non-keratinizing squamous metaplasia of conjunctiva– as well as remarkable melanotic pigmentation of their epithelium, seems to indicate that these cysts are not the result of casual invaginations of con-junctival epithelium, as has been suggested up to now.11 Actually, pigmented and non-pigmented epithelial cysts constitute the most important and frequent component of the hamartomatous struc-

ture of conjunctival subepithelial and compound nevi. Hamartomatous epithelial cysts, therefore, represent the main histologic difference between conjunctival and cutaneous nevi. It is well known that neither cutaneous intradermal nevi nor con-genital nevi can develop epithelial cysts, except when they are derived from atretic hair follicles or dilated sweat glands ducts. Although, in con-genital nevi abnormal skin appendages, nerves and vessels usually display a hamartomatous association with nevus cells.9,10

Organoid growth pattern and prevalence of type A nevus cells, sometimes mixed with type B cells (which have been named epithelioid and lymphoid, respectively), pertain to characteristics which were frequently found in conjunctival subepithelial and compound nevi. Moreover, taking part of an indisputable organoid grow-th pattern, type A nevus cells were frequently surrounded (64%) by one or several layers of laminated cells and their basement membranes (Figures 7 and 8), clearly corresponding to Mas-son´s foliated laminae or lamés foliacées.5,6 Our thoughtful opinion is that these peculiar and uni-que laminated cells (“onion layers-like cells”) are difficult to conceive as one more product of ma-turation or senescence of descended epidermal melanocytes, as abtropfung supporters propose it.3,4,12,13 In fact, to us, they are reminiscent of sus-tentacular and/or perineurial cells, in their shape and probable function. Immunohistochemically, they are analogous to type A nevus cells, because they are positive for Melan-A, tyrosinase, MiTF, HMB-45 and S-100 protein (Figures 8A, B and C), although their reactivity for EMA points out to a perineurial nature too (Figure 8D). Therefore, besides the 3 classical types of nevus cells (A,B,C) there is a fourth type of nevus cell: Masson´s foliated laminae or lamés foliacées.5,6 These cells have been disregarded until now by most experts in pigmentary cells.3,4 We propose to call them Masson´s laminated nevus cells. Most likely, organoid growth pattern and Masson´s laminated

Page 11: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

11

Rodríguez-Martínez HA y col. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structuresw w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

cells are a more frequent histologic component of conjunctival nevi than of cutaneous nevi.

In contrast, neuroid growth pattern and type C nevus cells (also named schwannoid), oc-cur more frequently in cutaneous intradermal and compound nevi.3,4 Type C nevus cells and neurotization of nevi, to the point that they can mimic neurofibromas and Wagner-Meissner´s corpuscles, which have been interpreted (¡again!) as products of maturation or senescence,4 were rarely found in conjunctival nevi (8.3%). It is important to take into account that some inves-tigations have recognized that type C nevus cells can have a schwannian or neural phenotype, because they possess the Schwann cell-asso-ciated antigen AHMY114 and cholinesterase.4 Such as Pierre Masson concluded in 1926 in his classic article “Les naevi pigmentaires, tumeurs nerveuses”5 and in 1951 in “My conception of cellular nevi”.6 The latter publication being translated from French into English, nothing more and nothing less than by Arthur Purdy Stout. For his generous collaboration, we assume that Stout also endorsed Masson´s histogenetic inter-pretation of nevi. If these findings conclusively prove to be correct, and we think they are, then at least one or two cellular components of nevi (such as type C cells and Masson´s laminated nevus cells) should be considered of direct neural crest origin, and not as products of “dropping off” of epidermal melanocytes (abtropfung). Most experts in the field still support abtropfung hypothesis nowadays;3,4,12,13 however, we and other investigators have serious reservations about it.15-20

In 8% of our nevi, another important finding was the presence of pilosebaceous units with choristomatous changes. Not a single ectopic pilosebaceous unit found was of normal morpho-logy. These choristomatous pilosebaceous units were exclusively present when they formed part of the structure of subepithelial and compound

nevi. Two were their most significant abnorma-lities: a) nests or thecae of nevus cells, identical to those of intraepithelial nevi, were situated inside the basement membrane of hair follicles of some pilosebaceous units, a feature that Mas-son6 assured could not occur (Figure 14); and b) numerous goblet cells forming true mucinous cysts were immersed amongst pilar keratinocytes of a frankly abnormal pilosebaceous unit. (Figure 15). Because of the unusual location of these mucinous cysts, within the very structure of a malformed hair folicle, and their minute size, it is almost impossible to conceive them as an outcome of conjunctival invaginations. Moreo-ver, the unusual location and tiny size of these mucinous cysts eliminate the possibility that these structures could belong to Henle´s crypts or pseudoglands or Manz´s glands. Therefore, we regard these peculiar structures as of choristo-matous lineage. This remarkable finding has not been reported before. Two other peculiarities, perhaps less important but needed to integrate the tissular components of a hamartoma, were: a) high frequency (46%) of frankly abnormal blood vessels between nevus cells (Figure 12); and b) ample presence (24%) of “intranevic” nerves, which varied from small myelinated nerve trunks interspersed among nevus cells (Figure 13A) to single unmyelinated axons seemingly within type A nevus cells´ cytoplasm (Figure 13B). Masson already noted and illustrated this im-portant phenomenon and interpreted the axons as “myelinated neurites” (Figures 21 and 25 of Masson´s publication6). Could this perplexing finding mean a probable schwannian function of nevus cells? We think it does.

It is pertinent to point out here that in a previous study of 145 epibulbar choristomas,21 we found 100 choristomas of dermolipoma type and 29 of limbic dermoid type. Fifty-eight had pilose-baceous units, although none presented tissular components, such as goblet cells forming cystic mucinous structures, or thecae of nevus cells

Page 12: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

12

Patología Revista Latinoamericana Volumen 57, Año 2019

https://doi.org/10.24245/patrl.v57id.3118

alike to intraepithelial nevi, as our conjunctival nevi did. However, the most important contribu-tion of that investigation,21 for our current study, was: pilosebaceous units can indeed represent a distinctive component of epibulbar choristomas.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study demonstrated that there are significant clinicopathologic differences between conjunctival and cutaneous nevi, no-twithstanding that they usually share 2 or 3 nevic cells types and one or two histologic growth patterns. The fundamental differences were: hi-ghly different clinical incidence; abundance of hamartomatous epithelial cysts in conjunctival nevi, a third of them pigmented by dendritic me-lanocytes and/or nevus cells; different prevalence of nevus cells types A, B, C; distinct occurrence of organoid and neuroid growth patterns; highly frequent association of type A nevus cells with Masson´s laminated nevus cells and melanoge-nesis, yielding an organoid growth pattern which is more prevalent than in cutaneous nevi; often hamartomatous vascular and neural structures in conjunctival nevi; and rare ectopic intraepithelial nevus-like thecae and minute mucinous cysts within choristomatous pilosebaceous units. We conclude with a proposal: to recognize Masson´s laminated cells as a fourth type of subepithelial nevus cell.

The findings of our investigation are in keeping with the hypothesis which states that it is highly probable that both cutaneous and conjunctival nevus cells may have a common and direct histo-genesis in the neural crests,15-20 and not as a result of “dropping off”, maturation and senescence of epidermal dendritic melanocytes, as most experts persist maintaining.3,4,12,13

Dedication

The authors wish to dedicate this work to the memory of late Professor Alfredo Gómez Leal

M.D. (1922-2018), undisputed pioneer and pillar of Ophthalmopathology of our country. Master of countless generations of Mexican and Latin American ophthalmologists, as well as of numerous ophthalmopathologists. All anatomo-pathological material included in this work was originally studied and diagnosed in his own La-boratory, as well as meticulously preserved in his unequaled organized files. Friendship, decency, knowledge, professionalism, dedication, order, discipline and perseverance, were just a few of his multiple virtues. Nevertheless, he was the Professor above all. ¡Descanse en paz querido Maestro Gómez Leal!

REFERENCES

1. Thiagalingam S, et al. Juvenile conjunctival nevus: clinicopa-thologic analysis of 33 cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2008;32:399-406. DOI: 10.1097/PAS.0b013e31815143f3

2. De la O-Pérez S. Nevos intra y subepiteliales de la conjun-tiva. Estudio clinicopatológico e intentos para determinar su histogénesis. Tesis de Licenciatura de Médico Cirujano. Director: Rodríguez-Martínez HA. Escuela de Medicina, ITESM, Monterrey, NL, 2013

3. McKee PH, et al. Melanocytic nevus. In: Pathology of the skin with clinical correlations. 3rd ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier Mosby, 2005;1250-1259.

4. Elder DE, et al. Melanocytic tumors of the skin. AFIP Atlas of Tumor Pathology, Series 4. Washington DC: American Registry of Pathology and Armed Forces Institute of Pa-thology, 2010;15-82; 135-162.

5. Masson P. Les naevi pigmentaires, tumeurs nerveuses. Ann d´anat path 1926; 3:417-453; 657-696.

6. Masson P. My conception of cellular nevi. Cancer 1951;4:9-38. https://doi.org/10.1002/1097-0142(195101)4:1<9::AID-CNCR2820040104>3.0.CO;2-0

7. Mackie RM, et al. The number and distribution of benign pigmented moles (melanocytic naevi) in a healthy Bri-tish population. Br J Dermatol 1985;113:167-174. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2133.1985.tb02060.x

8. Kabukcuoglu S, et al. Conjunctival melanocytic nevi of childhood. J Cutan Pathol 1999;26:248-252. DOI: 10.1111/j.1600-0560.1999.tb01838.x

9. Rhodes AR, et al. A histologic comparizon of congenital and acquired nevomelanocytic nevi. Arch Dermatol 1985;121:1266-1273.

10. Everett MA. Histopathology of congenital pigmen-ted nevi. Am J Dermatopathol 1989;11:11-12. DOI: 10.1097/00000372-198902000-00002

Page 13: Hamartomatous and choristomatous structures in 726 ...El tamaño de los nevos varió de 2-15 mm (± 5 mm). El 91% de los nevos fueron planos y 9% nodulares. La evolución promedio

13

Rodríguez-Martínez HA y col. Hamartomatous and choristomatous structuresw w w . r e v i s t a p a t o l o g i a . c o m

Patología Revista Latinoamericana

11. Rosai J. Eye and ocular adnexa, Chapter 30. In: Rosai and Ackerman´s Surgical Pathology, 10th ed. New York: Mosby Elsevier, 2004; 2484-2485.

12. Unna PG. Naevi und Naevocarcinome. Berl Klin Wochens-chr 1893;30:6-14.

13. Unna PG. Histopathology of diseases of the skin. New York: Macmillan, 1896;1129-1144.

14. Aso M, et al. Expression of Schwann cell charac-teristics in pigmented nevus. Immunohistochemi-cal study using monoclonal antibody to Schwann cell associated antigen. Cancer 1988;62:938-943. DOI: 10.1002/1097-0142(19880901)62:5<938::aid-cn-cr2820620515>3.0.co;2-2

15. Worret WI, et al. Which direction do nevus cells move? Ab-tropfung reexamined. Am J Dermatopathol 1998;20:135-139. DOI: 10.1097/00000372-199804000-00005

16. Gontier E, et al. The “Abtropfung Phenomenon” Revisited: Dermal Nevus Cells from Congenital Nevi Cannot Activate

Matrix Metalloproteinase 2 (MMP-2). Pigment Cell Res 2003;16:366-373.

17. Grichnik JM, et al. How, and from which cell sources, do nevi really develop? Experimental Dermatology 2014;23:310-313. https://doi.org/10.1111/exd.12363

18. Rodríguez-Martínez HA, et al: Migración de melanocitos dendríticos epidérmicos y colonización de un carcinoma mamario infiltrante. Patología Rev Latinoam 2011;49:43-52.

19. Rodríguez-Martínez HA, et al. Histopatogenia de las células névicas intradérmicas. Abtropfung versus Hochsteigerung. Patología. Rev Latinoam 2012;50:206-213.

20. Rodríguez-Martínez HA, et al. Proliferation, migration and colonization of dendritic melanocytes in 8 conjunctival pig-mented squamous cell carcinomas. Patología Rev Latinoam 2016;54:137-149.

21. Alarcón-Henao T, et al. Coristomas epibulbares. Característi-cas clinicopatológicas. Rev Mex Oftalmol 2004;78:182-187.