Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

77
Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

description

 

Transcript of Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

Page 1: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

Governance for Equitable Development Project:Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

Page 2: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

Governance for Equitable Development Project:Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

Page 3: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

G$"+ 6'>-1%(# $/+ @%%( .*'6->%6 A"#$ #$% )"(/(>"/: /++"+#/(>% ') #$% ,-*'.%/( 5("'( /(6 #$%

578;Q G$% 9"%A+ %S.*%++%6 #$%*%"( >/( "( (' A/B @% #/I%( #' *%):%># #$% '))">"/: '."("'( ') #$%

,-*'.%/( 5("'( /(6 578;Q

Page 4: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

书书书

!"#$%"#&

!"#$ #$% &'"(# %))'*#+ ') #$% ,-*'.%/( 0'11"++"'( 2,034 5("#%6 7/#"'(+ 8%9%:'.1%(# ;*'<*/11% 2578;3 /(6

#$% 0$"(%+% ='9%*(1%(#4 #$% ='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# ;*'&%># 2=,83 A/+ '))">"/::B :/-(>$%6 "(

0$"(/ "( C-:B DEEF

!

G$% .*'&%># /"1+ #' >'(#*"@-#% #' #$% 0$"(%+% ='9%*(1%(#H+ %))'*#+ "( .*'1'#"(< *-:% ')

:/A /(6 >"9": +'>"%#B 6%9%:'.1%(# #$*'-<$ #$% "1.*'9%1%(# ') :/A

"

1/I"(< 1%>$/("+1+4 &-6">"/: "(+#"#-#"'(/:

*%)'*1 /(6 #$% )/>":"#/#"'( ') #$% 0JK >'(+#*->#"'(

!

G$% .*'&%># "+ +' )/* #$% :/*<%+# >'1.*%$%(+"9% '(% /1'(<

#$% "(#%*(/#"'(/: >''.%*/#"'( .*'&%>#+ ') "#+ I"(6 "( 0$"(/

!

K9%* #$% ./+# )"9% B%/*+4 *%1/*I/@:% />$"%9%1%(#+ $/9% @%%( 1/6% "( /:: #$*%% >'1.'(%(#+ ') #$% .*'&%>#4

"(>:-6"(< 0'1.'(%(# L

"

!""#$$ %& '($%)"# )$ )*"+#,$#- "( >''.%*/#"'( A"#$ #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# 2J;034

M 0'1.'(%(# N

"

./# 0,1 ,*- 2&0)"3

"

4,5)*6 $3$%#4 )$ )42+&7#- A"#$ #$% O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"++"'( 2OL03 ')

#$% 7/#"'(/: ;%'.:% H + 0'(<*%++ 27;03 /(6 0'1.'(%(# 0

"

8)7)0 9&")#%3 :*7&07#4#*% )$ ;+&,-#*#- A"#$ #$%

M P"("+#*B ') 0"9": L))/"*+ 2P'0L3Q

R( />>'*6/(>% A"#$ 0$"(/ H + (/#"'(/: >'(+#*->#"'( '@&%>#"9%+4 =,8 +-..'*#%6 />#"9"#"%+4 %"#$%* 6'1%+#"> '*

"(#%*(/#"'(/: '(%+4 $/9% %(>'-*/<%6 -+%)-: *%+%/*>$ "( *%:%9/(# /*%/+ /(6 )/>":"#/#%6 #$% .*'1-:</#"'( ') :/A+

/(6 .':">"%+ "( 0$"(/4 1/I"(< / .'+"#"9% >'(#*"@-#"'( #' #$% .*'1'#"(< *-:% ') :/A /(6 /( '.%( +'>"%#B

!

G$% *%.'*#+ /*% >'1.:%#%6 @B 0$"(%+% /(6 "(#%*(/#"'(/: %S.%*#+4 .*%+%(# /( '9%*/:: /(/:B+"+ /(6 *%9"%A ') .*'&%>#

/>$"%9%1%(#+ /(6 "(6">/#% )-#-*% 6"*%>#"'(+ )'* *%)'*1

!

G$%*% /*% )'-* *%.'*#+

!

G$% )"*+# "+ /( '9%*/:: /++%++1%(#

/</"(+# #$% '@&%>#"9%:B 9%*")"/@:% "(6">/#'*+ 2KTR+3 ') #$% .*'&%>#

!

G$% '#$%* #$*%% )'>-+ '( ./*#+ ') #$% #$*%%

>'1.'(%(#+ ') #$% =,8 .*'&%>#4 (/1%:B '(&)*)+, $--)*)$.*/

!

,+% 0+1).2 +.& 34$ &$5$,"60$.3 "- *)5), 7"*)$3/

!

R A"+$ #' #/I% #$"+ '..'*#-("#B #' %S#%(6 1B +"(>%*% #$/(I+ '( @%$/:) ') #$% P"("+#*B ') 0'11%*>% #' #$% ,04

578;4 #$% OL0 ') 7;04 #$% J;0 /(6 P'0L )'* #$%"* %))">"%(# >''.%*/#"'( /(6 >'(#*"@-#"'( #' #$% +->>%++)-:

/(6 )*-"#)-: "1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') #$% .*'&%>#

!

L(6 1B #$/(I+ /:+' <' #' %S.%*#+4 +>$':/*+4 0JK+ /(6 1%6"/ )'*

#$%"* <*%/# /##%(#"'( /(6 /++"+#/(>%

!

U- C"/($-/

L++"+#/(# P"("+#%*

P"("+#*B ') 0'11%*>% ') #$% ;%'.:%H+ V%.-@:"> ') 0$"(/

P/B DEWD

!

Page 5: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

!"#$%"#&

G$% ,-*'.%/( 5("'( A/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 A"#$ / :%</: #*%/#B /(6 "+ )'-(6%6 '( #$% .*"(>".:%

') #$% *-:% ') :/A

!

G$"+ >'(>%.# >%(#*%+ '( / +%# ') *-:%+ <'9%*("(< /:: +'>"%#BH+ .*'>%++%+

/(6 "(#%*/>#"'(+ /(6 @%"(< /@'9% /:: +'>"%#BH+ "(+#"#-#"'(+ /(6 '*</("+/#"'(+

!

G$% *-:%+ '*

:/A+ +%# #$% 1'*/: /(6 %#$">/: +#/(6/*6+ @B A$">$ #$% @%$/9"'-* ') 1%1@%*+ ') +'>"%#B

/(6 '*</("+/#"'(+ /*% &-6<%6

!

X'* #$% *-:% ') :/A /(6 #$%*%@B >"9": +'>"%#B #' ):'-*"+$4 "#

*%?-"*%+ #$% >"#"Y%(+ ') / >'-(#*B #' *%+.%># /(6 #*-+# :%</: .*'>%++%+4 /(6 #$% :/A #' @%

/..:"%6 "( / >'(+"+#%(# A/B #' /::

!

G$"+ <"9%+ .%'.:% / )%%:"(< ') "(>:-+"9%(%++ /(6

'.#"1"+1 /@'-# #$%"* )-#-*%

!

G$% ,-*'.%/( 5("'( H + =KT,V7L70, XKV ,Z5RGLNO,

8,T,OK;P,7G 2=,83 .*'&%>#4 "1.:%1%(#%6 @B #$% 5("#%6 7/#"'(+ 8%9%:'.1%(# ;*'<*/11% 2578;3 )*'1 DEEF

#' DEWD 4 $/+ /++"+#%6 0$"(/ #' @%(%)"# )*'1 I('A:%6<% ') ,-*'.% H+ 6%9%:'.%6 :%</: +B+#%1 /(6 >"9": +'>"%#B

#$*'-<$ #%>$(">/: %S>$/(<%4 *%+%/*>$ /(6 I('A:%6<% +$/*"(<

!

L+ .%'.:% H + "(>'1%+ <*'A /(6 1/#%*"/: :"9"(< +#/(6/*6+ *"+%4 #$%"* %S.%>#/#"'(+ /@'-# #$% ?-/:"#B ') :")%4

./*#">"./#"'( "( >"9": +'>"%#B4 .*'#%>#"'( ') .*'.%*#B /(6 "(6"9"6-/: *"<$#+ "(>*%/+%

!

P%%#"(< #$%+% %S.%>#/#"'(+

)'* / @%##%* :")% "( / */."6:B -*@/("+"(< +'>"%#B A"#$ / +#":: +"<(")">/(# *-*/: .'.-:/#"'( "+ '(% ') #$% I%B

>$/::%(<%+ )/>"(< 0$"(/ #'6/B

!

G$"+ "+ A$%*% #$% =,8 .*'&%># $/+ +-..'*#%6 0$"(/ "( 1'9"(< #' / 1'*%

%?-"#/@:%4 "(>:-+"9% /(6 9"@*/(# >"9": +'>"%#B4 @/+%6 '( #$% *-:% ') :/A

!

G$% .*'&%># $/+ A'*I%6 A"#$ #$*%% I%B 0$"(%+% /<%(>"%+4 #$% 7/#"'(/: ;%'.:%+H 0'(<*%++4 #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H

+ 0'-*# /(6 #$% P"("+#*B ') 0"9": L))/"*+ '( #'.">+ */(<"(< )*'1 :/A 6*/)#"(< /(6 >'-*# %))">"%(>B #' *%<"+#*/#"'(

') >"9": +'>"%#B '*</("+/#"'(+

!

G$% .*'&%># $/+ .*'6->%6 *%1/*I/@:% *%+-:#+ '9%* )"9% B%/*+4 :%/6"(< #' /(

"1.*'9%6 %(9"*'(1%(# )'* >"9": +'>"%#B #' ):'-*"+$ "( 0$"(/4 "(>*%/+%6 >"#"Y%( ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A 1/I"(<4

*%6->%6 @/**"%*+ #' +%%I"(< &-+#">%4 "(>*%/+%6 #*/(+./*%(>B /(6 %))">"%(>B ') +%:%>#%6 >'-*#+ /(6 .*'<*%++ "( #$%

>'(+"+#%(>B ') >'-*# 6%>"+"'(+

!

G$"+ >'1.%(6"-1 ') ./.%*+ +-11/*"+%+ #$% />$"%9%1%(#+ ') #$% =,8 .*'&%># "( #$% A"6%* >'(#%S# ') 0$"(/H+

*%>%(# *%)'*1+ /(6 :''I+ #' #'.">+ '( 0$"(/H+ *%)'*1 /<%(6/ A$%*% #$%*% "+ +>'.% )'* )-#-*% "(#%*(/#"'(/: >'

"

'.%*/#"'(

!

G$% ./.%*+ .*%+%(#%6 >'(#*"@-#% #' #$% 6%@/#% '( 0$"(/ H+ *%)'*14 A$":% "(6">/#"(< #$% @%(%)"#+

"(#%*(/#"'(/: >'

"

'.%*/#"'( >/( @*"(< #' #$% *%)'*1 .*'>%++

!

P/*I-+ ,6%*%*

,5 L1@/++/6'* #' 0$"(/ /(6 P'(<':"/

"

Page 6: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

!"#$%"#&

R( *%>%(# 6%>/6%+4 0$"(/ $/+ />$"%9%6 *%1/*I/@:% <*'A#$ /(6 6%9%:'.1%(# A$">$ $/+

@*'-<$# /@'-# %?-/::B 6*/1/#"> *%6->#"'(+ "( .'9%*#B /(6 "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( .%'.:% H+

:"9"(< +#/(6/*6+

!

7%9%*#$%:%++4 6"+./*"#"%+ >'(#"(-% #' /@'-(6 /(6 #$%*% "+ 1->$ A'*I

#$/# *%1/"(+ #' @% 6'(% ") A% /*% #' %(+-*% #$/# 0$"(/H+ .''*%+# /*% /@:% #' ./*#">"./#%

1'*% )-::B "(4 /(6 @%(%)"# )*'1 +'>"/: /(6 %>'('1"> .*'<*%++

!

!"#$"( #$"+ >'(#%S#4 #$%

6%9%:'.1%(# ') "(+#"#-#"'(+ /(6 .':">B )*/1%A'*I+ A":: @% %++%(#"/: "( *%/>$"(< '-# #'

9-:(%*/@:% "(6"9"6-/:+ /(6 <*'-.+ /(6 %($/(>"(< '..'*#-("#"%+ #' "1.*'9% #$%"* :"9%+

!

578; *%</*6+ <'9%*(/(>% /(6 #$% *-:% ') :/A /+ /( %++%(#"/: ./*# ') "#+ >''.%*/#"'( A"#$ 0$"(/

!

G'<%#$%*4 '-*

A'*I "(>:-6%+ +-..'*# #' #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') #*/(+./*%(# /(6 />>'-(#/@:% :%</: .*'>%++%+ #$/# /*% %))%>#"9%

/(6 %?-"#/@:%4 /(6 #$/# +#*%(<#$%( #$% *-:% ') :/A

!

R# /:+' "(>:-6%+ @*'/6%("(< #$% ./*#">"./#"'( ') >"#"Y%(+4

#$*'-<$ / *'@-+# >"9": +'>"%#B4 "( +$/."(< 6%>"+"'(+ #$/# /))%># #$%"* :"9%+

!

R( #-*(4 #$"+ ./*#">"./#"'( "+ "(>*%/+"(<

.-@:"> #*-+# "( 0$"(/H+ :/A+ /(6 "(+#"#-#"'(+ /(6 *%"()'*>"(< #$% *-:% ') :/A

!

J#*%(<#$%("(< #$% *-:% ') :/A /(6 .*'1'#"(< >"9": +'>"%#B ./*#">"./#"'( "( :%</: +.$%*%+ $/9% @%%( &'"(#

'@&%>#"9%+ .-*+-%6 @B #$% ='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# 2 =,8 3 .*'&%># "( 0$"(/

!

G$*'-<$ /

./*#(%*+$". @%#A%%( 578; /(6 #$% ,-*'.%/( 5("'( 2,534 "(>:-6"(< )"(/(>"/: +-..'*# )*'1 #$% ,54 #$% =,8

.*'&%># "+ #$% )"*+# "(#%*(/#"'(/: >''.%*/#"'( "( 0$"(/ #' @*"(< #'<%#$%* #$% O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"++"'( ')

#$% 7/#"'(/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++4 #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# /(6 #$% P"("+#*B ') 0"9": L))/"*+

!

X"9% B%/*+ ') >:'+% >''.%*/#"'( $/9% B"%:6%6 "1.*%++"9% *%+-:#+4 /+ "(6">/#%6 @B *%+%/*>$ /(6 /++%++1%(#+

>'(6->#%6

!

O/A+ /(6 .':">"%+ /"1%6 /# "(>*%/+"(< />>%++ #' &-+#">%4 %($/(>"(< &-6">"/: #*/(+./*%(>B /(6

'.%((%++4 %S./(6"(< />>%++ #' >'-*#+ /(6 #$% *%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1 $/9% @%%( "(#*'6->%6

!

JB+#%1+ *%:/#%6 #' #$% 6*/)#"(< ') :/A+ /(6 #$%"* /..:">/#"'( $/9% @%%( #/I%( )'*A/*6 "( /( -(.*%>%6%(#%6

1/((%*4 A"#$ /( "(>*%/+"(< )'>-+ @%"(< .:/>%6 '( >'(+"+#%(>B /(6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( /# 6"))%*%(# +#/<%+ ')

:/A

"

1/I"(<

!

;':">B @*%/I#$*'-<$+ $/9% /:+' @%%( 1/6% #$*'-<$ #$% "(#*'6->#"'( ') .':">"%+ #$/# +-..'*# 0JK

6%9%:'.1%(#

!

U%#4 ('#A"#$+#/(6"(< #$% +"<(")">/(>% ') #$%+% />$"%9%1%(#+4 / (-1@%* ') >$/::%(<%+ *%1/"( "( #%*1+ ') #$%

+>/:% /(6 %S#%(# A"#$ A$">$ .':">"%+ /*% "1.:%1%(#%6

!

O''I"(< /$%/6 #$%*%)'*%4 "# "+ >:%/* #$/# )-*#$%* %))'*#+

#

Page 7: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

A":: @% *%?-"*%6 #' />$"%9% %))%>#"9% .':">B "1.:%1%(#/#"'( /# @'#$ >%(#*/: /(6 :'>/: :%9%:+ /(6 #' )-*#$%*

+#*%(<#$%( <'9%*(/(>% )'* %?-"#/@:% 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

G$"+ +%*"%+ ') )'-* *%+%/*>$ .-@:">/#"'(+ %(</<%+ %S.%*#+4 .*/>#"#"'(%*+ /(6 .':">B

"

1/I%*+ #' >*"#">/::B /(/:B+%

#$% +->>%++%+ /(6 :%++'(+ :%/*(# )*'1 #$% >''.%*/#"'(

!

R# >'(#/"(+ >'(+#*->#"9% .*'.'+/:+ )'* )-#-*% /..*'/>$%+

#' )-*#$%* +#*%(<#$%("(< #$% *-:% ') :/A /(6 #$% 9/:-% ') >"9": +'>"%#B 6%9%:'.1%(# "( #$"+ .*'>%++ "( 0$"(/

!

G$% #*-% 9/:-% ') #$% =,8 .*'&%># :"%+ "( @-":6"(< #$"+ +':"6 )'-(6/#"'( '( / ./#$ #' <''6 <'9%*(/(>%

!

0$*"+#'.$% N/$-%#

578; 0$"(/ 0'-(#*B 8"*%>#'*

$

Page 8: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

! "

>'(#%(#+

W R

!

R7GVK850GRK7 L78 J5PPLVU KX XR78R7=J

D

RR

!

V,TR,! KX KT,VLOO ;VKC,0G L0[R,T,P,7GJ\

KT,VLOO KTR+

DW

RRR

!

V,TR,! KX ;VKC,0G V,J5OGJ NU 0KP;K7,7G\

K;,VLGRK7LO KTR+

]^ RT

!

;VKC,0G 0K7GVRN5GRK7J

]_ T

!

0K70O5JRK7J

]` L77,a

Page 9: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators
Page 10: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

89:;<=>=?; !9< ;@ABC>DE; F;:;E9GH;=C I8;FJ

G<9K;?CL <;:B;M 9! <;NAECN >=F >?OB;:;H;=CN

=+3+,)$ E)*43$.73$).

!

#### P>=8 Q).R).

"

W

!

G$% ='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# 2 =,8 3 ;*'&%># #''I /+ "#+ <'/: +-..'*#"(< #$% .*'>%++ ')

<'9%*(/(>% "( 0$"(/ #'A/*6+ 1'*% #*/(+./*%(>B /(6 />>'-(#/@":"#B A$":% +#*%(<#$%("(< #$% %1%*<"(<

"(+#"#-#"'(+ ') #$% (/#"'(/: :%<"+:/#-*%4 #$% &-6">"/*B /(6 >"9": +'>"%#B

!

G$% ;*'&%># /"1%6 #' >'(#*"@-#% #' #$%

<'9%*(1%(#H+ %))'*#+ @B .*'1'#"(< >"9": +'>"%#B 6%9%:'.1%(# /(6 #$% *-:% ') :/A #$*'-<$ "(+#"#-#"'(/: *%)'*14

6%1'>*/#"> :/A

"

1/I"(<4 ./*#">"./#"'(4 >'11-(">/#"'(+ /(6 .":'#"(<

!

G$% ;*'&%># 6'('*+ A%*% #$% ,-*'.%/(

0'11"++"'( /(6 5("#%6 7/#"'(+ 8%9%:'.1%(# ;*'<*/1

!

G$% ;*'&%># A/+ >'1.'+%6 ') #$*%% >'1.'(%(#+\

!0'1.'(%(# L 2L>>%++ #' C-+#">%3 A/+ 6%+"<(%6 #' .*'1'#% .':">B 6%9%:'.1%(#4 %($/(>% #$% >/./>"#"%+ ')

#$% >'-*# +B+#%1 #' 6%:"9%* )/"* /(6 #*/(+./*%(# &-+#">%4 /(6 "(>*%/+% #$% #*/(+./*%(>B "( >'-*# 6%>"+"'(

"

1/I"(<

!

R1.:%1%(#"(< L<%(>B\ J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# 2J;03Q

!0'1.'(%(# N 2 O/A /(6 ;':">B P/I"(< 3 A/+ 6%+"<(%6 #' "1.*'9% #$% :/A /(6 .':">B

"

1/I"(< +B+#%14

#$*'-<$ "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y"(< .-@:"> %(</<%1%(# /(6 ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(< /(6 @*'/6%("(< :/A

$/*1'("Y/#"'(

!

R1.:%1%(#"(< L<%(>B\ 7/#"'(/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++ 27;03Q

!0'1.'(%(# 0 20"9": J'>"%#B R(9':9%1%(#3 A/+ 6%+"<(%6 #' "1.*'9% #$% .':">B /(6 :%</: %(9"*'(1%(# )'* >"9":

+'>"%#B '*</("Y/#"'(+ 20JK+34 #' %($/(>% .%*>%.#"'(+ ') 0JK *':%+ "( 6%9%:'.1%(#4 /(6 #' @-":6 <'9%*(1%(#

/(6 0JK >/./>"#"%+ *%:/#%6 #' 0JK 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

R1.:%1%(#"(< L<%(>B\ P"("+#*B ') 0"9": L))/"*+ 2PK0L3Q

G$"+ V%.'*# *%9"%A+ #$% *%+-:#+ ') =,8 ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* /:: #$*%% >'1.'(%(#+ "( *%:/#"'( #' ;*'&%>#

"(6">/#'*+ /(6 "6%(#")"%+ ./*#">-:/* /+.%>#+ A$%*% ;*'&%>#

"

*%:/#%6 />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' *%)'*1+

!

B

!

B=C<9FA?CB9= >=F NAHH><P 9! !B=FB=8N

D

!

R(#*'6->#"'(

!

G$% ;*'&%>#H+ 6%+"<( /(6 "(#%(6%6 *%+-:#+ A%*% +%# '-# "( / 1/#*"S4 #$% ;*'&%># O'<)*/1%4 A$">$

A/+ 1'+# *%>%(#:B *%9"+%6 "( :/#% DEEb /(6 /<*%%6 "( %/*:B DEWE

!

G$"+ )'*1/# +%# '-# #$% "(#%*9%(#"'( :'<">4 #$%

'@&%>#"9%:B 9%*")"/@:% "(6">/#'*+ ') />$"%9%1%(# 2KTR+ 34 #$% +'-*>%+ /(6 1%/(+ ') 9%*")">/#"'(4 /+ A%:: /+

!

!

"

=,8 0'(+-:#/(#

=,8 0'(+-:#/(#

Page 11: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

/++-1.#"'(+ /(6 *"+I+

!

G$% O'<)*/1% A/+ )-*#$%* +-@6"9"6%6 "(#' A$/# >/( @% >/::%6

"

K9%*/:: KTR+

#

)'* #$%

K9%*/:: K@&%>#"9%+ /(6 ;*'&%># ;-*.'+%+4 /(6

"

K.%*/#"'(/: KTR+

#

#' 1%/+-*% #$% %S.%>#%6 *%+-:#+ -(6%* %/>$

') #$% #$*%% >'1.'(%(#+

!

c

!

G$% )'>-+ ') #$"+ V%.'*# "+ #' 9%*")B4 #' #$% %S#%(# )%/+"@:%4 A$%#$%* #$% K9%*/:: KT R+ /(6 #$%

K.%*/#"'(/: KT R+ $/9% @%%( />$"%9%64 -+"(< /9/":/@:% "()'*1/#"'(4 "(>:-6"(< +'-*>%+ /(6 1%/(+ ')

9%*")">/#"'( :"+#%6 "( #$% O'<)*/1%

!

J%>#"'( RR 2 V%9"%A ') K9%*/:: ;*'&%># L>$"%9%1%(#+ 3 +-11/*"Y%+ #$%

>$/(<%+ '9%* #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6 )'* #$% %/>$ ') #$% K9%*/:: KT R+

!

J%>#"'( RRR 2 V%9"%A ') ;*'&%># V%+-:#+ NB

0'1.'(%(#3 .*%+%(#+ #$% 0'(#%S#4 V%+-:#+ /(6 ;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'( )'* %/>$ ') #$% K.%*/#"'(/: KT R+

!

X'*

%/>$ KT R4 /( "(#*'6->#'*B @'S ?-'#%+ #$% KT R /+ "( #$% O'<)*/1%4 /(6 +$'A+ #$% KT R J#/#-+ 2 />$"%9%64

+-@+#/(#"/::B />$"%9%6 '* ./*#"/::B />$"%9%6 3 Q J%>#"'( RT 2 ;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(+ 3 $"<$:"<$#+ >*'++

"

>-##"(<

=,8 >'(#*"@-#"'(+

!

J%>#"'( T 2 0'(>:-+"'(+ 3 '))%*+ +'1% '@+%*9/#"'(+ '( #$% ;*'&%># /(6 )-#-*%

>''.%*/#"'(4 /+ A%:: /+ @*"%) >'(>:-+"'(+

!

^

!

L((%S W 2J#/#-+ ') ;*'&%># R(6">/#'*+3 >'1@"(%+ "( '(% #/@:% /:: ') #$% +#/#-+ @'S%+ "( #$% #%S#4 )'* %/+B

*%)%*%(>%

!

L((%S D >'(#/"(+ #$% '-#+"6% *%)%*%(>%+ )'* #$% *%.'*#4 .*"1/*":B )'* #$% K9%*/:: KTR+

!

L((%S c

*%>'*6+ #$% +'-*>%+ ') ;*'&%>#

"

*%:/#%6 "()'*1/#"'( /9/":/@:% #' #$% >'(+-:#/(# #%/1

!

]

!

J-11/*B ') X"(6"(<+

!

L:: )"9% ') #$% K9%*/:: KTR+ A%*% )'-(6 #' $/9% @%%( />$"%9%6 @/+%6 '( #$% +'-*>%+

') 9%*")">/#"'( .*'9"6%6 "( #$% O'<)*/1%

!

X'* #$% ;*'&%># >'1.'(%(#+4 /:: ') #$% K.%*/#"'(/: KTR+ A%*%

>'(+"6%*%6 #' $/9% @%%( />$"%9%6\ )-::B />$"%9%6 2Wb 34 +-@+#/(#"/::B />$"%9%6 2W 3 /(6 ./*#"/::B />$"%9%6 2` 3Q

X'* 0'1.'(%(# L4 +%9%( KTR+ A%*% />$"%9%64 '(% +-@+#/(#"/::B />$"%9%6 /(6 #A' ./*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

X'*

0'1.'(%(# N4 )'-* KTR+ A%*% />$"%9%64 /(6 )"9% KTR+ A%*% ./*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

X'* 0'1.'(%(# 04 %"<$# KTR+

A%*% />$"%9%6 /(6 '(% ./*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

_

!

!$%*% KTR+ A%*% ('# )-::B />$"%9%64 "# "+ ('# (%>%++/*":B 6-% #' "++-%+ "( ;*'&%># "1.:%1%(#/#"'(4 #$'-<$ #$%

>'1"(< ;*'&%># %9/:-/#"'( 1/B +$%6 1'*% :"<$# '( #$"+ ?-%+#"'(

!

R( <%(%*/:4 "# +%%1+ %?-/::B :"I%:B #$/#

"(>'1.:%#% KTR+ /*% / *%):%>#"'( ') >$/(<%+ /)#%* ;*'&%># 6%+"<( "( #$% *%:/#"9% .*"'*"#B /(6 -*<%(>B ') +.%>")">

.':">B 1%/+-*%+ "( #$% >'-(#%*./*# /<%(>BH+ *%)'*1 /<%(6/

!

BB

!

<;:B;M 9! 9:;<>EE G<9K;?C >?OB;:;H;=CNL 9:;<>EE 9:B7

F

!

K9%*/:: K@&%>#"9%\ /( '.%( /(6 %?-"#/@:% +'>"%#B @/+%6 '( #$% *-:% ') :/A

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/6 /+ "#+ '9%*/::

'@&%>#"9% +-..'*# #' #$% 0$"(%+% ='9%*(1%(# "( "#+ %))'*#+ #' 6%9%:'. /( '.%( /(6 %?-"#/@:% +'>"%#B @/+%6 '(

#$% *-:% ') :/A

!

G$% />$"%9%1%(# ') #$"+ '9%*/:: '@&%>#"9% A/+ /++%++%6 @B *%)%*%(>% #' 6%9%:'.1%(#+ +"(>%

;*'&%># '*"<"( -(6%* )'-* +.%>")"> KTR+\ 2L3 />>%++ #' &-+#">%d 2N3 :/A /(6 .':">B

"

1/I"(< +B+#%1d 203 >"9": +'>"%#B

./*#">"./#"'( "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(<d /(6 283 *-:% ') :/A "( !'*:6 ='9%*(/(>% R(6">/#'*+

!

"

Page 12: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

I>J >??;NN C9 KANCB?;L B06#"5$0$.37 ). G",)*)$7S E+%7 +.& <$2(,+3)".7

##

KTR\ R1.*'9%6 .':">"%+4 :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+ /"1%6 /# :%/6"(< #' 1'*% '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% )'* 1'*%

.%'.:% "( +'>"%#BQ

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6Q ;':">"%+4 :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+ /"1%6 /# />>%++ #' &-+#">% $/9% @%%( "1.*'9%6 "( #$%

;*'&%># .%*"'6Q L*%/+ ') "1.*'9%1%(# "(>:-6% /+.%>#+ ') &-6">"/: '.%((%++d />>%++ #' >'-*#+d /(6 *%)'*1 ')

#$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1Q V%)'*1+ A"#$ "(6"*%># "1./># "(>:-6%\ @%##%* >'-*# )-(6"(<d <-"6"(< >/+%+d

+%(#%(>"(< <-"6%:"(%+d /(6 1%6"/#"'( *%)'*1+Q

`

!

J%9%*/: 6"1%(+"'(+ ') #$% >-**%(# /(6 .*%9"'-+ &-6">"/: *%)'*1 .*'<*/1+ +"(>% DEEF

!

$/9% @%%( /"1%64

6"*%>#:B '* "(6"*%>#:B4 /# 1'*% '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% )'* 1'*% .%'.:% "( +'>"%#B

!

V%)'*1+ "( .':">"%+4 :/A+ /(6

*%<-:/#"'(+ #$/# >'-:6 "(6"*%>#:B :%/6 #' 1'*% '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% "(>:-6%\ @%##%* )-(6"(< )'* >'-*#+d /(#"

"

>'**-.#"'( 1%/+-*%+d <-"6"(< >/+%+d +%(#%(>"(< *%)'*1d /(6 1%6"/#"'( *%)'*1+

!

V%)'*1+ 1'*% 6"*%>#:B /"1%6 /#

1'*% '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% "(>:-6%\ %S./(+"'( ') #*/(+./*%(>B 2 &-6">"/: '.%((%++3d %/+"%* />>%++ #' >'-*#+d

*%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1d /(6 %S./(+"'( ') :%</: /"6

!

ITJ <$-"#07 B.&)#$*3,/ >--$*3).2 96$. >**$77 3" K(73)*$

b

!

N%##%* X-(6"(< X'* 0'-*#+

!

X*'1 / 1/>*' .%*+.%>#"9%4 #$% *%)'*1 /(6 "1.*'9%1%(# ') #$% +B+#%1 ')

<-/*/(#%%6 )-(6"(< )'* #$% &-6">"/: +B+#%14 /(6 ./*#">-:/*:B #$% "(>*%/+%6 .*'9"+"'( ') >%(#*/: )-(6"(< )'*

.''*%* /*%/+4 A":: "1.*'9% >"#"Y%(H+ />>%++ #' &-+#">%

!

R( #$% ./+#4 #$% )-(6"(< )'* :'>/: >'-*# %S.%(6"#-*%+ >/1%

.*"1/*":B )*'1 #$% :'>/: <'9%*(1%(# /# #$% +/1% :%9%: /(6 >'-*# >/+% $/(6:"(< )%%+d )-(6"(< )'* +#/)) A/+ ')#%(

('# )-::B <-/*/(#%%64 %+.%>"/::B )'* @/+"> >'-*#+ /(6 "(#%*1%6"/#% >'-*#+ "( >%(#*/: /(6 A%+#%*(

.*'9"(>%+

!

J#/*#"(< "( DEEb 4 0$"(/ :/-(>$%6 / *%)'*1 "( #$% <-/*/(#%% ') >'-*# )-(6"(<

!

0%(#*/: /(6 .*'9"(>"/:

:%9%: <'9%*(1%(#+4 #$*'-<$ /( "(>*%/+% "( #*/(+)%* ./B1%(#+ /(6 >/."#/: "(9%+#1%(#4 /*% .*'9"6"(< )-(6"(< )'*

/:: #B.%+ ') :'>/: >'-*# %S.%(6"#-*%+

!

X'* #$% @/+"> >'-*#+ "( #$% >%(#*/: /(6 A%+#%*( .*'9"(>%+ /(6 "(#%*1%6"/#%

>'-*#+ "( #$% /*%/+ A"#$ %>'('1"> 6"))">-:#"%+4 #$% .*'.'*#"'( ') )-(6"(< @'*(% @B #$% >%(#*/: /(6 .*'9"(>"/:

<'9%*(1%(#+ /9%*/<%6 /@'9% ]Ee 4 A"#$ #$% $"<$%+# /# bEe

!

G$*'-<$ .*'1'#"(< #$%+% *%)'*1 1%/+-*%+4

#$%*% $/+ @%%( / >'(+"6%*/@:% "(>*%/+% "( )-(6"(< )'* >'-*#+ /:: />*'++ #$% >'-(#*B

$$$

"( #$% )"*+# B%/* ') #$%

*%)'*1+4 DEEb 4 )-(6"(< )'* /:: >'-*#+ A/+ W_e $"<$%* #$/( "( DEE`

!

"

WE

!

L(#"

"

>'**-.#"'( P%/+-*%+

!

V%6->"(< >'**-.#"'( /(6 #$% .%*>%.#"'( ') >'**-.#"'( "( #$% &-6">"/: +B+#%1 "+

/( "1.'*#/(# ./*# ') 1/I"(< #$% +B+#%1 1'*% />>%++"@:% #' /:: .%'.:%4 /# /:: "(>'1% :%9%:+4 )*'1 /:: A/:I+ ')

#

!

"

J;04 !"#$% &#'(

"

)(*$ +(,-$. /012#3( ,-$ 1"( 4(-52(67 8-0$17 9:;;<

"

:;=> ?4 P/*>$ WF 4 DEEb

!

G$"+ ./*/<*/.$ "+ @/+%6 '( #$% I%B('#% +.%%>$ <"9%( @B C-6<% U- O"(<B-4 8"*%>#'*4 C-6">"/: V%)'*1 K))">%4 '(

7'9%1@%* W_ 4 DEWW 4 /# #$% ./(%: '( O/A /(6 8%9%:'.1%(# "( 0$"(/\ K..'*#-("#"%+ /(6 0$/::%(<%+4 /+ ./*# ') #$% !'*:6

N/(IH+ O/A4 C-+#">% /(6 8%9%:'.1%(# !%%I DEWW

!

Page 13: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

:")%

!

G$% J;0 $/+ "++-%6 +%9%*/: 6'>-1%(#+ /"1%6 /# /(#"

"

>'**-.#"'(4 )*'1 #$% *-:%+ '( #$%

"

)"9% .*'$"@"#"'(+

#

#' #$% %+#/@:"+$1%(# ') / +B+#%1 ') +-.%*9"+'*+4

!

#' #$% *%9"+"'(+ ') #$% 0'6% ') 0'(6-># )'* &-6<%+

!

"

;%'.:%

H+ /++%++'*+ '))%* /('#$%* 1%>$/("+1 #$/# "+ ')#%( +-<<%+#%6 /+ /( "($"@"#"'( '( >'**-.#"'(

!

N'#$ <-"6"(<

>/+%+ /(6 +%(#%(>"(< <-"6%:"(%+ /:+' *%6->% '..'*#-("#"%+ )'* >'**-.#"'(

!

G$% >'-*#+ $/9% /:+' "(+#"#-#%6 /(

'(:"(% )'*-1 A$%*% >"#"Y%(+ >/( *%.'*# '( >'**-.# &-6<%+ /(6 1'("#'* #$% .*'<*%++ ') A$"+#:%

"

@:'A"(<

#".+

!

#

WW

!

=-"6"(< 0/+%+

!

$

8-*"(< #$"+ .%*"'64 #$% J;0 $/+ 6%9%:'.%6 /(6 %+#/@:"+$%6 / (%A +B+#%1 ') <-"6"(<

>/+%+

!

G$"+ >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1 6"))%*+ )*'1 #$% +B+#%1 ') .*%>%6%(#+ "( >'11'( :/A >'-(#*"%+4 @-# *%):%>#+

6%9%:'.1%(#+ "( '#$%* >"9": :/A &-*"+6">#"'(+

!

0/+% <-"6/(>% >/( 1/I% -. )'* </.+ "( A*"##%( :/A4 %+#/@:"+$

-(")"%6 +#/(6/*6+ )'* /6&-6">/#"'(4 /(6 *%6->% (%</#"9% "1./>#+ '( &-+#">% >/-+%6 @B 6"))%*%(>%+ "( *-:"(<+ "(

"6%(#">/: '* +"1":/* >/+%+ "++-%6 @B >'-*#+ "( 6"))%*%(# *%<"'(+

!

%

WD

!

J%(#%(>"(< V%)'*1

!

J%(#%(>"(< *%)'*1 $/+ 1-:#".:% /+.%>#+4 "(>:-6"(< @%##%* *%<-:/#"'( ') .-("+$1%(#+4 /

*%:/#"9%:B "(6%.%(6%(# .*'>%6-*% )'* 1%#"(< '-# .-("+$1%(#+4 /(6 6%9%:'."(< +>"%(#")"> /(6 1'*% ?-/(#"#/#"9%

1%/(+ ') .-("+$1%(#4 +-..:%1%(#%6 @B ?-/:"#/#"9% /(/:B+"+

!

&

G$% J;0 "++-%6 J%(#%(>"(< =-"6%:"(%+ "( DEWE

2A"#$ @/+%:"(% +%(#%(>%+ )'* W] ') #$% 1'+# >'11'(:B %(>'-(#%*%6 >*"1%+ 3 #$/# A":: $%:. "1.*'9%

+#/(6/*6"Y%6 +%(#%(>"(<4 %($/(>% '.%((%++ /(6 *%6->% #$%

"

+/1% >*"1% 6"))%*%(# .%(/:#B

#

.$%('1%('(

!

'

Wc

!

G$% "(#*'6->#"'( ') +%(#%(>"(< <-"6%:"(%+ /(6 #$% >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1 >/( >'(#*"@-#% #' @%##%* />>%++ #'

&-+#">% />*'++ #$% >'-(#*B

!

N'#$ *%)'*1+ +%%I #' +#/(6/*6"Y% #$% *%+-:#+ ') >/+%+4 +' #$/# +"1":/*:B +"#-/#%6

./*#"%+ >/( $/9% 1'*% .*%6">#/@:% /(6 *%<-:/*"Y%6 #*%/#1%(# *%</*6:%++ ') #$% >'-*#4 #$% &-6<% '* #$%

:'>/#"'(

!

L# #$% +/1% #"1%4 &-6<%+ $/9% +'1% :"1"#%6 :%%A/B #' 9/*B )*'1 +%(#%(>"(< <-"6%:"(%+ '* <-"6"(<

>/+%+4 +' #$/# *%<-:/*"Y/#"'( (%%6 ('# .*%9%(# )/"*(%++ "( / ./*#">-:/* >/+%

!

W^

!

P%6"/#"'( V%)'*1+

!

P%6"/#"'(4 "( 9/*"'-+ )'*1+4 /(6 /:#%*(/#"9% 6"+.-#% *%+':-#"'( 2L8V3 1%>$/("+1+ >/(

'))%* @%##%* />>%++ #' &-+#">%4 A$%*%4 )'* "(+#/(>%4 #$%+% ('(

"

:"#"</#"'( 1%#$'6+ :'A%* )"(/(>"/: /(6 $-1/( >'+#+

)'* ./*#"%+ "( 6"+.-#%+ /(6 >/( :%/6 #' 1'*% +/#"+)/>#'*B +':-#"'(+ #$/# 6' ('# *%?-"*% /66"#"'(/: %))'*#+ /#

$

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

a- DEEb

!

G$% )"9% .*'$"@"#"'(+ /*%\ .*'$"@"#"'( ') />>%.#"(< 6"((%* "(9"#/#"'( '* <")#+ <"9"(<4 .*'$"@"#"'( ')

-(&-+#")"/@:% >'(#/># A"#$ :/AB%*+4 .*'$"@"#"'( ') "(#%*)%*%(>% "( >/+%+ $/(6:%6 @B '#$%*+4 .*'$"@"#"'( ') 1/:.*/>#">% )'*

.%*+'(/: </"(+ "( />#"9"#"%+ ') /-#$'*"Y%6 %9/:-/#"'( '* /->#"'(4 /(6 .*'$"@"#"'( ') 6"9-:<"(< +%>*%#+ )*'1 >'-*# #*"/:+

!

R( 8%>%1@%* DEWE 4 J;0 "++-%6 #$% P'6%: C-6">"/: N%$/9"'* 0'6% /(6 #$% N/+"> 0'6% ') ;*')%++"'(/: 0'(6-># )'*

C-6<%+4 /(6 *%>-+/: *%<-:/#"'(+ 2#' .*%9%(# "1.*'.%* "():-%(>% )*'1 )/1":B 1%1@%*+ /(6 "(#%*(/: >'-*# .%*+'((%:3Q 0,00

DEWW 4 /# W`c

"

^

!

0,00 DEWW /# W`]

!

G$% >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1 "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L4 V%+-:# W@4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ __

"

FE

!

a- DEEb

!

a- DEEb

!

a- DEWE

!

Page 14: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

%()'*>%1%(#

!

G$% *%"(9"<'*/#"'( ') 1%6"/#"'( *%):%>#+4 "( ./*#4 / +$")# /A/B )*'1 %1.$/+"+ '( /6&-6">/#"'( /(6

.*'>%6-*%4

!

/:#$'-<$ .":'#+ :"I% #$% >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'( "( #$% ;-6'(< 7%A L*%/ 0'-*# .*'9"6% /

+#*'(<%* :%</: /(6 .*/>#">/: "()*/+#*->#-*% )'* 9/*"'-+ #B.%+ ') 1%6"/#"'(

!

"

L >'*% .*"(>".:% ') 1%6"/#"'(4

$'A%9%*4 "+ #$% .*"(>".:% ') 9':-(#/*"(%++

!

R( #$/# :"<$#4 #$% >'%*>"9% '9%*#'(%+ ') #$% .-+$ #' "1.*'9% /(6

+'1%#"1%+ *%?-"*% 1%6"/#"'( "( :"%- ') :"#"</#"'( */"+%+ >'(>%*(+ #$/# #$% @%(%)"#+ )'* />>%++ #' &-+#">% >'-:6 @%

*%6->%6 '* *%9%*+%6

!

#

W]

!

L >:%/* >'((%>#"'( #' '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% "+ %9"6%(# "( #$% DEWE /6'.#"'( ') 0$"(/H+ 4(-52(67 @(%#*1#-3

A*BC >'(+':"6/#"(< 6%>/6%+ ') %S.%*"%(>% A"#$ .%'.:% H+ 1%6"/#"'(

!

0"#"Y%(+ /*% +%:%>#%6 #' +%*9% #$*%%

"

B%/*

f #%*1+ '( .%'.:% H + 1%6"/#"'( >'11"##%%+ /# 9"::/<% >'11"##%% 1%%#"(<+ 2 "( *-*/: /*%/+3 /(6 /# *%+"6%(# H +

1%%#"(<+ ') (%"<$@'*$''6 >'11"##%%+ 2"( -*@/( /*%/+3Q ;%'.:%H+ 1%6"/#"'( >'11"##%%+ /*% %S.%>#%6 #' $/9%

*%.*%+%(#/#"'( ') A'1%(4 /(64 "( 1-:#"%#$("> /*%/+4 %#$("> 1"('*"#"%+

!

G$% 1%6"/#"'( +%*9">%+ /*% )*%% ') >$/*<%

/(6 *%+-:#"(< 1%6"/#"'( /<*%%1%(#+ /*% :%</::B @"(6"(< '( #$% ./*#"%+

!

G$%*% "+ /:+' .*'9"+"'( )'* &-6">"/:

>'()"*1/#"'( ') #$% 1%6"/#"'( /<*%%1%(#4 ") #$% ./*#"%+ @'#$ /<*%% #' *%?-%+# "#4 A$">$ 1/I%+ #$% /<*%%1%(#

6"*%>#:B %()'*>%/@:%

!

W_

!

G$% *%"(9"<'*/#%6 +B+#%1 ') .%'.:%H+ 1%6"/#"'( '))%*+ 1'*% ./*#">"./#"'( "( 6"+.-#% +%##:%1%(# 2@B $/9"(<

>'11-("#B 1%1@%*+ +%*9% /+ 1%6"/#'*+3 /(6 :'A%*+ #$% >'+# ') />>%++ #' &-+#">%4 )'* #$'+% >/+%+ A$%*% #$%

./*#"%+ /<*%% #' +%%I 1%6"/#"'(

!

2G$% :/A /:+' .%*1"#+ >'-*#+ #' /69"+% ./*#"%+ ') #$% '.#"'( ') 1%6"/#"'(

@%)'*% >/+%+ /*% )":%6

!

3 NB .*'9"6"(< / +#*'(< :%</: )'-(6/#"'( )'* #$% *%+-:#"(< 1%6"/#"'( /<*%%1%(#+4 #$%

:/A /:+' >/( /"6 />>%++ #' &-+#">%

!

IUJ <$-"#07 F)#$*3,/ >--$*3).2 96$. >**$77 3" K(73)*$

WF

!

,S./(+"'( ') G*/(+./*%(>B 2 C-6">"/: K.%((%++ 3

!

$

G$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:% H + 0'-*# H + D#E +(F02*1#-37 -3

G0%#H#*2 /5(33(774 "++-%6 "( DEEb 4 *%?-"*%+ #$/# +"S .$/+%+ ') &-6">"/: A'*I 1-+# @% #"1%:B /(6 1/6% .-@:"> '(

/ )-:: +>/:%\ >/+% )":"(<4 >'-*# #*"/:4 %()'*>%1%(#4 $%/*"(<4 6'>-1%(#/#"'( /(6 /61"("+#*/#"'( ') &-6">"/:

/))/"*+

!

%

L>#"9"#"%+ #' .*'1'#% '.%((%++ "( DEWE "(>:-6%6 #$% 0'-*# H+ 6%+"<(/#"'( ') WEE 1'6%: >'-*#+ )'*

%

!

"

#

$

%

O"%@1/( DEWW 4 ('#"(< 2/# W`E 3\

"

G$% *%#-*( #' 1%6"/#"'( *%):%>#+ )*-+#*/#"'( A"#$ +'1% ') #$% .*'@:%1+ ')

/6&-6">/#"'(4 1'+# ('#/@:B #$% >'-*#H+ "(/@":"#B #' %()'*>% 6%>"+"'(+ /(6 #$% .%*>%.#"'( #$/# 1/(B :"#"</(#+ /*% 6"++/#"+)"%6

A"#$ /6&-6">/#%6 >/+%+

!#

L8V "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L4 V%+-:# W64 "( ./*/<*/.$+ F]

"

FF 4 /(6 #$% ;-6'(< ;":'# "( N'S c

!

L>>'*6"(< #' 0,004 #$%*% /*% *%.'*#%6:B 1/(6/#'*B 1%6"/#"'( ?-'#/+ /(6 )"(/(>"/: *%A/*6+ /(6 >/*%%*

/69/(>%1%(#+ )'* &-6<%+ A"#$ $"<$ */#%+ ') 1%6"/#"'(4 A$">$ >'-:6 6%#*/># )*'1 #$% +-@+#/(#"9% )/"*(%++ ') #$% .*'>%++ /(6

-(6%*1"(% #$% :%<"#"1/>B ') #$% >'-*# +B+#%1

!

0,00 DEWW 4 /# W`c 4 ?-'#"(< 0/*: P"(Y(%*4

"

0$"(/H+ G-*( L</"(+# #$% O/A4

#

!/+$"(<#'( 5("9%*+"#B "( J#

!

O'-"+ O%</: J#-6"%+ V%+%/*>$ ;/.%*4 7'

!

WW

"

Ec

"

EW 2DEWW 34 /# cW

"

cF

!

J%% /:+' O"%@1/( DEWW /#

W`E

!

K.%( #*"/: *%)'*1 "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L4 V%+-:# D/4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ `W

"

`]

!

J;04 D#E +(F02*1#-37 -3 G0%#H#*2 /5(33(77 /(6 D('($*2 4$-'#7#-37 -3 1"( 4(-52( 6 7 8-0$17 IE5-70$( 1- 40J2#H

D05($'#7#-3 1"$-0F" @*77 @(%#*4 8%>%1@%* ` 4 DEEb

!

Page 15: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

C-6">"/: K.%((%++

!

0'-*#+ "( +%9%*/: .*'9"(>%+ $/9% +#/#%6 #$/# 6%>"+"'(+ A":: @% .'+#%6 '(:"(%4 /(6 #*"/:+

+#*%/1%6 '9%* #$% "(#%*(%#

!

!

X'* "(+#/(>%4 /# #$% :'>/: :%9%:4 /:: #$*%% :%9%:+ ') >'-*#+ "( J$//(S" ;*'9"(>% .-#

/:: &-6<1%(# 6'>-1%(#+ '( #$% A%@4 =-/(<Y$'- P-(">"./:"#B R(#%*1%6"/#% 0'-*# A%@>/+# #$% #*"/: ') /

>*"1"(/: >/+%

!

"

L('#$%* %:%1%(# ') &-6">"/: '.%((%++ "+ #$% .-@:">/#"'( ') 6*/)# &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+ '( #$%

J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# A%@+"#% )'* >'11%(#

!

#

W`

!

V%)'*1+ #' >*%/#% / 1'*% '.%( +B+#%1 ') &-6">"/: +%:%>#"'( /:+' .*'1'#% 1'*% '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% )*'1

+'>"%#B

!

J%:%>#"(< &-6<%+ )*'1 /1'(< :/AB%*+4 /(6 '#$%* :%</: A'*I%*+ "+ ./*# ') #$% .*'.'+%6 +B+#%14

/:#$'-<$ %S.%*"1%(#/#"'( +' )/* $/+ @%%( :"1"#%6

!

$

Wb

!

,/+"%* L>>%++ #' 0'-*#+

!

R( DEEb 4 #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# "++-%6 "#+ /5#3#-37 -3 &0$1"($ D1$(3F1"(3#3F

I,,-$17 1- @*K( L1 I*7M ,-$ 1"( 40J2#H 1- N(1 OHH(77 1- G0%#H#*2 D($'#H(4 A$">$ *%?-"*%+ >'-*#+ /# /:: :%9%:+ #' #/I%

1-:#".:% 1%/+-*%+ #' "1.*'9% />>%++ #' &-+#">%

!

J'1% $/9% +-<<%+#%6 #$/# +->$ %))'*#+ (%%6 #' @% #%1.%*%6

A"#$ *%+.%># )'* &-6">"/: (%-#*/:"#B /(6 ./++"9%(%++

!

G$% 0'-*# $/+ /:+' .*'1'#%6 $/9"(< +'1% #*"/:+ "( 6"))%*%(#

.:/>%+4 '-#+"6% >'-*#*''1+4 / I"(6 ') /++"Y%+ +B+#%1

!

%

DE

!

V%)'*1 ') #$% ;%'.:% H+ L++%++'*+ JB+#%1

!

&

!$":% .%'.:% H+ /++%++'*+ $/9% @%%( ./*# ') 0$"(/ H+ &-6">"/:

+B+#%1 )'* 6%>/6%+4 #$% *%)'*1+ "("#"/#%6 "( DEE^ @B #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% /*% /"1%6 /# 1'*%

./*#">"./#"'( @B >"#"Y%(+ "( >'-*# #*"/:+4 +%:%>#%6 "( / )/"*%* A/B /(6 A"#$ / >:%/*%* *':% 9"+

"

/

"

9"+ &-6<%+ "( #$%

+/1% >'::%<"/: ./(%:

!

DW

!

,S./(+"'( ') O%</: L"6

!

0$"(/ H+ :%</: /"6 +B+#%14 /61"("+#%*%6 @B #$% P"("+#*B ') C-+#">%4 .*'9"6%+ :%</:

+%*9">%+ )'* >%*#/"( #B.%+ ') >/+%+4 #$*'-<$ )"(/(>"/: +-..'*# )'* / (/#"'(A"6% (%#A'*I ') :%</: /"6

'))">%+

!

0%(#*/: )-(6"(< )'* :%</: /"6 $/+ @%%( "(>*%/+"(< "( *%>%(# B%/*+4 /+ $/9% +.%>"/: %))'*#+ #' .*'9"6% :%</:

+%*9">%+ "( .''*%* *%<"'(+

!

'

DD

!

['A%9%*4 "1.*'9%6 )-(6"(< )'* :%</: /"6 */"+%+ #$% ./*/::%: ?-%+#"'( ') #$% +>'.% ') :%</: +%*9">%+ #$/#

>"#"Y%(+ >/( />>%++

!

!$":% #$% :%</: .*')%++"'( >'(#"(-%+ #' <*'A4 #$% 6"+#*"@-#"'( ') :/AB%*+ /*'-(6 #$%

>'-(#*B "+ -(%9%(

!

R( DEWW 4 "# A/+ *%.'*#%6 #$/# '(:B ] 4 EEE ') 0$"(/H+ DEE 4 EEE :/AB%*+ A'*I "( #$% *%:/#"9%:B

&

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

O"%@1/( DEWW /# W`D 4 >"#"(< [%(/( ;*'9"(>% /+ /( %S/1.:%

!

a- DEWE

!

['*+:%B DEEb 4 >"#"(< $##.\ ggAAA

!

>$"(/>'-*#

!

'*<

!

>(gA+6>g1'*%

!

.$.h :'>/#"'( iD_EDEEEEEE

!

C-6">"/: *%>*-"#1%(# "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L4 V%+-:# c/4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ bW

"

bc

!

a- DEEb

!

V%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1 "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* K9%*/:: KTR+ "( ./*/<*/.$+ ]W

"

]^ 2/(6 N'S W '( #$%

!-Y$'(< ;":'#34 /(6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L4 V%+-:# D@4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ `_

"

bE

!

0,00 DEWW /# W`b

!

Page 16: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

.''*%* >%(#*/: /(6 A%+#%*( *%<"'(+

!

!

P'*%'9%*4 #$% 1/(B 1%6"/ *%.'*#+ ') *%+#*">#"'(+ '( :/AB%*+ /(6 #$%

I"(6+ ') >/+%+ #$/# #$%B >/( #/I% -. '( @%$/:) ') >:"%(#+ "(6">/#% #$/# />>%++ #' :%</: +%*9">%+ "+ >-*#/":%6 ('#

'(:B @B %>'('1"> )/>#'*+ @-# /:+' @B <'9%*(1%(# .':">"%+

!

L+ '(% /++%++1%(# .-# "#4

"

"( +."#% ') /../*%(#

%))'*#+ #' #*/"( 1'*% :%</: /"6 *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+4 1%/+-*/@:% .'+"#"9% %))%>#+ "( >"#"Y%(H+ />>%++ #' &-+#">% *%1/"(

%:-+"9%

!#

"

ID J E>M

"

H>VB=8 NPNC;HL B06#"5$0$.37 ). N/73$07 "- E+% F#+-3).2 +.&

?".7)73$.*/ "- >66,)*+3)".

##

KTR\ R1.*'9%6 +B+#%1+ ') :/A 6*/)#"(< /(6 >'(+"+#%(>B ') /..:">/#"'(Q

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6Q JB+#%1+ ') :/A 6*/)#"(< /(6 #$% >'(+"+#%(>B ') /..:">/#"'( ') :/A+ $/9% @%%(

"1.*'9%6 6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'64 "(>:-6"(< #$*'-<$ "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( /# 6"))%*%(#

+#/<%+ ') :/A

"

1/I"(<4 %9/:-/#"'( 1%>$/("+1+ /(6 "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y"(< #$% +B+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ')

:%<"+:/#"'(Q

Dc

!

G$% +B+#%1 ') :/A 6*/)#"(< $/+ +%%( "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( / (-1@%* ') /*%/+ +"(>% DEEF

!

P%>$/("+1+ )'* .-@:">

>'11%(# '( 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( $/9% @%%( +#*%(<#$%(%6 /(6 +#/(6/*6"Y%64 @'#$ /# #$% (/#"'(/: /(6 :'>/:

:%9%:

!

G$% .*/>#">% ') .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"'( %9/:-/#"'( $/+ @%%( .":'#%6

!

R(.-#+ )*'1 +'>"%#B /*% +'-<$# "( #$%+%

%9/:-/#"'(+4 /+ A%:: /+ "( #$% :%<"+:/#"9% /<%(6/

"

+%##"(< .*'>%++

!

G%>$(">/: 6*/)#"(< $/+ +%%( "1.*'9%1%(#+ /+

A%::

!

0'(+"+#%(>B ') /..:">/#"'( $/+ @%%( %($/(>%6 #$*'-<$ "1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') #$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1 /#

#$% :'>/: /(6 (/#"'(/: :%9%:+4 A$">$ .*'9"6%+ )'* >'(+"+#%(>B *%9"%A ') (%A :%<"+:/#"'( @B $"<$%* :%9%:+ /(6 '(

*%?-%+# )*'1 #$% .-@:">

!

V%9"%A+ ') %S"+#"(< :%<"+:/#"'( /:+' )'+#%* >'(+"+#%(>B ') /..:">/#"'(

!

ITJ B06#"5$0$.37 ). E+% F#+-3).2

D^

!

,S./(+"'( ') ;-@:"> 0'11%(# P%>$/("+1+

!

G$% "1.'*#/(>% ') .-@:"> >'11%(#+ '( :%<"+:/#"'( 6-*"(< #$%

6*/)#"(< .*'>%++ A/+ *%>'<("Y%6 "( #$% A(F#72*1#-3 A*B

!

G$/# O/A %(+$*"(%6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(<

"( 6"))%*%(# )'*1+ 2)'*-1+4 +%1"(/*+4 $%/*"(<+4 %#>

!

34

#

*%):%>#"(< #$/#

"

#/I"(< .-@:"> '."("'( "(#' >'(+"6%*/#"'(

"( #$% 6*/)#"(< +#/<%+ ') :%<"+:/#"'( >/( %($/(>% #$% :%<"#"1/>B /(6 %()'*>%/@":"#B ') #$% )"(/: .*'6->#

!#

$

,($/(>%6 .-@:"> >'11%(# /:+' *%):%>#+ / >$/(<"(< 6B(/1">4 @%#A%%( :%<"+:/#-*%+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# @'6"%+

!

%

'

!

"

#

$

%

0,00 DEWW /# W`b

!

0,00 DEWW /# W`D

!

O/A '( O%<"+:/#"'( ') #$% ;%'.:%H+ V%.-@:"> ') 0$"(/4 L*#">:%+ c^ /(6 ]`

!

;/:%* DEE] /# cWW

!

O"%@1/( DEWW /# W_` 4 '@+%*9%+ #$/#\

"

P/(B :/A+ /*% ('A #$% .*'6-># ') +"<(")">/(# 6%@/#%4 @'#$ "( #$% 7/#"'(/:

;%'.:%H + 0'(<*%++ /(64 /# #"1%+4 "( #$% 1%6"/4 */#$%* #$/( @%"(< %S>:-+"9%:B #$% .*'6-># ') 6%>"+"'(+ @B ./*#B

"

+#/#%

'))">"/:+

!#

G$% *':% ') +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+ "+ ('#%6 "( 0$' DEE_ /# ]b^ \

"

R( /66"#"'(4 +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+ $/9% @%%(

%1%*<"(< /+ (%A )'*>%+ "( :/A1/I"(<4 +-..'*#%6 @B :'>/: :%<"+:/#-*%+ "( #$%"* /##%1.# #' "1.*'9% #$%"* +#/(6 /</"(+#

<'9%*(1%(# 6'1"(/(>% "( :/A1/I"(< .':"#">+

!#

Page 17: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

D]

!

R( DEE` 4 #$% 7;0 0$/"*.%*+'(H+ 0'-(>": 6%>"6%6 #$/#

"

"( .*"(>".:%4 /:: 6*/)# :/A+ -(6%* 6%:"@%*/#"'( @B #$%

J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% +$'-:6 @% *%:%/+%6 #' #$% .-@:"> '( AAA

!

(.>

!

<'9

!

>(4 #$/# 1/&'* @"::+ +$'-:6 /:+' @%

.-@:"+$%6 @B 1/&'* (/#"'(/: 1%6"/ '*</("Y/#"'(+ #' +':">"# '."("'(+ )*'1 #$% <%(%*/: .-@:">4 /(6 #$/# #$"+

+$'-:6 @%>'1% >'11'( .*/>#">%

!#

!

J"(>% #$% "(#*'6->#"'( ') #$% (%A .*'>%6-*% "( L.*": DEE` 4 #$% 7;0

J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% $/6 .-@:">"Y%6 c] '-# ') c` 6*/)# :/A+ #$*'-<$ 8%>%1@%* DEWW

!

"

8*/)#+ $/9% @%%(

*%9"+%6 #' *%):%># +'1% "++-%+ */"+%6 "( .-@:"> >'11%(#+4 +->$ /+ #$% R(6"9"6-/: R(>'1% G/S O/A *%9"+"'(+

#

/(6

#$% J'>"/: R(+-*/(>% O/A

!

$

J"1":/* .*'>%++%+ $/9% @%%( "(#*'6->%6 /# #$% .*'9"(>"/: /(6 :'>/: :%9%:+

!

%

D_

!

L:+' "( DEE` 4 #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": "("#"/#%6 / .*/>#">% ') .-@:"+$"(< 9"*#-/::B /:: 6*/)# *-:%+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+

2'#$%* #$/( #$'+% "(9':9"(< +#/#% +%>*%#+ '* (/#"'(/: +%>-*"#B 3Q J"1":/*:B4 #$% J;0 $/+ "("#"/#%6 / .*/>#">% ')

+':">"#"(< >'11%(#+ '( 6*/)# &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+ '( "#+ A%@+"#%

!

&

DF

!

G%>$(">/: R1.*'9%1%(#+ "( 8*/)#"(<

!

L (-1@%* ') #*%(6+ "( :/A

"

1/I"(< /*% /"1%6 /# #%>$(">/:

"1.*'9%1%(#+ "( 6*/)#"(<4 "(>:-6"(< 1'*% %S.%*# "(9':9%1%(# /(6 @%##%* #*/"(%6 6*/)#%*+ 2/+ 0$"(/ H + :%</:

%6->/#"'( $/+ %S./(6%63Q G$% (%%6 )'* #%>$(">/: "1.*'9%1%(# >'(#"(-%+ #' @% *%>'<("Y%6

!

'

O''I"(< )'*

+'-*>%+ ') #%>$(">/: %S.%*#"+% '-#+"6% #$% *%+.'(+"@:% <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ "+ /('#$%* "1.'*#/(# 6"1%(+"'(

!

L

>'(>%*( "( 0$"(%+% :%<"+:/#"9% 6*/)#"(< $/6 @%%(

"

6%./*#1%(#/:"+1

#

/+ 1/(B 6*/)#+ A%*% .*%./*%6 @B

*%+.'(+"@:% 1"("+#*"%+ /(6 /<%(>"%+

!

0'11%(#/#'*+ $/9% ('#%6 #$% "1.'*#/(>% ') #$% :%<"+:/#-*% #/I"(< / 1'*%

/>#"9% /(6 +-@+#/(#"9% *':% "( 6*/)#"(<

!#

(

J'1% $/9% /:+' ('#%6 / 1'*% .*')%++"'(/: 6*/)#"(< .*'>%++4

>'1@"("(< "(#%*(/#"'(/: %S.%*"%(>% /(6 #$% >$/::%(<%+ ') 0$"(/H+ */."6 +'>"/: >$/(<% "( #$% *%)'*1 %*/

!

)

D`

!

R(.-#+ )*'1 R1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

G$% .*/>#">% ') ;'+#

"

O%<"+:/#"9% V%9"%A 2'* %9/:-/#"'(3 /:+' $/+ / )'-(6/#"'(

"( #$% A*B -3 D05($'#7#-3 JM 1"( D1*3%#3F 8-..#11((7 -, 1"( 4(-52( 67 8-3F$(77(7 *1 O22 A('(27 9A*B -3

(

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

$##.\ ggAAA

!

(.>

!

<'9

!

>(g%(<:"+$(.>gJ.%%>$%+gDEEb

"

EcgW_g>'(#%(#j W^bc^^Fj ^

!

$#1 X-:: G%S# ') 7;0 J#/(6"(<

0'11"##%% !'*I V%.'*# DEEb 2"( ,(<:"+$3

G$% +1/:: (-1@%* ') :/A+ A$%*% .-@:"> >'11%(#+ '( 6*/)#+ A/+ ('# +':">"#%6 *%:/#% .*"1/*":B #' (/#"'(/: +%>-*"#B

/(6 1":"#/*B 1/##%*+4 +->$ /+ #$% P":"#/*B J%*9">% O/A

!

7;0 R(#%*9"%A

!

X'* #$% R(6"9"6-/: R(>'1% G/S O/A4 #$% #$*%+$':6 )'* #/S :"/@":"#B A/+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 #$% '*"<"(/:

VPNcEEE #' VPNc]EE

!

0LJJ R(+#"#-#% ') O/A DEEb

!

R( DEEb 4 "( *%+.'(+% #' .-@:"> '."("'(+4 .*'9"+"'(+ *%:/#%6 #' ':6 /<% .%(+"'(+ /(6

1%6">/: "(+-*/(>% A%*% "(>:-6%6 "( #$% 6*/)# J'>"/: R(+-*/(>% O/A /)#%* )-*#$%* *%+%/*>$

!

;-@:"> >'11%(# 1%>$/("+1+ /*% )-*#$%* 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* K9%*/:: KTR+ "( ./*/<*/.$+ ]]

"

]F 2/(6 N'S D '( ;-@:">

;/*#">"./#"'( "( O/A

"

1/I"(< /# #$% ;*'9"(>"/: O%9%:3 /(6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# N4 V%+-:# W/4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ WEc

"

WE`

!

[%/*"(<+ /*%

6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# N4 V%+-:# W@4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ WEb

"

WWD

!

['*+:%B DEEb 4 >"#"(<\ )'* #$% J#/#% 0'-(>":4 7'#">% ') #$% =%(%*/: K))">% ') #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": '( ;*"(#"(< #$% J#/#%

0'-(>": DEE` O%<"+:/#"9% !'*I ;:/(d )'* J;04 $##.\ ggAAA

!

>$"(/>'-*#

!

'*<

!

>(gA+6>g1'*%

!

.$.h :'>/#"'( iD_EDEEEEEE

!

a- a"/(1"(< DEWW \

"

:%<"+:/#"'( (%%6+ #%>$(">/: "1.*'9%1%(# #' 1/I%

%

"#

&

1'*% .*%>"+% /(6 /..:">/@:%

!#

0$' DEE_ /# ]b`

!

O-@1/( DEWW 4 ('#"(< +.%>")"> %S/1.:%+ ') G'*# O"/@":"#B O/A /(6 L(#"

"

P'('.':B O/A

!

Page 18: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

D05($'#7#-3?

!

!

5(6%* #$"+ O/A4 *%.'*#+ '( "(+.%>#"'( ') :/A %()'*>%1%(# +$'-:6 "(>:-6% ('# '(:B /(

f /++%++1%(# ') #$% .*'@:%1+ #$/# %S"+# "( "1.:%1%(#/#"'( /(6 +-<<%+#"'(+ )'* "1.*'9"(< "1.:%1%(#/#"'(4 @-#

/:+' +-<<%+#"'(+ )'* *%9"+"(< #$% *%:%9/(# :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+ "( '*6%* #' "1.*'9% #$%1

!

"

G$% 7;0 J#/(6"(<

0'11"##%% $/+ @%%( >/**B"(< '-# .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A .":'#+ "( *%>%(# B%/*+4 A"#$ .-@:"> "(.-# /+ / ./*# ')

#$% .*'>%++

!

;*'9"(>"/: .":'#+ $/9% /:+' @%%( -(6%*#/I%(

!

#

Db

!

J%##"(< #$% O%<"+:/#"9% L<%(6/

!

0'(+-:#/#"'( '( /((-/: :%<"+:/#"9% /<%(6/+ "+ /('#$%* A/B ') '@#/"("(<

"(.-#+ )*'1 +'>"%#B

!

G$% *':% ') 7;0 8%.-#"%+ "( +-<<%+#"(< "#%1+ ') :%<"+:/#"'( "+ /:+' *%>%"9"(< /##%(#"'(4 /+

./*# ') #$% "1.*'9%1%(#+ #' 1/I% :%<"+:/#"'( "( / +>"%(#")"> /(6 6%1'>*/#"> 1/((%*

!

R( DEEb 4 )'* %S/1.:%4

/1'(< DW .*'.'+/:+ '( :%<"+:/#"'( 1/6% @B 8%.-#"%+4 #%( A%(# "(#' #$% /<%(6/ ') #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(<

0'11"##%% )'* 6%:"@%*/#"'(4 /(6 *%:%9/(# 8%.-#"%+ /##%(6%6 +-@+%?-%(# 1%%#"(<+ /+ '@+%*9%*+

!

$

;-@:"> "(.-#

"+ /:+' +'-<$#4 )'* %S/1.:%4 "( C"/(<+-

!

%

G$% (%A 7;0 .*/>#">% ') .*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A /:+' )%/#-*%+ "(.-#+ "(

#$% +%:%>#"'( ') :%<"+:/#"'( #' @% .*%./*%6

!

&

IUJ B06#"5$0$.37 ). ?".7)73$.*/ "- >66,)*+3)".

cE

!

G$% (%%6 #' +#*%(<#$%( >'(+"+#%(>B "( #$% /..:">/#"'( ') :/A />*'++ 0$"(/ $/+ @%%( *%>'<("Y%6 )'* +'1%

#"1%

!

G$% A(F#72*1#-3 A*B %+#/@:"+$%6 #$% $"%*/*>$B ') +'-*>%+ ') :/A4 /(6 :/"6 #$% <*'-(6A'*I )'* )":"(< ')

f :%<"+:/#"'( 2 /61"("+#*/#"9% *%<-:/#"'(+4 :'>/: *%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 *-:%+ 3 A"#$"( cE 6/B+ ') .*'1-:</#"'(

!

'

G$%

A(F#72*1#-3 A*B )-*#$%* 1/(6/#%6 #$/# /-#$'*"#"%+ +$'-:64 "( />>'*6/(>% A"#$ #$% .*"(>".:% ') +/)%<-/*6"(<

f -(")'*1"#B4 )'*1-:/#% .*'>%6-*%+ )'* %S/1"(/#"'( ') :%<"+:/#"'( #$/# "+ )":%6

!

(

7'(%#$%:%++4 %S/1.:%+ $/9%

.%*+"+#%6 ') "(/..*'.*"/#% :'>/: *-:%+ #$/# +'1%#"1%+ 6"*%>#:B >'(#*/9%(% (/#"'(/: :/A

!

)

cW

!

X":"(< /(6 V%9"%A JB+#%1

!

*+,

G$% A*B -3 D05($'#7#-3 @-":# '( #$"+ )'-(6/#"'(4 @B *%?-"*"(< #$%

f %+#/@:"+$1%(# @B .*'9"(>"/:

"

:%9%: .%'.:%H+ >'(<*%++%+ ') .*'>%6-*%+ )'* *%9"%A /(6 /((-:1%(# ') "(/..*'.*"/#%

*%+':-#"'(+ /(6 6%>"+"'(+ ') :'A%* :%9%: .%'.:%H+ >'(<*%++%+ /+ A%:: /+ "(/..*'.*"/#% 6%>"+"'(+ '* '*6%* "++-%6

@B #$% .%'.:% H + <'9%*(1%(# /# #$% +/1% :%9%:

!

G$/# :/A /:+' >:/*")"%6 A$/# A/+ #' @% >'(+"6%*%6

)

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

(

)

*+,

O/A '( J-.%*9"+"'(4 0$/.#%* RT

!

O/A '( J-.%*9"+"'(4 L*#">:% D_

!

;'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# N4 V%+-:# D 4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ WWc

"

WDE

!

0LJJ R(+#"#-#% ') O/A DEEb

!

J%% N'S c

!

;*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A "+ 6"+>-++%6 "( ./*/<*/.$+ WDW

"

WDD

!

O/A '( O%<"+:/#"'( L*#">:%+ F`

"

`E 4 `b

!

O/A '( O%<"+:/#"'( L*#">:% bD

!

O"%@1/( DEWW /# W_b \

"

7-1%*'-+ %S.%*"1%(#+ "( :/A

"

1/I"(< "(9':9% :'>/: /-#$'*"#"%+ /6'.#"(< *-:%+ #$/# 6"*%>#:B

>'(#*/6"># %S"+#"(< :/A4

#

>"#"(< k$'(<<-/(>-( DEEW *%<-:/#"'(+ #$/# .%*1"##%6 #$% )'*1/#"'( ') :"1"#%6 ./*#(%*+$".+ @B

"(6"9"6-/:+4 /:#$'-<$ #$% ;/*#(%*+$". O/A *%?-"*%+ #A' '* 1'*% "(6"9"6-/:+ #' )'*1 / :"1"#%6 ./*#(%*+$".d /(6 k$'(<<-/(>-(

DEE^ *%<-:/#"'(+ #$/# .%*1"# (/#-*/: .%*+'(+ #' @% C'"(# T%(#-*% ./*#(%*+4 %9%( #$'-<$ ,?-"#B C'"(#

"

T%(#-*% O/A .%*1"#+

'(:B :%</: .%*+'(+

!

X":"(< /(6 *%9"%A "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# N4 V%+-:# c 4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ WD]

"

Wcc

!

Page 19: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

"

"(/..*'.*"/#%

#

\ 2W 3 :%<"+:/#"'( %S>%%6"(< #$% +#/#-#'*B :"1"#+ ') .'A%* "( *%+#*">#"(< :/A)-: *"<$#+ ') >"#"Y%(+4

:%</: .%*+'(+ /(6 '#$%* '*</("Y/#"'(+4 6%.*"9"(< #$%1 ') #$%+% *"<$#+4 '* "( "(>*%/+"(< '@:"</#"'(+d 2D 3

>'(#*/9%("(< #$% .*'9"+"'(+ ') :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+d '* 2 c 3 '#$%* "(/..*'.*"/#% A/B+ #$/# *%?-"*%

/((-:1%(#

!

!

cD

!

J"(>% DEEF 4 #$% +B+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A $/+ @%%( +%# -. />*'++ #$% >'-(#*B4 /(6 "+ @%>'1"(<

*%<-:/*"Y%6 )'* .*'9"(>"/: :%9%: .%'.:% H + >'(<*%++%+4 /(6 )'* 1/(B +-@

"

.*'9"(>"/: .%'.:% H + >'(<*%++%+ /+

A%::

!

G$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% $/+ #/I%( +#%.+ #' 6%%.%( #$% +B+#%1 ') *%9"%A /(6 )":"(<4 @B %(>'-*/<"(<

#$% :'>/:"#"%+ #' +%# -. *-:%+ #' *%9"%A *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+

!

L:: .*'9"(>"/: ('A $/9% *%:%9/(# *-:%+ '( #$%

@''I+

!

cc

!

V%9"%A ') ,S"+#"(< O%<"+:/#"'(

!

L('#$%* 1%>$/("+1 )'* %($/(>"(< >'(+"+#%(>B ') /..:">/#"'( "+ #$%

.*'/>#"9% *%9"%A /(6 /((-:1%(# '* *%9"+"'( ') %S"+#"(< :/A

!

R( >'((%>#"'( A"#$ 0$"(/ H+ %(#*B "(#' #$% !'*:6

G*/6% K*</("Y/#"'( /(6 /6'.#"'( ') #$% L61"("+#*/#"9% O">%(+"(< O/A "( #$% %/*:B DEEE+4 / 1/&'* .*'>%++ ')

*%9"%A /(6 /((-:1%(#g*%9"+"'( A/+ -(6%*#/I%(

!

"

P'*% *%>%(#:B4 / +"1":/* %S%*>"+% "( DEEb *%+-:#%6 "( #$% 7;0

H+ /((-:1%(# ') %"<$# :/A+ /(6 *%9"+"'( ') / ./>I/<% ') ]b :/A+4 A"#$ '#$%*+ /66%6 #' #$% :%<"+:/#"9% /<%(6/

)'* )-*#$%* />#"'(

!

#

I?J ?B:BE N9?B;CPL B.*#$+7$& G+#3)*)6+3)". ). K(&)*)+, G#"*$77$7 +.& E+%

"

0+1).2

##

KTR\ 8%9%:'.1%(# ') 1%>$/("+1+ )'* "(>*%/+%6 ./*#">"./#"'( ') >"9": +'>"%#B "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6

:/A

"

1/I"(<Q

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6Q P%>$/("+1+ )'* "(>*%/+%6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(<

$/9% @%%( 6%9%:'.%6 6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'64 /+ +-11/*"Y%6 -(6%* 2L3 /(6 2N3 /@'9%Q

*!

!

"

#

O/A '( J-.%*9"+"'( L*#">:% Db

"

cE

!

J#/#% 0'-(>": R()'*1/#"'( K))">%4 DEE`

! "

L #'#/: ') _]] /61"("+#*/#"9% *%<-:/#"'(+ "( )'*>% #$/# $/6 @%%(

.*'1-:</#%6 @%)'*% #$% %(6 ') DEE_ $/9% @%%( *%%S/1"(%64 ') A$">$ ^b $/9% @%%( *%.%/:%6 +"(>% #$% 1/"( >'(#%(# ')

#$%+% *%<-:/#"'(+ $/9% @%%( *%.:/>%6 @B (%A :/A+ '* /61"("+#*/#"9% *%<-:/#"'(+d ^c 6%>:/*%6 "(9/:"6 @%>/-+% #$%"* %))%>#"9%

9/:"6"#B .%*"'6 $/6 %S."*%6 '* #$%B $/6 :'+# #$%"* 9/:"6"#B A"#$ #$% 6"+/..%/*/(>% ') #$%"* '@&%>#+ ') *%<-:/#"'(

''

X*'1

P/*>$ DEEc #' #$% %(6 ') DEEF 4 #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": %S/1"(%6 ` 4 ^ED :'>/: *%<-:/#"'(+4 /-#'('1'-+ *%<-:/#"'(+4 +%./*/#%

*%<-:/#"'(+4 :'>/: <'9%*(1%(#H+ *-:%+ /(6 *-:%+ %(/>#%6 @B #$% 6%./*#1%(#+ ') #$% J#/#% 0'-(>":4 A$">$ $/6 @%%( )":%6 )'* #$%

*%>'*6 @B :'>/: <'9%*(1%(#+ /(6 #$% 6%./*#1%(#+ -(6%* #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": A"#$ :%<"+:/#"9% .'A%*4 /(6 /66*%++%6 cDc

.*'@:%1/#"> *%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 *-:%+ "( />>'*6/(>% A"#$ #$% :/A

!#

J#/#% 0'-(>": R()'*1/#"'( K))">% DEWW 2!$"#% ;/.%* '( J'>"/:"+# O%</: JB+#%1 A"#$ 0$"(%+% 0$/*/>#%*"+#">+ 3Q G$%

!$"#% ;/.%* )-*#$%* ('#%+ #$/#4 )*'1 DEEb \

"

G$% J#/#% 0'-(>": /((-::%6 +%9%( /61"("+#*/#"9% *%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 *%9"+%6 WEF

/61"("+#*/#"9% *%<-:/#"'(+

!

O'>/: .%'.:% H + >'(<*%++%+ /(6 #$%"* +#/(6"(< >'11"##%%+ /((-::%6 ^]] :'>/: *%<-:/#"'(+4 /(6

*%9"+%6 W 4 ^WF :'>/: *%<-:/#"'(+

!

J->$ A'*I $/+ $%:.%6 #' +':9% #$% .*'@:%1 ') "(>'1./#"@":"#B /1'(< :/A+ /(6

*%<-:/#"'(+

!#

Page 20: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

c^

!

;/*#">"./#"'( "( C-6">"/: ;*'>%++%+

!

P'*% 1%>$/("+1+ $/9% @%%( 6%9%:'.%6 6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6 )'*

"(>*%/+%6 ./*#">"./#"'( ') >"9": +'>"%#B "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+

!

G$%+% 1%>$/("+1+ "(>:-6%\ /+.%>#+ ') &-6">"/: '.%((%++

2'.%( #*"/:4 .-@:">:B />>%++"@:% 6'>-1%(#+3d />>%++ #' >'-*#+d /(6 %+.%>"/::B #$% *%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:% H+ /++%++'*+

+B+#%1

!

R( /66"#"'(4 #$% %S./(+"'( ') .%'.:% H+ 1%6"/#"'( /(6 '#$%* #B.%+ ') 1%6"/#"'( 2')#%( >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%63

.*'9"6% '..'*#-("#"%+ )'* 1%1@%*+ ') +'>"%#B #' @%>'1% 1%6"/#'*+ /(6 #$-+ ./*#">"./#% "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+

!

G$%

.-@:">/#"'( ') 6*/)# &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+ )'* .-@:"> >'11%(# "+ /('#$%* 1%>$/("+1 )'* ./*#">"./#"'(

!

c]

!

G$%+% 1%>$/("+1+ /*% 6"*%>#%64 "( 1'+# >/+%+4 /# #$% .-@:"> /# :/*<%4 /(6 ('# /# >"9": +'>"%#B <*'-.+

+.%>")">/::B

!

K(% /*%/ A$%*% >"9": +'>"%#B '*</("Y/#"'(+ 20JK+3 $/9% @%%( />#"9% "+ "( #$% .*'9"+"'( ') :%</: 2/"63

+%*9">%+

!

J'1% ') #$%+% 1%>$/("+1+ $/9% @%%( *%9"%A%6 #$*'-<$ ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+4 +->$ /+ *%)'*1 ') #$%

.%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%14 '.%( #*"/:+ /(6 L8V

!

c_

!

;/*#">"./#"'( "( #$% O/A

"

1/I"(< JB+#%1

!

G$% 1%>$/("+1+ )'* "(>*%/+%6 ./*#">"./#"'( "( #$% :/A

"

1/I"(<

+B+#%1 6"+>-++%6 /@'9% "(>:-6%\ .-@:"> >'11%(# '( 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'(d :%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+d .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'(

"( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"'( %9/:-/#"'( /(6 .*%

"

:%<"+:/#"'( %9/:-/#"'(d /(6 "(.-#+ "(#' :%<"+:/#"9% /<%(6/+

!

P%1@%*+ ')

#$% .-@:"> >/( /:+' *%?-%+# *%9"%A ') :%<"+:/#"'( )'* >'(+"+#%(>B A"#$ $"<$%*

"

:%9%: :%<"+:/#"'(4 -(6%* #$% )":"(<

/(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1

!

cF

!

G$%+% 1%>$/("+1+ /*% ('# 6"*%>#%6 +.%>")">/::B /# 0JK+4 @-# */#$%* /*% '.%( #' #$% .-@:"> /# :/*<% #'

./*#">"./#%

!

;*/>#">% -(6%* +'1% ') #$%+% 1%>$/("+1+ $/+ @%%( *%9"%A%6 #$*'-<$ ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+4 +->$ /+

:%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+4 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"'( %9/:-/#"'( /(6 #$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1

!

IFJ <AE; 9! E>ML M"#,& 8"5$#.+.*$ B.&)*+3"#7 IM8BJ G"7)3)5$ C#$.&

##

KTR\ !'*:6 ='9%*(/(>% "(6">/#'*+\ H ;'+"#"9% #*%(6 "( #$% V-:% ') O/A H "(6">/#'* Wbb`

"

DEE` "+

1/"(#/"(%6Q

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6Q G$% !'*:6 ='9%*(/(>% R(6">/#'* H;'+"#"9% G*%(6 "( V-:% ') O/A H "1.*'9%6 +:"<$#:B

'9%* #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6Q ['A%9%*4 '#$%* /++%++1%(#+ *%9"%A%6 +-<<%+# >'(#"(-"(< >'(>%*(+Q

ITJ M"#,& 8"5$#.+.*$ B.&)*+3"#7 IM8BJ

c`

!

R( #$% !=R4 #$% "(6">/#'*

"

V-:% ') O/A

#

>/.#-*%+ .%*>%.#"'( ') #$% %S#%(# #' A$">$ /<%(#+ $/9% >'()"6%(>%

"( /(6 /@"6% @B #$% *-:%+ ') +'>"%#B4 "( ./*#">-:/* #$% ?-/:"#B ') >'(#*/># %()'*>%1%(#4 #$% .':">%4 /(6 #$%

>'-*#+4 /+ A%:: /+ #$% :"I%:"$''6 ') >*"1% /(6 9"':%(>%

!

R( #$% !=R Wbb_

"

DEWE 6/#/+%#4 )'* #$% .%*"'6 )*'1 DEEF

#' DEWE 4 0$"(/ $/+ "1.*'9%6 )*'1 ^E

!

F #' ^^

!

] .%*>%(#":% /1'(< >'-(#*"%+ "(>:-6%6

!

G$%*% A/+ / +:"<$#

"(>*%/+% "( */A +>'*% )*'1 DEEF #' DEE` 2

"

E

!

^F #'

"

E

!

c^ 34 A$">$ A/+ 1/"(#/"(%6 )'* DEE`

"

DEWE

!

=%(%*/::B4

#$"+ #*%(6 >'-:6 @% +%%( #' *%):%># /( "1.*'9%6 .%*>%.#"'( ') >'-*#+ /(6 "(>*%/+%6 >'()"6%(>% ') <%(%*/: .-@:">

"( #$% :%</: +B+#%1

!

G$% .'+"#"9% #*%(6 $%*% 1%/(+ #$/# #$% +.%>")"> KTR $/+ @%%( 1%#

!

cb

!

X'* #$% T'">% /(6 L>>'-(#/@":"#B "(6">/#'*4 A$">$ "+ /:+' 1%(#"'(%6 "( #$% 9%*")">/#"'( +'-*>%+ "( #$%

!!

Page 21: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

O'<)*/1%4 0$"(/ $/+ +$'A( +'1% ):->#-/#"'( "( #$% .%*"'6 )*'1 DEEF #' DEWE

!

T'">% /(6 />>'-(#/@":"#B

1%/+-*%+ #$% %S#%(# #' A$">$ / >'-(#*BH+ >"#"Y%(+ /*% /@:% #' ./*#">"./#% "( +%:%>#"(< #$%"* <'9%*(1%(#4 /+ A%::

/+ )*%%6'1 ') %S.*%++"'(4 )*%%6'1 ') /++'>"/#"'(4 /(6 / )*%% 1%6"/

!

0$"(/H+ .%*>%(#":% */(I"(< "1.*'9%6 )*'1

^

!

` "( DEEF #' ]

!

` "( DEE` 4 #$%( @/>I #' ]

!

D "( DEWE

!

V/A +>'*%+ "1.*'9%6 +:"<$#:B )*'1 DEEF #' DEE` 2

"

W

!

FE #'

"

W

!

__ 34 A$">$ A/+ +#/#"+#">/::B 1/"(#/"(%6 #$*'-<$ DEWE

!

IUJ 934$# >77$770$.37

^E

!

G$% +'-*>%+ )'* 9%*")">/#"'( )'* #$% KTR+ /:+' "(>:-6% "(#%*(/#"'(/: #$%1/#"> /++%++1%(#+ ') V-:% ') O/A /(6

T'">% /(6 L>>'-(#/@":"#B "( 0$"(/ 2 %

!

<

!

<'9%*(/(>% *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+ )*'1 K,084 ,54 L8N4 !NR4 X*%%6'1

['-+%4 /(6 [-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$ 3Q

!

L>>'*6"(<:B4 #$% )"(6"(<+ )'* *-:% ') :/A "++-%+ "( 0$"(/ <%(%*/::B "(

+%9%*/: "(#%*(/#"'(/: <'9%*(/(>%

"

#B.% /++%++1%(#+ /*% +-11/*"Y%6 @%:'A\ X*%%6'1 ['-+%4 [-1/( V"<$#+

!/#>$4 N%*#%:+1/(( G*/(+)'*1/#"'( R(6%S4 =:'@/: R(#%<*"#B V%.'*#4 !'*:6 C-+#">% ;*'&%>#4 /(6 K,08 V%9"%A ')

V%<-:/#'*B V%)'*1

!

^W

!

X*%%6'1 ['-+%

!

G$% X*%%6'1 ['-+% '(:"(% *%9"%A4 &$((%-. #3 1"( P-$2% :;=: 4 *%.'*#+ / 6'A(A/*6 #*%(6

f :"(% )'* 0$"(/

!

G$"+ *%9"%A +#/#%+\

"

8%+."#% 1"('* :%</: "1.*'9%1%(#+ *%</*6"(< #$% 6%/#$ .%(/:#B /(6 -*@/(

.*'.%*#B >'()"+>/#"'(4 #$% <'9%*(1%(# +#/::%6 '* %9%( *%9%*+%6 .*%9"'-+ *%)'*1+ *%:/#%6 #' #$% *-:% ') :/A

''#

"

G$% X*%%6'1 ['-+% 8-031$#(7 *1 1"( 8$-77$-*%7 :;== Q 8"#3* *%.'*#4 "( "#+ +%>#"'( '( V-:% ') O/A4

f 6%+>*"@%+ / @/>I:/+$ +"(>% DEE` /</"(+# %/*:"%* :%</: *%)'*1+4 ./*#">-:/*:B "( #$% *':% ') >'-*#+ /(6 .'+"#"'( ')

.-@:"> "(#%*%+# :/AB%*+

!

#

K) ./*#">-:/* *%:%9/(>% )'* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 #$"+ *%.'*# "(>:-6%+ A"#$"( #$"+ @/>I:/+$

%))'*#+ @B #$% 0$"(%+% /-#$'*"#"%+ #' *%"(9"<'*/#% 1%6"/#"'( "(+#"#-#"'(+ /(6 #' 6"+>'-*/<%

"

&-6<%+ /(6 ./*#"%+

)*'1 *%+'*#"(< #' >'-*#*''1 :"#"</#"'( /+ / 1%/(+ #' *%+':9% >"#"Y%( <*"%9/(>%+

!#

R( "#+ J%>#"'( '( L>>'-(#/@":"#B

/(6 ;-@:"> T'">%4 #$% *%.'*# ('#%+ / :"1"#%6 6%<*%% ') .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( #$% .':"#">/: +B+#%14 /(6 '@+%*9%+\

"

O%<"+:/#"9% "(+#"#-#"'(+ $/9% %9':9%6 1/*<"(/::B /A/B )*'1 #$%"* P/'"+#

"

%*/ *':% /+ +"1.:% *-@@%* +#/1.+

!#

^D

!

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$

!

G$% [V! 0'-(#*B J-11/*B )'* 0$"(/ )'* DEEb ('#%6 *%+#*">#"'(+ '( >"9": +'>"%#B /(6

:/AB%*+4 /(6 +:'A .*'<*%++ "( *"<$#+ /A/*%(%++ /(6 &-6">"/: .*')%++"'(/:"Y/#"'(

!

$

G$% [V! 0'-(#*B J-11/*B

)'* 0$"(/ )'* DEWE 4 "( "#+ +%>#"'( '( :%</: *%)'*1+4 ('#%6 #$/#

"

:%</: /A/*%(%++ /1'(< >"#"Y%(+ >'(#"(-%+ #'

<*'A /(6 :%</: *%)'*1+ .*'<*%++ +:'A:B4 /:#$'-<$ #$% <'9%*(1%(# H+ '9%*# $'+#":"#B #'A/*6+ <%(-"(% &-6">"/:

"(6%.%(6%(>% -(6%*>-#+ :%<"+:/#"9% "1.*'9%1%(#+

!#

G$"+ *%.'*# /:+' $"<$:"<$#%6 #$% P/B DEWE

/(('-(>%1%(# ') #A' 6"*%>#"9%+ %S>:-6"(< %9"6%(>% '@#/"(%6 #$*'-<$ #'*#-*%4 "(>:-6"(< >'()%++"'(+ ')

"!

!

"

#

$

='9%*(/(>% *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+ >'9%*"(< 0$"(/ )'* #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6 2DEEF

"

DEWD 3 A%*% ('# :'>/#%6 '( #$% .-@:">

A%@+"#%+ ') K,084 ,5 /(6 L8N

!

X*%%6'1 ['-+% DEWD

!

X*%%6'1 ['-+% DEWW

!

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$ DEWE /# W 4 c

!

Page 22: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

6%)%(6/(#+ /(6 #%+#"1'(B ') .*'+%>-#"'( A"#(%++%+

!

!

G$% [V! 0'-(#*B J-11/*B )'* 0$"(/ )'* DEWW ('#%+

#$/#

" %

6

&

%+."#% #$%"* .*%>/*"'-+ :%</: +#/#-+ /(6 +-*9%"::/(>% @B #$% /-#$'*"#"%+4 >"9": +'>"%#B <*'-.+ >'(#"(-%

#' #*B #' %S./(6 #$%"* A'*I4 /(6 "(>*%/+"(<:B %(</<% A"#$ "(#%*(/#"'(/: 7=K+

!#

"

G$% +%>#"'( '( :%</: *%)'*1+

)'>-+%+ '( #$% 6%@/#% '9%* 6*/)# *%9"+"'(+ #' #$% 0*"1"(/: ;*'>%6-*% O/A

!

#

^c

!

G$% N%*#%:+1/(( G*/(+)'*1/#"'( R(6%S 2NGR3 "+ / <:'@/: */(I"(< ') #*/(+"#"'( .*'>%++%+ "( A$">$ #$% +#/#% ')

6%1'>*/>B /(6 1/*I%# %>'('1"> +B+#%1+ /+ A%:: /+ #$% ?-/:"#B ') .':"#">/: 1/(/<%1%(# "( WD` #*/(+)'*1/#"'(

/(6 6%9%:'."(< >'-(#*"%+ /*% %9/:-/#%6

!

0$"(/ H + '9%*/:: */(I"(< /1'(< >'-(#*"%+ )'* #$"+ .-*.'+% 6%>:"(%6

+:"<$#:B4 )*'1 `]#$ "( DEE` #' ``#$ "( DEWE 4 #$% :/#%+# B%/* /9/":/@:%

!

G$% *-:% ') :/A +%>#"'( "( #$% :;=; 8"#3*

8-031$M +(5-$1 '@+%*9%+ #$/# #$% :%</: +B+#%1 *%1/"(+ A%/I4 /(6 (%"#$%* #$% &-6">"/*B ('* #$% @/* "+ .':"#">/::B

f "(6%.%(6%(#

!

R1.*'9%1%(#+ ('#%6 "(>:-6% #$% C/(-/*B DEEF 6%>"+"'( #' *%#-*( #$% /-#$'*"#B #' *%9"%A 6%/#$

+%(#%(>%+ #' #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:% H+ 0'-*#4

"

*%+-:#"(< "( / 9"+"@:% 6%>*%/+% "( 6%/#$ +%(#%(>%+ /(6 "11%6"/#%

%S%>-#"'(+

!#

$

^^

!

=:'@/: R(#%<*"#B V%.'*#

!

G$% =:'@/: R(#%<*"#B V%.'*# /++%++%+ *-:% ') :/A "( 0$"(/ /+ A%/I4 +$'A"(< / +:"<$#

"1.*'9%1%(# )*'1 / +>'*% ') _D "( DEEF #' _` "( DEE` /(6 DEEb 4 #$% :/#%+# B%/* +-*9%B%6

!

G$% DEEb V%.'*#

["<$:"<$#+ ('#%+ #$/# #$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> >'(#"(-%+ #' *%.'*# >'**-.#"'(4 /(6 #$/# / 1/&'*"#B ') "(9%+#"</#"'(+

@B #$% /(#"

"

>'**-.#"'( /<%(>B /(6 #$% &-6">"/: @*/(>$ '*"<"(/#% )*'1 >"#"Y%( >'1.:/"(#+

!

G$% V%.'*# /:+' ('#%+

#A' +1/:: "1.*'9%1%(#+4 "( >"#"Y%( />>%++ #' <'9%*(1%(# 6'>-1%(#+ /(6 #$% "(>*%/+%6 *':% ') #$% ;%'.:% H+

0'(<*%++ "( .':">B )'*1-:/#"'(

!

%

^]

!

!'*:6 C-+#">% ;*'&%># 2!C;3

!

G$% !C; V-:% ') O/A R(6%S .*%+%(#+ / >'1.*%$%(+"9% +%# ') "(6">/#'*+ '( #$%

*-:% ') :/A )*'1 #$% .%*+.%>#"9% ') #$% '*6"(/*B .%*+'(

!

&

0$"(/ A/+ "(>:-6%6 )'* #$% )"*+# #"1% "( #$% DEWW

*%.'*#4 +-11/*"Y%6 /+ )'::'A+\

"

0$"(/ 6'%+ A%:: /1'(< :'A%*

"

1"66:% "(>'1% >'-(#*"%+ "( 1'+# >/#%<'*"%+

''

0$"(/ $/+ +%%( 1/&'* "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( #$% ?-/:"#B4 %))%>#"9%(%++4 /(6 />>'-(#/@":"#B ') "#+ :%</:

"(+#"#-#"'(+

!

J%>-*"#B "+ $"<$ 2 */(I"(< D] #$ 34 /(6 #$% >*"1"(/: &-+#">% +B+#%1 */(I+ D(6 /1'(< "#+ "(>'1%

.%%*+

!

,()'*>%1%(# ') *%<-:/#"'(+ "+ *%:/#"9%:B "(%))%>#"9% 2*/(I"(< ^c *6 <:'@/::B /(6 `

#$

/1'(< :'A%*

"

1"66:%

"(>'1% >'-(#*"%+3Q G$% >"9": >'-*# +B+#%1 "+ *%:/#"9%:B />>%++"@:% /(6 +.%%6B4 @-# &-6">"/: "(6%.%(6%(>% *%1/"(+

/( /*%/ A$%*% 1'*% .*'<*%++ "+ (%%6%6

!

R(6">/#'*+ ') )-(6/1%(#/: *"<$#+ /*% A%/I4 "(>:-6"(< :/@'* *"<$#+

2*/(I"(< _W

+#

'-# ') __ 34 )*%%6'1 ') /++%1@:B 2*/(I"(< __ #$34 /(6 )*%%6'1 ') +.%%>$ 2*/(I"(< __ #$3Q

#

'

#!

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$ DEWW /# c

!

G$% V%.'*# .'"(#+ '-# / ./*#">-:/* >/+% A$%*% #$% (%A *%<-:/#"'(+ A%*% ('#

/..:"%6

!

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$ DEWD /# W

!

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$ DEWD /# D

"

c

!

N%*#%:+1/(( DEWE /# `

!

=:'@/: R(#%<*"#B V%.'*# DEEb

!

!'*:6 C-+#">% ;*'&%># DEWW

!

!'*:6 C-+#">% ;*'&%># DEWW

!

Page 23: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

^_

!

K,08

!

L( K,08 *%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B *%)'*1 "( 0$"(/ >'1%+ #' +'1% <%(%*/: >'(>:-+"'(+ /@'-# *-:% ') :/A

"( 0$"(/

!

!

K9%*/::4 #$% *%9"%A ('#%+ #$/# %+#/@:"+$"(< *-:% ') :/A *%+#+ ('# '(:B '( 1'*% %))%>#"9% %()'*>%1%(#4

@-#4 /+ "1.'*#/(#:B4 '( :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+ #$/# /*% >:%/* /(6 A%:: -(6%*+#''64 /(6 '( *%6->%6 "(>%(#"9%+ /(6

'..'*#-("#"%+ #' 9"':/#% #$%1

!

R( #$% >/+% ') 0$"(/4 #A' )%/#-*%+ ') #$% :/A1/I"(< .*'>%++ >*%/#% '@+#/>:%+ #'

#$% %+#/@:"+$1%(# ') *-:% ') :/A

!

X"*+#4 $"<$

"

:%9%: :/A+ /*% 6*/)#%6 "( #%*1+ ') .*"(>".:%+ /(6 <'/:+ 1'*% #$/(

>'(>*%#% "++-%+4 :%/9"(< +.%>")">+ #' *%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 6%>*%%+

!

!$":% '))%*"(< ):%S"@":"#B4 #$"+ .*/>#">% /:+' .*'9"6%+

'..'*#-("#"%+ )'* "(>'(+"+#%(# /..:">/#"'(

!

J%>'(64 :/A+4 *%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 6%>*%%+ /*% "++-%6 ('# '(:B @B >%(#*/:

/(6 :'>/: <'9%*(1%(#+ /(6 /<%(>"%+4 @-# /:+' @B :'A%*

"

:%9%: .%'.:%H+ >'(<*%++%+ /(6 ;/*#B '*</(+

!

G$% K,08

*%9"%A )"(6+ #$/# #$% *%:/#"9% +#/#-+ ') #$%+% "(+#*-1%(#+ "+ ')#%( 9%*B -(>:%/*4 1/I"(< "# 6"))">-:# #' 6%#%*1"(%

A$">$ *-:% .*%9/":+ "( / +.%>")"> >/+%

!

"

X"(/::B4 #$% *%9"%A %1.$/+"Y%+ #$% (%%6 )'* *%)'*1+ #' +#*%(<#$%( #$%

&-6">"/: +B+#%14 @'#$ #' *%1%6B A%/I(%++%+ "( >/./>"#B /(6 *%6->% %S#%*(/: >'(+#*/"(#+ '( /-#$'*"#B

!

#

IWJ N(00).2 A6

^F

!

G$% /++%++1%(#+ *%9"%A%6 /@'9% "::-+#*/#% / */(<% ') >'(>%*( )'* #$% )-#-*% #*%(6 ') *-:% ') :/A "(

0$"(/

!

NB A/B ') +-11"(< -.4 "# "+ -+%)-: #' #/I% ('#% ') *%>%(# >'11%(#+ @B ;*')%++'* C"/(< ;"(<4 / :%/6"(<

:%</: +>$':/* /(6 )'*1%* 1%1@%* ') #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%%

!

["+ >'11%(#+ 2'( #$% %9% ') #$% P/*>$

DEWD 7;0 +%++"'(3 .*'9"6% / @/:/(>%6 >'(>:-+"'(\

"

!$%( A% #/:I /@'-# #$% *-:% ') :/A4 A% >/(('# +.%/I "(

<%(%*/: #%*1+

!

J'1% #$"(<+ /*% 1'9"(< )'*A/*64 +->$ /+ :%<"+:/#"'(

!

L(6 #$% <'9%*(1%(# $/+ 1/6% %))'*#+

A"#$ *%</*6 #' +.%>")"> "++-%+ +->$ /+ "(>*%/+%6 #*/(+./*%(>B /(6 #$% 6"+>:'+-*% ') <'9%*(1%(# "()'*1/#"'(4

"(>:-6"(< #$% <'9%*(1%(# H + @-6<%#

''

X-*#$%*1'*%4 "( #$% B%/*+ /)#%* 0$"(/ H + ;*'.%*#B O/A A/+ ./++%64

.*'#%>#"'( ') "(6"9"6-/: *"<$#+ $/+ /:+' "(>*%/+%6

''

['A%9%*4 R )%%: #$%*% /*% +#":: +%9%*/: #$"(<+ :/>I"(<

!

K(% "+

#$% *%)'*1 ') #$% .':"#">/: +B+#%1

''

7'* 6'%+ '-* >'(+#"#-#"'( +-))">"%(#:B .*'#%># >"#"Y%(H+ *"<$#+4 %+.%>"/::B

#$% *"<$# #' )*%% +.%%>$4 #$% *"<$# #' .-@:"+$ /(6 6"++%1"(/#% "()'*1/#"'(4 #$% )*%%6'1 ') #$% .*%++ /(6

)*%%6'1 ') /++'>"/#"'(

!

G$%*% $/+ @%%( (' .*'<*%++ "( #$%+% /*%/+4 /(6 "( +'1% *%+.%>#+4 #$% <'9%*(1%(# H+

.'A%* "+ %S./(6"(<

!

G$%+% /*% /:: %9"6%(>% ') *%<*%++"'(

!#

$

^`

!

G$%+% >$/::%(<%+ "( *%/>$"(< *-:% ') :/A +%*9% /+ / *%1"(6%* #$/# *-:% ') :/A "+ ('# /( '@&%>#"9%:B 9%*")"/@:%

"(6">/#'* #$/# >/( @% 1/*I%6 ')) /+

"

/>$"%9%6

#

'* ('#

!

J#"::4 >'(#"(-"(< / .'+"#"9% #*%(6 "( *-:% ') :/A

"(6">/#'*+ "(#' #$% )-#-*% A":: .*'@/@:B *%?-"*% .*'<*%++ "( >*%/#"(< #$% I"(6 ') :%</: +B+#%1 %(9"+/<%6 @B #$%

7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% "( DEWW \

" %

L

&

+ A% >'(#"(-% #' +#*%(<#$%( :%<"+:/#"9% A'*I4 A% (%%6 #' #/I% />#"9% /(6 %))%>#"9% 1%/+-*%+ #'

$!

!

"

#

$

K,08 DEEb /# D]

!

K,08 DEEb /# FE

"

FW

!

K,08 DEEb /# FW

!

8-/( DEWD

!

Page 24: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

<%(-"(%:B <-/*/(#%% #$% %))%>#"9% %()'*>%1%(# ') #$% 0'(+#"#-#"'( /(6 :/A+

!

X"*+#4 A% (%%6 #' -.$':6 #$%"*

/-#$'*"#B /(6 6"<("#B

!

L:: +#/#% '*</(+4 /*1%6 )'*>%+4 .':"#">/: ./*#"%+4 1/++ '*</("Y/#"'(+4 %(#%*.*"+%+ /(6

"(+#"#-#"'(+ 1-+# /@"6% @B #$%1

!

7' '*</("Y/#"'( '* "(6"9"6-/: $/+ /(B .*"9":%<%+ #$/# #*/(+>%(6 #$%14 /(6 /::

9"':/#"'(+ ') #$% 0'(+#"#-#"'( /(6 :/A+ 1-+# @% .*'+%>-#%6

!

J%>'(64 A% (%%6 #' /6$%*% #' :/A

"

@/+%6

/61"("+#*/#"'( /(6 &-6">"/: &-+#">%

!

J#/#% /61"("+#*/#"9% '*</(+ 1-+# .%*)'*1 #$%"* 6-#"%+ "( +#*"># >'1.:"/(>%

A"#$ +#/#-#'*B /-#$'*"#B /(6 .*'>%6-*%+4 /(6 />>%:%*/#% #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') :/A

"

@/+%6 <'9%*(1%(#

!

J#/#%

&-6">"/: /(6 .*'>-*/#'*"/: '*</(+ 1-+# %S%*>"+% #$%"* &-6">"/: /(6 .*'>-*/#'*"/: .'A%*+ "( /( "(6%.%(6%(# /(6

&-+# 1/((%*4 /(6 -.$':6 +'>"/: %?-"#B /(6 &-+#">%

!

G$"*64 A% (%%6 #' %($/(>% #$% /A/*%(%++ ') :/A+ /(6 #$%

*-:% ') :/A />*'++ +'>"%#B

!#

!

I;J G><CB?BG>C9<P >=F B=?EANB:; >GG<9>?O;NL H$*4+.)707 C#)$& +.&

<$5)$%$&

^b

!

;*'&%># ;-*.'+%\ ./*#">"./#'*B /..*'/>$%+ "( :%<"+:/#"9%4 &-6">"/: /(6 <'9%*(1%(# .*'>%++%+

!

G$% ;*'&%>#

;-*.'+% A/+ #' .*'1'#% ./*#">"./#'*B /(6 "(>:-+"9% /..*'/>$%+ #' +%:%>#%6 :%<"+:/#"9%4 &-6">"/: /(6 <'9%*(1%(#

.*'>%++%+

!

G$%+% /..*'/>$%+ /*% +-11/*"Y%6 $%*% A"#$ / )'>-+ '( :%<"+:/#"9% /(6 &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ 1'*%

>:'+%:B *%:/#%6 #' #$% ;*'&%>#

!

##

KTR\ R(>*%/+% "( #$% */(<% /(6 (-1@%*+ ') 1%>$/("+1+ )'* ./*#">"./#"'( ') >"9": +'>"%#B "( :%</:

.*'>%++%+ /(6 .':">B 6%9%:'.1%(# #*"%6 /(6 *%9"%A%6Q

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6Q P%>$/("+1+ )'* "(>*%/+%6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(<

$/9% @%%( 6%9%:'.%6 6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'64 /+ +-11/*"Y%6 -(6%* 2L3 /(6 2N3 /@'9%Q J'1% ') #$%+%

1%>$/("+1+4 +->$ /+ .":'#+ '( .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ "( !-Y$'(<4 L8V "( ;-6'(<4 '.%( >'-*#+ "( =/(+-4 /(6

.'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A $/9% @%%( *%9"%A%6 #$*'-<$ ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+Q ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ "(>:-6%6 />#"9%

>'(+-:#/#"'(+ A"#$ >"9": +'>"%#B "( 6%9%:'.1%(# ') 0JK

"

*%:/#%6 .':">"%+ +->$ /+ 6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'(4 #/S

%S%1.#"'( /(6 0JK 1/(/<%1%(#Q

ITJ K(&)*)+, G#"*$77$7

]E

!

J%9%*/: ') #$% *%)'*1+ ('#%6 /@'9% "(>'*.'*/#% ./*#">"./#'*B /(6 "(>:-+"9% /..*'/>$%+ #' />>%++ #' &-+#">%4

"(>:-6"(< '.%( #*"/:+4 .%'.:% H + 1%6"/#"'( >'11"##%%+4 /(6 >'-*#+ A'*I"(< "( +'>"%#B4 '-#+"6% #$%

>'-*#*''1

!

=,8 />#"9"#"%+ +-..'*#%6 / (-1@%* ') #$%+% *%)'*1+\ >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'(4 &-6">"/: '.%((%++

/(6 *%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1

!

=,8

"

+-..'*#%6 .":'#+ "( .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ *%)'*1+ 2N'S W 3 /(6

1%6"/#"'( *%)'*1+ 2N'S c 3 A%*% *%9"%A%6 #$*'-<$ ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+4 /+ A/+ #$% =/(+- '.%( >'-*# .":'#

!

]W

!

;%'.:% H + L++%++'*+ V%)'*1+

!

5(6%* / 6%>"+"'( ') #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% %))%>#"9% "( DEE] 4

"(6"9"6-/:+ 1/B @% .*'.'+%6 )'* +%:%>#"'( /+ /++%++'*+ ('# '(:B @B #$%"* <*/++*''#+ '*</("Y/#"'(+4 @-# /:+' @B

%!

! J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% DEWW !'*I V%.'*#

!

Page 25: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

#$% "(6"9"6-/:+ #$%1+%:9%+

!

!

G$% (-1@%* ') .%'.:% H + /++%++'*+4 /..'"(#%6 #' )"9%

"

B%/* #%*1+ 2@B #$% O;0

+#/(6"(< >'11"##%% '( ('1"(/#"'( @B #$% :'>/: >'-*#34 +$'-:6 ('# @% :%++ #$/( '(%

"

#$"*6 ') #$% (-1@%* ')

"(>-1@%(# &-6<%+ "( %/>$ <*/++*''#+ >'-*#

!

R(>:-+"9%(%++ "+ %1.$/+"Y%6 "( / DEWE J;0 7'#">%4 .*'9"6"(< #$/#

"

/##%(#"'( +$/:: @% ./"6 #' #$% +#*->#-*% /(6 .*'.'*#"'( ') .%'.:% )*'1 6"))%*%(# A/:I+ ') :")% /(6 #'

/@+'*@"(< #$% .%'.:% ') 6"))%*%(# "(6-+#*"%+4 .*')%++"'(+4 /<%+4 (/#"'(/:"#"%+ /(6 <%(6%*+4 %#>

!

+' /+ #' *%):%>#

#$% 9/*"'-+ @/>I<*'-(6+ /(6 *%.*%+%(#/#"9%(%++ ') #$% /++%++'*+

!#

"

G$% */(6'1 +%:%>#"'( ') /++%++'*+ )'* /

./*#">-:/* >/+% /:+' $%"<$#%(+ "(>:-+"9%(%++4 /(6 #$% +%:%>#"'( @B >'1.-#%* .*'<*/14 "(>:-6"(< )*'1 +.%>"/:"Y%6

/++%++'* .'':+4 %($/(>%+ ./*#">"./#"'(

!

]D

!

G$%+% *%)'*1+ /:+' '))%* +'1% .'#%(#"/: 6%#%**%(>% #' '9%*# &-6">"/: >'**-.#"'( /(6 /66 :%<"#"1/>B #' #$%

>'-*# +B+#%1

!

#

7%9%*#$%:%++4 '(% ?-%+#"'( #$/# >'(#"(-%+ )*'1 #$% ./+# "+ A$%#$%* .%'.:% H + /++%++'* H +

./*#">"./#"'( "( #*"/:+ "+ +-@+#/(#"9%:B 1%/("(<)-:

!

K(% '9%*9"%A ') #$% )-(>#"'( ') .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ .*"'* #'

DEE] ('#%6\

"

.%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ 6' ('# >'(+#"#-#% / *%+#*">#"'( '( #$% .'A%* ') 0$"(%+% &-6<%+ /(6 -+-/::B

/*% *%</*6%6 /+

(

6%>'*/#"'(H+ "( #$% >'-*#*''1

!#

$

L DEEF +-*9%B "( '(% .*'9"(>% +-<<%+#%6 #$/# #$%"* *':%4

A"#$ 1"('* %S>%.#"'(+4 *%1/"(+ .-*%:B +B1@':">

!

%

]c

!

L 1'*% *%>%(# +-*9%B .'"(#+ #' "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( #$% )*/1%A'*I )'* .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ /+ A%:: /+ / .'+"#"9%

#*%(6 "( #$%"* "1./>#

!

&

X"*+#4 #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% 8%>"+"'( *%1%6"%6 +'1% %/*:"%* .*'@:%1+ "( #$%

+B+#%14 +->$ /+ :/>I ') 6%)"("#"'( ') /++%++'*H+ .'A%*+4 )/"*%* +%:%>#"'( ') /++%++'*+4 /(6 #'' >:'+% / *%:/#"'(+$".

A"#$ >'-*#+

!

J%>'(64 >"#"(< %1."*">/: *%+%/*>$4 #$% /-#$'* >'(>:-6%+ #$/# .%'.:% H+ /++%++'*+ /*% ('A .:/B"(<

1-:#".:% *':%+ "( /6&-6">/#"'(\ "( #*"/:+4 "( 1%6"/#"'( ') 6"+.-#%+4 '9%*+"<$# '9%* &-6<%+ /(6 .-@:">"#B ') *-:% ')

:/A

!

NB <%##"(< / @%##%* -(6%*+#/(6"(< ') >'-*# .*'>%%6"(<+4 *-:%+ ') %9"6%(>%4 "(#%*(/: >'-*# *-:%+ /(6 6/B

"

#'

"

6/B A'*I4 .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ /*% @%##%* /@:% #' /># /+ / >'(+#*/"(# A"#$"( / >'::%<"/: @%(>$ /(6 #' "(>*%/+%

#*/(+./*%(>B /(6 >*%6"@":"#B

!

G$% /-#$'* >'(>:-6%+ #$/#

"

?-"#% / :'# ') &-6<%+ $%%6 '."("'(+ /(6 &-6<1%(#+ ')

.%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+

#

/(6 #$% .-@:"> $/+ @%%( .'+"#"9%

!

'

]^

!

L+ "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( #$% )*/1%A'*I )'* .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ A%*% "++-%6 @B #$% J;0 "( DEWE /(6 DEWW 4 1'*%

#"1% 1/B @% (%%6%6 #' /++%++ #$% "1./># ') #$%+% *%)'*1+

!

R( #$/# :"<$#4 "# "+ .%*$/.+ 1'*% .*-6%(# #' >'(>-*

&!

!

"

#

$

%

&

'

R(H#7#-3 -, 1"( D1*3%#3F 8-..#11(( -, 1"( S*1#-3*2 4(-52(67 8-3F$(77 +(F*$%#3F 4($,(H1#3F 1"( DM71(. -, 4(-52(67

O77(77-$7C L-<-+# DEE^

!

S-1#H( -, 1"( D05$(.( 4(-52(67 8-0$1 -3 L770#3F 1"( D-.( O%'#H( -3 D1$(3F1"(3#3F *3% 4$-.-1#3F 1"( P-$K -,

4(-52(67 O77(77-$7 4 C-(% DEWE

!

O/(6+1/( l k$/(< DEE` /# DWc

!

k$'(< l U- DEE^ 4 >"#"(< J-( C-(<'(<4 +(3.#3 4(#7"(3M0*3 D"#

"

T*#7"(

#

.*U

%

O$( 4(-52( 6 7 O77(77-$7C

"

R(H-$*1#-37

#

#3 1"( 8-0$1$--.h

&

4 XLk[R VRNLK

%

O,=LO 8LROU

&

4 X%@

!

Wb 4 DEEW 4 *'*#2*J2( *1 $##.\ gg

f AAA

!

:%</:6/":B

!

>'1

!

>(g<@g>'(#%(#gDEEW

"

EDgWbg>'(#%(#j Wc]Eb

!

$#1

!

N/:1% DEWE /# WFc

!

!/(< DEWW

!

R6

!

Page 26: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

A"#$ /('#$%* '@+%*9%* #$/# 1'*% %1."*">/: *%+%/*>$ "+ (%%6%6 #' 6%#%*1"(% #$% "1./># ') 9/*"'-+ *%)'*1+ "(

#$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1

!

!

D9Q T

!

G$"6,$X7 >77$77"#7L C4$ M(Y4".2 G),"3 <$-"#07

0"#"Y%(+ /*% /..'"(#%6 @B #$% :'>/: .%'.:% H + >'(<*%++ +#/(6"(< >'11"##%% #' +%*9% / ]

"

B%/* #%*1 /+

.%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+4 ./*#">"./#"(< "( >/+%+ ') #$% )"*+# "(+#/(>% #*"%6 @B / >'::%<"/: ./(%: ') &-6<%+ /(6

/++%++'*+

!

R( #$% -+-/: c

"

.%*+'( ./(%:4 #$%*% A'-:6 @% '(% '* #A' .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+4 <%(%*/::B )'*\ 2/3

>*"1"(/:4 >"9": /(6 /61"("+#*/#"9% >/+%+ A"#$ *%:/#"9%:B <*%/# "1./># '( +'>"%#Bd /(6 2 @ 3 >/+%+ A$%*%

./*#">"./#"'( ') /++%++'*+ "+ *%?-%+#%6 @B #$% 6%)%(6/(# "( / >*"1"(/: >/+%4 #$% .:/"(#")) '* 6%)%(6/(# "( /

>"9": >/+%4 '* #$% .:/"(#")) "( /( /61"("+#*/#"9% >/+%

!

L >"#"Y%( '9%* /<% Dc 1/B @% %"#$%* *%>'11%(6%6 @B

$"+g$%* <*/++*''#+ '*</("Y/#"'( '* /..:B 6"*%>#:B #' #$% 6"+#*"># >'-*# )'* >'(+"6%*/#"'(

!

;%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+

/*% */(6'1:B +%:%>#%6 )'* %/>$ >/+%

!

;%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ /*% 1%1@%*+ ') #$% 6"9"+"'(+ ') #$% >'-*#+ "( A$">$

#$%B ./*#">"./#% /(6 %(&'B %?-/: *"<$#+ A"#$ &-6<%+

!

R( P/*>$ DEE` 4 !-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*# A/+ "6%(#")"%6 @B #$% J;0 #' .":'# *%)'*1+ "( #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+

+B+#%1

!

m%B %:%1%(#+ ') #$% .":'#\

!L..'"(#1%(#

!

V%+"6%(#+ '* #$'+% A$' A'*I "( !-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># /(6 $/9% /# :%/+# c B%/*+ ') >'::%<%

%6->/#"'( '* /*% -("9%*+"#B <*/6-/#%+ /*% %:"<"@:%4 @-# .%*+'(+ A"#$ :%</: #*/"("(< 2 :/AB%*+4 &-6<%+4

.*'+%>-#'*+3 /*% ('# %:"<"@:%

!

G$% '9%*/:: *'+#%* >'9%*+ @'#$ -*@/( /(6 *-*/:4 A"#$ *%.*%+%(#/#"'( )*'1 /::

9"::/<%+4 #'A(+ /(6 >'11-("#"%+4 /+ A%:: /+ 6"9%*+"#B ') .*')%++"'(+4 /<%4 /(6 <%(6%*

!

R( #$% ./+#4 1'+#

/++%++'*+ A%*% *%>'11%(6%6 @B #$%"* A'*I -("#+4 A$":% #'6/B /@'-# FEe /*% +%:)

"

.*'.'+%6

!

;-@:">"#B A/+

-+%6 #' %(>'-*/<% /..:">/#"'(+ A"#$ / :%(<#$%(%6 /..:">/#"'( .%*"'6d /..:">/#"'(+ /*% ('A />>%.#%6

>'(#"(-'-+:B

!

0-**%(#:B4 !-Y$'(< $/+ / 6/#/@/+% ') .'#%(#"/: /..:">/(#+ /(6 >-**%(#:B `E /++%++'*+

/..'"(#%6

!

!;/*#">"./#"'(

!

P'+# ') :/+# B%/*H+ ` 4 EEE >/+%+ A%*% $%/*6 @B / +"(<:% &-6<%d #$%*% A%*% >'::%<"/: ./(%:+

"( /@'-# W 4 EEE >/+%+

!

L++%++'*+ ./*#">"./#%6 "( b`e ') #$%+% ./(%:+

!

P'+# ./(%:+ "(>:-6%6 '(% &-6<%

/(6 #A' .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+4 %S>%.# )'* :%</::B >'1.:%S >/+%+ A$%*% #$%*% A'-:6 @% '(:B '(% /++%++'*

!

G$%

/9%*/<% >/+%:'/6 )'* / .%'.:%H+ /++%++'* "+ WD >/+%+ .%* B%/*

!

0'1.%(+/#"'( "+ /@'-# WDE VPN U-/( .%*

>/+%

!

!J%:%>#"'( "( +.%>")"> >/+%+

!

G$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'* '))">% "+ 1/(/<%6 @B '(% ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+4 A$'

-+%+ / >'1.-#%* 6/#/@/+% )'* */(6'1 +%:%>#"'( ') /++%++'*+

!

L++%++'*+ )'* / ./*#">-:/* >/+% >/( @% +%:%>#%6

/# */(6'1 A"#$"( )"9% 6"))%*%(# .'':+4 6%.%(6"(< '( #$% (%%6+ ') #$% >/+% 2%

!

<

!

4 )/1":B4 :/@'*4 &-9%(":%4

>'11%*>"/: '* /61"("+#*/#"9% >/+%+

!

3

!V':%

!

;%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ %(&'B %?-/: *"<$#+ A"#$ &-6<%+

!

R) #$%*% "+ / 6"+/<*%%1%(# '( :%</: "++-%+4 #$%

>/+% 1/B <' #' #$% &-6">"/: >'11"##%% ') #$% >'-*#4 /(6 #$% $%/6 ') #$/# >'11"##%% A'-:6 6%>"6%

!

K#$%*A"+%4 1/&'*"#B *-:%+4 /(6 #A' /++%++'*+ >/( '9%**"6% #$% '@&%>#"'(+ ') '(% &-6<%

!

'!

! 0'$%( DEWW 4 ('#"(< #$/#

"

6%+."#% "(#%*1"##%(# <'9%*(1%(# %))'*#+ #' @':+#%* A$/# "+ +-..'+%6 #' @% / 1"S%6 >'-*#4

.%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ $/9% )/":%6 #' .:/B /( "(6%.%(6%(# *':%

!#

G$% /*#">:% 6"+>-++%+ / &-*B ./(%: 1'6%: "( [%(/( .*'9"(>%

!

Page 27: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

IUJ E$2)7,+3)5$ G#"*$77$7

]]

!

G$% <'9%*(1%(# !$"#% ;/.%* '( J'>"/:"+# O%</: JB+#%1 A"#$ 0$"(%+% 0$/*/>#%*"+#">+ 2 K>#'@%* DEWW 34

%>$'"(< #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% V%.'*# '( !'*I "( P/*>$ DEWW 4 %1.$/+"Y%+ ./*#">"./#'*B /(6 "(>:-+"9%

/..*'/>$%+ "( :/A1/I"(<\

"

!% A":: A'*I #' .*'1'#% +>"%(#")"> /(6 6%1'>*/#"> :%<"+:/#"'(4 /(6 "1.*'9% :%<"+:/#"'( ?-/:"#B

!

!% A"::

"1.*'9% #$% 1%>$/("+1 A$%*%@B 7;0 6%.-#"%+ /*% "(9':9%6 "( :%<"+:/#"'(4 /(6 @*"(< #$%"* *':% #' #$% )-::

''

!% A":: %S.:'*% H"*33(27 *3% ,-$.7 ,-$ 1"( 50J2#H 1- 5*$1#H#5*1( #3 2(F#72*1#-3 *H1#'#1#(7 "( /( '*6%*:B 1/((%*4

f "1.*'9% ./(%: 6"+>-++"'(+4 )%/+"@":"#B +#-6B 1%%#"(<+4 "(*$#3F7 -3 2(F#72*1#-3 /(6 #$% </#$%*"(< ') .-@:">

f '."("'( #$*'-<$ #$% 50J2#H*1#-3 -, %$*,1 2*B7 *3% $(F02*1#-374 /(6 %+#/@:"+$ /(6 "1.*'9% #$% 1%>$/("+1

f #$*'-<$ A$">$ .-@:"> '."("'( >/( @% $%/*6 /(6 )%%6@/>I >/( @% <"9%(4 +' /+ #' :%# :%<"+:/#"'( *%):%># #$% A"::

') #$% .-@:">

!

!% A":: %+#/@:"+$ /(6 "1.*'9% / 1%>$/("+1 )%/#-*"(< ,(*7#J#2#1M 710%#(7 J(,-$( .*K#3F 2(F#72*1#-3

/(6 ('*20*1#-3 *,1($ .*K#3F 2(F#72*1#-34 >'(+#/(#:B %(6%/9'* #' 1/I% :%<"+:/#"'( 1'*% +>"%(#")"> /(6

f *%/+'(/@:%4 /(6 )-*#$%* "1.*'9% #$% .*/>#">/:"#B ') :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+

!#

!

J%9%*/: ') #$%+% /..*'/>$%+ $/9% @%%( .":'#%6 "( #$% .%*"'6 -(6%* *%9"%A\ "(>*%/+"(<:B >'11'( 1%>$/("+1+

)'* .-@:"> >'11%(# '( 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'(4 "(.-#+ )*'1 "1.:%1%(#/#"'(4 :%<"+:/#"9% /<%(6/

"

+%##"(<4 /(6 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

"

O%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+ /*% /('#$%* ') #$% ./*#">"./#'*B /..*'/>$%+ @%"(< 6%9%:'.%6

!

#

]_

!

N'S D "::-+#*/#%+ %S/1.:%+ ') .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(< /# #$% .*'9"(>"/: :%9%:

!

!$":% #$% C"/(<+-

1'6%:4 )'* "(+#/(>%4 *%:"%+ $%/9":B '( "(#%*(%# .'+#"(<+4 A$">$ >'-:6 *%+#*"># />>%++ #' #$'+% A"#$ *%:"/@:% /(6

+%>-*% "(#%*(%# />>%++4 #$%*% "+ /:+' .*'9"+"'( )'* .-@:">"Y"(< 6*/)#+ "( (%A+./.%*+4 /(6 *%>%"9"(< >'11%(#+ @B

1/": '* "( .%*+'(

!

J'1%#"1%+4 )'*-1+ /*% $%:6 -(6%* #$% /-+.">%+ ') :'A%*

"

:%9%: .%'.:%H+ >'(<*%++%+4 +' #$/# "(

.%*+'( /##%(6/(>% "( :'>/:"#"%+ "+ /:+' .'++"@:%

!

G$% 7;0 .*/>#">% /:+' .%*1"#+ ('(

"

%:%>#*'("> />>%++

!

]F

!

=,8 />#"9"#"%+ +-..'*#%6 +%9%*/: ') #$%+% *%)'*1+ 2.-@:"> >'11%(# 1%>$/("+1+4 :%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+4 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"'( %9/:-/#"'(4 /(6 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A3Q V%+-:#+ ') *%)'*1 %S.%*"%(>%+ A%*% 6"+>-++%6 /(6 /++%++%6 "(

;*'&%># )'*-1+

!

(!

!

"

#

J#/#% 0'-(>": R()'*1/#"'( K))">% DEWW 4 %1.$/+"+ /66%6

!

G$%+% 1%>$/("+1+ /*% 6"+>-++%6 "( ./*/<*/.$+ D^

"

cc /@'9%

!

[%/*"(<+ /*% 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# N4 V%+-:# W@4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ WEb

"

WWD

!

Page 28: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

D"R U

!

G(Z,)* G+#3)*)6+3)". ). E+%

"

0+1).2 +3 G#"5).*)+, E$5$,

R( C"/(<+-4 #$% O'>/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++ 2O;03 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% -+%+ +%9%*/: >$/((%:+ -(6%* "#+ DEEb

V%<-:/#"'( '( ;*'1'#"(< ;-@:"> ;/*#">"./#"'( "( O/A

"

1/I"(< #' <%# .-@:"> "(.-#\

!J':">"#"(< .*'.'+/:+ )'* X"9% U%/* O%<"+:/#"9% L<%(6/ /(6 L((-/: O%<"+:/#"9% ;:/(

!

R( #$% ./+# WE B%/*+4

#$% O;0 /(6 O'>/: ;%'.:% H + ='9%*(1%(# $/9% 1/6% #$%"* X"9% U%/* O%<"+:/#"9% L<%(6/+ /(6 L((-/:

O%<"+:/#"9% ;:/(+ /9/":/@:% '( "(#%*(%# /(6 1/&'* 1%6"/

!

G$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> >/( 1/I% +-<<%+#"'(+ @B 1/":4

"(#%*(%# '* '))">% 9"+"#+

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 A$%( 6%9%:'."(< "#+ >-**%(# X"9% U%/* O%<"+:/#"9% L<%(6/4 #$% C"/(<+-

;*'9"(>"/: ;0 >'::%>#%6 ^D_ :%<"+:/#"9% .*'.'+/:+ )*'1 /:: +'-*>%+4 "(>:-6"(< Dc .*'.'+/:+ )*'1 DE

"(6"9"6-/:+4 A$">$ :%6 #' +"S :%<"+:/#"9% /<%(6/ "#%1+

!

!J%%I"(< .-@:"> >'11%(#+ '( 6*/)# .*'9"(>"/: :%<"+:/#"'(

!

N%#A%%( #$% )"*+# /(6 #$% +%>'(6 *%/6"(<+ ')

O;0 :%<"+:/#"'(4 /:: 6*/)#+ /*% .'+#%6 '( #$% O;0 A%@+"#% )'* .-@:"> >'11%(#+

!

X'* #$'+% >:'+%:B *%:/#%6 #'

#$% +'>"%#B4 #$% )-:: #%S#+ /*% /:+' .-@:">"Y%6 #$*'-<$ 1/&'* 1%6"/ 2W` 6*/)#+ #$*'-<$ DEWW 3Q O'A%*

"

:%9%:

O;0+ $/9% /:+' *'-#"(%:B .-@:">"Y%6 #$%"* 6*/)# *%<-:/#"'(+ '( #$% A%@+"#%+ ') #$% .%'.:%H+ >'(<*%++%+ '*

<'9%*(1%(#+

!

!0'(6->#"(< :%<"+:/#"'( *%+%/*>$ "( 9/*"'-+ )'*1+

!

V%+%/*>$ "+ >'(6->#%6 )'* %/>$ 6*/)# *%<-:/#"'(4 A"#$ /::

*%:%9/(# <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ /(6 +#/I%$':6%*+ /##%(6"(< )'*-1+ '* +%1"(/*+ $%:6 />*'++ #$% .*'9"(>%

!

![':6"(< .-@:"> $%/*"(<+ )'* :/A+ >:'+%:B *%:/#%6 #' .%'.:%

!

L .-@:"> $%/*"(< A":: @% $%:64 ") #$% >'(#%(# ')

/ :%<"+:/#"'(\ >'(>%*(+ .*'9"(>%

"

A"6% %>'('1"> /(6 +'>"/: 6%9%:'.1%(#d *%:/#%+ #' "1.'*#/(# "(#%*%+#+ ')

>"#"Y%(+4 :%</: .%*+'(+ '* '#$%* %(#"#"%+d '* >/-+%+ 1/&'* 6"))%*%(>%+ ') 9"%A

!

J"(>% DEEE 4 )"9% .-@:">

$%/*"(<+ $/9% @%%( $%:6

!

X'* %/>$ .-@:"> $%/*"(<4 / +%# ') *-:%+ "+ "++-%64 '*</("Y%*+ /(6 1/&'*

./*#">"./(#+ /*% "6%(#")"%64 $%/*"(< ('#">% "+ .-@:">"Y%6 '( :'>/: .%'.:% H+ >'(<*%++ A%@+"#% /(6 "( 1/&'*

:'>/: 1%6"/ DE 6/B+ "( /69/(>%

!

[%/*"(< ./*#">"./(#+ "(>:-6% +"1":/* (-1@%*+ ') +.%/I%*+ $':6"(< 6"))%*%(#

9"%A+4 *%:%9/(# +#/I%$':6%*+ /(6 %S.%*#+

!

L:: $%/*"(<+ /*% .-@:">4 /::'A"(< 1%6"/ *%.'*#+ /(6 .-@:">

'@+%*9/#"'(

!

8-*"(< #$% $%/*"(<+4 9"%A+ )*'1 6"))%*%(# ./*#"%+ A":: @% +':">"#%6 /(6 .-@:"> /##%(6/(#+ >/(

/:+' '))%* #$%"* '."("'(+d 6%@/#%+ $/9% @%%( "(#*'6->%6

!

G*/(+>*".#+ /*% .'+#%6 .*'1.#:B /)#%*A/*6+ /(6 /

$%/*"(< *%.'*# "+ +-@1"##%6 #' #$% O;0 A"#$"( WE A'*I6/B+

!

7%>%++/*B *%+%/*>$ "+ >'(6->#%6 '( 9/*"'-+

9"%A+ .*%+%(#%6 6-*"(< #$% $%/*"(< /(6 *%+.'(+%+ /*% %"#$%* "(>:-6%6 "( $%/*"(< *%.'*# '* "( #$% )"(/:

*%9"%A *%.'*# '( #$% *%<-:/#"'(+ >'(>%*(%6

!

!J':">"#"(< 9"%A+ )*'1 .%'.:%H+ *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+4 +>$':/*+ /(6 %S.%*#+

!

X'* %/>$ 6*/)# *%<-:/#"'(4 A*"##%( :%##%*+

/*% +%(# #' #$% .%'.:%+H *%.*%+%(#/#"9%4 +>$':/*+ /(6 %S.%*#+ #' +':">"# #$%"* 9"%A+ 2W^EE *%+.'(+%+ "( DEWW3Q

R( J$//(S"4 #A' .-@:"> $%/*"(<+ A%*% >'(6->#%6 2"( DEED /(6 DEE^3Q R( #$% (%/* )-#-*%4 .-@:"> $%/*"(<+ A":: @%

$%:6 %9%*B B%/* '( #A' #' #$*%% 6*/)#+ ') :%<"+:/#"'( >:'+%:B *%:/#%6 #' .-@:"> :")%

!

;-@:"> >'11%(#+ A":: @%

+':">"#%6

!

J' )/*4 #$%*% "+ (' -(")'*1 .-@:"> $%/*"(< .*'>%6-*% /..:">/@:% .*'9"(>% A"6%

!

G' <-/*/(#%% $%/*"(<

?-/:"#B4 *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+ A":: @% +%:%>#%6 )*'1 <%(%*/: .-@:"> #' ./*#">"./#% "( #$% $%/*"(<+

!

J#/)) /# #$% :'>/: ;0+ A":: @*"(< 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( #' #$% >'11-("#"%+ )'* .-@:"> >'11%(#+4 /(6 %S.%*#+ /(6

.%'.:%H + *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+ A":: @% "(9"#%6 #' ./*#">"./#% "( )%/+"@":"#B +#-6"%+ /(6 <"9% +-<<%+#"'(+ )'*

*%9"+"'(+

!

)!

Page 29: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

IWJ ?)5), N"*)$3/ G+#3)*)6+3)".

]`

!

G$%*% /*% 6%9%:'.1%(#+ "( #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6 #$/# >'-:6 /))%># #$% .'#%(#"/: )'* >"9": +'>"%#B #' #/I%

/69/(#/<% ') ./*#">"./#'*B /..*'/>$%+ "( &-6">"/: /(6 :%<"+:/#"9% .*'>%++%+

!

]b

!

L( "1.'*#/(# #'': )'* >"9": +'>"%#B ./*#">"./#"'( "+ />>%++ #' "()'*1/#"'(

!

R( P/B DEE` 4 0$"(/ H+ K.%(

='9%*(1%(# R()'*1/#"'( 2 K=R 3 V%<-:/#"'(+ >/1% "(#' %))%>#

!

0"#"Y%(+ 1/B *%?-%+# <'9%*(1%(#

"()'*1/#"'( #$/# $/+ ('# @%%( 6"+>:'+%64 /(6 1/B +%%I /61"("+#*/#"9% '* &-6">"/: *%9"%A ") <'9%*(1%(#+

*%)-+%

!

L>#-/: "1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') K=R *%)'*1+ *%1/"(+ -(%9%(

!

!

G$% <'9%*(1%(# >'(#"(-%6 #' .*'1'#%

/61"("+#*/#"9% :/A *%)'*1 #' .*'9"6% <*%/#%* '9%*+"<$# ') +#/#% /<%(>"%+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# %1.:'B%%+ /(6

#' .*'#%># >"#"Y%( H + "(#%*%+#+

!

"

GA' (%A :%<"+:/#"9% 6%9%:'.1%(#+ #$/# /*% ./*# ') #$%+% *%)'*1+ /*% #$%

O%.#3#71$*1#'( D05($'#7#-3 A*B 4 %))%>#"9% "( C-(% DEWE 4 /(6 #$% D1*1( 8-.5(37*1#-3 A*B 4 /1%(6%6 "(

f 8%>%1@%* DEWE

!

_E

!

G$% '9%*/:: *%<-:/#'*B %(9"*'(1%(# )'* %+#/@:"+$1%(# /(6 '.%*/#"'( ') 0JK+ $/+ >'(#"(-%6 #' %9':9% '9%*

#$% .%*"'6

!

G$% #$*%% *%<-:/#"'(+ )'* +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+4 .*"9/#% ('(

"

%(#%*.*"+% -("#+4 /(6 )'-(6/#"'(+4 $/9%

@%%( *%9"+%6 /(6 +%(# #' #$% J#/#% 0'-(>":4 A"#$ #$% %S.%>#/#"'( ') "++-/(>% "( DEWD

!

L1'(< '#$%* *%)'*1+4

#$% 6*/)# *%<-:/#"'(+ /*% %S.%>#%6 #' *%1'9% 6-/: +.'(+'*+$". *%?-"*%1%(#+ /(6 .%*1"# +"(<:%

*%<"+#*/#"'(

!

V%1'9"(< #$% +.'(+'*+$". *%?-"*%1%(# "+ +%%( /+ / A/B #' %/+% 0JK %+#/@:"+$1%(#d "# >'-:6 /:+'

)/>":"#/#% ./*#">"./#"'( "( &-6">"/: /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(< .*'>%++%+

!

#

_W

!

R( <%(%*/:4 1'*% 0JK ./*#">"./#"'( "( #$% .':">B .*'>%++ $/+ @%%( ('#%6 "( *%>%(# B%/*+

!

K(% *%>%(# +#-6B

('#%6\

"

/ >'11'( #*%(6 %1%*<%+4 A$">$ "+ #$% "(>*%/+"(< ./*#">"./#"'( @B #$%+% <*'-.+ "( #$% .':">B

.*'>%++

!

R( )/>#4 1/(B +>$':/*+ $/9% )'-(6 #$/# >"9": +'>"%#B <*'-.+ ./*#">"./#% "( @'#$ +%*9">% 6%:"9%*B /(6

.':">B /69'>/>B4 %9%( ") '(:B "()'*1/::B /+ ./*# ') #$% +%*9">%

"

6%:"9%*B *':%4 "( .':">B /*%/+ /+ 6"9%*+% /+

%6->/#"'(4 $%/:#$ >/*%4 %(9"*'(1%(#4 .'9%*#B /::%9"/#"'(4 @-+"(%++ *%<-:/#"'( /(6 "(#%*(/#"'(/: #*/6%

!

G$%

%(9"*'(1%(# $/+ %1%*<%6 /+ / .':">B /*%/ A"#$ #$% 1'+# >"9": +'>"%#B ./*#">"./#"'(

''#

$

='9%*(1%(#

>'(+-:#/#"'( A"#$ 0JK+ '( "1.'*#/(# "++-%+4 +->$ /+ +':-#"'(+ #' #$% <:'@/: )"(/(>"/: >*"+"+4 /((-/: *%9"%A

*%<-:/#"'( )'* "(#%*(/#"'(/: 7=K+4 #/S %S%1.#"'( +#/(6/*6+ /(6 6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'( +B+#%14 A/+ ('#%6 @B

PK0L -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#

!

%

*"

!

"

#

$

%

X*%%6'1 ['-+% DEWW

!

0,00 DEWW /# `

!

V%<"+#*/#"'( ') 0JK+ "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# 04 V%+-:# D/4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ W^_

"

W]E

!

G%%#+ DEWW

!

0JK ./*#">"./#"'( "( .':">B 1/I"(< "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# 04 V%+-:# W /4 "( ./*/<*/.$+ Wc_

"

Wc`

!

Page 30: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

BBB

!

<;:B;M 9! G<9K;?C <;NAECN DP ?9HG9=;=CL 9G;<>CB9=>E 9:B7

?9HG9=;=C >

!

>??;NN C9 KANCB?; BN BHG<9:;F

!

<$7(,3 T

!

B.73)3(3)".+, *+6+*)3/ "- 34$ '(&)*)+#/ )7 $.4+.*$& ). 34$ -)$,&7 "- +J *#)0).+, #$3#)+,S 6+#",$ +.&

7$.3$.*$ *"00(3+3)".S ZJ *+7$ 2()&+.*$S *J 73+3$ *"06$.7+3)". -"# 5)*3)07 "- *#)0$ +.& &J >F<

!

I+J ?#)0).+, #$3#)+,S 6+#",$ +.& 7$.3$.*$ *"00(3+3)".

##

KTR\ R1.*'9%6 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/: .*'>%6-*% @B "++-"(< #$% *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(# J;0 H+ V%<-:/#"'(+ '(

O/A L..:">/#"'(+ 6-*"(< #$% G*"/: ;*'>%%6"(< ') J%(#%(>% 0'11-#/#"'( /(6 ;/*':%

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

G$% J;0 "++-%6 #$% V%<-:/#"'(+ '( O/A L..:">/#"'(+ 6-*"(< [/(6:"(< ') 0/+%+ "(

*%:/#"'( #' J%(#%(>% 0'11-#/#"'( /(6 ;/*':% "( DEWD

!

G$% J;0 /:+' "++-%6 / *%:/#%6 &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(

'( *%#*"/:

!

G$%+% "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+ "1.*'9%6 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/: .*'>%6-*% @B "(#*'6->"(< #$% .*"(>".:% /</"(+#

6'-@:% &%'./*6B /(6 @B .*'9"6"(< )'* 1'*% '.%( #*"/:+ "( +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'( >/+%+

!

_D

!

0'(#%S#

!

R++-%+ "( *%#*"/:4 ./*':% /(6 +%(#%(>"(< >'11-#/#"'( "(>:-6%\ 2/3 :/>I ') 6-% .*'>%++ /(6 '.%(

$%/*"(<+4 /+ 1'+# >/+%+ /*% 6%/:# A"#$ 1/"(:B @B >'-*#+ #$*'-<$ 6%+I *%9"%A ') A*"##%( /..:">/#"'(+d 2@3 #$%

'))%(6%*+H 9'">%+ /*% ')#%( %S>:-6%6 )*'1 #$% .*'>%%6"(<+d /(6 2 >3 "( #$% >/+%+ ') ./*':% /(6 +%(#%(>%

>'11-#/#"'(4 &-6<%+ #%(6 #' *%:B $%/9":B '( #$% "()'*1/#"'( .*'9"6%6 @B .*"+'(+4 +' #$/# #*"/: .*'>%%6"(<+

#%(6 #' /..*'9% A$/#%9%* #$% .*"+'(+ $/9% *%?-%+#%6

!

_c

!

V%+-:#+

!

+(1$#*2

!

R( K>#'@%* DEWW 4 #$% J;0 "++-%6 / &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( D('($*2 /5#3#-37 -3 V-B 1"(

4(-52(67 8-0$17 D"-02% O%W0%#H*1( 8*7(7 L3#1#*1(% JM 1"( 4$-H0$*1-$*1(7 *HH-$%#3F 1- 1"( !$#*2 D05($'#7#-3

4$-H(%0$(7

!

G$"+ &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( >:%/*:B >'()"*1+ #$% .*"(>".:% /</"(+# 6'-@:% &%'./*6B /..:"%6 "( '#$%*

f >'-(#*"%+\ -(:%++ #$%*% "+ (%A %9"6%(>%4 / .%*+'( +$'-:6 ('# @% #*"%6 #A">% )'* #$% +/1% '))%(+%

!

G$%

"(#%*.*%#/#"'( /:+' .*'9"6%+ #$/# ") #$% *%#*"/: "+ "("#"/#%6 @B #$% .*'>-*/#'*/#%4 #$% >'-*# 1-+# )":% #$% >/+%

A"#$"( '(% 1'(#$

!

_^

!

4*$-2( *3% D(31(3H( 8-..01*1#-3

!

G$% J;0 +(F02*1#-37 -3 A*B O552#H*1#-37 %0$#3F V*3%2#3F -, 8*7(7 #3

!"

! G$% O'<)*/1% :"+#+ #$% )'::'A"(< +'-*>%+ /(6 1%/(+ ') 9%*")">/#"'( )'* 0'1.'(%(# L\ (%A <-"6%:"(%+ '( .*%>%6%(#+

*%)%*%(#"/: +B+#%1 )":%6 A"#$ 7;0d </Y%##% ') J;0 (%A+ /(6 /*#">:%+d &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+ )":%6 A"#$ 7;0d />#"9"#B *%.'*# /(6

;PK 1'("#'*"(< *%.'*#d .*'&%># >'1.:%#"'( *%.'*#d .-@:"> 1%6"/ >'9%*/<%d (%A <-"6%:"(%+ )'* /..'"(#1%(# ') &-6<%+ 6*/)#%6

/(6 /6'.#%6d /(6 (-1@%* ') &-6<%+ #*/"(%6 /(6 9"%A+ ') ./*#">"./(#+

!

L:: ') #$%+% +'-*>%+ /*% 1%(#"'(%6 "( #$% )'::'A"(<

6"+>-++"'(4 %S>%.# )'* #$% .*'&%># >'1.:%#"'( *%.'*# A$">$ "+ ('# B%# /9/":/@:%

!

G$% "()'*1/#"'( $%*% '( J;0 9"%A+ "+ :/*<%:B

6%*"9%6 )*'1 /( "(#%*9"%A A"#$ J;0 '))">"/:+ "( X%@*-/*B DEWD

!

Page 31: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

$(2*1#-3 1- D(31(3H( 8-..01*1#-3 *3% 4*$-2( A%*% "++-%6 "( X%@*-/*B DEWD

!

G$"+ &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( A"::

f )-*#$%* .*'1'#% '.%( #*"/:+ "( +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'( >/+%+

!

R# .*'9"6%+ #$/# >'-*#+ +$'-:6 /..:B #$% .*'>%6-*%

') )"*+# "(+#/(>% #*"/:+ #' +"S #B.%+ ') +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'( >/+%+

!

J->$ >:%/* .*'9"+"'(+ A%*% /@+%(# "( #$%

./+#4 +' /+ #' /9'"6 #$% >'-*#+ @%"(< '9%*:'/6%6

!

G$"+ (%A &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( *%?-"*%+ / +#*">#%* ('#")">/#"'(

/(6 .-@:">"#B .*'>%6-*% "( +%(#%(>% *%6->#"'( >/+%+ "( '*6%* #' /::'A .*'>-*/#'*/#%+ /(6 '#$%* /<%(>"%+ #' <"9%

#$%"* 9"%A+ @%)'*% #$% >'-*#+ 1/I% #$% )"(/: 6%>"+"'(+

!

_]

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

N%)'*% #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 #$% 6"*%>#"'( ') *%)'*1 "( #$"+ /*%/ A/+ ('# 6%>"6%6

!

G$*'-<$

1/(B =,8 />#"9"#"%+4 +->$ /+ A'*I+$'.+ /(6 +%1"(/*+4 #$% .':">B 1/I%*+ A%*% /@:% #' >'::%># :'>/: .*/>#">%+4

</#$%* %S.%*#+H +-<<%+#"'(+ /(6 >''.%*/#% A"#$ '#$%* 6%./*#1%(#+ 2.*'>-*/#'*/#%+4 &-+#">% @-*%/-+3Q L>#"9"#B

./*#">"./(#+ @%(%)"#"(< )*'1 #$% =,8 +-..'*# >/1% )*'1 /:: :%9%:+ ') *%:%9/(# /<%(>"%+4 /+ A%:: /+ +>$':/*+

!

GA'

"(#%*(/#"'(/: +#-6B #'-*+ /:+' $%:.%6 #$%1 #' +#-6B "(#%*(/#"'(/: %S.%*"%(>%

!

L+ / *%+-:#4 #$% J;0 6%9%:'.%6

(/#"'(/: .':">"%+ '( #$%+% +-@&%>#+

!

IZJ ?+7$ 2()&+.*$

##

KTR\ X"%:6 *%+%/*>$ 2Sc 3 >'(#*"@-#%+ #' )'*1-:/#"'( ') #$% *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(# #' @% "++-%6 J;0 H+

0'11%(#+ '( J#*%(<#$%("(< /(6 K.#"1"Y"(< #$% 0/+% =-"6/(>% JB+#%1 >'1"(< "(#' %))%>#

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

G$% J;0 "++-%6 #$% V%<-:/#"'(+ '( 0/+% =-"6/(>% !'*I "( 7'9%1@%* DEWW 4 +%# -. /

*%+.'(+"@:% 6"9"+"'(4 /(6 $/+ "++-%6 #$% )"*+# <*'-. ') <-"6"(< >/+%+

!

;*'&%># )"%:6 *%+%/*>$ >'(#*"@-#%6 #'

#$% )'*1-:/#"'( ') #$% +B+#%1 /(6 "#+ 6'>-1%(#/#"'(

!

__

!

0'(#%S#

!

R( *%>%(# B%/*+4 +"1":/* >/+%+ $/9% *%>%"9%6 9%*B 6"))%*%(# &-6<%1%(#+ "( 0$"(/4 *%>'<("Y%6 /+ /

+"<( ') "(&-+#">% "( #*"/: .*/>#">%

!

G$% "(#*'6->#"'( ') / >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1 "+ %S.%>#%6 #' @*"6<% #$% </.+

>/-+%6 @B "(/6%?-/>B ') :/A /(6 &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(

!

L61"("+#*/#"9% "(#%*)%*%(>% "+ /('#$%* )/>#'* #$/#

&%'./*6"Y%+ &-6">"/: "(6%.%(6%(>%

!

K(% */#"'(/:% )'* >/+% <-"6/(>% "+ #$/# &-6<%+4 @/>I%6 -. @B <-"6"(< >/+%+

"++-%6 @B #$% J;04 A":: )%%: %1.'A%*%6 #' %S%*>"+% #$%"* "(6%.%(6%(>%

!

G$% >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1 "+ +%%( /+ /

+#*/"<$#)'*A/*6 A/B #' *%<-:/#% #$% 6"+>*%#"'(/*B .'A%* ') #$% &-6<%+4 %+#/@:"+$ &-6">"/: /-#$'*"#B /(6

+#*%(<#$%( &-6">"/: "(6%.%(6%(>%

!

_F

!

V%+-:#+

!

0$"(/H + >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1 $/+ @%%( "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y%6

!

G$% J;0 "++-%6 +(F02*1#-37 -3 8*7(

N0#%*3H( P-$K "( 7'9%1@%* DEWW

!

L (%A 6"9"+"'( A/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 A"#$"( #$% J;0 V%+%/*>$ 8%./*#1%(# #'

f >'1.":% /(6 "++-% <-"6"(< >/+%+4 /(6 #$% )"*+# >/+%+ $/9% @%%( "++-%6

!

!

R# "+ %S.%>#%6 #$/# #$% %(/>#1%(# ')

#$% +(F02*1#-3 -3 8*7( N0#%*3H( P-$K /(6 #$% "++-/(>% ') #$% <-"6"(< >/+%+ A":: :%/6 #' 1'*% .*%6">#/@:% /(6

""

! G$% )"*+# )'-* <-"6"(< >/+%+ A%*% "++-%6 "( 8%>%1@%* DEWW 4 #A' >*"1"(/: >/+%+4 /(6 #A' >"9": >/+%+

!

L +%>'(6 <*'-.

') )'-* >/+%+ A/+ "++-%6 "( L.*": DEWD 4 #A' /61"("+#*/#"9% .%(/:#B >/+%+4 '(% >'(+#*->#"'( .*'&%># >'(#*/># 6"+.-#% /(6 '(%

>'*.'*/#% 6"++':-#"'( 6"+.-#%

!

X'* ,(<:"+$ #*/(+:/#"'(+4 +%% $##.\ gg><>

!

:/A

!

+#/()'*6

!

%6-g<-"6"(<

"

>/+%+g

!

Page 32: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

>'1.*%$%(+"@:% *%+-:#+ "( &-6">"/: 6%>"+"'(+

!

G$"+ "+ / +#*"># +B+#%14 A"#$ >:%/* +#/(6/*6+4 #$/# J;0 $'.%+ >/(

>'(#*"@-#% #' )-#-*% 6%9%:'.1%(# /(6 *%)'*14 .*'1'#% +#/@":"#B /(6 %($/(>% :'>/: >'-*# >'(+"+#%(>B

!

_`

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(+

!

=,8 "(.-#+ A%*% %+.%>"/::B 9/:-/@:% 6-*"(< #$% .*%./*/#"'( ') #$% V%<-:/#"'(+ /(6

6%+"<( ') #$% +B+#%14 @'#$ )"%:6 *%+%/*>$

!

/(6 "(#%*(/#"'(/: %S.%*"%(>% 2 %+.%>"/::B )*'1 '#$%* >"9": :/A

>'-(#*"%+3Q G$%+% />#"9"#"%+ $%:.%6 .':">B 1/I%*+ #' @-":6 >'(+%(+-+ '( #$% )'::'A"(< "++-%+\ 2/3 J$'-:6 / >/+%

<-"6/(>% +B+#%1 @% %+#/@:"+$%6 "( 0$"(/4 / >'-(#*B A"#$ >"9": :/A #*/6"#"'(+h 2@3 L*% <-"6"(< >/+%+ &-6">"/:

"(#%*.*%#/#"'(+ '* '#$%*A"+% :%</::B @"(6"(<h 2>3 J$'-:6 '(:B #$% J;0 $/9% /-#$'*"#B #' "++-% <-"6"(< >/+%+4 '*

A'-:6 :'>/: $"<$ >'-*#+ /:+' $/9% #$% /-#$'*"#Bh 263 !$/# /*% #$% >*"#%*"/ )'* +%:%>#"'( ') <-"6"(< >/+%+h 2%3

!$/# /*% #$% .*'>%6-*%+ #' "++-% <-"6"(< >/+%+h

_b

!

G$% .':">B >'(+%(+-+ '( #$%+% "++-%+4 )'+#%*%6 @B ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+4 >/( @% +%%( "( #$% +B+#%1 ('A "(

.:/>%

!

,S#%(+"9% 6"+>-++"'(+ /(6 )"%:6 *%+%/*>$ 6%1'(+#*/#%6 #$% (%%6 )'* / >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1

!

=-"6"(<

>/+%+ /*% ('# #*%/#%6 /+ @"(6"(< &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+

!

['A%9%*4 #$% +#*"># .*'9"+"'(+ '( "++-/(>% 2'(:B @B #$%

J;0 /(6 '(:B /)#%* /..*'9/: @B #$% J;0 C-6">"/: 0'11"##%%3 %(+-*% #$/# <-"6"(< >/+%+ /*% /-#$'*"#/#"9%

!

O'>/:

>'-*#+ /*% %S.%>#%6 #' *%)%* #' <-"6"(< >/+% *%/+'("(< /(6 .*'9"6% +.%>")"> %S.:/(/#"'(+ ') 6%9"/#"'(+ "( >'-*#

&-6<%1%(#+

!

X"9% +%:%>#"'( >*"#%*"/ A%*% /<*%%6\ >/+%+ A"#$ %S#%(+"9% +'>"/: "1./># '* >'(>%*(+d >/+%+ )'* A$">$

>'6")"%6 :/A+ '(:B .*'9"6% .*"(>".:%+d #B.">/: >/+%+d >'1.:">/#%6 /(6 (%A #B.%+ ') >/+%+d /(6 '#$%* >/+%+

+-"#/@:% #' @% <-"6"(< >/+%+

!

FE

!

G$*'-<$ +#-6B #'-*+ #' >"9": :/A >'-(#*"%+ 2 "

!

%

!

;'*#-</:4 =%*1/(B4 N%:<"-1 /(6 X*/(>% 34 #$% J;0

./*#">"./(#+ :%/*(%6 /@'-# #$% >'(9%*<"(< #*%(6 @%#A%%( >"9": :/A /(6 >'11'( :/A &-*"+6">#"'(+ '( >/+%

<-"6/(>%

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 )*'1 #$%"* 9"+"# #' =%*1/(B4 #$% J;0 6%:%</#"'( :%/*(%6 #$/#\ 2/3 :'>/: >'-*# 6%>"+"'(+

+%:6'1 >'():"># A"#$ <-"6"(< >/+%+ ') #$% $"<$%+# >'-*#d 2@3 #$% $"<$%+# >'-*# %+#/@:"+$%6 / +.%>"/: 6"9"+"'(

6%/:"(< A"#$ >'(#*'9%*+"/: >/+%+d /(6 2>3 #$% $"<$%+# >'-*# ./B+ +.%>"/: /##%(#"'( #' %(>'-*/<% :'>/: >'-*#+ H

>*%/#"9"#B /(6 *%<-:/*:B *%):%>#+ -.'( #$% 6"))%*%(>% @%#A%%( :'>/: &-6<%1%(#+ /(6 #$%"* &-6<%1%(#+

!

I*J 9%,%# "&42#*$,%)&* <&+ 7)"%)4$ &< "+)4#

##

KTR\ ,(/># / (%A .':">B '( J#/#% >'1.%(+/#"'( )'* 9">#"1+ ') >*"1% /(6 "1.:%1%(# (/#"'(A"6%

!

J#/#-+\ J-@+#/(#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

G$% (%A .':">B $/+ *%.'*#%6:B @%%( "++-%6 "( P/*>$ DEEb 4 /(6 9">#"1+

/>*'++ #$% >'-(#*B /*% /:*%/6B *%>%"9"(< >'1.%(+/#"'( @/+%6 '( / +B+#%1/#"> /..*'/>$

!

O'>/: :%9%:

:%<"+:/#"'( $/+ /:*%/6B @%%( "++-%6 "( /@'-# #A'

"

#$"*6+ ') .*'9"(>%

"

:%9%: &-*"+6">#"'(+

!

FW

!

0'(#%S#

!

;*'9"6"(< .*'#%>#"'( /(6 *%6*%++ #' >*"1% 9">#"1+ $/+ @%%( *%>'<("Y%6 /+ / $-1/( *"<$#+ "++-% "(

#"

! G$% #$*%% )"%:6 *%+%/*>$ />#"9"#"%+ A%*% >'(6->#%6 "( Z"(<6/' 2 C-(% DEEb 34 7/(>$/(< 2 J%.#%1@%* DEEb 3 /(6

8'(<A/( 2C-(% DEWE 3Q

Page 33: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

0$"(/

!

R# $/+ /:+' @%%( *%>'<("Y%6 #$/# #$% "1./># '( 9">#"1+ ') >*"1% "+ ('# (%>%++/*":B :"1"#%6 #' .$B+">/:

"(&-*B4 @-# 1/B /:+' "(>:-6% :'++ ') .*'.%*#B '* '#$%* %>'('1"> :'++

!

['A%9%*4 #$% 6%)%(6/(# 1/B ('# $/9% #$%

)"(/(>"/: /@":"#B #' .*'9"6% *%6*%++ )'* #$% 9">#"1+

!

5(6%* #$%+% >"*>-1+#/(>%+4 #$% +#/#% >'-:6 +#%. "(

!

FD

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% J;0 /69"+%6 #$/#4 "( P/*>$ DEEb 4 / (%A (/#"'(/: 4-2#HM -3 D1*1( 8-.5(37*1#-3 ,-$ X #H1#.7 -,

8$#.(7 A/+ >'

"

+"<(%6 @B ` >%(#*/: <'9%*(1%(# @'6"%+4 "(>:-6"(< #$% 7;04 J;04 P"("+#*B ') ;-@:"> J%>-*"#B4

f P"("+#*B ') C-+#">% 2PKC3 /(6 P"("+#*B ') X"(/(>% 2PKX3Q G$"+ (%A .':">B .*'9"6%+ #$% .*"(>".:%+ '( )-(6"(<

+'-*>%4 >'1.%(+/#"'( +>'.%4 /(6 %:"<"@":"#B *%?-"*%1%(#+

!

!$":% #$% .':">B 6'>-1%(# $/+ ('# @%%( .-@:">:B

"++-%64 :'>/:"#"%+ /*% 6%>"6"(< $'A #' "1.:%1%(# "# "(#%*(/::B

!

P'*% #$/( DE .*'9"(>%+ $/9% "++-%6

"1.:%1%(#/#"'( *-:%+ /..*'.*"/#% )'* #$%"* :'>/: /(6 %>'('1"> >'(#%S#+

!

R( '#$%* .*'9"(>%+4 A$%*% "# "+ 1'*%

6"))">-:# #' "++-% / +#/(6

"

/:'(% 6'>-1%(#4 .*'9"6"(< >'1.%(+/#"'( #' >*"1% 9">#"1+ $/+ @%%( "(#%<*/#%6 /+ ./*#

') #$% :'>/: &-6">"/: /++"+#/(>% A'*I

!

Fc

!

O'>/: "1.:%1%(#/#"'( "+ @%"(< &'"(#:B >/**"%6 '-# @B :'>/: >'-*#+4 :'>/: .*'>-*/#'*/#%+ /(6 :'>/: .':">%

)'*>%+

!

R( DEEb 4 / #'#/: ') VPN ]E

!

WW 1"::"'( A/+ "++-%6 #' >*"1% 9">#"1+ @B :'>/: >'-*#+ 2VPN ^c

!

]] 1"::"'( #'

W`EE >*"1% 9">#"1+34 /(6 :'>/: .*'>-*/#'*/#%+ 2VPN _

!

__ 1"::"'( #' D`] >*"1% 9">#"1+3Q R( DEWW 4 / #'#/: ') VPN

WWD

!

^b 1"::"'( A/+ "++-%6 #' >*"1% 9">#"1+ @B :'>/: .':">% )'*>%+ 2VPN Dc

!

FF 1"::"'( #' W^bF 9">#"1+34 :'>/:

.*'>-*/#'*/#%+ 2VPN WW

!

FF 1"::"'( #' `__ 9">#"1+3 /(6 :'>/: >'-*#+ 2VPN F_

!

b] 1"::"'( #' D_`E 9">#"1+3Q

!

F^

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># +-..'*#%6 9/*"'-+ +%1"(/*+ /(6 6"+>-++"'(+ #' </#$%* :'>/: .*/>#">%

/(6 )/>":"#/#% #$% "++-/(>% ') / (%A (/#"'(/: .':">B

!

L+ #$"+ A/+ / (%A /*%/4 1/(B ?-%+#"'(+ *%?-"*%6 *%+%/*>$4

+->$ /+\ A$/# "+ %>'('1"> :'++d $'A #' $/(6:% +%9%*% >/+%+d A$/# ") #$% 6%)%(6/(# >/(

)

# .*'9"6%

>'1.%(+/#"'(d $'A #' #/I% >/*% ') 9">#"1H+ :")% A$%*% (%%6+ /*% ('# 1%#d /(6 #%1.'*/*B /++"+#/(>%

!

L)#%* #$%

"++-/(>% ') #$% .':">B 6'>-1%(#4 #$% =,8 ;*'&%># )-*#$%* +-..'*#%6 />#"9"#"%+ )'* <-"6/(>% ') :'>/:

"1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

=-> !0%#+*,%)7# ?)$2(%# @#$&0(%)&* =!?@>

##

KTR\ ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' %(/>#"(< #$% &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( '( J%9%*/: K."("'(+ '( #$%

V%:/#"'(+$". @%#A%%( L8V /(6 O"#"</#"'( 2"

!

%

!

#$% L8V K."("'(+3Q

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

G$% J;0 $/+ "++-%6 #$% L8V K."("'(+4 /+ A%:: /+ '#$%* *%:/#%6 .':">B 6'>-1%(#+4

/(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'( $/+ @%<-(

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') #$"+ *%)'*1

!

F]

!

0'(#%S#

!

G$% J;0 "++-%6 #$% L8V K."("'(+ 2D('($*2 /5#3#-37 -3 1"( +(2*1#-37"#5 J(1B((3 OR+ *3%

A#1#F*1#-33 /+ / &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( "( DEEb 4 +%##"(< '-# <%(%*/: *%?-"*%1%(#+ '( L8V

!

G$% L8V K."("'(+

$"

! G$% *%9"%A #%/1 A/+ ('# /@:% #' *%9"%A #$% .':">B 6'>-1%(#4 @-# @'#$ J;0 /(6 =,8

"

;PK >'()"*1%6 "#+

%S"+#%(>%

!

!"#$ #$"+ >'()"*1/#"'( /(6 />#-/: "1.:%1%(#/#"'(4 #$% */#"(< "+

(

+-@+#/(#"/::B />$"%9%6

) !

Page 34: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

f A%*% ./*# ') /( %))'*# #' 6%9%:'. 6"9%*+% 6"+.-#% *%+':-#"'( 1%>$/("+1+ #$/# >/( @% >'((%>#%6 #' >'-*#+ /(6

:"#"</#"'(4 A"#$ +%9%*/: '@&%>#"9%+\ /::%9"/#% >/+%:'/6 .*%++-*%+ '( >'-*#+4 +/9% &-6">"/: *%+'-*>%+ 2 )'* 1'*%

:%</::B >'1.:%S >/+%+34 "(>*%/+% #*-+# "( 1%6"/#"'( '*</("Y/#"'(+ /(6 .*'1'#% #$%"* 6%9%:'.1%(#4 /(6 *%6->%

#$% >'+# ') 6"+.-#% *%+':-#"'( )'* #$% ./*#"%+

!

!

F_

!

V%+-:#+

!

X'::'A"(< #$% L8V K."("'(+4 #$% 4(-52(67 @(%#*1#-3 A*B A/+ %(/>#%6 @B #$% 7;0 "( DEWE /(6

f "(>:-6%6 .*'9"+"'(+ '( &-6">"/: >'()"*1/#"'( ') #$% 1%6"/#"'( /<*%%1%(#+

!

R( L.*": DEWW 4 G-#31 N0#%*3H( -3

407"#3F &-$B*$% OR+ #3 R#7501( D(112(.(31 A/+ &'"(#:B "++-%6 @B W_ >%(#*/: <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+4 "(>:-6"(<

f #$% 0%(#*/: ;':"#">/: O%</: 0'11"##%% ') #$% ;/*#B4 J;04 #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ ;*'>-*/#'*/#% 2J;;34 #$% J#/#%

0'-(>": K))">% ') O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+4 /(6 P"("+#*B ') ;-@:"> J%>-*"#B

!

L( "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y%6 >'(+%(+-+ /(6

)*/1%A'*I '( L8V $/+ @%%( )'*1%6 #$*'-<$'-# #$% +'>"%#B

!

J'1% $"<$ >'-*#+ $/9% "++-%6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

*-:%+ )'* #$% C-:B DEEb /(6 L.*": DEWW 6'>-1%(#+

!

FF

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

L8V />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* #$% ;*'&%># 2.":'#+4 *%+%/*>$ /(6 +#-6B #'-*+ 3 +-..'*#%6 #$%

"++-/(>% ') #$% L8V K."("'(+ "( C-:B DEEb

!

=,8 "(.-#+ /)#%* "++-/(>% ') #$% L8V K."("'(+ $%:.%6 #' 1'("#'*

"1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') #$% (%A .':">B4 +#*%(<#$%( >''*6"(/#"'( A"#$ 6"))%*%(# /<%(>"%+ "(9':9%64 /(6 :%/*( )*'1

"(#%*(/#"'(/: .*/>#">%

!

R(#%*(/#"'(/: %S>$/(<% />#"9"#"%+ $%:.%6 #$% .':">B 1/I%*+ #' -(6%*+#/(6 $'A #$%

1%6"/#"'( +B+#%1 '.%*/#%+ #'.

"

6'A( g @'##'1

"

-.

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 "( #$% N0#%*3H( -3 D('($*2 L770(7 $(2*1(% 1-

@(%#*1#-3 ,-$ 8#'#2 *3% 8-..($H#*2 @*11($74 #$% ,-*'.%/( 5("'( $/+ *%?-"*%6 "#+ 1%1@%* >'-(#*"%+ #' +/#"+)B

f +'1% @/+"> *%?-"*%1%(#+ '( %+#/@:"+$"(< / 1%6"/#"'( )*/1%A'*I

!

L:: 1/&'* ,-*'.%/( >'-(#*"%+ $/9% ./++%6

6'1%+#"> :%<"+:/#"'( #' .*'1'#% 1%6"/#"'(

!

R( /('#$%* %S/1.:%4 ;'*#-</: $/+ / <''6 #*/"("(< +B+#%1 )'*

1%6"/#'*+ (/#"'(A"6%4 -+"(< +'>"':'<B /(6 '#$%* 6"+>".:"(%+

!

,5 >'-(#*"%+ -+% (/#"'(/: @-6<%#+ #' .*'9"6%

)"(/(>"/: /++"+#/(>% /(6 .'.-:/*"Y% L8V

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># /:+' $%:.%6 "( .-@:">"Y"(< L8V 2 "( ;%'.:% H+ 0'-*#

8/":B34 /(6 #$*'-<$ / 1/&'* +%1"(/*4 A$%*% *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+ ') #$% 7;0 /(6 #$% 0%(#*/: ;':"#">/:

"

O%</:

0'11"##%% /:+' ./*#">"./#%6

!

##

KTR\ 0'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'( >/+%+ )*'1 `e #' W]e ') /:: #$% >'(>:-6%6 >"9": /(6 >'11%*>"/:

>/+%+ "( #$% .":'# +"#% ') ;-6'(< 7%A L*%/ 8"+#*"># 0'-*#

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

G$% >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'( +B+#%1 "+ "( />#"9% -+% "( #$% ;-6'(< 0'-*#

!

R(

DEWW 4 DD

!

_e ') >"9": /(6 >'11%*>"/: >/+%+ A%*% *%+':9%6 #$*'-<$ >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'(

!

F`

!

0'(#%S#

!

R( #$% ;-6'(< 7%A L*%/ 8"+#*"># 0'-*# 2#$% ;-6'(< 0'-*#34 >/+%+ $/9% >'(#"(-%6 #' <*'A /@'-# WEe

.%* B%/* +"(>% DEED

!

G' '.#"1"Y% #$% :"1"#%6 *%+'-*>%+ /(6 #' />$"%9% @%##%* &-+#">% /(6 %))">"%(>B4 #$% ;-6'(< 0'-*#

+#/*#%6 %S.:'*"(< L8V /)#%* DEE_

!

G$% ;-6'(< 0'-*# @%>/1% / J;0 :'>/: :%9%: .":'# >'-*# "( P/B DEE`

!

%"

! P%6"/#"'( "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* #$% K9%*/:: KTR '( />>%++ #' &-+#">% "( ./*/<*/.$+ W^

"

W_

!

Page 35: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

Fb

!

V%+-:#+

!

R( #$% ./+# )%A B%/*+4 #$% ;-6'(< 0'-*# $/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 / +B+#%1 #$/# ('# '(:B /::'A+ &-6">"/:

>'()"*1/#"'( ') #$% /<*%%1%(#+ ') ('(

"

:"#"</#"'( 1%6"/#"'(4 @-# /:+' %(/@:%+ #$% >'-*# #' .*'1'#% .*%

"

:"#"</#"'(

1%6"/#"'( /(6 #' >'((%># #$% 1%6"/#"'( /(6 :"#"</#"'( .*'>%6-*%+ 2A"#$ / )/+#

"

#*/>I .*'>%++ /(6 +1/:: >:/"1+

>'-*# .":'#3Q 2J%% N'S c

!

3 P/(B 6"+.-#%+ A%*% *%+':9%6 A"#$'-# %()'*>%1%(# />#"'(+4 :%++%("(< .*%++-*% '( #$%

>'-*#4 +' #$% >'-*# >'-:6 6"*%># "#+ %))'*#+ #' 1'*% :%</::B 6"))">-:# >/+%+

!

G$"+ L8V 1'6%: $/+ /:+' +#*%(<#$%(%6

1%6"/#"'( '*</("Y/#"'(+ "( +'>"%#B4 </9% #$%1 :%</: +-..'*# /(6 / +#*'(< :%</: @/+"+

!

R( #$% ./+# )'-* B%/*+4 #$%

;-6'(< 0'-*# $/+ 6%/:# A"#$ cW 4 ]FE 1%6"/#"'( >/+%+4 A$">$ "+ /@'-# Wg] ') >"9": /(6 >'11%*>"/: 6"+.-#%+

!

K(

/9%*/<%4 1%6"/#"'( +/9%+ +%9%( 6/B+ "( >/+% $/(6:"(< /(6 +/9%6 / #'#/: ') VPN _`F

!

F 1"::"'( )'* /:: ./*#"%+

!

R(

DEWW 4 1%6"/#%6 >/+%+ (-1@%*%6 W_ 4 FWc /(6 :"#"</#%6 >/+%+ (-1@%*%6 ]F 4 cDD 4 +' >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'(

*%+':9%6 /@'-# DD

!

_e ') >"9": /(6 >'11%*>"/: >/+%+4 A$">$ %S>%%6+ #$% W]e KTR #/*<%#

!

`E

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% ;-6'(< .":'# $/+ @%(%)"#%6 )*'1 1/(B A'*I+$'.+ /(6 +%1"(/*+ +-..'*#%6 @B

#$% =,8 ;*'&%>#

!

C-6<%+ )*'1 #$% ;-6'(< 0'-*# >'()"*1%6 #$/# #$% =,8

"

+.'(+'*%6 1%%#"(<+ /(6 "(#%*(/#"'(/:

+%1"(/*+ $/9% @%%( 9%*B -+%)-:

!

G$%+% A%*% <''6 '..'*#-("#"%+ #' $%/* $'A '#$%* ./*#+ ') #$% >'-(#*B /(6

'#$%* &-*"+6">#"'(+ A%*% 6%/:"(< A"#$ +"1":/* "++-%+4 /(6 /:+' #' $%/* )*'1 +>$':/*+

!

G$%+% />#"9"#"%+ .*'9"6%6

(%A "6%/+ #' @*"(< @/>I4 /(6 #$%( 1'9%6 #$% 0'-*# H+ A'*I )'*A/*64 "1.*'9"(< @B #*B"(< (%A #$"(<+

!

X'*

"(+#/(>%4 /)#%* #$% =,8 />#"9"#"%+4 J;0 >/1% '-# A"#$ / ('*1/#"9% 6'>-1%(# A"#$ / )'*1 /(6 #"#:% )'* &-6">"/:

>'()"*1/#"'(4 )/>":"#/#"(< #$% &-6">"/: >'()"*1/#"'( .*'>%++

!

D"R W

!

>F<L C4$ G(&".2 G),"3

G$% ;-6'(< 7%A L*%/ 8"+#*"># 0'-*# "+ /1'(< #$% @-+"%+# >'-*#+ "( 0$"(/4 /(6 >/+%+ $/9% >'(#"(-%6 #'

<*'A /@'-# WEe .%* B%/* #' '9%* `E 4 EEE "( DEWW

!

L +%*"%+ ') .":'#"(< 1%/+-*%+ "( L8V 1%#$'6+ A%*%

@%<-( /)#%* DEE_ 2+'1% A"#$ =,8 +-..'*#34 @'#$ #' 6%/: A"#$ #$% "(>*%/+"(< >/+%:'/6 /(6 6"*%># &-6">"/:

*%+'-*>%+ #' :%</::B 6"))">-:# >/+%+4 /(6 #' *%+':9% 6"+.-#%+ /(6 *%6->% >'():"># "( +'>"%#B

!

!X":"(<

!

;/*#"%+ /*% <"9%( >$'">% ') 1%6"/#"'( /# >/+% )":"(<4 @-# #$% >$'">% ') 1%6"/#"'( 1-+# @%

9':-(#/*B

!

!O"#"</#"'(

"

P%6"/#"'( 0''*6"(/#"'( 0%(#%*

!

G$"+ >%(#%* >'1@"(%+ :"#"</#"'( /(6 1%6"/#"'(4 @/+%6 '( #$%

J;0 DEEb L8V K."("'(+

!

P/(B 6"))%*%(# 1%6"/#"'( '*</("Y/#"'(+ /(6 +#/)) 2 .%'.:% H + 1%6"/#"'(4

.*')%++"'(/: 1%6"/#"'(4 /61"("+#*/#"9% 1%6"/#"'( /(6 >'11%*>"/: 1%6"/#"'( 3 *%>%"9% #*/"("(<4 /(6

./*#">"./#% "( 1%6"/#"'( A'*I A"#$"( #$% >'-*#

!

!;*%

"

:"#"</#"'( 1%6"/#"'(

!

;/*#"%+ $/9% / >$'">% ') :"#"</#"'( '* .*%

"

:"#"</#"'( 1%6"/#"'(d 1'*% #$/( ]Ee

#*B .*%

"

:"#"</#"'( 1%6"/#"'(

!

R) 1%6"/#"'( +->>%%6+4 #$% >'-*# .*'9"6%+ (%>%++/*B :%</: 6'>-1%(#+4 "(>:-6"(<4

") *%?-%+#%64 &-6">"/: >'()"*1/#"'( #' <"9% :%</: %))%># #' #$% 1%6"/#"'( /<*%%1%(#

!

J'1%#"1%+4 1%6"/#"'(

6'%+ ('# +->>%%64 @-# ./*#"%+ 6*'. #$% >/+%

!

R( /@'-# FEe 2') 1%6"/#%6 >/+%+34 #$% 1%6"/#"'( 6'%+ ('#

+->>%%64 /(6 ./*#"%+ .*'>%%6 #' :"#"</#"'(

!

!X/+#

"

#*/>I .*'>%++

!

X'* >/+%+ A$%*% 1%6"/#"'( )/":+ /(6 :"#"</#"'( %(+-%+4 / &-6<% A":: $%/* #$% >/+%

A"#$"( ^] 6/B+ 2:%++ #$/( #$% -+-/: #"1%3Q

&"

Page 36: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

!J1/:: >:/"1+ >'-*#

!

X'* >"9": >/+%+ A$%*% 1%6"/#"'( )/":+4 #$% /1'-(# /# "++-% "+ ]E 4 EEE VPN '* :%++ /(6

#$% :%</: "++-%+ /*% +"1.:%4 #$% ./*#"%+ >/( >$''+% )'* #$% >/+% #' @% $%/*6 @B / +"(<:% &-6<%4 A"#$"( W

1'(#$ 2"(+#%/6 ') _ 1'(#$+3Q G$% .*'>%++ "+ /:+' +"1.:")"%6 /(6 ):%S"@:%\ )%%+ /*% :'A%*d ('#">%+ 1/B @%

+%(# -+"(< 1%++/<%+ '* %1/":d $%/*"(<+ 1/B @% /# ("<$#d /(6 -+-/::B #$%*% "+ '(:B '(% $%/*"(< A"#$ /

6%>"+"'( /(('-(>%6 )*'1 #$% @%(>$

!

G$%*% "+ (' /..%/: #' $"<$%* >'-*#4 @-# ./*#"%+ >/( *%?-%+# *%9"%A @B

#$% ;-6'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*#

!

K) 1'*% #$/( D 4 EEE >/+%+ +"(>% DEWW 4 '(:B W

"

De *%>%"9%6 &-6<1%(#+d '#$%*+

A%*% +%##:%6 '* 6*'..%6

!

K(:B '(% >/+% A%(# )'* *%9"%A

!

!V%+-:#+

!

5. #' cEe ') >/+%+ *%+':9%6 #$*'-<$ >'-*# >'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'(

!

2 R( DEWW 4 >/+%+ *%+':9%6

#$*'-<$ >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 L8V A%*% DD

!

_e

!

3

<$7(,3 U

!

C#+.76+#$.*/ ). *"(#3 &$*)7)". 0+1).2 )7 ).*#$+7$& 34#"(24 34$ &$5$,"60$.3 "- +J "6$. 3#)+,7 +.& ZJ

34$ 6$"6,$X7 +77$77"#7 7/73$0

!

=,> A2#* .+),0$

##

KTR\ ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% .*'1-:</#"'( ') #$% *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(# J"S V%<-:/#"'(+ '(

C-6">"/: K.%((%++ "++-%6 @B #$% J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*#

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

G$% J;0H+ J"S V%<-:/#"'(+ '( C-6">"/: K.%((%++ A/+ "++-%64 /(6 "(>:-6%6 '.%( #*"/:

*%)'*1

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% "++-/(>% /(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') #$% '.%( #*"/: *%)'*1

!

`W

!

0'(#%S#

!

K.%( #*"/: *%)'*1 $/+ @%%( .*'1'#%6 -(6%* #$% D#E +(F02*1#-37 -3 G0%#H#*2 /5(33(77 "++-%6 @B

f #$% J;0 "( DEEb 4 /:'(< A"#$ /('#$%* 6'>-1%(# D('($*2 R(H#7#-37 1- OHH(51 @(%#* D05($'#7#-3

!

`D

!

V%+-:#+

!

D#E +(F02*1#-37 >'9%*+ #$% )'::'A"(< /*%/+\ 2W 3 >/+% )":"(<4 2D 3 #*"/:4 2c 3 %()'*>%1%(#4 2^ 3 $%/*"(<4

f 2] 3 &-6<%1%(# /(6 '#$%* 6'>-1%(#+ .*'6->%6 @B >'-*#4 /(6 2_ 3 >'-*# #*"/: /61"("+#*/#"'(

!

G$% D#E +(F02*1#-37

/:+' ./*#">-:/*:B /66*%++%6 <%(%*/: .-@:">H+ >'1.:/"(#+ /@'-# "(/6%?-/#% %S.:/(/#"'( '( A$B >/+%+ /*% ('#

/>>%.#%6 @B >'-*#4 /(6 $'A #' "(?-"*% /@'-# #$% +#/#-+ ') >/+%+

!

R( DEWE 4 #$% J;0 "++-%6 #$% R(H#7#-3 -3

/32#3( T$-*%H*71 -, A#'( 8-0$1 !$#*27 /(6 +%:%>#%6 WEE >'-*#+ /+ K.%( G*"/: P'6%: 0'-*#+

!

R( DEWE 4 =/(+-

f .*'9"(>% A/+ +%:%>#%6 #' .":'# &-6">"/: '.%((%++ *%)'*1+ "( A%+#%*( 0$"(/

!

R( L-<-+# DEWW 4 #$% =/(+- .":'# A/+

%9/:-/#%6 2"(>:-6"(< #$*'-<$ =,8 />#"9"#"%+3 /(6 #$% >'(>:-+"'( A/+ #$/# #$% =/(+- ["<$ 0'-*# $/6 +%*9%6 /+

/ <''6 1'6%: #' .*'1'#% &-6">"/: '.%((%++ .*'9"(>%

"

A"6%d .*'9"(>"/: +#/(6/*6+ '( &-6">"/: '.%((%++ A%*%

"++-%6 @B ;*'9"(>"/: ["<$ 0'-*#

!

`c

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

L>>'*6"(< #' #$% J;0 '))">"/:+4 1'*% #$%'*%#">/: *%+%/*>$ '( '.%( #*"/: A/+ (%%6%6

A$%( #$% ;*'&%># @%</(

!

8"))%*%(# 9"%A+ *%1/"(%6 '( A$%#$%* #$% >'-*# +B+#%1 +$'-:6 +.%%6 -. '* #' +:'A

6'A( #$% '.%( #*"/: *%)'*1

!

K.%( #*"/: *%)'*1 :/*<%:B 6%.%(6+ '( :'>/: %>'('1"> 6%9%:'.1%(# /(6 "(#%*(%#

'"

Page 37: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

-+/<%

!

U%# "( *%1'#% /(6 .''* /*%/+4 :/>I ') )-(6+ /(6 "(+#"#-#"'(/: +/)%<-/*6+ )'* '.%( #*"/: .*%+%(# / +%*"'-+

>$/::%(<%

!

`^

!

!"#$ #$% +-..'*# ') #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 #$% J;0 >'(6->#%6 #%( 1/&'* />#"9"#"%+ *%:/#%6 #' '.%( #*"/:+

!

X'*

"(+#/(>%4 / 6'1%+#"> +%1"(/* 2DEEb 3 /(/:BY%6 '.%( #*"/: .*/>#">% "( 0$"(/4 A"#$ :'>/: >'-*#+ /(6 %S.%*#+

./*#">"./#"(<d 6'1%+#"> %S.%*#+ >'(6->#%6 *%+%/*>$

!

J#-6B #'-*+ #' #$% 5("#%6 m"(<6'1 /(6 =%*1/(B4 /(6 #'

JA"#Y%*:/(6 /(6 X*/(>%4 /:+' >'(#*"@-#%6

!

L A*/.

"

-. %9%(# 27'9%1@%* DEWW 3 A/+ $%:6 A"#$ =,8 +-..'*# #'

+-11/*"Y% :%++'(+ /(6 %S.%*"%(>% '( &-6">"/: '.%((%++ "( #$% ./+# #$*%% B%/*+4 /(6 / +%*"%+ ') <''6 .*/>#">%+

A%*% *%.'*#%6 "( #$% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# 8/":B

!

`]

!

G$"+ +%# ') ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ +-..'*#%6 +%9%*/: /+.%>#+ ') #$% *%)'*14 />>'*6"(< #' J;0 '))">"/:+

!

G$% *%)'*1

$/+ @%%( *''#%6 A"6%:B /(6 6%%.:B "( #$% %(#"*% &-+#">% +B+#%14 "(>:-6"(< #*"/: /61"("+#*/#"'(4 :%##%* .%#"#"'(

/(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

G$% '.%( #*"/: 1%>$/("+1 $/+ @%%( )-*#$%* "1.*'9%64 A"#$ (%A +')#A/*% /(6 $/*6A/*% /#

/:: :%9%:+ ') >'-*#+4 /(6 / (/#"'(A"6% +#/(6/*6 '( '.%( #*"/:+ $/+ @%%( 6%9%:'.%6

!

R( +-11/*B4 =,8 />#"9"#"%+

/::'A%6 #$% J;0 #' '@#/"( "()'*1/#"'( '( #$% 6"))%*%(# /..*'/>$%+ #' .-@:"> #*"/:+ A"#$ #$% '@&%>#"9% ')

A'*I"(< '-# /( "(#%<*/#%6 (/#"'(/: .':">B

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ $/9% #$-+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#

D#E +(F02*1#-37 -3 G0%#H#*2 /5(33(77 "++-%6 /(6 %(/>#%6 "( DEEb

!

=;> ./# B#&20#C$ !$$#$$&+$ 93$%#4

##

KTR\ R1.*'9%6 ;%'.:%H+ L++%++'*+ JB+#%1 @B %(:/*<"(< #$% +>'.% ') *%.*%+%(#/#"9%(%++ ') >"#"Y%(+ /#

#$% .":'# +"#% ') !-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># >'-*# )*'1 b #' ]E

!

;%'.:% H + /++%++'*+ ./*#">"./#"'( */#% "( >/+%+

"(>*%/+%6 )*'1 WEe #' F]e

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

R( !-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*#4 #$% .%'.:% H+ /++%++'*+ ./*#">"./#"'( */#% "( >/+%+ $/+

"(>*%/+%6 )*'1 WEe #' b`e "( )"*+# #*"/: >/+%+4 /(6 #$% (-1@%* ') /++%++'*+ $/+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 b #' `E

!

G$% !-Y$'(< .":'# +%*9%6 /+ #$% 1'6%: )'* (/#"'(A"6% *%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1

!

`_

!

0'(#%S#

!

;%'.:% H + /++%++'*+ /*% 1%1@%*+ ') #$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> A$' ./*#">"./#% "( #$% &-6">"/:

.*'>%++

!

L++%++'*+ /*% /..'"(#%6 )*'1 #$% :'>/: >'11-("#B )'* / )"S%6 .%*"'64 #' $%/* >/+%+ A"#$ &-6<%+ "(

#*"/:+

!

R( DEE] 4 #$% 7;0 "++-%6 / 6%>"+"'( #' %($/(>% #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1

!

!-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*# "(

J-Y$'- P-(">"./:"#B .":'#%6 #$"+ *%)'*1

!

!

`F

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% !-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*# $/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 +%9%*/: 1%>$/("+1+ #' .*'1'#% #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+

("

! V%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1 "+ 6"+>-++%6 -(6%* K9%*/:: KTR+ "( ./*/<*/.$+ ]W

"

]^ 2/(6 N'S W '( #$%

!-Y$'(< ;":'#3Q

Page 38: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

+B+#%1

!

J'1% .*'9"+"'(+ "( #$% *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ "++-%6 @B !-Y$'(< )'* #$% .":'#

!

)'*1%6 #$% @/+"+ )'*

.*'9"+"'(+ "( J;0 6'>-1%(#+ /..:">/@:% (/#"'(A"6%

!

"

G$% >'(#*"@-#"'(+ )*'1 #$% !-Y$'(< .":'# "(>:-6%\

>:/*")B"(< #$% +>'.% ') >/+%+ A$%*% /++%++'*+ A'-:6 ./*#">"./#%d 6%)"("(< #$% *"<$#+ ') :"#"</(#+ #' *%?-%+#

/++%++'* ./*#">"./#"'(d *%)"("(< #$% .*'>%6-*% ') */(6'1 +%:%>#"'( ') /++%++'*+d /(6 %(+-*"(< #$% .*'#%>#"'( ')

*"<$#+ ') /++%++'*+ #' $%/* #$% #*"/:

!

``

!

G$% +->>%++ ') #$% !-Y$'(< 1'6%: >/( @% +%%( )*'1 #$% )'::'A"(< +#/#"+#">+\ .%'.:% H + /++%++'*+

./*#">"./#"'( */#% "( >/+%+ $/+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 WEe #' b`e "( )"*+# #*"/: >/+%+4 /(6 #$% (-1@%* ') /++%++'*+ 2#$%

KTR 1%/+-*% ') *%.*%+%(#/#"9%(%++3 $/+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 b #' `E

!

`b

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% ;*'&%># $/+ +-..'*#%6 #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') #$% !-Y$'(< .":'# @B /++"+#"(< A"#$

*%+%/*>$4 "()'*1/#"'( %S>$/(<% /(6 #$% )'*1-:/#"'( ') <-"6%:"(%+ )'* /++%++'*+

!

5(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 )"9%

+%1"(/*+ A%*% $%:64 / (-1@%* ') )"%:6 *%+%/*>$ /++"<(1%(#+ -(6%* #$% .":'# .*'<*/1 A%*% >'(6->#%6 /(6 #A'

"(#%*(/#"'(/: +#-6B #'-*+ A%*% -(6%*#/I%(

!

P/(B A'*I+$'.+ $%:.%6 #' A'*I '-# #$% 6%#/":+ ')

"1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

G$*'-<$ *%+%/*>$ /(6 9"+"#+ #' >'-*#+ "( %>'('1">/::B 6%9%:'.%6 >'-(#*"%+ 2 %

!

<

!

=%*1/(B4

L-+#*"/4 J./"(4 /(6 ;'*#-</:34 #$%B >'-:6 @%##%* -(6%*+#/(6 "++-%+ A"#$ +B+#%1+ +"1":/* #' .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+

%:+%A$%*%

!

X*'1 #$% =,8

"

+.'(+'*%6 "(#%*9%(#"'(+4 #$%B >'-:6 "(>*%/+% #$% %(#$-+"/+1 /(6 -(6%*+#/(6"(< ')

/++%++'*+4 /(6 A'*I '-# $'A #' *%<-:/*"Y% /++%++'*H+ A'*I 2:'<"+#">+4 *':%4 %#>3Q

bE

!

R( /66"#"'( #' #$% =,8 "1./># '( %+#/@:"+$"(< /(6 "1.*'9"(< #$% !-Y$'(< 1'6%:4 #$% .*'1'#"'( ') #$%

!-Y$'(< 1'6%: (/#"'(A"6% @B J;0 6%%.%(+ #$% ;*'&%># H+ >'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% ./*#">"./#"'( */#% $/+ "(>*%/+%6

(/#"'(A"6%4 )*'1 ]E 4 EEE .%*+'(+ "( DEE] A$%( #$% *%)'*1+ A%*% :/-(>$%6 #' 1'*% #$/( `E 4 EEE "(

DEWW

!

V%.*%+%(#/#"9%(%++ $/+ /:+' "(>*%/+%6 /(6 @/:/(>% 6%9%:'.%6 "( #%*1+ ') <%(6%*4 /<%4 %6->/#"'( /(6

.*')%++"'(

!

X/"*(%++ "+ .*'1'#%6 @B #$% */(6'1 +%:%>#"'( 1%>$/("+1

!

G*/"("(< "+ .*'9"6%6 #' .%'.:% H +

/++%++'*+ #' %(+-*% #$/# #$%B .'++%++ #$% (%>%++/*B .*')%++"'(/: I('A:%6<% /(6 +I"::+ 2 #$% J;0 *%?-"*%+ DE

$'-*+ .%* .%*+'( .%* B%/*3Q X"(/(>"/: +-..'*# "+ /:+' .*'9"6%6 #' <-/*/(#%% %))%>#"9% ./*#">"./#"'(

!

R( DEE_ 4

#$%*% A%*% c^E 4 EEE >/+%+ A$%*% .%'.:% H + /++%++'*+ ./*#">"./#%6 "( #$% #*"/:4 /(6 "( DEWW 4 #$"+ (-1@%*

"(>*%/+%6 #' W

!

D 1"::"'(4 />>'*6"(< #' #$% DEWD J;0 !'*I V%.'*#

!

)"

!

"

+02(7 *3% +(F02*1#-37 ,-$ 4(-52( 67 O77(77-$7 O%.#3#71$*1#-3 /(6 I'*20*1#-3 &$*.(B-$K -, 1"( 4(-52( 67 O77(77-$

4#2-1

!

J;04 4$-'#7#-37 -3 4(-52( 67 O77(77-$7 6 4*$1#H#5*1#-3 -3 !$#*2 OH1#'#1#(7 /(6 +(75-37( 1- D-.( L770(7 +(2*1(% 1-

4(-52(67 O77(77-$7C 9S-'(.J($ :;;< ?

!

Page 39: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

<$7(,3 W

!

C4$ '(&)*)+, +66").30$.3 +.& 3#+).).2 7/73$0 )7 $.4+.*$& +.& '(&)*)+, $--)*)$.*/ )7 ).*#$+7$&

!

=,> D(-6# @#"+()%4#*%

##

KTR\ R(>*%/+%6 #*/(+./*%(>B ') *%>*-"#1%(# ') &-6<%+ @B >/**B"(< '-# #$% "(#%*"1 .*'>%6-*% )'* '.%(

+%:%>#"'( ') ('9">% &-6<%+

!

J#/#-+\ ;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

G$% "(#%*"1 .*'>%6-*% )'* '.%( +%:%>#"'( ') ('9">% &-6<%+ $/+ @%%(

6%9%:'.%6 @-# "+ ('# %S.%>#%6 #' @% "++-%6 @B #$% J;0 .%(6"(< '#$%* .%*+'((%: *%)'*1+

!

['A%9%*4 +'1%

.*'9"(>%+ /*% %S.%*"1%(#"(< A"#$ (%A 1%#$'6+ ') *%>*-"#"(< &-6<%+ )*'1 #$% .-@:">

!

bW

!

0'(#%S#

!

K(% *%?-"*%1%(# )'* >/(6"6/#%+ )'* &-6<%+$".+ "+ ./++"(< #$% -(")"%6 :%</: %S/1"(/#"'( )'* :/AB%*+4

&-6<%+ /(6 .*'+%>-#'*+

!

K#$%* *%?-"*%1%(#+ "(>:-6% / >'::%<% 6%<*%% /(6 #A' B%/*+ ') A'*I"(<

%S.%*"%(>%

!

=%(%*/::B4 *%>*-"#1%(# ') &-6<%+ "(>:-6%+ #$*%% >/#%<'*"%+\ 2W 3 ('(

"

&-6<%+ A"#$"( / >'-*# #' @%

*%>*-"#%6 /+ &-6<%+d 2D 3 :'A%* :%9%: >'-*# &-6<%+ #' @% *%>*-"#%6 #' / $"<$%* :%9%: >'-*#d /(6 2c3 *%>*-"#"(< &-6<%+

%S#%*(/::B )*'1 #$% +'>"%#B

!

R( DEE` 4 #$% K*</("Y/#"'( 8%./*#1%(# ') ;/*#B 0%(#*/: 0'11"##%% "++-%6 4$-'#7#-3*2

@(*70$(7 -, 40J2#H D(2(H1#-3 -, S-'#H( G0%F(7 *3% 4$-7(H01-$74 .*'9"6"(< #$/# .-@:"> +%:%>#"'( "+ '(% A/B #'

f *%>*-"# ('9">% &-6<%+ /(6 .*'+%>-#'*+4 #$/# "+4 +%:%>#"(< %:"<"@:% /(6 ?-/:")"%6 >/(6"6/#%+ )*'1 +'>"%#B

!

bD

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% L31($#. 4$-H(%0$( ,-$ /5(3 D(2(H1#-3 -, S-'#H( G0%F(7 "+ +#":: /# #$% "(#%*(/: 6"+>-++"'(

f +#/<%

!

0-**%(#:B4 #$% J;0 "+ -(6%*<'"(< / .%*+'((%: 1/(/<%1%(# *%)'*1 "( >:/++")">/#"'(

!

8%#/":%6 +%:%>#"'(

.*'>%6-*%+ )'* /:: #$*%% >/#%<'*"%+ /@'9% /*% .%(6"(< "++-/(>% ') / *%9"+%6 J;0 .%*+'((%: 1/(/<%1%(#

>:/++")">/#"'(

!

L>>'*6"(< #' #$% J;04 1/(B .*'9"(>%+ $/9% %S.%*"1%(#%6 A"#$ '.%( *%>*-"#1%(# ') &-6<%+ )*'1

#$% .-@:">

!

G$% <%(%*/: +%:%>#"'( */#% "+ W \ c '* W \ ] 2'(% '-# ') c '* ] >/(6"6/#%+3Q ['A%9%*4 "( A%+#%*(

0$"(/4 A$%*% #$% (-1@%*+ ') ?-/:")"%6 >/(6"6/#%+ /*% :"1"#%64 #$% +%:%>#"'( */#% >'-:6 @% $"<$%*

!

J'1%

.*'9"(>%+4 +->$ /+ J$/(S" /(6 J$//(S"4 $/9% "++-%6 +%:%>#"'( .*'>%6-*%+ /(6 >*"#%*"/

!

bc

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

L>#"9"#"%+ +-..'*#%6 -(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%># 1/"(:B )'>-+%6 '( 6%9%:'."(< /( "(#%*"1

.*'>%6-*% )'* '.%( +%:%>#"'( ') ('9">% &-6<%+

!

GA' +%1"(/*+ A%*% $%:6 "( DEWE )'* >'-*# '))">"/:+ /# /:: :%9%:+

#' +$/*% %S.%*"%(>%4 >$/::%(<%+ /(6 :%++'(+ '( *%>*-"#"(< ('9">% &-6<%+ %S#%*(/::B )*'1 #$% +'>"%#B

!

G$%

/>#"9"#"%+ .*'9"6%6 / )'*-1 )'* 6"+>-++"(< #$% .*'<*%++ /(6 >$/::%(<%+ "( #$% .*'9"(>"/: %S.%*"1%(#+

!

R(

/66"#"'(4 / .-@:">/#"'( '( &-6<% *%>*-"#1%(# >/1% '-# "( P/*>$ DEWD 2/J7($'*1#-37 -3 &-$(#F3 G0%F(7

@*3*F(.(31 DM71(.3 /(6 c 4 EEE >'."%+ $/9% @%%( .*'6->%6 -(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%># )'* 6"++%1"(/#"'(

!

=;> 8&$% #<<)")#*"3

##

KTR\ 7%A C-6">"/: ,))">"%(>B =-"6% 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' >'-*#+ (/#"'(A"6%

!

J#/#-+\ ;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

G$% J;0 $/+ .*%./*%6 / C-6">"/: ,))">"%(>B =-"6%4 @/+%6 '( *%+%/*>$4 +#-6B

/(6 %S.%*"%(>%+ "( %"<$# .*'9"(>%

"

:%9%: &-*"+6">#"'(+

!

G$% 6*/)# "+ @%"(< *%9"%A%6

!

G$% >'(>%.#+ /*% @%"(<

.":'#%6

!

*#

Page 40: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

b^

!

0'(#%S#

!

G$% >-**%(# 6%@/#% '( &-6">"/: >'+# /(6 %))">"%(>B "( #$% 0$"(%+% &-6">"/: +B+#%1 )'>-+%+ '( #$%

)'::'A"(< I%B "++-%+\ 2/3 %))">"%(# /::'>/#"'( ') &-6">"/: *%+'-*>%+4 A$">$ "(>:-6%+ @'#$ <-/*/(#%%"(< /( %))">"%(#

/::'>/#"'( ') @-6<%#/*B *%+'-*>%+ #' #$% &-6">"/: +%>#'* /(6 %))%>#"9% -+% ') #$%+% *%+'-*>%+ A"#$"( #$% &-6">"/:

+%>#'*d 2@3 *%/+'(/@:B +$/*"(< &-6">"/: >'+# @%#A%%( ./*#"%+ /(6 #$% >'-*#+ /(6 /1'(< 6"))%*%(# :%9%:+ ') >'-*#+d

2>3 %+#/@:"+$"(< L8V #' "1.*'9% &-6">"/: %))">"%(>Bd 2 6 3 )-*#$%* *%)'*1"(< >"9": /(6 >*"1"(/: .*'>%6-*%+ #'

"1.*'9% %))">"%(>Bd /(6 2%3 "1.*'9"(< >'-*# 1/(/<%1%(# /(6 %9/:-/#"'( +B+#%1+

!

b]

!

V%+-:#+

!

L .":'# '( *%6->"(< &-6">"/: >'+#+ /(6 />>%:%*/#"(< &-6">"/: %))">"%(>B A/+ :/-(>$%6 "( 7/(&"(< "(

7'9%1@%* DEWE

!

G$*%% :'>/: >'-*#+ "( 7/(&"(< $/9% @%%( +%:%>#%6 /+ #$% .":'#"(< +"#%+4 '(% /# #$% 1-(">"./:

:%9%: /(6 #A' /# #$% @/+"> :%9%:4 #' .":'# (%A 1%/+-*%+ '( >/+% 1/(/<%1%(# *%)'*14 +1/:: >:/"1+ .*'>%6-*%

/(6 "1.*'9"(< &-6">"/: %))">"%(>B "( /:: +#/<%+ ') :"#"</#"'(

!

P'*% *%>%(#:B4 / 6"+#*"># >'-*# "( C":"( 0"#B "( C":"(

;*'9"(>% "+ .":'#"(< #$% >'((%>#"'( @%#A%%( 1%6"/#"'( /(6 :"#"</#"'(4 /(6 / 6"+#*"># >'-*# "( G/"B-/(

P-(">"./:"#B "( J$/(S" ;*'9"(>% "+ .":'#"(< *%)'*1 ') A*"##%( &-6<%1%(#+ /(6 "1.*'9"(< #%>$(">/: +#*%(<#$+ ')

>'-*#+

!

b_

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

5(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 #$% 0$"(/ R(+#"#-#% ') L..:"%6 C-*"+.*-6%(>% $/+ >'(6->#%6

9/*"'-+ +#-6"%+4 +-*9%B+ /(6 >'(+-:#/#"'( A'*I+$'.+ '( :"#"</#"'( >'+#+

!

L>>'*6"(< #' #$% R(+#"#-#%H+ +#/#"+#">+4

#$% ;*'&%># +-..'*#%6\ +%1"(/*+d )"%:6 +#-6B 2W_ :'>/: >'-*#+ "( )'-* .*'9"(>%+3d #*/(+:/#"'( ') )'*%"<( 1/#%*"/:+

/(6 @''I+d +#-6B #'-*+ 2=%*1/(B4 5m4 7%A k%/:/(6 /(6 L-+#*/:"/3d /(6 %S#%(+"9% 1%6"/ *%.'*#+ "( +%9%*/:

1/"(+#*%/1 &'-*(/:+ 2;%'.:%H+ C-+#">%4 O/A L..:">/#"'( /(6 ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# 7%A+3Q X"9% >'-*#+ A%*% +%:%>#%6 /+

.":'#+4 /(64 @/+%6 '( #$%"* %S.%*"%(>%4 / G0%#H#*2 I,,#H#(3HM N0#%( A/+ 6*/)#%6

!

G$*%% @''I+ $/9% @%%(

f .-@:"+$%6 -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#\ I.5#$#H*2 D10%M -, G0%#H#*2 8-71 *3% G0%#H#*2 I,,#H#(3HMC D(*$H"#3F ,-$ D0HH(77 #3

G0%#H#*2 +(,-$.Q X-#H(7 ,$-. 1"( O7#* 4*H#,#H IE5($#(3H( /(6 8*2#,-$3#* G0%F(7 T(3H"J--KQ D.*22 82*#.7 8-0$1

*3% 8-370.($ A*B

!

bF

!

P'*% #$/( FEE &-6<%+ ./*#">"./#%6 "( 6"))%*%(# ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ "( ` 6"))%*%(# .*'9"(>%+4 A$%#$%* /##%(6"(<

+%1"(/*+ 2(%/*:B DEE 34 >'(#*"@-#"(< "6%/+ "( )"%:6 *%+%/*>$ 2W_E 4 "(>:-6"(< WE )'*%"<( &-6<%+34 '* ./*#">"./#"(<

"( +-*9%B+ 2cEE 3Q R( /66"#"'(4 / >'(+"6%*/@:% /1'-(# ') *%)%*%(>% 1/#%*"/: $/+ @%%( #*/(+:/#%6 A"#$ ./.%*+

.-@:"+$%6 /(6 6"++%1"(/#%6 #' :'>/: >'-*#+

!

G$% .'': ') "()'*1/#"'( $/+ #$% .'#%(#"/: #' $/9% /( "1./># '(

#$% (%S# &-6">"/: *%)'*1 .:/(

!

b`

!

;*'&%># >'(#*"@-#"'(+ >/( @% +%%( "( #$% )'::'A"(< /*%/+

!

2/3 G$% >'(>%.# ') &-6">"/: >'+#

"

%))">"%(>B $/+

@%%( A"6%:B />>%.#%6

!

!$":% .*%9"'-+ *%+%/*>$ '( #$"+ +-@&%># A/+ 1/"(:B >'(6->#%6 /# / 9%*B <%(%*/: :%9%:4

1'*% *%+%/*>$ #'6/B )'>-+%+ '( +.%>")"> .*/>#">% "++-%+ *%:/#%6 #' >'+#

"

%))">"%(>B

!

R( DEWW 4 #$% J;0 .*'1'#%6 WE

&-6">"/: >'(>%.#+ (/#"'(A"6% /(6 >'+#

"

%))">"%(>B A/+ '(% ') #$%1

!

2@3 G$% ;*'&%># .*'1'#%6 +'1% (%A J;0

.':">"%+ '( >'+#

"

%))">"%(>B4 +->$ /+ #$% .":'# '( +1/:: >:/"1+

!

G$% %S#%(+"9% 1/#%*"/:+ >'::%>#%6 -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#

!#

Page 41: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

:/"6 / <''6 #$%'*%#">/: )'-(6/#"'( )'* )-*#$%* *%)'*1

!

2>3 G$% ;*'&%># $/+ /:+' .*'1'#%6 #$%'*%#">/: *%+%/*>$ "(

&-6">"/: >'+#

"

%))">"%(>B "( />/6%1"/

!

263 G$% D48 G0%#H#*2 I,,#H#(3HM N0#%( $/+ @%%( 6*/)#%64 /(6 %1.$/+"Y%+

f .*/>#">/:"#B4 "(('9/#"'( /(6 )'*%+"<$#%6(%++

!

G$% 6*/)# =-"6% $/+ @%%( -+%6 "( #$% )"9% .":'# >'-*#+4 A"#$

%S.%*"%(>% /++%++%6 "( ;*'&%># A'*I+$'.+

!

G$% =-"6% "+ >-**%(#:B -(6%* )'*%"<( %S.%*#+H *%9"%A

!

2%3 G$% *%/>$

') #$% ;*'&%># A/+ @*'/6%(%6 A"#$ #$% ./*#">"./#"'( ') @/+"> >'-*# &-6<%+ "( "(#%*(/#"'(/: +#-6B #'-*+

!

!

="> D(-6#$ .+,)*)*6

##

KTR\ ]EE &-6<%+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(< '( #$% /..:">/#"'( ') :/A /(6 -(6%*+#/(6"(< ') (%A:B %(/>#%6

.':">"%+ )*'1 #$% =,8 .*'&%>#

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

7%/*:B FEE &-6<%+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(< -(6%* #$% ;*'&%># "( *%:/#%6 /*%/+\ &-6">"/:

1%#$'6':'<B4 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/:+4 ./*':% /(6 +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'(4 /1%(61%(# ') 0*"1"(/: O/A /(6

0*"1"(/: ;*'>%6-*% O/A4 >/+% <-"6/(>% /(6 L8V

!

bb

!

0'(#%S#

!

J.%>"/:"Y%6 &-6">"/: #*/"("(< "(+#"#-#"'(+ A%*% %+#/@:"+$%6 "( 0$"(/ "( WbbF d #%/>$"(< 1%#$'6':'<B

/(6 >'-*+% >-**">-:-1 /*% -(6%* >'(#"(-'-+ 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 "1.*'9"(< #%/>$"(< 1/#%*"/:+ A/+ +%#

/+ / A'*I .*"'*"#B )'* #$% >'-*# +B+#%1 "( DEWE

!

N-":6"(< #$% >/./>"#B ') #$%+% #*/"("(< "(+#"#-#"'(+ /(6

.*'6->"(< #*/"("(< 1/#%*"/:+ #$/# /*% +-"#/@:% #' #$% 0$"(%+% >'(#%S# $/9% @%%( >*"#">/: )'* &-6">"/:

1'6%*("Y/#"'( "( 0$"(/

!

WEE

!

V%+-:#+

!

G/@:% W @%:'A +$'A+ #$/#4 A"#$ Fb` #*/"(%%+ -(6%* #$"+ 0'1.'(%(#4 #$% KTR #/*<%# 2]EE 3 "+

%S>%%6%6

!

C+Z,$ T

!

C#+).).2 >*3)5)3)$7 (.&$# ?"06".$.3 >

F+3$ N(Z'$*3 B06,$0$.3+3)". >2$.*/ =(0Z$# "- G+#3)*)6+.37

8%>%1@%* DEE` C-6">"/: P%#$'6':'<B 7/#"'(/: C-6<%+ 0'::%<% DEE

P/B DEEb 0*"1"(/: V%#*"/: G*"/: J-.%*9"+"'( 8"9"+"'(4 J;0 ]^

8%>%1@%* DEEb ;/*':% /(6 J%(#%(>% 0'11-#/#"'( G*"/: J-.%*9"+"'( 8"9"+"'(4 J;0 W]D

8%>%1@%* DEWE

G$% L1%(61%(# ') 0*"1"(/: O/A /(6

0*"1"(/: ;*'>%6-*/: O/A

G*"/: J-.%*9"+"'( 8"9"+"'(4 J;0 WcE

8%>%1@%* DEWE 0/+% =-"6/(>% !'*I V%+%/*>$ 8%./*#1%(#4 J;0 FE

P/B DEWW G$%'*B /(6 .*/>#">% '( L8V 7/#"'(/: C-6<%+ 0'::%<% WbD

Fb`

"#

! L 6%#/":%6 *%9"%A /(6 /++%++1%(# ') #$% ;*'&%># +-@

"

>'1.'(%(# '( &-6">"/: >'+# /(6 %))">"%(>B "+ .*%+%(#%6 "(

N/:1% DEWD

!

Page 42: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WEW

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ A%*% >'(6->#%6 -(6%* #$"+ +-@

"

>'1.'(%(# /(6 #$*'-<$'-# /::

#$% />#"9"#"%+ ') 0'1.'(%(# L4 A"#$ #A' '@&%>#"9%+\

!G' "1.*'9% #$% .*')%++"'(/: >/./>"#B ') #$% +%("'* &-6<%+ 2)'>-+"(< '( /6&-6">/#"'( 1%#$'6':'<Bd >*"1"(/:

*%#*"/:4 ./*':% /(6 +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'(d >/+% <-"6/(>% A'*Id /(6 >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'(3Q

!G' "1.*'9% #$% #*/"("(< >/./>"#B ') &-6">"/: #*/"("(< "(+#"#-#"'(+ 2 "6%(#")B"(< #*/"("(< (%%6+4 %S.:'*"(<

>$/(<%+ "( #*/"("(< 6%:"9%*B4 /(6 #*/"("(< :%/6%*+ "( #$% >'-*# .%*+'((%: 6%./*#1%(#+ #' $%:. #$%1 -(6%*+#/(6

>'-*# 1/(/<%1%(# /(6 .*')%++"'(/: #*/"("(< /(6 @% %))%>#"9% #*/"(%*+3Q

5(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 %))'*#+ A%*% 1/6% #' %S.:'*% #*/"("(< 1%#$'6':'<"%+ +-"#/@:% #' #$% 0$"(%+%

>'(#%S#

!

K(% %S/1.:% "+ #' -+% 0$"(%+% :/A /(6 >/+%+ @-# #' >/**B '-# #*/"("(< #$*'-<$ "(#%*/>#"9% 1%#$'6+

:%/*(%6 )*'1 =%*1/(B4 #' 1/S"1"Y% #$% #*/"("(< "1./>#

!

WED

!

=''6 .*'<*%++ $/+ /:+' @%%( 1/6% "( "1.*'9"(< #%/>$"(< 1/#%*"/:+

!

0$"(%+% &-6">"/: #*/"("(<

"(+#"#-#"'(+ $/9% 6%9%:'.%6 +'1% #*/"("(< 1/#%*"/:+ "( #$% ./+# )%A B%/*+4 @-# #$%+% /*% ('# )-::B

+#/(6/*6"Y%6 /(6 +B+#%1/#">

!

G$*'-<$ +#-6B #'-*+ #' [-(</*B /(6 0Y%>$ V%.-@:">4 /(6 /( "(#%*(/#"'(/:

+%1"(/*4 0$"(%+% #*/"("(< "(+#"#-#"'(+ )'-(6 1'*% +B+#%1/#"> 1/#%*"/:+ "( '#$%* >'-(#*"%+4 +->$ /+ +%./*/#%

#%/>$"(< 1/#%*"/:+ )'* @/+"> /(6 /69/(>%6 :%9%:+ ') :%/*("(<

!

R( X*/(>%4 #$%*% "+ / )"9%

"

B%/* #*/"("(<

.*'<*/1 #' @-":6 Wc >/./>"#"%+ #$/# #$% &-6<%+ (%%6

!

G$%+% )"(6"(<+ A%*% 9%*B -+%)-: )'* #$% "1.*'9%1%(#

') 0$"(%+% &-6">"/: #*/"("(< 1/#%*"/:+

!

?9HG9=;=C D

!

E>M >=F G9EB?P H>VB=8 NPNC;H BN BHG<9:;F

!

<$7(,3 T

!

C4$ 6+#3)*)6+3"#/ 6#"*$77 -"# ,+%

"

0+1).2 )7 ).73)3(3)".+,)Y$&

!

WEc

!

0'(#%S#

!

R( 0$"(/4 #$*%% 1/"( )'*1+ ') .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :%<"+:/#"'( /*% "( -+%\ .-@:"> >'11%(#+ '(

6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'(d :%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+d /(6 +':">"#"(< .*'.'+/:+ )'* :%<"+:/#"'(

!

;-@:"> >'11%(# .*'>%++%+ $/9%

@%%( "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y%6 /# #$% 7;0 :%9%:

!

G$%*% /*% (' (/#"'(/: *-:%+ )'* :%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+ '* +':">"#"(<

.*'.'+/:+ )'* :%<"+:/#"'(

!

;*/>#">%+ $/9% 6%9%:'.%6 /# #$% .*'9"(>"/:g:'>/: :%9%: "( /:: #$*%% /*%/+

!

"

##

!

"

G$% +'-*>%+ /(6 1%/(+ ') 9%*")">/#"'( :"+#%6 "( #$% O'<)*/1% )'* 0'1.'(%(# N >'9%*\ 7;0 </Y%##%4 *%.'*#+ /(6

.-@:">/#"'(+ 27;0 A%@+"#% 3d .*'&%># 1'("#'*"(< *%.'*#+ /(6 .*'&%># />#"9"#B *%.'*#+d 1%6"/ >'9%*/<%d /(6 J#/#% 0'-(>":

</Y%##%4 *%.'*#+ /(6 .-@:">/#"'(+ '( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'(

!

J"(>% 6'>-1%(#+ $/9% ('# @%%( '))">"/::B "++-%64 (%"#$%* </Y%##%

A/+ (%%6%6 /+ / +'-*>%

!

P%6"/ >'9%*/<% "+ ('#%6 /+ *%:%9/(#

!

G$% "()'*1/#"'( $%*% '( 7;0 9"%A+ "+ :/*<%:B 6%*"9%6 )*'1 /(

"(#%*9"%A A"#$ 7;0 O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"++"'( '))">"/:+ "( X%@*-/*B DEWD

!

;-@:"> >'11%(# 1%>$/("+1+ /*% 6"+>-++%6 <%(%*/::B -(6%* K9%*/:: KTR+ "( ./*/<*/.$+ D^

"

D_ 4 ./*/<*/.$+ ]]

"

]F

/(6 N'S D '( ;-@:"> ;/*#">"./#"'( "( O/A

"

1/I"(< /# #$% ;*'9"(>"/: O%9%:3Q

Page 43: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

=,> B(;0)" B,+%)")2,%)&* :* E,1 ?+,<%)*6

##

KTR

*

R1.*'9%6 "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+4 "(>:-6"(< +-@+#/(#"9% /(6 .*'>%6-*/: +#/(6/*6+4 )'* .-@:">

./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A 6*/)#"(<

!

=-"6%:"(%+ 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' .%'.:%+ >'(<*%++%+ (/#"'(A"6%

!

J#/#-+\ ;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

G' "1.:%1%(# #$% 7;0H+ DEE` .':">B *%<-:/*"Y"(< .-@:"> >'11%(# '( 6*/)#

:%<"+:/#"'(4 #$% 7;0 O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"++"'( $/+ "(+#"#-#%6 / 6%#/":%6 +%# ') >'11'( .*/>#">%+

2*%.'*#%6:B +%# '-# "( "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+3Q K( #$/# @/+"+4 #$% 7;0 $/+ +':">"#%6 .-@:"> >'11%(# '( /:1'+# /::

6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( +"(>% DEE`

!

!$":% <-"6%:"(%+ )'* O;0+ '( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( $/9% ('# @%%( 1/6% .-@:">4

%/>$ .*'9"(>% $/+ "++-%6 *-:%+ '( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(<4 %"#$%* /+ +#/(6

"

/:'(% :%<"+:/#"'( '*

A"#$"( '#$%* :%<"+:/#"'(

!

;-@:"> >'11%(# .*'>%++%+ /*% /:+' "( -+% "( .*'9"(>"/: :%9%: :/A 1/I"(<

!

WE^

!

V%+-:#+

!

N%#A%%( L.*": DEE` /(6 8%>%1@%* DEWW 4 / #'#/: ') c] 7;0 6*/)# :/A+ A%*% .-@:">"Y%64 A"#$

1/(B >:'+%:B *%:/#%6 #' #$% .-@:"> H + "(#%*%+# <%(%*/#"(< >'(+"6%*/@:% >'11%(#+

!

2 G$*%% 6*/)#+ A%*% ('#

.-@:">"Y%6 "( #$"+ .%*"'6 *%:/#%6 #' (/#"'(/: +%>-*"#B '* 1":"#/*B 1/##%*+4 +->$ /+ #$% P":"#/*B J%*9">% O/A

!

3

WE]

!

L( "(#%*(/: A'*I"(< .*'>%6-*% )'* #$"+ .-@:"> >'11%(# .*'>%++ A/+ +%# -. "( DEE` 4 #' "1.:%1%(# #$%

(%A .':">B

!

L>>'*6"(< #' #$% 7;0 +#/))4 #$% .*'>%++ 6%+>*"@%6 )'* .-@:"> >'11%(# "+ 6%#/":%6

!

G$% 6*/)#+ /*%

-+-/::B *%:%/+%6 )'* >'11%(#+ /)#%* #$% )"*+# '* +%>'(6 ') #$% #$*%% J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% V%/6"(<+

!

0'11%(#+

>/( @% +%(# @B %1/":4 :%##%*4 )/S '* #%:%.$'(% >/::

!

8%+"<(/#%6 +#/)) /# #$% 7;0 >'::%>#4 '*</("Y% /(6 /(/:BY%

%/>$ +%# ') >'11%(#+ /(6 .*'9"6% / 1"6

"

#%*1 )%%6@/>I #' #$% .-@:"> "( #$% 1"66:% ') #$% >'(+-:#/#"'( .%*"'64

-+-/::B /*'-(6 #$% W]

#$

6/B ') #$% '(%

"

1'(#$ >'(+-:#/#"'( .%*"'6

!

7;0 '))">"/:+ /:+' "(#%*/># A"#$ #$% <%(%*/:

.-@:"> #$*'-<$ '(:"(% 6"/:'<-%

!

!$%( #$% J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% >'(+"6%*+ / :/A4 #$%*% "+ -+-/::B / 1%6"/

@*"%)"(< '( #$% 6*/)# :/A+

!

J'1%#"1%+4 #$% 1%6"/ .-@:">"Y%+ #$% 1/"( >'(#%(# /(6 1/&'* "++-%+ ') #$% .*'.'+%6

:%<"+:/#"'( %9%( @%)'*% #$% 6*/)# :/A "+ .-@:">"Y%6 #' #$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> @B #$% 7;0

!

=%(%*/:"Y%6 *%+.'(+%+ #'

>'11%(#+ *%>%"9%6 >/( @% .'+#%6 '( #$% A%@

!

K) 6*/)# :/A+ .'+#%6 )'* >'11%(#4 #$% R(6"9"6-/: R(>'1% G/S

O/A *%9"+"'(+ *%>%"9%6 #$% 1'+# .-@:"> )%%6@/>I4 DcE 4 EEE >'11%(#+

!

N/+%6 '( .-@:"> '."("'(4 #$% +#/*#"(<

#/S/#"'( .'"(# )'* "(6"9"6-/: "(>'1% #/S A/+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 #$% '*"<"(/: VPN cEEE #' VPN c]EE

!

WE_

!

O;0+ $/9% #$%"* 'A( +#/(6/*6+

!

G$% 7;0 .*'1'#%+ #$% O;0+ A'*I "( #$"+ /*%/ 1/"(:B #$*'-<$ +%1"(/*+

/(6 *%+%/*>$ />#"9"#"%+d (' (/#"'(A"6% <-"6%:"(%+ $/9% @%>'1% .-@:">

!

G' 6/#%4 %/>$ .*'9"(>% "++-%6 *-:%+ '(

.-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(<4 %"#$%* /+ +#/(6

"

/:'(% :%<"+:/#"'( '* A"#$"( '#$%* :%<"+:/#"'(

!

;-@:"> >'11%(#

.*'>%++%+ /*% /:+' "( -+% "( .*'9"(>"/: :%9%: :/A

"

1/I"(<

!

J'1% "(('9/#"'( /(6 ):%S"@":"#B $/9% %1%*<%6 "( :'>/:

.*/>#">%4 "(>:-6"(< %(#*-+#"(< $"<$%* %6->/#"'(/: "(+#"#-#"'(+ #' +':">"# .-@:"> '."("'(+ '( @%$/:) ') #$% O;0

!

WEF

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

=,8 "(.-#+ $%:.%6 #' )'>-+ 6"+>-++"'(+ '( +%9%*/: I%B ?-%+#"'(+4 /+ *%>'-(#%6 @B

#$% 7;0\ 2/ 3 6'%+ %(</<"(< #$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> "( #$% :%<"+:/#"'( .*'>%++ +$'A 1'*% +B1@':"> 9/:-% #$/(

$#

Page 44: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

+-@+#/(#"9% 9/:-%d 2@3 /*% %S.%*#+ H '."("'(+ 9/:-%6 1'*% #$/( #$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> H+ '."("'(+d 2 >3 A$":% #$%

<%(%*/: .-@:"> "+ %(#$-+"/+#"> /@'-# ./*#">"./#"'(4 >/( '*6"(/*B >"#"Y%(+ .*'9"6% "(.-#+ ') $"<$ ?-/:"#Bd 263 #$%

/@+%(>% ') +#/(6/*6 *%<-:/#"'(+4 @'#$ +-@+#/(#"9% /(6 .*'>%6-*/:4 '( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'(d /(6 2 % 3 /*%

%S.:/(/#"'(+ .*'9"6%6 A$%( .-@:"> '."("'(+ /*% ('# />>%.#%6

!

WE`

!

!"#$ =,8 +-..'*#4 .-@:">"Y"(< 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( $/+ @%>'1% / .*/>#">% ') #$% 7;0 /(6 #$% O;0+

!

G$% =,8

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% >'(+%(+-+ @-":6"(< #$/# 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( 1-+# @% .-@:">"Y%6 /(6 "(+."*%6

:'>/: ;0+ #' "++-% *-:%+ <-"6"(< /(6 "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y"(< .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( !'*I+$'.+ /(6 +#-6B #'-*+ $%:.%6 #'

>$/(<% 9"%A+ /(6 +-..'*# #$"+ .*/>#">%

!

2J%% N'S D '( .*'9"(>"/: .*/>#">%

!

3

=;> E#6)$0,%)7# F#,+)*6$

##

KTR\ P'*% >:/*")"%6 +-@+#/(#"9% /(6 .*'>%6-*/: +#/(6/*6+ /..:"%6 #' %($/(>"(< #$% ?-/:"#B ') .-@:">

$%/*"(<+ "( #$% :%</: .*'>%++%+

!

J#/#-+\ ;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

L:: .*'9"(>%+ $/9% $%:6 .-@:"> :%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+ /(6 .*'6->%6 *-:%+4

A$">$ $/9% +#/*#%6 #' >:/*")B /..:">/@:% +#/(6/*6+

!

['A%9%*4 (/#"'(/: <-"6%:"(%+ )'* .-@:"> $%/*"(<+ 2@B #$%

7;03 $/9% ('# @%%( "++-%6

!

WEb

!

0'(#%S#

!

G$% )"*+# :%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(< A/+ "( =-/(<6'(< ;*'9"(>% "( Wbbb 4 /(6 #$% )"*+# +/(>#"'("(< ') #$%

.*'>%6-*% 2/+ / <%(%*/: '.#"'(4 ('# / 6%#/":%6 *%?-"*%1%(#3 A/+ "( #$% A(F#72*1#-3 A*B "( DEEE

!

!

R(#%*%+#"(<:B4

#$% =-/(<6'(< $%/*"(< >'9%*%6 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( '( .*'>%6-*%+ )'* "(9"#"(< /(6 /A/*6"(< >'(+#*->#"'(

>'(#*/>#+4 / +'-*>% ') .-@:"> )*-+#*/#"'( A"#$ >'(>%*( '9%* */1./(# >'**-.#"'(

!

"

NB 8%>%1@%* DEED 4 /::

.*'9"(>"/: .%'.:% H + >'(<*%++%+ 2 %S>%.# #$% a"(&"/(< L-#'('1'-+ V%<"'( 34 Wb 1-(">"./:"#"%+ /(6 #$% )'-*

+.%>"/: %>'('1"> Y'(%+ $/6 A*"##%( $%/*"(<+ "(#' #$%"* :%<"+:/#"9% .*'>%6-*/: *-:%+

!

U%#4 %9%( / )%A B%/*+ :/#%*4

#$%*% A%*% +#":: (' %+#/@:"+$%6 (/#"'(A"6% *-:%+ )'* $%/*"(<+ /(6 '(:B %"<$# .*'9"(>%+ /(6 1-(">"./:"#"%+ $/6

>*%/#%6 *-:%+ '( $%/*"(<+ -+%6 #$*'-<$'-# /( %(#"*% &-*"+6">#"'(

!

#

WWE

!

V%+-:#+

!

;*'<*%++ "( #$% /*%/ ') .-@:"> $%/*"(<+ "( :%<"+:/#"9% .*'>%++%+ "+ :"1"#%64 1/"(:B @%>/-+% #$%*% "+

('# B%# / >'(+%(+-+ '( #$% (/#-*% /(6 *':% ') $%/*"(<+

!

;-@:"> $%/*"(<+ $/9% ')#%( @%%( 9"%A%6 /+ #$%

>'()*'(#/#"'( ') #A' +"6%+ $':6"(< '..'+"#% 9"%A+4 1/I"(< "# "1.'*#/(# #' )"(6 #A' '..'+"#% +"6%+ A%::

"

1/#>$%6

!

G$% '*</("Y"(< .*'>%++ >'-:6 @% %S#*%1%:B >'1.:">/#%6 /(6 >'+#:B

!

$

G$% 7;0 $/+ $/6 '(:B '(%

$%/*"(<4 "( DEE] 4 '( #$% R(6"9"6-/: R(>'1% G/S O/A

!

%#

!

"

#

$

;/:%* DEE] /# cWW

!

;/:%* DEE] /# cW^

!

;/:%* DEE] /# cW]

!

7;0 R(#%*9"%A

!

Page 45: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WWW

!

J"(>% #$%(4 /:: cW .*'9"(>%+ $/9% $%:6 .-@:"> $%/*"(<+ /(6 $/9% /..:">/@:% *-:%+4

!

/:#$'-<$ />#-/:

.*/>#">% /# #$% .*'9"(>"/: :%9%: "+ :"1"#%6

!

"

0'11'( )%/#-*%+ ') #$%+% $%/*"(<+ "(>:-6%\ /69/(>% ('#">%4

.-@:">/#"'( ') 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( "( 1%6"/ )'* >'11%(#4 *%<"+#*/#"'( ') A"#(%++%+ /(6 '@+%*9%*+ 2@'#$ /##%(6/(>%

/(6 ./*#">"./#"'( ')#%( *%?-"*% /69/(>% /..*'9/:34 /(6 1%6"/ 1/B @% "(9"#%6 #' /##%(6

!

#

WWD

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% >'(#*"@-#"'(+ ') #$% =,8 ;*'&%># "(>:-6%\ 2/3 .*'9"6"(< / )'*-1 #' +-11/*"Y%

/(6 %S>$/(<% :'>/: .*/>#">%+4 /::'A"(< #$% O;0+ #' +$/*% #$%"* 'A( 9"%A+ '( .-@:"> $%/*"(<+d 2@3 #$*'-<$

9/*"'-+ +%1"(/*+4 )'*1"(< #$% >'(+%(+-+ #$/# / .-@:"> $%/*"(< "+ ('# / >'()*'(#/#"'( @-# / *'-#"(% >$/((%: #'

+':">"# .-@:"> '."("'(d /(6 2>3 %(>'-*/<"(< #$% O;0+ #' "++-% :'>/: *-:%+

!

G$% 7;0 /:+' $/+ "#+ 'A( 6*/)# *-:%+

A$">$ /*% +#":: -(6%* 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

<$7(,3 U

!

;.4+.*$& *+6+*)3)$7 "- 34$ ,$2)7,+3(#$ I=G?J -"# ,+%

"

0+1).2 34#"(24 6"73

"

,$2)7,+3)5$ #$5)$% I$R 6"73

)06+*3 +77$770$.3 "- ,$2)7,+3)".J[

WWc

!

0'(#%S#

!

;'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A "( 0$"(/ "+ /:+' >/::%6 %9/:-/#"'( ') :%<"+:/#"'( %))%>#"9%(%++ '* :%<"+:/#"9%

?-/:"#B

!

G$"+ *%9"%A /"1+ #' %S/1"(% A$%#$%* #$% 1%>$/("+1 %+#/@:"+$%6 "( #$% :%<"+:/#"'( "+ /..*'.*"/#%4 #$%

>'(#%(# ') #$% :%<"+:/#"'( "+ )'>-+%6 %('-<$ #' +':9% +.%>")"> .*'@:%1+4 #$% :%<"+:/#"'( $/+ @%%( %()'*>%/@:%

/(6 #$% :%<"+:/#"'( $/+ <%(%*/#%6 <''6 *%+-:#+

!

!'*I '( .'+#

"

*%9"%A ') 7;0 :%<"+:/#"'( @%</( "( DEE_ 4 @-#

6%9%:'.%6 )-*#$%* A"#$ ;*'&%># +-..'*#

!

;*'9"(>"/: :%9%: .*/>#">%+ /*% /:+' %1%*<"(<

!

I+J G"73

"

E$2)7,+3)5$ <$5)$%

##

KTR

*

7%A "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+ 6%9%:'.%6 '( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%AQ

J#/#-+

*

;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6Q 7/#"'(/: <-"6%:"(%+ '( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A /*% +#":: -(6%* 6%9%:'.1%(#4

@-# .*/>#">%+ /*% @%"(< 6%9%:'.%6 /(6 .":'#%6Q G$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% $/+ >/::%6 )'* .*/>#">%+ #' @%

"1.*'9%64 /(6 *%<-:/*"Y%6Q

KTR

*

;":'#"(< <*'-. %+#/@:"+$%6 )'* A'*I '( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%AQ

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6Q GA' .":'#+ '( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A A%*% >'(6->#%6 "( DEEb /(6 DEWE

*%+.%>#"9%:B4 /(6 / .":'#"(< <*'-. +%# -.Q

KTR

*

R(>*%/+%6 ./*#">"./#"'( ') %S.%*#+ "( #$% .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A .*'>%++Q

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6Q ,S.%*#+ A%*% "(9':9%6 "( #$% .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A .":'#+Q

WW^

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% 7;0 :/-(>$%6 / .":'# "( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A "( DEEb 4 )'::'A"(< 1'*% #$/( WE .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A .":'#+ /# #$% :'>/: :%9%:

!

GA' .":'#+ A%*% >'(6->#%6 '( A*B -3 DH#(3H( *3% !(H"3-2-FM

&#

!

"

#

7;0 R(#%*9"%A

!

[-/(< l ;%%*%(@''1 DEWD /# WW

!

;/:%* DEE] /# cW]

!

Page 46: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

4$-F$(77 /(6 OF$#H0210$*2 !(H"3-2-FM 4$-.-1#-3 A*B /(6 >'1.:%#%6 @B DEWW

!

G$% 7;0 *%9"%A ') #$% DH#(3H(

*3% !(H"3-2-FM 4$-F$(77 A*B "(>:-6%6 =,8

"

>'((%>#%6 />#"9"#"%+ "( 7/(&"(<4 A$%*% #$% )'>-+ A/+ '( #A'

f ./*#">-:/* /*#">:%+

!

R( /66"#"'( #' '@#/"("(< +#/#"+#">+ )*'1 #$% .*'9"(>%4 #$% 7;0 #%/1 $%:6 / 1%%#"(< A"#$ #$%

*%:%9/(# 6%./*#1%(#+ ') #$% :'>/: .%'.:% H+ <'9%*(1%(#4 )'::'A%6 @B / )'*-1 A"#$ *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+ )*'1 #$%

:'>/: +>"%(>% /(6 #%>$(':'<B @-*%/-4 %(#%*.*"+%+4 +>"%(>%

"

*%:/#%6 *%+%/*>$ -("#+4 -("9%*+"#"%+ /(6 "(+#"#-#%+

!

!

WW]

!

L .":'# <*'-. A/+ +%# -.4 />>'*6"(< #' =,8

"

;PK4 A"#$ %S.%*#+ )*'1 '9%* WE <'9%*(1%(#

'*</("Y/#"'(+

!

,S.%*#+ $/9% .:/B%6 /( "1.'*#/(# *':% "( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

P'*% #$/( ^E %S.%*#+ A%*%

%(</<%6 "( *%+%/*>$

!

"

G$% DH#(3H( *3% !(H"3-2-FM 4$-F$(77 A*B .":'# $%/9":B *%:"%6 '( %S.%*#+ "( *%:%9/(#

f #%>$(':'<B 6%./*#1%(#+ #' 6%+"<( +-*9%B+4 6%9%:'. A'*I"(< .*'>%6-*%+ /(6 6*/)# #$% *%9"%A *%.'*#

!

P/(B

*%+.'(+%+ A%*% *%>%"9%6 )*'1 '(:"(% ?-%+#"'((/"*%+ 2'9%* WE 4 EEE '( +>"%(>%g#%>$(':'<Bd '9%* _ 4 EEE '(

/<*">-:#-*/: #%>$(':'<B3Q

#

WW_

!

G$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% $"<$:"<$#%6 #$%+% .":'#+ "( "#+ DEWD /((-/: *%.'*# #' #$% 7;0\

"

!% '@&%>#"9%:B %9/:-/#%6 $'A +>"%(#")"> /(6 .*/>#">/@:% :/A+ A%*% /+ A%:: /+ $'A %))%>#"9%:B #$%B A%*%

"1.:%1%(#%64 /(6 )'>-+%6 '( #$% 'A(%*+$". /(6 -+% ') "(#%::%>#-/: .*'.%*#B *"<$#+ "( +>"%(#")"> /(6

#%>$(':'<">/: .*'&%>#+4 "(>%(#"9%+ )'* >'*.'*/#% "(9%+#1%(# "( Vl84 #*/(+

"

*%<"'(/: 1%>$/("Y%6 )/*1"(< +%*9">%+4

+-@+"6"%+ )'* .-*>$/+"(< /<*">-:#-*/: 1/>$"(%*B4 /(6 )-%: +-@+"6"%+ )'* /<*">-:#-*/: 1/>$"(%*B

!

G$% J#/(6"(<

0'11"##%% 6%:"@%*/#%6 #$% *%:%9/(# *%.'*#+4 /(6 >/::%6 )'* "1.*'9"(< #$% 1%>$/("+1 )'* %9/:-/#"(< :/A+ /)#%*

#$%B /*% ./++%6 '( #$% @/+"+ ') / *%9"%A ') #$% %S.%*"%(>%+ </"(%6 )*'1 #$% .":'# .*'&%># /(6 )'* >/**B"(< '-#

+->$ %9/:-/#"'(+ '( / *%<-:/* @/+"+ /(6 "( / +#/(6/*6"Y%6 A/B

!#

$

G$% 7;0 $/+ 6%>"6%6 #' >'(6-># #A' .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A+ .%* B%/*

!

V%9"%A+ $/9% @%%( :/-(>$%6 )'* #$%

A*B -3 4$-.-1#-3 -, @(%#0.

"

*3% D.*22

"

D#Y(% I31($5$#7(7 /(6 1"( A*B -3 4$-1(H1#-3 -, R#7*J2(%

4($7-37

!

%

G$%+% *%9"%A+ A":: )'::'A #$% .*%9"'-+ *%9"%A .*'>%6-*%

!

G$% -:#"1/#% <'/: "+ #' "(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y% #$%

f .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A 1%>$/("+1 /)#%* / )%A 1'*% .":'# .*'&%>#+4 A"#$ )'*1/: *-:%+ #' <-"6% .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9%

*%9"%A .*/>#">%

!

J$'A"(< #$/# #$%+% *%9"%A+ :%/6 #' *%+-:#+4 /1%(61%(#+ #' #$% OF$#H0210$*2 !(H"3-2-FM

4$-.-1#-3 A*B A%*% 6%:"@%*/#%6 '( /# #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% +%++"'( "( L.*": DEWD

!

&

'#

!

"

#

$

%

&

C"/(<+- ;*'9"(>"/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++ R(#%*9"%A

!

7;0 R(#%*9"%A

!

G$% =,8

"

;PK DEWW L((-/: V%.'*# 2L((%S c 3 $/+ #$% )"<-*% ') DE %S.%*#+

!

=,8

"

;PK DEWW L((-/: V%.'*#4 L((%S c

!

$##.\ ggAAA

!

(.>

!

<'9

!

>(g%(<:"+$(.>gJ.%%>$%+gDEWD

"

EcgWbg>'(#%(#j WFW]Db]

!

$#1 2X-:: G%S# ') #$% 7;0 J#/(6"(<

0'11"##%% !'*I V%.'*# DEWD 3

G$% D(H0$#1#(7 L3'(71.(31 &03% A*B A/+ /:+' 1%(#"'(%6 /+ / .'++"@:% #/*<%# )'* *%9"%A

!

7;0 R(#%*9"%A

!

"

0$"(/ 1-::+ /1%(61%(# #' /<*'

"

#%>$(':'<B .*'1'#"'( :/A4

#

a"($-/4 L.*": D^ 4 DEWD

!

$##.\ ggAAA

!

(.>

!

<'9

!

>(g

%(<:"+$(.>g(%A+gO%<"+:/#"'(gDEWD

"

E^gD]g>'(#%(#j WFW``Eb

!

$#1

!

Page 47: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WWF

!

;'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A+ $/9% /:+' @%%( -(6%*#/I%( /# #$% .*'9"(>"/: :%9%:

!

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 #$% C"/(<+-

;*'9"(>"/: O;0 >'(6->#%6 "#+ )"*+# .":'# "( DEWW 2;*'9"(>"/: V%<-:/#"'( '( V'/6 G*/(+.'*#/#"'( P/(/<%1%(#3Q L

A'*I"(< <*'-. $/6 1%1@%*+ )*'1 #$% O;0 )"(/(>% /(6 %>'('1"> >'11"##%% /(6 +'1% O;0 6%.-#"%+4

.*'9"(>"/: :%</: /(6 #*/(+.'*# @-*%/-+4 %S.%*#+ /(6 +>$':/*+

!

R()'*1/#"'( A/+ </#$%*%6 )*'1 +%9%*/: +'-*>%+\

2/3 /( "(#%*(/: %9/:-/#"'( @B #$% .*'9"(>"/: #*/(+.'*# @-*%/-d 2@3 *%<"'(/: %9/:-/#"'( >'(6->#%6 @B O;0+ "( #A'

>"#"%+d 2>3 '9%* ^_EE +-*9%B+ ') O;0 6%.-#"%+4 .*')%++"'(/:+ "( #$"+ /*%/4 /(6 #$% <%(%*/: .-@:"> 6"+#*"@-#%6 /(6

/(/:BY%6 @B 7/(&"(< 5("9%*+"#B O/A J>$'':d 26 3 +%1"(/*+ A"#$ +#/I%$':6%*+ /(6 +"#% 9"+"#+ @B #$% A'*I"(<

<*'-.d /(6 2%3 .-@:"> *%+.'(+%+ #' / ('#">% '( #$% O;0 A%@+"#%

!

G$% J$//(S" ;*'9"(>"/: O;0 A":: >'(6-># "#+ )"*+#

.'+# :%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A "( DEWD 2;*'9"(>"/: V%<-:/#"'( '( L<*">-:#-*% 0'1.*%$%(+"9% 8%9%:'.1%(# V%<-:/#"'(3Q

G$% 7;0 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A .":'#+ .*'9"6%6 %S/1.:%+ )'* #$% .*'9"(>"/: .":'#+

!

WW`

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

=,8 "(.-#+ $%:.%6 #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A )*'1 DEE` /# #$%

7;0 :%9%: @B .*'1'#"(< :%/*("(< )*'1 :'>/: .":'#+4 +#-6B"(< "(#%*(/#"'(/: %S.%*"%(>%4 /(6 )-(6"(< .":'#

/>#"9"#"%+

!

X"*+#4 #$%*% A/+ / *%+%/*>$ .*'.'+/: )'* .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A /(6 6"+>-++"'(+ A%*% "("#"/#%6 A"#$

O;0+

!

O;0 %S.%*"1%(#+ "( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A +#/*#%6 "( DEEE d @B DEE` 4 1'*% #$/( #%( :'>/: ;0+ $/6

%S.%*"1%(#%6 A"#$ .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># .*'9"6%6 '..'*#-("#"%+ )'* #$% O;0+ #' %S>$/(<%

#$%"* %S.%*"%(>% /(6 /::'A%6 #$% 7;0 #' :%/*( )*'1 :'>/: .*/>#">%

!

WWb

!

J%>'(64 -(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 .':">B 1/I%*+ >'(6->#%6 +#-6B #'-*+ #' ,(<:/(64 X*/(>% /(6 J./"(4 /+

A%:: /+ '*</("Y"(< '(% "(#%*(/#"'(/: +%1"(/* /(6 %S>$/(<"(< 9"%A+ A"#$ 1'*% #$/( ^E 6'1%+#"> /(6

"(#%*(/#"'(/: %S.%*#+

!

G$% 7;0 >'(6->#%6 )%/+"@":"#B +#-6"%+ /(6 >/1% -. A"#$ .":'# .*'.'+/:+ @/+%6 '( 9/*"'-+

*%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+

!

WDE

!

G$"*64 #$% =,8 ;*'&%># )-(6+ .*'9"6%6 6"*%># +-..'*# #' #$% .":'# .*'&%>#+

!

V%+%/*>$ /(6 +%1"(/*+ -(6%*

#$% .":'#+ A%*% +-..'*#%6 @B #$% =,8 ;*'&%># /(6 #$%+% />#"9"#"%+ .*'9"6%6 -+%)-: "()'*1/#"'( #' /++%++ #$%

/@'9%

"

1%(#"'(%6 :/A+ +>"%(#")">/::B

!

G$% #A' .":'# .*'&%>#+ A%*% +->>%++)-: /(6 .*'9"6%6 >'(>*%#% %S.%*"%(>%

'( "++-%+ +->$ /+ #$% #/*<%# /(6 +>'.% ') .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A /+ A%:: /+ $'A #' )'*1-:/#% #$% *%9"%A

*%.'*#

!

WDW

!

;*%

"

O%<"+:/#"9% V%9"%A

!

G$% +#-6B #'-*+ +-..'*#%6 @B #$% =,8 ;*'&%># /:+' 6%1'(+#*/#%6 #$% "1.'*#/(>%

')

"

.*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

#

4 %+.%>"/::B >'+#

"

@%(%)"# /(/:B+"+

!

J"(>% :/+# B%/*4 #$% 7;0 $/+ +#/*#%6 /( %S.%*"1%(#

'( .*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

R( DEWW 4 #A' .":'#+ A%*% >'(6->#%6 '( .'#%(#"/: :%<"+:/#"'(4 / !/#%*A/B O/A /(6 /(

L(#"

"

8'1%+#"> T "':%(>% O/A

!

0'(>*%#% A'*I .*'>%6-*%+ )'* .*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A $/9% @%%( .*%./*%64

"(>:-6"(< #$% +>'.% /(6 .*'>%6-*% )'* *%9"%A

!

8%>"+"'(+ '( A$%#$%* / :/A "+ (%%6%6 "( / >%*#/"( /*%/ A":: #/I%

/ 1'*% +>"%(#")">4 6%1'>*/#">4 /(6 ?-/(#"#/#"9% 6"*%>#"'( "( #$% )-#-*%

!

(#

! [-/(< l ;%%*%(@''1 DEWD /# WF

!

Page 48: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WDD

!

J-*9%B+ $/9% @%%( -+%6 /+ / 1/"( 1%/+-*% #' %(+-*% .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'(

!

R( #$% >/+% ') #$% !/#%*A/B

O/A4 '9%* c 4 EEE +-*9%B+ A%*% 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' *%:%9/(# +#/I%$':6%*+4 "(>:-6"(< <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ /(6

1"("+#*"%+4 %(#%*.*"+%+ /(6 #*/6% /++'>"/#"'(+

!

R( #$% >/+% ') #$% L(#"

"

8'1%+#"> T "':%(>% O/A4 /@'-# c 4 EEE

+-*9%B+ A%*% */(6'1:B 6"+#*"@-#%6 "( +%:%>#%6 >'11-("#"%+

!

G$%+% .":'#+ $/9% /:+' 6%1'(+#*/#%6 #$%

"1.'*#/(>% ') %(</<"(< %S.%*#+ "( #$% *%9"%A .*'>%++4 %+.%>"/::B )'* /(/:B+"+ ') >'+#+ /(6 %))">"%(>B4 /(6 )'*

)%/+"@":"#B +#-6"%+

!

L)#%* #$% +#-6B #'-*+ #' R+*/%: /(6 R(6"/4 #$% 7;0 "+ >'(+"6%*"(< *%9"+"'(+ #' #$% A(F#72*1#-3

A*B /(6 '#$%* :/A+ #' %+#/@:"+$ #$% .*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A 1%>$/("+1

!

=;> .+,)*)*6

##

KTR

*

P'*% #$/( DEEE '))">"/:+ )*'1 #$% 7;0 /(6 #$% :'>/: .%'.:%H+ >'(<*%++%+ *%>%"9"(< #*/"("(< )*'1

#$% .*'&%># />#"9"#"%+

!

J#/#-+

*

;/*#"/::B L>$"%9%6

!

7%/*:B bEE '))">"/:+ *%>%"9%6 *%:%9/(# #*/"("(< -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#4 A$">$

%S>%%6+ #$% '*"<"(/: "(6">/#'* ') `EE #*/"(%%+

!

['A%9%*4 #$% >-**%(# "(6">/#'* "+ n 1'*% #$/( DEEE

'))">"/:+n *%>%"9"(< #*/"("(<4 /(6 #$"+ $/+ ('# @%%( />$"%9%6

!

WDc

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% 0'1.'(%(# N #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ /*% +%# '-# "( #$% )'::'A"(< #/@:%\

!

C+Z,$ U

!

C#+).).2 >*3)5)3)$7 (.&$# ?"06".$.3 D

P$+# C"6)* B.&)*+3)5$ ;73)0+3$ "- G+#3)*)6+.37

DEE`

;'+# O%<"+:/#"'( %9/:-/#"'( ]E

;-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(< FE

DEEb

;%'.:%H+ *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+ "( :/A

"

1/I"(< WEE

;-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(< FE

V%<-:/#"'( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A WEE

V%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ b]

DEWE V%<-:/#"'( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A bE

DEWW

;-@:"> $%/*"(< "( #$% :%<"+:/#"9% .*'>%++ FE

V%<-:/#"'( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A bE

DEWD O/A [/*1'("Y/#"'( _]

V%<-:/#"'( X":"(< /(6 V%9"%A bE

GKGLO `bE

)#

! G$% 6/#/ "( #$% #/@:% A/+ .*'9"6%6 @B =,8

"

;PK "( P/*>$ DEWD 4 @%/*"(< "( 1"(6 #$% 6"))">-:#B ') '@#/"("(< />>-*/#%

/(6 9%*")"/@:% "()'*1/#"'(

!

G$% =,8

"

;PK DEWW L((-/: V%.'*# 2/# ]

"

_ 3 +$'A+ 1'*% #$/( D^EE =,8 #*/"(%%+\ "( .-@:">

./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(< 21'*% #$/( WcEE 3d "( *%<-:/#"'( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A 21'*% #$/( `EE 3d /(6 "( .'+# :%<"+:/#"'(

%9/:-/#"'( 21'*% #$/( cEE 3Q [-/(< l ;%%*%(@''1 DEWD *%.'*# +"1":/* )"<-*%+4 A"#$ '(:B _EE #*/"(%%+ )'* *%<-:/#"'( )":"(<

/(6 *%9"%A

!

Page 49: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WD^

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G*/"("(< '*</("Y%6 -(6%* #$% ;*'&%># >'9%*%6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(<4

.-@:"> $%/*"(<+4 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A4 *%9"%A /(6 )":"(<4 *%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+4 /(6 *':% ') .%'.:%H

+ *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+ "( :/A

"

1/I"(<

!

<$7(,3 W

!

E+% 4+#0".)Y+3)". )7 )06#"5$& 34#"(24 34$ #$5)$% "- #$2(,+3)".7 Z/ 34$ =G? +.& EG?7

!

WD]

!

0'(#%S#

!

G$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1 "+ /( "1.'*#/(# #'': #' %(+-*% :%<"+:/#"9% +-.%*9"+"'( /(6 :%</:

$/*1'("Y/#"'(

!

G$% DEEE A(F#72*1#-3 A*B .*'9"6%6 #$/# /61"("+#*/#"9% *%<-:/#"'(+4 :'>/: *%<-:/#"'(+4

f /-#'('1'-+ *%<"'(+ H *%<-:/#"'(+4 +#/(6

"

/:'(% *%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 *-:%+ 2 *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ 3 +$'-:6 @%

*%.'*#%6 #' #$% *%:%9/(# '*</(+ )'* #$% *%>'*64 A"#$"( cE 6/B+ ') .*'1-:</#"'(

!

R( DEE^ 4 / 6%+"<(/#%6 )":"(<

/(6 *%9"%A '))">% A/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 /# #$% 7;0 :%9%:

!

R( DEEF 4 #$% D05($'#7#-3 A*B A/+ ./++%6 A"#$ 0$/.#%* ]

f @%"(< 6%9'#%6 #' )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+

!

J"(>% #$%(4 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A A'*I $/+ @%%(

.*'1'#%6 /# #$% :'>/: :%9%:

!

0'1.*%$%(+"9% /(6 +.%>")"> .*'9"+"'(+ '( $'A O;0+ +$'-:6 >'(6-># )":"(< /(6

*%9"%A /*% ('# )'-(6 "( >-**%(# :/A+4 :%/6"(< #' #$% +"#-/#"'( A$%*% 6"))%*%(# :'>/:"#"%+ $/9% /6'.#%6 6"))%*%(#

.*/>#">%+4 +'1%#"1%+ /*@"#*/*":B

!

L+ / *%+-:#4 "1.*'9"(< O;0 >/./>"#B "( >'(6->#"(< )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '(

*%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ $/+ @%%( /( -*<%(# >$/::%(<% "( 0$"(/

!

=,> G,%)&*1)-# 93$%#4 &< H)0)*6 ,*- @#7)#1

##

KTR

*

JB+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A %+#/@:"+$%6 (/#"'(A"6% /# #$% :'>/: .%'.:% >'(<*%++%+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

G$% +B+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A $/+ @%%( %+#/@:"+$%6 (/#"'(A"6%

!

P'+# .*'9"(>%+

2D_ 3 $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 +.%>")"> )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+

!

R( #$% '#$%* )"9% .*'9"(>%+4 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A A'*I "+

>'(6->#%6 @B 6%+"<(/#%6 +#/)) "( *%:%9/(# /<%(>"%+

!

P'*% #$/( $/:) ') #$% *%:/#"9%:B :/*<% >"#"%+ A"#$ :'>/:

:%<"+:/#"9% .'A%* $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+4 /(6 #A%(#B .%*>%(# ') cEE >"#B :%9%: ;0+ $/9%

%+#/@:"+$%6 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+

!

WD_

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% +B+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A $/+ @%%( %+#/@:"+$%6 /# #$% O;0 :%9%: (/#"'(A"6%4 /+ A%:: /+ /#

#$% 7;0 :%9%:

!

G' 6/#%4 D_ '-# ') cW .*'9"(>%+ $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 +.%>")"> )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+

!

R( #$% '#$%*

)"9% .*'9"(>%+ 2[%(/(4 =-/(<S"4 U-((/(4 Z"(<$/" /(6 J$//(S" 34 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A A'*I "+ >'(6->#%6 @B

6%+"<(/#%6 +#/)) "( *%:%9/(# /<%(>"%+

!

L1'(< #$% ^b @"< >"#"%+ A$">$ .'++%++ :'>/: :%<"+:/#"9% .'A%*4 1'*% #$/(

$/:) $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+

!

L1'(< cEE >"#B :%9%: ;0+4 DEe $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 )":"(< /(6

*%9"%A '))">%+

!

WDF

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

=,8 "(.-#+ .*'1'#%6 %S>$/(<%+ @%#A%%( #$% 7;0 /(6 #$% O;0+4 /(6 /1'(< #$%

O;0+4 #' .*'1'#% /(6 %(>'-*/<% "1.:%1%(#/#"'( /# #$% O;0 :%9%:

!

;*'&%># +-..'*# /:+' %(/@:%6 #$% 7;0 #'

"1.*'9% %S"+#"(< *-:%+4 "(>:-6"(< >'1.:/"(# *%<"+#*/#"'(4 >'::%>#"9% *%+%/*>$ )'* >'1.:%S "++-%+4 /(6 "(#%*(/:

>'(+-:#/#"'( *-:%+

!

*$

Page 50: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WD`

!

!$%( #$% J-.%*9"+"'( O/A A/+ %(/>#%6 "( DEEF 4 :'>/: >'(<*%++%+ 6"6 ('# $/9% 6%+"<(/#%6 +-.%*9"+"'(

'))">%+

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/+ +-..'*#%6 / +%*"%+ ') :'>/: *%+%/*>$ /(6 +%1"(/*+ #' .*'1'#% %S.%*"%(>% %S>$/(<%

@%#A%%( #$% 7;0 /(6 #$% O;0+ /(6 /1'(< #$% O;0+

!

V%9"%A 1%#$'6+ "(>:-6% @'#$ />#"9% *%9"%A /(6 ./++"9%

*%9"%A 2"

!

%

!

@/+%6 '( *%?-%+#+ )*'1 #$% <%(%*/: .-@:">3Q X'* %S/1.:%4 @/+%6 '( .-@:"> '."("'(+4 7;0 6%>"6%6

#$/# #$% R(#%*"1 V%<-:/#"'( '( #$% L61"("+#*/#"9% ;-("+$1%(# )'* J.%>-:/#"'( /(6 ;*')"#%%*"(< A/+ '-# ') 6/#%

/(6 #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": #%*1"(/#%6 #$% "1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') #$"+ *%<-:/#"'(

!

WDb

!

G$*'-<$ =,8 />#"9"#"%+4 #$% 7;0 /:+' %(>'-*/<%6 :'>/: >'(<*%++%+ #' +%# -. *-:%+ #' *%9"%A *%<-:/#'*B

6'>-1%(#+

!

G$% ;*'&%># $%:.%6 #' +#*%(<#$%( "(#%*/>#"'(+ @%#A%%( #$% 7;0 /(6 #$% O;0+ /(6 /1'(< #$% O;0+

#' )/>":"#/#% +$/*"(< ') %S.%*"%(>%

!

R# /:+' %(/@:%6 #$% 7;0 #' )-*#$%* "1.*'9% %S"+#"(< *-:%+4 "(>:-6"(<

>'1.:/"(# *%<"+#*/#"'( *-:%+4 >'::%>#"9% *%+%/*>$ *-:%+ )'* >'1.:%S "++-%+4 "(#%*(/: >'(+-:#/#"'( *-:%+ )'* >'1.:%S

"++-%+4 )":"(< *-:%+ /(6 *%.'*#"(< *-:%+

!

=;> GB8 :*%#+*,0 I()-#0)*#$ &* H)0)*6 ,*- @#7)#1 &< @#6(0,%&+3 ?&"(4#*%$

!

##

KTR\ R(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+ ') 7;0 6%9%:'.%6 '( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ #' %($/(>%

:/A $/*1'("Y/#"'(

!

J#/#-+\ ;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

7;0 <-"6%:"(%+ '( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ $/9% ('#

@%%( "++-%6

!

L( 7;0

"

.-@:"+$%6 @''I '( #$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1 )'* *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ $/+ @%%(

>"*>-:/#%6 #' O;0+ #' <-"6% "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

;*'9"(>"/: :%9%: O;0+ $/9% "++-%6 :'>/: *-:%+ 2Db 3 '* "(#%*(/:

.*'>%6-*%+ 2D 3 "( #$"+ /*%/

!

WcE

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% 7;0 "++-%6 !'*I"(< ;*'>%6-*%+ )'* X":"(< /(6 V%9"%A ') V%<-:/#'*B 8'>-1%(#+ "(

DEE]

!

N%B'(6 #$/#4 7;0 "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+ /*% +#":: -(6%* 6%9%:'.1%(#4 #$'-<$ *-:%+ '( *%+.'(+% #'

.%#"#"'(%*+ /*% @%"(< 6%9%:'.%6

!

!

['A%9%*4 / ;*'&%>#

"

+-..'*#%6 @''I '( #$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1 )'*

*%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ A/+ .*%./*%6 @B #$% 7;04 A"#$ c 4 EEE >'."%+ 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' O;0+4 #' <-"6%

"1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

X'* *%9"%A ') *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+4 /:1'+# /:: .*'9"(>%+ 2Db 3 $/9% "++-%6 :'>/: *-:%+4 %"#$%* /+

+#/(6

"

/:'(% :%<"+:/#"'( '* A"#$"( #$% :'>/: +-.%*9"+"'( :%<"+:/#"'(

!

N%"&"(< /(6 J$/(<$/" $/9% "(#%*(/: A'*I"(<

.*'>%6-*%+

!

"

K( #$/# @/+"+4 #$"+ KTR "+ >'(+"6%*%6 ./*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

WcW

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

5(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 #$% 7;0 .-@:"+$%6 G$%'*B /(6 ;*/>#">% '( X":"(< /(6 V%9"%A

JB+#%1 ') V%<-:/#'*B 8'>-1%(#+4 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' #$% O;0+ #' %S./(6 #$% "1./># /(6 <-"6%

"1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

G$% 7;0 $/+ /:+' A'*I%6 '-# /( "(#%*(/: A'*I"(< .:/( '( $'A #' *%+.'(6 #' .-@:"> "(?-"*B

:%##%*+

!

!$

!

"

[-/(< l ;%%*%(@''1 DEWD /# W^

!

G$% N%"&"(< O;0 6%:"@%*/#%6 '( V%<-:/#"'(+ '( X":"(< /(6 V%9"%A ') V%<-:/#'*B 8'>-1%(#+ "( P/*>$ DEWD 4 @-#

%(/>#1%(# ') #$% *%<-:/#"'( $/+ ('# @%%( >'()"*1%6

!

Page 51: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WcD

!

L>>'*6"(< #' "(#%*9"%A+4 9%*B )%A >'():">#+ $/9% @%%( )'-(6 %/>$ B%/* '-# ') #$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A

.*'>%++

!

K(% %S.:/(/#"'( >'-:6 @% #$/# / .*%

"

>:%/*/(>% .*'>%++ 2 "

!

%

!

#' >:%/* #$% %S"+#"(< :/A+ @%)'*% (%A

:%<"+:/#"'( "+ "++-%63 $/+ *%6->%6 #$% >'():">#+

!

="> .+,)*)*6 &< E&",0 A<<)"),0$

##

KTR\ R1.*'9%6 (/#"'(/: +B+#%1 ') *%9"%A /(6 )":"(< )'::'A"(< #$% #*/"("(< ') :'>/: '))">"/:+

!

J#/#-+\ L>$"%9%6

!

G$*'-<$ ;*'&%>#

"

+.'(+'*%6 #*/"("(< ') #*/"(%*+4 #$% #*/"("(< ') :'>/: +#/)) $/+ @%%(

/(6 A":: @% %S./(6%64 ./*#">-:/*:B "( 1'*% *%1'#% /*%/+

!

Wcc

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G' "1.*'9% #$% O;0+H >/./>"#B "( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A A'*I4 #$% =,8 ;*'&%># $%:6 #A'

#*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ )'* #$% O;0+ "( %#$("> 1"('*"#B *%<"'(+4 "

!

%

!

k$%&"/(< G*/"("(< /(6 G"@%# G*/"("(<

!

L@'-# DEE

#*/"(%%+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(<

!

P/(B ') #$%+% #*/"(%%+ /*% )*'1 *%1'#% /*%/+ ') #$% >'-(#*B

!

L1'(< #$%14 /@'-#

WEE .%'.:% A%*% )*'1 G"@%# /(6 /@'-# bE .%'.:% A%*% )*'1 N%"$/"4 =-/(<S" ;*'9"(>%

!

J'1% #*/"(%%+ A"::

)-*#$%* #*/"( #$%"* >'::%/<-%+ /)#%* *%#-*(

!

?9HG9=;=C ?

!

?B:BE N9?B;CP B=:9E:;H;=C BN D<9>F;=;F

!

Wc^

!

0$"(%+% 0JK+ )/:: "(#' +%9%*/: >/#%<'*"%+

!

G$%*% /*% #$*%% :%</: )'*1+ ') 0JK+ "( 0$"(/\ +'>"/:

'*</("Y/#"'(+ 2+$%$-" Y-Y$"34 .*"9/#% ('(

"

%(#%*.*"+% -("#+ 21"(@/( )%" ?"B% 6/(A%"3 /(6 )'-(6/#"'(+ 2&"&"($-"3Q

R( DEWE 4 #$%*% A%*% ^^_ 4 EEE 0JK+ (/#"'(A"6%\ #$% (-1@%*+ ') 0JK+ -(6%* %/>$ >/#%<'*B /*% D^] 4 EEE +'>"/:

'*</("Y/#"'(+4 Wb` 4 EEE .*"9/#% ('(

"

%(#%*.*"+% -("#+ /(6 D 4 DEE )'-(6/#"'(+

!

"

G$"+ V%.'*# -+%+ #$% #%*1

0JK #' *%)%* #' #$%+% '*</("Y/#"'(+

!

<$7(,3 T

!

<$*"2.)3)". "- 34$ 6"7)3)5$ #",$ "- *)5), 7"*)$3/ )7 ).*#$+7$&

!

Wc]

!

0'(#%S#

!

L 1/&'* >$/::%(<% )/>"(< 0$"(/ H+ %1%*<"(< >"9": +'>"%#B "+ #' </"( #$% #*-+# /(6 >'()"6%(>% ')

@'#$ #$% 0$"(%+% <'9%*(1%(# /(6 #$% <%(%*/: .-@:">

!

X*'1 #$% <'9%*(1%(# .%*+.%>#"9%4 #$%*% A%*% >'(>%*(+

#$/# ('(

"

<'9%*(1%(# 1%/(# /(#"

"

<'9%*(1%(#4 /(6 /@'-# ('(

"

<'9%*(1%(# '*</("Y/#"'( 27=K3 #"%+ #' )'*%"<(

"$

!

"

G$% J'-*>%+ /(6 P%/(+ ') T%*")">/#"'( )'* #$"+ 0'1.'(%(# +%# '-# "( #$% O'<)*/1% A%*% /9/":/@:% )'* #$"+

*%9"%A

!

G$%+% A%*%\ .'+"#"9% 1%6"/ >'9%*/<% ') 0JK />#"'(+d .-@:">/#"'( /(6 6"+#*"@-#"'( ') 0JK B%/*@''I DEE`

"

WE d 6*/)#

*%<-:/#"'(+ /(6 <-"6%:"(%+ '( *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 1/(/<%1%(# ') 0JK+4 .*"9/#% )'-(6/#"'(+ /(6 +'>"/: /++'>"/#"'(+d (%A

*%<-:/#"'( *%</*6"(< #/S 6%6->#"'( )'* >'(#*"@-#"'(+ #' 0JK+ /9/":/@:%d #*/"("(< %9%(#+ $%:6 "( 6"))%*%(# :'>/#"'(+d />#"9%

>%(#*/: <'9%*(1%(# 0JK !%@+"#%d >'."%+ ') / &'-*(/: '( 0JK 1/(/<%1%(# 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' <'9%*(1%(# '*</(+ /(6 0JK+d /(6

%9"6%(>% ') )'*-1+ /(6 A'*I+$'. @%"(< $%:6

!

L66"#"'(/: "()'*1/#"'( A/+ .*'9"6%6 #$*'-<$ / X%@*-/*B DEWD "(#%*9"%A A"#$

PK0L '))">"/:+

!

PK0L R(#%*9"%A "(6">/#%6 #$/# #$% )"(/: (-1@%* )'* DEWW A'-:6 .*'@/@:B @% /*'-(6 ^_E 4 EEE 4 /@'-# / ce

"(>*%/+%

!

Page 52: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

"(+#"#-#"'(+

!

X'* #$% .-@:"> /# :/*<%4 #$% .*'.%* *':% ') 0JK+ "+ ')#%( +%%( /+ #'

"

+-..'*#

#

'*

"

+-..:%1%(#

#

#$%

A'*I ') <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+

!

V%>%(# +>/(6/:+ "(9':9"(< 0JK+ $/9% /:+' /))%>#%6 0JK >*%6"@":"#B A"#$"( #$%

<%(%*/: .-@:">

!

=,> 89A :*7&07#4#*% )* B&0)"3 J,5)*6

##

KTR

*

R(>*%/+%6 "(9':9%1%(# ') 0JK+ "( .':">B 1/I"(< #$*'-<$ ./*#">"./#"'( ') 0JK+ "( +%1"(/*+4

)'*-1+4 A'*I+$'.+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

G$%*% A/+ >'(+"6%*/@:% 0JK ./*#">"./#"'( "( =,8 +%1"(/*+4 )'*-1+ /(6

A'*I+$'.+

!

PK0L >"#%6 %S/1.:%+ ') "(>*%/+%6 >'(+-:#/#"'( A"#$ 0JK+4 "(>:-6"(< '( #/S %S%1.#"'( /(6

*%<"+#*/#"'( *%)'*1+

!

Wc_

!

V%+-:#+

!

='9%*(1%(# >'(+-:#/#"'( A"#$ 0JK+ '( "1.'*#/(# "++-%+4 +->$ /+ +':-#"'(+ #' #$% <:'@/: )"(/(>"/:

>*"+"+ /(6 /((-/: *%9"%A *%<-:/#"'( )'* "(#%*(/#"'(/: 7=K+4 $/+ /:+' "(>*%/+%64 /+ '@+%*9%6 @B PK0L

!

!$%(

PK0L4 PKX /(6 #$% J#/#% L61"("+#*/#"'( ') G/S/#"'( 2JLG3 A%*% A'*I"(< '( #/S %S%1.#"'( +#/(6/*6+4 0JK+

9"%A+ A%*% +':">"#%6 /(6 />>%.#%6

!

!$%( =-/(<6'(<4 J$/(<$/" /(6 N%"&"(< .":'#%6 / 6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'(

+B+#%14 0JK A%*% /:+' #$% 1/"( ./*#">"./(#+ "( #$% .':">B 1/I"(< 6"+>-++"'(

!

7-1%*'-+ A'*I+$'.+ /(6

+%1"(/* -(6%* #$% ;*'&%># )'>-+%6 '( <'9%*(1%(# .':">B >'(+-:#/#"'( A"#$ 0JK+

!

WcF

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# 0 )'>-+%6 '( >$/(<"(< #$% .-@:">H+ .%*>%.#"'(

') 0JK+ #' *%>'<("Y% #$%"* .'+"#"9% *':%+ /(6 '( #*/(+)%**"(< *%+%/*>$ *%+-:#+ #' *%<-:/#"'( /(6 .':">B

1%/+-*%+

!

X'* #$% ^E

"

.:-+ +%1"(/*+4 )'*-1+4 /(6 #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ $%:6 -(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 0JK+ A%*%

#/*<%#%6 /+ #$% 1/"( ./*#">"./(#+

!

=,8 />#"9"#"%+ A%*% .-@:">"Y%6 '(:"(% /(6 '.%( #' /:: ./*#">"./(#+

!

L*'-(6 ^ 4

DEE 0JK+ $/6 /##%(6%6 =,8 />#"9"#"%+ @B 1"6

"

DEWW 4 /(6 9/*"'-+ A'*I+$'.+ '*</("Y%6 @B PK0L $/9% *%+-:#%6

"( 6"*%># >'11-(">/#"'( @%#A%%( 0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# '( "++-%+ +->$ /+ >'():">#+ ') "(#%*%+#4 #$%

1/(/<%1%(# /(6 %9/:-/#"'( ') 0JK+4 /(6 #$% >'(#*"@-#"'( ') 0JK+ #' +'>"%#B

!

!

Wc`

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ $/9% @%%( A"6%:B *%.'*#%6 @B 1%6"/

!

X'* "(+#/(>%4 / +%*"%+ ') )"9% %."+'6%+ '(

#$% .'+"#"9% >'(#*"@-#"'(+ ') 0JK+ /"*%6 '( (/#"'(/: GT 4 /(6 / @''I A/+ .-@:"+$%6 '( #$% -("?-%

>'(#*"@-#"'(+ ') 0JK+ "( J">$-/( %/*#$?-/I% *%:"%)

!

L .*'<*/1 ') '#$%* .-@:">/#"'(+ +-..'*#%6 @B #$% ;*'&%># "+

)-*#$%* 6%+>*"@%6 @%:'A

!

PK0L *%.'*#+ #$/# #$%+% />#"9"#"%+ /(6 1%6"/ >'9%*/<% $/9% <%(%*/#%6 .'+"#"9%

/##"#-6%+ /1'(< +>$':/*+ /(6 %S.%*#+

!

P/(B A$' .*%9"'-+:B $%:6 / >*"#">/: /##"#-6% #'A/*6 PK0L H+ A'*I /*%

('A 1'*% A"::"(< #' .*'9"6% >'(+#*->#"9% +-<<%+#"'(+

!

#$

! =,8

"

;PK DEWW L((-/: V%.'*# /# F

!

Page 53: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

=;> 89A @#6)$%+,%)&* ,*- ?#7#0&24#*% K#;$)%#

##

KTR

*

,/+"%* />>%++ #' "()'*1/#"'( '( 0JK *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 6%9%:'.1%(# 9"/ /( '))">"/: @":"(<-/:

A%@+"#%

!

J#/#-+

*

;/*#"/::B />$"%9%6

!

G$% +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+ >''.%*/#"'( /(6 >'11-(">/#"'( A%@+"#% A/+

%+#/@:"+$%6 "( DEE` 2AAA

!

>(.'$Y&:

!

'*< 3Q G$% ,(<:"+$ 9%*+"'( "+ +#":: -(6%* >'(+#*->#"'(

!

G$% A%@+"#%

.*'9"6%+ %/+"%* />>%++d $'A%9%*4 .*'9"(>"/: "()'*1/#"'( "+ ('# -. #' 6/#% '* >'1.:%#%

!

Wcb

!

V%+-:#+

!

L( '))">"/: @":"(<-/: A%@+"#% $/+ @%%( :/-(>$%6 #' >'::%># 0JK *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 1/(/<%1%(#

"()'*1/#"'( )*'1 %/>$ .*'9"(>% /(6 #' .*'1'#% :'>/: <''6 .*/>#">% 2AAA

!

>(.'$Y&:

!

'*< 3Q ['A%9%*4 #$%

,(<:"+$ 9%*+"'( "+ +#":: -(6%* >'(+#*->#"'(

!

G$"+ A%@+"#% "+ 1/(/<%6 @B #$% J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'( 0''.%*/#"'( /(6

,S>$/(<%+ 8"9"+"'( -(6%* PK0LH+ N-*%/- ') 7;K L61"("+#*/#"'(4 /(6 "+ 6"))%*%(# )*'1 #$% N-*%/-H+ A%@+"#%

2AAA

!

>$"(/(.'

!

<'9

!

>(3Q

W^E

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% A%@+"#% .*'9"6%+ %/+"%* />>%++ #' 0JK "()'*1/#"'(

!

['A%9%*4 .*'9"(>"/:

"()'*1/#"'( "+ ('# -. #' 6/#% '* >'1.:%#%

!

K(% >$/::%(<% #$% A%@+"#% )/>%+ "+ #' <%# /6%?-/#% :'>/:

"()'*1/#"'( )*'1 %/>$ .*'9"(>%

!

R( '*6%* #' %(>'-*/<% :'>/: .*'9"+"'( ') "()'*1/#"'(4 / (%A "(>%(#"9% +#*->#-*%

"+ >-**%(#:B -(6%* >'(+"6%*/#"'( "( '*6%* #' %(>'-*/<% 1'*% :'>/: "()'*1/#"'( +-@1"++"'(

!

G$"+ @":"(<-/:

A%@+"#% A":: >'(#"(-% #' '.%*/#% %9%( /)#%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/+ )"("+$%6

!

="> B(;0)",%)&*$ &* 89A J,*,6#4#*%

##

KTR

*

;-@:">/#"'( ') / &'-*(/: /(6 @''I+ '( 0JK 1/(/<%1%(#4 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' 0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(#

'*</("Y/#"'(+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

L @"1'(#$:B &'-*(/:4 V%+%/*>$ '( 0JK+ 8%9%:'.1%(# /(6 L61"("+#*/#"'(4 $/+ @%%(

:/-(>$%64 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' <'9%*(1%(# 1"("+#*"%+4 .*/>#"#"'(%*+ /(6 +>$':/*+

!

L +%*"%+ ') +%9%( #%S#@''I+ '(

0JK "++-%+ A/+ .-@:"+$%64 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' 0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ /(6 -+%6 "( #*/"("(<

!

G$% 0JK+ "(

0$"(/ U%/*@''I +%*"%+ A/+ .*'6->%6 )'* DEE`

"

DEWW

!

R( DEWW 4 / +%*"%+ ') +"S <*%%(

"

>'9%*%6 @''I+ ') .':">B

/(6 *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+ A/+ .-@:"+$%6

!

W^W

!

V%+-:#+

!

L @"1'(#$:B &'-*(/:4 +(7(*$H" -3 8D/7 R('(2-5.(31 *3% O%.#3#71$*1#-34 A/+ :/-(>$%64 A"#$ =,8

+%%6 1'(%B )*'1 DEEF

"

DEEb

!

0'."%+ ') #$% &'-*(/: /*% 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": /(6 /:: 1"("+#*"%+d "# "+

f /:+' *%/6 @B .*/>#"#"'(%*+ /(6 +>$':/*+

!

;*'&%># *%.'*#+ "( DEE` ('#%6 6"+#*"@-#"'( ') D^ 4 EEE >'."%+

!

L('#$%*

.%*"'6">/: .-@:">/#"'(4 #$% 8D/7 #3 8"#3* )(*$J--K +%*"%+4 A/+ .*'6->%6 )'* DEE`

"

DEWW 2-(6%* =,83Q

W^D

!

L +%*"%+ ') +%9%( #%S#@''I+4 +%*9"(< /+ #%/>$"(< /(6 #*/"("(< 1/#%*"/:+ '( +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+4 A/+

.-@:"+$%6 "( DEWE

!

G'.">+ >'9%*%6 "(>:-6%6\ <%(%*/: "(#*'6->#"'( ') +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(4 +'>"/: <*'-.4 ('(

"

$$

Page 54: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

.*')"# .*"9/#% %(#%*.*"+%4 )'-(6/#"'(4 >/./>"#B @-":6"(< ') +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(4 )"(/(>"/: 1/(/<%1%(# ') +'>"/:

'*</("Y/#"'(4 /61"("+#*/#"'( /(6 :/A %()'*>%1%(# ') +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(

!

PK0L -+%6 / @"66"(< .*'>%++ #'

>'(#*/># A"#$ /-#$'*+ )'* #$%+% @''I+

!

J'1% W 4 ]EE #' D 4 EEE >'."%+ $/9% @%%( 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' :'>/: >"9":

/))/"*+ @-*%/-+4 0JK+4 :'>/: <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ /(6 +>$':/*+ 2/@'-# #A'

"

#$"*6+ #' 0JK+ /(6 '(%

"

#$"*6 #'

<'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ 3 Q L('#$%* c 4 EEE >'."%+ A":: @% 6"+#*"@-#%6 #$"+ B%/*

!

G$%+% @''I+ $/9% @%%(

A"6%:B -+%6 /+ #*/"("(< 1/(-/:+ "( =,8 #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+

!

!$":% 1/(B >'(+"6%* #$/# #$"+ +%*"%+ ') @''I+

$/+ @%%( #$% 1'+# >'1.*%$%(+"9% /(6 /-#$'*"#/#"9% #%/>$"(< 1/#%*"/:+ '( 0JK+ 6%9%:'.1%(# #' 6/#%4

+'1% -+%*+ /:+' .'"(#%6 '-# #$/# #$% >'(#%(# "+ 1'*% #$%'*%#">/: #$/( .*/>#">/: A"#$ :"1"#%6 >/+% +#-6"%+

/(6 <''6 .*/>#">%+

!

W^c

!

J"(>% DEE` 4 PK0L $/+ "(9"#%6 @"66"(< .*'.'+/:+ )'* *%+%/*>$ #'.">+ '( )*'(#"%* "++-%+ #$/# PK0L $/+

.*"'*"#"Y%6 -(6%* "#+ 'A( .:/( /(6 +%:%>#%6 A"((%*+ #$*'-<$ / +#*"># %9/:-/#"'( .*'>%++

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 "( DEWW 4

_Eb *%+%/*>$ <*'-.+ A$">$ "(>:-6% c 4 EEE +>$':/*+ $/9% +-@1"##%6 *%+%/*>$ .*'.'+/:+

!

J%9%(#B

"

)"9% .*'.'+/:+

$/9% @%%( /..*'9%64 /(6 #' 6/#%4 Fc ') #$%1 $/9% @%%( >'1.:%#%6

!

R( DEWW 4 / +%*"%+ ') _ <*%%(

"

>'9%*%6

@''I+ A$">$ "(>:-6% +'1% =,8

"

+-..'*#%6 .':">B /(6 *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+ A/+ .-@:"+$%6 2A"#$ =,8 :'<'3Q 0'."%+

$/9% @%%( 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' :'>/: *%<"+#*/#"'( @-*%/-+ /(6 '#$%* /<%(>"%+

!

P'('<*/.$+ '( >'11-("#B

"

@/+%6

'*</("Y/#"'(+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# .*'>-*%1%(# ') +'>"/: +%*9">%+ @B 0JK+ A%*% .-@:"+$%6

!

!

W^^

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># +-..'*#%6 /:: ') #$%+% .-@:">/#"'( />#"9"#"%+\ #$% @"

"

1'(#$:B

&'-*(/:4 /((-/: B%/*@''I+4 #%S#@''I +%*"%+ /(6 .':">B /(6 *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+

!

G$%+% .-@:">/#"'(+ /66%6

+-@+#/(#"/::B #' #$% (%A:B

"

6%9%:'."(< )"%:6 ') 0JK 1/(/<%1%(#

!

NB "(#*'6->"(< #$% @"66"(< .*'>%++ )'* #$%

#%S#@''I /(6 *%.'*# +%*"%+4 #$% ;*'&%># $%:.%6 #' <%(%*/#% +>$':/*:B "(#%*%+# /(6 6%1'(+#*/#% #$% @%(%)"#+ ')

'.%( >'1.%#"#"'(

!

G$%+% @"66"(< .*'>%++%+ A%*% /( %))%>#"9% A/B #' .'.-:/*"Y% #$% ;*'&%>#4 %(>'-*/<%

>'11-(">/#"'( @%#A%%( +>$':/*+ /(6 '#$%* +#/I%$':6%*+ /(6 )'+#%* #$% <*'A#$ ') / <*'-. ') (%A +>$':/*+ '(

+'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+ 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

W^]

!

J-@+#/(#"9%:B4 #$%+% .-@:">/#"'(+ /:+' >'(#*"@-#%6 #' 0JK 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

G$% U%/*@''I J%*"%+ A/+ #$% )"*+#

') "#+ I"(64 .*'9"6"(< / >'1.*%$%(+"9% *%)%*%(>% +'-*>% )'* +>$':/*+ /(6 .*/>#"#"'(%*+

!

"

G$% *%+%/*>$ ./.%*+

/:+' .*'9"6%6 +-<<%+#"'(+ )'* .':">B >$/(<%+4 +->$ /+ '( 6"+>:'+-*% ') >$/*"#B 6'(/#"'( "()'*1/#"'(

!

#

<$7(,3 U

!

C4$ 6",)*/ +.& ,$2+, $.5)#".0$.3 -"# ?N97 )7 )06#"5$& ). 34$ -)$,& "- +J #$2)73#+3)". "- ?N97 +.& ZJ

3+R &$&(*3)".7 +.& $R$063)".7 -"# ?N97

!

W^_

!

0'(#%S#

!

G$% Wb`b V%<-:/#"'(+ '( V%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 P/(/<%1%(# ') J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'(+ "(#*'6->%6 #$%

%$

!

"

#

!- l [% DEWD /# WD

!

!- l [% DEWD /# WW

"

WD

!

!- l [% DEWD /# WW 2>"#"(< PK0L =-"6%:"(% '( 8"+>:'+-*% ') 0$/*"#B 8'(/#"'( R()'*1/#"'(3Q

Page 55: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

6-/: 1/(/<%1%(# +B+#%14 A$">$ *%?-"*%+ /..*'9/: /(6 '9%*+"<$# @B @'#$ #$% PK0L /(6 / +-.%*9"+'*B /<%(>B

"( #$% 0JKH+ :"(% ') A'*I

!

8-% #' #$% <*%/# 6"))">-:#B ') *%<"+#*/#"'(4 1/(B 0$"(%+% 0JK+ *%1/"( -(*%<"+#%*%6 '*

*%<"+#%* /+ >'11%*>"/: %(#"#"%+

!

O/>I ') *%<"+#*/#"'( *%+-:#+ "( :%</: -(>%*#/"(#B /(6 >/( /:+' /))%># @%(%)"#+

/9/":/@:% #' / 0JK

!

L1'(< #$%+% @%(%)"#+ >/( @% %S%1.#"'( )*'1 1'+# +"<(")">/(# #/S%+4 /(6 #$% /@":"#B )'*

6'('*+ #' <%# >$/*"#/@:% #/S 6%6->#"'(+ )'* #$%"* >'(#*"@-#"'(+ #' / 0JK

!

W^F

!

G$% GA%:)#$ X"9%

"

U%/* ;:/( )'* 7/#"'(/: ,>'('1"> /(6 J'>"/: 8%9%:'.1%(# 2DEWW

"

DEW] 3 "(>:-6%+ /

>$/.#%* 2cb 3 '( J#*%(<#$%("(< P/(/<%1%(# )'* J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'(+

!

G$% WD

#$

8%9%:'.1%(# ;:/( 1/.+ '-#

+%9%*/: 0JK

"

*%:/#%6 *%)'*1+4 "(>:-6"(<\ 2W 3 /@':"+$"(< #$% 6-/: 1/(/<%1%(# *%<"+#*/#"'( +B+#%1d 2D 3 %S./(6"(<

(%A #/S 6%6->#"'(+ )'* +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+d /(6 2c 3 "(>*%/+"(< #*/(+./*%(>B )'* ('(.*')"#+ #' */"+% #$%"*

+#/(6/*6+ /(6 >*%6"@":"#B

!

T\]

!

=,> @#6)$%+,%)&* &< 89A$

##

KTR

*

8*/)#"(< /(6 +-@1"++"'( ') /1%(61%(#+ #' *%<-:/#"'(+ #' /::'A 7=K+ #' *%<"+#%* 6"*%>#:B A"#$

<'9%*(1%(#

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

PK0L *%.'*#%6 #$/# 6*/)#+ ') /1%(61%(#+ ') /:: #$*%% 0JK *%<-:/#"'(+ 2 +'>"/:

'*</("Y/#"'(+4 .*"9/#% ('(

"

%(#%*.*"+% -("#+ /(6 )'-(6/#"'(+ 34 .%*1"##"(< 6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'(4 $/9% @%%(

+-@1"##%6 #' #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": )'* *%9"%A

!

R++-/(>% "+ %S.%>#%6 #$"+ B%/*

!

!$":% +-@1"##"(< 6*/)#+ #' #$%

J#/#% 0'-(>": A'-:6 ('# "1.*'9% #$% .':">B /(6 :%</: %(9"*'(1%(# )'* 0JK+4 :'>/:

"

:%9%: .":'#+ "( 6"*%>#

*%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 PK0L .':">B .*'('-(>%1%(#+ +-..'*# #$% 9"%A #$/# #$% .':">B %(9"*'(1%(# "+ "1.*'9"(<

!

W^b

!

V%+-:#+

!

L</"(+# #$"+ @/>I<*'-(64 PK0L $/+ .*%./*%6 /1%(61%(#+ #' #$% *%:%9/(# .*'9"+"'(+ 2#' .%*1"#

6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'( 3 "( /:: #$*%% 0JK *%<-:/#"'(+ 2 )'* +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+4 .*"9/#% ('(

"

%(#%*.*"+% -("#+ /(6

)'-(6/#"'(+3Q G$%+% 6*/)#+ $/9% @%%( +-@1"##%6 #' #$% J#/#% 0'-(>":

!

PK0L #/I%+ /( '.#"1"+#"> 9"%A '( #$%

/..*'9/: ') #$%+% /1%(61%(#+ "( DEWD

!

;":'# *%)'*1+ /*% -(6%*A/B "( +%9%*/: :'>/#"'(+

!

G$*%% .":'#+ "(

=-/(<6'(< ;*'9"(>%4 )'* %S/1.:%4 %S#%(6 6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'( #' +.%>")"> #B.%+ ') 0JK+ 2%"<$# "( =-/(<Y$'-

/(6 X'+$/(4 /(6 #$-+ )/* )'-* "( J$%(Y$%(34 /(6 "( +'1% >/+%+4 *%6->% ?-/:")">/#"'( *%?-"*%1%(#+

!

N%"&"(< $/+

/ +"1":/* .":'# "( %))%>#

!

L +"1.:")"%6 )'*1 ') *%<"+#*/#"'( 2@%"

)

/(3 "+ /:+' ./*# ') *%)'*1+ "( +'1% /*%/+

!

W]E

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

=,8 +-..'*# )'* #$% *%9"+"'(+ #' #$% *%<-:/#"'(+ #''I 1/(B )'*1+

!

P/(B A'*I+$'.+

/(6 *%+%/*>$ A%*% -+%6 #' :''I /# .':">B "++-%+ /(6 '.#"'(+

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 /( %))%>#"9% "(.-# #' #$% *%9"+"'(

.*'>%++ >/1% #$*'-<$ 1'*% #$/( WE *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+ @B cE :%/6"(< +>$':/*+ '( 0JK 6%9%:'.1%(# /(6

*%<-:/#"'(4 A$">$ A%*% +-@1"##%6 #' +%("'* '))">"/:+ )*'1 PK0L /(6 '#$%* /<%(>"%+

!

!

;*'&%>#

"

+-..'*#%6 .":'#+

/(6 >'(+-:#/#"'(+ A%*% /:+' ./*# ') #$% *%9"+"'( .*'>%++ )'* #$% 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'(

!

=,8 +-..'*# )'* .":'#"(< ')

&$

! !- l [% DEWD /# Wc

!

Page 56: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'( *%)'*1+ "( =-/(<6'(< >/( @% +%%( "( #$% A'*I+$'.+ /(6 A%:: /+ / >'()%*%(>% #'

6"++%1"(/#% /(6 6"+>-++ :'>/: .":'# %S.%*"%(>%

!

!

K#$%* +%1"(/*+ "(>:-6%6 '#$%* >'(>%*(%6 /<%(>"%+4 +->$ /+ #$%

I%B J#/#% 0'-(>": K))">% ') O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+

!

=;> .,L ?#-("%)&*$ ,*- ML#42%)&*$ <&+ 89A$

##

KTR

*

R(#*'6->#"'( ') #/S *%:"%) .':">B #' @%(%)"# 7=K+ /(6 )"(/(>"/: >'(#*"@-#'*+ #' 7=K+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

PKX /(6 JLG "++-%6 / >"*>-:/* '( #$% >*"#%*"/ )'* %:"<"@":"#B ') 0JK+ )'* >'*.'*/#%

>$/*"#/@:% 6%6->#"'(+4 "( :"<$# ') #$% "(>*%/+% "( #$% >'*.'*/#% 6%6->#"'( :"1"# )*'1 ce #' WDe

!

PKX /(6

JLG /:+' "++-%6 / >"*>-:/* #$/# %S%1.#+ +%9%*/: >/#%<'*"%+ ') 0JK "(>'1% )*'1 #/S/#"'(

!

N'#$ 0JK+ /(6

6'('*+ @%(%)"# )*'1 #$% >$/(<%+

!

W]W

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% DEE` ,(#%*.*"+% R(>'1% G/S O/A */"+%6 #$% :"1"# '( #/S 6%6->#"'(+ )'* >$/*"#/@:% >'(#*"@-#"'(+

@B >'1./("%+ )*'1 ce #' WDe ') /((-/: #/S/@:% "(>'1%

!

G$% .*'.'*#"'( ') #/S 6%6->#"'(+ )'* >$/*"#/@:%

>'(#*"@-#"'(+ @B "(6"9"6-/:+ *%1/"(+ /# cEe ') #/S/@:% "(>'1%

!

PKX /(6 #$% J#/#% G/S L61"("+#*/#"'( 2JLG3

"++-%6 / 8#$H02*$ -3 @*3*F(.(31 L770(7 8-3H($3#3F S-3

"

4$-,#1 /$F*3#Y*1#-3 6 7 I2#F#J#2#1M ,-$ !*E R(%0H1#-3

27'

!

DEEb

"

WDc3 '( #$% >*"#%*"/ )'* %:"<"@":"#B ') 0JK+ )'* >'*.'*/#% >$/*"#/@:% #/S 6%6->#"'(+

!

PKX4 JLG /(6

f PK0L $/6 "++-%6 /( %/*:"%* >"*>-:/* '( +%9%*/: ?-%+#"'(+ '( .*%

"

#/S 6%6->#"'(+ )'* >$/*"#/@:% 6'(/#"'(+

27'

!

DEE`

"

W_E34 .*'9"6"(< 6%#/":+ '( #$% 6%6->#"'(+ )*'1 .*%

"

#/S "(>'1% )'* 6'(/#"'(+ #' ?-/:")"%6 0JK+

!

G$"+

>"*>-:/* A/+ :/#%* +-..:%1%(#%6 "( DEWE @B 0"*>-:/* 27'

!

DEWE

"

^] 3Q L+ / *%+-:#4 >'(#*"@-#"'(+ #' 1'*% 0JK+ /*%

('A 6%%1%6 ?-/:")"%6 )'* #$"+ #/S 6%6->#"'(d #$% (-1@%* "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 )%A%* #$/( DE #' WWE 4 A$">$ />>'-(#+

)'* / +1/:: .%*>%(#/<% ') #$% 0JK+ *%<"+#%*%6 A"#$ PK0L

!

0JK+ /# #$% 1-(">"./: 2>'-(#B3 /(6 .*'9"(>"/: :%9%: >/(

/..:B #' #$%"* :'>/: /-#$'*"#"%+ )'* ?-/:")">/#"'( -(6%* #$%+% *-:%+d *%.'*#"(< '( DEEb 4 .*'&%># 6'>-1%(#+ +#/#%

#$/# $-(6*%6+ ') 0JK+ /# #$% :'>/: :%9%: $/9% /:*%/6B </"(%6 ?-/:")">/#"'(

!

W]D

!

J%>'(64 "( DEEb 4 #$% PKX /(6 JLG &'"(#:B "++-%6 / 8#$H02*$ -3 !*E

"

IE(.51 L3H-.( ,-$ S-3

"

5$-,#1

/$F*3#Y*1#-37 27'

!

DEEb

"

WDD 34 A$">$ '))%*+ #/S /69/(#/<%+ #' 0JK+

!

G$"+ >"*>-:/* .*'9"6%+ #$/# )"9% I"(6+ ')

f 0JK "(>'1% >/( @% %S%1.# )*'1 #/S/#"'(\ 6'(/#"'(+ )*'1 +'>"%#B4 @-6<%# #*/(+)%*4 1%1@%*+$". "(>'1%4

"(#%*%+# />>*-%6 '( ('(

"

#/S/@:% "(>'1% /(6 '#$%* ?-/:")"%6 "(>'1%

!

G$%+% >$/(<%+ #'<%#$%* "1.*'9% #$%

%(9"*'(1%(# )'* 0JK+ /(6 #$%"* 6'('*+

!

W]c

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

PK0L -(6%*#''I %S#%(+"9% =,8

"

+-..'*#%6 *%+%/*>$ /(6 >/**"%6 '( 6"+>-++"'(+ A"#$

0JK+4 /(6 A"#$ PKX /(6 JLG4 #' @*"(< /@'-# #$% @*%/I#$*'-<$ 6%+>*"@%6 /@'9%

!

=,8

"

+-..'*#%6 />#"9"#"%+

>'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% -(6%*:B"(< *%+%/*>$ /(6 >'(+-:#/#"'(+ )'* #$%+% >$/(<%+

!

G$% />#"9"#B *%.'*#+ >'(>:-6% #$/#

;*'&%>#

"

+.'(+'*%6 >'11-(">/#"'( /(6 >'(+-:#/#"'(4 A$%*% '."("'(+ /(6 *%>'11%(6/#"'(+ A%*% +'-<$# )*'1

'$

! !- l [% DEWD /# W^

!

Page 57: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

6"))%*%(# +#/I%$':6%*+4 %+.%>"/::B 0JK+4 >'1@"(%6 A"#$ *%+%/*>$ /(6 +%1"(/*+ #' >'(#*"@-#% <*%/#:B #' #$%

'-#>'1%+

!

P'*%'9%*4 #$% ;*'&%># 6"*%>#:B >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% %+#/@:"+$1%(# ') /( %))%>#"9% A'*I"(< 6"/:'<-%

/1'(< #$% 6"))%*%(# <'9%*(1%(# 6%./*#1%(#+4 .*"1/*":B PK0L4 PKX /(6 JLG

!

G$% ;*'&%># /:+' +-..'*#%6 / .":'#

"( [-@%" '( ?-/:")">/#"'(+ *%?-"*%6 )'* +'>"/: <*'-.+ #$/# /..:B )'* #/S 6%6->#"'( ') >$/*"#/@:% 6'(/#"'(+4 /(6

PK0L "(>'*.'*/#%6 #$% [-@%" %S.%*"%(>% A"#$ '#$%* %S.%*"%(>% "( "#+ R(#%*"1 P%/+-*%+ )'* #$% Z-/:")">/#"'(

V%9"%A ') 7/#"'(/: J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'(+ '( G/S 8%6->#"@:% 0$/*"#/@:% 8'(/#"'(+4 "( C-(% DEWW

!

!

<$7(,3 W

!

C4$ 2"5$#.0$.3 *+6+*)3)$7 3" ).5",5$ ?N97 ). 6(Z,)* 7$#5)*$ &$,)5$#/ 34#"(24 6+#3.$#74)67 +.&

*".3#+*3).2 +#$ $.4+.*$&

!

##

KTR

*

R1.*'9%6 >/./>"#B ') /*'-(6 `EE :'>/: <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ /(6 7=K +#/)) 9"/ #*/"("(< #'

.*'1'#% >''.%*/#"'( @%#A%%( ='9%*(1%(# /(6 >"9": +'>"%#B '*</("Y/#"'(+

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

R( #'#/:4 '9%* WDEE ./*#">"./(#+ @%(%)"#%6 )*'1 W^ #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* #$%

;*'&%>#

!

G*/"("(< A/+ '))%*%6 )'* +#/)) A'*I"(< /# *%<"+#*/#"'( /<%(>"%+4 )'* +#/)) A'*I"(< /# 0JK+ /(6 )'*

#*/"("(< ') #*/"(%*+ )'* @'#$ <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ /(6 0JK +#/))

!

G*/"("(< /66*%++%6 "1.*'9%1%(# ') #$%

>/./>"#B ') <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ /(6 /<%(>"%+ #' )'*1-:/#% .':">"%+ /(6 #' "1.:%1%(# .':">"%+

!

W]^

!

V%+-:#+

!

L +-11/*B ') 0JK #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ "+ .*'9"6%6 "( #$% #/@:% @%:'A

!

C+Z,$ W

!

N(00+#/ "- ?N9

"

#$,+3$& C#+).).2 >*3)5)3)$7

"

C#+).).2 >*3)5)3)$7 >*3(+, 9(36(3

0-**">-:-1 8%9%:'.1%(#

DD >'-*+%+ 6%9%:'.%64 >'9%*"(< 0JK+ *%<"+#*/#"'(4 "(#%*(/: <'9%*(/(>%4 )-(6

"

*/"+"(<4

)"(/(>"/: 1/(/<%1%(#4 $-1/( *%+'-*>%+4 %#>

!

G*/"("(< )'* 0JK +#/))

_ #*/"("(<+ >'(6->#%6 A"#$"( c B%/*+

!

;/*#">"./(#+ "(>:-6% / (-1@%* ') (/#"'(/: 0JK+ /(6

^F_ :'>/: 0JK+ )*'1 WW] #'A(+ /(6 9"::/<%+ ') D` .*'9"(>%+

!

G'#/::B4 ]`` .%*+'(+

*%>%"9%6 #*/"("(<

!

G*/"("(< )'* *%<"+#*/#"'( +#/))

_ #*/"("(<+ >'(6->#%6 A"#$"( c B%/*+

!

;/*#">"./(#+ "(>:-6% +#/)) )*'1 Wb_ >"#B /(6 >'-(#B

:%9%: *%<"+#*/#"'( /<%(>"%+ )*'1 /:: cW .*'9"(>%+

!

G'#/::B4 cbW .%*+'(+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(<

!

GKG G*/"("(<+ c #*/"("(<+ >'(6->#%6 A"#$"( c B%/*+

!

G'#/::B4 D^D .%*+'(+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(<

!

GKGLO ;LVGR0R;L7GJ\ WDDW

W]]

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

L>>'*6"(< #' #$% =,8 ,9/:-/#"'( V%.'*# @B #$% J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'( J%*9">%

0%(#%* -(6%* PK0L4 ./*#">"./(#+ +$'A%6 $"<$ +/#"+)/>#"'( A"#$ #$% #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ /+ #$%+% #*/"("(<+ $/9%

%($/(>%6 @'#$ #$%"* "(6"9"6-/: .%*)'*1/(>% "( >/**B"(< '-# 6/":B A'*I /(6 #$%"* '*</("Y/#"'(/: >/./>"#B "(

>/**B"(< '-# '*</("Y/#"'(/: 1"++"'(

!

X'* "1.*'9%1%(# "( 6/":B .%*)'*1/(>%4 :%++ #$/( WEe ') #$% ./*#">"./(#+

*%.'*#%6 1"("1/: "1.*'9%1%(#d 1'*% #$/( #A'

"

#$"*6+ ') 0JK /(6 <'9%*(1%(# ./*#">"./(#+ /:"I% *%.'*#%6

+"<(")">/(# '* >'(+"6%*/@:% "1.*'9%1%(#

!

X'* "1.*'9%1%(# "( "(+#"#-#"'(/: >/./>"#B4 / 1/&'*"#B ') ./*#">"./(#+

($

!

"

!- l [% DEWD /# W^

!

X*'1 =,8 ,9/:-/#"'( V%.'*# '( 0JK+ G*/"("(< L>#"9"#"%+4 .*%./*%6 @B #$% J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'( J%*9">% 0%(#%* -(6%*

PK0LH+ N-*%/- ') 7;K L61"("+#*/#"'(4 6/#%6 8%>%1@%* Wc 4 DEWW

!

Page 58: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

*%.'*#%6 "1.*'9%1%(# "( /:1'+# /:: >/#%<'*"%+

!

L@'-# $/:) ') 0JK ./*#">"./(#+ *%.'*#%6 #$/# #*/"("(< A'-:6

"(>*%/+% #$%"* /@":"#B #' <%# 9':-(#%%*+ '* )-(6"(<4 /(6 /:1'+# $/:) ') <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ A%*% .'+"#"9% /@'-#

"1.*'9%6 >/./>"#B )'* .':">B "(('9/#"'(

!

W]_

!

G$*'-<$ "(#%*/>#"9% /(6 #A'

"

A/B >'11-(">/#"'(4 #$% =,8 #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ %(/@:%6 #$% *%<"+#*/#"'(

/<%(>"%+ /# 9/*"'-+ :%9%:+ #' >'1.*%$%(6 #$% +#/#-+ /(6 >$/::%(<%+ /++'>"/#%6 A"#$ 0JK +-*9"9/: /(6

6%9%:'.1%(#

!

7'#/@:B4 ^_

!

Fe ') ./*#">"./(#+ )*'1 #$% <'9%*(1%(# *%<"+#*/#"'( /<%(>"%+ "(6">/#%6 #$/# #$%+%

#*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ $/9% "(+."*%6 #$%"* "(+#"#-#"'(+ #' .*'1'#% :'>/: .':">B "(('9/#"'( '( 0JK+ *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6

1/(/<%1%(#

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 #$% N-*%/- ') J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'(+ L61"("+#*/#"'( "( C"/(<+- "++-%6 / +%*"%+ ')

('*1/#"9% 6'>-1%(#+ '( 0JK 1/(/<%1%(#

!

W]F

!

L>>'*6"(< #' PK0L4 #$% <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ /(6 /<%(>"%+ $/9% "1.*'9%6 #$%"* >/./>"#B "( #A' 1/&'*

/+.%>#+

!

X"*+#4 #$% >/./>"#B #' )'*1-:/#% .':">"%+ $/+ @%%( +#*%(<#$%(%6

!

!"#$ +-..'*# )*'1 #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4

*%:%9/(# <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ $/9% >'(6->#%6 *%+%/*>$ /(6 +%1"(/*+4 :%/*(%6 /@'-# )'*%"<( %S.%*"%(>% /(6

:'>/: .*/>#">% "( 0$"(/

!

G$%+% />#"9"#"%+ $/9% .*'<*%++"9%:B @*'/6%(%6 #$%"* $'*"Y'(+4 .*'9'I%6 #$%"* #$'-<$#+

/(6 "(+."*%6 1'*% %))%>#"9% 1%/+-*%+

!

J%>'(64 #$% >/./>"#B #' "1.:%1%(# .':">"%+ $/+ @%%( %($/(>%6

!

J'1%

<'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ $/9% +#*/#%<">/::B "(>*%/+%6 %(</<%1%(# A"#$ 0JK+ "( .*'>-*"(< +'>"/: +%*9">%+

!

<$7(,3 \

!

?""#&).+3)". +.& *"00(.)*+3)". +0".2 ?N97 +.& Z$3%$$. ?N97 +.& 34$ 2"5$#.0$.3 +#$ )06#"5$&

34#"(24 .$3%"#1).2 0$*4+.)707

!

##

KTR

*

R1.*'9%6 >'11-(">/#"'( @%#A%%( 0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# /(6 0JK+ 9"/ #$% &'"(# ='0

"

7=K+

'*</("Y/#"'( ') W] @" 1'(#$:B )'*-1 /(6 A'*I+$'.+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

N"

"

1'(#$:B )'*-1+ 2W] 3 A%*% $%:6

!

V%.'*#+ )*'1 ./*#">"./(#+ "(6">/#% #$/# =,8

/>#"9"#"%+ $/9% @%%( $%:.)-: "( )/>":"#/#"(< (%#A'*I+ /1'(< 0JK+ /(6 @%#A%%( 9/*"'-+ 0JK+ /(6

<'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+

!

['A%9%*4 #$% +-+#/"(/@":"#B ') #$%+% (%#A'*I+ *%1/"(+ #' @% +%%(

!

)$

Page 59: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

W]`

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% :"+# ') W] @"

"

1'(#$:B )'*-1+ "+ +$'A( @%:'A

!

C+Z,$ \

!

N(00+#/ ,)73 "- 8;F ?N9 !"#(07

F+3$ E"*+3)". G+#3)*)6+.37 C"6)*

W DEE`

"

c 7/(("(< `E J#/(6/*6"Y%6 6%9%:'.1%(# ') 0JK+

D DEE`

"

_ G"/(&"( WEE 0/./>"#B @-":6"(< '( 0JK *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 *%<-:/#"'(

c DEE`

"

_ J$%(B/(< bE ;-@:"> >*%6"@":"#B @-":6"(< ') 0JK+

^ DEE`

"

WD N%"&"(< WFE V':% /(6 *%+.'(+"@":"#B "( <:'@/: )"(/(>"/: >*"+"+

] DEEb

"

] N%"&"(< cEE ;'+"#"9% )-(>#"'( ') 7=K+ "( %/*#$?-/I% 6"+/+#%* *%:"%)

_ DEEb

"

F [%"$% WDE 8%9%:'.1%(# /(6 "(('9/#"'( ') 0JK+ "( 0$"(/

F DEEb

"

F N%"&"(< ]EE W

+#

.*"9/#% )'-(6/#"'( 6%9%:'.1%(# )'*-1

` DEEb

"

` J$%(Y$%( WEE 0*%/#"9% <'9%*(/(>% ') 7=K+

b DEWE

"

] 0$%(<6-

WE DEWE

"

b 7/(>$/(<

WW DEWE

"

WE N%"&"(<

WD DEWE

"

WW [/"I'-

FEE

O/A %()'*>%1%(# ') 0JK *%<-:/#"'(

;-@:"> >*%6"@":"#B ') 0JK+ "( 0$"(/

D

(6

.*"9/#% )'-(6/#"'( 6%9%:'.1%(# )'*-1

['A #' /##*/># 1/(/<%*"/: #/:%(#+ #' 0JK A'*I

Wc DEWW

"

^ 7/(>$/(< `E 8%9%:'.1%(# 1'6%:+ ') 0$"(/H+ 0JK+

W^ DEWW

"

WW !-$/( WEE 0JK "(('9/#"'( /(6 6%9%:'.1%(#

W] DEWD

"

c N%"&"(< FE O%</: %(9"*'(1%(# "1.*'9%1%(# ') 0JK+

G'#/: D^WE

+

"(>:-6"(< 0JK +#/))4 <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+

,

W]b

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

X")#%%( @"

"

1'(#$:B )'*-1+ A"#$ 0JK /(6 <'9%*(1%(# ./*#">"./#"'( A%*% '*</("Y%6

@B PK0L -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#

!

R( /66"#"'( #' .*'9"6"(< (%#A'*I"(< />#"9"#"%+ "( 6"))%*%(# :'>/#"'(+ /*'-(6 0$"(/4

#$% )'*-1+ >'9%*%6 / */(<% ') #'.">+ *%:%9/(# #' 0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# A'*I A"#$ 0JK+

!

G'.">+ "(>:-6% "(#%*(/:

0JK "++-%+ 2 *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 *%<-:/#"'(d /##*/>#"(< 1/(/<%*"/: #/:%(#d >*%/#"9% <'9%*(/(>%3 /+ A%:: /+ "++-%+

*%:/#%6 #' 0JK+ /(6 +'>"%#B 2 .-@:"> >*%6"@":"#B @-":6"(<d 0JK *':% "( 6"+/+#%* *%:"%)d "(('9/#"'( /(6

6%9%:'.1%(#3Q K#$%* ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ ') #$"+ #B.% "(>:-6%6 #$% DEWE 7/#"'(/: 0JK ,S>$/(<% 0'()%*%(>%4

A$">$ *%9"%A%6 #$% *%+-:#+ ') #$% .":'#"(< ') / 6"))%*%(# 0JK *%<"+#*/#"'( +B+#%1 "( =-/(<6'(<d #$% W]E

./*#">"./(#+ "(>:-6%6 1/(B /<%(>"%+4 /(6 #$% PK0L P"("+#%*

!

W_E

!

G$*'-<$ #$%+% #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+4 _Ee

"

FEe ') ./*#">"./(#+ *%.'*#%6 #$/# #$%B $/9% )'*1%6 /( %))%>#"9%

(%#A'*I A"#$ 9/*"'-+ 0JK+ /(6 PK0L /<%(>"%+ /# 6"))%*%(# :%9%:+4 A$">$ @*'/6%(+ #$%"* +'-*>%+ )'*

"()'*1/#"'( /(6 *%+'-*>%+

!

['A%9%*4 .'+#

"

#*/"("(< +-*9%B+ /:+' +$'A #$/# 1'+# ./*#">"./(#+ 6' ('# +#/B "(

>'(+#/(# #'->$ A"#$ #$%"* (%#A'*I+

!

L@'-# _

"

Wce ') ./*#">"./(#+ $/9% (%9%* >'(#/>#%6 '#$%* ./*#">"./(#+ '*

PK0L /<%(>"%+ /)#%* #$% #*/"("(<4 /(6 1'+# '#$%* ./*#">"./(#+ H >'11-(">/#"'( )*%?-%(>B A"#$ '#$%*

./*#">"./(#+ "+ :'A '* &-+# /@'-# ('*1/:

!

!

*%

! X*'1 =,8 ,9/:-/#"'( V%.'*# '( 0JK+ G*/"("(< L>#"9"#"%+4 .*%./*%6 @B #$% J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'( J%*9">% 0%(#%* -(6%*

PK0LH+ N-*%/- ') 7;K L61"("+#*/#"'(4 6/#%6 8%>%1@%* Wc 4 DEWW

!

Page 60: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

<$7(,3 ^

!

C4$ ).73)3(3)".+, +.& 6#"-$77)".+, *+6+*)3)$7 "- ?N97 +#$ )06#"5$&

!

=,> I+,*% H(*-

##

KTR

*

=*/(# )-(6"(< ') -. #' DE .*'&%>#+ A"#$ 7=K+ )'>-+%6 '( %($/(>"(< #$%"* 1/(/<%1%(# /(6

*%+%/*>$ >/./>"#"%+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

G$% )"*+# *'-(6 ') <*/(#+ A/+ 6"+@-*+%6 "( DEWE #' W_ 0JK+4 /(6 #$%+% <*/(#

.*'&%>#+ $/9% @%%( >'1.:%#%6

!

G$% +%>'(6 *'-(6 ') c^ .*'&%>#+ "+ +#":: -(6%* "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

L>>'*6"(< #'

0L7;K4 #$"+ %S.%*"%(>% $/+ %))%>#"9%:B @-":# 0JK <*/(# '*</("Y/#"'( H+ >/./>"#B "( .*'&%># "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

/(6 *%.'*#"(<

!

R( DEWD 4 #$% >%(#*/: <'9%*(1%(# 6%+"<(/#%6 /( /66"#"'(/: VPN DEE 1"::"'( #' +-..'*# 0JK

+%*9">% .*'9"+"'(

!

W_W

!

0'(#%S#

!

G$% =,8 =*/(# X-(6 A/+ :/-(>$%6 "( C-:B DEEb

!

5J8 ^EE 4 EEE A/+ %/*1/*I%6 )'* 1/(/<%1%(#

@B #$% 0$"(/ L++'>"/#"'( ') 7'(

"

;*')"# K*</("Y/#"'(+ 2 0L7;K 3 -(6%* #$% X-(6

!

L )-(6 1/(/<%1%(#

>'11"##%% A/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 /(6 >'11"##%% 1%1@%*+ "(>:-6% 0JK *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+4 <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+4 /(6

+>$':/*+

!

J%9%*/: 1/(/<%1%(# 6'>-1%(#+ A%*% .-@:"+$%64 "(>:-6"(< L((-/: R1.:%1%(#/#"'( V-:%+ '( =*/(#

X-(6 /(6 R1.:%1%(#/#"'( V-:%+ '( 8'(/#"'(

!

W_D

!

V%+-:#+

!

G$% )"*+# *'-(6 ') <*/(# )-(6"(< A/+ >/**"%6 '-# "( DEWE

!

G$% .*'.'+/: +':">"#/#"'( ('#">% A/+

.-@:"+$%6 '(:"(%

!

0JK+ >'-:6 +-@1"# #$%"* 'A( .*'&%># .*'.'+/:+ A"#$'-# /(B :"1"#/#"'( '( .*'&%># +>'.% /(6

"1.:%1%(#/#"'( 1%#$'6+ "1.'+%6 @B 0L7;K

!

G$% +%:%>#"'( .*'>%++ "(>:-6%6 "("#"/: +%:%>#"'( /(6 )"(/: +%:%>#"'(

>'(6->#%6 @B @'#$ 0'11"##%% 1%1@%*+ /(6 %S#%*(/: %S.%*#+

!

G$% )"(/: +%:%>#"'( *%+-:#+ A%*% /:+' .-@:"+$%6

'(:"(%

!

R) (' >$/::%(<% A/+ */"+%6 6-*"(< #$% +.%>")"%6 .%*"'64 0L7;K A'-:6 +"<( /( /<*%%1%(# A"#$ #$% 0JK

<*/(#%%+

!

5.'( +"<("(< #$% /<*%%1%(#4 `Ee ') #$% <*/(# A/+ #*/(+)%**%6 #' #$% <*/(#%%4 /(6 #$% *%1/"("(<

DEe A/+ #*/(+)%**%6 -.'( #$% *%>%".# ') 0JKH+ )"(/: *%.'*#

!

W_c

!

L #'#/: ') Dbb 0JK+ +-@1"##%6 #$%"* .*'.'+/:+4 /(6 W_ A%*% +%:%>#%6 )'* #$% )"*+# *'-(6 /(6 c^ +%:%>#%6

)'* #$% +%>'(6 *'-(6

!

L:: .*'&%>#+ -(6%* #$% )"*+# *'-(6 $/9% @%%( >'1.:%#%6

!

G$% +%>'(6 *'-(6 "+ +#":: -(6%*

"1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

L:: <*/(# )-(6"(< A/+ <"9%( #' 0JK+ )'* .*'&%># 6%9%:'.1%(# /(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

0L7;K

6'%+ ('# >$/*<% /(B 1/(/<%1%(# )%%+

!

R(+#%/64 "# >'(#*"@-#%6 +'1% 1'(%B #' '.%*/#% #$"+ .*'&%>#

!

W_^

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

J'1% :%++'(+ :%/*(%6 )*'1 =*/(# X-(6 '.%*/#"'( A%*% *%.'*#%6 @B 0L7;K

!

0L7;K

+$'-:6 @% <"9%( 1/(/<%1%(# )%%+ /(6 (%>%++/*B #*/"("(< +$'-:6 @% .*'9"6%6 #' 0JK <*/(#%%+

!

P'+# 0JK

<*/(#%%+ /*% <*/++*''#+ '*</("Y/#"'(+ )*'1 *%1'#% /*%/+ A"#$'-# .*'&%># 1/(/<%1%(# %S.%*"%(>%4 .*'&%>#

*%.'*#"(< I('A:%6<% '* /6%?-/#% "(#%*(/: <'9%*(/(>% +#*->#-*%

!

G$%+% '*</("Y/#"'(+ A%*% ('# (%>%++/*":B

>'9%*%6 @B #$% #*/"("(< .*'9"6%6 -(6%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 @-# >'-:6 $/9% @%(%)"#%6 )*'1 #*/"("(< #' >/**B '-#

<*/(# />#"9"#"%+

!

['A%9%*4 6-% #' #$% #"<$# @-6<%# ') #$% <*/(# >'1.'(%(#4 #*/"("(< A/+ ('# .'++"@:% /(6 #$%

!%

Page 61: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

"1./># ') <*/(# '( +'1% 0JKH+ :'(< #%*1 6%9%:'.1%(# "+ :"1"#%6

!

2J%% N'S ^

!

3

W_]

!

0L7;K /:+' ('#%6 +%9%*/: @%(%)"#+

!

G$*'-<$ %1/": %S>$/(<%+ /(6 #$% )"(/: *%.'*# *%?-"*%1%(#4 #$% 0JK

<*/(#%%+ $/9% "1.*'9%6 #$%"* /A/*%(%++ ') /(6 %S.%*"%(>% A"#$ )'*1/: .*'&%># 1/(/<%1%(# .*'>%6-*%+

!

X'*

+'1% 0JK+4 #$% )-(6+ '))%*%6 )*%+$ @:''6 #' #$%"* 6/":B '.%*/#"'( /(6 "1.*'9%6 #$%"* .*')%++"'(/: +I"::+

!

G$%

+1/:: /1'-(# ') +%%6 1'(%B )*'1 #$% <*/(# $/+ %(/@:%6 +'1% 0JK+ #' @% %:"<"@:% )'* +'1% >'

"

)-(6"(<

'..'*#-("#"%+ .*'9"6%6 @B '#$%* 6'('*+

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/+ /:+' "(+."*%6 +'1% :'>/: <'9%*(1%(# "(('9/#"'(

"( 0JK 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

R# %(/@:%6 0L7;K #' @%##%* -(6%*+#/(6 :'>/: 0JK '*</("Y/#"'(+4 /+ A%:: /+ .*'9"6"(< "#

A"#$ %S.%*"%(>% "( 6%/:"(< A"#$ "(#%*(/#"'(/: '*</("Y/#"'(+

!

W__

!

0L7;K .'"(#%6 #' #$% 6%>"+"'( ') #$% >%(#*/: <'9%*(1%(# #' .*'9"6% VPN DEE 4 EEE 4 EEE #' +-..'*#

0JK+4 "(6">/#"(< #$/# #$% <*/(# >'1.'(%(# $/+ %))%>#"9%:B @-":# >'(+%(+-+ /(6 /69/(>%6 .':">B 6%9%:'.1%(# #'

.*'1'#% 0JK 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

20L7;K A":: *%>%"9% VPN FEE 4 EEE )'* 0JK #*/"("(< /(6 >/./>"#B @-":6"(<

!

3

0L7;K ('#%6 #$/# #$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/+ .:/B%6 /( "1.'*#/(# *':% "( 6%%.%("(< +>$':/*+ H -(6%*+#/(6"(< ')

)'*%"<( #$%'*"%+ /(6 .*/>#">% /(6 %(/@:"(< 0$"(%+% +#/I%$':6%*+ #' )/1":"/*"Y% #$%1+%:9%+ A"#$ "(#%*(/#"'(/:

.*/>#">%+ '( 0JK 1/(/<%1%(# /(6 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

=;> .+,)*)*6

##

KTR

*

L*'-(6 WEEE 7=K :%/6%*+ /(6 +#/)) #*/"(%6 "( 1/(/<%1%(#4 .':">B /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+

!

J#/#-+

*

L>$"%9%6

!

J.%>")"> )"<-*%+ )'* 0JK ./*#">"./(#+ "( #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* V%+-:# c "(6">/#% /#

:%/+# ]`` 0JK +#/))

!

R( /66"#"'(4 #$% >'1@"(%6 (-1@%* ') 0JK ./*#">"./(#+ /(6 *%<"+#*/#"'( /<%(>B

./*#">"./(#+ "( 0JK )'*-1+ -(6%* V%+-:# ^ "+ D^WE 4 /(6 "# "+ )/"* #' /++-1% #$/# A%:: '9%* $/:) ') #$%+%

./*#">"./(#+ A%*% )*'1 0JK+

!

G$% >'(#%(# ') #$%+% />#"9"#"%+ /:: )"# A"#$"( 1/(/<%1%(#4 .':">B /(6

*%<-:/#"'(+ #'.">+

!

W_F

!

;*'&%># 0'(#*"@-#"'(

!

G$% "1./># ') #$% #*/"("(<4 /+ '-#:"(%6 /@'9%4 "+ 6"+>-++%6 "( 6%#/": -(6%* V%+-:#+ c

/(6 ^ 4 *%+.%>#"9%:B

!

"%

Page 62: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

D"R \

!

8;F 8#+.3 !(.& -"# ?N97

B.."5+3)5$ G#"*$77

!

0L7;K %+#/@:"+$%6 / 1/(/<%1%(# >'11"##%%4 >'1.'+%6 ') 0JK *%.*%+%(#/#"9%+4

o <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+4 /(6 +>$':/*+4 )'* #$% '.%*/#"'( ') #$% J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'( 8%9%:'.1%(# X-(6 2JK8X3Q

!G*/(+./*%(>B

!

0L7;K .-@:"+$%6 +%9%*/: 1/(/<%1%(# 6'>-1%(#+4 "(>:-6"(< #$% J#/(6/*6+ )'* ,9/:-/#"'(

') JK8X ;*'&%>#+4 #$% L((-/: R1.:%1%(#/#"'( V-:%+ '( =*/(# X-(6 /(6 #$% R1.:%1%(#/#"'( V-:%+ '(

8'(/#"'(

!

!N"66"(<

!

L( '.%( @"66"(< .*'>%++ A/+ -+%6 #' +':">"# <*/(# .*'.'+/:+ )*'1 0JK+4 A"#$ #$% .*'.'+/:

+':">"#/#"'( ('#">% .-@:"+$%6 '(:"(%

!

0JK+ >'-:6 +-@1"# #$%"* 'A( .*'&%># .*'.'+/: A"#$'-# /(B :"1"#/#"'(

'( .*'&%># +>'.% /(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'( 1%#$'6+ "1.'+%6 @B 0L7;K

!

!J%:%>#"'(

!

G$% +%:%>#"'( .*'>%++ "(>:-6%6 "("#"/: /(6 )"(/: +%:%>#"'( >'(6->#%6 @B @'#$ #$% 0'11"##%%

1%1@%*+ /(6 #$% %S#%*(/: %S.%*#+

!

G$% )"(/: +%:%>#"'( *%+-:#+ A%*% /:+' .-@:"+$%6 '(:"(%4 +-@&%># #'

>$/::%(<%+ A"#$ / +.%>")"%6 .%*"'6

!

!R1.:%1%(#/#"'( J-..'*#

!

0L7;K .*'9"6%6 +-@+#/(#"/: +-..'*# #' @-":6 #$% <*/(#%%H+ >/./>"#B #' >'1.:B

A"#$ #$% +#/(6/*6"Y%6 *%?-"*%1%(#+ "( <*/(#%% .*'&%># 1/(/<%1%(#4 %9/:-/#"'( /(6 *%.'*#"(<

!

V%>"."%(#

0JK+ A%*% *%?-"*%6 #' +-@1"# /( "(#%*"1 *%.'*# #' 0L7;K /# #$% %(6 ') #$% )"*+# +"S 1'(#$+ /)#%* #$%

>'11%(>%1%(# ') #$%"* .*'&%>#+

!

5.'( >'1.:%#"'(4 #$%B A%*% /+I%6 #' +-@1"# / )"(/: +%:)

"

%9/:-/#"'(

*%.'*#

!

PK0L $/+ @%%( /::'>/#%6 VPN DEE 1"::"'( )*'1 #$% DEWD )"+>/: @-6<%# #' )-(6 0JK+ #$*'-<$ JK8X4

1/I"(< #$"+ / +-+#/"(/@:% 1%>$/("+1 %9%( /)#%* #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#

!

N4+.24+) G(&".2 N"*)+, M"#1$#X7 >77"*)+3)". IGNM>J[ K(% <*/(#%% 0JK A/+ ;J!L4 / +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(

o 1/6% -. ') +'>"/: A'*I%*+ /(6 '#$%* +'>"/: A'*I '*</("Y/#"'(+ "( ;-6'(< #$/# .*'1'#%+ #$% +.%>"/:"Y/#"'(

/(6 .*')%++"'( ') +'>"/: A'*I

!

G$%*% /*% >-**%(#:B c` '*</("Y/#"'( 1%1@%*+ /(64 /+ ') DEWE 4 1'*% #$/(

FEE "(6"9"6-/: 1%1@%*+

!

P'+# ') "#+ '*</("Y/#"'( 1%1@%*+ +#/*#%6 @B 6'"(< +'>"/: +%*9">% .*'&%>#+ /+ ./*#

') #$% ;!JL /(6 #$%( @%>/1% "(6%.%(6%(# '*</("Y/#"'(+ 2;J!LH+ "(>-@/#'* )-(>#"'(3Q

!=*/(# ;*'&%>#

!

;J!L *%>%"9%6 / <*/(# -(6%* #$% JK8X )"*+# *'-(6 #' +-..'*# / V%+%/*>$ ;*'&%># '( #$%

G$%'*B /(6 ;*/>#">% ') J$/(<$/" ;-6'(< J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'(+4 >'9%*"(< <*'A#$ /(6 6%9%:'.1%(# ') ;-6'(<

+'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+d *':%+ /(6 *%:/#"'(+$".+ A"#$ #$% <'9%*(1%(#4 +'>"/: A'*I *%+%/*>$%*+ "( >'::%<%+ /(6

-("9%*+"#"%+4 .*')%++"'( ') +'>"/: A'*I%*+d '.%*/#"'(/: 1'6%:+4 1/(/<%1%(# +#B:%+ /(6 *%>*-"#"(< 1%>$/("+1

') ;-6'(< +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+d /(6 #$% "(>-@/#"'( )-(>#"'( /(6 #$% >''*6"(/#"'( )-(>#"'( ') ;J!L4 /1'(<

'#$%* +-@&%>#+

!

L *%+%/*>$ <*'-. ') -("9%*+"#B +>$':/*+ /(6 0JK .*/>#"#"'(%*+ -(6%*#''I :"#%*/#-*% *%+%/*>$4

"(6"9"6-/: "(#%*9"%A+4 )'*-1+ /(6 / (-1@%* ') +'>"/: +-*9%B+4 /(6 "(#%*9"%A%6 #$% #A' <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+

*%+.'(+"@:% )'* 0JK+ *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 1/(/<%1%(#

!

G$% )"(/: @'-(6 9':-1% @*'-<$# #'<%#$%* #$% +-11"(<

-. ') WE B%/*H+ %S.%*"%(>% /:'(< A"#$ +%9%*/: /(/:B#">/: ."%>%+

!

!R1./>#

*

G$% )"(/: *%.'*# "+ .-@:">:B /9/":/@:% /(6 -+%6 /+ -("9%*+"#B #%/>$"(< 1/#%*"/:+4 A"#$ +'1% +%>#"'(+

.-@:"+$%6 "( &'-*(/:+

!

G$% *%.'*# A/+ .*%+%(#%6 #' #$% :'>/: <'9%*(1%(#4 -+%6 "( A'*I+$'.+ /(6 )'* 1/(B

+.%%>$%+

!

R1.*%++%6 @B #$% -+%)-:(%++ ') #$% *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#4 #$% :'>/: <'9%*(1%(# >'(+-:#%6 #$% #%/1 )'* "#+

9"%A+ '( 6%9%:'.1%(# ') +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+4 .*'@:%1+ /(6 +':-#"'(+

!

G$%+% 9"%A+ $/6 /( "1./># '(

<'9%*(1%(# .*'<*/1+ /(6 A%*% *%):%>#%6 "( #$% WD#$ X"9% U%/* 8%9%:'.1%(# ;:/( )'* ;-6'(<4 /+ A%:: /+

;-6'(<H+ WD#$ X"9% U%/* ;:/( )'* G/:%(#4 A$">$ "+ / >:%/* %S/1.:% ') >"9": +'>"%#B ./*#">"./#"'( "( .':">B 1/I"(<

!

#%

Page 63: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

B:

!

G<9K;?C ?9=C<BDACB9=N

W_`

!

=%(%*/:

!

R( /66"#"'( #' #$% ;*'&%># >'(#*"@-#"'(+ 6%#/":%6 -(6%* %/>$ KTR4 #$% =,8 ;*'&%># /:+' .*'9"6%6

#$*%% >*'++

"

>-##"(< #B.%+ ') >'(#*"@-#"'(+\ 2/3 #$*'-<$ "1.:%1%(#/#"'( 1%#$'6+ #$/# .*'1'#%6 '.%((%++ /(6

#*/(+./*%(>Bd 2@3 #$*'-<$ %1."*">/: *%+%/*>$ /(6 %S>$/(<%+ #$/# @*'-<$# '-# :%++'(+ )*'1 :'>/: .*/>#">%d /(6

2>3 #$*'-<$ %S.%*# /69">%4 "(#%*(/#"'(/: +%1"(/*+ /(6 +#-6B #'-*+ #$/# 6*%A '-# >'1./*/#"9% %S.%*"%(>%

!

W_b

!

K.%((%++ /(6 G*/(+./*%(>B

!

G$% ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ #' @*'/6%( >"9": +'>"%#B "(9':9%1%(# 20'1.'(%(# 03

.*'9"6%6 / (-1@%* ') '..'*#-("#"%+ #' .":'# '.%( /(6 #*/(+./*%(# "1.:%1%(#/#"'( 1%#$'6+4 A"#$ :/+#"(<

"1./># '( PK0L /(6 >"9": +'>"%#B

!

X"*+#4 /:: =,8 />#"9"#"%+ A%*% .-@:">"Y%6 '(:"(%4 /(6 '.%( #' /::4 /##*/>#"(<

A"6% ./*#">"./#"'(4 )*'1 0JK+4 +>$':/*+ /(6 %S.%*#+

!

J%>'(64 PK0L -+%6 / @"66"(< .*'>%++ #' +%:%># /-#$'*+

)'* #$% #%S#@''I +%*"%+ '( 0JK "++-%+4 /+ A%:: /+ )'* *%+%/*>$ #'.">+ '( )*'(#"%* "++-%+ #$/# A%*% +-@+%?-%(#:B

.-@:"+$%6 "( / +"S

"

9':-1% +%*"%+ ') .':">B /(6 *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+

!

G$% .*'>%++ $/6 +#*"># %9/:-/#"'( .*'>%6-*%+4

/66"(< #' "#+ >*%6"@":"#B

!

G$"+ @"66"(< .*'>%++ ('# '(:B .'.-:/*"Y%6 #$% ;*'&%>#4 "# /:+' %(>'-*/<%6

>'11-(">/#"'( /1'(< +>$':/*+ /(6 '#$%* +#/I%$':6%*+ /(6 )'+#%*%6 #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') / <*'-. ') (%A

+>$':/*+ '( +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+ 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

J'1% c 4 EEE +>$':/*+ +-@1"##%6 *%+%/*>$ .*'.'+/:+

!

WFE

!

G$"*64 #$% .*'>%++ )'* +%:%>#"'( ') 0JK .*'&%>#+ #' *%>%"9% <*/(#+ )*'1 #$% =*/(# X-(6 A/+ /:+' '.%( /(6

#*/(+./*%(#

!

G$% .*'.'+/: +':">"#/#"'( ('#">% A/+ .-@:"+$%6 '(:"(%4 /(6 0JK+ >'-:6 +-@1"# .*'.'+/:+ A"#$'-#

:"1"#/#"'( '( .*'&%># +>'.% /(6 1%#$'6+

!

L)#%* / +%:%>#"'( .*'>%++ #$/# "(>:-6%6 "(#%*(/: >'11"##%% 1%1@%*+

/(6 %S#%*(/: %S.%*#+4 #$% +%:%>#"'( *%+-:#+ A%*% .-@:"+$%6 '(:"(%4 +-@&%># #' >$/::%(<%+ */"+%6 6-*"(< / +.%>")">

.%*"'6

!

WFW

!

J-@+#/(#"9%:B4 #$% ;*'&%># .*'1'#%6 <*%/#%* '.%((%++ /(6 #*/(+./*%(>B #$*'-<$ +-..'*# )'* '.%( #*"/:

*%)'*1+ /(6 #$% !-Y$'(< .%'.:% H + /++%++'*+ .":'# -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L

!

G$% 7;0 H + .*'>%6-*%+ )'* .-@:">

>'11%(# '( 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( /:+' .*'1'#%6 <*%/#%* '.%((%++ /(6 #*/(+./*%(>B

!

WFD

!

O%++'(+ )*'1 O'>/: ;*/>#">%

!

0$"(/ H+ *%)'*1 .*'<*/1 )'* #$% :/+# cE B%/*+ $/+ *%:"%6 $%/9":B '( :'>/:

%S.%*"1%(#/#"'( #' 6%9%:'. 9"/@:% 1%>$/("+1+ #$/# >/( @% %S#%(6%6 (/#"'(A"6%

!

R( #$/# >'(#%S#4 +-..'*# )'*

:'>/: .":'#+ /(6 >*%/#"(< '..'*#-("#"%+ #' /++%++ .":'# *%+-:#+4 *%+%/*>$ /(6 %S>$/(<% :'>/: .*/>#">% "+ /(

%++%(#"/: %:%1%(# ') #$% *%)'*1 .*'>%++

!

G$% =,8 ;*'&%># .*'1'#%6 +%9%*/: *%)'*1+ "( #$"+ A/B

!

X'* "(+#/(>%4

#$% ;*'&%># $%:.%6 #' 6%9%:'.4 /++%++ /(6 .'.-:/*"Y% #$% !-Y$'(< .":'# '( .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+4 #$% ;-6'(<

.":'# '( L8V /(6 #$% =/(+- .":'# '( '.%( #*"/:+4 #$'-<$ #$% 6%>"+"'( '( .":'#+ /(6 #$% 1/"( )-(6"(< /(6

"1.:%1%(#/#"'( )'* #$%1 A%*% ./*# ') #$% 0'-*#H+ 'A( *%)'*1 .:/(+

!

X"%:6 *%+%/*>$ /(6 :'>/: .":'#+ A%*% /:+'

+-..'*#%6 /+ ./*# ') &-6">"/: >'+# /(6 %))">"%(>B *%)'*1+ /(6 #$% (%A >/+% <-"6/(>% +B+#%1

!

$%

Page 64: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

WFc

!

;*'9"6"(< )'*-1+ #' +$/*% :'>/: .*/>#">% /(6 A'*I #'A/*6+ / >'(+%(+-+ A/+ / I%B 6"1%(+"'( ') ;*'&%>#

+-..'*# )'* #$% :/A

"

1/I"(< +B+#%1

!

,S/1.:%+ "(>:-6% 1%#$'6+ )'* .-@:"> >'11%(# '( 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'(4

:%<"+:/#"9% $%/*"(<+4 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A /(6 #$% +B+#%1 ') *%9"%A /(6 )":"(<

!

J"1":/*:B4 PK0L -+%6 / 9/*"%#B

') A'*I+$'.+ /(6 '#$%* />#"9"#"%+ #' <%# 0JK "(.-# "( #$% .':">B .*'>%++4 "( ./*#">-:/*4 '( #/S %S%1.#"'(4 6"*%>#

*%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 0JK 1/(/<%1%(# "++-%+

!

;":'#+ .:/B%6 / *':% $%*%4 #'' 2%

!

<

!

[-@%" '( >$/*"#/@:% 6%6->#"'(+3Q

WF^

!

0'1./*/#"9% ,S.%*"%(>%

!

,S.:'*"(< #$% %S.%*"%(>% ') '#$%* >'-(#*"%+ "( 6%#/":%6 /*%/+ ') *%)'*1 $/+ /:+'

@%%( / $/::1/*I ') 0$"(/ H + *%)'*1 .*'>%++

!

R( 0$"(/4 /+ %:+%A$%*%4 #$%+% %S.:'*/#"'(+ *%?-"*% / +':"6

-(6%*+#/(6"(< ') *%:%9/(# )'*%"<( %S.%*"%(>%4 +"(>% "# "+ :"I%:B #' *%?-"*% /6/.#/#"'( #' 1/I% "# A'*I/@:% "(

0$"(/H+ -("?-% :%</:4 %>'('1">4 .':"#">/: /(6 +'>"/: >'(#%S#

!

,S/1.:%+ ') ;*'&%># .*'9"6%6 '..'*#-("#"%+ )'* #$"+

I"(6 ') +#-6B "(>:-6%\ >/+% <-"6/(>% .*/>#">% "( >"9": :/A +B+#%1+d ,5 .*/>#">% '( 1%6"/#"'( /(6 A"#$ '.%(

#*"/:+d &-6">"/: #*/"("(< 1%#$'6+ "( '#$%* >'-(#*"%+d /(6 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

G$%+% '..'*#-("#"%+ >/1%

#$*'-<$ +#-6B #'-*+ /+ A%:: /+ "(#%*(/#"'(/: +%1"(/*+

!

5(6%* #$% :%<"+:/#"9% >'1.'(%(#4 #A' -(/(#">"./#%6

>'(#*"@-#"'(+ ') #$% ;*'&%># >/1% 6"*%>#:B )*'1 =,8 +#-6B #'-*+\ #$% (%A .*/>#">% ') .*%

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A A/+

)'+#%*%6 @B / +#-6B #'-* #' R+*/%: /(6 R(6"/4 /(6 >'1.%(+/#"'( )'* 1%(#/: $/*1 A/+ "(>:-6%6 "( #$% )"(/: J#/#%

0'1.%(+/#"'( O/A /1%(61%(#+ /)#%* / 9"+"# #' ,(<:/(6 /(6 J./"(

!

X'* >"9": +'>"%#B 6%9%:'.1%(#4 #$% ;*'&%>#

.:/B%6 /( "1.'*#/(# *':% "( 6%%.%("(< +>$':/*H+ -(6%*+#/(6"(< ') )'*%"<( #$%'*"%+4 /+ A%:: /+ %(/@:"(< 0$"(%+%

+#/I%$':6%*+ #' @%>'1% )/1":"/* A"#$ "(#%*(/#"'(/: .*/>#">%+ '( 0JK 1/(/<%1%(# /(6 6%9%:'.1%(#

!

WF]

!

P%6"/ J-11/*B

!

R( #$% 0$"(%+% 1%6"/4 #$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/+ @%%( *%.'*#%6 /+ /( "(#%*(/#"'(/:

>''.%*/#"'( .*'&%># A"#$ #$% :/*<%+# +>/:% /(6 @*'/6%+# >'9%*/<% "( #$% )"%:6 ') 6%1'>*/#"> <'9%*(/(>%

!

G$%

'9%*/:: .*'&%># '@&%>#"9%+ /(6 >'(#%(#+ /*% .'+#%6 '( #$% A%@+"#% ') 0$"(/ R(#%*(/#"'(/: 0%(#%* )'* ,>'('1">

/(6 G%>$(">/: ,S>$/(<% 2/(6 578;3Q ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ $/9% @%%( A"6%:B *%.'*#%6 @B 9/*"'-+ (%A+./.%*+ /(6

A%@+"#%+

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 .*'&%>#+ -(6%* 0'1.'(%(# L4 L>>%++ #' C-+#">%4 /*% *%.'*#%6 '( J;0H+ '))">"/: A%@+"#%4

;%'.:%H+ 0'-*# 8/":B4 O%</: 8/":B4 0$"(/ 8/":B4 a"($-/ (%A+ /<%(>B4 /+ A%:: /+ "( :'>/: (%A+./.%*+ A$%*% #$%

/>#"9"#"%+ A%*% $%:6

!

K(

"

:"(% 1%6"/ $/+ @%%( /('#$%* %))%>#"9% #'': #' 6"++%1"(/#% />#"9"#B "()'*1/#"'( /(6

.*'&%># />$"%9%1%(#+

!

X'* %S/1.:%4 #$% X'*-1 '( 0"9": J'>"%#B K*</("Y/#"'(+ /(6 V-*/: 8%9%:'.1%(# "( 0$"(/

A/+ *%.'*#%6 '( 1/&'* 0$"(%+% (%A+ A%@+"#%+4 "(>:-6"(< J"(/4 J'$-4 ZZ4 7%#%/+% /(6 ;$'%("S

!

WF_

!

G$% *%>'<("#"'( ') #$% ;*'&%>#H+ */#"'(/:% /(6 "#+ "1./># >/( @% *%):%>#%6 )*'1 / 578;

"

6%9%:'.%6 .*'&%>#

.'.-:/*"Y/#"'( 9"6%'

!

!

R( #$% 9"6%'4 P*

!

U/' J$%($'(<4 7/#"'(/: ;*'<*/11% 8"*%>#'* /# 0$"(/ R(#%*(/#"'(/:

0%(#%* )'* ,>'('1"> /(6 G%>$(">/: ,S>$/(<% >/::%6 #$% =,8 ;*'&%># / +->>%++)-: 1'6%: "( "(#%*(/#"'(/:

>''.%*/#"'(

!

!$%( *%):%>#"(< '( #$% "1./># ') #$% =,8 ;*'&%>#4 / :%/6%* /# J;0 >'()"*1%6 #$/# #$%"* <'/: $/6

@%%( />$"%9%64 /+ ;*'&%># +-..'*# $/6 %(/@:%6 <''6 .*'<*%++ "( 1/(B /*%/+ /(6 %+#/@:"+$%6 *%<-:/* >'(#/>#+

A"#$ "(#%*(/#"'(/: >'::%/<-%+

!

P'*%'9%*4 1/(B ;*'&%># ./*#">"./(#+ *%>'<("Y%6 #$/# #$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/6

%%

! $##.\ gg9

!

B'-I-

!

>'1g9j +$'Ag"6j aP&<^P&LA7&UE

!

$#1:

!

Page 65: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

<%(%*/#%6 .'+"#"9% "1./># "( .*'1'#"(< &-6">"/*BH+ *':% "( />$"%9"(< +'>"/: &-+#">%

!

:

!

?9=?EANB9=N

WFF

!

K@+%*9/#"'(+

!

G$"+ *%9"%A ') KTR *%+-:#+ /(6 />$"%9%1%(#+ A/+ ('# "(#%(6%6 #' 6%:9% "(#' #$% ?-%+#"'(+

') A$/# >'-:6 $/9% @%%( 6'(% @%##%* /(6 A$/# >'-:6 @% +-..'*#%6 (%S#

!

7'(%#$%:%++4 +'1% '@+%*9/#"'(+ >/(

@% '))%*%6 /@'-# ./+# /(6 )-#-*% 6'('* /++"+#/(>% "( #$%+% /*%/+ ') <'9%*(/(>% "( 0$"(/4 *%>'<("Y"(< #$/# #$%

>$/::%(<%+ /(6 *%)'*1 /<%(6/+ /*% 6"))%*%(# )'* %/>$ ') #$% #$*%% R1.:%1%(#"(< L<%(>"%+

!

WF`

!

X'* #$% D484 #$% #$*%% )"9%

"

B%/* *%)'*1 .:/(+ #' 6/#% $/9% +%# #$% >'-*+% )'* / >'1.:%S /(6 /1@"#"'-+

f .*'<*/1 ') &-6">"/: *%)'*1+4 A"#$ />>%++ #' &-+#">% *%)'*1+ ./*# ') #$% '9%*/:: .*'<*/1

!

L::'>/#"'( ')

<'9%*(1%(# *%+'-*>%+ /(6 /##%(#"'( )'* /(B .*'.'+%6 *%)'*1 "+ 1'*% :"I%:B #' @% <-"6%6 @B J;0 *%)'*1

.*"'*"#"%+ #$/( %S#%*(/: .*'&%># >'11"#1%(#+

!

U%#4 #$% >'(#%(# /(6 "1./># ') #$% *%)'*1+ >/( @% /69/(>%6

#$*'-<$ #%>$(">/: >''.%*/#"'(4 /+ #$% =,8 >'(#*"@-#"'(+ '-#:"(%6 "( #$"+ V%.'*# 6%1'(+#*/#%

!

L I%B )/>#'* "+

#$% &-6">"/*B H+ $"%*/*>$">/: +#*->#-*%4 A"#$ *%.'*#"(< *%:/#"'(+$".+ @%#A%%( >%(#*/: /(6 :'>/: :%9%:+

!

J;0 /+ /

>'-(#%*./*# >/( 1'*% %/+":B '9%*+%% ;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ /# #$% :'>/: :%9%: /+ ./*# ') "#+ *%<-:/* '9%*+"<$# /(6

<-"6/(>% )-(>#"'(+

!

X-#-*% /++"+#/(>% )'* #$% &-6">"/*B >'-:6 1/S"1"Y% #$%+% /+.%>#+ @B <*'-(6"(< #%>$(">/:

>''.%*/#"'( "( #$% (%S# )"9%

"

B%/* *%)'*1 .:/(

!

;*'&%># +-..'*# )'* /++%++1%(# ') #$% c *6 )"9%

"

B%/* .:/( #$/#

%(6+ A"#$ DEWc /(6 )'* #$% 6%+"<( ') #$% (%S# .:/( A'-:6 @% '(% A/B #' 1/S"1"Y% #$% =,8 1'1%(#-1

!

WFb

!

X'* #$% S484 #$% *%)'*1+ "( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( A%*% ('# ./*# ') / .-@:">4 6%#/":%64 .*%

"

+%# /<%(6/

!

;-@:">

+#/#%1%(#+ "(6">/#% / >'(#"(-%6 >'11"#1%(# #' @*'/6%("(< >"#"Y%( H+ "(.-# "( :%<"+:/#"'(4 /(6 #' >'(#"(-'-+

"1.*'9%1%(# "( :%<"+:/#"9% 6*/)#"(< /(6 $/*1'("Y/#"'(

!

V%.'*#+ +-<<%+# #$/# 1->$ />#"9"#B "( #$%+% /*%/+ "+

#/I"(< .:/>% /# #$% .*'9"(>"/: /(6 +-@

"

.*'9"(>"/: :'>/: :%9%:4 A"#$'-# #$% /../*%(# (%%6 )'* (/#"'(/: <-"6%:"(%+

/(6 "(+#*->#"'(+

!

R( 0$"(/ H+ *%)'*1+4 :'>/: %S.%*"%(>% >/( ')#%( >'/:%+>% "(#' (/#"'(/: *-:%+4 */#$%* #$/( #$%

'#$%* A/B /*'-(64 1/I"(< >'(+':"6/#"(< /(6 >'1./*"(< :'>/: .*/>#">% "+ /( "1.'*#/(# )-(>#"'(

!

G$% /@+%(>% ')

/ $"%*/*>$">/: *%.'*#"(< +#*->#-*% @%#A%%( #$% 7;0 /(6 O;0+ +-<<%+#+ #$/# 6"*%># %(</<%1%(# A"#$ O;0+ 2A"#$

7;0 +-..'*#3 1/B .*'9% .*'6->#"9%

!

L</"(4 / (%A /<%(6/ >/( @% %S.%>#%6 A"#$ #$% (%A >'(<*%++%+ "(

DEWc

!

;*'&%># /++"+#/(>% #' *%9"%A .*'<*%++ /(6 6%+"<( .'#%(#"/: *%)'*1+ /(6 "1.*'9%1%(#+ )'* #$% (%S# )"9%

"

B%/* #%*1 >'-:6 .*'9% 9/:-/@:%

!

W`E

!

X'* @/8O 4 #$% ;*'&%># *%9"%A "+ :%++ "()'*1/#"9%

!

J#*->#-*/: .':">B *%)'*1+ "( #$"+ /*%/ A%*% / +1/:: ./*# ')

=,8 />#"9"#"%+4 #$'-<$ #$% ;*'&%># 6"6 >'(#*"@-#% #' *%+%/*>$ /(6 0JK .':">B "(.-#+ "( #$% .*%./*/#"'( ') #/S

>$/(<%+ /(6 *%9"+%6 *%<-:/#"'(+

!

R) #$'+% *%<-:/#"'(+ /*% "(6%%6 %(/>#%6 @B #$% J#/#% 0'-(>":4 +-..'*# )'*

"1.:%1%(#/#"'( >'-:6 @% @%(%)">"/:

!

V'::

"

'-# />#"9"#"%+ >'-:6 "(>:-6% 6%#/":%6 "1.:%1%(#"(< *-:%+ )'* (/#"'(/:

/(6 :'>/: :%9%:+ /+ A%:: /+ .-@:">"#B /(6 #*/"("(< )'* 0JK+ #' #/I% /69/(#/<% ') #$% (%A .*'9"+"'(+

!

&%

Page 66: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

W`W

!

L++%++1%(#

!

X'* #$% =,8 .*'&%># #$/# "+ ('A >:'+"(<4 #$% *%+-:#+ /(6 />$"%9%1%(#+ /*%

>'(+"6%*/@:%

!

K9%*/::4 #$% O'<)*/1% "(6">/#'*+ )'* #$% =,8 ;*'&%># $/9% @%%( :/*<%:B />$"%9%6

!

V%)'*1 /(6

"(('9/#"'( "( %/>$ ') #$% #$*%% ;*'&%># /*%/+ $/9% @%%( 6%%.%(%6 /(6 )/>":"#/#%6 #$*'-<$ ;*'&%>#

/>#"9"#"%+

!

0'(+"6%*"(< #$% @*%/6#$ ') #$% ;*'&%># /(6 #$% >$/::%(<%+ "( #$% :/+# )"9% B%/*+ ') 0$"(%+% *%)'*1+4

#$"+ "+ (' +1/:: />$"%9%1%(#

!

W`D

!

!$/# "+ 1'*% 6"))">-:# #' /++%++4 :%# /:'(% ?-/(#")B4 "+ $'A 1->$ "1./># #$%+% *%)'*1+ /(6 "(('9/#"'(+

$/9% $/6 '( #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ') / 1'*% '.%( /(6 %?-"#/@:% +'>"%#B @/+%6 '( #$% *-:% ') :/A

!

0'(>:-6"(< #$/#

#"<$#:B

"

6%)"(%6 KTR+ 2 *%9"+%6 /# ;*'&%># 1"6

"

.'"(# 3 $/9% @%%( />$"%9%64 #$/# #$% .':">B %(9"*'(1%(# $/+

"1.*'9%6 /(6 #$/# 0JK ./*#">"./#"'( $/+ "(>*%/+%6 >'1.:%#%+ #$% #/+I ') #$"+ *%9"%A

!

!$":% '#$%* *%9"%A+ #/I%

'( #$% %9/:-/#"'( ') ./+# .%*)'*1/(>% /(6 .*%+>*".#"'(+ )'* )-#-*% /++"+#/(>%4

!

#$"+ V%.'*# +$'-:6 .*'9% /(

"1.'*#/(# *%+'-*>% "( /66*%++"(< #$'+% ?-%+#"'(+

!

'%

! V%.'*#+ $/9% @%%( .*%./*%6 )'* %/>$ ') #$% #$*%% >'1.'(%(#+\ N/:1% DEWD 20'1.'(%(# L3d [-/(< l ;%%*%(@''1

DEWD 20'1.'(%(# N3d /(6 !- l [% 20'1.'(%(# 03Q L ;*'&%># ,9/:-/#"'( V%.'*# $/+ /:+' @%%( >'11"++"'(%6

!

Page 67: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

>==;Q T

89:;<=>=?; !9< ;@ABC>DE; F;:;E9GH;=CL

NC>CAN 9! G<9K;?C B=FB?>C9<N

B.3$#5$.3)". E"2)*

9Z'$*3)5$,/ 5$#)-)+Z,$ ).&)*+3"#7

"- +*4)$5$0$.3 I9:BJ

NC>CAN

95$#+,, 9Z'$*3)5$L

.& $(22&+% %/# 8/)*#$#

I&7#+*4#*% )* )%$

#<<&+%$ %& -#7#0&2 ,*

&2#* ,*- #N()%,;0#

$&")#%3 ;,$#- &* %/#

+(0# &< 0,1

R1.*'9%6 .':">"%+4 :/A+ /(6

*%<-:/#"'(+ /"1%6 /# :%/6"(< #'

1'*% '.%( />>%++ #' &-+#">% )'*

1'*% .%'.:% "( +'>"%#B

!

>*4)$5$&

!

;':">"%+4 :/A+ /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+ /"1%6 /# />>%++ #'

o &-+#">% $/9% @%%( "1.*'9%6 "( #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6

!

L*%/+ ')

"1.*'9%1%(# "(>:-6% /+.%>#+ ') &-6">"/: '.%((%++d />>%++ #'

>'-*#+d /(6 *%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1

!

V%)'*1+

A"#$ "(6"*%># "1./># "(>:-6%\ @%##%* >'-*# )-(6"(<d <-"6"(<

>/+%+d +%(#%(>"(< <-"6%:"(%+d /(6 1%6"/#"'( *%)'*1+

!

R1.*'9%6 +B+#%1+ ') :/A

6*/)#"(< /(6 >'(+"+#%(>B ')

/..:">/#"'(

!

>*4)$5$&

!

JB+#%1+ ') :/A 6*/)#"(< /(6 #$% >'(+"+#%(>B ')

o /..:">/#"'( ') :/A+ $/9% @%%( "1.*'9%6 6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%>#

.%*"'64 "(>:-6"(< #$*'-<$ "1.*'9%1%(#+ "( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'(

/# 6"))%*%(# +#/<%+ ') :/A

"

1/I"(<4 %9/:-/#"'( 1%>$/("+1+ /(6

"(+#"#-#"'(/:"Y"(< #$% +B+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ') :%<"+:/#"'(

!

8%9%:'.1%(# ') 1%>$/("+1+ )'*

"(>*%/+%6 ./*#">"./#"'( ') >"9":

+'>"%#B "( &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6

:/A

"

1/I"(<

!

>*4)$5$&

!

P%>$/("+1+ )'* "(>*%/+%6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "(

o &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(< $/9% @%%( 6%9%:'.%6

6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'64 /+ +-11/*"Y%6 /@'9%

!

!'*:6 ='9%*(/(>% "(6">/#'*+\

(

;'+"#"9% #*%(6 "( #$% *-:% ')

O/A

)

"(6">/#'* Wbb`

"

DEE` "+

1/"(#/"(%6

!

L>$"%9%6

!

G$% !'*:6 ='9%*(/(>% R(6">/#'*

(

;'+"#"9% G*%(6 "(

V-:% ') O/A

)

"1.*'9%6 +:"<$#:B '9%* #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'6

!

['A%9%*4 '#$%* /++%++1%(#+ *%9"%A%6 +-<<%+# >'(#"(-"(<

>'(>%*(+

!

G#"'$*3

G(#6"7$L

.& 2+&4&%#

2,+%)")2,%&+3 ,*-

)*"0($)7# ,22+&,"/#$ %&

$#0#"%#- 0#6)$0,%)7#O

'(-)"),0 ,*-

6&7#+*4#*% 2+&"#$$#$

!

R(>*%/+% "( #$% */(<% /(6

(-1@%*+ ') 1%>$/("+1+ )'*

./*#">"./#"'( ') >"9": +'>"%#B "(

:%</: .*'>%++%+ /(6 .':">B

6%9%:'.1%(# #*"%6 /(6

*%9"%A%6

!

>*4)$5$&

!

P%>$/("+1+ )'* "(>*%/+%6 .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "(

o &-6">"/: .*'>%++%+ /(6 :/A

"

1/I"(< $/9% @%%( 6%9%:'.%6

6-*"(< #$% ;*'&%># .%*"'64 /+ +-11/*"Y%6 /@'9%

!

J'1% ')

#$%+% 1%>$/("+1+4 +->$ /+ .":'#+ '( .%'.:% H + /++%++'*+ "(

!-Y$'(<4 L8V "( ;-6'(<4 '.%( >'-*#+ "( =/(+-4 /(6 .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A $/9% @%%( *%9"%A%6 #$*'-<$ ;*'&%>#

/>#"9"#"%+

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ "(>:-6%6 />#"9% >'(+-:#/#"'(+ A"#$

>"9": +'>"%#B "( 6%9%:'.1%(# ') 0JK

"

*%:/#%6 .':">"%+ +->$ /+

6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'(4 #/S %S%1.#"'( /(6 0JK 1/(/<%1%(#

!

?9HG9=;=C >

!

>??;NN C9 KANCB?; BN BHG<9:;F

<$7(,3 T

!

B=NCBCACB9=>E ?>G>?BCP 9! CO; KAFB?B><P BN ;=O>=?;F B= CO; !B;EFN 9!L

/ 3 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/:4

./*':% /(6

+%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'(

R1.*'9%6 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/:

.*'>%6-*% @B "++-"(< #$%

*%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#

(

J;0 H +

*%<-:/#"'(+ '( :/A /..:">/#"'(+

6-*"(< #$% #*"/: .*'>%%6"(< ')

+%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'( /(6

./*':%

!)

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% J;0 "++-%6 #$% +(F02*1#-37 -3 A*B

O552#H*1#-37 %0$#3F V*3%2#3F -, 8*7(7 #3 $(2*1#-3 1- D(31(3H(

8-..01*1#-3 *3% 4*$-2( "( DEWD

!

G$% J;0 /:+' "++-%6 /

f *%:/#%6 &-6">"/: "(#%*.*%#/#"'( '( *%#*"/:

!

G$%+% "(#%*.*%#/#"'(+

"1.*'9%6 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/: .*'>%6-*% @B "(#*'6->"(< #$%

.*"(>".:% /</"(+# 6'-@:% &%'./*6B /(6 @B .*'9"6"(< )'* 1'*%

'.%( #*"/:+ "( +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'( >/+%+

!

@3 >/+% <-"6/(>%

X"%:6 *%+%/*>$ 2Sc 3 >'(#*"@-#%+ #'

)'*1-:/#"'( ') #$% *%<-:/#'*B

6'>-1%(# #' @% "++-%6d

(

D48 67

8-..(317 -3 71$(3F1"(3#3F

*3% -51#.#Y#3F 1"( H*7(

F0#%*3H( 7M71(. H-.#3F #31-

(,,(H1

!)

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% J;0 "++-%6 #$% +(F02*1#-37 -3 8*7( N0#%*3H(

P-$K "( 7'9%1@%* DEWW 4 +%# -. / *%+.'(+"@:% 6"9"+"'(4 /(6

f $/+ "++-%6 #$% )"*+# <*'-. ') <-"6"(< >/+%+

!

;*'&%># )"%:6

*%+%/*>$ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% )'*1-:/#"'( ') #$% +B+#%1 /(6 "#+

6'>-1%(#/#"'(

!

(%

Page 68: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

>3 +#/#% >'1.%(+/#"'(

)'* 9">#"1+ ') >*"1%

/(6

,(/># / (%A .':">B '( J#/#%

>'1.%(+/#"'( )'* 9">#"1+ ')

>*"1% /(6 "1.:%1%(#

(/#"'(A"6%

!

N(Z73+.3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

G$% (%A .':">B $/+ *%.'*#%6:B @%%(

o "++-%6 "( P/*>$ DEEb 4 /(6 9">#"1+ />*'++ #$% >'-(#*B /*%

/:*%/6B *%>%"9"(< >'1.%(+/#"'( @/+%6 '( / +B+#%1/#">

/..*'/>$

!

O'>/: :%9%: :%<"+:/#"'( $/+ /:*%/6B @%%( "++-%6 "(

/@'-# #A'

"

#$"*6+ ') .*'9"(>%

"

:%9%: &-*"+6">#"'(+

!

63 L8V

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #'

%(/>#"(< #$% &-6">"/:

"(#%*.*%#/#"'( '(

"

J%9%*/:

K."("'(+ '( #$% V%:/#"'(+$".

@%#A%%( L8V /(6 O"#"</#"'(

#

2"

!

%

!

L8V K."("'(+3Q

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% J;0 $/+ "++-%6 #$% L8V K."("'(+4 /+ A%:: /+

o '#$%* *%:/#%6 .':">B 6'>-1%(#+4 /(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'( $/+

@%<-(

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% 6%9%:'.1%(# ')

#$"+ *%)'*1

!

0'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'(

>/+%+ )*'1 `e #' W]e ') /:: #$%

>'(>:-6%6 >"9": /(6 >'11%*>"/:

>/+%+ "( #$% .":'# +"#% ') ;-6'(<

7%A L*%/ 8"+#*"># 0'-*#

!

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6 1%6"/#"'( +B+#%1 "+ "( />#"9%

o -+% "( #$% ;-6'(< 0'-*#

!

R( DEWW 4 DD

!

_e ') >"9": /(6

>'11%*>"/: >/+%+ A%*% *%+':9%6 #$*'-<$ >'-*#

"

>'((%>#%6

1%6"/#"'(

!

<$7(,3 U

!

C<>=NG><;=?P B= ?9A<C F;?BNB9= H>VB=8 BN B=?<;>N;F CO<9A8O CO; F;:;E9GH;=C 9!

/3 '.%( #*"/:+ /(6

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+ >'(#*"@-#%6 #'

#$% .*'1-:</#"'( ') #$%

*%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#

"

J"S

V%<-:/#"'(+ '( C-6">"/:

K.%((%++

#

"++-%6 @B #$%

J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*#

!

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% J;0H+ D#E +(F02*1#-37 -3 G0%#H#*2 /5(33(77 A/+

"++-%64 /(6 "(>:-6%6 '.%( #*"/: *%)'*1

!

;*'&%># />#"9"#"%+

>'(#*"@-#%6 #' #$% "++-/(>% /(6 "1.:%1%(#/#"'( ') #$% '.%(

#*"/: *%)'*1

!

@ 3 #$% .%'.:% H +

/++%++'*+ +B+#%1

!

R1.*'9%6 ;%'.:% H + L++%++'*+

JB+#%1 @B %(:/*<"(< #$% +>'.%

') *%.*%+%(#/#"9%(%++ ') >"#"Y%(+

/# #$% .":'# +"#% ') !-Y$'(<

8"+#*"># >'-*# )*'1 b #' ]E

!

;%'.:% H + /++%++'*+ ./*#">"./#"'(

*/#% "( >/+%+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1

WEe #' F]e

!

>*4)$5$&

!

R( !-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*#4 #$% .%'.:% H+ /++%++'*+

o ./*#">"./#"'( */#% "( >/+%+ $/+ "(>*%/+%6 )*'1 WEe #' b`e "(

)"*+# #*"/: >/+%+4 /(6 #$% (-1@%* ') /++%++'*+ $/+ "(>*%/+%6

)*'1 b #' `E

!

G$% !-Y$'(< .":'# +%*9%6 /+ #$% 1'6%: )'*

(/#"'(A"6% *%)'*1 ') #$% .%'.:%H+ /++%++'*+ +B+#%1

<$7(,3 W

!

CO; KAFB?B>E >GG9B=CH;=C >=F C<>B=B=8 NPNC;H BN ;=O>=?;F >=F KAFB?B>E ;!!B?B;=?P BN B=?<;>N;F

!

/ 3 R(>*%/+%6 #*/(+./*%(>B ')

*%>*-"#1%(# ') &-6<%+ @B

>/**B"(< '-# #$% "(#%*"1

.*'>%6-*% )'* '.%( +%:%>#"'( ')

('9">% &-6<%+

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

G$% "(#%*"1 .*'>%6-*% )'* '.%( +%:%>#"'( ')

('9">% &-6<%+ $/+ @%%( 6%9%:'.%6 @-# "+ ('# %S.%>#%6 #' @%

"++-%6 @B #$% J;0 .%(6"(< '#$%* .%*+'((%: *%)'*1+

!

['A%9%*4

+'1% .*'9"(>%+ /*% %S.%*"1%(#"(< A"#$ (%A 1%#$'6+ ')

*%>*-"#"(< &-6<%+ )*'1 #$% .-@:">

!

@3 7%A C-6">"/: ,))">"%(>B =-"6%

6"+#*"@-#%6 #' >'-*#+

(/#"'(A"6%

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

G$% J;0 $/+ .*%./*%6 / G0%#H#*2 I,,#H#(3HM

N0#%(4 @/+%6 '( *%+%/*>$4 +#-6B /(6 %S.%*"%(>%+ "( %"<$#

f .*'9"(>%

"

:%9%: &-*"+6">#"'(+

!

G$% 6*/)# "+ @%"(< *%9"%A%6

!

G$%

>'(>%.#+ /*% @%"(< .":'#%6

!

>3 ]EE &-6<%+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(<

'( #$% /..:">/#"'( ') :/A /(6

-(6%*+#/(6"(< ') (%A:B %(/>#%6

.':">"%+ )*'1 #$% =,8 .*'&%>#

!

>*4)$5$&

!

7%/*:B FEE &-6<%+ *%>%"9%6 #*/"("(< -(6%* #$%

o ;*'&%># "( *%:/#%6 /*%/+\ &-6">"/: 1%#$'6':'<B4 >*"1"(/: *%#*"/:+4

./*':% /(6 +%(#%(>% >'11-#/#"'(4 /1%(61%(# ') 0*"1"(/:

O/A /(6 0*"1"(/: ;*'>%6-*% O/A4 >/+% <-"6/(>% /(6 L8V

!

)%

Page 69: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

?9HG9=;=C D

!

CO; E>M >=F G9EB?P

"

H>VB=8 NPNC;H BN BHG<9:;F

<$7(,3 T

!

CO; G><CB?BG>C9<P G<9?;NN !9< E>M

"

H>VB=8 BN B=NCBCACB9=>EB_;F

!

/ 3 R1.*'9%6 "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+4

"(>:-6"(< +-@+#/(#"9% /(6 .*'>%6-*/:

+#/(6/*6+4 )'* .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( "(

:/A 6*/)#"(<

!

=-"6%:"(%+ 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' .%'.:%+

>'(<*%++%+ (/#"'(A"6%

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

G' "1.:%1%(# #$% 7;0 H + DEE` .':">B

o *%<-:/*"Y"(< .-@:"> >'11%(# '( 6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'(4 #$% 7;0

O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"++"'( $/+ "(+#"#-#%6 / 6%#/":%6 +%# ')

>'11'( .*/>#">%+ 2*%.'*#%6:B +%# '-# "( "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+3Q K(

#$/# @/+"+4 #$% 7;0 $/+ +':">"#%6 .-@:"> >'11%(# '( /:1'+# /::

6*/)# :%<"+:/#"'( +"(>% DEE`

!

!$":% <-"6%:"(%+ )'* O;0+ '( .-@:"> ./*#">"./#"'( $/9% ('# @%%(

1/6% .-@:">4 %/>$ .*'9"(>% $/+ "++-%6 *-:%+ '( .-@:">

./*#">"./#"'( "( :/A

"

1/I"(<4 %"#$%* /+ +#/(6

"

/:'(% :%<"+:/#"'( '*

A"#$"( '#$%* :%<"+:/#"'(

!

;-@:"> >'11%(# .*'>%++%+ /*% /:+' "( -+%

"( .*'9"(>"/: :%9%: :/A

"

1/I"(<

!

@ 3 P'*% >:/*")"%6 +-@+#/(#"9% /(6

.*'>%6-*/: +#/(6/*6+ /..:"%6 #'

%($/(>"(< #$% ?-/:"#B ') .-@:">

$%/*"(<+ "( #$% :%</: .*'>%++%+

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

L:: .*'9"(>%+ $/9% $%:6 .-@:"> :%<"+:/#"9%

o $%/*"(<+ /(6 .*'6->%6 *-:%+4 A$">$ $/9% +#/*#%6 #' >:/*")B

/..:">/@:% +#/(6/*6+

!

['A%9%*4 (/#"'(/: <-"6%:"(%+ )'* .-@:">

$%/*"(<+ 2@B #$% 7;03 $/9% ('# @%%( "++-%6

!

<$7(,3 U

!

;=O>=?;F ?>G>?BCB;N 9! CO; E;8BNE>CA<; I=G?J !9< E>M

"

H>VB=8 CO<9A8O G9NC

"

E;8BNE>CB:; <;:B;M I;Q

G9NC BHG>?C >NN;NNH;=C 9! E;8BNE>CB9=J[

/3 7%A "(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+ 6%9%:'.%6

'( .'+# :%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

7/#"'(/: <-"6%:"(%+ '( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

o /*% +#":: -(6%* 6%9%:'.1%(#4 @-# .*/>#">%+ /*% @%"(< 6%9%:'.%6

/(6 .":'#%6

!

G$% 7;0 J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% $/+ >/::%6 )'* .*/>#">%+

#' @% "1.*'9%64 /(6 *%<-:/*"Y%6

!

@3 R(>*%/+%6 ./*#">"./#"'( ') %S.%*#+

"( #$% .'+# :%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A .*'>%++

!

>*4)$5$&

!

,S.%*#+ A%*% "(9':9%6 "( #$% .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

o .":'#+

!

> 3 ;":'#"(< <*'-. %+#/@:"+$%6 )'*

A'*I '( .'+# :%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A

!

>*4)$5$&

!

GA' .":'#+ '( .'+#

"

:%<"+:/#"9% *%9"%A A%*% >'(6->#%6 "(

DEEb /(6 DEWE 4 *%+.%>#"9%:B4 /(6 / .":'#"(< <*'-. +%# -.

!

63 P'*% #$/( DEEE '))">"/:+ )*'1 #$%

7;0 /(6 #$% :'>/: .%'.:% H +

>'(<*%++%+ *%>%"9"(< #*/"("(< )*'1

#$% .*'&%># />#"9"#"%+

!

G+#3)+,,/ >*4)$5$&

!

7%/*:B bEE '))">"/:+ *%>%"9%6 *%:%9/(# #*/"("(<

o -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#4 A$">$ %S>%%6+ #$% '*"<"(/: "(6">/#'* ') `EE

#*/"(%%+

!

['A%9%*4 #$% >-**%(# "(6">/#'* "+

"

1'*% #$/( DEEE

'))">"/:+

#

*%>%"9"(< #*/"("(<4 /(6 #$"+ $/+ ('# @%%( />$"%9%6

!

<$7(,3 W

!

E>M O><H9=B_>CB9= BN BHG<9:;F CO<9A8O CO; <;:B;M 9! <;8AE>CB9=N DP CO; =G? >=F EG?N

!

/ 3 JB+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A

%+#/@:"+$%6 (/#"'(A"6% /# #$% :'>/:

.%'.:% >'(<*%++%+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% +B+#%1 ') )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A $/+ @%%( %+#/@:"+$%6

o (/#"'(A"6%

!

P'+# .*'9"(>%+ 2D_ 3 $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 +.%>")"> )":"(<

/(6 *%9"%A '))">%+

!

R( #$% '#$%* )"9% .*'9"(>%+4 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A

A'*I "+ >'(6->#%6 @B 6%+"<(/#%6 +#/)) "( *%:%9/(# /<%(>"%+

!

P'*%

#$/( $/:) ') #$% *%:/#"9%:B :/*<% >"#"%+ A"#$ :'>/: :%<"+:/#"9% .'A%*

$/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+4 /(6 #A%(#B .%*>%(# ')

cEE >"#B :%9%: ;0+ $/9% %+#/@:"+$%6 )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A '))">%+

!

@ 3 R(#%*(/: <-"6%:"(%+ ') 7;0

6%9%:'.%6 '( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ')

*%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ #' %($/(>%

:/A $/*1'("Y/#"'(

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

7;0 <-"6%:"(%+ '( )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A ')

o *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ $/9% ('# @%%( "++-%6

!!

L( 7;0

"

.-@:"+$%6

@''I '( #$% )":"(< /(6 *%9"%A +B+#%1 )'* *%<-:/#'*B 6'>-1%(#+ $/+

@%%( >"*>-:/#%6 #' O;0+ #' <-"6% "1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

;*'9"(>"/: :%9%:

O;0+ $/9% "++-%6 :'>/: *-:%+ 2Db 3 '* "(#%*(/: .*'>%6-*%+ 2D 3 "( #$"+

/*%/

!

> 3 R1.*'9%6 (/#"'(/: +B+#%1 ')

*%9"%A /(6 )":"(< )'::'A"(< #$%

#*/"("(< ') :'>/: '))">"/:+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

G$*'-<$ ;*'&%>#

"

+.'(+'*%6 #*/"("(< ') #*/"(%*+4 #$%

o #*/"("(< ') :'>/: +#/)) $/+ @%%( /(6 A":: @% %S./(6%64 ./*#">-:/*:B

"( 1'*% *%1'#% /*%/+

!

*&

Page 70: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

?9HG9=;=C ?

!

B=:9E:;H;=C 9! ?B:BE N9?B;CP BN D<9>F;=;F

<$7(,3 T

!

<;?98=BCB9= 9! CO; G9NBCB:; <9E; 9! ?B:BE N9?B;CP BN B=?<;>N;F

!

/3 R(>*%/+%6 "(9':9%1%(# ') 0JK+ "(

.':">B 1/I"(< #$*'-<$ ./*#">"./#"'(

') 0JK+ "( +%1"(/*+4 )'*-1+4

A'*I+$'.+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

G$%*% A/+ >'(+"6%*/@:% 0JK ./*#">"./#"'( "( =,8

o +%1"(/*+4 )'*-1+ /(6 A'*I+$'.+

!

PK0L >"#%6 %S/1.:%+ ')

"(>*%/+%6 >'(+-:#/#"'( A"#$ 0JK+4 "(>:-6"(< '( #/S

%S%1.#"'( /(6 *%<"+#*/#"'( *%)'*1+

!

@ 3 ,/+"%* />>%++ #' "()'*1/#"'( '(

0JK *%<"+#*/#"'( /(6 6%9%:'.1%(#

9"/ /( '))">"/: @" :"(<-/: A%@+"#%

!

G+#3)+,,/ +*4)$5$&

!

G$% +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+ >''.%*/#"'(

o /(6 >'11-(">/#"'( A%@+"#% A/+ %+#/@:"+$%6 "( DEE`

2AAA

!

>(.'$Y&:

!

'*< 3Q G$% ,(<:"+$ 9%*+"'( "+ +#":: -(6%*

>'(+#*->#"'(

!

G$% A%@+"#% .*'9"6%+ %/+"%* />>%++d $'A%9%*4

.*'9"(>"/: "()'*1/#"'( "+ ('# -. #' 6/#% '* >'1.:%#%

!

>3 ;-@:">/#"'( ') / &'-*(/: /(6 @''I+

'( 0JK 1/(/<%1%(#4 6"+#*"@-#%6 #'

0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(#

'*</("Y/#"'(+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

L @"1'(#$:B &'-*(/:4 +(7(*$H" -3 8D/7

R('(2-5.(31 *3% O%.#3#71$*1#-34 $/+ @%%( :/-(>$%64

f 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' <'9%*(1%(# 1"("+#*"%+4 .*/>#"#"'(%*+ /(6

+>$':/*+

!

L +%*"%+ ') +%9%( #%S#@''I+ '( 0JK "++-%+ A/+

.-@:"+$%64 6"+#*"@-#%6 #' 0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+ /(6

-+%6 "( #*/"("(<

!

G$% 8D/7 #3 8"#3* )(*$J--K +%*"%+ A/+

f .*'6->%6 )'* DEE`

"

DEWW

!

R( DEWW4 / +%*"%+ ') +"S <*%%(

"

>'9%*%6

@''I+ ') .':">B /(6 *%+%/*>$ *%.'*#+ A/+ .-@:"+$%6

!

"

<$7(,3 U

!

CO; G9EB?P >=F E;8>E ;=:B<9=H;=C !9< ?N97 BN BHG<9:;F B= CO; !B;EF 9!

/3 *%<"+#*/#"'( ')

0JK+ /(6

8*/)#"(< /(6 +-@1"++"'( ')

/1%(61%(#+ #' *%<-:/#"'(+ #' /::'A

7=K+ #' *%<"+#%* 6"*%>#:B A"#$

<'9%*(1%(#

!

>*4)$5$&

!

PK0L *%.'*#%6 #$/# 6*/)#+ ') /1%(61%(#+ ') /::

o #$*%% 0JK *%<-:/#"'(+ 2 +'>"/: '*</("Y/#"'(+4 .*"9/#% ('(

"

%(#%*.*"+% -("#+ /(6 )'-(6/#"'(+ 34 .%*1"##"(< 6"*%>#

*%<"+#*/#"'(4 $/9% @%%( +-@1"##%6 #' #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": )'*

*%9"%A

!

R++-/(>% "+ %S.%>#%6 #$"+ B%/*

!

!$":% +-@1"##"(< 6*/)#+

#' #$% J#/#% 0'-(>": A'-:6 ('# "1.*'9% #$% .':">B /(6 :%</:

%(9"*'(1%(# )'* 0JK+4 :'>/:

"

:%9%: .":'#+ "( 6"*%># *%<"+#*/#"'(

/(6 PK0L .':">B .*'('-(>%1%(#+ +-..'*# #$% 9"%A #$/# #$%

.':">B %(9"*'(1%(# "+ "1.*'9"(<

!

@3 #/S 6%6->#"'(+ /(6

%S%1.#"'(+ )'* 0JK+

!

R(#*'6->#"'( ') #/S *%:"%) .':">B #'

@%(%)"# 7=K+ /(6 )"(/(>"/:

>'(#*"@-#'*+ #' 7=K+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

PKX /(6 JLG "++-%6 / >"*>-:/* '( #$% >*"#%*"/ )'*

o %:"<"@":"#B ') 0JK+ )'* >'*.'*/#% >$/*"#/@:% 6%6->#"'(+4 "( :"<$#

') #$% "(>*%/+% "( #$% >'*.'*/#% 6%6->#"'( :"1"# )*'1 ce #'

WDe

!

PKX /(6 JLG /:+' "++-%6 / >"*>-:/* #$/# %S%1.#+ +%9%*/:

>/#%<'*"%+ ') 0JK "(>'1% )*'1 #/S/#"'(

!

N'#$ 0JK+ /(6

6'('*+ @%(%)"# )*'1 #$% >$/(<%+

!

<$7(,3 W

!

CO; 89:;<=H;=C ?>G>?BCB;N C9 B=:9E:; ?N9N B= GADEB? N;<:B?; F;EB:;<P CO<9A8O G><C=;<NOBGN >=F

?9=C<>?CB=8 ><; ;=O>=?;F

!

R1.*'9%6 >/./>"#B ') /*'-(6 `EE :'>/:

<'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ /(6 7=K +#/)) 9"/

#*/"("(< #' .*'1'#% >''.%*/#"'(

@%#A%%( ='9%*(1%(# /(6 >"9": +'>"%#B

'*</("Y/#"'(+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

R( #'#/:4 '9%* WDEE ./*#">"./(#+ @%(%)"#%6 )*'1 W^

o #*/"("(< />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* #$% ;*'&%>#

!

G*/"("(< A/+ '))%*%6 )'*

+#/)) A'*I"(< /# *%<"+#*/#"'( /<%(>"%+4 )'* +#/)) A'*I"(< /#

0JK+ /(6 )'* #*/"("(< ') #*/"(%*+ )'* @'#$ <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+

/(6 0JK +#/))

!

G*/"("(< /66*%++%6 "1.*'9%1%(# ') #$%

>/./>"#B ') <'9%*(1%(# '))">"/:+ /(6 /<%(>"%+ #' )'*1-:/#%

.':">"%+ /(6 #' "1.:%1%(# .':">"%+

!

!&

Page 71: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

<$7(,3 \

!

?99<FB=>CB9= >=F ?9HHA=B?>CB9= >H9=8 ?N9N >=F D;CM;;= ?N9N >=F CO; 89:;<=H;=C ><; BHG<9:;F

CO<9A8O =;CM9<VB=8 H;?O>=BNHN

R1.*'9%6 >'11-(">/#"'( @%#A%%(

0JK+ /(6 <'9%*(1%(# /(6 0JK+ 9"/

#$% &'"(# ='0

"

7=K+ '*</("Y/#"'( ') W]

@" 1'(#$:B )'*-1 /(6 A'*I+$'.+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

N"

"

1'(#$:B )'*-1+ 2W] 3 A%*% $%:6

!

V%.'*#+ )*'1

o ./*#">"./(#+ "(6">/#% #$/# =,8 />#"9"#"%+ $/9% @%%( $%:.)-: "(

)/>":"#/#"(< (%#A'*I+ /1'(< 0JK+ /(6 @%#A%%( 9/*"'-+ 0JK+

/(6 <'9%*(1%(# /<%(>"%+

!

['A%9%*4 #$% +-+#/"(/@":"#B ') #$%+%

(%#A'*I+ *%1/"(+ #' @% +%%(

!

<$7(,3 ^

!

CO; B=NCBCACB9=>E >=F G<9!;NNB9=>E ?>G>?BCB;N 9! ?N9N ><; BHG<9:;F

!

/3 =*/(# )-(6"(< ') -. #' DE .*'&%>#+

A"#$ 7=K+ )'>-+%6 '( %($/(>"(< #$%"*

1/(/<%1%(# /(6 *%+%/*>$ >/./>"#"%+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

G$% )"*+# *'-(6 ') <*/(#+ A/+ 6"+@-*+%6 "( DEWE #'

o W_ 0JK+4 /(6 #$%+% <*/(# .*'&%>#+ $/9% @%%( >'1.:%#%6

!

G$%

+%>'(6 *'-(6 ') c^ .*'&%>#+ "+ +#":: -(6%*

"1.:%1%(#/#"'(

!

L>>'*6"(< #' 0L7;K4 #$"+ %S.%*"%(>% $/+

%))%>#"9%:B @-":# 0JK <*/(# '*</("Y/#"'(+ H >/./>"#B "( .*'&%>#

"1.:%1%(#/#"'( /(6 *%.'*#"(<

!

R( DEWD4 #$% >%(#*/:

<'9%*(1%(# 6%+"<(/#%6 /( /66"#"'(/: VPN DEE 1"::"'( #'

+-..'*# 0JK +%*9">% .*'9"+"'(

!

@3 L*'-(6 WEEE 7=K :%/6%*+ /(6 +#/))

#*/"(%6 "( 1/(/<%1%(#4 .':">B /(6

*%<-:/#"'(+

!

>*4)$5$&

!

J.%>")"> )"<-*%+ )'* 0JK ./*#">"./(#+ "( #*/"("(<

o />#"9"#"%+ -(6%* V%+-:# c "(6">/#% /# :%/+# ]`` 0JK +#/))

!

R(

/66"#"'(4 #$% >'1@"(%6 (-1@%* ') 0JK ./*#">"./(#+ /(6

*%<"+#*/#"'( /<%(>B ./*#">"./(#+ "( 0JK )'*-1+ -(6%* V%+-:# ^

"+ D^WE4 /(6 "# "+ )/"* #' /++-1% #$/# A%:: '9%* $/:) ') #$%+%

./*#">"./(#+ A%*% )*'1 0JK+

!

G$% >'(#%(# ') #$%+% />#"9"#"%+ /::

)"# A"#$"( 1/(/<%1%(#4 .':">B /(6 *%<-:/#"'(+ #'.">+

!

"&

Page 72: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

>==;Q U

<;!;<;=?;N

N/:1%4 J#%.$/("%4 DEWE

!"

O'>/: 0'-*#+ "( !%+#%*( 0$"(/\ G$% Z-%+# )'* R(6%.%(6%(>% /(6 8"<("#B4

#

"( V/(6/::

;%%*%(@''14 %6

!

4 G0%#H#*2 L3%(5(3%(3H( #3 8"#3*C A(77-37 ,-$ N2-J*2 +02( -, A*B 4$-.-1#-3 2DEWE34 ..

!

W]^

"

WFb

!

$$$

DEWD

!"

L>>%++ #' C-+#">%\ V%9"%A ') ,))'*#+ #' R1.*'9% C-6">"/: ,))">"%(>B /(6 V%6->% C-6">"/: 0'+#+4

#

,5

"

0$"(/g=,8 ;*'&%>#

"

0'1.'(%(# L

"

,9/:-/#"'( V%.'*#

!

N%*#%:+1/(( J#")#-(<4 DEWE

!

T!L 9T($1(27.*33 !$*37,-$.*1#-3 L3%(E ? :;=;

$

8"#3* 8-031$M +(5-$1

!

=

$

#%*+:'$\

f N%*#%:+1/(( J#")#-(<4 DEEb

!

$##.\ ggAAAg@%*#%:+1/((

"

#*/(+)'*1/#"'(

"

"(6%S

!

6%g

!

0$"(%+% L>/6%1B ') J'>"/: J>"%(>%+ 20LJJ3 R(+#"#-#% ') O/A4 DEEb

!

L((-/: V%.'*# '( 0$"(/H+ O%</: 8%9%:'.1%(#+

5(6%* V-:% ') O/A 2DEEb3Q $##.\ ggAAA

!

"':/A

!

'*<

!

>(g<:'@/:g%(g+$'A7%A+

!

/+.h "6 iDD]_D

0$'4 U'-(< 7/14 DEE_

!"

G$% ;':"#">+ ') O/A1/I"(< "( 0$"(%+% O'>/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++%+4

#

!"( 8"#3* Z0*$1($2MC

T':-1% W`F4 .. ]bD

"

_Eb

!

0'$%(4 C%*'1% L

!

4 DEWW

!"

L

(

;%'.:%H+ C-*B

)

G*"/: )'* 0$"(/H+ 0*"1"(/: 8%)%(6/(#+h

#

P/*>$ W]4 DEWW4 /# $##.\ gg

AAA

!

-+/+"/:/A

!

'*<gh . i]DWW

!

0'(<*%++"'(/:

"

,S%>-#"9% 0'11"++"'( '( 0$"(/ 2 0,00 3

%

5J

&

4 DEE`

!

0,00 L((-/: V%.'*# DEE`4 $##.\ gg

)*A%@</#%

!

/>>%++

!

<.'

!

<'9g><"

"

@"(g<%#6'>

!

><"h 6@(/1% iWWEj $'-+%j $%/*"(<+l6'>"6 i)\ ^]Dcc

!

.6)

$$$

4 DEEb

!

0,00 L((-/: V%.'*# DEEb4 $##.\ ggAAA

!

>%>>

!

<'9g./<%+g/((-/:V.#g/((-/:V.#Ebg0,00/((V.#DEEb

!

.6)

$$$

4 DEWE

!

0,00 L((-/: V%.'*# DEWE4 $##.\ ggAAA

!

>%>>

!

<'9g./<%+g/((-/:V.#g/((-/:V.#WEg0,00/((V.#DEWE

!

.6)

$$$

4 DEWW

!

0,00 L((-/: V%.'*# DEWW4 $##.\ ggAAA

!

>%>>

!

<'9g./<%+g/((-/:V.#g/((-/:V.#WWgLVDEWW)"(/:

!

.6)

!

8-/(4 ['(<?"(4 DEWD

!

8%+."#% V%<*%++"'(4 O%/6"(< J>$':/* J%%+ ['.% )'* V-:% ') O/A4 P/*>$ D4 DEWD4 0/"S"( K(:"(%4

$##.\ gg%(<:"+$

!

>/"S"(

!

>'1gDEWD

"

Ec

"

EDgWEEc_cWFE

!

$#1:

!

2"(#%*9"%A A"#$ ;*')%++'* C"/(< ;"(<3

#&

Page 73: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

['*+:%B4 C/1"%4 DEEb

!"

;-@:"> ;/*#">"./#"'( "( #$% ;%'.:%H+ V%.-@:">\ 8%9%:'."(< / P'*% ;/*#">"./#'*B ='9%*(/(>%

P'6%: "( 0$"(/4

#

J%.#%1@%* DEEb4 $##.\ ggAAA

!

:/A

!

B/:%

!

%6-g"(#%::%>#-/::")%g.-@:">./*#">"./#"'(

!

$#1

[-/(<4 C"(*'(< l ;%%*%(@''14 V/(6/::4 DEWD

!"

,S.%*#+ V%.'*# '( #$% 7;0 /(6 O'>/: ;%'.:% H+ 0'(<*%++%+ )'*

='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(#

$$$

J#*%(<#$%("(< V-:% ') O/A /(6 0"9": J'>"%#B ;/*#">"./#"'( "( 0$"(/

!#

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$4 DEWE

!

0'-(#*B J-11/*B )'* 0$"(/ DEEb 2 C/(-/*B DEWE 34 $##.\ ggAAA

!

$*A

!

'*<g%(g

('6%g̀ F^bW

!

$$$

4 DEWW

!

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$4 0'-(#*B J-11/*B )'* 0$"(/ DEWE 2C/(-/*B DEWW 34 $##.\ ggAAA

!

$*A

!

'*<g%(g

A'*:6

"

*%.'*#

"

DEWWg>$"(/

!

$$$

4 DEWD

!

[-1/( V"<$#+ !/#>$4 0'-(#*B J-11/*B )'* 0$"(/ DEWW 2C/(-/*B DEWD34 $##.\ ggAAA

!

$*A

!

'*<gA'*:6

"

*%.'*#

"

DEWDgA'*:6

"

*%.'*#

"

DEWD

"

>$"(/

!

X*%%6'1 ['-+%4 DEWW

!

0'-(#*"%+ /# #$% 0*'++*'/6+ DEWW\ 0$"(/ 20/*: P"(Y(%*34 $##.\ ggAAA

!

)*%%6'1$'-+%

!

'*<g

+"#%+g6%)/-:#g)":%+g"(:"(%j "1/<%+g0$"(/XR7LO

!

.6)4 /:+' /# $##.\ gg++*(

!

>'1g/@+#*/># iWb]`W_F

!

$$$

4 DEWD

!

X*%%6'1 "( #$% !'*:6 DEWD4 0$"(/ >$/.#%*

!

$##.\ ggAAA

!

)*%%6'1$'-+%

!

'*<g*%.'*#g)*%%6'1

"

A'*:6g

DEWDg>$"(/

"

E

!

=:'@/: R(#%<*"#B V%.'*#4 DEEF

!

=:'@/: R(#%<*"#B V%.'*#\ 0$"(/4 DEEF

!

$##.\ gg*%.'*#

!

<:'@/:"(#%<*"#B

!

'*<g0$"(/gDEEF

!

$$$

4 DEE`

!

$##.\ gg*%.'*#

!

<:'@/:"(#%<*"#B

!

'*<g0$"(/gDEE`

!

$$$

4 DEEb

!

$##.\ gg*%.'*#

!

<:'@/:"(#%<*"#B

!

'*<g0$"(/gDEEb

!

O/(6+1/(4 J#%.$%( l k$/(<4 C"(<4 DEE`

!"

L G/:% ') GA' C-*"%+\ O/B ;/*#">"./#"'( 0'1%+ #' C/./(%+% /(6 0$"(%+%

0'-*#+4

#

D] [8AO 4*H#,#H T*7#3 A*B G-0$3*2 WFb 2J.*"(< DEE`3Q

O"%@1/(4 N%(&/1"( O

!

4 DEWW

!"

L V%#-*( #' ;'.-:"+# O%</:"#Bh ["+#'*">/: O%</>"%+ /(6 O%</: V%)'*14

#

"( J%@/+#"/(

[%":1/(( /(6 ,:"Y/@%#$ ;%**B4 %6

!

4 @*-67 L3'#7#J2( V*3%Q !"( 4-2#1#H*2 &-03%*1#-37 -, O%*51#'( N-'($3*3H( #3 8"#3*

2DEWW34 ..

!

W_c

"

DEE

!

O-@1/(4 J#/(:%B4 DEWW

!"

L =:"1.+% "(#' 0$"(%+% O/A

"

P/I"(<4

#

0$"(/ V%/: G"1% V%.'*#4 K>#'@%* D]4 DEWW

!

$##.\ gg

@:'<+

!

A+&

!

>'1g0$"(/*%/:#"1%gDEWWgWEgD]g/

"

<:"1.+%

"

"(#'

"

>$"(%+%

"

:/A

"

1/I"(<

!

$&

Page 74: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

K,08 2K*</("+/#"'( )'* ,>'('1"> 0'

"

K.%*/#"'( /(6 8%9%:'.1%(#34 DEEb

!

0$"(/\ 8%)"("(< #$% N'-(6/*B N%#A%%(

#$% P/*I%# /(6 #$% J#/#% 2K,08 V%9"%A+ ') V%<-:/#'*B V%)'*13Q

;/:%*4 O/-*/4 DEE]

!"

0$"(/ H+ O%<"+:/#"'( O/A /(6 #$% P/I"(< ') / P'*% K*6%*:B /(6 V%.*%+%(#/#"9% O%<"+:/#"9%

JB+#%14

#

!"( 8"#3* Z0*$1($2M4 T':-1% W`D4 ..

!

cEW

"

cW`

!

%

J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% DEWW !'*I V%.'*#

&

J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% ') #$% 7/#"'(/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++4 DEWW

!"

V%.'*#

'( !'*I ') #$% J#/(6"(< 0'11"##%% ') #$% 7/#"'(/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++4

#

6%:"9%*%6 P/*>$ WE4 DEWW4 /(6 /6'.#%6 '(

P/*>$ W^4 DEWW

!

J#/#% 0'-(>": R()'*1/#"'( K))">%4 DEE`

!

0$"(/H+ ,))'*#+ /(6 L>$"%9%1%(#+ "( ;*'1'#"(< #$% V-:% ') O/A4 X%@*-/*B

DEE`

!

$##.\ gg%(<:"+$

!

<'9

!

>(gDEE`

"

EDgD`g>'(#%(#j bE^bEW

!

$#1

$$$

4 DEWW

!

G$% J'>"/:"+# JB+#%1 ') O/A+ A"#$ 0$"(%+% 0$/*/>#%*"+#">+4 K>#'@%* DEWW

!

$##.\ ggAAA

!

(.>

!

<'9

!

>(g

%(<:"+$(.>g(%A+gDEWW

"

WEgD`g>'(#%(#j W_FF`cbj D]

!

$#1

G%%#+4 C%++">/4 DEWW

!"

,9':-#"'( ') #$% ;':">B ;*'>%++ "( 0$"(/\ G$% R1./># ') #$% 0':'* V%9':-#"'(+ /(6 =:'@/:

,>'('1"> 0*"+"+ '( 0"9": J'>"%#B ;/*#">"./#"'( "( ;-@:"> ;':">B4

#

[/*9/*6 L+"/ Z-/*#%*:B4 P/*>$ DEWW

!

!/(<4 U/(@"(<4 DEWW

!"

;%'.:% H+ L++%++'* JB+#%1+ ;"9'#/: #' ;*'#%>#"'( ') [-1/( V"<$#+4

#

"( V0.*3 +#F"17

@*F*Y#3(4 T':-1% WE4 7'

!

c4 P/B DEWW4 $##.\ ggAAA

!

$-1/(*"<$#+

!

>(g%(g0J[VJgP/</Y"(%gG%S#g#DEEFEbWc

f j D`b_c`

!

$#1

!

!'*:6 C-+#">% ;*'&%>#4 DEWW

!

G$% !'*:6 C-+#">% ;*'&%># V-:% ') O/A R(6%S4 DEWW

!

$##.\ ggA'*:6&-+#">%.*'&%>#

!

'*<g+"#%+g

6%)/-:#g)":%+gA&.*':"DEWWj E

!

.6)

!

!-4 X%(<+$" l [%4 C"/(B-4 DEWD

!"

L .':">B *%+%/*>$ ./.%* .*%./*%6 )'* #$% ='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(#

;*'&%>#4

#

L.*": DEWD 2D6 8*/)#3Q 27'#% #$/# ./<% (-1@%*+ "( )''#('#%+ 1/B 6"))%* )*'1 )"(/: 9%*+"'(

!

3

a-4 a"( l O-4 V'(<*'(<4 DEEb

!"

L((-/: V%.'*# '( 0$"(/H+ C-6">"/: V%)'*1 2DEEb34

#

$##.\ gg%(<:"+$

!

>/"&"(<

!

>'1

!

>(g

DEWW

"

EW

"

DWgWWE_D]Dc_

!

$#1:

!

$$$

4 2 /(6 [-/(<4 U/($/' 34 DEWE

! "

L((-/: V%.'*# '( 0$"(/ H + C-6">"/: V%)'*1 2 DEWE 34

#

$##.\ gg

AAA

!

>/"&"(<

!

>'1

!

>(gDEWWgDEWE+)<<(6@<g"(6%S

!

$#1:

!

a- a"/(1"(<4 DEWW

!"

O/A 1-+# @% 1'*% #$/( &-+# A'*6+4

#

0$"(/ 8/":B4 L.*": W`4 DEWW /# `

!

%&

Page 75: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

k$'(<4 C"/($-/ l U-4 =-/(<$-/4 DEE^

!"

,+#/@:"+$"(< #$% G*-#$ '( X/>#+\ [/+ #$% 0$"(%+% 0"9": ;*'>%++ L>$"%9%6

G$"+ ='/:h

#

4 Wc G-0$3*2 -, !$*373*1#-3*2 A*B *3% 4-2#HM ^E^ 2J.*"(< DEE^3Q

&&

Page 76: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

>==;Q W

N9A<?;N 9! B=!9<H>CB9=

T

!

8;F G#"'$*3 F"*(0$.3+3)".

!,0

"

578; 0'(#*"@-#"'( L<*%%1%(#

$$$

='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# 2P/B DEEF3

! ='9%*(1%(# ') #$% ;%'.:% H + V%.-@:"> ') 0$"(/

"

578; ;*'&%># 8'>-1%(#

$$$

='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:%

8%9%:'.1%(# 2C-:B DEE`3

!='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# 2=,83

"

J#*%(<#$%("(< V-:% ') O/A /(6 0"9": J'>"%#B ;/*#">"./#"'( "( 0$"(/4

K9%*/:: !'*I ;:/( 28%>%1@%* DEEF3

!='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(#

"

*%9"+%6 :'< )*/1% 27'9%1@%* DEEb3

!P"6

"

G%*1 ,9/:-/#"'( ') #$% ='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# ;*'<*/11% 2=,834 X"(/: V%.'*# 2P/*>$ DEWE3

!='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# ;*'&%># P/(/<%1%(# K))">%4 L((-/: V%.'*#+ DEE`4 DEEb4 DEWE4 DEWW

!0'1.'(%(# L "(#%*(/: *%.'*#+\

'

#

0/+% =-"6/(>% X"%:6 V%+%/*>$ V%.'*#+ 2c3

'

#

V%.'*# '( C-6">"/: J%:%>#"'( J%1"(/*

!0'1.'(%(# N "(#%*(/: *%.'*#+

!0'1.'(%(# 0 "(#%*(/: *%.'*#+

'

#

;-@:">/#"'( O"+#+

'

#

0JK X'*-1 J-11/*B

'

#

0JK 0'()%*%(>% J-11/*B

'

#

X"(/: V%.'*#+ '( =*/(# X-(6 2X"*+# /(6 J%>'(6 V'-(63

'

#

G/S 0"*>-:/*+ 2WDD /(6 WDc3

'

#

=,8 ,9/:-/#"'( V%.'*# '( 0JK+ G*/"("(< L>#"9"#"%+4 .*%./*%6 @B #$% J'>"/: K*</("Y/#"'( J%*9">% 0%(#%* -(6%*

PK0LH+ N-*%/- ') 7;K L61"("+#*/#"'(4 6/#%6 8%>%1@%* Wc4 DEWW

U

!

B.3$#5)$%7 +.& !)$,& :)7)37 I).*,(&).2 0+3$#)+,7 6#"5)&$&J

!N%"&"(<4 X%@*-/*B W_

"

Dc4 DEWD

'

#

7/#"'(/: ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++ 27;034 O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"++"'( 2OL03

'

#

J-.*%1% ;%'.:%H+ 0'-*#

'

#

P"("+#*B ') 0"9": L))/"*+ 2PK0L34 N-*%/- ') L61"("+#*/#"'( ') 7=K+

'

#

578;

'

#

='9%*(/(>% )'* ,?-"#/@:% 8%9%:'.1%(# 2=,83 ;*'&%># P/(/<%1%(# K))">% 2;PK3

'

#

0$"(/ L++'>"/#"'( ') 7'(

"

;*')"# K*</("Y/#"'(+ 20L7;K3

!7/(&"(< 2C"/(<+-34 X%@*-/*B DD4 DEWD

'&

Page 77: Governance for Equitable Development Project: Evaluation of Progress on Objectives and Indicators

'

#

C"/(<+- ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++4 O%<"+:/#"9% L))/"*+ 0'11"##%%

!G/"B-/( 2J$/(S"34 X%@*-/*B DD4 DEWD

'

#

J$/(S" ;%'.:%H+ 0'(<*%++4 O/A 0'11"++"'(

!!-Y$'(< 2J-Y$'-4 C"/(<+-34 X%@*-/*B Dc4 DEWD

'

#

!-Y$'(< 8"+#*"># 0'-*#

!J$/(<$/"4 X%@*-/*B D^4 DEWD

'

#

;-6'(< 7%A L*%/ 8"+#*"># 0'-*#

'

#

;-6'(< J'>"/: !'*I L++'>"/#"'(

(&