gpcb.gujarat.gov.in · Vill : Anjesar, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara He asked how many workers were...

55

Transcript of gpcb.gujarat.gov.in · Vill : Anjesar, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara He asked how many workers were...

ANNEXURE – B (ENGLISH)

As per the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its Notification No. S. O. 1533 dated 14/09/2006 and subsequent amendment S.O. 3067 (E) dated 1st December, 2009, Public Hearing is conducted on 07/03/2012 at 11.00 Hrs. for the project covered under Category ‘B’ M/s T.J. Agro Fertilizers Pvt. Limited for expansion of existing plant by addition of new products NPK Granulated Mixed Fertilizers, Single Super Phosphate Powder, Single Super Phosphate Granulated and Flurosilisic Acid (by product) at Survey No. 41, 42, Vill: Mahapura, Tundav Rania Road, Ta. Savli, Dist. Vadodara, which is covered under Category ‘B’ of above referred notification. Shri Ashok Mehta, Additional Collector & Representative of District Magistrate, Vadodara supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings. Shri R.B. Trivedi, Regional Officer, GPCB and representative of Member Secretary, GPCB – a panel member of public hearing committee; welcomed all present to the Public Hearing. He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local dailies. He added that other modes of publicity like auto-rickshaw with public address system and news strip in local channel were also adopted for wider coverage. He announced that as per the provisions of the Notification, only locally affected persons will be allowed to represent in the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake may give their representation in writing which would be included in the proceedings. Regional Officer, GPCB further informed the forum that three written representations had been received prior to the Public Hearing. The first from Shri Mahesh Pandya, Paryavaran Mitra, Ahmedabad, the second from Shri Pravin Sheth, Senior Citizen, Ankleshwar and the third from Shri Jitendra Patel, Bird View of Industries, Ankleshwar. All the representations and the replies to the same would be included in the proceedings. The representations are enclosed as Annexures C1 to C3 and the replies to the same as Annexures D1 to D3. The Regional Officer, GPCB then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from the Additional District Collector. He invited the Project Proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project. The representative of the Industry gave a power point presentation of the proposed project, Environmental Management System, its impact on the environment along with proposed mitigation measures and socio-economic issues, in the Gujarati language. After the presentation by the project proponent, Regional Officer, GPCB with the due permission of the Additional Collector opened the forum for representations / suggestions / objections from the locally affected people.

The statement showing issues / suggestions / objections / opinion raised by the participants and responded to by the representative of the applicant during the Public

Hearing is as under: Sr. No.

Name & Address

Points represented Reply from the Project Proponent

1 Shri Vitthalbhai Dahyabhai Patel, Vill : Mahapura, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara.

He started by saying that although he had his fields in Mahapura village, he lived in Chhani and was well aware of the pollution caused by fertilizer plants since GSFC caused a lot of pollution near Chhani area. Hence he requested the Company to give commitment to the farmers that pollution will not be caused and no damage will be caused to the fields and crops. He further added that the Company should be ready to compensate the farmer in case his land or crops were damaged due to the air pollution from the unit. On hearing this, he asked the Company to extend the benefit to the smallest farmer also who may require probably only one bag of fertilizer for his entire land.

The representative of the Project Proponent welcomed the suggestion given and gave his commitment that whenever any farmer had a problem with the unit, they could contact the unit directly and immediate measures would be taken to resolve the problem. Moreover, he added that NPK fertilizers would be sold at Rs.40 less than the market cost to the farmers in the area, as per their requirement.

2. Shri Rajeshbhai Ambabhai Patel, Vill : Anjesar, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara

He asked where was the hazardous waste going to be disposed ? He then queried what would happen if it was not used ? Would it be disposed on some land like other Companies do?

The representative of the Project Proponent replied that the hazardous waste generated was used as a filler for Magnesium Sulphate Production. The representative of the Project Proponent replied that their hazardous waste was actually their raw material and so, there was no question of disposing it off somewhere else. They further gave their commitment for the same.

3. Shri Jagdishbhai Punjabhai Patel, Vill : Anjesar, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara

He asked the Company to put up the plant such that there was no damage to their fields.

---

4. Shri Gaurav Patel, Vill : Anjesar, Ta : Savli, Dist : Vadodara.

He stated that The Company has said that Green Belt will be provided. He asked the Company to give a commitment to plant 500-1000 trees

The representative of the Project Proponent replied that they welcomed his suggestion and would certainly involve his inputs while planning the Green

for green belt, which may curb the air & noise pollution.

Belt.

5. Shri Ashwinbhai Kalidabhai Patel, Deputy Sarpanch, Vill : Mahapura, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara

He said that he had heard everybody raise their objections and give their suggestions and had only one thing to say that the Company should give in writing that they would take suitable steps to compensate the damage, if any to the environment due to their industry in an area of 10Kms radius.

----

6. Shri Vitthalbhai Dahyabhai Patel, Vill : Mahapura, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara.

He asked to carry out videography of the surrounding area and fields for documentation so that in the years to come, if the environment would be degraded in any way by the industry, they could be held responsible. He further added that the Company should give preference to the local people for employment and not take high profile people from other parts of the country.

The representative of the Project Proponent replied that since theirs was a fertilizer manufacturing unit, high profile people were not required and hence they would give first preference to the local people only. He added that those interested could leave their names and addresses with the management. He further added that even women were going to be considered for employment and hence any woman who was needy or wanted to augment the household earnings could apply.

7. Shri Rajeshbhai Ambabhai Patel, Vill : Anjesar, Ta: Savli, Dist: Vadodara

He asked how many workers were going to be employed by the Company? He told the Company that they only promise, but seldom take local people. And added that even if locals were taken, they had to work too hard, so they had to leave.

The representative of the Project Proponent replied that 38 personnel were going to be taken. The representative of the Project Proponent reiterated that they would be giving preference to locals.

The following representations were received from the respondents during the Public Hearing – from the Talati Cum Mantri of Raniya Gram Panchayat, Sarpanch of Natwar Nagar Gram Panchayat, Sarpanch of Mokshi Gram Panchayat, Sarpanch of Bhadarwa Gram Panchayat and the Sarpanch of Mahapura Gram Panchayat, which are included as Annexure C4-C8 and the replies to the same have been included as Annexures D4-D8.

1

V[[G[1FZ AL v ! sU]HZFTLf

EFZT ;ZSFZGF JG VG[ 5IF"JZ6 D\+F,I4 GJL lN<CLGF HFC[ZGFDF S|DF\So V[;PVMP!5## TFP!$q)qZ__&

VG[ T[GF 5KLGF ;]WFZF S|DF\S V[;PVMP#_&*s.f TFP_!q!ZqZ__) GF VG];\WFG[ S[8[UZLv cAL[c DF\ VFJZL

,[JFI[, D[P 8LPH[P V[UM" O8L",F.hZ 5|FP l,DL8[0 V[ T[GF ;J[" G\P$!4$Z4 UFDo DCF5]ZF4 8]\0FJ Z6LIF ZM04 TFP

;FJ,L4 HLP J0MNZF BFT[GF CF,GF %,Fg8DF\ V[G5LS[ U|[gI],[8[0 DL1F O8L",F.hZ4 ;L\\U, ;]5Z OM:O[8 5FJ0Z4

;L\U, ;]5Z OM:O[8 U[|gI],[8[0 VG[ O,]ZM;L,L;LS V[;L0GF pt5FNGDF\ JWFZM SZJF DF\U[ K[ S[ H[ p5ZGF

GMl8OLS[XGDF\ S[8[UZL cALc DF\ VFJZL ,[JFI[, K[ T[GL ,MS ;]GFJ6L TFP_*q_#qZ_!Z GF ZMH !!P__ S,FS[

p5ZMST :Y/[ ZFBJFDF\ VFJ[,P

;DU| ,MS ;]GFJ6LGL SFI"JFCL zL VXMS DC[TF4 VlWS S,[S8ZzL VG[ HL<,F D[HL:8=[8zL4 J0MNZFGF 5|lTGLWLGL

N[BZ[B TYF VwI1F56F C[9/ SZJFDF\ VFJ[,P T[VMV[ AWFG[ ,MS ;]GFJ6LDF\ VFJSFZ[,P

zL VFZPALP +LJ[NL4 5|FN[lXS VlWSFZL4 HLP5LP;LPALP4J0MNZF VG[ ;eI ;lRJzL4 U]HZFT 5|N]QF6 lGI\+6 AM0"4

GF\ 5|lTlGlWV[ ,MS ;]GFJ6LDF\ p5l:YT ;F{G[ VFJSFIF"P T[VMV[ .PVF.PV[P GMl8OLS[XG V\TU"T lJlJW

HMUJF.VM VG[ ,MS ;]GFJ6L AFAT[ ;\l1F%TDF\ DFlCTL VF5LP T[D6[ VF ,MS ;]GFJ6LGL ACM/L 5|l;wWL V\U[

U]HZFT 5|N]QF6 lGI\+6 AM0[" SZ[, SFI"JFCLGL DFlCTL VF5L VG[ :YFlGS N{lGS 5+MDF\ VUFp VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,

HFC[ZBAZ lJX[ H6FJ[,P T[DG[ V[ 56 H6FjI]\ S[4 GM8LlOS[XGGL HMUJF. 5|DF6[ :YFlGS V;ZU|:T ,MSM H ,MS

;]GFJ6LDF\ ZH]VFT SZL XSX[ HIFZ[ VgI lCT WZFJTF jIlSTVM ,[lBTDF\ ZH}VFT SZL XSX[ H[GM SFI";}lRDF\

;DFJ[X SZJFDF\ VFJX[P

5|FN[lXS VlWSFZL4 HLP5LP;LPALP4J0MNZF VG[ ;eI ;lRJzL4 U]HZFT 5|N]QF6 lGI\+6 AM0" wJFZF H6FJJFDF\

VFJ[, S[4 ,MS ;]GFJ6L 5C[,F # ,[lBT ZH]VFTM D/[, K[P H[DF\YL V[S ZH]VFT zL DC[XEF. 5\0IF4 5IF"JZ6

lD+4 VDNFJFN4 ALHL zL 5|lJ6EF. X[94 l;GLIZ ;L8LhG VG[ 8[SGMS|[8 V\S,[`JZ4 +LHL ZH]VFT zL

HLT[gN|EF. 58[,4 A0" jI] VMO .g0:8=Lh4 V\S,[`JZ TZOYL D/[, K[P H[GM ;DFJ[X SFI"JFCLDF\ SZJFDF\ VFJX[P H[

VG]S|D[ V[G[1FZ ;Lv! YL ;Lv# TZLS[ VG[ S\5GL wJFZF ,[lBTDF\ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, HJFA 0Lv! YL 0Lv# TZLS[

lA0F6 SZ[, K[P

tIFZAFN VlWS HL<,F D[HL:8=[8zLGL 5ZJFGULYL ,MS ;]GFJ6LGM 5|FZ\E SZ[,P T[VMV[ 5|MH[S8 5|5MGg8zLG[

T[DGL ;}lRT 5lZIMHGF lJX[G] 5|[hg8[XG ZH] SZJF DF8[ H6FJ[,P

pnMU wJFZF U]HZFTL EFQFFDF\ VM0LIM lJhI]V, 5|[hg8[XG SZJFDF\ VFJ[, H[DF\ 5IF"JZ6GL jIJ:YF5G 5wWlT4

T[GL V;ZM VG[ ;]lRT lGI\+6M TYF p5FIMG[ VFJZL ,[T] 5|[hg8[XG SZJFDF\ VFjI]P

5|MH[S8 5|5MGg8 wJFZF SZJFDF\ VFJ[, 5|[hg8[XG 5]6" YIF AFN 5|FN[lXS VlWSFZL4 U]HZFT 5|N]QF6 lGI\+6 AM0"

wJFZF VlWS HL<,F D[HL:8=[8zLGL 5ZJFGULYL :YFlGS V;ZU|:T ,MSMGL ZH]VFTMq;]RGMqJF\WFVM DF8[ D\R B]<,M

D]S[,P

2

,MS ;]GFJ6L NZdIFG CFHZ ,MSM wJFZF 5]KJFDF\ VFJ[, 5|xGMq;]RGMqJF\WFVMq VlE5|FI T[DH ZH] SZJFDF VFJ[, ZH}VFTM T[DH VZHNFZGF 5|lTlGlW wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, HJFA GLR[ D]HA K[[P S|D 5|xG 5]KGFZG]\ GFDq

;ZGFD] ZH]VFT SZ[, D]NNF S\5GL wJFZF V5FI[, 5|tI]TZ

! zL lJ9,EF. 0FCIFEF. 58[,4 UFDo DCF5]ZF4 TFP;FJ,L4 HLP J0MNZF

T[D6[ SCI] S[4 T[VM KF6L UFDDF\ ZC[ K[ 5Z\T] T[DG]\ B[TZ DCF5]ZF UFDDF\ VFJ[, K[4 T[VM KF6L UFDDF\ ZC[ K[ T[YL T[VM BFTZ AGFJTL S\5GLVM wJFZF YTF 5|N]QF6 AFAT[ DFlCTUFZ K[P H[DF\ GSFC wJFZF KF6L lJ:TFZDF\ B]A H 5|DF6DF\ 5|N]QF6 O[,F. ZCI] K[P

H[YL ;NZ S\5GL wJFZF B[0]TMG[ T[DGF B[TZG[ T[DH 5FSG[ SM.56 5|SFZG]\ G]SXFG G YFI T[ AFATGL BF+L VF5JF lJG\TL SZLP

T[D6[ JW]DF\ pD[I]" S[4 S\5GL wJFZF CJF 5|N]QF6G[ SFZ6[ B[0]TMGF B[TZG[ S[ 5FSG[ SM. G]SXFG YFI TM T[GF DF8[ J/TZ VF5JF DF8[ T{IFZ ZC[J] HM.V[P

;]GFJ6L NZdIFG T[D6[ SCI] S[4

S\5GLV[ GFGF B[0]TG[ 56 T[GL H~ZLIFT 5|DF6[ BFTZGL V[S A[UGL H~Z CMI TM 56 VF5JL HM.V[P

pnMUGF 5|lTGLWL wJFZF ;]RGMG[ VFJSFZJFDF\ VFjIF T[DH T[GF wJFZF AFC[\WZL VF5JFDF VFJL S[ HIFZ[ SM.56 B[0]]TG[ S\5GL wJFZF 5|̀ G pEM YX[ TM T[VM S\5GLDF\ HFT[ H D],FSFT SZL XSX[ VG[ T[GF pS[, DF8[ S\5GL wJFZF T]Z\T 5U,F\ EZJFDF\ VFJX[P

JW]DF\ T[D6[ pD[I]" S[ VF lJ:TFZGF B[0]TMG[ V[G5LS[ BFTZ AHFZ EFJ SZTF\ $_ ~5LIF VMKF EFJYL B[0]TMGL H~ZLIFT D]HA BFTZGL OF/J6L SZJFDF\ VFJX[P

Z zL ZFH[XEF. V\AFEF. 58[,4 UFDoV\H[;Z4 TFP;FJ,L4 HLPJ0MNZF

T[D6[ SCI] S[4 HMBDL SRZFGM lGSF, SIF\ SZJFGF KMm

T[D6[ OZLYL 5]KI] HM T[DGM p5IMU

G YFI TM X]\ YX[m ALHL S\5GLVMGL H[D SM.56 HuIF 5Z O[\SJFGF TM GYL G[m

pnMUGF 5|lTGLWL wJFZF H6FJJFDF\ VFjI] S[4 pt5gG YGFZ HMBDL SRZM D[uG[XLID ;<O[8G] pt5FNG SZJFG\] K[ T[DF lO,Z TZLS[ p5IMU SZJFDF\ VFJX[P

pnMUGF 5|lTGLWLV[ JW]DF\ H6FjI] S[4 pt5gG YGFZ HMBDL SRZM BZ[BZ T[G] V[S ZMvD8LZLI, H K[ H[YL T[G[ SM.56 HuIFV[ O[SJFGM 5|`G pt5gG YTM GYL VG[ T[GF DF8[ T[G[ BF+L VF5LP

3

S|D 5|xG 5]KGFZG]\ GFDq ;ZGFD]

ZH]VFT SZ[, D]NNF S\5GL wJFZF V5FI[, 5|tI]TZ

# zL HUNLXEF. 5\]HFEF. 58[,4 UFDoV\H[;Z4 TFP;FJ,L4 HLPJ0MNZF

T[D6[ H6FjI]] S[ S\5GLV[ T[GM %,Fg8 V[JL ZLT[ pEM SZJM HM.V[ S[ H[YL T[VMGF B[TZMG[ SM. G]SXFG G YFIP

vvv

$ zL UF{ZJ 58[,4 UFDoV\H[;Z4 TFP;FJ,L4 HLPJ0MNZF

T[D6[ SCI]] S[4 S\5GL wJFZF U|LG A[<8 pEM SZJF DF8[ H6FJJFDF\ VFjI] K[P

T[D6[ S\5GLG[ VF;5F;GF lJ:TFZDF\ 5__v!___ J'1FM pUF0JF DF8[ BF+L VF5JF DF8[ H6FjI]\ H[YL CJF VG[ VJFH 5|N]QF6G] lGI\+6 SZL XSFIP

pnMUGF 5|lTGLWL wJFZF YI[, ;]RGG[ VFJSFZJFDF\ VFjI] VG[ SCI] S[ U|LG A[<8G\] %,FGL\U SZTL JBT[ T[VM[GF ;]RGMGM ;DFJ[X SZLX]\P

5 zL V`JLGEF. SF,LNF;EF. 58[,4 0[P;Z5\R4 UFDoDCF5]ZF4 TFP;FJ,L4 HLPJ0MNZF

T[D6[ SCI]] S[4 AWF ,MSM wJFZF p9FJJFDF\ VFJ[,F D]NNFVM T[DH ;]RGMG[ T[D6[ ;F\E?IF VG[ T[VMV[ DF+ V[SDF+ ,[lBT AFC[\WZL DF8[ SCI] S[4 VFH]AFH]GF !_ lSPDLPGF lJ:TFZDF\ HM SM. G]SXFG YX[ TM S\5GL wJFZF T[VMG[ J/TZ VF5J]\ HM.V[P

vvv

& zL lJ9,EF. 0FCIFEF. 58[,4 UFDo DCF5]ZF4 TFP;FJ,L4 HLP J0MNZF

T[D6[ VFH]AFH]GF lJ:TFZGF B[TZMGL lJ0LIM U|FOL SZJF H6FjI]\ H[YL VFJGFZ ;DIDF\ ;NZ S\5GL wJFZF 5IF"JZ6DF\ SM.56 5|SFZG] G]SXFG YFI TM T[GF DF8[ S\5GLGL HJFANFZL GSSL SZL XSFIP

T[D6[ JW]DF\ pD[I]" S[4 S\5GLV[ :YFGLS DF6;MG[ ZMHUFZL DF8[ 5|FnFgI VF5J] HM.V[ VG[ ACFZGF V[8,[ S[ N[XGF VgI EFUGF prR lX1FLT ,MSMG[ G ,[JF HM.V[P

pnMUGF 5|lTGLWL wJFZF H6FJJFDF\ VFjI] S[4 T[VM V[S BFTZ AGFJTL S\5GL K[ T[DF prR lX1FLT ,MSMGL H~Z ZC[TL GYL H[YL :YFGLS ,MSMG[ 5|YD 5|FnFgI VF5JFDF\ VFJX[P

T[D6[ pD[I]" S[4 H[VMG[ Z; K[ T[VMV[ T[DGF GFD VG[ ;ZGFDF S\5GLGF ;\RF,G D\0/G[ VF5L N[JFP

T[D6[ JW]DF\ pD[I]" S[4 ZMHUFZL DF8[

:+LVMG[ 56 ,[JFDF\ VFJX[ H[YL

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C1

Save environment:care for next generation Environment public hearing of T J Agro Fertilizers pvt ltd Dist. Vadodara , GUJARAT

Draft REIA Report reviewed by Pravinbhai Sheth, Ankleshwar.Cell 09377958840

Date: 01/03/12 Page 01/03 From : Pravinbhai Sheth, senior citizen , technocrate and environmentalist A-8, Kalindi Appartment, Chikuwadi,Ankleshwar–393001. Gujarat. Cell No. : 09377958840

Sub. : Environment public hearing of m/s T J Agro Fertilizers pvt ltd On 07/03/12 at, Dist. Vadodra Respected Mr. Hardik Shah Saheb I will try to remain present myself at schedule date, in case if I cannot report, please read my suggestions and minute the same with response from Project Proponent. Now, there is a need to harmonize industrial growth with the environmental concerns and developments options under consideration should be sustainable, daft REIA studies can often prevent future liabilities or expensive alterations in project design, if presented in an effective way. Hope project proponent shall give due consideration to my suggestions and try to implement to the possible extent

SUGGESTIONS TO BE IMPLEMENTED IF FOUND ACCEPTABLE AND ECONOMICAL 01 Pl encourage timber free construction. 02 Pl use solar system for garden lanterns, pumping water to overhead tanks 03 Pl celebrate world environment day each year to create awarness on environment protection.

04 Pl try offer your products ( fertilizers) at subsidized rates as a part of CSR activity to needy farmers r residing in study area so that farmers can be encouraged to carry out farming in economical Way. Pl do not hesitate to contact me if you need any further in puts I, personally is of the opinion that we should encourage agro based specially fertilizer based industry in Gujarat We welcome the projects having due mitigation measures for environment protection

Pravinbhai sheth File :eph tj agro savli/eco care

Jai Jai Garvi Gujarat Jai Hind

To, Member Secretary GPCB, Gandhinagar, Gujarat E mail [email protected]

copy copy R.O. GPCB, Dist collector Vadodara Vadodara [email protected] [email protected]

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C2
Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C3

LETTER FROM BIRD VIEW OF INDUSTRIES

DATE: 06/03/2012

To,

Regional Manager,

Gujarat Pollution Control Board,

Vadodara division,

Vadodara.

Subject: In reference of Public Hearing of T. J. Agro Fertilizers.

Respected Sir,

With respect that Public Hearing for expansion of project will organize on dated:

7th March of M/s. T. J. Agro Fertilizer Pvt. Ltd., Tal.: Savli, Dist.: Vadodara. We have

some questions regarding that.

1. In plant, how many employees will be local to get employment for existing as

well as after expansion?

2. It is surprise that in your unit their shall be no any kind of effluent or solid waste

generation including cleaning activity. Please specify whether any management

proposed for cleaning effluent.

3. Please give us copy of any shaw cause notice issue by GPCB in the past.

4. What will be the company’s policy to give more than 80% local employment?

5. Please provide us copy of company’s commitment and its compliances submitted

during past Public Hearing for existing plant?

We hope that company will progress towards beneficial of local villagers.

Regards,

Jitendra Patel

Editor

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C4

Letter from Rania Gram Panchayat

Date: 22/02/2012 To,

Chairman sir,

Public Hearing Committee

Vadodara.

Subject: Establishment of fertilizer factory of M/s. T. J. Agro fertilizers.

Reference: Your advertisements of Public Hearing on dated: 7th March.

Respected Sir,

Due to your upcoming fertilizer factory employment will be generated, but

simultaneously farmers will get cheaper fertilizer compare to costly fertilizer available in

the market which will beneficial to farmers.

If you fill any negative impact due to above fertilizer factory, we hereby request you to

eliminate the same towards better generation of employment & grant then permission at

the earliest.

Signature

Talati cum Mantri

Village: Rania

Taluka: Savli

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C5

Letter from Natvarnagar Gram Panchayat

Date: 27/02/2012 To,

Chairman sir,

Public Hearing Committee

Vadodara.

Subject: Establishment of fertilizer factory of M/s. T. J. Agro fertilizers.

Reference: Your advertisements of Public Hearing on dated: 7th March.

Respected Sir,

Due to your upcoming fertilizer factory employment will be generated, but

simultaneously farmers will get cheaper fertilizer compare to costly fertilizer available in

the market which will beneficial to farmers.

If you fill any negative impact due to above fertilizer factory, we hereby request you to

eliminate the same towards better generation of employment & grant then permission at

the earliest.

Signature

K. C. Gohil

Sarpanch

Natvarnagar Gram Panchayat

Tal.: Savli, Dist.: Vadodara

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C6

Letter from Mokshi Gram Panchayat

Date: 25/02/2012 To,

Chairman sir,

Public Hearing Committee

Vadodara.

Subject: Establishment of fertilizer factory of M/s. T. J. Agro fertilizers.

Reference: Your advertisements of Public Hearing on dated: 7th March.

Respected Sir,

Due to your upcoming fertilizer factory employment will be generated, but

simultaneously farmers will get cheaper fertilizer compare to costly fertilizer available in

the market which will beneficial to farmers.

If you fill any negative impact due to above fertilizer factory, we hereby request you to

eliminate the same towards better generation of employment & grant then permission at

the earliest.

Signature

Sarpanch

Mokshi Gram Panchayat

Tal.: Savli

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C7

Letter from Bhadarva Gram Panchayat

Date: 21/02/2012 To,

Chairman sir,

Public Hearing Committee

Vadodara.

Subject: Establishment of fertilizer factory of M/s. T. J. Agro fertilizers.

Reference: Your advertisements of Public Hearing on dated: 7th March.

Respected Sir,

Due to your upcoming fertilizer factory employment will be generated, but

simultaneously farmers will get cheaper fertilizer compare to costly fertilizer available in

the market which will beneficial to farmers.

If you fill any negative impact due to above fertilizer factory, we hereby request you to

eliminate the same towards better generation of employment & grant then permission at

the earliest.

Signature

Sarpanch

Bhadarva Gram Panchayat

Tal.: Savli

Administrator
Text Box
ANNEXURE-C8

Letter from Mahapura Gram Panchayat

Date: 18/02/2012 To,

Chairman sir,

Public Hearing Committee

Vadodara.

Subject: Establishment of fertilizer factory of M/s. T. J. Agro fertilizers.

Reference: Your advertisements of Public Hearing on dated: 7th March.

Respected Sir,

Due to your upcoming fertilizer factory employment will be generated, but

simultaneously farmers will get cheaper fertilizer compare to costly fertilizer available in

the market which will beneficial to farmers.

If you fill any negative impact due to above fertilizer factory, we hereby request you to

eliminate the same towards better generation of employment & grant then permission at

the earliest.

Signature

R. D. Gohil

Sarpanch

Mahapura Gram Panchayat

Taluka: Savli

M/s. T. J. Agro Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd. R.S.No.41, 42, At.Mahapura, Tundav Savli Road, Ta: Savli, Dist.: Vadodara

[1]

=

COMPLIANCE STATUS OF THE EXISTING UNIT WITH RESPECT TO VARIOUS CONDITIONS GIVEN IN CC&A OF GPCB.

NAME OF UNIT: T.J.AGRO FERTILIZERS PVT. LTD. (VADODARA)

SR. NO. DESCRIPTION OF CONDITION COMLIANCE

STATUS CORRECTIVE &

PREVENTATIVE ACTION TAKEN

1.0 Consent Order No. 31288 date of issue : 16/12/2008 valid up to 03/09/2013

Complied We have already requested to correct validity of our authorization as per CC&A Condition No.6.3

2.0 Water & Air Act Consent Validity : 3/09/2013 Hazardous Waste Act Consent Validity : 28/02/2012 Production Capacity:

Sr. No. Product Quantity (MT/MONTH) 1. Magnesium Sulphate 600 MT/month 2. Filler 60 MT/month

Complied

----

3.0 CONDITION UNDER WATER ACT

3.1 There shall be no disposal of industrial effluent from the manufacturing process and other ancillary industrial operations.

Complied ----

3.2 The quantity of sewage effluent from the factory shall not exceed 1000 lit/day. Complied ---- 3.3 TRADE EFFLUENT

3.3.1 Sewage shall be disposed of through septic tank/soak pit system Complied ----

4.0 CONDITIONS UNDER THE AIR ACT 4.1 There shall be no generation of flue gas emission from the manufacturing

activities and other ancillary industrial operation as you have submitted undertaking dtd. 09/07/2008 for no applicability of Air Act-.

Complied ----

M/s. T. J. Agro Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd. R.S.No.41, 42, At.Mahapura, Tundav Savli Road, Ta: Savli, Dist.: Vadodara

[2]

4.2 There shall be no generation of process emission from the manufacturing activities and other ancillary industrial operation. You have submitted undertaking dtd. 09/07/2008 for no applicability of Air Act.

Complied.

--

4.3 The concentration of the following parameters in the ambient air within the premises of the industry shall not exceed the limits specified hereunder.

Parameter Permissible Limit,g/m3 SPM 200 SOx 80 NOx 80

RSPM 100

Complied.

--

4.4 The industry shall take adequate measures for control of noise levels from its own sources within the premises so as to maintain ambient air quality standards in respect of noise to less than 75dB(a) during day time and 70dB(A) during night time. Daytime is reckoned I between 6a.m. and 10 p.m. and nighttime is reckoned between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m.

Complied --

5.

GENERAL CONDITIONS

5.1 Any change in personnel, equipment or working conditions as mentioned in the consents form/order should immediately be intimated to this Board.

Complied If any change than we will intimate to the board.

5.2 Applicant shall also comply with the general condition given in Annexure-I. Complied. We will try our best to comply it.

6. AUTHORISATION FOR THE MANAGEMENT & HANDLING OF HAZARDOUS WASTES Form-2 [See rule 3 (c) & 5 (5)] 6.1 Number of authorization: 31288, Date of issue : 16/12/2008

Complied

M/s. T. J. Agro Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd. R.S.No.41, 42, At.Mahapura, Tundav Savli Road, Ta: Savli, Dist.: Vadodara

[3]

6.2 M/s. T. J. Agro Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd. is hereby granted and authorization to operate facility for following hazardous wastes on the premises situated S. No. 41, 42, Mahapura, Tal – Savli, Dist – Vadodara.

Sr. No. Waste Quantity Schedule

process No. Facility

1. Process Residue

60 MT/Year

7.2 Collection, storage, transportation, disposal at TSDF

2. Used Oil 150 Lit/Year

5.1 Collection, storage, transportation disposal by selling to registered reprocess.

3. Discarded Container

60000 Nos./Year

33.3 Collection, storage, Decontamination

Complied

• We have already requested to GPCB to consider our process residue as filler (By product).

• Used oil is totally reused as a lubricant within premises.

• Discarded bag & containers is

reused for filler packing.

6.3 The authorization is granted to operate a facility for collection, storage, within the factory premises, transportation and ultimate disposal of Hazardous wastes at nearest authorized TSDF

Complied We will strictly comply all the conditions of H.W. authorization.

6.4 The authorization shall be in force for a period up to 03/09/2013. 6.5 The authorization is subject to the conditions stated below and such other

conditions as may be specified in the rules from time under the Environment (Protection) Act-1986.

6.6 TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF AUTHORIZATION 6.6.1 The applicant shall comply with the provisions of the Environment (Protection)

Act- 1986 and the rules made there under. Complied

--

6.6.2 The authorization shall be produced for inspection at the request of and officer authorized by the Gujarat Pollution Control Board.

Complied

--

6.6.3 The persons authorized shall not rent, lend, sell transfer of otherwise transport the hazardous wastes without obtaining prior permission of the Gujarat Pollution Control Board.

Complied

--

M/s. T. J. Agro Fertilizers Pvt. Ltd. R.S.No.41, 42, At.Mahapura, Tundav Savli Road, Ta: Savli, Dist.: Vadodara

[4]

6.6.4 Any unauthorized change in personnel, equipment or working conditions as mentioned in the authorization order by the persons authorized shall constitute a breach of this authorization.

Complied

--

6.6.5

It is the duty of the authorized person to take prior permission of the Gujarat Pollution Control Board to close down the facility.

Complied

--

6.6.6

An application for the renewal of an authorization shall be made as laid down in rule 5(6)(ii)

Shall be Complied

--

6.6.7

Industry shall have to display the relevant information with regard to hazardous waste as indicated in the Court’s order in W.P. No.657 of 1995 dated 14th October 2003.

Complied

--

6.6.8

Industry shall have to display on line data outside the main factory gate with regard to and nature of hazardous chemicals being handled in the plant, including waste water and air emission and solid hazardous waste generated within the plant, including waste water and air emission and solid hazardous waste generated within the factory premises.

Complied

--

6.6.9

Industry shall have to manage waste oil, discarded containers etc., process waste as per Amended Rules-2003 and shall apply Authorization for all applicable waste as per Amended Rules-2003 with 15 days.

Complied

--

DATE OF  SAMPLING 

Ambiant air sampleing location 

Project Site A1 

BAHIDHARA(A2) 

ANJESAR(A3) 

MAHAPURA(A4) 

RANIYA(A5) 

03/12/2010           

07/12/2010            

11/12/2010            

14/12/2010           

18/12/2010           

21/12/2010           

25/12/2010           

28/12/2010            

04/01/2011            

08/01/2011            

11/01/2011            

13/01/2011            

18/01/2011           

21/01/2011           

25/01/2011           

28/01/2011           

02/02/2011           

05/02/2011           

07/02/2011           

10/02/2011           

14/02/2011           

17/02/2011           

21/02/2011           

24/02/2011           

 

 

 

 

 

sampleing 

location  

Type of sample and its collection date 

Ground 

Water 

Surface 

water 

Noise 

monitoring   

Soil 

PROJECT SITE  08/01/2011 ‐‐ 08/01/2011  08/01/2011

BAHIDHARA  11/01/2011 11/01/2011 11/01/2011  11/01/2011

ANJESAR  

11/01/2011 11/01/2011 11/01/2011  11/01/2011

MAHAPURA  

11/01/2011 11/01/2011 11/01/2011  11/01/2011

RANIYA  

11/01/2011 11/01/2011 11/01/2011  11/01/2011

JALAMPURA  08/01/2011 ‐‐ ‐‐ ‐‐

MAHI RIVER  ‐‐  08/01/2011 ‐‐ ‐‐