Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style,...

28
Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare-related products that have almost nothing to do with Shakespeare

Transcript of Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style,...

Page 1: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare,

Shakespeare-related products that have almost nothing to dowith Shakespeare

Page 2: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

“To quack, or not to quack.”

Is this Shakespeare ??

Page 3: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Kawaii可愛 Shakespeare:mascot for Shakespeare Forum in Tokyo (2012) Tokyo,

at Professor Minami’s college, ShirayuriCollege

Is This Shakespeare ?

Shakespeare = the most authoritative global writer

Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan

Page 4: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

2. Shakespeare-related products that has almost nothing to do with Shakespeare

♡ Manga is originally from Japan, but now it has been globalized and localized---you have a large

number of Taiwan homegrown manga artists.

♡ Shakespeare is originally from England, but nowhis works has been globalized and localized.

Page 5: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare
Page 6: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Twelfth NightBy Nana Li

Born in China,Brought up in Sweden,Now in London

Manga Shakespeare Series(SelfMadeHero Publishing)

♡ Publisher : London♡ style: manga♡ artists: from everywhere

Living in UK.

Page 7: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Shakespearean products that are produced in one country often travels across national and cultural borders, not necessarily because they are ‘Shakespearean’, but because ‘Shakespeare’ is put in a global media/vehicle such as anime and manga.

Yilin Chen and Minami Ryuta, “Popular Shakespeares in East Asia: Local and Global Dissemination”, Shakespeare450 , Paris, 21-27 April 2014

Page 8: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare
Page 9: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Can you tell the differences?

Original, Korean Version Chinese translation version

By Won Soo Yeon

Page 10: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Won Soo Yeon, a top manhwaartist in South Korea

(right) Elio & Yvette, based on Romeo and Juliet

Page 11: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Taiwanese translation of Korean Manhwa versionsof Shakespeare

Cordelia and King of France

Hamlet as bishonen (a kawaii boy)

Page 12: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

English text book version, Yanbian Daxue University, China.

Page 13: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Black Butler (黒執事)by Toboso Yana (2006- )

Three Shakespeare-related episodes/images.

1. Grell quoting “Wherefore art thou Romeo?”

2. Visual references to Hamlet

3. reference to to princes in London Tower(Richard III)

Page 14: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Grell’s version of “O Romeo, Romeo, Wherefore art thou Romeo.”

Page 15: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Black ButlerA Visual Reference to Hamlet with Yorick’s skull

Do you recognize this as coming from Hamlet?

Page 16: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

First ClownThis same skull,sir, was Yorick's skull, the king'sjester.

HAMLETThis? . . . Let me see.

Takes the skullAlas, poor Yorick! I knew him, Horatio (5.1)

Page 17: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

The image suggests that Ciel (protagonist) is like Hamlet ----he is seeking revenge for his father’s death.

Page 18: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Alas, poor Pig-rick

Ham-let as a piggy

Page 19: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Shakespeare related products that cannot be easily recognized as coming from Shakespeare, --------but somehow we do. Why?

Page 20: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Cosplay (コスプレ, kosupure), short for"costume play",is a type of performance art whose participants outfit themselves, with often-elaborate costumes and accessories, as a specific character. Characters are usually sourced in various Japanese and East Asian media, including manga, anime, tokusatsu, comic books, graphic novels, video games, and fantasy movies.).

1st Annual Manga Shakespeare Cosplay and Performance Competition (2008)

Page 21: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Cosplay based on Manga Shakespeare Hamlet 37

Page 22: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Dress Up Shakespearean Actor magnet figures

Page 23: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

These are toys are basing their commercial values on Shakespeare’s authority [a flagship model in the market of cultural capital], even though sometimes in parody.

If Shakespeare is not big, these toys wouldn’t sell.

http://rebrick.lego.com/en-US/bookmark/alas-poor-yorick/do0e7g

Page 24: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Some might say this sort of de-contextualized quotation or spin-offish second order creation are abuse of Shakespeare.

Yet I am no purist.

I would like to see and examine what these by-product (as it were) are doing with Shakespeare’s cultural authority by using Shakespeare’s works, as a sort of raw materials (as it were) to work on, rather than finished works.

Page 25: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Lady Capulet in Harumo Sanazaki,Romeo and Juliet (2001)

Creative re-creation of Shakespeare’s works in manga

Page 26: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Harumo Sanazaki, Macbeth

Creative re-creation of Shakespeare’s works in manga

Page 27: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

manga adaptation of Hamlet by Ms. Meng Chen, 全力出版有限公司(台北)

Creative re-creation of Shakespeare’s works in manga

Page 28: Glocalization of manga and Shakespeare, Shakespeare ...€¦ · Kawaii, stupid, manga-style, locally coming from Japan. 1. Glocalization (Global + Local) of manga and Shakespeare

Kill Shakespeare T-shirt, with the artist’s autograph