GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry...

77
GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe Radio Station Manager NIST Time & Frequency Division

Transcript of GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry...

Page 1: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

GPS Time Backup for Power Industry

John LoweRadio Station ManagerNIST Time & FrequencyDivision

Page 2: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWV Ft. Collins, CO.

Page 3: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWVH Kauai, HA.

Page 4: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWV/WWVHProvided Syntonization

Frequency Calibration

• Standard Carrier Frequencies • 2.5, 5, 10, 15, 20 & 25 MHz • @10 kW radiated power on 5, 10, and 15 MHz• @2.5 kW radiated on 2.5, 20 and 25 MHz

Page 5: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWV/WWVH Reception

Transmit

Ground/surface

E

FMultiple-hop1FL

1FH

2FL1EL

Receive

Page 6: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWV/WWVH Reception

Transmit

Ground/surface

E

FMultiple-hop1FL

1FH

2FL1EL

Receive

Frequency stability 1 x 10-9

Time Synchronization 1mS

Page 7: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWVBProvided Syntonization

Frequency Calibration

• Standard Carrier Frequency • 60 KHz• @70 kW radiated power (upgraded in 99’)

Page 8: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

WWVB

Page 9: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Electron Content Diurnal Maps

Page 10: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Sunset Greenbelt, MD Sunset Boulder, CO

SunriseBoulder, CO

Time (UTC)

Sunset Greenbelt, MD

Sunrise Boulder, CO Sunrise

Greenbelt, MD

Sunset Boulder, CO

12

00

Sunrise Greenbelt, MD 0

60

0

00

00

18

00

12

00

06

00

00

00

June

3

June

4

June

5

50 µsec

WWVB in terms of WWV Controlling

Oscillator June 3,4, & 5 Slope +1µsec/24 hrs. (1800-1800 UT)WWVB 10 10 x 10N pts above WWV

Page 11: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Frequency stability 1 x 10-11

Time Synchronization 100 uS (?)1 x 10-12 With averaging

Page 12: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Power Grid Application Timing Needs

Application Need

General Purpose < ±100 ms

Time-Stamping SCADA and Operational Data Logs < ±1 ms

Substation Monitoring e.g. phasor measurement units (PMUs)(IRIG-B Replacement Applications with a local PTP grandmaster )

< ±1 μs

Extended distance applications(fault detection, transient suppression)

< ±1 μs

Page 13: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Power Grid Application Timing Needs

Application Need

General Purpose < ±100 ms

Time-Stamping SCADA and Operational Data Logs < ±1 ms

Substation Monitoring e.g. phasor measurement units (PMUs)(IRIG-B Replacement Applications with a local PTP grandmaster )

< ±1 μs

Extended distance applications(fault detection, transient suppression)

< ±1 μs

What GPS gives you!

Page 14: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Proposed SolutionTo Backup GPS

Page 15: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Proposed Solution

Internet Connected“Radio Common View”

Radio KNITKnowledgeable Networked

Integrated Time

To Backup GPS

Page 16: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Proposed Solution

Internet Connected“Radio Common View”

Radio KNITKnowledgeable Networked

Integrated Time

To Backup GPS

Page 17: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,
Page 18: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,
Page 19: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Proposed Solution

Page 20: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Pinch Hitting for GPSRadio KNIT

Knowledgeable Networked Integrated Time

Backing up GPS “time” by knitting together:-NIST radio station signals-Common View algorithms-Smart Internet connectivity

Page 21: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

Local clock

Page 22: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

Page 23: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

KNITting

Page 24: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

KNITting

Page 25: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

Page 26: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

Page 27: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

Page 28: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

Page 29: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

New Type Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

Page 30: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

AddBetterClock

New Type Receiver

Page 31: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Atomic clock InternetConnection

AnAtomicClock

New Type Receiver

Page 32: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Monitoring Station

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Atomic clock InternetConnection

AnAtomicClock

Page 33: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Monitoring Station

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Atomic clock InternetConnection

Page 34: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

Page 35: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

MonitorStation

MonitorStation

MonitorStation

MonitorStation

MonitorStation

MonitorStation

Page 36: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

Page 37: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

Good Clock

Wants to beA Good ClockWithout GPS

Page 38: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

WWVB

WWVH

WWV

CHU

Page 39: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

WWVB

Page 40: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

WWVB

Page 41: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

WWVB

GPS

Page 42: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

WWVB InternetConnection

GPS

Page 43: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Monitoring Station

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Atomic clock InternetConnection

Page 44: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Monitoring Station

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Atomic clock InternetConnection

PostsPathDelay

Page 45: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

Page 46: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

Page 47: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

ComparesTo Field

Path Delay

Page 48: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

ComparesTo Field

Path Delay=- ε

Page 49: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

WWVB ε

Page 50: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

ComparesTo Field

Path Delay

Page 51: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

ComparesTo Field

Path Delay

Page 52: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

ComparesTo Field

Path Delay

_ =Corrects

Local ClockCommon View ε

Page 53: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Field Receiver

GPSAntenna

NISTRadio Station

Antenna

Local clock InternetConnection

ReadsMonitor’s

PathDelay

ComparesTo Field

Path Delay

_ =Corrects

Local ClockCommon View ε

Maintains Synch

Page 54: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Monitoring Station ClockWe want a clock that can hold <1 µs timing accuracy for >7 days…

A synchrophasor is defined as the magnitude and angle of a cosine signal as referenced to an absolute point in time.

Page 55: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,
Page 56: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FieldReceiver

MonitorStation

How Far?

Page 57: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

10 100Distance of WWVB Receiver relative to Reference [Miles]

10.0

1.0

0.1

RM

S D

iffe

renti

al T

imin

g E

rro

r (U

nm

od

eled

) [u

s]Differential WWVB Error (over 24 hrs) as a function of Distance

from Reference Receiver (Maryland)

Page 58: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

How Far?North/SouthEast/West

Page 59: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Joint Proposal

Page 61: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Other thingsNIST is working on…

Page 62: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,
Page 63: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

GPSAll in View

Page 64: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

GPSAll in View

Page 65: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

NISTDisciplinedOscillator

Page 66: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

NISTDisciplinedOscillator

Page 67: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Frequency stability 5 x 10-14

Time Synchronization 10 nS

NISTDisciplinedOscillator

Page 68: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

FMASFrequency Measure& Analysis Service

TMASTime Measure& Analysis Service

SIMSistema Interamericano de Metrologia(SIM). This time scale, known as the SIM timescale, or SIMT, was developed to complementthe official world time scale,

Coordinated Universal Time

Frequency stability 5 x 10-14

Time Synchronization 10 nS

NISTDisciplinedOscillator

Page 69: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

AlsoPrecision Time Protocol

Page 70: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Setup

Page 71: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Setup

Precision Time Protocol

Page 72: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Average Time Offset

13.6 us

Specification forLTE 1.5 us

Ideally: < 1 us

Calibratethe Client

Page 73: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Specification forLTE 1.5 us

Ideally: < 1 us

Calibratethe Client

300 nS RMS

Average Time Offset

13.6 us

Page 74: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Chip-scale Atomic Clocks

Page 75: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Chip-scale Atomic Clocks

1 mm

Page 76: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

Passively Pumped Design:

Actively Pumped Prototype:

MEMS Beam-Clock Design:

Monitoring Station Clock<1 µs timing error over a week and 1×10-12 fundamental accuracy

NIST-on-a-Chip

Page 77: GPS Time Backup for Power Industry - NASPI · 22/03/2017  · GPS Time Backup for Power Industry John Lowe. Radio Station Manager. NIST Time & Frequency. Division. WWV Ft. Collins,

The End