Globalization and

Human RightsLAWS Global Citizenship ConferenceJosephine Wong and Parneet Kahlon

Agenda• The globalization and human rights nexus

o Definitions and Implications

• Case studieso The oil and beverage industries – who knew?

• Where do we go from here?o Things we can doo Resources

The NexusGlobalization and Human Rights

What is globalization?

Ongoing process

Across Time and Space Integration

EconomiesCommunicatio

nIdeas Trade

Examples of globalization

• Smoothie: o Banana from Colombiao Strawberries from Californiao Milk from Michigano Juice from South Africa

• Clothing: o Socks from Bangladesho Shirt from Thailand o Jeans from Indiao Sweater from Cambodia

What are human rights?

Guaranteed Universal

Rights and

Freedoms

Universal Declaratio

n of Human Rights

Examples of human rights

- Freedom of assembly- Freedom of religion- Right to life- Freedom of expression- Right to equality before the law

- Freedom from discrimination

Clip

Globalization and human rights

• Companies operate across borders and are gaining increasing influence and power

• Corporate activity has not always benefited the society it operates in

• There are few effective tools to prevent human rights abuses or hold companies accountable

• People affected are left powerless and vulnerable• Natural environments are exploited, unprotected,

and have devastating long-term implications

Case StudiesWhat’s happening in the world?

Case #1A large oil company begins operations in Nigeria. As people living in the oil-extraction region begin to voice their concerns with regards to environmental and worker abuses, the company finances the military who then conduct mass raids. The leader of the group calling for justice faces unfounded accusations and is eventually executed.

Wiwa v. Royal Dutch Shell

ABC News (http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/ 2009/06/09/2593497.htm)

Shell began oil production in Nigeria in 1958 and worked with the government to quell opposition to its presence. Shell financed and assisted violent military raids against popular movements by the Ogoni people who raised concerns with respect to the widespread poverty, inequalities, human rights abuses, and environmental degradation occurring in the region. Wiwa, the founder and leader of the human rights group called Movement for the Survival of the Ogoni People, was falsely accused, arrested, detained, convicted, and executed by hanging in 1995. The case of Wiwa v. Royal Dutch Shell was brought by human rights groups and lawyers against Shell on grounds of human rights violations, crimes against humanity, and torture. In 2009, Shell agreed to a settlement of $15.5 million.

What are the pros and cons of settlements?

Case #2A large American beverage manufacturer has partner factories in Colombia. Both the beverage corporation and the partner companies face charges of directing paramilitary groups in the intimidation, kidnap, and murder of trade unionists. The court dismisses the case against the beverage corporation on the grounds that the events are geographically too far removed from the corporations headquarters.

Sinaltrainal v. Coca Cola

In 2001, Sinaltrainal, representing workers in Colombian facilities, brought an action alleging Coca Cola’s complicity in human rights abuses committed by Colombian paramilitaries against trade unionists. The claims outline various human rights abuses including the torture, kidnapping, unlawful detention, and murder of Sinaltrainal leaders and members. The case against Coca Cola was dismissed in 2003 when the Court ruled that the abuses were too far removed from Coca Cola’s headquarters in the US. Subsequently, the case against two of Coca Cola’s Colombian bottling companies were dismissed in 2006. The court held that the plaintiffs’ claims did not suffice to find war crimes under international law and failed to draw a close enough connection between the Colombian government and the three defendant companies.

How do we draw the line between corporations’ “apathy” with regards to

government action vs. corporations’ “support” of government action?

Clip

Where do we go from here?

Things we can do• Learn about human rights issues: they are

everywhereo What’s in the news?

• Raise awarenesso Talk to your family, friends, teachers… o Spark dialogue and discussion

• Become a member of a human rights group• Advocate

o Write to the government and speak to community leaders

• Be conscious of everyday lifeo Notice where your clothing and food comes fromo Think about how it got to youo Question how it was made, who was involved, and the impact it may have

no other human beings and natural environments around the world

Resources • U of T’s International

Human Rights Program o http://www.utorontoihrp.com

• David Asper Centre for Constitutional Rightso http://www.aspercentre.ca

• Earth Rights Internationalo http://www.earthrights.org/

• Business and Human Rights Resource Centreo http://

www.business-humanrights.org/Home

• CorpWatcho http://www.corpwatch.org

• Amnesty Internationalo http://www.amnesty.org

Questions?